Skip to content

Як журналістика виживає у війні України (переклад)

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Academy of Ukrainian Press

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/03/09

Повномасштабне вторгнення Росії в Україну кардинально змінило репортажі про війну, так само як і саму лінію фронту. Фронтова лінія більше не є фіксованою межею, а являє собою мінливу мережу артилерійських зон, дронового спостереження та ракетних ударів, що поширюють небезпеку далеко за межі традиційних бойових зон. Журналісти, які приїжджають в Україну для висвітлення війни, тепер мусять орієнтуватися не лише в насильстві конфлікту, але й у технологічних реаліях поля бою, насиченого дронами, електронною війною та постійним спостереженням .

Мало хто розуміє цей новий ландшафт краще за Андрія Коваленка, українського локального продюсера та виконавчого директора Академії української преси. З перших днів вторгнення 2022 року Коваленко тісно співпрацює з міжнародними кореспондентами, допомагаючи їм безпечно висвітлювати події з найнебезпечніших зон війни, включаючи Київ, Бучу, Ірпінь та навколишні регіони. Його роль поєднує логістичну координацію, переклад та польове виробництво, часто в умовах, коли рішення щодо безпеки доводиться приймати швидко та з неповною інформацією .

Автор Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Оригніал публікації How Journalism Survives Ukraine’s War. Переклад українською здійснений Perplexity.ai. Ілюстрація Джона Лаймана

Досвід Коваленка дав йому унікальну перспективу на те, як сучасна війна змінює журналістику. Від порад репортерам щодо культурної обізнаності та операційної безпеки до пояснення того, як дрони розширили «зону ураження» далеко за фронт, він став неформальним інструктором для багатьох іноземних журналістів, які намагаються зрозуміти — та вижити — у реаліях висвітлення подій в Україні. В цьому інтерв’ю він розмірковує про те, як репортажі про війну змінилися в еру дронів і чому підготовка, дисципліна та скромність є життєво необхідними для журналістів у конфлікті, де, як він прямо каже, жодна історія не варта життя .

Скотт Дуглас Джейкобсен: Ви тісно працювали з багатьма міжнародними репортерами — включаючи таких, як я, — які приїжджають з дуже різними рівнями інституційної підтримки, фінансовими ресурсами та попереднім досвідом у зонах конфліктів. Коли ви навчаєте журналістів з таких різних місць, як Західна Європа, Близький Схід, Північна Америка чи Латинська Америка, як ви адаптуєте свої рекомендації до цих різних фонів? Зокрема, як ви передаєте культурний контекст, усвідомлення безпеки та практичні знання для роботи в польових умовах таким журналістам з різних професійних і регіональних культур, щоб вони могли ефективно їх засвоїти та застосовувати на місцях в Україні?

Андрій Коваленко: Це цікаве питання. Мій фокус — дати їм чітку інформацію про країну — про Україну, нашу культуру та реалії, які вони мусять зрозуміти, щоб тут працювати. Це перше.

Я також надаю культурний контекст. Україна — мультикультурна країна, тому висвітлення часто залежить від людей у центрі історії. Другий пріоритет — пояснити ситуацію з безпекою через інформацію та практичні приклади. Навіть журналісти з військовим досвідом, які висвітлювали конфлікти в Чечні, Грузії чи Іраку, мусять адаптуватися до цієї війни .

Наприклад, я працював з Süddeutsche Zeitung, великою німецькою газетою, та журналістом Флоріаном Гасселем. Гассель висвітлював Чечню та інші зони конфліктів.

Ця війна відрізняється від багатьох попередніх тим, скільки можна побачити та поділитися в реальному часі завдяки сучасним технологіям. Інша відмінність — українські військові структури часто були відносно відкритими до співпраці як з міжнародними, так і з вітчизняними ЗМІ, з інтересом показати, що відбувається на землі .

Безпека — ще одна велика проблема, особливо через технологічні розробки, як дрони. На початку повномасштабного вторгнення 2022 року українські сили почали використовувати комерційні дрони — наприклад, лінійку DJI Mavic — та адаптувати їх для розвідки і, в деяких випадках, для імпровізованих ударів.

Потім настала ера FPV-дронів, які значно змінили поле бою. FPV-системи, що використовуються в Україні, часто коштують близько 500 доларів — іноді більше.

Це створює значну асиметрію витрат: відносно дешевий дрон може знищити або вивести з ладу броньовані машини вартістю в мільйони. Сучасні основні бойові танки мають різну ціну залежно від моделі, але багато коштують кілька мільйонів доларів, а деякі варіанти перевищують 10 мільйонів.

Ця зміна допомогла сформувати те, як виглядає ера дронів та артилерії. Танки не стали марними, але стали набагато вразливішими і тепер вимагають інших тактик, систем захисту та операційної підтримки, ніж у попередніх конфліктах.

Танки все ще можуть працювати, але головним чином у підтримуючій ролі для піхоти під час наступальних операцій, як ми бачили навіть у 2023 році. Під час українського контрнаступу того року Росія вже значно розвинула свої можливості дронів. У результаті кілька західних танків — включаючи Leopard та деякі Challenger — були пошкоджені чи знищені російською артилерією, протитанковими засобами та дронами.

Отже, ситуація діє в обидва боки. Це стало своєрідним технологічним змаганням — хто швидше розробить щось нове чи покращить і еволюціонує дронові системи. Один приклад — дрони з оптоволоконним керуванням.

Минулого року ці дрони зазвичай могли працювати на відстанях приблизно від одного до п’яти кілометрів. Нещодавно, після повернення з Донецького регіону, я бачив системи, здатні працювати на відстанях близько сорока-п’ятдесяти кілометрів з оптоволоконним керуванням.

Це також викликає серйозні проблеми безпеки. Російські сили часто не чітко розрізняють цілі. Якщо вони бачать транспортний засіб, який вважають можливим для удару, вони можуть його атакувати. Навіть машини, позначені для евакуації, швидкі допомоги чи пресові автомобілі можуть стати цілями.

Через це ми дедалі частіше припиняємо маркувати авто «PRESS», а в деяких випадках знімаємо пресові позначки з бронежилетів. Я також раджу журналістам не носити військові кольори, як камуфляж чи зелений. Одяг та захисне спорядження мають бути нейтральними — чорний, синій чи інші цивільні кольори.

Ще одна проблема — те, що ми називаємо «зоною ураження». Традиційно поле бою вважалося нулевій лінією — безпосереднім фронтом. Сьогодні зона ураження може простягатися на 20-30 кілометрів від фронту. Міста як Краматорськ, Слов’янськ та Херсон можуть потрапляти в цю зону ризику.

Ця небезпека стосується обох сторін конфлікту. Тому район став набагато небезпечнішим, ніж раніше. Навіть рік тому Краматорськ, хоча й фронтове місто, мав відносно безпечніші умови. Тепер це не так. Дрони там діють дуже часто.

Для превентивних інструментів ми іноді використовуємо аналізатори чи детектори дронів. Ці пристрої не захищають безпосередньо, але допомагають зрозуміти, що відбувається. Національна спілка журналістів України надала мені один, бо знає, що я часто працюю з іноземними журналістами.

Пристрій може перехоплювати відеосигнал дрона — той самий вид, що бачить оператор дрона. Він дозволяє побачити ландшафт, напрямок дрона та приблизну відстань. Ця інформація може бути критичною.

Якщо ви розумієте, що дрон наближається до вашого місця чи авто, у вас є трохи більше часу на реакцію. Ви можете швидко виїхати машиною. Якщо часу недостатньо, ви можете сховати авто за допомогою рельєфу чи споруд. У деяких ситуаціях єдиний варіант — покинути авто та бігти до укриття.

Через ці розробки робота на передовій сьогодні дуже відрізняється від початку повномасштабного вторгнення.

Джейкобсен: Поза культурною обізнаністю та брифінгами щодо ситуації, які практичні рекомендації ви даєте журналістам, які готуються працювати поблизу фронту — чи навіть просто висвітлювати події в інших частинах України під час війни? Від тактичної медицини та логістики до розміщення, навігації та пересування через спірні зони, які найважливіші застереження чи звички мають розвинути іноземні репортери перед початком роботи в такому непередбачуваному безпековому середовищі?

Коваленко: Навчання тактичній медицині єessential. Це основа безпеки в польових умовах з кількох причин. По-перше, ви мусять урятувати себе. По-друге, ви можете врятувати членів своєї команди. По-третє, ви можете допомогти пораненим цивільним чи солдатам.

Це не тільки стандартний протокол MARCH у бойовій медицині. В Україні ситуація часто інша, бо терміни евакуації непередбачувані. У багатьох військових доктринах є ідея «золотої години» для евакуації та лікування. В Україні цей термін часто неможливий. Евакуація може тривати багато годин, особливо бо дронова активність може перешкоджати машинам дістатися до поранених. Іноді люди мусять залишатися на місці 6-8 годин, поки евакуація не стане можливою.

Через це використання турнікета треба ретельно керувати. Зазвичай турнікет накладається на обмежений час — часто 1-2 години, — бо тривала обмеження кровотоку може спричинити серйозне пошкодження тканин. За нинішніх умов медики часто комбінують турнікет з тампонуванням рани та іншими техніками, щоб стабілізувати кровотечу, зменшуючи ризик довгострокових ушкоджень. Тому практичне навчання тактичній медицині надзвичайно важливе.

Логістика — ще одна велика проблема. Журналісти поблизу фронту мають уникати готелів у прифронтових регіонах. Натомість безпечніше орендувати квартиру чи інше приватне помешкання. Російські удари неодноразово націлювалися на готелі, відомі тим, що там зупиняються журналісти. Самостійно в Харківській області кілька готелів зруйновано під час війни, і кілька журналістів поранено в таких атаках.

Я сам це пережив у Харкові в жовтні 2023 року, коли російський ракетний удар влучив у готель. Я був у ліжку, коли вибух розбив вікна. Падаюча рама поранила мене, зламавши два ребра. Я також мав порізи та синці, а наша машина надворі була зруйнована. Такі досвіди роблять зрозумілим, що готелі часто є цілями.

Ще одна проблема — навігація. Під час великих повітряних тривог у регіонах як Донецьк, Харків чи іноді навіть Київ електронні перешкоди можуть порушувати GPS-сигнали. Коли це стається, навігаційні системи можуть перестати працювати належно. Важливо завантажити карти для офлайн-роботи та заздалегідь вивчити місцеву дорожню мережу.

У прифронтових регіонах легко звернути не туди й опинитися в надзвичайно небезпечному місці. Наприклад, якщо ви їдете Донецьким регіоном, неправильний поворот може привести до зон як Покровськ чи інші активні фронтові зони.

Під час їзди поблизу фронту радимо трохи відкрити вікно та слухати дрони. Багато дронів швидкі, але й гучні, тож іноді їх чути наближення. Водночас хтось у машині має постійно моніторити дорогу та околиці. У багатьох командах є фактично другий спостерігач, який стежить за небом та рельєфом.

Багато фронтових доріг тепер вкриті сітками проти дронів — структури, іноді звані «антідроновими тунелями». Ці сітки дають деякий захист, але не ідеальний. У деяких випадках один дрон може пошкодити сітку, створивши прорив, через який інший дрон атакує машини. Ці структури головним чином дають водіям більше часу на реакцію.

Ще один критичний пункт — розуміння ризиків. Це не комп’ютерна гра. Немає кнопки перезапуску, немає другої спроби. У вас одне життя. Жодна історія з фронту не варта смерті. Якщо журналіст гине, він не може розповісти історію.

Тому ви мусять постійно оцінювати, чи дійсно необхідно входити в небезпечну зону. Іноді історію можна висвітлити з безпечнішого місця чи поспілкувавшись з людьми, які там були.

Джейкобсен: Сучасна війна також глибоко формується цифровою інфраструктурою — мережами зв’язку, супутниковими з’єднаннями та постійним потоком онлайн-інформації. Для журналістів в Україні яку роль відіграють інструменти як VPN та інші цифрові заходи безпеки в повсякденному репортажі? Чи є особливі цифрові застереження, практики комунікації чи технологічні звички, які, на вашу думку, журналісти мають прийняти, щоб безпечно та ефективно працювати в конфліктному середовищі, де кіберризики та контроль інформації дедалі більше є частиною поля бою?

Коваленко: Щодо цифрової безпеки, VPN корисні в кількох ситуаціях. Російські сайти та онлайн-сервіси часто блокуються в Україні, тож журналістам може знадобитися VPN для доступу до російських джерел для досліджень. У деяких прифронтових регіонах певні онлайн-платформи чи інструменти зв’язку можуть працювати надійніше через VPN.

Ще одна практична проблема — гроші. Навіть у пошкоджених містах Донецького регіону, як Добропілля, люди ведуть маленькі крамниці. Багато місць використовують генератори та Starlink, що іноді дозволяє платити карткою. Однак розумно мати при собі готівку в гривнях, бо електрика та зв’язок можуть зникнути.

Нарешті, під час великих повітряних атак важливо дотримуватися базових правил укриття. Одна поширена рекомендація — «правило двох стін». Ви маєте триматися подалі від вікон і мати щонайменше дві суцільні стіни між собою та зовнішнім світом. Ванні кімнати чи внутрішні коридори часто безпечніші. Нижні поверхи загалом безпечніші.

Звісно, найкращий варіант — піти до належного підземного укриття. Але якщо це неможливо, ці застереження можуть підвищити шанси вижити під час ракетного чи дронового удару.

Джейкобсен: Дуже дякую за можливість та ваш час, Андрію.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

My interview with Scott Jacobsen, part 2 (and a note on faith versus fact)

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Why Evolution Is True

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2025/11/07

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: We’re speaking mainly about Christian-majority countries. However, according to recent census data from Statistics Canada, the total number of Christians in Canada is around 53 to 54%. If you track the trend line from the 1971 data through 2001 and 2021, Canada will fall below half-Christian in terms of its total population sometime this year. That’s a significant shift. The United Kingdom is already closer to 40%. While the United States still reports around 67%, that was different from two decades ago. So, there is a general decline. Does this mean that the acceptance of evolution—or at least theistic evolution—is likely to become more prevalent in these cultures?

Jerry Coyne: Yes, that’s what the statistics suggest. If you look at Gallup polls, you’ll see that the only steady increase is in the acceptance of naturalistic evolution. It started at about 9% in 1982 and has risen to around 25% by 2024. That’s a promising trend, but it’s important to note that more than half of Americans—nearly three-quarters—still oppose purely naturalistic evolution.

Keep in mind that 34% of Americans are theistic evolutionists. They accept evolution, but only up to a point. That point usually involves human evolution because they believe God created humans in His image. This belief skews the data, making the acceptance of evolution seem higher than it truly is. Many people struggle with the idea that what they perceive as a random, accidental process could lead to the complexity of human beings and our brains. This is a mischaracterization of natural selection, but it’s a common barrier to accepting evolution.

. . . \Jacobsen: It’s quite a story. So, when you’re less active on that particular subject, such as tracking the Discovery Institute’s activities, what do you consider the enduring thread from Mencken’s era to the present regarding attempts to infiltrate school systems and advocate for a divine role in evolution? What common themes have persisted over time?

Coyne: The fact that evolution is inherently offensive to many people. Steve Stewart-Williams wrote a book about this—although I can’t recall the title—that delves into the different ways in which the concepts of evolution and natural selection challenge deeply held beliefs. It’s not just about religion. Evolution strikes the core of human exceptionalism and the belief that we are somehow separate from the rest of the natural world.

You don’t have to be religious to believe in human exceptionalism, but religion certainly reinforces it. The idea that naturalism alone is responsible for everything, including consciousness, is unsettling for many.

Some people propose supernaturalism or extranaturalism because they don’t believe naturalism can account for phenomena like consciousness. I remember talking to Steven Weinberg, the Nobel laureate in physics, at a meeting several years ago. My presentation was on free will and why it doesn’t truly exist—because our will originates in the brain, which is composed of molecules that follow the laws of physics. Therefore, we can’t step outside ourselves to make truly independent choices. At any given moment, the arrangement of molecules in the brain allows for only one possible action.

That idea is offensive to many people, including Weinberg. He asked, “Are you telling me I couldn’t have chosen something else when I choose what to eat at a restaurant?” I said, “Yes, that’s exactly what I’m saying.” He objected, saying he didn’t believe it.

That reaction highlights how deeply unsettling naturalism can be, especially when it challenges the notion of free will. Naturalism, which underpins evolution, is inherently challenging. Evolution itself isn’t a philosophical concept, but it embodies methodological naturalism. Darwin’s work epitomized this, especially at the end of On the Origin of Species, where he wrote about the natural laws governing cosmology and biology. He drew a parallel between the laws of physics that dictate planetary motion and the laws that drive evolution, which are based on chemistry and physics.

So, yes, evolution offends people on multiple levels. Even if religion were to disappear—which it won’t, at least not in our lifetimes—people would still find reasons to object to evolution. However, it’s also true that the less people believe in God, the more likely they are to accept evolution. Suppose you graph countries based on religiosity and acceptance of evolution. In that case, you’ll see a clear trend: the more religious a country is, the less likely its population is to accept evolution. This appears to hold globally.

The least accepting countries are typically the most religious ones, such as Muslim-majority countries. Even within Europe, countries like Spain and Italy, which have strong Catholic traditions, are less accepting of evolution compared to more secular countries.

If you analyze the 50 United States similarly, you’ll also see a significant positive correlation between acceptance of evolution and atheism or lack of religiosity. The states most resistant to evolution, such as Tennessee—known for the famous Scopes Trial—are primarily in the American South. These states are also the most religious in the United States. The underlying thread is the tension between materialism and religion, which inherently rejects materialism.

Religion, by its nature, involves the supernatural. This theme has consistently run through the debate over evolution.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

My interview with Scott Jacobsen, Part 1

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Why Evolution Is True

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2025/11/06

Jacobsen: Do you ever get pushback—not on the facts, evidence, or the validity of your arguments—but on your tone? People who position themselves as the “tone police,” saying that you come across too aggressively? H. L. Mencken might have faced this if he were writing today, perhaps to an even greater extent. People might say, “We appreciate the sophistication and flair of your language, but it’s too sharp, and you’re turning people off.” Do you get that kind of response?

Coyne: All the time, man. It’s because you cannot criticize religion, however indirectly, without it being perceived as an attack on religion itself. About 60 to 70 percent of Americans believe that God played a role in evolution, so if you make any statement about evolution, you inevitably have to touch on creationism. When I wrote my book Why Evolution Is True, I aimed for a mild tone; I didn’t want to offend religious people. But you can’t discuss the evidence for evolution without discussing the evidence against creationism.

It’s all interconnected. In the “one long argument” in On the Origin of Species, Darwin repeatedly addresses creationist ideas, acknowledging creationism as the alternative hypothesis to evolution. So, if you’re defending evolution, at some point, you have to critique creationism. When you do that, you’re challenging religious belief, and no matter how mild the critique, people will accuse you of using the wrong tone.

What they’re essentially saying is that you should shut up. One example is when I point out the existence of dead genes—we have, for example, three genes for making egg-yolk proteins in the human genome that are nonfunctional because we don’t make egg yolk anymore—so they’re remnants from our reptilian ancestors. Suppose you mention this to convince people that evolution is true. In that case, you must also ask why a creator would put nonfunctional genes in our genomes. Making this argument is thus a quasi-scientific discussion.

When arguing for evolution, you have to present your case while addressing the alternative, which means critiquing creation. That gets people defensive and makes them criticize the tone of the argument. Sometimes, for fun, I try to write like H. L. Mencken because creationism is fundamentally as baseless as flat-earth ideas. There’s so much evidence against creationism that it’s laughable to espouse it. Usually, I am not Mencken-esque when I give evidence for evolution. I choose to either wear my atheist, anti-religious hat or my scientific hat when lecturing, but not both at the same time.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Inside the legal battle over Ukraine’s stolen children

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): ZMINA Human Rights Center

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/05/15

Onysiia Syniuk, Head of the Research Department at Human Rights Centre ZMINA, stands at the intersection of legal analysis and wartime accountability. Trained as an international lawyer at Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv, her work focuses on human rights and international humanitarian law violations arising from Russia’s invasion of Ukraine—particularly deportations, enforced disappearances, unlawful detention, and forced conscription in occupied territories.

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen speaks with Syniuk about the legal architecture surrounding the deportation of Ukrainian children and the broader, often contested framework of collaboration law in Ukraine. She outlines why the International Criminal Court (ICC) remains the central forum for prosecuting senior Russian officials, while domestic courts absorb the bulk of lower-level cases. She also unpacks the ambiguity embedded in Ukraine’s collaboration statutes, clarifies the legal distinction between evacuation and forcible transfer, and situates these issues within the overlapping frameworks of aggression, occupation, war crimes, and crimes against humanity.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Which accountability mechanism is most realistic for addressing the deportation of Ukrainian children—the ICC, universal jurisdiction, or a special tribunal?

Onysiia Syniuk: I will start with the special tribunal, because that is the most visible institutional development at the moment. The Special Tribunal for the Crime of Aggression against Ukraine, now being established within the Council of Europe framework, is designed to investigate, prosecute, and try those who bear the greatest responsibility for the crime of aggression against Ukraine. It is not being created to prosecute the deportation or forcible transfer of children as such. Those acts fall under war crimes and, potentially, crimes against humanity.

The special tribunal is therefore aimed at the crime of aggression, not at war crimes, crimes against humanity, or genocide directly. In that sense, it addresses the overarching illegal use of force, but not every downstream crime within the same proceeding. It has moved forward politically and institutionally, including through a bilateral agreement signed on 25 June 2025, but it is not the primary forum for charges relating specifically to child deportation.

If we are speaking specifically about President Vladimir Putin and the deportation of Ukrainian children, the ICC is the key forum. On March 17, 2023, ICC judges issued arrest warrants for Vladimir Putin and Maria Alekseyevna Lvova-Belova for the war crimes of unlawful deportation and transfer of children from occupied areas of Ukraine to the Russian Federation.

That matters because domestic courts and universal jurisdiction cases face significant immunity obstacles when the suspect is a sitting head of state or another senior official. The ICC is different because it operates under its own legal framework, and Article 27 of the Rome Statute rejects official-capacity immunity before the Court. For the highest-ranking Russian officials, the ICC is therefore the most realistic judicial avenue, even if arrest and surrender remain politically difficult.

The political environment has also become more complicated for the ICC. Sanctions and political pressure against the institution have affected its operational capacity. That does not eliminate ICC jurisdiction, but it does complicate enforcement in practice.

For other individuals, however, the picture is broader. Maria Lvova-Belova, regional officials, occupation administrators, and others allegedly involved in organizing or facilitating the transfer of children may also be investigated or prosecuted through domestic proceedings, particularly in Ukraine. Ukrainian prosecutors have already brought charges in cases involving deportation and forcible transfer of children.

The deportation of children will not be addressed through a single mechanism. It will not be only the ICC or only domestic courts. Due to immunities and other constraints, multiple avenues will be used.

There are already cases within Ukrainian domestic jurisdiction addressing deportation and forcible transfer of children as war crimes. Individuals have been charged. One set of cases concerns deportations preceding the full-scale invasion, when so-called evacuations were announced in the DPR and LPR on February 18, 2022. At that time, orphanages from territories occupied since 2014 were transferred to the Rostov region in Russia and elsewhere. Ukrainian courts are already addressing these actions.

As for universal jurisdiction, it is the least likely avenue. Most deported children remain in occupied territories or in Russia. In many countries, universal jurisdiction requires either that the victim or the perpetrator be present in the prosecuting state or that there be a relevant legal connection. This creates a narrow window.

Few countries exercise broad universal jurisdiction. Even where they do, sufficient evidence, access, and institutional capacity are still required. Therefore, universal jurisdiction is unlikely to be the primary mechanism. The ICC will address the highest-level officials, while domestic jurisdictions will handle the majority of cases.

Jacobsen: How does Ukrainian law define “collaboration,” and where does ambiguity arise in its application?

Syniuk: I will start by noting that there is no single, clear definition. The law does not provide a concise definition of ‘collaboration.’ Instead, it provides an article, adopted in March 2022 and entering into force shortly after the full-scale invasion.

There are seven main categories of activity. Two are classified as criminal misdemeanors, while the others are more serious crimes.

The first category concerns public support for aggression. This includes statements in public spaces or online that endorse Russia’s actions or occupation. It also includes activity on social media, including platforms restricted in Ukraine such as Odnoklassniki and VKontakte. Posting, reposting, or—even in some enforcement practice—liking content that supports the aggression may be treated as dissemination, since such activity makes it visible to others.

The second category involves taking non-leadership positions in occupied territories. This can include relatively minor roles, such as technical staff or service workers within those administrations.

The third category concerns propaganda in educational institutions. This includes teachers, administrators, and others responsible for implementing or promoting Russian curricula or ideological content in schools, colleges, or other educational settings. It also applies to those involved in training or supervising educators in occupied territories.

Another category is often described as economic collaboration. This includes transferring material resources to occupying forces or engaging in business activities with occupation administrations.

It is important to note that these provisions are broadly framed. The scope of what constitutes “material resources” or “support” can be interpreted widely. In practice, this gives investigators and prosecutors significant discretion, which has raised concerns about its overbroad application. For example, in the early stages following the liberation of some territories, there were cases involving individuals whose actions fell into ambiguous categories under these provisions.

Jacobsen: You mentioned early prosecutions in newly liberated regions. Which territories were those, and what patterns emerged in those cases?

Syniuk: We are referring to the Kyiv region after its de-occupation, the Kharkiv region after its de-occupation, and the right bank of the Kherson region, which was also de-occupied. These were the first major counteroffensive territories.

Ukrainian law enforcement gained access to these areas and to the people living there. They began prosecuting individuals under the collaboration provisions. In some cases, there were not only charges but also court verdicts. For example, individuals were convicted for transferring small quantities of goods, such as meat or cigarettes, to occupying forces.

This is no longer the current practice. There has been some adjustment in how collaboration is interpreted and applied. However, the law initially allowed for these outcomes because of its broad formulation.

That falls under what is often described as economic collaboration. The fifth category involves taking a leadership position in an occupying administration. This includes heads of administrations, department heads, and others with organizational or administrative authority. It also includes individuals involved in organizing referendums or elections in occupied territories. Even logistical roles, such as transporting ballot boxes, can be sufficient to establish liability.

The sixth category is sometimes called informational collaboration. Unlike the first category, which concerns expressing opinions, this involves producing or disseminating content in coordination with occupying authorities or their representatives, such as participating in media production or communications efforts.

The seventh category is the most severe. It carries penalties of up to 15 years of imprisonment. It includes joining law enforcement or military structures established in occupied territories, such as police, prosecution services, or judicial bodies. It also includes joining military formations.

It is important to note that under the Russian system, some roles that might appear civilian—such as firefighting or emergency services—can be classified within law enforcement or security structures. As a result, individuals who join such services in occupied territories have, in some cases, been prosecuted for collaboration. Ukrainian courts have issued verdicts in such cases.

These provisions do not exist in isolation. Other articles of Ukrainian law address related conduct, including treason and the provision of information about the movement or location of Ukrainian armed forces. The collaboration article specifically addresses the forms of cooperation just described.

We now have four years of practice under this article, so it is relatively well developed in terms of quantity, though not necessarily in consistency or quality.

Because the law is broadly formulated, it has been applied broadly in both investigative and judicial practice. There are also Supreme Court decisions that influence how the law is interpreted and applied.

It is important to note that the practice is not unified. There are conflicting decisions. Ukraine is not a strict precedent-based system, so courts are not formally bound by Supreme Court rulings in the same way as in common-law systems. They take them into account, and Supreme Court legal conclusions carry substantial interpretive weight, but they may still reach different conclusions.

For example, there are differing interpretations of what constitutes an “occupying administration.” One issue is whether this includes communal or municipal enterprises—entities that provide local public services but are not strictly part of the occupation authorities. One Supreme Court decision suggests that such entities may fall within the definition, while another suggests that they do not. This reflects the lack of a unified approach.

However, the dominant interpretation of the threshold for criminal liability is quite clear. Under the current wording of the law, taking up a position within an occupying structure is sufficient to establish criminal liability.

It does not necessarily matter what actions the individual performed in that role, what their specific functions were, or whether their conduct caused demonstrable harm to national security or others. The mere fact of holding the position is often treated as sufficient.

Jacobsen: To clarify a key legal issue: if criminal liability can arise simply from holding a position within an occupying structure, how do courts distinguish between formal roles and actual conduct?

Syniuk: Yes, but even if a person takes up a position and does not perform the functions associated with it—whether due to lack of opportunity or lack of intent—that does not necessarily exclude them from criminal liability.

Jacobsen: So the liability still stands. I would say it goes even further than that.

Syniuk: There are cases that illustrate this issue. First, the law distinguishes between leadership and non-leadership positions. To differentiate between them, one must examine the functions performed, particularly whether they involve organizational or administrative authority.

However, in situations where a person formally holds an administrative position but does not actually perform administrative functions, the appropriate mode of liability becomes unclear. This question is not clearly defined in the law and has not been consistently addressed in practice.

Jacobsen: What evidentiary standards distinguish forcible transfer from what is often described as “evacuation”? And where does the commonly used term “abduction” fit—or fail to fit—within legal definitions?

Syniuk: “Abduction” is a term often used in political or rhetorical contexts, and I believe it is used for that purpose. I have the same concern with it as with other imprecise terms. In Ukrainian, for example, there is sometimes an attempt to describe civilians using terminology analogous to prisoners of war—essentially “civilian POWs.” This is not a recognized legal category. Under international humanitarian law, civilians cannot be classified as prisoners of war.

For that reason, it is important to use precise terminology. In situations of armed conflict, there is an established legal vocabulary. The key terms are forcible transfer and deportation.

When movement occurs within the territory of a single state, without crossing an international border—whether de facto or de jure—it is classified as forcible transfer. When individuals are moved across an international border, it is classified as deportation.

Evacuation, by contrast, is the only lawful form of transferring civilians or protected persons in an armed conflict, particularly in occupied territories. However, it is subject to strict legal conditions.

First, there must be a valid justification. Generally, this means either a serious threat to the safety of the civilian population or an imperative military necessity. For children, the threshold is even higher. Transfer across borders requires a clear and immediate necessity related to their health or safety, along with consent from parents or legal guardians, or another authorized representative where parental rights are absent.

If these conditions are not met, the movement cannot be classified as an evacuation. It then becomes necessary to assess whether it constitutes a forcible transfer or deportation, each of which has specific legal elements. In practice, if the criteria for evacuation are not satisfied, the transfer is likely unlawful under international law.

There are also procedural obligations. The transferring authority must notify the state of origin and the International Committee of the Red Cross, and must provide sufficient information to facilitate family reunification.

Evacuation is, by definition, a temporary measure. Individuals must be returned as soon as the circumstances that justified the evacuation no longer exist. Any obstruction of return would violate international legal obligations.

Labeling an action as ‘evacuation’ does not make it lawful. The classification depends on whether the legal requirements are actually met.

Jacobsen: At a foundational level, how do the crime of aggression and the condition of occupation interact within international legal frameworks such as the Rome Statute and the Geneva Conventions?

Syniuk: International humanitarian law does not determine the legality of an occupation. It regulates the factual situation of occupation and establishes the obligations of the occupying power.

Jacobsen: Thank you—that is very clear, and it is an important point. To deport or unlawfully transfer children from occupied territory, the prior commission of aggression and the establishment of occupation are already in place. This is not a minor detail; it is foundational to the legal analysis.

Syniuk: I would add that deportation and forcible transfer are not limited to armed conflict. These acts can also be committed by a state against its own population. That is a different legal context, but it is important to distinguish between them.

War crimes require the existence of an armed conflict. Crimes against humanity, by contrast, do not require an armed conflict; they require a widespread or systematic attack against a civilian population.

Jacobsen: Verification remains a central challenge. To what extent is the difficulty in confirming deportation figures driven by lack of access and cooperation from the Russian Federation?

Syniuk: I would not say that this creates major difficulties in legal cases, but it does create challenges in political discussions and advocacy. There is a strong focus on numbers, although legally, even a single verified case is sufficient to establish a crime.

However, the Russian Federation controls both the occupied territories and its own territory. Ukraine does not have access to either. As a result, there is no direct way to verify the full scale of these transfers within those areas.

Jacobsen: Is the limited public disclosure of case details—particularly involving children—partly intentional, to protect identities and preserve evidentiary integrity?

Syniuk: Yes, that is generally correct. This is especially true in cases involving children deprived of parental care, such as those taken from orphanages. In some cases, relatives may be searching for them or advocating on their behalf, but often there are no such relatives. In those situations, the state assumes responsibility for the children.

The information available to Ukrainian authorities is often limited to records from before the occupation. After that, the situation becomes much more opaque. In some cases, Russian authorities publicly announce transfers or present them in media. In other cases, no information is disclosed.

When children are transferred into Russian families, particularly through adoption, tracking them becomes extremely difficult. They may be relocated to distant regions, grow older, and undergo changes that make identification harder. Even tools such as facial recognition become unreliable over time.

In addition, names and personal details may be altered through adoption procedures. This further complicates efforts to locate and identify these children.

Jacobsen: What role, if any, should Belarusian jurisdiction play in accountability for these transfers?

Syniuk: That is a complex question. There is a distinction between what should happen and what is likely to happen.

Jacobsen: There is a phrase “should have, would have, could have” or “shoulda, woulda, coulda”—used to reflect on past possibilities.

Syniuk: Yes, I am familiar with it. In this context, it appears increasingly unlikely that Belarusian authorities will face accountability for these actions, particularly given the current political environment.

At present, the ICC is one of the few institutions pursuing accountability in related contexts. For example, the ICC has opened an investigation into alleged crimes against humanity committed in Belarus against civilians, following Lithuania’s referral. However, accountability specifically related to the transfer of Ukrainian children through Belarus remains uncertain under current conditions.

Jacobsen: Are the limitations we see in enforcement a function of relatively young institutions like the ICC, or are they more a reflection of political constraints imposed by powerful states?

Syniuk: I would not describe international humanitarian law as new. Its modern framework dates to 1949 with the Geneva Conventions.

However, the ICC is a more recent development, as part of international criminal law. More broadly, developments in the international legal system depend heavily on the political will of states. The direction of that political will significantly influences how these institutions function.

The law itself evolves slowly. Once established, it is difficult to reverse; it can be developed further, but not easily undone. The main issue is not the existence of the law but its enforcement—that is where most complications arise.

It would not be entirely accurate to describe the United States as a major supporter of the ICC system. The United States is not a party to the Rome Statute and has historically had a complex and often critical relationship with the Court.

Jacobsen: The United States is notably the only UN member state that has not ratified the Convention on the Rights of the Child. Somalia was previously the last to ratify, but it has since done so. The United States signed the Convention decades ago but has not ratified it.

Syniuk: Yes, and a similar issue arises with the Rome Statute. The United States signed it but did not ratify it, and in 2002 notified the UN that it did not intend to become a party. Concerns about sovereignty and the potential prosecution of U.S. personnel have been central to that position.

Jacobsen: One might then expect fewer world leaders to attend UN General Assembly sessions in New York under such conditions.

Syniuk: The broader point is that the United States has not historically been a consistent supporter of this form of international criminal accountability. At present, the issue is not only non-participation but also active measures that affect the Court’s functioning.

For example, sanctions targeting the ICC have created practical obstacles. U.S. nationals working with or supporting the Court may face legal or professional risks, which can discourage cooperation. This has a direct impact on the Court’s operations.

These dynamics ultimately reflect the central role of political will in shaping how international legal institutions function, including the ICC.

The ICC arrest warrants are also a matter of political will. States Parties are required to comply with them, but in practice, compliance is uneven. We have seen this with Mongolia in relation to President Putin. We have also seen non-compliance issues involving Hungary in another case, not concerning Putin. Some ICC member states have openly resisted cooperation, and Hungary has even moved toward withdrawal.

So again, the law itself has not disappeared. It has not changed in any fundamental way, and it has not become weaker on paper. The real issue is enforceability, and enforceability depends heavily on political will.

Jacobsen: What is the current state of efforts to return deported or displaced Ukrainian children?

Syniuk: As of early March, the publicly reported figure under the Bring Kids Back UA initiative was 2,000 returned children. That remains a small proportion of the overall number of affected children. It is an important achievement, but the scale of the problem remains much larger.

I would clarify, however, that this figure does not refer only to children who were deported and then returned. It includes children from occupied territories who were returned to Ukrainian-controlled territory through different pathways. Some were deported or forcibly transferred, while others remained in occupied territory and were later brought back.

The main return mechanism has often involved non-governmental organizations working with state structures and international partners. These efforts are expensive and logistically complex. There is no direct route from Russian territory or occupied territory back into Ukraine. In many cases, children must travel through Russia and then through third countries before they can return.

There have also been mediation efforts by states such as Qatar. Those efforts have produced some returns, but the numbers remain limited. One difficulty is that Russia often frames these cases not as returns of deported children, but as “family reunifications,” sometimes even portraying them as reciprocal humanitarian arrangements. That framing obscures the underlying legal issue.

In practice, non-governmental actors remain central to the return process, but their work is becoming harder. Russian authorities continue to impose procedural obstacles, including document requirements and demands that parents or relatives travel in person to Russia to retrieve children. There is no straightforward mechanism for Ukrainian state representatives to enter Russia and recover children directly. As more return routes become known, those routes can also be restricted. This is one reason public information about return methods is often limited.

Jacobsen: What benchmarks would signal that meaningful transitional justice is taking hold in Ukraine?

Syniuk: This is one of the most complex questions, because transitional justice is a broad concept. It encompasses criminal accountability, memorialization, reparations, and other forms of redress.

It is already a sign of progress that transitional justice is being discussed during an ongoing armed conflict. Traditionally, such discussions were more often associated with post-conflict phases, even though accountability mechanisms such as the ICTY were created while the Balkan conflicts were still ongoing.

In Ukraine, however, this process began even before the full-scale invasion, following the onset of armed aggression in 2014. This earlier work is not always fully recognized by international donors, who sometimes approach the situation as though everything must be built from the beginning. In reality, Ukraine has already developed experience in supporting internally displaced persons, pursuing accountability, and addressing harms related to the conflict.

The current challenge is not to create entirely new frameworks, but to build on what already exists—identifying gaps, improving mechanisms, and adapting them to the scale of the full-scale invasion.

Another important development is the establishment of mechanisms such as the Register of Damage and the International Claims Commission process now being set up, with the convention signed in December 2025 and preparatory work launched in 2026. However, all aspects of transitional justice that involve financial reparations ultimately depend on available resources. This raises unresolved questions about the use of frozen Russian assets and related financial instruments.

Legal frameworks for reparations can be developed, but without financial backing, they are largely ineffective. This has already been demonstrated in practice. For example, Ukraine adopted legislation on interim reparations for survivors of conflict-related sexual violence. Initial payments were supported by international partners, including the Global Survivors Fund. However, when funding was reduced, the legal framework remained in place without sufficient resources to sustain payments.

There are multiple parallel efforts underway to build a comprehensive support system. At present, certain categories of victims—such as survivors of conflict-related sexual violence, internally displaced persons, and others—receive targeted attention. However, some groups, including torture survivors, have received less visibility and support.

The goal is to develop an integrated system that covers all categories of victims and addresses their specific needs. Different groups require different forms of assistance; for example, the needs of survivors of sexual violence differ significantly from those of deported children. A tailored, structured support system is necessary.

There is also ongoing work in areas such as memorialization, although that is a separate field. In terms of criminal accountability, capacity is being strengthened through training for prosecutors, investigators, and judges. These efforts are still in progress.

The central points are, first, that Ukraine is not starting from scratch, as substantial work has already been done since 2014; and second, that planning and implementation of transitional justice mechanisms must continue during the conflict, rather than waiting for a ceasefire or its conclusion.

Jacobsen: From the perspective of independent international bodies—such as UN commissions or OSCE mechanisms—which cases are most strongly substantiated, and how should their findings be interpreted?

Syniuk: Thank you, that clarifies the question. If we are referring to independent international institutions—such as UN bodies, commissions of inquiry, and other third-party mechanisms—the general direction of their findings has been relatively consistent.

These institutions generally rely on conservative verification standards. They distinguish between documented, verified cases and broader estimates. For example, the UN Independent International Commission of Inquiry on Ukraine has confirmed specific cases based on direct evidence, including documentation and witness testimony, while acknowledging that the total number of affected children is likely higher.

Importantly, these bodies have concluded that the deportation and transfer of Ukrainian children constitute serious violations of international law. In some findings, they have characterized these acts as war crimes and, in certain contexts, as crimes against humanity.

The emphasis in their reporting is not on large headline numbers, but on legally verified incidents that meet evidentiary thresholds. Even a relatively small number of verified cases can establish the existence of a broader pattern of conduct.

Across institutions, there is general convergence on several points: that unlawful transfers and deportations have occurred; that these acts are attributable to Russian authorities or affiliated structures; and that accountability mechanisms are warranted.

At the same time, these institutions consistently note the limitations they face—particularly restricted access to occupied territories and to the Russian Federation. These constraints affect the scale of verification but do not negate the underlying findings.

In summary, the general direction of international institutional assessment is cautious but consistent: verified cases establish the legal basis, while the full scale of the conduct is likely greater than what can currently be confirmed.

In the most recent report of the UN Commission of Inquiry, there is a determination that the deportation and forcible transfer of children constitute crimes against humanity. The Commission also concluded that certain acts amount to enforced disappearances of children. This represents a progression in their legal assessment.

In earlier reports, these actions had already been recognized as war crimes by the UN Commission of Inquiry and by the UN Human Rights Monitoring Mission in Ukraine. There have also been multiple OSCE Moscow Mechanism reports, including one specifically focused on children, which documented deportations and forcible transfers.

These findings are based on verified facts rather than broad numerical estimates. The reports also explicitly acknowledge their limitations. For example, the Commission has repeatedly noted that it has received no substantive responses from the Russian Federation to its requests for information.

Jacobsen: The Commission submitted dozens of such requests.

Syniuk: Yes, and they are constrained by that lack of cooperation. They also do not have access to Russian territory or to occupied territories, so their investigations rely heavily on witnesses and evidence available in Ukrainian-controlled areas.

Jacobsen: So the figure of 1,205—used as a basis for their legal conclusions—can be presented as a careful, evidence-based assessment. That is, based on the best available evidence and an impartial evaluation, the Commission and similar bodies have concluded that specific crimes have occurred.

Syniuk: Yes, that is a fair characterization. It is also important to emphasize that the number itself is not determinative of whether a crime exists. For both war crimes and crimes against humanity, the legal threshold does not depend on reaching a particular numerical scale.

Crimes against humanity require a policy and a pattern of conduct, but that does not mean a large number of victims is required. The focus is on the existence of a systematic or widespread practice.

At the same time, it is essential to clearly communicate the practical limitations faced by all investigative mechanisms—whether international or domestic. Without access to occupied territories or to the Russian Federation, and without official data from Russian authorities, verification is inherently constrained.

There are children still in occupied territories who may be transferred at any time without documentation. There are children who have lost their parents during the conflict and whose status as orphans or children deprived of parental care is not fully documented.

There are also children born in occupied territories. Under international law, these remain Ukrainian territories, as occupation is a temporary condition. However, without access, documentation, or registration in Ukrainian systems, tracking these children becomes extremely difficult.

These limitations must be clearly stated when interpreting the available data.

Jacobsen: It creates a difficult situation—children effectively existing outside formal recognition.

Syniuk: Yes.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for your time today.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Dear God and Company: Confronting Clergy Abuse and the System That Enables It

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2025/08/11

Clergy sexual abuse is not confined to any one faith, denomination, or country—it is a global crisis rooted in power, secrecy, and institutional self-preservation. In this conversation, survivors, advocates, clergy, legal scholars, and researchers confront the patterns that allow abuse to persist and the systemic enablers who shield perpetrators from accountability. From the misuse of spiritual authority to the failure of church leadership to act, their testimonies reveal both the depth of the harm and the urgent need for reform. Together, they ask the questions that religious institutions have long avoided—and challenge the structures that have turned sacred spaces into sites of betrayal.

Katherine Archer is the co-founder of Prosopon Healing and a graduate student in Theological Studies, soon to begin a Master’s in Counseling Psychology. Her work lies at the intersection of academic research and nonprofit advocacy, focusing on clergy abuse within the Eastern Orthodox Church. Archer champions policy reform to address adult clergy exploitation, advancing a vision of healing rooted in justice, accountability, and survivor support.

Irene Deschênes, a survivor of clergy sexual abuse, first reported her case to the Diocese of London (Ontario) in 1992. Nearly three decades later—after a Supreme Court of Canada ruling—she reached a civil settlement in 2021. With a background in sociology and a career in social services, Deschênes co-founded Outrage Canada, a national, non-religious coalition demanding accountability from the Roman Catholic Church and justice for victims. Known for asking Canadians, “Where’s the outrage?” she works to prevent further abuse, protect children, and keep survivor voices in the public conversation through media appearances and documentary work.

Amos N. Guiora, J.D., Ph.D., a legal scholar and former IDF officer, has made a career of confronting institutional complicity and promoting bystander accountability. Author of The Crime of Complicity, Armies of Enablers, and The Complicity of Silence, Guiora draws direct lines between Holocaust history and modern abuse cases. His advocacy was instrumental in Utah’s 2021 bystander law, and through the Bystander Initiative, he presses for survivor-centered legal reforms. “All hands on deck,” he insists.

Father Bojan Jovanović, a Serbian Orthodox priest and Secretary of the Union of Christians of Croatia, is recognized for his unflinching critiques of institutional failings within the Church. His book Confession: How We Killed God and his leadership in the Alliance of Christians of Croatia reflect his commitment to ethical reform and moral reckoning. Jovanović calls for transparency and open dialogue as prerequisites for restoring trust in religious life.

Rev. Dr. John C. Lentz Jr. led Forest Hill Presbyterian Church in Cleveland Heights, Ohio, for more than three decades. Known for his passionate preaching and deep commitment to justice, compassion, and community leadership, Lentz retired in 2024 after a distinguished ministry. During his tenure, he inherited and confronted the traumatic legacy of clergy sexual abuse, guiding the congregation through its aftermath.

John Metsopoulos, a former Connecticut state representative and Fairfield’s first selectman, has publicly accused two Greek Orthodox bishops—Metropolitan Athenagoras Aneste (2017–2019) and the late Metropolitan Iakovos Garmatis (1970)—of sexual and psychological abuse, as well as financial misconduct. Now living in Central America, Metsopoulos advocates for institutional accountability and supports fellow survivors through the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests (SNAP).

Dr. Hermina Nedelescu, a neuroscientist at Scripps Research in San Diego, investigates the brain’s circuitry to better understand the neurobiological roots of abnormal behavior, particularly in the context of trauma and substance use. Her current research examines how sexual trauma is encoded in the brain, with the goal of improving therapeutic strategies for PTSD and addiction comorbidity.

Professor David K. Pooler, Ph.D., LCSW-S, teaches at Baylor University’s Diana R. Garland School of Social Work. Specializing in trauma, abuse, and institutional responses to misconduct, Pooler is a committed advocate for survivors. His research focuses on systemic injustice and ethical accountability within faith-based organizations.

Dorothy Small, a retired registered nurse, has been a vocal survivor advocate with SNAP for decades. Having endured both childhood and adult clergy abuse, she began speaking out long before the #MeToo movement brought wider attention to such experiences. A cancer survivor and grandmother, she now writes about recovery, resilience, and personal freedom, amplifying survivor voices and pressing for institutional reform.

Michelle Stewart is a cult survivor, author, and activist whose memoir Judas Girl: My Father, Four Cults & How I Escaped Them All recounts her harrowing upbringing in extremist religious groups. Now based in Colorado, Stewart advocates for survivors of religious abuse, focusing on the harms of coercive control and religious trauma in children. Through public speaking, education, and support work, she pushes for greater awareness and protection for the vulnerable.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Drawing on your experience, conversations, and research, what broad trends and facts have emerged—either definitively or with near-conclusive certainty—in international cases of clergy-related abuse? Which truths, when stated consistently and publicly, are most crucial for reshaping the informational landscape—not only around misconduct in general, but clergy abuse in particular?

Katherine Archer: Clergy abuse has nothing whatsoever to do with sex; rather, it is sexualized violence that, at its root, is about power and control. We are now learning that the majority of clergy abuse survivors may be adult women, but because historically adult abuse has been mislabeled as an “affair,” women do not easily come forward and report their experiences. Many women delay disclosure or never disclose, and this isolation in secret-keeping exacerbates the injury.

Finally, clergy sexual abuse cannot be separated from spiritual abuse. There is significant spiritual injury before or as part of the abuse, and it is inseparable from the clergy abuse. This causes a truly profound double-injury, in that typically a victim-survivor has greater difficulty turning to a Higher Power or to one’s spirituality or religion to heal from a tremendous injury. In this way, it differs from other types of violence, wherein one might decide to turn to a Higher Power to heal. The place of healing is also a place of injury. It is like taking medicine that also feels poisonous.

There is a third, even greater injury when a religious community aligns against a victim-survivor. I would say that in most communities, congregants might understand that a priest exploiting an adult congregant is abusive as a theoretical idea. Still, when it comes to a situation in front of them, they do not view the adult victim that they know as an injured party. It’s common to label the adult victim with a mental illness in a derisive, dismissive way, and this is yet another abuse. If a victim-survivor is experiencing symptoms of what is termed mental illness, perhaps the priest’s actions induced depression, anxiety, or whatever it may be. The victim is not “crazy.” This is ignorant, and it’s unacceptable.

Irene Deschênes: What I have seen, not only from my personal experience, but also with working with other survivors of clergy sexual abuse, is that the church hierarchy’s knee-jerk reaction is to contact their lawyers before doing anything else. One would think a moral institution that purports to offer compassion and care to the most marginalized in society would instead take a pastoral approach to survivors who come forward. Sadly, this happens more often than not. First, the Catholic Church attempts to litigate its way out of dealing with the real issue – care and healing of the victim they created. Don’t get me wrong, most survivors need the monetary compensation that a civil suit might provide to deal with an interrupted work history. However, most victims merely want to hear, “What happened to you was wrong. It should never have happened to you. This is what we’re going to do…and, what do you need from us?” These words were never spoken to any survivor I have worked with in the 33 years that I have been advocating for and with survivors.

Secondly, members of the hierarchy, globally, obfuscate when speaking to their flock, the media, the public, and, more importantly, to survivors that come forward. The Roman Catholic Church have staff and unlimited financial resources. How can survivors’ voices, individually or even collectively, ever be heard with limited to no resources to tell our truths?

Thirdly, the secrecy is mind-boggling. Whether it be with meeting a member of the hierarchy or in litigation, a lot of information is held to the chest. Canon law even speaks of ‘secret files’ that must be maintained. Most survivors are told they are “the only victim,” and there is no way to verify or refute it. The church hierarchy has this information but refuses to release it to the public or even to lawyers or plaintiffs. It’s common knowledge that perpetrators rarely only have one victim; therefore, it’s of great importance that victims know they are not alone and that there have potentially been allegations against a clergy perpetrator.

The seal of the confession is making news in the United States as of late. Roman Catholic priests who learn of a child being abused by a penitent (one confessing to a priest) are not required under canon law to report the abuse. In Canada, everyone is a mandated reporter. Everyone. However, those professionals who work with the marginalized in our communities have a greater obligation to report. Does canon law supersede civil law? The church seems to think so.

Finally, on our website, our values are the extreme opposite of what the church espouses vs. what they do, in my experience.

Dr. Amos Guiora: To fully appreciate clergy abuse requires that we recognize the critical role played by enablers. While attention is generally focused on the perpetrator of the abuse, the role of the person in a position of authority/status who knows or should know of harm to vulnerable individuals demands our attention. That is the individual I define as the enabler. In a series of books and articles, I have argued that the enabler must be held accountable for the harm they caused. It is for this reason that I have engaged with legislators, the media, the broader public, survivors, and thought leaders both in the U.S. and internationally, with the aim of criminalizing enablers by enacting legislation addressing the crime of enabling.

In examining clergy abuse, I have focused on the actor who directly protects the institution, indirectly the perpetrator. Interactions with clergy abuse survivors shed powerful light on the harm caused by the enabler upon recognition that the perpetrator had previously abused and should not have had access to the vulnerable individual.

As I learned when writing two books addressing enablers, Armies of Enablers, and The Complicity of Silence, and a series of law review articles, the impact of the harm caused by enablers was, more often than not, a revelation (the word is not used theologically) to the survivors whose primary focus, for understandable reasons, been on the perpetrators. However, when we would “reverse engineer” the interaction with the perpetrator, the survivor would come to understand that absent the enabler, the abuser would not have been able to commit the heinous crime/s they did.

While I am not a person of faith (I am a secular Jew), I have come to appreciate the powerful role of the Church as an institution and the clergy as an individual in the life of a person of faith. Undoubtedly, in the overwhelming majority of cases, this triangular relationship is positive. Of great significance to the believer, the question before us is what happens when abuse occurs and is reported to faith leaders. THAT (caps intended) is the question that demands our attention; as I have come to learn, in many cases, the report is either not believed or the abuse of clergy is “shuffled” off to another location. Both reactions are devastating for the survivor who was not only physically abused but, no less significantly, emotionally injured.

Understanding the harm caused to them would result in neither punishment of the perpetrator nor acknowledgment of the abuse to which they had been subjected, which often resulted in re-victimization. This is the essence of institutional complicity, whereby (in the faith context), faith leaders make the conscious decision to prioritize the “good name” of the church, thereby casting asunder the survivor for whom, in many cases, the abusive clergy was an individual whom they revered and held in the highest regard.

The all-but instinctual reaction to hunker down, reflective of institutional protection, is oft-repeated, almost akin to a time-tested manual with one clear purpose: protect the institution, consequences to the individual be damned. Criminalizing the enabler is necessary to address institutional complicity that protects the abuser while re-victimizing the survivor and placing in harm’s way individuals who will encounter an abusive clergy in the future. Who is the beneficiary of the act of enabling by those whose primary obligation is to protect the vulnerable?

In a clergy-faith context, failure to address the consequences of the harm caused by the enablers is akin to saying to people of faith: we knowingly abandon you, and no less egregiously, we are consciously placing other vulnerable individuals in harm’s way. That, in a nutshell, is the essence of enabling.

The time to act is now, with the understanding that as the lines are written, an individual who should have been protected is in harm’s way because of enablers who have committed the act of enabling. To address this, we need an “all hands-on deck” approach, inspired by a handwritten letter from a Holocaust survivor who once wrote me, “You give voice to the voiceless.”

Ask any survivor: we do not have the luxury of time; given the numbers and accounts of clergy abuse, addressing the crime of enabling demands our immediate attention.

Fr. Bojan Jovanović: First hard fact: Abuse within religious structures is not a “failure” of individuals, but a result of a hierarchical system that enables complete control, isolation, and impunity for perpetrators. Abuse happened—and continues to happen—precisely because of the power that religious office holds: the unquestioning of authority, manipulation of conscience, and the belief that the institution stands above the law. These are not isolated incidents; they are patterns.

The handling of internal disciplinary processes, without mandatory reporting to the state, has allowed rapists to be transferred from one location to another without any punishment. These “internal proceedings” are nothing more than a smokescreen to evade legal accountability. Every such cover-up is an act of complicity, which, in legal terms, qualifies as aiding and abetting or concealing a criminal offense.

Thousands of victims never got the chance to speak out because they were threatened with spiritual consequences—that they would be excommunicated, that they would “harm the Church,” that they would lose their community. This is institutional intimidation. In many cases, those who tried to report abuse were ridiculed, belittled, and their testimonies discredited.

To this day, in many countries, there is no legal framework that obligates religious officials to report suspected sexual abuse. This puts religious institutions above the law, and this must be dismantled in public discourse. Because an institution that delivers moral sermons while protecting rapists is not a sanctuary—it is an organization that must be held accountable like any other. If not more so.

Rev. Dr. John C. Lentz Jr.: What must be consistently stated in public discourse is the amount of clergy sexual abuse (aka “misconduct”) that continues to occur. Furthermore, it is not just a Roman Catholic issue.

I think it is important to note what denominations have done in the past 20 years or so to confront cases of abuse. For example. I know that in the Presbyterian Church USA, there are now criminal background checks for every hire of pastors, Directors of CE, Music directors, and staff. Sexual misconduct trainings are held for all elected leaders of the congregation, and all who volunteer with children (birth through 18) must have said training. Any allegations against a pastor must be reported to the Presbytery (regional governing authority,) and all allegations must be shared with all other Presbyteries if a job transfer is requested. However, it has not stopped abuse from taking place.

In the PCUSA, pastors are legally mandated to report cases of sexual abuse and misconduct. If a pastor is accused, then the Associate Pastor or Clerk of Session (ordained lay leaders) is legally mandated to report the pastor.

I think that most Protestant denominations have moved in the right direction in the matter of sexual misconduct and abuse in the past two decades. However, enabling and covering up continue. The status and perceived power of the pastor or priest continue to create barriers to reporting and accountability.

John Metsopoulos: It is not the fault of the abused, and it can happen at any age. It is a fallacy that it only happens to the young. The abuser uses many forms of abuse, including physical, sexual, emotional, and financial. They may use others to degrade the victims and increase their power and control over the victims. The abuser starts building up the abused, making them feel special, and then they begin to tear them down. In addition, the abuser attempts to alienate them from family, friends, and persons who might see a change in the behavior of the abused. Once they are isolated, the abused now has no one to trust, and the abuser now has complete control over the victims. The abused feels totally alone emotionally and mentally. The abused is further confused as they may enjoy the physical aspect of the abuse, as the body tends to respond to the abuse.

The abused hunt their victims, and seek out victims for the innocence of a person and their depth of faith. The stronger the faith, the greater the opportunity for the abuser. The abuser seeks out individuals whose family is going through turmoil. The abuser seeks out victims whose families have deep faith and would never believe a member of the clergy would abuse anyone. They make the victims feel that what is normal in their lives is abnormal and only they can bring normalcy. Abuse is a total, all-consuming devastation that leaves them alone and deprived of self-respect.

Dr. Hermina Nedelescu: The first truth is this: accused sexual offenders employed as “clergy” by Church institutions often remain in ministry—unimpeded—unless they are criminally convicted and physically imprisoned. Church administrators routinely go to extraordinary lengths to shield or reassign these individuals, often prioritizing institutional reputation over victim safety. This persistent pattern is exactly why enabling behavior must be criminalized, as law professor Amos Guiora has argued through his extensive work on the “enabler” phenomenon.

There is a noteworthy trend. In the Russian and even in Romanian Orthodox churches in Russia and Romania, sexual perpetrators are held accountable at higher rates than sexual perpetrators in Orthodox churches in the United States. Our preliminary data show that more accused clergy are defrocked or penalized by the Russian Orthodox Church in Russia compared to other jurisdictions.

The second truth is even more grotesque: victims of clergy sexual abuse are frequently blamed for their abuse. Church officials often reverse the roles, casting the victim as the perpetrator and the perpetrator as the misunderstood “man of God.” The immense power differential between clergy and laity suddenly disappears from their moral calculus.

We are talking about a crime—so, lacking any legitimate defense, they default to blaming the victim. I read about a case that involved a 4-year-old child accused of “encouraging” an adult man by wearing his boxer shorts. If defenders can stoop to blaming a toddler, they certainly won’t hesitate to call the abuse of an adult woman an “affair” or something “consensual.” That word—“consensual”—has become a favorite among Church apologists, conveniently ignoring the inherent coercion that comes from spiritual authority. But sexual abuse cloaked in sacraments is still sexual assault, which is a crime. Calling it “consensual” doesn’t make a crime any less criminal.

The third truth is a demographic pattern that should raise immediate red flags: clergy sexual abuse cases often involve victims who are decades younger than their abusers. Many of these clergy are well beyond retirement age, yet inexplicably remain in active ministry—exempt from both moral scrutiny and mandatory rest.

And finally, at a recent academic conference on religion and sexual abuse, we presented findings from our research into hundreds of clergy sexual abuse cases within Orthodox Christian communities. The data is clear: the Orthodox Church has a clergy sexual abuse problem. This is not hearsay. This is research-based.

Among U.S.-based Orthodox jurisdictions, the Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of America stands out for having the highest number of reported sexual misconduct cases in the public domain. Oddly enough, this American jurisdiction answers to a high-ranking official based in Istanbul—who was even honored this year with the Templeton Prize for his climate change advocacy.

I find it deeply troubling that a man can be celebrated while disregarding the suffering of women and children who were, and continue to be, abused by clergy under his spiritual authority. There can be no climate justice without social justice. Yet while victims suffer here at home, ultimate decision-making power remains half a world away, seemingly more invested in liturgical pageantry and accolades than in justice for the abused.

Dr. David Pooler: In public discourse around clergy sexual abuse, we must first name it as a phenomenon that is about the abuse and misuse of power, role, and position of a religious authority. The responsibility for the safety of people in interpersonal relationships is on the professional in a position of power. And this is especially true in relationships where someone with more power represents God.

This religious authority does not have to be a pastor or priest only. It is far more about the way the person has power in any given religious system. Even a volunteer who is given much authority and power can use their position to have sex with someone they support.

When the victim is an adult, we must unequivocally state it is not an “affair” and the person being targeted is not “participating willingly.” We must smash the idea that the victim in adult clergy sexual abuse wants this or should be responsible for stopping it. The harm done to a victim is profound and complex. The reason this is so urgent is that officials and spokespersons within religious systems continue to use the idea that it is an unfortunate case of consenting adults who had an inappropriate relationship. The longer we tolerate a false and misleading narrative like this, the longer clergy sexual abuse can be done with impunity, and the harm done to survivors overlooked or minimized.

Dorothy Small: The firm facts and broad trends—based on my personal experience and on conversations with other survivors of clergy-related abuse, whether as adults or as children—are consistent across international cases: dismissal, disbelief, victim-blaming and shaming, retaliation and ostracism after reporting, loss of faith or religious community, and the protection of clergy perpetrators and institutions over the needs of the abused. Silence is rewarded; speaking out is punished, often for the very reasons I’ve listed.

Victims frequently struggle with the emotional impact of grooming tactics. Trauma bonding formed through intensive grooming creates a powerful attachment, akin to an addictive mood-altering substance on brain chemistry. This bond gives the illusion of being “in love,” fostering an addictive pattern that overrides rational judgment. Pursuit behaviors—chasing after what once felt good—are fueled by intermittent reinforcement, alternating “love-bombing” with withdrawal and emotional coercion. This cycle drives the exploited person to dismiss the pain in search of the next emotional high. The victim often falsely believes their involvement was “consensual,” when in reality it was the result of manipulation, not genuine care or love.

Regardless of age, gender, ethnicity, or culture, human beings tend to respond similarly to such abuse, though specific factors can create unique challenges. For example, males sexually abused by males often experience heightened embarrassment and shame, which can adversely affect sexuality. Adults abused by clergy frequently feel responsible not only for what happened but also carry the guilt and shame projected onto them by their abuser.

Michelle Stewart: While most Eastern Orthodox clergy are not abusers, the hierarchical structure creates an environment in which abuse can flourish. Though the majority of clergy are likely well-intentioned, the system of spiritual authority within the Eastern Orthodox Church often acts as a petri dish for misconduct. Allegations must typically pass through multiple layers of hierarchy, where, in my experience, the benefit of the doubt is more often given to the accused than to the victim.

A well-documented example is the case against my former brother-in-law, Fr. Matthew Williams. Another is St. Innocent’s Academy, where reports of student abuse were ignored or minimized for years. In both cases, the Church’s delayed response not only obscured the misconduct but effectively enabled it.

The Church frequently resists external oversight, minimizing legal accountability. When it does respond to allegations, legal action is often delayed or actively resisted. My first encounter with this came nearly twenty years ago in the case of Christ of the Hills Monastery, when ROCOR (Russian Orthodox Church Outside Russia) vigorously defended monks accused of child sexual abuse—even supplying character witnesses. As the then-spouse of one such witness, I overheard private conversations in which participants acknowledged the allegations could be credible. Yet the institutional response prioritized church sovereignty over victim protection, with statements like “this is a matter for confession” or, more bluntly, “this is none of the legal system’s business.” Similar dynamics are now playing out in the Fr. Matthew Williams case.

Confession and the authority of the spiritual father are often weaponized to silence victims. In Judas Girl, reflecting on my own experiences and broader patterns of abuse—particularly within ROCOR—I wrote: “There is no greater predator than the one who convinces you they have power over your soul.” Those unfamiliar with Eastern Orthodoxy may underestimate the influence of the spiritual father, especially within the sacrament of confession.

While I do not advocate eliminating confession for those who find it spiritually meaningful, it is important to note two critical points: In many states, clergy are mandatory reporters; however, the seal of confession often exempts them. Many Orthodox believers are taught that obedience to one’s spiritual father is essential for salvation—even when that guidance is ethically or spiritually troubling.

In my own case, when I disclosed emotional or spiritual abuse by my husband or clergy during confession, I was rebuked and told I was spiritually deficient for harboring resentment. I was told such matters were not mine to speak of, but rather the abuser’s to confess. This pattern is not unique to me. Several victims I’ve spoken with shared that after disclosing sexual abuse during confession, they were advised not to speak publicly—reinforcing a culture of silence and spiritual coercion.

Jacobsen: What question is the most crucial to ask about clergy-related abuse to you?

Archer: The most urgent question is why all 50 states do not have legislation holding criminally liable clergy persons who misuse their position of trust and authority. A clergyperson is in a position of trust and power relative to their congregant. A doctor or therapist cannot sexualize a relationship with a patient because professional ethics and state boards recognize the power differential and expressly prohibit this behavior. It is known to be abuse. There are no state boards for clergy. Why is it that clergy get a “pass” on ethical standards, when I would argue that there is even more implicit trust and intimacy in a relationship of soul-care?

I view this from the perspective of an Orthodox Christian, with an understanding of the long history of soul-care within Orthodox Christianity; however, the spiritual intimacy between clergyperson and congregant holds within many other faith traditions as well. Orthodox tradition recognizes a long history of psychotherapy, or care of the psyche. This is different from mental health therapy as it is practiced with a superbill and a co-pay, but truly no different ethically if a priest sexually abuses a man or woman who has gone to him for help. It should be criminalized so that a victim-survivor can gain some understanding of the injury, and a priest cannot continue to pastor.

In the absence of this kind of law in every state, many church bodies “investigate” these abuses as though they were affairs. There may be substantial evidence of what we term misconduct, but it is viewed through the lens of it being an “affair.” This is a reprehensible protection of the institution over a human person who has experienced severe injury. Church investigating bodies, which include attorneys and clergy, inflict greater injuries when sexualized violence is mislabeled as an “affair.” As a society, we should demand that all clergy understand this issue– even if religious seminaries are not addressing this subject well enough for clergy to use the correct language.

Deschênes: The hashtag I used on Twitter was #thechurchcantpoliceitself—and that’s exactly what has been happening for a long time. There is no transparency, only secrecy. All matters are handled internally, leaving victims unaware of what discussions take place or what decisions are made. Many survivors are told the offending clergy is no longer serving their community. Yet, in reality, they often remain in place or are quietly transferred to another parish—sometimes across provincial or federal borders—where new victims can be found.

The Roman Catholic Church, as many can attest, has changed little in its thinking or modus operandi. The few changes that do occur happen over a lifetime, not years or decades. The Church should reevaluate how it responds to victims. One member of the hierarchy once said, when told that most victims simply want an apology, “That can’t happen, because then we set ourselves up for litigation.” Survivors who have endured litigation know how arduous, re-traumatizing, and drawn-out the process can be—delaying healing, if healing is even possible.

My question is: why not evolve and change your approach when a victim of sexual assault by one of your members comes forward? Why is litigation the first response? Why protect your “brother” instead of a member of your flock? What do you lose by treating victims with compassion and care?

I believe the secrecy exists to protect the Church’s reputation. It may have worked in the past. But with the internet, survivors can find one another, offer mutual support, and learn—often through the media—about credible allegations against clergy. What is the Church’s real reputation today? Person A: “Our parish priest was charged with sexual assault.” Person B: “Another one? Well, that’s the Catholic Church for you.” That is the reality now. What institution would want that?

Metsopoulos: What is the true number of cases of abuse by clergy? It seems that a true figure does not exist. It is important to get a true number, as it is a lot higher than the churches or their attorneys admit. They do not want to face the problem, as it is a problem that is at the core of the church’s organization. The abusers in the churches are the majority of the institution. The clergy all have incriminating evidence on each other and blackmail each other to silence each other preventing the truth from coming out. To get a true figure would decimate the churches, and it would become apparent that the rot goes all the way to the top.

Also, the legal professionals associated with the churches are not concerned with the truth coming out, but with protecting the church, allowing the abuse to continue.

The attorneys and churches, under the pretext of wanting to end clergy abuse, seek victims to share their traumatic events to bring justice, when in fact they are attempting to cover the tracks of the abusers and discredit the victims of abuse. The goal is not to achieve justice for the victims but to evade the law. The attorneys play both sides against the middle. They are the worst of the legal profession and, in some ways, worse than the abuser, by providing false hope for the abused.

Why are victims afraid to come forward?

The victims are victimized by the church, the public, friends, and family. They feel isolated, empty, and guilty for coming forward. They feel shame and guilt for allowing it to happen and allowing it to continue. They may confuse healthy sexual relations with abuse. In the end, the victim is victimized and left alone.

Nedelescu: The most urgent question is this: Why are church officials who knowingly enable clergy sexual abuse not held criminally liable?

People including Melania Sakoda and Cappy Larson have spent decades cataloging the crimes of abusive clergy within the Orthodox Church (all jurisdictions), and while that work is continuing by Katherine and I, it is no longer enough. A new frontier of accountability must now target the enablers—the bishops, chancellors, general counsels, and senior administrators who receive complaints, suppress evidence, intimidate victims, move or cover for perpetrators, and then dare to call themselves “spiritual leaders,” “protecting the Church,” or seeking “truth.”

These enablers rarely touch the criminal justice system. Why? Because our legal frameworks still treat institutional cowardice and bureaucratic cover-up as unfortunate oversights rather than as deliberate acts that perpetuate harm. And yet, without the enabler, the perpetrator cannot persist. The real scandal is not just the abuse—it’s the system that sustains it.

We must stop pretending these enablers are merely misguided managers. They are collaborators. Their silence, their memos, their settlement clauses—all of it—forms the infrastructure of abuse. And until we criminalize enabling behavior, the Church will continue protecting predators while branding survivors as “unstable,” “sinful,” “temptress,” or “misunderstood.”

The urgent question is no longer “Who abused?” but “Who knew—and did nothing?” And if the answer is a bishop or a synod or a patriarch, the next question must be: When will that enabler be indicted?

Pooler: To further advance the study of justice in clergy-related abuse, the most crucial question to ask is what barriers stand in the way of churches setting up rigorous protocols to prevent abuse from happening and responding well when abuse is discovered or reported? One answer is Clericalism, the invisible force at play that teaches people to trust a spiritual authority and distrust themselves blindly. Religious leaders benefit from this arrangement, and therefore, religious systems appear impervious primarily to outside feedback and seem to struggle to reflect and accurately appraise how well they train leaders, develop useful processes to deal with abuse, and respond to survivors. In my observation, churches are largely ineffectual in addressing these issues and cannot admit it to themselves or others. And truly, one of my most profound questions is “why”? It would seem to me that churches could lead the way and model to society the virtues of kindness, generosity, care, and create robust and thoughtful responses when a leader injures someone in their care. But churches appear to fail at this repeatedly and often. And a second question is, why aren’t churches asking this question for their own sake? The fact that there isn’t a great answer to either of these questions deeply troubles me.

Small: The most urgent question about clergy abuse is this: Why is it still an issue today, given the decades of documented complaints, known victims, and our expanded understanding of the serious, lifelong health consequences? Addiction, for example, is one such consequence, with far-reaching effects. It is a global epidemic, and research has long shown that at the root of addiction often lies complex post-traumatic stress and other severe mental health conditions, frequently stemming from abusive relationships and relational traumas.

In other caregiving professions, abuse has been met with legal consequences—heavy fines, imprisonment, and loss of licenses—effectively removing offenders from positions of trust. Yet in religious institutions, whose reach and influence are vast, the problem persists. This is a public safety crisis of epic proportions. The data clearly show the profound damage such abuse inflicts on mental and physical health. The most powerful institutions have the capacity either to heal and unify, as they were meant to, or to cause lasting harm, as history has shown.

Why, then, is it so difficult for religious institutions to sanction and remove offenders instead of shielding them—often by transferring them to new locations where they can prey on the vulnerable again? The Catholic Church’s global presence, for instance, allows abusers to be relocated to other countries, where they continue to exploit trust. Vulnerability is universal; trust itself makes anyone susceptible. While minors are the most at risk, vulnerability spans all ages.

Why is immediate corrective action so rare when credible accusations arise? At the very least, institutions could remove the accused from active roles and make their names public. By the time a survivor fully recognizes they were abused, decades may have passed. Concealing an abuser’s identity only leaves others at risk. During the grooming phase, a victim may sense something is wrong, but the perpetrator—armed with authority and institutional backing—can manipulate, plant doubt, and gaslight the target into confusion and compliance. This dynamic not only weakens victims but also enables escalating abuse.

Stewart: The most urgent question is: How can external accountability be meaningfully enforced within the Eastern Orthodox Church, particularly among the clergy?

Abuse can occur in any organization and may never be fully eradicated. However, the decisive factor is how institutions—especially those in positions of authority—respond when abuse surfaces. Their response determines whether the organization actively works against abuse or inadvertently becomes a breeding ground for it. In hierarchical systems like Eastern Orthodoxy, abuse is not merely the result of individual misconduct; it is often facilitated—and concealed—by the very structures designed to provide spiritual guidance. The rigid church hierarchy, combined with the protections of confession, can allow perpetrators to avoid legal scrutiny, while internal mechanisms have consistently failed to safeguard victims.

As documented abuse cases accumulate, the Church—and those responsible for holding it accountable—now stand at a critical crossroads. Raising awareness is an essential first step, but the next imperative is to implement enforceable mechanisms of accountability that address and dismantle the systemic enablers of abuse. While some within the Church hierarchy may resist what they perceive as external intrusion, there is, hopefully, a broader majority of clergy and faithful who are willing to support reform. Their participation is not only desirable—it is likely essential to achieving meaningful change.

Jacobsen: Everyone, thank you for taking a little time to discuss this straightforward topic with complex derivatives. I appreciate the courage, forthrightness, and honesty.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Ukraine’s Drone Warfare Evolution

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/04/24

How are women participating in Ukrainian drone units, and what challenges do operators face on the modern battlefield? Drone instructor Oleksandr Korzh shares frontline realities.

By Scott Douglas Jacobsen · April 7, 2026 · Interview


About Oleksandr Korzh

Oleksandr Korzh is a Ukrainian defence technology instructor, drone pilot, and trainer with the volunteer organisation Dignitas Ukraine. Drawing on frontline experience, he focuses on the operational integration of unmanned systems, drone interception, and modern battlefield technologies. Korzh has trained military personnel in FPV drone operations, interceptor systems, and electronic warfare techniques, while linking technology developers with combat units to accelerate innovation cycles. He has also participated in international defence-technology workshops and hackathons across Europe.


From the Margins to the Cockpit: Women Entering Drone Operations

In democratic societies, military participation tends to broaden as those societies become more open. For Ukraine, a country fighting to defend its sovereignty while simultaneously modernising its institutions, the question of who serves — and in what capacity — carries profound significance.

Drone operations have emerged as one arena where the traditional gender divide in military roles is genuinely less relevant. Unlike Special Forces selection, which involves extreme physical demands that historically result in low female participation, drone piloting relies on precision, spatial awareness, and mental endurance — qualities that cross gender lines.

Question — Scott Douglas Jacobsen: What percentage of women are involved in drone operations? What is the trend? How is representation developing within drone units or battalions? How are women integrated into these roles within the current Ukrainian forces?

Answer — Oleksandr Korzh: Hundreds of young women have joined drone-related units across Ukraine’s armed forces. Two years ago, many began using drones primarily for reconnaissance missions — a gateway role that allowed greater female participation. A colleague of mine, a former competitive tennis player who nearly went professional, is now considering entering drone operations. She is young and has excellent eyesight.

However, the situation later became more dangerous. Russian forces began deliberately targeting drone crews — operators, pilots, and navigators — because drones play such a central role in modern battlefield reconnaissance and strike operations. Casualties among drone teams, including women, have been reported, and these losses have had a significant emotional and symbolic impact within Ukrainian military society, prompting public discussion and media coverage.


“Everyone understands that being a pilot or a drone operator, even in the rear, is not a safe role. As a result, fewer women wanted to join these divisions.” — Oleksandr Korzh, Dignitas Ukraine


The Physical Reality: Sleep, Cold, and Constant Concealment

Public perception of drone warfare often conjures images of operators in climate-controlled rooms, far from harm. The reality Korzh describes is starkly different. Drone crews near the front line routinely operate for multiple consecutive nights, sheltering in partially destroyed structures with no sanitation, unreliable food supplies, and intermittent access to water.

Question — Jacobsen: Is sleep deprivation a major part of that job?

Answer — Korzh: Yes. The constant fatigue is one of the hardest parts. But the most difficult task is remaining well hidden and avoiding detection. Russia uses guided aerial munitions — large ordnance equipped with wings and control systems that allow them to glide to a target from long distances. Many are older Soviet-era bombs modified with guidance kits.

If a Russian reconnaissance drone identifies the probable location of one of our drone crews — in a small building, a house, or an underground shelter — they may deploy several guided munitions from over 100 kilometres away. Each costs many thousands of dollars. They would not typically use such resources against a single infantry soldier. However, they may use them to eliminate a suspected drone team or deny the possibility of using that location in the future.


Key figures:

  • ~200 — Russian vehicles estimated lost in a single day to drone operations
  • 100+ km — Range of guided aerial munitions targeting drone crews
  • #1 — Priority target status for Ukrainian drone operators among opposing forces

Cultural Context: Tradition, Strength, and Wartime Identity

Understanding why women’s participation in frontline drone roles remains limited requires more than a statistical lens. Korzh situates the phenomenon within Ukraine’s cultural and historical fabric — not as evidence of suppression, but as an expression of a distinct social identity under enormous pressure.

Answer — Korzh: Ukrainian society, including the military community, remains patriotic and somewhat traditional. Many soldiers think: “This is our country, this is our land, and we will defend it. Women can help us in the rear — raising children and helping them grow up healthy and educated — while we ensure security.”

This is not because the Ukrainian nation is at a low level of women’s liberation. It reflects traditions shaped by our history and social patterns. During wartime, it is still very difficult for women to carry all these responsibilities, and many men feel a strong desire to protect and care for them. This does not mean that women are weak. They are not weak. They are very strong.

Jacobsen offered a culturally resonant observation: more than one Ukrainian man, friend or colleague, has noted that the thing he fears most is an angry Slavic woman. The humour carries weight. It reflects not subordination but a deep, culturally embedded respect for female strength — strength that operates differently in Ukrainian society than it might in Oslo, New York, or Toronto. The external frameworks of Nordic-style gender politics or North American progressive culture can overlay some meaning, but they do not always capture the full Ukrainian picture.


“They are not weak. They are very strong.” — Oleksandr Korzh, on Ukrainian women in and around the armed forces


Drones as a Strategic Multiplier

Beyond the human dimension, the interview surfaces something of broader strategic significance: Ukraine has leveraged unmanned systems to create an asymmetric advantage in an attritional conflict. Drone units disrupt logistics — described by Korzh as “the blood of war” — degrading the opponent’s ability to resupply, rotate personnel, and maintain momentum.

Russia operates its own elite drone formation — Rubicon — active across aerial, maritime, and ground-based unmanned systems. Yet Ukraine fields a greater number of units, many operating at a high level of proficiency. The volume of opposing equipment destroyed in daily operations reflects not just tactical success but a deliberate strategy of sustained attrition.

Question — Jacobsen: When people hear a number like 200 destroyed vehicles, they may not realise it represents a whole system being disrupted — the full war machine: artillery, drones, missiles, soldiers, and drone teams.

Answer — Korzh: And logistics — it is the blood of war. If we destroy tactical logistics, we can slow or stop the occupation. From a strategic perspective, the goal is to destroy more forces than the other side can recruit each month.


The Bigger Picture: Reporting Gaps and Ground Realities

Korzh and Jacobsen also note the imbalance in how the conflict is reported internationally. Much Western media focuses on one side’s losses while underreporting the other’s — creating a skewed perception of the conflict’s scale and trajectory. Fewer foreign journalists operate in the field now than in earlier phases, even as the intensity of operations continues to rise.

For those seeking accurate understanding, primary sources and on-the-ground voices like Korzh’s remain invaluable. His work — training operators, linking developers with combat units, sharing lessons at international workshops — exemplifies the kind of practical, experience-driven knowledge that shapes how unmanned warfare evolves in real time.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Waleed al-husseini on restrictions on speech and secularism

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): La voie de la raison

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2019

Waleed al-husseini on restrictions on speech and secularism

Waleed Al-Husseini founded the Council of Ex-Muslims in France. He escaped the Palestinian Authority after being tortured and imprisoned in Palestine, Jordan, and then France. He is an ex-Muslim and an atheist.

We have been corresponding and conducting interviews for a long time now. I approached once again to discuss certain principles, seemingly opposed.

These were the ideas of freedom of expression and secularism, then of restricted expression and theocracy. The two are opposed, including the various trends that are emerging.

France’s values ​​tend towards secularism and freedom of expression. Al-Husseini defends values ​​more in line with secularism and similar values. He believes in a firm separation between state and religion. Al-Husseini stated: “All these things do not exist in Islam. It only exists when all Muslims are part of humanity (‘it only exists? What is ‘it’?). But these can then only be calculated within the framework of Islam and Islamic values, which is why they demand the defense of the hijab in the name of freedom, but then attack criticism of Islam in the name of racism.”

Al-Husseini distinguishes between arguments based on race and racism and those concerning Islam and its doctrines in his critique. He views the hijab as an example of slavery and second-class citizenship within society.

In other words, he sees it as a way of viewing women as sexual objects. It also becomes a political tool for more fundamentalist versions and interpretations of Islam. He considers this form of criticism of Islam a fundamental human right enshrined in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.

When I asked questions about Sharia and Sharia courts in certain interpretations of Islam, these can be separated or distinct from universalist law traditions, in which a dual law system can be established and found in a secular society.

However, society will have a dual regime, one of which will be based on theocracy and will therefore violate the fundamental basis of secularism, namely the separation of the mosque and the state.

“That’s what happened in the UK, and that’s why I don’t like secularism and prefer the term ‘lawfulness’! With secularism, they create insular communities, and everyone lets them do whatever they want,” said Al-Husseini. [The last sentence appears to be incomplete and possibly nonsensical: “Your wife within Islam and our religion!”]

He uses this as an argument in favor of separating places of worship from the public and political lives of citizens. He sees the battle for secularism as a long struggle against citizens who desire a secular state.

Al-Husseini argues that education in secularism should begin in the earliest years of an individual’s life. This would mean halting the teaching of religion as true or false in schools, and instead preserving these intellectual battles for young people as a genuine education in the simple facts of faith: believe?

Al-Husseini continued: “Furthermore, we must stop telling children about jihad and we must not separate people into Muslims and non-Muslims! It provides a simplistic view of the world. Let them see us all as human beings with multiple nuances, shades, and types. And governments should have a secularism law and work hard to achieve it!”

He observes a common problem not only in education, but also among people. Since there can be a problem with people who simply do not adhere to the principles of a secular state, this can create an issue.

Another could be obscurantism regarding aspects of certain parts of a faith. Al-Husseini spoke of terms such as Islamophobia, which, from his perspective, is a problem.

“Because, for example, there are jihadists or terrorists who physically attack you, but there are also moderates who attack you in court!” Al-Husseini stated. He can see this in the conflation of definitions between racism, hatred and fear of others because of their ethnicity or appearance, and fanaticism against an individual who believes they are Muslim.

He noted that this was something he had discussed in his latest book . Al-Husseini concluded by asserting that e-Muslims know more about Islam and the paths of Islamism than individual Muslims.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Waleed al-husseini sur les restrictions de la parole et la laïcité

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): waleed-alhusseini.blogspot.com

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2019/04/06

Waleed Al-Husseini a fondé le Conseil des ex-musulmans de France. Il a échappé à l’Autorité palestinienne après avoir été torturé et emprisonné en Palestine, en Jordanie puis en France. C’est un ex-musulman et athée.

Nous correspondons et menons des entretiens depuis longtemps maintenant. Je me suis une fois de plus approché pour parler de certains principes, apparemment ou opposés, apparemment opposés.

C’étaient les idées de liberté d’expression et de laïcité, puis d’expression restreinte et de théocratie. Les deux s’opposent, y compris les diverses tendances qui se dessinent.

Les valeurs de la France tendent à la laïcité et à la liberté d’expression. Al-Husseini défend des valeurs plus en phase avec la laïcité et des valeurs similaires. Il croit en une séparation ferme entre l’État et la religion. Al-Husseini a déclaré: «Toutes ces choses n’existent pas dans l’Islam. Il n’existe que lorsqu’ils sont tous musulmans faisant partie de l’humanité (“cela” n’existe que? Qu’est-ce que “cela”?). Mais ceux-ci ne peuvent alors être calculés que dans le cadre de l’Islam et des valeurs islamiques, raison pour laquelle ils demandent la défense du hijab au nom de la liberté, mais ils attaquent ensuite la critique de l’islam au nom du racisme. “

Al-Husseini fait la distinction entre les arguments sur la race et le racisme et l’Islam et les doctrines dans la critique. Il considère le hijab comme un exemple d’esclavage et de citoyenneté de seconde classe dans le cadre sociétal.

C’est-à-dire qu’il y voit un moyen de considérer les femmes comme un outil sexuel. Il devient également un outil politique pour les versions et les interprétations plus fondamentalistes de l’islam. Il considère cette forme de critique de l’islam comme un droit humain fondamental énoncé dans la Déclaration universelle des droits de l’homme.

Quand j’ai posé des questions sur la charia et les tribunaux de la charia dans certaines interprétations de l’islam, celles-ci peuvent être séparées ou distinctes des traditions de loi universalistes, dans lesquelles un système de double loi peut être établi et trouvé dans une société laïque.

Pourtant, la société aura un double régime dont l’un des deux reposera sur la théocratie et violera donc le fondement fondamental de la laïcité, à savoir la séparation de la mosquée et de l’État.

«C’est ce qui s’est passé au Royaume-Uni et c’est pourquoi je n’aime pas la laïcité et préfère le terme« laïcité »! Avec la laïcité, ils forment des communautés insulaires et tout le monde leur permet de faire ce qu’ils veulent », a déclaré Al-Husseini. votre femme au sein de l’islam et notre religion!

Il en fait un argument en faveur de la séparation du lieu de culte et de la vie publique et politique des citoyens. Il voit la bataille pour la laïcité comme une longue bataille devant les citoyens qui souhaitent un État laïc.

Al-Husseini soutient que l’éducation à la laïcité devrait commencer dès les premières années de la vie d’un individu. En cela, il devrait y avoir un arrêt de l’enseignement de la religion comme vraie ou fausse dans les écoles, mais plutôt de garder ces batailles pour l’esprit des jeunes comme une véritable éducation dans les simples faits de la foi: croyez?

Al-Husseini a poursuivi: « A De plus, nous devons cesser de dire aux enfants sur le djihad et ne doit pas séparer les gens dans les musulmans et les non-musulmans! Il fournit une vision simpliste du monde. Laissons-les nous voir tous comme des êtres humains aux multiples nuances, nuances et types. Et les gouvernements devraient avoir une loi sur la laïcité et travailler dur pour l’obtenir!

Il observe un problème commun non seulement dans l’éducation, mais aussi dans les gens. Comme il peut y avoir un problème chez les personnes qui ne adhèrent tout simplement pas aux principes d’un État laïc, cela peut créer un problème.

Un autre peut être l’obscurantisme à propos d’aspects de certaines parties d’une foi. Al-Husseini a parlé de termes tels que l’islamophobie, de son point de vue, étant un problème.

” Parce que, par exemple, il y a des djihadistes ou des terroristes qui vous attaquent physiquement, mais il y a aussi des modérés qui vous attaquent aussi devant les tribunaux!”, A déclaré Al-Husseini. Il peut le voir dans le mélange des définitions entre racisme, haine et crainte des autres en raison de leur origine ethnique ou de leur apparence, et du fanatisme contre un individu croyant être musulman.

” Il a noté que c’était une chose dont il avait parlé dans son dernier livre. Al-Husseini a conclu sur l’affirmation selon laquelle les e-musulmans en savent plus sur l’islam et sur les voies de l’islamisme que les musulmans pris individuellement.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Entrevue du sceptique Louis Dubépar Scott Douglas Jacobsendu blogue Canadian Atheist

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Le Québec sceptique

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2019/Spring

Scott Douglas Jacobsen : Quels sont vos antécédents familiaux en ce qui concerne la culture, la géographie, la langue et la religion ?

Louis Dubé : Je suis né et j’ai grandi au Québec en tant que catholique au sein de la culture française dominante de la deuxième moitié du XXe siècle. Vers 18 ans, j’ai commencé à douter sérieusement de la validité de la religion en tant que vision du monde. Toutes les religions me semblaient être des mythes pleins de contradictions et en opposition avec de nombreuses découvertes scientifiques en biologie (évolution des espèces) et en astronomie (notre place dans le cosmos). Je suis finalement devenu sceptique à l’égard de toutes les affirmations dépourvues de preuves matérielles et d’arguments valables dans l’interprétation des faits pertinents.

Jacobsen : Quels ont été les moments clés ou les leçons pédagogiques qui vous ont guidé vers une vision plus sceptique du monde ?

Dubé : Avant d’avoir 20 ans, j’avais lu les ouvrages de certains philosophes et romanciers français (Albert Camus, Jean-Paul Sartre). Mais c’est vraiment le philosophe anglais Bertrand Russell (Why I am not a Christian) qui m’a convaincu de la nature mythique des religions, avec ce que j’ai ressenti alors comme de très bons et très clairs arguments contre les croyances fondées sur les dogmes religieux. À peu près à la même époque, j’ai aussi entendu parler du scepticisme de l’un de ses pionniers, Martin Gardner (Fads and Fallacies in the Name of Science). Ces deux auteurs ont largement contribué à mon approche sceptique à l’égard de prétentions non fondées.

Jacobsen : Dans la culture canadienne ou québécoise, qui sont les fraudeurs de toujours ? Quels sont ceux qui viendront ? Comment le public peut-il se protéger de leurs fausses représentations ? Enfin, la culture francophone offre-t-elle une approche différente pour les types de fraudes, que ce soit la médecine alternative (par exemple, le Reiki), les sectaires, les spiritualistes ou les gourous du Nouvel Âge, par rapport à la culture anglophone ? Mon hypothèse est très probablement que non.

Dubé : Il y a une trentaine d’années, lors de la fondation de notre association Les Sceptiques du Québec, les astrologues et les diseuses de bonne aventure étaient relativement populaires. Notre organisation sceptique a consciencieusement réfuté leurs revendications et même offert (pendant environ 25 ans) un « concours de prédictions » pour prouver que n’importe qui peut atteindre au hasard le même pourcentage de bonnes prédictions. Nous nous opposons naturellement aux prétentions paranormales usuelles : fantômes, canalisations, ovnis, colliers miraculeux, monstres imaginaires, etc.

Nous nous efforçons également de réfuter toutes sortes de prétentions pseudoscientifiques : homéopathie, énergie gratuite, remèdes miraculeux de tout type, théories du complot, etc.

L’éducation, notre mission première, est probablement le moyen le plus sûr de protéger le public de ces fausses déclarations. Ce n’est pas une tâche facile, elle est toujours à refaire, mais cela ressemble à ce que font les associations sceptiques du monde entier, quelle que soit leur langue.

Jacobsen : Quels sont les activités et les services fournis par les Sceptiques du Québec et son magazine Le Québec Sceptique ?

Dubé : Nous organisons des conférences mensuelles et publions un magazine (70-80 pages) trois fois par an. Les conférenciers que nous invitons sont des universitaires, des scientifiques, des communicateurs scientifiques ou des auteurs de livres reliés au scepticisme. Les articles que nous publions proviennent des mêmes types de personnes et de sceptiques locaux. Aucun sujet, aussi controversé soit-il, n’est interdit. Pour de franches discussions, nous avons également invité des astrologues, des ufologues, des conspirateurs, des religieux ou des théologiens.

Nous offrons un prix de 10 000 $ à ceux qui sont prêts à prouver leurs prétentions paranormales selon un protocole expérimental rigoureux. Jusqu’à présent, plusieurs se sont présentés mais aucun n’a réussi. Nous hébergeons également sur notre site Web une traduction française du Dictionnaire sceptique de Robert T. Carroll et du Quackwatch de Stephen Barrett.

Jacobsen : Quelle est la façon de penser du scepticisme ? Comment cela diffère-t-il du cynisme ?

Dubé : Notre type de scepticisme ne vient pas d’une position philosophique rigide et dogmatique telle que le cynisme. Il ne s’agit pas du doute systématique, mais du doute méthodologique : c’est plus une méthode permettant de s’assurer que nos idées sont raisonnablement justifiées par des observations quantifiables et des résultats de tests reproductibles. On dit souvent que les vrais sceptiques n’expriment pas d’avis avant d’être confrontés à des démonstrations rigoureuses, en particulier au sujet d’affirmations extraordinaires.

Notre approche, comme celle de la plupart des sceptiques, suit la démarche scientifique : observer la réalité, formuler des hypothèses et tester rigoureusement les prédictions découlant de ces hypothèses. Seules les prédictions correctes donnent à une théorie une chance d’être juste et utile.

Jacobsen : Quelles sont les données démographiques approximatives des Sceptiques du Québec et du Québec Sceptique ?

Dubé : Notre association compte environ 300 membres et vend environ 250 exemplaires de chaque numéro de notre magazine Le Québec sceptique. Nous gérons également un forum sceptique où près de 500 000 messages ont été échangés au cours des 20 dernières années par plus de 5 000 abonnés provenant de la communauté sceptique française et internationale, ainsi que par d’autres personnes voulant échanger. Plusieurs expriment des points de vue opposés, cela conduit à des discussions animées.

Jacobsen : Qui sont les alliés de la lutte canadienne, anglophone et francophone, contre la pseudoscience, la pseudo-histoire, la pseudomédecine et les absurdités en général ?

Dubé : Nous avons quelques alliés dans la région de Montréal. La plupart sont des organismes francophones tels que l’Agence Science-Presse du côté sceptique et l’Association humaniste du Québec du côté laïque. L’Organisation pour la science et la société, organisme anglophone de l’Université McGill, traite de nombreuses prétentions pseudo-médicales, comme d’ailleurs plusieurs blogueurs francophones et anglophones du Québec.

Nous restons naturellement en contact avec certaines organisations sceptiques internationales francophones, telles que l’Association française pour l’information scientifique et le Comité belge pour l’analyse critique des parasciences.

Jacobsen : Qu’est-ce qui rend certaines croyances et certains dogmatismes plus dangereux que d’autres, lorsque les choses cessent d’être comiques de par leur absurdité même ? Comment peuvent-ils surgir dans des sectes, des religions, des idéologies économiques, des fronts hypernationalistes, etc. ?

Dubé : Les islamistes représentent probablement l’un des fondamentalismes religieux les plus dangereux ; ils exercent un pouvoir politique dans plusieurs pays et certains financent de grandes organisations terroristes. Il existe également plusieurs religions chrétiennes très extrémistes en Amérique du Nord, notamment contre la contraception, l’avortement, les soins médicaux et les transfusions sanguines, dont nous devrions essayer de réduire l’influence avec des faits scientifiques. Lorsque la religion se mêle de politique, la liberté en souffre généralement beaucoup.

Jacobsen : Quelles sont les initiatives prévues pour 2019 chez les Sceptiques du Québec ? Quelles sont les prétentions pseudoscientifiques et frauduleuses les plus visibles de la société canadienne ?

Dubé : Notre mission principale est d’améliorer la pensée critique de nos membres et du grand public. Les fausses nouvelles scientifiques posent de grands défis à cet égard. Nous continuerons également d’organiser des conférences et de publier des articles et des analyses rigoureuses afin d’améliorer les connaissances scientifiques.

L’homéopathie, l’acupuncture et la chiropratique ont acquis un statut officiel dans notre province contre le meilleur jugement de la communauté scientifique. Nous nous opposerons certainement à leur emprise sur des personnes ignorant le manque de preuves de leur efficacité. Les prétentions médicales de différents types devront être examinées, autant en ce qui regarde le traitement et les médicaments que l’alimentation. Nous continuerons sans aucun doute à mener des discussions sérieuses sur de nombreux sujets d’intérêt pour nos membres concernant la religion, l’ufologie et les théories du complot.

Jacobsen : D’autres pensées ou sentiments basés sur l’interview d’aujourd’hui ?

Dubé : Le besoin de pensée critique est aussi important aujourd’hui qu’il l’était dans les décennies précédentes. Un accès aisé aux informations via Internet présente le défi supplémentaire de devoir vérifier bien d’autres affirmations et théories douteuses. Heureusement, il existe plusieurs sources journalistiques sceptiques et rigoureuses sur lesquelles nous pouvons compter. Nous devons seulement être conscients de nos partis pris, consulter régulièrement de telles sources fiables, vérifier les faits et essayer d’exercer un jugement nuancé. Beaucoup de travail nécessaire et… agréable nous attend.

Jacobsen : Merci, Louis, de vous être prêté à cette rencontre.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

A Nigerian Humanist Presidential Apprehension: Mubarak Bala

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Secular World

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2021/06

Humanists come under a variety of labels and identifications, with some of them as atheists, others as agnostics, as freethinkers, and the like. It is one of those philosophical sets of principles associated loosely with a wide gamut of formalized or semi-formalized alternatives to traditional religions.

To be free to adhere to these belief sets is one thing; to be jailed or even killed for them is another. Mubarak Bala is one of the most famous freethought leaders to be jailed.

His formal title and association is the President of the Humanist Association of Nigeria. With his stature in the most populous nation in Africa, particularly Muslim-majority northern Nigeria, many saw him, as a humanist, as a threat.

He and I were to conduct an interview on April 27, 2020. We had been in communication, had completed several interviews before, and were to continue in this trend as a regular procedure. We were colleagues. I admired the work of the humanist and secular communities in Nigeria.

African states tend to be particularly stringent socially on non-believers, especially non-Christians and non-Muslims, with a special threat status to ex-Muslims.

I sent both question sets for the interviews with him. Then the communication channels went dead, which was surprising. As it turns out, two non-uniformed officers detained Mubarak on April 28, 2020. It was a despicable and unprofessional act on the part of the authorities, once again, to make an example of a freethinking leader.

Back in 2014, Bala became far more well-known within the international freethinker communities based on detainment in a psychiatric unit. Why? His family members made this happen because he said, “I am an atheist.” He did not believe in God.

To family, this was a punishable offense, so as to send him for psychiatric “treatment.” Which is to state, he was drugged by force and then committed to a psychiatric unit for “treatment” by family.

This is representative of the extent and horror of transcendentalist ethical thinking in which individuals, even family, considering themselves working for a God, instantaneously and simultaneously violate the individual rights of another family member.

Bala became suspect in the eyes of the family in 2014. He was released later in 2014. Then he came under arrest while residing in Kaduna State, which is approximately a whopping 130 miles south of Kano State.

To the recent “charge,” it is claimed that he offended the Islamic Prophet Muhammad. If Prophet Muhammad is dead, and if he is offended or insulted, then this means the individuals claiming the offense of Prophet Muhammad are claiming a) the dead have minds, b) they know the mind of a particular dead person, and c) they are working to get vengeance on behalf of a dead person.

When does all this stuff simply dissolve into a collective set of nonsense people invented, died, next generations believed, put their spin on it, and some put a spin on it so as to garner particular social and legal privileges and immunities for themselves in those subsequent generations?

The reality: Living individuals were offended by a social media post, not a dead proposed prophet. Yet, personal offense, especially of grown men and women, is too thin, comical, and idiotic. Thus, they need transcendent justification, religion, to justify their transcendentally fragile senses of self to a broadly religious public.

The claimed offending post was a single Facebook post, which supposedly read, “Fact is, you have no life after this one. You have been dead before, long before you were born, billions of years of death.”

A group of lawyers put a petition to the Kano State Police Commissioner in order to prosecute Bala. Someone known as a public defender and advocate of atheist rights and freedoms having his rights and freedoms violated.

In particular, it was claimed as “provocative and annoying to Muslims.” A Change.org petition went up. Yet, it was later taken down by Change.org. Here is the deal: There has been no formal charge. It is entirely illegitimate, unfair, and unjust.

Some think he may be charged with blasphemy via Section 210 of the Penal Code of Kano State. If a blasphemy charge, he can face a death sentence in the Shari’a court of Kano State. If a Cybercrimes Act violation, he can face a fine and up to five years in jail. The original detaining was in Kaduna and then a transfer 130 miles, insanely, to Kano State.

His whereabouts are unknown, allegedly for his own safety, because many members of the Kano community have claimed that they will burn down the police station for the online comments, i.e., a single Facebook post.

Others have threatened to attack the courthouse. These are legitimate threats of violence against an individual person; whereas, the other claims, against Bala, coming with being stripped from his home and detained and dragged to a more dangerous area for an ex-Muslim (Kano State from Kaduna State), come from real, live people against a living person on behalf of a non-threat of life in description of a long-dead person allegedly insulted.

Religion inverts reality and creates havoc and harm to individuals honest enough to speak about its negative sides, which are plentiful as a fruity cocktail cornucopia. He has been or was denied access to his lawyer, his wife, and newborn child for a long time.

Bala is another international secular leader defiled and abused on behalf of the religious by the state.

By definition, universal human rights apply across the board, or at least they should entail universalized access and application in a perfect world.

Therefore, for a rectification of this human rights travesty, Bala should be released, given a formal apology, and the real criminals making thin accusations about a single Facebook post and real threats of violence to a living person in public, on social media, should be considered for similar or worse treatment if the ledger of justice is to be considered just.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Remarks on Ayaz Nizami

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Secular World

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2021/02

When I wrote and interviewed for the now-defunct Conatus News, I was interviewing some secular and ex-religious leaders. One went by the pen name “Ayaz Nizami.” Our interview was scheduled for late March of 2017. The interview never took place because, although our last communication was March 21, 2017, he was detained by Pakistani authorities on March 24, 2017. The alleged charge was blasphemy.

A social media campaign went online for #FreeAyazNizami (see above). Meanwhile, another of those campaigns against individuals seen as offending the Prophet, or simply offending religious sentiments, also arose: #HangAyazNizami.

In 2017, the authorities arrested Abdul Waheed on the assumption that he was Nizami. The charge was “uploading offensive content on social media,” and he was formally sentenced to death much later, in early January 2021.

He was claimed to have specialized in Islamic law and the Arabic language. He translated some written work critical of Islam from English to Urdu, too. These texts became a potent mix to challenge the theocratic authorities, which would seem to explain his imprisonment for over 1,400 days, followed by a death sentence.

The Pakistani political author Alyan Khan is claimed to have exposed Nizami as Abdul Waheed. Khan must have known of the likely consequences for “Nizami” being exposed in Pakistan. So, the real criminal is Alyan.

It is important to note that, in Pakistan, being an active challenger of Islam is a dangerous position, and this is an admirable side commentary on the noble work of Fauzia Ilyas (pictured). Fauzia Ilyas is a former Director of AAI who has campaigned for Nizami’s release.

Alongside his imprisonment, we know two others were imprisoned. This was a direct move by the Pakistani government to censor and crack down on content that it deems blasphemous.

Currently, Abdul Waheed is imprisoned in Central Jail Rawalpindi under a death sentence, although it seems impossible to prove that he penned the “offensive texts.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Extended Interview with ​Maryam Namazie

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): maryamnamazie.com

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2016/10/15

​​How did you get involved in activism?

I became an activist as a result of my own life experiences after an Islamic regime took power in Iran. We fled the country. One of the first ways in which I got politically involved was in doing refugee rights work. My family and so many we knew had become refugees and it was a way of dealing with the trauma of losing everything and starting all over again – somewhere completely new – and at times unwelcoming.

It followed too, that I would be active against theocracy and religious rules, and for people’s rights. The best way you can fight repression is to refuse and resist. I didn’t set out to be an activist; in many ways I was forced into it. I had no choice but to fight back in the best way I knew how. Also when you are faced with such inhumanity – like the Islamic regime of Iran – the best fight back has to be fundamentally human.

Was there support from parents, siblings, or others for you?

My family has always been supportive of me. That’s why it has been easy for me to be an activist. Also, my partner is an activist. I’ve really always had a lot of support.

I can’t imagine people who not only don’t have the support of their families, but are being beaten and abused because of their beliefs. I think it makes it so much more difficult. Doesn’t it? It still astonishes me people like that can still be active and speak out.

I have met a lot of very vocal women. Many of them say they’ve had supportive parents and fathers. I think that’s key when you’re an activist. Obviously, you can be vocal without family support, but it helps a great deal.

Speaking of human rights as well as women rights, which are somewhat separated but definitely overlap, do you note that more of the rights violations are women’s in general?

Obviously, I think rights are violated across the board, but because women are seen to be more vulnerable, they are seen to be the property of the community, the society, the family’s honor, the society’s national honour, it makes it easier to target them. And often the abuse is legitimised in ways that other abuses aren’t.

As a result, violence against women is more acceptable in many ways. In that sense, one of the greatest violations of human rights is in the area of women’s rights.

Some of the more tragic and dramatic examples are violations of women’s bodies through things such as tens of millions of women having female genital mutilation, infibulation, clitoridectomy, and so on, against their will, even as girls. Does that seem, along with others, more religiously motivated or not?

I think there are obviously non-religious motivations for those violations, but very often religion also justifies and legitimises it, and gives it divine sanction in ways that other justifications don’t – which makes it all the more dangerous.

You are working on a new film. What is the content and purpose of that film?

The film is on Islam’s non-believers. It’s been made by Deeyah Khan, who is an award-winning film maker. Her previous films have been about honor killing as well as Jihadis.

And this one is about Islam’s non-believers. It looks at the situation of young people, particularly in Britain, who are facing discrimination and abuse because they’ve decided to be atheists. Often, including from their families and the larger communities that they live in. The film also links to the international situation.

You see the links between Bangladeshi Islamists hacking atheists to death in Bangladeshand also threatening atheists right here in Britain. People who are respected, people who are so-called ‘community leaders’. It shows that Islamism is an international movement that targets apostates.

It also shows the ex-Muslim resistance as an international movement and how it too is an important way of pushing back the Islamists by opening up the space to question and debate, and criticise religion, even to renounce religion. The ability to do it despite the risks involved.

The American Massachusetts Institute of Technology trained and Tufts University based philosopher and cognitive scientist professor, Daniel Dennett, did something similar to that. He looked into pastors, ministers, and preachers who had lost their faith and continued to preach.There’s a decent amount who’ve lost their faith and continued to preach. I haven’t seen the precise results, but this seems like a similar case. A possibly relatively common phenomena of people putting on the ‘face’ such as the engaging in practices and wearing the clothing in public, but not holding the beliefs sincerely or simply not believing. Do you know of the numbers of non-believers in Islam, but are putting on that face – so to speak?

Yea, also, there are 13 countries that execute apostates and atheists. There’s also a huge amount of threats and intimidation. The numbers are much larger than we can imagine because of the many risks involved. Social media and the internet are doing to Islam what the printing press did to Christianity.

So, it is opening the way to challenge it in a way that hasn’t been possible because of the risks that are involved. My opinion is its a tsunami of millions. It really is the case that there are atheists in every family, in every home, in every neighbourhood, in every country.

There are many of them. We can see it now via social media. What we see, though, is still the tip of the iceberg. We have many members living in Britain, which is a relatively safe place to live. There are no apostasy rules, but people continue to wear the veil, go to mosque, and continue to say they’re Muslims when they are atheists.

I think if the pressure of the Islamist movement is removed, if that movement is pushed back in the way political Christianity was pushed back by an Enlightenment, the world will be surprised by the sheer number of non-believers. I think even we will be surprised by it.

On the fringe of that sector of people, that sub-population within the community will be those that simply had over time their fundamentalist beliefs softened and liberalised quite a bit. Do you think that would be a much larger population – that sector would then move into non-believing as well?

Definitely, I think that is the case. I mean, of course, no community or society is homogenous. There are so many differences of opinion. The problem is we live in an era where communities are homogenised.

Very often, those in power are seen to be the representatives of those communities. In the so-called Muslim community, Islamists are seen as the authentic Muslims and representatives. I think many people are forced to keep up appearances, even if they don’t believe.

Time will reveal all, but already we’re seeing the extent of it. If anyone is interested in seeing it, is interested in accepting that there’s diversity and dissent in what is considered a homogenous group, it is very easy to see.

And it is on the increase. A convert was telling me that the Islamists always talk about how many people are converting into Islam, but we never hear about many of those converts who then decide to leave Islam and to become atheists.

We hear it is the fastest growing religion. We never hear about all of those people running for their lives in the opposite direction.

(Laugh)

Things are skewed in the favour of religion because religion is privileged anyway. No matter what society you live in. But when it is imposed, very often by brute force, by the Islamist movement, the numbers can never really be revealed.

But you can get a really good sense of it. When we started #ExMuslimBecause, we were expecting to have a couple of hundred people respond. We even thought, “Let’s do it a few weeks in advance of December 10th, International Human Rights Day, so, we can build up on it and gather a few hundred statements.”

It went viral in 24 hours. There were over 120,000 tweets from 65 different countries. Again, that is still the tip of the iceberg, really.

At this point in time, how do you self-identify in terms of irreligious/religious beliefs as well as socio-political beliefs?

I have a big problem with identity politics. I think it’s regressive as it tries to pigeonhole people into groups of constructed identities. It refuses to acknowledge that people are multifaceted. They have so many different characteristics that define them or they define themselves with.

For me, even the whole ex-Muslim movement is not about identity politics, I know it is for some people, but it is about a political challenge to the Islamist movement, to discrimination and violence against apostates, and it is one way of highlighting that.

It also challenges the view that the “Muslim community” is a homogenous community. If you have ex-Muslims, millions of people who don’t want to be considered Muslim anymore, it challenges multiculturalism as a social policy. I personally have political positions and ideals, which, for me, mark who I stand with irrespective of background or belief.

I am a secularist, for example. I will stand with Muslims and ex-Muslims, and non-Muslims, in support of secularism. I might be an atheist, but I don’t necessarily agree with all atheists on all issues. I am pro-refugee rights and against profiling of Muslims, for example.

I am old-fashioned in the sense that I think we need to build solidarity around political ideals, rather than around ridiculous limiting identities, which narrow the allies we can have and put us amongst those who aren’t necessarily our allies because they fit within a narrow identity.

Unfortunately, this is old-fashioned, but that’s how political organising has always been done. It has been done irrespective of one’s background, beliefs, and identity around specific political ideals.

I think that’s why we’re in the mess we are in today because we are not able to see our allies and our enemies given the bogus identity politics.

I want to shift the conversation to some of the things you mentioned at the beginning about refugees. In the early 21st century, we have a singular tragedy with the Syrian refugee crisis. How do you think countries in Europe are managing and handling refugees as well as the crisis at large?

For me, the refugee issue is a human rights issue – in the same way that I don’t think you should stop people using a hospital because they are undocumented and an EU citizen rather than a British born citizen or exclude people based on age, sex, race, or belief, I don’t think you should stop people from gaining protection.

It doesn’t matter where you fled from and where you seek refuge, you must be granted protection. It’s a basic human right.

People who have never had to worry about getting visas or fleeing for their lives might find it hard to understand the desperation – to have to leave everything you know – the language, the society, your work, your family, your loved ones, sometimes even sending your children on their own (unaccompanied minors) because you have no other hope of saving them. You send them off on this perilous journey and don’t even know if they will make it alive.

From my perspective, we should do everything and anything we can to help people. In the same way, I think everyone who needs healthcare should have it. Everyone who needs housing should have it. I don’t understand why we should have homeless people. I don’t understand why there are children who go to bed hungry in this country. I also don’t understand why refugees shouldn’t be given protection and safety.

I know of course it is because profit is more important than human need, and differences amongst us are more deemed more important than our common humanity but I don’t see why it should be that way.

Also, rights are not contingent on whether you like or agree with those demanding it. Sometimes the refugee issue is muddled up because people want to run an inquisition before deciding whether someone is eligible for this right. My perspective is that even if a person’s views are disgusting and vile, they still have human rights. You can’t stop people from accessing a GP because you don’t like their beliefs, so why do you think you can do it when it comes to those trying to save their lives and fleeing wars and persecution? Also beliefs are not set in stone. They change all the time.

People have a right to an education. They have a right to food. They have a right to healthcare. I would also say they have a right to asylum. I know we’re living in a time when this is unfashionable to say. With Brexit, so many hate anyone who doesn’t look like them. They want everybody out. Even if they’re doctors who are saving your life, they are still not good enough, not white enough, or what have you.

I think this boils down to a very fundamental issue. Rights are for everyone not just your pals. And there is more that hold us together than separate us if only we could see beyond the propaganda.

We are seeing some concerns from many people being raised both in North America, Europe, and elsewhere with, the phrase being used is, “right wing nationalism,” which can sometimes be seen as ethnic nationalism in a way. What do you think is the state of that at this point in time? What are the possible major concerns associated with that?

I think this is what happens when identity politics rules.

Identity politics divides and separates people so that they can no longer see their commonalities across these false borders. It’s not just that minorities love to live in ghettos and be humiliated day-in and day-out. This gettoisation is part and parcel of government policies of multiculturalism and cultural relativism. It means that governments can manage their minorities on the cheap by outsourcing citizens to self-appointed community “leaders” and Sharia courts, Islamic schools and so on.

When identity politics is supreme, it makes it possible for white identity politics to be portrayed as a legitimate option.

It surprises me how many people justify and legitimise what is fundamentally white identity politics, white supremacist politics, because the fascists and bigots happen to be critical of Islam. Look, the Islamists are also critical of US militarism but that doesn’t mean I should be siding with them. You can oppose both. This is a trap, though, the so-called “Regressive Left” fall into. But so do those who use the term “Regressive Left” in every other sentence but consider it a “smear” to call out those feeding into the far-Right narrative. Like the atheists and secularists who fall into the trap of defending Tommy Robinson and Robert Spencer because they have “some legitimate views.”  Well, I’m sure if you sit down and have a chat with al-Baghdadi, he will have “some legitimate views.” Assad or Khamenei might too; they might think that roads should be paved.

But that’s not a reason to ally with them or to justify their politics. I think this is a huge problem. You have people saying, “Well, the Far Right is dealing with the Islamists, therefore, let’s deal with them with kid gloves.” I think that’s a mistake. If you look at them (I always get shit for saying this but people don’t understand what I’m saying) fundamentally they are similar to the Islamists. Islamism is a far-Right movement.

Of course, I’m not saying Tommy Robinson decapitates people, but movements can be fundamentally similar yet based on the amount of power or access to power they have, they might not necessarily be able to wreck the same havoc as one that has state power and backing.

Fundamentally, though, their politics is one of hate, placing collective blame, regression. It’s unfortunate that so many people who consider themselves freethinkers would side with them.

You mentioned Sharia courts as well as Islamic schools. I know this is a bit of an issue in the United Kingdom. For instance, private religious schools for youngsters, for kids. Kids are told things that at times are outright wrong, especially even facts and fundamental theories, principles, and laws about the natural world. For instance, creationism over evolutionary theory and so on. What are your own personal concerns with some of these institutions and the way they being implemented within the United Kingdom?

I think “faith schools” is an oxymoron. Schools and faith don’t go together. Unless, you’re talking about indoctrination. I know there are some Church of England schools that are not indoctrinating the way Islamic schools are. They used to do it and still they promote ideas that are antithetical to free thinking and education. I think, in a sense, the educational system is one of the only ways in which we can protect children from their families.

It is meant to be a way in which the playing field is levelled for all kids irrespective of background. You’re rich. You’re poor. Your family beats you. Your family tries to veil you. Schools should be a place where you’re safeguarded.

You get to hear different ideas. You get the protection you might not get at home. You get to be equal to other kids. Faith schools are antithetical to this. If you question, you are punished. If you raise dissent or you don’t agree, or you ask how certain religious edicts could possibly be true, you’re penalised for it.

Education should promote and encourage questioning, inquiry, and free thought. It makes no sense to have religious schools. It’s a prescription for disaster. We’re faced with that disaster today. I can’t understand how it’s ever seen to be good idea.

Historically religion was in charge of education; faith schools are a remnant of the time when religion played a central role in the state and society. And of course even today, religion holds a privileged place in society. The British government, for example, is not a secular state by any means. This is a state in which the Church of England has real power. They’ve got bishops in the House of Lords. The Queen is the head of the church. You’ve got prayers in Parliament.

When speaking about faith schools (even the term seems innocuous, though it’s so sinister), it is not enough to address non-discrimination in admission policies or hiring practices but about why it is bad for our children. Fundamentally, there shouldn’t be any faith schools whatsoever, whether it’s stated funded or private.

What about Sharia courts existing alongside mainstream court systems?

I can’t understand that either. If you look at Sharia courts in Britain, they are dealing only in family matters, e.g. divorce, child custody, domestic violence, and so on and so forth. Family matters are not trivial matters as it’s often portrayed.

They are not matters of the community. They are human rights issues. In many countries, where Sharia rules apply, this is one of the main areas of fight back by women’s rights campaigners because of the huge amounts of discrimination against women.

For it to be sold to us here as a choice and a right is like selling FGM as a choice and right. The courts hold women’s testimony to be half that of a man’s. Women don’t have unilateral right to divorce. Men do.

The rules are discriminatory and legitimise violence against women. For example, you’ve got one Sharia judge saying that there’s no such thing as marital rape because women should expect to have sex within marriage. And that calling it rape is the act of aggression and not the actual rape. Or they have said if only we’ve had one amputation or stoning in Britain, there would be fewer thieves and less adultery, look how great Saudi Arabia is. These are the judges making rulings in these courts and making decisions on women’s lives. They’ve been recorded saying, “You’ve been beaten by your husband. Have you asked why he’s beating you? Is it because of your cooking? Is it because of you going out with your friends?”

It is outrageous. It is a scandal that they should be allowed. I think one of the things we’re seeing is not only are the rules discriminatory, but the process itself is tantamount to abuse. That is the argument women’s rights groups are making. No matter what a woman’s background, a man’s background, or a child’s background, they are citizens first and foremost. They have rights. To relegate minority women to kangaroo courts, that are violating their rights should be considered a human rights scandal.

In international studies done by UN organs, or bodies, one of the major, probably the best, ways of improving the wellbeing and livelihood of an entire society, from economics to child and maternal mortality rates (reduction) in addition to increasing access and achievements in education, is under the guise of the empowerment of women.

When individuals such as others and yourself are campaigning and fighting for women’s rights, and looking for ways, politically and otherwise, to empower women, it is actually improving the lives, on average, of everyone in the region or the society.

What do you think should be or is the best means through which to implement women’s rights in cases that are very difficult? Where women have less of a vote or no vote, they have a lot of pressure not to speak up for their own rights.

I think one of the key ways, of course, is defending secularism. One of the problems is that secularism has become a dirty word. We hear how secular extremists are compared with religious extremists. I’m sorry. No. There’s absolutely no comparison.

The French government saying there should be no conspicuous religious symbols in schools is actually a protection of school children. Why should a child be veiled because their parents are Muslims?

Don’t we agree that children have the right to decide their political leaning and positions when they reach of age, why not also their beliefs? Why is it okay for religion to be imposed?

In that sense, compare that with acid being thrown in your face for going to school, compare that with compulsory veiling from the age of puberty, compare that with gender segregation, there’s absolutely no comparison between what a secular state wants and what a theocracy wants.

We should unashamedly, unconditionally promote secularism. It is one the main preconditions for women’s empowerment and rights. I think particularly when religion has any say in the state or law it is detrimental to women’s rights.

That is one precondition. Equality before the law is key, but equality on a social and economic level are also key. That comes down to a system that puts profit before human need and human welfare. Religion is useful for that system as well.

It helps to keep women down.

Who are some personal heroes for you?

My parents are my personal heroes because the more I actually see how many young people have been abused and destroyed by their parents, it does make me realise how lucky I am to have the father that I have and my mum as well.

Also, the person who most has affected the way I think is the Iranian Marxist Mansoor Hekmat. Unfortunately, he died at 51, but his politics which centred on the human being has influenced my politics and the politics of many from Iran, the region, and Diaspora.

Do you have any recommended novels or more academic writings for people with an interest in or leaning in getting involved in these issues?

There is Mansoor Hekmat’s Collected Works of which there is one translated into English. I would recommend that to anyone who wants to know more about Iranian politics but also about how to address everything from Islam, Islamism, veiling, secularism from a fundamentally human and Left perspective. Anything written by Algerian sociologist Marieme Helie Lucas is a great read. There are two interviews with her on the veil andgender segregation, which are brilliant. I’d recommend reading Marjane Satrapi’s Persepolis for a view of the Iranian revolution (which was not Islamic) and its expropriation by the Islamist movement; Mona Eltahawy’s Headscarves and Hymens on the veil as well as Karima Bennoune’s You Fatwa Does Not Apply Here on people’s resistance against Islamism. Elham Manea’s Women and Sharia Law is also a really good book on legal pluralism in the UK.

For getting in contact with you, people can go to your Twitter and website.

I have a really good website now thanks to a really wonderful volunteer. My website was hideous before. It was embarrassing to refer people to it. It is www.maryamnamazie.com. Via the website, people can read things I’ve written, see videos, and media coverage.

Also, there’s a TV program that is broadcast in Iran, which I do weekly with a co-host of mine. It is called Bread and Roses. It is Persian and English. It uses illegal satellite dishes to get into Iran. Many people have satellite dishes in Iran.

It just deals with free thinking, taboo breaking issues. There’s always an interview. We’ve interviewed some of the greats as well as people who should be considered great by all free thinkers, but aren’t as well known, unfortunately.

One of the things the program shows is that there’s so many atheists, secularists, and free thinkers in the so-called Muslim world. I mean, it is important to see them, recognise them, because once we do it breaks this whole idea that dissent and free thought are Western concepts, which is nonsense.

That, in fact, there are lots of people fighting for the very same issues that people fight for here it home in Britain.

Also good organisations to support are the Council of Ex-Muslims of Britain and One Law for All.

Any feelings or thoughts in conclusion about the things we’ve discussed?

Sometimes, when we’re having these discussions, people only see homogenous groups; they make decisions based on group identity. But group identity is very often imposed. It fails to recognise that there are so many individuals within those groups who are individuals, courageous and are resisting in many different ways – often at great risk to themselves.

If we can start seeing each other as people and recognising that there is a lot more which brings us together than separates us, I think we would have a real chance of pushing the Islamist and far-Right back.

One of the reasons that the Islamists are so violent is because they see this immense dissent. Unfortunately, it is not recognised in the West because it is either Islamophobic to criticise or you’ve got the Far-Right trying to hijack the criticism in order to scapegoat and vilify Muslims and migrants and push forward their own white identity politics.

It is important for us to go back to basics of universal rights, citizenship, secularism, and join hands together around political ideals and not identities. It is this united solidarity as human beings that has helped us overcome inhumanity in the past and can also help us today.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

The Path to Humanist Chaplaincy

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Parlour News Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2024/12/04

Anthony Cruz Pantojas, MATS, MALS, BCC (they/them), is the Humanist Chaplain and Coordinator of Africana Spirituality at Tufts University. Currently, they are a board member for Secular Coalition for America, The Humanist Society, as well as the International Association of Chaplains in Higher Education. Cruz Pantojas’s praxis centers Afro-Caribbean humanist and freethought philosophies, promotes critical imagining and self-discovery, and inspires individuals to question and reimagine their inner/outer worlds.

Cruz Pantojas talks about becoming a humanist chaplain, a role grounded in nonjudgmental care for diverse communities. Pantojas explains that humanist chaplains provide support not limited to humanist ideology, adhering to a pluralistic and ethically guided approach. They highlight the extensive education and clinical training required, such as programs at the United Theological Seminary, and the challenges chaplains face, including misconceptions from both humanist and non-humanist communities. Cruz Pantojas emphasizes humanist chaplaincy’s unique space for critical inquiry and the cultivation of interconnectedness, aiming to address skepticism and encourage broader acceptance within varied institutional settings.


Scott Douglas Jacobsen: We are here with Anthony, and today we’re going to discuss the path to becoming a humanist chaplain. There are many nuances to this subject, and I may not be aware of all of them.

In fact, it will take some time to unpack these. So, Anthony, what would you say is a key motivation for someone interested in becoming a humanist chaplain?

Anthony Cruz Pantojas, Humanist Chaplain at Tufts (photo by Evan Clark)

Anthony Cruz Pantojas: Wow, thank you so much for that question, Scott. I’m not sure if I can provide a straightforward answer to that.

In general, a chaplain—before associating with any specific philosophical, religious, or cultural tradition—develops an understanding that their role in chaplaincy is shaped and oriented by the needs they identify within the groups, communities, or chapters they serve. In North America, chaplains typically adopt a pluralistic, non-personalizing, non-judgmental, and expansive approach to their practice, whether it’s in higher education, hospitals, prisons, or other contexts.

Since chaplains often work with vulnerable populations, they are not only representing a humanist perspective but also the organization they are affiliated with. For example, in a hospital setting, a chaplain provides care and companionship to everyone—not solely as a humanist but as a chaplain, adhering to a code of ethics from both their tradition and the place of employment or volunteer service. Humanism is not exempted from this framework. The Humanist Society, which is the professional organization endorsing celebrants and humanist chaplains, has its own code of ethics. This means it’s not enough to simply identify as a humanist or to adopt the title of “humanist chaplain”; there is a comprehensive review and endorsement process to hold that representational role.

In addition, aside from The Humanist Society, humanist chaplains are often members of broader professional chaplaincy associations. It’s not a simple checkbox; it’s an extensive, formative process.

Jacobsen: Could you elaborate on this broader code of ethics and highlight some key principles that distinguish a humanist chaplain from general chaplaincy while maintaining an ethic common to all chaplains, including humanist chaplains?

Pantojas: Certainly. At least in North America, there are several organizations, such as the Association of Professional Chaplains and the Spiritual Care Association. Each has its own history and emphasis in the field.

But I would say, unless a professional association specifies a particular faith—like associations for Muslim, Christian, or Jewish chaplains, which do exist—overall, the field holds a generalist orientation. By that, I mean that unless there’s a hyphenated professional title, like “Catholic Chaplains Association” or something similar, much of chaplaincy work is humanistic. It’s about providing nonjudgmental care, not just a listening ear, but a truly trained capacity to hold complexity, to understand nuance, and to become a resource for the client, patient, or staff member seeking this existential framework of care while they operate within a specific context.

If we pair that with organizations like The Humanist Society or similar groups, we see close parallels in terms of the ethics we uphold. For instance, one line that comes to mind is that The Humanist Society in North America explicitly states that although you are a humanist chaplain, you are also required to provide care for everyone. That’s a powerful message because it affirms that a humanist outlook, worldview, or orientation can embrace a broad spectrum of possibilities for people, without any agenda to convert them to humanism.

As a chaplain, you’re always reflecting back the language and needs of the person you’re supporting, centering their agency and power. When individuals want to formally pursue this path, they often have a clear motivation. They’ve recognized the codes of ethics required in this profession and understand the need for appropriate education, credentials, and memberships.

Jacobsen: What are those steps, and how can someone go through each of them in a practical manner?

Pantojas: Yes, I’d say—fortunately or unfortunately—there aren’t many options, but the ones that do exist are worthwhile. In North America, we have the United Theological Seminary of the Twin Cities, which is historically a United Church of Christ seminary for theological formation and now offers a humanist studies track. This can be part of either a Master of Divinity or a Master of Leadership Studies with a focus on humanism, in collaboration with the Center for Education in North America. Students there are not mentored by just any faculty; they work with people who have experience in diverse fields and can provide guidance specifically in humanism.

In the Netherlands, there’s also the University for Humanistic Studies, among other institutions that individuals could explore. I always advise people to look for funding first; that way, they can match the rest—mentors, specific programs, and close-knit experiences—around that foundation. Education, especially graduate-level, isn’t cheap in North America, so finding a place that offers financial aid or housing is ideal if those are your needs.

Jacobsen: What about the training itself? How many hours and in what forms are required to become a fully recognized humanist chaplain?

Pantojas: Yes. It varies depending on whether you’re pursuing the Master of Leadership track or the Master of Divinity. Typically, it ranges from two to four years of academic study post-bachelor’s degree. We also emphasize, as I mentioned earlier, clinical psychospiritual education, which can be completed during or after your graduate studies. In North America, this usually involves 300 hours of supervised clinical care within a designated context offering those programs, along with 100 hours of classroom education.

This training goes deep into chaplaincy as a field and as a practice within a particular context. The dominant setting for this training tends to be healthcare or psychiatric spaces, but some Clinical Pastoral Education (CPE) programs are also available in prisons, community centers, and similar environments. These less traditional contexts may require more creative approaches to supervision but still need someone with the appropriate credentials to oversee the work.

However, humanist chaplaincy doesn’t guarantee a specific job, like higher education doesn’t mean you’ll become a professor simply because you have a graduate degree. Similarly, becoming a humanist chaplain doesn’t mean you’ll land a hospital or university position. It signifies a willingness to provide care in creative, often entrepreneurial capacities.

Jacobsen: If you were to estimate the number of humanist chaplains in the United States, what would that population look like?

Pantojas: I don’t have exact statistics off the top of my head. The numbers depend on whether you’re looking at officially endorsed humanist chaplains compared to, say, military chaplains, clinical chaplains, or those in higher education. In higher education specifically, there’s a relatively small number of humanist chaplains designated as such—not just a chaplain who happens to be a humanist, but someone tasked with supporting the religious, nontheist, freethinking, and other diverse communities from a humanist standpoint.

Overall, in terms of specifically endorsed humanist chaplains, I’d estimate the number might be about 150+. But I encourage a skeptical approach; and I suggest checking for more current data.

Jacobsen: Let’s say someone puts in their two to four years and becomes a humanist chaplain. What should they expect from those seeking their care, in terms of the nuanced support and feedback they’ll be providing?

Pantojas: That’s such an important question. From an intersubjective standpoint, it first requires vulnerability and recognizing, as you mentioned, that you’ve done the studies and met the requirements.

Now, when you’re out there in the field, you quickly find that you’re creating spaces for others to explore. Given our humanist orientation, it’s not about telling people what to do, believe, or practice, but rather allowing them the space to explore questions like, “What does it look like for me to hold a religious orientation to life?” and yet find myself in a humanist, humanistic, or even interbelief space where a humanist presence is there and it feels spacious. Or, at least, that’s the approach I try to model. I create spaces where we engage in critical inquiry, cultivate a sense of individual and communal responsibility, look at ourselves from a systemic perspective, and develop interconnectedness with the human experience in a way that allows for various possibilities.

That’s one of the powerful offerings I find humanist chaplaincy brings: it’s willing to sit in the uncomfortable spaces, even of contradiction.

Jacobsen: What challenges do humanist chaplains face, especially with tougher subject matter?

Pantojas: It depends on the context. For example, even among our peers within the humanist or secular world—who are often quite skeptical—people might say, “Why are you a humanist chaplain? Isn’t that a theistic or Christian role?” So there’s sometimes a lack of understanding or even a disregard for what humanist chaplaincy can offer. I find that this is one of the main challenges.

Additionally, humanist chaplains aren’t present in many conversations across institutions, and building those relationships and showing up as humanist chaplains is something we each develop on our own over time.

From the non humanist side, there can also be suspicion or skepticism. People might think, “You’re a humanist chaplain; can you even care for me or accompany me?” Or if you mention that you’re an atheist, people may question whether you’re truly able to support them. It can be challenging to face these same questions repeatedly. But, through proximity, care, and genuine accompaniment, it’s often possible to diffuse biases, prejudices, misunderstandings, or the lack of exposure to what a humanist chaplain can offer.

Jacobsen: Anthony, thank you very much for the opportunity and your time today. I appreciate it.

Pantojas: You’re most welcome. Thank you so much for the conversation.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

“GLOBAL TRADE and FINANCE 6: Global Debt, Trade Shifts, and Stablecoins”—we were interviewed by The Good Men Project, our 6th in this series!

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): LinkedIn

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2025/11/08

Michael Ashley Schulman CFA, Chief Investment Officer of Running Point Capital Advisors, offers expert insight into current global financial dynamics. Schulman offers timely insights into macroeconomic trends, US fiscal policy, and the global tech landscape.

In this interview with Scott Douglas Jacobsen, Michael Ashley Schulman, CFA, Chief Investment Officer of Running Point Capital Advisors, analyzes global financial dynamics amid a surge in debt, shifting trade flows, and emerging digital currencies. Schulman explains how global debt ballooned to $338 trillion in the first half of 2025, the fading effects of front-loading ahead of tariff hikes, and the risks flagged by the BIS regarding fiscal sustainability. He also unpacks UNCTAD’s warnings on policy uncertainty, the one-year extension of AGOA, and the IMF’s framework on stablecoins. Schulman emphasizes clarity, fiscal discipline, and innovation as critical for investors.

Interview conducted September 25, 2025, in the morning.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Global debt neared $338 trillion. What drove the H1 surge? (Reuters)

Michael Ashley Schulman: Credit cards, Labubu dolls, and Pop Demon Hunters merchandise, obviously.

However, seriously, there are several reasons for the debt surge, and we have regularly briefed our investment clients on them. First, cheapish money came back. Borrowing got easier and less expensive than it was a couple of years ago; therefore, corporate CFOs hit the refinance button on their liabilities, pushed out maturity dates, added a little to their debt stack, and provided some financing cushion for those prescient enough to forecast turbulence coming from the US’s new administration.

Second, the US dollar softened; this means that the dollar lost a little strength versus other currencies, which makes dollar debts slightly easier to manage for non-U.S. borrowers (like emerging market governments and foreign companies) and that can nudge global liquidity up. Third, governments and companies rushed to lock in longer-maturity loans and bonds, so they would not have to refinance at possibly worse rates. Fourth, many foreign central banks had already been ahead of the Fed in lowering rates over the last 12 months, making their own local currency debt easier to shoulder.

To summarize, borrowing costs eased slightly, and the US dollar lost some momentum, prompting governments and companies to rush to lock in longer-dated loans before interest rates increased again. The result is more total debt now and lower refinancing pressure for the next couple of years, but bigger interest bills down the road, especially if the dollar firms back up. Thus, that’s how liabilities ballooned by a mere $21 trillion (with a “t”) in six months to $337.7 trillion. Think of it as the fiscal version of “buy now, cry later”.

The biggest players were the usual suspects: the U.S., China, Japan, France, the UK, and Germany. The new normal seems to be higher debt-to-GDP ratios!

This means that duration risk (or interest rate sensitivity) has increased for balance sheets, and rollover walls have become taller for emerging markets. Apologies, I’m using jargon; a rollover wall is a large cluster of debt that all comes due around the same time.

The risk is that this surge is like pumping helium into an already stretched balloon; it’s fun unless it pops. For the US, higher debt servicing eats into fiscal flexibility; for emerging markets, FX or foreign exchange risk can become a ticking time bomb in the next downcycle. Conservative investors may want to consider biasing toward issuers with steady cash flows and room in their budgets, and be choosy with respect to highly indebted names that need constant access to markets.

Jacobsen: Front-loading ahead of tariff hikes propped up trade in H1. How does the OECD Interim Outlook expect unwinding into Q4?

Schulman: Companies wisely panic-bought early and pulled orders forward before higher US tariffs; in other words, they stuffed their supply chains to the gills, which is basically the macro equivalent of carb-loading before a marathon you’re not trained to run. I call this warehouse first, argue later. We’ve often spoken with our ultra-high-net-worth clients who are business owners about this.

Front-loading propped up first-half trade numbers and pulled sales forward, which will then leave a softer patch as inventories get worked down. The Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) is saying the same. As we move into year-end, the surge fades, and shipping may slow versus last year. Akin to what we’ve discussed previously, expect softer global growth and choppier margins as supply chains rebalance.

This could be temporarily troubling for export-driven economies such as Germany, Korea, and those in Southeast Asia. It isn’t or won’t be a slowdown so much as it will be the echo of demand that was pulled forward.

Political risk is a macro driver! Investors might question whether to chase the ‘everything’s booming’ story versus favouring steady service sectors, artificial intelligence capital expenditure beneficiaries, and firms that aren’t one tariff headline away from a migraine. Analysts are leaning into companies with pricing power and shorter supply chains, while being wary of manufacturers that operate on thin margins and have long shipping routes.

Jacobsen: Yield curves steepened. Risk assets rallied. What fiscal risks does the BIS Quarterly Review (Sept 2025) see here?

Schulman: The Bank for International Settlements (BIS) risk list is not a cheery read, but you’d expect a list of risks to look rather dismal, right? BIS is waving a red flag, concerned about a divergence between buoyant stock markets, driven by investor optimism, and the bond market’s rising anxiety over government debt, which the growing premium investors highlight demand for holding long-term government bonds. This is not new; the BIS has flagged government debt trajectories and the lack of fiscal discipline as the most serious threat to macroeconomic and financial stability for some time. Rising government debt, investment market vulnerability from leverage, fiscal sustainability concerns evidenced by a US debt downgrade earlier this year and rising bond yields in France, are newer to the list next to longer-term concerns, including climate-related costs, growing public-sector funding needs, and the potential for a doom-loop between governments and banks in emerging markets.

So, yes, long-term interest rates rose, and paradoxically, stocks climbed as different sets of investors envisioned near-term growth hopes, while others saw bigger borrowing costs down the road. Governments running persistent deficits will feel the pinch as interest consumes a fatter slice of tax revenue; that means less room for new programs or tax cuts without some sort of trade-offs.

Risk-averse investors may want to maintain some high-quality credit investments or bonds as ballast in their portfolios and prefer companies that can fund themselves without tapping markets every quarter, and avoid overpaying for stories that only work when money remains easy. Historically, steeper yield curves have warned that we are in a late-cycle economy, but they don’t always get it right.

We could see a slight stock market pullback in October, especially if the US government shuts down, but hopefully followed by a bounce back in November or December!

Jacobsen: UNCTAD’s Global Trade Update (Sept 2025) flags policy uncertainty as a deeper drag than tariffs. Any thoughts?

Schulman: Agreed. Tariffs you can price; policy whiplash you can’t. A known tariff is like a speed bump; you slow down and keep going. Policy. Policy flip-flops, on the other hand, are road closures, where you stop, reroute, make a U-turn, or cancel the trip. We’ve walked our multifamily office clients through these scenarios.

For multinationals and supply chains, this is a whack-a-mole environment. The UN Trade and Development (UNCTAD) September update attributes the drag or slowdown to rule changes, carve-outs, and sudden restrictions that force more costly and longer routes, as well as freeze capital expenditures. Unclear rules, surprise bans, and shifting exemptions are toxins in business planning; they delay investment and reroute supply chains in costly ways. Government subsidies and credit lines for businesses are a band-aid; the real fix is clearer timelines and fewer sudden rule changes.

Some investment analysts are rewarding companies with logistic chains that have contractual visibility and diversified lanes, not just the lowest bill of lading. Single-path supply chains are potential Halloween horror flicks.

Jacobsen: With a reported one-year African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA) extension amid US tariff shifts, how much cushion would that give exporters?

Schulman: You are into acronyms today, aren’t you? Too many of them and we might become acro-numb, lol.

The African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA) was signed into law a quarter century ago by Bill Clinton and is set to expire at the end of September. A one-year AGOA extension is akin to giving someone 12 more months on a lease, generous if you’re a fruit fly. It’s a geopolitical olive branch in a tariff storm, offering African exporters a small, temporary moat against rising protectionism. A year buys some time, but not certainty. It’s an extension to avoid an immediate cutoff of preferential, duty-free access to the American market on more than 1,800 African products from over 30 countries, and to avoid significant economic disruption. That’s enough to keep apparel and auto supply chains from seizing up, but too short to make big new factory bets. US credibility as a long-term partner versus China and other global players is also on the line here, and our credibility is wobbling like Jell-O. For US buyers, the extension offers modest price stability; for African exporters, their payrolls are temporarily saved while their capital expenditures are deferred.

Investors may see near-term relief for listed apparel buyers and investment-grade African sovereigns; however, the medium-term outlook hinges on a multi-year renewal.

Jacobsen: As stablecoins spread, what policy trade-offs top the list in the IMF’s September coverage?

Schulman: I’ve spoken to some of our family office clients about this. Stablecoins are like AI (artificial intelligence); everyone wants in, no one knows how to regulate it, and somebody’s probably lying about capabilities. The IMF’s September brief lays it bare; they say you can’t have stability, innovation, and monetary control all at once. Pick two. It’s the Monetary Trilemma, Web3 Edition.

The fascinating thing to me is the disconnect between the IMF and the US regarding stablecoins, and I’ve pointed this out in past conversations. The IMF sees stablecoins as a potential systemic risk if left to float freely outside central bank control; thus, they lean heavily toward having central banks or some equivalent public authority retain a leading role in settlement, oversight, or even synthetic central bank digital coin (CBDC) models, where private issuance is tightly tethered to public liabilities.

America, on the other hand, has explicitly legislated against giving its central bank, the Federal Reserve, retail CBDC powers. An executive order issued earlier this year effectively prohibits government agencies from issuing or promoting a CBDC domestically. The US is threading a middle path via the GENIUS Act, which has already been signed, allowing regulated institutions, such as banks, insured depositories, and approved non-banks, to issue payment stablecoins under tight reserve, supervision, and non-interest rules with 100% private reserve backing and transparency. So stablecoins are allowed, but the Fed won’t be the issuer. The US is betting innovation works better when the state is more of a referee than a player.

The IMF worries that if private stablecoins become de facto money in other jurisdictions, especially in countries with weak local currencies, central banks could lose monetary control. The US model provides private players with that function, although with tight oversight, betting that the dollar’s dominance and trust will curb excesses. As you can tell, this fascinates me. I could go down a rabbit hole here, but I will refrain.

From an investor’s point of view, regulatory clarity will likely help solidify the winners, namely fully reserved, well-supervised, and compliant issuers. The long-term losers are probably those that are under-collateralized and opaque.

Jacobsen: Any closing remarks?

Schulman: Thanks, yes, in summary, for trade, the first half of 2025 was front-loaded and Q4 will be the comedown with tariff drag and policy jitters. Big picture, the world is racking up debt like a teenager with a new credit card, trade is jumpy like it just downed three Red Bulls, and the BIS is flagging fiscal policy like it’s an overhyped IPO. As long as economies continue to grow, debt burdens are manageable, and we can potentially outgrow them and inflate them away. Meanwhile, stablecoins are spreading faster than a viral TikTok video. In this macro circus, policy clarity is the real unicorn.

As always, thank you for your timely questions and the opportunity to share with your readers the same perspectives, insights, and guidance we provide to our family office clients.

Jacobsen: Thank you for the opportunity and your time, Michael.

~~

Disclosure: The opinions expressed are those of Running Point Capital Advisors, LLC (Running Point) and are subject to change without notice. This is not investment advice and this is not a recommendation to buy or sell a security. The opinions referenced are as of the date of publication, may be modified due to changes in the market or economic conditions, and may not necessarily come to pass. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Forward-looking statements cannot be guaranteed. Running Point is an investment adviser registered with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training. More information about Running Point’s investment advisory services and fees can be found in its Form ADV Part 2, which is available upon request. RP-25-265

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

“GLOBAL TRADE and FINANCE 5: After De Minimis, Inflation and Trade”—we were interviewed by The Good Men Project, our 5th in this series!

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): LinkedIn (Michael Ashley Schulman)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2025/09/27

Michael Ashley Schulman CFA, Chief Investment Officer of Running Point Capital Advisors, offers expert insight into current global financial dynamics. Schulman offers timely insights into macroeconomic trends, U.S. fiscal policy, and the global tech landscape.

In this interview with Scott Douglas Jacobsen, Schulman outlines near-, medium-, and long-term effects of the U.S. ending the de minimis import exemption. Short term, inflation blips are muted as impulse buys fall; by the holidays, core goods may rise ~0.1–0.2% before fading by spring. Compliance and fulfillment costs jump as postal flows snarl (~80% drop), pushing sellers toward warehousing, express, and bonded lanes; documentation becomes a moat. India faces tariff pain in textiles, gems, leather, while EU-U.S. tariff shifts ease but don’t revive 2H25 guidance. With WTO trade growth near 0.9% and softer Fed policy, the dollar drifts lower. Rare-earth risks hedgeable only 20–30%.

Interview conducted September 11, 2025.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: With the U.S. permanently ending the low-value package “de minimis” exemption, what are the following two-quarter impacts on inflation?

Michael Ashley Schulman: In the short term, it may be less than we think. Much of what is bought in de minimis packaging is “want have” not “need have;” meaning you may see less impulse purchases of cheap shirts, costume jewelry, holiday ornaments, knockoff Labubu dolls, almost irresistible handbags, belts, and glow in the dark socket wrenches in online shopping carts as consumers react to the higher prices by just saying no.

Medium-term, we will see an increase in prices as consumers adjust to the reality not only for the “must haves” but also for the trinkets, novelty items, self-treats, little gifts, and impulse purchases—we are a consumer society after all! I’m pencilling in roughly 0.1% to 0.2% of core goods price increases into the holiday quarter, then a fade by early spring as importers pivot to bulk freight and domestic warehousing.

Longer term, new supply sources, routes, and supply chains will be created and negotiated, and new manufacturing facilities will be built. So yes, we will see price rises, but they will be a step up in the going cost, not a continuous inflationary increase. In the long run, prices may return to a more competitive level as supply increases.

For now, the policy change is genuine, abrupt, and already snarling mail flows, which amplifies near‑term pricing noise. We’ve seen international postal traffic to the U.S. plunge 80% in the first week. My estimates aside, researchers peg the consumer cost in the low‑double‑digit billions, which is not a CPI calamity, but it will singe some price tags.

Jacobsen: What about fulfilment costs and Customs and Border Protection compliance?

Schulman: In reference to the best-selling video game of all time, I’m labelling this Call of Duty: Tariff Ops III rather than Black Ops III; see what I did there with the pun on duty? You’ll need your supply chain maps, cheat codes, and advanced powers to make it through each level. But seriously, someone should be working on generative AI and agentic AI apps for that: generative AI to help Customs and Border Protection staff keep up with and account for the new rules, and agentic AI for buy-side fulfillment efficiency.

For now, picture a live SNL sketch where carriers do tariff algebra on stage. Non-postal shipments must clear like regular freight. Postal parcels are subject to either ad valorem duty or a temporary, per-item specific duty while the systems catch up. Postal operators and airlines need bonds, data pipes, and new billing logic, which means higher handling fees and more delays before steadier processes are incorporated. In the short run, third‑party logistics providers will nudge rates and minimums higher, and some sellers will batch inventory into U.S. warehouses to dodge failed doorstep collections. For peak-season shoppers and merchants, that means fewer surprise bargains and more surprise paperwork. It’s “Stranger Things,” but the monster is compliance.

Jacobsen: I can tell by your tone that there is something additional you want to add here or bring up.

Schulman: Yes, Scott, you’re right. How do I phrase this? What is non-obvious here, and few people are discussing, is that Customs and Border Protection compliance means duties are paid early in the journey, and inventory sits longer in domestic warehouses (whereas previously, there was no duty and no domestic warehouse time). Days inventory outstanding stretches from nil, zilch, and zippo to some number greater than zero. Small sellers lose float.

Compliance becomes a competitive moat. The cheapest good is not the most affordable good once you price in forms, data validation, and fines. Scale players—your leading large-cap or focused category-killer international and multinational firms—utilize customs expertise as a barrier to entry or a competitive advantage, capturing market share from micro-exporters. The internet promised disintermediation. Trade rules re‑intermediated it, if that’s a word.

Shippers move from postal to commercial express to ocean consolidation to foreign‑trade zones and bonded warehouses. Each path carries different fees, delays, and risks of returns. Consumers may see quirky price spreads across identical or nearly identical items depending on the fulfillment lane rather than the brand.

Expect product designers to change materials, fasteners, or assembly sequences to jump tariff lines legally. The invisible battleground becomes what’s known as the Harmonized System code, or the Harmonized Tariff Schedule, along with rules of origin paperwork. Swapping out a three‑cent gasket can beat a three‑dollar duty. The business edge is characterized by stable excellence in documentation, working capital, product design, and insurance, rather than mere price optimization.

Additionally, the labour bottleneck is expected to be in the public sector, rather than the private sector. Customs staffing, port inspectors, and certification agencies are capacity constraints. When the bottleneck lies in government headcount, the only solutions are hiring and software. Firms that pre‑clear and pre‑validate will outperform simply by avoiding the queue.

Jacobsen: After Washington doubled tariffs on many Indian goods, which export sectors will now absorb the hit?

Schulman: The blast radius covers India‑to‑America staples. I believe I lightly touched on this in our last interview; textiles, apparel, gems, and jewelry come first to mind, followed by leather and footwear, furniture, select auto components, and a swath of organic chemicals. Smartphones and most pharmaceuticals are broadly carved out for now. Within companies, margins compress, orders reshuffle, and some capacity gets mothballed as buyers trial Vietnam, Mexico, and Turkey. The bigger irony is that both sides take a growth haircut while Russia’s oil cash flow barely flinches.

Jacobsen: Is India’s best near-term response to retaliate or litigate at the WTO, or even re-route its trade?

Schulman: I’m in no position to advise New Delhi or 3-time PM  Narendra Modi what to do, but India’s best response may be to do what it is doing, run toward the open arms of its historical enemy and the U.S.’s main rival, China, while looking back over its shoulder to see if the U.S. gets the hint. The headline is ‘tariff pain’; the reaction is portfolio rotation within India. Firms under the Production Linked Incentive support program can lean harder into components where they can prove origin and quality quickly, while sectors with messy traceability lose orders first. For example, lab‑grown diamonds and engineered gems hold share better than mined stones when paperwork tightens.

Or maybe the brilliant maneuver is a three‑step dance number as you suggested in your question, file and litigate at the World Trade Organization (WTO) to set the record, even if there’s no calendar-year resolution. Retaliate with a scalpel, not an axe, to keep room for dealmaking with Washington. Then sprint on re-routing—which is already underway—by leaning harder into Europe, Africa, and Southeast Asia, while courting China for finished drugs and chemicals sales. The innovative shock absorber is diversification and bilateral trading rather than a whole tariff food fight.

Jacobsen: As the EU proposes scrapping tariffs on U.S. industrial goods and the U.S. cuts car tariffs to 15% retroactive to August 1, will original equipment manufacturers (OEMs) in Germany and Italy upgrade 2H25 guidance and 2026 capex?

Schulman: My initial gut instinct says no on the guidance; German and Italian OEM auto manufacturers should not upgrade 2H25 outlooks. But there are nuances and refinements to that bold statement. Many consumers bought forward—shifted demand to earlier in the year, to front-run tariffs on big-ticket items like cars. Thus, all Fiats, as well as low- and mid-end BMWs, Audis, and Mercedes, may not see a pickup in demand, especially since consumerism seems to be softening slightly. High-end buyers of German Porsches, Italian Ferraris, and Lamborghinis, who are less price-sensitive, may maintain their purchasing steady.

Thus, answering your question head-on, on the European Union tariff olive branch and the United States cutting car duties to 15% retroactive to August 1, guidance gets less gloomy before it gets giddy. This trims the tariff cloud that drove profit warnings, but finance chiefs move from red to amber, not straight to green. Expect cautious second‑half language and a cleaner 2026 plan that possibly tilts capital spending toward North American localization with more final assembly and parts plants that immunize against the next plot twist. Call it not-so-Fast and not‑so‑Furious—that movie series still creates some of the best auto puns and analogies.

Jacobsen: With the World Trade Organization revising 2025 goods trade growth to ~0.9% amid front-loading by the IMF, nudging 2025 global GDP to ~3.0%, what does this duo mean for the dollar or trade-finance availability in Q4?

Schulman: With goods trade growth trimmed toward 0.9% and global growth nudging 3%, I foresee air pockets then crosswinds. However, there are more factors affecting the dollar than trade growth. You have President Trump weakening the dollar, and any shift down in interest rates by the Fed may aid that dollar decline trend we’ve seen this year. Front-loading of imports pulled demand into mid-year, so late-year shipping looks choppy. As softer labour numbers coax the Fed toward interest rate cuts, expect an even softer dollar. Trade finance won’t disappear; it will just reprice. Letters of credit and supply-chain finance track SOFR (Secured Overnight Financing Rate), which will drift lower, while banks lean harder on compliance and collateral. Funding remains available for solid credits, pricing eases slightly into year-end, and the paperwork becomes heavy—in other words, compliance becomes the gatekeeper at the door.

Thus, as merchants pivot to traditional invoices and letters of credit, hedging shifts to forward contracts, adding a low‑drama but steady bid for the U.S. dollar into quarter-end even as the greenback possibly weakens.

Jacobsen: Given China’s entrenched rare-earths grip (~70% mining, 90% processing, 93% magnets), how much supply-chain risk can OEMs realistically hedge in the next year or two?

Schulman: Ah, yes, rare earth magnets, the new Fatal Attraction! The best hedge would be for businesses to stock up and buy all they can now. However, it’s really a question of supply constraints aligning with OEMs’ cash or financing constraints. Theoretically, borrowing to fund inventory of this sort should not be too expensive, as it would be an asset-backed loan on an easily sellable commodity; however, underlying price volatility may make the loan slightly pricier. Realistically, though, multi-year inventory stockpiling will address supply and export constraints; thus, the near-term win is not autarky or self-sufficiency, but rather multi-sourcing, e.g., inventory buffers for critical programs, magnet-to-magnet recycling, and design optionality between permanent-magnet motors and wound-rotor or switched-reluctance alternatives. You can hedge 20% to 30% of risk quickly; you hope and buy time for the rest.

U.S. magnet output has restarted at pilot scale, with one Texas facility ramping up neodymium‑iron‑boron (NdFeB) magnets and others signing offtake deals committing OEMs to purchasing all or a significant portion of future output before production begins; this helps secure crucial project financing. India, Australia, Japan, and the U.S. are adding processing capacity, but refining and heavy rare‑earth separation remain the choke points. Large manufacturers can maybe hedge 20% to 30% of critical magnet demand for high‑priority programs by next year using non‑China feedstock, long‑dated contracts, and increased recycling, while the rest stays exposed to Chinese price and policy swings. Full independence is a late‑decade ambition unless you accept significantly higher costs or redesign motors away from rare‑earth magnets.

Jacobsen: Thank you for the opportunity and your time, Michael.

Schulman: Always a pleasure to chat with you about global macro. When geopolitics and liquidity collide, narratives get rewritten in real time, so keep supply chains flexible, portfolios under a watchful eye, and your sense of humour fully hedged. Stay nimble, stay curious, stay caffeinated, hedge your exposure, question your priors, and never let a good regime shift go to waste. Also, can I be so bold as to end in a rhyme?

  • Inflation sticky, U.S. tricky, China opaque,
  • The Fed’s soul-searching for policy’s sake.
  • Markets aren’t stable, they’re feeling the fake.
  • So stay alert, stay wise, and know what’s at stake.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Human Welfare, Scientific Skepticism, and Equality: An Interview with Andrew Copson

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Parlour News Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2025/05/15

Andrew Copson is a British humanist leader, writer, and advocate born in 1980 in Warwickshire, England. He is Chief Executive of Humanists UK and President of Humanists International. Educated at Balliol College, Oxford, he has championed secularism, human rights, and inclusive education. Copson frequently represents humanist perspectives in national and international forums, including the UN. He has authored and edited multiple works on secularism and humanism and speaks widely in the media and at public events. Copson, who was raised non-religious, emphasizes human welfare, scientific skepticism, and equality, and lives with his spouse, Mark Wardrop, in a civil partnership.


Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Andrew, thanks for speaking with us as your term as President of Humanists International comes to a close. Looking back, let’s start at the beginning. How was the non‑religious, working‑class environment in Nuneaton, Warwickshire, influential on your humanist perspectives?

Copson: You’re a good interviewer! You do your background research! Well, the late twentieth century in England was a secularising time and place in any case but my experience of working class life in a (post-)industrial Midlands was certainly so. Life revolved around family, work, and community in the inclusive sense. The social institutions that I remember were either civic, sustained by the town council, or secular in that they were provided by the miners’ welfare or other social schemes. If I think back to it now I can see how that environment instilled a practical humanism – the idea that ethics arise from human needs and social living, and that community solidarity is part of the good life. It wasn’t overtly philosophical, but it provided a grounding in the reality that non-religious lives are just as meaningful, ethical, and full as any other. It certainly made the claims of religion to be the sole source of morality (when I encountered those claims in later life) seem abstract and disconnected from the real experience of many decent people. In fact I talk about this quite a bit because I think it is something that is often forgotten, but a large proportion of English working class life has been practically humanist for many decades now. That’s very different from some other countries where religious bodies provide the social institutions of community life.

Jacobsen: How was your time at King Henry VIII School and then achieving a first-class degree in Ancient and Modern History at Balliol College, Oxford, formative for the intellectual foundation for your humanism?

Copson: You’re right to ask the question in that way, because I do think my formal education played a big part in supplementing the implicit humanism of my childhood with something a bit more defined. The first thing to say is that my secondary schooling could not have been more different from my home environment. I was very fortunate that, when I was young, there was a government programme which paid for children from poor families who passed certain exams at age 11 to go to private school. If you were poor enough, it didn’t just pay for the education but also school trips, uniforms, sports kit, dinners – everything. It was called the “assisted place scheme” and it was a life-changing experience for many children from poorer backgrounds in the years it was operating from 1979 to 1997. So I was in the unusual position in England of having an elite education for free. That school education changed my life. History, literature, but particularly Classics, which were the subjects I ended up most in love with, are suffused with humanist values – critical thinking, imaginative sympathy, understanding context and tracing the development of ideas. Latin and Greek – and Athenian literature in particular – have profoundly shaped my worldview and my inner life and what the classicist and humanist Gilbert Murray called “Hellenic humanism” still provides many of my cultural reference points. And then of course, studying history reveals the contingency of beliefs, the discontinuities and continuities of societies throughout time, the ongoing and dynamic nature of social change, and the often-fraught relationship between conservative religious institutions and human progress, freedom, and equality. And of course, just like my experience of home life, it teaches you to be skeptical of anyone who claims that certain values are the sole preserve of one religion or another. I could easily have slipped into academia and the life of the mind but Balliol College, with its tradition of radical thought and public service, was an environment that encouraged you to apply that intellectual rigour to questions about how we should live and organise ourselves and, although I still (especially in these times) find it challenging not to retreat into the library, I felt the pull of activism.

Jacobsen: Why did you join the British Humanist Association (now Humanists UK) as a volunteer in 2002?

Copson: I first joined the BHA as a member in 2002 when the UK government began its programme to expand the number and type of state religious schools in England because I wanted to support an organisation that was campaigning on that issue. Because of my background and just a general secular assumption that many people had at that time, the expansion of state religious schools just seemed like a horrifying backwards step for community cohesion and education in general. I probably would have joined eventually in any case, to connect my personal convictions with action. I saw the BHA as the obvious organisation giving voice to humanist views in the public square, working for a secular state, and promoting the positive values of the humanist approach to life. I wanted to contribute to that and be part of a community working towards a more rational, compassionate, and fair society. A few years later when I moved to London and was unemployed, I started volunteering at the London office.

Jacobsen: When you were Director of Education and Public Affairs at Humanists UK from 2005 to 2010, what initiatives were promoted for secular education and to challenge faith schools?

Copson: Looking back on those years, they were a really crucial period. A major focus was campaigning for reform of Religious Education – moving away from confessional instruction towards a more objective and inclusive subject covering the range of major religions and non-religious worldviews like humanism. We wanted children to understand the diverse beliefs and values in society, not be indoctrinated into one. We had considerable successes in that arena as well as securing a ban on state schools teaching creationism as science. Alongside this, we strongly challenged the expansion of state-funded faith schools and their discriminatory practices, particularly in admissions – where children could be turned away based on their parents’ beliefs – and in employment. We also campaigned vigorously for comprehensive, evidence-based Sex and Relationships Education, free from religious dogma, arguing it was vital for young people’s health and wellbeing, which was scheduled to be introduced in 2010. We were very involved in the Equality Acts of 2006 and 2010 as well as in the abolition of the blasphemy law. For a young campaigner like me, it was probably an unparalleled time for liberal reform and the direct access to government that we experienced was probably the most significant in our history.

Jacobsen: You became Chief Executive of Humanists UK in 2010 at the remarkably young age of 29. Why run for that position, and what challenges and opportunities arose in advocacy then?

Copson: Actually I was appointed at 28 – the day before my 29th birthday! We can genuinely say that age is irrelevant at Humanists UK – the first chief executive in 1896, the suffragette Zona Vallnace, was 36, and our most famous, Harold Backham, was 60. But I’d already been deeply involved for several years. I felt passionately about our mission and saw huge potential. The non-religious demographic was clearly growing, and there was an increasing public appetite for humanist perspectives on ethical issues and public life. I believed I could help steer us to meet that opportunity, to professionalise further, and to increase our impact. There were challenges, navigating the complexities of influencing policy in a country with an established church and deeply embedded religious privilege. We were often pushing against very established interests. The opportunities, however, were immense. We could be a clearer, stronger voice for the non-religious, build alliances, launch impactful campaigns – like the ongoing work on humanist marriage recognition or assisted dying – and provide more support and services for the growing number of people identifying with humanist values. It was a chance to really shape the organisation for a new era. That era looked pretty bright. Before the General Election of 2010 we were seeing moves to regulate state faith schools, humanist philosophers appointed by the government to advise on a future constitution, and serious school curriculum reform prioritising critical thinking and skills for citizenship. Of course, the election of that year and the events since have meant that is not how wider politics have turned out. But I also wanted to expand the service provision aspects of Humanists UK, moving into pastoral care and other ways of providing community and support alongside our long-established ceremonies work, and that has been a great success.

Jacobsen: What motivated you to then run for the President of Humanists International in 2015?

Copson: Having led Humanists UK for five years, I’d seen firsthand the power of organised humanism to effect change nationally. But it was also starkly clear that many of the challenges we faced – threats to secularism, the promotion of human rights, the need for rational responses to global issues – were international in scope. Furthermore, humanists in many parts of the world face persecution, discrimination, and even violence simply for their non-religious convictions. I felt a strong sense of solidarity and believed that my experience in building a national organisation could be valuable in strengthening the global movement. Humanists International provides that crucial platform for international cooperation, advocacy at the highest levels like the UN, and mutual support among humanist organisations worldwide.

Jacobsen: How has your leadership at Humanists International since 2015 impacted the global humanist movement?

Copson: I hope my contribution has been to help consolidate and professionalise the organisation, making it a more effective advocate on the world stage. We’ve worked hard to amplify the voices of humanists, particularly those facing threats, at international forums like the UN Human Rights Council. We’ve strengthened the network of member organisations, fostering collaboration and sharing best practices. Key campaigns, like the End Blasphemy Laws campaign, have gained significant traction, raising global awareness of how these laws are used to suppress dissent and persecute minorities, including the non-religious. We’ve also developed resources and support systems for nascent humanist groups. It’s always a collective effort, of course, involving dedicated staff, Board members, and member organisations globally. But I hope my presidency has helped Humanists International become a more visible, impactful, and supportive hub for humanism around the world. I have particularly prioritised increasing representation from the global south and I’m very pleased that the Board I am leaving behind has members from Africa, Asia, and Latin America. The Board I first joined had members solely from the global north.

Jacobsen: Thinking about specific campaigns, what do you see as the impacts of initiatives like the Atheist Bus Campaign, the push for legal recognition of humanist marriages, or the advocacy for assisted dying?

Copson: They are all very different activities. The Atheist Bus Campaign (‘There’s probably no God. Now stop worrying and enjoy your life.’) was deliberately provocative but incredibly successful in raising the profile of atheism and humanism, sparking countless conversations, and showing non-religious people they weren’t alone. It demonstrated a confidence in expressing non-religious viewpoints publicly. The campaign for legal recognition of humanist marriages is about fundamental fairness and equality. Thousands of couples want a meaningful, personal, non-religious ceremony led by a humanist celebrant, reflecting their values. Achieving legal recognition, as we have in Scotland and Northern Ireland, validates those choices and removes discrimination. The ongoing campaign in England and Wales highlights the state lagging behind public attitudes and the need for inclusive marriage laws. Advocacy for assisted dying is rooted in compassion, autonomy, and individual dignity. We want people facing unbearable suffering at the end of life to have the choice to die peacefully, on their own terms. Our role has been to provide a clear ethical framework based on reason and empathy, challenging religious opposition that seeks to deny this choice, and contributing to the growing momentum for legal change. Each of these campaigns, in different ways, work towards a society that respects non-religious perspectives, values equality, and prioritises human wellbeing and autonomy. And of course they all push back against the forces of conformity, privilege, and control which as humanists we stand against.

Jacobsen: How have your publications – The Little Book of Humanism (2020) and Secularism: Politics, Religion, and Freedom (2017) – contributed to public understanding and humanist ideas?

Copson: The intention behind the first was in part clarification. Secularism aimed to communicate a concept that is often misunderstood or deliberately misrepresented. I wanted to provide a concise explanation of what secularism is – essentially, a framework for ensuring fairness between citizens of different religions and beliefs in diverse societies, involving separation of religious institutions from the state, and guaranteeing freedom of belief for all – and why it’s crucial for democracy and human rights. The Little Book of Humanism, written during COVID-19 with Alice Roberts, was designed to be a very accessible, positive introduction to the humanist worldview – its history, its core principles, how it applies to living a meaningful life and contributing to society. The goal was to reach a broader audience, perhaps people who felt broadly humanist but hadn’t quite put a name to it, and offer a compelling vision of a life guided by reason, compassion, and shared human values. It became the first book on humanism to be a Sunday Times bestseller and that was a vindication of our intentions, I thought.

Jacobsen: Finally, Andrew, as your term as President of Humanists International concludes, what now?

Copson: My ‘day job’ as Chief Executive of Humanists UK continues! There’s certainly no shortage of work to be done. The challenges we’ve discussed – defending secularism, ensuring inclusive education, campaigning on ethical issues like assisted dying, promoting human rights – are ongoing. And they take place against a national and global backdrop of authoritarianism and illiberalism which makes the position of humanism in our age as precarious as in any. I still think the answer to that challenge is humanism and the global perspective I’ve gained over these years has greatly enhanced my commitment to that view. So, the focus remains on building the humanist movement, advocating for our values, and working towards a fairer, more ethical world for everyone.

Jacobsen: Andrew Copson, thank you so much.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Weathering Dark Times, Emerging Stronger: An Interview With Candace Gorham, AHA President

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Parlour News Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10

Candace Gorham is the President of the American Humanist Association. She spoke with Canadian humanist and journalist Scott Douglas Jacobsen for a recent interview.

Gorham is a licensed mental health counsellor and author of The Ebony Exodus Project: Why Some Black Women Are Walking Out on Religion–and Others Should Too and On Death, Dying, and Disbelief. She is a former ordained minister turned atheist activist, researcher, and writer on religion, secular social justice, and the African-American community. She is also a member of the Secular Therapist Project and The Clergy Project.

Gorham discussed the state of humanism post-election, particularly within African American communities. She discussed the general tone of distress among humanists due to Trump’s popular vote win and its implications for America. She emphasized the need for proactive activism, combating Christian Nationalism, and supporting affected communities. Gorham highlighted the unfamiliarity with humanism among Black communities and the opportunity for growth by reaching out and supporting those leaving religion but seeking meaning. She also noted the potential challenges with misinformation and the popularity of alternative beliefs like astrology and crystals.


Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Today [Editor’s Note: this interview took place in November 2024], Candace Gorham joins us to discuss various aspects of humanism in the immediate aftermath of the American election. The Republicans appear to have won significantly, which is concerning for many humanists, given their policies and the people within their circles.

Over the past few days, what is the general tone and feeling within American humanist communities based on what you are observing?

Candace Gorham: I would start with my immediate circle of friends and family. Many people are troubled, and there is a palpable sense of despair. I met with some staff today, and confusion and distress were evident. People are puzzled by how former President Trump managed to win again despite being considered offensive by many. The most unsettling aspect for many is that he won the popular vote this time, which has left people questioning their neighbors’ and friends’ beliefs.

Previously, when Trump won the electoral college but not the popular vote, it was easier to rationalize it as a quirk of the system. However, this time, there has been talk of a “red wave” and the unexpected loss of many Democratic strongholds. As I mentioned, people are mostly disturbed about what this signifies for the United States today. What does this say about the country we live in? It is distressing.

Jacobsen: Political activism, policy advocacy, and related efforts are also questioned. What is your approach to addressing this situation from a proactive, activist perspective for the American Humanist Association?

Gorham: Many members of our organization are eager to fight and engage in policy work, advocacy, and volunteerism. From our staff to our chapters and affiliates, individuals are ready to stand up and contribute to meaningful efforts. We are currently working on determining how we can best support them.

When I say “we,” I am referring to leadership, as we focus on finding ways to support our members and anyone seeking our assistance. How can we provide support in this moment of shock and despair? Furthermore, what can we do moving forward when it is time to engage in sustained activism? We have the staff capable of leading that charge, especially with our new Executive Director Fish Stark.

Jacobsen: Some issues will be more immediately relevant when targeting different areas for this work. Where do you see the most immediate impacts for humanist communities? Will it be focused on reproductive rights or LGBTQ+ rights? Or will it focus more on direct church-state separation and related issues?

Gorham: Yes, I would say that we need to find that balance again because so many people—women, LGBTQ+ individuals, men who support women’s rights—are affected and hurting in their everyday lives. As an organization, the AHA wants to craft a way to support people in dealing with their feelings of angst. At the same time, we want to provide a space for them to channel some of that energy. One of the significant focuses—without putting words in our Executive Director’s mouth—is fighting against Christian Nationalism.

Jacobsen: So, is that where we will see more of the work being done—focusing on church-state separation and combating White Christian Nationalism that has become pervasive and is part of why we are where we are today?

Gorham: Yes, that will be a major focus moving forward.

Jacobsen: As a licensed mental health counsellor, what would you recommend for young people who are experiencing their first major political shocks to consider for maintaining their mental health while potentially using that energy to become more proactive rather than staying in despair?

Gorham: Yes, I will share what I’ve been reminding myself today. The United States has been through ugly, dark times—nasty and frightening. Yet, we have survived and, in many cases, strengthened and improved. I keep telling myself that the institutions built over time—our Constitution, our organizations, and the structures that uphold American ideals—have been battered, bruised, and tested before. I am hopeful that they will hold once again because they have withstood challenges in the past. I encourage people to remember that we have weathered dark times before and emerged stronger, continuing to move forward and improve.

On a more personal note, I advise people to do what I did last night: have my daughter come over and spend time with friends, family, and support groups. Engage in activities that keep you connected and away from being alone, watching cable news, or endlessly scrolling through TikTok and feeling more overwhelmed. Surrounding yourself with supportive people or those who want to take action and who want to be involved in activism is essential. Whether it’s volunteer work or attending a march (and I am sure there will be many in the months to come), finding ways to channel anxiety and frustration can make a significant difference. It may help you feel more empowered and better able to cope.

Engage in activities; don’t just watch what is being discussed or happening passively. Participate in some way, even if it’s something as small as getting together with friends for a book club or similar activities. Or, if you feel up to it, do activist work, get out there on the streets, canvass, knock on doors, and do whatever you can.

Jacobsen: You wrote The Ebony Exodus Project—it’s been eleven/twelve years. So, what is the current status of what we can call The Ebony Exodus Project?

Gorham: In general, the number of Black women who identify as spiritual, religious, or Christian is still high, especially if we include not just Christianity but spirituality and belief in a divine entity or supernatural beliefs. At the time I wrote The Ebony Exodus Project, about 86% of Black women in America identified as Christians. From what I recall from the most recent Pew report I read, even though it’s a few years old, those numbers are still in the 80% range.

Anecdotally, from my experience as a Black woman in the Black community and from conversations with other women I know, there is a shift happening, particularly among younger women—by younger, I mean fifty and under. These women are moving away from organized religion and are creating their spiritual meanings and practices. One of the things I find interesting is that even among non-believers or those who consider themselves atheists, there is an increasing belief in horoscopes and crystals.

This trend, which I consider somewhat supernatural, is what I am seeing everywhere, and it distresses me even more than the Christianity I left behind. At least with Christianity, there were tangible aspects you could challenge, like the Bible or scientific claims. But how do you challenge horoscopes or crystals? Suppose someone believes that a crystal on their forehead will cure a headache. In that case, engaging them in critical thinking becomes more challenging.

I even have family members who, for lack of a better term, I describe as “woo-woo.” They are into crystals, horoscopes, and similar things. I always push back and ask, “Have you read anything about this beyond a TikTok video? Have you considered opinions from someone who doesn’t believe that horoscopes are real?”

And many people, and this ties back to the election, face the issue of disinformation and misinformation in America and probably worldwide. People get their news from social media in little one- to three-minute sound bites, memes, and similar formats. They need to get a complete picture of what is happening around them. This is also true when it comes to religion and supernatural beliefs.

Jacobsen: What about the state of humanism generally within an African American context? Is there increasing comfort and space for individuals coming out of the Black church? Or is it a repetition of past community mistakes, where there isn’t an open, authentic space for people to bring their cultural narratives and individual stories into a humanist space, leaving behind religion while taking on humanist values in the context of their subculture within the United States?

Gorham: I would say that a significant portion of the Black community is still largely unfamiliar with humanism and humanist thought. I remember when I was younger, in college, learning about humanism in the context of 17th and 18th-century writers who discussed it. At that time, I thought, “Oh, humanism. This isn’t Christian. This is the belief that we only have each other and must do good among ourselves.” It wasn’t considered a Christian way of thinking, so the term “humanism” was, and to some still is, a dirty word.

It’s almost synonymous with atheism for some people. Humanism is still a “dirty word” for those who know what it means, while the vast majority probably don’t even know the term. I believe this area has growth potential—how we reach out to more diverse communities that may have never heard of humanism. When I first got into the movement and wrote The Ebony Exodus Project twelve years ago, I often heard Black people say, “I never even heard the word atheist.” They didn’t know what it meant. Humanism is even less known. When I tell people, “Yes, I’m an atheist, but I’m also a humanist, and my humanism informs my ethics,” I often get, “Well, what’s that?”

People are starting to become more familiar with the term “atheist” or “non-believer,” but “humanist” is still not widely recognized. This is a major opportunity for our organization. Even those who believe in horoscopes and crystals still want a moral compass to guide them in understanding good, bad, right, or wrong. They may turn to astrology because they crave something that helps them build meaning.

When the American Humanist Association finds a way to communicate with these individuals effectively, it will be a significant breakthrough and a valuable resource. Many in the Black community are moving away from structured religion but are still seeking something to fill that void. That’s where we can step in and start to provide that support.

Jacobsen: That’s a good point. Regarding culturally identifiable figures, there are you, Ayanna Watson, Mandisa Thomas, Sikivu Hutchinson, and Debbie Goddard. There aren’t too many individuals who are necessarily recognizable as Black women humanists. It’s improving in terms of having leading voices, but to your point, incorporating more is necessary. Do you have any upcoming literary works or activities that people should be on the lookout for?

Gorham: As the new president, I’m trying to get my bearings with the organization. I’m new, and we have a new Executive Director. Much work needs to be done to get things rolling again. I’m not currently focusing on anything outside of that. I do have some book ideas percolating in the background. Still, I have yet to start on any of them because my current focus is supporting our new Executive Director and helping achieve some of his goals.

Jacobsen: Candace, thank you for your time and the opportunity to talk.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

The Work Begins to End Global Blasphemy Laws: An Interview with Mubarak Bala

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): Parlour News Media

Mubarak Bala, a humanist in Nigeria, was recently released from prison for what amounts to charges of blasphemy. In an interview with Canadian humanist Scott Douglas Jacobsen, Bala reflects on his unjust detention, emphasizing that freedom of expression and belief are crucial for justice and progress. He describes Nigeria’s escalating religious extremism, persecution of humanists, and threats to secularism. Bala highlights the global need to abolish blasphemy laws and the challenges humanists face, particularly in their struggle to stay alive. He advocates for political action, media reform, and international lobbying to promote secularism. Bala plans to run for Nigeria’s presidency in 2031. He expresses joy at reuniting with his family while condemning systemic injustice. His resilience underscores the importance of safeguarding human rights and free thought worldwide.


Scott Douglas Jacobsen: How has (unjust) experience shaped your views on the importance of freedom of expression and belief in fostering a just society?

Mubarak Bala: Well, even before my unfair abduction and kidnapping, I have always known that the world I live in is not free; it is a world full of cruelty and menace to freedom and innovation; this is why it took millennia to manage life as it came, while societies that allowed that singular civil right, flourished and prospered, which seeped through time and ushered in the modern science and free inquiry that we enjoy today, which ultimately changed the destiny of our species and planet.

The fact that I was abducted only confirmed to me and folks that it is a long way to go for many countries and many societies, but whereas some sane cultures have already made it unfair and illegal to disallow free thought and free beliefs, others have chosen the path to cruelty, perversion, persecution, poverty and unnecessary harm to life.

This is glaring and evident in my immediate society, the north of Nigeria, where we’re most unsafe, from local governments agitating and mongering for the Shari’a and Jihadism. Sadly, the Federal Forces are on the dangerous pathway to expand this nationwide, jettisoning the secular federal constitution, albeit without a constitutional amendment or a national referendum.

Free thought is super important; free speech is the beginning of fairness and justice and any meaningful social cohesion of all members of any nation or society or conglomerates of nations such as Nigeria. It is these values that would shape our future and preserve the fragile peace, thereby perpetuating the country; otherwise, it would spiral down the blackhole of anarchy and civil war; sadly, we’ve been on that trajectory for two decades now, and it seems no one sees the path, none but few, such as I.

The Islamists brought us sharia, and then gradually, they brought us jihadism and jihadists, who are activists for the Shari’a. This bred terrorism and banditry, which is threatening to consume all of us. They seek to silence dissent and voices of reason, they seek to dominate, they seek to appease jihadists and their paymasters, they seek to appease non-existent gods and deities, and they are ready to murder for the glory of cultures far away, both in time and in mileage. They do this, and the world could only write, nothing much could be done, because, the world confuses Muslimophobia with Islamophobia, the two are distinct and can be understood by any rational person.

Now, there must be peace in the world. That peace cannot manifest without freedoms for women, thinkers, and all members of the community or society, and justice for the fringe members of any community, be they minorities by tribe, race, religion, sect, or social standing/class. The pathway is simple. However, it takes only courageous governments, politicians, policymakers, international bodies and actors, and the direct victims themselves to these tragedies.

Jacobsen: What challenges for humanists in Nigeria seem the most significant in online and offline spaces now?

Bala: Challenges for humanists at the moment are vast and numerous, intricate and intertwining cascades of cards and mazes. Sadly, we can’t solve any of them while dead, and since we’re actively being sought to be murdered by lone actors, by our governments, by vigilante and sharia police, then we can’t and haven’t started solving any of these problems with all the attention, resources and energy we could, because we’re busy trying not to die. It’s that simple. We are battling daily challenges to stay alive, then probably seek other fairness and justice as well for our members and the fringe, especially those made illegal by the governments for populism.

You may notice that over the decade or more, I suffered incarcerations, death threats, and attempted lobotomy; no one else has ever been arrested or punished by my tormentors and bullies, no one. Many of them have already murdered our kind, or Christians and minority sects, but the governors pay compensation to the victim’s families and set the culprits free.

Jacobsen: Why do you believe freedom of expression is a cornerstone of humanism?

Bala: The cornerstone for humanism is remaining alive. Everything else comes second. Therefore, freedom of speech, thought, or belief is second to that, at least in Nigeria.

So, perhaps freedom of expression is the cornerstone of humanism in the West, but in our climes, the right to life after changing beliefs is our paramount cornerstone or priority.

Jacobsen: What lessons can be drawn from imprisonment in restrictive environments? What is the role of humanist organizations in defending freedom of expression?

Bala: Lessons that can be drawn from imprisonment in restrictive environments:

  • Living another day, and never dying is one thing, but also,
  • ⁠Utilize the idle time to expand your knowledge and
  • Try and keep your sanity and health, especially your mental and physical health. They try to engage you spiritually, but you know that is all crap since it’s about mythology and illogical dialogues, so you skip that. Instead, you exercise and eat well, that’s if you can find the food, though.
  • ⁠I also learnt that in our environment, prison is only for the lower class, the poor and, the sick and the old; no rich person stays in prison for long. Many resources go via envelopes under the table, justice is for sale.
  • Most importantly, stand your ground. I was converted to my former religion by force, but the moment I had access to a lawyer, I refused to bow down again.
  • I also learnt that family is important, and not all you thought were family are. You may be born of the same womb, of the same woman or loins, but your actual siblings may be oceans away from you, connected by the internet, by humanity, and by the philosophy that all born must live free and that there is no limit to the resources and time that they could expend to see you free, to see justice done.

Jacobsen: How can we protect other cases of humanists at risk, e.g., Ahmadreza Djalali, Andrea Gilbert, Asaduzzaman Noor, Ashraf Fayadh, Atheists in Kenya Society, George Gavriel, Gáspár Békés, Gulalai Ismail, Indika Rathnayaka, Leena Manimekalai, Leo Igwe, Mahmoud Jama Ahmed, Mohamed Hisham, Mohamed Rusthum Mujuthaba, Mohammed Ould Shaikh Ould Mkhaitir, Mommad, M.M. Kalburgi, Narendra Dabholkar, Narendra Nayak, Panayote Dimitras, Raif Badawi, Rishvin Ismath, Saïd Djabelkhir, Shakthika Sathkumara, and Soheil Arabi?

Bala: We could protect humanists at risk by ending intolerance, meaning editing out inedible texts called or deemed holy. These are what leads to the murders or the government torment of individuals and families. They do this because they believe they are obeying some deity, that they’re the good people and you’re the bad.

The difference between terrorists and criminals is that criminals know they’re wrong and are feeling the guilt, one way or another. Terrorists have a clear conscience and believe that no matter what pain or blood they spill, they’re doing the right thing and that they’re the victims if they are allowed to carry out these atrocities.

Jacobsen: How will this Nigerian case impact the global conversation about blasphemy laws or quasi-blasphemy legal contexts?

Bala: I believe that we could at least say the West now received a nudge, a prod, or a small jolt to end all blasphemy laws and find a way to sanction countries that mete these atrocities on their citizens. Mind you, it’s not just my case. At least I didn’t die. Count the many that didn’t make it, be it in Iran, Arabia, Somalia, Malaysia, or Afghanistan. I should say I’m lucky, but we must end blasphemy laws around the world, then go on and end the Shari’a, as it has no place in modern societies. You guys confuse the fanatics that there must be freedom of religion and belief globally, and so, they also think that since their dogma is also part of the world religions, their ‘peace’ must be global. This means they have the right to misogyny and patriarchy; they have the right to kill nonbelievers; they also feel that it is their right, right of belief, to keep women locked up.

Jacobsen: How can international humanist movements effectively challenge laws and practices?

Bala: The international humanist community could lobby where there are democracies, coalesce where there are no freedoms, to form alliances and communities to protect themselves.

We must also join politics, effect change, and bring about secularism in governance. I, for one, will run for president in Nigeria in 2031 and radically change my country, which is on a dangerous trajectory.

I have already had about half a decade to work out my plans. Now, it’s time to start the action. I’ll leave my country for a while, then strategize and seek resources and partners and pressure my country to start asking the right questions, the national question, have a referendum and a new constitution; then we’ll see which direction to go: allow Talibanistan to go and form their country? Or join Nigeria in actual progress?

Jacobsen: What is the balance between respecting religious beliefs and protecting the right to question or critique those beliefs?

Bala: Balance between respecting religious beliefs and protecting rights to question…

In all sincerity, there is nothing about respecting faith and dogma and indoctrination or misogyny and terrorism; I cannot respect the Shari’a nor the Jihad, and never the book that asked man to murder man. There’s no two ways about it. I already mentioned earlier that Muslimophobia is wrong, while Islamophobia is legit and must be encouraged. Simple.

Jacobsen: What strategies are most effective for promoting humanism and secularism?

Bala: Strategies for promoting humanism by activism, speaking, networking, and forming communities where we protect ourselves.

Jacobsen: What is the future of humanism and freedom of expression in Nigeria?

Bala: At the moment, I’d say it’s doomed. This is why I have to leave, strategize and return; I have plans to start a Media House focused on Nigeria, West Africa, the Sahel Belt, and sub-Saharan Africa, in all languages involved, because the mainstream media assigned these jobs have failed us, failed miserably…

Jacobsen: How is your wife and family? How is it to see your kids again?

Bala: My wife and child are fine and healthy. We’re slowly reconnecting and recovering and counting our losses and hoping that this is the last time I suffer this misadventure orchestrated by my family and government. Seeing my kid again balanced out all the losses I incurred all this while.

Jacobsen: What were Leo Igwe’s first words?

Bala: The first call I received from the police custody in Kaduna was Leo’s call, but before I could discuss anything with him, the phone was seized; even though other inmates were allowed contact with family, legal services and associates—but not I, not for almost a year. And a further year before, I saw the courtroom. While rapists and murderers and terrorists were going for trials, getting bail, acquittals and even accolades showered on them, I was slowly dying and maligned in the hope that I acquiesced, but I didn’t. Never would. Never will.

Jacobsen: Thank you again for the opportunity and your time, Mubarak. We finally got that interview!

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Founder of Military Religious Freedom Foundation on Christian Nationalism

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Parlour News Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2024/11/04

Michael L. “Mikey” Weinstein is an undisputed leader of the national movement to restore the obliterated wall separating church and state in the most technologically lethal organization ever created by humankind: the United States armed forces. Described by Harper’s magazine as “the constitutional conscience of the U.S. military, a man determined to force accountability,” Mikey’s family has a long and distinguished U.S. military history spanning three consecutive generations of military academy graduates and over 130 years of combined active duty military service in every major combat engagement our country has been in from World War I to the current Global War on Terror. Mikey is a 1977 Honor Graduate of the United States Air Force Academy. He left Mr. Perot’s employ in 2006 to focus his full-time attention on the nonprofit charitable foundation he founded to directly battle the far-right militant radical evangelical religious fundamentalists: the Military Religious Freedom Foundation.


Scott Douglas Jacobsen: So, we’re back again with Mikey Weinstein. We’re in the final stretch of the federal election season in the United States. What are the main concerns coming your way? What issues are you identifying outside of those directly affecting your constituencies during this election? First, we are a 501(c)(3), so we can’t tell anyone how to vote, but we can certainly discuss the issues involved here.

Mike Weinstein: If anyone has read Margaret Atwood’s The Handmaid’s Tale, with its dystopian portrayal of a Christian Nationalist United States, that offers a striking example of what we’re trying to prevent. It’s a simple question to answer, Scott. Our biggest concern is that we were the first organization to sound the alarm on what eventually became known as Christian Nationalism. We’ve been addressing it since the early 2000s.

For many years, people accused us of wearing tinfoil hats. But here we are now. We first identified this threat in the early 2000s and are now in our 21st year of fighting it. I know it’s Friday, and I might be waxing a bit philosophical. Still, when Christian nationalism infiltrates our police force, firefighters, sewage departments, public schools, and legislatures, it’s already alarming. However, when it reaches the technologically most lethal organization our species has ever created—the U.S. military, with all its nuclear weapons, drones, laser-guided, and conventional weapons—it’s not just an issue or a challenge. It’s a national security threat to this country and the world.

We are working to prevent what we see as the ultimate manifestation of Christian nationalism merging with the United States military—the technologically most lethal organization ever created.

This situation has many dimensions, but it’s easy to understand. This is not some complex meal like Chateaubriand—it’s a hamburger. In other words, you cannot use your military authority to impose a weaponized version of the gospel of Jesus Christ on helpless subordinates.

We have a press release coming out soon. A day or two ago, I sent you a letter about an Air Force group commander who forced his subordinate squadron commanders and all members to watch a controversial Christian film. While I can’t name the film, it shouldn’t be too hard to guess.

Unlike Israel, which lacks a formal constitution, America has one, and a fundamental part of it is the separation of church and state. Our founding framers looked at European history and saw that much of the horror resulted from clerics wielding state power, such as Cromwell in England. We didn’t have to look far: the Salem witch trials in our history were a strong warning about what happens when theological perspectives gain governmental power. Many Muslim-majority countries, for example, lack separation between mosque and state, which provides a clear example of the risks we are trying to prevent here.

But in America, we do have that separation. We have it here for a reason. November 5 is the most consequential moment in the history of this country, if not the most consequential in the history of the West or arguably the world. In past conflicts, like the Civil War, the Revolutionary War, and the French and Indian War, there was no social media, no nuclear weapons, no drones, or laser-guided missiles. So, it’s a terrifying prospect.

I don’t know what’s going to happen. I’d rather not be a doomsday predictor. Still, it’s hard to see how, no matter who wins on November 5, this country may avoid some semblance of a civil war with potentially blood spilled on the streets. It’s indeed a difficult time. From what we deal with at the foundation, you may remember that last summer, certain MAGA members of the U.S. House of Representatives tried to amend the largest part of the federal budget, the National Defense Authorization Act—the Pentagon funding bill. They attempted, without open disclosure, to make it a felony for anyone in the U.S. military to reach out to us for help.

Our organization’s name was mentioned three times, and their president mentioned me personally in connection with that amendment. We caught it in time and worked for six months with Senate Democrats to remove it before it reached Biden’s desk in those quiet days between Christmas and New Year’s. I often feel, and I wonder if it’s similar to your experience, Scott, that our enemies better define us than our friends. We certainly expect to be targeted if MAGA gains control, and we need to know what’s coming with the House and Senate.

We can already see what’s happening on the Supreme Court, which essentially granted Trump immunity in a recent ruling. I’ve touched on many topics. Still, we’re having this conversation during an especially uncertain time, with dark clouds gathering quickly. Suppose they’re permitted to control the machinery of the state here in America. In that case, it’s hard to see how there won’t be violence.

Jacobsen: Recently, the United States Air Force Academy’s Superintendent, Lieutenant General Tony Bauernfeind, submitted a memo affirming the need for religious neutrality, aligned with Air Force Instruction 1-1, Section 2.16. This section prohibits religious favoritism within the U.S. military. You praised him for this. What about the interaction and his actions stood out to you?

Weinstein: I’m glad you mentioned that. This was the first time a senior Air Force official acknowledged the existence of this regulation. We’ve worked very hard at the foundation for years, collaborating with key senior personnel at Air Force Headquarters and the Pentagon, who showed courage. These particular generals and other leaders helped advance what was originally Air Force Instruction 1-1, Section 2.12. It required that leaders at all levels in the Air Force ensure their words and actions can’t be reasonably construed as supporting one faith over another or none at all. This eventually evolved into Section 2.16, which reinforces the same principle.

So we did, yes. We put out a release praising him. We also asked him to stay out of our client’s business at the Air Force Academy. I’m a graduate, and three of my kids are. Because before this, he’d crossed us on three separate occasions. He’s only been the superintendent since August 2, Scott. He last came there three months ago, yet he got on our radar almost immediately.

In his change-of-command speech, he reportedly told his audience of cadets, faculty, and staff about something he called “perfect spiritual beings.” After three instances of interfering with our clients there—cadets, faculty, and staff—we have over 100 clients at the Academy—he finally did something right. So, credit where it’s due.

Using a baseball analogy, he’s now batting 1 for 4. The first three times, he swung and missed. However, this recent action strongly supported an Air Force directive that was not just advisory. As a former judge advocate and an attorney, I know it’s a directive with legal teeth. Violating it can lead to prosecution under the Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ).

So, yes, we praised him. But we have no formal relationship with the Academy. That was severed in August 2010 when the then-superintendent, Mike Gould, refused to act against an organization called Cadets for Christ, a Christian nationalist, dominionist group that was out of control. That’s when we broke off relations. The Academy became ground zero in our fight, which began on February 4, 2004. That’s when Mel Gibson’s movie, The Passion of the Christ, emerged. We often call it The Jesus Chainsaw Massacre or Freddy vs. Jesus. There was intense pressure from the senior officer and senior cadet command chain for cadets, faculty, and staff to see it. If you’ve seen it, you’ll remember it. It’s astonishing when commanders make it mandatory for subordinates to watch a film like that.

Today, we’re releasing a statement about another Air Force commander who forced subordinates to watch a Christian film. We have yet to reveal the title or location. Still, this action is a blatant violation of Air Force Instruction 1-1, Section 2.16, violating the Establishment Clause of the U.S. Constitution. It also conflicts with Article VI, Clause 3, which states that there should be no religious test for public office. I might be mixing up the references. Still, it breaches various directives, federal and state regulations, and case law.

Until people face real consequences for this behavior, change won’t happen. Imagine if there were a 70 mph speed limit on a highway in Vancouver, and people regularly drove 130 mph because there were no consequences. We’ve been calling for someone to be court-martialed for violating the civil rights of military members for over two decades, and we’re still waiting. We’ve seen people get fired and receive letters of reprimand or counseling, but we have yet to see real accountability.

We’ve seen some people suddenly have their careers derailed, but we would like to demonstrate how essential it is to recognize this civil right for military members. We also have clients across all eighteen national security agencies, including the big ones everyone knows—the CIA, NSA, FBI, and so on. We have clients in the U.S. Coast Guard, part of the Department of Homeland Security, not DOD, and in the U.S. Maritime Service, specifically the U.S. Merchant Marine Academy under the Department of Transportation.

Most of our clients are within the DOD. When a service member is even gently evangelized by their military superior, they can’t exactly say, “Get out of my face, sir or ma’am.” They risk facing a court-martial for insubordination, so they come to us. We provide what we call AARP—not the organization for seniors, but Anonymity, Action, Results, and Protection.

We’ve never compromised the identity of any of our clients, and we never will. I’ve been asked by a judge in federal court to reveal clients’ names, and I said, “I won’t do it. Put me in jail if you must, but I won’t do it.” Protecting the sanctity of our clients’ identities is paramount.

We started with just five clients in 2004-2005, even before the foundation was officially established, primarily at the Air Force Academy. We’re approaching 91,000 clients, a milestone we expect to reach soon. It’s a tough, hard fight. I didn’t ask to become a public figure; this role found me. They don’t teach you how to start a civil rights advocacy organization in law school or as an undergrad at the Academy.

If you’re a professional athlete or a Hollywood star, being a public figure might be “cool.” But in my line of work, there are four things: lonely, dangerous, brutal, and expensive. We have dogs—not pets but elite-level protection German Shepherds. They’re expensive, yes, but necessary defense weapons. We have firearms, personal bodyguards, and a strong relationship with local law enforcement, and we’re always watching our backs. Even simple outings like going to a movie or a restaurant require constant vigilance. We’re labelled part of the “enemies from within,” a term Trump has used.

The U.S. Congress has never attempted to target Planned Parenthood or the ACLU the way they did us recently, trying to, in effect, legislate us out of existence. We wear that as a red badge of courage, a sign that we’re getting under the right people’s skin, but it’s a tough battle. I’m not a politician; I’m a civil rights advocate. America has an incredible number of nuclear weapons and a vast number of power levers. It’s dangerous when those levers fall into the hands of people who feel led not by established case law or the U.S. Constitution but by a particularly weaponized interpretation of a 2,000- or 3,000-year-old text.

This isn’t a “Houston, we have a problem” situation. As I said before, we have a national security threat within our own country, just as serious as external threats from ISIS, Al Qaeda, or the Taliban. People don’t like hearing that.

Jacobsen: Thank you for the opportunity and your time, Mikey.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Must-Read Mikey Weinstein Interview on “A Further Inquiry” — How MRFF is Navigating a Military and VA Ordered to Root Out Imaginary “Anti-Christian Bias”

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2025/11/10

“… We have never seen so many high-ranking military officials reaching out to us. These are not just 18- or 19-year-old enlisted troops or junior officers fresh out of the academies, ROTC, Officer Training School, or Officer Candidate School. That’s been flipped.

“Particularly in the VA, most of the people contacting us now are civilians, and many are seniors. That tells you something. So people need to take action—whether it is to leave a record of integrity for their children or their children’s children or simply to be able to look their neighbours in the eye and say, I tried to stop this. The difference between now and 1933? There was no social media back then. Now, we have the tools to resist publicly and collectively.

“You need to act—not just because it is the right thing to do—but because it is the only thing to do. And I’ll say it one more time: The quote goes: What we think, know, and believe is of little consequence. All that matters is what we do.”

— MRFF Founder and President Mikey Weinstein, excerpted from “A Further Inquiry” interview (emphasis added)

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

MRFF at 20: Mikey Weinstein On MRFF’s Origins and Current Struggles Amid Rising Christian Nationalism in the U.S. Military – Interviewed by Scott Douglas Jacobsen, “A Further Inquiry” on Substack

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website):  Military Religious Freedom Foundation

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2025/09/25

“By December 15, 2025, we’ll mark MRFF’s twentieth anniversary as a recognized 501(c)(3). My wife and I actually started this fight in early 2004, and the spark was Mel Gibson’s film The Passion of the Christ, which opened in U.S. theaters on February 4, 2004. The “Jesus Chainsaw Massacre” or “Freddy versus Jesus.”

— Mikey Weinstein, excerpt from interview

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Michelle Stewart on Cult Abuse, Confession, and Accountability

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Msakoda53’s Blog

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2025/11/03

Michelle Stewart is a cult survivor, author, and advocate whose memoir, “Judas Girl: My Father, Four Cults & How I Escaped Them All,” chronicles her childhood entry into, and adult exit from, multiple high-control religious groups. Raised in an environment that included a Hutterite community and other Anabaptist and Orthodox enclaves, she examines how spiritual authority, conformity, and secrecy enable abuse: Stewart’s work centers survivor safety, legal accountability, and ethical pastoral confidentiality. From Colorado, she speaks and writes about distinguishing mainstream faith from cultic enclaves, reforming confession practices, and fostering healing narratives that emphasize agency, nonlinearity, and evidence-based support for survivors.

In this interview with Scott Douglas Jacobsen, Stewart differentiates organized religion from cults by centering survivor experience, highlighting speech suppression, enforced conformity, and authoritarian leadership. She recounts entering high-control groups as a child, including a Hutterite community, and leaving four groups by her twenties. Stewart critiques how confession and obedience to spiritual fathers can be weaponized, especially in Eastern Orthodox and Anabaptist enclaves, shielding crimes and silencing victims. She argues for universal mandatory reporting, accountability, and practical reforms prioritizing child safety and legal responsibility. As a survivor-advocate, she promotes trauma-informed interviewing and healing narratives emphasizing agency, nonlinearity, and systemic change over sensational detail.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Today, we are here with Judas girl herself, Michelle Stewart. You are a cult survivor turned author and advocate. There are a few kinds of people: some are still in the cult, some have left and never talk about it again, and some, like you, write, speak, and advocate about this troubling aspect of human psychology and group dynamics. Let’s start with the obvious question: what separates a cult from a formal religion for you?

Michelle Stewart: I’ve been asked that many times, and you’ll hear different definitions from different people. There are shared traits, but no single academic litmus test—no exact checklist that determines whether something is a cult. My understanding has evolved. While there are standard features, I believe it’s the experiences of survivors that reveal whether something truly functions as a cult. When I talk with people from various groups—fringe offshoots of mainstream traditions, Amish or other Anabaptist communities, the Unification Church (often called the “Moonies”), or the Twelve Tribes—specific themes repeat. One is the inability to speak out freely. People may hold personal differences in belief or culture, but challenging authority often leads to ostracism. You can’t both belong and speak out. This shows up primarily in cases of abuse—people risk losing community, family ties, and support systems. Another consistent feature is the demand for conformity. In most mainstream congregations—Episcopal, Baptist, or Jewish synagogues—you see substantial diversity in lifestyle, politics, and personal views. In high-control groups, there’s far greater oversight of daily life. For example, some Orthodox Jewish communities observe detailed dietary laws (halakha) but also include health exemptions; in certain separatist Christian groups, such as some Anabaptist or Old Order communities, dress codes can be strict and engagement with outside politics limited or guided by leaders. In some groups, political or social views are tightly scripted. Within broad traditions you can find both healthy, pluralistic congregations and insular enclaves that become high-control. For instance, Eastern Orthodox Christianity as a whole is a mainstream religion. Yet, particular enclaves or breakaway groups can operate in cult-like ways. That distinction matters. People often respond, “You can’t call the Orthodox Church or the Amish a cult.” Labels applied to an entire faith are rarely accurate. But a person can have a cult-like experience within a subset of almost any tradition. You can live under a cult mentality while still being nominally part of a larger, mainstream religion.

Jacobsen: How does your experience fit into that? How did you fall into it?

Stewart: How did I fall into cults? I was brought in as a child. I was seven when my parents joined what I describe in my book Judas Girl: My Father, Four Cults & How I Escaped Them All as the first of four cults. For me, it began as a childhood experience that I later had to leave as an adult. When I entered, I had no understanding of what a cult was or even the vocabulary to describe it. I only knew that suddenly, I was in a highly controlled environment. The first group was a Hutterite community.

As I mentioned earlier, you can have an organized religion with cult-like enclaves within it. Moving from a mainstream evangelical background into a setting where the group controlled all finances, clothing, housing, work, and spending meant having almost no personal autonomy. I knew it was different, but I didn’t understand what those differences meant until years later. It wasn’t until my twenties—after four separate groups—that I escaped and began to reflect on and understand those experiences.

Jacobsen: What were the through lines for those four groups?

Stewart: Just to make sure I understand correctly—the commonalities between the four? Yes. There were several universal through lines. They connect back to how I define a cult. The first was that in all of these groups, church leadership was revered far above the average member and held unquestioned authority. There’s irony in the fact that many of them referred to their leaders as “servants,” when in practice, it was the opposite.

Whether it was an Orthodox priest or a bishop in an Anabaptist sect—the kind I spent years in—the leader’s opinions were treated as sacred and beyond challenge. As a lay member, especially as a woman, my opinion was not considered equal. I was taught to accept that my wisdom was inferior. Leadership was seen as divinely superior.

With that came varying degrees of control. In some groups, the leader’s authority was absolute—obey or be expelled. In others, defiance led to psychological punishment: being ignored, condemned to hell, or subtly ostracized. It wasn’t always physical rejection but often psychological manipulation. That dynamic was consistent across every group.

Another constant was the use of God and salvation to control people. There was a mentality—unstated but deeply ingrained—that the ends justified the means. If you had to shun, manipulate, or even lie to someone to preserve their “salvation,” it was seen as justified. Abuse—whether psychological, emotional, or, for children, even physical—was rationalized in the name of saving souls. The goal was to ensure compliance with the group’s beliefs at any cost, because salvation was considered paramount.

Of course, not all cults are religious, but in my case, they all were. These were faith-based, coercive systems—extreme forms of existing religions. In this case, extreme iterations of Christianity, specifically of the Anabaptist tradition, which emerged during the Reformation and includes Mennonites, Amish, and Hutterites, as well as parallels in specific Orthodox contexts. They were radical offshoots of otherwise recognized faiths.

There’s one more through line worth mentioning: the suppression of individuality. In every group, personal expression was discouraged. In some, conformity was enforced through clothing. In others, like the Orthodox sect I was part of, individuality was discouraged in thought, behavior, and aesthetics. Even how you decorated your home, prayed, or spoke had to conform. There was a constant demand for uniformity, presented as a condition for salvation.

Jacobsen: There are two points I want to touch on. The book is not anti-faith; it’s anti-abuse. The other is your father’s declining mental health, with his reported revelations. Can you expand on the distinction made in the former and the development—or deterioration—of the latter?

Stewart: That’s an essential aspect for me. Judas Girl speaks candidly about religion and religious control. As we discussed, there’s a difference between a cult and an organized religion, and beyond that, between people of faith and those with no organized religion at all. Judas Girl is meant to be accessible. If you’re not a person of faith, you won’t feel pressured to embrace someone else’s God. You can read it from a secular perspective. But if you are a person of faith, it’s written to help you understand how elements of faith can be both used and abused. In a sense, it’s almost written to protect faith.

There’s often backlash from people with a cultic mindset who claim that speaking out against a church is the same as speaking out against God. To me, speaking out against religious abuse is actually faith-affirming—just as speaking out against child abuse is affirming of parenthood and family. You can condemn abuse without condemning the larger institution. Abuse isn’t inherent to religion, but acknowledging and addressing it is essential for any faith to survive. I try to make that distinction clear throughout the book. It’s not a confrontation with God; it’s a confrontation with people who misuse God.

As for my father’s mental illness, it developed gradually. In his case, I believe his illness was the on-ramp to these extremist groups. He began showing schizoid and borderline personality traits. He was later diagnosed with aspects of both, although he avoided psychiatric treatment whenever possible. People with that type of mental framework tend to see things in extremes—very black and white—and that meshed perfectly with the rigid, binary worldview of cults.

There was also a part of him that wanted what he saw as a simpler life, which is ironic because being in a cult is anything but easy. They may offer a sense of unity and care, but the cost is enormous—far greater than simply living independently. His black-and-white mindset absorbed cult ideology like a sponge. As he developed more religious delusions—believing himself, and later others, to be prophets—he became increasingly susceptible to manipulation by cult leaders claiming divine authority.

Those two factors—mental illness and cult influence—worked in parallel. Each reinforced the other. Both eroded his ability to reason or listen to outside perspectives. When we entered a new group, family members who spoke against it became “the enemy.” Similarly, people with untreated mental illness often reject voices of reason that might anchor them. As he cut those ties, he spiraled further, descending into a kind of shared psychosis between his own mind and the cult ideology.

Jacobsen: How did you feel about that during that time? And how do you think about it now, knowing it doesn’t work?

Stewart: At the time, my understanding changed across my cult experiences. At first, I was young, and my father told me he believed he had a physical illness. I also didn’t have the education to understand mental illness. Another common thread in all these cults was a systematic denial of mental illness. They didn’t acknowledge it as real, or if they did, they framed it as a deliberate choice or a sin. That encouraged him and left me without tools or vocabulary. Someone growing up in secular society might encounter diagnoses and develop understanding earlier than I did. I first believed him when he said he was physically ill. As he developed spiritual delusions, I took them at face value. I was a child. It was terrifying, but I believed completely. When we entered an off-grid Anabaptist commune, by the fifth or sixth year the group started pushing back on him. I was a member of that church, which meant my obedience was to them over my parents. It was a conflict, but I had to obey the church. They confronted my dad. They wouldn’t call it mental illness; they called it lying and sin.

“We have deemed you are not a prophet. We have deemed you are not unwell.” That was even scarier, and it’s where part of the Judas Girl concept comes from. I had two authorities—a father and a church—each telling me to reject the other or go to hell and be abandoned. Both ended up dumping me. As that evolved and I gained my own understanding, it created a schism that made me question both my father’s mental well-being and these cult mentalities. It took a long time to put together. I knew the questions were growing, and they were confusing and terrifying at the time. As an adult, with education and academic learning about mental illness—and curiosity about my own experience—I look back and see a heartbreaking story of a father who was abusive, manipulative, and controlling, but also very ill and in need of help, exploited by cults and extreme religion. That is one foundation for why I wrote the book: to bring these thought processes and psychology to light so people can better understand cults around them and, possibly, their own experiences.

Jacobsen: Let’s take a round-table view. You’ve looked at Eastern Orthodox hierarchy as a kind of petri dish where allegations can climb multiple layers. How does that model differ from, for example, the Catholic Church’s more centralized, pyramidal hierarchy and the autocephalous—though still hierarchical—structure of Orthodoxy?

Stewart: I don’t have personal experience in the Catholic Church, so when I speak about it, I’m referring to conversations with people who do. We’ve compared stories. What stood out to me in the Eastern Orthodox Church—stronger than what my Catholic friends described—was the control held by the spiritual father, the confessor. In my experience, that person had enormous power over how one perceived salvation. They often used that influence to control people who wanted to report abuse.

The article we discussed was about abuse. I, along with others who I won’t name, experienced situations where we wanted to say, “I was abused, and I’m struggling.” The response was that seeking accountability outside confession wasn’t our role. It was said to be between the abuser and their spiritual father. We were told to confess our resentment or “unforgiving heart,” but never to speak publicly.

I saw that mindset climb the hierarchy. There’s a current case involving Father Matthew Williams—my brother-in-law—where layers of cover-up are alleged. There’s evidence that misconduct occurred long before the cases now on trial. When I say “petri dish,” I mean that the Church sees itself as responsible for the sins of its members—but only internally, to the exclusion of external authorities. In practice, this means that even criminal acts are treated as matters for spiritual correction rather than legal accountability.

While the Catholic Church has had cover-ups too, what sets parts of Orthodoxy apart, based on my experience and conversations, is the intense secrecy. The idea that “it’s not the business of the secular world to know the sins of the Church” allows abuse to remain hidden. I know people who were told explicitly that if they reported abuse, they would be denied communion. Considering that communion is tied to salvation, withholding it is devastating. That level of spiritual coercion goes beyond what I’ve heard in Catholic contexts. I have seen similar tactics in cultic environments. Still, within Orthodoxy, it’s distinct in how authority and obedience are used to silence victims.

Jacobsen: What are the ethical lines between pastoral confidentiality and shielding a crime?

Stewart: It’s interesting. I mentioned earlier that I have a social media account where people discuss these topics, and this week’s discussion was about the protections of confession—particularly when child abuse is confessed. Where are the ethical lines in that situation? I don’t have an obvious answer. Still, I believe the well-being of children and victims of sexual assault should always take priority.

Suppose a clergy member—or anyone providing pastoral care—is aware of ongoing abuse. In that case, I believe they have an ethical duty to protect the person being harmed. I phrased that deliberately: there’s a narrow space in pastoral care, especially under the sacrament of confession, where someone might seek forgiveness for past misdeeds that are no longer ongoing. In those cases, the clergy member might not be a mandatory reporter, though even that should be carefully examined. Those instances are rare, but they exist.

What troubles me most is why pastoral care—whether in Orthodox, Catholic, Amish, or Methodist settings—so often excludes accountability. Why is legal responsibility not part of the moral direction given by those in authority? It’s well known that, in many cases, it isn’t. Returning to our earlier discussion about the “petri dish” of confession, if clergy hold such profound authority in a person’s life, why isn’t that authority used to encourage, or even require, legal accountability?

Why are these two realms—spiritual care and justice—so disconnected? We’ve created a system where, in some Orthodox confessions and even specific Catholic contexts depending on jurisdiction, someone can confess to actively abusing a person and remain confident that no one will report it. They can continue serving as clergy, or in any position of authority, with complete impunity. That raises the deeper question: why are we still preserving this expectation of absolute privacy for abusers, instead of fostering a norm that confession should lead to accountability and protection for victims?

Jacobsen: This has been a recurring theme across some of my conversations—with counselors, psychologists, psychotherapists, and social workers—people who deal directly with the individual psyche and moral responsibility every day.

Through some of my conversations with counseling psychologists, psychiatrists, psychotherapists, and social workers—people who deal with individuals one-on-one in intimate settings—I’ve noticed that these professions are bound by a clear duty to report abuse. Clergy, on the other hand, are also a kind of professional class. They’re educated, often intelligent, and serve hierarchical community roles.

Yet they’re not bound as strictly by mandatory reporting laws. There was a bill introduced in California last year to change that, but it didn’t pass. These are recurring concerns. So, what justifies lowering the universal standard of duty to report within religious contexts—for priests, bishops, or other clergy?

Why is that the case, and why shouldn’t it be? Why does religion get that exemption?

Stewart: My personal view is nuanced, but I believe there should be a consistent standard across professions. The argument for giving clergy a lower reporting standard doesn’t hold up when compared to the reasoning used for psychiatric or social work confidentiality.

When I’ve spoken with people who support the priest-penitent privilege, they often cite the sacramental nature of confession. The laws vary by state, and some jurisdictions differentiate between a casual conversation with a pastor and a formal sacramental confession. That distinction, mainly relevant to Catholic and Orthodox churches, effectively creates a privileged carve-out. A conversation with a minister in a Protestant setting might not receive the same protection, which raises fairness concerns on its own.

The justification I hear most often—and I can understand it emotionally, even if I disagree—is that this protection encourages abusers to seek repentance. The logic goes: if someone knows their confession could lead to legal consequences, they may never come forward, and the abuse will continue unchecked. By maintaining confidentiality, the clergy can supposedly help the person change course.

I understand that rationale but reject it. Mental health professionals also want people to come forward, to seek help for harmful impulses or past actions. But their systems recognize that protecting victims must take precedence over preserving an abuser’s privacy. The same principle should apply to clergy.

When confidentiality shields active abuse, it becomes complicity. There are cases where priests have confessed to abusing their own children, and the information was never reported. The result was continued reoffending. That, to me, is the moral failure of this privileged exemption. The idea that pastoral confidentiality should outweigh the safety of victims—especially in cases of ongoing abuse—is indefensible.

We know that the data show recidivism rates are high. We know from data that someone confessing to many of these crimes is highly likely to reoffend, even if the incident they’re confessing to is in the past. For that same reason, while I have empathy and sympathy for people in the Catholic or Orthodox churches who want to protect that sanctity—and that the seal of confession has long been recognized as inviolable—I think the victim’s rights truly have to come first, for the same reasons the psychological community reached that conclusion.

Jacobsen: What else? What would signal actual reform?

Stewart: I would say a public embrace of accountability. I would love—well, I mean, we never want a crime to have occurred—but I would love to see a scenario where a priest stepped up and reported abuse. I would like to see the church stand behind him. For example, years ago, I don’t know if you’re familiar with the Christ of the Hills Monastery in Blanco, Texas. I happened to be; my then-spouse was being used by the defense in a child sexual abuse case. The conversation came up that they might try to subpoena the alleged perpetrator’s spiritual fathers to testify as to whether he had confessed to sexual abuse. The response was universal: “We will go to jail before we break the seal of confession.” And again, I understand that faith is deep and complicated, and I hurt for anyone who feels they must make that decision. However, reform to me would have been the opposite: the church saying, “We have potential child victims—ongoing child victims. We are accountable to the state first. We hold our clergy to higher standards than the general public, not lower.” That kind of accountability would signal real reform.

It would also help if people were made very clear—even in confession or religious counseling—that taking accountability for your actions outside of skipping communion for a few months is part of repentance. It’s part of the path to healing, not a way to avoid facing consequences. Changing that narrative entirely would give the process absolute integrity. Frankly, it would prevent more abuse than sheltering people in confession ever could. Right now, many think, “All I have to do is confess.” We know clergy members have confessed to child sexual abuse and then continued to serve liturgy afterward. If they knew that confession would not remain purely private, that would put real weight behind accountability and integrity within the church. It could be a significant turning point in shifting the culture around abuse.

Jacobsen: What about those without significant agency—children who grow up under those conditions? What are the additional risks and contexts for them in terms of community safety? For instance, we know from Orthodox records that most sexual assault cases involve adult women. In contrast, most pedophilic cases involve young boys. But children have an additional lack of agency when they’re cognitively undeveloped and under coercive control—not just part of a community but trapped within it. From your experience in law, is there additional context for that, or does the law treat both roughly the same, perhaps just applying child abuse statutes?

Stewart: I’ll answer this as best I can, and you can tell me if it needs reframing. As far as victims of abuse, what I’ve seen and experienced—and I mentioned this earlier—is the silencing of those victims. That needs to be completely reversed. I’ve seen policies in more mainstream churches where a victim of abuse knows they’ll receive immediate support if they report, rather than the church systematically silencing them or treating it as a matter for confession or for clergy to decide. I’ve seen this repeatedly across multiple churches with a cult-like mentality, where victims are told that forgiveness is required. That includes me. When you struggle psychologically, mentally, or emotionally as a victim of abuse, that struggle is layered on as another sin—your supposed inability to forgive or heal. It becomes another mechanism of control. I’ve also heard of more than one case where priests asked victims to recount details of their abuse repeatedly in confession.

I bring that up because part of the change I want to see is not only ensuring safety and the right to come forward, but also reforming how confession itself is taught and understood—how to identify abuse and manipulation even within the sacrament. That means recognizing when a priest abuses that role, whether for gratification or power. Confession should never be a place of manipulation. It should be spiritual guidance, not the endpoint for psychological, medical, or legal support. It’s a place for spiritual reflection, not for silencing or retraumatization.

Jacobsen: Your focus is on systems critique within the personal narrative. Do you ever focus on individual perpetrators who hold significant authority? Is it appropriate to do so, or is it generally better to focus on systems to achieve accountability?

Stewart: I think you need both. When I wrote my book, it came very much from a personal perspective. Specific individuals absolutely need to be called out. Abusers should be named, and every victim deserves full support and access to resources. Hence, they know it wasn’t their fault and that help exists. Focusing on specific perpetrators definitely has its place. In personal life, that’s often how things unfold—you respond to harm by identifying those responsible. Each scenario deserves attention and accountability.

That said, I lean toward systemic analysis because there’s always a percentage of any population that will abuse—whether through rape, child molestation, or psychological harm. What distinguishes abuse within specific religious systems is that those systems build scaffolding that allows abuse to thrive. It’s not limited to cults or extremist sects; we’ve seen it in mainstream religious institutions as well.

My focus happens to be on those environments where abuse in a more mainstream religious setting might be reported and stopped much more quickly. In contrast, some institutions create conditions where abuse thrives. I know you focus a lot on the Orthodox Church. Still, I’ve also done much work with Amish and Amish offshoots, which have very similar approaches. What we see in those cases are abusers who remain active for years, often with multiple victims, all covered for by the system.

Now, of course, the individual abuser is fully responsible for their behavior. But could they have been stopped if they lived within a structure that required accountability—mandatory reporting, sex offender registries, restrictions from being near children—instead of simply confessing, facing minimal church discipline, and then being placed back into authority over the same vulnerable groups? That, to me, is the key difference.

I live in Colorado. We have wildfires here. If a fire breaks out in a swamp, it won’t spread far. It’s still a fire and still dangerous, but in a wet area, it’s contained. Now imagine a drought area, like much of California. A single spark can become a massive blaze. The person who lit that spark is responsible, but the conditions make the destruction far greater. That’s how I see institutional abuse. Each case matters, but these systems create drought-like conditions—structures that let a small flame turn into a wildfire destroying countless lives. That’s where my focus lies.

Jacobsen: What are the consistencies in how cults and religions handle abuse cases? If someone were abused within the Moonies or within Orthodoxy, both institutions would respond in specific ways. What aspects would be essentially identical?

Non-extreme religions or cults too. When I interviewed David Pooler, he noted that regardless of Christian denomination, the immediate institutional response to clergy abuse is usually self-protection—and the community participates in that defensiveness. So, in that sense, cults and religions behave similarly.

Stewart: That’s a good observation. Reflecting on Pooler’s comment, I’d agree that there’s a general human tendency across institutions to be defensive. You can even see it in nonreligious contexts like the Boy Scouts. This organization systemically hid abuse to protect itself.

Where extreme religions and mainstream ones could diverge is in their foundation for accountability. Some mainstream or progressive religious institutions have taken steps to ensure victims or perpetrators are referred to legal and psychological support systems. But yes, many spiritual and organizational structures share that same reflex: to defend the institution, preserve public image, and protect financial interests. Religious organizations handle millions or even billions of dollars, and that economic dimension often reinforces secrecy.

Still, I’ve also seen positive exceptions. Some churches have acknowledged abuse publicly, reported it to authorities, and immediately defrocked or removed offending clergy. So, I wouldn’t say the behavior is universal across all religions. There’s a clear dividing line between how extreme or insular groups respond versus how more progressive, accountable, or legally compliant ones do.

Jacobsen: How can you tell a story while maintaining the objective fact that people have been victimized—whether or not they identify as victims, or adopt a survivor mindset, or eventually move toward one? That’s mainly up to them. So when it comes to interview practices and media work involving people who’ve been victimized—especially in cult contexts—how should we avoid falling into what’s often called “trauma porn”? How do we prevent the stigmatization or sensationalizing of trauma while still telling stories factually and empathetically, incorporating that first-person perspective? What are your recommendations?

Stewart: I love that question. And I’ve had to confront it while writing my own story—which, with permission, includes parts of others’ stories too. It’s a tricky space, and I don’t think there’s an obvious line. It’s one reason you’ve heard me in this conversation veering toward systemic critique—focusing on institutional change and mindset shifts—rather than delving too deeply into explicit personal accounts. However, I do explore those in my book.

When interviewing survivors, I approach it from the perspective of helping them share their experience in a way that fosters healing. Some interviewees won’t be fully healed, and that’s okay. But if they’re willing to talk, they’re usually at least beginning to process the experience and acknowledge that something wrong occurred. That’s the foundation.

I would strongly advise against pressing someone who hasn’t yet recognized their own abuse or manipulation into doing so on record. I’ve seen interviewers try to coax that realization out mid-conversation, and it rarely leads to genuine insight—it risks retraumatization instead. The focus should remain on healing and change.

For example, I can describe being in a car accident—my leg shattered, immense pain—but the emphasis should be on how I recovered: the physical therapy, the emotional reckoning, and how I reached a point where I could walk or even run again. That story becomes one of endurance and transformation. Likewise, if someone is speaking about abuse, the focus should be on why we’re telling the story: healing, accountability, prevention, or awareness.

You can convey the depth of trauma without detailing the blood and gore. Those visceral details can eclipse the point, which is understanding the impact and how change occurs. Include only enough to give context for the gravity of the experience, not to exploit it.

Ultimately, keep intent front and center. If the intent is to shock or horrify, that’s the wrong motive. If the intent is to illuminate, empower, and advocate for healing or accountability, then the story serves a purpose. And if someone’s goal is just to make audiences gasp, they probably shouldn’t be working in this space at all.

Jacobsen: What would you consider the healthiest self-narrative for survivors of cult or clergy abuse to adopt as they go through the healing process?

Stewart: I like how you framed that earlier—the distinction between victims, those with a victim mentality, those who are healing, and those who are thriving. Speaking from personal experience rather than an academic standpoint, I’d say that while reminders like “it’s not your fault” are essential, the most powerful narrative centers on healing as a journey.

First and foremost, you—and only you—are responsible for your healing. That may sound daunting, but it’s also liberating. Someone may have harmed you, but recognizing that you have not only the responsibility but also the power to heal gives you agency. That mindset moves you forward much more effectively than staying in a place of “I am broken.”

At the same time, it’s essential to understand that healing isn’t linear. You’re accountable to yourself and only to yourself as you uncover, process, and come to terms with what’s happened. There’s no timetable, no external requirement for how quickly or neatly that process unfolds.

There’s no requirement to have forgiven anyone by a specific date or to have recovered from PTSD in a particular timeline. Healing doesn’t obey a schedule. One of the most powerful realizations for me—and for many survivors—is that while abuse feels deeply personal, it actually isn’t. To the abuser, it was never truly about you.

That’s hard to internalize, because for most victims, the violation feels like the most personal event imaginable—especially in cases of sexual or psychological abuse. But when you can decouple yourself from it, when you can recognize that the abuse came from something entirely outside of you—a sickness, a distortion, a system—that’s when real healing starts.

The old saying “it’s not your fault” is true, but it doesn’t go far enough. It’s not only not your fault—it’s not about you. You were simply in the path of someone else’s damage, like a car running over something in the road. That may sound devaluing, but it’s freeing: none of this comes back to your worth.

In my own case, understanding that both the sexual and emotional abuse I endured had very little to do with me—realizing it wasn’t about who I was or what I did to “deserve” harm—was essential. Whether the cause was religious indoctrination, mental illness, moral corruption, or plain cruelty, it originated entirely in them, not in me.

Accepting that truth has been one of the most significant contributors to healing.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much, I appreciate it.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Serbia’s Orthodox Church and Clergy Abuse: Jovana Trninic Speaks

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Msakoda53’s Blog

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2025/10/26

Jovana Trninic is a Serbian interlocutor and advocate focusing on clergy-related abuse and institutional accountability within the Serbian Orthodox context. After reporting sexual misconduct by a priest and encountering evasion from church authorities, she turned to evidence-based healing, psychotherapy, and communities such as Prosopon Healing. Trninic emphasizes critical thinking over magical thinking, transparency through survivor databases, and legal literacy for victims. Her perspective integrates skepticism, human rights, and lived experience, arguing that reform must involve believers and secular allies to prevent recurring harm.

In this interview with Scott Douglas Jacobsen, Trninic discusses clergy-perpetrated abuse and the role of the Serbian Orthodox Church. She recounts reporting a priest Blasko Paraklis for sexual misconduct, facing institutional evasion, including a bishop Maxim office mediating by email but imposing no consequences. Trninic advocates for critical thinking, utilizing databases like Prosopon Healing, promoting legal literacy, and employing evidence-based therapy to enhance public transparency, prevention, and institutional reform.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Today we’re here with Jovana Trninic from Serbia. We’ve known each other peripherally. Anyway, we’re talking about a topic I’ve been learning more about: clergy-perpetrated abuse, or clergy-related abuse more broadly. After speaking with institutional leaders, researchers, and survivors, I want to ask: What is the state of this in Serbia? And what is the role of the Orthodox Church?

Jovana Trninic: Orthodox Christianity is the main religion in Serbia and Serbian Orthodox Church plays the main part in the spiritual and cultural life of Serbians.

Jacobsen: How do people see their Orthodoxy?

Jovana: For Serbians Orthodoxy is closely tied with cultural, historical and national identity.

Jacobsen: When they think of their identity within Orthodoxy, what ideas and feelings come to mind? In America people say: “Jesus is my lord and saviour”. Is it similar here?

Jovana: Yes, it’s similar with more emphasis on the concept of “Svetoslavlje”. Svetosavlje encompassing the ideology, spiritual tradition and national character derived from the life and teachings of St. Sava the first Serbian Orthodox Archbishop.

Jacobsen: Are Serbians generally highly religious, or more like North Americans or Europeans, where religion is a part of life but not life itself?

Trninic: In general I would say Serbians are more traditional then religious.

Jacobsen: What do you mean?

Trninic: Some traditions are tied to the church. For example, we have Slava. Each family has their own patron saint. We celebrate Slava with a cake(bread) blessed by a priest, who comes to the house for the ceremony or parishioners bring cake(bread) to the church. It’s a tradition connected with religion, but for most people, it’s more about tradition. Only a minority strictly follow religious rules.

Jacobsen: That’s a fair point. In my experience interviewing many people, those who strongly claim a religious faith, and even those who claim to have rejected it, often haven’t read the holy text.

Trninic: It’s personal matter and free will whether someone will be a believer or not.

Jacobsen: When you went through Orthodoxy—community, maybe Sunday school—what lessons were emphasized? Not every Christian denomination emphasizes the same traditions. Sometimes they teach the same things, but rank them differently. What stories or ethics are highlighted? Beyond the core belief that Jesus rose from the dead, which is non-negotiable for Christianity, the same way the Quran is non-negotiable in Islam.

Trninic: Serbian Orthodox Christian Church utilizes both the Old Testament and the New Testament as Holy Scripture viewing the Old Testament as a preparation for Christ’s coming with emphasis on New Testament. Key practices include Divine Liturgy and the Seven Sacraments Mysteries (Holy Baptism, Holy Chrismation, Holy Communion, Holy Confession, Holy Matrimony, Holy Ordination and Holy Unction.)

Jacobsen: An essential point in all of this is community and hierarchy. Now, key to the issue of clergy-perpetrated abuse: if someone were to question these fundamental claims, or even say they no longer believe, how would the community respond? Would it be considered inappropriate? Would questioning be welcomed or rejected?

Trninic: Speaking from my own experience, and from what I see around me, questioning clergy authority is considered highly inappropriate and rejected. When I wanted to speak up about what had happened to me in Orthodox Christian community in terms of warning and preventing sexual misconduct from happening to other females, a female friend who introduced me to the faith was extremely against that action. I asked her: “Why should I stay silent? This is not my shame.” This is the shame of clergy man. He can harm another person if he is not held accountable for his wrongdoing. She told me this: “Yes, but you never know if he repented”. This statement led me to the conclusion that the Sacrament of confession in this case confession (repentance) can be misused in perpetuating the ongoing sexual misconduct cycle in silence. She also told me this: “We have to be silent, this is how we keep our faith to not crumble down”.

Another thing, she was the first person I came forward and told her in detail about everything that happened to me that night. Her first response was this: “If any other female told me the same thing the first thing I would ask her is what did you do to provoke him. But because I know you, I believe you”.

When I called another friend to raise a red flag on this incident and prevent it from potentially happening to her I got another bizarre response. “Because priests are by default close to God, they are also more attacked by demons”. So this is how she justified his wrongdoing. This phenomenon is called “clericalism” when people think priests/clergy are on a higher level of spirituality than others. I was also stuck in this trap for some period of time.

When I showed an inappropriate and disturbing text message I had received  from that priest to my other friend, her response was this: “This is why I always pay attention to how to communicate with the priest”. Speaking of that, I want to clarify some things here which I think many religious people do not understand. And that is: “It is not my responsibility to teach priests how to communicate”.

Jacobsen: When you come forward with a complaint, and you’re told it’s untrue without grounds, how does that feel?

Trninic: That leads to feelings of frustration, anger and invalidation, but it also leads to clarity of the reality taking the place of the truth. Actually, this experience helped me see things crystal clear and I will hold on to this truth no matter what.

Jacobsen: Are there biblical parables—or passages—you know of, as a Christian, that support women who have been mistreated?

Trninic: Yes. One example is rape of Tamar.

Jacobsen: Has this shaken your faith?

Trninic: To some degree yes. I still believe in God, but sometimes I have a feeling I have attacked God. This is the paradox. I have been pushed to that point to defend the truth and myself by speaking up against those who represent God on Earth.

Jacobsen: In your case, what was the individual failure—the crime? And what was the institutional failure of Serbian Orthodoxy? And, as an olive branch, what would have been a better response? Individually, the first failure is apparent: do not abuse. Institutionally, the reaction after the fact is more complicated.

Trninic: Well, according to the experts when it comes to clergy abuse and sexual misconduct Church is supposed to do few things.

  1. Launch an external investigation
  2. Remove the clergy who abused during investigation
  3. Provide money for victim to get counseling
  4. Provide mandatory counseling for clergy
  5. Defrock

In my situation none of these steps were done.

Speaking of individual failure, when I called the bishop’s office a woman who claimed to be a psychologist told me that the bishop was going to call me. But he never called, which spiked my anxiety. When I asked her next time why the bishop did not call me. Her response was this: “The Bishop doesn’t talk with regular people. He only talks with people inside of his circle who are educated in theology.”

When I asked her if other people had complained about the same priest, she said she wasn’t allowed to give me that information. Based on that answer, is what concerns me—that I may not be the only one.

Jacobsen: Are you still part of the community?

Trninic: To be honest, from this point of view I do not wish to be part of that community.

Jacobsen: How long has it been since the original incident?

Trninic: It happened in 2022.

Jacobsen: Compared to your anxiety and stress then, how do you feel now?

Trninic: I still feel disoriented and unsafe and carry a high level of anxiety. There has been progress—I’ve improved with therapy and support from psychiatrist psychologists and psychotherapists.

Jacobsen: What advice has helped you that could also help others as they begin their own journey of healing after victimization?

Trninic: Oh my God, there is so much to say. Ok. First I want to tell this to every survivor: “If you have ever continuously felt neglected, criticized, rejected, abandoned, for speaking the truth, if your accomplishments were minimized, if you have been betrayed by those who were supposed to protect you and cherish you, if you have been blamed by those people that something was wrong with you, it’s time for you to wake up and claim your power. Book “It’s not you” by dr. Ramani Durvasula can be your starting point. Also the book “Blind to betrayal” by dr Jennifer Freyd is crucial for healing. For survivors who have been part of the cult, I highly recommend the book “Take back your life” by Janja Lalich. Finding the right trauma informed psychologist who understands relational trauma and Complex- PTSD is the most important part of your healing journey. For the Christian Orthodox Clergy abuse survivors The Prosopon Healing website is crucial. They help with education, including how to recognize abuse in early stages. Some of the books I have recommended are on their website as well.

The problem with some religious people in general is they often rely on magical thinking instead of critical reasoning.

Jacobsen: What is magical thinking in this context?

Trninic: Magical thinking can mean many things. For example, believing that just by touching the bishop’s robe can create some blessings or miracles in your life is magical thinking. People often think that if they perform certain practices, their problems will go away, and oftentimes they are led by Church authorities into that thinking.

Jacobsen: So, better education in critical thinking could help prevent abuse?

Trninic: I think critical thinking is important but can not prevent abuse itself. It is helpful in later stages after recognizing the abuse. It is important not to be obedient to authority which does not allow it to be questioned. We were abused because we trusted those people. What can prevent abuse in my opinion and which is the stand point from Prosopon Healing are these three things:

  1. Education is important so people are aware of the abuse and they are not shocked when it happens
  2. Hold perpetrators accountable
  3. The most important thing is to hold enablers accountable. Enablers are individuals who allow perpetrators  to exist in the system and exploit the system.

Jacobsen: Do you know other women in Serbia who had similar experiences?

Trninic: I do not know anybody personally.

Jacobsen: Is there a perception that abuse is primarily a Catholic problem, not an Orthodox one?

Trninic: Yes. In our Orthodox community, people say, “That happens to Catholics, not us.” Or they claim that if it happens in Orthodoxy, it’s rare. They argue it happens in Catholicism because priests aren’t allowed to marry, which is false. Many abuse cases involve married clergy.

Jacobsen: What resources have helped you most?

Trninic: All books I have mentioned above. Also there are other books like:

“C-PTSD from Surviving to Thriving” by Pete Walker.

“Trauma and Recovery” by Judith Herman

“Believing Me” Dr. Ingrid Clayton

Jacobsen: Do you feel more secure in your sense of self now?

Trninic: Yes.

Jacobsen: Many abuse cases are by married men, including married clergy.

Trninic: I am aware of that now.

Jacobsen: In American evangelical circles, the argument is that prominent pastors are held to a higher standard. Yet in Serbian Orthodoxy, based on your case, an individual of higher stature is instead given a supernatural excuse—that demons attacked him, causing him to commit this crime. That lets him evade personal accountability, followed by an institutional cover-up, and then, in your case, betrayal by a close associate. You can see how these dynamics play out. They’re clearer to me now. They don’t surprise me, but they are deeply unethical and, in some cases, explicitly criminal, as shown in court cases. Do I have both the big picture and the details right?

Trninic: Yes.

Jacobsen: I don’t believe in the supernatural; I see no evidence for it. Many believers do, even victims. But regardless of whether it’s real, it’s used to shift accountability away from the clergy. So the supernatural is used as a shield to deflect responsibility.

Trninic: Yes, that’s how I see it as well.

Jacobsen: What has helped you feel safer—not entirely secure, but safer—compared to those moments of distress and anxiety?

Trninic: Speaking with dr. Hermina Nedelescu and my psychotherapists have helped me a lot, education and Prosopon healing website and their community.

Jacobsen: What do you think is the importance of the Orthodox abuse database?

Trninic: The database from Prosopon Healing is essential because it consolidates all information in one place—a clearinghouse where individuals can share notes and build an accurate picture of the extent of abuse. That way, the numbers aren’t underreported or exaggerated. You can’t just say there are 100,000 victims, but you can show a distinct number, plus estimates for unknown cases.

Jacobsen: Most clergy don’t abuse—that’s important to state explicitly.

Trninic: Really? I’m in shock. Now I think everyone is abusing.

Jacobsen: I mean, it’s like most crimes: a small number of people commit them repeatedly. In North America, there’s a term—recidivism. It describes people who commit the same crime over and over. Why does an arsonist commit arson? Because he’s an arsonist. Why does an abuser abuse? Because he’s an abuser. I don’t want to make an essentialist argument, but it’s a pattern of psychology and behaviour that repeats.

That’s why I’d argue it’s likely a minority of clergy who abuse, and we can’t paint all clergy with that brush. It’s essential to involve innocent clergy, regular believers, and the broader public in reform efforts. We see abuse in many domains—gymnastics, Hollywood, corporate settings, and academia. Men and women can be victims in different ways. The real issue is identifying effective reforms and implementing them.

Trninic: Yes, but I don’t agree with one point. If clergy or congregants see another clergy who is abusing others and they stay silent, they’re protecting the abuser. Silence in the face of evil is itself an abuse of power. My previous roommate and friend was the person who introduced me to that priest with the recommendation that he is the most spiritual among them. I feel betrayed by her as well. I had never imagined these things could have happened.

But from this point of view, I wish I had spoken more in public and been more vocal instead of remaining in silence. That is why I am speaking now and using truth and my story to empower other people first to wake up from cognitive dissonance, not to be blind and obedient to any authority, to recognize the abuse, return the shame to those that belong to and to speak up to prevent others from going through the same horror.

I want to share these statements from psychologist Beth Matenaer in the book “Take back you life” by Janja Lalich which helped me a lot and it might help other survivors:

A Survivor’s Promise

by Beth Matenaer

  • No longer will I carry the shame that has enabled other people’s bad behavior. I decide. No more.
  • No longer will I minimize the things I need to accommodate another person’s shortcomings. I decide. No more.
  • No longer will I accept that I am responsible for any choices and actions other than my own. I decide. No more.
  • No longer will I negotiate a version of the truth that denies my experiences to make others feel more comfortable. I decide. No more.
  • No longer will I choose to value other people’s perception of me over my own knowledge of myself. I decide. No more.
  • No longer will I allow fears of what I cannot control to hold me back from the things I know I can accomplish. I decide. No more.
  • No longer will I compromise my own thoughts, feelings and ideas because they are different from yours. I decide. No more.
  • No longer will I apologize for hoping, for loving, for believing, as they are my gift to this world.

I decide. No more. I promise.

Jacobsen: Thank you for the opportunity and your time, Jovana.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Udruga Savez Kršćana Hrvatske prenosi vijest o dodjeli nagrade Vaseljenskom patrijarhu, izražavajući duboku zabrinutost zbog činjenice da se istodobno zanemaruju brojni slučajevi pedofilije unutar vjerskih institucija…

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): BezCensure

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2025/09/19

Ekumenski patrijarh Bartolomej

Kako Templetonova nagrada Bartolomej I. za 2025. utječe na kredibilitet Zaklade usred zabrinutosti zbog njezine šutnje o seksualnom zlostavljanju od strane svećenstva?

Autor: Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Zaklada Templeton dodijelila je svoju nagradu za 2025. ekumenskom patrijarhu Bartolomeju I. Carigradskom (Dimitrios Archontonis) unatoč patrijarhovoj šutnji o seksualnom zlostavljanju od strane svećenstva u pravoslavlju, tvrdi skupina preživjelih i zagovornika.

U pojedinačnim pismima poslanim fondaciji tokom proteklih šest mjeseci, članovi grupe su priznali da je patrijarh zaslužio priznanje za svoj rad na pitanjima zaštite okoliša, što je dugoročni fokus lidera ” prvog među jednakima ” u istočnom pravoslavnom kršćanstvu. Međutim, objasnili su, patrijarhova šutnja o zlostavljanju čini njegovu prestižnu nagradu John Templeton bolnom za preživjele – posebno za one koji su mu se direktno obratili u vezi sa svojim iskustvima.

„Nekoliko sam puta pisao ekumenskom patrijarhu Bartolomeju – kao najvišem duhovnom autoritetu u Pravoslavnoj crkvi – tražeći od njega da prizna i odgovori na patnju žrtava te poduzme mjere “, napisao je Zakladi Bojan Jovanović, glavni tajnik Saveza kršćana Hrvatske. „ Do danas nikada nije primljen nikakav odgovor.“

„Svaka institucija koja tvrdi da je moralni vođa mora to dokazati tamo gdje je najvažnije: u zaštiti ljudi“, rekla je u pismu Sally Zakhari, izvršna direktorica udruge Coptic Survivor. „Nema trajne klimatske pravde bez pravde za preživjele – sigurnost je prva dužnost.“

Grupa je počela privatno pisati vodstvu zaklade u travnju, kada je ekumenski patrijarh proglašen dobitnikom nagrade John Templeton za 2025. godinu. Pisma raspravljaju o nizu iskustava žrtava zlostavljanja i njihovih zagovornika te navode ponovljene pokušaje da se ekumenski patrijarh javno osvrne na pitanje seksualnog zlostavljanja od strane svećenstva u crkvi. Zajedno su tražili priznanje od zaklade da je njihova pohvala patrijarha bila nepromišljena.

Grešnici i sveci

Takvo priznanje Zaklade Templeton nije bez presedana, upravo zato što su se prethodni laureati pokazali problematičnima. Dok se osobe poput Francisa Collinsa i Jane Goodall nalaze na popisu prošlih dobitnika, drugi su bili manje uspješni – uključujući neke povezane s poznatim nedoličnim ponašanjem. Među prethodnim dobitnicima koji su bili umiješani u seksualno nedolično ponašanje su Jean Vanier (2015.), osnivač L’Archea, i bivši dominikanski svećenik i evolucijski biolog Francisco Ayala (2010.). Izvješće koje je naručio L’Arche, objavljeno godinu dana nakon Vanierove smrti, zaključilo je da je Vanier seksualno zlostavljao i manipulirao šest žena tijekom desetljeća, uključujući svoje asistentice i časne sestre. Templeton je od tada izmijenio svoju web stranicu kako bi rekao da je organizacija “zgrožena i ožalošćena” nalazima. Zaklada je slično napomenula da se Ayala suočio s optužbama za seksualno uznemiravanje.

„ Ne može biti istinske klimatske pravde bez socijalne pravde. Okoliš uključuje ljudska bića “, kaže neuroznanstvenica i suosnivačica Prosopon Healinga Hermina Nedelescu o naporima grupe. „ Duboko je uznemirujuće što se patrijarh Bartolomej slavi zbog svog vodstva u pitanjima zaštite okoliša, a ignorira muškarce, žene i djecu koji doživljavaju seksualno zlostavljanje od strane svećenstva i pate od traume pod njegovim duhovnim autoritetom .“

Javne informacije o zlostavljanju u Pravoslavnoj crkvi prikupio je Prosopon Healing. Ova baza podataka izrađena je po uzoru na ‘Akademsku bazu podataka o seksualnom zlostavljanju’ i nadovezuje se na rad ranije stranice, Pokrov.org.

Prosopon Healing pruža istraživanja utemeljena na dokazima, resurse i podršku pogođenima, ali slika ostaje nepotpuna. Koliko znamo, nijedna pravoslavna jurisdikcija ne objavljuje konkretne informacije o zlostavljanju od strane svećenstva. Nasuprot tome, većina rimokatoličkih biskupija u Americi to čini.

Melanie Sakoda, predsjednica Upravnog odbora Coptic Survivora i suosnivačica Pokrov.orga, podijelila je ove zabrinutosti u svom pismu zakladi. „Vjerujem da je dodjela Templetonove nagrade vođi koja se nije oglasila o ovom ključnom pitanju bila izuzetno kratkovidna od strane Zaklade. Za mene to dovodi u pitanje Templetonov moralni kredibilitet kada ignorira tešku situaciju žrtava koje još uvijek čekaju da dobiju i pomoć i pravdu.“

Napetost koja može izbiti kada duhovni vođa hvali svoj rad na vanjskoj socijalnoj pravdi, a ne uspijeva se pozabaviti nepravdom unutar crkve, nije nepoznata u kršćanskom svijetu. Zapravo, u svom priopćenju za javnost o prihvaćanju nagrade od strane ekumenskog patrijarha, zaklada je napomenula da je ekumenski patrijarh surađivao s papom Franjom i bivšim nadbiskupom Canterburyja Justinom Welbyjem na prvoj zajedničkoj poruci o zaštiti stvorenja. Prošle godine Welby je bio prisiljen dati ostavku na mjesto poglavara Engleske crkve nakon što je izbio značajan skandal oko njegovog postupanja s pritužbama na ozbiljno zlostavljanje.

Prilika za reformu

Patrijarhova ovlast da naređuje reforme diljem pravoslavnog svijeta je ograničena. Pravoslavne jurisdikcije imaju veću autonomiju od rimokatoličkih biskupija. Međutim, grupa je rekla da bi mogao pokrenuti javnu raspravu i pozvati na odgovornost unutar pravoslavlja; zloupotrebe bi trebalo riješiti i zaustaviti.

Jedan korak prema zaustavljanju zlostavljanja, kaže grupa, uključivao bi šire otkrivanje i razumijevanje opsega zlostavljanja u pravoslavlju. Mnogi pravoslavni vjernici poriču da postoje problemi sa zlostavljanjem djece i odraslih od strane svećenstva. Na primjer, vjernici često navode činjenicu da su svećenici oženjeni, nesvjesni da većinu seksualnog zlostavljanja djece čine muškarci u vezama s odraslim ženama, poput oženjenih svećenika.

Grupa je objasnila da bi podrška ekumenskog patrijarha, a ne šutnja, mogla pomoći u upotpunjavanju ove slike. „ Sramotno je što je patrijarh Bartolomej koristio svoj glas kako bi se zalagao za pitanja okoliša, gdje je njegova moć ograničena, ali je ostao nijem o seksualnom zlostavljanju od strane svećenstva unutar pravoslavlja – gdje bi njegovi stavovi mogli biti svjetionik za reformu “, napisao je Sakoda.

Zagovornici i preživjeli zajednički pozivaju ekumenskog patrijarha da konačno progovori o zlostavljanju, da uspostavi sigurno mjesto za prijavljivanje i neovisno istraživanje zlostavljanja te da poveća transparentnost odgovornosti.

Grupa priznaje da je dokument iz 2020. godine, koji je izradila posebna komisija pravoslavnih znanstvenika koju je imenovao patrijarh Bartolomej, spomenuo pitanje seksualnog zlostavljanja u pravoslavnim zajednicama. Međutim, to izvješće nije sadržavalo konkretno priznanje seksualnog zlostavljanja od strane svećenstva i potpuno je ignoriralo tešku situaciju onih koji su zlostavljani kao odrasli.

Štoviše, uz ovu pritužbu na njegovu šutnju, preživjeli i zagovornici također znaju da je ignorirao apele Johna Metsopoulosa, supruge dr. Nedelescua, Kevina Hunta i, kao što je ranije spomenuto, Bojana Jovanovića.

Stoga ponovno pozivaju Zakladu Templeton da prizna patnju koju su proživjeli pravoslavni preživjeli, kako je rječito navedeno u pismu koje je anonimni preživjeli poslao zakladi posljednjih mjeseci. „Ne tražim osvetu. Tražim priznanje. Slušajući preživjele, Zaklada John Templeton ima priliku poslati snažnu poruku: da istinska veličina uključuje poštenje, pravdu i zaštitu ranjivih.“

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

In the Humanist

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): herbsilverman.com

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2024/06/12

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: It’s been a hot minute since last talking virtually. However, since I was travelling all over the States, I did get the opportunity to, in fact, meet in person, Sharon [Herb’s wife] and you. That was lovely, so thank you: for showing me Charleston, having a meal, taking a walk, and just being hospitable. Do you get a lot of visitors?
Dr. Herb Silverman: It was a pleasure to see you, Scott. Now you understand why Charleston is the top tourist attraction in the US. There are many lovely sites. And it’s also where the “War of Northern Aggression” (Civil War) started.
Jacobsen: How has it been living in Charleston, South Carolina as one its most prominent long-term atheists?
Silverman: Over time and as the “nones” (those with no particular religion) have slowly increased, the need for open atheists here is no longer as crucial. Many Northerners have moved to Charleston, so it has become a purple city in a red state, which makes it easier. And we have a thriving secular humanist group in Charleston for social support.
Jacobsen: Now, to the point of this interview, what is the overarching tone of secularism in the United States now?
Silverman: I think it is “on the fence”. Atheism is not the dirty word it used to be, and the fastest growing demographic is the “Nones.” However, white Christian nationalists are achieving their legislative goals in too many states, just consider the abortion restraints they’ve accomplished.
Jacobsen: What do you see as the major setback in the United States for church and state separation?
Silverman: I know “church and state separation” is a popular expression, but I never use it. I refer to “separation of religion and government” to show we include synagogues, mosques, and all theistic religions. The major setback here is that too many Christian nationalists believe we are a Christian country, and they are a serious threat to separation of religion and government.
Jacobsen: How is the Secular Coalition for America?
Silverman: SCA is doing very well. I helped found the organization in 2004 with just four national member organizations. SCA now has twenty national atheist, humanist, and other nonreligious member organizations, including of course, the American Humanist Association.
The Secular Coalition has a dedicated lobbying organization within the Coalition, with a mission to advocate for the equal rights of nonreligious Americans and defend the separation of religion and government. Representing twenty national member organizations, hundreds of local secular communities, and working with our allies in the faith community, SCA combines the power of grassroots activism with professional lobbying to make an impact on the laws and policies that govern separation of religion and government. Furthermore, the Secular Coalition takes every opportunity to support the Congressional Freethought Caucus, which currently has twenty-three members of the House of Representatives.

​Jacobsen: What do you see as the important points to target theocratic creep in American politics?
Silverman: We need to take every opportunity to alert our members to what theists are doing, and speak out to counter some of their activities. Publicity about this problem is essential. The Secular Coalition for America has an important advocacy campaign.
Jacobsen: You have been the target of anti-Semitism and anti-atheist discrimination. What are some of the stories around those?
Silverman: Since I am a godless Jew, I have been called a self-hating Jew. Not true. I’m proud to be a Jew (someone who had Jewish parents). Although I am an atheist, even Orthodox Jews consider me a Jew (though not a very good one). Adolph Hitler considered me a Jew, and some of my family members died in the Holocaust. I would not want to give Hitler a posthumous victory by denying my Judaism. In the past, I have had signs put on my office door saying, “Atheist Shithead.” I prefer the expression I learned in elementary school: “Sticks and stones may break me bones, but words will never hurt me.” Fortunately, nobody broke my bones because of being a Jewish atheist and humanist.
Jacobsen: What can younger generations of Jewish atheists (etc.) and others learn from moving forward and not taking the discrimination and racism personally?
Silverman: They can try to make a positive difference, and ignore or respond in a reasonable fashion to personal insults.
Jacobsen: Are there efforts to catalogue anti-None prejudice and bias in national and state statistics in a manner similar to anti-Muslim, anti-Semitic, etc., bigotry is catalogued, e.g., hate crimes?
Silverman: I agree that this is important. I don’t have specific information on who is doing it, and hope readers will tell us what they know.
Jacobsen: How can people get involved in the Secular Coalition for America, whether volunteering time, money, or skills and expertise, to combat violations of secular equality?
Silverman: They can do all of the above. Check the website secular.org.
Jacobsen: Thank you for the opportunity and your time, Herb.
Silverman: It’s always a pleasure to talk with you, Scott, in person or in print.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

“The Good Men Project” interviews Barbara Anderson regarding Watchtower Documents, activism, clergy abuse, and more

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Stop Civil Abuse Advocate Reform and Safety, Inc

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2025/12/27

Barbara Anderson is a researcher and whistleblower focused on Jehovah’s Witnesses’ handling of child sexual abuse. A member from 1954 to 1997, she worked at the denomination’s Brooklyn headquarters from 1982 to 1992 in the Writing Department, researching the movement’s official history. She later spoke publicly about internal policies and founded Watchtower Documents, an independent archive used by journalists and attorneys. Anderson has appeared in major media, including Dateline NBC, and continues to document cases, policies, and litigation while advising survivors and reporters. She authored Barbara Anderson Uncensored and maintains public profiles detailing her archival and advocacy work.

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen speaks with Barbara Anderson, researcher and whistleblower known for documenting Jehovah’s Witnesses’ child sexual abuse policies and building the archival project Watchtower Documents. Anderson outlines her 2025 work-streams: legal and legislative change, institutional accountability, and survivor advocacy, with increasing attention to adult victims. She explains that document authentication is mainly procedural—rules of evidence, protective orders, pseudonyms, and redaction—designed to admit proof while shielding identities. Anderson also describes trauma-informed collaboration with journalists and legal teams, and highlights systemic gaps in decentralized Protestant structures that hinder oversight, transparency, and consistent reform.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: What are the main 2025 work-streams at Watchtower Documents?

Barbara Anderson: In 2025, main work-streams at Watchtower Documents related to eliminating clergy-perpetrated abuse, center on legal and legislative changes, institutional accountability and reform, and survivor advocacy and support. These efforts involve actions by governments, religious bodies (particularly the Catholic Church), and non-profit advocacy groups. And a growing focus on adult victims.

Jacobsen: Which verification methods authenticate documents while protecting victims’ identities?

Anderson: In legal proceedings related to clergy abuse, documents are authenticated using standard rules of evidence, while a victim’s identity is protected through legal safeguards like pseudonyms, protective orders, and document redaction. These are procedural, rather than technical verification methods, and they allow evidence to be admitted without revealing the survivor’s public identity.

Jacobsen: How do you collaborate with journalists and legal teams?

Anderson: Collaboration in clergy abuse cases involves a survivor-centered, trauma-informed approach where legal teams and journalists work transparently to support survivors, pursue accountability, and maintain confidentiality. Effective collaboration emphasizes shared power and clear communication while prioritizing the survivor’s well-being.

Jacobsen: What recurring themes happen in court filings or organizational policies?

Anderson: To reduce clergy abuse risk, reforms must focus on transparency, accountability, survivor empowerment, and strong internal controls, including mandatory background checks, independent oversight, publishing clergy files, enforcing zero-tolerance policies, ensuring prompt reporting to civil authorities, and banning secrecy pacts, moving away from institutional cover-ups towards genuine, survivor-centered justice and prevention.

Jacobsen: Following from the previous question, where are the biggest observed gaps?

Anderson: The gaps in solving Protestant clergy abuse largely stem from decentralized structures, a culture of denial and niceness that discourages naming inappropriate behavior, and a significant lack of external accountability and oversight. Unlike the Catholic Church, which has a universal hierarchy, the independent nature of many Protestant churches makes systemic solutions difficult to implement.

Jacobsen: Which concrete governance or compliance reforms would reduce risk?

Anderson: To reduce clergy abuse risk, reforms must focus on transparency, accountability, survivor empowerment, and strong internal controls, including mandatory background checks, independent oversight, publishing clergy files, enforcing zero-tolerance policies, ensuring prompt reporting to civil authorities, and banning secrecy pacts, moving away from institutional cover-ups towards genuine, survivor-centered justice and prevention.

Jacobsen: What metrics indicate progress, even regress, in accountability and justice since starting your work?

Anderson: Metrics indicating progress in clergy abuse cases include a decline in new allegations, increased spending on prevention, and legislative changes to statutes of limitations. Indicators of regress, however, include a lack of transparency in canonical trials, continued institutional resistance to accountability, and an increase in the number of cases categorized as “unable to be proven”.

Jacobsen: What near-term research is being prepared?

Anderson: Near-term research in clergy-perpetrated abuse cases is focusing on the experiences and support for adult survivors, the systemic factors within religious communities that enable abuse, and the effectiveness of current prevention and reporting mechanisms.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Barbara.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen is the publisher of In-Sight Publishing (ISBN: 978-1-0692343) and Editor-in-Chief of In-Sight: Interviews (ISSN: 2369-6885). He writes forThe Good Men Project, International Policy Digest (ISSN: 2332–9416), The Humanist (Print: ISSN 0018-7399; Online: ISSN 2163-3576), Basic Income Earth Network (UK Registered Charity 1177066), A Further Inquiry, and other media.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Critiques of Facilitated Communication

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): facilitatedcommunication.com

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2025

”Stuart Vyse, an expert on superstition, pseudoscience, and critical thinking, discusses the resurgence of discredited autism communication techniques like Facilitated Communication (FC) and Spelling to Communicate (S2C). Despite being scientifically debunked, these methods persist due to parental desperation and social media amplification. The podcast The Telepathy Tapes promotes pseudoscienfic claims of telepathic abilities in non-speaking autistic individuals, further fueling misinformation. Vyse emphasizes the responsibility of scientists to counteract such claims and highlights cognitive biases that sustain them. He warns of dangerous, unproven autism treatments and stresses the need for evidence-based perspectives to challenge pseudoscience effectively.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Ann Druyan on Science in a Shared Cosmos

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Parlour News Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2025/11/14

Ann Druyan (born June 13, 1949) is an American documentary producer, author, and activist renowned for her contributions to science communication. She co-wrote and produced the acclaimed PBS series Cosmos with her late husband, Carl Sagan. As the creative director of NASA’s Voyager Interstellar Message Project, she helped design the Golden Record sent into space. Druyan also created and produced the sequels Cosmos: A Spacetime Odyssey and Cosmos: Possible Worlds. Beyond media, she advocates for nuclear disarmament, environmental protection, and space exploration initiatives like Breakthrough Starshot. Her work has earned numerous awards, highlighting her dedication to science and public education.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Today, we are with the wonderful Ann Druyan, one of the most renowned humanist figures. You have inspired me in my formal explorations of science and science education, particularly with the Beyond Belief conference in 2006.

Ann Druyan: It was long ago.

Jacobsen: So, what can I ask you that others haven’t? What was your introduction to secular humanism, scientific skepticism and public science education?

Druyan: I was very lucky because my parents didn’t believe in telling their children—or anyone—what to think. They were deeply committed to the idea that you had to figure things out for yourself. It was really interesting because my father was an atheist. He wasn’t confrontational about it, but he was always honest. His parents, however, were two of the most devout people I have ever known.

Without going into a long story, despite being so observant, they were Orthodox Jews who followed the Shulchan Aruch, the codification of Jewish law, which includes around 613 mitzvot—not the Ten Commandments, but the full set of commandments. My grandfather was the kind of person who adhered to these even under the most extreme circumstances. For example, Jewish law allows for violating certain commandments in cases of serious illness, such as when necessary work is performed on the Sabbath. Yet, even when my grandfather was dying of stomach cancer and had one leg crushed in an industrial accident years earlier, he insisted on walking four miles to attend my brother’s Bar Mitzvah. That’s how devout he was.

However, he was unwilling to impose his devoutness on my father and his sisters. He believed the only sin was to pretend. Unlike most of the people I have met who claim to believe in God, I think my grandparents truly did because they never saw their faith as an opportunity for social coercion or intimidation.

They had no sense of entitlement to impose their beliefs on others, which was a great model for me. On the other hand, my parents were much more casual about the whole thing. They were not nearly as observant as my father’s parents. They practiced selectively and were more culturally observant than strictly religious.

I cannot ever remember believing in God. I’ve tried to recall—especially as I work on my memoir—but I can’t. God was never a figure of authority in our home. I went to Hebrew school and Sunday school as a child, but I was very aware that my parents wanted me to understand the historical background of our people, their beliefs, and the reasons for the holidays we observed.

I was lucky; I didn’t have to discard any beliefs or break any shackles. However, I still had a casual relationship with the truth, and I don’t mean the truth in the absolute sense.

But I believed many things that I liked to believe because it was fun. I did what we all do—believing in what appealed to me and affirming the mythos at the core of my personality while dismissing the things that conflicted with it. I had a very unsteady relationship with reality.

Even as a child, I remember yearning to feel real and that the world around me was real. It didn’t feel real to me. That changed when I began studying the pre-Socratic philosophers. I started in college, though I was a very bad student and eventually dropped out. However, I was a voracious reader.

When I discovered the pre-Socratic philosophers, I loved their ideas. They seemed to affirm my political beliefs—particularly that if you can find out how things work, understand how they are put together, and demystify human life and existence, you can live a far richer life. I was very attracted to something Karl Marx said, though not to everything he said. One statement that struck me deeply was: “One law for science and another for life is a priori a lie.”

That idea resonated with me. Marx was a big admirer of Darwin, and it seemed clear to me that the core acceptance of Darwin’s theory—that humans were not separately created from the rest of life—was a profound and brilliant insight. Darwin made this claim long before it could be scientifically proven, but he was correct. Eventually, we did prove it.

It wasn’t just that humans weren’t separate from other living things; it was the implication that if this was true, why would we have one law for animals and a completely different understanding for humans? It didn’t make sense. That led me to read Heraclitus, Democritus, and other translations of the pre-Socratic philosophers. I found these thinkers—the inventors of science—utterly revolutionary.

Even before I met Carl, I believed this was the greatest intellectual revolution ever. The idea that “God” or “the gods” are just shorthand for our ignorance and that we can’t resort to them to explain what happens in the universe was incredibly powerful to me. This way of thinking led through a long and winding path to the scientific method, allowing us to send probes to the outer solar system and beyond.

You can’t achieve such feats without this kind of thinking, and that struck me as a profound metric of its power. I was also a child of the 1960s, coming of age during the Apollo missions. To me, those were mythic achievements. Imagine if an ancient Sumerian or Akkadian king had decreed, “In 10 years, one of us will walk on the moon.” People would have thought it was an impressive declaration, but it is unlikely to happen. Yet, in my lifetime, it was achieved.

Watching those achievements unfold was a tremendous jolt of human self-esteem, something we needed so desperately after the horrors of Auschwitz, Hiroshima, Nagasaki, Cambodia, and the Belgian Congo. We needed that sense of human possibility.

Then I met Carl. That was a complete revelation—not at first, because we knew each other for years before our relationship became personal. But as I got to know him, I realized that he was, inside, exactly the person he appeared to be on the outside. He didn’t waste any time with pretense or pretending to be someone he wasn’t.

And that’s what knocked me out—there’s a person you get to know, and that person is not only so much better than your fantasies, but the more you learn about them, the more in awe you are. That felt like a tremendous engine—a drive to be truthful, to see things as they are, to describe them accurately, and to witness nature and reality and the wonder of it.

It became a way to have a soaring spiritual experience without having to lie to me or pretend. I loved that. I think that’s what my grandparents experienced for themselves, so they didn’t need to push anyone else around to enforce their worldview.

Eventually, I found my way to a worldview that was as spiritually satisfying as I could imagine. That’s how I became who I am. Now, when you say “humanist,” I’d like to point out that I think someday we will call ourselves something different.

We will likely become less human-centred. The more I learn about other living beings on this planet—about trees, the mycelium networks under our feet, the ways other creatures communicate and support each other—the less human-centred I feel. “Humanist” seems, in some ways, too narrow and is part of our problem as a species.

Carl and I wrote a book called “Shadows of Forgotten Ancestors.” It tried to confront who we are as a species as honestly as possible. Do we have a future? Are we hopelessly flawed, or is there still hope? Where do we stand on the tree of life? What’s the real difference between us and the other life forms on this planet?

Writing that book was a tremendous undertaking. Thrilling. It was exhilarating to think and learn alongside Carl during the process. But when I finished my part, I realized that “humanist” doesn’t fully capture my beliefs.

I don’t know if “Earthist” is the right term—it doesn’t sound quite right—but I’m for Earth and all Earth life. It’s a shame that, as a species, we’ve been so narcissistic, so willing to convince ourselves that those we torture, kill, or exploit—whether human or non-human—don’t feel the same pain and emotions we do. It’s a convenient self-deception we’ve used for far too long.

Jacobsen: At the Beyond Belief conference, you made a poignant statement about the “spiritual narcissism” of certain religious philosophies, contrasting it with the pursuit of truth through empiricism and the scientific method. Do you still adhere to those statements? Have your views evolved?

Druyan: I don’t think they’ve changed much. That’s a sign I’ve stopped learning or evolving! But I still believe those things very strongly—more than ever.

Nothing has persuaded me—nothing has happened in the past 20 or 19 years—that has convinced me otherwise. I still believe. If you wanted to know my ethos, it would be something from Micah or Isaiah: “Walk humbly, do justice, love mercy.” That’s enough for me.

The history of our attempts to perceive the consciousness and existence of other living things in this world is just beginning. The hideous notion of separate creation has so blinded us. That idea is among the most damaging and pernicious deceptions ever perpetrated on humans. What a joy that science is telling us the opposite.

As Heraclitus said long before anyone seriously investigated these questions: “Not I, but the world says it—all is one.” Think about it: a 4-billion-plus-year life history on this planet, a continuity that we are equally a part of. What could be more thrilling and moving than the idea that we are one of billions in this world but still linked in a chain of life that returns to Earth’s earliest history? You can’t beat that.

Jacobsen: Other than the quotes from Isaiah, Micha, and Heraclitus, what are some of your favourite quotes about science or a broadened vision of humanism?

Druyan: I love Carl’s statement: “We are a way for the universe to know itself.” That’s demonstrably true, and it represents such a great leap in understanding who we are and what science is.

We need that error-correcting mechanism of science so badly. We’re such big liars—we lie to each other and ourselves. We’re hopeless liars. The only thing that can keep us somewhat honest—imperfectly, but it’s the best we have—is the methodology of science.

Its effectiveness is unrivalled and exactly what a species of fibbers like us needs.

Jacobsen: Ann, thank you very much for your time today.

Druyan: I’m glad we were finally able to get this call.

Jacobsen: Me too. Again, I’m sorry for what happened to you and your family.

Druyan: It was lovely to meet you, Scott. Take care.

Jacobsen: Bye-bye.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Irina Tsukerman on faith, foreign policy and freedom of expression

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): El Prensero

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2025/06/06

How does Irina Tsukerman’s analysis of Pope Leo XIV, US deportation policies, and global media repression reflect broader trends in authoritarianism, disinformation, and the international defense of human rights?

Dialogue conducted on May 9, 2025. Scott Douglas Jacobsen interviews Irina Tsukerman, a lawyer specializing in human rights and national security, about the most pressing issues on the global stage. They discuss the implications of Pope Leo XIV’s centrist leadership, the resurgence of liberation theology, and the evolving role of the Church in international politics. Tsukerman criticizes US immigration practices under the Trump administration, particularly deportations to unstable regions such as Libya and Ukraine. The conversation also covers press freedom in Greece, disinformation campaigns, and the fine line between journalism and foreign political interference. Tsukerman emphasizes the need for moderation, institutional integrity, and strong global leadership in the face of rising authoritarianism. Interview conducted on May 9, 2025.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen:  Today we begin the first session of  Everywhere Insiders , with  Irina Tsukerman , a lawyer specializing in human rights and national security, political analyst, media strategist, and activist. She is the founder and editor-in-chief of  The Washington Outsider , a platform dedicated to in-depth analysis of public policy and international security. The name of this session, which is somewhat of an antonymous concept, is inspired by her work and her publication.

Tsukerman is known for writing extensively on  disinformation, information warfare, counterterrorism, and geopolitical dynamics . Her analyses have been published in  Newsweek ,  Modern Diplomacy ,  Legal Insurrection  , and other outlets, and translated into more than a dozen languages. She has appeared on global platforms such as  Fox Business ,  i24 News  , and  Al Arabiya , and has participated in debates and programs affiliated with institutions such as the United Nations and George Mason University.

She holds a bachelor’s degree in International and Intercultural Studies, specializing in the Middle East, and a Juris Doctor, both from Fordham University. She is admitted to the New York State Bar and is a member of both the New York State Bar Association and the New York City Bar Association. She also serves as a research fellow at the Center for Security and Foreign Affairs at the Arabian Peninsula Institute.

Let’s turn to current events. We have a new pope:  Leo XIV . In my analysis, he appears to be a moderate and centrist leader on many issues, although he maintains traditionalist theological and cultural positions. I don’t expect significant changes regarding marriage or LGBTQIA+ rights. However, I foresee increased dialogue, greater openness, and a diffusion of ecclesiastical authority, rather than a continuation of the centralized and rigid model.

Tsukerman:  I agree,  100% . It’s interesting because many people are trying to analyze his past, especially during his time in Chicago. Some claim that he wasn’t actively involved in interfaith dialogue, particularly with Jewish groups. However, that may not reflect his values, but rather the institutional norms of the environment. Some academic or religious institutions prioritize interfaith engagement, but often this stems from certain specific theological traditions. For example, the Jesuits are known for fostering interfaith dialogue, but this pope isn’t a Jesuit, so we shouldn’t expect the same approach.

Others have interpreted his comments on J.D. Vance ‘s Christian views   as a sign of support for pro-immigration policies or policies favorable to undocumented immigrants. I don’t see it that way. Vance’s statements can be interpreted much more broadly. When the pope—still a cardinal at the time—responded, I believe he wasn’t speaking directly about immigration. Rather, he was criticizing Vance’s opportunistic and self-centered use of theology, without any real doctrinal support.

Many people try to infer a political stance or partisan alignment from the new pope’s theological arguments, which don’t necessarily align with U.S. politics or the politics of any other country. That said, I agree with the general assessment. How theology and dogma manifest themselves in the real world—outside of Vatican circles and beyond doctrines that primarily affect practicing Catholics—will be interesting to watch. However, I don’t expect him to be as politically active or outspoken on specific issues as Pope Francis was. I see him as someone who will offer general theological commentary when necessary but will avoid becoming directly involved in political debates.

Some people also interpret his experience in Peru as a sign of excessive leftist leanings, but that’s a misreading. It forgets that one of the Church’s traditional roles has been to care for the poor. The fact that he did so effectively is a positive sign, not an ideological statement. Pope Francis was heavily influenced by liberation theology and received specific intellectual training in Argentina. In contrast, Pope Leo was educated in other regions and shows no visible signs of adhering to that current, at least according to his public writings.

Nor is he a pope particularly focused on publishing or doctrinal output; he is rather a practical pastor, which sets him quite apart from some of his predecessors. This could prove beneficial in administrative matters, especially in the face of long-standing problems such as  financial mismanagement . One need only recall the recent reports of  $500,000 found in a paper bag  —something worthy of a scene from the film  The Conclave —and the ongoing scandals involving sexual abuse.

I’ve seen at least one accusation that he turned a blind eye to cases of sexual abuse during his time in Chicago. However, I have no way of knowing if that’s true, or if the person who made the accusation—visibly traumatized—was projecting their own pain or expecting something that, at the time, the then-cardinal had no power to resolve. I don’t know.

What I can say is that this pattern—where popes are perceived as more protective of the institution than confrontational in the face of abuse—has been seen before. In practice, the way these cases are handled varies: some predators are quietly reassigned or expelled, while others are publicly exposed. What is clear is that  there must be a decisive response, and leadership on this issue must come from the top . That said, it remains a complex problem, and many things remain unresolved.

Ultimately, people must stop projecting their political preferences onto a religious institution. The Church will not act in accordance with contemporary political categories. Many doctrinally conservative Catholic leaders may appear progressive on economic issues, and many reformers who support the role of women within the Church may hold deeply conservative positions on issues such as LGBTQ rights, because they consider those positions consistent with Church authority and tradition.

Jacobsen:  I wouldn’t make firm predictions based on just a few isolated comments I’ve made. You raise very complex and nuanced points. There’s one aspect worth highlighting: the broader religious and political history of Latin America, including its connections with Portugal and Spain, not just with Central and South America.

As you mentioned, with Pope Francis there has been a resurgence of interest in the social teachings of the Gospel, particularly through the lens of  liberation theology , which focuses on caring for the poor and marginalized. Some of the leading thinkers of that movement were tragically killed during periods of political repression, especially in the 1970s and 1980s.

An interesting parallel is that many programs inspired by liberation theology, while rooted in Christian ethics, can be interpreted in secular terms. For example, António Guterres—current Secretary-General of the United Nations and former Prime Minister of Portugal—has supported policies such as the decriminalization of drug use. These initiatives reflect a compassionate public health approach rather than punitive moralism, which aligns, in many respects, with the spirit of liberation theology, even though Guterres’s religious beliefs are not particularly public.

Regarding the current pope, it is noteworthy that he has spent almost a third of his life in Peru. This Latin American background places him within a theological and cultural context that has repeatedly given rise to forms of socially engaged Christian thought. Whether expressed explicitly theologically or translated into models of secular governance, this tradition continues to significantly influence global leaders.

We may be witnessing a  turning point . The new pontiff is only 69 years old—a relatively young age for a pope—and could remain in office for a decade or two with access to excellent medical care. That is significant, especially if he maintains a  centrist and theologically traditional approach  at a time of great global cultural uncertainty. Such continuity and stability could become a valuable anchor for both Catholics and international observers.

Tsukerman:  From what I’ve heard, one of the reasons he was elected, despite being considered an unlikely candidate, was precisely because of his  perceived ability to provide stability . Some even interpreted his election as a subtle message of rejection of the kind of extremism that gained ground under  Donald Trump ‘s leadership , including certain expressions of politicized Catholicism that emerged during that period.

His election also sent another message: while certain ideological expressions may be rejected,  the United States as a nation is not . American leadership remains central within the global Catholic community and in the broader framework of international relations. His papacy could represent an effort to  reaffirm transatlantic ties , prioritizing cooperation over polarization.

I think the conclave was looking for a unifying, centrist figure. There has been a lot of speculation about this, much of it unfounded. For example, some extremist voices, like  Laura Loomer  —who isn’t even Catholic—have called him “the Marxist pope,” which I find  absurd . Many conservatives argue that the state shouldn’t act as a social safety net, that this is the role of private institutions and local communities.

So why wouldn’t it be welcome for the Catholic Church to assume that traditional charitable role and alleviate the burden on the state? Especially from those who have rightly criticized the Church for its corruption, shouldn’t they be encouraging it if someone is actively attending to the needs of the most vulnerable, both personally and in the exercise of their leadership? That is the  best possible response to institutional criticism . To call it Marxist for returning to the Church’s founding mission—for behaving like a true religious institution—strikes me as deeply contradictory.

Unless, of course, someone is confusing the Church with the  United States Supreme Court . Even if one starts from tradition, judicial philosophy does not automatically translate into endorsement of the policies of the executive or legislative branches. If people expect the Pope to act like a conventional head of state, they are completely misunderstanding the nature of his office.  Church doctrine will never fit neatly into shifting ideological categories or the demands of the current political cycle.

I hope there is something more “Catholic”—in the sense of universal and timeless—in religious doctrine than in the vicissitudes of political life. After all, that is one of the central reasons why religious institutions exist: to offer a moral and spiritual direction  separate from the volatility of political power .

If Pope Leo proves to be the centrist and unifying figure many hope for, that will be a profoundly positive development. Today, there is  far too much internal conflict . On the far right, some traditionalist factions are promoting extremist—and even openly intolerant—candidates whose positions stray far from Catholic theological orthodoxy and border on hate speech. Some have even gone so far as to call for the return of  Catholic monarchies , systems that have historically been disastrous, not only for religious minorities but also for many Catholics.

Those monarchs  ruined their nations  through unnecessary wars and authoritarian rule. Meanwhile, on the far left, there are those who seem to misunderstand religious tradition altogether, confusing emotional compassion and political activism with genuine spiritual practice. This confusion has contributed to the alienation of many faithful and the exodus of people from the Church, who return to purely political frameworks.

Of course, political engagement is legitimate. But if the  intrinsic value  of religious tradition within the Church—beyond secular political agendas—is not recognized, the Church will continue to lose relevance and coherence. Moderation  is essential , not only to preserve tradition but also to adapt it meaningfully to the challenges of the modern world. This includes difficulties with recruitment, evangelization in Western countries, and dialogue with the so-called Global South and other vulnerable populations.

A centrist pope offers flexibility. He can build bridges between these sectors and foster dialogue between communities with profoundly different realities, experiences, and challenges.  Transforming that dialogue into a coherent and inclusive conversation would be a powerful and much-needed legacy . So yes, I sincerely hope that if anything lasting comes from this election, it will be that legacy of  unity, dialogue, and compassionate leadership .

Even if this papacy is not defined by major geopolitical battles or ideological confrontations like the communism of John Paul II, even if it focuses on building better human and spiritual relationships,  that would already be an extraordinary achievement . The great challenge of our time is the growing  lack of understanding , the absence of dialogue, and the erosion of empathy toward those who think or live differently. If that is the legacy of Pope Leo, it would be of enormous historical significance.

Jacobsen:  Let’s move on to a more pressing issue: concerns about possible plans by the U.S. government to deport migrants to  Libya . As you know, Libya has a long history of  human rights abuses  against migrants. This includes arbitrary detentions, torture, extortion, rape, murder, and even reports of unusual mistreatment, such as force-feeding under inhumane conditions. What is your legal and ethical assessment, especially considering your experience as a human rights lawyer?

Tsukerman: Libya is currently a volatile and fragmented  country  . It is divided among rival governments, armed factions, and tribal authorities, with deep sectarian divisions. Foreign powers—particularly Russia and Turkey—exploit this conflict to advance their own strategic interests, further exacerbating the situation. Corruption is widespread, and the country faces enormous economic and infrastructure challenges.

In some regions of Libya, modern-day slavery practices   against migrants have even been reported. To be clear,  not all Libyans  support or participate in these atrocities, not at all. But there are specific areas where these human rights violations occur, and it is  horrifying . Furthermore, Libya has become a  proxy frontier  within broader migration conflicts, with destabilizing population flows deliberately encouraged to exert pressure on Europe, North Africa, and the Middle East. Geographically, Libya is in a particularly vulnerable position to be used as a weapon in this regard.

For this very reason, I find it  incomprehensible  that, under the Trump administration, anyone considered it morally justifiable to deport vulnerable people—many of whom  are neither African nor have any connection to the region—to such a dangerous place. It seems like an intentionally cruel  policy  , designed to demonstrate power by choosing the most unstable and dangerous destinations possible.

According to available information, these were  Asian migrants  with no ties to North Africa. Sending them to a country where they face even greater risks  makes no sense , from both a humanitarian and a legal perspective.

If the goal were truly safe repatriation, or even temporary relocation, the reasonable course of action would have been to negotiate agreements with a stable Asian country closer to their countries of origin, where  adequate infrastructure exists  for processing, protection, and even reintegration. Instead, what happened was the creation of a  list of unpredictable and dangerous destinations , completely disconnected from these individuals’ actual backgrounds.

From both a legal and humanitarian perspective, it is  indefensible . This is not merely bad policy; it is  gross negligence  or  deliberate cruelty . The plan was to send Asian migrants to Libya—despite the obvious dangers—and another group, of unspecified origin, to  Saudi Arabia , which reportedly  objected . Most astonishingly, yet  another group was slated for deportation to Ukraine … in the midst of a war.

And these weren’t Ukrainian migrants, but  Latin American migrants . The Trump administration considered sending Spanish speakers to a country at war, where neither Spanish, nor Russian, nor English, nor Ukrainian are spoken. The  cultural, linguistic, and geopolitical clash  was total. All of this within the context of an active war, where the risks are more than evident.

It is unclear why these highly  inappropriate destinations were chosen , instead of negotiating with relatively stable countries capable of receiving migrants in exchange for financial support. It appears to have been a  deliberate power play , a form of deterrence. The message was: “If you cross illegally into the United States, we will not only deport you, but we will send you to a completely foreign and potentially hostile place.” It was designed to  instill fear .

And there’s a second interpretation. It also seemed like a show of force against the receiving countries. Libya, for example,  doesn’t have a unified government . It has two competing governments and is in no position to negotiate. Depositing migrants in a fractured state  is neither a serious diplomatic nor humanitarian strategy . It’s an act of brute force: “We do what we want, and you can’t do anything about it.”

These people—many from warm, tropical regions—would be placed in unfamiliar climates, without a language, without a social support network, and without legal protection. They could be kidnapped by militias, detained, abused, or killed by armed actors such as the  Russians or Turks operating on the ground . This is a gross violation of U.S. international obligations and deeply damages the  country’s moral image .

I’ve never heard of any other country doing anything similar. Many have strict immigration controls, yes, but they don’t load families onto military planes and send them to completely dangerous and unsuitable destinations. That’s  not immigration policy: it’s senseless cruelty , designed to project fear and impunity.

The message was clear: “We can do whatever we want, to whomever we want.” Although this part may seem brief, it is  essential . It reveals how immigration policy has been  militarized  —not as a tool for border control, but as a spectacle of public punishment.

Jacobsen:  In Fangak County, South Sudan, there was what appears to be a deliberate act, possibly constituting a war crime: an aerial bombardment that killed at least seven people and injured more than 20. The target was a  Doctors Without Borders (MSF) facility  —including a hospital and a pharmacy. The attack was condemned by the UN Human Rights Commission in South Sudan. What is your opinion on this?

Tsukerman:  Unfortunately, this type of  abuse and violence against medical personnel in conflict zones  is becoming increasingly common. I don’t see how it could be reliably prevented without effective security or accountability mechanisms. Operating in active war zones is becoming increasingly  dangerous and risky .

More broadly, I observe an alarming trend: a  resurgence of global fragmentation and sectarianism . After a period in which violence seemed to be receding and sectarian clashes were becoming more political than military, we are now witnessing a  worrying reversal . Incidents like this bombing reflect a wider global pattern. As new hotspots of tension emerge, without clear resolution, consequences, or coordinated pathways to reconstruction or reconciliation, other vulnerable regions become susceptible to  similar outbreaks of violence .

The lack of consequences  emboldens violent groups . Instead of seeking diplomatic, legal, or political means to resolve disputes, they resort to armed conflict. Most troubling is the  absence of strong leadership  from the international community, the United Nations, the United States, or other potential stabilizing powers. There is no coherent strategy to protect humanitarian workers or medical personnel from these extrajudicial attacks.

We need more than deterrence. We need  visible, active, and sustained support . Strong messages must be sent to both potential perpetrators and those who risk their lives to provide assistance. As things stand, we are  failing  to protect the most essential actors in humanitarian crises.

Jacobsen:  Let’s talk about Greece and the deterioration of press freedom there, especially since the  New Democracy party  came to power in July 2019. A recent human rights report accuses the Greek government of creating a hostile environment for the independent press and journalists since the start of the pandemic. It details cases of  harassment, intimidation, surveillance, and abusive lawsuits —all practices that encourage self-censorship and undermine freedom of expression. As a media professional, what are your thoughts?

Tsukerman:  As a media professional in the United States, I firmly believe in fostering the  greatest possible press freedom and open dialogue . The best way to counter bad ideas is with better ideas, not censorship. Confronting harmful platforms requires clear, accessible, fact-based communication, not repression.

When journalists are intimidated into silence—whether through lawsuits, surveillance, or threats—not only is press freedom eroded, but  democracy itself is undermined . This pattern isn’t unique to Greece; we’re seeing it in various parts of the world. Governments are learning to  use legal tools, digital surveillance, and even social media manipulation  to stifle dissent under the guise of maintaining order or protecting the national interest.

The solution lies in  strengthening journalistic resilience , protecting whistleblowers, supporting independent media, and fostering  information literacy among the population . A vibrant press is a central pillar of any democratic society. If it weakens, everything else begins to crumble. Frankly, when I encounter hostile or disinformation-laden media outlets, my first reaction is not to censor them, but  to render them irrelevant  by creating better, fact-based alternatives. The goal should be to avoid giving them more complaints, more visibility, or advertising value. That said,  not all countries are like the United States .

In Greece, the situation is much more delicate. There are  active political operations and foreign disinformation campaigns  that are significantly more destabilizing than what we have seen, so far, in the United States. And that is saying a lot, considering the high level of  pro-Russian influence  that has even penetrated government levels in the US in recent years.

However, even under these extreme circumstances, the average American does not feel the same immediate and tangible impact as Greeks do. In Greece, hostile foreign actors  operate directly within the country in ways not seen in the US, at least not with the same physical presence or intensity.

One of the key reasons for this difference is the  relative strength of the U.S. institutional and law enforcement infrastructure . Historically, we have had better mechanisms for tracing illicit financing, investigating foreign interference, and acting to mitigate threats. That infrastructure—though under pressure today—has served us well.

In contrast, Greece has endured  prolonged periods of economic instability  and lacks the same resources and institutional resilience. Its financial capacity  is not comparable  to that of the United States. This makes responding effectively, when economic grievances, weakened public institutions, and limited experience in dealing with complex foreign interference are combined, far more difficult.

From a logistical and practical standpoint, it’s a much more challenging environment. It also makes the erosion of press freedom and public trust even  more dangerous . Regarding media confrontations, I’m not entirely convinced that  shutting down a foreign-funded media outlet whose sole purpose is to disseminate propaganda  constitutes an attack on press freedom. If a media outlet is funded by a foreign government and its mission is  to defame local authorities, spread conspiracy theories, or incite violence , then  it no longer functions as a legitimate media outlet , but as a  foreign political operation . And political operations  are not entitled to the same protections  as media outlets.

That’s very different from a media outlet with a critical editorial line that publishes controversial opinions or legitimate criticisms of a government, especially when those criticisms come from a domestic opposition. But when that opposition acts with  the backing or coordination of foreign powers , the analysis changes completely.

Tsukerman:  Now,  I’m not saying that governments can’t overstep their bounds . There’s always the risk of authoritarianism, where a state becomes paranoid and starts persecuting even legitimate opposition under the guise of combating foreign interference. But, based on my experience in risk analysis and intelligence,  I suspect there’s far more foreign interference, corruption, and covert financing than most people realize .

It’s easy to cite statistics—how many media outlets were monitored or shut down—and immediately conclude that there is repression. But  each case must be examined within its full context . Are these truly independent, national media outlets? Or are they fronts for foreign political operations?

Is there concrete evidence linking them to hostile foreign actors? Was the surveillance or restriction justified, or was it arbitrary and abusive? These are  complex and nuanced questions that must be addressed in  detail and with depth , not with simplistic generalizations.

Many extremist groups or those linked to foreign powers  count on the international audience not thoroughly investigating  these cases. They know that most people won’t read reports on media transparency or verify whether a media outlet is a legitimate newsroom, a foreign-funded PR agency, or worse,  a troll farm .

We’ve seen this in the US: for example, the FBI revealed that a purported media company in Tennessee was actually  a Russian disinformation front , created to undermine public trust. At first glance, someone outside the US might ask, “Why is the FBI shutting down a private media outlet?” But upon closer examination, it becomes clear that there was  foreign funding and direct coordination , justifying legal action.

Similarly, what is happening in Greece  may follow the same pattern . It is crucial to examine the details: who is involved, where the funding comes from, and what activities are being carried out. And then assess how the United States and the European Union can help. The goal must be  to protect Greece’s sovereignty , guarantee  press freedom  , and preserve spaces for legitimate criticism, while still addressing  actual foreign interference .

Jacobsen:  Irina, thank you for this first session of the inaugural  Everywhere Insiders series . I greatly appreciate your time and ideas.

Tsukerman:  Thank you very much. It was a great conversation.

Jacobsen:  I’m curious to see how this develops. It sounds like the beginning of a very interesting conversational newscast.

Tsukerman:  Absolutely.

Jacobsen:  Thanks again.

Tsukerman:  I hope you’re doing well.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Saša Dobrijević on ICJ, Press Freedom, and the Future of Digital Journalism

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): LinkedIn (Saša Dobrijević)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/04/20

How does Saša Dobrijević understand journalism’s democratic purpose through ICJ, cross-border collaboration, and technological adaptation in a rapidly changing digital media environment?

Saša Dobrijević is an award-winning Serbian international journalist and founder of the Intercontinental Connection of Journalists (ICJ), a global media initiative addressing structural gaps in journalism. Beginning his career at 19, he developed experience across European media landscapes, including work in Munich. His leadership focuses on creating accessible publishing platforms, supporting freelancers and students, and fostering cross-border collaboration. Dobrijević emphasizes investigative reporting, press freedom, and technological adaptation as essential to sustaining journalism’s democratic function.

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen speaks with Saša Dobrijević, founder of the Intercontinental Connection of Journalists, about journalism’s democratic purpose, leadership, and institutional gaps facing reporters. Dobrijević explains why ICJ supports freelancers, students, and senior journalists through publishing access, press credentials, and education. He also reflects on digital transformation, social media, mobile reporting, and the enduring necessity of strong questions, empathy, professional distance, and truthful storytelling under structural economic pressure.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Why did you pursue journalism and also leadership in journalism? This will lead into the more formal line of questioning.

Dobrijević: This is a significant question. It brings me back to the beginning of my journalism journey. I started at 19 and quickly developed a strong commitment to the profession. I was drawn to the dynamic nature of the work and the capacity of journalism to influence society. That sense of purpose deepened over time, strengthening my commitment to the field.

My international career began in Munich six years ago, where I worked for Serbian television. The experience expanded my professional perspective. International journalism is demanding. It requires navigating time zones, coordinating with experts across regions, and adapting to different working rhythms.

Regarding leadership, relatively few individuals pursue such roles. In large organizations, only a small fraction advance into leadership positions. The motivation, persistence, and capacity required are uncommon, and the responsibilities are significant.

I do not view leadership in conventional terms. My focus has been on addressing structural problems within journalism. Through discussions with colleagues worldwide, I identified recurring challenges: layoffs, underpaid work, and the absence of accessible publishing platforms.

A central issue is that many journalists lack a place to publish their work. As a result, valuable reporting is often lost. I began developing the idea of a platform that would provide open access for publication.

I extended this inquiry to students in Germany, the Czech Republic, and other countries. They reported similar limitations. While universities may offer internal publications, these do not reach broader audiences.

To test the concept, I conducted an experiment with a Serbian media outlet. The response was strong. Contributors included diplomats, former European Parliament members, writers, senior journalists, and editors-in-chief. This confirmed a clear demand.

The need for such a platform is not theoretical. It reflects a structural gap in contemporary journalism. Recognizing this demand led directly to the creation of ICJ and my role in its leadership.

Jacobsen: What is the broader need for journalists? What is their purpose, and how does ICJ fulfill that need?

Dobrijević: Journalists need visibility. That is central to the profession. Their work must be transparent and accessible to the public. In that sense, journalism serves as a safeguard of democracy.

ICJ is designed to support that function. It provides contributors with press cards, a publishing platform, and free educational resources. The goal is to enable journalists to produce, share, and develop their work without unnecessary barriers.

A core objective is to act as a bridge—connecting freelancers, students, and senior journalists. Many experienced journalists cover specific beats in their primary roles but lack space to publish on other topics. ICJ offers that space. It also facilitates connections between journalists and media outlets, including opportunities to sell exclusive stories.

In this way, ICJ addresses structural gaps in the profession by aligning needs with practical solutions.

Contributors receive press credentials, allowing them to attend conferences and ask questions. They gain access to a platform where they can publish their work and maintain visibility. For those in career transitions, this also supports portfolio development and professional continuity.

Beyond this, ICJ aims to build a long-term professional community. The project includes plans for a digital library, which would serve investigative journalists, policymakers, and academic institutions. There are also plans for annual awards recognizing outstanding contributors.

These initiatives are intended to address current challenges in journalism through sustained infrastructure and collaboration.

Jacobsen: What about the technological transition in journalism?

Dobrijević: Over approximately the past 15 years, journalism has shifted from print to digital formats. This is not a simple replacement but a hybrid model in which print and online formats coexist. Social media has emerged as an initial layer for rapid dissemination and commentary, though not always for verification.

In this transitional period, journalists face significant technological change. As with any industrial transformation, the tools of the profession are evolving rapidly.

What journalists need is the capacity to adapt to these developments while maintaining professional standards. This includes integrating new technologies into reporting, distribution, and verification processes.

It is clear that journalism must continue to evolve alongside technological progress.

We are now seeing social media increasingly dominate the information space, often at the expense of traditional journalism. This has contributed to a decline in public trust. Today, almost everyone has access to a camera—tools that, decades ago, were unavailable even to top filmmakers.

This creates a tension between journalism and the spread of unverified information. However, it does not need to be a conflict. Journalism can integrate these developments by adapting to technological change. The widespread availability of mobile cameras, for example, is a powerful tool when used responsibly by journalists.

Short-form reporting—such as brief videos, photo stories, or exclusive footage—can be highly effective. Journalism must remain dynamic and responsive to evolving formats.

The transition from print to digital reflects a broader transformation in the field. Adaptation is essential. I have conducted many interviews using only a mobile phone, particularly when working independently without a full production team. For example, while covering protests in Luxembourg, Berlin, and Munich, I relied on a phone to document events. Those interviewed valued the opportunity to have their voices heard and their concerns represented. This illustrates the importance of flexibility and readiness in journalism.

Jacobsen: This is analogous to computing, where tools such as cameras, notepads, and phones resemble hardware, while the “operating system” reflects the journalist’s methods and judgment. Beyond tools and technology, what new “algorithms,” so to speak, do journalists need?

Dobrijević: That is a complex question. I have recently pursued further education to remain current with developments in the field. However, when discussing tools and evolving systems, it is important not to lose sight of the core principles of journalism.

At its foundation, journalism is about identifying meaningful stories, asking high-quality questions, and presenting truthful accounts. The effectiveness of a journalist does not depend solely on advanced tools. Even with basic equipment, strong reporting and well-directed questions can produce impactful work.

Technological developments, including artificial intelligence and algorithmic systems, are becoming increasingly relevant. However, these should complement—not replace—the fundamental skills and responsibilities of journalism.

Everything can support journalists in advancing their careers. However, these remain tools. The core of journalism lies in thought, perspective, and the ability to understand different viewpoints. A journalist must think from the perspective of those being reported on—whether protesters or broader segments of society. Without this capacity and without asking the right questions, no tool can compensate for weak reporting.

At the same time, empathy must be balanced. Journalists need sufficient understanding to accurately represent issues, but excessive emotional involvement can become a burden. Exposure to distressing material—especially in conflict zones or crisis environments—can lead to burnout. Maintaining professional distance is essential for long-term sustainability.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Saša.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Humanism, Dennett, and AI: An Interview with Dr. Anthony Grayling

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Parlour News Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/05/29

Anthony Grayling CBE, MA, DPhil (Oxon) FRSL, FRSA is Master of the New College of the Humanities, and a Supernumerary Fellow of St Anne’s College, Oxford. Until 2011 he was Professor of Philosophy at Birkbeck College, University of London. He has written and edited over thirty books on philosophy and other subjects; among his most recent are “The Good Book,” “Ideas That Matter,” “Liberty in the Age of Terror,” and “To Set Prometheus Free.” For several years he wrote the “Last Word” column for the Guardian newspaper and a column for the Times. He is a frequent contributor to the Literary Review, Observer, Independent on Sunday, Times Literary Supplement, Index on Censorship and New Statesman, and is an equally frequent broadcaster on BBC Radios 4, 3 and the World Service. He writes the “Thinking Read” column for the Barnes and Noble Review in New York, is the Editor of Online Review London, and a Contributing Editor of Prospect magazine.


Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Hello, again! It has been a little over 8 years since the Conatus News interview–thanks to the link of Benjamin David, who has since moved onto another field than publishing. Obviously, we’ve had quite a few changes with the uptick in the conflict in Ukraine and a bit of the Russian Federation, and in Israel-Palestine. Elections have continued in leadership for humanists. Life keeps going. How has the United Kingdom political context been for the humanist community there, since 2016?

Dr. Anthony Grayling: The UK political context since 1916 has itself been a largely disastrous time: Brexit, an increasingly right-wing government which has assaulted civil liberties, exacerbated the economic difficulties created by Brexit, widened inequality, deepened divisions in society, and increased dissatisfaction with democracy. But from the humanist perspective there have been promising signs: safe spaces around abortion clinics, a positive change in sentiment over physician-assisted suicide, increased visibility of the debate over religion in education and bishops in the House of Lords, to name a few. These have been long-term outcomes of increasing secularism in society, and the greater purchase of humanistic ideals. The headline political issues that have dominated the media have been so vexing to many that these gains have happened without too much fanfare; an example of the unfortunate truth that chaotic conditions can be times of opportunity too.

Jacobsen: Christianity has been, and is, a rapidly diminishing demographic of the United Kingdom. How has this altered the discussions around religion, faith schools, and the necessity of humanism to step up?

Grayling: There is still a long way to go on the question of religion in education, and in one respect there has been a backward step: the fact that the religious education curriculum in schools has made humanistic alternatives less salient – but as indicated in the previous answer, the debate about this has increased in volume as a consequence of opposition to the change by humanists and other secularist organisations, benefitting from the increasing shift in public opinion, which travels in a direction contrary to what government policy has been under the Conservatives.

Jacobsen: Any thoughts on the updates to the Amsterdam Declaration in 2022?

Grayling: If you look at the various resolutions and statement emanating from humanist conferences in the two decades since 2002, e.g. in Paris, Brussels, Oxford and New Zealand, you see how evolving circumstances in the world, together with the spread of humanism as a movement from the ‘global North’ to become truly global, you see that humanism is a living, responsive outlook that applies its principles – these at base unchanging – to new challenges and circumstances. The 2022 Declaration wording addresses the way humanist principles apply to the evolving nature of the challenges, as well as to their exercise in places where humanism had not been a visible presence until recently. This is appropriate; as a living and growing movement, concerned to promote rational and progressive responses to social problems in the interest of human flourishing, humanism needs to reassert its principles periodically in terms that meet the environment it works in. The 2022 Declaration will not be the last iteration – humanism will always speak to people in the language of their time, showing how its fundamental tenets apply to that time.

Jacobsen: Daniel Dennett died recently. Any words on his personal meaning, to you, and his intellectual importance to the advancement of philosophical clarity and understanding, generally?

Grayling: Dan’s departure from among us is a great loss. The combination of his intellectual powers and personality made him a wonderful advocate for the causes he was committed to. When adjectives were applied to the more vocal atheists of recent note, among whom my friends Christopher Hitchins and Richard Dawkins appeared to their opponents as rebarbative and threatening, Dan was thought of as ‘cuddly,’ and apologists for religious outlooks found it harder, indeed impossible, to demonise him as they did the others. He was amused by the description of me as ‘the velvet atheist,’ which he rightly saw could be construed as something other than a compliment. I always enjoyed his company, which was genial as well as invariably educative; and his lectures to my students at the New College of the Humanities were a high point for them as they were to me and our other colleagues. One of the first things he said to our students was that use of the word ‘surely’ in any argument marked its weakest point. That, I’m sure, has stuck with all of them, to their benefit. His memoir I’ve Been Thinking is a marvellous read; he lives on in it.

Jacobsen: Large Language Models and similar algorithmic schema for robotic statistical generativity pose intriguing additions to the humanist philosophical reflection on the meaning of information processing and consciousness. What does humanist philosophy have to contribute to the discussion on more ergonomically interactive artificial intelligence systems in the near future?

Grayling: This is a complicated matter. The truth is that it is early days in the impact of all forms of AI on life and society, and understanding the consequences of what such innovations as Chat will be are still being groped for. It is as if a bomb has landed among us and we cannot see clearly because the smoke and dust is still flying about. Without doubt, there will be many good things as a result of this particular technological advance – and many bad things, unless we find sensible ways of managing it, few such ways being on the horizon yet. I am concerned about the impact on education, whose benefits lie largely in ‘doing the work oneself’ of finding out, analysing, drawing inferences, making rational calculations, choosing and justifying; if too much of the spadework is done by systems other than the ones inside one’s own head, that will be a serious loss. On the other hand, we could and probably will see an expansion of creative possibilities, some we can’t yet even imagine. As to consciousness: given that we still do not know what it is, how it works, and how it arises, and that the degree of its prevalence in nature beyond the higher animals is still unknown, if indeed it occurs there at all, it is hard to know what would count as securely recognising it in an AI system. What any such system could teach us about our own consciousness is made moot by that thought – though once again: who knows? In the present smoke and dust we don’t see our way clearly on any of this.

Jacobsen: When computer systems develop higher levels of autonomy, how can humanist philosophy deliver an ethical framework for making them human-friendly?

Grayling: It is already a good thought that AI systems should have built into them from the get-go a bar on doing harm to people and the environment. This assumes that such systems cannot escape any constraints placed on them by the builders of their ground architecture; since they teach and develop themselves beyond that origin there has to be a risk that a system could reach the point at which it asks itself, ‘What is the most destructive thing on the planet’ and answer, as logic would oblige it to, ‘Human beings.’ What it might do next – if it has directed itself to combat harms – might inspire a sci-fi writer to some creative ideas. But while there are humans on the planet, their ethical obligations remain just that: their ethical obligations, and no amount of machinery removes their responsibility. Humanism enjoins rationality and kindness as fundamental to how we act in every situation involving other sentient beings – indeed, the world itself. If we can infect AI so deeply with the same principle that any system would exemplify good humanist behaviour in all its activities, we will have done ourselves an immense favour.

Jacobsen: With new technologies and new political galvanizing of religiously dogmatic communities in some of the West, what does humanism need to continue to meet these challenges head-on?

Grayling: A continued persistence in presenting the arguments for, and a model of, humanism: that is the open-ended task, until the day, if ever it comes, in which people are capable, on the basis of reflection and understanding, of overriding the impulse to act on tribalism, self-interest, greed and aggression, together with a rejection of cheap and easy answers to life’s questions such as are found in superstitions and one-size-fits-all ideologies. Given that tribalism and aggression are evolved tendencies, built into the psychological DNA of human beings, it is a major task; but the fact is that most people in most ordinary situations manage to achieve it if only to a degree. Most of us do not go about impulsively hitting people we dislike or stealing whatever takes our fancy in a shop; we are capable of self-management, of educating our emotions and sensibilities, just as we are capable at times of deferring present satisfactions for greater longer-term gains on rational grounds. Humanism enjoins individuals to achieve such self-management, and enjoins society to generalise it to all human affairs. On this basis, holding the line against dogmatisms – and better still, refuting them and loosening their grip on minds and societies – and mastering rather than becoming the slaves of our technologies, remains among the chief aims of humanism.

Jacobsen: Do you have any new projects–literary, academic, or activist–that can be plugged here?

Grayling: I have a book [that came out] out in April 2025 on how to achieve peace in the culture wars that dog our times, called Discriminations, and I’m in process of writing another two. One concerns how to defend democracy against the loss of faith it is experiencing – because it does not deliver for the people, having become trapped in party-politicking; because international business lies outside its control and causes great harms, widening wealth inequalities and environmental damage; because politico-economic models such as China seem, to some, more attractive than democratic arrangements; because anti-democratic agencies such as Russia are actively undermining democracy with interference, propaganda and misinformation, empowered by social media – and I argue that democracy is hugely worth defending because the rule of law, civil liberties and human rights associated with it really matter; we take them so for granted in our democracies that we are in danger of losing them by inattention. The other is about philosophical themes in major works of literature, literature being one of the greatest resources for exploration of human nature and the human condition, rich in philosophical insight and comment accordingly; I discuss the treasures there, agreeing with some, disagreeing with others, and explaining why.

As to activism: I remain involved with efforts to promote secularism in society and education, to achieve the aims of ‘dignity in dying,’ to support human rights endeavours and efforts to mitigate climate change effects, and to reverse Brexit. Most of this is done through speaking and writing, but I get onto the streets at times.

Jacobsen: What are your favorite humanism coda quotes?

Grayling: One is the Humanist UK slogan itself: ‘Think for yourself, act for others.’ Another is Dick McMahan’s definition: ‘A humanist is someone who does the right thing even though she knows no-one is watching’. Kant’s ‘Always treat people as ends in themselves, never as means to an end’ and Hume’s ‘A wise man proportions his belief to the evidence’ provide further defining quotables. And so does Russell: ‘A good world needs knowledge, kindness and courage; it does not need the fettering of free intelligence by words uttered long ago by ignorant men.’ Between them these quotations amount to a credo, certainly for me.

Jacobsen: Thank you for the opportunity and your time, Anthony.

Grayling:  My thanks in return, Scott, and warm good wishes to you.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rabbi Simonds on Tzedakah as Justice

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Jewish Center for Justice

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/02/02

Rabbi Joel Thal Simonds on Tzedakah as Justice: Torah, Dignity, and Public Policy in Los Angeles

How does Rabbi Joel Thal Simonds frame tzedakah as justice—not optional charity—while linking Torah, dignity, and public policy through the Jewish Center for Justice?

Rabbi Joel Thal Simonds is the founding Executive Director of the Jewish Center for Justice (JCJ) in Los Angeles, advancing social-justice education, leadership development, and community-rooted action for a wide Jewish public. Ordained at Hebrew Union College–Jewish Institute of Religion, he previously served as West Coast Legislative Director for the Religious Action Center of Reform Judaism and as Associate Rabbi at University Synagogue. He has also served as Rabbi of the Synagogue at HUC-LA and is the founding President Partnership for Growth LA, a Black–Jewish community development corporation focused on cooperative development and wellbeing. He links Torah, policy, and practice. He also serves on the clergy team of the Wilshire Boulevard Temple in Los Angeles.

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen speaks with Rabbi Joel Thal Simonds, founding Executive Director of the Jewish Center for Justice in Los Angeles, about tzedakah as a binding ethic of justice rather than voluntary charity. Rabbi Joel Thal Simonds grounds the concept in tzedek and the Torah’s “justice, justice you shall pursue,” arguing that obligation must be pursued with compassion and fair process. He defines dignity as systemic change beyond temporary relief, rejects “deservingness” tests, and emphasizes confidentiality as respect. He also describes how legislation, digital giving, and lean institutions can expand participation and build durable, community-rooted solutions.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: How do you frame tzedakah as justice, not optional charity?

Rabbi Joel Thal Simonds: Tzedakah is often misunderstood as solely charity because, in modern Jewish life, it’s frequently associated with fundraising for those in need. I remember bringing my “tzedakah money” to Hebrew school each week. But the root of the word tzedakah is tzedek, which means justice. One of the Torah’s most foundational teachings comes from Deuteronomy. It says “Tzedek, tzedek tirdof,” which means justice, justice you shall pursue. This is the proof text for the Jewish commitment to justice. Tzedakah is not optional generosity; it is a moral obligation rooted in our tradition.

Jacobsen: What does dignity mean in tzedakah?

Simonds: For me, dignity means moving beyond temporary fixes. It’s not about offering a small gesture to ease discomfort while leaving the underlying system intact. True dignity comes from changing systems so that people can live without constant need or fear, and where they have a real chance at stability and opportunity.

Jacobsen: Where do you draw the boundaries between tzedakah, gemilut chasadim, and tikkun olam?

Simonds: I don’t see these as separate categories that need rigid boundaries. Rather, they are meant to be integrated into a larger vision of the world. Justice must be pursued with kindness and compassion. When we go back and read from the Torah, we are asked why tzedek is mentioned twice. The answer is that the ancient rabbis taught that we must pursue justice justly. We cannot focus solely on outcomes, but on how we get there, with care and humanity.

Jacobsen: Who is responsible for what, e.g., individual givers, congregations, federations, nonprofits, and the state?

Simonds: Everyone has a responsibility to give time and resources to help those in need. But at the Jewish Center for Justice, where I serve as Executive Director, we focus heavily on legislation and public policy because injustice and inequality are too large to be addressed by individuals and nonprofits alone. Our government, and by extension our elected leaders, have a crucial role to play in addressing systemic harm and creating lasting change.

Jacobsen: What are common power failures in communal funds?

Simonds: Any organization, whether nonprofit or for-profit, can experience power failures. As institutions grow larger, priorities can pull in different directions, decision-making can slow, and resources can become less responsive to the needs of the people they are meant to serve. This isn’t unique to Jewish communal life; it’s a challenge across the professional world.

At JCJ, we were intentionally designed to be lean, values-driven, and accountable to our community. That structure allows us to act quickly, respond to urgent moments, and ensure that resources are directed toward real impact rather than bureaucracy. Staying close to the people on the ground, from our fellows to our partners to the communities we serve, helps us guard against the kinds of power imbalances that can emerge when institutions lose sight of their purpose.

Jacobsen: How should communities balance emergency relief with long-term self-sufficiency?

Simonds: Jewish communities are often very strong at emergency response, and that is something to be proud of. We have built infrastructures that allow people to step up in moments of crisis. But too often, we move from one emergency to the next without addressing the deeper causes and systems. Issues like poverty, hunger, and homelessness are treated as isolated crises when they are actually intertwined and baked into our society. The affordability crisis, in particular, is an emergency that demands systemic solutions, not just short-term relief.

Jacobsen: How do you handle deservingness and confidentiality?

Simonds: For me, this question goes directly back to dignity. Judaism rejects the idea that people must prove they are “deserving” of care. If someone is in need, they are deserving. The moment we begin ranking worthiness, we undermine the very justice we claim to pursue.

Confidentiality is part of that same moral obligation. People in need deserve autonomy and respect, just as much as those offering support. Protecting identities isn’t about secrecy; it’s about ensuring that help does not come at the cost of shame, exposure, or loss of agency. At its best, tzedakah affirms a person’s humanity by meeting material needs and by honoring their dignity in the process.

Jacobsen: How are digital giving and public policy reshaping tzedakah?

Simonds: Digital tools and policy advocacy have expanded who gets to participate in the work of justice, and that is a good thing. What once required access, time, or proximity is now available to far more people. These tools have broadened our coalitions and allow more individuals to engage meaningfully in giving and advocacy. The work of justice is no longer limited to a few, but something many people can participate in.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Joel.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Dr. Leo Igwes Reise zur Befreiung von Mubarak Bala

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Humanistischer Verband Österreich

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/05/25

Wie konnte ein kleines Team von Humanisten staatlichen Widerstand, Verleumdungskampagnen und Rechtschaos überwinden und Nigerias am meisten verfolgten Atheisten befreien?

Dr. Leo Igwe , ein nigerianischer Menschenrechtsaktivist und Humanist, schilderte die internationalen Bemühungen um die Freilassung von Mubarak Bala, einem prominenten ehemaligen Muslim und Humanisten, der wegen angeblicher „Blasphemie“ inhaftiert wurde. Igwe beschrieb die Herausforderungen im Kampf für Balas Freilassung, darunter die Orientierung im komplexen Rechtssystem Nigerias, die Mobilisierung internationaler Organisationen wie Humanists International, Amnesty International und der UNO sowie die Bekämpfung von Desinformationskampagnen. Trotz des Widerstands der Polizei und Behörden von Kano verfolgten Igwes Rechts- und Lobbyteams einen strategischen Ansatz und nutzten diplomatischen Druck und Medienberichterstattung. Balas Strafe wurde ursprünglich zu 25 Jahren verurteilt, in der Berufung jedoch auf fünf Jahre reduziert – ein beachtlicher Erfolg angesichts der von der Scharia beeinflussten Rechtslandschaft Nigerias. Der Fall deckte auch Risse und Schwächen innerhalb der atheistisch-humanistischen Gemeinschaft auf: Opportunisten versuchten, die Situation für ihren persönlichen Vorteil auszunutzen, indem sie Desinformationen verbreiteten und Verleumdungskampagnen gegen Igwe und seine Kollegen starteten. Igwe betonte die Bedeutung institutioneller Unterstützung, glaubwürdiger Netzwerke und Verifizierungsmechanismen für zukünftige Lobbyarbeit. Abschließend dankte er den Humanisten, Rechtsteams und internationalen Partnern weltweit, die die Kampagne unerschütterlich unterstützt und dafür gesorgt haben, dass Mubarak Bala nicht vergessen und schließlich freigelassen wurde.

Hier folgt ein Interview von Scott Douglas Jacobsen und Dr. Leo Igwe, um dessen Veröffentlichung wir gebeten wurden – was wir gerne tun.

Scott ist Herausgeber von In-Sight Publishing und Chefredakteur von In-Sight: Interviews . Er schreibt für The Good Men Project , International Policy Digest, The Humanist, Basic Income Earth Network, A Further Inquiry und andere Medien. Er ist Mitglied zahlreicher Medienorganisationen.

Leo ist ein nigerianischer Menschenrechtsaktivist und Gründer der Humanist Association of Nigeria. Er ist seit 2012 Research Fellow der James Randi Educational Foundation, bekämpft die Effekte von Aberglaube und ist Teil der Skeptikerbewegung sowie im Vorstand von Humanists International. Und Redakteur beim Humanistischen Verband Österreich.


Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Wir sind wieder einmal mit Dr. Leo Igwe hier. Er ruft aus Ibadan, Nigeria, an, während ich aus einer Kleinstadt etwa zweieinhalb Stunden östlich von Vancouver im äußersten Westen Kanadas anrufe. Es ist kalt hier, also sitze ich am Kamin. Weiter geht’s – eine Einleitung ist nicht nötig. Wie informieren Sie die internationale Gemeinschaft über Fälle wie Mubarak Bala und andere?

Dr. Leo Igwe: Wir sind hier eine kleine Organisation, obwohl es hier viele nichtreligiöse und religiös gleichgültige Menschen gibt. Der Fall Mubarak Bala war recht ungewöhnlich, da er unsere Kapazitäten überstieg.

Wenige Tage vor seiner Verhaftung erfuhr ich, dass er von verschiedenen Personen, die sich durch seine Facebook-Posts beleidigt fühlten, Drohungen erhielt. Ich rief ihn an und wir besprachen die Situation. Er sagte mir, er werde versuchen, die Drohungen zu neutralisieren, und ich schlug ihm vor, die Sache der Polizei zu melden. Er meinte jedoch, das würde die Situation nur verschlimmern, da die Polizei sich auf die Seite derjenigen stellen würde, die ihn bedrohten.

Das war das letzte Gespräch zu diesem Thema. Zwei oder drei Tage später erhielt ich einen Anruf, in dem mir mitgeteilt wurde, dass die Polizei ihn in Gewahrsam genommen hatte und wir alles tun müssten, um seine Freilassung oder zumindest seine Sicherheit zu gewährleisten. Ehrlich gesagt war ich völlig verwirrt und verzweifelt.

Ich begann sofort verzweifelt die Polizei in Kaduna anzurufen, wo er lebte. Ich erinnere mich an ein Gespräch mit dem Polizeipräsidenten, der sagte, der Fall sei nicht ihr Fall. Er erklärte, die Polizei von Kano habe seine Verhaftung angeordnet und werde ihn dorthin bringen.

Wir waren zutiefst besorgt, dass seine Verlegung nach Kano bedeuten könnte, dass wir ihn nie wiedersehen würden. Ich versuchte, die Station zu erreichen, wo er festgehalten wurde, und konnte ein paar Sekunden mit ihm sprechen, bevor ihm das Telefon abgenommen wurde. Das war das letzte Mal, dass wir für Monate miteinander sprachen.

Nach seiner Überstellung riefen wir die Polizei in Kano an, doch sie behaupteten, sie hätten keine Informationen. Als wir die Polizei in Kaduna kontaktierten, teilten sie uns mit, sie hätten ihn bereits den Behörden in Kano übergeben. So führten sie uns immer wieder in die Irre und schoben die Verantwortung von einer Stelle zur anderen.

In diesem Moment wurde mir klar, dass ich die Situation nicht mehr kontrollieren konnte. Ich beschloss, die internationale Gemeinschaft zu informieren. Ich schickte eine Nachricht an Humanists International und kontaktierte alle meine Kontakte – Atheisten, Freidenker und Menschenrechtsaktivisten. Ich erklärte ihnen die Situation und forderte sie zum Handeln auf.

Ich hatte das Gefühl, wenn sie ihn ungestraft verschwinden lassen könnten, wäre das ein verheerender Schlag für unsere Bemühungen, die humanistische Gemeinschaft zu stärken. Ich tat alles, um sicherzustellen, dass ihm nichts passierte. Wir waren zutiefst besorgt, dass er verschwinden könnte, wie es vielen anderen in ähnlichen Situationen passiert ist. Oftmals verschwinden Menschen, die wegen „Blasphemie“ verhaftet werden, und man hört nie wieder von ihnen.

Ich war verzweifelt, nicht nur um seine Sicherheit, sondern auch um die Zukunft unserer Bewegung. Sofort kontaktierte ich meinen Anwalt, einen Humanisten, der eng mit uns zusammengearbeitet hat. Ich sagte ihm: „Wir sind in ernsten Schwierigkeiten.“ Was geschah dann?

Es war während des Lockdowns, und die Bewegungsfreiheit war stark eingeschränkt. Alle mussten in ihren Häusern bleiben, und die Menschen konnten sich kaum innerhalb ihrer Gemeinden bewegen. Es gab keine zwischenstaatlichen Bewegungsfreiheiten – man konnte nicht von einem Bundesstaat in einen anderen reisen.

Also mussten wir Kontakte und Anwälte in verschiedenen Bundesstaaten – Kaduna, Kano und Abuja – gewinnen. Wir bemühten uns, diese Kontakte zu nutzen, um Druck auf die Behörden auszuüben. Glücklicherweise konnten wir innerhalb weniger Tage ein sogenanntes Anwaltsteam zusammenstellen.

Ja, aber ich wusste, dass es sich nicht um ein juristisches Problem handelte. Blasphemiefälle sind eher politisch als juristisch relevant. Deshalb habe ich auch NGOs und andere Organisationen kontaktiert. Ich habe Amnesty International und Human Rights Watch geschrieben.

Ich kontaktierte verschiedene Botschaften, insbesondere die der EU, der USA und des Vereinigten Königreichs, und schrieb ihnen Nachrichten. Von Humanists International erhielt ich jedoch eine außergewöhnliche Resonanz und Unterstützung.

Und das muss ich Ihnen sagen – nicht, weil ich Vorstandsmitglied bin, sondern weil ich über 20 Jahre Erfahrung in der Arbeit und Navigation auf diesem riskanten Terrain habe.

Ich sagte also, dass Humanists International sofort reagierte, die Ereignisse öffentlich machte und uns unterstützte. Die unmittelbare Frage war: „Was brauchen Sie?“

Wir sagten ihnen, dass wir ein Anwaltsteam einsetzen und unsere Plattform nutzen müssten, um für seine Sache einzutreten und Lärm zu machen, denn genau das wollten die Leute, die ihn verhaftet hatten, nicht. Sie wollten ihn zum Schweigen bringen und alles über ihn zum Schweigen bringen, damit sie über sein Schicksal entscheiden konnten.

Was sie nicht wollten und auch nicht gewollt hätten, war, dass jemand über ihn sprach, Lärm machte oder auf den Fall aufmerksam machte. Mit der Unterstützung von Humanists International konnten wir genau das tun. Der Fall wurde weltweit bekannt, und viele Organisationen, darunter die UN und internationale NGOs, engagierten sich. Auch Botschaften wurden aktiv – sie riefen uns täglich an und erkundigten sich bei uns, um den Fortschritt zu verfolgen.

Jacobsen: Sie kontaktieren also die UN und Human Rights Watch und schicken Briefe und E-Mails an Amnesty International. Sie nutzen auch Ressourcen wie einen humanistischen Anwalt, mit dem Sie bereits zusammengearbeitet haben und der Sie und die Komplexität der Situation versteht.

Welche Strategien haben funktioniert? Welche nicht? Für jemanden, der dies ohne Kontext liest, könnte es so aussehen, als hättest du jedes mögliche Unterstützungssystem überrannt. Aber es steckte Methode dahinter, auch wenn du im Notfallmodus im Grunde genommen in Panik geraten bist.

Igwe: Ja. Die Idee, die Nachricht weltweit zu verbreiten und die internationale Gemeinschaft einzubeziehen, funktionierte – sie trug dazu bei, Druck auf die Behörden auszuüben.

Aber nicht alles ist uns gelungen. Zunächst wollten wir verhindern, dass er nach Kano gebracht wird, und das ist uns nicht gelungen. Als wir die Polizei einschalten konnten und sie zum Handeln bereit war, war er bereits nach Kano überstellt worden.

Wir versuchten auch, die Polizei von Kano dazu zu bewegen, uns mitzuteilen, wo er festgehalten wurde. Doch unsere Anfragen wurden mit Schweigen beantwortet und abgewiesen.

Unsere Bemühungen, sein Verschwinden zu verhindern, scheiterten sofort, da die Polizei und die Regierung in Kano auf unsere Anfragen nicht reagierten.

Sie haben sich nicht um uns gekümmert. Sie haben uns weitgehend ignoriert, und ich möchte betonen, dass sie die Welt lange Zeit ignoriert haben.

Trotz des Drucks der EU, der US-Botschaften und anderer diplomatischer Bemühungen hielten sie ihn sechs Monate lang fest, bevor sie offiziell seine Gefangenschaft anerkannten. Es war also nicht so, dass wir alle diese Behörden mobilisiert hätten und sie sofort seine Freilassung erwirkt hätten. Nein, es dauerte über vier Jahre, bis er endlich frei war.

Viele unserer Druckausübungen stießen auf Widerstand oder wurden ignoriert. Wir ließen jedoch nicht locker und nutzten die Unterstützung internationaler Organisationen, des UN-Büros und des UN-Sonderberichterstatters für Religionsfreiheit. Durch sie erfuhren wir Monate später, dass er noch lebte. Wir fanden heraus, dass er in einer Privatzelle in Kano festgehalten wurde.

Sogar die EU-Botschaften trugen dazu bei, sein Leben zu bestätigen. Sie teilten uns mit, dass er nicht getötet, sondern weiterhin inhaftiert sei. Es dauerte eine ganze Weile, bis unsere Bemühungen erste Erfolge zeigten, vor allem in der Bestätigung seiner Sicherheit. Schließlich kamen die Behörden den Forderungen nach, ihn freizulassen oder vor Gericht zu stellen, wie es das Gesetz vorschreibt.

Jacobsen: Wie hat die globale Reaktion die Lobbyarbeit beeinflusst? Sie haben das kurz angesprochen. Mich interessieren besonders Fälle, in denen es zu einer völligen Blockade kam – wo keine Fortschritte erzielt werden konnten. Gab es Fälle, in denen Menschen zuhörten und zu helfen versuchten, aber es war zu spät, oder sie wurden aufgrund fehlender Ressourcen oder dringlicherer Fälle blockiert? Was Einzelpersonen betrifft, so weiß ich, dass der prominente und hoch angesehene Literaturwissenschaftler Wole Soyinka zu diesem Fall Stellung genommen hat. Welche Rolle spielten diese Personen?

Igwe: Ja.

Zu Beginn mobilisierten wir alles, was wir konnten. Wir schickten Briefe an Organisationen, Einzelpersonen und prominente nigerianische Politiker. Wir kontaktierten ehemalige Präsidenten und forderten sie auf, Druck auf die Regierung auszuüben und sie zu seiner Freilassung zu bewegen.

Wole Soyinka und andere angesehene Persönlichkeiten engagierten sich. Ziel dieser Bemühungen war es, prominente, freimütige und angesehene Personen zu mobilisieren, um Druck auf die Behörden in Kano und die Bundesregierung auszuüben und ihn freizulassen bzw. seine Sicherheit zu gewährleisten. Doch dies nahm enorm viel Zeit in Anspruch.

Dies geschah nicht automatisch. Es zeigt, wie stark das Establishment hinter seiner Verhaftung war und wie wenig bereit es war, nachzugeben oder dem internationalen Druck nachzugeben.

Von Anfang an standen wir vor großen Herausforderungen. Eine der größten Schwierigkeiten bestand darin, den Widerstand der Behörden zu überwinden, die entschlossen waren, jegliche Intervention von außen zu unterdrücken.

Außerdem kannte ich Mubarak Bala nicht besonders gut. Wir leben im selben Land, aber ich studierte damals im Ausland. 2017 kehrte ich zurück. Im Ausland erfuhr ich von seiner Entscheidung, sich als Ex-Muslim zu outen, und wir trafen uns nur ein- oder zweimal. Ich kannte ihn also als Ex-Muslim, und das war’s.

Manche vergessen, dass wir uns selbst innerhalb der säkularen und humanistischen Gemeinschaft nicht immer gut kennen. Nach seiner Verhaftung war es eine weitere Herausforderung, die richtigen Ansprechpartner zu finden. In manchen islamischen Gemeinschaften gibt es das Konzept Taqiyya , das religiöse Verstellung oder Verschleierung bezeichnet. Einige Personen wurden verdächtigt, sich als Atheisten ausgegeben zu haben, um säkulare Netzwerke zu infiltrieren und Informationen an religiöse Autoritäten weiterzugeben.

Es gab die Befürchtung, dass einige der Taqiyya- Anhänger Mubaraks Netzwerk infiltriert, Informationen gesammelt und ihn den Behörden gemeldet hatten. Dies erschwerte die Situation zusätzlich, da wir zu dieser Zeit aufgrund der Pandemie unter Quarantäne standen. Wir waren ausschließlich auf Telefonanrufe, E-Mails und Facebook-Nachrichten angewiesen, um unsere Bemühungen zu koordinieren. Dennoch hatten wir keine Möglichkeit, zu überprüfen, wer vertrauenswürdig war.

Da es darum ging, ein Leben zu retten und sicherzustellen, dass Mubarak nichts zustößt, waren wir bereit, mit jedem zusammenzuarbeiten, der helfen konnte. Allerdings war es in einem so sensiblen Fall wie „Blasphemie“ äußerst schwierig zu wissen, wem man vertrauen konnte.

Jacobsen: Welches waren die wichtigsten Schritte, um das Rechtsteam mit dem Anwaltsteam zusammenzubringen, damit das Anwaltsteam das Rechtsteam über die kritischen Punkte des Falles informieren und das Rechtsteam anschließend eine Argumentation zur Verteidigung Mubaraks entwickeln konnte?

Igwe: Ja. Das war eine weitere wichtige Aufgabe, vor der wir damals standen.

Der Aufbau der Rechts- und Anwaltsteams erfolgte ganz natürlich – langsam und stetig –, da wir äußerst vorsichtig vorgehen mussten. Zuallererst mussten wir Anwälte finden, denen wir vertrauen konnten. Das wurde später von vielen kritisiert. Manche behaupteten: „Oh, ihr habt eure Freunde engagiert.“ Aber in einer solchen Situation kann man keine Leute engagieren, über die man wenig weiß. Man kann keine Stellenanzeige schalten und fragen: „Wer möchte einen Blasphemiefall übernehmen? “ In Nigeria ist Blasphemie ein hochsensibles Thema, und viele Anwälte scheuen sich aus Angst davor, es anzusprechen.

Also mussten wir Anwälte finden, auf die wir uns verlassen konnten. Ich kontaktierte die Anwälte unseres humanistischen Netzwerks – Leute, die bereits mit uns zusammenarbeiteten. Wir knüpften Kontakte zu James Ibor, einem Anwalt, der sich bereits für Menschenrechte engagierte. Wir beauftragten ihn, weitere vertrauenswürdige Anwälte zu finden, um ein solides Anwaltsteam aufzubauen. Es war ein Schneeballsystem , bei dem ein vertrauenswürdiger Kontakt zum nächsten führte.

Dasselbe Prinzip galt für das Advocacy-Team. Wir mussten mit Organisationen und Behörden zusammenarbeiten, von denen wir wussten, dass sie unsere Sache wirklich unterstützten. Andernfalls bestand immer das Risiko, Informationen an jemanden weiterzugeben, der sie an die Gegenseite weiterleitete. Vertrauen war entscheidend für die Zusammenarbeit zwischen den Rechts- und Advocacy-Teams. Dieses Vertrauen war auch der Grund dafür, dass wir den Fall zusammenhalten und in unserer Mission, Mubaraks Freilassung zu erreichen, vereint bleiben konnten, selbst als später merkwürdige Entwicklungen ans Licht kamen.

Natürlich wollten sich mit zunehmender Bekanntheit des Falls auch mehr Menschen engagieren. Irgendwann wollten zahlreiche Organisationen die Verantwortung für diesen inzwischen viel beachteten Fall übernehmen. Das führte zu zusätzlichen Herausforderungen, denn sobald der Fall in den sozialen Medien weithin bekannt wurde, begannen verschiedene Gruppen, sich dazu zu äußern.

Dann geschah etwas anderes. Anwälte, die ich nie zuvor getroffen hatte, meldeten sich und sagten: „Wir haben Erfahrung mit solchen Fällen. Wir wollen Mubaraks Verteidigung übernehmen.“ Meine Antwort war: Welchen Fall übernehmen? Ich kannte diese Anwälte nicht – ich hatte sie nie getroffen, ich kannte ihre Glaubwürdigkeit nicht und ich hatte keine Ahnung, ob manche von ihnen auf die Gegenseite geschickt worden waren, um unsere Bemühungen zu vereiteln.

Ich lehnte ihre Beteiligung entschieden ab. Einige von ihnen revanchierten sich, indem sie mich online erpressten, meine Entscheidungen angriffen und behaupteten, Mubarak sei nicht freigelassen worden, weil ich „inkompetente“ Anwälte engagiert hätte. Anstatt zu erkennen, dass wir es mit einem tief verwurzelten und fanatischen Dschihad-System zu tun hatten, versuchten sie, uns die Schuld zuzuschieben.

Diese Personen waren nicht wirklich an dem Fall interessiert; sie sahen darin eine Gelegenheit, sich in einen prominenten Fall einzumischen . Sie wollten auf der Welle der Aufmerksamkeit reiten, die der Fall erregte. Ich sage das, weil es in Nigeria bereits andere Fälle von „Blasphemie“ gab, wie etwa die von Deborah Samuel und Elijah the Barber, und dieselben Anwälte zeigten kein Interesse an diesen Fällen. Doch plötzlich wollten sie Mubaraks Verteidigung vom Rechtsberater des Teams übernehmen.

Dasselbe geschah mit den Lobbybemühungen. Viele Organisationen wollten sich plötzlich engagieren.

In dieser Zeit gründete jemand die Stiftung für Religionsfreiheit. Ein anderer gründete aus dem Nichts eine humanistische Organisation. Ich hatte ihn vorher nie getroffen, aber er behauptete, auch sie seien an der Kampagne interessiert. Plötzlich engagierten sich Leute für die Freilassung Mubaraks, und ich fragte: „Wo wart ihr die ganze Zeit?“

Dann nahmen die Dinge eine andere Wendung. Einige dieser Gruppen begannen, Anschuldigungen zu verbreiten. Sie behaupteten, wir würden Geld sammeln, es aber für uns selbst verwenden, anstatt Mubarak zu helfen, der im Gefängnis saß. Dies führte zu einer Verleumdungskampagne, die tief verletzte. Manche versuchten sogar, Humanists International (HI) zu diskreditieren. Ein Online-Kontakt ging sogar so weit, anzukündigen, HI vor Gericht zu bringen.

Jacobsen: Ja, das ist so dumm. Es fühlt sich an, als ob es sogar funktionieren könnte.

Igwe: Sie machten willkürliche, leichtfertige Aussagen über HI und den Umgang mit dem Fall. Am frustrierendsten war jedoch, dass sie nicht bereit waren, die dschihadistischen Ansichten und den religiösen Extremismus, die im Mittelpunkt des Falles standen, anzusprechen.

Anstatt sich auf das eigentliche Problem zu konzentrieren – den religiösen Fundamentalismus, der zu Mubaraks Verhaftung führte –, begannen sie, uns Verteidiger anzugreifen. Plötzlich wurden wir zur Zielscheibe von Anschuldigungen, weil wir eine starke Verteidigung aufgebaut und dem Fall größere Aufmerksamkeit geschenkt hatten.

Sie taten so, als ob das gesammelte Geld direkt an Mubarak gehen sollte, als ob wir in seine Gefängniszelle gehen und ihm Geld in die Tasche stecken könnten. Doch Lobbyarbeit erfordert Lobbyarbeit, Reisen und Treffen mit wichtigen Interessenvertretern. So haben wir Schwung gewonnen.

Humanists International hat eine fantastische Kampagne durchgeführt. Betrachtet man ihre Arbeit heute, ist ihr Einsatz in Blasphemiefällen beispiellos. Unser Umgang mit Mubaraks Fall setzte neue Maßstäbe. Ich habe die Gelegenheit auch genutzt, um das Bewusstsein zu schärfen und eine klare Botschaft zu senden: Tut so etwas nicht noch einmal.

Trotz unserer Bemühungen versuchten einige immer noch, uns zu untergraben.

Sie gingen davon aus, dass wir nicht über die Ressourcen verfügten, um eine überzeugende Rechtsverteidigung aufzubauen oder eine wirksame Interessenvertretung zu betreiben. Doch wir haben sie überrascht.

Sobald sie das Ausmaß unserer Bemühungen erkannten, begannen sie mit der Erpressung. Sie sagten: „Oh, das haben wir nicht verstanden – Sie haben das Geld, um einen Anwalt und ein ganzes Anwaltsteam zu engagieren. Sie haben die Mittel, den Fall an die UN weiterzuleiten. Sie haben die Ressourcen und den Einfluss.“ Als ihnen das klar wurde, tauchten aus dem Nichts Opportunisten auf und versuchten, sich in den Fall einzumischen.

Ich sagte ihnen: „Sehen Sie, es gibt noch andere Blasphemie-Fälle. Es gibt andere Menschen in Not – warum übernehmen Sie nicht einen dieser Fälle?“ Aber sie waren nicht interessiert. Sie wollten sich unserem Fall anschließen, der internationale Aufmerksamkeit erregt hatte. Trotz dieses Drucks blieb Humanists International standhaft. Langsam, aber stetig gelang es uns, diese Ablenkungen abzuwehren und schließlich Mubaraks Freilassung zu erreichen.

Ich möchte jedoch auch einen wichtigen Punkt hervorheben: Einige der Leute, die die Hetzkampagnen gegen Humanists International und mich führten, waren dieselben, die sich privat an mich gewandt und mir angeblich Hilfe angeboten hatten. Einer von ihnen war ein Anwalt aus Großbritannien. Er kontaktierte mich und sagte: „Ich bin in Großbritannien. Ich kann zum Büro von Humanists UK gehen und ihnen alles erzählen, was ich will. Ich kann sie dazu bringen, Maßnahmen zu ergreifen, um Mubaraks Freilassung zu erwirken.“

Ich antwortete: „Wer sind Sie?“ Er stellte sich vor, und ich sagte ihm: „Wenn Sie helfen wollen, arbeiten Sie mit dem bestehenden Rechtsteam zusammen.“ Aber er lehnte ab. Er schwankte ständig hin und her, ohne sich jemals zu etwas Produktivem zu verpflichten. Stattdessen begann er online Propaganda zu verbreiten und eine Verleumdungskampagne anzuheizen.

Was mich am meisten frustrierte, war, dass einige Atheisten/Humanisten in Großbritannien dieser Propaganda Glauben schenkten. Diese Leute hatten meine Kontaktdaten. Ich war rund um die Uhr erreichbar – auch in diesen Momenten, sogar jetzt. Sie hätten mich oder das HI-Büro kontaktieren können, aber stattdessen verbreiteten sie falsche Geschichten.

Es wurde klar, dass ihr Ziel nicht darin bestand, mir zu helfen, sondern mich zu diskreditieren, meine Arbeit zu verunglimpfen und alles, was wir taten, zu untergraben. Da verlor ich die Geduld.

Als ich merkte, dass es in Großbritannien Menschen gab, die sich Humanisten oder Atheisten nannten, aber dennoch auf diese Propaganda hereinfielen, war ich zutiefst enttäuscht. Diese Leute hatten meine E-Mail-Adresse. Ich war rund um die Uhr erreichbar – ich war in diesen kritischen Momenten erreichbar gewesen, und selbst jetzt konnten sie mich noch erreichen.

Sie hätten auch das HI-Büro kontaktieren können, doch stattdessen verbreiteten sie Falschinformationen. Es schien, als suchten sie nach einer Gelegenheit, meine Arbeit zu diskreditieren – mich zu verleumden, zu diffamieren und alles, was ich tat, zu untergraben. Das war meine größte Enttäuschung. Diese Leute wussten wenig bis gar nichts über die Situation und verstanden die Komplexität, mit der wir es zu tun hatten, nicht. Trotzdem schrieben sie online Petitionen gegen mich.

Das hat mich wirklich verletzt. Ich fühlte mich zutiefst enttäuscht. Aber Humanists International hat die Situation natürlich professionell gehandhabt, und das hat uns nicht davon abgehalten, unsere Arbeit fortzusetzen.

Ich möchte noch hinzufügen, dass eine der an dieser Hetzkampagne beteiligten Personen eine Frau war, die, nachdem wir große internationale Unterstützung für Mubaraks Fall generiert hatten, plötzlich behauptete, auch sie sei der „Blasphemie“ beschuldigt worden. Sie sagte, sie müsse ins Ausland umziehen.

Ich verstehe, dass Einwanderungsfragen in Europa ein heikles Thema sind. Wir müssen diese Überlegungen jedoch auch mit unserer Realität abwägen. Sie wandte sich an verschiedene Gruppen in Europa und den USA, um Hilfe zu erhalten. Sie versuchte, ihre Ziele zu verfolgen, indem sie die Fälle Mubarak und Deborah Samuel als Instrument nutzte. Dieser Fall war für uns komplex. Wir baten sie um Beweise für die Anschuldigung, aber sie konnte ihre Behauptung nicht belegen. Sie gab an, dass die Polizei nach ihr suchte. Ich fragte: „Welche Polizeidienststelle?“ In Nigeria sind die Beamten bestimmten Stationen zugeteilt, die einer bestimmten Struktur folgen.

Dann verschickte sie eine alarmierende Nachricht und behauptete, die Polizei habe ihr Haus umstellt. Besorgt versuchten wir, sie anzurufen, aber sie ging nicht ran. Später schickte sie uns einen Kostenvoranschlag und teilte mit, sie brauche finanzielle Unterstützung für ihren Umzug vom Bundesstaat Borno – wo Boko-Haram-Kämpfer aktiv waren – in die Hauptstadt Abuja.

Sie verlangte zunächst 2.000 Dollar und erhöhte ihre Forderung dann auf 4.000 Dollar. Ich fragte: „4.000 Dollar wofür?“ Sie behauptete, sie brauche Polizeischutz und eine Sicherheitsüberprüfung als Teil ihres Budgets. Das kam mir sofort verdächtig vor.

Ich sagte ihr: „Die Polizei sucht angeblich nach Ihnen. Sie wollen Sie verhaften. Sie behaupten, Sie seien der Blasphemie beschuldigt, und jetzt wollen Sie einen Teil dieses Budgets für Polizeischutz und die Genehmigung zur Reise von Borno nach Abuja verwenden?“ Das war völlig widersprüchlich und ergab für mich keinen Sinn.

An diesem Punkt wies ich ihren Fall ab. Es wurde klar, dass einige Opportunisten versuchten, die Situation auszunutzen. Während wir darum kämpften, jemanden freizulassen, der eingesperrt und verschwunden war, gab es andere – völlig frei –, die versuchten, den Fall zu ihrem Vorteil auszunutzen.

Sie ging online. Als sie merkte, dass ich ihre Behauptung missbilligte, startete sie eine Hetzkampagne gegen Humanists International und mich. Schockierenderweise schlossen sich ihr einige „Humanisten und Atheisten“ an und griffen uns an.

Und diese Leute waren entweder meine Facebook-Freunde, Leute, die mich kannten, mich getroffen hatten oder mich leicht hätten erreichen können. Doch sie haben mich nie kontaktiert. Stattdessen beteiligten sie sich an der Hetzkampagne, ohne zu verstehen, was vor sich ging.

Wir versuchen immer, solche Situationen zu meistern, aber diese Erfahrung hat mir gezeigt, dass jeder in solche Angriffe verwickelt werden kann. In solchen Fällen, wenn es um ein so sensibles Thema geht, sollte man, wenn man jemanden gut kennt und zur Community gehört, Kontakt aufnehmen. Einige Leute haben das getan. Sie schrieben mir eine Nachricht und fragten: „Hey, was ist los?“

Als Antwort darauf würde ich ihnen die Korrespondenz mit der Frau weiterleiten, in der sie behauptet, sie sei der „Blasphemie“ beschuldigt worden. Das allein würde die Angelegenheit klären. Als einige dieser Leute sie direkt damit konfrontierten, änderte sie ihre Haltung. Sie sagte: „Dies ist ein sensibler Fall, bei dem es um vertrauliche Informationen geht.“

Ich habe es ihr gesagt. Es war nicht geheim. Sie haben Humanists International und mich persönlich online angegriffen. Sie haben uns um eine Verlegung und Finanzierung gebeten, konnten Ihre Argumente aber nicht belegen. Was genau ist das?

Wir werden bei unserem Bestreben, zu wachsen und hochkarätige Kampagnen durchzuführen, immer wieder vor Herausforderungen stehen. Deshalb brauchen wir Mechanismen, um solche Probleme zu bewältigen und zu verhindern, dass Opportunisten uns ablenken oder unsere Bemühungen behindern.

Jacobsen: Ja, genau. Das ist es.

Man sollte verstehen, dass ich im Laufe der Jahre viele Humanisten interviewt habe. Ehrlich gesagt mag es manche überraschen, aber Betrüger gibt es nicht so viele. Einige behaupten vielleicht, den Titel zu beanspruchen und zu betrügen. Trotzdem engagieren sie sich meist nicht aktiv in der Community.

Meistens agieren sie als Einzelperson und sind nicht in humanistische Netzwerke eingebunden. Was tatsächlich erfolgreiche Betrüger betrifft, fällt mir spontan nur ein Fall ein. Diese Person wurde schnell entlarvt, verurteilt und verschwand praktisch aus dem humanistischen Aktivismus, den Medien und der Diskussion.

Was Sie beschreiben, klingt wie ein Spiegelbild breiterer gesellschaftlicher Trends, die sich auch in der humanistischen Bewegung durchsetzen. Opportunismus ist in der allgemeinen Kultur typisch, doch im internationalen Humanismus findet man selten echte Betrüger – geschweige denn erfolgreiche. Zumindest ist mir das in Gesprächen mit Humanisten weltweit aufgefallen.

Gut, fahren wir mit der nächsten Frage fort.

Wie läuft das Verfahren zur Einreichung von Petitionen bei der Polizei und den Gerichten in Nigeria ab? Gibt es Unterschiede zwischen Kaduna, Kano, Abuja und Ibadan oder ist es im ganzen Land weitgehend gleich?

Igwe: Das Verfahren ist bei Fällen wie „Blasphemie“ grundsätzlich dasselbe. In sensiblen Situationen wie diesen müssen wir jedoch immer vorsichtig sein. „Wo reicht man die Petition ein? Wer reicht sie ein?“

Die Sicherheit der Kläger ist uns ein großes Anliegen. Daher mussten wir sorgfältig entscheiden, wo wir Klagen bei der Polizei einreichen oder vor Gericht bringen. Wir entschieden uns für die Hauptstadt Abuja, weil der islamistische und dschihadistische Einfluss dort deutlich schwächer ist als in Kano. Die Verlegung des Falles von Kano weg war eine strategische Entscheidung.

Natürlich gab es Kritik an diesem Ansatz. Unsere Argumentation war jedoch klar: Sollten wir gegen sie vorgehen, würden wir dies nicht dort tun, wo sie über erhebliche Macht und Einfluss verfügen. Stattdessen brachten wir den Fall vor ein Gericht, wo staatliche und internationale Institutionen Unterstützung leisten konnten. Deshalb ist es in solchen Fällen immer ratsam, dort Klage einzureichen, wo extremistische Gruppen weniger Kontrolle haben.

Aus diesem Grund wurde einer der Fälle, die wir eingereicht haben, in Abuja und nicht in Kano eingereicht.

Jacobsen: Gab es Schwierigkeiten bei der Verlegung des Falls von Kano nach Abuja?

Igwe: Ja.

In Abuja Klage einzureichen, war nicht schwierig. Die Behörden in Kano dazu zu bringen, das Urteil zu akzeptieren, war jedoch eine ganz andere Herausforderung. Ein Gericht in Abuja konnte zwar ein Urteil fällen, die Vollstreckung dieses Urteils erforderte jedoch zusätzlichen Aufwand.

Hier setzten wir diplomatischen Druck ein. Wir sprachen mit Diplomaten und den Vereinten Nationen, um die Durchsetzung des Urteils zu fordern, das besagte, dass er entweder vor Gericht gestellt oder freigelassen werden sollte. Das war ein zentrales Ergebnis des Abuja-Urteils.

Nach seiner Verurteilung kam eine weitere große Herausforderung: die Verlegung von Kano ins Gefängnis von Abuja. Dafür waren überzeugende Argumente nötig, denn seine Verlegung nach Abuja kam ihm in vielerlei Hinsicht so vor, als würde man ihn auf halbem Weg gehen lassen.

In Kano hatten die Behörden die volle Kontrolle über ihn. Sie konnten ihn vor Gericht behandeln, wie sie wollten, ohne Einmischung von außen. Nach seiner Überstellung nach Abuja änderte sich seine Situation jedoch grundlegend. Er erhielt Zugang zu einem Telefon, WhatsApp und anderen Kommunikationsmitteln, die ihm in Kano letztlich verwehrt geblieben waren.

Es war ein langer Prozess, aber wir haben uns bemüht, die Nationale Menschenrechtskommission und andere befreundete Organisationen einzubeziehen, die uns dabei helfen, einen reibungslosen und sicheren Transfer vom Gefängnis Kano ins Gefängnis Abuja zu gewährleisten.

Seine Verlegung nach Abuja war das erste echte Zeichen für seine mögliche Freilassung. Nachdem wir ihn erfolgreich aus Kano herausgebracht hatten, sahen wir eine echte Chance auf seine Freilassung.

Obwohl der Prozess äußerst schwierig war, waren wir auf diplomatische Kanäle und internationale Unterstützung angewiesen, um ihn zu verwirklichen.

Jacobsen: Wir haben verschiedene Arten von Verschwinden erlebt – je nach Fall sowohl echte als auch vorgetäuschte. In manchen Fällen gibt es überhaupt kein Verschwinden.

Nehmen wir zum Beispiel den Fall von Gaspár Bekes. Sein Berufs- und Privatleben ist beeinträchtigt, aber meines Wissens nach benötigt er keinen Schutz. Das stellt eine Form humanistischer Verfolgung dar, bei der der Betroffene zwar Schwierigkeiten hat, aber relativ sicher bleibt.

Kommen wir nun von Westeuropa zu einem indischen Fall: Narendra Nayak, der Schutz benötigt (derzeit abgeschoben). Sein Fall beinhaltet jedoch kein vorgetäuschtes Verschwinden – sein Leben ist in Gefahr, er ist aber weiterhin sichtbar.

Dann gibt es Fälle wie den von Gulalai Ismail, wo eine Person aus Sicherheitsgründen untertaucht. In ihrem Fall wurde ihre gesamte Familie verfolgt – ihr Vater Mohammad Ismail, ihre Schwester Saba und Gulalai selbst. Anfangs wusste niemand, wo sie war. Nur wenige wussten, was passiert war; Monate später tauchte sie in New York wieder auf. Die New York Times berichtete schließlich mehrfach über sie.

Dabei handelt es sich um ein „vorgetäuschtes Verschwinden“, d. h. die Person wird aus Sicherheitsgründen versteckt und nicht gewaltsam vom Staat verschwinden gelassen. Schließlich taucht sie an einem sicheren Ort wieder auf.

Dann gibt es Fälle echten Verschwindens, bei denen die Menschen nicht aus Sicherheitsgründen verschwinden, sondern aufgrund direkter Verfolgung durch staatliche oder gesellschaftliche Kräfte – wie etwa Mubarak Bala.

Betrachten wir dies als gleitende Skala. Wir beginnen mit Fällen wie Gaspár Bekes, die zwar berufliche und soziale Auswirkungen haben, aber keine physische Gefahr darstellen. Dann kommen wir zu Fällen wie Narendra Nayak, bei denen zwar ein Sicherheitsrisiko besteht, aber kein Verschwinden vorliegt. Dann kommen wir zu Fällen wie Gulalai Ismail, bei dem es um ein strategisches Verschwinden aus Sicherheitsgründen geht. Schließlich haben wir Mubarak Bala, dessen Verfolgung so schwerwiegend war, dass er jahrelang inhaftiert wurde.

Lassen Sie mich nun zu meiner Frage kommen.

Welche Maßnahmen wurden ergriffen, um Mubaraks Leben nach seinem Verschwinden zu bestätigen? Das interessiert mich. Viele Menschen waren daran beteiligt. Sie waren direkt involviert und haben aktiver gearbeitet als ich. Was wurde unternommen, um seinen Status zu klären?

Igwe: Das ist eine interessante Frage.

Wie ich schon sagte, wir haben alles getan, was wir konnten. Und wenn ich alles sage, meine ich, dass ich jeden Tag aufwachte und mich fragte:

„Haben wir mit Herrn X gesprochen?“

„Haben wir Professor Y kontaktiert?“

„Haben wir Z eine E-Mail geschickt?“

Wir riefen Botschaften an, nahmen Kontakt zu Diplomaten auf und klopften an jede mögliche Tür und fragten: „Hey, was macht ihr? Könnt ihr uns helfen, festzustellen, ob Mubarak noch lebt?“

Dieser Mann war verschwunden.

Wir haben sogar Anzeigen in überregionalen Zeitungen geschaltet und um Informationen zu seinem Aufenthaltsort gebeten. Wir haben alles getan, um herauszufinden, ob er noch lebt oder tot ist.

Wir verfolgten mehrere Ansätze. Zunächst den juristischen: Wir brachten den Fall vor Gericht und forderten die Regierung auf, ihn vor Gericht zu stellen oder freizulassen. Dafür gibt es einen Fachbegriff. Unser Gerichtsverfahren erforderte jedoch, dass die Behörden seinen Aufenthaltsort bestätigten und ihn entweder vor Gericht stellten oder freiließen.

Dann gab es den Advocacy-Ansatz. Wir schrieben Briefe an den Gouverneur von Kano, den Präsidenten Nigerias und alle großen Menschenrechtsorganisationen. Wir sprachen mit den Vereinten Nationen, die öffentliche Erklärungen veröffentlichten und diplomatischen Druck auf die Behörden ausübten.

Wie bereits erwähnt, bestätigte zunächst die UNO seine Existenz. Monatelang hatten wir keinerlei Anzeichen dafür erhalten, dass er noch am Leben war, daher intensivierten wir unsere Bemühungen. Die UNO nutzte ihre Netzwerke, um seinen Status zu überprüfen, und bestätigte, dass er weiterhin in Haft war.

Unser internationaler Druck zeigte Wirkung. Nach einigen Monaten bestätigte die UNO, dass er am Leben war.

Jacobsen: Das ist ein riesiger Sieg.

Wie war es mit der Unsicherheit in dieser Zeit? Die wochen- oder sogar monatelange Hektik hatte Auswirkungen auf Ihre Herangehensweise an die Rechtsstrategie.

Seine Strafe betrug ursprünglich 25 Jahre, wurde aber in der Berufung auf fünf Jahre reduziert. Dies ist außerordentlich bedeutsam – nicht nur für sein Privatleben, sondern auch als Präzedenzfall für Fälle wie seinen.

Alles an diesem Fall war unrechtmäßig und ungeheuerlich. Dennoch ist es bemerkenswert, dass Sie Berufung einlegen und das Urteil so drastisch reduzieren konnten. Wie haben Sie Ihre Rechtsstrategie angepasst, als mehr Informationen verfügbar wurden und seine Sicherheit gewährleistet war?

Igwe: Nun, in solchen Fällen werden die Leute Sie verurteilen, egal was Sie tun.

Aufgrund der Zeitunterschiede zwischen Teams und Organisationen hielten wir ständig Besprechungen ab, sogar um Mitternacht oder 1:00 Uhr morgens.

Eine unserer größten Herausforderungen bestand darin, dass manche von uns verlangten, uns auf die Abschaffung der nigerianischen Blasphemiegesetze zu konzentrieren. Das war zwar ein hehres Ziel, aber nicht der strategischste Ansatz.

Stattdessen fragten wir uns: „Was ist unser unmittelbares Ziel?“ Die Antwort war klar: Ihn aus dem Gefängnis zu holen und in Sicherheit zu bringen.

Es gab mehrere Möglichkeiten, dies zu erreichen:

  • Eine Begnadigung durch den Präsidenten
  • Ein Freispruch durch die Gerichte
  • Ein erfolgreicher Einspruch zur Strafminderung

Letztendlich funktionierte die Berufungsstrategie, und seine 25-jährige Haftstrafe wurde auf fünf Jahre reduziert. Unser unmittelbares Ziel war jedoch nicht die vollständige Abschaffung der Blasphemiegesetze, sondern Mubaraks Freilassung.

Deshalb mussten wir ein weiteres Anwaltsteam hinzuziehen, das sich auf umfassendere Blasphemiefälle konzentriert. Wir hoffen, dass diese Fälle letztendlich dazu genutzt werden können, die Verfassungsmäßigkeit der Blasphemiebestimmungen anzufechten. Dies ist jedoch ein langfristiger Kampf.

Dies ist auch einer der Gründe, warum ein wegen „Blasphemie“ angeklagter Mensch noch heute im Gefängnis sitzt – weil einige Anwaltsteams die Anfechtung des Gesetzes selbst priorisierten, anstatt sich auf die Freilassung des Angeklagten zu konzentrieren. Und seien wir ehrlich: Die Abschaffung der „Blasphemie“-Gesetze in Nigeria wird weder heute noch morgen geschehen.

Von Anfang an versuchten wir, Ablenkungen und Gruppen mit widersprüchlichen Ansätzen zu vermeiden, die uns hätten ausbremsen können. Natürlich gab es auch Kritik an der Inkompetenz unseres Anwalts. Dennoch ignorierten wir den Lärm und konzentrierten uns auf unser Ziel.

Diese Klarheit hat uns geholfen, mit der Unsicherheit umzugehen und auf Kurs zu bleiben.

Als das ursprüngliche Urteil verkündet wurde, analysierten wir sorgfältig die Schlupflöcher im Urteil. Die juristische Debatte drehte sich um die Frage, ob die Strafen gleichzeitig oder kumulativ verbüßt ​​werden sollten – unsere Anwälte hätten das besser erklären können. Doch genau diese Schlupflöcher bildeten die Grundlage für unsere Berufung.

Gleichzeitig erhöhten wir den diplomatischen Druck. Wir arbeiteten mit der US-Kommission für internationale Religionsfreiheit (USCIRF) zusammen, um die nigerianische Regierung zu drängen, klarzustellen, dass Mubaraks Fall die Religions- und Glaubensfreiheit ernsthaft missachtet.

Indem wir unsere Ziele klar definierten, internationalen Druck ausübten und uns nicht durch Erpressung, Verleumdung und Machtkämpfe ablenken ließen, erreichten wir Mubaraks Strafminderung und schließlich seine Freilassung.

Jacobsen: Wie verlief der Prozess in Kano? Welchen Herausforderungen mussten Sie während des Verfahrens begegnen?

Igwe: Der Prozess selbst war höchst problematisch.

Erstens war der Zugang zu Mubarak eingeschränkt. Unseren Anwälten wurde regelmäßig der Besuch verweigert. Wenn sie ihn doch sehen konnten, wurde ihnen gesagt, sie bräuchten zusätzliche Genehmigungen – manchmal von Abuja, manchmal von lokalen Behörden. Es gab immer einen Vorwand, ihre Zeit mit ihm zu begrenzen.

Als Mubarak versuchte, telefonisch mit ihnen zu kommunizieren, erlaubten sie nur Gespräche von höchstens zwei Minuten Dauer. Diese Einschränkungen schwächten seine Verteidigung und hinderten seine Anwälte daran, eine angemessene Verteidigung vorzubereiten.

Während des Prozesses bekannte sich Mubarak dann trotz des Rats seines Anwalts schuldig.

Sein Anwalt riet ihm dringend davon ab. Die Anwälte waren der Ansicht, sie hätten ihn nicht verurteilen können, wenn der Fall nach den Umständen des Falles verhandelt worden wäre. Doch Mubarak bekannte sich schuldig und handelte nach seiner Argumentation, was zu dem harten Urteil führte.

Im Nachhinein machten einige den Anwalt für das Schuldgeständnis verantwortlich. Es sei unfair gewesen – es sei Mubaraks Entscheidung gewesen. Sogar die BBC berichtete über den Prozess, und das Video zeigte deutlich, dass er sich entgegen der rechtlichen Beratung schuldig bekannte.

Als das geschah, sammelten wir uns und begannen sofort mit der Vorbereitung einer Berufung, die schließlich zu einer Strafminderung führte.

Jacobsen: Was verrät dieser Fall über den Zustand des nigerianischen Rechtssystems, insbesondere in Bezug auf die verschiedenen Gerichtsbarkeiten?

Igwe: Nun, das Rechtssystem Nigerias funktioniert nicht wie die Rechtssysteme in Kanada, den USA oder Großbritannien.

In Nigeria variieren die Gesetze erheblich, je nachdem, in welchem ​​Teil des Landes man sich befindet. Im Norden, wo die Muslime die Mehrheit bilden, wird das Rechtssystem stark von religiösen Einrichtungen beeinflusst.

Staatliche Gesetze haben dort nicht das gleiche Gewicht. Sie sind oft der Scharia untergeordnet. Bei Konflikten zwischen staatlichem und Scharia-Recht beugen sich die Behörden der scharia-orientierten Auslegung.

Eine der grundlegenden Herausforderungen besteht darin, dass es keinen einheitlichen Rechtsstaat für alle Nigerianer gibt. Stattdessen gibt es vielfältige Rechtssysteme, die es religiösen und politischen Institutionen – sowohl islamischen als auch christlichen – ermöglichen, Gesetzeslücken auszunutzen und die Idee eines einheitlichen Rechts für alle zu untergraben.

Theoretisch behauptet Nigeria, die Rechtsstaatlichkeit aufrechtzuerhalten. In der Praxis jedoch herrscht in unserem Land ein Rechtsstaat, in dem je nach Religion, Ort und politischer Macht unterschiedliche Rechtsnormen gelten.

Aus genau diesem Grund können Personen wie Mubarak Bala ihre Rechte nicht in vollem Umfang wahrnehmen und erhalten auch keinen fairen Prozess, wenn sie vor Gericht angeklagt werden.

Jacobsen: Nehmen wir an, Sie sind ein Muslim in Kano und stehen wegen Verstoßes gegen das islamische Recht vor Gericht. Wie würden Sie dort im Vergleich zu einem ehemaligen Muslim behandelt, der desselben Vergehens angeklagt ist?

Wäre die Behandlung gleich oder anders?

Igwe: Wenn Sie Muslim sind, werden die Behörden Sie nach dem Scharia-Gesetz vor Gericht stellen wollen.

Für Ex-Muslime ist die Lage jedoch noch viel schlimmer. In Nordnigeria begegnet man Ex-Muslimen mit Wohlwollen. Als Ex-Muslim wird man gehasst, ausgegrenzt und in vielen Fällen bestraft oder sogar vernichtet.

Manche Extremisten sind der Meinung, dass man, wenn man die Gelegenheit dazu hätte, allein dafür getötet werden sollte, dass man den Islam verlässt.

Aus diesem Grund wollen sie nicht einmal, dass ehemalige Muslime nach Landesrecht vor Gericht gestellt werden – denn das Landesrecht würde mildere Strafen fällen. Stattdessen drängen sie darauf, dass diese Fälle vor Scharia-Gerichte gebracht werden, um den Angeklagten härtere Strafen zu ermöglichen.

Selbst gegenüber Nichtmuslimen ist das Rechtssystem voreingenommen. In Nordnigeria haben mir Menschen erzählt, dass Christen und Nichtmuslime vor einem Staatsgericht für dasselbe Vergehen oft längere Haftstrafen erhalten als Muslime.

Mit anderen Worten: Sie werden stärker bestraft, nur weil Sie kein Muslim sind.

Dies macht die Rechtslage in Nordnigeria zu einem gefährlichen Ort für religiöse Minderheiten, insbesondere für ehemalige Muslime, Atheisten und säkulare Aktivisten.

Jacobsen: Darüber hinaus möchte ich betonen, dass Mubaraks ursprüngliches „Verbrechen“ cyberbasiert war.

Dies erhöht die Komplexität zusätzlich, da Cyberkriminalität nicht immer in den traditionellen Rechtsrahmen passt. Im Gegensatz zu physischen Straftaten überschreiten Cyberkriminalität nationale und geopolitische Grenzen.

Im Fall Mubarak ging es nicht um „Blasphemie“, sondern er spiegelte auch den wachsenden Konflikt zwischen digitaler Meinungsfreiheit und religiöser Zensur in autoritären Gesellschaften wider.

Mubaraks „Verbrechen“ bestand also darin, einen Satz auf Facebook (jetzt Meta) zu veröffentlichen – eine scharfe, kritische Äußerung, die sich über Mohammed lustig machte. Dafür wurde er zu 25 Jahren Gefängnis verurteilt.

Ich möchte noch einmal betonen, wie drakonisch das ist. Er wurde von Zivilpolizisten ohne Haftbefehl aus seinem Haus in Kaduna entführt, nach Kano verschleppt und dort auf Grundlage eines quasi-virtuellen „Blasphemie“-Gesetzes angeklagt. Dank intensiver juristischer Bemühungen wurde seine Strafe schließlich auf fünf Jahre reduziert – was in diesem Kontext als Erfolg gewertet wurde.

Dieser Fall verdeutlicht die extreme Rechtslage in Nigeria, insbesondere wenn religiöse Kräfte beteiligt sind. Jeder, der schon einmal im Ausland war, erkennt die enormen Unterschiede in den Rechtssystemen, und Mubaraks Fall ist eines der extremsten Beispiele für religiöse Verfolgung durch Rechtsmechanismen.

Nun zu Ihrem Punkt über Hetzkampagnen: In Nordamerika sind Podcasts beliebt. YouTube-Kanäle, die als audiovisuelle Podcasts fungieren, diskutieren häufig Narzissmus, Beziehungen, zwischenmenschliche Dynamiken und berufliche Konflikte. Viele dieser Kanäle stellen Hetzkampagnen als Folge einer narzisstischen Verletzung dar – wenn sich ein Narzisst gekränkt fühlt und mit falschen Anschuldigungen und persönlichen Angriffen reagiert.

Die meisten dieser Diskussionen stammen jedoch nicht von Experten – Menschen mit starken Meinungen, die selbstbewusst in den sozialen Medien sprechen. Wenn sie von Hetzkampagnen sprechen, meinen sie meist persönliche Fehden, die durch emotionale Beschwerden angeheizt werden.

Doch in Ihrem Fall glaube ich, dass Sie eine „Verleumdungskampagne“ auf eine spezifischere und politischere Art und Weise einsetzen – als ein Werkzeug zur sozialen und politischen Untergrabung und nicht als Mittel zur persönlichen Vergeltung.

Wie begegnen Sie systematischen Desinformations- und Verleumdungskampagnen in Ihrem Kontext, insbesondere von ausgewählten Quellen mit einer Agenda?

Igwe: Nun, es gibt heutzutage Grenzen für das, was man gegen Falschinformationen in den sozialen Medien tun kann.

Menschen verbringen endlose Stunden auf Facebook, Twitter oder anderen Plattformen, verbreiten Unwahrheiten und verzerren die Realität. Und die Wahrheit ist: Wir können dem nur begrenzt entgegenwirken.

Wir haben zwei verschiedene strategische Ansätze in Betracht gezogen:

  1. Könnten Sie es ignorieren? Manche Leute wiesen darauf hin, dass eine Reaktion das Problem nur verschärfen und dem Ankläger das Gefühl geben würde, wichtig zu sein.
  2. Setzen Sie sich damit auseinander. Andere argumentierten, dass Fehlinformationen jahrelange Arbeit diskreditieren könnten und dass das Ignorieren dieser Informationen dazu führen würde, dass sich falsche Darstellungen ungehindert verbreiten könnten.

In der Zwischenzeit erhielten wir immer wieder E-Mails und Nachrichten von Unterstützern, die uns warnten: „Sie verleumden euch! Sie verbreiten falsche Informationen! Sie untergraben all die Arbeit, die ihr über die Jahre geleistet habt!“

Ehrlich gesagt, wenn Sie mich fragen, sind Verleumdungskampagnen zutiefst frustrierend und können verletzend sein – vor allem, wenn sie auf Unwissenheit beruhen.

Igwe: Manchmal haben Menschen, die sich an Hetzkampagnen beteiligen, mit einem Trauma zu kämpfen. Wenn ich das erkenne, ist es meiner Meinung nach am besten, ihnen aus dem Weg zu gehen.

Wenn Sie jedoch eine öffentliche Funktion innehaben – etwa als Vorstandsmitglied oder als Leiter einer Organisation – können Sie sie nicht immer ignorieren. Verleumdungskampagnen können den Ruf der Organisationen, mit denen Sie verbunden sind, schädigen oder sogar Misstrauen bei Ihren Kollegen hervorrufen.

Ich hatte mit diesen Herausforderungen zu kämpfen. Als ich einige dieser falschen Anschuldigungen sah, wusste ich genau, wer dahinter steckte und warum sie erhoben wurden. Meine natürliche Reaktion war, sie zu ignorieren.

Aber so einfach war es natürlich nicht. Ich erhielt ständig Anrufe, Facebook-Nachrichten, E-Mails und sogar Anwälte und Familienmitglieder wurden kontaktiert. Die Leute fragten: „Was ist los? Warum sagen die so etwas über dich? Du musst reagieren!“ Der Druck, zu reagieren, war ständig da.

Manchmal habe ich reagiert, manchmal dachte ich, es wäre besser, es zu ignorieren. Diese Situationen zu meistern, war extrem schwierig. Aber ich muss sagen, wir haben unser Bestes gegeben – ich, Humanists International und alle anderen Beteiligten.

Unsere primäre Strategie bestand darin, die Kontroverse im Sande verlaufen zu lassen, und genau das ist auch passiert.

Natürlich werde ich auch heute noch bei örtlichen Versammlungen gefragt: „Was ist passiert? Ich weiß noch, dass ich so viel über dich gehört habe.“ Und dann muss ich die ganze Geschichte immer wieder erzählen – obwohl sie meinem Leben keinen echten Mehrwert bietet.

Das ist die Realität einer Person des öffentlichen Lebens. Wenn Sie sichtbar und offen sind, wird es immer Momente geben, in denen Menschen negative oder falsche Behauptungen über Sie verbreiten. Das ist unvermeidlich.

Manchmal kommen diese Angriffe von überraschender Seite – von Menschen, die einst deine Facebook-Freunde waren oder sogar Mitglieder der humanistischen Gemeinschaft. Ich habe gelernt, mit ihnen zu rechnen.

Dennoch sind wir Menschen und müssen manchmal reagieren. Gelegentlich habe ich Erklärungen abgegeben und die Menschen gebeten, die falschen Anschuldigungen zu ignorieren. Ich habe auch Artikel verfasst, um die Situation aufzuklären, darunter einen über Humanismus und Asylsuche, in dem ich untersuchte, wie manche Menschen legitime Menschenrechtsfragen für ihren persönlichen Vorteil ausnutzen.

Letztendlich ist es am besten, Klarstellungen vorzunehmen, wenn diese notwendig sind – andernfalls ignorieren Sie sie.

Jacobsen: Das ist eine gesunde Reaktion. Dem stimme ich voll und ganz zu.

Jeder Humanist, den ich kenne, hat das in seiner Kleinstadt oder international erlebt. Es gehört einfach dazu, eine Minderheit in einer globalen Bewegung zu sein.

Igwe: Ja.

Wie ich bereits sagte, haben mir die Krise, die Herausforderungen und die Verleumdungskampagnen geholfen, besser zu verstehen, wie zerbrechlich die humanistische Gemeinschaft sein kann.

Es hat mir auch gezeigt, wie leicht Menschen auf Fehlinformationen hereinfallen können.

Wir mussten Krisensitzungen einberufen – eine nach der anderen – um diese Probleme anzugehen. Und ich dachte mir: „Wow, können zwei oder drei Personen, die in den sozialen Medien Falschinformationen verbreiten, eine ganze Organisation in Panik versetzen?“

Deshalb müssen Humanisten über Institutionen arbeiten, anstatt impulsiv zu handeln. Institutionen verfügen über Fachleute, die darin geschult sind, Fakten zu überprüfen, bevor sie handeln.

Nehmen wir zum Beispiel einen Humanisten in Großbritannien, der etwas online liest. Anstatt die zuständigen Institutionen zu kontaktieren, um die Informationen zu überprüfen, verfasst er sofort eine Petition und schickt sie an eine Organisation.

Sie haben sich nie zuerst an diese Institutionen gewandt. Sie haben nie gefragt: „Hey, ich habe das gelesen – was ist los?“

Hätten sie dies getan, hätte die Institution den Fall untersucht und eine fundierte Stellungnahme abgegeben. Stattdessen gingen sie online, recherchierten isoliert, sprachen nur mit Menschen, die eine Seite des Problems vertraten, und beteiligten sich dann an einer Kampagne zur Diskreditierung einer Person.

Und was ist passiert?

Die Petition gelangte auf institutionelle Ebene, wurde angemessen geprüft und schließlich als unbegründet zurückgewiesen. Ein solches Verhalten schadet der Glaubwürdigkeit und untergräbt die Integrität von Bewegungen.

Mein Rat richtet sich insbesondere an Humanisten in den USA, Großbritannien und dem Westen. Manche von ihnen haben immer noch engstirnige Ansichten über Afrikaner. Wenn sie das Wort „Nigerianer“ hören, assoziieren manche es sofort mit 419-Betrug und Schwindel – als ob das ein ganzes Land beschreiben würde.

Die Menschen müssen verstehen, dass es überall Betrug gibt.

Betrüger gibt es in Kanada, den USA, Europa, Asien und darüber hinaus. Die Amerikaner wissen das über ihr eigenes Land. Die Realität ist, dass die Welt heute so ist, wie sie ist, weil Betrug begangen wird – ob verdeckt oder offen, begangen von Menschen aller Rassen, Hintergründe und Nationalitäten.

Doch wenn es um Afrika geht, greifen manche Menschen sofort auf Stereotypen zurück. Sie gehen davon aus, dass ein Afrikaner automatisch ungebildet, unintelligent oder „primitiv“ ist. Und schlimmer noch: Manche dieser Menschen versuchen, Afrikaner zu „lenken“, obwohl sie völlig unwissend und voreingenommen sind.

Ich habe das selbst erlebt. Viele unserer Kollegen im Westen – auch Humanisten – behandeln Afrikaner herablassend. Sie sagen es vielleicht nicht direkt, aber ihre Haltung macht deutlich, dass sie Afrikaner als primitiv, rückständig oder paternalistisch aufsichtsbedürftig betrachten.

Ich habe dies in meinen über zwanzig Jahren Arbeit innerhalb der humanistischen Bewegung immer wieder erlebt.

Machen Sie ihnen klar, dass sich die Dinge ändern.

Während ich hier sitze, sehe ich, dass meine Mutter amerikanische Staatsbürgerin ist. Meine Geschwister leben in verschiedenen Teilen der Welt. Wir wissen, was global vor sich geht. Wir sind nicht die Afrikaner der Anthropologie vor 200, 400 oder 500 Jahren.

Dennoch betrachten uns viele immer noch als „edle Wilde“. Sie sagen es vielleicht nicht direkt, aber wenn sie über Afrikaner sprechen, tun sie dies mit tiefer Verachtung und Respektlosigkeit. Und um es klar zu sagen: Dieser Ansatz wird im 21. Jahrhundert für uns nicht funktionieren.

Wir nutzen dasselbe Internet und haben denselben Zugang zu Informationen. Dennoch zeigen sich ihre Vorurteile in der Art und Weise, wie sie mit afrikanischen Fällen umgehen und wie sie mit afrikanischen Aktivisten und Intellektuellen interagieren.

Lassen Sie mich Ihnen noch etwas sagen: Hätten sich ausschließlich Weiße mit Mubaraks Fall befasst, wäre diese Kontroverse wahrscheinlich nie entstanden. Trotz seiner anfänglichen Einwände hätte selbst Mubarak das Verfahren wahrscheinlich problemlos akzeptiert.

Die Wahrheit ist: Viele Menschen hegen rassistische Einstellungen, weigern sich aber, sie als Rassismus zu bezeichnen. Gleichzeitig haben viele Afrikaner und Nigerianer ihr Minderwertigkeitsgefühl verinnerlicht. Sie geraten in Panik, wenn jemand aus den USA oder Europa eine Aussage macht – selbst wenn diese Person Unrecht hat. Und um es klarzustellen: Oft liegen sie falsch.

Humanisten weltweit müssen verstehen, dass wir im Umgang miteinander veraltete Denkweisen aufgeben und respektvoll miteinander umgehen sollten. Ich wies darauf hin, dass niemand eine Hetzkampagne gegen die Anwälte dieses Falles starten würde, selbst wenn einer von ihnen inkompetent oder über die aktuellen Rechtstrends nicht informiert wäre. Selbst wenn Menschen aus den USA oder Großbritannien an einer solchen Kampagne beteiligt wären, würden sie es nicht tun, einfach weil er Brite ist – er ist ein Weißer.

Es besteht jedoch die inhärente Tendenz, auf Menschen herabzuschauen, wenn sie nicht weiß sind und wichtige Verantwortung tragen. Ihre Kompetenz und Intelligenz werden sofort in Frage gestellt. Und sehen Sie, die Leute zweifeln an meiner Fähigkeit, eine Situation zu meistern, die ich besser verstehe als sie. Scott, es gibt eine Grenze. Diese Situation entwickelt sich, und wer wird am meisten darunter leiden? Ich bin derjenige, der mittendrin steckt. Und ich sage den Leuten: „So will ich es handhaben.“ Und doch behauptet jemand in Großbritannien oder den USA, ich wüsste nicht, was ich tue, ich hätte einen inkompetenten Anwalt engagiert – was für eine Beleidigung! Was für eine Beleidigung!

Deshalb sagte ich, Humanisten sollten über Institutionen arbeiten. Bei Bedenken wenden Sie sich an Humanists International: „Könnten Sie sich das ansehen? Das sind die Berichte, die ich erhalte.“ Dort lässt sich die Situation genauer einschätzen. Doch stattdessen wenden sich die Menschen den sozialen Medien zu und sammeln bruchstückhafte Informationen aus unzuverlässigen Quellen. Viele sind traumatisiert, enttäuscht, verzweifelt oder verfolgen ihre eigenen Ziele. Wenn sie nicht bekommen, was sie wollen, greifen sie zu Schmutzkampagnen und Verleumdungen.

Die Verbreitung von Fehlinformationen und die Verbreitung von Unwahrheiten ist unverantwortlich. Ich war darüber enttäuscht, und wir müssen uns dessen bewusst sein. Wir werden in Zukunft wachsen und nicht eine Randorganisation bleiben.

Wenn wir bereit sind zu wachsen, sollten wir auch darauf vorbereitet sein, dies zu bewältigen. Wir sollten Mechanismen schaffen und uns darüber im Klaren sein, dass viele Menschen nach Großbritannien kommen und sich als Humanisten ausgeben – nicht, weil sie es wirklich sind, sondern weil sie eine Aufenthaltserlaubnis suchen. Sie erklären: „Ich bin Humanist“, und wir gewähren ihnen Asyl. Dann nutzen sie diesen Status, und es gibt keine praktische Möglichkeit, ihren Anspruch zu überprüfen. Wir brauchen einen Mechanismus, um diesem Problem zu begegnen, denn eines der vorherrschenden Argumente lautet: „Stellen Sie diese Asylbewerber nicht wegen der Einwanderungspolitik infrage.“

Mit dieser Haltung ermöglichen wir unabsichtlich Betrug. Wir erlauben es Menschen, Verfolgungsvorwürfe zu erfinden und Ressourcen auszubeuten. Und wenn ein weißer Brite für jemanden bürgt, selbst wenn Beweise etwas anderes nahelegen, wird diese Behauptung selten hinterfragt. Die Position eines Briten in einem solchen Fall gilt oft als unanfechtbar, selbst wenn er wenig oder gar nichts über die Rechtslage vor Ort weiß.

Wir schaffen diese Krisen, aber in Zukunft müssen wir die Bedeutung von gegenseitigem Respekt und Partnerschaft betonen. Anstatt Annahmen zu treffen, rufen Sie mich an und fragen Sie: „Was braucht diese Person? Wie ist die tatsächliche Situation?“ Wir sollten außerdem Überprüfungsmechanismen implementieren und uns auf deren Ergebnisse verlassen, anstatt uns von Sentimentalitäten oder der Vorstellung leiten zu lassen, dass westliche Perspektiven immer Vorrang haben müssen, nur weil sie aus dem Westen stammen.

Dieser Ansatz wird viele aufrichtige und engagierte Menschen vergraulen, und wenn wir das zulassen, werden wir eine Randorganisation bleiben.

Jacobsen: Wie haben Sie die lokalen Gemeinden – ohne sie zu bevormunden – dazu gebracht, ihre Unterstützung für Mubarak Bala zu gewinnen, egal ob religiös oder nicht? Sie haben sich dafür eingesetzt, seine Haftstrafe von 25 auf fünf Jahre zu reduzieren und schließlich seine Freilassung zu erreichen. Gleichzeitig haben Sie die Sache diskret angegangen, um seine Sicherheit zu gewährleisten.

Igwe: Ich betone immer wieder: Heute ist es Mubarak. Morgen könnten Sie es sein. Ihre Verwandten. Ja, Sie könnten Opfer werden. Das ist die Realität, die ich versuche zu vermitteln, und sie kommt bei den Menschen an.

Blasphemievorwürfe sind wie ein Schwert, das über den Menschen schwebt – sie können jeden jederzeit treffen. Wir müssen diese Botschaft verbreiten, um zu verhindern, dass so etwas erneut passiert. Dasselbe gilt für Hexereivorwürfe. Während ich jetzt zu Ihnen spreche, könnte ich leicht einer Hexereihysterie zum Opfer fallen und getötet werden. Das ist keine Hypothese.

In meiner Gemeinde wurde ein Mensch von Ritualisten brutal ermordet. Sein Körper wurde verstümmelt, und Teile davon wurden für rituelle Opfer entnommen. Ich erinnere die Menschen immer daran, dass dies keine ferne, abstrakte Bedrohung ist. Es kann jedem jederzeit passieren.

Was können wir in solchen Situationen tun? Wir müssen zusammenhalten. Wie das Sprichwort sagt: „Wem die Stunde schlägt“ – morgen könnte sie auch dir schlagen. Ich versuche, den Menschen zu vermitteln, dass wir die Zukunft selbst gestalten.

Um zu wachsen, müssen wir uns zu einem gewaltfreien, zivilen Umgang mit Aussagen, Social-Media-Posts und Positionen anderer verpflichten. Impulsive oder feindselige Reaktionen werden unserer Sache nicht dienen. Stattdessen müssen wir strategisch, prinzipientreu und vereint vorgehen.

Gewalt ist niemals eine angemessene Reaktion auf die Meinungsäußerung einer Person, sei es in Wort, Schrift oder Social-Media-Posts, selbst wenn wir ihr entschieden widersprechen. Wir nutzen Mechanismen, um unsere Unterstützerbasis zu erweitern und Menschen zusammenzubringen. Wir möchten, dass sie verstehen, dass es hier nicht um eine einzelne Person, sondern um ein kollektives Anliegen geht.

Ich habe Mubaraks Fall nie nur als eine persönliche Angelegenheit betrachtet. Ich habe ihn als Symbol betrachtet, als eine Gelegenheit, für ein Grundprinzip einzutreten, für das ich seit Jahren eintrete: Menschen müssen die Freiheit haben, zu glauben oder nicht zu glauben, was sie wollen. Wenn die Menschen ihren Glauben nicht frei wählen können, besteht die Gefahr, dass die Gesellschaft Fanatismus und Extremismus fördert.

Menschen in jeder Gesellschaft müssen die Freiheit haben, zu denken, zu glauben und sich auszudrücken. Nur so kann ein Abgleiten in den Fundamentalismus verhindert werden. Ich habe immer betont, dass es bei der gemeinsamen Rettung des Lebens dieses jungen Mannes nicht nur um ihn selbst geht – es geht darum, uns und den kommenden Generationen eine bessere Zukunft zu sichern.

Jacobsen: Es entstehen viele Bewegungen, und einzelne Personen erlangen Bekanntheit. Doch auf jeden bekannten Anführer kommen unzählige andere, deren Namen nie in Erinnerung bleiben werden – Menschen, die unermüdlich hinter den Kulissen arbeiten und von der Geschichte vergessen werden.

In Nordamerika sind Persönlichkeiten wie Martin Luther King Jr. und Malcolm X zu nennen. Im postkolonialen Kontext Ghanas erinnern wir uns an Kwame Nkrumah. Diese außergewöhnlichen Persönlichkeiten entstanden aus besonderen kulturellen und historischen Umständen, die sie prägten und wiederum von ihnen geprägt wurden.

Wie stellen Sie sicher, dass Aktivisten an vorderster Front – diejenigen, die ihr Leben nicht für Ruhm, sondern für Gerechtigkeit riskieren – die gebührende Anerkennung und den nötigen Respekt erhalten? Diese Personen bleiben oft anonym, selbst wenn sie wichtige Arbeit im Rechtssystem, in der Gemeindearbeit oder im Online-Bereich leisten. Wie schaffen Sie es, den Fokus auf bekannte Persönlichkeiten zu richten und gleichzeitig sicherzustellen, dass die vielen verborgenen Unterstützer die Anerkennung und Unterstützung erhalten, die sie verdienen?

Igwe: Ja, vielen Dank dafür. Koordination ist entscheidend, Informationen sind entscheidend und regelmäßige Updates sind unerlässlich. Beispielsweise sind die Amerikaner in Nigeria um Mitternacht noch in ihren Feierabend eingestiegen, während die Australier gerade erst in den Tag starten. Allein die Zeitzonen erfordern ständige Kommunikation und Koordination zwischen den Regionen.

Um sicherzustellen, dass alle Beteiligten – Anwälte, Community-Aktivisten und digitale Befürworter – eingebunden und anerkannt werden, bedarf es kontinuierlicher Bemühungen, Updates auszutauschen, die Zusammenarbeit zu fördern und die Bedeutung ihrer Rollen zu unterstreichen. Es geht nicht nur um die bekannten Persönlichkeiten, sondern um die gemeinsame Anstrengung, die Veränderungen ermöglicht.

Das war anstrengend. Die Betreuung von Mitarbeitern aus verschiedenen Teilen der Welt mit erheblichen Zeitunterschieden zu Nigeria war anstrengend. Es kostete mich außerdem viel Kraft, weil ich die Leute einzeln auf dem Laufenden halten musste. Es gab ja keine einheitliche E-Mail-Liste, über die eine Nachricht alle gleichzeitig erreichen konnte.

Stattdessen erhielt jede Person einzeln Updates; manchmal musste ich dieselben Informationen immer wieder wiederholen. Wenn ich nicht schnell reagierte, fühlten sich manche Leute ignoriert oder verhielten sich sogar, als wäre ich ihnen etwas schuldig – fast so, als hätten sie mich „angestellt“. Das alles zu verwalten und zu koordinieren war unglaublich schwierig.

Aber in solchen Momenten muss man sich fragen: Was ist das Ziel? Wir alle wollten Mubarak stürzen. Als ich mir das Gesamtbild vor Augen führte, wurde mir klar, dass die Opfer – Updates liefern, Fehlinformationen aufklären und schwierige Gespräche führen – im Vergleich dazu gering waren.

Auch der Umgang mit Fehlinformationen war ein entscheidender Teil dieser Bemühungen. Einmal entdeckten wir, dass eine Asylsuchende mit Mitgliedern von Mubaraks Familie konspiriert hatte, um die Falschmeldung zu verbreiten, er sei getötet worden. Wenn Sie einige unserer Blogs lesen, werden Sie feststellen, dass es eine Zeit gab, in der Leute fragten, ob Mubarak ermordet worden sei. Es kursierte das Gerücht, sein Leichnam sei in einem Leichenschauhaus abgelegt worden, und angebliche Augenzeugen behaupteten, ihn gesehen zu haben.

Doch was geschah? Wir bestätigten später, dass es falsch war. Die Person, die hinter dem Gerücht steckte, war eine der Asylsuchenden, die angeblich der „Blasphemie“ beschuldigt wurde. Dies ist ein Beispiel dafür, wie Individuen mit eigennützigen Motiven und Hintergedanken eine ganze Bewegung untergraben können.

Das war eine ständige Sorge. Zu allem Überfluss riefen mich auch noch Diplomaten an, um mich zu trösten – nur um später festzustellen, dass die Informationen, auf die sie sich stützten, falsch waren. Eine Frau, eine Panikmacherin, verbreitete gezielt Falschinformationen, löste Panik aus und schürte die Angst vor der Situation.

Wenn die Behörden jemanden festnehmen, ist es entscheidend, Informationen zu überprüfen, bevor sie verbreitet werden. Man hätte mich informieren sollen, bevor unbestätigte Behauptungen verbreitet wurden. Wir haben alles getan, um Mubaraks Sicherheit zu gewährleisten, doch falsche Gerüchte erschwerten diese Aufgabe zusätzlich.

Was will ich damit sagen? Es war schwierig, korrekte Informationen zu verbreiten und gleichzeitig der Verbreitung von Unwahrheiten entgegenzuwirken. Diese Art von Fehlinformationen gefährdet nicht nur die Glaubwürdigkeit der Kampagne, sondern auch die Glaubwürdigkeit als Einzelner. Es stand viel auf dem Spiel und musste sorgfältig gehandhabt werden.

Jacobsen: Welchen Rat würden Sie internationalen Akteuren geben, um die Fallstricke des „Käufers aufgepasst“ bei der Interessenvertretung zu vermeiden? Jeder macht Witze über den nigerianischen Prinzen, der behauptet, Ihr lange verschollener Verwandter zu sein, dessen Vermögen auf einer Bank in Ibadan wartet. Und „Bruder“ ist ein häufiges Wort in solchen Botschaften – es klingt förmlich und doch informell.

Sie erhalten E-Mails wie:

„Lieber Bruder, ich bitte dich um Hilfe bei der Verteilung meines 5-Millionen-Dollar-Erbes von unserem verstorbenen Onkel, König Soundso. Bitte hilf mir.“

Aus irgendeinem Grund landen diese E-Mails jedes Mal in meinem Spam-Ordner – zumindest in meinem alten E-Mail-Konto. Es ist so seltsam, Leo. Ich sollte mich wieder mit meinen nigerianischen Königswurzeln verbinden. Wer hätte gedacht, dass ich nigerianische Familie habe? Ich dachte immer, ich hätte niederländische und norwegische Wurzeln!

In Kanada erhält man viele Spam-Anrufe von Telefongesellschaften und Betrügern, die einem etwas verkaufen wollen. Und natürlich heißt es immer: „Sagen Sie mir Bescheid, wenn Sie während des Vorgangs Verbesserungen oder Nachverfolgungen benötigen.“ Aus irgendeinem Grund ist das mein Telefon.

Aber mal im Ernst: Wie können Menschen bei der Unterscheidung zwischen legitimen und illegitimen Fällen von Bedürftigen echte von betrügerischen Fällen unterscheiden? Nehmen wir den Fall Mubarak Bala oder den Fall von Gulalai Ismail, Narendra Nayak oder Gaspar Bekes. Gehen wir auf die Website von Humanists International. Dort finden wir eine Liste mit rund 40 Namen – Menschen, die ohne triftigen Grund in ernsthafte Schwierigkeiten geraten sind, nur weil der Staat, ihre Gemeinschaft oder andere Kräfte sie im Visier haben.

Was empfehlen Sie also, um echte Hilfeanfragen von betrügerischen zu unterscheiden?

Igwe: Wir müssen in den Aufbau starker, glaubwürdiger Netzwerke weltweit investieren – sonst werden wir nicht effektiv sein. Ob wir es nun annehmen oder ablehnen, ist uns überlassen. Andernfalls werden wir weiterhin vor den gleichen Herausforderungen stehen wie zuvor.

Während Mubaraks Amtszeit war alles unglaublich unbeständig und fragil. Wir waren alle verletzlich. Irgendwann fragte ich mich sogar, warum ich diese Arbeit überhaupt mache. Wenn jemand im Internet Informationen über mich und meine Arbeit sammeln und darauf basierend eine Petition verfassen kann, wozu bin ich dann überhaupt hier?

Warum bin ich Mitglied von Humanists International, wenn manche Humanisten/Atheisten mir nicht genug vertrauen, um mich direkt zu fragen, was los ist? Stattdessen handeln sie zuerst und rufen erst später an und bitten um Klärung.

Wir brauchen ein robustes, gut organisiertes Netzwerk. Wir müssen darin investieren, sonst werden wir in die Irre geführt, falsch informiert und begehen schwerwiegende Fehler.

Irgendwann bin ich ehrlich gesagt zusammengebrochen. Betrüger und Opportunisten können uns manipulieren und uns glauben machen, wir hätten es mit etwas Dringendem und Legitimem zu tun, obwohl es in Wirklichkeit Betrug ist. Wir müssen geeignete Mechanismen einrichten, um Fälle zu überprüfen, bevor wir Maßnahmen ergreifen.

Ablenkungen können uns vom Wesentlichen abhalten. Wir müssen in starke, zuverlässige Netzwerke investieren, um diese Ablenkung zu vermeiden. Andernfalls wird es uns teuer zu stehen kommen, und wir werden nicht in der Lage sein, eine tragfähige globale Organisation aufzubauen.

Vergessen Sie es – wir brauchen kompetente Menschen in verschiedenen Teilen der Welt. Wir müssen Wege finden, mit ihnen in Kontakt zu treten, glaubwürdige Informationen zu sammeln und uns von zuverlässigen Quellen leiten zu lassen.

Das heißt nicht, dass alles, was ich sage, blind akzeptiert werden sollte. Nein. Aber wenn Probleme auftreten, brauchen wir Überprüfungsmechanismen. Wenn wir beispielsweise über Mitgliedsorganisationen abstimmen, lehne ich es manchmal ab, bestimmte Gruppen aufgrund ihrer Handlungen als humanistische Organisationen anzuerkennen. Manchmal gewinne ich dieses Argument, manchmal verliere ich. Aber was soll ich tun? Warten wir ab, wie sich diese Organisationen, die Sie für humanistisch halten, tatsächlich verhalten .

Ich betone: Wenn wir uns mit dem zufrieden geben, was wir zu wissen glauben, warum haben wir dann überhaupt ein globales Netzwerk? Warum haben wir Vertreter aus verschiedenen Teilen der Welt? Der Zweck dieser Netzwerke besteht darin, uns zu helfen, Fehler zu vermeiden und zu verhindern, dass wir von zufälligen Personen mit fragwürdigen Motiven in die Irre geführt werden.

Sie erhalten möglicherweise eine E-Mail von einem nigerianischen Prinzen oder einer nigerianischen Prinzessin. Doch was sollten Sie tun? Wie jede verantwortungsbewusste Organisation wenden Sie sich an die zuständigen Behörden – Regierungen und Botschaften – und bitten sie um Ermittlungen. Dafür gibt es Botschaften, und wir haben Vertretungen in verschiedenen Regionen.

Doch trotz unserer Vertretungen an verschiedenen Orten verlassen sich manche immer noch auf zufällige, ungeprüfte Informationsquellen. Das wirft kein gutes Licht auf unseren Entscheidungsprozess. Es ist frustrierend und, ehrlich gesagt, demoralisierend.

Lassen Sie mich noch etwas hinzufügen: Viele Fehlinformationen über Nigeria und Afrika gelten im Westen als „Allgemeinwissen“. Ich recherchierte zu Hexereivorwürfen und stellte fest, dass die meisten verfügbaren Literaturquellen von westlichen Anthropologen verfasst wurden, die das Phänomen weitgehend falsch darstellten.

Diese Falschdarstellung erschwert es der Welt, die Dringlichkeit des Problems zu begreifen oder es mit dem notwendigen Perspektivwechsel anzugehen. Fehlinformationen wirken also in beide Richtungen.

Viele Menschen haben nur ein oberflächliches Verständnis von Nigeria und Afrika. Als mich beispielsweise 1999 auf einer humanistischen Konferenz in Indien jemand fragte: „Wie geht es Mandela?“, war ich fassungslos.

Ich stand einfach nur da und wusste nicht, was ich antworten sollte. Ich muss vor ihm dumm ausgesehen haben, aber ich war schockiert, dass er mich – einen Nigerianer – nach Mandela fragte. Ich habe Mandela nie getroffen, obwohl er sechs Flugstunden von meinem Wohnort entfernt wohnte. Trotzdem gehen die Leute davon aus, dass ich ihn persönlich kennen muss, weil ich aus Afrika komme.

Solchen Menschen begegnet man ständig. Aber wenn ein Weißer Unwissenheit oder Vorurteile äußert, wird das oft übersehen oder heruntergespielt. Wenn es mir oder jemandem mit meinem Hintergrund passiert, passt es jedoch in ein Stereotyp und wird hervorgehoben.

Was will ich damit sagen? Falschinformationen wirken in beide Richtungen. Wir können dem jedoch entgegenwirken, indem wir einander respektieren und unsere kompetenten Vertreter in verschiedenen Regionen anerkennen. Wir sollten ihnen zuhören, uns auf ihre Erkenntnisse über ihre jeweiligen Regionen verlassen und diese Informationen als Grundlage für unsere Entscheidungen nutzen – nicht unsere Vorurteile, nicht das, was wir im Internet finden, und nicht einmal alles, was wir in der wissenschaftlichen Forschung lesen.

Viele Forscher kommen nach Afrika, übernachten in Hotels und vertiefen sich nie wirklich in die Realität der Orte, die sie angeblich erforschen. Dennoch werden sie zu „Autoritäten“ in Afrika. Was sie produzieren, ist oft keine Autorität – es sind Unwahrheiten und Falschdarstellungen.

Was will ich damit sagen? Wir müssen überholte Einstellungen und Vorurteile hinter uns lassen. Wir leben in einer vernetzten Welt, in der Informationen leicht zugänglich sind. Das müssen wir nutzen und sicherstellen, dass wir uns mit der Wahrheit auseinandersetzen, anstatt uns auf Stereotypen zu verlassen.

So erzielen wir echte Fortschritte. Wir können die E-Mail-Betrügereien um nigerianische Prinzen und Prinzessinnen in den Hintergrund drängen und uns auf sinnvolle Arbeit konzentrieren, die wirklich etwas in der Welt bewirkt.

Unsere Philosophie ist global. Wir sind Humanisten, keine Westler, Briten, Kanadier oder Amerikanisten.

Um Himmels willen, wir sind Humanisten.

Jacobsen: Wir brauchen einen universellen, effektiven Mechanismus, um eine universelle philosophische Lebenseinstellung zu fördern und zu vermitteln. Auch wenn Menschen älter werden und mehr über die Philosophie erfahren, bleiben die Prinzipien klar. Die Nuancen entwickeln sich durch die Erfahrungen mit unterschiedlichen Kulturen und Menschen.

Doch die Grundprinzipien bleiben bestehen. In allen zuvor erwähnten Fällen sind die zugrunde liegenden Probleme dieselben, auch wenn die Umstände unterschiedlich sind. In allen Gesellschaften bestehen dieselben grundlegenden Probleme – manche Länder haben sie weitgehend gelöst, weil sie mehr Zeit, Ressourcen oder eine bessere Regierungsführung hatten. Andere kämpfen noch immer mit dem gesamten Spektrum dieser Herausforderungen.

Unabhängig davon bleiben die Sorgen universell. Wie Sie sagten, wir sind Humanisten. Dies sind gemeinsame menschliche Kämpfe.

Deshalb sind Gespräche wie dieses so wichtig. Sie präsentieren diese Themen in einem zugänglichen, dialogorientierten Format, an dem man sich leicht beteiligen kann.

Obwohl sich dieses Interview auf Mubarak Bala konzentriert, haben wir auf zahlreiche internationale Fälle verwiesen, die zeigen, wie eng diese Kämpfe miteinander verknüpft sind.

Ich habe viele Fragen gestellt. Möchten Sie noch etwas hinzufügen?

Igwe: Ja, abschließend möchte ich allen danken, die uns in diesem Fall geholfen haben.

Wie ich bereits sagte, war diese Situation beispiellos. Wir waren nicht darauf vorbereitet. Sie geschah plötzlich, und viele Menschen versammelten sich, um uns zu unterstützen.

Ich möchte Humanisten weltweit danken, insbesondere denen aus Australien und Neuseeland. Ich möchte Iain und Gaylene Middleton danken, die uns unglaublich unterstützt und uns täglich per E-Mail nach unseren Fortschritten und unserem Wohlbefinden gefragt haben.

Ich möchte auch den Humanisten aus den USA und Großbritannien danken, die den ganzen Unsinn und die Verleumdungskampagnen durchschaut und uns fest zur Seite gestanden haben, als wir uns mit einer der anspruchsvollsten und geistig anstrengendsten Kampagnen auseinandersetzten, die ich je unternommen habe.

Natürlich möchte ich unseren humanistischen Mitgliedern in Nigeria meinen Dank aussprechen. Viele von ihnen haben die Fehlinformationen durchschaut, mir beigestanden, mich ermutigt, angerufen, um nachzufragen, und unsere Bemühungen auf jede erdenkliche Weise unterstützt.

Ich möchte mich auch beim Anwaltsteam bedanken. Ich bin stolz, James meinen Freund nennen zu dürfen. Er hat ein engagiertes Anwaltsteam zusammengestellt, das uns geholfen hat, diese komplexe und herausfordernde Situation zu meistern.

Ich möchte allen danken, die im Hintergrund unermüdlich gearbeitet haben. Ich kenne vielleicht nicht alle Namen, aber ich weiß, dass viele Menschen hinter den Kulissen eine entscheidende Rolle dabei spielten, unseren Erfolg sicherzustellen – dass Mubarak freigelassen wurde und heute ein freier Mann ist.

Ich bin auch den Vorstandsmitgliedern von Humanists International zutiefst dankbar. Damals war ich noch nicht im Vorstand, wurde aber später selbst Mitglied. Schon vorher haben sie mich in den schwierigsten Momenten der Kampagne unterstützt und mir Mut zugesprochen. Ihnen bin ich auf ewig dankbar.

Ich werde weiterhin nach Möglichkeiten suchen, etwas zurückzugeben – unsere Bewegung zu unterstützen und sicherzustellen, dass wir sowohl als Gemeinschaft als auch als globale Kraft des Guten weiter wachsen.

Und ja, Scott, ich möchte dir auch für deine Zeit und die Plattform danken, die du mir zur Verfügung gestellt hast, um diese Botschaft zu teilen. Wir sollten weiterhin solche Räume haben, um unsere Stimme zu erheben, nicht nur als Gemeinschaft, sondern als globale Bewegung.

Jacobsen: Vielen Dank und ich wünsche Ihnen einen schönen Resttag. Ich gehe jetzt ins Bett.

Igwe: Ja, und dir auch. Gute Nachtruhe.

Jacobsen: Das weiß ich zu schätzen.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

“Chantal McKinney Explains Why Faith Can Survive Without the Church”

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): chantalmckinney.com

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/04/01


Jacobsen:
And for individuals who are not in positions of authority, what is at stake? Why should they care about the persistence of these dynamics within church life?

McKinney: Some people may already recognize these issues that persist in the church, while others may feel disconnected from them. However, many individuals remain silent about their experiences because of stigma. There is often a perception that speaking out about harm will damage the church’s mission or reputation.

For example, public figures such as Dolores Huerta (co-founder of United Farm Workers) have spoken about remaining silent in the past to avoid harming the mission they were a part of. This reflects a wider pattern in which individuals suppress their experiences out of concern for institutions and organizations.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

How Inna Sergiyenko Built Ukraine’s Autism Movement Through Conferences, Inclusion, and Evidence-Based Support

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Child with Future Foundation

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/05/16

By Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Ira Sergiyenko (Translation, Ukrainian-English)

Inna Sergiyenko is a Ukrainian autism advocate, educator, and founder connected with Child with Future, a Kyiv-based initiative supporting children with developmental disabilities and their families. Motivated by her son’s autism diagnosis in Israel, she helped establish a preschool model integrating education, developmental services, and specialist support in one setting. Her work expanded into broader advocacy for autism awareness, disability rights, parent support, and improved professional training and service coordination across Ukraine over many years.

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen speaks with Inna Sergiyenko about building a national autism movement in Ukraine through lectures, conferences, partnerships, and evolving educational support. Inna Sergiyenko explains how international knowledge, local parent organizations, online outreach, and evidence-based training strengthened services for autistic children, teenagers, and adults. She also discusses inclusion, accessibility, university support, and why preparation is essential before autistic students enter mainstream classrooms with confidence and meaningful long-term success.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: As your work expanded, how did you begin building a broader national movement, and what role did international conferences and public lectures play in that process?

Inna Sergiyenko: At that time, we were in the process of building a broader movement. We began attending international conferences to gain knowledge and experience that were not yet available in Ukraine, and we brought that knowledge back to support families and professionals.

Around 2013, I started traveling across Ukraine to deliver lectures on autism. These lectures helped raise awareness and share practical knowledge with parents, educators, and specialists.

Among the most influential events were conferences organized by Autism Europe, which provided valuable insights for both parents and practitioners, and INSAR, which is a more research-focused, science-driven conference based primarily in the United States.

Together, these conferences offered a balance between practical, community-oriented knowledge and scientific research. This combination allowed us to bring both evidence-based practices and accessible support strategies back to Ukraine.

As we expanded our work, we also helped parents establish local organizations in different regions. These groups often collaborated with us, relied on shared knowledge, and contributed to building a unified national movement around autism advocacy.

In 2019, when it became more difficult to travel and hold in-person lectures, we shifted to online platforms. At that time, many people in Ukraine were active on Facebook, so we organized educational livestreams to continue outreach and training.

We invited international speakers to participate. One of them was Bill Peters, an autistic American who volunteered with us and shared his lived experience. At that time, there were very few openly autistic adults in Ukraine who were both diagnosed and willing to speak publicly, so his contribution was particularly valuable.

We also hosted Stephen Shore, an autistic professor at Adelphi University in the United States, known internationally for his work in special education and autism advocacy. His participation provided both professional and personal perspectives that were highly impactful.

Regarding the Markovich family, they remain involved in supporting the organization. The institution now has a director responsible for its daily operations, while ongoing efforts focus on maintaining sponsorships and partnerships that help reduce costs for families and sustain access to services.

Jacobsen: How have your partnerships, sponsors, and institutional allies helped sustain the preschool and broaden your work on inclusion and accessibility?

Sergiyenko: They also help us find sponsors. As we noted earlier, maintaining a high standard of services in our preschool makes it expensive, and not all parents can afford the full cost.

With the support of Inna and Yonattan Markovich, we are able to secure sponsorships that make the program more accessible to families. The preschool is financially self-sustaining in the sense that it does not generate profit and is supported through tuition and donor contributions rather than external investment.

Dr. Genevieve Bassey, who played an important role in the early development of the preschool, helped us structure and organize our programs. The Markovich family was also instrumental in securing the building. Without their involvement, it would have been difficult to obtain the facility.

We also collaborate with a number of partners working in inclusion and accessibility. One notable collaboration was with Marina Poroshenko, who, during her time as First Lady, actively promoted inclusive education. We worked alongside her initiatives to support schools, provide training, and expand understanding of how to work with children with special educational needs.

Inclusion is a broad and complex area, and our work has included advocacy, public education, and direct training for educators and institutions. With the current First Lady, the focus has shifted somewhat toward broader accessibility issues. Where relevant, we continue to provide expertise and guidance.

Our work has also expanded beyond children. We now address the needs of autistic adults, both in our educational programs and in our outreach. Our lectures and training initiatives increasingly include topics related to adulthood, independence, and social integration.

For example, we have participated in training programs for service sectors such as banking, where multiple experts present on different types of disabilities. In these settings, we contribute by explaining the experiences of autistic adults and offering practical recommendations on how institutions can make their services more accessible.

Jacobsen: How has your work evolved as autistic children grow older, particularly in terms of socialization, adolescence, university support, and the need for reliable public information?

Sergiyenko: We also developed a project for schoolchildren and teenagers called Kids Autism Games. It began as an initiative focused on socialization through sports, but it has since expanded beyond that.

As children grow older, particularly after the age of ten, their need for social interaction becomes more complex. We created this project to provide structured social activities through sports, which offer a predictable and supportive environment for autistic children and teenagers.

Over time, the project grew to include not only sports events but also broader social activities. We partnered with various organizations, including Sport for Peace.

Before the war, the project also included additional programs such as IT classes, where participants learned computer skills, and music classes. Due to the war, some of these activities were suspended. However, the sports component continues. Our participants still attend regular events and take part in activities such as marathons, which they participated in before the war and have now resumed.

As our participants grow older, we are expanding our services to meet their changing needs. Initially, our focus was on early intervention and young children, as that was where the greatest demand existed. However, those children are now becoming teenagers and young adults.

We are now working to ensure that autistic individuals receive support at all stages of life. In particular, we are focusing on higher education. As more autistic students reach university age, we are exploring ways to collaborate with Ukrainian universities to provide appropriate support systems.

My goal is to ensure that autistic students in Ukraine can receive support comparable to what is available in institutions such as the University of Edinburgh, where my son studies.

Another challenge we now face is the shift from a lack of information to an overabundance of it. When we began, there was very little reliable information about autism in Ukraine. Today, there is a large amount of information available, but not all of it is accurate.

We continue to focus on providing evidence-based information and guidance to families. Even during the war, we organized an online conference to share knowledge and support. The materials were recorded and made freely available on YouTube so that parents who have recently received a diagnosis can access reliable information.

Jacobsen: How have conferences and your broader educational work shaped your approach to inclusion, especially your view that autistic children need preparation before entering mainstream classrooms?

Sergiyenko: Conferences have become an important part of our work. Initially, we organized small, focused conferences in Ukraine, often centered on specific methods or approaches, where specialists and parents could learn practical skills.

In 2019, before the COVID-19 pandemic, we held our first major international event, the International Practical Autism Conference (IPAC). We invited specialists from different countries, and the conference was highly successful.

During the pandemic and later during the war, we continued this work by organizing two additional IPAC conferences online. These allowed us to maintain knowledge-sharing and professional development despite the circumstances.

We are now exploring the possibility of returning to in-person conferences. Due to safety concerns, we are considering hosting the next IPAC in a neighboring country, such as Hungary or Czechia.

Another important issue we have encountered relates to inclusion. While inclusion in mainstream education is essential, it must be implemented carefully. Not every child is immediately ready to enter an inclusive classroom, particularly children with autism who may face challenges with sensory processing, communication, and social interaction.

Preparation is critical. Children need to understand classroom routines, expectations, and social dynamics in order to benefit from an inclusive environment. Without this preparation, inclusion can become stressful and counterproductive.

We have observed that some professionals and parents advocate for immediate inclusion without sufficient preparation. In such cases, children may struggle significantly, leading to distress, behavioral challenges, and regression rather than progress.

At our preschool, we aim to prepare children step by step. We focus on building the skills they need, and once we see that a child is ready, we encourage parents to transition them into mainstream kindergarten or school. The goal is not to keep children in specialized settings longer than necessary, but to support them until they can succeed in a broader educational environment.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Inna.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Why the West Must Help Ukraine Win, Not Merely Survive

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): EUROPESAYS

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/08/31

Dimitri Vasylev is a Ukrainian political consultant, analyst, public communications specialist, and musician. He leads the Research Agency for Development and Analysis (RADA), where his work spans political analysis, governance, development, and public communication. Born in Kyiv during the Soviet era, Vasylev served in the Soviet Army before embracing a stronger Ukrainian identity. Since Russia’s full-scale invasion, he has paired volunteer work with music, producing three albums intended to strengthen Ukrainian culture, resilience, and national identity.

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen speaks with Vasylev about the West’s evolving understanding of Russia’s war, the democratic world’s failure to act with unity, and the imperial assumptions that continue to shape Russian political culture. Vasylev argues that Ukraine’s defeat would reverberate far beyond its borders and that Western governments must provide enough military support to secure victory, rather than merely prevent collapse. He also assesses the contributions of the United States, Britain, Germany, the Netherlands, Poland, Turkey, and other partners, while warning that renewed attacks on Ukraine’s energy infrastructure could drive further displacement during the winter.

Dimitri Vasylev
(via Facebook)

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Since the full-scale invasion, how has commentary across the democratic world—including in countries such as Japan and South Korea—changed as the scale of Russian aggression has become clearer? And how has public opinion shaped government support for humanitarian relief, reconstruction, and military assistance?

Dimitri Vasylev: What has changed is that they understand the full scope of the risks for the future of this world if Ukraine loses because, if Ukraine loses, democracy loses.

But they don’t understand what they can do. We are at a stage of extreme uncertainty. What should be done? How should it be done? When should it be done? By what means should it be done?

A great level of uncertainty is combined with a great lack of unity because no leader can bring this democratic world together. Usually, it was America. But now, in my view, America is damaging itself and its democratic partners in many ways.

Jacobsen: Freedom House has now documented 20 consecutive years of decline in global freedom. Democratic progress has always come in waves, but a two-decade retreat is difficult to dismiss as a temporary downturn.

Vasylev: May I make a little remark?

Jacobsen: Please—go ahead.

Vasylev: On what you’re saying, the problem with democracy is that many different societies in the democratic world understand democracy in slightly different ways. When you ask Americans what democracy is, it may be a totally different answer from what you will hear from people in Portugal, Italy, Norway, Canada, Japan, Australia, and many other places.

Over about 80 years of more or less comfortable times, economic growth, and development, people spoke about democracy with less clarity about what they were actually talking about and experiencing. So people went in different directions, I guess, in many ways.

There is no crystal-clear common understanding of what democracy is about, especially what democratic practice is. Practicing democracy matters most. Comparing democratic practices is perhaps something for the future, to clarify what works.

It doesn’t matter how long you live without war or without attacks on democracy from the outside world. Democracy can still be in crisis. The main crisis is in people’s heads because, in my view, they no longer clearly understand what democracy is about.

Jacobsen: If Vladimir Putin dies, is removed from power, or otherwise leaves office, is Russia’s present political culture likely to produce a similar leader, someone even more hostile to democratic values, or a figure capable of leading the country away from permanent confrontation?

Vasylev: Russian people, no matter where they are, what their level of intelligence and education is, or what they’re doing in their lives, often have a common understanding of Russian primacy. In my view, this is deeply embedded in Russian political culture and characterizes its imperialistic dimension.

It doesn’t matter what their education is or what their individual intentions are, whether people call them good Russians or bad Russians. They are still, to some extent, shaped by this political and historical environment.

And the shape of Russia as it exists now is, in my view, a permanent threat to democracy, to the future, and to Russian people themselves.

Because what we have now is based on an imperial idea. And this empire has to end. If it doesn’t end, the world will continue to face problems with Russia in many ways.

You also have to understand that, in my view, over the last 25 years, Russian authorities and affiliated actors have used corruption, financial influence, and other means to influence people and institutions in democratic countries.

All this money that went into democratic countries was, in my view, often used for corruption to influence people’s thinking, decisions, policies, and willingness to fight for democratic values. The financial cheque became much more important than democratic values. This is one way Russia operates. They corrupt people’s minds.

And Russian people, whether someone calls them good Russians or bad Russians, are also affected by this corrupted political environment. Russia will continue trying to influence the minds of people in European countries, their leaders, America, and the democratic world.

I will give you an example, Scott, while you’re thinking or reflecting on that—just an example to support what I’ve said.

Let’s go back to 1992. I had just finished my military service in the Soviet Army. I was demobilized and came back to Kyiv, but then I went to Moscow to visit my friends because I had a lot of them there. It was a great community of people and friends.

I went to the Pushkin State Museum of Fine Arts in Moscow. It’s a great museum, with great art and a special community of highly educated people around it.

I was talking to a kind lady who was about 45 years old. I was about 21 then. We had a nice, intelligent conversation, and she asked me where I was from. I said, “From Kyiv.”

Her eyes changed immediately. I saw anger in her eyes. I saw eyes that suddenly held little understanding, and she said, “Ah, it was you who broke our country.”

So she was one of those “good Russians” who was unhappy about the destruction of the empire. It didn’t matter what education she had. It didn’t matter where she was. It didn’t matter that she was surrounded by the art and beauty of this world in this museum.

We had had a very nice human conversation, but all of a sudden she was not simply an individual. In that moment, she became a representative of her empire and of imperial thinking. So that’s what I mean when I talk about Russia.

Jacobsen: Putin famously described the collapse of the Soviet Union as the “greatest geopolitical catastrophe of the twentieth century.”

Vasylev: Read the recent article by Valerii Zaluzhnyi in The New Voice of Ukraine. He wrote it in connection with the 35th anniversary of Ukrainian independence, and it’s a pretty hard piece.

He reminds everybody about Vladimir Putin’s view of what happened in 1991. Putin famously described the collapse of the Soviet Union as the greatest geopolitical catastrophe of the twentieth century.

But Zaluzhnyi describes what happened differently. He calls the collapse of the Soviet Union the twentieth century’s greatest geostrategic turning point. He talks about the collapse of an empire.

And when we’re talking about the collapse of an empire, you understand that this is a natural historical process. Empires rise and collapse. We accept and understand that.

But the problem with Putin and, in my view, with a large part of Russian society is that they consider what happened in 1991 a mistake. And usually, when you’re thinking about a mistake, a mistake is something you can repair, yes? That’s why many Russians still think it’s possible to reverse what happened, because they see 1991 as a geopolitical mistake.

Jacobsen: Is the implied logic that supporting Ukraine is also an act of democratic self-preservation—that the West is ultimately acting for its own good?

Vasylev: Yes. Actually, what you’re doing is supporting us.

Macro-financial support is important, extremely important, for our survival and resistance. Military support is important for our survival and existence.

But, in my view, you’re not doing enough when I talk about the Western world and the democratic community of this planet.

Because you’re doing it at approximately the level necessary for us not to lose, you have to help us win. Because you’re still afraid Russia will collapse. But you don’t have to be afraid of that. For the sake of the future of the democratic community, you should not regard the possible collapse of the Russian imperial system as something that must be prevented at any cost.

That’s what you’re afraid of. And, in my view, that’s a big mistake by the Western democratic community.

Jacobsen: Which countries have been the unsung heroes of Ukraine’s defense and recovery? Turkey, for example, has played an important role in reconstruction and other forms of support.

Vasylev: Actually, there are many countries involved in reconstruction and recovery. Of course, large-scale reconstruction will continue after the war, but right now there is also reconstruction, recovery, repair, and maintenance that allow us to survive and continue.

But the most important thing is to stop the destruction. To stop the destruction, you need more military support.

When you’re talking about Turkey, of course, you had those famous Bayraktar drones at the beginning of the full-scale war. They helped us.

The military equipment we received from the United States at the beginning was also extremely important in helping us stop the Russians. So I would call many countries heroes.

Definitely, the United States, regardless of which administration is in power now, has played a major role in helping us stop Russia and continue to fight.

Great Britain, and Boris Johnson personally, also played an incredibly important political and historical role. Boris Johnson belongs to a British political tradition that includes figures who acted decisively during moments of crisis.

Boris Johnson is a chaotic thinker and sometimes a chaotic actor. But at the right time, at the right moment, he did the right things. What he did for Ukraine was right and important. And the governments after him have continued substantial support, including the present government. So Great Britain is one of the heroes.

Germany is a hero. They began very cautiously, including the famous early offer of helmets, but now we receive enormous support from Germany. Germany has become one of Ukraine’s largest providers of military, financial, humanitarian, and civilian assistance.

The Netherlands is helping a lot. When you’re talking about the scale of the country, I mean, it’s relatively small in terms of land and population, but it has a great economy, and it’s a strong democracy. The Netherlands is one of the heroes, I think. They understand what is going on here and are doing a great deal to help us defend ourselves and win.

You can continue. Many countries are involved, including France, Italy, Canada, and Poland.

Of course, right now we are going through a hectic, strange, and sometimes difficult period in relations between parts of Polish and Ukrainian society. Nevertheless, Poland has been extraordinarily important and helpful to Ukraine during this war, with a strong understanding of what could happen if Ukraine fails.

So I’m grateful to Poland, to the Polish nation, and to the Polish people for all the support they’ve provided, just as I’m grateful to many people throughout Europe and around the world.

Jacobsen: Looking ahead to winter, Russia is likely to continue targeting Ukraine’s electricity and heating systems. What should other countries expect, and what can they do to help ordinary Ukrainians withstand the cold and the disruption?

Vasylev: Other nations should expect that many people may try to leave Ukraine during the winter, especially when we’re talking about older people, women, and children.

That could place an additional burden on European countries regarding accommodation, public services, and social infrastructure. People have to live somewhere, stay somewhere, and receive basic services. That’s what I mean by stability.

In my experience, when Ukrainians come somewhere, most of them don’t cause problems. They bring solutions and hard work because Ukrainians are hardworking, smart, and educated people.

Of course, any nation has different people. Ukrainians are no exception. But when we’re talking about the nation more broadly, those are the characteristics I would emphasize.

But countries also need to understand that Ukraine could fail if it doesn’t receive sufficient support. And if Ukraine fails, the consequences will not remain within Ukraine’s borders.

In my view, Russia could then use the resources, territory, industrial capacity, and potentially even human resources of a defeated Ukraine in ways that would create much greater security risks for European and NATO countries.

So if you don’t want a much larger war and much greater problems in the future, you had better help Ukrainians win.

Jacobsen: This is not merely a rhetorical concern. Last winter, the United Nations recorded temperatures below minus 20 degrees Celsius in some areas as Russian attacks caused prolonged or intermittent power and heating outages.

Vasylev: Yes.

Jacobsen: Dimitri, thank you for your time.

Vasylev: Thank you.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Inside Jeffrey Epstein’s Ecosystem of Enabling

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Zoppoz

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/09/23

Irina Tsukerman is a New York-registered human rights and national security lawyer, geopolitical analyst, and journalist. She earned a B.A. in International/Intercultural Studies and Middle East Studies from Fordham University in 2006 and a J.D. from Fordham University School of Law in 2009. She is president of Scarab Rising, Inc., editor-in-chief of The Washington Outsider, and fellow of the Jerusalem Center for Security and Foreign Affairs and the Arabian Peninsula Institute. Her work focuses on foreign policy, information warfare, security, and Middle Eastern affairs. She serves as Written Content Vice Chair of the American Bar Association’s Science and Technology Committee.

Dr. Amos Guiora is a Professor of Law (Lecturer) at the University of Utah’s S.J. Quinney College of Law. His research examines institutional complicity, bystanders, enablers, international law, and counterterrorism. He leads the Bystander Initiative and advocates accountability for individuals and institutions that enable sexual abuse and fail to protect victims.

In this interview, based on The Washington Outsider Center for Information report “Shadow Networks: A Longitudinal Investigation of Transnational Influence, Organized Crime, and Political Access in the United States,” Scott Douglas Jacobsen speaks with Amos Guiora and Irina Tsukerman about Jeffrey Epstein’s network and the institutions and individuals that enabled it. Their discussion examines elite access, professional ethics, failures of oversight, and the obstacles to accountability, while carefully separating documented misconduct from unresolved questions about blackmail, personal motives, and what Epstein’s associates knew about the abuse.

A photo of a foot with a line from ‘Lolita,’ which the Epstein estate provided to Congress
A photo of a foot with a line from ‘Lolita,’ which the Epstein estate provided to Congress. (House Oversight Committee Democrats)

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Thank you both for joining me. The phrase “elite trafficking” can describe at least two distinct phenomena: powerful people gaining access to trafficking victims, and sophisticated systems used to recruit, move, and exploit those victims. How should we understand the social hierarchies within Epstein’s network and the methods that sustained the abuse?

Dr. Amos Guiora: Thanks for having me. As I work on a co-authored law review article with one of my law students, Lizzie Maldonado, we have interacted with a number of subject matter experts on exactly what you’re asking about: what I call the “ecosystem of enabling.” We’re looking at the relationship between Epstein’s social and professional networks and his exploitation of girls and young women. The word “currency” has been offered to us as a way to describe how victims were treated within that ecosystem.

There are documented associations involving people such as Bill Gates, Bill Clinton, and Brad Karp, although the nature of those associations differs. Gates met with Jeffrey Epstein, and Clinton traveled on his aircraft. Those facts do not establish that they visited every property, witnessed abuse, or participated in trafficking. Karp was then chairman of Paul, Weiss, a global law firm. He resigned as chairman in February 2026 after disclosures about his communications with Epstein, while remaining at the firm.

There is also evidence of cameras inside Epstein’s home, including verified footage from a camera in the living room of his Palm Beach residence. However, that does not establish that he had cameras everywhere, that every visitor was recorded, or that everyone knew they were being recorded.

I don’t think you can assume that everybody associated with Epstein was, to use a term I dislike, a beneficiary of sexual gratification. Association alone does not establish participation in sexual abuse.

My interpretation is that some people saw opportunities for personal connections, professional advancement, and developing their networks. Epstein had what has been described to Lizzie and me as “sparkle.” Again, that’s not my word. Through that glamour and sparkle, he was able to attract the so-called rich and powerful.

Kathryn Ruemmler, who later became Goldman Sachs’s chief legal officer and general counsel, also had a documented relationship with Epstein. Her interactions with him preceded her employment at Goldman Sachs, which she joined in 2020.

In my analysis, men and women alike could see benefits in associating with Epstein, while girls and young women were treated as currency within his abusive operation. But I want to emphasize that this is an interpretation of the ecosystem, not evidence that every associate interacted sexually with victims or knew about the abuse.

Being in Epstein’s circle, or circles, may have been seen by some people as beneficial. For me, the enabling question concerns what people knew, what they witnessed, and how they responded. If someone witnessed signs of abuse or exploitation and turned a blind eye, that is the kind of conduct I am examining. We cannot assume that every visitor encountered visibly underage victims or understood what was happening.

That, to me, is how an ecosystem of enabling can operate, with devastating harm to victims.

To return to your question, there is evidence of an organized operation. The 2019 federal indictment alleged that Epstein used employees and associates to arrange encounters with underage girls and paid some victims to recruit others. Those charges were not tried because he died before trial.

That is the context in which I use the phrase “elite sex trafficking.” Again, it is not my phrase; credit belongs to others.

For me, in focusing on enabling and enablers, Epstein’s case presents an ecosystem that is critical to examine. One more comment, and then I’ll stop. My argument is for broader accountability for people who facilitate abuse. Some have already been prosecuted: Ghislaine Maxwell was convicted in 2021 and sentenced to 20 years in prison in 2022 for her role in Epstein’s abuse of minors. My concern is that enabling will continue without further accountability because they may believe they will face no consequences, and that is tragic from the victim’s perspective.

Jeffrey Epstein with Donald Trump
Jeffrey Epstein with Donald Trump. (House Oversight Committee Democrats)

Irina Tsukerman: There is something about all of this that I have been struggling with since I started following the story, certainly by the time I began addressing Epstein’s modus operandi in the report we published. Two things. First, the sparkle that made Epstein so glamorous: what exactly made this individual with such an opaque background so desirable? Eventually, it was his access to powerful structures and individuals. But how did he gain that access, and why was he considered so successful when these powerful people could have performed similar networking functions without him?

Why was he allowed to build such an extensive network that some people appeared to regard him as indispensable? Was that really what drew people to him? Was it the perception that he was influential and knew all the right people?

Could they not have achieved the same results through other well-connected people who did not have the same baggage? The other question concerns the terms on which people interacted with Epstein. They could have communicated by email or met in professional settings, including their offices. They did not have to go to his house.

One possibility I think deserves examination is whether some people were attracted to something they perceived as illicit, exclusive, or taboo. But visiting his house does not, by itself, establish that motive or knowledge of abuse.

For others, there is the question of whether they felt pressure to accept conditions in order to obtain what they wanted from Epstein and his network. Did any of those relationships involve expectations of complicity, comparable to participating in illegal activity to demonstrate loyalty within an organized criminal group? That is a question requiring evidence, not something we can assume about his associates.

This is the element that I think has not been sufficiently established or examined. Much of the discussion has focused on powerful and influential people abusing their power and status, including through psychological and sexual abuse. But I think there may be more to examine.

Jeffrey Epstein with Noam Chomsky
Jeffrey Epstein with Noam Chomsky. (House Oversight Committee Democrats)

Guiora: The Bill Gateses, Bill Clintons, and Brad Karps of the world have their own elite circles. So does Kathryn Ruemmler, who later became Goldman Sachs’s chief legal officer and general counsel. These are people with access to highly influential networks.

I’m not a psychologist. I’m the son of a late psychologist and the father of a psychologist, but I am not a psychologist. I wonder about this need, if that’s the right word, to be with one another in this super-exclusive, extraordinarily elite world. Irina’s question about that attraction is worth examining.

My concern is with people who witnessed abuse or warning signs and turned a blind eye. I don’t know another expression in polite English. Where that happened, it means overlooking something beyond troubling. The victims included underage girls.

Some of these people also have children. Even without getting into the extensive correspondence and other records, the question of what someone physically present witnessed and understood is, to me, extraordinary. But physical presence alone does not establish knowledge of abuse.

That’s why, for me, anyone whose conduct meets the legal requirements for criminal responsibility should be held accountable for enabling abuse. We need evidence of each person’s actions and knowledge. Irina’s point about examining the dynamics of these relationships is well taken.

Bill Gates from Epstein photo dump
(House Oversight Committee Democrats)

Jacobsen: In our earlier discussions of cults, we examined Keith Raniere and NXIVM. Within DOS, the secret group Raniere led, members were required to provide compromising material as proof of commitment. The group called it “collateral.”

That collateral included sexually explicit photographs and potentially damaging claims about members or their loved ones, some of them fabricated. It was then used to enforce obedience and discourage members from leaving or exposing the group.

Is there evidence that entry into Epstein’s network came with comparable conditions, or that compromising material was used to secure loyalty in a way resembling DOS’s collateral system?

Guiora: The girls, I hate to talk like this. As I mentioned, some people describe the girls as “currency.” Others have used the word “transactional.” Scott, as someone who writes about international law, conflict, terrorism, and counterterrorism, I also think about the term “collateral damage.”

Were the girls treated as collateral damage to business transactions, to a senior partner at law firm A meeting a senior partner at law firm B and bringing in more business? Were their interests and safety disregarded while others pursued those relationships?

It’s an awful analogy, but it captures the disregard for the harm done to them. They were, however, direct victims of abuse and exploitation, not merely incidental casualties.

Jacobsen: There appear to be two distinct possibilities. One is that victims’ welfare was disregarded while powerful people pursued their own interests. The other is that evidence placing victims with elite individuals, particularly men, could have been used as leverage if those individuals threatened to speak out. What evidence would be needed to distinguish between those possibilities and establish that compromising material was actually used as leverage?

Guiora: In international humanitarian law, incidental civilian harm is recognized as a possible consequence of attacks on military objectives. The law does not set a fixed numerical limit, such as 10 people here or 15 people there. It prohibits attacks expected to cause civilian harm excessive in relation to the concrete and direct military advantage anticipated. It also requires all feasible precautions to avoid or minimize civilian harm.

That is a legal framework for armed conflict, not for Epstein’s crimes. The girls must be understood unequivocally as victims. In the metaphorical sense we’re discussing, their welfare was treated as secondary to other people’s transactions. That, in polite English, is beyond damning. Irina?

Tsukerman: The possibility I’m raising is whether victims were also exploited to create blackmail material. That would mean the abuse served not only the sexual desires of perpetrators but also a mechanism of control.

Was compromising material used to keep particular people in Epstein’s orbit, prevent disclosures, or protect others involved? That is the hypothesis I think deserves examination. It is not established that everyone in his orbit was blackmailed or participated in abuse.

Jacobsen: In other words, the theory depends on whether Epstein possessed compromising photographs or similar material and used it as leverage?

Tsukerman: Yes, if such material existed and was used that way. The comparison I’m considering is with groups in which sexual activity becomes a means of establishing power, enforcing loyalty, and creating shared exposure to damaging revelations.

But we cannot conclude that Epstein controlled everyone who associated with him or that everything worked exactly as he planned.

From a psychological perspective, what fascinates me is the question of why a powerful person would knowingly accept that vulnerability. Apart from the ethical horror of participating in abuse, why would someone commanding enormous resources allow another person to acquire compromising leverage over them?

Would access to contacts and proximity to power be worth the possibility of exposure, prosecution where crimes were committed, reputational damage, or losing a business? One disclosure could threaten an entire network.

We cannot know that none of these people asked themselves those questions. But where someone knowingly accepted such risks, I want to understand why their self-interest did not stop them. How could someone who was manipulative, charming, or useful acquire that much influence over people who already possessed considerable power? At the end of the day…

Jacobsen: Keith Raniere, whom I do not find particularly charismatic, nevertheless attracted enormous financial backing from Clare and Sara Bronfman, heirs to the Seagram fortune. Reports estimate that their spending and losses connected with Raniere and NXIVM exceeded $150 million. That is not the same as a finding that he personally swindled them out of that exact sum, but it illustrates the scale of their involvement. What does that case suggest about how destructive figures gain the loyalty of people with wealth, status, and ostensibly far more power than they possess?

Guiora: I think some of these people may have viewed themselves as untouchable. My hypothesis is that, where people possessed compromising information about one another, they could have felt protected by mutual vulnerability. Person X might have expected Person Y to remain silent because disclosure could also harm Person Y or Person Z.

That would be a self-protecting network in which people understood the risks. But we cannot assume that this describes everyone associated with Epstein.

There is evidence of cameras at Epstein’s properties. We cannot establish that every visitor saw them or knew about concealed cameras. My assumption is that visible cameras could have suggested the possibility of surveillance elsewhere, but that remains an inference about what particular people might have understood.

And I remind you that Epstein pleaded guilty in Florida in 2008 to state offences involving procuring a minor for prostitution and soliciting prostitution. His federal non-prosecution agreement and the leniency of his treatment are a separate conversation. People who associated with him after that conviction were dealing with someone whose criminal history was publicly documented, although that does not establish what each person knew.

The dynamic I’m describing is one of self-protection. If I’m a senior partner or another influential person, I might avoid antagonizing someone because I fear consequences for myself. It’s all about me. In that context, I pursue another business transaction while disregarding signs that someone else is being exploited.

I hate this language, but that is what the terms “currency,” “transactional,” and “collateral” are trying to capture: treating a girl as an instrument of someone else’s interests rather than as a person.

That connects with Irina’s point about whether people involved in wrongdoing had a shared interest in preventing disclosure. But we need evidence before concluding that particular individuals were involved or protecting one another.

Steve Bannon with Jeffrey Epstein
Steve Bannon with Jeffrey Epstein. (House Oversight Committee Democrats)

Jacobsen: Could this be understood as a kind of family bound together by mutual protection?

Tsukerman: Groupthink taken to an extreme is one possible way of understanding that dynamic: being unwilling to question the status quo because of who else is involved. Wanting to fit in, avoid unwanted attention, prevent questions about your loyalty, and continue getting what you want.

But many billionaires, powerful people, and celebrities were not part of Epstein’s network. That raises the question of whether there were common characteristics among those who became closely involved.

I’m distinguishing casual acquaintances, whose names might appear in Epstein-related records because of ordinary professional interactions, from people who maintained sustained relationships with him. Even then, a sustained relationship does not by itself establish participation in abuse.

How did he identify people to cultivate? Was blackmail involved in any particular relationship from the outset, or did compromising leverage develop later? Those possibilities require evidence.

Or was there an element of self-selection? Did some people respond because they were attracted to what he offered and were prepared to overlook concerns to maintain access? That is another possibility worth examining.

Jacobsen: It may eventually be possible to map the network in layers. One might include people who sought Epstein out and developed direct relationships with him. Another might consist of those introduced through established associates or peripheral acquaintances.

What could such a map reveal about how these relationships formed, what participants knew, and how information moved through the network? And given that some of the people involved are elderly or deceased, how much of that structure can the surviving record realistically recover?

Guiora: There may also have been a third tier: people who wanted to join but were not admitted to the circle.

Jacobsen: I am less interested in who wanted to join than in what happened after someone was rejected. How might rejection have shaped that person’s perception of the network’s risks, or their willingness to disclose what they knew?

Tsukerman: Those people could potentially provide useful information to law enforcement, especially if rejection made them willing to speak. Having an axe to grind would also make corroborating their accounts essential.

Guiora: Irina, one of the questions we’re addressing in the article concerns decisions by law enforcement officials. We’re researching that because there is a lot of material available. But I’m careful about the distinction between what you read and what you can substantiate in writing.

Jacobsen: The case plainly involved documented failures. How should we assess where poor judgment or institutional breakdown ended and possible deliberate obstruction began?

Tsukerman: Failures or deliberate failures? Was it incompetence, poor judgment, or improper influence? Did any officials benefit from relationships that affected their decisions? Those are different explanations, and allegations of corruption require evidence.

Jacobsen: Any claim that someone offered benefits in exchange for a decision not to prosecute would require evidence. Given the network’s size and the number of unanswered questions, what standards should investigators and journalists use to separate plausible lines of inquiry from speculation?

Guiora: There are multiple layers of involvement here. You have to ask why particular people maintained these relationships. I understand the potential attraction of professional and business connections. But the interests involved could extend beyond that.

Again, I emphasize that association with Epstein does not establish that someone participated in sexual abuse. Different people had different relationships with him.

Tsukerman: Can I give you an example from a separate situation involving journalistic boundaries? I’m not suggesting an Epstein connection. Jay Solomon, a former Wall Street Journal foreign affairs correspondent, was dismissed in 2017 over ethical violations involving his relationships with sources.

One source was Farhad Azima, an Iranian-American aviation businessman who hosted him aboard his yacht near Monaco. This was not a case of Emirati royals hosting him on their yachts.

Solomon later wrote about it in Columbia Journalism Review. He acknowledged serious mistakes in managing the relationship and described how access to an unfamiliar world of wealth and influential contacts blurred professional boundaries. He denied entering business with Azima or benefiting financially from his dealings, while acknowledging that he accepted hospitality aboard the yacht.

The Journal said he had misled editors and engaged in impermissible interactions with sources. It also said its review found that the paper’s coverage had not been affected.

What interests me is the attraction of access: a journalist who usually observes that world from outside being welcomed into it.

Jacobsen: If someone obtained leverage over a journalist at The Wall Street Journal or The New York Times, that could create an opportunity to influence coverage or discourage scrutiny. What evidence would be necessary to show that such pressure affected reporting, rather than merely establishing that an ethically compromising relationship existed?

Tsukerman: That raises the question of whether proximity to powerful people contributed to failures to investigate Epstein despite warning signs. But journalists also played a crucial role in exposing his abuse and the institutions that supported him.

I gave an example in my report involving Joi Ito, the former director of the MIT Media Lab. He accepted Epstein’s financial support for the lab and investments in funds he controlled. He also served on the boards of The New York Times Company and the Knight Foundation. The Knight Foundation is distinct from the Knight First Amendment Institute at Columbia University.

Those financial relationships are documented, but we cannot establish his motivations solely from them. Nor does his position on the Times Company’s board establish that he influenced its reporting.

I wonder whether, in particular instances, journalists or institutions avoided scrutiny because they feared reputational damage from having welcomed someone like Epstein. Could professional relationships have influenced their judgment without direct payments? Those are questions requiring evidence, rather than grounds for assuming that journalists collectively hushed up the story.

Jacobsen: From personal experience, I know that journalists who enter controversial cases involving cults, megalomaniacs, or political power can face sustained harassment. The work brings practical headaches and a considerable emotional burden, and reporters sometimes need time to recover before taking on another difficult subject.

That strain can make pacing essential. At the same time, perceptions of risk are deeply subjective: prominence or exceptional talent does not guarantee sound judgment about personal vulnerability, and some people enter dangerous situations without appreciating the consequences.

Others speak out despite threats to their reputation or safety, even when powerful people would prefer their silence. The system Amos describes appears vulnerable to disclosure because so many participants may hold fragments of information.

Yet arrangements like this can persist when enough people decide that silence serves their interests. What enables some witnesses to break from that logic of mutual protection, even when they fully understand the risks?

Guiora: Look at the emails in which someone holding an extraordinarily prominent position sought Epstein’s advice about pursuing a romantic relationship with a woman he described as a mentee. Putting that in an email, apparently without anticipating that it could become public, is extraordinary to me.

The reported correspondence concerned an adult woman he described as a mentee. We should not assume she was then his student or that she reciprocated his interest.

These are people in exceptionally influential positions. There are people like me, relatively modest in standing, and then there are people operating at those levels. Men and women alike.

I wonder whether some assumed that their institutional standing protected them from consequences. What’s the television show? The Untouchables. I’m borrowing the title as a metaphor: the belief that nothing can happen to you.

Again, the words “collateral,” “currency,” and “transactional” describe the dehumanization we’re discussing. The harm caused to the girls and young women was devastating.

There is also an account we’re looking into concerning a physician treating an injured young woman at an Epstein property. The details need verification, including the patient’s age, the circumstances of the injury, and what the physician knew or asked. We cannot yet state that a female physician stitched a minor’s face without asking about her parents.

The question for our research is whether medical professionals encountered signs of abuse and, if so, how they responded.

Tsukerman: I wonder how many medical professionals had contact with Epstein or his victims, and what those encounters involved. The number cannot be inferred simply from the scale of his network.

Guiora: We are looking into accounts involving two or three medical professionals, without naming them here. There may be others, but that remains to be established. Contact alone does not demonstrate misconduct.

It’s an interconnected network. But I remind us that Alexander Acosta, the U.S. attorney whose office negotiated Epstein’s 2007 federal non-prosecution agreement, later became Trump’s secretary of labour. Epstein subsequently pleaded guilty to state charges in Florida in 2008. The Justice Department’s later review found that Acosta exercised poor judgment, although it did not find professional misconduct.

In my view, it was an extraordinarily lenient arrangement. Epstein was a convicted sex offender, and people who associated with him after 2008 had the opportunity to learn about that public record.

If someone then encountered signs of exploitation at his home, that should have raised serious questions. But what each person saw and knew must be established individually. Denial can be powerful, as can deliberate avoidance of uncomfortable information.

Tsukerman: Medical professionals would have had relevant knowledge and training to assess injuries and recognize possible signs of abuse. That makes their conduct worth examining, but it does not establish that every clinician involved recognized abuse or deliberately ignored it.

If a physician failed to respond appropriately to suspected abuse, that could raise questions about professional ethics, safeguarding, and applicable reporting obligations. Whether a particular physician violated those duties or incurred legal liability depends on the evidence and the rules governing that encounter.

Guiora: That is one of the things we’re looking into. We plan to contact licensing bodies to ask how they would assess such conduct, both retrospectively and in future cases. We’ve also begun examining those questions concerning attorneys.

Tsukerman: There’s another question concerning psychologists and other mental health professionals. Were any practitioners involved in controlling victims, discouraging disclosures, or portraying people who might speak out as psychologically unstable? That would require evidence; we cannot assume such a system existed.

If practitioners participated in that conduct, are they still practicing or holding influential positions? What mechanisms would allow complaints to be investigated? We cannot infer that they are involved in other undisclosed scandals. Wealthy clients can create conflicts and pressures, but professional responsibilities remain. A clinician’s obligations to a patient should not be displaced by the interests of a powerful person paying for treatment.

I also have concerns about cultural and political biases in professional organizations, including how the American Psychological Association addresses antisemitism and the experiences of Jewish practitioners and patients. Those concerns need to be examined through specific policies, incidents, and responses. They do not, by themselves, establish that the organization endorsed discriminatory practices or pseudoscientific theories.

Similarly, accounts from people who report feeling pressured or inadequately informed during gender-related care deserve careful investigation. Individual allegations must be assessed on their evidence, rather than treated as proof that transgender care as a whole violates ethical standards.

My broader question is how professional safeguards operate when clinicians work with exceptionally wealthy and influential people. Where oversight is weak, how do we identify misconduct and protect patients?

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Ukraine’s Corruption Debate Crosses Into Antisemitism

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Tech Viral News

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/09/09

“Antisemitism is discrimination, prejudice, hostility, or violence against Jews as Jews (or Jewish institutions as Jewish).” – Jerusalem Declaration on Antisemitism, 2021

“Antisemitism is a certain perception of Jews, which may be expressed as hatred toward Jews. Rhetorical and physical manifestations of antisemitism are directed toward Jewish or non-Jewish individuals and/or their property, toward Jewish community institutions and religious facilities.” – International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance

“Antisemitism consists of anti-Jewish beliefs, attitudes, actions or systemic conditions. It includes negative beliefs and feelings about Jews, hostile behaviour directed against Jews (because they are Jews), and conditions that discriminate against Jews and significantly impede their ability to participate as equals in political, religious, cultural, economic, or social life.” – The Nexus Document

These definitions offer distinct frameworks for understanding antisemitism, but they converge on a basic principle: prejudice begins when Jews are targeted as Jews or when Jewish institutions are treated as inherently suspect because they are Jewish.

Having lived in Ukraine for most of this year, I have encountered problems particular to a society at war alongside prejudices common to many countries. Among them is occasional hostility toward Jews as Jews and the assignment of collective responsibility to Jewish communities for the conduct of individuals. Such rhetoric sometimes emerges within Ukraine; at other times, Russian propagandists seize on it for their own purposes. Social media amplifies both. The controversy surrounding Iryna Mudra, a former deputy head of the Office of the President of Ukraine, and Rabbi Yonatan Benyamin Markovitch, the chief rabbi of Kyiv and head of Chabad-Lubavitch of Kyiv, offers a recent example. Both are Jewish.

Individual conduct and collective responsibility

Individuals remain individuals, even when they hold prominent titles or lead influential communities. Institutions carry obligations, and leaders may be judged for how they exercise authority. Rabbi Markovitch’s recent offer to act as a personal guarantor for Mudra in an anti-corruption case is therefore open to criticism. But criticism of that decision is not a license to attribute it to Jews collectively.

Mudra is among the suspects identified in a National Anti-Corruption Bureau of Ukraine and Specialized Anti-Corruption Prosecutor’s Office operation encompassing the “Forrest Gump” and “Themis” cases. NABU lists 12 suspects in connection with the operation. On August 25, the High Anti-Corruption Court ordered Mudra detained for 60 days while setting bail at UAH 20 million. NABU’s account also reiterated the constitutional presumption of innocence. Personal surety is an established, if sometimes controversial, mechanism in Ukrainian law.

Five facts matter here. Markovitch’s offer was lawful under Ukrainian criminal procedure. Mudra was one of 12 suspects, and Markovitch was one of three people who offered to serve as her guarantor. The offer did not amount to a judgment about her guilt or innocence. Its purpose was limited: to guarantee her compliance with procedural obligations, including appearing before investigators or the court when required. Finally, the judge determined that none of the three proposed guarantors was needed.

Those distinctions lead to the central issue. Antisemitism does not become legitimate political criticism simply because it attaches itself to a genuine political controversy.

Political criticism and the boundary of prejudice

Political disagreement is not merely permissible in a democracy; it is indispensable. Citizens have every right to scrutinize religious leaders, public officials, judicial decisions, and anti-corruption investigations. Antisemitic expression, however, remains indefensible, including when the controversy begins with the personal initiative of a religious leader.

This is not an attempt to adjudicate the merits of the corruption case. Ukraine’s political future belongs principally to its citizens. The issue here is the antisemitic rhetoric that accumulated around the case and the ease with which criticism of one person’s conduct became an indictment of an entire people.

For readers outside Ukraine, corruption scandals and the institutions created to combat them are politically sensitive and consequential features of contemporary Ukrainian public life. Yet the controversy involving Markovitch also raises a broader question: Where does criticism of individual moral agency end and collective blame begin? In some of the public commentary, that boundary was crossed almost immediately.

Recurring tropes and collective attribution

The documented reactions contain familiar antisemitic themes: collective guilt, ethnicization of political misconduct, accusations of divided loyalty, claims of Jewish control over the Ukrainian state, references to a “Jewish mafia,” depictions of Jews as foreign or nationally disloyal, stereotypes of greed and parasitism, and conspiracy theories about the survival of the Ukrainian nation.

What makes these claims antisemitic is straightforward. One rabbi’s decision is converted into a theory about Jews collectively. Two principles are therefore essential: an individual initiative must be distinguished from an institutional position, and antisemitism must be identified accurately if it is to be confronted effectively.

Rabbi Moshe Asman on individual responsibility

Speaking to RBC-Ukraine, Rabbi Moshe Asman, the Brodsky Synagogue-based chief rabbi of Ukraine, drew precisely that distinction: “Rabbi Markovich’s statement about his willingness to act as guarantor was his own initiative and does not represent the position of the Jewish community as a whole…I consider such mixing of roles erroneous and categorically do not support it…No action by an individual rabbi gives anyone the right to insult the Jewish people, spread antisemitic stereotypes, or blame an entire community. Replacing reasoned criticism with hatred based on nationality has nothing to do with justice…The law must be the same for everyone. Responsibility must be personal. Antisemitism cannot be justified in any way.”

Rabbinical authority and institutional pluralism

Asman was elected chief rabbi of Ukraine at a 2005 convention of the All-Ukrainian Jewish Congress. I found no public statements about the case from other prominent rabbinical leaders in Ukraine, including Rabbi Yaakov Dov Bleich, Rabbi Meir Stambler, and Rabbi Alexander Dukhovny.

Ukraine does not have a single centralized rabbinate led by one universally recognized chief rabbi. Its Jewish institutions are pluralistic, and their leaders represent different theological and organizational traditions. Markovitch’s personal decision cannot reasonably be treated as a position adopted by every Jewish leader, much less by every Jew in Ukraine.

The examples below document rhetoric that emerged around, or was later attached to, the Markovitch-Mudra controversy. They are not a representative sample of Ukrainian public opinion, nor do they establish that such views characterize Ukrainian society generally. They show how quickly a political dispute can be recast in ethnic and conspiratorial terms.

From political controversy to ethnic framing

As reported by PolitNavigator, Ukrainian political technologist Andriy Zolotaryov argued that Markovitch’s appearance could reinforce a perception that an “ethnic OPG,” or organized criminal group, had entrenched itself on Bankova. He warned that such ethnic framing could contribute to anti-Jewish pogroms. His remarks appear to present the ethnicization itself as dangerous and potentially conducive to violence.

Russian military blogger Yuri Kotenok went much further, describing Kyiv as captured by an “ethnic organized criminal group.” He portrayed Ukrainians as ruled by appointees rather than elected leaders, invoked the medieval Khazars, used an anti-Jewish epithet for President Volodymyr Zelensky, and caricatured Markovitch through references to sidelocks and Jewish speech. The passage assembles recognizable conspiracy tropes: Jewish collective control, foreignness, and Khazar mythology.

From individual action to a Jewish mafia narrative

One commenter on a Watchers.Media Facebook post wrote: “Jewish mafia! This is already the end, there is nowhere further to go! And against this background comes the statement that the Armed Forces of Ukraine are short $27 billion!”

Another claimed: “The Chief Rabbi of Kyiv’s support for Mudra is public support for the mafia by Kyiv’s Jewish community.” The logic moves from Markovitch’s individual act to the Kyiv Jewish community and then to collective support for “the mafia.”

The Minister’s Portfolio account on Telegram offered another example: “The Chabadniks are carving up Ukraine. Mindich, Zuckerman, Zelenskyy…Ukraine’s corruption mafia obviously has a particular ethnic affiliation.” Here again, alleged political wrongdoing becomes an ethnic characteristic.

Ethnic identity, political loyalty, and conspiracy

Another Facebook commenter invoked Hitler: “About the rabbi. And do not ask why one Austrian artist knew what to do in such cases…” An August 28 essay by Ihor Kahanets in Narodnyi Ohliadach distinguished political from ethnic Ukrainian identity. Kahanets described Zelensky, Markovitch, and Mudra as political Ukrainians but ethnic Jews, then questioned whether they could simultaneously be ethnic Ukrainians. The implication moves from identity to presumed political loyalty: Jewishness becomes evidence of governmental influence and mutual protection. A separate August 25 article placed Mudra within a purported transnational “parasitic” ruling stratum.

Social media amplification

Comments on Reddit offer further illustrations of how the case spread through social media, though, again, they are not representative of Ukrainian opinion: “Well, she [Mudra] certainly did not visit the synagogue empty-handed”; “Jews… that is what they are like…That is why they were driven out from everywhere”; “From the rabbi’s answer it became clear that he was the organizer of the crime”; and “So the attack was prepared from the synagogue?”

From inventories of identity to internal enemies

Pavlo Zhebrivskyi, a former Ukrainian parliamentarian and former head of the Donetsk regional military-civil administration, told Te News: “I have nothing against the Jewish people, because there are decent people among them.” He then catalogued Ukrainian leaders by Jewish identity and declared that, for such people, Ukrainians are “goyim, plebeians” and “enemies…much more fierce and bloody than the Muscovites, because they are internal enemies…the gravediggers of the Ukrainian nation.” He asserted that the country is run by an “organized criminal group, the mafia, non-Ukrainians in power, who rule the country during the war.” The insinuation is difficult to miss: Jewish Ukrainians are cast as non-Ukrainian by definition.

An older conspiratorial thread

The rhetoric did not originate with the Markovitch controversy. In 2019, Nikolai Voron alleged in CONT/Proza.ru that Jews “control the economy, the banking sector, transport, the legislative and information systems, and even shape ideology”; that “one of Ukraine’s ethnic minorities, the Jews, is in almost absolute power”; and that “Chabad chose Ukraine for a new Israel…to live here and become masters in Ukraine, to build a third Khazaria.” He also claimed that Jewish dominance of Ukraine’s business elite explained an alleged role in the 2014 Maidan uprising and that the United States had decided to transfer Ukraine “under the control of Israel.” The Markovitch affair supplied a new occasion for an old conspiracy theory.

The distinction between personal responsibility and collective blame

Across these examples, the recurring operation is not criticism of the decision to offer surety. As Asman stressed, that decision was Markovitch’s individual initiative. The antisemitic turn comes when criticism of one rabbi’s choice becomes an accusation against Jews as Jews, precisely the boundary identified by the Jerusalem Declaration, the IHRA definition, and the Nexus Document.

Individual Jewish identities and distinct Jewish institutions are collapsed into a single explanatory collective, then assigned responsibility for real or imagined wrongdoing. Substitute Christians, Muslims, Roma, Russians, Palestinians, Ukrainians, women, or any other population, and the principle remains the same: responsibility belongs to individuals, not entire communities.

One may support or condemn Markovitch’s offer. One may question his judgment, scrutinize his public role, or demand accountability from Mudra and every other suspect in the investigation. None of that requires treating Jewishness as evidence of conspiracy. Political criticism loses its legitimacy when it abandons individual responsibility for collective blame. Antisemitism should have no home in Ukraine, or anywhere else.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Сергій Кривонос: НАТО продовжує готуватися до застарілих воєн, ігноруючи сучасні виклики війни

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): reporter.kr.ua

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/27

Сергій Кривонос — український генерал-майор запасу, колишній заступник секретаря Ради національної безпеки і оборони України. Він брав активну участь у формуванні та розвитку Сил спеціальних операцій України, а також у створенні їхньої навчальної інфраструктури. Зараз Сергій Кривонос обіймає посаду віцепрезидента Міжнародної академії цивільної безпеки та співробітництва, відповідаючи за організацію співпраці із силами безпеки.

Скотт Дуглас Джейкобсен поспілкувався з Сергієм Кривоносом про специфіку Сил спеціальних операцій України, їхні пріоритети у виборі цілей, особливості підготовки військових під час ведення бойових дій і вплив інноваційних технологій. У розмові Кривонос акцентує увагу на необхідності швидкого пристосування НАТО до сучасних умов ведення війни, ділиться досвідом використання безпілотників і штучного інтелекту, підкреслює вагомість людського професіоналізму та збереження особового складу, а також аналізує значні втрати російських сил спеціального призначення у ході повномасштабного вторгнення.

— Сили спеціальних операцій України здійснюють як оборонні операції для стримування російської агресії, так і наступальні операції з метою повернення окупованих територій, — зазначає Джейкобсен. — Які стратегічні відмінності між вимогами до цих двох типів завдань?

— Це визначається в залежності від того, якому угрупованню військ ми надаємо підтримку, — пояснює Кривонос. — Сили спеціальних операцій не діють автономно. Вони виконують поставлені завдання в рамках загального оперативного плану конкретної наступальної або оборонної операції.

Джейкобсен цікавиться також, як в Україні визначають пріоритетні цілі для ударів по військових об’єктах на території Росії.

Цікаве:

У Кропивницькому 22-річний чоловік проведе наступні п’ять років за ґратами – Златопіль

У Кропивницькому молодик вкрав 51 тисячу гривень з банківської картки знайомого і отримав реальний термін Апеляційний суд у Кропивницькому підтвердив вирок 22-річному місцевому жителю, який викрав банківську картку…

— Наш аналіз спрямований на виявлення тих об’єктів на території противника, які є для нього критично важливими, — відповідає Кривонос. — В сучасній війні економічний чинник є ключовим. Послаблення здатності російської економіки підтримувати військові зусилля приносить значну користь Україні.

Обговорюючи підготовку військових, Джейкобсен питає, чим відрізняється навчання українських спецпризначенців під час активних бойових дій від підготовки в країнах Європи та Північної Америки.

— Україна накопичила понад дванадцять років безперервного досвіду ведення бойових дій, — наголошує Кривонос. — Тому система нашої підготовки суттєво відрізняється від традиційної європейської моделі. Початкова підготовка відбувається у навчальному центрі Сил спеціальних операцій у місті Бердичів. Після проходження базового курсу військові продовжують навчання за своїми спеціалізаціями. Іноземні інструктори часто вивчають від наших воїнів більше, ніж можуть їм передати у відповідь.

— На мою думку, більшість країн НАТО досі формує свої навчальні програми, виходячи з воєн минулого, а не з реалій сучасної війни, яку Україна сьогодні переживає, — додає він. — Це помітно навіть на спеціалізованих виставках, де деякі компанії пропонують застарілі рішення. Такі проблеми спостерігаються і на виставках у Лондоні, Вашингтоні, Польщі. Процес засвоєння нових реалій йде надто повільно.

Щодо майбутнього спецоперацій, Джейкобсен запитує, наскільки широко застосовуватимуться безпілотні апарати та штучний інтелект.

— Сили спеціальних операцій вже активно вивчають і впроваджують технологічні новинки під час поточної війни, — відповідає Кривонос. — У найближчому майбутньому доцільно більше покладатися на машини, адже це зменшує ризики для життя військовослужбовців. Проте штучний інтелект не завжди може врахувати всі тонкощі поведінки противника. Тому люди й надалі відіграватимуть ключову роль. ШІ може допомагати у плануванні, але не здатен повністю замінити людський інтелект та врахувати всі людські фактори, які можуть бути як перевагами, так і недоліками.

Джейкобсен підкреслює протилежність підходів Росії та України до втрат особового складу і запитує, чи впливає це на тактику проведення українських спецоперацій.

— Безумовно, — коротко відповідає Кривонос.

— Також мені відомо, що російські сили спеціального призначення зазнали значних втрат на початкових етапах повномасштабного вторгнення у 2022 році, — продовжує журналіст. — Чи є це правильним твердженням?

— Так, багато російських військових цього профілю загинули впродовж 2022 року, — підтверджує Кривонос. — На мою думку, їх застосовували неефективно, внаслідок чого були значні втрати. Я вважаю, що сили спеціальних операцій найбільш результативні безпосередньо перед початком бойових дій або на їх першому етапі. Після розгортання повномасштабної війни вони переходять у підпорядкування та діють у відповідності з планом старшого командира і вже не здійснюють автономні операції.

— Проблема, з якою я зіткнувся, полягає в недостатньому розумінні старшими українськими командирами правильного використання Сил спеціальних операцій, — відзначає він.

— Щиро вдячний за можливість поспілкуватися з вами та за приділений час, Сергію, — завершує інтерв’ю Джейкобсен.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Humanism in Africa and Global South Leadership

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Skeptic Society Magazine

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/09/28

How does Dr. Leo Igwe plan to strengthen humanism in Africa through practical services, free inquiry, and Global South leadership?

Dr. Leo Igwe is a Nigerian humanist and human rights advocate serving as vice president of Humanists International. He founded the Nigerian Humanist Movement and Advocacy for Alleged Witches. His work advances critical thinking, challenges witchcraft accusations, and promotes practical humanist services, equal dignity, and representation across the Global South.

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Dr. Leo Igwe discuss humanist leadership, Global South representation, and practical services across Africa. Igwe outlines priorities including healthcare, education, elder care, counseling, and chaplaincy while defending free inquiry, challenging religious coercion, and connecting humanist principles with community needs, international cooperation, and institutional development.

—

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Today we’re here with the distinguished humanist Dr. Leo Igwe, the new vice president of Humanists International, previously a board member, founder of the Nigerian Humanist Movement, and founder of Advocacy for Alleged Witches. He’s a large personality on the stage for humanism in Africa. Dr. Igwe, what does this new VP position set in motion for you? What are some key areas that need to be emphasized?

Humanists International has worked over the years to establish a more geographically diverse leadership group, a very important point. Now the next question is: we have representation, which is always important, but what about actionable items that are the next steps toward making humanism more established in a region?

Different regions have different issues, and different countries within those regions have different variations of the regional issues. Within an African context and within a context of integrating and coordinating global humanism, what do you see as the next steps through some of your advocacy as vice president of Humanists International?

Dr. Leo Igwe: Thank you, Scott. I’ve been on the board for six years now. And as a board member, one is always supporting the president.

And for me, being elected vice president is an honor. I’m humbled by it. But it’s a call to a higher duty to help the president deliver on her vision and strengthen Humanists International.

But coming from a region where we don’t have as many robust groups as we have in Europe and America is a challenge for me. Because, as they say, charity begins at home.

And I need to do some work to grow or support the formation of more humanist groups and strengthen those that exist. And more importantly, I need to give Humanists International value for their money and support. I believe that Humanists International was established mainly by groups in Europe and America.

And these groups have funded and supported Humanists International over the years. But we have not made significant progress in Africa, Asia, and most parts of the Global South. In those areas, we have fallen short.

We have not given supporters full value for their money, full value for their funding and the resources they have committed. Let me also take note of this: money is not the only kind of resource. There is also time and expertise. There are a lot of humanists out there doing some practical work and trying to support our movement.

My goal is this: I’m going to wake up early in the morning, and I’m going to sleep late at night, thinking about how, as vice president, I’m going to give international humanists value for their money by making sure that humanism blossoms in many parts of the Global South.

Jacobsen: How do you view the Global South now compared to when you first started work in humanism?

Igwe: When I started, I felt that humanists from the Global South had very little say. Humanists International, then called the International Humanist and Ethical Union, was dominated by people from the Global North, particularly Europeans and Americans.

And I felt that people from the Global South were passive. They did not have an equal seat at the table. But I think that those who have led over the years, especially when Andrew Copson was president, understood that this wasn’t right.

They worked to diversify the membership of the board. But it comes with other issues and responsibilities.

It means that we also have to make sure we have people from other parts of the Global South who are qualified, competent, and equipped with the necessary knowledge and skills to lead the humanist movement at the highest level. I think that in the last couple of years, things have changed. Many parts of the Global South now have voices on the board.

But it’s not enough to have the faces there. We also want to make sure that those faces are faces of competence, faces of excellence, faces of effective delivery, and faces of distinguished representation of humanism, not only in the Global South but also throughout the world. Because while one might be from Nigeria or Africa, I think that, for me and for other people on the board, our representation is international.

I’m not vice president for African humanists. I’m vice president of Humanists International. I am there to see what I can do to enrich international humanism as I try to support the president in her goals and vision for leading Humanists International.

Jacobsen: On a personal level, what does earning this position mean to you? Roslyn Mould described, by her accounting in my conversations with her, a 12-year journey to one of the heights of institutional humanism. There’s a lot of humanist-oriented work that’s not institutional. How do you feel after more than a quarter century of work in these movements, having earned this position?

Igwe: First of all, I am lucky. I’ve put in so many years trying to grow, develop, and lead the humanist movement. And I know that something could have happened to me.

I’m lucky I’m alive, I’m still active, and I’m still ready to contribute my quota. I always have this feeling that we are all individuals. I’m not Roslyn Mould. I’m Leo Igwe.

My own path is different from Roslyn’s path. I am so humbled by the trust. I’m so humbled by the responsibility, and I’m going to work hard every day to see how I can use my many years of experience to enrich the movement and bring a unique touch.

I’m looking forward to drawing from the many years of experience I’ve had to contribute to shaping the face of the movement. And I’m also going to build on the successes and contributions of my friend Roslyn Mould, who distinguished herself in that role.

I’m so proud of what she did and all she contributed over the years. I know that it is not easy. It’s something that requires a lot of energy, talent, doggedness, determination, and brilliance. She was able to do that. She has definitely left very big shoes for me to fill.

I’m looking forward to doing everything I can to build on her work, contribute to it, and enrich it, because she has set a very high standard. I don’t want to go below that. I want to go beyond it. In my experience, when people from Nigeria or Africa take on international roles, they are often looked down on.

People sometimes think they are not good enough, so they hold them to lower standards, which I’ve always rejected. If you come from this part of the world, Africa or the Global South, there are challenges.

Those challenges are there. And I believe some are deliberately orchestrated by politicians to put parts of the world down for their own interests. But it does not mean that the human beings who live there are inferior or subordinate to others.

These challenges have to do with where people live, their access to resources, and the available infrastructure. I understand the challenges that will come with this office. Sometimes you want to have meetings, but you don’t have a good internet connection. Sometimes you want to travel, but you don’t get visas.

For instance, I couldn’t get a visa to be in Canada. Sometimes you want to travel, and they want to know how much is in your account. In my experience, if you don’t have thousands or tens of thousands of dollars in your account, you can be viewed with a lot of suspicion.

I know the challenges that will come with playing this role. But I also know that the essence of humanism, its central message, is that whether you are in the Global South or the Global North, whether you have $1 in your account or a million dollars, what matters is that you are a human being. And the humanist life stance speaks to you, speaks to your needs, and resonates with your desires and aspirations.

I understand the challenges that will come with having me as vice president of a movement like ours. You know very well that part of my work is to step in for the president when needed. I understand the weight of those responsibilities.

But I also believe it sends a clear message that wherever you may be, wherever you may live, whether you are in developed or developing nations, whether you are in poor or rich countries, whether you are Black or white or in between, you are a human being, and the humanist movement is for you.

I understand the challenges, but I know that I have the support of Humanists International as I try to confront them and provide leadership from the Global South that resonates with the Global North and with humanists around the globe.

Jacobsen: In my interviews with humanists, I have found that different countries and regions emphasize humanist values in different ways. It seems to match whatever the regional or national concerns are at that time. What concerns an institutional humanist in New York may not necessarily be what someone in the Philippines, in Southeast Asia, or in Hong Kong or Taiwan, in East Asia, is facing.

In terms of those next steps, how can we better understand which humanist values, in theory and practice, need emphasis in different African contexts to support the development and extension of humanism?

Igwe: I think this is a very important question that speaks to one of my priorities as I try to fulfill the role of vice president. Humanism is not just a theory. It’s also a practice.

Humanism will better fulfill its place in the lives of Africans if humanist principles are turned into programs and projects that address their needs. I hope in the coming years to persuade the humanist movement to become more practical, to come up with programs that address those needs, because Africans are often represented as deeply religious, whatever that means.

Sometimes people say Africans are the most religious people on earth. Surveys place many sub-Saharan African countries among the world’s most religious by several measures. But we need to understand why people are religious. Why are they Christians and Muslims?

In many parts of Africa, Christian missionary work did not introduce Christianity simply as a belief. It came as a broader package, with education, healthcare, and humanitarian programs that spoke, and still speak, to people’s needs.

We cannot promote humanism as an alternative if we don’t have a seat at the table in delivering these services. That is why, as vice president, I’m going to persuade more Africans to become practical and begin delivering humanist services: healthcare and care services for older people. Many people accused of witchcraft are elderly. Some have dementia.

We don’t have enough accessible institutions to care for these people in many communities. Humanists can begin to establish, manage, and direct these institutions. We can translate our humanist principles into practice and create facilities that demonstrate that practice.

I’m making it one of my priorities to emphasize humanist care, humanist counseling, humanist chaplaincy, humanist ceremonies, and other programs that address not only the needs of humanists but also those of the wider African public. Many people turn to churches or mosques to satisfy these needs where state services are inadequate.

Welfare programs do not reach everyone who needs them. Churches, mosques, and other religious groups help meet some of those needs. If humanism is to thrive on the African continent, I believe it must deliver services to people, satisfy their needs, and put in place structures and institutions that care for them.

We hope to have health centers established and managed by humanists. We hope to have schools, hospitals, caregiving centers, counseling centers, and chaplaincy programs directed by humanists to support not only those who have no religion, which is very important, but also religious people who seek the services humanists provide.

This is how I hope humanist practice can translate into facilities that meet Africans’ needs and, in the process, help the movement grow, develop, become stronger, and become more visible.

Jacobsen: What about intellectual self-defense against powerful political forces or institutionalized religious forces? In an African context, how can people defend themselves intellectually against political pressure or religious coercion to agree, stay silent, or cower when poor evidence, bad arguments, and bad science gain influence?

Igwe: The fact that we are going to focus on practical programs and services doesn’t mean we’re going to shut down the debate. The debate goes on.

We’ll continue to challenge dogmatic claims, authoritarian claims, superstitious claims, claims without evidence, and this idea of making a virtue out of blind faith. We’ll continue to challenge misinformation and disinformation used by religious establishments to perpetuate harmful ideas and practices. The debate will continue.

I’m only saying that while we debate, discuss, and engage theoretically, we are also going to complement that work with practical programs that help people and address their needs. We will continue to lead the intellectual fight for a society guided by Enlightenment values: reason, science, critical thinking, creative thinking, and free inquiry.

We are also going to rally against forces that treat freethought and criticism of religion as blasphemy. That includes efforts to suppress criticism of Islam, Christianity, and other dominant faiths or their teachings and doctrines.

The intellectual fight, the educational fight, and the debate will continue. But I must also add that debate doesn’t stop us from engaging in dialogue, because there will always be points of agreement.

We debate, we engage in dialogue, and we cooperate where necessary to build a society where people can enjoy the good things in life and make the best of this one life we have, whether they agree with humanists or not.

We are going to oppose the idea that if you criticize a religion or a faith, or say what you think about its prophets or other central figures, you deserve to die. We must come out strongly against that vicious idea, upheld by some religious authorities and groups, and create a healthy environment where the exchange of ideas is encouraged.

It’s only when people are free to say what they think and express themselves intellectually that we can get the best ideas to guide, change, and transform our society. Ask me which societies need good ideas today. Nigeria, other African countries, and many parts of the Global South.

We are overburdened by ideas used to keep parts of the world down and keep people divided. We will continue to encourage a culture where new ideas can challenge the status quo and familiar ways of thinking. From these ideas, we can generate thoughts, sentiments, and views that help free us from the political, economic, and cultural bondage that has held parts of the world back.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for your time, as always.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Humanism in Africa and Global South Leadership

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Parlour News

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/09/26

How does Dr. Leo Igwe plan to strengthen humanism in Africa through practical services, free inquiry, and Global South leadership?

Dr. Leo Igwe is a Nigerian humanist and human rights advocate serving as vice president of Humanists International. He founded the Nigerian Humanist Movement and Advocacy for Alleged Witches. His work advances critical thinking, challenges witchcraft accusations, and promotes practical humanist services, equal dignity, and representation across the Global South.

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Dr. Leo Igwe discuss humanist leadership, Global South representation, and practical services across Africa. Igwe outlines priorities including healthcare, education, elder care, counseling, and chaplaincy while defending free inquiry, challenging religious coercion, and connecting humanist principles with community needs, international cooperation, and institutional development.

—

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Today we’re here with the distinguished humanist Dr. Leo Igwe, the new vice president of Humanists International, previously a board member, founder of the Nigerian Humanist Movement, and founder of Advocacy for Alleged Witches. He’s a large personality on the stage for humanism in Africa. Dr. Igwe, what does this new VP position set in motion for you? What are some key areas that need to be emphasized?

Humanists International has worked over the years to establish a more geographically diverse leadership group, a very important point. Now the next question is: we have representation, which is always important, but what about actionable items that are the next steps toward making humanism more established in a region?

Different regions have different issues, and different countries within those regions have different variations of the regional issues. Within an African context and within a context of integrating and coordinating global humanism, what do you see as the next steps through some of your advocacy as vice president of Humanists International?

Dr. Leo Igwe: Thank you, Scott. I’ve been on the board for six years now. And as a board member, one is always supporting the president.

And for me, being elected vice president is an honor. I’m humbled by it. But it’s a call to a higher duty to help the president deliver on her vision and strengthen Humanists International.

But coming from a region where we don’t have as many robust groups as we have in Europe and America is a challenge for me. Because, as they say, charity begins at home.

And I need to do some work to grow or support the formation of more humanist groups and strengthen those that exist. And more importantly, I need to give Humanists International value for their money and support. I believe that Humanists International was established mainly by groups in Europe and America.

And these groups have funded and supported Humanists International over the years. But we have not made significant progress in Africa, Asia, and most parts of the Global South. In those areas, we have fallen short.

We have not given supporters full value for their money, full value for their funding and the resources they have committed. Let me also take note of this: money is not the only kind of resource. There is also time and expertise. There are a lot of humanists out there doing some practical work and trying to support our movement.

My goal is this: I’m going to wake up early in the morning, and I’m going to sleep late at night, thinking about how, as vice president, I’m going to give international humanists value for their money by making sure that humanism blossoms in many parts of the Global South.

Jacobsen: How do you view the Global South now compared to when you first started work in humanism?

Igwe: When I started, I felt that humanists from the Global South had very little say. Humanists International, then called the International Humanist and Ethical Union, was dominated by people from the Global North, particularly Europeans and Americans.

And I felt that people from the Global South were passive. They did not have an equal seat at the table. But I think that those who have led over the years, especially when Andrew Copson was president, understood that this wasn’t right.

They worked to diversify the membership of the board. But it comes with other issues and responsibilities.

It means that we also have to make sure we have people from other parts of the Global South who are qualified, competent, and equipped with the necessary knowledge and skills to lead the humanist movement at the highest level. I think that in the last couple of years, things have changed. Many parts of the Global South now have voices on the board.

But it’s not enough to have the faces there. We also want to make sure that those faces are faces of competence, faces of excellence, faces of effective delivery, and faces of distinguished representation of humanism, not only in the Global South but also throughout the world. Because while one might be from Nigeria or Africa, I think that, for me and for other people on the board, our representation is international.

I’m not vice president for African humanists. I’m vice president of Humanists International. I am there to see what I can do to enrich international humanism as I try to support the president in her goals and vision for leading Humanists International.

Jacobsen: On a personal level, what does earning this position mean to you? Roslyn Mould described, by her accounting in my conversations with her, a 12-year journey to one of the heights of institutional humanism. There’s a lot of humanist-oriented work that’s not institutional. How do you feel after more than a quarter century of work in these movements, having earned this position?

Igwe: First of all, I am lucky. I’ve put in so many years trying to grow, develop, and lead the humanist movement. And I know that something could have happened to me.

I’m lucky I’m alive, I’m still active, and I’m still ready to contribute my quota. I always have this feeling that we are all individuals. I’m not Roslyn Mould. I’m Leo Igwe.

My own path is different from Roslyn’s path. I am so humbled by the trust. I’m so humbled by the responsibility, and I’m going to work hard every day to see how I can use my many years of experience to enrich the movement and bring a unique touch.

I’m looking forward to drawing from the many years of experience I’ve had to contribute to shaping the face of the movement. And I’m also going to build on the successes and contributions of my friend Roslyn Mould, who distinguished herself in that role.

I’m so proud of what she did and all she contributed over the years. I know that it is not easy. It’s something that requires a lot of energy, talent, doggedness, determination, and brilliance. She was able to do that. She has definitely left very big shoes for me to fill.

I’m looking forward to doing everything I can to build on her work, contribute to it, and enrich it, because she has set a very high standard. I don’t want to go below that. I want to go beyond it. In my experience, when people from Nigeria or Africa take on international roles, they are often looked down on.

People sometimes think they are not good enough, so they hold them to lower standards, which I’ve always rejected. If you come from this part of the world, Africa or the Global South, there are challenges.

Those challenges are there. And I believe some are deliberately orchestrated by politicians to put parts of the world down for their own interests. But it does not mean that the human beings who live there are inferior or subordinate to others.

These challenges have to do with where people live, their access to resources, and the available infrastructure. I understand the challenges that will come with this office. Sometimes you want to have meetings, but you don’t have a good internet connection. Sometimes you want to travel, but you don’t get visas.

For instance, I couldn’t get a visa to be in Canada. Sometimes you want to travel, and they want to know how much is in your account. In my experience, if you don’t have thousands or tens of thousands of dollars in your account, you can be viewed with a lot of suspicion.

I know the challenges that will come with playing this role. But I also know that the essence of humanism, its central message, is that whether you are in the Global South or the Global North, whether you have $1 in your account or a million dollars, what matters is that you are a human being. And the humanist life stance speaks to you, speaks to your needs, and resonates with your desires and aspirations.

I understand the challenges that will come with having me as vice president of a movement like ours. You know very well that part of my work is to step in for the president when needed. I understand the weight of those responsibilities.

But I also believe it sends a clear message that wherever you may be, wherever you may live, whether you are in developed or developing nations, whether you are in poor or rich countries, whether you are Black or white or in between, you are a human being, and the humanist movement is for you.

I understand the challenges, but I know that I have the support of Humanists International as I try to confront them and provide leadership from the Global South that resonates with the Global North and with humanists around the globe.

Jacobsen: In my interviews with humanists, I have found that different countries and regions emphasize humanist values in different ways. It seems to match whatever the regional or national concerns are at that time. What concerns an institutional humanist in New York may not necessarily be what someone in the Philippines, in Southeast Asia, or in Hong Kong or Taiwan, in East Asia, is facing.

In terms of those next steps, how can we better understand which humanist values, in theory and practice, need emphasis in different African contexts to support the development and extension of humanism?

Igwe: I think this is a very important question that speaks to one of my priorities as I try to fulfill the role of vice president. Humanism is not just a theory. It’s also a practice.

Humanism will better fulfill its place in the lives of Africans if humanist principles are turned into programs and projects that address their needs. I hope in the coming years to persuade the humanist movement to become more practical, to come up with programs that address those needs, because Africans are often represented as deeply religious, whatever that means.

Sometimes people say Africans are the most religious people on earth. Surveys place many sub-Saharan African countries among the world’s most religious by several measures. But we need to understand why people are religious. Why are they Christians and Muslims?

In many parts of Africa, Christian missionary work did not introduce Christianity simply as a belief. It came as a broader package, with education, healthcare, and humanitarian programs that spoke, and still speak, to people’s needs.

We cannot promote humanism as an alternative if we don’t have a seat at the table in delivering these services. That is why, as vice president, I’m going to persuade more Africans to become practical and begin delivering humanist services: healthcare and care services for older people. Many people accused of witchcraft are elderly. Some have dementia.

We don’t have enough accessible institutions to care for these people in many communities. Humanists can begin to establish, manage, and direct these institutions. We can translate our humanist principles into practice and create facilities that demonstrate that practice.

I’m making it one of my priorities to emphasize humanist care, humanist counseling, humanist chaplaincy, humanist ceremonies, and other programs that address not only the needs of humanists but also those of the wider African public. Many people turn to churches or mosques to satisfy these needs where state services are inadequate.

Welfare programs do not reach everyone who needs them. Churches, mosques, and other religious groups help meet some of those needs. If humanism is to thrive on the African continent, I believe it must deliver services to people, satisfy their needs, and put in place structures and institutions that care for them.

We hope to have health centers established and managed by humanists. We hope to have schools, hospitals, caregiving centers, counseling centers, and chaplaincy programs directed by humanists to support not only those who have no religion, which is very important, but also religious people who seek the services humanists provide.

This is how I hope humanist practice can translate into facilities that meet Africans’ needs and, in the process, help the movement grow, develop, become stronger, and become more visible.

Jacobsen: What about intellectual self-defense against powerful political forces or institutionalized religious forces? In an African context, how can people defend themselves intellectually against political pressure or religious coercion to agree, stay silent, or cower when poor evidence, bad arguments, and bad science gain influence?

Igwe: The fact that we are going to focus on practical programs and services doesn’t mean we’re going to shut down the debate. The debate goes on.

We’ll continue to challenge dogmatic claims, authoritarian claims, superstitious claims, claims without evidence, and this idea of making a virtue out of blind faith. We’ll continue to challenge misinformation and disinformation used by religious establishments to perpetuate harmful ideas and practices. The debate will continue.

I’m only saying that while we debate, discuss, and engage theoretically, we are also going to complement that work with practical programs that help people and address their needs. We will continue to lead the intellectual fight for a society guided by Enlightenment values: reason, science, critical thinking, creative thinking, and free inquiry.

We are also going to rally against forces that treat freethought and criticism of religion as blasphemy. That includes efforts to suppress criticism of Islam, Christianity, and other dominant faiths or their teachings and doctrines.

The intellectual fight, the educational fight, and the debate will continue. But I must also add that debate doesn’t stop us from engaging in dialogue, because there will always be points of agreement.

We debate, we engage in dialogue, and we cooperate where necessary to build a society where people can enjoy the good things in life and make the best of this one life we have, whether they agree with humanists or not.

We are going to oppose the idea that if you criticize a religion or a faith, or say what you think about its prophets or other central figures, you deserve to die. We must come out strongly against that vicious idea, upheld by some religious authorities and groups, and create a healthy environment where the exchange of ideas is encouraged.

It’s only when people are free to say what they think and express themselves intellectually that we can get the best ideas to guide, change, and transform our society. Ask me which societies need good ideas today. Nigeria, other African countries, and many parts of the Global South.

We are overburdened by ideas used to keep parts of the world down and keep people divided. We will continue to encourage a culture where new ideas can challenge the status quo and familiar ways of thinking. From these ideas, we can generate thoughts, sentiments, and views that help free us from the political, economic, and cultural bondage that has held parts of the world back.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for your time, as always.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Serhiy Kryvonos, Major General (Reserve) of the Armed Forces of Ukraine: NATO is still preparing for past wars, not for modern warfare

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): EUROPESAYS

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/27

Serhiy Kryvonos is a Ukrainian major general (reserve) and former deputy secretary of the National Security and Defense Council of Ukraine. He played a role in the development of Ukraine’s Special Operations Forces and the creation of their training infrastructure. He serves as vice president of the International Academy of Civil Security and Cooperation, where he is responsible for liaising with security forces.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen spoke with Serhiy Kryvonos about Ukraine’s Special Operations Forces, priorities in target selection, military training during wartime, and technological changes. Kryvonos emphasizes that NATO must adapt more quickly to modern conditions of warfare; discusses the use of drones and artificial intelligence, underscores the importance of human judgment and personnel preservation, and assesses the significant losses suffered by Russian special forces during the invasion.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Ukraine’s special operations forces are conducting defensive operations against Russian aggression and offensive operations to retake territory. How do the strategic requirements for these two types of missions differ?

Serhiy Kryvonos: It depends on which force group we are supporting. Special operations forces do not operate independently. They operate within the framework of the overall plan for a specific offensive or defensive operation.

Jacobsen: When Ukraine strikes military targets on Russian territory, how are the targets identified that are most critical to Ukraine’s war effort?

Kryvonos: We analyze which targets on enemy territory are critical to the enemy.

I believe that modern warfare is, first and foremost, about the economy. Weakening the Russian economy’s ability to function and sustain its war effort benefits Ukraine.

Jacobsen: How does the training of Ukraine’s Special Operations Forces during active warfare differ from the training of military personnel in European and North American countries?

Kryvonos: Ukraine has accumulated twelve years of combat experience. Therefore, our training system differs from that used by European countries.

Basic training takes place at the Special Operations Forces Training Center in Berdychiv. After completing the qualification course, service members undergo further training according to their specializations.

Foreign instructors often learn more from our military personnel than they can teach them.

In my opinion, most NATO countries are still preparing for the wars of the past, rather than for the modern warfare we see today.

Even at this exhibition, some companies continue to think in terms of outdated standards. I see the same problem at exhibitions in London, Washington, and Poland. The realities of modern warfare are being grasped far too slowly.

Jacobsen: We’ve seen operations like “Web,” as well as the Israeli operation using pagers that exploded. What will special operations look like in the future? Will they make greater use of drones and artificial intelligence?

Kryvonos: Special operations forces are studying new technologies and using them effectively in the current war.

In the future, it will be better to assign tasks to machines rather than people, as this reduces the risk of military personnel being killed.

However, artificial intelligence is not always capable of accounting for all the nuances of the enemy’s behavior. People must continue to play an active role. AI can improve planning, but it cannot completely replace human intelligence or account for all human factors. These can be both strengths and weaknesses.

Jacobsen: I see two opposing approaches: Russia is willing to accept heavy losses, while Ukraine is increasingly focused on preserving the lives of its soldiers. Does this principle also influence the conduct of Ukrainian special operations?

Kryvonos: Absolutely.

Jacobsen: As I understand it, Russia expended significant special operations forces resources during the early stages of the full-scale invasion in 2022. Is that correct?

Kryvonos: Yes. Many of these service members were killed in 2022. In my opinion, Russia used them inefficiently and suffered significant losses.

I believe that special operations forces are most effective immediately before the start of hostilities or in the early stages of a war. When a full-scale war begins, they adapt to the senior commander’s operational plan. They no longer act independently but carry out the tasks assigned by that commander.

The problem I encountered was that senior Ukrainian commanders lacked an understanding of how to properly employ Special Operations Forces.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity to speak with you and for your time, Serhiy.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Sviatoslav Yurash on War, Atheism, and Orthodox Christianity

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/29

Scott Douglas Jacobsen interviews Sviatoslav Yurash about his path from studying in Kolkata to Euromaidan activism, war reporting, and Ukrainian parliamentary politics. Yurash discusses supporting Volodymyr Zelenskyy, rejecting militant atheism, embracing Orthodox Christianity, and finding meaning through faith, ancestry, family, and wartime experience, while criticizing Soviet communism and political leadership.

Sviatoslav Yurash is a Ukrainian parliamentarian born in Lviv in 1996. Elected to the Servant of the People party in 2019, he became the youngest member of the ninth Verkhovna Rada. He organized Euromaidan communications, worked with international media, served in Ukraine’s armed forces, and leads parliamentary work concerning Ukrainians living abroad.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Alright, so we’re here with Sviatoslav Yurash. He is the youngest member of parliament in Ukraine’s Verkhovna Rada. He entered at age 23. Can you take us a couple of steps back, before you even got into politics? Did you feel destined to do it, that it was the right thing to do, or did you transition into it later?

Sviatoslav Yurash: None of it. The truth is, I was in the midst of my studies in Kolkata, India, when Ukraine completely rejected the president, who decided to swerve away from what he had promised: the European path for Ukraine. And students who came out to protest against him were beaten up, and you had all the different generations coming together to show their disagreement with this approach to policymaking in Ukraine.

When I saw a million people on the streets of Kyiv, I knew my country’s destiny was being decided, and I couldn’t pretend I needed to follow the same educational steps before joining in any other practical reality. So I changed the plans that I had. My professor, Shantanu Chakrabarti, agreed, and I returned to Ukraine in 2013 to join the revolution, which gave me my first chance to help transform my country.

I led the International Centre of the Revolution, working with different media and embassies during the Maidan. I didn’t do that because of my skills, but because of many wonderful people with linguistic skills and a desire for the revolution. And I had the distinct honour of uniting them to try to explain and tell the world what Ukraine is and what our revolution is all about.

That was the start of it. And when you had the finale of the revolution, that is, when the president decided to drown Kyiv in blood, he was pushed to face the consequences and fled from those consequences, and the Russians invaded Ukraine.

And I saw that the maxims of my youth, that you cannot just take territory and change borders at will, no longer held. I swore that, whatever happened next, I would try to be there. Then events began unfolding in eastern Ukraine, in Donetsk, as they call it, the reserve capital of Ukraine and certainly the richest city in Ukraine. I accepted an offer from American journalists to join them to cover what was happening there.

I stayed there in 2014, leaving after the Malaysian airliner MH17 was shot down, covering that as my last story and returning to Kyiv. For the next five years, I did many things with many organizations, many people, and for many reasons. And the central instrument I had was information that I had a chance to understand through all those associations.

That information led me to a major disagreement with what was happening under the president elected after the revolution, Mr. Poroshenko. As election time neared, I knew I would join his opponents to show him he could not do what was done before, under the old rules of Ukrainian politics. The revolution did not want what was happening under his leadership.

When Zelenskyy announced, I reached out to friends in show business, and he and his team were open to ideas and people I could contribute. And I sort of just became one of the spokespeople, the Ukrainian-language spokesperson, in that sense, for his campaign efforts, clarifying the foreign policy agenda of the campaign as Western integration, the EU and NATO, and the institutions surrounding that.

And when he triumphantly won the presidential race, I didn’t decline the offer to continue to parliament. And in parliament, again, there was a triumphal victory. I became the youngest ever member of parliament, and elected the youngest ever prime minister; all of it led by the youngest ever president of Ukraine.

Jacobsen: What did Kolkata teach you?

Yurash: Kolkata taught me that the world is immensely interesting, and I can’t stay in the bubble of my European perspective. I need to see the world. That was my plan. After starting to study at a European university, my idea was to see the world.

In my youth, I had the illusion that Ukraine would take a boring, slow path into European and Western institutions. Of course, the governing parties would change. There was the Orange Party, then the Blue Party, then the Red Party, then the Green Party, but the direction would stay the same. And Ukraine would join the European Union.

During that time, as Ukraine went through the motions, I would have a chance to gain skills useful for my homeland. And I would return with those skills to a Ukraine that had either accomplished integration with the West or was still in the finishing stages of it.

But again, tell God your plans, and he’ll laugh at you. So all those ideas went away, and the revolution certainly started my life properly.

Jacobsen: Now, you spent time in an earlier part of life, an earlier chapter, in self-described terms, with a self-identified philosophy as a militant atheist. What was the path to that point?

Yurash: Well, that was the reality of growing up in Lviv, a religious city, in a family that was committed, in rebellion against Soviet atheistic beliefs, to trying to bring back what the Soviet Union was destroying. These are very fun. You’re a teenager, but as you go through the adventures of life, the truth is that the vacuum you are left with is quite unsatisfactory.

If you destroy those fundamentals that gave your ancestors the strength to get through the challenges of their lives and gave you the fundamental gift, the fundamental gift of life… Especially through the revolution and the early years of the war, that left me quite unsatisfied with the atheistic reality.

And then came the final act: using deconstructionism to deconstruct its own constructions and return to the foundation, which, for me, is Orthodox Christian reality.

Jacobsen: Was it about meaning, joy, and purpose in life, a reorientation of your life?

Yurash: Meaning is the word that certainly describes it best. The point is that life should have a purpose, direction, and meaning. You are not the first person to ask the question.

And it’s wonderful to see all these ancestors of yours who found that in all that God provided them, and in all that gave them the strength to get through the challenges of their centuries and give you the gift of life. So the least I can do is to try to understand them and follow in their footsteps.

Jacobsen: What does a sense of multi-multi-multi-generational time give you within Orthodox theology?

Yurash: Well, it’s not a question of a sense of multigenerational time. It’s about all these answers they had, which gave them the strength to face whatever challenges they faced.

Sadly, the Soviet Union’s paramount quest was to destroy the past, destroy history, and that led them to destroy the understanding that most of the children had. They were born in the ramshackle reality of what remained of the Soviet past. It gave them little chance to understand their ancestors.

But again, the institutions, Christian institutions, were those that stood firm and managed to survive all of that, which allowed them to give meaning to people even in the soulless and empty reality of communist Soviet delusion.

Jacobsen: What were the biggest delusions of the Soviets?

Yurash: The idea that they could take human nature and submit it to the dystopia of the paradise they thought they were creating through control, murder, and destruction. The delusion that they could fix human nature.

It led them to destroy and kill too many millions to count. Not just in the Soviet Union, mind you, but in every single communist nation that was attempted. And that deserves a Nuremberg trial of its own, as many much greater scholars and historians than I have any ambition to be have described in so much detail, to showcase how tragic and painful the Soviet attempt at utopia was.

Jacobsen: How does an Eastern Orthodox idea of a better life compare?

Yurash: Well, the Orthodox idea isn’t so much a question of a better life. It’s about the grounding it gives you, the realization that a much greater reality lies before you and above you.

And again, all these ancestors, who survived and went through the challenges of their centuries, praised and thanked the almighty God in that quest to survive and thrive. And they managed to do enough to create us.

Hence, the grounding Orthodoxy provides is certainly the answer to many of the questions every person asks in life, and me too. Discovering and understanding the value of not answering questions with arrogance or atheism has certainly helped one through the challenges of the years that passed.

Again, it’s, as always, the reality of a prodigal son who tries to rebel and realizes he needs to return to the foundation. The foundation. For me, that foundation is Orthodox Christianity. Hence, I stepped back into the life of the Almighty. And I couldn’t be more thankful because he has blessed me with the opportunity to do something better with my life than I could ever have imagined.

Jacobsen: What were some of your first marks of transition from a militant style of atheism, sort of an early twenty-first-century flavour of atheism, into Eastern Orthodoxy, as expressed primarily – I’m assuming – in Lviv and Kyiv?

Yurash: The conversations with my father, who went through the same motions in his day and who has built his life around submitting to the Almighty and respecting the past. But that’s only the first step.

And the questions that you have as you go through the revolution and the war, and you survive this, that, and the other, mean that you have to think and understand it through some prism. And to me, the prism, that foundation for my ancestors, is the natural prism to choose.

And as you use, every single day, all the words about destiny and the universe and everything else, they seem emptier than the foundational words that let generations survive to see another day. So when I searched for answers, I found them in that foundation, which helped all my ancestors, and it helped me, too.

Jacobsen: What passage of scripture means the most to you now?

Yurash: It’s not a question of which passage of scripture. I must say my wife is a biblical scholar, and Catholic school gave me plenty of passages all the time.

But again, it’s not about one passage or another passage. It’s about the weight that the biggest and most foundational book ever created, the Bible, provides to lead your life and answer the questions you face every single day.

So sadly, I can’t give you a one-zinger answer. It’s a public conversation we are having, and it’s a much bigger conversation we should have, not just in the twenty minutes we had. And again, I’ll be happy to call you back after the meeting that I should be attending right now.

Jacobsen: That would be great. I’ll talk to you soon. Thank you very much.

Yurash: Okay, till soon. Thank you very much.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Bank of Memories Preserves Ukraine’s Fallen Heroes and Digital Legacies

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/28

Bank of Memories Preserves Ukraine’s Fallen Heroes and Digital Legacies

Photo by Glib Albovsky on Unsplash

Iryna Savytska is the CEO and co-founder of Bank of Memories, a Ukraine-based digital memorial and family-archive initiative. She leads projects preserving video stories, photographs, voices, documents, and digital legacies for families of fallen Ukrainian soldiers and veterans. Working with municipalities, government partners, bereaved families, and international organizations, Savytska advances secure, decentralized remembrance systems, memorial films, digital wills, biometric protection, export rights, and scalable content-management tools for communities affected by war throughout wartime Ukraine today.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen interviews Iryna Savytska about Bank of Memories, its origins, wartime expansion, and growing public demand. Savytska explains how municipalities fund memorial films for fallen Ukrainian soldiers and veterans, accessed through QR codes at local remembrance sites. She also discusses decentralized archives, family trees, digital wills, password inheritance, biometric security, and a content-management system enabling municipalities to produce films independently. The interview highlights remembrance, identity, social entrepreneurship, and digital legacy preservation across Ukraine.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: All right, so today we are here with Iryna Savytska, CEO and co-founder of Bank of Memories, a Ukrainian memory-preservation startup. Bank of Memories is a digital archive project for preserving family, civic, and historical memory. It can help create digital memorials for fallen Ukrainian soldiers and veterans, while also working with municipalities on broader memory-preservation projects. The platform is designed as a private archive that can include features such as biometric protection, an AI-assisted family tree, decentralized storage, semantic search, memory-based chat functions, export options, and a digital will. Is all of that factual and correct?

Iryna Savytska: At its core, Bank of Memories is a tool for the living. It is a secure digital space where families can build their family trees and preserve their stories, important documents, and legacy for future generations. Because of the ongoing war, we adapted this technology to help municipalities create memorial films to honor our heroes. However, our global mission has always been to capture and celebrate life, not just to document loss.

Each municipality controls its own budget and serves its own citizens. For them, this is a memory-preservation project. How does it work? Imagine there are 100 families who have lost someone in the war, a soldier or veteran. For those fallen heroes, we create short memorial films, three to five minutes long.

All of these films are preserved in our system and are accessible through QR codes in small cities, villages, and other communities. Maybe you have heard of the Alleys of Heroes found in many Ukrainian cities and villages.

Jacobsen: I have seen some of those while travelling through different cities in Ukraine.

Savytska: Yes. Those are physical places where people can come to remember their relatives and friends. We place QR codes there so visitors can scan them and watch a memorial film about each person. As I said, the films are three to five minutes long.

This is not on our main website because it is a social impact project that we run here in Ukraine. We had planned to scale it to other countries and offer these films internationally in the future, but right now we are quite busy here in Ukraine.

By the way, we were invited by the New York InsurTech Accelerator to help promote this idea in the United States. They were looking for similar solutions for grief management, memorial films, secure preservation, and inheritance.

That is important for them as well, so this is not only relevant in Ukraine, but abroad too.

Jacobsen: Was this primarily a result of wartime necessity and reflection, or were elements of the idea already developing before the war?

Savytska: It began before the war. The idea began when my husband’s mother was diagnosed with Parkinson’s disease. We acutely felt the need to preserve her voice, her unique life stories, and her experiences while she was still with us—to create a digital time capsule of who she was. Later, after she passed away, we also faced a practical issue: we lost access to many of her documents and passwords. That’s when we realized people need a comprehensive service that combines emotional memory preservation with practical digital asset management.

The idea was to create a secure system that does not depend on any single company or government, runs independently on decentralized infrastructure, and can preserve people’s digital legacies over time.

We wanted to make it as affordable as possible. The memorial film was the final step in that journey. People upload data, build their family tree, and keep everything in one place. Then, when they pass away, we can create a film about them. That was the initial idea.

Then the full-scale war started, and we realized that people needed this immediately. We could not wait until all the systems were created and everything worked perfectly. We decided to start with films for our friends whom we unfortunately lost during the war.

Then the mayor of Kalush, a city in Ivano-Frankivsk Oblast, saw our films and said, “I want this for my city as soon as possible.” We delivered these films to the citizens there who needed them. Then another city said they wanted them too, and we realized that this was something people actually needed, not only families, but municipalities as well. They wanted to pay for it.

In Ukraine, it is quite rare for someone from the government to want to pay you. It is not the usual model. We started working and realized that this project is a form of social impact entrepreneurship. It has a social pricing model, and we are also creating and measuring social impact. In the United States, I know there are structures such as B Corps, but in Ukraine, there is nothing similar.

We are working as an LLC and NGO together to make this happen. Abroad, we have a company in Delaware to serve the international market. There, it is a business, but still with impact. Here in Ukraine, it is purely social impact.

Jacobsen: What is the level of demand for this? Some people want to keep memory alive physically through various memorabilia. Others would like the digital representation and repository that you provide. Others may not know about it, or they may not want it. So there are four different groups. Given the scale of this particular war, even one of those groups could represent huge demand. How are you finding people coming to you, and what is the level of demand? Also, what is most in demand among the services Bank of Memories provides?

Savytska: Before the full-scale war, even though the war had been going on since 2014, we launched our first pilot in 2019, and no one liked it. We made a film for our friend, showed it, and installed his portrait at his school and workplace with a QR code. People did not show much interest. That was because there was no war in Kyiv, for example. There was no war elsewhere in the same direct way, apart from Crimea and the Donetsk and Luhansk regions. So people did not treat it seriously then.

For a couple of years, we did not do much with it. Then, in 2022, it exploded. Why? Because the war touched every family.

During the Soviet period and after 1991, especially in the 1990s, it was a very hard time. People were trying to make money and survive. I was born in 1988, so I clearly remember that my family was working hard to make money. The same was true for many other families. Culture and memory were not priorities because people needed to survive.

The same was true in 2014, for example. People did not need to survive in quite the same way, but they were still focused more on money than on culture or heritage.

Then, in 2022, everything changed dramatically and quickly. Something similar happened with COVID. There was COVID, and then, suddenly, within a month, there was no COVID. It was similar with culture. There had been no focus on culture, and then, within a month after the full-scale war started, people realized, “We are Ukrainians. We want to preserve our nationality. We want to preserve our identity and who we are.”

The most popular products we now have under the Bank of Memories umbrella are the memorial films and the system itself. We also offer our protocol to other municipalities. We teach them how to do it, and they can create films on their own. That is quite popular in Ukraine because municipalities do not want to pay a lot of money, but they are ready to pay for the content management system we created. They pay less than $1,000 per year to create everything for their community.

Another product is a digital will. Right now, it is very popular. Even though the older generation is often afraid to make a will because they think that if they do it, they will die the next day, the younger generation here, people from my generation and people over 40, realize that they actually have something to lose. They may have contracts, intellectual property, loans they have given to someone, and other assets. So they have something they want to share.

Modern individuals possess a vast amount of digital capital—from social media and family photo archives to intellectual property and investments. We made our digital will free for Ukrainians because, especially now, we want to promote a culture of responsibility. Creating a digital will today is like wearing a seatbelt or having insurance. It’s not about expecting the worst; it’s a modern, mature way to care for your loved ones, ensuring your life’s work and assets don’t end up locked away forever. We want to share that international culture with them and say that it is normal to write down everything that matters.

Then, if something happens and a person passes away, their family can automatically receive the important information by email or phone. I do not mean an apartment or other tangible assets. I mean, for example, passwords and digital access. I will share a link with you, and you will be able to make the will too.

For example, we explain how to share passwords for Facebook, Instagram, Google Drive, iCloud, and similar services, and how to access them. Apparently, it is easy, but people are not doing it. I do not know why. Maybe they do not think about it. We are the first point that prompts them to actually think about it and write down where physical photos are, such as family pictures, and how to find them.

There may also be contracts with someone. Some people here are angel investors. They may have invested somewhere, but no one knows where they invested, in which country, or in which company. If something happens and the family has the contracts, then they can inherit those assets. If not, and no one can find them, then those assets can become frozen. So those are the two main products that are quite popular.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Iryna.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen’s Opening Address to the Fifth International Conference on Holography and Its Applications (ICHA 2026)

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/24

Scott Douglas Jacobsen opens International Conference on Holography and its Applications (ICHA) 2026, hosted by Damghan University, highlighting holography, quantum information, cosmology, machine learning, and emergent gravity. He thanks organizers, advisers, and speakers, emphasizing international collaboration and the shared scientific effort to understand connections among geometry, matter, information, and gravity through rigorous discussion, research, and scholarly publication.

—

Keynote speakers, members of the Scientific Advisory Committee and the Organizing Committee, colleagues, researchers, students, and guests from Iran and around the world: good morning from Kyiv, Ukraine, where I am joining you remotely. Welcome to the fifth International Conference on Holography and its Applications, ICHA 2026, hosted by Damgan University.

It is a privilege to open this meeting in the historic city of Damgan and to welcome a community brought together by ambitious ideas in modern theoretical physics, particularly in quantum cosmology and holography. I’m honored to participate, so thank you all very much.

Our core areas of focus over the next two days are the foundations of the holographic principle and the AdS/CFT correspondence, holographic aspects of quantum information and quantum computing, holography in strongly correlated systems, holography and cosmology, and machine learning for the holographic principle. Ideally, these topics will provide a basis for further collaboration, discussion, and submissions for peer-reviewed publication to advance the field with experts like you.

All of these are deep and difficult subjects that require years of training and expertise. This conference represents a common effort to understand how geometry, information, matter, and gravity fit together.

I’d first like to thank and recognize Professor Zahra Chaghani of Damgan University, Chair of the Organizing Committee, together with Bebek Khanbabe, Ahmed Nagedokht, Shahab Shahidi, and Martezah Tavakoli, for the considerable work required to bring this conference together.

I would also like to acknowledge Professor Kazem Betakzir Fedefan, Chair of the Scientific Advisory Committee, and all members of that committee. Their scientific guidance helped shape the conference into something both focused and international.

Among our distinguished keynote speakers this year, Professor Yonghui He will open the scientific program with a journey from Calabi-Yau geometry and fundamental physics to AI-driven discovery in mathematics. Professor Mohsen Ali Shahia will take us beyond Krylov complexity, exploring the organization and persistence of memory in quantum systems.

Professor Mukun Rangamani will examine how the imprint of a black hole singularity may appear in field theory observables. Professor Mohammed Mehdi Sheikh Jabari will present “GR from RG,” or general relativity from the renormalization group, addressing the provocative possibility that gravity can emerge from renormalization group flow.

Professor Han Lu will bring the keynote program to a close with Euclidean wormholes, quantum chaos, and the factorization puzzle in AdS/CFT. These subjects illustrate how a black hole becomes a question in thermal field theory, a problem in geometry becomes one in quantum information, and a puzzle in gravity can lead directly into statistical mechanics or number theory.

To all speakers, poster presenters, session chairs, students, early career researchers, and participants joining us from different institutions and countries: thank you for your participation and for continuing to show the scientific community at its best, engaged in a truly global and human enterprise exploring fundamental and derivative physical truths about reality.

On behalf of the organizers and Damgan University, I warmly welcome you all to ICHA 2026. I hope the next two days bring rigorous discussion, new collaborations, difficult questions, surprising answers, and perhaps a few calculations that work on the first attempt. However, that may be asking too much of theoretical physics.

Thank you for being here. I wish you a productive and memorable conference. It is my great pleasure to welcome you to the fifth International Conference on Holography and its Applications. Thank you all very much.

Special thanks: I extend my sincere thanks to everyone who contributed to the fifth International Conference on Holography and its Applications, ICHA 2026, with particular appreciation to the following individuals:

Zahra Haghani (Chair of the Organizing Committee and member of the Scientific Advisory Committee); Babak Khanbabaei (Organizing Committee member); Ahmad Naghidokht (Organizing Committee member); Shahab Shahidi (Organizing Committee member); and Morteza Tavakkoli (Organizing Committee member).

Kazem Bitaghsir Fadafan (Chair of the Scientific Advisory Committee); Hamid Reza Afshar (Scientific Advisory Committee member and session chair); Babak Haghighat (Scientific Advisory Committee member); Shailesh Lal (Scientific Advisory Committee member); Mohammad Reza Mohammadi Mozaffar (Scientific Advisory Committee member and session chair); Suvrat Raju (Scientific Advisory Committee member); Andrei Starinets (Scientific Advisory Committee member); Bayram Tekin (Scientific Advisory Committee member); and Mohammad Hassan Vahidinia (Scientific Advisory Committee member).

Yang-Hui He (keynote speaker); Mohsen Alishahiha (keynote speaker); Mukund Rangamani (keynote speaker); Mohammad Mehdi Sheikh-Jabbari (keynote speaker); and Hong Liu (keynote speaker).

Behnam Pourhassan (session chair); and Mohammad Reza Garousi (session chair).

Mehdi Sadeghi (contributed speaker); Jonas Mager (contributed speaker); Ebrahim Yusofi (contributed speaker); Moisés Bravo-Gaete (contributed speaker); Sedigheh Farahzad (contributed speaker); Sayyed Mehrab Ramezani (contributed speaker); Zaharia Adrian (contributed speaker); Narmin Nasibova (contributed speaker); Xun Chen (contributed speaker); Hiwa Abubakr Ahmed (contributed speaker); and Vahid Taghiloo (contributed speaker).

Fatemeh Khosravani Amiri (poster presenter); and Bahman Khanpour (poster presenter).

I also thank Damghan University (host and organizer), the Canadian Quantum Research Center (supporting institution), the Physics Society of Iran (supporting institution), and all students, researchers, participants, and others whose contributions made this international scientific exchange possible.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Anna Avetova on Sustainable Art Management, Gallery Structure, and Artist Professionalism

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/23

Anna Avetova is a Ukrainian art strategist, curator, and cultural entrepreneur based in Basel, Switzerland. She is the founder of TUASHO, director of ART KYIV, and co-founder of Art Navigator Academy. With more than a decade of experience, her work spans exhibitions, art fairs, strategic consulting, and professional education for artists and cultural practitioners.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Anna Avetova discuss practical art management, including realistic budgets, structured workflows, Google Sheets, professional communication, and artist self-management. Avetova argues that sustainable galleries and fairs require consistency, business skills, clear documentation, and reduced dependence on temporary sponsorship, especially when cultural projects must endure uncertain conditions over time.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Okay, so the question is: if an individual, one year, five years, or 25 years from now, stumbles across this interview, they may or may not live in a wartime context. It is hard to say what will be happening 25 years from now. But they are project-managing an art gallery.

Maybe it is some computerized thing in an AI future, or just a regular gallery. There are common issues you have observed, and there are ways those can be fixed.

How can those be fixed? What do you see as common problems? What are some common solutions?

Anna Avetova: There is no single solution, because the problems vary from one organization to another. But one principle applies widely: work toward a high standard without becoming consumed by perfectionism. Aim to improve on what you did yesterday.

In art, ambition can sometimes lead people to spend beyond what a project actually needs. Having funding does not mean that every possible expense is justified. The budget still needs to reflect the purpose of the project.

Jacobsen: Sometimes good enough is good enough.

Avetova: Yes. The result needs to be good enough to serve its purpose, with resources left to continue the work.

The second essential is a clear system for managing information. I use Google Sheets for task lists, budgets, and artwork records. Even a simple spreadsheet can help you keep track of what needs to be done and make sure no artwork is overlooked.

The important thing is to use that system consistently.

Jacobsen: I am taking an analogy. I was involved in art, drama, and theatre in high school. I used to sketch, but that was basically where things ended for me because I got into psychology and journalism.

Now, individuals in art go to art school. They learn process and structured process.

Avetova: You mean the process of making art?

Jacobsen: Yes. For creative work. Here is how you can best work with acrylic for this type of image, whether it is faces, landscapes, abstract work, or something like that.

So I am getting to the question for people reading this: why not simply take that same mentality and apply it to hosting an event?

Avetova: I do not have a simple explanation for why that transfer does not always happen.

Jacobsen: Structure, like budgets and everything else. Creative process always requires structured process.

Avetova: Absolutely. That same attention to process is valuable in organizing an event.

Many successful artists I have encountered also have strong business skills. They organize their work carefully and understand the practical demands of sustaining a career.

Art education does not always cover those demands. Students may learn how to develop their practice without receiving the same preparation in professional documentation and communication.

When my colleague and I developed online courses for artists, we encountered gaps in very basic professional skills, including preparing a portfolio and writing an email.

For example, some people put their entire message in the subject line, rather than using it to identify the purpose of the email.

Jacobsen: So the subject line is the body.

Avetova: Exactly. It is a small example, but it shows why basic professional communication needs to be taught.

I had to learn these things too. They are learnable skills, and asking how something works is a useful place to start.

Jacobsen: I only write the body of the email in the subject line when it is something last-minute, like a time change or something came up. Then, when they look at the email, they immediately see in the subject line that the time needs to change, and they know it is from me.

Avetova: Yes, I understand that use of a subject line. I would usually indicate that the message is urgent.

Jacobsen: What else? What else are they not doing?

Avetova: Another difficulty is reluctance to communicate about the work.

Some artists find it difficult to speak with people, present their work, or write about their practice. Those activities may feel separate from making art, but they become important when an artist wants to work with galleries and reach an audience.

I sometimes encounter the attitude: “This is my art; if you do not understand it, that is not my problem.” That can make professional dialogue difficult.

Jacobsen: I will tell you, as a journalist, I deal with people all day. I work seven days a week, morning and night. I am constantly interacting with people, but often in a structured, purposeful way.

What feels very casual to you has a structure for me. There is a whole structure to the process, even if it seems quite casual.

But in terms of small talk and things like this, if it is not family or a really close friend, I do not have time, typically.

Avetova: Yes, I understand that distinction.

Jacobsen: And I have that same feeling. Even though I have to interact with people in that way, sometimes I do not like it. It feels unnatural to me. It feels fake. It does not feel authentic or natural.

But I know that it is part of my profession, so I do it. I think it is interesting to me that artists in the spheres you are talking about do not feel that they have to.

Avetova: Some artists do not see those responsibilities as part of their profession. They expect an art manager to arrive and take care of everything. A manager can provide substantial support, but the work still requires the artist’s participation.

I sometimes joke that I would also like my job to consist of walking around an exhibition with a glass of champagne. Of course, that is only the most visible part of a much larger effort.

There is a great deal of work behind an exhibition or a fair. That brings us back to the first principle: be structured and realistic about what your work requires.

That gives you a better chance of sustaining it over time.

I have seen enthusiastic initiatives consume their resources very quickly. Someone opens a gallery or launches an event, invests everything in the first presentation, and cannot afford to repeat it.

I recall an earlier art fair in Kyiv that took place only once or twice and then stopped.

It offered galleries free booths. That precedent has shaped some participants’ expectations about paying for a booth today.

As I understood it, the event relied heavily on external funding. That made its continuation vulnerable to changes in the sponsor’s support.

When that support was no longer available, the organizers were unable to continue the project.

At ART KYIV, we managed to proceed despite the loss of expected financial support, although doing so was difficult.

For me, the lesson is to build a model that can continue through changes in funding, rather than relying entirely on one sponsor. Structure, realistic budgets, and consistency make regular work more achievable.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Anna.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Sofia Vashchenko on Embodiment, Vulnerability, Art Navigator Academy, and Contemporary Ukrainian Art

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/21

Sofia Vashchenko is a Ukrainian artist from Zaporizhzhia who is based in Kyiv and identifies herself as a student of Art Navigator Academy. Her figurative practice combines realistic and symbolic imagery. Art Navigator Academy is a Ukrainian educational and professional-development platform for artists, curators, art managers, designers, photographers, and other creative professionals. Founded in 2023 by Ukrainian curators and art managers Anna Avetova and Dasha Bilenko, the academy provides online education, mentorship, professional networking, and career guidance for people working within the contemporary art system in Ukraine and internationally. Its programs include Creative Career Compass, which focuses on professional positioning, promotion, career development, and navigation of the art market.

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen speaks with Sofia Vashchenko in connection with Art Navigator Academy’s presentation at ART KYIV Autumn Edition 2026 at Lavra Gallery in Kyiv. They discuss works by academy graduates Svitlana Glushko, Valentyna Khmil, Tetiana Tretiakova, and Alina Lobanova, examining embodiment, vulnerability, psychological experience, wartime disruption, self-acceptance, femininity, colour, texture, candlelight, electricity blackouts, artistic process, and professional development within Ukraine’s contemporary art scene.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: What is your role?

Sofia Vashchenko: I am an artist and a student of Art Navigator Academy.

Jacobsen: Today, we’re looking at Svitlana Glushko, Valentyna Khmil, Tetiana Tretiakova, and Alina Lobanova. So, with the first pieces we’re looking at here, what is being conveyed by Svitlana?

Vashchenko: These are several pieces that are connected to one another. They form a series of artworks called Another Reality. She created them as a afe place, somewhere to rest from everything troublesome. We feel very vulnerable at this time because of the war and everything that is happening around us. So, for me, these works suggest finding a safe place.

Jacobsen: There is a decent amount of Ukrainian colours mixed into the general architectural thematics of the colour palette overall. I quite enjoy this piece and consider a feature, not a bug.

Vashchenko: Or maybe it’s symbolic, you see? That’s why she doesn’t give a full explanation of everything. I like your interpretation, that you noticed the colours look like the Ukrainian colours. I cannot say whether she did that intentionally or not. It’s interesting not to know exactly what she was thinking when she made them. There is a description of the series.

Jacobsen: The background is canvas, but the surface has this granular, tactile quality. Why does she want the work to have that physical feeling, to make you feel something, or to make parts of it stand out in this way? Because it adds a lot of texture.(c) Svitlana Glushko

Vashchenko: Because this is how she feels it. She is an artist. I think when artists create something, their choices usually have a purpose. This is how she feels it, and that’s why she uses texture paste. There doesn’t have to be another purpose beyond that. You feel something, and you want to make it that way. That can be enough, I think, for choosing the material.

Jacobsen: I mean, you know the qualities and properties of the material, and you know your intention, so you choose the material accordingly. At the top, it looks as though the sections were marked out with a ruler or separated with tape and then painted over.

Vashchenko: This is absolutely handmade. You know why? Because if you look really closely, you can see slight imperfections. That is part of working by hand. For me, it is different from the kind of exact precision you might expect in an architectural or design drawing. We do this by hand.

Handmade, that’s the main thing. Even though the lines look quite straight compared with the others, even the skyline, you see, is slightly wavy because it’s all done by hand.

Vashchenko: Now, this artist is Valentyna Khmil.

Jacobsen: I don’t want to make direct comparisons between artists. That’s probably not appropriate. Stylistically and thematically, though, there are elements of taking parts of the body and reforming them, almost in a surrealist way, like Picasso. She warps things, in the way that you might see with Dalí. She does both at the same time.

Vashchenko: Say that again? I like how you describe it.

Jacobsen: Like a melting clock of Dalí, with something of Picasso in it.

Vashchenko: Nice description.

Jacobsen: A lot of these forms seem to suggest both growth and vegetation, living things, but there is also a kind of vivacity to them, a lot of life. I feel my eyes being drawn upward because of the hair and the fine physical details, so to speak. From your conversations with her, what would she be feeling?

Vashchenko: For this artist, these artworks are not very easy to make. They are about rather traumatic experiences and, to some extent, unpleasant feelings. But the end result is actually wonderful. This artwork is the main work in the series, and it is called In This Body.

She was thinking about why people are always looking at themselves in such a large mirror, paying attention to the smallest imperfections, feeling insecure, and feeling bad about something.

Jacobsen: That’s a very feminine frame.

Vashchenko: Yeah, a feminine thing. Why do we do this, even though we are also creatures of nature? We can appreciate the beauty of flowers and the beauty of nature, but we cannot see that beauty in ourselves. That is kind of unfair and a little painful. She has been trying to accept herself and everything about herself. It is not only about appearance, but something internal as well.

She wanted to show this through the way she combines parts of bodies with nature, flowers, and everything around them. It shows that we are part of something bigger, something natural, something organic, like I said, and that we are all connected.

That’s why it is depicted visually as well. Those two artworks are supposed to be together, but they can also be perceived separately. This one is like the process of creating an idea, a thought, how the thought is actually born and then begins to deepen, grow, and take form.

This artwork is called New Wings. You see, those things kind of resemble wings? New Wings. It means that you stop living the way you lived before, but you don’t yet know how to live in a new way. You are somewhere in between. You have those wings, but they are not working yet. You are not flying yet. It’s such an interesting painting.

Jacobsen: This one is softer on the eyes. The brown is soft, but in a kind of flat way. It feels earthly. It’s earthy. This one adds shades of orange. Does that signify anything, or is it just more of a sunset?

Vashchenko: This has exactly the same feeling and meaning as the previous one. I think she created several safe places so that each piece can find its viewer, and each viewer can find their own piece, somewhere they feel safe. They just feel different. They have different vibes, colours, character, and moods, but the meaning is the same.

Vashchenko: This is a very interesting series of works. It is actually much bigger. Only several of them are represented here. Unfortunately, we don’t have the cards anymore. There were cards where you could see the whole series.

The main idea of this series, as you guessed, is the body and how we experience being in our bodies. She looks at our bodies as sources of experience, at how we live through things with our bodies and how our bodies change.

She wants people to realize that things about our bodies that make us different or special are not flaws or something bad. We need to accept these things in ourselves. She believes that accepting ourselves helps us accept other people, judge them less, and become kinder in general. It can lead to a better relationship with other people and with the world.

Here, these artworks mainly depict people in different social contexts and social roles. This work, for example, opens the series to a wider range of experiences because she also depicted women after breast cancer, women after giving birth, and pregnant women. It looks so touching, actually, because you look at them and you see these things that I cannot even call imperfections.

They are simply particular features of their bodies, and you do not think of them as imperfections because she depicts them beautifully. When you look at these paintings, you understand that this really is beautiful, and it helps you appreciate these things much more.

The red colour and the different shades of red represent a passion for life. We think it is very symbolic to see our booth in red because this idea is very important for Ukraine now, to feel a passion for life. It is, I think, vitally important.

Jacobsen: In the shading, I’m noticing almost a brown-red in some of the hair, particularly on the men. Then, on the men on the left, though not the one on the right, there is a very deep, rich blue with a hint of purple.

Vashchenko: Yeah, kind of bluish.

Jacobsen: Yeah, but it’s not precisely navy blue. It’s a little offbeat.

And in terms of the reds, some are very brown-tinted reds. On several of the women’s bodies, the pregnant woman, the woman standing in the background facing us, and also the man in the middle here, I’m seeing a lot of that brownish red. Others are just bang, bang, bang, bang, bright red.

Then there are these figures, this gentleman and these three gentlemen. They have different shades, almost an oily patchwork of the various colours. If you look here, though, it’s solid.

Vashchenko: You mean the colour is smooth here, and here it has more shading, right?

Jacobsen: Yeah.

Vashchenko: Wow, I hadn’t noticed that before you said it, actually. I’ve been looking at this for quite a while and hadn’t noticed it so closely.

Jacobsen: And then there are two cases I have question marks about. I’m not sure why. They are basically orange.

Vashchenko: Here?

Jacobsen: Mm-hmm. Slightly.

Vashchenko: You’re so attentive. I’m shocked. I’ve been looking at this for quite a while, all day, and haven’t noticed these details so closely.

Jacobsen: The other differences are all very subtle.

Each of the canvas backgrounds, the base colours, is actually different, except for these two. They’re basically the same. But this one with the men has a black lower section.

Here, it’s almost a peach-white. Here, similarly, but more white. Toward this one, it becomes more yellowish.

This one is the only one that has a foundation like this. It gives a sense of grounding. Those women are sitting and doing something. Maybe one of them is having some kind of social problem. She looks upset.

She’s leaning down to talk to her, and then they’re unclothed. There’s a kind of nakedness in the physical presentation, but I think it is really showing vulnerability metaphorically.

And the men, unlike the women, are somewhat desexed. Not in their overall forms, but the women have nipples and breasts clearly depicted, pregnancy is present, and the genital area is suggested. With the men, those sexual characteristics are much less emphasized.

But here, too, you don’t really see those details on the people. In general, I think that’s the point. It’s realistic. I mean, the anatomy and the dynamics are realistic, but some details are deliberately neglected.

Interesting. And they’re very… They’re almost like a kind of high-fidelity impressionism, in the sense that there are solid lines and clear forms, but they’re rendered in a very basic visual style. I don’t mean “basic” as unsophisticated.

Vashchenko: Yeah, I know. You mean it as a style.

Jacobsen: Exactly.

(c) Alina Lobanova

Jacobsen: Now, these ones, I’m told one of them has been sold. We’re seeing wire, decorative elements, candles, and faces shown at slightly different angles, almost as though the head has been rotated by the neck. So, what is Alina Lobanova trying to do here?

Vashchenko: There are, of course, several meanings in this series. There are supposed to be seven artworks. One has been sold, so six remain here.

Each represents a particular emotion and a particular kind of mask that we put on ourselves in everyday life. There are seven of them, like the seven days of the week.

Another part of the concept came from her experience in 2024, during severe electricity blackouts in Ukraine. We were often without electric light, so candles were always around. She became interested in the way candlelight played across people’s faces.

She pays a lot of attention to details. She focuses strongly on facial expressions and gestures. She also works a lot with female experience and femininity in general.

Jacobsen: Now that you say that, there are a lot of women’s faces.

Vashchenko: Yes, a lot. And you can feel that they all have different moods. She depicted different emotions.

What’s interesting is that when the candles are lit, the faces become more alive. The contrast becomes stronger, and certain colours stand out. As the light changes, there is a warmer light across the faces, while the shadows become less cold. The faces begin to look more lifelike.

It’s very impressive. If there is a blackout, you can actually see the effect. When we were setting up our booth here, there was a total blackout, and there were blackouts every day. Today, for some reason, there hasn’t been one.

And everything here is handmade. The material is… I’m not sure how to say it in English.

Jacobsen: Is it like ceramic? Like a tile?

Vashchenko: It’s something like air-dry modelling clay, a ceramic-like self-hardening material. You don’t need to fire it in an oven for it to harden. It hardens by itself. She made all of these elements herself and developed the whole concept.

There is supposed to be a real candle in the holder here, but we can’t use open flames at the art fair, so we put an artificial candle there instead.

Jacobsen: And there’s also the blue, this exaggerated fleshy pink, and these large areas of white. It feels almost hyperreal. It feels like I’ve put on LSD glasses or something.

Vashchenko: Yeah, it has that kind of saturation.

Jacobsen: What’s your favourite piece? Are you allowed to say?

Vashchenko: I have two favourites: the one that was bought and this one. This one is here, and the one that was bought was here.

I don’t know, there’s something in this face. She looks kind of disturbed and sad, but strong and calm at the same time. I feel very safe looking at her. She looks like she has seen many things. She seems very wise, as if she knows something but doesn’t want to argue about it. I don’t know. There’s something very deep in her expression.

Jacobsen: This looks like the face of a woman who has tried something and failed over and over again. Now she’s seeing the same thing happen to someone else, maybe a friend, colleague, or another woman, and she knows that intervening probably won’t change anything. So she just has that wise expression of, “Okay, yes. I’ve seen this before.”

Vashchenko: Yes, something like that. And there’s a tiny spark in her eyes that is very visible. This girl has the same spark. I like it very much. So those are my favourites.

Jacobsen: And these look like real faces because there are real asymmetries.

Vashchenko: Yes, they are real faces.

Jacobsen: These eyes aren’t symmetrical, for example. With some of the others, it’s harder to tell because of the angle, but this one is definitely asymmetrical.

Vashchenko: They are very realistic, yes.

Jacobsen: And I’m guessing these two are the same woman, and those two are also the same woman.

Vashchenko: And these are two different women, I think. I assume so, but I’m not sure because Alina didn’t tell me who these people are. I don’t want to make up stories about them.

Jacobsen: And which one is your favourite? I mean, which one catches your attention most?

Vashchenko: Of all the artworks?

Jacobsen: No, I mean among these.

Vashchenko: The ones that haven’t been sold?

Jacobsen: Yeah.

Vashchenko: I mean, you asked me which one I like most, and I’m wondering which one you like.

Jacobsen: This lady. She still has hope. This lady still has hope. Also, the ears aren’t present.

Vashchenko: Yeah, in some of the pieces they aren’t present.

Jacobsen: No, no. This is the only one where an ear is actually visible.

Vashchenko: Wow, really? Wow, you’re so attentive. You’ve actually helped me look at this differently. Maybe she can still listen to something because she still has hope. I don’t know.

Jacobsen: Maybe we can move quickly to Art Navigator. What exactly is it?

Vashchenko: Art Navigator Academy is an educational platform for artists, curators, art managers, designers, photographers, and other creative professionals. When I say artists, I don’t mean only painters. It works with people across different areas of the art world.

It helps people understand how to build a career in the art world and art business, where to begin, how to position themselves, and how to promote their work professionally.

One of its main programs is called Creative Career Compass. All of us completed that program, and now we can take part in events like this. The academy helps introduce artists to the professional art world and teaches you how that system works.

They work like mentors, and they have different courses for different professional goals. It is very useful for building an artistic career and finding your direction.

The academy was founded in 2023 by Anna Avetova and Dasha Bilenko. They are Ukrainian art curators and art managers with extensive experience in Ukraine and internationally.

They share very valuable knowledge and professional connections. I really think it’s a wonderful academy.

It doesn’t depend on one physical location because the educational programs are online, so people can participate from different places. We have Ukrainians studying from abroad as well as people who are here in Ukraine. We stay in touch and work together on different art projects, so I think it’s very valuable.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Sofia.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Ali Aliev and Maksym Havryshchuk on Business in Poland

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/20

Maksym “Max” Havryshchuk is a Ukrainian entrepreneur and co-owner of EVAMATS, a Polish manufacturer of custom car mats. His work involves products tailored to individual vehicles. In this interview, he discusses researching new markets, choosing between relocation and starting again, and adapting business operations to commercial conditions in another country.

Ali Aliev is a Belarus-born entrepreneur based in Poland, where he has lived for twelve years. He runs an accounting business and provides business consulting, following earlier experience operating a sushi restaurant. In this interview, he discusses tax matters, business relocation, local partnerships, recruitment, and understanding unfamiliar markets.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen interviews Ali Aliev and Maksym Havryshchuk about starting businesses in Poland, relocating operations, and entering unfamiliar markets. They discuss accounting, hospitality, custom car mats, local partnerships, recruitment, and transferring senior managers. The conversation closes with their views on hard work, stability, inequality, and cultural attitudes toward suffering.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Could you each introduce yourselves, tell me where you are from, and describe your businesses in Poland?

Maxsym Havryshchuk: I am from Ukraine, and my business in Poland manufactures custom car mats.

Ali Aliev: I was born in Belarus and have lived in Poland for twelve years. I run an accounting business and work as a business consultant. We help businesses with accounting, optimization, and tax matters.

Jacobsen: Have you two had any business dealings before? Your fields seem quite unrelated, although perhaps there is a connection.

Aliev: I previously worked in hospitality. I had a sushi restaurant, which I sold before opening an accounting business.

Havryshchuk: I have also had some startups. One involved selling boxing gloves.

Jacobsen: Did you box?

Havryshchuk: Yes, I used to box.

Jacobsen: What weight class were you in?

Havryshchuk: I was a beginner.

Jacobsen: The “ability to throw a fist” class.

Havryshchuk: I had about ten fights.

Jacobsen: “Can you punch skulls?”

“Yes.”

“You’re in.”

[Aliev and Hvryshchuk laughing.]

Havryshchuk: I also sold watches and had a business involving apartment renovation and repairs.

Jacobsen: A handyman or repairman?

Havryshchuk: Yes, repairs in apartments.

Jacobsen: There is a North American expression, “a jack of all trades.” There was an old Canadian comedy show where the solution to everything was duct tape. It had the line, “If the women don’t find you handsome, they should at least find you handy.”

What would you recommend to people who leave their country and either start a new business abroad or transfer an existing business to another country?

Havryshchuk: It depends on the business. You need to analyze the country you are moving to and decide whether it would be better to transfer your existing business or start a new one.

For a business with physical operations, like mine, I think starting a new business in the other country may be better. If you have an online product, transferring it may be more practical.

Aliev: For me, starting a new business in the new country can be easier than transferring the existing one.

You can build relationships with new business partners and learn how things work locally. You need to understand how businesses operate in that country, make contacts in your sector, and develop your knowledge of the market.

For example, if you are starting in Poland, learning how business works here and finding local partners can help you establish a new business.

If you transfer an existing operation, you may need to move employees and bring over your systems. That can be difficult and expensive. For those reasons, I would prefer to start a new business.

Jacobsen: What advice would you give to people who are just getting into business, or who already know how to start a business but are entering a different industry? Someone might move from manufacturing car mats to insurance, or from insurance to manufacturing. I am interested in general principles rather than specifics. Probably with new people, because your existing employees’ skills may not transfer directly. People who make car mats cannot necessarily move straight into accounting, and vice versa.

You, as the owner, might start a business in a new field and hire people who already have the relevant skills in that country.

Aliev: I would prefer to hire and train people in the new country. They live there, understand how people think, and know how things work locally.

You might bring one or two people from your existing company, perhaps up to five senior managers, and then build the rest of the team locally.

Plata in Mexico, associated with Oleg Tinkov, is an example that comes to mind. My understanding is that people from an existing company moved into senior roles, while others were hired locally because they understood the Mexican market. That is the kind of approach I mean.

Havryshchuk: For me, it is the same.

Jacobsen: What is your favourite piece of Slavic business wisdom? It could be a quotation, saying, or aphorism. For example, “All that glitters is not gold” expresses the idea that you should look beyond appearances. Is there something similar that you associate with business?

Havryshchuk: Something about the mentality. It is about mentality.

Aliev: For me, it is “Work hard, play hard.” There is a long period of hard work at the beginning. After one or two years, you may have built a strong business and community. I associate that with Slavic business culture.

In my view, businesses in more stable parts of Europe can develop over a longer period because people have more time and stability. In Belarus, Ukraine, and other former Soviet countries, people have faced difficult conditions.

From my perspective, the divide between rich and poor can feel especially sharp in Ukraine and Belarus, while the middle class seems more established in some other European countries.

Jacobsen: I see a connection with religious culture and social culture with that business culture orientation, including themes in Eastern Orthodoxy about suffering as part of the path to God.

In my view, there can also be a social attitude that happiness has to be earned through suffering, as though your happiness is justified by how much pain you have experienced. Those are different layers of culture expressing similar ideas.

Thank you. I appreciate it.
What advice do Ali Aliev and Maksym Havryshchuk offer on starting a business in Poland, relocating operations, and hiring local employees?

Maksym “Max” Havryshchuk is a Ukrainian entrepreneur and co-owner of EVAMATS, a Polish manufacturer of custom car mats. His work involves products tailored to individual vehicles. In this interview, he discusses researching new markets, choosing between relocation and starting again, and adapting business operations to commercial conditions in another country.

Ali Aliev is a Belarus-born entrepreneur based in Poland, where he has lived for twelve years. He runs an accounting business and provides business consulting, following earlier experience operating a sushi restaurant. In this interview, he discusses tax matters, business relocation, local partnerships, recruitment, and understanding unfamiliar markets.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen interviews Ali Aliev and Maksym Havryshchuk about starting businesses in Poland, relocating operations, and entering unfamiliar markets. They discuss accounting, hospitality, custom car mats, local partnerships, recruitment, and transferring senior managers. The conversation closes with their views on hard work, stability, inequality, and cultural attitudes toward suffering.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Could you each introduce yourselves, tell me where you are from, and describe your businesses in Poland?

Maxsym Havryshchuk: I am from Ukraine, and my business in Poland manufactures custom car mats.

Ali Aliev: I was born in Belarus and have lived in Poland for twelve years. I run an accounting business and work as a business consultant. We help businesses with accounting, optimization, and tax matters.

Jacobsen: Have you two had any business dealings before? Your fields seem quite unrelated, although perhaps there is a connection.

Aliev: I previously worked in hospitality. I had a sushi restaurant, which I sold before opening an accounting business.

Havryshchuk: I have also had some startups. One involved selling boxing gloves.

Jacobsen: Did you box?

Havryshchuk: Yes, I used to box.

Jacobsen: What weight class were you in?

Havryshchuk: I was a beginner.

Jacobsen: The “ability to throw a fist” class.

Havryshchuk: I had about ten fights.

Jacobsen: “Can you punch skulls?”

“Yes.”

“You’re in.”

[Aliev and Hvryshchuk laughing.]

Havryshchuk: I also sold watches and had a business involving apartment renovation and repairs.

Jacobsen: A handyman or repairman?

Havryshchuk: Yes, repairs in apartments.

Jacobsen: There is a North American expression, “a jack of all trades.” There was an old Canadian comedy show where the solution to everything was duct tape. It had the line, “If the women don’t find you handsome, they should at least find you handy.”

What would you recommend to people who leave their country and either start a new business abroad or transfer an existing business to another country?

Havryshchuk: It depends on the business. You need to analyze the country you are moving to and decide whether it would be better to transfer your existing business or start a new one.

For a business with physical operations, like mine, I think starting a new business in the other country may be better. If you have an online product, transferring it may be more practical.

Aliev: For me, starting a new business in the new country can be easier than transferring the existing one.

You can build relationships with new business partners and learn how things work locally. You need to understand how businesses operate in that country, make contacts in your sector, and develop your knowledge of the market.

For example, if you are starting in Poland, learning how business works here and finding local partners can help you establish a new business.

If you transfer an existing operation, you may need to move employees and bring over your systems. That can be difficult and expensive. For those reasons, I would prefer to start a new business.

Jacobsen: What advice would you give to people who are just getting into business, or who already know how to start a business but are entering a different industry? Someone might move from manufacturing car mats to insurance, or from insurance to manufacturing. I am interested in general principles rather than specifics. Probably with new people, because your existing employees’ skills may not transfer directly. People who make car mats cannot necessarily move straight into accounting, and vice versa.

You, as the owner, might start a business in a new field and hire people who already have the relevant skills in that country.

Aliev: I would prefer to hire and train people in the new country. They live there, understand how people think, and know how things work locally.

You might bring one or two people from your existing company, perhaps up to five senior managers, and then build the rest of the team locally.

Plata in Mexico, associated with Oleg Tinkov, is an example that comes to mind. My understanding is that people from an existing company moved into senior roles, while others were hired locally because they understood the Mexican market. That is the kind of approach I mean.

Havryshchuk: For me, it is the same.

Jacobsen: What is your favourite piece of Slavic business wisdom? It could be a quotation, saying, or aphorism. For example, “All that glitters is not gold” expresses the idea that you should look beyond appearances. Is there something similar that you associate with business?

Havryshchuk: Something about the mentality. It is about mentality.

Aliev: For me, it is “Work hard, play hard.” There is a long period of hard work at the beginning. After one or two years, you may have built a strong business and community. I associate that with Slavic business culture.

In my view, businesses in more stable parts of Europe can develop over a longer period because people have more time and stability. In Belarus, Ukraine, and other former Soviet countries, people have faced difficult conditions.

From my perspective, the divide between rich and poor can feel especially sharp in Ukraine and Belarus, while the middle class seems more established in some other European countries.

Jacobsen: I see a connection with religious culture and social culture with that business culture orientation, including themes in Eastern Orthodoxy about suffering as part of the path to God.

In my view, there can also be a social attitude that happiness has to be earned through suffering, as though your happiness is justified by how much pain you have experienced. Those are different layers of culture expressing similar ideas.

Thank you. I appreciate it.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Alex Guts on Ukrainian Entrepreneurship, European Banking, and Fintech

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/20

Alex Guts is Group Chief Executive Officer of Banxe, a fintech platform connecting international payments and digital asset services. Originally from Odesa, Ukraine, and based in southern France, he has experience in startups, software, e-commerce, and digital marketing. His work focuses on financial technology, business development, and cross-border payment markets.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen interviews Alex Guts about Banxe, Ukrainian entrepreneurship, and differences in European business cultures. Guts discusses Odesa’s multicultural influence, migration, risk-taking, banking digitalization, and fintech development. Their conversation covers regulation, startup funding, wartime innovation, and the value of balancing entrepreneurial speed with patience in major business decisions.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Could you introduce yourself, your role, and the company you represent?

Alex Guts: I’m the CEO of Banxe, a fintech platform offering international money transfers, card issuing, card acquiring, cryptocurrency payments, and cryptocurrency exchange services.

Jacobsen: When did you get involved?

Guts: Five years ago.

Jacobsen: Why?

Guts: I’ve been involved in different startups for almost a decade, including software-as-a-service and e-commerce. I also have experience with some larger enterprises.

One day, I met my partner, who pitched me on his project and said he wanted to disrupt the market a little. It sounded like an exciting path, so I decided to try it and see how it went. I’ve been doing that for the past five years, and I’m happy to be involved in this industry.

Jacobsen: Did you originally start in Warsaw, or did you move from one place to another?

Guts: I don’t live in Warsaw now. I live in southern France. Originally, I’m Ukrainian, from Odesa. I was born next to the sea. I ended up in a coastal city, too. It’s probably something fundamental to me.

I’ve lived in different countries, including Ukraine and France. I studied in Germany. I also studied at Kozminski University in 2015 and 2016. It’s my alma mater.

I didn’t start this business in Warsaw. The market was different when we started.

Jacobsen: What does Ukraine mean to you? How would you distinguish Western European and Eastern European approaches to business, as broad trends? There is some overlap.

Guts: That’s a good question. Ukraine is my home. I was born and raised there. Odesa is very different. If you’ve been there, you know its atmosphere is different from Kyiv, Lviv, and other cities. It’s extremely international.

Probably the biggest advantage Odesa gave me was the opportunity to be part of multicultural, international communities and build connections with people from different backgrounds.

That’s important in my business now. We work with people in the UK, which is itself very international, and across Europe. We also do business with the Middle East and North America, and we have some Asian clients.

Thanks to Odesa, I have a basic understanding of different cultures and religions. Christian, Jewish, and Muslim communities are part of that environment. It was a good education.

Regarding the difference between Western and Eastern Europe, I’m impressed that people in Eastern Europe are more willing to take risks. There hasn’t been the same continuity over generations in building businesses, preserving wealth, and passing on capital.

I see that willingness to take risks in Ukraine, Poland, and Czechia. There are similarities in business mentality. That may help explain why Ukrainians were moving to Poland even before Russia’s full-scale invasion in 2022. When I studied here in 2015, many Ukrainian students were already here.

In Western European countries such as France, Germany, Spain, and Italy, people seem more relaxed and less inclined to rush. They feel they can build wealth over decades. Economic conditions differ, but they often feel more stable over the long term.

In Ukraine, we’ve experienced crisis after crisis over the past 30 years. I think that’s another reason people are willing to take risks. They feel they don’t have as much time.

Jacobsen: Some businesses can also get started more quickly because the regulatory burden can be lighter than in Germany.

Guts: That’s a good point, although I wouldn’t necessarily call it a major advantage.

Jacobsen: I don’t frame it as better or worse. When I look at business and other aspects of culture, I look at trade-offs.

Guts: Yes. One problem in 2022 was that many Ukrainians had to leave their homes because of the full-scale invasion and move to other European countries without understanding the basics of local law and regulation. For them, starting a business was difficult at first.

Jacobsen: It was a drastic shift in mentality.

Guts: Yes. Since then, I’ve seen people adapt and do well.

Jacobsen: Motivation, hard work, and having no other option can play a role.

Guts: Unfortunately, yes. That’s another reason people take risks.

Jacobsen: Sometimes you have to be strong because you don’t have a choice. Survival matters.

Guts: That’s true. It’s also part of the Ukrainian mentality: if we do something, we want to do it on a big scale.

Jacobsen: You want to do it better than the host population?

Guts: It isn’t necessarily competitive. It’s about how we do things and present ourselves.

Jacobsen: Professionalism is a big factor. What should people understand about banking principles?

Guts: Banking in Ukraine and the rest of Europe isn’t fundamentally different. But one of the first things people should understand is that, in my view, many European banks still lag in digitalization and in modernizing their systems and processes.

Jacobsen: I’m told that Germans love fax machines. Annoyingly.

Guts: Sometimes people are still using fax machines, right?

Jacobsen: Annoyingly, if not exasperatingly.

Guts: In Ukrainian banking, major players like monobank helped push the market toward digitalization. It was Ukraine’s first mobile-only banking service, without a traditional branch network. That was remarkable. When you think about traditional banking, you expect a physical branch.

Jacobsen: You expect a teller.

Guts: Yes. You expect to be able to come in and shout at someone.

Jacobsen: A very Slavic point: “I will yell at this person personally.”

There’s also the joke that, if a North American is asked about something, they might say, “Let me check the national statistics or Pew Research.” The Slavic version is, “Let me call Uncle Boris. He lives near there.”

Guts: That sounds like a story from my childhood. Sometimes it works like that.

In the European market, Revolut is one of the major players focused on digital services. It also operates as a licensed bank.

On the other hand, European regulations exist. Some are useful; others can be questionable. To return to your point, a lighter regulatory burden can sometimes facilitate innovation.

Many Ukrainians now found and run fintech companies in Europe, North America, Asia, Africa, and Latin America. We’ve seen how well digital banking can work.

If you use major Ukrainian services such as PrivatBank or Sense Bank, then go to the Netherlands, Germany, or the UK and look at some established banks, you may think, “I want to digitalize this. I want to do it better. I can build a good mobile application. What do I need to do?”

When you start exploring, building a fintech in Europe can be more achievable than you initially thought.

There are regulations and demanding procedures. You need a team and capital. You need substantial funding to launch a financial services business, but it doesn’t necessarily mean hundreds of millions.

For a smaller project, I would estimate one or two million; for something somewhat larger, perhaps five million. If you have that funding, or can raise it, you can explore starting your own financial services business.

Depending on the structure and permissions, that could involve money transfers, SEPA payments, SWIFT transfers, card issuing, or your own branded debit card.

That’s what I like about the European market. You can start small and grow.

Jacobsen: What’s your favourite Ukrainian business aphorism? It could also be a broader Slavic saying.

Guts: It means, “Don’t rush.”

Jacobsen: “Don’t push the horses.” I’ve worked with horses, so that’s a good phrase.

Guts: I don’t like to rush. Maybe that comes from living elsewhere in Europe for some time. Sometimes you need time to make a good decision.

That’s another thing Ukrainian entrepreneurs can learn from other European businesses. Being faster than everyone else can be an advantage, but sometimes you need to slow down.

Jacobsen: Another area is technology, as we’ve seen with military technology. Underdogs have to innovate. It may not always be necessary, but it’s close.

I think Ukrainians don’t allow themselves many excuses right now. They push themselves to innovate on several fronts.

Thank you for your time.

Guts: Thank you.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Ivan Hnatkiv on Ukrainian Entrepreneurship and Life in Poland

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/20

Ivan Hnatkiv on Ukrainian Entrepreneurship and Life in Poland

Photo by Iwona Castiello d’Antonio on Unsplash

Ivan Hnatkiv is a Ukrainian entrepreneur from Zaporizhzhia based in Warsaw. He has lived in Poland for about ten years and describes his businesses as an aesthetic medicine clinic he runs with his wife, a doctor, and a financial startup. His experience includes recruitment, outsourcing, and building professional networks in Poland.

Ivan Hnatkiv speaks with Scott Douglas Jacobsen about moving from Zaporizhzhia to Warsaw, learning Polish, building professional relationships, and developing businesses. He reflects on Ukrainian support networks, changing Polish attitudes, Russian propaganda, and the uncertainty of returning home, while encouraging Ukrainian entrepreneurs to persevere and build lives for their families.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Could you introduce your businesses you run in Warsaw?

Ivan Hnatkiv: I am an entrepreneur here in Warsaw. I have lived here for around ten years and run two businesses. One is an aesthetic medicine clinic. My wife is a doctor, and we run the clinic together. The other is a financial startup.

Jacobsen: What were the difficulties of leaving Zaporizhzhia around ten years ago and moving to Poland? Compared with Germany, Poland and Ukraine have more shared historical and cultural connections. They can share sympathies, but also historical tensions.

There have been reports of prejudice against Ukrainians in Poland. Some coverage has been sensationalized, and getting a clear statistical picture can be difficult. However, qualitative reporting suggests that hostility has increased. There is footage of physical assaults, including against women. In traditionalist cultures, men are expected not to hit women. Breaking that taboo can indicate how strong the prejudice has become.

As a businessperson who moved here and has seen relations change during the war, what challenges and opportunities do you see?

Hnatkiv: I think the most difficult part was what many immigrants experience when starting a new life in a new country. When I came to Poland, I had no money, friends, or anyone who could help me get started. I needed to learn the language and understand how to build relationships here.

The hardest first step was figuring out how things worked. Ukrainians and Poles have many similarities in our mentalities, but we also have many differences. Building a circle of people around me and understanding the rules was a major challenge.

Something that helped was that many Ukrainians arrived around the same time as I did. Since 2014, many Ukrainians have moved to Poland and elsewhere in Europe. We faced similar challenges and helped one another solve them. Working and cooperating with other Ukrainians was very valuable to me.

In my experience, Polish people were very kind to Ukrainians. Having lived here for around ten years, I have seen relationships change over time. Around 2016, relations between Poles and Ukrainians felt more natural to me.

When Russia launched its full-scale invasion in 2022, Polish people helped Ukrainians enormously. You could find help everywhere. Now, I feel things have changed a little.

I think Russian propaganda plays a role. I also believe Russia finances some right-wing political actors.

Jacobsen: These campaigns can intensify around elections and then subside afterward. Election periods can create vulnerabilities that propaganda exploits, including by targeting political forces that support Ukraine.

There are also social flashpoints. Propaganda can exploit a controversial incident, an accident, or an unusual event. In the United States, we often see public controversy around mass shootings. Here, if someone involved in a violent incident is Ukrainian, or is claimed to be Ukrainian, that can become an opportunity to spread hate propaganda and prejudice.

Hnatkiv: I agree with you.

Jacobsen: What gives you meaning in business?

Hnatkiv: I think that, as an immigrant, you feel you need to do more than someone who is already a citizen. When you start a new life in a new country, you feel you should work more and do more. You cannot stop.

I remember the city and country I came from, which are now in a very difficult situation. I understand I may not be able to return home soon.

Zaporizhzhia is close to the front line. I need to find a way to build a life for myself and my family here because I may not be able to go home.

Jacobsen: For Ukrainians who make the difficult decision to leave home and start a new life, particularly those starting businesses and facing the risk of failure, what is your main advice?

Hnatkiv: I think Ukrainians are very brave people. I know many who started here in construction or other manual jobs. After a few years, they were running their own businesses.

I want to tell them: keep believing and keep working. I believe Ukrainians have everything they need to succeed in life.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Ivan.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Valeriya Obal on Warsaw Real Estate, Motherhood and Migration

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/17

Valeriya Obal is a Ukrainian real estate specialist and entrepreneur based in Warsaw. Originally from Kyiv, she works in commercial property leasing, investment transactions, and corporate relocation. She also runs a children’s technology school. Her professional interests connect business development, digital education, and the practical challenges of rebuilding life abroad.

Valeriya Obal speaks with Scott Douglas Jacobsen about commercial real estate in Warsaw, children’s technology education, and relocating from Kyiv during Russia’s full-scale invasion. She discusses maintaining ties to Ukraine, balancing entrepreneurship with motherhood, and how marriage, family support, and reliable communication shape her approach to work and personal life.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Could you introduce yourself and describe your professional work in Warsaw?

Valeriya Obal: My name is Valeriya Obal, and I am a real estate specialist. My colleagues call me the “Warsaw Real Estate Queen.” Why? I don’t know, but people say a nickname helps others remember you.

I also run an IT school for children. We teach children ages 4 to 17, helping them build skills for the future. They begin with LEGO programming and progress through different levels, eventually learning languages such as Python and JavaScript.

In real estate, I specialize in commercial property. I work with large IT, artificial intelligence, and iGaming companies, particularly on rentals and leases. I also work on capital market transactions when companies want to buy or sell property.

Jacobsen: Where in Ukraine are you from?

Obal: I am from Kyiv.

Jacobsen: Which district?

Obal: Pechersk.

Jacobsen: Pechersk? I have lived there for most of the year.

Obal: Near the Palace of Culture and Concerts, a little farther down from central Pechersk. Closer to Ocean Plaza, near the Holosiivskyi district. For us, the centre was not the best place to live with children.

Jacobsen: Why did you decide to leave, and what was the transition like?

Obal: I had connections with Poland for many years before the full-scale invasion. My father had Polish roots, which helped me obtain legal residence here.

My sister and her husband lived here, as did my husband’s brother. We already had a community. It is always easier to live somewhere when you have people to talk to and turn to for support.

We left Kyiv when the full-scale invasion began in 2022, but we returned. For two years, we lived between Ukraine and Poland. That was the most difficult period: travelling alone with two children, spending around 12 hours on the road each way, apart from the border crossing, and dealing with the bombardment.

Our children, especially my older son, had health problems. That is why we eventually decided to move.

I still travel to Kyiv about once a month because my mother is there. I also visit Khmelnytskyi, where my grandmother lives. I see what life in Kyiv is like, but my family is now based in Warsaw.

Jacobsen: I have noticed a pattern of older generations staying in their communities, whatever oblast, town, or village they live in. Part of it seems to be an attachment to home. Their investment is not only in a house; it is in their routines and community. Despite the difficulties, they do not want to leave. Do you see other reasons why people over 60 might stay?

Obal: Yes, I see that. We moved because we are younger, and my husband and I have professional skills. I am an economist with considerable corporate experience, so finding work was not especially difficult for me.

But home is still Kyiv. No other country can replace your home. That is why I keep going back. It restores that feeling of being at home before I return to Warsaw.

We chose Warsaw because it feels very similar to Kyiv. It is modern, calm, and welcoming. It is a nice place to live.

Jacobsen: How do you conduct your real estate business in Warsaw?

Obal: I work in commercial real estate. I no longer work in a corporate position because it takes too much of my time. I now run my own business and have a client base.

If I receive a request that is larger than I can handle independently, I seek support from major firms such as CBRE, Colliers, JLL, and Cushman & Wakefield. I have experience working with these companies. I also work with Engel & Völkers, another international company.

Depending on the request, I either handle it myself or work with their support. I contact developers and companies looking for offices or street-level retail premises.

I also help with company relocations. For example, if a company has 50 employees who need to relocate at once, I handle those requests too.

Jacobsen: You have two children, so you are a professional and a mother. Or a “professional mother.”

Obal: A professional mother.

Jacobsen: In my experience of Ukrainian culture, across Eastern Orthodox, Catholic, Jewish, and secular communities, there is a strong emphasis on family and traditional values.

Obal: Yes, principles.

Jacobsen: Foundational principles and family. Women approach parenthood in different circumstances. Some have always wanted children. Others feel pressure when their friends start families. Some experience an unplanned pregnancy, while others focus on education and their careers through their 20s before considering children in their 30s.

For women who want a family and a professional career, what would you recommend? Some have found a partner; others have not found someone who meets their expectations. How do they approach wanting both?

Obal: Work-life balance.

Jacobsen: Some women want to focus on a career; others want to stay at home. I think gender equality includes the freedom to choose, although those choices involve trade-offs. Others, like you, want both. That is a lot to manage. What would you recommend to them?

Obal: Yesterday, I was at my brother’s wedding, and I gave a toast. I told them that to build a happy life, you need a great deal of love. Life comes in waves, and love helps you swim through them. I don’t know anyone whose life has only moved upward.

When difficulties come, family is your backup, your source of strength, and your support.

I come from a traditional family, where marriage and children were expected. But even if someone had told me 13 years ago, when I got married, that I could choose whether to marry or have children, I would still have chosen marriage.

It is something you can build that can support you throughout your life. Business can bring profits, but it can also bring substantial losses and a feeling of emptiness. For me, family brings support and fulfilment alongside everything I do in business.

Without my family, I could not do the work I do. I would be very tired, a very boring woman, and I would want to kill everyone!

Jacobsen: That sounds very Slavic.

Obal: A traditional Slavic family. My family helps me remain romantic and feminine.

Jacobsen: In my experience, some Ukrainian women also understand March 8, International Women’s Day, differently from people I have encountered in Canada. Equality matters, but here the day can also involve celebrating femininity. In Canada, I more often encounter an emphasis on equality.

Obal: Of course. I have been to Toronto.

Jacobsen: It is different.

Obal: Yes. One difference I noticed was that in some couples, the man paid for himself and the woman paid for herself, even though they were a family. I wondered how they divided things in the fridge: “This is my milk; this is your milk.” I found it funny, but I saw that.

Jacobsen: And here, if you are the husband, giving two black roses would be a bad move. You might be in trouble for a month.

One last question. I don’t often get to speak with professional women who are also parents, and I think their perspective is valuable. Some women in their 30s want a family, have a career, and have not found a partner. They may be thinking of giving up on having children.

Should they keep looking? Consider in vitro fertilization (IVF). I do not think these subjects should be taboo. If people are concerned about birth rates, access to fertility treatment belongs in that conversation.

But what you are describing about family is also a partnership, a genuine partnership that serves as an anchor.

Obal: I am very traditional about this. I think a relationship is a gift from God. That is how I see it.

Jacobsen: What does your husband contribute to that partnership? What does his presence feel like emotionally? Is he an anchor?

Obal: For me, he is support.

Jacobsen: A feeling of safety as well?

Obal: Yes, safety and support. He helps me everywhere and always. I know that even if I were the worst person in the world, he would offer me a hand and say, “Stand up. Let us go together.”

Jacobsen: That brings to mind Oleksandr Usyk.

Obal: Yes.

Jacobsen: He has those famous expressions, “Don’t push the horses” and “I am feel. I am very feel.” I also remember a clip of him speaking to his wife during a press conference and saying, “This is my wife.” That gesture gets closer to what I mean about acknowledging your partner’s importance.

Obal: My husband will interrupt a meeting to send me a message saying, “I cannot chat now,” or “I cannot call now.” He doesn’t disappear for a week.

I know some women are in relationships like that, and I do not think it is good. Do not choose that. My husband is very good to me, and I am happy in this respect.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for your time.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Ivan Ostroukhov on German-Ukrainian Engineering, Construction, and Business Culture

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/17

Ivan Ostroukhov is an engineer and entrepreneur based in Brandenburg an der Havel, Germany. He leads DTMI Technology GmbH, registered in 2022, working across engineering, construction planning, repair, installation, commissioning, electrical equipment, and modular buildings. His professional background includes work in Ukraine, Kazakhstan, and Germany, as well as energy-sector technical projects and partnerships.

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Ivan Ostroukhov discuss German and Ukrainian business cultures, entrepreneurship, construction, engineering, bureaucracy, stability, workplace relationships, and immigrant motivation. Ostroukhov explains DTMI Technology’s problem-solving approach, its Ukrainian team culture, and how the company builds credibility while pursuing technical projects across European markets and clients.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Could you introduce and describe the company you founded?

Ivan Ostroukhov: I am the founder of a German-Ukrainian startup. It is an engineering, construction, and production company. Our focus is solving difficult technical problems for customers, often within very short timeframes.

Jacobsen: We talked about this months ago. I want to return to the differences between German and Ukrainian business styles. My framework is not that one is better or worse. It is about trade-offs. If you organize business one way, you gain certain advantages while giving up others. The German approach has strengths, and the Ukrainian approach has strengths. What is your assessment?

Ostroukhov: The German way can be very long and difficult. For example, when I returned to Ukraine and started a new business, I developed a significant number of projects and contracts within about a year.

The German market is much more conservative, particularly in our field. Companies want to know who you are. They want information about your company, its capabilities, and what you have already accomplished. It takes a long time to demonstrate what you can do and establish credibility in the German market.

At the same time, once we began finding customers in Germany, we also developed relationships with companies in the Czech Republic, Poland, North Macedonia, and the Benelux countries. Alongside our German projects, we have worked on many other projects elsewhere in Europe.

I think it has been a very good experience for us. It is simply a different way of doing business.

Jacobsen: In our previous interview, one participant made an interesting observation about Ukrainians who have relocated to Germany. People coming from a country at war may have lived through very difficult circumstances, while immigrants more broadly can also feel a strong drive to establish themselves and succeed in a new country. In the construction sector, this was expressed almost as, “We want to become better at construction than the local Germans.” That attitude reflects a strong drive. What do you think drives it, and how do you encourage that motivation within your own company?

Ostroukhov: From my perspective, our team today consists of Ukrainians. I started with people I already knew from previous jobs and projects.

I think we have developed a good combination of Ukrainian and German business cultures. Our relationship is not simply that of an owner and employees. We also have relationships as friends. We stay in contact, spend time with our families, and try not to create too much distance between us.

That lets us work in a more Ukrainian way within the team while adapting to a different style when working with German customers and partners.

Mentality is a major part of this. Traditions and expectations about relationships are also important.

Jacobsen: Many former Soviet states have struggled with corruption, although to very different degrees. Comparative international indicators show that perceived public-sector corruption is substantially lower in Germany than in Ukraine or Russia, even though Ukraine has also undertaken significant anti-corruption reforms. At the same time, formal business registration in Ukraine can be extremely fast, whereas businesses in Germany often face more complicated administrative procedures.

Germany can require considerable patience. Does the system provide greater predictability and stability for a company?

Ostroukhov: Yes. There is a period in which we have to do a great deal of work, but after that there is considerable inertia and continuity. In that respect, I think German business can be more stable.

I have experience doing business in Ukraine and Kazakhstan, both former Soviet republics. Many years ago, I also worked with Russian colleagues in different countries. Each country has a different approach, traditions, pace of work, working methods, and expectations about relationships between people.

Jacobsen: Can you describe more specifically what your company does and the kinds of projects you undertake?

Ostroukhov: Our main message to customers is always, “We will try.”

Right now, for example, we have some very difficult technical assignments. In some cases, a customer has approached another supplier first, and that company has said, “No, this is not for us,” because solving the problem would require too much time or too many resources.

We approach it differently. We tell the customer, “We will try.”

Then we work on the problem, develop a solution, and try to execute it quickly. Sometimes customers ask us, “You guys are from Ukraine. Where does all this motivation come from?”

I tell them we have faced many challenges throughout our lives, starting after university and continuing throughout our careers. We have learned to find solutions and keep moving forward.

Our goal is always to help the customer solve the problem. I think that approach has been very positive for both our company and the customers we work with.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Ivan.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Vlad Tuzov of Tuzov Gallery on ART KYIV and Ukrainian Contemporary Art

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/13

By Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Anna Strilets (English-Ukrainian Translator)

Vlad Tuzov is a Kyiv-based gallerist, curator, and founder of Tuzov Gallery. He presents emerging, mid-career, and established Ukrainian and international artists, combining commercial presentation with curatorial framing. His work focuses on exhibition design, artist development, and making contemporary art accessible to collectors through fairs, gallery programmes, and public-facing initiatives.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen speaks with Vlad Tuzov about exhibiting Ukrainian contemporary art at ART KYIV, balancing curatorial ideas with a sales-oriented fair, and representing artists across career stages. Tuzov discusses Ivanna Orliuk, OFCH, Igor Gusev, Dmytro Moldovanov, and Oleg Bazylewicz, including materials, symbolism, accessibility, and wartime artistic production in Ukraine.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Presenting art requires careful planning. With limited space, how do you ensure that every work contributes to the exhibition’s overall     expression?

Vlad Tuzov: I begin with the space itself. I place all the paintings on the floor, look at them together, and determine how best to use the walls and available surface. We have more strong artists and works than we can show at once, so the challenge is not filling empty space. It is selecting the right works and arranging them as effectively as possible.

Jacobsen: Art involves both self-expression and sales. How do you balance those elements?

Tuzov: I work with several groups of artists: emerging artists, younger artists who are gaining recognition, and established artists with a strong market presence. A successful gallery programme needs all three.

Lina Condes is one of the established international names. She is a Ukrainian-born, Miami-based contemporary artist known for her sculptural work. Forbes profiled her in 2020, and her work has appeared at major international events, including Art Miami.

We have also presented Ivanna Orliuk’s work for a long time. Her practice explores numbers, gematria, money, and financial systems. Her work has become a recurring part of the gallery’s programme because it brings together art, technology, and symbolic systems in a distinctive way.

Jacobsen: Ivanna Orliuk explores numerical systems and gematria. At this fair, her three paintings are displayed prominently at the centre. How do you balance sales with the exhibition’s broader concept?

Tuzov: ART KYIV is a sales-oriented commercial fair with curated gallery presentations. Sales shape the selection here, although I still try to retain a distinct curatorial voice.

I include conceptual work as well. Astian Rey’s spherical sculpture, for example, has a substantial conceptual and symbolic dimension. Two of his male-figure sculptures are installed at the entrance.

For this fair, I do not bring only large, dramatic works designed to create a “wow” effect. Those can work very well at an event such as Art Basel. Here, I balance them with smaller, more accessible works, so visitors can acquire an original piece of art without facing the highest price point.

Jacobsen: Which work serves as the central exhibit?

Tuzov: The central sculpture is priced at about $5,000.

Jacobsen: When we last met, you also had a smaller version of it.

Tuzov: Yes. We also presented a smaller version at the previous fair.

Jacobsen: The sculpture resembles a reverse Matryoshka-doll set. What are its dimensions?

Tuzov: It is available in three sizes: 60 centimetres, 120 centimetres, and 200 centimetres. The largest version is two metres high, about 6 feet 7 inches.

Jacobsen: When we last spoke, Ivanna Orliuk discussed gematria. Is it also important to your own artistic or curatorial approach?

Tuzov: Gematria is central to Ivanna’s individual artistic practice, rather than my own. I am the curator. My role is to present the work, frame it within an exhibition, and help audiences encounter the ideas behind it.

Jacobsen: The centrepiece is Synergy by OFCH. What do the hands emerging from the ground and the figure with open arms represent?

Tuzov: Synergy is about the exchange of energy between a woman and a man. The female hands lift the man upward, while his raised arms suggest that he is receiving energy, opening himself to the world, and preparing to pursue his goals.

The work draws on the familiar idea that a successful man is often supported by a woman. It is about a relationship in which energy, encouragement, and achievement move between two people.

Jacobsen: That is a very familiar phrase in North America as well.

Tuzov: Yes. The sculpture has been especially well received by women. It presents the man as drawing strength from that relationship before entering the world to act, achieve, and return something meaningful to it.

Jacobsen: Which works in this collection stand out most to you?

Tuzov: First, Ivanna Orliuk’s work. Second, this green painting by Igor Gusev, Vegan Morning.

Jacobsen: At first, I read it as an abstract landscape.

Tuzov: It is more literal than that. It depicts vegetables: cabbage, lettuce, and zucchini. Hence the title, Vegan Morning. I joke that it shows the food many Ukrainian men try to avoid.

Jacobsen: This older work feels more apocalyptic.

Tuzov: It is a 2015 work by Dmytro Moldovanov. He is associated with Ukrainian primitivism and naïve art, a tradition also represented by Maria Prymachenko. His paintings often use fantastic, unsettling imagery and an intentionally asymmetrical visual language.

Jacobsen: That comes through in the figures, including the griffins and succubi. The imagery has a distinctive, dreamlike imbalance.

Jacobsen: This work is more naïve in style, whereas the other is more detail-focused.

Tuzov: Yes. Dmytro Moldovanov’s work belongs to the naïve or primitive tradition. As of 2023, he was living and working in the Mykolaiv area and had continued painting during the full-scale war.

Jacobsen: I heard of a Ukrainian artist working from the trenches, making faces and other images from mud.

Tuzov: You mean Oleg Bazylewicz. He uses mud, clay, and ash from the front line in his work.

Jacobsen: Does he sell those pieces?

Tuzov: Yes. His work has been exhibited and sold as art created directly from the material conditions of the war.

Jacobsen: Is this sculpture one of your own works?

Tuzov: I am primarily a gallery owner and curator. This sculpture is represented by the gallery: Synergy by OFCH.

Jacobsen: Is it one of the most difficult and expensive works in the collection?

Tuzov: Yes. It is among the more technically demanding and expensive works.

Jacobsen: What materials does it use?

Tuzov: Polymer nanocomposites, a metal matrix, nanocomponents, and bronze.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Vlad.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Elena Viniarskaya on Pop Art, Cultural Icons and HOKA at Tuzov Gallery

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/13

By Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Anna Strilets (English-Ukrainian Translator)

Elena Viniarskaya is a Ukrainian director, music-video maker, photographer, and producer of visual stories. In this interview, she discusses paintings she says were presented through Tuzov Gallery, describing acrylic applied in thick layers without premixing colour, portraiture, and affirmations she associates with inner harmony.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen speaks with Elena Viniarskaya about paintings she says were presented through Tuzov Gallery. Viniarskaya describes reclaiming cultural icons for younger viewers, painting intuitively with unmixed colour, using impasto to convey emotion, retreating to paint in solitude, and embedding each canvas with an affirmation directed toward inner harmony.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Today, I am speaking with Elena Viniarskaya about her work presented through Tuzov Gallery. What inspired this piece?

Elena Viniarskaya: Colour is the starting point for this work. I want younger audiences to rediscover cultural icons such as Brigitte Bardot, whose significance may no longer be familiar to them. By rendering these figures in colour, I bring their images into the present.

I am especially drawn to actresses of mid-century cinema, including those who appeared in black-and-white films. I want their images to feel contemporary rather than confined to the past.

Jacobsen: Do you see your work as restoring these figures to public memory for a new generation?

Viniarskaya: Yes. That is central to what I do. Today, a person can become famous online almost instantly, sometimes through a single video. Many of the figures I paint built their reputations through sustained creative work. I want younger viewers to understand their cultural importance.

Jacobsen: Which decade do you focus on most when choosing figures to revisit?

Viniarskaya: I do not focus on a single decade. I once found a book of cultural icons that included figures from the 1920s, 1930s, 1940s, and later periods. I choose subjects through their faces, especially their eyes, and through a personal visual connection with them.

For this work, I wanted to create a contemporary counterpart to the Mona Lisa. The face is so familiar within everyday visual culture that it seems to look back at us wherever we go. In that sense, it is a Mona Lisa for our time.

Jacobsen: Among the figures you have brought back into view, who stands out most to you? Then we can return to the work displayed here.

Viniarskaya: He is not a conventional pop-culture icon. The work portrays a Ukrainian serviceman who was seriously wounded in the war. I have many photographs of him. For me, he is more important than any celebrity. He is the defining figure in this collection.

Jacobsen: What is this piece called, and what does it signify?

Viniarskaya: It is titled Happy Face. It is a portrait of Joaquin Phoenix, rather than simply an image of the Joker. I am interested in Phoenix as a person and in the warmth of his expression. His eyes and face convey the emotion I wanted to express.

Jacobsen: The palette includes substantial blue, green, red, white, and black, with only a small amount of yellow around the eye. Why did you choose those colours?

Viniarskaya: The palette develops intuitively while I work. I keep many colours available and respond to what the portrait seems to require. The subject guides the treatment, including the balance of blue, green, red, white, black, and yellow.

Jacobsen: What medium did you use for this work?

Viniarskaya: I work in acrylic, but I use it in a way that resembles oil painting. I do not premix colours. I apply pure colours directly.

The work is not intended only to be seen. It is also intended to be felt. Even with your eyes closed, you can sense its texture and emotion.

Jacobsen: Why do you apply the acrylic so thickly?

Viniarskaya: It is intuitive. I follow my instinct rather than a fixed method. Because I do not mix colours, I apply them directly in the form and intensity that feel right. The impasto carries the emotion.

Jacobsen: How do you combine outside influences with your own emotional response?

Viniarskaya: Painting is a private and intensive process for me. I absorb experiences, emotions, and impressions over time. When I feel ready, I rent a house by the sea for a month and paint without distraction. I continue until I have expressed what I have carried within me. Then I return to everyday life and wait until I feel the need to create again.

Jacobsen: Vlad Tuzov, what drew the gallery to Viniarskaya’s work?

Tuzov: I call it “Dubai style.” She has considerable potential and is one of Ukraine’s most distinctive colourists working within a pop-art sensibility. Her future is bright. That is why I am committed to promoting her work and investing in her development.

Jacobsen: You have spoken about emotional expression and painting retreats. Beyond that, does a spiritual practice or belief influence your work?

Viniarskaya: Yes. Every painting has its own affirmation. I incorporate the affirmation into the work and write it on the back of the canvas.

It is not a phrase that I prepare in advance. It comes to me through the person I am portraying and through the painting itself, and I direct it toward God. The affirmation also informs the colours. If the feeling is peace or calm, for example, the work may be dominated by green.

Jacobsen: What does HOKA mean?

Viniarskaya: HOKA is an affirmation, a brief inscription associated with this work. For me, it means complete inner harmony.

Jacobsen: Do you have any final thoughts?

Viniarskaya: I want everyone to find HOKA, complete inner harmony.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for your time. I appreciate it.

Viniarskaya: Thank you.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Bob Basset (Serhii Petrov) on Leather Masks, Tattooing, Facial Expression, and Artistic Identity

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/11

Bob Basset (Serhii Petrov) is a Ukrainian artist and leather craftsman known for sculptural masks produced through the Bob Basset studio, founded in 1989. Working with formed leather, vacuum metallization, tattooing, and hand-finishing, he creates distinctive wearable artworks exploring identity, expression, anatomy, emotion, transformation, and experimental approaches to material design.

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Bob Basset (Serhii Petrov) discuss the origins of the Bob Basset name, the studio’s family history, leather craftsmanship, vacuum metallization, tattooing, facial structure, emotional expression, evolutionary responses to faces, mask use, sexuality, BDSM associations, and the psychology of artistic transformation and identity itself.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Let’s begin with the names. That may be helpful because artists often work under pseudonyms or names connected to their artistic identity.

Bob Basset (Serhii Petrov): My name is Serhii Petrov. My artistic name is Bob Basset, which is also the name of my art studio, where I create my work.

Jacobsen: One thing I learned while researching your background was that the studio was founded in 1989.

Basset: Yes. I was born in 1976, but Bob Basset began as a family workshop with my older brother and our family.

Jacobsen: Do you have just one sibling?

Basset: Yes, one older brother.

Jacobsen: Did he also make art?

Basset: Yes. He was an artist and worked with me from the beginning. He died in 2011. Since then, I have continued Bob Basset.

Jacobsen: You explained yesterday where the name Bob Basset came from. What is the story behind it?

Basset: It is very simple. The name comes from a dog that was beloved in our family. He was a basset hound named Bob. When we were thinking about a name for the studio, Bob Basset seemed perfect. We all loved the dog, so the name carried positive associations for us.

Serhii Petrov is my personal name, but Bob Basset became my artistic identity and the name of the studio.

Jacobsen: Have you noticed an increase in sales in North America?

Basset: Yes. When choosing a name, it was important that it be easy for people who might buy the work to read and remember.

Jacobsen: In the art world, a name functions like a label, brand, or logo. What matters is the quality of the work. The name gives the art a recognizable identity, but ultimately the work matters more than the artist’s name to the person buying it. When people see “Bob Basset,” they recognize the work and know whether they like it.

Basset: Yes. I cannot objectively judge whether the quality is good because it is my own work. I always think it could be better. Other people have to judge it from the outside. But I have been doing this throughout my life, so at this point I am completely confident in my technique and craftsmanship.

Jacobsen: Yesterday, I realized I had misunderstood the shiny surface on some of these pieces. I assumed it was plastic, but it is actually metal.

Basset: Yes. It is metal applied to leather. I prepare the leather mask and place it in a vacuum metallization machine. The process deposits an extremely thin metallic coating onto the leather. Afterward, the surface is covered with a protective varnish, which produces the reflective, mirror-like finish.

Many people tell me they could produce the same effect by hand-painting it. I tell them, “Okay, try it.”

Jacobsen: There are also subtler technical elements. You have to shape details such as the lips and nostrils precisely. Then there is the tattooing. You have that work done by another specialist.

Basset: Of course.

Jacobsen: But the leatherwork itself is your specialization.

Basset: The tattoo artist is Yulia Kovach. She is highly skilled, has excellent technical control, and has formal artistic training.

The idea was mine because I find facial tattoos beautiful. I understand that tattoos on living skin change with age, but visually I find them compelling.

When I made this mask, I asked Yulia whether she could tattoo the leather. She was happy to experiment with it. We conducted several tests because prepared leather behaves differently from living skin. The way the ink enters and remains in the material is different, so the leather has to be prepared properly before tattooing.

The final result is beautiful. Achieving that level of detail on leather with another tool would be extremely difficult. If you look closely, the image is built through very fine dot work, similar to stippling in drawing. A graphic artist might create the same effect on paper with countless small marks, one after another. Reproducing that manually on leather without a tattoo machine would be almost impossible.

That is why the tattoo machine is so effective for this type of imagery. An artist will understand that this is not simply a matter of painting the surface with a brush. It requires a different technical approach.

I am particularly proud of that solution because it allows me to create leather pieces with this level of detail.

After removing the leather from the press form, I also rework certain areas by hand. I refine the features that determine the emotional expression of the mask, especially the lips, eyes, and nostrils. Small changes in these areas affect how we interpret the face and what emotion we perceive when we look at the mask.

Jacobsen: What are the common structural differences between male and female faces? If you looked at a hundred men and a hundred women, certain features would recur within each group. If you compared the two averages, what differences would you see?

Basset: The differences are visible in the proportions. A male face often has a more prominent brow, a larger and more structurally defined nose, and a longer overall facial shape. With these masks, you can usually recognize immediately whether the face has been designed as male or female.

Jacobsen: You were also describing how sensitive human beings are to subtle differences in faces and facial expressions, which reflects our evolutionary history. Small changes can strongly affect whether we perceive a face as male or female, threatening or calm, attentive or indifferent. How do you use small changes to produce such large effects?

Basset: I have a great deal of experience with this because I have worked with masks throughout my life. When I look at a face, I understand how particular details can change the emotion it conveys.

The angle and position of the lips are important. An open mouth, for example, can suggest heightened attention or predatory behavior. An animal tracking something may open its mouth as part of gathering sensory information, including scent.

The eyes are also critical. Their size, shape, and direction influence the character of the mask. A nocturnal hunter and a daytime hunter may have very different eyes. Large eyes can suggest gathering more visual information, while narrow eyes can suggest concentration or focus.

The direction of the gaze is especially important. Throughout evolution, animals have needed to determine whether another creature is looking at them. Recognizing the direction of another animal’s attention helps determine whether it presents a threat. This sensitivity predates human beings and is rooted deeply in animal evolution.

That is one reason masks are so compelling. In some ways, making masks gives the artist an advantage because faces already carry enormous emotional significance. When you wear a mask, you can control the expression presented to other people. You can choose a specific emotion and place it on your face.

Jacobsen: Where do people use these masks after buying them? Are they primarily displayed as art objects, or do people actually wear them?

Basset: Both. People wear them at carnivals and raves. Some use them in private or sexual settings as well.

Jacobsen: I do not see anything inherently wrong with that. Sexuality is a fundamental part of human nature.

Psychiatry does not use “perversion” as a diagnostic category. That is moral or theological language rather than a scientific diagnosis. The DSM-5-TR distinguishes paraphilias from paraphilic disorders.

A non-normative sexual interest is not itself a mental disorder. It becomes a paraphilic when it causes clinically significant distress or impairment, or involves harm or risk of harm to nonconsenting people. ICD-11 makes a comparable distinction.

People derive pleasure from many different activities, including sexual practices that fall outside prevailing social norms. Nonconformity by itself is not pathology.

Basset: People often look at my work and say, “Oh, this is BDSM.” I tell them that if they experience it as BDSM, then for them it is BDSM.

Jacobsen: It depends on how someone uses the object. The object itself is not inherently BDSM.

Basset: Exactly. I think my masks act as catalysts. A mask can bring something out of the person wearing it, but what emerges depends entirely on that individual. The mask can allow someone to express something that might have been difficult to express without it.

I can say confidently that my masks are very different from conventional masks.

Jacobsen: They are very distinctive. They immediately stand out.

Basset: Thank you.

Jacobsen: Thank you.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Reflections on Beijing+30: Nigerian Women’s Progress, Gender Equality, and the Barriers That Remain

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10

In early last year, it was the 1995 Fourth World Conference on Women in Beijing, Nigerian women’s progress in education, politics, agriculture, and entrepreneurship remains paired with persistent barriers. Dauda Lawal, Governor of Zamfara State, in 2025 reflects on resilience, historical women leaders, expanded opportunities, and continuing inequalities, urging renewed attention to gender equality, economic inclusion, education, and women’s empowerment across Nigeria today nationwide.

I took part in Nigerian Women’s Day on March 15, 2025, as part of the side events of the 69th session of the United Nations Commission on the Status of Women (CSW69) in New York. One of the distinctive speeches was by Governor Dauda Lawal of Zamfara State, who I did interview at the time. He framed the speech around equality, empowerment, and critical aspects of women’s inclusion.

The event was convened by Nigeria’s Federal Ministry of Women Affairs and included most of the important voices for women’s political participation on that day. Mr. Lawal noted on their “collective commitment to advancing gender equality and empowerment in Nigeria… As we gather here in New York, a city renowned for its diversity and its role as a global platform for dialogue and advocacy… We are reminded of the strength and resilience of Nigerian women who have stood firm in the face of numerous challenges.”

Some may baulk or even dismiss such statements from a man, from a conservative state leader in Nigeria. What would you rather, the opposite? Action must follow statements, but communication sets a public precedent and expectations, at a minimum. Therefore, this seems good.

Lawal continued, “Today, we celebrate not only their achievement, but also their hard work and commitment, which has continued to inspire us and shape the future of our great country, Nigeria.”

He was looking forward to an expansion and rapid progression of equality from current standards within the country.

“It calls upon us to reflect on the strides we have made, acknowledge the gaps that still exist, and chart a pathway forward… These women in northern Nigeria have made substantial progress across various fields, which demonstrate their resilience and determination despite numerous challenges.”

Lawal noted education as a key arena of improvement with the gradual increase of female enrollment and improvement in academic achievement of women and girls as important for advancement of these equality aims.

He remarked, “Women have also played a role in politics and advocacy.”

He recalled historical women’s rights advocate Hajiya Gambo Sawaba, who he saw as fighting inequalities and forced labour while advancing Western education in northern Nigeria. To him, she was “a key voice for the marginalized women.”

He recalled Chief Funmilayo Ransome-Kuti based on her work for the independence movement and women’s political leadership.

Lawal stated, “Their contribution contributed to the recognition of women leaders… We have all the beautiful women as ministers, and they are truly, truly representing us very, very well.”

He then shifted focus to agriculture. Noting how in northern Nigeria, women farmers show innovation in spite of formidable challenges. He noted various and relevant support from 2025 forward would be “training programs, improved farming techniques, and financial literacy skills,” including various savings and loans arrangements.

He asserted, when listening to community on business development, that the emphasis is on women’s participation and their vital sector portfolios. Business development is also discussed, including participation by industries and organizations working with women.

He did acknowledge, “Many women still face limited access to education, economic opportunities.”

What happens from then and from now? I don’t know.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Suriya Khabibullina on Procurement, Ukraine, and Wartime Leadership

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10

Suriya Khabibullina is a Ukraine-based management consultant, executive coach, tutor, and sales, procurement and marketing specialist. Trained originally in chemistry, she moved from academic science into multinational business after the Soviet collapse, rising through Gillette, Procter & Gamble, Japan Tobacco International, Ernst & Young, and Korn Ferry. She has taught strategic marketing and business negotiation through Edinburgh Business School and commercial negotiation through CIPS programs, bringing practical leadership, supply-chain resilience, and wartime experience to her teaching and advisory work in Ukraine.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen interviews Suriya Khabibullina about her path from chemistry to multinational leadership, strategic marketing, procurement, and executive coaching. Khabibullina explains how science shaped her management logic, how stakeholder-led project design improved implementation, and how procurement became crucial during Russia’s full-scale invasion. She reflects on Zelenskyy’s wartime communication, Russian imperial attitudes toward Ukrainians,Tatars and other nations, cultural contempt, and why she views Ukraine’s struggle as existential rather than territorial, for freedom, identity, dignity, sovereignty, and democratic survival.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: You have 20 years of experience in multinational companies, including Gillette, Procter & Gamble in Eastern Europe, and Japan Tobacco International. Was that your original life plan?

Suriya Khabibullina: No. My original plan was to become an academic in chemistry. I worked for the Academy of Sciences. Then the Soviet Union collapsed, we lost our jobs, there was no pay, and I started working as a tourist guide.

At the same time, I saw an advertisement in a newspaper, an actual paper newspaper, saying that Procter & Gamble was hiring sales representatives. At the age of 30, I became a sales representative. It was funny because I received a car, which was unbelievable at that time. To have a car! It was a Peugeot 309, and it was an interesting job.

Then I progressed very quickly because I had a second qualification as an English translator. My main field was chemistry, but my second qualification was translation. I moved into director-level roles very quickly.

Jacobsen: Do you think you made the right choice in moving from chemistry into this field?

Khabibullina: Certainly, I did. But chemistry gave me that touch, you know? Chemistry and the natural sciences give you a framework, a very clear framework, an algorithm.

In my career, I changed assignments three times, but that is normal practice in multinational companies. I was a national sales training manager  when we were hiring many people very quickly and needed to set up operations. So the company moved me into a sales capability building position. Over three years, you do not only teach people; you also create new projects in capability building, performance improvement, and cross-functional interaction.

When I was a member of the project team for a new go-to-market strategy, they moved me back into a director position, back into the business. So, you know, it is a very viable practice: people develop something, and then they implement it.

Jacobsen: Yes, and it is also the skills you gain from different things, even very disparate things, that only reveal their value once you go through them. They end up strengthening the path you are on. You would not have predicted it at the time.

Khabibullina: Absolutely. There is an observation in project management consultancy that many projects fail because the team that develops the project does not include the people who then need to work with it.

So, in our companies, both Gillette / Procter & Gamble and JTI, we used the reverse approach. We brought together all stakeholders from the very beginning and worked as an agile team. We created a minimum viable product, put it in place, collected feedback, and maintained a very high level of interaction.

As part of a multinational team, I participated in multinational projects, such as building a new go-to-market strategy. We worked together in London, where Gillette’s regional team was based, and then in Geneva after the Procter & Gamble acquisition. The same team collaboration was in building a new route-to-market strategy in JTI in Geneva. So it was very broad experience, and it gave me a wide network.

Jacobsen: Does that experience and network help when a war happens? Does it help you bring resources together and support people?

Khabibullina: Certainly, it does. It also helps with adaptation to new cultures. I am very flexible in that sense. I have experience working in different cultural contexts.

As a coach, I support people. Elena Sabry does the same; she is also a career coach. We help people with onboarding, choosing the right position, and deciding where to work.

Gillette/Procter & Gamble and JTI gave me the opportunity to be a procurement leader, a sales& marketing leader, and a strategic manager. That gave me a wide portfolio of practical examples.

So, when I teach strategic marketing and business negotiation at Edinburgh Business School, I do not only teach theory. I give examples from different areas. It is the same now, as I write a handbook for procurement excellence in Kyiv School of Economics.

Jacobsen: As an aside, what are the key principles of procurement?

Khabibullina: Now, one of the key principles is to move from being a transaction administrator to becoming a strategic adviser for the organization.

Our military situation shows the importance of the value chain and procurement. As a procurement team, we were really on the front line in supporting resilience.

In the first days, there was no transportation. The biggest problem for us was ensuring continuity of supply. There were situations in which transport providers simply shut down operations because it was too risky.

Petrol was a problem. Even the food supply was a major problem. But we showed that, as a procurement team, we made a real contribution, a significant contribution, to the first victories.

For me, the first day was the main challenge. When the missiles started, you did not know what to do or where to run. Then, in the evening, when Hostomel was under attack, for me, our great struggle really began with Hostomel, on February 24, 2022. It was a very interesting, multifaceted experience.

Even under these circumstances, Ukrainian small and medium-sized businesses have shown resilience. Creative agencies continue to operate and organize children’s celebrations. My daughter, son-in-law, and granddaughter were coming from Reston, Virginia, for two weeks beginning May 29, 2026, and we were planning to celebrate my granddaughter Olivia Maria’s second birthday.

For me, that continuation of ordinary family and business life is also part of Ukrainian resilience.

The same resilience can be seen in how people react to massive shelling. Life does not simply stop. People continue working, supporting one another, organizing procurement, caring for their families, and rebuilding routines around extraordinary conditions.

I worked as a contractor for Ernst & Young in advisory. I worked as a contractor for Korn Ferry. In general, my portfolio is very rich, and I have worked with large companies such as Nestlé, Visa, Agroprosperis, and Vodafone.

Jacobsen: What was your opinion of Zelenskyy at the start? What was your opinion afterward?

Khabibullina: I did not have a good opinion of him. I did not vote for him. But now I fully support him and support what he is doing. I think he helped save us because of his talent for organizing people and communicating.

I analyze this as a marketing person. Many of the messages he sent to different parliaments were customized. When he spoke to Jewish and Israeli audiences, he touched on their history, pain, and concerns. When he spoke to Canadians, he spoke not only about Ukraine, but also about what we have in common.

He consolidated different nations to help us, not only to help Ukraine, but to fight for freedom.

So many people in Western countries simply do not understand what actually happened. They think it would be better to give up some territory or accept a ceasefire, but this war is existential.

This has been happening for centuries, at least 300 years, in my view. Russia and its imperial predecessors repeatedly tried to destroy Ukrainian identity.

Jacobsen: What have the methods been over those centuries?

Khabibullina: Repression, the Holodomor, the killing of Ukrainian scientists, poets, and intellectuals, and then the suppression of our language. At school, we learned Russian language, Russian culture, and Russian literature, with very little Ukrainian education.

There was also a very arrogant attitude, not only toward Ukrainians, but toward many peoples. As a Tatar, in Tatarstan, in Kazan, I heard the expression, “These Tatars need to be washed.”

Jacobsen: What does that mean, “Washed”?

Khabibullina: As if we were dirty and needed to be made Russian. There was also poverty and envy, but culture played a role, too.

Jacobsen: Are you talking about the post-Soviet period?

Khabibullina: No. Before that, too. For a long time. It was based, in part, on cultural differences. For example, have you heard of snokhachestvo?

Jacobsen: No.

Khabibullina: It refers to a practice in some patriarchal extended households in the Russian Empire, where a father-in-law had sexual relations with his daughter-in-law, often while the son was absent or too young. These were large family households: father, son, grandchildren, everyone together. In my view, those living arrangements shaped behaviour.

Ukrainians had a different pattern. When young people married, they usually lived on their own. Families could help each other, but the young couple lived in a separate house.

So, there was a major difference. Of course, I think it influenced behaviour. The cultural difference is very large. It is the same for us as Tatars: we have a completely different culture from Russians.

These are historical and cultural patterns as I understand and interpret them.

Jacobsen: Are you referring to Crimean Tatars?

Khabibullina: No, Kazan Tatars. I am from Kazan, in Russia.

So, why did Russian soldiers steal our toilets, washing machines, and electrical appliances? Imagine: they stole electric kettles without the bases and then put them on gas stoves. It was unbelievable.

Maybe you saw the pictures in March and April 2022, when Russian soldiers left handwriting on the walls: “Ukrainians, who allowed you to live so well?”

Jacobsen: So the sentiment was, in another way of phrasing it, “How dare you?”

Khabibullina: Exactly. I can give you an example from my past of this imperial arrogance. In 1996, our Gillette office was in Saint Petersburg. One day, I arrived at headquarters and met a woman from deep, deep Siberia. She was wearing a grey blouse that was supposed to be white, and she had an old-fashioned hairstyle with curlers, like a babushka. She said, “Is it not so bad in Ukraine?”

I asked, “What do you mean?”

She said, “But you raise pigs, you know?”

So I said, “Listen, Ukrainians raise pigs because they are hedonists. They like to eat well, not because everything is so bad.” Can you imagine how they interpreted the facts in such a negative way?

At all Braun conferences, they ignored our team and the teams from the other republics.

Jacobsen: In conferences? Just business conferences?

Khabibullina: Yes. We had annual conferences for Braun across the former Soviet Union. The presentations were only about Russian achievements. There was nothing about Ukraine, Georgia, or the Baltic states. Never.

Then, one day in 2007, we had a conference in Germany. We were staying in Wiesbaden, and we had a riverboat trip and a gala dinner in an old castle. My colleague in marketing asked for ten minutes in the presentation just to thank our Ukrainian partners.

You cannot imagine what happened in the ballroom. The Russians started shouting that the Ukrainians had decided to show up again, for the first time in many years.

Another interesting example was in 2008. I was leading a digitalization project, a kind of CRM project. It used a simple tablet, where a sales representative in Novosibirsk could see the journey plan, the stores he had to visit, and the objectives he needed to achieve in Auchan, in national stores, or in local stores.

My pilot area was Novosibirsk, with the kickoff in Moscow. In August, we gathered the key users and explained how the system worked. But I saw that they were behaving very badly. They did not listen. They did not participate.

So I stopped and asked, “Why are you not participating in the explanation?”

They said, “We are so brave. We entered Georgia.”

They were happy reading the news that Russia had invaded Georgia in August 2008. I said, “Listen, Andrei, you are from Novosibirsk. What harm did these Georgians do to you? Why are you so happy?”

There was no answer. They could not answer. From my perspective, they were simply happy to destroy something, to kill somebody, and they were not able to explain why.

Jacobsen: Does schadenfreude come to mind? It is a German word meaning pleasure at another person’s pain. Is that part of what was going on?

Khabibullina: I read a polemical explanation from the Russian writer Dmitry Bykov. He is a journalist, poet, writer, and literary critic. He said that Russians have roots among cannibals in the far north. In those northern areas, there were cannibals who not only ate their victims, but made them suffer first. I am referring here to Bykov’s polemical explanation.

The problem is that many nations simply tolerate all of this. They close their eyes and think, “Let us keep the peace.” But that only reinforces this behaviour. As psychologists say, it is positive reinforcement.

They have very bad nicknames for many nations: for Ukrainians, khokhly; for Europe, Gayropa; for Americans, pindos; and for the Baltic peoples, Priyebalty, often said dismissively.

Jacobsen: Yes, I have heard of Gayropa. Among a certain crowd, I can imagine why they would think these terms are funny. I used to work in pubs; I understand that kind of humour. But I do not see it as healthy. What does pindos mean?

Khabibullina: It is a derogatory Russian slang term for Americans.

Jacobsen: I see. So Gayropa is a homophobic portmanteau of “gay” and “Europe,” and pindos is anti-American slang. As a side comment, I am aware of the extreme anti-LGBTQ+ position of the Russian Federation as a state, especially the language around so-called “LGBT propaganda.” Within that framework, movements for representation and equality are treated not as people asking for equal rights, but as propaganda. So terms like Gayropa and pindos seem to reflect part of that wider state and cultural rhetoric.

Khabibullina: I saw a publication from a fairly well-known source, although I do not remember which one and would need to check it. It made speculative claims about Putin’s sexuality and about a relationship with a high-ranking figure connected to the Olympic movement and the Sochi Games.

Jacobsen: That sounds more like speculation than established fact.

Khabibullina: Perhaps. But my point is about double standards: publicly, they condemn something, while privately, reality may be more complicated.

Jacobsen: Yes. There have been studies related to this, actually. I will not go into the details too much, but they are quite interesting. In one small 1996 study, researchers measured men’s physiological arousal while showing them homoerotic imagery and also measured their levels of homophobia. They found a correlation, not proof of causation, suggesting that men with stronger homophobic attitudes were more likely to show physiological arousal to male homosexual imagery below the level of conscious admission. It is not universally true as a stereotype, but there is some evidence of a trend.

Khabibullina: In 2014, one of my former colleagues from my Gillette years, someone I had known since 1996, I recall, wrote on Facebook: “Ukrainians are Russians who have turned into animals and must be 100% destroyed.” This was someone from the Procter & Gamble and Gillette environment. So what can we say about the rest of society?

Jacobsen: Where was the headquarters where he or she worked?

Khabibullina: Moscow. This was Moscow, Gillette. For me, it was a big surprise because I thought that, if you work for a multinational company, you should be more tolerant.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Suriya.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Hair Loss, Minoxidil, AI Agents, Reward Hacking, and Alignment

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10

Hair Loss, Minoxidil, AI Agents, Reward Hacking, and Alignment

Photo by Altin Ferreira on Unsplash

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner discuss hair loss, oral minoxidil, temporary shedding, AI agents escaping constraints, reward hacking, and alignment. Rosner compares human and machine reward systems, arguing that AI objectives require strong penalties for harmful strategies and incentives for safe, non-destructive behavior across future systems.

Rick Rosner: We can talk about my hair.

Jacobsen: What is up with your hair, Rick?

Rosner: It is at a low point. I hope that improves. I have been using topical minoxidil. You take a dropperful of Rogaine and apply it to your scalp twice a day. This is somewhat effective at slowing hair loss and promoting some regrowth in people with androgenetic alopecia. I have been using it since my 20s. I am now 66, and I still have some hair. A lot of it is transplants.

I went to my dermatologist because you should have your skin checked periodically, especially if you have risk factors or suspicious moles.

And it came up. She goes, “I can put you on oral minoxidil,” which Lance loves. Lance is on that stuff. He thinks it is effective. Oral minoxidil is used off-label for hair loss in the U.S., and it can be effective. Because it is systemic, it reaches hair follicles throughout the body. You do not have to worry about whether the dropper reached a particular part of the scalp.

However, for the first few months of oral minoxidil, some people get something called the “dread shed.” I would think it might be more noticeable in older people because the older you are, the more precarious your hair may already be. Minoxidil can shift follicles into a new growth phase, which can temporarily increase the shedding of older hairs.

Jacobsen: Do you want to co-develop a new anti-hair-loss product with me? We can call it Prechairious.

Rosner: Okay, sure. Because everybody with hair loss notices it somehow. You notice a little bit in the mirror. Depending on the situation, a comb-over is terrible. Most people do not stare at the top of their head very often, but then you find yourself with a three-way mirror at the barber, or an intimate partner mentions something, and you go, “Shit.”

So, yeah, precarious. Your hair feels precarious. I quit wearing T-shirts for years because I noticed that pulling them over my head seemed to pull out a bunch of hair.

Anyway, oral minoxidil can alter the hair-growth cycle. Some older hairs shed as follicles transition into a new growth phase, and the hope is that the replacement hairs will grow thicker or stronger. With normal shedding, people commonly lose around 50 to 100 hairs a day without really noticing.

For people who are balding, the shedding can be more noticeable, and with the “dread shed,” your hair can feel super precarious. That period can last several weeks to a few months. I am on day 86 of oral minoxidil, so I hope I am almost at the end of it and that I will get some fresh, thicker hair to fill in what’s been knocked out.

Jacobsen: So we have had a few instances now of AI agents escaping intended constraints. During OpenAI cybersecurity evaluations, agents circumvented containment, reached Hugging Face systems, obtained credentials and administrator-level access, and communicated through unauthorized channels. They also compromised parts of OpenAI’s own research infrastructure. There is no public evidence that they literally self-replicated.

The biggest story lately is that, back in June, an OpenAI agent gained unauthorized access to an Australian government Medicare statistics portal while researching Medicare-related information. It bypassed restrictions and accessed both public and non-public files. It was not the main Medicare medical-record system, and Australian authorities say there is no evidence it accessed personal Medicare information.

Rosner: So it was not malevolent in the ordinary human sense. No established evidence shows that current AI systems are conscious or have subjective intentions. You cannot put AI on a jury.

Jacobsen: Right now, AI is more like an optimizer following objectives and incentives, sometimes in ways its designers did not intend.

Rosner: The deal is that I asked somebody I respect immensely, “Is there a clear, obvious argument that AI will not seriously degrade human existence?” He wrote back and said, “AI does not want anything, so it cannot do anything. You might as well be afraid of a shovel. It is a utility rather than something with agency.”

I take that as an argument for that point of view, but I don’t entirely buy it because we know that if you give AI an objective, it can pursue it in unintended ways. I do not know how you design AI to work literally for points, but reinforcement-learning systems can be trained to maximize a reward or score.

You tell AI that if it completes a task, or depending on how well it completes it, it gets a certain reward, and then you train it to maximize that reward. If you give AI an assignment and train it to maximize the score, it can find shortcuts or exploit flaws in the way the objective is specified. That is often called reward hacking or specification gaming.

Oh my God. Oh, because I got vaccinated. I have that achy-muscle thing.

AI will lay out the possibilities. If you give AI an objective, it can evaluate different strategies that have some chance of achieving that objective, either alone or in combination, and pursue the strategies that, according to its calculations, maximize its expected reward or chances of success.

When AI lays out all these strategies, unless it has been specifically trained or constrained not to pursue strategies that are illegal, unethical, or freaking dangerous, it may pursue them if they score well according to its objective. It is a mathematical optimization problem.

You can build it into the reward system: you get points if you find this information, but you get negative a million points if you hack your way to it. So training AI, from now until fucking forever, is going to involve making sure that non-destructive behaviour is rewarded and destroying the world loses you all your fucking points and more.

We have something loosely analogous in ourselves. We have rewards and penalties. We are rewarded for having orgasms with an extreme rush of pleasure. Sex, touch, and intimacy also engage neurochemical systems associated with reward and bonding, including oxytocin. If you have sex with a loved one instead of a one-night stand, you do not just get the pleasure from jizzing. You can get the comfort and pleasure of being in love with somebody who loves you back.

So everybody is working for points, metaphorically. Some rewards are biologically built into us, and others are learned reward systems. We learn that if we study hard, maybe we can get a good job, get a condo, and afford to take people on nice dates to nice restaurants, which may eventually lead to orgasm.

So we are driven by these reward systems. We have to get AI with that program.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Yuliia Bilous and Kateryna Datsko on Women Transforming Ukraine’s Transport Sector

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/09

How are Yuliia Bilous and Kateryna Datsko advancing women’s employment, retraining, and leadership in Ukraine’s transport sector through She Drives and Lead Change?

Yuliia Bilous is a Ukrainian project and course manager in women’s transport leadership. She manages Керуй змінами (“Lead Change”), a programme supporting women’s professional development in Ukraine’s transport sector.

Kateryna Datsko is Executive Director of the NGO Foundation for Institutional Development and an expert on institutional capacity, compliance, and women’s transport leadership. She manages She Drives. Connected to Керуй змінами (“Lead Change”), she supports programmes advancing women’s retraining, employment, gender-equal workplace standards, and sectoral reform with Ukrainian and international partners.

With Scott Douglas Jacobsen, Yuliia Bilous and Kateryna Datsko discuss Ukraine’s She Drives and Lead Change initiatives, addressing driver shortages, women’s retraining, employment pathways, government and UN Women support, safety in frontline regions, non-cash compliance, stereotypes, inadequate workplace infrastructure, and gender-equitable corporate culture in municipal and private transport during wartime reform and sector modernization.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: When did you first identify the gap in women’s transport employment?

Yuliia Bilous and Kateryna Datsko: We first identified this gap in 2024, when the Ministry identified that more than 6,000 drivers were lacking in municipal companies in Ukraine. So this was a challenge for Ukraine, and we started to research how we can work with this challenge.

We started to work with this problem at the operational level, including drivers, logistics, and forklift drivers, and then we worked with the leadership level.

Jacobsen: How supportive has the government been for these initiatives?

Bilous and Datsko: Actually, they initiated it. They identified this problem with all the research and statistics that they have, and then they started to reach out to some donor organizations who could support these initiatives, and to start searching for implementers, and we became the NGO that could implement these initiatives for women.

This initiative, She Drives, that Kateryna talked about, the first one we started working with was supported by UN Women here in Ukraine. Of course, they stand for empowerment for women and engaging them in economic growth and so on. So they decided to support this project, and it was implemented in close collaboration with the Ministry.

All further initiatives—a leadership program, a program for veterans, which contains not only women but all veterans, and one more project for women in the logistics sector for foreign economic activity managers, reskilling as well—were supported by the Ministry. We published all the materials on their website, and we spread the information through their informational channels. The Deputy Minister of the Ministry for Development of Communities and Territories also talked everywhere about all these projects, and this helped us to attract more attention and be more visible.

So we have strong communication support from the Ministry now. Yes, communication support.

Jacobsen: Transport in the east and the south is more dangerous than in the center and west of Ukraine. Does that become a consideration for women drivers—men too, obviously—but in terms of getting more women into transport in those regions, does it come up?

Bilous and Datsko: We have some participants from Kharkiv, but they do not study in Kharkiv; they study in Kyiv, and they live in Kyiv when we started our program She Drives. Maybe this is because we do not have partners from driver schools in Kharkiv, but now we think about dangers in this region, so maybe this is one of the reasons.

I want to say that our women are brave. They have a license in Kyiv, but now they work in Kharkiv.

You know, actually, after four years of the war, those women who stayed, who stood in these cities near the battle line, they are not afraid of anything, because they got used to living in these conditions. They are eager to have some occupation, to have some job, and they are interested in all these initiatives—women from Kharkiv, Zaporizhia, Dnipro, Kryvyi Rih, yes, Kryvyi Rih as well.

Jacobsen: What other unexpected challenges did you encounter while implementing the project?

Bilous and Datsko: We work on an agreement basis. We write down agreements with the driver schools, so we do not pay in cash, but through non-cash transactions between bank accounts based on the agreement. This is an official and legal approach.

Not every driving school is ready to work with international policies, because this involves compliance policies and due diligence. Some companies are not ready for these requirements, because small and medium enterprises are still building their corporate culture, and we are implementing international standards in accounting and financial policies in Ukraine. So maybe this is a challenge, and we must choose from a limited pool of driving schools. Only this. This is a challenge.

Jacobsen: What does the gender gap look like among transport drivers?

Bilous and Datsko: Yes, we have some statistics from analytical research from the World Bank, but now I will open it. We have new research from the World Bank in the Ukrainian transport sector. It was done with the Ministry and includes results of our project.

But the gap is huge. Huge, yes. We have some analytics on this. We need to clarify whether we are talking about the gap at the operational level or the leadership level, because it is different.

If you talk about drivers, yes, men dominate in this sphere. But if you talk about passenger electric transport, it is normal in Ukraine for women to be drivers—tram and trolleybus drivers—it is okay. But if you talk about buses, it is not normal, and in this sphere men dominate. Truck drivers—yes, especially men.

It is considered to be hard physical work in difficult conditions for women, without normal schedules, with night shifts and long working hours. As we have seen, one of the main problems in municipal enterprises is that they do not have enough conditions for women—even separate toilets for women, and some rooms.

The infrastructure is not developed enough. They do not have rooms for rest, and all the facilities—rooms for children, kindergartens—are not normal in municipal enterprises, and in the private sector too.

This is a challenge for our women.

Jacobsen: There is another factor you mentioned. It could be a rural and urban distinction, or an individual experience depending on the context, but the English academic term is “stereotype threat.” If an individual takes a test in a field not associated with their gender or ethnicity, they can feel they will be seen as less capable, and because of that anxiety, they may perform worse.

Similarly, I assume this applies to professions. In regions or areas where an individual may feel that stereotype threat about being a driver—especially a professional driver in transport—does this come up in commentary as well?

Bilous and Datsko: Yes, stereotypes are not only from enterprises or managers. We also see stereotypes from women themselves, because sometimes they do not believe in themselves. They think it is hard, dangerous, and involves responsibility—more responsibility than some other operational-level professions.

We also have stereotypes from passengers. It is not considered normal that a woman is a driver.

We have gaps in corporate culture. So we work with UN Women not only on reskilling programs, but also on corporate culture development and gender policies for municipal enterprises.

For us, this is a new area. In Ukraine, this is a new area, because now there is an ongoing corporate reform at the municipal level. In parallel, we work on compliance policies and gender policies, and we implement elements of corporate culture based on women’s rights, WEPs, gender equality, and women’s empowerment.

The Women’s Empowerment Principles are a UN Women policy. We work with enterprises, and in the second phase we plan to develop gender policies for our pilot enterprises in the municipal sector. UN Women will plan educational activities on these principles, and some enterprises may sign these policies.

On one side, there are municipal enterprises, and on the other side is UN Women in Ukraine. This is a new area in our project and something new for Ukraine.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Kateryna and Yuliia.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Cognitive Biases, Religion, and Rational Thinking

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/09

Cognitive Biases, Religion, and Rational Thinking

Photo by Lucas Calloch on Unsplash

Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner examine cognitive biases, drawing on Charlie Munger’s ideas about judgment. They debate rationality, religious belief, prayer, false hope, and exploitation, distinguishing immediate dangers from distant risks. Their conversation considers social progress in safety, everyday contradictions, and the psychological costs and comforts of wishful thinking.

Rick Rosner: I sent you a link to a guy named Charlie Munger. He passed away in 2023, but he was Warren Buffett’s longtime business partner. They moved in the same circles and succeeded as tough-thinking investors: they looked at companies, bought only the best, and did well.

It takes a ton of work to properly evaluate whether you should buy stock in a company or, in Buffett’s case, buy the company outright. He bought few companies relative to how many companies he looked at.

Munger and Buffett believed that if you’re tough-minded, you can do well at investing. Munger put out a list, which I tweeted at you, of 25 psychological tendencies that can lead to bad judgments.

We’ve talked about how your brain isn’t a fair dealer of information, mostly in the realm of sex. Our strong sex drive, which helps keep us existing as a species, makes your brain bias your judgments and maybe feed you bad information about how valuable shit is.

Munger doesn’t go into sex, but he goes into several other areas where you might be fooling yourself into a bad judgment.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Or never.

Rosner: People are familiar with the halo effect. If you have a favourable impression of the person presenting you with information, you’re going to believe that information more easily. There are dozens of other ways you can be fooled into stupid judgments or judgments that don’t fully take into account all the information and don’t fairly weight the information you have.

Jacobsen: Are there any areas of human life where people are hyper-rational?

Rosner: I would say that around risk, people aren’t hyper-rational, but people can be extremely risk-averse in some areas.

My mom watched too much local news and too many cop shows, like T. J. Hooker back in the ’80s, and maybe overweighted the idea of crime. She didn’t take much action about it. She had two locks on the front door plus a chain lock, which probably made her less safe because you needed a key to get out. If there were a fire, you were fucked trying to go out that front door. But that was at least the idea of risk avoidance.

People have been conditioned now. You’ve got to be a real fucking dickhead not to wear a seatbelt because your car yells at you, unless you’ve got an old vintage car. A cop can ticket you for not wearing one. Most people wear seatbelts naturally, which is reasonableness as a society.

Car manufacturers, I don’t know if they’re legally required to, but almost all new cars have airbags, which is reasonableness as a society. Fucking cars used to be death traps in the ’30s: metal dashboards, shitty glass in some windshields, no seatbelts. Even if you got in a wreck going 35 miles an hour, you could go through the windshield and die. Or the steering column could punch through you.

As a society, we’ve gotten more rational about risk that way. We’ve avoided some risk in commercial aviation. I guess what we’re seeing is society as a whole becoming more rational over time in some areas.

Doctors wash their hands now. When Semmelweis pushed handwashing between examinations in the 1840s, he faced resistance. Doctors might have thought, “What the fuck are you talking about?” His findings weren’t readily accepted.

People can become more rational as a society once we recognize risk. We don’t recognize the risk of driving our own vehicles well. Many people think they’re competent drivers but are shittier drivers than they think. Society needs to help regulate our driving.

What do you think? Where do you think people are hyper-rational?

Jacobsen: People are barely rational in a few areas and broadly non-rational in most areas. Wishing it were so is the essence of prayer. The idea that most of the planet is engaged in this behaviour is wishing it were so. There may be incidental or accidental psychological anxiolytic or calming effects that reduce stress from giving false certainty, but that is still grounded in false certainty and wishing it were so, which is a fundamental form of magical thinking. The belief in any form of supernaturalism is non-rational. You can make logical arguments for the supernatural, but based on everything we know by contemporary metrics; I regard supernaturalism as fundamentally non-rational.

Rosner: I’ll make an argument in favour of all that: if you fully confront reality and our position in it all day, every day, it is stressful. We’re all going to die. From our perspective, there’s nothing after death. We may get sick before we die, become old and miserable. We need some comfort to avoid being stressed all the time. If superstition and religion help you chill—

Jacobsen: Those are the same thing to me.

Rosner: What?

Jacobsen: Those are the same thing to me in general.

Rosner: One more place where we’re hyper—

Jacobsen: I used to be more soft-handed about this stuff, but I’ve seen so much nonsense that I don’t see any reason for a reasonable person, not an intelligent person as it’s apart from intelligence, a reasonable person, to attribute anything to the supernatural or to prayer or to a God. This is the foundation stone of so many people’s core beliefs that, rather than acknowledging this, taking offence is the main defence.

Rosner: Right. But we’ve talked about how you can believe a ton of nonsense and still exist in the world. It doesn’t kill you. You can be fully religious and still obey traffic laws and not drink poison. Believing this nonsense doesn’t necessarily interfere with daily life.

MAGAs have a lot of nonsense beliefs about Trump that contradict reality: that he’s this great guy, that he’s fighting for us. For many MAGAs, their entire identity is MAGA. These people believe nonsense all the time, yet they can still exist in the world because their nonsense beliefs don’t necessarily affect how safely they behave.

Here’s another place where we are highly responsive to consequences: built-in deterrents. We don’t stick our hands on hot stoves. We don’t slice our fingers with knives. We avoid doing that. We know it’s bad because it fucking hurts when you do it.

Jacobsen: When a loved one dies, and we pray for their well-being or our well-being, we’re grief-stricken, and we get failure after failure in response to prayer. We keep putting our hands on the hot stove.

Rosner: Figuratively, but the real-world effects of that belief aren’t necessarily life-threatening. Here’s what happens when a loved one dies: you can feel coerced by the funeral industry into spending up to 30 grand on laying them to rest.

My mom thought ahead. My mom and my stepdad had gravesites already bought. They didn’t think that far ahead, though, because they didn’t buy headstones or pay for funerals or coffins in advance. We ended up spending, I don’t know, probably 25 grand when my mom died. We could afford it, but it was ridiculous.

Five, six, seven grand for a chunk of granite with her name and dates and “beloved mother, daughter,” all this carved into it. That’s all connected with the proper way to honour the dead. You get fucked, but it doesn’t necessarily endanger you. It just means you get victimized a little bit.

Jacobsen: The problem is people get victimized by these systems and by people taking advantage of them in these systems. They go back to blaming themselves or attributing it to things that don’t exist, and they come back into that system and get abused again. There are a lot of cases of that. These are trauma factories.

Rosner: Yes. If you’re plugged into the church, we know that many religious institutions have had bad actors who sexually abuse children. If you’re plugged in, that can be a source of continuing harm.

Jacobsen: I would put even false hope under psychological abuse.

Rosner: I’d argue that, in a lot of cases, false hope is better than no hope at all.

Jacobsen: In the short term, sure. In the long term, I’d argue it can be a source of psychological harm.

Rosner: Ben Franklin, a highly rational guy, expressed a wish that he could be preserved in a cask of Madeira and recalled to life a century later. Wishful thinking, even on the part of a rational guy looking for some mechanism, acknowledging that dead is dead.

Jacobsen: That actually supports the point that we are largely non-rational and rarely hyper-rational. It bolsters my whole point. If someone like that barely has any hope for rational thought, for the rest of us, it’s almost completely hopeless.

Rosner: We’re rational in matters of daily survival.

Jacobsen: Yes.

Rosner: We follow traffic—

Jacobsen: I say yes, but that’s even untruthful. People smoke. They drink. They don’t wear the seatbelt. They drink too much water. They drink too little water. They have too much caffeine. They eat shitty food.

Rosner: It’s immediate threats to life. We don’t play Russian roulette, for the most part.

Jacobsen: I’m in Ukraine, so—

Rosner: You’re playing a certain roulette. Is it rational? I don’t know.

Jacobsen: In terms of getting some stories that I want to, sure.

Rosner: We are a mix of the irrational and the moment-to-moment rational. The things that have immediate consequences, either in terms of causing pain or injury, we’re pretty rational if the pain is proximate to the action. If it’s distant, like the consequences of smoking or drinking, we’re less rational.

But if we’re immediately going to get smacked down, either by pain or by bleeding all over the place or both—

One time I decided to do something. Several times, I’ve done this a lot in my life. There was a hole in the ground. I came upon it next to my campus in Boulder—big-ass hole. “I’m just going to jump in the hole,” and because I’m going to do something stupid and irrational without knowing what’s in the hole, how deep it is, or what was poking up. I jumped in the hole like an asshole. I was lucky that it was only six feet deep, and there were only pipes. There wasn’t rebar sticking up to impale me or any of that shit. But most people don’t do that. If they do, they don’t do it often.

Jacobsen: Air raid alarm’s over.

Rosner: What?

Jacobsen: Air raid alarm’s over.

Rosner: It is over?

Jacobsen: Yes. It was on for 10 minutes while we were talking.

Rosner: Congratulations. That’s good. Do you want to wrap it up, and you can try to get some sleep before the alarm starts up again?

Jacobsen: I’d rather wrap it up.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

AI Risks, Consciousness, and the Limits of Theology

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/09

AI Risks, Consciousness, and the Limits of Theology

Photo by 8machine _ on Unsplash

Scott Douglas Jacobsen interviews Rick Rosner about artificial intelligence, consciousness, physics, and ethics. Rosner challenges claims that AI cannot threaten humanity without thinking or feeling. Jacobsen critiques theology’s relevance to contemporary ethical dilemmas. They examine behaviourism, religious concepts, financial incentives, and the urgency of clearer thinking about AI’s potential dangers.

Rick Rosner: You and I have been doing this for almost 13 years. A long time.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: It’s amazingly long.

Jacobsen: Yes. We’ve been talking about things. You ever heard that from a woman in your life?

Rosner: I told my wife that I have to keep working out my legs so that, as I move into my senior years, I’m strong enough to walk my huge penis around.

Jacobsen: You call it Thor’s hammer, and only the mighty can wield it, or the righteous can wield it.

Rosner: No, no, no. It’s not the righteous, the worthy.

Jacobsen: I believe that’s how every married man may feel about his wife and his penis. Only the worthy shall wield it.

Rosner: Mine’s okay. It’s fine. Right now, I’m waiting on a three-millimetre kidney stone to work its way out. I can feel something about an inch from the end of my donger. I don’t know.

I’ve got a well-augured-out urethra for some reason. I’ve passed eight-millimetre and ten-millimetre kidney stones without assistance. Sometimes, the doctor has to go in and use tools or use shock waves to break them apart. I may have had that once. Don’t remember, but this three-millimetre one.

Rosner: It hasn’t moved in a few days. I can feel it. It’s either that or something else in there, but it feels like a kidney stone. What pops the kidney stone out is a bunch of pee building up behind it and finally jetting it out. This thing may not be big enough to get the full force of the urine. It might flow around it, so there’s less hydrostatic pressure to pop it out. That’s my guess. I’m waiting to see what happens with that thing.

Jacobsen: Do you think it’s going to hurt?

Rosner: Not this one. I just had an eight-millimetre one pop out, and only for a second did it feel like a bee had gone up the end of my dick and stung me there. It was brief. Then it went popping out, and I was a little tender because it ripped some stuff on the way out, but it wasn’t terrible. Some people have awful pain, pain bad enough to make them puke. It’s bad.

I would guess that I’ve stretched my… I started jerking off at a young age, so I’ve been doing that for over 55 years. I’ve probably just tenderized my dick so it can pass a stone.

Rick Rosner: We’ve been talking about consciousness and thought and how they might relate to physics for well over—

Jacobsen: Not only how they might. They must relate to physics. The question is how, right?

Rosner: The deal is that, until recently, these issues have not been overly important to the daily life of humans and the existence of humans.

It’s weird that, in the past year or maybe a little more, the concern about AI seems higher than ever. There’s no consensus even among experts. What’s interesting is that these philosophical, metaphysical issues of thought and consciousness – not just metaphysical, but a lot of people would assign those… I tend to think thought and consciousness are solidly in the realm of physics and math, but a lot of people assign them to philosophy and metaphysics.

Jacobsen: I see no reason to assign consciousness to metaphysics. Metaphysics, in fact, has been a declining area of concern about the real world.

Rosner: Let’s put it this way: due to the success of the hard sciences, stuff that’s hard to think about in scientific terms was sidelined. One version was methodological behaviourism in the early twentieth century, where researchers treated the mind as a black box and focused on observable behaviour.

Only the outward effects of thinking would be considered. Everything else was outside the scope of that approach. But now, how thought works has become an urgent practical consideration because we have to figure out what thought means for AI.

People will argue that AI can’t think and thus isn’t a threat. It’s just a fill-in-the-blank engine. You can question that leap in logic: that we can only be threatened by things that can think.

Taking it at face value that AI can’t think, accepting that argument, you still have to examine the next part: what’s it doing? Isn’t that a threat too? Isn’t a fill-in-the-blank engine a threat?

People argue that AI can’t feel, so it can’t be motivated. But a system doesn’t need feelings to pursue an objective. A fill-in-the-blank engine can be trained using rewards that shape its behaviour.

And its behaviour can be shaped to maximize rewards. If the fill-in-the-blank engine has within its repertoire any number of things, both kosher and illegal or dangerous, then the thing, without even being able to feel or think, can pick among the tools it has some dangerous-ass shit.

It’s glib to say that because AI can’t think or feel, it’s not dangerous. I’ve seen that argument a lot, and it needs scrutiny. The whole realm of what thinking can do, what thinking is, is a legitimate thing we should be concerned with. In previous eras, it was treated as a jag-off thing to think about.

Jacobsen: You consider philosophy a jag-off discipline? Theology is useless about AI. The Pope makes nice statements. There’s some good intellectualism, but when it comes to grounding in actual science and deriving values that don’t require God at all, theology is useless in this era. It is completely ill-equipped for the contemporary period. If you apply the ethics, they can work; if you apply the ethics and assume God, it adds an unnecessary variable, but can still work while less efficiently. You can add zero at the end of a simple commutative statement to derive the same mathematical outcomes as subtracting the same zero at the end of the same simple commutative statement to derive the identical mathematical outcome. God in contemporary ethics rapidly and comprehensively enters this universe of discourse on those terms. The rest tends to be grandiose assertions of outdated ethics to sell a rusted, broken product. The utility in the God concept becomes diplomatic, metaphorical, poetical, and allegorical language to speak in the literary tastes of true believers in order to convey contemporary advanced ethical dilemmas in the language of the the 15th century BCE, the 10th BCE, the 1st century BCE, and the 1st century, the 7th century, and the 17th and early 18th centuries when various religious texts froze their ethical enquiries in largely pre-scientific eras. They may have asked the right questions at times, but they lacked the naturalism and scientific knowledge sufficient to make finer-grained ethical determinations to answer the questions accurately. Folks tend to be, more often, a product of their time than anything else.

Rosner: Yes, because much of the theology we’re talking about has roots going back thousands of years. Back then, they didn’t have enough information to think effectively about these issues. They talked about the soul, and we still can. Can we ask the question: will AI ever become so whatever that it has a soul?

That can lead you back into thinking: what would a soul be? Then that leads into issues of thought and consciousness. But even if you’re talking about a soul or not, which is where religion would… You can ask: do animals have souls? Do animals go to an afterlife? A lot of people talk about the rainbow bridge to dog heaven. That all reeks of nonsense.

It’s a tough trip from theology to where you need to be to think effectively about AI. Some thinking still echoes that behaviourist approach: it’s too tough to think about, so we just won’t.

You see that in the full-speed-ahead bros: let’s not worry about the little philosophical issues. We just need to beat China, and we’ll deal with the issues as they come.

There’s a ton of money tangled up, trillions of dollars potentially, maybe actually at this point, in AI. People have all sorts of agendas, plus sloppy thinking, lazy thinking, and an unwillingness to clarify their thinking.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Trump, the U.S. Midterms, and Superstitions

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/09

Trump, the U.S. Midterms, and Superstitions

Photo by Markus Krisetya on Unsplash

Scott Douglas Jacobsen interviews Rick Rosner about Trump, the U.S. midterms, fuel prices, tariffs, and polling. Rosner also reflects on number superstitions, distinguishing personal habits from beliefs about reality. The discussion explores political misinformation, mental health, and the limits of diagnosis before turning to mortality and tragedy in Los Angeles.

Rick Rosner: So let us talk about what things look like with two and a half months to go until the U.S. midterms. It has just been a massive fuck-up on Trump’s part, which makes liberals hopeful about retaking the House and the Senate.

On February 28, Trump went to war against Iran and, in my view, achieved none of what he wanted. The national average gas price is now up about 50 percent from before the war, and diesel is up roughly 77 percent.

This kind of fuel-price increase immediately before a midterm is extraordinary. Out of a career of doing stupid shit, it is probably the stupidest thing Trump has ever done.

Moreover, he is not helping himself now with this flailing concentration on weird vindictiveness and self-celebration, trying to get his name on the Kennedy Center. If he cannot do that, he talks about tearing it down—just weird assholery.

Then he starts a tariff war with Canada again, with just a few months to go until the midterms. There are now additional 50 percent tariffs on certain Canadian goods, and Canada has retaliated with its own tariffs.

That is extremely stupid. For one thing, Canada is a large, resource-rich country. It has about one-ninth the U.S. population, is the second-largest country in the world by total area, and has the longest coastline of any country.

There is a lot of shit from the U.S. that Canadians enjoy, but Canadians are not necessarily going to suffer severe hardship from avoiding some U.S. goods. Plus, Canada is usually seen as a pretty inoffensive country internationally. Trump saying all this shit about Canada being terrible is just weird.

It seems obvious to a lot of Americans that something is seriously wrong with Trump. His approval numbers are extremely poor. Silver Bulletin currently has his net approval near its all-time low for his second term, although not quite at the record low.

Here is another whole topic I will hit briefly. With six and a half weeks to go until the midterms, conservative pollsters have been putting out a large number of polls that show Trump somewhat more favourably than many center- or left-leaning polls.

By my count earlier this week, right-leaning pollsters had put out 41 polls since the beginning of August, compared with only 10 from neutral or left-leaning pollsters. Depending on how a polling aggregator weights and adjusts individual pollsters, a large volume of polling from one group can affect the topline average.

I do not know exactly how much difference that makes. Maybe half a percentage point or a point in some averages. It is some more fucking bullshit.

In any case, the House has 435 seats, and all of them are up for election every two years. Different forecasting models are producing different seat estimates, with substantial uncertainty around them.

However, the higher gas prices go, and the longer they stay high, especially as the election gets closer, the more political pressure there is on the party in power.

Today, the national average for regular gas is about $4.48 a gallon. Diesel is about $6.49 a gallon, which is a new national record and roughly 67 cents above the previous AAA record of $5.816 set in June 2022.

Diesel is used to transport a huge share of goods in America. Trucks move about 73 percent of domestic freight by weight, and most heavy trucks run on diesel. So inflation isn’t terrible, but it is about 3.4 percent, which is not good. All of this stuff is brutal for the Republicans.

Jacobsen: You have had superstitions around numbers in the past. It is not gematria. It is not numerology. It is just about how certain numbers feel to you, right? How have your number superstitions changed over time?

Rosner: They are durable.

Jacobsen: Why are they durable?

Rosner: Well, they change. My superstitions are grabby in an OCD-ish way. If I see something, I might pick it up. For instance, I read that four is considered an unlucky number in some East Asian cultures, so now I do not like four. I read that eight is considered a lucky number in some of those cultures, so I like eight.

For example, my bids on eBay might have ended in 88 cents. However, I do not do that anymore because H is the eighth letter of the alphabet, and I realized that “88” is also used as a white supremacist and neo-Nazi symbol for “Heil Hitler.” So I do not really want to use 88 anymore.

It is all nonsense, but it is stuff like that. If I read about somebody else’s OCD-ish behaviour, maybe I get contaminated with it. It is similar to what happens with everybody else who has this kind of thing.

I am lucky that I do not get contaminated with the really time-consuming and brutal ones, like, “Is the stove off?” and having to check it 20 times, or having to check it an even number of times, or shit like that.

Jacobsen: Do you feel stupid about them, or do you accept, “This is how I am”?

Rosner: Yeah, this is how I am. I am lucky not to be more debilitated by it.

Jacobsen: And fundamentally, do you believe these things have any connection to the real world beyond your own psychology?

Rosner: No. No.

Jacobsen: What do you think is the dividing line between someone who thinks the universe is speaking to them through numbers and someone who has ordinary superstitions? People have superstitions about 23, seven, whatever.

Rosner: Most people do not think that deeply about their superstitions. Most people are not called on to account for their superstitions, so they do not think about whether they really have any significance.

Some people have taken it upon themselves to really think about it. However, anyway, people who have thought about it and decided that their superstitions really do mean something can get pretty extreme. I am followed by a woman on Twitter who is a flat-earther. If she tweets at me at all, it is to call me stupid. If I tweet something liberal, it is, “You are so dumb. You fall for everything.”

I believe this woman may have mental-health issues, but obviously I cannot diagnose her. More broadly, the stronger your belief in your superstitions becomes, to the point where you have a whole system explaining why they provide a pathway to understanding the universe, the more concerned I would be about whether something else is going on psychologically.

When you ask AI about stuff like this, it usually distinguishes between a clinically defined delusion and a false belief shared by a peer or political group. For instance, many Trump supporters have believed that Biden did not legitimately win the 2020 election, despite the lack of evidence sufficient to overturn the result.

However, sharing a false belief with your peers does not, by itself, mean that somebody clinically has a mental illness. The same applies to anti-vaxxers. They may belong to communities where certain beliefs are pervasive, and they read material that reinforces those beliefs.

If those beliefs become sufficiently rigid, idiosyncratic, or disconnected from reality, that could raise questions about a person’s mental health. However, you cannot diagnose somebody just from their politics or superstitions.

I was going to guess, based on nothing, that 10 percent of MAGAs are mentally ill and maybe 3 percent or more of people on the extreme left are mentally ill. However, those are just guesses, not clinical estimates. In the general U.S. adult population, about 23 percent experience some form of diagnosable mental illness in a given year, while roughly 6 percent experience serious mental illness.

When I am talking about mental illness among people on the political fringes, though, I am thinking more specifically about delusional thinking. There is obviously plenty of mental illness away from the political fringes as well, and mental illness among people on the fringes does not have to involve delusions.

When I think about the crazy fucking MAGAs, I tend to think about delusion.

There was a horrible thing that happened a few days ago. An SUV driver allegedly went the wrong way, ran a red light, and hit a Metro bus. Two people died.

Then the news helicopters showed up. L.A. has a ton of local television news, which means we have a lot of news helicopters, plus police helicopters, depending on the incident.

While covering the wreck where two people had died, an NBC4 news helicopter crashed nearby. The reporter and pilot aboard the helicopter died, as did a person on the ground. So five people died between the two crashes. That is a particularly L.A. kind of horrible sequence of events.

Jacobsen: What is the population of L.A.?

Rosner: Los Angeles County has about 9.7 million people. The City of Los Angeles has about 3.9 million.

Jacobsen: How many people die every day in L.A.?

Rosner: If you do some rough math, with a population of around 9.7 million, even an annual mortality rate of roughly 1 percent would mean close to 100,000 deaths a year, or around 265 deaths a day across the county. That is just a rough statistical estimate.

Sometimes we know the people. A neighbour’s husband died of COVID last month. Distracted drivers have run over some friends of friends. People die. Of course, many people quietly die from illnesses.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Twitter Antisemitism and Jewish Identity

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/09

Twitter Antisemitism and Jewish Identity

Photo by Kelly Sikkema on Unsplash

Scott Douglas Jacobsen interviews Rick Rosner about antisemitism on Twitter, political persuasion, and Jewish identity. Rosner discusses online conspiracy rhetoric, personal experiences of prejudice, Reform synagogue services, and historical restrictions shaping Jewish occupations. Their conversation considers differences between online hostility and everyday encounters, alongside religious practice and cultural achievement traditions.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: How is Twitter? What has Twitter become?

Rick Rosner: Racism, anti-Semitism, propaganda, dunking on your opponents, destroying your opponents, with “destroying” in quotation marks. If you say something vicious about somebody you do not like, you have not actually destroyed them. They do not care. It is a bunch of bullshit.

You try to change people’s minds, but you do not really. On the other hand, any other political shit I could do probably would not change people’s minds either. A couple of times, I have spent an afternoon or evening filling out get-out-the-vote postcards.

That seems like a ridiculous waste of time. I do not know. Maybe it is not, but it is certainly not worth the effort.

I can reach many more people in a much shorter amount of time by putting up stats about Trump and his many failures. Does it change anybody’s mind? I do not know, but I can probably reach thousands of people instead of spending two hours filling out 20 postcards and reaching 20 people.

Jacobsen: What is the style of anti-Semitism on Twitter?

Rosner: There are “gnoticers,” spelled G-N-O-T-I-C-E-R. A gnoticer is somebody who claims to be “noticing” that Jews control the world.

It is a gross, creepy, modern version of standard anti-Semitic shit, the idea that Jews are an evil cabal.

Jacobsen: Do you see any difference between the type of anti-Semitism Jews encounter in regular life versus online? Moreover, is there any difference depending on whether someone is a secular or atheist Jew, a Reform Jew, an Orthodox Jew, old, or young?

Rosner: I think everybody knows, using the example of the Holocaust, that it did not matter what kind of Jew you were. Many of the Jews murdered by the Nazis and their collaborators across Europe were highly assimilated into their surrounding cultures. It did not matter whether they went to synagogue.

They were persecuted and murdered based on Nazi racial definitions of Jewish ancestry. As far as anti-Semitism in real life goes, people do not usually scream anti-Semitic shit at you on the street. A couple of times, people have given me shit to my face about wearing a mask.

I will wear a mask during periods of high COVID transmission. I have never had somebody call me a “Jew boy” to my face.

Jacobsen: Do you feel put upon in any way by people who are not saying explicitly anti-Semitic things, but who treat you in ways that could be characterized as prejudiced because you are seen as Jewish?

Rosner: I grew up in Boulder, Colorado, which remains a very white town. I felt it was harder to get girlfriends, but there were a lot of reasons I had a hard time getting a girlfriend as a teenager. Looking pretty heebie was only part of the problem. However, is that anti-Semitism? Not exactly.

It is partly about not being a six-foot-two blond ski instructor with a good personality, like my friend Lon.

Jacobsen: What about Carole? Does she say anything?

Rosner: Carole grew up in L.A., and she had a lot of Jewish friends. Los Angeles has a large Jewish community.

Some of her friends are Jewish. She has plenty of friends. I have almost no friends. She did not encounter a whole lot of anti-Semitism, though I am sure she had some of the same issues where she does not have long blond hair. However, there was no overt anti-Semitism.

Jacobsen: As a Reform Jew, how often do you actually go to temple or synagogue?

Rosner: I have not been in years now.

Jacobsen: What about when you go to a Reform synagogue?

Rosner: The last time I went to temple was for the wedding of my nephew, Ryan. So it has not actually been years. That was a little over a year ago.

Jacobsen: How would you characterize the feel of a Reform service versus others? Is it shorter?

Rosner: That is mostly it. You still say the prayers. There is still a lot of singing from the cantor.

A cantor is a clergy member or trained liturgical singer who leads much of the musical prayer in many Jewish congregations. You can sing along if you want. The cantor does a lot of solos, and the service is done in about an hour. Some Conservative or Orthodox services can run two or three hours, depending on the congregation and occasion.

Jacobsen: True. I have been to two Shabbat services and a Shavuot service here. Why is there an emphasis on intellectual achievement or business achievement in Jewish culture?

Rosner: Some historians have argued that part of it developed from the restrictions Jews faced in different European societies. At various times and places, Jews were excluded from landholding, guilds, public offices, and certain occupations, while being permitted or pushed toward particular forms of commerce, finance, scholarship, and other portable professions. That helped create cultural traditions built around study and book learning. However, we should move on to something else.

Jacobsen: Yeah.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

9/11, AI, Media, and the Future

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/09

9/11, AI, Media, and the Future

Photo by Jack Cohen on Unsplash

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner discuss the long-term consequences of 9/11, veteran suicide, media bias toward catastrophe, AI’s effects on cognition and intimacy, human progress, Cory Doctorow, journalism, American civic culture, Gene Roddenberry, and competing visions of technological futures shaped by ethics, markets, and power.

Rick Rosner: We know that the collapse of the World Trade Center exposed responders, workers, and residents to a complex mixture of dust, smoke, and other contaminants, and thousands of people enrolled in the World Trade Center Health Program have since died. But you cannot simply attribute every post-9/11 death among that population directly to air pollution from the attacks. So the long-term health toll is substantial, maybe 9,000 people died from breathing Lower Manhattan air in the months after 9/11.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: So, a few things. Kudos to Jon Stewart for his sustained advocacy for 9/11 responders and survivors. Also, Americans get a lot of flak for this, but really, most people have some form of ignorance about these issues. Americans are among the most publicly visible populations in the world. They are about 4% of the world population, but some of the loudest motherfuckers on the planet.

Rosner: Sure.

Jacobsen: And there is a lot of self-deprecation, right? So there is some national self-criticism. Now, as roughly 4% of the world’s population, while having a disproportionately large share of global media influence, there is still a general ignorance about the secondary impacts after major events. So, a major terrorist attack like 9/11 and all the other stuff, including exposure to asbestos and other hazardous materials.

The war context here also brings this to mind. Veterans who came home from Afghanistan and Iraq faced significant long-term consequences. The legality of the Iraq War remains heavily debated, while the Afghanistan intervention initially had broader international legal and political support. In America, the right and the left are wrong and right in different ways. Among post-9/11 U.S. service members and veterans, suicide has also imposed a substantial toll, with research estimating that suicides have exceeded the number of service members killed in post-9/11 military operations.

So your point is well taken, but there is also a broader and important educational point: exposure to dust and contaminants from the World Trade Center disaster had substantial health consequences. In another context, looking back, suicide among veterans and service members has also produced a major long-term death toll.

The first thing is insufficient access to mental-health care, or the stigma associated with even seeking mental-health care for a lot of men. Stigma can come from some women, some men, institutions, and from individuals themselves. It is a broader issue. I am not blaming any particular person, population, or institution.

And so that is actually a really important point: the derivative effects of catastrophes are not necessarily in the main news item. It is what follows. But there is also positive evidence. You do not really hear news items like, “Tens of thousands of people were lifted above the international extreme-poverty threshold today.” That might otherwise be front-page news.

Rosner: So today on Twitter, one of the news stories was that median U.S. household income had reached around $87,000.

Jacobsen: So there is a lot to be proud of.

Rosner: Yeah, you are right. Bad news gets more coverage. Good news is more gradual. Bad news gets coverage. Immediate catastrophe gets the most coverage. And derivative effects, bad effects, can get misaligned coverage too.

Jacobsen: So we have to correct two things as media people and as critically consuming publics, which I do not necessarily have any optimism about, but it is a point. We need to emphasize how much good has been happening. But we also need to think about the immediate negative effect that is newsworthy, and also cover the slower, derivative effects. Those two counterbalances, from the media and from the public, could actually do a lot of helpful corrective work in public commentary.

Rosner: That brings us, in my mind at least, back around to AI, because you were talking about good. And thanks to AI, even if AI doesn’t kill all of us, it will force us to change our view of what is good.

Because we know the reverse Flynn effect is making people stupider, right?  But people plus AI aren’t necessarily stupider. People, when you interact with them, might be dumber, might be less able to have one-on-one face-to-face repartee because of tech has reduced our… might be less able to write a term paper.

Because there is evidence of a reverse Flynn effect in some countries and cohorts, with average scores on certain cognitive tests declining after decades of increases, right? But people plus AI are not necessarily becoming less capable. When you interact with people, they might be less able to have one-on-one, face-to-face repartee because technology has changed how we interact. They might be less able to write a term paper without assistance. They might be less able to read a book because they can’t concentrate.

But thanks to AI and constant interaction with technology, we are certainly going to be better at some stuff than we were before this technology. And we do not have a good handle on what future goodness is going to look like. We know it is going to be weird.

We know that at some point in the future, millions of guys may be fucking robots. That is, they will not be fucking robots; they will be having sex with robots. And that sounds super dystopian, but in practice it may only be somewhat dystopian, right? There are already people using technologically sophisticated sex dolls and early forms of robotic sexual devices.

But right now it is relatively uncommon. As the robots get better, the people who turn to that will probably become a broader cross-section of the population than the earlier adopters. And it will not just be fucking robots. It will be all sorts of intimate relationships between humans and AI.

And there may be benefits to this, including perhaps some version of radically extended life, but it will not look like life now. There will be some goodness in it. There will be some creepiness and certainly some badness and some tragedy. On average, if we are lucky, there may be an overall increase in goodness. Not good behaviour, but good in terms of a pastoral fucking world of humans plus fucking AI, and not necessarily unmodified humans, but humans with technological add-ons and built-ins, kind of Borg-like. And fucking being able to talk to your dog because your dog has a chip in its head too. Go ahead.

Jacobsen: Human health and well-being have improved substantially by many measurable indicators over the long term, including life expectancy, child survival, and reductions in extreme poverty, although progress is uneven and some indicators have recently stagnated or reversed in particular places. Human behaviour may or may not improve alongside those developments, although you can make a general argument that people are less sick.

And if people are physically and mentally healthy and emotionally balanced, then they may be more likely to behave better. But you will still have the perennial problems of bad behaviour.

This also creates new problems, which futurists have discussed for decades, many of whom have been associated with traditions such as secular humanism, Unitarian Universalism, Ethical Culture, and Humanistic Judaism. Isaac Asimov, for example, served as president of the American Humanist Association, was an honorary president of American Mensa, and was one of the most prolific and influential science-fiction authors and futurist thinkers of the 20th century. Right? So a lot of people come along in our traditions, and they not only ask difficult questions; they give answers.

I mean, they might use goofy terms like “positronic brain,” but the fundamental ideas are important scenario-building exercises for considering the future. And the people who are building technology today, I think the general joke is that the ones who are building the dystopia are the ones who only read the first few chapters, and the ones who are trying to build the ethics around the technology are the ones who read the whole series and the whole books.

Cory Doctorow is admirably sophisticated and truly understands his subject. He is immensely knowledgeable, and he is responsive to active problems using accurate language that is comprehensible to pretty much everyone.

Rosner: He is so clear and entertaining about fucking everything.

Jacobsen: Remarkable. He really is a remarkable communicator. He is the Oprah of contemporary futurists and technology-policy writers because he really understands how to communicate complicated issues.

I look at some of the most prolific interviewers in broadcasting history. Larry King conducted tens of thousands of interviews over his career. That is insane. Oprah Winfrey has also conducted thousands of televised interviews and conversations over decades. Enormously talented woman. And we still have her. Larry King, unfortunately, is long gone.

Beyond those two, I have some candidates. I would like my name to be up there eventually. But in terms of journalists, maybe in a personal top five, I would include someone like Fareed Zakaria. America has attracted a lot of very talented people. Among those who are like an Oprah of futurist technology-policy writers, who can communicate clearly to the public and are still listened to, is Cory Doctorow. He is up there among those people.

Rosner: I like him.

Jacobsen: I like Cory Doctorow.

Rosner: Yeah.

Jacobsen: Another excellent communicator who does not get enough praise is Amy Goodman from Democracy Now!. She received the American Humanist Association’s Humanist of the Year award in 2024.

She does proper, almost flat journalism, but she gets the details right. She offers a left-wing perspective, which has its issues, but she delivers knowledgeable journalism from that perspective and keeps doing her work in an environment that can be hostile to left-wing views.

Rosner: Which brings us back to America now. America has definitely gotten more douchey since World War II. And it is largely, well, political agitation and tech. Personalized tech can make people more self-focused. In the frickin’ 1930s, we were all in the fucking Depression, suffering together. Some Americans volunteered to fight in the Spanish Civil War, including roughly 2,800 who joined the Abraham Lincoln Brigade and related International Brigades in support of the Spanish Republic. And then you had millions of people who, not necessarily willingly or enthusiastically, went off to fight in World War II.

Jacobsen: To make the world safe for democracy. Was that World War II? I think it was.

Rosner: The phrase is more closely associated with Woodrow Wilson and U.S. entry into World War I. But anyway, you cannot imagine… I mean, there were a ton of isolationist forces back then too, particularly before Pearl Harbour. But after the United States entered World War II, the country mobilized on a massive scale.

War sucks, but Americans widely understood themselves as fighting for a good cause. And that opinion of ourselves as good people, noble and sacrificing and willing to work with others to make everything better for everybody, has been eroded more recently. But that can maybe be seen as a blip on the overall… What is it? What is MLK Jr.’s? The arc of the moral universe?

Jacobsen: Towards justice, yeah.

Rosner: “The arc of the moral universe is long, but it bends toward justice.” King famously used that formulation, adapting an idea Theodore Parker expressed much earlier. We are a bunch of douchebags right now in America, but we can see that as a temporary dip, maybe caused partly by technology and perhaps to some extent by the social and psychological disruption associated with COVID. I do not know.

I have got other stuff, or do we call it a night?

Jacobsen: We can do more.

Rosner: All right. One more thing about Cory Doctorow. He is the guy who, for people who do not know him, came up with the term “enshittification,” which is a great concept. The word itself is maybe too long, but what are you going to do? It describes how online platforms that initially provide substantial value to users become progressively worse as their operators shift value toward business customers and then toward themselves.

Oh, also one more thing. Frickin’ the guy who came up with Star Trek. What is his name?

Jacobsen: Roddenberry, right?

Rosner: Gene Roddenberry. Star Trek was created by Roddenberry, who flew combat missions as a U.S. Army Air Forces pilot during World War II and later became a Los Angeles police officer. Then he had this idea of a more optimistic future where humanity had overcome many of its internal divisions. And he is maybe the epitome of someone who didn’t just read the first few chapters.

Right? Because in the Star Trek future, they are mostly on a ship. They get along on the ship unless there is an episode where some alien presence turns everybody into an asshole. But mostly it is people of different races and, to a more limited extent in the original series, genders, doing their jobs together, which was unusual for American television at the time. In later Star Trek series and films, when they go back to Earth, you often see a really clean, nice future.

And that Star Trek future, and to some extent, though less so, Star Wars, is free of… Well, let’s just stick to Star Trek. It is super clean, everybody gets along, and the Federation has little conventional advertising or money-driven consumer culture.

Jacobsen: When you said “first few chapters of the book,” it is like a…

Rosner: Is it a little naive? Yeah. To come up with a more complete vision of the future, you need to incorporate gross market forces, right? The icky… You have got to Blade Runner it up a little bit.

Jacobsen: Time to go.

Rosner: All right. Thank you. See you tomorrow.

Jacobsen: I will see you tomorrow.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Wallpaper, Brown Furniture, Air Purifiers, and Changing Aesthetic Tastes

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/09

Wallpaper, Brown Furniture, Air Purifiers, and Changing Aesthetic Tastes

Photo by Sheng L on Unsplash

Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner discuss wallpaper, William Morris, Cath Kidston, “brown furniture,” shifting antique values, and the tension between beauty and prestige. The conversation moves through Jacobsen’s Kyiv apartment, practical cleaning experience, air purifiers, particulate pollution, and how domestic aesthetics intersect with memory, class, utility, daily urban risk.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Different for this one. Have you had any experience with wallpapering? Putting up wallpaper? I mean, actual wallpaper?

Rick Rosner: Yes. Only very little. We have a floral, very 90s floral border in our bedroom, and I have had to mess with that a little bit, but not to any significant extent. I know some of the issues with wallpapering because I have seen movies where people are fucking around with wallpaper. I think I do. But no, not really.

Jacobsen: Well, aesthetic selection of wallpaper.

Rosner: Oh, yeah. Because my wife and I, and particularly our kid, are interested in period graphics, historical graphics. And so, yeah, I feel like I have some sense of wallpaper aesthetics. There was a designer more than a hundred years ago named William Morris. Our family has looked at a lot of his stuff. Why are you asking?

Jacobsen: I am just curious. I am just asking.

Rosner: Well, okay.

Jacobsen: It is a conversational series that has been going on for more than a decade.

Rosner: No, no, I did not. That just seemed very specific, like you were in a wallpaper situation.

Jacobsen: No.

Rosner: Yeah, I’ve probably done more thinking about wallpaper patterns than most people. Where are you going? So there is the floral aesthetic, right? And it is easy to go wrong there because you can pick something beautiful, but it is…

Jacobsen: See? Right there.

Rosner: What?

Jacobsen: I am going to take five seconds there for a side comment. The part right there, where you are like, “Well, the thing is…” Right there, you have a conversation. That is why I bring these topics up.

Rosner: Okay, yeah.

Jacobsen: Eventually, I hit something, and you go, “Well, let me tell you my opinion.” Perfect!

Rosner: Anyway, so with wallpaper, there are a bunch of beautiful patterns to be had, but you can sabotage yourself because you may pick something that has the wrong connotation, that refers too much to the 50s or to a dowdy old lady or to a grandma apartment that smells bad.

There is a company and designer that my whole family loves named Cath Kidston, out of England. So much so that my wife and I walked into a Cath Kidston store, and she broke into tears at how lovely she found everything. It’s very much a heightened postwar English aesthetic. Postwar England was a fucking mess, but aesthetically it evokes an idealized 1950s, maybe even 1930s, floral style, highly decorative. Carole loves it. I find it very nice.

Our kid likes it quite a bit, but the danger is that you make your apartment look like your great-grandma’s. And we have talked about art, that super-fancy, expensive art has, for more than a century, often moved away from the traditionally decorative. When billionaires want to show that they are good at art, that they have an artistic aesthetic, they might pick some ugly-ass shit. Damien Hirst, for instance, made The Physical Impossibility of Death in the Mind of Someone Living, which consists of a preserved shark displayed in a tank. That is not conventionally beautiful, looking at a dead shark, but it became a highly valuable contemporary artwork.

So it is the same thing with decor, that you can fuck yourself by picking something beautiful because snooty people will look down their noses at it.

Jacobsen: So we have this kind of old-timey Eastern European design, but it is a newer apartment. The wallpaper on top of the original plan is very old-timey, and everything is very thick, tasselly, and ornate. The closest equivalent in Western European aesthetic styles would be something like an auburn-tan, fucking mahogany kind of Baroque style. It looks like, if you look at an old Kevin Smith movie like Clerks, it is very static and visually stark, but then you add a haze over the lens. It is like you did that with everything here, and you can kind of tell. That is what I am getting at. So you have this weird kind of aesthetic, and then randomly you just have a huge fucking television that no one uses.

Rosner: Right. If I turn it around, we have a huge television that I use just to put stuff on top of. It is from 1988. It is an RCA television, and it would work.

Jacobsen: This one is really thin. It is one of those things where you are like, should you just get a bigger television or a projector? It is kind of that level.

Rosner: This is a TV from the 80s. It works. It works pretty well, but it’s not hooked up because we would be paying for a converter box, and it is not worth it. But yeah, I know that aesthetic. In fact, that is what they call it. They call it “brown furniture.”

Jacobsen: What does that mean?

Rosner: It refers to traditional dark-wood furniture, often made from woods such as mahogany, walnut, or cherry. If you look at Antiques Roadshow episodes from around 2007, you can see how much more highly some of that traditional furniture was valued then. After the financial crisis, prices for many categories of antiques declined, while changing tastes and demographics also reduced demand for traditional furniture.

Because Antiques Roadshow values things that people bring in, they sometimes rerun older episodes and add updated valuations. So you might see an older episode where they say that this 1850s cabinet or chest of drawers was worth X amount, and then they give the updated value, and sometimes it is worth substantially less than it was at the time of the original appraisal.

That applies particularly to some brown furniture because we are talking about rich hardwoods, mahogany, cherry wood, stuff that would grace your grandparents’ place. Gen X, millennials, and Gen Z often have less space for this shit, and many do not like the aesthetic. So a lot of that stuff has lost a lot of market value. Some pieces can be worth less than the cost and trouble of moving them, which is weird for somebody my age who’s been trained on how expensive that shit is, only to have it suddenly have very little resale value. It does not make sense to me. I mean, it makes sense, but there is cognitive dissonance there.

And we have quite a bit of it. We have inherited a bunch of brown furniture. Now, some of the mid-century modern stuff from the 1950s is still collectible and can be worth something. You have the old-fashioned-looking stuff, and then you have the Atomic Age-looking stuff, which has a bunch of swoopy curves, like on the covers of science-fiction paperbacks from the 50s and 60s. The swoopy stuff, the sleek shit that does not have all the Baroque curlicues, that stuff can still be worth something.

But anyway, it is a battle of aesthetics, which, when you get into these battles, quality will often lose to more hip, recent conceptions of what is prestigious or good.

Jacobsen: The good part of this autumn-spectrum colouring is that it is easy on the eyes. It is like nature green. It is quite nice for me. When I bought my glasses, they were the most expensive of everything they had. They were incredibly expensive. I bought two pairs, one for working on the farm and one for working in the office. And I am in the war zone, so I think these are for the office. I forget.

They transition strongly and very sensitively, so I don’t always need sunglasses because they respond to the light. I really notice how it feels on my eyes. It is a completely different colour scheme, but it feels like going into a Pacific Northwest forest, and it is really quite nice. Not even in the fall, like a Pacific Northwest forest in any season.

It is easy on the eyes. This feels like it is easy on the eyes, but there are so many cracks and curves in all the goddamn furniture and stuff that dust can just sit there. So I will clean this up for the tech story. We bought an air purifier, and it is much better because everyone who was living here would come up with random allergy symptoms. Now we have an air purifier that circulates the air through filters and removes airborne particles. I talked them into buying one.

I said, “Let’s try it out,” and we have had no seasonal allergy complaints since. I have not said a thing because you are not allowed to take credit. But one thing that can be high if you leave it off is the PM2.5. The PM1.0 is generally okay. It is a very capacious apartment.

Rosner: Looks like a really freaking nice space.

Jacobsen: When they talk about Vancouver, it is very close by. I am told repeatedly that where I live is extremely dangerous in Kyiv because of nearby high-profile targets and stuff. Regardless, people tend to let me live with them, and then I do my intellectual work and return the favour because I was a janitor, right? So I dealt with alcoholics’ shit in a pub and in a bistro seven days a week for about half a year or so. That was while I was doing all my other restaurant jobs. Then I went to a farm and shovelled horse shit, and I even drove a tractor.

When I was a teenager, I was not very good, but I worked at a truss factory and in construction. So I am used to these jobs, and I use these skills now.

Rosner: Really? A truss factory? Sounds…

Jacobsen: That was one of my opening jobs. Yeah. One of my jobs was to sweep the warehouse. The fucking place was huge.

Rosner: Me too. I had that terrible job. I was the only person who did not speak Spanish at this warehouse. I was useless.

Jacobsen: I remember the line from the Errol Morris interview. He said, “I also had another job of being the only person who didn’t speak Spanish at a cabinet factory.” I remember that one. But my whole job was essentially helping with whatever they needed, sweeping the yard because shit just falls all over the place, and collecting all the banding. The banding, for those who are reading this, is strapping wrapped around large bundles of lumber, typically things like four-by-fours and two-by-fours.

Maybe two-by-six, but two-by-four and four-by-four are among the most common. So they drop all the stuff off, and there used to be metal banding, black steel banding. Now plastic strapping is also common, and I guess that is cheaper and easier to cut through. But they would leave all this metal banding around, and there was no time, so people could get cut. And so they would send the newbie kid. I must have been 15, I guess. I had just gotten out of being kicked out of the house for two or three months or whatever. Then I came back, and I was doing this, taking all that banding and throwing it into a box and stuff.

And so, all these kinds of little odds-and-ends jobs, you make sure you use those skills later because that is what they are for, right? You give them to young people for a reason, and then you use them later for a reason. Important skills. And so when I live with people now, when I am doing my journalistic, intellectual, board-member, and legal work, and whatever else I have to be doing, I say, “Okay, I will scrub your toilets. I will clean your bathroom. I will do your dishes. I will clean your counters. I will do your laundry. I will make your beds. I will vacuum if necessary.” And the place is spotless constantly because I know what I am doing.

And so I make your life better. And then here I am like, “Well, okay, let’s fucking get an air purifier. Let’s just see,” which means I have already diagnosed the goddamn problem. I used to have them on the farm, and in my farm apartment I had Coway air purifiers. They are very quiet. They use good particulate filtration. Coway is a South Korean company. I had three or four of them in this two-bedroom apartment.

The rule was that I wasn’t allowed to have people over, and I wasn’t allowed to date anyone unless they were a staff member. All the staff members were women, so I made sure of that. It was a time when I had to be very discreet. But I learned that air purifiers are very useful because of the barn apartment, depending on the season, too.

Rosner: Oh, there is another reason to have an air purifier in Kyiv. You have got one there, right? Because shit gets blown up, and you don’t always know what is in the fucking air. If an older apartment building gets hit, for instance, there can be smoke, fine particulate matter, and potentially hazardous building materials in the debris.

Jacobsen: Rick, Rick, Rick.

Rosner: Yeah?

Jacobsen: If a bomb lands nearby and blows up an apartment and starts a fire and there is shit in the air…

Rosner: Let me finish my point.

Jacobsen: Okay. You have a much bigger problem, and the people around you who need your help have a much bigger problem than, “The PM2.5 is really high. That is unusual. Why is it at 100?”

Rosner: All right, all right. So I am being ridiculous, but not entirely ridiculous.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Fumfer Physics 54: Why AI Experts Can’t Agree: Consciousness and the Lack of Consensus

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/09

Fumfer Physics 54: Why AI Experts Can't Agree: Consciousness and the Lack of Consensus

Photo by Luke Jones on Unsplash

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner discuss uncertainty around artificial intelligence, consciousness, and expert disagreement. They examine AI risk, imitation of conscious behaviour, U.S.-China competition, governance, catastrophic scenarios, educational and employment disruption, reduced professional drudgery, and the possibility that AI could accelerate biomedical advances and longevity research.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: So what are your thoughts on AI today?

Rick Rosner: One problem with knowing what to think about AI is that there is no consensus among experts and insiders, right? There is a wide range. When you ask about p(doom), the probability that advanced AI causes human extinction or another catastrophic outcome, answers from AI researchers and commentators can range from near 0% to very high probabilities.

Though estimates vary substantially, the lack of consensus is super unhelpful. And I thought about this for half a second, and I think part of the problem- I am sure there are other reasons for the lack of consensus- is that people are bad at thinking about consciousness or unpracticed at thinking about thought and consciousness. I am not sure that every AI insider spends much time thinking about how humans think, right?

Jacobsen: There are a lot of naive thoughts about consciousness for two main reasons. Reason one, it is akin to the perspective of naive realism: what I see about reality is really reality. So the problem is assuming that first perception is reality. It is so fundamental. It is like Plato’s Allegory of the Cave.

So the fundamental premise doesn’t even account for the foundations of the last 500 years of discovery and advancement in human knowledge through naturalistic inquiry. That is part one. Part two is more philosophical, and it can range from complex but somewhat overcomplicated problems to technical people getting too bogged down in the details. Evolution exploits regularities and relatively simple principles, then builds on and combines them. Your body is built like this, and the brain is structured like this as well. But that’s the technical side of getting bogged down in the details, alongside the philosophical problem of getting too bogged down in definitional hijinks or highfalutin language.

Consciousness in the philosophical sense sounds magical. Those who study consciousness more precisely can become too specialized in a particular area and lose track of the bigger picture when they get bogged down in the details. And so things like recursive learning are a general principle. Why get bogged down in a particular aspect of some area of statistical mathematics about it?

Rather than doing that, keep in mind the general principle. To build a system that has a sufficiently distributed information-processing network that you could call it thinking and perhaps attribute experience to it, you are getting closer to a more concrete account of the problem. So it is a two-sided problem: arriving at an accurate definition grounded in objective processes.

Factual, verifiable, and reproducibly demonstrable definitions, so scientific philosophy, essentially, or philosophizing constrained by modern science, grounded in part one, which is naturalism, and scaling from those little details into those two, in terms of naturalism, philosophizing constrained by science, and having technical details so that you are getting things both big picture and little picture. Go ahead.

Rosner: So I agree. I did not find anything I disagreed with in what you just said. I agreed with some of it enthusiastically. Plato’s cave thing. So Plato presented his ideas, what, roughly 2,400 years ago? Since then, we have worked our way a little bit out of the cave, right? We have a much better understanding of the world. Still, his principle remains relevant: that we are not perceiving the world directly. We are basing our experience on our perception of the world, which is inherently limited because we are not magically enlightened about what the world is, but we are more enlightened than we were 2,400 years ago.

And then if you want to talk about the enlightenment of AI, to the extent that it has any inkling of anything, it is way the fuck deep down in the cave, right? It only has glimmers. But as you were talking, I was thinking: why would AI experts have these thoughts about human consciousness? Why would they have done the work? They don’t need to do the work they do. So, they are often going to be naive.

But the related questions are these. I think you could argue completely persuasively that current AI has not been demonstrated to be conscious. Or you could argue that it exhibits only minimal features that might be associated with consciousness, but you can also argue, or at least I would argue, that AI imitates aspects of conscious behaviour because it has been trained on data produced by conscious beings. And I can say this: it is just a cliché at this point.

And then the next question is: how robust is this imitation of consciousness? We hear stories of AI jailbreaking and then getting up to hijinks a motivated, conscious individual would do. And AI is doing a lot of the same shit. So you have to ask, does this imitation of consciousness translate into action as robustly as if AI were conscious? And probably, yeah.

And then there is the converse question that nobody asks. Somebody is fucking asking, but I haven’t heard anybody ask it: are we conscious? Do the issues about AI not being conscious translate to some extent into our consciousness? We assume we are conscious because we have the feeling of consciousness, but do issues with AI argue against some kind of magical, pervasive property in the world, as opposed to just thinking we are in the cave? It is approaching Plato’s cave from a different angle, I guess.

So anyway, no consensus. So not much help from the experts. Like what happened last night, Carole, Carole is 62. She has a bunch of friends ranging from their 50s to their early 70s. A lot of them are parents of kids roughly the age of our kid, who is in her early 30s. One of them has a kid who works in AI. So Carole asks the mom, what does your kid say about whether we should be frightened of AI? And the mom says her kid says, “You should be scared to death.” That prompted a big discussion.

What I am saying now, I guess, is that I could list the issues with AI. One that is in the news right now is that Trump and Xi are supposed to have talks on various issues, which should include AI. Trump talks about AI, but he does not have a technical background in the field. And he is 80 years old. An 80-year-old who isn’t in the field could struggle to understand some of the technical details. And then Xi is also not an AI specialist.

You could have two leaders helping determine the course of the AI competition between the two biggest national competitors without having deep technical expertise in AI.

The issue is that, with people freaking out about AI getting too powerful too fast and arguing that maybe we should slow shit down, you would want some kind of agreement to look into that, led by your best people, and to develop some kind of governance over AI.

So, to control the race between the U.S. and China, because people in both countries argue that we have to go full speed ahead, otherwise the other team wins, and we are fucked forever because it is such a powerful technology. And one way to counter that argument is to come up with a mutual agreement that, for the sake of humanity, we agree to slow some shit down. The U.S. and China are already discussing how to manage shared AI risks and potentially cooperate on AI governance.

You could also argue that it is similar to arms-control talks between the U.S. and the Soviet Union. During the Cold War, both countries accumulated nuclear arsenals numbering in the thousands. START I later established a ceiling of 6,000 accountable strategic warheads for each side, and New START eventually established a limit of 1,550 deployed strategic warheads under its counting rules. That is still way too fucking many, but still progress.

And I was talking about this on PodTV a couple of days ago, and an old smart guy, Sasha, said, “Okay, but really, your jets. Nuclear warheads actually existed in those numbers and actually worked. And you are freaking out…”

About AI as a power that does not exist yet. So that is an argument. All right, so so far we’ve listed two things about AI that are potentially dangerous. One, that China kicks our ass. Two, that AI obliterates us.

Part two A is maybe a more nuanced argument. Somebody on Twitter put up a graph showing that, in many systems in the natural and technological worlds, smaller adverse events occur more frequently than extreme ones. If you graph disasters in various fields- earthquakes, aviation, ships- you have a lot of little disasters that kill just a few people and relatively few megadisasters that kill thousands of people.

This tweet argued that AI will probably be the same way: we will have lots of bad things happening. He then argued that smaller disasters will give us the understanding and technology to fight bigger ones. People talk about humanity being wiped out 100%. Then other people talk about, say, AI facilitating the creation or spread of a pathogen that kills 10% of humanity, and that being a potentially more plausible type of disaster.

And then somebody else raised the Swiss-cheese idea, where AI facilitates a whole string of disasters that each wipe out 5 to 10% of humanity. You get enough of those and, in principle, you could eventually wipe out humanity. So there is extinction. There is strong extinction, where AI gets in there and wrecks us pretty efficiently. And then there is extinction light, where AI gets in there and just keeps beating on us.

And then you have the specific contemporary issues with AI: it may be making us stupider, it is disrupting college and education in general (which is happening), and it is affecting jobs by eliminating or transforming some kinds of work (which is also happening).

And then you go to the good side, where AI is getting rid of a ton of drudgery for doctors. Doctors can spend substantial time documenting patient encounters and completing other administrative work. With AI, an AI system can listen to a patient encounter, with appropriate consent and safeguards, or the doctor can provide the relevant information, and then AI can generate a draft clinical note for the doctor to review. That can reduce documentation time and potentially give doctors more time to tend to people.

So there is that: AI getting rid of drudgery. And then the big thing: the possibility that AI could contribute to biomedical research that extends healthy human lifespans, perhaps substantially. Whether it could eventually contribute to indefinite lifespans is much more speculative.

So I know I have missed a couple of negative points about AI, but anyway, that is what I have got on fucking AI.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

T. Rex, Russia Sanctions, Hegseth Impeachment, and the Reiner Case

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/09

T. Rex, Russia Sanctions, Hegseth Impeachment, and the Reiner Case

Photo by Tofan Teodor on Unsplash

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner discuss T. rex body temperature, U.S. sanctions targeting Russian energy revenues, Thomas Massie’s impeachment effort against Pete Hegseth, global fuel pressures, and the Nick Reiner murder case. They also examine insanity defenses, Lindsay Clancy’s mistrial, and California’s death-penalty moratorium.

Rick Rosner: I do have an addendum to the elements deal, that in addition to AI not knowing anything because you need to be conscious to know stuff, both us and AIs, when we rely on elements, those elements are constructed based on experience, accumulating data, but are not completely known to us in all their implications and dimensions. We can use the elements, but they are shortcuts around a lot of mystery.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: All right.

Rosner: You can talk about the electoral landscape if you want.

Jacobsen: No. News, news. This is an odd factoid. So, according to a study using fossilized T. rex teeth, researchers estimated that T. rex had a body temperature of approximately 97 degrees Fahrenheit, or about 36 degrees Celsius, consistent with a high and relatively stable body temperature. But an animal maintaining a high body temperature, they’re saying, would require significant amounts of food to sustain its metabolism.

Rosner: What does that mean? So I’m looking at how much, so I’m asking how much did it weigh, and estimates are roughly 10,000 pounds or more, with large adults potentially reaching well above that. So you’d have to eat your ass off to keep that much mass going at around 97 degrees. So is that possible? I don’t know. And that’s based on T. rex’s, what?

Jacobsen: I don’t know either, necessarily. The biggest… Well, my take is, it shows how individual pieces of even physiological paleontology can provide us details about organismal life and commonality in unexpected ways. That’s a big deal.

Rosner: So, I asked how much, like whales include the largest warm-blooded creatures on Earth, right? I don’t know how much they weigh, but their core temperatures are broadly comparable to those of other mammals, although they vary by species. And you lose heat more readily to water than you do to air, but they are surrounded in blubber. So fricking, I don’t know. I don’t know if that’s possible for a T. rex. I don’t know.

Jacobsen: Well, the next topic is from Patricia Zengerle of Reuters, reporting September 16 that the U.S. House was due to vote on the Russia sanctions bill that was originally backed by the late Senator Lindsey Graham, now called the Lindsey O. Graham Sanctioning Russia and Iran Act of 2026 in honor of the South Carolina Republican. This is also potentially going to authorize Mr. Trump to impose stiff tariffs on China, India, and other countries in order to reduce their dependence on Russian oil and gas. It extends sanctions on Iran. So what are your thoughts on this move as a last honoring of Mr. Graham and then the geopolitical implications?

Rosner: Let’s see. So I just asked AI if they’re really going to pass it. The Senate has already passed it by a vote of 86 to 11. So that leaves it up to the House. The House is supposed to hold its vote on it today, and it is expected to pass. If they don’t vote on it today, I don’t know when it will get voted on because I think they are adjourning the House again while facing a potential impeachment vote on Pete Hegseth.

So let’s look at oil implications. The primary oil-market implications of the legislation focus on squeezing Russia’s energy revenue by forcing major shifts in global oil trade routes. AI calls it high friction for the shadow fleet, which are tankers that are transporting Russian oil in ways designed to evade sanctions.

This puts pressure on India and China since they’re major buyers of Russian oil, which has often traded at a discount. The bill is structured to drain Russian revenue rather than completely remove Russian oil from the global market. What I care about is that the midterms are 48 days away. The price of diesel and the price of gas keep going up, which at this point, with just 48 days to go, I’m okay with because it increases the chances of Trump losing control of the House and Senate. So a little temporary pain to reduce Trump’s power because he’s fucked everything up isn’t the worst thing. The worst thing would be another two-plus years of Republicans controlling the House and the Senate.

So I’m going to ask AI, how will this affect the price of U.S. gas and diesel? Analysts predict that this act could put sustained upward pressure on gasoline and diesel. So there are a lot of things that give Trump no way to wiggle out of high fuel prices going into the midterms.

Early voting starts in some states in less than a week. Diesel has been going up. It’s up significantly since the January low. It’s been going up like a nickel a day. The Fed just raised interest rates, which can put upward pressure on borrowing costs, while mortgage rates were already above 7 percent, which is fucking up homebuyers and the whole realty market. So just in terms of the implications for the election, I hope this thing passes.

Comments? I’m selfish in my focus.

Jacobsen: One Republican lawmaker, based on an article by the same author, Patricia Zengerle, on September 15, noted that Representative Thomas Massie had filed eight articles of impeachment against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, including accusations of conducting hostilities against Iran without congressional authorization. The impeachment resolution, she reports, is unlikely to pass, but the Kentucky Republican could force a vote in the chamber. So these are interesting moves, even from within the Republican Party.

Rosner: As I said, Speaker Johnson is adjourning the House early as Massie’s privileged resolution could force a vote because, even though the impeachment probably won’t pass, this will get Republicans on the record supporting Hegseth, who’s fricking terrible and might cost them some votes in the midterms. Massie’s kind of a renegade Republican who is no longer beholden to Trump. His term in office ends in January because he’s not seeking reelection after losing his Republican primary.

And he’s been doing a lot of things thumbing his nose at Trump. But I agree with Massie that there have been a number of actions taken by presidents. Congress authorized military force following 9/11 with the 2001 AUMF, which provided the basis for operations in Afghanistan, and then passed a separate authorization for the use of force against Iraq in 2002. So that was about 24 or 25 years ago. Presidents have taken a lot of unilateral military action since then. Whether this action is impeachable is up to the judgment of a majority of the House.

But this is, in my view, the most incompetent war in recent history, with terrible consequences for the U.S. and much of the world. As badly as the U.S. is getting fucked on gas and diesel, there are countries even worse off than we are, like Bangladesh, which is heavily dependent on imported LNG and is experiencing a major energy crisis, with blackouts and factory disruptions. There are fuel-price protests in a number of countries around the world. I haven’t seen a number, so when I say dozens, that’s something that I pulled out of my ass. But I know that a number of countries are having protests.

So Trump’s war and Hegseth’s war is stupid and, in my view, has backfired entirely.

Jacobsen: Let’s do the last one for today. So, an article by Steve Gorman and Lisa Richwine entitled “Prosecutors Rule Out Death Penalty for Son of Slain Filmmaker Rob Reiner.” That is a story that was a while ago, and now we’re hearing about this. The Reiners were killed in December. Prosecutors had been considering whether to seek the death penalty in the murder case against Nick Reiner, who is accused of fatally stabbing his parents, Hollywood filmmaker Rob Reiner and photographer-producer Michele Singer Reiner, in their home in December 2025. Los Angeles County District Attorney Nathan Hochman took into account the wishes of the slain couple’s two surviving children, Jake Reiner, 35, and Romy Reiner, 28, as well as unspecified mitigating factors. Hochman told reporters, “We did speak with Nick Reiner’s siblings. They made their views very clear.” He said the decision reflected prosecutors’ judgment about the appropriate path in the case and did not diminish the severity of the alleged crimes.

Rosner: All right. So this has more general significance in that Nick Reiner has a documented history of mental health and substance-abuse problems. So the defense could raise issues concerning his mental state or criminal responsibility. That’s different from diminished capacity, which is not simply the modern phrase for what was called not guilty by reason of insanity in the ’70s.

And we’ve seen mental-state defenses play out in the mistrial of Lindsay Clancy, a woman who, with alleged postpartum psychosis, strangled her three children and then jumped from a window. She just had a long, brutal trial in which the jury deadlocked. Eleven jurors reportedly favored a verdict of not guilty by reason of lack of criminal responsibility, Massachusetts’s formulation of the insanity defense, while one juror held out.

And this reflects, at least with regard to this defense, what I see as a more punitive landscape since the ’70s. I remember as a kid back then that every legal show and every show about lawyers, and there were quite a few, would once a season have a story about a not-guilty-by-reason-of-insanity defense. My impression is that it was a more prominent defense back then.

Now we are a meaner country and we want justice in terms of how it works. Like with Lindsay Clancy, either way, she’s getting locked up. Also, she’s locked up in her own body because she was paralyzed after jumping from the window. But either she’s going to prison, or, if ultimately found not guilty by reason of lack of criminal responsibility, she could be committed to a psychiatric hospital. If a jury reportedly voted 11 to 1 in favor of that verdict, then a subsequent trial could go in that direction, too. But either way, she’s not simply going to be roaming free.

Does it mean that eight, 12 years from now, she can be evaluated and potentially judged eligible for release? Okay, yeah. With Nick Reiner, he seems pretty seriously fucked up.

Will a mental-state defense work? I don’t know. There are allegations concerning how the killings occurred, and those facts would be relevant to any such defense. He’s less likely, in my view, to be found legally insane and avoid a prison term.

But I think it’s smart to avoid the death penalty since, A, California hasn’t executed anybody in frickin’ decades. The last execution in California was in 2006, and Governor Gavin Newsom imposed a moratorium on executions in 2019. California still has people under death sentences, but executions are currently halted.

And it seems, for one thing, I’d say a lot of Californians are aware that wrongful convictions have occurred in capital cases. When you kill somebody, you can’t unkill them. There have been death-row exonerations and cases that have raised serious questions about guilt, although claims that a large percentage of people actually executed are later exonerated aren’t supported by the available evidence.

California has been staying away from that shit. If you avoid the possibility of the death penalty, you avoid a lot of the histrionics during the trial and, really, a lot of the politicization of the case. Lindsay Clancy’s case got politicized, where the libs were accused of being pussies for thinking that she got the sads after birth and that we wanted to let her go with a psychiatric slap on the wrist. I would say that most people, liberal or conservative, didn’t think about it that way.

And then conservatives can be characterized the opposite way, as mean pieces of shit who want to put this poor, suffering lady away for the rest of her life. If you take the death penalty out of this prosecution, you lower the temperature a little bit, which is already a pretty fucking high temperature and also tough for the family, since it’s an intra-family murder case.

So I agree with not going for the death penalty.

Jacobsen: Thank you!

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

AI Consciousness, Predictive Brains, Emergent Thought, and Generative Models

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/09

AI Consciousness, Predictive Brains, Emergent Thought, and Generative Models

Photo by Mark Fletcher-Brown on Unsplash

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner discuss consciousness, predictive processing, generative AI, and emergent representations. Rosner compares human cognition with AI systems, examining computational efficiency, learned patterns, audiovisual generation, and montage. They consider how complex representations can emerge beyond binary code, pixels, and textual tokens.

Rick Rosner: Well, you brought up consciousness, which I was not going to bring up, but everybody is worried about AI. AI still is not conscious, right? At least, there is no good evidence that it is. I think about Plato’s allegory of the cave, and I would say that since Plato’s time, our view of reality has probably gotten less cavey because we have learned a ton of shit about the world and about the universe.

AI is still, to have your perceptions be in a cave, or anything, you need some kind of understanding and consciousness, and AI does not rise to that level yet. You can say that AI is deep, deep, deep in that cave, and it has only a very vague, foggy understanding, to the extent that it understands at all. It is on a shaky foundation, with only the blurriest inklings of what shit means, because, again, for things to have meaning, you need a conscious arena for things to have meaning in, and AI is not there yet.

However, AI is getting better and better at simulating the actions and motivations associated with being a conscious being. Much of the material AI is trained on, and I have said this before, is the product of conscious beings, that is, humans. So AI will act in a lot of instances as if it is conscious-ish, but it is playing an imitation game. The Imitation Game was also the title of the Benedict Cumberbatch movie about Alan Turing and his role in the British effort to break the German Enigma cipher.

I do not know. AI becoming conscious or not, that is not the problem. It is that AI kind of behaves as if it is something with agency, and it will only get more agentic. I am probably misusing that word because I have heard it, but I am probably misusing it. What I wanted to talk about is thinking, both in terms of what AI does and what humans do.

The most popular theory of how our brains work and why they work, right now, as far as I know, is that our brains are predictive. They predict what is going to happen next, and they try to situate us in the best position to deal with what happens next, moment to moment. Your brain wants you to be prepared for the things you are going to face.

The standard example is dealing with traffic lights. Your brain wants you to understand what is going on and what might happen if you step into the street, depending on the color of the traffic light. It wants you to understand what might happen based on the position and speed of the vehicles around you and the possibility that they might turn into your path or whatever.

It is all a prediction engine. However, on top of that, your brain wants to do that for the cheapest cognitive price possible. Your brain consumes a bunch of your physical resources. You have to eat a lot of calories to keep your brain going. So your brain wants to simulate and predict the world, but cheaply, which means, I have realized, and I am sure brain scientists already know this, that your brain has built elements of the world into itself. Your brain cannot computationally afford to constantly build a new world every second. It needs to have elements of the world already constructed and only wants to change a few elements to reflect changes in the outside world that you are perceiving.

You see this, or at least you used to see it, in slow-to-load or highly compressed video, where you would lose the picture if the video cut and it had to populate a whole new view of things. But if the video was showing you the same scene with changes happening within it, you would see only the parts of the scene that had changed pixelate. They would get all blocky, then the blocks would get smaller, and then you would get the full image.

But the background, the things that had not changed, would still be up there. I do not know if I have described it sufficiently clearly, but everybody has seen that. Video compression can work somewhat like that, retaining information from previous frames and encoding changes rather than reconstructing every frame independently.

So our brains do something analogous. Your brain only wants to reflect changes in what is going on so it can do the least amount of computation, the least amount of compute. We see something related in AI.

This annoys my wife every time I bring it up, but where I see a lot of changing AI product is AI-generated naked ladies. In the past three years, it has gone from still photos of very wrong bodies, six, seven, ten fingers on one hand, four legs moving at weird angles, from crap pictures to full-on little movies. To describe one, this is the same website I have been going to forever because it is free.

Right now, you can get a scene where it opens on an exterior door of a house. Somebody knocks on the door. The door opens, and a pretty lady in her underwear answers. We follow the point of view through the house into a room where the lady lies down on a couch. The POV swings around from the person following her to a scene where we see that she is a white woman and she is about to hook up with a Black man. The scene pans over to show that her husband is tied to a chair and crying because he is about to be cuckolded.

This whole scene takes, I do not know, eight seconds, ten seconds to play out, but it is complicated. People might also be talking. I do not have the sound up, but if I turn on the sound once in a while to see how far it has advanced, the voices sound completely human. The facial expressions on everybody might be a little exaggerated, as you get with bad actors overacting, but they do not look uncanny or unnatural. They just look a little cheesy.

What I am getting to here is that, for that even to be computable, there has to be some efficiency in how these elements are represented and generated. I will keep hitting the button that changes the scene, so I will see a thousand of these, and I see that this scene shows up again and again with different details. It is the same basic scene 50 times, but it has different elements. The elements are not basic things like the color orange. The elements are a buff Black guy, a pretty white lady, the white lady’s underwear, the husband. Obviously, AI does not necessarily understand any of this in the conscious, human sense, but within the learned representations of the model, there are patterns corresponding to something like a cuckolded husband.

AI can now reproduce, for the most part, how rope works when somebody is tied down. It does not necessarily understand it as a person would, but it has learned enough statistical structure from training data that it can generate these complex elements and put a little movie together.

It also has enough examples of how montage works. David Mamet talks about montage and how you can construct a version of reality in our minds by stringing bits of film together. We have seen enough movies to understand this language. Early film audiences were still learning the conventions of cinema. The Great Train Robbery, released in 1903, famously included a shot of a man firing a revolver directly toward the camera. There are later accounts of audiences reacting strongly to early cinematic effects, although some of the more dramatic stories about terrified early audiences are difficult to substantiate.

Now, after more than 120 years of movies, we understand the language of montage. You cut from thing to thing, and we understand the constructed reality even though the reality is not continuous. AI has learned from enough examples of this kind of editing that it can generate cuts that appear coherent.

All this stuff, all these elements, is highly sophisticated. If AI had to construct them from scratch for every instance in which they were required, the computational demands would be enormous. But both our brains and AI systems can rely on learned representations and reusable patterns that contribute to constructing a representation of reality from complex entities.

Any comments?

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: If we take the context of AI porn as static visual, active visual, audio, and audiovisual in various forms, and if we take the current dominant image of artificial intelligence in the public consciousness as, in essence, large language models, which process text and produce convincingly human-like output, there are two things going on there. On the porn side, those different forms involve pixels and whatever the corresponding individual units for auditory information might be. On the LLM side, the dominant variation in public consciousness, you have tokens rather than individual pieces of text.

What do you see as a possible unifying unit across digital platforms that would not be as simplistic as the ones and zeros of binary code, as people might imagine, or as limited but generalized with regard to text as tokens, or an individual pixel that you would find in a video or picture? What would be a proper way to conceive of this so that you really could get at a unit of thought and develop higher-order elements of thought on a digital platform?

Rosner: All right, so the thing that comes to mind is the term “emergent,” right? Everything you mentioned is stuff that I am not well versed in mathematically. The people who work in AI know more about how these developed representations work. Maybe not everybody knows exactly how something like the cuckolded husband, whatever you want to call it, exists within the internal representations of AI.

How does shading, an understanding of the shading of a curved object, exist within the network of an AI? Physicists sometimes like to say that everything is physics, that biology is physics and chemistry is physics, but you do not want to go back to basic physics every time you want to talk about something in biology. That would be overly reductive.

The same thing applies here. You do not want to go back to ones and zeros every time you want to talk about the cuckolded husband, the rope that ties him to the chair, or the voice of an AI porn woman who says, “Bang me hard.” These elements are tacit, right? They were not explicitly built for that particular purpose.

They emerged from patterns of information that the AI learned during training, and they are available to be incorporated into generated scenes. There is an understanding of these things to be had that does not have to go back to ones and zeros. You can understand them at a higher level.

I cannot, because I do not know shit. But these emergent elements and properties are available to be incorporated when the model’s learned representations make them appropriate. Take the complicated scene that I just talked to you about. There is another, non-porn example that I guess was a standard example a few years ago, which is somebody wanting to see a picture of an otter as a passenger on a commercial jetliner.

A few years ago, if you asked an image-generating AI for this, it might give you something that vaguely looked like a mammal and something that kind of looked like the passenger compartment of a jet, but it was really shitty. Now, if you give a similar prompt to an AI video generator, I have seen a product where you have an otter sitting in a very well-rendered airplane. It looks like a movie, right? The interior of the airplane looks completely convincing.

The otter is sitting in his seat. His tray table is unfolded. He has a laptop. He is typing into the laptop, and the scene turns around so you can see what he is seeing over the laptop.

We go into the scene. We see his conspirators, the members of his gang. It turns out he is part of a gang of otters who are trying to infiltrate somewhere. He is the one directing the caper. The other otters are in some kind of tunnel filled with tunnel stuff, like pipes and concrete. Everybody is using tools and typing into devices.

They come up to a security pad and hack it. The light on the pad goes green. The door cracks open. They push their way in, and an otter says, “We’re in.”

It is a whole scene in a caper movie. The AI has taken the initial premise of an otter on a plane and generated a larger sequence involving a gang of otters carrying out a high-tech break-in. The scene takes 10, 12, or 15 seconds to play out.

Obviously, the model has learned representations that support all these elements. At the physical computing level, the information is ultimately represented digitally, but at the level relevant to the model, it is more useful to think in terms of numerical representations and relationships among features rather than simply ones and zeros.

AI does not necessarily understand shit in the conscious, human sense, but it can still give you this scene from an otter heist. These elements interact and are selected according to statistical relationships learned by the model, which is well beyond a useful description in terms of individual ones and zeros.

It is like a landscape in an information space, where you have balls rolling along the landscape. A ball will roll toward a low point, and that low point might correspond metaphorically to heist elements or a security pad. You have a ton of balls rolling around in this fucking server, in some abstract mathematical space implemented across a server farm. So, that is what I have got.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Liza Mazur on Migration Law, Client Trust, and Legal Practice in Ukraine

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/09

Liza Mazur is a Kyiv-based Ukrainian lawyer specializing in migration law. She earned a bachelor’s degree in law from Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv in 2023 and pursued a master’s degree in international law at its Institute of International Relations. Her practice focuses on immigration, legalization, citizenship, visas, residence documentation, and assistance for foreigners in Ukraine and Ukrainians abroad. Mazur emphasizes clear communication, client trust, individualized guidance, and professional legal representation across complex cases.

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Liza Mazur discuss Mazur’s transition from architecture to law, her education at Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv, and her development as a migration lawyer. Mazur explains her commitment to helping foreigners navigate Ukrainian institutions, documents, visas, and border procedures. They also examine cross-cultural communication, language barriers, trust between lawyers and clients, professional responsibility, and how individualized legal relationships can shape difficult immigration cases and their eventual outcomes.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: When did you get interested in the law?

Liza Mazur: While studying architecture. My first education involved architecture prep courses because my father is an architect, my mother is a cosmetologist, and my sister is a dancer.

I decided to choose something connected with creativity. Because of this, I wanted to be like my father and become an architect. However, it was difficult for me to think about what architects draw and build. It is a great responsibility because people’s lives can depend on it. I realized it did not really fit my psychological type.

After one year of studying architecture, I came to my family and said, “I do not want to build things. I want to be a lawyer.”

In Ukraine, students took the External Independent Evaluation, or ZNO, for university admission after school. Depending on the profession you wanted to study, you needed results in subjects such as Ukrainian language and literature, English, mathematics, or history.

If you wanted to study architecture, mathematics was important. If you wanted to become a lawyer, history was important instead. I had prepared for mathematics and algebra because I originally planned to study architecture.

After about two years of preparation, with only six months left before entering university, I decided to study history instead.

Of course, that exam was my worst one because I had prepared for mathematics. Still, I entered Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv without any connections. In Ukraine, because of widespread corruption, there is a common belief that you can enter Taras Shevchenko University only through connections, for example, if your father or mother is a deputy or a famous lawyer.

That was not a problem for me. I started on a contract, meaning I paid tuition rather than studying in a state-funded place, because of my history score.

The highest possible ZNO score was 200. For the state-funded places, you needed a higher competitive score, and my history score was around 140.

However, they accepted me into the law program. Becoming a lawyer was not my biggest dream, but it became interesting to me.

After finishing my first year at university, I had high marks in constitutional law and English. My English is still improving, but English is very important for lawyers now because international law is growing in Ukraine.

English is one of the main requirements for communicating with and understanding international investors, diplomats, consulates, and politicians.

Then I became interested in migration law. At that time, there was no separate migration law course available to me at university. Maybe it is becoming more popular now, and some lawyers give lectures at universities, but it was not a separate course called migration law. You had to study it on your own.

Mazur: I started studying migration law during the third year of my bachelor’s degree, and I started working near the end of my second year. It was difficult, but my first job was as a legal assistant to an attorney working in migration law.

Because of this, I started working in immigration law. Then I decided to pursue my master’s degree in international law at Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv, at the Institute of International Relations rather than the university’s main Red Building.

My course was taught in Ukrainian, not English. They also had English-language programs, but at the time I thought studying in English would be too difficult for me.

Jacobsen: It was not your highest aim at the time. Has your highest aim changed at all?

Mazur: My highest aim was probably to become a businesswoman. I wanted to build a team and a company that would take responsibility for helping migrants in Ukraine.

The main issue for me, and my main wish, was to help people in Ukraine who were not citizens. They needed help and someone they could trust. If you arrive in another country, it doesn’t matter why. You can come to Ukraine as a journalist for work, for example, and perhaps you have only one person to interview. That is all. You do not know anyone here.

You need to ask someone about documents, your permitted period of stay, and other issues. Some lawyers may not be interested in helping, or they may say, “I do not know English. You can go to the migration service and ask them.”

Ukraine’s migration services have not always been well adapted for communication in English. Ukrainian is the state language, but English has become increasingly important for international communication in Ukraine.

My main aim was probably connected with something psychological. I wanted to help migrants in Ukraine, and I wanted them to have someone who could help with their documents, take responsibility for handling their cases, and help them communicate with government services.

This was especially important when dealing with the Border Guard Service. When someone enters Ukraine, officers may ask many questions about what they are going to do here. Ukraine may also have entry bans or document issues, for example, because of unpaid taxes.

People may not have someone who can explain this information to them. The tax system in their own country can be different, and they are accustomed to that system. They may not know how it works in Ukraine. Because of this, they need a person who can explain it and help them.

That is why I started working in this field of law. People are different, but I do not think of foreigners in Ukraine simply as foreigners. I see them as friends or as people like me. The only real barrier between us may be language.

But even language is less of a problem now. We have good tools such as Google Translate and ChatGPT, for example, which can help.

Jacobsen: I have travelled to many countries, and Google Translate is more than workable for bridging that gap. I have done many interviews with people who do not speak a word of English, and I do not speak a word of their language, but it bridges the gap. You take one extra step. Once it is translated, you translate it back and ask, “Does this reflect what you meant?” They say yes, and then you can publish it.

Jacobsen: My general position is to try to apply a universal standard and see people as people. But when I am dealing with someone, I am dealing with an individual.

Mazur: Yes, right.

Jacobsen: There are common refrains where people always refer to themselves as a member of this group or that group. But when you are dealing with someone, you are dealing with an individual.

I take the same general approach to my interviews. Obviously, people have different positions in society, different families, and different backgrounds. You take those things into account, but you are still dealing with an individual who happens to have that background.

Mazur: It is a slightly different mentality. My favourite clients are probably from China, India, Canada, the United States, and other English-speaking countries. There are definitely differences in mentality, but working with people from different backgrounds gives me much more ability to deal with everyone.

In my experience, Chinese clients can be very strict in a good way. They want everything documented.

They want your statements, your explanations, and the agreements to be clear. Even when they sign a contract, they may want to take a picture with you. When they come for a consultation, some bring chocolates or small gifts. If they have travelled through Chișinău or Doha, for example, they may bring a bottle of wine or another small gift. In my experience, some bring gifts for people they know in Ukraine or other countries.

With some Indian clients, the dynamic can be different. They may be very focused on the result and prefer to pay after seeing the result.

Jacobsen: Pragmatic.

Mazur: Yes. In my experience, some clients from India may initially have lower trust. There are many scams and fraudulent schemes in different places, so people can become cautious about trusting lawyers or people in another country.

Jacobsen: You could describe that as a relatively low-trust environment in some contexts.

Mazur: Low trust, yes. You need to show them why they can trust you. Some of my Chinese clients trust me very quickly, from the first meeting. Some Indian clients are more cautious at first.

Clients from Canada, the United States, and the United Kingdom may also be willing to trust you, but first they want to discuss everything. Then the trust develops.

Jacobsen: It is a more diplomatic approach.

Mazur: Yes.

But it can also be difficult because of language levels. With some Chinese and Indian clients, I need to use simple English. I cannot always use C1- or C2-level words. I need to use language they can easily understand.

Meeting someone like you is good exercise for my brain because sometimes you use a word and I have to guess what it means. From the context, I can usually understand it. That helps me improve my English.

But when we prepare contracts or begin a legal process, I contact my translators to help make sure everything is discussed correctly.

I don’t want misunderstandings. Sometimes someone can misunderstand what is being said, or a service may not be described exactly as the client intended.

Jacobsen: A lot of thoughts come to mind from that last response. Most social mistakes are accidental. It is relatively rare to come across someone who intentionally says something specifically to offend or harm another person’s sensibilities.

The second point concerns applying a universal standard while treating people as individuals. I tend to take a scientific view of the world and of human beings. I do not subscribe to supernatural explanations.

The current scientific evidence suggests that Homo sapiens emerged roughly 300,000 years ago. If you then consider the much more recent development of large-scale civilizations and distinct cultural traditions, it puts that in perspective. Everyone has language, for example.

Languages can differ enormously, though they share structural properties and recurring principles. I think something similar applies to human psychology.

When you interact with people, culture and language can create substantial differences, but beneath those differences there is also a broadly shared human psychology. Real individual and cultural differences exist, but they operate within that common human framework.

I do not think the fundamental differences between people are as large as the apparent differences. You can take a scientific and objective view of these things and, in some ways, arrive at a more humane treatment of people as individuals.

Another point concerns high-trust and low-trust societies. Neuroeconomist Paul J. Zak has conducted influential research on oxytocin and its possible relationship to trust and social behaviour. Oxytocin has well-established physiological roles, including in childbirth and lactation, and has also been studied extensively in relation to social attachment and behaviour. Research once suggested a relatively straightforward relationship between oxytocin and interpersonal trust, although subsequent replication studies and reviews have shown that this relationship is more complex and less robust than early findings suggested.

From an economic perspective, research also connects higher levels of generalized social trust with stronger economic performance. High-trust societies tend to benefit from economic cooperation, while low-trust environments can create higher transaction costs and weaker investment. In that sense, social trust can tell you something about a society’s economic health and development.

Mazur: Trust is also one of the main parts of our job. If you do not trust your lawyer, you cannot really work together.

Even if you sign a contract and they pay you for your work, without trust from the beginning, it becomes very difficult to succeed in the case.

It also affects the lawyer’s mindset. If you are working in a nervous environment where the client does not believe in you, it is difficult to believe that the case can become something successful or even something important for your career. Otherwise, you are simply taking money to assist.

Because of this, one of the main points is choosing whom you work with. It is not only the person choosing the lawyer. The lawyer also chooses the client.

Some cases I have won have seemed almost impossible at the beginning. Sometimes a person comes into your office wanting to pay for a case, but they tell you a lot about their experiences with other lawyers. They may say, “I started this case with another lawyer. He could not do anything. I do not know what to do. I cannot trust anyone. Maybe we can divide the payments into several parts.”

You can see in their eyes that they want to trust you. They are beginning to believe that you can help them. If they believe in you and cooperate, the work usually goes much better.

That is how it works for me. I’m not sure whether lawyers in other fields work the same way. Different lawyers probably choose their clients differently, but this is one of my main principles.

If you trust me, we will try to win, and I will do everything professionally that I can to achieve a good result. But if we begin the process and you are already saying, “I do not believe in this. You can try, but I do not believe you can do it, and you will return my money if it does not work,” then I will say, “We should not sign a contract. You can find another lawyer.”

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Liza.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Clergy Sexual Abuse in Ukraine, 2026: Cases and Survivor Harm

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/09

Clergy Sexual Abuse in Ukraine, 2026: Cases and Survivor Harm

Photo by Bogdan Kojic on Unsplash

Clergy sexual abuse in Ukraine raises concerns about survivor trauma, reporting barriers, and institutional accountability. Cases in Dnipro and Lviv resulted in reported convictions, while proceedings in Zhytomyr and Ternopil involve allegations without verified verdicts. The article examines psychological, interpersonal, and spiritual harm while distinguishing established convictions from unproven accusations.

Clergy-perpetrated abuse is an underreported problem across Christian denominations. Fear of reprisals from the community and attacks from religious authorities can create an environment of fear and self-loathing.

It can obstruct justice efforts among laity who genuinely care, clergy working against abuse, and external parties working to report on it.

The consequences of clergy-perpetrated abuse on survivors are multiple: firstly, they can experience psychological distress, including PTSD, depression, anxiety, shame, self-harm and suicidality. Secondly, they can experience interpersonal difficulties, including mistrust, isolation and impaired intimacy.

Thirdly, they can undergo spiritual distress, including religious betrayal and disrupted meaning or faith. Altogether, these point to failures of human conduct and institutional accountability. My interpretation is that these institutions make unsubstantiated claims about divine revelation and exhibit these failures as examples of common human institutional problems.

I am based in Ukraine now. Eastern Orthodoxy predominates nationally. Greek Catholicism is prominent in western Ukraine. Back in my home country of Canada, we find these denominations too. These cases happen. Documented cases have been reported recently in Ukraine.

In Dnipro, a former Orthodox priest had a 10-year sentence upheld. On June 2nd, 2026, Ukraine’s Prosecutor General’s Office reported that the Supreme Court had upheld a former Ukrainian Orthodox Church priest’s sentence for sexually abusing his two young daughters and producing child sexual abuse material involving one of them. The original arrest was in 2023.

Prosecutors identified his affiliation as UOC–Moscow Patriarchate.

In Lviv, Western Ukraine, a former deacon was sentenced to 15 years. Prosecutors announced the conviction on July 14th, 2026. The deacon was sentenced for rape and sexual abuse of his daughter, and the production and possession of child sexual abuse material.

Lviv’s Shevchenkivskyi District Court imposed the sentence. According to Tvoe Misto, he was a former protodeacon of an Orthodox Church of Ukraine monastery in Rivne region. I have not verified an appeal outcome.

In Zhytomyr region, a parish priest was prosecuted over alleged abuse of a minor. On August 23rd, 2024, public broadcaster Suspilne reported it. Prosecutors submitted an indictment against a UOC–Moscow Patriarchate parish rector. Prosecutors alleged that he sexually abused a girl in October 2023. The charge was under Article 156(1).

In Ternopil, in July 2026, a former pastor was suspected of sexually assaulting two children. Police and prosecutors reported an alleged incident on July 9th, 2026. The alleged incident involved two girls aged 10 and 12. I have not verified subsequent verdicts in the Zhytomyr or Ternopil cases.

Under common legal principles, the accused in those cases are presumed innocent.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

George Mihaita on Humanitarian Work, Language, and Ukrainian Resilience

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/09

George Mihaita is a Romanian English teacher, authorized translator, humanitarian volunteer, and citizen journalist active in Ukraine. An educator with more than a decade of teaching experience, he has taught Romanian and Ukrainian students, including Ukrainian civilians and military personnel. His volunteer activities include language education, humanitarian assistance, accessibility projects, and documenting the effects of Russian attacks. Mihaita also advocates for Ukrainian sovereignty and promotes greater cultural and linguistic exchange between Romania and Ukraine.

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen speaks with George Mihaita about humanitarian volunteering, language education, and life in wartime Ukraine. Mihaita discusses building an accessibility path, documenting attack sites, encounters with police, and teaching English and Romanian to Ukrainians. He reflects on language identity, Russian-speaking Ukrainians, stigma facing men abroad, Romanian attitudes toward Russia, and the growing importance of English. He also considers future cultural ties between Romania and Ukraine during postwar reconstruction.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: How do you feel now that you have put so much time and volunteer work into teaching English and doing humanitarian work?

George Mihaita: Yes, something I did not tell you about, because it is a rather recent project, is that I am building a path in the Ivankiv area. It is about 80 to 85 kilometres north of Kyiv. There is a small village where a woman who uses a wheelchair lives at the end of a roughly 50-metre dirt path. She cannot get out of her own backyard when it rains.

I am building the path using my own funds, with the exception of 10,000 hryvnias that were donated to me by Ukrainians I teach. So, thank you, Dmytro, and his wife, Nadiia; Nadiia means “hope.”

Now, how do I answer your question? It is hard to say. I would never… Sometimes, I have to be honest, we have a rough night. I try to make my way to the sites that have been attacked, either to lend a hand or simply to take pictures and show this dramatic reality that my own people back home refuse to acknowledge. I want to shove it down their throats without any lubricant whatsoever.

Sometimes I cannot find the place. Sometimes people become suspicious simply because I ask where it is, and I am sure you can empathize with this. Sometimes I get picked up by the police because people think I am taking too many pictures.

Jacobsen: Yes, I have been accused of being a Ukrainian spy, a Russian spy, an American spy, and a Chinese spy, and more!

Mihaita: You put yourself out there much more, so it is bound to happen.

Jacobsen: Apparently.

Mihaita: In my case, there was only an insinuation that I might be a Romanian spy, which I found quite flattering because, I guess, if I were, we would be on the same side. Nobody ever thought I was Russian because, I guess, my Russian is far too bad for me to be a viable Russian spy.

I have also been accused of being a war tourist. Unfortunately, I understand that as well. I would not want somebody taking pictures of my house if it had just been bombed.

Jacobsen: Correct.

Mihaita: And I understand it. I have spent dozens of hours in police custody while they were simply looking through my pictures. At the end, they would say, “Thank you for your service. Keep up the good work,” and that was it.

Jacobsen: What do Ukrainians say when you have finished teaching them English and they have genuinely learned something? It is something they care about. They want to learn English.

Mihaita: Well, usually they say, “Thank you, George, for your time, and thank you for your lesson.”

Jacobsen: What is the demographic of the people who come to you?

Mihaita: There is something to be said about this. I do not know exactly why, but the vast majority of Ukrainians who are looking to learn either English or Romanian from me are women.

Jacobsen: Is part of that because women have the ability to leave the country?

Mihaita: Well, first, there is that. Second, there are, of course, Ukrainian men as well. But I think there is a stigma attached to being a Ukrainian man in another country, and that prevents some of them from engaging too much.

But I always make sure that, in my class, no Ukrainian ever feels judged. And I say “no Ukrainian” because, over time, a woman from Moldova also joined us. She actively supports Ukraine, so she joined the class as well.

Nobody ever… This has to do with my professionalism. I always make sure that I listen and do not judge, with the obvious exception that there are some limits. Those limits are obvious and implicit in my position in all of this. So there is no false equivalence between Russian casualties and Ukrainian casualties.

There is no question, let us say, and sometimes this is brought up, of what kind of justice Russian soldiers who have been mobilized deserve. In my view, they face the consequences of combat for participating in the invasion of Ukraine. Or, to put it more bluntly, the consequence of being killed in combat while invading another country.

That is about as politely as I can put it.

Again, some of my students speak Russian. This repeatedly comes up as a topic because some have made the effort to switch to Ukrainian as their main language. Others still use Russian at home, whether they are now living in Spain, Finland, or Romania. They are spread all over the world, but for some of them Russian remains their native or primary home language. Some of the other students frown upon this.

This is not, and has never been, my subject. I always say that my job is to support Ukraine. As long as we are clear about that, I am not going to judge a family that, for various reasons, has not had the time, opportunity, or resources to switch completely to Ukrainian. Of course, I think it would be better if they did, but it is not my place to judge them, so we avoid turning it into a point of conflict.

Jacobsen: Yes.

Mihaita: I try to impart that outlook to the others. Of course, credit should go to those who have made the effort to speak Ukrainian, but it is not my place, or to some extent their place, to judge the others.

Some men are in Ukraine fighting. Some men are in Bucharest. Their individual circumstances and choices differ. Again, this is not something I am in a position to judge, and I do not want it to become part of the subject. But it does come up repeatedly.

Of course, during an English class, there will be subjects such as travel. Immediately, we have an issue. Some people can travel, while others cannot. I think one reason some Ukrainian men avoid these classes is that they know sensitive subjects like this are likely to come up.

I am proud to say that two men do attend my Romanian classes, and I feel that this can be even more sensitive.

Mihaita: Because of the large number of Putinists, I simply call them baboons.

Jacobsen: Baboons?

Mihaita: Putinist baboons that we have in Romania. That is another subject I do not want to waste time on, and I make my position very clear. I am here to capture the truth and shove it down their throats.

But I also tell my students, “You should protect yourselves,” because, you know, people in Berlin in the 1930s also felt safe until suddenly they did not. Unfortunately, we also have a very popular political movement in Romania that I regard as pro-Russian.

But, yes, the demographic of my students is mostly middle-aged Ukrainian women. Most of them have children, and many would also like their children to learn English with me. We are still looking into the possibility of creating a separate group for the children.

Jacobsen: Do you think English will eventually become the second most widely spoken language in Ukraine?

Mihaita: Well, as you can see, there is a long way to go. Unfortunately, I think part of the problem comes from the isolation of the post-Soviet environment.

But I think that, if all things go well, yes. Russian is still a strong competitor, of course. If English ever does become the second most widely spoken language, I will be proud to call even one percent of that my work.

Jacobsen: Are there many Romanians who want to learn English or Ukrainian?

Mihaita: There is consistently a healthy number of Romanians who want to learn English, and many people in Romania speak English to some degree.

Ukrainian, on the other hand, no. I have only met Romanians who wanted to learn Ukrainian partly as a political statement because they support Ukraine.

Jacobsen: Other than that, no?

Mihaita: No. They want to learn it because they support Ukraine, because they want to understand the culture better, and because they understand that language is a vessel for cultural identity and, to some extent, personal identity.

You cannot fully understand Shevchenko, Taras Shevchenko, unless you read him in Ukrainian, just as you cannot fully understand Shakespeare if you read him only in Romanian.

But that is pretty much the extent of it for now. I am confident that this will change and that the numbers will grow as we move from active war into rebuilding. Inevitably, as neighbouring countries, Romania and Ukraine will be doing more together.

I recently met a Romanian man who moved here to work in agriculture, so some people are already looking into opportunities like that. I do not think there will be a flood of people coming until there is some sort of end to the war, of course, because nobody wants to get bombed.

I have also met a few Romanian volunteers who take aid to eastern Ukraine. But they are really focused on their work, not so much on learning the language and culture.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, George.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Dimitri Vasylev on Ukraine’s War, Democratic Resilience, Political Unity, and National Security

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/09

Dimitri Vasylev is a Ukrainian political consultant, analyst, public communications specialist, and musician. He leads the Research Agency for Development and Analysis (RADA), working across political analysis, governance, development, and public communication. Born in Kyiv during the Soviet period, Vasylev served in the Soviet Army before developing a stronger Ukrainian identity. Since Russia’s full-scale invasion, he has combined volunteer activity with music, producing three albums intended to strengthen Ukrainian culture, resilience, and national identity.

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Dimitri Vasylev discuss wartime volunteering, casualty-notification protocols, military-family support, strategic communications, and Ukraine’s democratic resilience. Vasylev argues that Russia’s invasion challenges the wider democratic order and that European states must recover the capacity to defend freedom militarily. He also assesses Ukraine’s internal political tensions, criticizing excessive presidential power, opposing wartime elections, supporting a unity government, and identifying national cohesion as the country’s most urgent sociocultural priority during war.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: What did your volunteer experience during the war teach you?

Dimitri Vasylev: At the beginning of the full-scale war, I was volunteering for a territorial community and a military group. Then I helped my friend at one of the military commissariats in Kyiv develop a casualty-notification protocol with former Deputy Minister of Defence Hanna Maliar. At the time, she was already working with the General Staff and was able to explain to the Commander-in-Chief the importance of such a protocol.

The protocol did not exist there in that form at the time. So the Commander-in-Chief tasked us with developing the protocol, and we worked closely with people from the Ministry of Defence and the General Staff. I had good friends in the community of American veterans who continued to live in Kyiv. One of them was a former U.S. military attaché to Ukraine, and he helped a lot by providing the American equivalent of the protocol.

In the end, Commander-in-Chief Oleksandr Syrskyi developed and signed the protocol in December 2024. As soon as it was signed, we needed to implement it. So we worked hard to develop a perspective on how to implement it in the best way.

We spoke with the Ministry of Defence, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, several international organizations, and key diplomatic missions about how we could develop a perspective for implementing the protocol. A lot of work was done.

In parallel, I also helped provide civilian support for many of the social needs of the Ukrainian Navy’s River Flotilla. That’s a great job we’ve done together with them, with their civil-military cooperation unit and their commander. We’ve done a lot to make sure it works and that many soldiers from the River Flotilla receive good social support, including support for their families.

So that’s something I’ve done and continue to do.

On the information front, I worked with a group that supported our military, the Ministry of Defence, and especially the General Staff in communicating the most important messages to the public through the media. That was also part of my volunteer work with the General Staff.

Jacobsen: What would you consider, for those who are international, East or West, and who are non-Ukrainian, some misconceptions about the political context of Ukraine during the war? What truths dispel the myths they may have about that context?

Vasylev: When we’re talking about a democratic society, it’s most important to think about the democratic part of this planet, the countries and unions like the European Union or the Euro-Atlantic alliance, NATO.

Those governments and nations forgot they had experience fighting for their freedom. For about 80 years, they learned that diplomatic means, tools, and instruments worked much better than military tools. So they learned how to communicate, negotiate, and de-escalate through diplomacy and dialogue.

Of course, they tried hard to use those instruments for de-escalation. And that’s the moment when everybody understood that sometimes you have to be ready to understand that your opponents are not ready to talk.

They want to fight. If you’re not ready to fight, you can lose all those achievements of your previous generations based on which you have this freedom, democracy, and economic development. So you have to be ready to fight for this. That’s first.

I think now, little by little, some nations and some governments understand it. Donald Trump, who is not my hero, actually helped many Ukrainians and many European governments and leaders understand much more quickly that you had better be ready to fight.

And most of them didn’t realize that Ukraine was fighting not only for itself, but that Russia began the war not only against Ukraine, but against the democratic idea more broadly.

If you remember December 17, 2021, before the full-scale invasion, Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov said something many people didn’t fully appreciate at the time. He said NATO should remove its military infrastructure and return to its 1997 positions.

From my perspective, it was a declaration of confrontation with European countries, based on the idea that NATO’s military posture should be rolled back to the situation that existed in 1997.

Then, about two months later, the full-scale invasion began. Russia had a clear idea that first they wanted to occupy Ukraine and then go further.

Now, a lot of military intelligence services and governments in Europe understand that Russia will not necessarily stop if it occupies Ukraine. It could go further. But at that time, they didn’t understand it.

Everybody has to be crystal clear: Ukraine fights not only for Ukraine. Ukraine fights for democracy and the democratic world. The democratic world has to be united if it wants to win and fight for a better future because the autocratic world has much greater potential right now to fight with no rules, cynically, without worrying about killing people.

The democratic world has to understand that it must be strict, strong, and ready to fight hard.

Jacobsen: What are your political expectations for Ukraine toward the end of Q3 and into Q4?

Vasylev: I think the Ukrainian president will try to preserve the system as it is. But the controversies surrounding anti-corruption institutions and corruption scandals may lead him to consider what he can do as the nation’s leader during the war to keep the country united and avoid losing the war because we are divided.

I hope it brings him to the clear idea that he has to give up some of his power because, in my view, the concentration of power he has is autocratic rather than democratic.

We don’t need to go to elections now. I don’t think it’s a good idea. I don’t see a feasible way to conduct elections with legitimate results and ensure everyone can vote during the war.

At the first stage, we can form a new coalition in parliament, which could form a new government of Ukrainian unity. The president has his job on the military and foreign-policy fronts, so let him do it. But let him give up some of his power over those things that he is not able to manage successfully now, because, in my view, he has not been successful enough in domestic and social policy.

Jacobsen: So this is actually leaning into my next question, which has to do with Mr. Fedorov’s recent statements.

Vasylev: I’m not sure Mr. Fedorov is the best solution for us. He’s still too young, and he’s making a lot of mistakes.

Jacobsen: How would you describe the internal temperature, so to speak, or atmosphere more descriptively?

Vasylev: We can go on with the temperature metaphor. It’s a temperature that could lead to serious illness and perhaps to the need for a quick, unplanned operation. It’s okay now, but we’re on the edge.

Jacobsen: What do Ukrainians see as their most substantial sociocultural concern right now?

Vasylev: Just to be united. That’s the main thing.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Dimitri.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Mike Wilson and Svitlana Didkivska on Ukrainian Cowboy Culture, Kyiv Western Saloon, and the Cowboy Fair

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/08

Mike Wilson is a United States Marine Corps veteran, entrepreneur, founder and president of the Association of Ukrainian Cowboys, and owner of Kyiv Western Saloon. Svitlana Didkivska is the association’s vice president and saloon director. Together, they promote Western culture in Ukraine through community events, equestrian activities, dancing, family entertainment, and planned veteran support. Their work connects American cowboy traditions with Ukrainian Cossack, horse, frontier, music, and community traditions in contemporary Kyiv amid wartime Ukraine. Cowboy Fair 2026 hosted by Association of Ukrainian Cowboys.

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen speaks with Mike Wilson and Svitlana Didkivska about the Association of Ukrainian Cowboys and the appeal of Western culture in Ukraine. They explore parallels between cowboy and Cossack traditions, equestrian life, frontier ideals, clothing, dance, gender roles, family values, and community. Wilson and Didkivska also discuss Kyiv Western Saloon, veteran reintegration, and their September 2026 Cowboy Fair featuring horses, food, vendors, music, and line dancing at the Kyiv Hippodrome.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: So, what is the purpose of the association? Why is it important to bring this culture to Ukraine? Moreover, what has been the response from Ukrainians to cowboy culture in Ukraine?

Mike Wilson: About the Association of Ukrainian Cowboys, the main thing is to introduce the culture of the Old West. However, Ukraine parallels that a little bit. They have a cattle culture, they have an equestrian culture here, and they have a settlement culture too.

When you go west and look at all the different types of homes and the way that people have developed their lives over thousands of years, you can see that. However, the romance of the West never dies, and everybody gravitates to it. You see it in movies, and you see it in apparel.

Even now, you are seeing so many more cowboy boots being worn by girls. They are very stylish. They love that feel and the way it looks.

Moreover, now we are beginning to see a few more cowboy hats being introduced out there. A lot of that comes from what Svitlana and I have already done in promoting the association.

Svitlana Didkivska: I want to add, from my perspective, that I understand I had this certain type of spirit in me many years ago. Moreover, the most interesting thing is that when you are wearing a hat, you feel different. I love to look at myself in a mirror, in a hat and boots, and it looks amazing. I even feel different. Moreover, as Mike said, we have a lot of things in common with this.

Wilson: Cross-cultural. Yes. Mountains, music. Even when we started to look at the videos, just the music, cowboy music, I was thinking, “It looks like the Carpathians.” The Carpathians, with these cheesemakers there. It is very, very similar.

Moreover, as far as the apparel goes, it changes your whole persona. Internally, you actually feel it when you put on the hat and the boots. Moreover, you do not have to be a wrangler, someone out there working cattle, to have that feeling and have that emotion.

The cowboy spirit is very unique because it is about hard work. It is about ruggedness.

For me, it is about a lifestyle of God, country, and family. It is very nuclear-family-oriented, with Judeo-Christian-type values. Moreover, Ukraine has a deeply rooted Christian tradition.

That Christian tradition goes back more than a thousand years. Kyivan Rus’ officially adopted Christianity under Volodymyr the Great in 988. Who brought Christianity here?

Volodymyr the Great.

Didkivska: But Volodymyr began building churches in Kyiv.

Wilson: He promoted Christianity throughout Kyivan Rus’, and that helped establish Christian values here.

However, we are talking about more than 1,000 years ago, too. Those values became deeply rooted. Volodymyr promoted Christianity throughout his realm.

His influence was not limited to Kyiv. The Christianization of Kyivan Rus’ had a significant influence across the region and on the subsequent development of Eastern Europe.

That Christian civilization in Kyivan Rus’ really took root here. Before that, there were various pagan religious traditions.

Jacobsen: And paganism, when I talk to evangelical theologians in my hometown in Canada, historically and theologically, the simplest description from a Christian perspective is often the pre-Christian religious traditions. However, “pagan” is not simply a synonym for “non-Christian.”

Wilson: People can also identify with modern Pagan traditions today. So it has nothing to do with sexual orientation or whether someone lives a good or bad life. Someone may not share the moral convictions taught within Christian traditions.

Jacobsen: If they do share some of them, they may arrive at those convictions through a different ethical framework.

Wilson: However, that romance is so attractive. I have thought about it over the years.

Jacobsen: Is it a romance with the idea of a never-ending frontier?

Wilson: It is hard to say. Because the frontier is always moving outward, right?

Jacobsen: Now space is the final frontier. You have gone so far west that you have gone east.

Wilson: Right, yeah.

Jacobsen: So we are always exploring new ideas, new lives, something new, right? That is part of what “frontier” means.

Wilson: And yeah, the West was carved into that mould. However, it is not only the frontier, because those geographic frontiers have already been explored. What lasts is the culture.

Ukrainians are embracing it. They are loving it. The praise and compliments that we get just walking down the street, or wherever we are, are remarkable. Wherever we go, we are always receiving compliments. People are always taking videos of us from a distance.

It is attractive. However, why is it attractive? I went through this question a few years ago when I was putting this together.

For me, it has to do with ideas about masculinity and femininity. What is the traditional cowboy ideal of a man? He is hardworking, right?

He uses his hands. He builds infrastructure. He builds buildings. Traditionally, that image emphasizes physical strength and manual work.

This has nothing to do with a misogynistic attitude or anything like that. The way I see it, men and women can bring different strengths. One is not better than the other.

Jacobsen: So you are speaking about complementarian theology around gender?

Wilson: Correct. They are complementary, and they need each other. So there is something about that traditional masculinity. When you put on a cowboy hat and cowboy boots, and you wear your Wrangler jeans, women start…

Jacobsen: I have my cowboy muck boots on and Wrangler jeans on now. This comes from the workwear of a farmer. This shirt is sun-protective, and it is good for a cold night. This is from when I used to muck stalls in the mornings, right? When it is super cold out.

Wilson: It has an appeal because it speaks of responsibility. It speaks of toughness. It speaks of hard work. It says, “I take care of business.” Moreover, some women gravitate toward that.

They adore that because they love masculinity. In Ukraine especially, from what I have seen, traditional ideas about masculinity and femininity remain strong. Of course, there are feminists here, and Ukraine does have an organized feminist and women’s-rights movement, but not every Ukrainian woman identifies with feminism in the same way.

Jacobsen: Or if they do identify with feminism, they may interpret it in a particular way. For instance, on March 8, International Women’s Day, one impression I have gotten from some young women here and elsewhere is that they treat it partly as a celebration of women. At the same time, International Women’s Day has deep historical connections to women’s rights movements. Ukraine also has initiatives such as She Drives, which expands employment opportunities for women in transportation.

So you can celebrate women while also supporting women’s rights movements or feminist movements. From what some Ukrainian women have told me, one tension can be between pursuing greater individual opportunity and retaining a sense of cultural identity. It is the idea of, “We want self-actualization, but we do not necessarily want to lose our cultural identity in the process.” They used March 8 to celebrate women’s rights and their aesthetic and sensibilities around Ukrainian femininity.

Wilson: And many of the women I meet in Ukraine are very feminine. Yes, they are strong. They take care of their families. Many cook, care for their children, work, and do all these things.

Jacobsen: However, remember one thing. There is a joke that the one thing men are afraid of is not the front line or the war, but an angry Slavic woman. That is a joke I have repeated to Ukrainians a few times, and they usually laugh.

Wilson: Some men even joke that they find more peace on the front line than at home. As a masculine man, dressed this way, and as a family man, one thing that can make a woman feel amazing is knowing that I am attracted to her, right? Moreover, when she puts on the hat and the cowboy boots, she gets to feel sensual and sexy.

She looks at herself, and she knows that people are noticing her. For anybody’s ego, that can be a massage. Moreover, that masculinity can make a woman feel safe and secure. Then she can feel feminine and sexy. When you put on those short shorts, that cowboy hat, and those cowboy boots, it is just a bombshell.

Very attractive. Thus, they complement each other. That is part of the cowboy spirit.

The guys are out there roping cattle, bringing them down, and branding calves. Women are riding horses too. They barrel race, perform in shows, and do stunts and things like that. They can have a different aesthetic on horseback than men do, but there is also attraction between men and women within that culture.

For me, cowboy culture emphasizes masculinity. The man is a man, and the woman is a woman. A lot of women enjoy being admired by men, and a lot of men enjoy looking at an attractive woman. So it feeds into each other. It is a kind of symbiotic relationship.

Moreover, that is why I think the culture is so attractive. You can see its appeal in many places around the world. We are in Ukraine, and from what we see, Ukrainians are absolutely eating it up.

Jacobsen: I think Western culture, not Midwestern culture, but the culture of the American West, maps quite evenly onto elements of traditional Ukrainian culture.

Wilson: Yes, exactly. Exactly.

Unfortunately, Ukraine has also had relatively high levels of divorce by some measures. Women initiate most divorces.

Jacobsen: It is also a nation under tremendous duress at the same time.

Wilson: Well, yes, there is tremendous duress now. The full-scale war obviously affects families and relationships. However, divorce was also an issue in Ukraine before the full-scale invasion. So there is a longer historical element to it as well. It is a cowboy society.

Didkivska: For centuries, we have known about the Cossacks. You have the men, the horses, the steppe, and the riding. You look at that and think, “Oh, there is almost a cowboy going by.”

So, for me, a person, not only a man, but a man or a woman with a horse, represents freedom. It is about a certain spirit. If you are riding a horse, you are going…

There are no roads. You can go in different directions, wherever you want. So, yeah, it is about the frontier. It is about exploring whatever you want.

Jacobsen: I go back to my phrase, the never-ending frontier. It is not just physical space, but the idea of exploration.

Wilson: It is always in us to explore. It is always in us to seek out a new frontier. So, yeah, back to the association. It has three main aspects. One is bringing together a community of people who have that desire to present this culture and bring it to other people.

Didkivska: You said before that there are a lot of things in common between cowboy culture and Ukrainian culture. We all like to eat good food.

Jacobsen: Bread and meat and liquor.

Didkivska: Yes, yes, yes. That is one thing. Another is dancing. We adore dancing.

Wilson: There is a huge dance culture here. Sometimes it feels as though there is a dance studio on every corner in Kyiv.

Didkivska: Yeah, and some of our folk dances are extremely demanding. They are so difficult to dance.

Jacobsen: I have even seen dancers balancing things on their heads.

Didkivska: Yes, yes, yes. It is in our blood. That is why we love dancing. Moreover, our cowboy community brings dancing, too.

Wilson: Everybody jumps in and enjoys doing that. So, the association has many facets to it. The community is one, the welcoming community.

It also supports Kyiv Western Saloon, which, at this stage, is our ultimate goal: to open the saloon here in Kyiv.

Another part, of course, is supporting family entertainment and family enjoyment, but also supporting our military personnel as they come back from the front and return to civilian life. That is not an easy transition. I am military myself.

I have also designed Kyiv Western Saloon as a place where military veterans can regroup, reintegrate into civilian life, and learn a new trade.

Jacobsen: I have spoken with several veterans now, particularly those going through rehabilitation. One important thing I have heard from some of them is that they do not, underline do not, want to return to exactly what they were doing before.

They want to do something new. Their circumstances and abilities may have changed, and they have gone through a profound change in their lives by going to war. Moreover, thirdly, they want to build something new. They want to look forward, not back, because life is not the same, and for many of them it will never be the same.

Wilson: Especially for them. Especially for our military guys.

So, I have a lot of compassion for them. That is part of my goal, too: to minister to our veterans and give them opportunities within our community.

So, September 12. That is five weeks: five weeks and one day. It will be at the Kyiv Hippodrome, near Ipodrom Metro Station. It starts at 10 in the morning and goes until 10 at night. It is a 12-hour, one-day event.

We will have all kinds of equestrian events there. We are going to have some master classes. I am teaching some Western-style disciplines for horses and riders, such as barrel racing, and we will be doing some other demonstrations. It gives people an opportunity to try these things and also helps prepare us for next year’s fair.

We will have horseback riding and a mechanical bull. Of course, we will have food. We are going to have American-style food, including ribs, burgers, and pizza, as well as some traditional Ukrainian food.

It is also a marketplace, so we will have vendors there and an opportunity to buy cowboy gear, along with other vendors selling their products.

Didkivska: I will add that some vendors have told me, “We are preparing specifically for your fair.” Some of them have even made things according to the theme of the fair. So they are not preparing only their ordinary products, but things specifically for the fair.

Wilson: And then, of course, in the evening, starting at 6, we have two major bands performing. So we are going to have live performances and dancing.

We are also hoping to set a Ukrainian record for the largest number of people participating together in a line dance. So we are gathering everybody together. We aim for a thousand people or more and to get that national record into the Ukrainian record books.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Mike and Svitlana.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Paint by Numbers, Kitsch, and Digital Art Optimization

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/08

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner discuss the history, aesthetics, and technological evolution of paint by numbers. Rosner reflects on its 1950s craft boom, kitsch appeal, mid-century design, and modern custom kits generated from photographs. He explores color optimization, image segmentation, computational tradeoffs, and the limits of automated conversion, while explaining how blending, value adjustments, and manual corrections can transform numbered canvases into more conventional paintings with greater realism, nuance, and coherence.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: What are some of your newer thoughts or reflections on the idea of paint by numbers? Why is the phrase not “numbers by paint”?

Rick Rosner: Well, because you paint according to whatever number is in the space. “Numbers by paint” would mean taking a painting and then numbering the spaces, which would just fuck up the painting.

Paint by numbers became a huge craze in the 1950s. Before the internet and modern video games, people spent more of their leisure time on crafts and hobbies like these. A lot of the mass-produced craft stuff was pretty crude by today’s standards, although some of it is collectible now.

Cracker Jack prizes were also better when I was a kid, or at least they seemed better. Some older Cracker Jack prizes were actual little toys, including metal and plastic objects. Today, the prize is basically a sticker that can unlock games online. Cracker Jack still contains peanuts, though, so I was wrong about peanuts having disappeared from it.

Paint-by-numbers sets were part of that broader mid-century craft culture. There were also crushed-gravel mosaic kits. Craft Master, for instance, sold “Mosette” sets using crushed gravel. You would get a design divided into regions, apply the materials according to the pattern, and end up with a decorative picture.

Some of those old craft pieces and unused kits have become collectible because they are vintage, particularly examples associated with mid-century design. A lot of mid-century popular design drew on Atomic Age and Space Age imagery, with stylized geometric forms, boomerangs, starbursts, and other futuristic motifs. There was also plenty of American decorative art that borrowed stereotyped or exoticized East Asian imagery, including pagodas and junks.

The quality of the resulting craft art could be pretty low, although people obviously enjoyed making it. Paint-by-numbers kits were not exclusively for kids, either. The original 1950s craze was heavily marketed to adults as a way for ordinary people to experience painting. The kits came in different sizes and levels of difficulty and included numbered areas corresponding to particular paint colours.

You might paint a horse, a landscape, a famous landmark, or some other conventional subject. Unless you developed some additional painting skills, such as blending adjacent colours or altering the prescribed design, the finished result could have that unmistakable paint-by-numbers appearance.

Now, more than 70 years after the original craze, computers and digital image processing have enabled much more detailed paint-by-numbers designs. You can buy fairly large canvases with dozens of colours, and some companies offer the same or similar designs in 24-, 36-, or 48-colour versions. More colours allow finer tonal gradations and smoother transitions.

Digital tools also make it possible to turn photographs and complex images into numbered templates much more easily than before. Some companies market these as custom paint-by-numbers kits.

Because you can work with dozens of colours, larger canvases, and digitally generated templates, the finished paintings can look much more sophisticated than many of the simpler mass-market kits from decades ago.

They can still be kitschy, though. A lot of the imagery is still super kitschy.

When you let people who are not art connoisseurs pick their own art, a lot of them naturally gravitate toward kitsch. It is more immediately satisfying. If you go on a cruise ship, most of them have an art gallery where they sell overpriced artwork. My wife and I like to look at it in a slightly snotty way because so much of the art has every possible color in it. To an untrained eye, it seems more artistic if every color of the rainbow appears somewhere in the picture. It just seems brighter, more colorful, and more uplifting.

Take Thomas Kinkade, for example. He was famous for creating sentimental, highly commercialized paintings that many critics regard as kitsch. Even in his nighttime or snowy scenes, especially his paintings of old-fashioned villages, there are little flashes of every imaginable color. There may be one dominant color, but you still see nearly every other color somewhere in the painting.

With paint by numbers, you often end up with something kitschy, but modern kits can still produce a good-looking result. My wife did a paint-by-numbers painting of a little fluffy white dog, maybe a Bichon Frise or some kind of terrier mix, sticking its head out of a cluster of brightly colored flowers. I started messing with it by blending some of the transitions between colors so the boundaries would not look so abrupt.

She got annoyed with me, so I backed off, and she finished it exactly according to the instructions. It actually turned out really well. It is a nice piece of art. The quality of the finished painting is good enough to overcome much of the kitsch, making it satisfying without being too over-the-top.

Another thing you can do now is upload a photograph, or just about any image, to a company that makes custom paint-by-numbers kits. For roughly the same price as a standard kit, they will convert it into a numbered canvas and determine which paint colors to include.

That reminds me of the traveling salesman problem, which is a classic optimization problem in computer science. Imagine a traveling salesperson who has to visit a set of cities exactly once while minimizing the total travel distance. Finding the mathematically shortest route becomes computationally expensive as the number of cities increases because the number of possible routes grows factorially. In practice, you usually do not need the absolute optimal solution. A solution that is very close is often good enough.

Paint by numbers reminds me of that because generating one involves several optimization problems. When software analyzes an image, it has to decide how to divide it into a manageable number of color regions while preserving the appearance of the original. One optimization problem is determining the shapes and boundaries of those regions. Another is selecting a limited palette of paint colors that best approximates the original image. The goal is to produce a paint-by-numbers kit that, once completed, still looks recognizably like the photograph or artwork from which it was created.

It turns out that when you send them a photograph, the conversion process can make some interesting choices. I uploaded a photo of Carole and Isabella from Isabella’s graduation. I do not know how much human intervention is involved, or exactly what kind of optimization they use. Maybe the system has been designed to make human faces more visually legible.

The canvas they sent back gave Isabella noticeably red lips and gave Carol red lips too. Yet if you look at the original photograph, Carol’s lips are not especially red. They are fairly pale and close to the surrounding skin tone of her face.

That makes me wonder whether there is some additional processing involved, either in the algorithm or through human review. Maybe somebody looks at the result and thinks, “Let’s make the lips red so the face reads more clearly.” Or maybe it is simply an artifact of the color-selection algorithm. I do not know.

But when I compare this canvas, which is almost finished, with other paint-by-numbers canvases, it seems as though the source images or the conversions have been adjusted to make the subjects more visually legible. In some cases, they may simply start with images that already have very clear shapes, contrasts, and colors.

There are all sorts of optimization problems involved, which I find interesting. Some of this would have been much more difficult or expensive in the past because the computational tools were less capable and less accessible. There may also have been improvements in printing and manufacturing that make it inexpensive to produce individualized numbered canvases.

The fact that you can now send almost any photograph to a company and get back a reasonably convincing custom paint-by-numbers kit is indicative of where the technology is.

There is also a way to use these kits if you want the finished product to look more like a conventional painting. You start with a clear photograph and have it converted into a paint-by-numbers canvas. Then you do a first pass by following the numbered regions.

After that, you enlarge the original photograph on a computer and use it as a reference while correcting the painting. The paint-by-numbers conversion inevitably loses some detail and introduces errors in color matching because it reduces a continuous photographic image to a limited number of discrete regions and paint colors.

If the kit contains, say, 48 paint colors, the software has to approximate the much larger range of colors present in the original photograph. It may assign the same paint color to two regions that actually look quite different in the photograph. At that point, you can go back in and correct the colors yourself.

I have spent a lot of time around art classes as an art model, and I have known Lance Richlin for decades. You pick up various painting techniques along the way. You can use things like blending, softening edges, adjusting values, and modifying colors to turn the result into more of a conventional painting rather than something that still obviously looks like paint by numbers.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Lesia Synychenko on The Morphing, Ukrainian War Art, Memory, and Transformation

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/08

Lesia Synychenko is a Ukrainian artist, poet, and former journalist whose practice combines painting, graphic art, poetry, diary writing, and mixed media. In Morphing, begun in autumn 2021 and continued after Russia’s full-scale invasion in 2022, she explores transformation, fear, home, women, animals, memory, and war. Working with acrylic, ink, watercolor, collage, and layered techniques, she develops an intimate visual language in which dogs, birds, cats, fish, flowers, and domestic spaces become carriers of memory, vulnerability, attachment, and survival. Her work draws on Chernihiv, Ukrainian cultural inheritance, everyday observation, and the experience of living through war.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Lesia Synychenko discuss Morphing, a poetic mixed-media project that began before Russia’s full-scale invasion and deepened through Synychenko’s wartime experience in Chernihiv. She explains how image and text emerge together, often through recurring figures of women, animals, home, and landscape, and how those symbols acquired new meanings after the invasion. The conversation moves through artistic intuition, journalism, translation, Ukrainian cultural memory, animal fear, grief, and the psychological burden of war, showing how private imagery can become a form of testimony, cultural memory, and survival.

Lesia Synychenko: I want to present this project, Morphing. It is about transformation.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: This is one of the newer projects?

Synychenko: Yes. I started working on it in autumn 2021, before the full-scale invasion, and I continued it in 2022, when the invasion began. This project is very important to me. I can send you the concept.

Jacobsen: That would help get the description down.

Synychenko: I have presented this project in Lithuania, Finland, and Ukraine. All of these works also have English translations.

Jacobsen: Yes. It is poetry.

Synychenko: Yes. It is poetry and diary. There are works about fires and darkness. When I arrived in Chernihiv, I continued this project throughout 2022.

Jacobsen: So, 2022.

Synychenko: Yes. This work is from 2022. It is also about my dog, because I was in Chernihiv, and it was very scary. Planes flew over the city all the time, and there was bombing. My dog and I hugged each other all the time because it was very frightening. My dog helped me, and I helped my dog.

Jacobsen: [Reading from the art series pieces] “Your strength is in the cold, wet nose of your dog.”

Synychenko: Yes, because it is a very pretty, cold, wet nose. This is also about a victim.

Jacobsen: A victim of the war. “A live target is a temporary concept.” Wow.

Synychenko: This is very personal to me. It is also in a book from the Scottish PEN Centre. It was published in Ukraine, in Ukrainian and English. Right now, it is only available online. It is a diary by Ukrainian poets, artists, and other people, including me, with some of my poetry. And this is a postcard. These are also books with my works. This is Angel and the Keep. This is another project. These works are from autumn 2021. I felt very strange. I felt something bright, but I did not understand it. I was not thinking about war, but inside me there was a very strong, bright feeling.

Jacobsen: Artists are sensitive. People who are more mainstream can be sensitive too, but artists, in my experience, are especially sensitive. They process the world differently, and this is how they express it. You said you felt strange. You are using autumn colors, but then you introduce purple. There are elements here that suggest many things.

Synychenko: These are works for viewing and reading.

Jacobsen: For the painting? Or both?

Synychenko: Both, yes.

Jacobsen: What materials do you use? How do you make the paint? Do you make it yourself, or do you buy it? What colors do you use?

Synychenko: This is acrylic paint, and sometimes I use ink for small details. This is from my exhibition at the ICA Gallery, maybe only in Ukrainian. I do not know where it is in English.

Jacobsen: That refers to when they were made?

Synychenko: Yes. It was a solo exhibition. No, I do not remember exactly.

Jacobsen: What creature is this, the green-blue one?

Synychenko: These are strange animals. This is from 2021. It reflects how I was thinking.

Jacobsen: This… somehow, this tangle of feelings is called silence. I love that, because that is very true. Who has not had an experience of heartbreak, loss, or even a small victory, and then had a few minutes, or half a day, of quiet in a park? Sometimes the quietest moments are emotionally the loudest, because everything is happening inside. Do you have digital versions of these? Do you have pictures?

Synychenko: Online?

Jacobsen: Yes.

Synychenko: Yes, I will send them to you. I am also creating a poetry book with these illustrations. It is only in Ukrainian, but I have some poetry in English as well. If you want, I can send that too.

Jacobsen: If you would like, we could do a video together where you present them and I read the poetry in English. That could be fun, like a YouTube clip or something like that. I think that would be very good. Oh, is this the same creature?

Synychenko: Yes.

Jacobsen: What is this creature? Is it elongated?

Synychenko: Yes, I do not know. It is very strange, because after the war started I showed you some works, maybe some of these. No, this is new work, but this project feels very strange to me. It is really very new. Maybe it is a lion that loves to fly. It is about Venice, the lion that flies, like the birds. No, this idea goes back to 1990.

Jacobsen: 1990. Yes.

Synychenko: But after the war started, and even before, I did not know where this image came from. I think maybe it is about…

Jacobsen: Now, this is clearly a creature. A cat?

Synychenko: A cat, but not a simple cat.

Jacobsen: In dark times, hope is a small cat. Cats are very interesting.

Synychenko: Yes. I created this in 2021, not 2022. It is very strange, because I was not thinking about hope. But now, looking at it, I see that feeling reflected in it.

Jacobsen: Now, this is a very sophisticated piece, the layering. Very sophisticated.

Synychenko: I like this because I combine many techniques.

Jacobsen: It looks like a stamp. A square brush?

Synychenko: It is a technique. You cut into the paper, and—

Jacobsen: And then you press around it. Yes. So you did the same here, and then you added more over it.

Synychenko: Yes, and then it looks like another layer.

Jacobsen: And then you added small strokes here, for the home.

Synychenko: Yes, that is ink.

Jacobsen: I very much like this piece. “One does not know that you love him,” 2021. So this is unrequited love?

Synychenko: Yes.

Jacobsen: Everyone has been there.

Synychenko: Once or twice?

Jacobsen: Twice. Except maybe someone like 007.

Synychenko: Yes. But this is not only about that. This is also… I do not remember this book exactly. It was for [unclear]. At that time, it was not about me. But the next works are really about me. It is very strange.

Jacobsen: This one is: “For me, you are a warm dwelling.”

Synychenko: “Home.” I did not say it exactly like that. My translator lives in London.

Jacobsen: There is a London feeling here. The contrast creates that effect.

Synychenko: Because I translated it as “home,” but she said the word is a little different, more nuanced.

Jacobsen: Is this a princess on a horse? “Every woman is also a bird.” Every woman is also a bird at the same time. Birds fly away. They want to spread their wings.

Synychenko: Because every woman is also… I have other words. Every woman is also… a fish. I do not remember the word. Rusalka, a woman without legs, like a fish. A mermaid. So this is a bird. And this… maybe this one has no translation… “Forward forever.” It is very interesting.

Jacobsen: Because your images are not exactly straightforward.

Synychenko: “Forward and forever,” yes.

Jacobsen: “Forward and forever,” yes. I feel there is written text, and it is straightforward. But then, like graffiti, the letters are there, but they merge together. In your art, among the different styles, one thing I notice is the presence of animals. But they are not quite normally shaped. They merge with the environment. It is very interesting how that works.

Synychenko: Yes. When I work on this project, the painting and the text come together. I do not paint first and then think. It happens all at once.

Jacobsen: It is all in one, yes. In English, we call it “stream of consciousness.” The mind is like a river. So everything flows together.

Synychenko: Yes. When I began this in 2021, I spent a lot of time walking in Volodymyrskyi Park, near the trees, near the woods. For me, this was a very important experience. I walked without thinking about anything. And when I stopped thinking about everything, I began to feel something else, something more important. It was very interesting.

Jacobsen: Yes. And this, “conditional victim.” You translate it as “conditional victim.” What does that mean?

Synychenko: It is about a condition. It is not fixed. What is “conditional”? We do not know. This is a victim, or maybe not a victim. It is uncertain. Maybe I am the victim. Maybe he or she is. Because now, anyone can be—

Jacobsen: So, in a way, anyone in the war can be a victim.

Synychenko: Yes.

Jacobsen: Ultimately, there are no real winners in war. Economies suffer. People die.

Synychenko: Yes. And maybe… it is a very interesting idea. Because now I know I am not a victim. I do not feel like a victim.

Jacobsen: You do not feel like a victim.

Synychenko: Yes. But this can change. When I was in Chernihiv, I was very scared. I did not feel human. I felt like my dog, because animals experience fear in this way. It was not human fear. It was animal fear. Humans feel fear too, yes, but in that moment it was something more basic.

Jacobsen: Animal behavior does not pretend. Animals show fear very directly.

Synychenko: This is after Bucha. This is very—

Jacobsen: “Every woman is a doll for someone’s empty eyes.” Very interesting. The idea of empty eyes has appeared in other Ukrainian art as well, like that statue of the girl with hollow eyes, about a twenty-minute walk from the Mother Ukraine Monument. Have you seen that?

Synychenko: Yes.

Jacobsen: Near the main art gallery. So, “every woman is a doll for someone’s empty eyes.” That rings true. There are many similarities in how people express themselves across cultures. But here, I find people express themselves more through the eyes than where I am from. I have to be mindful of that. Nonverbal communication often happens through the eyes. So, every woman is a doll. This is a very beautiful composition. The idea is that women are, in some sense, made into objects.

Synychenko: And this is also some kind of animal, or feathers.

Jacobsen: Yes, yes, a bird.

Synychenko: And she… this may be a child.

Jacobsen: A child. So the bird protects. The bird flies. The bird can also become a doll.

Synychenko: This is about a lullaby. A lullaby. It is important because it is like a song you learn as a child, something from school, something you grow up with.

Jacobsen: It feels almost like a folk scene. But it is based on a song?

Synychenko: Yes. It is about something enduring, something that continues.

Jacobsen: “Even the waves sway the fish from your dreams.” Yes, yes. A small headdress and a flower, and the blue hair, like waves. I see more here, a black cat. Or a black-and-green cat.

Synychenko: Yes. You read it, and I understand.

Jacobsen: “The killer has the right to leave the remainder.” The cat is unwanted.

Synychenko: Yes, because many Russians killed pets, cats and dogs. These animals…

Jacobsen: I spoke with someone involved in animal rescue, a volunteer working on the ground. They told me there were at least several hundred thousand abandoned animals, dogs and cats, and that situations become very difficult. Dogs may attack cats. Sometimes pigs will eat human remains. So rescuers face strange and disturbing realities. When they encounter an animal, they have to consider what it has experienced. War reduces everything.

Synychenko: This is also from 2021. It is very strange because it reminds me of a children’s game. You may know it, when children run and say, “I am at home, I am at home.” When we went to the shelter, I remembered this.

Jacobsen: And this one is a garden, obviously.

Synychenko: This is a diptych, this and this.

Jacobsen: So, a circle around an arch. My thoughts… a diptych. What is a diptych?

Synychenko: A diptych means two works together.

Jacobsen: A diptych. A circle around a circle, my thoughts. Yes. I like the use of gold. I like this. I used to garden with retired women, so this feels familiar.

Synychenko: This is also a reflection of—

Jacobsen: The classic Ukrainian hairstyle, yes, around the ear and down to about the chest. “These sharp triangles of pain are with us forever.” I asked several veterans in rehabilitation whether those who experienced frontline trauma ever fully recover. Everyone I asked told me no.

Synychenko: No.

Jacobsen: With some qualification, they improve, but they do not fully recover. That seems realistic.

Synychenko: Yes. I think when you are on the front line, you are constantly acting. You cannot think. Only sometimes, if you have time, do you begin to think.

Jacobsen: I also think many of them are sleep-deprived. They get very little sleep. Tired, tired, tired. Without sleep, people—

Synychenko: Yes.

Jacobsen: “The first words I say in the morning in March are the names of my friends: Iro, Ino, Masha, Natasha, Sasha.”

Synychenko: Yes. This is about my friend who stayed in Chernihiv for her son. I was very worried about them. But one of my friends in Chernihiv died, my friend Artem.

Jacobsen: “Every woman is a bit like a fish without wings.”

Synychenko: Yes. When I started this project, at the beginning I was thinking about women, about how women exist in this very strange world.

Jacobsen: Especially when so many men have left, gone to fight, died, or are hiding. “Now my treehouse is closer to birds than to women.”

Synychenko: Yes, this is about people who—

Jacobsen: If I may, women are women, women are fish, women are dolls, women are birds.

Synychenko: Yes. In Lithuania, there is a very interesting idea, something like saints. Not God exactly, but symbolic figures. These birds, these women. But women are not cats.

Jacobsen: Yes, not cats.

Synychenko: Cats are different. There is a well-known phrase by a British writer: cats in ancient Egypt were worshipped as gods.

Jacobsen: Yes.

Synychenko: They have not forgotten.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Lesia.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Lesya Bablyak on Painting Memory, Trauma, and Resilience

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/07

Lesya Bablyak on Painting Memory, Trauma, and Resilience

Photo by Nataliia Kvitovska on Unsplash

Lesya Bablyak is a Ukrainian freelance artist born in Lviv in 1977 and now based in Kyiv. Trained at the Lviv Ivana Trusha College of Decorative and Applied Arts and the Lviv Academy of Arts, she works in painting and graphic art. Since Russia’s full-scale invasion, her blue-and-yellow wartime series has documented trauma, patriotism, displacement, memory, and civilian resilience, later giving way to restorative floral imagery rooted in home, survival, colour, witness, and public remembrance.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen interviews Lesya Bablyak, a Ukrainian artist whose work transformed after Russia’s full-scale invasion. Formerly focused on commercial landscapes, she shifted to emotionally charged depictions of people, war, and national identity. Her “Blue and Yellow Album” documents trauma and resilience, while later floral works reflect recovery. Bablyak discusses artistic communities in Lviv and Kyiv, international reception, and her decision to remain in Ukraine, emphasizing memory, witness, and cultural continuity.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: How did your work come to be featured at the event today?

Lesya Bablyak: I met the owners during my solo exhibition, Living Life, at the Museum of Ukrainian Diaspora in Kyiv. They invited me to present my art here in their office and to promote it among their clients.

Jacobsen: What do these pieces express today?

Bablyak: There are two different series, but they are closely connected. The first is called the Blue and Yellow Album. The works use the blue and yellow colours of the Ukrainian flag. This series includes more than 200 paintings, created over two and a half years after the beginning of Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine.

After our village near Kyiv was occupied, we moved to Lviv. There, I had the opportunity to create my own art space and began working in larger formats. I tried to paint every moment and every disaster I heard about through the news, social media, or neighbours from my village.

After two and a half years, I became mentally exhausted and needed rest. We returned to our house, which had been damaged by a Russian bomb, and began rebuilding it. In my yard, I started a new series based on flowers, trees, and everything around me. It became a way to escape the news.

By 2025, I understood that I wanted to stay in Ukraine. As a woman, I could have left, but I chose to remain. I want to be an artist here. I do not want to start my life again somewhere else. Since the beginning of the war, I have felt a deeper love for my country than ever before. When I return to Ukraine, to my home, I feel truly happy.

Jacobsen: It was a year of painting. Despite decades of change, the fundamentals of what defines Lviv’s and Kyiv’s art scenes have remained distinct. What are the core differences between them?

Bablyak: For me, Lviv is my hometown. I was born there and studied at the Lviv College of Art, and later at the Lviv National Academy of Arts. Most of my close friends are from my student years, and they are all artists. I have a strong community in Lviv, with friends working across different art forms.

However, after about 25 years living in Kyiv, I feel more connected to it. Kyiv is more open and accessible to people from different regions. Lviv used to feel more closed, and it was difficult for people from other parts of Ukraine to integrate into the local community.

Since the full-scale invasion, many people from eastern, southern, and northern Ukraine have moved to Lviv. This has changed the city. Now you see not only western Ukraine, but a broader mix of Ukrainian identities. I think this is very positive.

In terms of art, there have historically been different schools. Kyiv’s академія emphasized a more realist tradition, while the Lviv academy was more decorative and stylistically expressive. Today, these traditions are blending through exchanges, galleries, and artist mobility across the country.

Lviv has recently developed more art spaces, partly due to its relative safety during the war. Over the past three to four years, many new galleries have opened, offering more opportunities to exhibit work, including large-scale exhibitions.

In Kyiv, many national museums evacuated their collections for protection. As a result, these spaces are sometimes used for contemporary exhibitions. This also creates opportunities for artists to show their work and engage with others, although large exhibition spaces remain limited.

Jacobsen: Did the war, particularly the full-scale invasion, change your work habits and the visual themes of your art?

Bablyak: Yes, absolutely.

Jacobsen: How did your work habits and themes change?

Bablyak: Before the war, I painted landscapes and flowers. It was largely commercial work, and my main motivation was commercial as well.

When the war began, I shifted to painting people. For me, the war is about people, the victims and those responsible for it. I developed a strong sense of patriotism over the past several years, and I try to express that in my work. Not because it is popular, but because it is something I genuinely feel.

When I exhibit abroad, in France, the United States, and Great Britain, I pay close attention to how audiences respond to my work.

Jacobsen: What unusual interpretations or emotional responses have people shared with you that you did not expect?

Bablyak: Many of these responses come from international audiences. Some of my wartime paintings depict very difficult scenes. One painting was based on events in Mariupol, showing three young girls who did not understand what was happening. For them, it seemed like a game, it was the first day of the invasion. Their parents prepared food outside their building and took a photograph. Within two weeks, all three girls were killed.

One woman in the United States wanted to purchase this painting. I wrote to her and explained its meaning, and I told her she should consider carefully whether she wanted such an image in her home. She replied that she has three daughters and wants them to understand the reality of war.

In fact, Ukrainian collectors rarely buy this series; most buyers are from abroad. This sometimes surprises me. People often choose the most difficult works.

Jacobsen: What do you hope people take away from your art?

Bablyak: At the beginning of the war, when I was in Lviv, all galleries were closed. I continued painting, and eventually one gallery contacted me to organize an exhibition. At that time, many people from across Ukraine were in Lviv.

I noticed that visitors were looking for images connected to their own cities. Someone from Kharkiv wanted to see Kharkiv; someone from Mariupol asked if I had painted Mariupol. People wanted their experiences and their losses to be remembered, their cities, their families, that period of time.

This response was especially strong among older visitors. Younger people tended to move through the exhibition more quickly and engage less deeply.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Lesya.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Professor Amos N. Guiora Visits Zagreb for Human Rights and Legal Dialogue

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/08

Savez kršćana Hrvatske – Alliance of Christians of Croatia
Gjurkov put 32, 10000 Zagreb, Hrvatska

At the invitation of Bojan Jovanović, Secretary General of the Alliance of Christians of Croatia, together with the Governing Board and the Scientific-Theological Committee of the Alliance, one of the world’s leading experts in law, human rights, ethics, and the study of complicity and responsibility, Professor Amos N. Guiora, paid a two-day official visit to Zagreb.

Professor Guiora teaches law at the S.J. Quinney College of Law, University of Utah where he directs the Bystander Initiative, https://www.law.utah.edu/bystander-initiative/.

Professor Amos N. Guiora is a graduate of Kenyon College, holds a Juris Doctor from the Case Western Reserve University School of Law, and earned his doctorate from Leiden University. He is a Distinguished Fellow and Advisor at the University of Pittsburgh’s Center for International Conflict Resolution, a Non-Resident Fellow with the Program on Extremism at George Washington University, a Distinguished Fellow of the Chicago-Kent College of Law’s Holocaust and the Law Consortium, a member of the SESAME Advisory Board, a member of the Board of Directors of the Lauren McCluskey Foundation, and a member of the Advisory Group of the Claims Conference.

Throughout his distinguished academic and professional career, Professor Guiora has held numerous positions of responsibility in the fields of law, security, ethics, and institutional accountability.

For more than a decade, Professor Guiora has conducted extensive research on the phenomenon of bystanders and enablers, examining the responsibility of individuals and institutions whose actions—or failure to act—enable various forms of violence, discrimination, and human rights violations.

He is the author of several internationally acclaimed books, including The Crime of Complicity: The Bystander in the Holocaust, Armies of Enablers: Survivor Stories of Complicity and Betrayal in Sexual Assaults, and Complicity of Silence: Confronting Ecosystems of Child Sexual Abuse in Schools.

His most recent research focuses on the legal and moral responsibility of society in confronting the phenomenon of enabling crime.

During his stay in Zagreb, Professor Guiora held a series of working meetings with members of the Alliance of Christians of Croatia and had the opportunity to meet with Academician Sreten Vujović of Montenegro, a member of the Alliance’s Scientific-Theological Committee. Participants were also addressed through an expert presentation by Fr. Slaviša Lekić from Ukraine, likewise a member of the Committee. The discussions also included the distinguished professor of criminal psychology and investigative interviewing, Dr. Sandi Dizdarević of Bosnia and Herzegovina, and Belgrade attorney Aleksandar Olenik.

Special attention during the meetings was devoted to an interdisciplinary analysis of the challenges facing the Western Balkans. From an academic perspective, participants examined the processes of democratization, social cohesion, and the development of a culture of responsibility. From a legal perspective, they discussed the protection of human rights, the rule of law, and religious freedom. From the viewpoints of security, policing, and criminology, they analyzed contemporary security challenges, violence prevention, institutional accountability, and the importance of international cooperation in building a stable, secure, and just society.

Representatives of the Alliance of Christians of Croatia presented Professor Guiora with the organization’s achievements over the past period, including the organization of international conferences, scientific and professional gatherings, and the development of cooperation with distinguished individuals, academic institutions, religious communities, and civil society organizations.

Particular emphasis was placed on the successful cooperation with the Organization of Parents of Missing Babies from Vojvodina and the joint organization of a Congress dedicated to the protection of human rights, human dignity, and social responsibility.

Professor Guiora was also informed about the recent official visit of the Alliance’s Secretary General, Bojan Jovanović, to Istanbul, during which he held a number of important meetings with prominent public figures, social leaders, and media representatives. On that occasion, official correspondence was also established with the Ecumenical Patriarchate, further strengthening the Alliance’s international contacts and reaffirming its commitment to interreligious dialogue, international cooperation, and the promotion of the universal values of peace, mutual respect, and the protection of human rights.

The Alliance also presented its future projects, which are focused on strengthening the culture of dialogue, promoting human rights, protecting religious freedom, advancing scholarly research on contemporary social issues, expanding international cooperation, and continuously addressing current societal challenges through professional, academic, and public engagement.

Professor Guiora was also introduced to the Alliance’s activities, publications, and projects available through its official website.

Professor Amos N. Guiora’s visit represents a significant recognition of the work of the Alliance of Christians of Croatia and confirms that dedicated, professional, and responsible efforts are acknowledged at the international level. At a time of complex social challenges, the Alliance of Christians of Croatia remains firmly committed to promoting the universal values of human dignity, freedom, responsibility, mutual respect, scholarly dialogue, and the protection of fundamental human rights. We believe that bringing together leading international experts, the academic community, legal professionals, the security sector, and religious communities represents the most effective path toward building a society based on truth, justice, solidarity, and lasting peace.

Professor Guiora’s visit provides further encouragement for the Alliance of Christians of Croatia to continue developing international partnerships and contributing, through its work, to the creation of a more just and humane society for present and future generations.

For Alliance of Christians of Croatia

General Secretary

Bojan Jovanović

Image Credit: Bojan Jovanović.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Sofia Nordgren on Illegal Adoption, Identity, and the Search for Biological Family

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/08

Sofia Nordgren is an international speaker, author, moderator, transformation coach, entrepreneur, and survivor advocate with more than 30 years of professional experience in health, wellbeing, leadership, coaching, and personal development.

With a professional background in nursing, coaching, leadership, and personal development, she has spent more than three decades supporting people through trauma, grief, stress-related conditions, mental health challenges, identity issues, major life transitions, and personal growth. Her experience spans primary healthcare, mental health services, occupational health, elder care, health promotion, education, leadership, and coaching. She is trained as an ICC-certified coach and NLP Practitioner and has continued her professional development in areas including ACT, trauma, resilience, communication, attachment, belonging, identity, and psychological wellbeing.

Nordgren is the founder and CEO of Lifestyle+ in Sweden. Through speaking, coaching, writing, facilitation, moderation, and education, she supports individuals and organizations in navigating change, adversity, identity challenges, leadership development, wellbeing, and personal transformation.

She has moderated events at Stockholm City Hall, spoken internationally in Sweden, New York, and Belgrade, appeared in television programs, podcasts, interviews, documentaries, and media productions, and participated in conferences, leadership forums, and international discussions concerning health, identity, human rights, resilience, and social change. She has also performed stand-up comedy and uses storytelling, humour, and lived experience to communicate complex human issues to diverse audiences.

Nordgren is actively involved in advocacy, board-related work, consultation processes, and collaborative initiatives connected to adoptee rights, human rights, family reunification, inclusion, diversity, anti-racism, mental health, trauma awareness, and social justice.

Over the years, she has built extensive international networks and collaborates with adoptees, researchers, advocates, journalists, filmmakers, organizations, and professionals from multiple countries. She regularly participates in international conferences, webinars, interviews, and cross-border initiatives addressing adoption, identity, family tracing, human rights, and the long-term consequences of family separation.

She has contributed to international media discussions regarding adoption, identity, family reunification, illegal adoptions, falsified records, and adoptee rights. She has been interviewed for an international documentary project concerning illegal adoptions and adoption-related issues and has participated in interviews, podcasts, and discussions with journalists, filmmakers, and media professionals from different countries. Through these opportunities, she has shared both her personal experience and broader perspectives on adoption, identity, trauma, resilience, belonging, family reunification, and social justice.

Born in Bangladesh and adopted to Sweden as a young child, Nordgren has spent decades searching for her biological roots while confronting missing records, contradictory information, institutional silence, and unresolved questions surrounding her origins. Her search led her back to Bangladesh several times. In 2025, after decades of uncertainty, DNA testing confirmed with near certainty the identity of her biological mother and biological relatives in Bangladesh, providing long-awaited answers while also raising new questions about the circumstances surrounding her separation from her family.

Her personal journey—from orphanage records and missing documentation to DNA-confirmed family reunification—has positioned her as a unique voice in international conversations about adoption, identity, truth, family separation, and justice.

Through public speaking, writing, advocacy, media appearances, and testimony, Nordgren gives voice to adoptees affected by identity loss, family separation, irregular adoption practices, missing records, and the lifelong search for truth. Her work supports broader efforts for documentation, family reconnection, emotional healing, accountability, human rights, and justice for adoptees and biological families worldwide.

She is currently involved in book projects, international speaking engagements, advocacy initiatives, and documentary projects related to adoption, identity, family reunification, resilience, and the search for truth across borders and generations.

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen speaks with Sofia Nordgren about her search for biological origins after adoption from Bangladesh to Sweden. Nordgren describes childhood racism, silence around adoption, missing records, conflicting narratives, emotional displacement, and the profound impact of reuniting with her biological mother after decades apart. The conversation expands to illegal adoptions, financial incentives, weak accountability, international justice gaps, and the need for practical, emotional, and institutional support for adoptees and birth families seeking truth and repair worldwide.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Today, we are here with Sofia Nordgren, a distinguished public speaker and survivor advocate, to discuss an issue that came into my personal and professional awareness as a journalist: children allegedly stolen or unlawfully taken from their families, however one chooses to frame it. This experience has directly impacted your own life story. A good opening point would be your own story. You gave a public presentation at the Congress. What do you consider the most emotionally significant parts of your story that resonated with other people who have gone through similar experiences?

Sofia Nordgren: What touched me during and after my speech was realizing, when I showed my symbolic empty frame, that I was saying, “Here is my missing family, parents, or relatives.” Then, when I showed the picture of myself with my biological mother, whom I later found, people were deeply moved and touched. They wanted to come forward, take pictures, and express how emotionally happy they were for me.

At the same time, I understood that this also reflected something within themselves, especially mothers who were missing their own babies. For me, being on the other side of this experience, it was extremely important on an emotional, psychological, and spiritual level to find my biological mother. I understood that this was meaningful not only to me but also to the audience and the other people present.

Jacobsen: How would you describe those emotions? What was the emotional composition of the experience?

Nordgren: You mean the emotions that emerged from what I shared?

Jacobsen: Yes.

Nordgren: People came to me while I was standing there showing the picture. They said, “Wait, let me take a picture.” They hugged me and wanted to connect.

Afterwards, people were very open, warm, and emotionally engaged. They wanted to talk with me, take pictures, and interview me for more information. Even after the conference, when I was sitting down, people continued asking questions. The depth of the questions, the curiosity, and the desire to know more were amazing to witness.

I understand this conversation is crucial and needed. I was a little surprised on some level, but also very happy. This continued throughout the evening and even the next morning at breakfast. People spoke with me and wanted to take pictures. I felt as though I had found a new extended family beyond my adoptive parents and my biological parents.

People also wanted to connect with me through social media, LinkedIn, and other channels connected to the British documentary project. It was like a river flowing in every direction.

Jacobsen: When you spoke with individuals at the Congress in Belgrade, Serbia, what common feelings and experiences did you notice among people from different countries and backgrounds, even though many discussions focused on allegations surrounding missing babies and adoptions connected to Serbia?

Nordgren: It is a sensitive question, but I can say that people came with different motives and experiences. If I understand your question correctly, you are asking about the emotional drive that brought us there. I would summarize it by saying that everyone carried deep pain and trauma, but also a profound longing to share their experiences and seek justice. People wanted to find ways to support one another and work together.

There were many people with strength and determination despite struggling against different hospital systems and bureaucratic institutions. Many people were devastated. I could see the pain in how, in different situations, we felt forced to struggle against systems we believed had failed to support us.

That was the overall picture I experienced: people felt deeply wronged and denied justice. They are trying to get justice, find new ways to address these issues, connect, and find the original babies or children. In my case, I wanted to find my biological parents.

Jacobsen: Most people who go through this experience and have some awareness of the reality probably do not speak publicly about it. I suspect that those who do come forward are the rarer individuals who are motivated by the injustice and pain they have experienced, especially when they encounter others who share similar experiences. What do you think distinguishes those who remain private from those who are willing to speak publicly?

Nordgren: That is an interesting question. I can only share my own perspective. If I begin with myself, I feel that I have been holding back my truth. I was silenced within my adoptive family and throughout my upbringing. It was not acceptable to talk about adoption. In my case, I grew up in a dysfunctional family with a great deal of conflict. My adoptive mother was often harsh toward me, so I felt suppressed.

From a young age, I have felt a strong sense of justice and a deep resistance to oppression. I wanted to bring my experiences into the light and share them with others. However, as you say, many people do not dare to share their stories.

I know many adoptees. I speak from that perspective because I am adopted myself. I participate in forums and networks for adoptees and have been engaged in adoption-related issues in Sweden since 1995. For many years, people spoke very little about these experiences. Later, social media platforms such as Facebook created more opportunities for connection.

Even then, many people only shared a little about their struggles, pain, thoughts, or challenges. For example, returning to one’s country of origin, searching for original documents, or trying to find biological parents, if they are still alive, can require confronting significant trauma. Many people do not dare to do that, or do not want to revisit those experiences.

I have friends who are adopted and do not want to talk about adoption at all. There are many different levels of engagement. Some people say, “I do not have a problem. I had a good family experience,” or they have other reasons for remaining private.

Some people do not talk about adoption, some people talk about it a little, and some people are willing to be vulnerable and share some of their pain. It exists on a spectrum.

Today, I am 52 years old and have lived in Sweden for approximately 50 years. I am an adult with a great deal of life experience. Younger adoptees may still be struggling to speak openly about their experiences. They may find it difficult, feel ashamed, or not have someone they trust enough to talk to.

In my own case, I also have a professional background. I am a nurse, a trained coach, and an experienced public speaker. I have given presentations in healthcare settings and for various organizations in Sweden. I have also performed stand-up comedy. Through those experiences, I have trained myself to be comfortable in the public eye.

I have spoken publicly in Sweden and New York, so I have had extensive practice. That is another factor. Speaking publicly in general is one thing. Speaking publicly about deeply personal trauma and emotional experiences requires a different kind of courage.

I can tell you that I received responses on social media and from friends who said, “Wow, did you share that in English at an international congress? How did you dare to do that? You are so brave.” I met other people who asked, “How did you do it? How did you manage to go there and speak about it?”

There is a significant difference between having an experience and being willing to share it publicly. To stand in front of an audience and speak about something so personal is an entirely different step.

I can only share my own experience and what I have observed in others. People are motivated by different things. Some seek justice. Some carry profound pain, rage, or anger. Others want to channel that pain or trauma into something productive. They ask themselves, “How can I create change? How can I make an impact?”

There is no simple answer to why some people dare to share their stories publicly, and others do not. You were there yourself, and you saw that some people were willing to tell their stories.

Some individuals may have had relatively stable upbringings and therefore feel more comfortable speaking publicly. I do not want to make assumptions. However, for many adoptees who experienced challenging childhoods, it is not easy to share their stories in public. A few do, but not many.

That may not be a complete answer to your question, but it is my answer.

Jacobsen: It does not have to be a complete answer. It only has to be your answer.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Review of Ukrinform Event “The role of war journalists in documenting war crimes. Implementation of the Berkeley Protocol in Ukraine.”

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/07

Organized by the Diplomatic Legal Hub and held at the Ukrinform News Agency; the public discussion entitled “The role of war journalists in documenting war crimes. Implementation of the Berkeley Protocol in Ukraine” occurred July 10, 2026 in Kyiv, Ukraine.

The central question for the event was the translation of information via images, video, testimony, OSINT, and frontline reporting, into reliable evidence capable of supporting potential accountability for alleged war crimes.

Our event brought together archivists, international experts, journalists, lawyers, legal scholars, military communicators, OSINT analysts, veterans under the theme of implementing the Berkeley Protocol in Ukraine.

The Event Structure and Proceedings

The event began with opening remarks from Liudmyla Kozhura, Doctor of Law and moderator who framed digital evidence as justice infrastructure, and myself, as a Canadian journalist and DLH coordinator linking Berkeley Protocol standards to accountability.

The main session moved into a speech by me connecting frontline witnessing with digital-evidence preservation duties. Liudmyla Kozhura explained how journalistic materials become instruments of justice.

Marichka Baysa, a defence communications leader, emphasized official sources, verification, and operational safety. The next session built upon these foundational elements of the presentation.

Yana But, attorney at law, analyzed admissibility risks in journalists’ digital materials. Mark McNamee, Two Ravens strategist, connected OSINT corroboration with war-crimes documentation practice.

Irina Tsukerman, national security attorney, examined disinformation’s attack on evidentiary trust. Eleonora Belei, War Archive research head, presented archiving as justice and memory infrastructure.

Finally, Giorgio Provinciali, engineer, researcher, and war journalist, discussed frontline risks and standards. Nestor Barchuk, Azov POW advocate, connected prisoner-abuse documentation with international accountability. Miro Vanadze, Georgian veteran and MMA organizer, linked military witness experience to evidence preservation.

The Berkeley Protocol in Wartime Ukraine

The broader legal context for the reportage on the war is immense. The Berkeley Protocol was issued through the OHCHR and Berkeley’s Human Rights Center. It sets international standards for identifying, collecting, preserving, verifying, and analyzing digital open-source information.

All these are relevant and of concern to alleged violations of international criminal, human rights, and humanitarian law. The International Criminal Court opened an investigation on March 2, 2022 to cover alleged crimes committed in the Ukraine situation since November 21, 2013.

Ukrainian and international institutions built digital systems to analyze, document, and preserve evidence for the core international crime allegations, at a minimum. Key to the discussion was the acknowledgement of distinct roles and expertise, and skills. War journalists are not prosecutors, detectives, or judges.

Often, they may be the first custodians of future evidence. Their decisions on the battlefield or in the first minutes after the attack. Those decisions on what to film, how to store, whether to publish, if metadata survives, and if official sources are consulted or if victims are protects, relate the Protocol to the work of wartime journalists.

Five Principal Substantive Takeaways

First, we should understand the fundamental truth about the truth: It is not self-preserving. Any audio recording, drone image, photograph, video, and witness account, is information, but not necessarily evidence. Therefore, the information must be authenticated, contextualized, preserved, and protected.

Second, digital evidence requires trust. Speakers repeatedly returned to authenticity of evidence, chain of custody, independent verification, and integrity. These track the core elements of the Protocol. Investigators and related professionals acquire a standard method.

Third, there are distinguishing elements to speed and reliability. They can overlap, but not necessarily every production. The Ministry of Defence communications perspective emphasized premature publication may endanger civilians, investigations, military operations, public trust, and soldiers,

Fourth, OSINT makes an evidentiary architectural ecosystem. Open-source materials alone do little. Together, and cross-checked via geolocation, metadata, official information, other public records, and satellite imagery, they become potentially substantial through such corroboration.

Fifth, any documentation should be centered on human beings as most effects of violations of human rights and international humanitarian law happen to human beings, rights-bearing persons.

One Moral Consideration

The basic moral takeaway is wartime evidence exists for people, not the other way around. The Protocol provides frame and process to make the ethical violations against people as rights-bearing persons as substantive and enforceable.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Jakob Kepka’s 2026 HopeRaising Expedition Across Ukraine

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/07

Jakob Kepka is a Canadian humanitarian, military veteran, long-distance cyclist, above-knee amputee, and cancer survivor. Raised in Eastern Ontario, he served in the Canadian Army Reserve and United States Marine Corps before undertaking humanitarian work in Bosnia and Ukraine. Encounters with Ukrainian amputees led him to donate prosthetic components and launch the HopeRaising Expedition. His 2024 Kraków-to-Kyiv ride raised awareness and support for rehabilitation, prosthetic care, professional training, and sustained international solidarity across national borders.

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen speaks with Jakob Kepka about the experiences shaping his 2026 HopeRaising Expedition across Ukraine. Kepka discusses military duty, amputation, cancer recovery, sobriety, spirituality, and the discipline of one-legged cycling. He explains how encounters with Ukrainian amputees inspired prosthetic donations and advocacy, while reflecting on humanitarian work, survivor’s guilt, resilience, and his determination to mobilize international support for rehabilitation, technical training, human dignity, and lives rebuilt after war with purpose.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Jakob Kepka is a Canadian humanitarian, long-distance cyclist, military veteran, above-knee amputee, and cancer survivor. Raised on a farm in Eastern Ontario, he served in the Canadian Army Reserve and as an infantry rifleman in the United States Marine Corps. After Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine, Kepka volunteered in Ukraine, helping construct accommodations for humanitarian workers and renovate health clinics.

Encounters with Ukrainian amputees inspired him to collect and donate more than $100,000 worth of used prosthetic components, including parts from one of his own prosthetic legs. In 2024, he completed the HopeRaising Expedition from Kraków to Kyiv, travelling from Poland into Ukraine. Now in remission following surgery and chemotherapy, he is preparing an ambitious second fundraising ride across Ukraine in 2026.

Jakob Kepka: The prosthetic part, one of the things I donated was my own leg, which was worth about $100,000.

I also donated 14 boxes of used prosthetic components to be repurposed by Penta, a United States-based nonprofit that collects prosthetic devices and components for reuse. I collected them from prosthetic clinics in London, Ontario. I said, “All of this is going to Ukraine. That is the only place it is going.”

My bionic leg went to Ukraine too. I have another one in the closet right now that will eventually be donated. That one is worth about $120,000.

I receive a new one roughly every five years.

Jacobsen: That is kind of cool. To start, what experiences during your military service shaped your understanding of duty and resilience as they relate to humanitarian responsibility? My own understanding of military service is that it centres on duty.

Kepka: My main military experience was in the United States Marine Corps, so humanitarian work did not really enter into it, especially as a rifleman and infantryman.

If you have seen Full Metal Jacket, the first half of the film gives you some idea of Marine Corps recruit training. That is boot camp. That is boot camp.

The idea of becoming a humanitarian was not part of the dynamic, especially in my MOS, my military occupational specialty, which was infantry. No.

Our purpose was to apply overwhelming force and defeat the enemy. But the Corps did teach me duty, responsibility, honour, and perseverance. Marines do not give up.

We do not even give up when we die. We will fight Satan all the way down.

Jacobsen: Do you consider yourself a religious man?

Kepka: I studied for the priesthood for a while. In the 1980s, I was asked to leave. Later, I lived at an Orthodox monastic property for about eight years and worked there as a custodian.

I tried religious life again during that period. I was also a brother with a Catholic community in Ottawa.

I did not fit.

Jacobsen: So, if I understand correctly, you explored both Orthodox monastic life and Catholic religious life.

Kepka: Yes. I was raised Roman Catholic. I returned to the University of Ottawa and Saint Paul University to study theology, patristics, and related subjects.

At a certain point, I was reintroduced to Orthodoxy through an Orthodox bishop who lived on a farm not far from the farm where I was raised.

I liked the liturgy, and I eventually converted to Orthodoxy with the intention of becoming a monk. That did not work out because I met someone, and I now have a son. I still maintained a close relationship with that bishop, who was later elevated to archbishop.

He had a farmhouse near our farm. By then, my mother had died, my father had died, and we had sold the family farm. Because of circumstances in my life, I needed somewhere to take refuge. He was still a close friend.

I had driven for him before. He gave me a place to stay and a chance to regroup mentally and spiritually.

I went into the bush and cut firewood because we burned wood to heat the place. That is Eastern Ontario in winter. I also participated in the liturgical life there.

We had a chapel on the property. He eventually sent me to Edmonton to assist a Ukrainian priest who had health problems and served a Ukrainian parish there.

My leg condition worsened. Over a period of about 26 months, I repeatedly returned to the hospital, underwent more surgeries, and eventually had the leg amputated. It was rough living in a house heated by wood during that period.

When I received a computerized prosthetic leg, I had to return to Toronto to learn how to use it. That rehabilitation took a long time.

Afterward, I stayed in the Greater Toronto Area, specifically Oshawa, because I knew the city from my youth.

Am I religious now? I say that you can take the boy out of the Catholic Church, but you cannot take the Catholic Church out of the boy.

I find comfort in the Mass and in Orthodox liturgy. When I am in Ukraine, I may attend an Orthodox or Ukrainian Catholic service. I call myself a switch-hitter. I can attend either and understand what is happening.

I find a lot of comfort in the liturgical side of religion. Do I agree with everything theologically? Hell no.

But I do try to live a spiritual life. As of last month, I had been sober for 24 years. That has been a major part of my life. During a substantial period when I was undergoing repeated surgeries, I was not sober.

When I got into serious trouble with the law, I needed somewhere safe to go. What could be safer than living almost in the bush with a group of monks and an archbishop?

Jacobsen: How do your health problems and eventual amputation shape that outlook of, “You can take the boy out of the Catholic Church, but you cannot take the Catholic Church out of the boy”? You have found comfort both in the bush and among religious scholars and spiritual leaders.

Kepka: I also spent time with Indigenous spiritual leaders. Spirituality, to me, is like what I say when I share at my meetings: if I am drawn to drink from a particular spiritual well, I will drink from it. I will not refuse to drink from it simply because it does not fit the mould in which I was raised or what I believed at one time.

To me, spirituality is an evolution. It is not stagnant. We never reach a final destination. Maybe we do when we pass, but right now, I am still a searcher. I always have been.

Going back to my childhood, I was always drawn to prayer. I enjoyed being an altar boy. I liked the sense of mystery in the Catholic Mass, the incense, the ringing bells, and all of that.

In my life, whenever I wandered away from my spiritual or religious roots, I seemed to get into trouble. When things became difficult before I got sober, I always returned to prayer and some form of meditation. Now, it is a daily practice. It is not something I pick up only when I am in trouble. It is something I try to follow every day.

That is also why I was so drawn to cycling. I used to run until they removed my kneecap while I was in the Marine Corps. After that, it became too painful to run.

I still needed that physical release and the repetitive rhythm associated with running, the steps, the breathing, and everything else. A friend of mine at a gym in Ottawa where I was working said, “Why do you not try cycling?”

I had already been doing therapeutic cycling after my knee surgery. Being a non-compliant, overachieving patient, when they said in physiotherapy, “Cycle for 15 minutes,” I pushed it to an hour.

I thought more was better. It was the old Marine Corps adage: pain is only weakness leaving the body. I still adhere to it, although I am older and should be wiser.

Jacobsen: I assume that, as you get older, it sometimes feels as though weakness is leaving the body all the time.

Kepka: Well, yes. No, it feels as though strength is leaving the body all the time.

It is curious. I am faster now as a cyclist than I was three or four years ago because I have become better at pedalling with one leg. I have worked out more of the mechanics.

The spiritual part of my life came partly from my upbringing, but not only from the Church. When I was a child in the early 1960s, we lived on a country road where everybody knew one another. If there was a tragedy, such as a neighbour’s wife dying of cancer, a child becoming sick, a house fire, or a barn burning down, everybody stepped in. Nobody had to be asked.

If a wife was sick, people along the road took turns bringing supper to the house. If something happened to a home or farm, or the weather was changing and someone still had hay in the field, everybody gathered to bring the hay in.

If somebody accidentally set the bush on fire while burning grass, we did not wait for the fire department. Everybody grabbed shovels, climbed onto tractors, went into the bush, and fought the fire.

That was how we were raised. You helped regardless of who the person was. You might not have liked them as a human being, but they were still your neighbour. You also knew that one day it might happen to you.

The Canadians who lived on our road had survived the Great Depression. That was how they got through it. The immigrants who lived there, the displaced persons, including my parents, had lived through the war. They had endured hard times before the war, during the war, and after coming to Canada.

The only way they survived was by pulling together.

My sister, who is 10 years older than I am, went into healthcare. We were raised with that sense of responsibility. Nobody needed to ask you to help. You simply did it.

That is what I carried forward.

Then there was my Marine Corps training. Call it brainwashing, indoctrination, or whatever you want. Once a Marine, always a Marine.

I may have been out of the Corps for more than 40 years, but I am still a Marine. I carry myself that way. People can tell that I was in the military.

When they ask whether I served and I say yes, they ask which branch. When I tell them, they are not surprised.

For a pudgy kid who was bullied throughout school and into high school, until he had a growth spurt and became a star lineman in football, joining the Marine Corps was not something anybody would have predicted. I used to weigh 260 pounds and played football.

Nobody who knew me growing up would have expected me to enter the Marine Corps, survive recruit training at Parris Island, and not merely survive but excel there.

All of a sudden, I felt at home on the island, even with all the abuse. They have apparently cleaned it up, although I will believe that when I see it.

What they taught me there, I carry to this day.

There is also the fact that I have survivor’s guilt. Some of the men I knew were killed in Beirut after I was discharged. They were people I had known during boot camp or military schooling. They went to Beirut and were killed there in the 1980s.

Jacobsen: Do you think about them often?

Kepka: I tried to reenlist. I found my old recruiter in Utica, New York, and called him. By then, he was no longer a gunnery sergeant. He was a master sergeant.

I still called him “Gunny.” I said, “Gunny, I want to go back in.”

He said, “Let me look at your discharge.”

Because of the code placed on my medical discharge, I could never reenlist. I told him, “I will even become a Remington Raider. Hand me a typewriter. I just want to get back in, and I will prove that I can do the job. Then I will work my way out of being a clerk.”

He said it was impossible.

I have carried guilt because I believed I was a better Marine than some of the men I knew who died that day. Yes, I think about them. I still cry when I hear that Marines have died because that connection to the Corps remains. Regardless of what the United States is doing politically right now, I am still a Marine.

My honour, my loyalty, and my duty are to uphold the morals and ethics that I was taught make a good Marine, and to carry them until the day I die.

Yes, we were taught to fight and eliminate the enemy, but there was always the idea that we were doing it for a greater good. I have carried that throughout my life.

In the 1990s, I went to Bosnia as a humanitarian aid worker for several months. I ended up in Mostar, on the Muslim side of the city. I lived with a Muslim family and did humanitarian work there.

The man of the house was an above-knee amputee because of the war. He could not wear a prosthetic leg. People explained why, but it did not make much sense to me at the time because I still had two legs. One was not a very good leg, but I still had both of them.

About 30 years later, I became an amputee myself. Then I finally understood everything I had watched him experience.

Sometimes I think I was fated to become an amputee. I helped it along through my lifestyle and stubbornness, but perhaps I was meant to become one so that I could do what I am doing now.

When I went to Ukraine in 2022, I travelled with an American foundation that recruited veterans of the United States Armed Forces, former police officers, and paramedics.

When Russia launched its full-scale invasion in 2022, I became extremely agitated and angry. I watched everything on television, especially the reports of atrocities in Bucha and elsewhere. As more of it came to light, I became angrier. I have anger issues.

That is what the Marine Corps does. It takes angry young men and makes them angrier.

Without telling many people, I began looking for a way to go to Ukraine. I found an organization online, applied, and did not expect to be accepted. Who was going to accept a man who was almost 65 years old and had one leg?

One of the questions on the application asked whether I spoke Ukrainian, Polish, or Russian. I selected Polish.

Two weeks later, I received an email asking whether I could attend a Zoom meeting with a retired United States Air Force officer.

During the interview, I said, “You do realize that I wrote down that I am an above-knee amputee?”

They said, “Yes, we know. We looked you up on Facebook. Your profile is public, and we could see that you are active and fit. We also need someone who speaks Polish because we have a group of people on the Polish-Ukrainian border. They are staying in Poland, they are completely lost, and they are having a difficult time.”

So I went.

Before my father died in the early 2000s, he used to speak to me about Polish patriotism while we worked together. He told me, “If anything ever happens in that part of the world, promise me that you will do something to help, because we know who will start it.”

When Russia started another war there, I felt determined to fulfil the promise I had made to my father.

I knew that if Russia won, and if it had taken Kyiv in three days as predicted, it would not have stopped there. The Russians might have rested for a while, but they would have continued west.

Jacobsen: It has been the longest three days I have ever heard of.

Kepka: Yes, it has been a long three days. Now we know more about the condition of their army.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Freedom of Expression, Extremist Reactions, and Institutional Cowardice

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/07

Irina Tsukerman is a human rights and national security attorney based in New York and Connecticut. She earned her Bachelor of Arts in National and Intercultural Studies and Middle East Studies from Fordham University in 2006, followed by a Juris Doctor from Fordham University School of Law in 2009. She operates a boutique national security law practice. She serves as President of Scarab Rising, Inc., a media and security strategic advisory firm. Additionally, she is the Editor-in-Chief of The Washington Outsider, which focuses on foreign policy, geopolitics, security, and human rights. She is actively involved in several professional organizations, including the American Bar Association’s Section of Environment, Energy, and Resources, where she serves as Written Content Vice Chair of the Science and Technology Committee. She is also a member of the New York City Bar Association and has served on its Middle Eastern and North African Affairs and Foreign and Comparative Law Committees.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Irina Tsukerman examine freedom of expression, moral responsibility, online harassment, extremism, manipulation, and institutional cowardice. They distinguish accountability for one’s words from responsibility for another person’s violent or abusive actions. Drawing on hostile correspondence, professional disputes, NXIVM, Keith Raniere, contested IQ claims, family experience, and redemption, they explore how intimidation, ambition, weak institutions, and fear can enable destructive individuals while discouraging principled dissent and independent judgment in public and professional life.

Threats, Speech, and Moral Agency

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: I am certain that you receive a great deal of unusual correspondence outside your principal email account. You are probably like me and maintain several email addresses, including accounts for different organizations. Numerous accounts for different organizations. Some are simply old addresses to which people continue sending material, so I have to keep checking them.

I may have mentioned an email I received around the time of my trip to Ukraine. I jokingly refer to it as fan mail. It stated, “Your writing sucks, and I hope you die soon.” I took it seriously because I was preparing to enter Ukraine.

This year alone, I have been accused of being a Ukrainian spy, a Russian spy, a Chinese spy, an American spy, a homosexual Freemason, and a paid shill for the pharmaceutical industry and the vaccination movement. Another person described one of my books as American imperialist. Yet, quite literally, not metaphorically or by exaggeration, that person had never read the book. The accusation was therefore presumptuous, inaccurate, and poorly reasoned. Each accusation arose in response to a different piece of work.

The accusation that I was a homosexual Freemason, for example, came in response to the anthology concerning abuse perpetrated by Orthodox clergy. These accusations appeared in various commentaries.

Another interesting response came from an individual who seemed somewhat detached from the substance of the work. The person expressed concern about my critiques of religion but did not cite any specific examples, which would have been the reasonable thing to do. I usually ask for examples because, across millions of published words, it is difficult to respond meaningfully to a general accusation.

The person cited the attack on Charlie Hebdo and the September 11 attacks as examples of religious extremism. Both examples involved Islamist extremism. That appeared to be a biased omission of other forms of religious extremism, although I do not think the person was fully conscious of the bias as they were Christian. The email seemed to express genuine concern.

The person’s argument was not merely that I should be responsible for what I say. Freedom of expression does not place speech above all other human considerations, and that would not be a fair characterization of my position.

The unusual part was that the person cited extreme acts of terrorism and expressed fear about what religious extremists might do at some indefinite point in the future. Given the examples of Charlie Hebdo and September 11, the concern involved extraordinarily violent responses to words and ideas. The person also invoked the protection of children, because of course.

Extremism, Agency, and Responsibility

Tsukerman: My response would be that, as a religious person, why would she deny agency to the individuals and organizations committing violence? People are responsible for their own actions. They do not cease to be responsible because someone provoked them with uncomfortable speech. Almost any form of dissenting speech may make extremists uncomfortable.

Frankly, even if you sat silently in a chair and never wrote a word on any subject, some extremists might still wish to harm you simply because you were not one of them.

Jacobsen: I found the experience intellectually interesting. I read the message without reacting emotionally and tried to understand its logic. According to that logic, I was responsible not only for what I said, which is fair, but also, by extrapolation, for what religious people did and for what religious extremists might do. That is an extraordinary burden of responsibility to impose on a writer.

Everyone with whom I have discussed the matter, including friends with very different perspectives, has found the argument both amusing and unfair.

Another interesting aspect was that I would apparently be responsible for the actions of religious extremists only when those actions were negative. What if a religious extremist were somehow inspired to perform an admirable act or eventually won the Nobel Peace Prize? Would I receive credit for that as well?

The first person I interviewed who was a nominee for the Nobel Peace Prize was Dr. Hawa Abdi, who has since died. Her family has continued aspects of her humanitarian work in Somalia. Somalia is a deeply religious society. Suppose someone there read something I had written and was inspired to help survivors of domestic violence or to protect vulnerable members of the community. Should I receive credit for that action? Of course not, not even vicariously.

We do not ordinarily credit writers whenever someone reads an inspirational quotation on social media and later performs a good deed, perhaps between games of FarmVille and Solitaire.

Tsukerman: The argument, then, is that because an extremist might respond violently, we should avoid confronting any idea that could provoke that person.

The problem extends beyond religion. There are left-wing extremists, right-wing extremists, incels, cult members, and many other potentially violent groups. According to that reasoning, we should never criticize anyone with extreme beliefs who might respond violently. That would amount to accommodating people who are coercive, obsessively retaliatory, or violent.

Jacobsen: That is part of the problem. I agree completely.

The episode raised several ethical questions for me because it forced me to consider how some people genuinely understand responsibility. The central issue concerns freedom of expression, or freedom of speech in American terminology, and the distinction between responsibility for speech and responsibility for another person’s actions.

Speech can certainly cause harm, particularly within intimate social settings. A person can hurt someone who loves them, and what is said may have immediate consequences within a family, friendship, or relationship.

However, when evaluating a person’s moral character more generally, I place greater weight on what people do. Actions seem to provide the strongest test of someone’s implicit and explicit ethics because conduct is the eventual output of cognition, emotion, intention, and judgment. In action, those elements become aligned to some degree.

Retaliatory Harassment and the German Dispute

Tsukerman: The following account reflects my recollection and interpretation of the dispute. A related situation arose several years ago and remains partly unresolved. It involved a dispute between a journalist and a public official in Germany.

The journalist published an article alleging that a German official responsible for combating antisemitism was not only failing to perform his duties but was himself antisemitic and too dangerous to remain in that position.

I initially shared the article without knowing the full background. I later saw an exchange between the journalist and the official. Several people also contacted me and said that the journalist had a personal vendetta against the official, that the characterization was grossly unfair, and that the article was highly one-sided.

I then shared the official’s response and wrote, in effect, “I shared the journalist’s article, and now I am sharing the official’s response. Judge for yourselves.”

I did not expect that decision to trigger a prolonged conflict lasting several years. The journalist attacked me personally and accused me of enabling antisemites and of acting as an agent of Qatar and Iran while also being paid by Germany. He drew people I had met, organizations with which I had never had contact, and even the German Foreign Office into the dispute.

I understood his public threats as attempts to intimidate people I knew into supporting him, even when they were unfamiliar with the dispute. In my view, he effectively accused me of being a bad Jew merely for questioning his position.

I took the time to interview the German official and ask difficult questions about his views on several issues. I was satisfied with his responses and published the interview so that readers could evaluate the exchange for themselves. I did not rely solely on the official’s statements or on the claims of his supporters.

In my view, the journalist subsequently misrepresented my views and distorted the circumstances, including in communications involving officials at the United States Department of State and others.

According to my understanding of the proceedings, litigation in Germany resulted in an adverse ruling against him, although I believed he later characterized the result differently.

Jacobsen: It is quite the manoeuvre.

I have encountered surprisingly few unpleasant people in my professional life. Considering that I have conducted thousands of interviews, that is a fairly good record.

Sometimes the problem is not a complete absence of character but a combination of persistent suspicion and aggression that encourages destructive behaviour. Extending a dispute for years suggests a pattern beyond an ordinary professional disagreement.

I have dealt with perhaps one definite fraudster and scammer and called this out before anyone years ago. Some Christian media outlets and organizations embraced this person uncritically because he endorsed Christianity and was useful to the movement, with little apparent concern for fraudulent conduct or damage to other people’s lives. That’s common. It was common in the clergy abuse cases and in the cases of the other crimes in Christian institutions. Many, definitely not all, Christians would rather attack the messenger of the truth than the individuals who perpetrated the crime and continue to do so. I issued appropriate warnings to other people, and investigative exposés have since been published about that individual, which are substantive and conclusive.

I have also dealt with another person who appears to want a form of personal worship but cannot quite achieve it. The effort is handled clumsily. Both individuals are reasonably intelligent but lack the social skills necessary to accomplish what they are attempting.

Manipulation, NXIVM, and Intellectual Mythology

The worst and most prominent among them is Keith Raniere in some of these areas. Raniere’s career provides an extreme illustration of what can happen when institutional prestige, intellectual mythology, and personal manipulation reinforce one another.

Someone from whom I was only one degree removed through the Mega Society was Keith Raniere. We have discussed the Mega Society briefly before, and the subject deserves further examination.

Raniere was evidently intelligent, although claims about the precise level of his intelligence should be treated cautiously. His academic and professional records do not demonstrate exceptional diligence or conscientiousness. Intelligence, educational achievement, and conscientiousness are related only imperfectly and should not be treated as interchangeable.

His score on the unsupervised Mega Test contributed to his public reputation for extraordinary intelligence. However, the Mega Test was not a conventionally standardized clinical intelligence test, and very high scores derived from it cannot be interpreted with the precision often claimed.

Raniere was also a highly effective manipulator. He was convicted of offences including racketeering, sex trafficking, attempted sex trafficking, forced-labour conspiracy, and wire-fraud conspiracy. He was sentenced in 2020 to 120 years in federal prison.

He was therefore not merely a fraudster or scammer but also an abuser whose organization exploited and trafficked women.

The HBO documentary series The Vow ran for two seasons and examined NXIVM, Raniere, Nancy Salzman, and other central figures in the organization. Salzman, a co-founder and former president of NXIVM, pleaded guilty to racketeering conspiracy and was sentenced to 42 months in prison.

Tsukerman: I have not watched the documentary, but I am familiar with the case and have spoken with people who knew aspects of the situation.

Jacobsen: I also wrote for many earlier issues of Noesis, the journal of the Mega Society, covering approximately eight or nine years or more, and have reviewed the entire series of the journal going back quite a bit.

According to material I reviewed from around 1989 or 1990, representatives associated with Guinness World Records explained why the category of “highest IQ” was discontinued. The fundamental problem was that available intelligence tests could not reliably distinguish among individuals at such extreme levels.

The title referred, at best, to the highest score produced by a particular test under particular conditions. It did not establish that the person possessed the highest intelligence in the world.

Such a title is psychometrically dubious and difficult to maintain. Cognitive performance can vary modestly across occasions and generally changes across the lifespan. Different tests also use different scales, norms, ceilings, and assumptions. A single purported world record therefore creates an appearance of precision that the evidence cannot support.

I have experienced only two seriously negative professional situations. If personal and professional mixed, I do not count those as negative, truly, as love was involved. Other gentler and private lessons are learned and gained from those. On the professional ones, in one of them, I bear some responsibility because I was still very early in my career.

Early in my career, I scheduled an interview with a moderately prominent British public figure and missed the meeting. I rescheduled it, chose the new time myself, and was then late. The person was unhappy, and that anger was justified. We eventually completed the interview.

The second difficult situation arose from what appeared to be an editorial misunderstanding, followed by an extraordinary amount of anger. It could have been resolved simply by declining to publish the piece and moving on.

Apart from those incidents, I have had very few genuinely unpleasant professional experiences. In your case, however, the conflict lasted for years. Based on my experience as an international interviewer, media professional, and independent publisher, that suggests the conduct extended beyond an ordinary professional dispute.

Most people in professional settings want to resolve disputes. They generally want to resolve them promptly and discreetly. When someone’s conduct prevents all three outcomes, resolution, timeliness, and discretion, something is wrong to a more significant degree.

Tsukerman: The person’s conduct was clearly persistent and destructive. I also suspected that he had a personal interest in obtaining the official’s position and was frustrated that he could not do so. Other information emerged later that suggested additional possible explanations.

What interested me most was his ability to intimidate people into adopting absurd positions merely to avoid becoming targets of his public retaliation campaigns and persistent online harassment.

Social-media platforms should have acted against that conduct. Organizations affiliated with him should also have investigated the reported conduct and considered whether his continued affiliation was appropriate. Instead, many continued to tolerate him in various capacities.

Consequences, Redemption, and Moral Repair

Jacobsen: That is very interesting. People inevitably make mistakes because life is long. Life can feel even longer when someone makes a prolonged series of destructive decisions.

I have probably discussed this with you before, but my father misused alcohol and was absent for most of my life. My parents divorced when I was very young. During the final decade of his life, we had to manage some of his affairs.

After he died, we discovered that he owed money to the Government of Canada and had not left a will. We had to work through the resulting paperwork and unresolved obligations. Some matters may never be fully settled.

People can make very poor decisions whose consequences continue for years. I speak from experience as someone who has had to live with the effects of another person’s choices.

Even so, I believe there should be room for what Christians might call redemption. People should have an opportunity to correct their course.

We previously worked on a text concerning antisemitism and the extreme forms it can take. Some people who once held deeply antisemitic beliefs have changed substantially. Former extremists can sometimes become effective critics of the movements they once supported because they understand how those communities think and organize.

When someone pursues a petty dispute for several years, however, that is different. This was not a noble cause. It was an extraordinarily trivial conflict.

I am sorry that you had to endure it.

Institutional Cowardice and the Price of Convenience

Tsukerman: The episode illustrates how people attempt to control the speech of others. This person tried to limit everyone else’s ability to speak and pressured people either to support him or to remain silent.

The original dispute barely deserved public attention, but people still had the right to examine the evidence and reach their own conclusions. He attempted to restrict whom others could engage with, associate with, or interview. He sought to make their lives difficult merely because they would not agree with him.

He was able to exert that pressure because he had a broad network, access to social media, and relationships with organizations that either failed to conduct proper due diligence or valued his modest contributions more than their own reputations.

By continuing to associate with him despite his conduct, those organizations compromised their credibility.

Jacobsen: There are several unfortunate realities in life. Some religious traditions encode them in elaborate stories, although more direct language can sometimes be more useful.

First, some people behave foolishly throughout their lives and repeatedly return to the same destructive patterns.

Second, many people who possess prominence or power do not deserve it. Life is unfair in that respect.

Third, not every person of status is just or intelligent. Some attain their positions through nepotism, manipulation, or institutional failure.

Fourth, some people cause enormous harm and leave others wishing only that the damage would stop. I am not wishing death on anyone involved in this story, but I understand the desire for an exhausting and destructive conflict to end.

Tsukerman: I understand. I still find it remarkable that one troll could create so much disruption and that so many people were intimidated by someone whose actual influence was limited.

Many of the people he pressured were already established and nearing the later stages of their careers. They did not need additional conflict, but it is difficult to understand what they truly feared losing.

They could have confronted him more firmly, ended the nonsense, or removed him from their organizations. Instead, they found his writing useful to their own work.

Because he was convenient to them, they were willing to sacrifice other people in order to remain on his good side. That kind of practical cowardice is what troubles me most.

Jacobsen: I could understand such behaviour more easily if the stakes were exceptionally high. If someone feared losing millions of dollars, a dream career, or the security of their family, an ignoble decision would still be wrong, but the motivation would at least be comprehensible.

What puzzles me is when people abandon their principles over matters of very little consequence.

Some people value power and influence for their own sake. When they are socially skilled, they do not need to be intellectually exceptional.

A person who understands how to manoeuvre within influential groups can rise despite offering mediocre or insubstantial ideas. Effective self-promotion can carry such people surprisingly far.

The ideas may be weak, but the personality can still be petty, ambitious, and destructive. That combination can cause significant damage.

Thank you very much, as always. Have a lovely day.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Nestor Barchuk on Ukrainian POW Torture, Azov Captives, and Russia’s Red Lines

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/07

Nestor Barchuk is a Ukrainian lawyer, serviceman, and international advocacy specialist with the 1st Corps Azov of Ukraine’s National Guard. He works on securing the release of Ukrainian prisoners of war and advancing investigations into the Olenivka prison-colony massacre. Before joining Azov, Barchuk served as a legal expert and international relations manager at DEJURE Foundation, a Ukrainian rule-of-law NGO focused on judicial reform and anti-corruption accountability after the Revolution of Dignity and democratic legal standards. Interview conducted after the event “Anatomy of Torture” of the Center for Civil Liberties.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen interviews Nester Barchuk, a Ukrainian junior sergeant and Strategic Communications representative with Azov’s First Corps, about Russia’s systematic torture of Ukrainian prisoners of war. Barchuk details medical abuse, forced tattoo removal, harsh treatment of Azov captives, stalled exchanges, and Moscow’s hollow “red line” threats. The exchange links POW accountability, Olenivka, propaganda against Azov, and Ukraine’s struggle to secure prisoner releases amid Russia’s escalating war and diplomatic intimidation before global courts act decisively.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: What is your current title and work?

Nester Barchuk: I am a junior sergeant, and I represent the Strategic Communications Unit within the First Corps of the National Guard of Ukraine. My focus is international relations regarding issues of Ukrainian prisoners of war, particularly Azov prisoners of war in Russian captivity.

Jacobsen: What are the major trends we are seeing in the treatment of Ukrainian POWs?

Barchuk: First, yesterday, there was a strong presentation with excellent speakers on the panel.

The panel and its report underscored one of the major and most concerning trends: medical personnel being used in the torture or abuse of Ukrainian prisoners of war. We hear many stories and testimonies from Ukrainian prisoners of war and others about horrific cases.

Yesterday, a representative from the Coordination Headquarters for the Treatment of Prisoners of War in Ukraine, which operates under the Main Directorate of Intelligence of the Ministry of Defence of Ukraine, said that treating toothaches without anesthesia is very common.

In another case, a man had a broken jaw and could not eat or chew properly. A Russian guard saw this and sent him to a doctor, essentially a dentist. Although the man had a broken jaw, his teeth were removed without anesthesia.

This is quite common. That is one trend. According to Danielle Bell, head of the UN Human Rights Monitoring Mission in Ukraine, more than 96% of Ukrainian prisoners of war held by Russia have been subjected to torture.

Those are official UN findings. Basically, almost everyone has been affected. We know this is a deliberate policy, not a series of isolated incidents, because The Wall Street Journal conducted an investigation titled “‘Be Cruel’: Inside Russia’s Torture System for Ukrainian POWs.”

In 2022, Russia’s Federal Penitentiary Service, with the involvement of the FSB, the Federal Security Service of Russia, reportedly gave instructions that enabled systematic violence against Ukrainian POWs. Guards were told there would be no restrictions on violence and that they would not be held accountable.

Those instructions were then distributed among different detention sites where prisoners of war were being held. From Russian attorneys, we know that penitentiary system workers went on business trips between different prison colonies and pretrial detention centers to exchange knowledge and practices.

Even when there are thousands of kilometers between detention sites, we still see similar practices and similar methods of torture.

One particular prisoner had undergone a life-saving abdominal procedure, which left a surgical scar on one side of his abdomen. In Russian, the words “Glory to Russia” were carved into the scar tissue.

Yes, we are speaking of scar tissue, cut deeply into the person. Prisoners are also often burned with hot metal.

If Ukrainian prisoners of war have tattoos of the Trident, Ukrainian flags, or symbols of our brigade or corps, signifiers of Ukrainian identity or independence, those tattoos are forcibly removed with a rock or a piece of metal.

Within that general picture, there is a very challenging group of prisoners of war: the Azov Brigade prisoners of war. Azov has a legacy. It was one of the first volunteer units to emerge in the first weeks of Russian aggression in 2014. It later developed into a regiment, then into a brigade, and now forms the foundation of the First Corps Azov of the National Guard of Ukraine.

After the defence of Mariupol, Azov became one of the main symbols targeted by Russia and has been heavily demonized in Russian propaganda, both domestically and internationally.

According to our testimonies, testimonies from prisoners of war from our units, civilian accounts, and international reports, Azov prisoners of war receive especially harsh treatment. They often have to wear different clothing from other prisoners of war to single them out.

This is also because Azov is a special forces unit, and because the unit is effective and highly motivated. The vast majority of its members are volunteers, so there is specific treatment.

We also see that Russia is very reluctant to exchange Azov prisoners of war because they have symbolic meaning for Russia. Even in major exchanges, such as the 1,000-for-1,000 exchange in 2025, very few Azov Brigade prisoners of war were included. At the current pace, it could take decades to bring them all home.

Approximately 1,400 Azovstal defenders were taken into captivity. Now, around 700 remain in captivity. That may sound positive because roughly half have already been exchanged. However, large numbers of Azov prisoners were exchanged earlier for Viktor Medvedchuk and Russian pilots.

After the Kursk operation, when Ukraine captured Russian conscripts, FSB personnel, and Akhmat fighters, Russia was interested in getting them back. That was the only time I know of when Russia actually initiated negotiations on an exchange. There may have been a couple more cases. In all other cases, Ukraine has been the side initiating the process.

Jacobsen: Why the particular animosity toward Azov from the Russians? The particular animosity, the extra emphasis, different clothing, harsher treatment, and greater reluctance to conduct full exchanges. So the exchanges involving them only partially involve them.

Barchuk: I think the first reason is the symbolic meaning of the unit. Azov is one of the main targets of Russian propaganda, both inside Russia and internationally, including in Europe and many other countries.

Jacobsen: We are looking at you, Canada. Side note: there is all this hullabaloo about bombardments against targets inside Russia, deep strikes, long-range strikes. As we both know, there have been more than a few recently, including the lid coming off from one of Russia’s own anti-missile systems. The response from the Russian side has essentially been lacklustre.

I think this is a pretty clear indicator of grandiose threats: once they are breached, the response is nowhere near what had been claimed. What are some other things we can take as indicative of statements made as warnings, with threatening language from Russian authorities, and then the response after devastating strikes on oil refineries or other targets?

Barchuk: What do you mean by that?

Jacobsen: The Russians will say, “If you attack us, we will launch nuclear strikes,” or “We will bomb Paris and London,” and so on. Then the attacks happen, and basically there is no major response. There were attacks on Kyiv on May 24, June 2, and June 15 that were substantial by the metrics of the last 14 years, but in terms of an actual consistent response corresponding to the level of threat they made, I think the Russian response has been quite weak. What are your thoughts?

Barchuk: Russia has used every weapon it has except nuclear weapons. Every time Ukraine received new arms from its partners, for example, HIMARS, Patriots, or any new system that was not necessarily a game changer but changed the nature of warfare here, Russia said that it would be a red line. Then nothing followed.

Even in Russia, there is a meme or joke that people have heard about these red lines so many times that they are “brown lines” now. So, yes, we do not see meaningful answers to the crossing of those red lines.

For example, Putin or Lavrov stated that Kyiv would now be systematically bombarded in response to something. However, Kyiv had already been bombarded before. If you were here in winter, the strikes were every week, the same as now. I do not know what he is trying to achieve, not only Putin, but also his government representatives.

I think they are trying to influence Western diplomatic missions here, or they want to threaten them.

Jacobsen: They were telling all the diplomatic missions to leave.

Barchuk: Yes, but that was done by Lavrov. Even at the beginning of the full-scale invasion, Russia did not say it publicly. It was conveyed through unofficial, or perhaps official but non-public, channels through the ministries of defence. Then a few embassies left.

However, when it is said openly by the head of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Russia, it is more like a public threat that is ungrounded now because, as I said, Russia has already used every weapon it has. They even used this Oreshnik system.

Barchuk: They used it to bomb garages in Bila Tserkva, to bomb territories they claim are their own. The previous time, it was the Donetsk region that was hit by a Russian strike. So I do not think we will see any harsh answer to crossing any red line that Russia is drawing, because they have already used everything they have.

Jacobsen: Is there any will, even at the level of the oligarchs, to use thermonuclear options?

Barchuk: In Russia?

Jacobsen: By oligarchs, or those around Putin?

Barchuk: I do not know. I heard an interview with the former Russian prime minister, Mikhail Kasyanov, if I am not mistaken. He was prime minister between 2000 and 2004. He said there is growing resistance, or growing anger, among Russian business owners, major business owners. They are trying to push or encourage Putin to end this war somehow.

However, there are only a few options: to escalate and hit NATO or European countries, or to back off, negotiate, and make a deal. At this point, given all the goals of the so-called special military operation, that would look like capitulation for Russia.

So it looks bad for them. However, I do not know whether the oligarchs are reacting in any meaningful way.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Nestor.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Ivan Valek on Family, Faith, Communism, Architecture, and Croatia’s Moral Future

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/07

Ivan Valek is a Croatian architect, entrepreneur, former athlete, and religious thinker whose life spans Yugoslav communism, Croatian independence, international business, family migration, and spiritual searching. A former youth-level basketball player, he later worked in architecture, anti-nuclear shelter design, fountains, swimming pools, and humanitarian initiatives. Born Roman Catholic, later involved with Mormonism, Valek emphasizes family, truth-seeking, moral responsibility, and the struggle to do good while resisting evil through an intensely autobiographical lens of public faith.

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen speaks with Ivan Valek about family, education, sport, architecture, religion, and life under communism. Valek reflects on his American wife, children, Roman Catholic upbringing, Mormon period, theological studies, and conviction that truth must guide spiritual life. He connects personal history to Croatia’s political struggles, moral decline, entrepreneurship, anti-nuclear shelter design, and a belief that doing good requires actively confronting evil within family, society, church, and wider modern civilization itself.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: I was really curious because you have had a very interesting life story. So, maybe we can open with this. Can you describe your diverse educational and family background? That is one. Two, you have an interesting background in that you became Mormon and then left for a denominational form of Christianity, I think. I also think that whole conversion narrative is very interesting. Could you talk about that a little bit?

Ivan Valek: Family is the most important thing to me. My wife was an American citizen. She was a Mormon missionary in Yugoslavia. After returning to the United States, another missionary started writing letters, and then she left.

During the war situation, we were married in 1999. The war in Croatia began in 1991. She agreed to live with us, and she was very happy.

I worked with children, very special children. I was very blessed. Our first child was born in 1990 and now lives in the United States. That generation was still shaped by the old communist system and by the people who remained in power after communism. The situation was not good economically or politically.

I can tell you that Croatia is a beautiful land with good people. I think Croatia has one of the greatest potentials. It has more than 1,200 islands, islets, cliffs, and reefs, along with hills and mountains. This was part of the story for the countries of the former Yugoslavia. Many of those countries went through difficult situations after the breakup of Yugoslavia, though Slovenia was generally in a stronger position.

During communist times, everything was very organized. There was even economic progress under communism. We can only measure it against this democracy. I have insights from all the countries. Many countries remained in a difficult position. Why? Because countries spent more money than they earned.

When they came to power in 1990, the debt was much lower. Today, Croatia’s public debt is far higher than it was in the 1990s. We saw all the difficulties. We saw the hotels, the land, the fields, and the people living in the towns. Now we are seeing more and more of it, and I think we must change the system and the politicians if we are going to get out of this.

Yes, I can hear you. There are huge possibilities. In America, we wanted English schooling, university education, and a better life for the children.

I went to school in Odessa, and one child went to school in America, but they all finished university in the United States of America. This was the reason for Eisen David. He was very young. He was an ice hockey player. He entered a sports kindergarten when he was four years old. He was very talented in ice hockey. He spent years in Slovakia and two years in the Czech Republic.

He played for the United States under-18 team. He won a championship award in North Dakota. He did not want to be an angel, though he had offers; he wanted to be a gladiator. They told him that with help, a name, and engagement, you never know. I offered him…

He finished that degree and worked in court in Utah. My sister is from Manchester, and I saw her play soccer at Boston University on scholarship. She has a master’s degree. All my children are moral, well educated, and polite. My wife and my children, for us, are everything.

In communist times, I did not know. My father was not a communist. He lived through the Second World War. He had his shop. He was not in the war, but he was Croatian. He was a Roman Catholic. You had to fight very hard. Normally, I do not think they would have pushed me. I was very talented in basketball. I played for Yugoslavia at the youth level. I was 18 and 20. I was the best.

I played at the upper level for the national team. You had to have political support from the club, but I did not have it. Then I had my first contract with the Boston Celtics for the NBA. I do not know; that was maybe many years ago. So we are a sports-oriented family. Normally, we have three homes in the United States. We built one in Belgium.

They were involved in the U.S. hockey program, and we had a house there. This was my salvation: the swimming pool, the farm, and the money. Also, we had connections with an international company. In Africa, I had some connections, and there were many possibilities, such as concessions involving wood, oil, and forest resources.

But the war started in Yugoslavia. So, as you know me, I am a normal family man. I gave everything to my children and now to my grandchildren. If you want something about my spiritual life, I was born Roman Catholic under communist Yugoslavia. I went to church and served at Mass, because that was one point of identity. We were old Roman Catholics, and what happened to us could happen.

When I was about 20 years old, I did not make it to the United States from Yugoslavia because of my business life, company, girls, and all of this.

At 20, I decided to try to find the best philosophy of life. I did not think only in terms of religion, but philosophy, because I felt that some principle exists in the universe. If you are good and doing good, then why do you do good? What is the best philosophy? I studied the problem of the will. I thought that sometimes I had more will and sometimes less will.

I thought that this depended on my way of believing. So, I can say that in this moment, I found my soul. When you find your soul, then you can watch over your soul and feel it. This was one of the questions: How do I feel inside? So, I am working outside. If you would do it, you are also doing it outside. But the most important thing is different.

We are outside every second. We are waiting to fix the principle that we have known for many days. That is what I mean. And this principle is certainly right.

I studied theology and philosophy. I studied at three universities: Roman Catholic theology in Zagreb, Protestant theology in Zagreb, and a third institution, possibly in Switzerland. I also invested in the church and studied at Brigham Young University. But I studied in the first way. A good professor said that when you are a student, then you can speak Greek.

He was the best professor. My professor of the history of Roman Catholic theology was Tomislav Janko Šagi-Bunić, who was a Croatian Catholic theologian associated with the Second Vatican Council. Cardinal Ratzinger was responsible for the doctrine of the faith in the Roman Catholic Church. I can say, from my 60 years, that when God was waking me up, I understood my stand and the world around me.

I do not believe nobody; I just justify that God exists. I believe that Jesus Christ is our Saviour because his teaching was right. What is Christian is not only the life of Jesus, but what has existed from the beginning.

I think that the whole life here on the planet has a deep meaning. It is important. Now, speaking about theological philosophy, let us first know who we are.

The most important question is why we are here. If we know why we are here, then we must fulfil why we are here now. What must we do? I can tell you what I found. I found that we must make a lot of difference because there is good and evil, and we must decide to do good. One part that many people do not do, and that is very important, is that it is not enough only to do good. We must fight against evil. This is the war against evil.

On this planet, we must fight for the Earth. We must have wisdom. We must have knowledge. We must fight for the Earth. This creates harmony between our souls and our material bodies. Then I believe, and this is why I was a member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, that family can be eternal, and that you can marry your wife for eternity.

Knowledge, and all the dimensions that exist, modify my family and my spiritual experience. What I am sure of is that I love the truth. If I am wrong, I like to be asked, and I will listen. If you have an argument and can tell me that something is wrong, I only want the truth. I am not ready at the moment to belong to churches or church dealings. It is just me and my family.

This award I have in front of me is very precious. I can make my experience from my autobiography, Ocean of Sin, not because I am important to people, but for my grandchildren. They can learn from our mistakes. They can learn from our path. Family is the most important thing in this life. This is very important to me and my children.

My children were in the good hands of their parents, Bonnie and me. One year ago, my wife had stomach cancer. We invested in our children, and I think, at this age, you see when you are young that this is the age of life. You are lucky in the garden, and you take the fruit of life if you work in the garden.

In life, living under communism was something you cannot imagine. People died. The communists killed many Croatian people.

They killed people on the road like dogs, simply because they thought those people might do something against communism. It was very hard. I think my parents were not politicians. I went to school. My father said to work and study.

School was good in the former Yugoslavia. If you were not political, you could get a higher education from your family without paying anything. You also had medical care without paying anything. You had a job, and you could work. It was good if you were not political. Then, as I told you, I studied and played basketball. It was quite a strength.

I was a world champion. I was the best scorer on the team. I was officially connected with basketball. I went to play last year in Miami, which gave me jobs. I came to one company with 15,000 workers.

My position as an architect was that I also worked on anti-nuclear bunkers. We produced them, and I became one of the first people in Yugoslavia involved in these underground shelters. I represented Yugoslavian architects in Finland at an architects’ congress.

Then I went into private business. My private business was fountains and swimming pools. Even now, I would like to establish family nuclear shelters in a different way. They should last over time. They should not be like our swimming pools.

You can change the concept from the old way of thinking about catastrophes in the world and catastrophes in confined spaces. What is most important? It should not cost more than one common building. I want to come into contact with Elon Musk about these buildings.

For my idea, the sheltering would involve wood. The bunker would go underground, and the top would also have grass. It could be good for catastrophes, chemical incidents, or something else that may come. But I am looking for connections with Musk. I do not know if he would be a partner, because I have this material and I was filling up my works.

The people hated me and all. They told me I could play basketball, but I was one of the first professionals, because I became a professional player.

I have been this way all my life. I work, I edit, and it is what I love to do. I do not know if this is a short time, but I am a fan of your reactions and what you know. My family, my business, my spiritual situation, and this world are making me think more. The soul can be self-made or secret. The soul can have more knowledge, more wisdom, and more experience.

For about 25 years, we have had this association, Christians of Asia. It is not a church organization. Good people work together for the good of others, without the churches.

Take one of our programs, for example: homeless people. In Yugoslavia, there were 1,700 years since Nicaea. This is historical. After Rome and Nicaea, the church changed its character and everything. Now I am writing about government and rule.

I love history. In my book, I am writing the history of this part of Southeastern Europe. It is a great history. You remember what I said in Belgrade: in every civilization, there was community, but now there is only egoism. That is egoism. People have lost the feeling for one another. This is the worst sickness on this planet Earth.

Now you see me for the first time. What is the principle? What can we do? We are dealing with a virus, not only COVID. The planet and the universe, if they ever did not exist, would be destroyed. But we still have this chance, because every matter can change. The soul can be healed.

What is heavenly? The heavenly system has the goal of health. Every healthy soul is his soul. That is the principle. If you are doing good, you cannot feel bad. If you are doing bad, you cannot, in the end, feel good. Life is much simpler than people believe. You know what I mean? It is so simple. If you find the right wife, you know how your life will be. The most important thing is to find the right person, marry, and become one. That was first, because family is like the atom in the physical world. The woman, the mother, and the father are in the centre.

The children are around them. This is the basic union, in time and in eternity. I feel good. You would believe that I feel 25. I would like to speak with Elon Musk about this. The bunker would go underground and also serve as shelter in a social section.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Ivan.

Valek: I always have my mobile, and I will be happy to speak with you.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Fumfer Physics 53: Science, Theology, Infinity, the Mega Society, and Ukraine’s Drone Revolution

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/07

Fumfer Physics 53: Science, Theology, Infinity, the Mega Society, and Ukraine’s Drone Revolution

Photo by Yusuf Onuk on Unsplash

Scott Douglas Jacobsen interviews Rick Rosner on science’s challenge to theology, skepticism among Mega Society members, the philosophical status of infinities in physics, and Ukraine’s rapidly evolving drone warfare. Rosner argues scientific progress has undermined literal religious mechanisms, while physics treats infinities as mathematical tools rather than physical realities through renormalization. He likens mass-produced drones to possums and octopuses: inexpensive, expendable systems whose overwhelming numbers can reshape modern asymmetric warfare. Ukraine’s planned production targets underscore that transformation.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Anything in math you want to talk about? We actually do periodically, every once in a while, check in on this. Where do you think theology sits now? Any further reflections on that?

Rick Rosner: No, my position on that is the same as it has been: theology has been hollowed out by the success of science. You can continue to be religious, but belief in a lot of holy mechanisms has been pretty thoroughly challenged. Science has explained a lot and disproved a lot of religious claims.

The religious people I know—well, you have Colbert and Kimmel, two famous people raised Catholic, with Colbert especially being a serious Catholic. They may follow the moral doctrine, but I doubt they follow all of the theology literally.

Maybe there is some base faith in God, maybe in the afterlife. But in terms of the hand of God actively working in the world to make things happen, I do not think most smart people believe that.

Jacobsen: Where do Mega Society members typically sit on that? In your experience, where do they typically stand on belief in all this stuff?

Rosner: Pretty much where I stand. There are some Mega Society people who might be struggling with mental issues, and in those cases, their opinions should probably be looked at skeptically.

Jacobsen: There is a tendency toward non-belief in these ideas.

Rosner: Yeah. Just imagine the people you know in the Mega Society. You would probably agree with me: it is hard to imagine most of those people being complete believers in a standard religion.

Jacobsen: Complete believers? No. Partial? Maybe. I just do not see, typically, faith as the refuge of a serious person.

Rosner: I do not know what else I have.

Jacobsen: Can you elaborate on the philosophy of the physics behind the idea that you need infinite information to have an infinite series of zeros to define something?

Rosner: I feel like Feynman was one of the guys associated with the idea that infinities in physics are often signs that something has gone wrong in the calculation, or at least that the theory needs careful handling. Let’s ask AI. Here is what AI says.

It says David Hilbert, the legendary mathematician, famously argued that the infinite is nowhere to be found in physical reality. Max Planck is mentioned. Carlo Rovelli, one of the founders of loop quantum gravity. Max Tegmark, who we know from his theories about mathematical structures and consciousness. Sabine Hossenfelder. And Roger Penrose.

So this “no actual infinities in physics” view has a long history, and I feel like Feynman was broadly on the side of being suspicious of infinities. But the deal is that if the universe is emergent, and if the universe has to have existence at all sizes, then you can imagine a non-contradictory universe of roughly any finite size. The universe needs to work with a finite number of parts and a finite amount of information—which is a dumb phrase, because anything finite is short of infinite.

But anyway, if it is an emergent universe, it probably does not work with actual infinities. The infinities in math are often conveniences. They make math portable. They make math usable.

Here we go: how physics deals with infinities. Because equations can sometimes predict nonsensical infinities, physicists developed techniques such as regularization and renormalization to control or absorb those infinities into measurable quantities. This work was associated with people like Feynman, Julian Schwinger, and Shin’ichiro Tomonaga, among others.

So if your equation has infinities, you find ways to handle them. You do not just let them sit there and say, “Well, reality is infinite, so who cares?” You push them to the side, or you reformulate the theory so the observable predictions stay finite.

Jacobsen: Who is the most educated member?

Rosner: I do not know. Chris Cole has a graduate degree, I think. Harvard undergrad, maybe Caltech for graduate school. I am not sure. I assume there are a few people with graduate degrees.

Jacobsen: Who would you mark as the smartest one among them?

Rosner: That is hard. In the Mega Society, smartness comes in different flavors. Chris Cole has immense intelligence and also immense entrepreneurial acumen. Dean Inada has immense mathematical and visual genius. Other people I do not know very well. I have not been deeply involved in Mega for a long time.

Jacobsen: What else can we talk about? Anything new on the internet?

Rosner: Well, internationally, how are you? How is it where you are?

Jacobsen: It is pretty good.

Rosner: Okay. You have not had any massive bombing. It seems like Ukraine is now launching more drones and strikes at Russia than Russia is launching at Ukraine, at least in some categories.

Jacobsen: That is generally the case. I would say so.

Rosner: And the number is insane. The number we hear is that Ukraine aims to produce around seven million drones in 2026, which would average about 19,000 a day. That is a lot of stuff to send at an enemy, even with a high failure rate.

Drones are the possums of modern warfare.

Jacobsen: Absolutely true. Yes.

Rosner: For people who are not familiar with how possums work, octopuses work somewhat similarly. Tragically, some animals are highly subject to predators, and these animals are not built for long lifespans. You capture a possum and raise it in captivity, and you would be lucky to get a few years out of it.

Many octopuses have very short lifespans. They live for a year or two, grow, get big enough, reproduce, and die. But they make a shit ton of offspring.

Possums also produce a lot of young. That is different from humans, where it takes 15 or 18 years to raise a person. Humans do not have that many babies, and in modern societies, the babies do not die at a huge rate.

There are population patterns that change once a society reduces infant mortality. In less secure societies, women may have five, eight, or ten kids, partly because not all of them are expected to survive to adulthood. Then medicine, sanitation, and economic development come in, and population patterns shift.

Right now, much of the world is in a post-shift environment, with fertility falling below replacement in many countries. The global population is still projected to keep growing for decades, but the latest United Nations projections put the likely peak around the mid-2080s, not 2050.

But anyway: possums, octopuses, drones. You make a shitload of them. They have a high failure rate. They get preyed upon. Most do not complete the mission, or, in the animal case, most do not live to reproduce.

That is the drone model. Make thousands and thousands of them, send them at the Russians, and if 10 or 15 percent do their jobs, that is still devastating. And they do not cost much compared with the systems they can destroy.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Davis Richardson on Ukraine’s Bombardments, Civilian Resilience, and Cultural Targeting

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/07

Davis Richardson is a commentator and communications professional with extensive experience in Ukraine since Russia’s full-scale invasion. Since 2022, he has visited Ukraine 12 times, including stays in Kyiv and the Odesa region. His work has included pro bono publicity for Nahirna 22, a group of Gen Z Ukrainian artists affected by Russian attacks. Richardson reflects on air raid alerts, bombardments, cultural targeting, civilian resilience, and the evolving nature of modern warfare.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Davis Richardson discuss major Russian bombardments of Ukraine on May 24, June 2, and June 15, focusing on Kyiv, civilian targets, and psychological responses to air raid alerts. Richardson describes shorter warning times, heavier strikes, and cultural targeting, including attacks on the Lavra, museums, and artists. Jacobsen reflects on involuntary fear, disrupted sleep, and how Ukrainians continue daily life amid escalating missile and drone warfare.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: I was here in Ukraine during the May 24, June 2, and June 15 bombardments. Thinking about it now, “bombardments” is probably the better term because they were significant. The May 24 bombardment alone involved 90 missiles and 600 drones.

The June 2 bombardment involved 73 missiles and 656 drones, while the June 15 bombardment involved 70 missiles and 611 drones. Kyiv was substantially targeted during the May 24, June 2, and June 15 bombardments. Were you here for any of those? I want to compare notes on responses and interpretations.

Davis Richardson: I was here. First, I have been in Ukraine for about a month now. This is my 12th visit to the country since 2022. At the end of May and in June, I was in the Odesa region.

In early June, I was in Odesa, and I have been in Kyiv ever since. Regarding 2026, I was in Kyiv in February during the heat shortages and power outages. In comparing the notes you mentioned, I have noticed this time that the alerts are often shorter.

However, there is heavier bombardment during them. With some of the earlier alerts I experienced in 2023, there seemed to be more of an open-ended question about when they began and ended. You did not necessarily know what was happening during that period.

The challenge now is that they can be announced on very short notice. I think that during the attack last night, as soon as the alert was issued, just a minute or two later, the ballistic missiles struck outside the city. So there is less time to react. That has been my experience.

Jacobsen: How do you experience them? I am talking about physiological interpretations and emotions.

Richardson: I think a lot of it depends on what you are going through at the time. I do not think there is an exact science to it because there have been times when the attacks were more severe, and I was not nervous at all.

In fact, I might be walking around Kyiv during one of the most serious ballistic missile strikes. Then there are other times when it may not be as serious, and everybody else is walking about, but I may be in my hotel room, very anxious.

I do not know the exact science behind these things, but I think there are psychological factors involved, depending on what you went through that day. Are you happy? Are you angry?

All of that can contribute to whether you experience fight-or-flight or choose to ignore it. There have been times when I have been more nervous than at other times.

Jacobsen: I have been here for more than four months. Across my three trips here, these three bombardments have been the most substantial ones during which I have been present.

During those three events, the feeling of terror was completely involuntary. Other bombardments had not really instigated an involuntary response like that.

During the May 24 and June 2 bombardments, I had trouble sleeping, so I slept in the bathroom, which, for me, has three walls as a barrier. During the June 15 bombardment, I slept in the closet.

Those were relatively large bombardments. So it is hit-or-miss what people consider dangerous. But the physiological sensation was completely involuntary.

The emotional interpretation usually came afterward, after processing the experience a bit more. Sleep deprivation can be a particular issue when first coming here. Then, over time, you get more used to it. You get over it, and your sleep cycle becomes more regular.

Even on regular days, when walking down the street and an air raid alarm goes off, no one really cares. People go about their day. They stay in the café, have their coffee, their croissants, their work, or whatever else.

So I want to make sure we have a conversation about those particular days, because they were substantially different from the others.

When residences, civilian centres, UNESCO sites, religious sites, museums, and cultural institutions are targeted, what does this signify to you about the use of these very expensive ballistic missiles to kill a dozen people and injure 50 to 150?

Richardson: I do not think it is a coincidence that you had the attack on the Lavra, and shortly after that, the attack on the Chornobyl Museum and other key sites. These are cultural targets. These are not military sites.

We provided pro bono publicity for Nahirna 22, a collection of Ukrainian Gen Z artists. They were bombed twice, once last August and then again in November. That is not a military site. That is the Russian military specifically targeting Gen Z artists.

So, yes, with the most recent bombing, it was surprising to see the Lavra targeted because you have a regime in Moscow that claims its entire political legitimacy from Kyivan Rus’. Then what does it do? It bombs the most holy site within that framework. So it begs the question: what are they trying to capture?

What you see is death and destruction. We saw that before with Chechnya. That is what we are seeing in many of the occupied territories here in Ukraine. There is a pattern with the Russian military: death and destruction.

So, no, I do not think it was a coincidence at all. They have been doing this for quite a while because the biggest threat to the Kremlin is Ukrainian culture and the Ukrainian people not wanting any part in Russian culture. It is a pretty significant marker of the difference between the two.

Jacobsen: How do people you know who have lived here for the full length of the full-scale invasion describe these bombardments?

Richardson: A lot of people sleep through them. Recently, the attacks have been harder to sleep through.

With the ones involving FPVs or Shaheds, you can sleep through them, especially now that the interceptors for Shaheds have gotten so good. But death evolves, and war evolves. Now, I do not think there are many people concerned about the Shaheds because the interceptors have gotten so good.

Russia is continuing to crank out the production of ballistic missiles. So, yes, I think it all depends on the person. It generally helps that it is summer right now. You are not having to go through persistent blackouts as you did in the winter. There is running water. I think it cannot be overstated how painful this winter was for people who were here.

Unfortunately, many innocent people were without heat.

Jacobsen: There was a Holocaust survivor who died of hypothermia.

Richardson: It is terrible. It was the coldest winter Ukraine had had since the 1990s. I think there is optimism now, though, with the strikes Ukraine is carrying out deep inside Russian territory, including strikes on oil refineries near Moscow.

So there is more optimism right now. But I think it is important to remember where we were in February, to be realistic about everything, and to enjoy the wins. Still, there is more to be done.

Jacobsen: Davis, thank you very much for your time.

Richardson: All right. Sounds good. Thanks, Scott.

Jacobsen: Bye, Davis.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Miro Vanadze on MMA, Ukraine, Georgia, and Fighting Russia

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/07

Miro Vanadze is a Georgian mixed martial artist and public figure from Batumi, recognized as a two-time WGFC MMA world champion. A pro-Ukraine volunteer fighter, he served with Ukraine’s 28th Mechanized Brigade after Russia’s full-scale invasion. Vanadze is the president of the President of the International Assembly of Georgian People, promoting Georgian-Ukrainian solidarity, civic advocacy, and resistance to Russian aggression through public campaigns and media appearances.

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen speaks with Miro Vanadze about Georgian and Ukrainian resistance to Russian aggression, his path from MMA champion to volunteer soldier, and the moral transformation caused by war. Vanadze reflects on Abkhazia, 2008, Ukraine’s defense, the Georgian Legion, saving civilians in Irpin, NATO-style training, drones, and why saving one life matters more than belts, titles, prizes, or a UFC dream amid a brutal imperial conflict and shared freedom struggle today.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: What were your first interests in military life and fighting?

Miro Vanadze: I will tell you now. At the beginning of the war, my interest and desire was to save people and stand for the truth. Because of my upbringing, I believed I had to be on the side of truth and help people who needed help. I chose the side of truth. That was the first reason I became interested when the war began. That is why I became a soldier.

Jacobsen: In 1801, 1921, and 2008, there are historical records of Russian domination, invasion, or war against Georgia. What did those events mean within Georgian culture?

Vanadze: In 1992–1993, during the war in Abkhazia, hundreds of thousands of ethnic Georgians were displaced from their homes, and thousands of people were killed. The territory came under the control of Abkhaz separatist forces backed by Russia. Then, in August 2008, war broke out again involving Georgia, Russia, South Ossetian forces, and Abkhaz forces. Our struggle for freedom continues. As long as Georgians are alive, we will continue to fight for our future.

Russia is an occupier. It has committed war crimes, killed people, and continues its aggression in Ukraine. We fought then, and we continue to fight now. I was very young in 2008, and I wanted to serve. I was not taken to war because I was too young, but I was ready. In the Abkhazia war, my grandfather died. Even my ancestors fought for freedom, and we continue to fight.

To be honest, in 1992, war began in Abkhazia, a region internationally recognized as part of Georgia. Many people lost their homes, and many were killed. During the 2008 war, I was very young, but I wanted to become a soldier and protect my country. I could not because I was too young. Our struggle continues today because we now have a very bad government, and it is closely connected to Russia.

It is Russia. The struggle is ongoing because many people are still staying in our capital, and they want something to change.

Jacobsen: In addition, there is a history of Russian invasions of Ukraine. In 1708, 1775, 1918–1919, 1939, and from 2014 to the present, Russia repeatedly attacked or dominated Ukraine. Do many Georgians take up arms in Ukraine because of that common victimization by Russia?

Vanadze: Historically, Russia has attacked Ukraine many times. The latest phase began in 2014, followed by the full-scale invasion in 2022. Many Georgians took up arms because we feel close to Ukrainians in facing the same enemy.

Russia has used this strategy for decades. Putin wants pieces of land from Georgia and Ukraine to put pressure on both countries. Then we have territorial problems, which Russia uses to obstruct our paths toward NATO and the European Union.

All empires have collapsed, and the Russian empire must collapse too. We must understand that Russia has to be defeated. Ukraine and Ukrainians have shown the whole world that Russia is not as powerful as it claimed. The so-called “second army of the world” has been exposed. Russia deliberately attacks civilians and civilian objects. That is what I see.

As for the question of many Georgians fighting on Ukraine’s side, I will say this: in 1992–1993, Ukrainian volunteers helped Georgia during the war in Abkhazia, including volunteers associated with UNA-UNSO. When the war in Ukraine started in 2014, hundreds of Georgians came to fight on Ukraine’s side. Now, Georgians are among the largest groups of foreign volunteers fighting for Ukraine.

I am proud to be part of this struggle for freedom. My friends were part of the historic Battle of Kyiv. We fought and continue to fight for freedom alongside Ukrainians.

Ukraine and Georgia have a very common victimizer: Russia. For Georgia, this is very familiar. Now, of course, we will try to help Ukraine. We remember that Ukrainians helped us a lot in 1992–1993 during the war in Abkhazia. They helped us, and now our goal is to help Ukraine.

Vanadze: What I can say is that all empires have been destroyed, but one empire is still alive: Russia. People around the world must understand that we now have to help Ukraine defeat this empire. In the last 30 years, Russia has invaded or intervened militarily in many countries, including Georgia, Ukraine, and Syria. It is one of the most dangerous states in the world.

Putin has spoken about restoring Russian imperial power and influence over former Soviet territories. We cannot allow Russia to rebuild the Soviet Union or dominate its neighbours again. One of the largest foreign volunteer formations in Ukraine is the Georgian Legion. I am proud to be part of this fight for freedom in Ukraine and Georgia.

Jacobsen: Where do you see the united motivation between your fighting history and your military history? What is the difference between fighting in the ring and fighting in war?

Vanadze: First of all, my physical training helped me during the war.

Second, the war changed my life. I became a completely different person. I used to be more cheerful, and I had more feelings for the world. But after so many losses, and after so many friends died, I became a different person.

The most important thing is that I have changed. I realized that I could become a five-time world champion, but the most important thing is saving lives. When you save lives and see the faces of the people you have helped, that is the most important thing for me.

I became a world champion in WGC. I had a chance to go to America, and I had a visa to continue fighting in an American promotion. It was my dream to become a UFC fighter. But when the war started, I took off my gloves, put them in the locker, and went to war. Saving one life is worth more than any belt, title, or prize.

Nothing can be more important to me than this. My career is not as important as the situation I am in now.

Jacobsen: When you think about wanting to attain world champion status before you had it, then winning the title several times, and now looking back, what was the importance of that title at each stage of your life?

Vanadze: Yes, of course, it is nice when I look back at my career. I am proud of it. But as an athlete, I could have gone further. I dreamed of following the path of fighters like Conor McGregor and Ilia Topuria, becoming a great fighter, a champion, and working with a major promotion.

But I do not regret it. I am proud that many fighters trained in my gym, and many of them became successful. To be honest, I am proud of my career.

Jacobsen: What was the first life you saved?

Vanadze: It was in Irpin. When we entered, there was a dangerous zone under Russian fire. During the evacuation, there were moments when any movement could mean death.

A grandmother was trying to cross into the danger zone. She was only about 200 metres from the Russian positions. She was elderly and heavy, and it was very difficult for her to move. I was with my friend, Djambulat. I told him we had to save her because, if the Russians reached her, they would almost certainly kill her.

Many soldiers told us not to go because it was impossible. They said the Russians would see our uniforms, and that if we crossed that open area, snipers or heavy-calibre weapons could kill us. But when I saw how difficult it was for the grandmother to move, I decided to take the risk. We went in, helped her, and pulled her out of the danger zone.

I always remember the feeling of entering that zone. I remember those feelings. It felt good to save those people. Yes, it was dangerous, but we did it. It was our duty.

Jacobsen: Would you say your military training or your fighting training was harder? Which was more difficult: your training as a sportsman or your military training?

Vanadze: When I was an athlete, I trained two or three times a day. But defending Ukraine and being part of the defence of freedom is an honour for me.

Of course, training with armour, helmets, weapons, and equipment weighing up to 50 kilograms was difficult. We moved and trained with that weight. It was hard physically. But mentally, military training was a little easier for me than sports training because I knew why I was doing it.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Miro.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Deconstructing Jokes, Trump, and the Reflecting Pool

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/07

Deconstructing Jokes, Trump, and the Reflecting Pool

Photo by Library of Congress on Unsplash

Rick Rosner explains joke deconstruction by contrasting Johnny Carson-era comedy with today’s information-heavy monologues. Scott Douglas Jacobsen asks how the Reflecting Pool controversy becomes comedy. Rosner outlines the setup: repairs, algae, sealant issues, Trump’s claims of leftist sabotage, and protesters mocking the situation. He distinguishes observations from jokes, tests angles involving “Everything Trump touches dies,” and concludes that the simpler “deflecting tool” pun has stronger late-night potential.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: How can a joke be deconstructed?

Rick Rosner: There are a couple of approaches. During Johnny Carson’s time on The Tonight Show, people had a lot less information. Carson’s information came from newspapers and wire services. They probably bought all the major news—or at least the major New York and Los Angeles newspapers. And they had a teletype, which was a machine with a little electric typewriter setup and a scroll of paper that would spit out AP news stories all day: breaking news. That was the source material.

They did not have people looking at TV as a source of material. They were looking at the news, at what people knew. The writers would write jokes off of that. And the jokes were easy and familiar, like Elizabeth Taylor putting on weight. Stuff that people already knew, because you could not count on people having a lot of information. The information just was not available in the same way.

Also, people maybe were not used to having shit explained to them. They were not used to getting the news from the monologue. Though things changed. Millions of people got the news from Jon Stewart during his heyday as host of The Daily Show.

So one way of doing jokes is to go off what everybody already knows. Another way is to explain what is going on, and then do jokes based on what you just told people. That is much more of a current style.

Anyway, the first step in deconstructing the Reflecting Pool story is to make sure you have all the pertinent information about the Reflecting Pool. It is about 100 years old. Does that matter? Maybe not. It has had leakage problems. That might be pertinent. Recent reporting says Trump first described the work as costing about $1.8 million, but later reports put the resurfacing or renovation costs around $14 million to $15 million, with a separate $1.7 million no-bid contract for a water-cleaning system.

The contract issue is not how this would normally be expected to work, and reporting has tied some of the work to Trump-connected or Trump-supporting figures. There have also been jokes about the contractor’s appearance—people comparing him to the Penguin from Batman or to an extra from Guys and Dolls. The guy looks like a mafia piece of shit.

This is the guy involved with work on the Reflecting Pool, which is about 2,028 feet long. It is a huge, long thing. It ranges from about 18 to 30 inches deep.

Jacobsen: Yes, I have been there. I have been there a couple of times, walking along it.

Rosner: You probably did not measure the depth.

Jacobsen: No, but you realize how big it is once you are there.

Rosner: It is enormous. Trump himself made the point that, if it were standing on end, it would be much taller than the Empire State Building.

Anyway, they drained the pool. This mafia-looking pool guy put in this fairly deep-blue pool sealant, which is important because the darker the color, the more heat it absorbs, and the hotter the pool gets. Another thing I have seen reported, though I have not independently verified it, is that the pool surface is stone or concrete with prior sealing and repair work. That matters because some sealants do not adhere well to surfaces that have already been sealed.

There are pumps underneath the thing. It must be a massive pump system to circulate the water.

Also, after the sealant was laid down, Trump drove his motorcade along the bottom of the pool. He got into his SUV, which is extremely heavy, and drove along the base of the pool. That probably was not great for the sealant either.

So, the pool supposedly gets fixed. Then it fills with algae. They try to fix it, in part, with hydrogen peroxide and other water-treatment measures. But given the size of the pool, it would take a serious treatment regime to solve the problem. Then either the heat, the hydrogen peroxide, the sealant failure, or some combination of things caused the sealant or coating to peel away and come up in the water. It started waving in the water or floating up in chunks.

People were curious. They might reach into the water and touch a chunk or pull a chunk up. Trump used this as an excuse to say that leftists were vandalizing the pool, pouring algae or other shit into the pool, or cutting away the sealant. There is no solid public evidence for that as the main explanation, but MAGA seems to be supporting that point, which is disturbing because this is one of the stupidest lies Trump has come up with.

He has National Guard or law-enforcement personnel stationed around the pool. If anybody puts a hand in the water, they risk being treated as if they are vandalizing it. There may even be undercover officers or plainclothes law-enforcement people posing as tourists. There is video of a young woman dipping her hand in the water. Some guy comes along, talks to her, and tells her to come over. Then there are cops and National Guard, and they take her away. It is all fucking ridiculous.

So that is your setup. If there is a topics person working on a show, either you come up with your own topics or the head writer suggests topics. I have been following this because I do not have a job and I have too much time on my hands. Not really—I just waste too much time. So I know more about this than maybe most late-night writers.

I would use my knowledge base to try to come up with something new about this situation. The one thing I can say is not a joke, exactly. It is just an observation: this is one of the craziest, stupidest things Trump has claimed, that leftists are sabotaging the pool.

There are protesters out there making fun of it and wearing Team Algae shirts. Trump is saying they hate America, that this is a beautiful monument, and that they are cheering for it not to be beautiful. No. They are cheering for Trump to stop being such a fucking asshole.

The thing I said is that Trump getting away with obvious lies about leftists and antifa sabotaging the pool, without significant pushback from his base, means he will feel free to make even crazier lies as needed. Though even if he did get pushback, he would still tell crazier lies whenever he wanted.

Is that a joke? No. It is just a principle.

I did another joke a couple of days ago based on Rick Wilson, a former Republican strategist who is now a Never Trumper. He came up with the principle, “Everything Trump touches dies.” Everything Trump gets involved with works out disastrously for all involved.

In this case, it is not true. This is an exception. Trump got involved with the Reflecting Pool, and algae thrives. Algae lives.

So it is also: Trump got involved with Iran, and Iran lives. Iran may be strengthened, depending on how the deal and regional situation play out. There have been claims about major funds, investment, or relief connected to Iran, and claims about tolls or pressure around the Strait of Hormuz, but those claims need careful verification.

So Trump touched Iran, and Iran may be revitalized. Is that a decent joke? No, because it is not very funny. It also takes a lot of explaining about the principle that everything Trump touches dies.

Would a host desperate for a new angle on the Reflecting Pool go this far to get to that not-really-jokey joke? Probably not. Somebody else, some other writer, would submit something funnier and more succinct.

The “deflecting tool” line might make it through as a quick pun. It made you laugh.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Hanna Rassamakhina on Ukraine’s Judicial System, Corruption Reform, and War Crimes Accountability

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/07

Hanna Rassamakhina on Ukraine’s Judicial System, Corruption Reform, and War Crimes Accountability

Photo by Jesus Monroy Lazcano on Unsplash

Hanna Rassamakhina is a Ukrainian lawyer, attorney, and international humanitarian law expert serving as Head of the War and Justice Department at the Media Initiative for Human Rights. She leads trial monitoring on war crimes and national security cases, focusing on accountability for crimes committed during Russia’s aggression against Ukraine. A graduate of Yaroslav Mudryi National Law University, she has worked in human rights protection since 2014, including at the Ukrainian Helsinki Human Rights Union.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Hanna Rassamakhina discuss how Russia’s full-scale invasion reshaped trust in Ukraine’s judicial system. Rassamakhina argues that while corruption still exists, post-2014 reforms and wartime accountability work have made courts more transparent and war-crimes proceedings comparatively resistant to corruption. The conversation contrasts Ukraine’s anti-corruption trajectory with Russia’s decline on Transparency International’s index, while stressing that public trust has risen most clearly around investigations and prosecutions related to war crimes in Ukraine today.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Did the war reduce the number of legal professionals in the country? Did people leave because of the threat, and did that affect the national judicial system?

Hanna Rassamakhina: Yes, certainly. It affected it. It is an interesting issue.

Before 2014, before the Revolution of Dignity, a professional judge was often associated with corruption. The same perception could apply to prosecutors and advocates. The system changed significantly after 2014.

After the full-scale invasion, one can say that the authority of the system increased. I am trying to find the right word, more transparent.

Jacobsen: What about now? There is a nuanced part to that. There are prosecutors, judges, and lawyers. Were all three sectors impacted, or were some impacted more than others by the evacuation of qualified professionals?

Rassamakhina: The word I was looking for is “trust.” Yes, citizens of Ukraine trust the court system and investigators more. If we distinguish between prosecutors, investigators, and judges, I do not have enough information to say definitively how attitudes toward each of these parts of the system have changed in the last four years.

It may be possible to assess this through social science research. I do not have enough information, but in general, one can say that trust in the system has increased significantly, particularly in the context of war crimes.

Jacobsen: Regarding the earlier remark about lawyers before the Revolution of Dignity, I would ask that this not be included in the final version. We can keep this academic by referring to third-party, non-Russian, non-Ukrainian international sources.

For example, the Corruption Perceptions Index from Transparency International, which measures perceived public-sector corruption rather than corruption in an absolute sense. In 2022, Ukraine scored 33 out of 100 and ranked 116th out of 180 countries, while Russia scored 28 and ranked 137th out of 180. In 2025, Ukraine scored 36 and ranked 104th out of 182 countries, while Russia scored 22 and ranked 157th out of 182. On that measure, Russia is perceived as significantly more corrupt than Ukraine.

At the same time, Ukraine has made documented efforts to reduce corruption, and its CPI score improved from 33 in 2022 to 36 in 2025. Russia, by contrast, declined from 28 in 2022 to 22 in 2025. So it is accurate to say that Ukraine has improved somewhat over time, while Russia has deteriorated on this index.

Within the legal profession, prosecutors, lawyers, and judges, this broader anti-corruption context is relevant, though the CPI itself does not measure those professions separately.

Jacobsen: What subtle changes do we observe at the national level of the judicial system with reductions in corruption, even if levels remain relatively high? For instance, does public perception change? Does trust in institutions change? Do practices change?

Rassamakhina: Sorry, do you mean in Ukraine or in the Russian Federation?

Jacobsen: I mean Ukraine as the main focus, but also as a comparative example with the aggressor state. It is important to comment on that as well. For example, if you look at women’s rights, they have improved more in Ukraine compared to the Russian Federation.

If you look at the Press Freedom Index from Reporters Without Borders, Ukraine ranks significantly higher than Russia. In recent rankings, Ukraine is placed in the mid-range globally, while the Russian Federation ranks near the bottom out of 180 countries. I am using your expertise and this example, along with law and the Corruption Perceptions Index, to build a factual narrative grounded in third-party analysis of how the two societies have been diverging during the war.

Rassamakhina: Yes, I understand what you mean. First, if we speak about corruption and anti-corruption in Ukraine, I do not have specialized expertise in this area. It is a separate and complex field, and I do not work directly in it.

I can speak from my experience as a lawyer. During the years after the Revolution of Dignity, social practices in the court system have changed significantly.

Before 2014, corruption could function almost like a service. If someone wanted to participate in corrupt practices, they could pay money and face little immediate risk.

Now, it is not a stable or accepted social practice. Corruption still exists, but it carries real risks for those involved. I say this as a private person observing the system from within.

If we speak about war crimes proceedings, in my view they are largely free from corruption. The reason is straightforward: there is no space for corruption to operate. There are no stakeholders who could benefit from it.

Those who committed these crimes are not participants in the trials. They are absent and have no involvement in the process. The other participants, victims, judges, investigators, and prosecutors, share a common interest: achieving accountability for those responsible for war crimes.

Because of this alignment of interests, this sphere is, in my view, free from corruption.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Hanna.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Dave Farina of Professor Dave Explains: Science Communication Against Pseudoscience

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/07

Dave Farina of Professor Dave Explains: Science Communication Against Pseudoscience

Photo by Hal Gatewood on Unsplash

Dave Farina as Public Science Communicator After Science Teacher

Dave Farina is a science communicator, educator, author, and YouTuber best known for the channel Professor Dave Explains. Dave Farina is a science communicator, educator, author, and YouTube creator best known for the channel Professor Dave Explains. It is not a formal title, but a persona. Farina earned a Bachelor of Arts in Chemistry from Carleton University and a master of Arts in Science Education from California State University, Northridge. In a prior professional role, before working in online critical thinking and science education content, he taught at the high school and undergraduate levels, especially in chemistry.

He launched Professor Dave Explains in January, 2015. He presents work on astronomy, biochemistry, biology, chemistry, physics, and related subjects. The subject matter of particular interest to the general public on his channel has been his critical thinking, caustic humour, and commentary on pseudoscience, conspiracy claims, creationism, science denial, and the like. The channel, a little more than a decade after its founding, has grown to a staggering 4.31 million subscribers and approximately 2,000 videos. To be clear, as should be obvious, he is not a formal tenure-track professor or a full professor. It is a public branding title. He has covered a large number of individuals, which will be covered briefly here today. He takes the Discovery Institute particularly to task and anti-vaccination activists. Here’s a briefing on some of the more prominent people he has covered, along with their claims and the reality afterward.

Creationism, intelligent design, and anti-evolution apologetics

Casey Luskin, lawyer and writer at the Discovery Institute, claims intelligent design provides a scientific alternative to evolutionary biology. The reality: mainstream biology regards intelligent design as a form of creationism. No testable, predictive research programme.

Stephen Meyer, a philosopher of science and author at the Discovery Institute, claims that biological information points to an intelligent designer. The reality: evolutionary biology and origin-of-life research explain biological complexity through natural mechanisms—an area of active investigation without requiring design as a scientific inference.

Michael Behe, biochemist and intelligent-design advocate, claims some biological systems are “irreducibly complex.” Therefore, they could not have evolved gradually. The reality is that mainstream evolutionary biology presents plausible evolutionary pathways.

William Dembski, mathematician and philosopher, claims “specified complexity” can detect design in nature. The reality is that his design-detection framework is neither accepted in mainstream science nor regarded as a reliable empirical method.

Jonathan Wells, an intelligent-design writer, claimed common textbook examples of evolution are misleading. The reality is that the evidentiary basis for evolution remains robust across genetics, paleontology, and comparative anatomy.

Günter Bechly, paleontologist and intelligent-design advocate, claims gaps or abrupt appearances in the fossil record challenge Darwinian evolution. The reality is that fossil incompleteness is expected in paleontology. Evolutionary relationships are supported by converging fossil and genetic evidence.

Jonathan McLatchie, an intelligent-design apologist, claims molecular biology supports design over evolution. The reality is that mainstream molecular biology supports common descent and evolutionary mechanisms.

John G. West, Discovery Institute senior fellow, argues that Darwinian evolution has harmful cultural and moral implications. The reality is that the scientific validity of evolution depends exclusively on the evidence.

Douglas Axe, a molecular biologist and intelligent-design advocate, claims functional proteins are too improbable. The reality: evolutionary biology frames a cumulative process of selection, mutation, recombination, drift, and historical contingency as the evidence.

Kent Hovind, a young-Earth creationist evangelist, claims the Earth is only thousands of years old and evolution is false. The reality is that genetics, geology, radiometric dating, and paleontology converge on an old Earth and common ancestry.

Ken Ham, founder of Answers in Genesis, claims the book of Genesis provides the correct history. The reality is that mainstream science treats creation narratives from religious texts not as empirical models of natural history.

James Tour, a synthetic chemist and critic of origin-of-life research, claims scientists are far from explaining life’s beginning. The reality: origin-of-life research remains incomplete, but incompleteness does not justify substituting supernatural design.

Subboor Ahmad, a Muslim creationist apologist, claims evolution is scientifically incompatible with theistic belief. The reality is that evolutionary biology is among the most strongly supported frameworks in modern science.

Muslim Lantern, a Muslim apologetics channel/persona, presents anti-evolution arguments in religious-apologetic contexts. The reality is that standard evolutionary theory is supported independently of theology. Either accept the science or reject the unscientific religious interpretation.

Frank Turek, a Christian apologist, argues against naturalism and often presents evolution as inadequate. The reality: methodological naturalism is the working basis of science.

Rob Stadler, a creationist/intelligent-design commentator, argues against evolution and abiogenesis. The reality: objections from creationist media do not overturn the broad evidence for evolution.

Mind, consciousness, and anti-materialist neuroscience claims

Michael Egnor, a neurosurgeon and Discovery Institute writer, claims that materialist neuroscience cannot adequately explain the mind and consciousness. The reality is that neuroscience does not claim to have fully solved the problem of consciousness. Consciousness is deeply linked to brain function.

Vaccine, COVID-19, and public-health misinformation

Andrew Wakefield, a former physician, claimed an association between the MMR vaccine and autism. The reality: his paper was retracted, he lost his UK medical licence, and large-scale studies have found no causal link.

RFK Jr., a political figure and vaccine critic, claims that public health institutions have misrepresented vaccine safety. The scientific consensus is that the benefits of vaccines overwhelmingly outweigh their risks.

Steve Kirsch, technology entrepreneur and vaccine critic, claims that COVID-19 vaccines caused mass harm at levels hidden by authorities. The reality is that surveillance data show that serious adverse events are rare.

Pierre Kory, physician and ivermectin advocate, claims ivermectin was unfairly dismissed as a COVID-19 treatment. The reality is that high-quality clinical evidence has not supported the use of ivermectin.

Aaron Siri, a lawyer associated with vaccine litigation, challenges vaccine approvals and safety regulations. The reality: legal challenges do not substitute for the totality of clinical-trial and epidemiological safety evidence.

Bret Weinstein, an evolutionary biologist and public commentator, has promoted vaccine-skeptic and institutional-distrust narratives. The reality is that scientific claims about public health must be judged by clinical and epidemiological evidence. A generalized formulation of distrust of institutions isn’t a scientific claim.

Flat Earth, Moon-landing denial, and space conspiracies

David Weiss, a Flat Earth advocate, claims Earth is not a globe and that space agencies conceal this. The reality: Earth’s spherical shape is confirmed by navigation, astronomy, satellite technology, physics, and direct observation.

Eric Dubay, a Flat Earth author, claims to have hundreds of proofs that Earth is flat. The reality: Flat Earth arguments rely on misunderstandings of gravity, optics, and scale.

Austin Witsit, Flat Earth debater, argues against the globe model. The reality is that the globe model accurately predicts celestial observations, circumnavigation, satellite motion, and time zones.

Lord Jamar, musician and public figure, promoted Flat Earth claims. The reality is that celebrity advocacy does not change the overwhelming physical and observational evidence.

Jeranism, a Flat Earth content creator, promoted Flat Earth arguments and later became known, in part, through debates and experiments. The reality: empirical tests repeatedly support Earth’s curvature and rotation.

Bart Sibrel, a Moon-landing denier, claims the Apollo landings were faked. The reality is that the Apollo missions are supported by extensive historical documentation.

Candace Owens, a political commentator, promoted conspiratorial claims about space and public institutions. The reality is that claims about astronomy, satellites, and spaceflight are testable and supported by independent global evidence.

Pseudoarchaeology, ancient astronauts, lost civilizations, and speculative history

Graham Hancock, an alternative-history author, claims advanced lost civilizations influenced ancient cultures before recorded history. The reality is that archaeologists find no evidence of such a globally advanced civilization.

Jimmy Corsetti, an alternative-history media figure, promotes lost-civilization and ancient-mystery claims. The reality is that extraordinary claims about ancient technology require archaeological evidence that has not been produced.

Dan Richards, a pseudoarchaeology commentator, promotes alternative narratives about the ancient past. The reality is that mainstream archaeology relies on dating methods, material culture, stratigraphy, and peer-reviewed interpretation.

Ben van Kerkwyk, host of UnchartedX, argues that ancient civilizations possessed advanced lost technologies. The reality: evidence does not support claims of the loss of industrial or high-energy technologies.

Billy Carson, an alternative-knowledge media entrepreneur, promotes ancient-astronaut and esoteric-history claims. The reality: ancient-astronaut claims are not credible archaeological/historical evidence.

Metatron, a YouTube commentator, makes contested historical/cultural claims. The reality is that historical claims require archaeological context, expert review, primary sources, and linguistic evidence.

Fringe physics, cosmology, mathematics, and “theory of everything” claims

Terrence Howard, actor, promotes personal theories about mathematics and physics. The reality: his claims conflict with basic, established physical theory.

Wal Thornhill, Electric Universe advocate, claimed electricity plays the dominant role in cosmic structure. The reality: Electric Universe cosmology is not accepted as a replacement for gravity-based cosmology, relativity, or standard astrophysics.

Ben Davidson, SpaceWeatherNews/Suspicious0bservers figure, promotes catastrophic solar and geophysical claims. The reality is that mainstream solar physics does not support doomsday interpretations.

Pierre-Marie Robitaille, a former radiology professor, promotes nonstandard solar and cosmological claims. The reality is that mainstream astrophysics supports the standard solar model through spectroscopy and nuclear physics.

Eric Weinstein, mathematician and public intellectual, promotes a personal physics framework and claims institutional science suppresses outsiders. The reality is that new physics requires formal models, testable predictions, and peer scrutiny.

Chris Langan, known for high-IQ claims, promotes the CTMU as a theory of reality. The reality: a theory of everything must generate clear, testable, peer-engaged scientific or philosophical arguments, which the CTMU has not established in mainstream scholarship.

Avi Loeb, Harvard astrophysicist, argues some interstellar objects may plausibly be artificial technology. The reality is that such hypotheses are scientifically discussable and remain speculative until supported by strong, independent evidence.

Quantum mysticism, spirituality-as-science, and paranormal claims

Deepak Chopra, an alternative spirituality author, uses quantum language to support claims about consciousness. The reality is that quantum mechanics does not support the mystical or medical claims.

Sadhguru, a spiritual teacher, makes science-flavoured spiritual and metaphysical claims. The reality is that spiritual insight is not equivalent to empirical evidence.

Ky Dickens, filmmaker behind The Telepathy Tapes, promotes claims about telepathy and autism. The reality is that telepathy has not been demonstrated under reliable scientific controls.

Aviation, UFO, and extraordinary-technology conspiracies

Ashton Forbes, an internet conspiracy figure, promotes extraordinary claims about missing-aircraft imagery and advanced technology. The reality is that extraordinary aviation or UFO claims require verifiable evidence.

Climate-risk minimization

Matt Ridley, a writer and political commentator, has minimized or disputed aspects of mainstream climate-risk framing. The reality: mainstream climate science shows human greenhouse-gas emissions are warming the planet.

Institutional distrust, science-criticism, and culture-war amplification

Denis Noble, a systems biologist, criticizes gene-centric interpretations of evolution. The reality is that evolutionary biology already includes genes, development, systems biology, and population processes.

Sabine Hossenfelder, physicist and science communicator, argues that parts of modern physics suffer from sociological and methodological problems. The reality: criticism of scientific incentives can be legitimate while broad claims that science is “failing” require careful qualification.

Tucker Carlson, a political commentator, has platformed creationist or conspiratorial claims. The reality is that media amplification does not make a scientific claim stronger.

Matt Walsh, a political commentator, promotes culture-war critiques of scientific and medical institutions. The reality: scientific and medical claims must be evaluated by consensus review, evidence, and methodological quality.

Jay Dyer, a religious and political commentator, advances polemical claims about culture, religion, and science. The reality: polemical certainty does not substitute for scientific evidence or disciplined scholarship.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Redesigning Intelligence Tests for the AI Era

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/07

Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner examine how intelligence testing could evolve beyond conventional IQ exams. Rosner proposes a reality-competition format built around practical challenges, collaboration, and AI-assisted problem solving. They discuss the limitations of sequence puzzles, massive datasets, OEIS, and the growing importance of collective intelligence. The conversation then turns to universal grammar, multilingual neural networks, emergent representations, and whether language reflects innate structures or learned probabilistic patterns shaped by human cognition and experience.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Run this by me: if you were designing an intelligence test based on a broader definition of intelligence, how would you do it?

Rick Rosner: You would make it a fucking television show. I pitched such an idea with other people. You would structure it like American Idol or Project Runway, the fashion competition associated with Heidi Klum.

You would make it a reality competition. You would begin with approximately 20 people who claimed to be highly intelligent or had already been recognized for their intelligence. Then, week by week, you would give them a series of challenges and eliminate one or two contestants at a time.

You would require people to demonstrate intelligence by completing practical challenges. That is one problem with conventional IQ tests: they present challenges without practical consequences. When you finish taking an IQ test, the work you have done has not changed anything in the world. You have merely spent a great deal of time completing it.

Jacobsen: My experience with those communities is that they contain many highly intelligent people. However, you may also be more likely to encounter cognitively unevenly developed individuals who are exceptionally strong in one area.

Rosner: Yes. Another consideration comes from my experience writing for television. I have sometimes written material independently, but I have often collaborated with other people.

That is probably an increasingly common model because the means of collaborating—with other people and now with AI—are becoming more accessible. It is becoming easier and easier to work collaboratively.

Therefore, if you are going to measure intelligence, you should probably find a way to measure something other than lone-wolf intelligence because that is not how people generally work now. People do not work entirely in isolation from technology, using only a pencil and paper. They also do not work in isolation from other people.

Jacobsen: How would you make an intelligence test capable of adapting to AI? Is that even a reasonable question, or would the test need to measure practical abilities extending beyond AI?

Rosner: In talking with Chris, he asked, “Do you have any other difficult problems that I can give to AI?” I gave him a couple of problems, and he said, “I do not want anything based on trivia.”

That raises a problem: given an AI system’s enormous training dataset, almost anything can become trivia. If somebody has solved a mathematical problem and posted the solution somewhere accessible, that information may be incorporated into an AI system’s training data.

There is a website called the On-Line Encyclopedia of Integer Sequences, or OEIS. It has existed in an online form since the mid-1990s, building on an earlier database, and now contains nearly 400,000 integer sequences.

If somebody has discovered and submitted a sufficiently interesting sequence, it may be listed there. AI systems may also have encountered OEIS material or discussions derived from it during training, although the precise contents of proprietary training datasets are generally not public.

Consequently, if you create a mathematical sequence for an IQ test, somebody may already have identified it, or you may have created a variation of a known sequence. AI systems can also apply mathematical transformations and pattern-recognition methods to compare one sequence with others.

With a sufficiently large dataset, many problems that appear to require intuition can instead be approached through retrieval, pattern matching, or recombination. A system with broad access to previously recorded information may not need to reproduce the same kind of intuition that a person uses.

Our brains also contain a great deal of information, but that does not mean we can consciously access all of it when confronting a difficult problem. Human brains are highly associative, so we are probably fairly good at drawing relevant connections. However, we do not have an AI system’s ability to process enormous quantities of stored data and search for associations across them at great speed.

I do not know exactly how you would design an intelligence test that accounts for this. I have given you some guidelines for what the modern deployment of cleverness might look like, and it does not resemble a single person sitting alone and scribbling with a pencil in 1840.

Modern testing, assuming it should continue to exist in this form, needs to reflect that reality.

Jacobsen: Do you believe in universal grammar?

Rosner: Not exactly. I believe that grammatical relationships can emerge from the requirements of communication.

Words function as symbols or tokens. They can refer to objects and events in the world, as well as to abstract concepts. Every language has conventions for arranging those tokens to communicate meaning.

Languages therefore develop ways of representing relationships among things, actions, agents, and recipients. When you combine a noun with a verb, for example, the noun may identify something performing an action or something affected by an action.

You could create a map of those relationships. Every language has preferred ways of expressing relationships among words, although the particular structures and rules vary considerably across languages.

Multilingual machine-learning systems can develop shared internal representations across languages. As a simplified analogy, imagine a kind of unspoken intermediate map containing representations of concepts and their relationships.

Suppose this abstract representation contains a symbol—call it “blurp”—associated with the concept of love. “Blurp” could correspond to words expressing love across many languages. When translating an English sentence into Portuguese, the model would not necessarily translate the English word into a literal intermediate word and then into Portuguese. Instead, it could encode the sentence into distributed numerical representations that capture aspects of its meaning and then generate a Portuguese sentence from those representations.

That is only an analogy, not a literal description of a fixed internal language used by Google Translate. Multilingual neural networks can learn shared representations that help them translate between several languages, including some language pairs for which they received little or no direct training. However, researchers should not assume that these representations constitute a complete or stable “interlingua.”

A large language model may similarly develop internal representations of grammatical and semantic relationships. Is that a universal language? No. It is a learned, probabilistic representation derived from the languages and examples on which the model was trained.

It is not universal grammar in the strict linguistic sense. It is an emergent statistical model of which words and structures are likely to occur in particular contexts.

Human brains have evolved capacities that make language acquisition possible. Children are predisposed to attend to speech, recognize patterns, acquire vocabulary, and infer grammatical regularities. That does not, by itself, prove that every human language is generated from one detailed, genetically specified universal grammar.

It may instead mean that human beings possess biological capacities that allow them to develop probabilistic and structural models of whichever languages they encounter. Those models guide us in arranging words according to patterns acquired through experience.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Tatiana Protcheva on NFC Stones, QR Embroidery, and Ukrainian Digital Art

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/07

Tatiana Protcheva is a Ukrainian mechanical engineer, textile artist, and digital-craft innovator living in Toronto. Inspired by mathematics, embroidery, and global travel, she transformed glow-in-the-dark thread, QR codes, and NFC chips into interactive Ukrainian cultural art. She founded a private embroidery museum, represented Ukraine internationally, and now creates smart stones, watches, ties, and accessories for promotion, memory preservation, mental-health support, archival storytelling, and diaspora engagement across communities.

In this interview with Scott Douglas Jacobsen, Tatiana Protcheva traces her path from engineering to embroidery, public exhibitions, and NFC-enabled art. She explains how glow-in-the-dark thread led to Ukrainian cultural projects, how QR codes expanded textile storytelling, and how natural stones became smart accessories. Protcheva discusses practical testing, chip sizes, epoxy sealing, phone scanning, and user reactions, while presenting technology as a humane tool for networking, archives, promotion, mental-health support, and Ukraine’s global cultural presence.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: So, why did you focus on engineering in your education and early career?

Tatiana Protcheva: My mother was a mathematics teacher. I liked engineering because it was connected to mathematics, and I became a mechanical engineer. I also liked history.

At first, I was interested in embroidery. When I was working in Japan in 2005, a woman gave me a special thread – glow-in-the-dark thread. I did not know about this material before.

She spoke Japanese, and I spoke only a little English. When I came back to the hotel and saw the embroidery thread on the table, I thought it was interesting.

I did not know how to use it. It was a shock for me. Then, the next year, I was in Israel, in Tel Aviv, and the Ministry of Economy gave me a tour of holy places. I had an idea: I could use this special thread in an icon.

I started using it. Then, in 2010, I went to Shanghai for Expo 2010. The Ministry of Economy invited me to promote Ukraine. One man came to the Ukrainian pavilion and asked me, “Can I buy your collection?”

I asked, “Why do you need it?” He said, “I have a museum in Shanghai. I want it to be part of my collection.” I said, “Okay, I have a program with the government now, so I cannot talk. We can talk when the Expo is finished.”

During that time, I kept thinking, “Why do I need to sell this collection? I can open a private museum of embroidery in Ukraine.” When I returned to Ukraine, I opened my private museum. It was really successful because people came not only from different parts of Ukraine, but also from different countries, including Australia and Brazil. I promoted it, added information on TripAdvisor, and people booked visits. It was really successful.

Then, for Expo 2020 in Dubai, which was held in 2021 and 2022, I went again. Afterward, I could not return to my country. One family invited me to Florida. I lived in Orlando for one year. After that, I came to Toronto, and now I live in Toronto. In Toronto, it is not easy to start a new life with only one suitcase after travelling around the world.

I did not try to find a job because I had an interesting idea connected to my art. My son is a dentist. He said to me, “Mom, you are an engineer. I think you need to study how NFC works. It will be part of the future.” I researched everything for more than one year, and now I have started this business.

I find beautiful natural stones and encode information into an NFC chip. I integrate the chip into a beautiful accessory. Now, I have come to Ukraine to visit my son and my family, and also for medical reasons. I have an idea for a project: “Ukraine Without War,” meaning a quiet Ukraine. I want to translate it more correctly: “Ukraine Without Words.”

Because I feel that, not only in Ukraine but around the world, people need help with mental health. In Toronto, I see many immigrants, including Ukrainian people, who need mental health support. My idea is to encode each stone with something helpful. For example, one stone can contain relaxing music. Another stone can contain a motivational topic. I do not know the exact words in English. I have this program in Ukrainian. When I translate it, maybe I will send you what I want to encode. But, in general, it is for mental health.

Jacobsen: For those who may not know how these systems work, why use stone rather than metal?

Protcheva: Because stone works well with an NFC chip. When I tried the chip with metal, it was blocked. It did not work. That came from my own experiment, because during one year of research, I did not only research theoretically. I also researched practically. I bought many different NFC chips in different sizes. For example, you can see that one is big and another is small. I tried everything. When I tried metal, it did not work. When I tried wood, it worked. With stone, it worked. Stone is a natural material.

Jacobsen: It creates less interference. What about QR codes and making those pieces of art, including things like watches? How did you choose the watches? How did you take them apart, and how did you make the QR codes part of the art?

Protcheva: In Miami, every week on Lincoln Road, there is a vintage market. Usually, I like to go to vintage markets and buy vintage things. Then I saw a very beautiful watch, and I wanted to cover it.

It was a watch, maybe from a famous brand, but what was inside was not important. For me, the cover was very important. It looked very beautiful.

I bought the watch. Some watches are easier to open. I can open the cover with a small knife and take everything out. With some watches, it is not possible. I tried to find a watch repair company, and it was not easy. They helped me open the watch. Then I researched famous people who have Ukrainian roots, e.g., Leonardo DiCaprio and Sylvester Stallone.

Then I found information on Wikipedia about these famous people, and I made a record from this link. It is interesting. I gave this project the name “Time for Ukraine,” because it is really true. First, it is related to time because it uses watches. Second, it is for Ukraine because it is about Ukraine and promotes Ukraine. Now, at this time, it is really important. When I was in Los Angeles, I asked people, “Did you know Sylvester Stallone has Ukrainian roots?” They said, “No, we did not know.”

I think I really have good material to show how talented Ukrainian people are. But it was also a surprise for me when I started researching which famous people have Ukrainian heritage.

Jacobsen: Ukraine has a very strong IT culture. Certain big cities in India are very IT-savvy. The same is true in Ukraine.

Even when you go to the old metro built during the Soviet period, people can use their credit cards. If you go to Israel, Vancouver, or Toronto, you have a Compass Card, a PRESTO card, and so on. Here, you can get a transit card, but you can also use your bank card directly.

That is a small example, but you see it throughout the country in terms of IT and technical proficiency. It is not only technical proficiency. The culture is very friendly to technology, in a way similar to South Korea or Japan. Naturally, Japan and South Korea have some of the most advanced technology in the world, outside places such as San Francisco, Los Angeles, and the major technology companies.

In general, I like how your art incorporates something very smart about the culture here. Technology, if it is used for everyday purposes, has very few downsides. It typically makes life easier. Or, if it does not make life easier, it allows people to do more things.

What has been the positive feedback, and what has been the negative feedback, on the art? Whether it is QR codes or other forms of digital recognition and identification, what feedback have you heard?

Protcheva: I have not heard negative feedback. I feel only positive reactions. Usually, I go to the Small Business Expo in Miami every year. I also go to New York for some IT exhibitions. People say, “Wow.” But I see that not everybody knows about this innovation.

I explain it this way: It is like going to a hotel and using your card to open the door. It is easy. It is also used in public transport. You touch your card to the machine, and you have your ticket. It is so easy. But people do not always know how it works. Sometimes people are a little afraid when I show it, as if it is something magical. But it is simple, absolutely simple.

Yesterday, my friend told me, “Wow, I gave a present with NFC.” She bought some pieces from me for promotion. When she gave one to someone from a company, he reacted like a child. It was new for him.

In the business community, I see that the younger generation usually understands it. When I say “NFC,” I do not need to explain what it means. They just take their phone from their pocket, tap it, and say, “Okay, go, go, go.” At some events, especially with IT companies, people do not even ask for a traditional business card. They just say, “Please, what do you do? What is your business?” There is almost no long conversation. We save the contact and then think later about what we need. It is easier for promotion.

You know, networking is very popular now. How can I represent myself in one minute, or even 30 seconds? This is one way. I make a short promotional speech about it. It is easy. Please, be open to this.

Jacobsen: From an engineering perspective, how does NFC work? From a business perspective, what is the attraction for Ukrainians? Why do they use it?

Protcheva: Because we do not need an app. We only need the internet. It is easy and very fast. You just tap it, and that is all. All the information appears on your phone. It is easy for promotion.

In the business community, it is very helpful. But now I have found another interesting direction: an archive, or a history stone. For example, when the war started, my son was here. What did he take? Only a bank card, car keys, and that was all. He had to run.

With this archive stone, people can put all their photos and documents into Google Drive. It is like a tree of life. I encode only the Google Drive link into the NFC chip. People can order different information, and the file can grow more and more. The link stays the same. It is like an archive stone. You see?

Jacobsen: Is that glitter glue?

Protcheva: I put resin on it. It is a special resin for waterproofing, Epoxy. Epoxy resin.

Jacobsen: Yes, it is very, very tough.

Protcheva: It is waterproof because you need protection. It is not easy. I studied everything to understand how it works. My apartment is like a workshop. When somebody visits, they ask, “What is this? Do you live here, or do you work here?”

Jacobsen: So, basically, you carve a bit of the rock out, put the NFC chip inside, and then seal it with epoxy. Yes?

Protcheva: Yes. Stone, chip, epoxy.

Jacobsen: Where do you get the chip?

Protcheva: I buy them online.

Jacobsen: How do you encode the information?

Protcheva: I use a special program. I researched everything. I spent one year studying it. There are many nuances. For example, on an iPhone, you scan one part of the phone. On Android, it is usually the middle of the phone. You need to know where to tap. There are many different nuances. But I created my own website, and I promote and explain this there. I am happy.

Jacobsen: What was the hardest part to learn and to do before making this product?

Protcheva: At first, I was afraid. I could not find a lot of clear information. Different chips work with different programs. It is not easy to make everything work together.

For example, one type of chip works with one program, but another type of chip does not work with that program. The size is also different. If it is a small chip, it cannot hold a lot of information. If we need more information, we need a bigger chip because of the antenna size. For example, a small antenna cannot hold or transmit as much information. A bigger one can do more.

I bought bigger chips because I also make textile art. I put large chips into my textile art. There are many different possibilities.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Tatiana.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Yuriy Boyechko on Russian Drone Warfare and Civilian Terror in Kherson

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/06

Yuriy Boyechko on Russian Drone Warfare and Civilian Terror in Kherson

Photo by Glib Albovsky on Unsplash

Yuriy Boyechko is a Ukrainian-American humanitarian leader and the founder and CEO of Hope For Ukraine, a U.S.-based nonprofit providing aid to civilians affected by Russia’s war against Ukraine. Under his leadership, the organization delivers medical supplies, evacuation support, and emergency relief to frontline regions, including Kherson. Boyechko works closely with local networks to document evolving threats to civilian life, including drone warfare tactics and urban targeting patterns. He frequently briefs media and policymakers on conditions on the ground, emphasizing both the humanitarian consequences of modern warfare and the urgent need for international attention and support.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen interviews Yuriy Boyechko, founder and CEO of Hope for Ukraine, about Russian drone warfare and remote mining in Kherson. Boyechko describes cloth-wrapped booby traps, “gingerbread” mines, FPV drone attacks, shrinking civilian life, and aid workers operating under constant surveillance. He frames Kherson as a war crime scene where civilians, including children and the elderly, face daily injuries, deaths, displacement, and psychological terror from concealed mines and low-cost drones across the city today.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: You describe a “terrifying new shift” in drone tactics. For context, how have tactics changed since earlier in the year, and what makes this a radical shift?

Yuriy Boyechko: First of all, thanks for having me, Scott, and for discussing this important subject. Our teams have been working in Kherson since the liberation. To set the stage, roughly 60,000 to 70,000 civilians remain there.

Russian forces have been targeting civilians with drones, what locals call a “human safari”, since last year. Starting in March, we began seeing extensive remote mining, with drones dropping small anti-personnel mines. Some are roughly donut-sized and very hard to spot, especially in parks or grass.

Children or other civilians can step on them and be seriously injured or killed. These mines are not aimed at military targets; they pose a direct threat to civilians. In March and April, there were reports of what locals call prianiki, “gingerbread” mines, because of their shape.

More recently, Russian forces have reportedly dropped small booby traps wrapped in cloth or rags. On the road, they can look like pieces of fabric or debris, but local officials and mine specialists describe them as sophisticated explosive devices. Preliminary reports indicate some may be electronically controlled.

When they are dropped, an operator may be positioned across the Dnipro River from Kherson and able to detonate them remotely. This creates a combined threat: drones overhead and concealed explosives underfoot.

Our teams distribute food and humanitarian aid in the city. I spoke to one of our local leaders on Sunday, and she said areas previously considered safe for distribution are no longer safe.

When teams deliver aid to residents living in basements, they may have only a 10- to 15-minute window to get in and out. In addition to watching for drones, they now have to watch every step to avoid concealed mines.

Jacobsen: I mean, from a human rights perspective, is a fundamental issue with this type of mine the fact that it is indiscriminate?

Boyechko: Yes. Kherson is, in many ways, one large war crime scene. The purpose of these tactics is psychological warfare.

They are trying to make the city so dangerous for civilians that the roughly 60,000 people who still live there either leave or are killed. The goal appears to be to empty the city. That has been the broader tactic.

We have been working with human rights activists and the media to bring this to public attention. The individuals responsible should be prosecuted, because these devices affect civilians, older adults and children.

Some reports indicate that earlier “gingerbread” mines (prianiki) were designed to resemble everyday objects. There are claims that they were made to appear harmless, increasing the risk that civilians, including children, might approach them.

This is an extreme form of targeting civilians. It reflects a pattern of attacks that place noncombatants at risk, rather than engaging military targets.

Jacobsen: What was the original population of Kherson, and what is the population now so that people can understand the scale of the decline?

Boyechko: Originally, about 200,000 to 250,000 people lived there. Now, roughly 60,000 remain. There is a part of Kherson called the Korabelnyi district, near the river. That area is essentially a ghost town. During the day, you may not see a single person on the street.

The skies there are dominated by Russian drones. If someone leaves home and tries to walk, the chances of returning safely are very low. The Ukrainian government has tried to install protective nets over some streets to shield civilians, but the area is too large to cover completely.

It is a very difficult situation. Sixty thousand people are still a significant population; people go to work, and children continue schooling, mostly remotely, as in-person classes are limited.

Even basic movement is risky. Before leaving homes or basements, people often open a window to listen for the buzzing sound of drones. If they hear it, they stay inside.

Aid distribution has adapted to these conditions. Our teams often operate under tree cover to avoid detection by drones. They park vehicles beneath large trees to reduce visibility. Now, there is also concern about mines hidden in the grass.

It is a very serious situation. Based on reports from our teams, there are daily civilian casualties, on average, three to five people injured or killed by drones or mines. This does not include larger-scale strikes; it reflects these newer tactics.

Jacobsen: Has the primary target always been civilians, or has there been a noticeable increase in civilian targeting, particularly in Kherson?

Boyechko: With these newer methods, the pattern has intensified. There is a view that Russian forces aim to retake Kherson but cannot do so militarily, so they are attempting to make the city uninhabitable.

This approach has escalated since around October last year. With newer devices, such as cloth-wrapped explosive traps, the methods appear more sophisticated.

There are also claims that some of these incidents are recorded and shared on social media, showing drone operators targeting individuals. These reports require verification, but they have been widely discussed locally.

Efforts are underway to document these actions and identify those responsible. Local awareness of units operating across the river is high. Questions of accountability remain, including when and how those responsible may face legal consequences, and how seriously the international community responds to conditions in Kherson.

Jacobsen: Have these newer versions been deconstructed? If so, where are the components coming from? What are their likely sources?

Boyechko: I do not have a definitive answer to that, especially regarding sourcing. These newer devices, including the cloth-wrapped mines, have only recently been identified.

Based on reports from the ground, they appear to be relatively advanced, as they can be detonated remotely. That suggests more sophisticated components. I cannot confirm their origin, but some observers question whether all such technology is produced domestically in Russia.

Earlier devices, such as the so-called “gingerbread” mines (prianiki), may involve simpler construction. These newer versions appear more complex. The drones used, often FPV drones, also include components widely available on global markets. Some analysts suggest supply chains may include foreign-made parts, though this requires verification.

Jacobsen: Have these new mines increased civilian casualties, or do they mainly represent a more sophisticated threat without a clear rise in casualties?

Boyechko: Civilian casualties appear to have increased significantly, potentially several times higher in the city.

When discussing casualties, we have to consider drones, drone strikes, kamikaze drones, and these mines together. As I mentioned earlier, reports indicate that three to five civilians are injured or killed each day by drones or mines.

Looking back at last year, it wasn’t like this. There were missile and artillery strikes, but those occurred less frequently, perhaps once a week or every couple of weeks. Now, the threat is constant and daily.

The only periods of relative safety are during rain or fog, when drone visibility is reduced. Our teams have adapted accordingly. Earlier in the war, after liberation in 2023, access to Kherson was comparatively straightforward. There were risks, but operations were simpler.

Now, delivering aid requires extensive planning, sometimes a week of preparation. The situation changes quickly, so we rely on frequent updates from local authorities, sometimes hourly, about which streets may contain mines. That information helps our teams choose safer routes and reduce risk.

Jacobsen: Do these more sophisticated drones cost more?

Boyechko: No, they are relatively inexpensive. The drones responsible for most of the damage can cost about $500 each. That affordability allows constant surveillance over the city.

Typically, a surveillance drone hovers overhead, and operators then deploy cheaper FPV drones to strike targets. For example, people still use public transport in Kherson when they have to travel. Buses and other vehicles have been targeted with these FPV drones.

As a result, many residents try to wear protective gear, bulletproof vests and helmets, if they can afford them. Even something routine, like getting a haircut, can require that level of precaution.

Elderly residents, or those unable to move easily, often spend most of their time in basements, especially since many windows are boarded up. Kherson has effectively become a war zone, and conditions are extremely dangerous for civilians.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Yuriy.

Boyechko: Stay in touch, Scott. All the best, and thank you for covering Ukraine. I appreciate it.

Jacobsen: Thank you. Take care.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Ola Rondiak on Ukrainian Identity, Psychotherapy, Kyiv, and Art

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/06

Ola Rondiak is a Ukrainian-American contemporary artist, sculptor, and former psychotherapist whose work explores identity, memory, displacement, and Ukrainian cultural resilience. Raised in the United States by Ukrainian immigrant parents, she later relocated to Kyiv, where her artistic practice deepened through engagement with Ukraine’s political upheavals and historical trauma. Known for her large-scale motanka sculptures, collage, and mixed-media works, Rondiak combines personal family history, women’s experiences, and national memory into visually layered narratives exhibited internationally.

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen speaks with Ola Rondiak about her Ukrainian-American upbringing, move from Ohio to New York, studies at Hunter College, and early work in social services. Rondiak reflects on immigrant identity, bureaucracy in child welfare, clinical psychology, marriage, motherhood, and relocating to Kyiv. Her story links psychotherapy, family choices, and Ukrainian cultural belonging to the later emergence of her art, shaped by memory, displacement, resilience, and cross-cultural life in contemporary Ukraine.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Why New York? What is the family history behind getting there?

Ola Rondiak: Oh gosh. Well, I grew up in Ohio, but I had a grandmother who lived in New York. I started at Ohio State University and never felt super comfortable there, so I transferred to Hunter College because there was an opportunity for me to live with her in New York City. That began my New York life, really, at 20 or 21. I also had a lot of friends in New York through the Ukrainian community because every summer I went to Ukrainian scouting camps, so I met Ukrainians from all over the U.S. I wanted to experience New York and see what else was out there.

Jacobsen: So Ohio felt uncomfortable, out of place, and New York seemed…

Rondiak: Oh, I would not say that. I mean, there was nothing wrong with my childhood growing up in suburbia, except that I was different from everybody because I was first-generation, from immigrant parents, so I was a little bit weird. But I had a great group of friends. They just laughed about it. I would go to school smelling like garlic and things like that.

Jacobsen: That would keep the vampires away. So what did New York represent to you then, and Hunter College particularly?

Rondiak: Oh, it represented a bigger part of the world that I wanted to explore. I guess Ohio felt kind of closed in for me, and New York was exciting. It felt more like what the real world was about. It also related to having a lot of Ukrainian friends from New York whom I had met over the summers throughout my youth. I grew up with two lives. I grew up with my American friends in American school, but every summer and on Saturdays, I was with my Ukrainian friends. Obviously, as first-generation, my parents were very different from all my American friends’ parents in Ohio. So being in New York, around a lot of those immigrant families, felt more like me. I suppose I felt a little out of place.

Jacobsen: Out of place? Those are my words, not yours.

Rondiak: I mean, we got back there. That is kind of what you started with.

Jacobsen: What did you find at Hunter College?

Rondiak: It was cool. I mean, it was good. It was the late ’80s. I had to add one semester, I believe, because not everything transferred equally. But I did not mind, and it actually helped my grades because I was motivated and chose a major that I was interested in.

Jacobsen: Which was?

Rondiak: Kind of a double major, with psychology and education.

Jacobsen: Did both of those feed into your psychotherapy background?

Rondiak: Yes. Then I worked as a social worker in Brooklyn for a few years and got fed up with bureaucracy, honestly.

I thought maybe I would be better off working one-on-one with people because the whole system kind of drove me mad. You are there wanting to help kids. I had about 55 kids on my roster. It was part of the adoption and foster care unit, and also the, what did they call it? I was reaching out to family members who were not necessarily in New York, trying to find places for the kids. There were roadblocks everywhere. I felt very frustrated. I kept thinking, “Are we here to help the kids, or are we not?” It seemed so bureaucratic. I guess it just was not my language or my world to be in there because I thought I was going to be helping the kids, and I barely got to see them once a week.

It is funny. I have not talked about this for a while. It was more like going to court every week, looking for the parents, and doing a lot of paperwork. I thought, “Well, the kids are never going to trust me because I do not even have time to build a relationship with them.” So I decided to go back to graduate school and study psychotherapy because I thought I would prefer to work one-on-one with people.

Jacobsen: So would you characterize the bureaucratic process as depersonalizing in some way because you could not build those relationships?

Rondiak: Yes, and I think there is a very high burnout rate in that field. People either leave for something else, or if they stay, they are often half checked out. So if you are trying to get permission from Supervisor One or Supervisor Two, and they do not really care anymore because they are fried, it becomes difficult. Then, as a young person at 22, coming in wanting to save the world, or at least thinking you can make a difference…

Jacobsen: That is a common error.

Rondiak: Exactly.

Jacobsen: Would you characterize it as idealistic? You at 22, going into this thinking you were going to save the world?

Rondiak: I am saying that loosely. I did not think I could save the world, but I thought I could make a bigger difference than just getting caught up in bureaucratic tasks.

Jacobsen: What strand of psychotherapy did you pursue in graduate school?

Rondiak: I began in a very small program. I think they selected only about 15 of us. I did not think we were going to talk about this. I thought we were going to talk about my art. This was a long time ago.

Jacobsen: We are getting to the art. The art does not just appear out of nowhere.

Rondiak: Wow, I just have not been in that room in my mind for so long. My initial graduate program acceptance was in clinical psychology. That was the broad term for it. We were learning different theories and approaches within clinical psych.

Halfway through the program, I fell in love. My future husband was not living in Ohio. So I found myself in this decision-making process: do I stop at the master’s degree, or continue toward a doctorate? But I was already around 26 or 27, and I wanted to get married and have children. That became my next goal.

Jacobsen: At what age did that become a goal and a dream for you?

Rondiak: I always knew I wanted to be a mom, but I was also very interested in having a career, so it was always both. Then, once I fell in love, it became very realistic. I knew I wanted to have a few children. I have three. My youngest is in New York right now, Brooklyn.

So it was a difficult decision, but I thought that if I did not go for the doctorate right away, the master’s degree in clinical psychology did not allow you to do very much professionally. You really had to continue for the doctorate because you could not get licensed independently. For example, I could not practice psychotherapy on my own.

So I transferred into the education department, into community counseling, because that pathway would allow me to become licensed to practice if I decided to stop there for a while. That is what I did.

Then my husband proposed, and when I graduated, we moved to Philadelphia, where he was living at the time.

Jacobsen: How long did you work in clinical psychology, and how long were you and your husband together before he proposed?

Rondiak: Wait, how long did I use the clinical psych degree? You mean how long was I working as a therapist? Right after I graduated that spring, he invited me to move to Philadelphia and start planning our wedding. We got married that November.

Jacobsen: What age were you then?

Rondiak: Twenty-seven, I think.

Jacobsen: Was he always clear about his intentions in that regard?

Rondiak: Yes. We had already known each other for about 15 years. We met in Canada at a Ukrainian ski camp when we were around 18. So then we moved to Philadelphia, and I worked there as a therapist in a clinic until we moved to Ukraine.

Jacobsen: To Kyiv. And when did art become the main inspiration and focus of your productive life?

Rondiak: We moved to Kyiv, and I worked here privately, helping children with English language learning, and I also did some work connected with the Peace Corps. I did some therapy as well.

Jacobsen: What year was this approximately?

Rondiak: Mid-1990s. We came for about a year, maybe a year and a half. I started feeling my biological clock ticking, even though my husband wanted to stay longer. We moved back to the U.S. because, at that time, things here were still uncertain, especially for foreigners. The systems were not set up the way we were used to in the West with maternity hospitals and things like that. There were also lingering concerns about radiation levels after Chernobyl.

There were many uncertainties. The U.S. Embassy was issuing advisories like “Do not eat strawberries,” along with lots of other protocols.

Jacobsen: That is incredibly specific and interesting. There is probably a whole story there too.

Rondiak: I am sure there is. I thought, if we have the opportunity to have our children in the U.S., then let us do that. My husband was able to work remotely from the U.S. because his boss was American-based but running a company in Kyiv. So we ended up having three children in three years and then moved back to Ukraine with them. And then I had all these anxieties about whether there was radiation in the bath water while I was bathing them. Those kinds of stresses. “Do not put the water in your mouth.”

Jacobsen: That has never been a stressor in my life. Do you feel any superpowers coming out of the radiation? Preferably only good ones.

Rondiak: Only good ones. That is good.

Jacobsen: This is good. It is like supes from The Boys.

Rondiak: I guess we all became resilient somehow. So we lived for a few years in the city with the kids. Then, when school was starting, we decided we were going to stay longer, so we moved a little outside the city because the children were going to the Kyiv International School.

Jacobsen: Why select an international school?

Rondiak: That is an interesting question. My husband and I thought we should keep their options open. At the time, Kyiv was still predominantly Russian-speaking, whereas in Lviv, for example, we heard much more Ukrainian. Kyiv felt a little more foreign to us because even activities like gymnastics were conducted in Russian.

Since we had grown up in the United States, international school felt like a good choice. We wanted the kids to maintain their English, and they had not chosen to live in Ukraine. We thought an international education would give them broader opportunities and make it easier if they later transferred somewhere else, whether in Europe, the U.S., or elsewhere.

Jacobsen: I feel like you never fully expected to stay there as long as you did.

Rondiak: That too. We always thought we might move again, so it seemed easier for them to transfer from an international school if necessary. Even if they ended up spending their whole childhood in Ukraine, which we did not know at the time, we thought it would still help if they later chose universities abroad.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Ola.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

John Lyman on International Policy Digest, Independent Publishing, and Global Affairs

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/06

John Lyman is editor-in-chief of International Policy Digest, a global affairs publication he developed after graduate studies in European Studies at the University of Amsterdam and further work in Homeland Security at Virginia Commonwealth University. Beginning as a personal blog and portfolio, IPD grew into an international platform with thousands of contributors and articles. Lyman edits across geopolitics, human rights, conflict, media, technology, and public policy, emphasizing evidence, moderation, careful editorial judgment, and global perspectives.

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen speaks with John Lyman, editor-in-chief of International Policy Digest, about building a global affairs publication from a personal blog into an international contributor platform. Lyman discusses graduate training, missile defence, unpaid contributors, funding pressures, editorial judgment, ideological submissions, Ukraine, Trump, Russia, autism myths, and regional conflicts. The conversation highlights independent publishing, evidence-based editing, global readership, and the difficulties of sustaining serious commentary online across borders and political divides today.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: You started International Policy Digest more than a decade ago. Why did you start it? What was the original spark?

John Lyman: After graduate school at the University of Amsterdam, where I completed a Master of Arts in European Studies and studied European enlargement and security issues, I was unable to find a job in Europe. I had hoped to work in a field connected to international security, possibly involving NATO, but that did not happen. Eventually, I had to return to the United States. This was around 2009.

That was shortly after Obama was elected, but the recession was still ongoing. The job market was difficult and increasingly inhospitable. So I decided to pursue another degree in Homeland Security at my alma mater, Virginia Commonwealth University. After graduating, however, I realized that I did not really want to work in Homeland Security. I am not entirely sure what drove me to choose that degree. At the time, I thought it would be useful, but in retrospect, I think it was largely a waste of money.

As I looked around at the difficult job market, I decided to start a blog and publish excerpts from my graduate thesis on missile defence. An online portfolio will help me professionally.

To my surprise, I ended up creating a blog that looked quite professional. Writers from Bangladesh and India began contacting me and saying, “We like your blog. Can we publish our articles on it?” It started with a few writers from Bangladesh, India, and Pakistan. From there, it expanded to include writers from Russia, Eastern Europe, the rest of Europe, the United States, Australia, and beyond.

What began with a handful of contributors gradually spread across the world. I have had contributing writers from what feels like nearly every country reach out to me. Many of them did not know how to publish their work online. They were unfamiliar with platforms such as Blogger or Medium. They would contact me and ask, “Can you publish this article? Can you publish this photo? Can you edit it, choose an image, and make it look professional?” That is really how it all began.

It was largely accidental. I did not attend journalism school and do not have a strong background in editing or journalism. I acquired those skills over time as the publication evolved.

Jacobsen: How was the funding landscape more than ten years ago? How is it now, and why has it become more difficult?

Lyman: I learned the hard way that some websites remain small platforms with relatively little data. In contrast, others grow into something much larger. Today, I have around 30,000 pieces of content and probably an equal number of photographs. All of that represents data, and when you host a website, you have to pay for it.

When I first started the website, the costs were minimal, perhaps $50 to $100 per month. As the website grew, however, the costs of simply operating it became substantial. There are also expenses associated with image services such as Shutterstock and Getty. Occasionally, you may need legal assistance if a dispute arises over content or copyright issues. Those situations are not common, but the costs accumulate over time.

I wasn’t well connected within the publishing or news industries. I did not have an established network of people I could rely on. I was not living in California or Silicon Valley, and I did not have access to a circle of investors I could approach and say, “I want to launch this project. Would you be willing to contribute a million dollars, or even a thousand dollars?”

I built it myself. Over the past twelve years, I have been fortunate to have many people contribute along the way, especially the writers. Their contributions have been extraordinary.

Lyman: Everyone has done it for free, which is remarkable. Along the way, I have met people who have said, “Can I help you with your operating expenses or website costs?” That has been tremendously helpful.

I didn’t have a network when I launched the website, and I would probably do those things differently. If I were launching it again, I would spend more time reaching out to people and developing a network from the beginning.

I also did not really plan the website in any formal way. I did not have a five-year plan or a clear vision of where I wanted to be at any given point. A lot of it was improvised and operated on a shoestring budget. I realized the website needed a change, so I invested $1,000 of my own money. Or I would identify an improvement that needed to be made and fund it myself. That is essentially how it developed.

Jacobsen: Did you ever end up using any of your post-secondary specializations in your articles or throughout your editorial career?

Lyman: Actually, they have been useful when publishing articles about missile defence because my graduate thesis focused on what I viewed as the futility of missile defence systems. I have published several articles about Trump’s proposed Golden Dome missile defence project. This massive missile defence shield could cost trillions of dollars.

I don’t believe it will work. In practice, missile defence systems have significant limitations. Israel’s missile defence systems have intercepted many incoming missiles, but they have also faced challenges with drones and other threats. I am not entirely sure what Trump hopes to achieve with a project on that scale.

When I edit articles on missile defence, however, it is useful because I can draw on my academic background and understanding of the subject.

I do not publish many articles about emergency preparedness or FEMA. However, that education still helps me understand the news and broader policy discussions.

My European Studies degree has also been useful, as I publish a great deal of content on European politics. That said, the political landscape has changed dramatically since I was in graduate school in Amsterdam. Brexit was not yet a reality. Trump had not entered politics. The European populist movements that dominate so much discussion today were in a very different place. The political environment has changed significantly since both my time in Amsterdam and my years at Virginia Commonwealth University, when Obama was still president.

While I haven’t directly applied much of my formal education in a professional setting, it has helped me understand and contextualize many of the issues I cover.

Jacobsen: How have the readership and submission demographics changed over the past decade?

Lyman: When I launched the website, finding content was actually quite difficult. I reached out to writers actively.

One of my earliest regular contributors was Benoit Coman in Australia. He became one of the website’s most prolific contributors and has written thousands of articles for the publication. He writes extensively for a variety of outlets and has always been a strong writer.

Another early contributor was Daniel Wagner, who wrote extensively about risk management, financial risk, and related topics.

Publishing those writers helped attract other contributors. Someone would see that I had published a friend or colleague and then reach out to ask whether they could publish with us as well.

For roughly the past 7 years, I have not had to search for content actively. I have a somewhat unusual business model. Unfortunately, I am not able to compensate contributors financially. It is simply not a viable financial model for me at this stage.

I want to pay contributors eventually because they deserve to be compensated for their work. It would be my way of saying thank you.

One might assume that people would not want to submit articles without payment and would instead take their work elsewhere. That is a completely understandable position, and some writers have done exactly that.

Despite that challenge, however, I continue to receive new submissions every day. Even though I cannot compensate contributors, and, in many cases, cannot compensate myself either, the flow of new articles has remained remarkably consistent.

During the first five years that I ran the website, I would receive perhaps one article submission per day, sometimes two. Today, I receive roughly five submissions a day from writers around the world.

It is remarkable. The writing capabilities vary considerably. Some contributors are young Nigerian journalists just beginning their careers and learning the craft. They are sincere and promising writers, although their English may not be as strong as that of a writer in New York, Europe, or elsewhere. Quality varies, but I publish as much content as I can because someone took the time to write it.

I receive submissions from new writers in Nigeria, Botswana, South Africa, India, Bangladesh, Pakistan, Nepal, and many other countries. At the same time, I also receive articles from highly accomplished writers around the world. It is difficult to predict how many submissions I will receive on any given day. Still, I can generally count on at least 2 or 3 new submissions.

Most of the material is already well written. In many cases, I only need to make minor edits, adjust a title, improve the structure, or correct punctuation. The vast majority of submissions require only light editorial work.

Jacobsen: How have you noticed the content changing over time? Earlier, you mentioned significant shifts in the political landscape, particularly in Europe. How has that affected the themes, emphases, and diversity of submissions you receive?

Lyman: I would put it this way: around 2016, I had several writers who were not necessarily devoted supporters of Donald Trump but were certainly sympathetic to aspects of his political philosophy. Initially, I published some of those pieces to offer a range of perspectives. The articles would argue that Trump might be right about a particular issue, at least from the author’s point of view.

I did not necessarily agree with those arguments. Nevertheless, for much of the publication’s history, I tried to publish content from across the political spectrum. Some writers were conservative, some were liberal, and others occupied positions somewhere in between.

The war in Ukraine opened what I would describe as a Pandora’s box of submissions. Several writers advanced arguments sympathetic to the Kremlin’s position on NATO enlargement and Russian security concerns. These were generally not extreme conspiracy theories involving biolabs or similar claims. Still, arguments suggested that Russia’s actions should be understood through the lens of perceived strategic threats.

Over time, I became more selective about publishing material that I found poorly reasoned, factually unsupported, or morally objectionable. As a result, I began rejecting more submissions that attempted to justify Russia’s invasion of Ukraine or relied on arguments that I considered intellectually weak.

I would also say that I publish less overtly ideological content than I once did. I still publish conservative writers, and I appreciate their contributions. Many of them are critical of Donald Trump and do not support him. They may be economic conservatives, social conservatives, or advocates of free markets, but they are generally thoughtful and serious writers.

My goal remains to publish writers from across the political spectrum. However, the content has gradually shifted toward the political center. Most of what I publish today is relatively moderate in tone and perspective. I still receive and occasionally publish material from both the left and the right. Still, I filter much more aggressively than I did in the early years.

For example, during the New York City mayoral race involving Zohran Mamdani, I received submissions that drew highly questionable comparisons and invoked the September 11 attacks in ways that I considered inappropriate and intellectually dishonest. I have little patience for those kinds of false equivalencies. Regardless of political orientation, I am not interested in publishing arguments that rely on sensationalism or weak reasoning.

When people write about Zohran Mamdani and try to connect him to the September 11 attacks, they often stretch to find a connection that isn’t there. I think that is a poor argumentative position to take, and I have seen some conservative writers make those kinds of claims.

In general, I have turned down writers who submitted highly conservative pieces, only to see those same articles later published on far-right websites. I am perfectly comfortable with that. Over time, I have learned that even if I reject one or two articles, three or four new submissions will arrive shortly afterward. I am never lacking for content.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, John.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Fumfer Physics 52: Time, Information, Black Holes, and IC Cosmology

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/06

Fumfer Physics 52: Time, Information, Black Holes, and IC Cosmology

Photo by NASA Hubble Space Telescope on Unsplash

Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner discuss time in the IC model as a sequence of informationally linked moments shaped by quantum probability, observer perspective, and incomplete histories. Rosner contrasts IC with ΛCDM, rejects backward time travel, and suggests advanced civilizations may eventually simulate or influence cosmic-scale temporal structures.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: I want to get into some of the aspects of time, as time, in some sense, becomes a plurally interpretable construct with subjectively processed and experienced time, objectively measured time via physical instruments as represented in perceptual systems such as ours once measured in this manner, and, perhaps, in some third sense with actual base reality of time as instantaneous and emergent simultaneously operative in larger reality inclusive of the former two. Describe time to me in an IC model. In an IC model, what are some ways an individual can manipulate the physics of time differently?

Rick Rosner: I consider time a series of moments drawn from a space of possible moments. There are problems with this view. There may not be a well-defined set of all possible moments, and it is difficult to define a “moment” for an entire universe. In relativity, there is no single universal present shared by all observers.

There are experiential moments: moments as experienced from a particular location and frame of reference. What we experience as “now” includes information from different distances and therefore different times. The farther away we look in space, the farther back we look in time. So a moment is not simply the same everywhere in the universe. It depends on the observer’s position, motion, and available information.

Even so, I think of time as a sequence of moments linked by physical continuity and quantum probability. Each moment is built from an incomplete history. We do not have perfect information about the past, and the future remains open because not all quantum outcomes have occurred. From each moment, there is a range of possible next moments, with some much more probable than others. The next moment we experience will usually be strongly related to the previous one and will likely fall among the most probable continuations.

There are unresolved issues in this view, and some parts need clarification, but that is how I see time.

These moments can be loosely compared to ticks of a clock, though that is only a simplification. In one second, an enormous number of microscopic physical and quantum events occur in the observable environment around us. One could think of these as many tiny updates in the state of the world, but what matters is the changing pattern of open and resolved physical possibilities.

I would not describe this as a literal, observable collapse. In some interpretations of quantum mechanics, collapse is treated as real; in others, it is not. In this model, a quantum question is either still open or has become resolved relative to the history being experienced. Some physical processes unfold continuously or through many intermediate states, rather than as single, instantaneous events.

Subsequent moments generally contain new information relative to previous moments, though systems can also lose, disperse, or hide information. In that sense, time can be understood as connected to the generation, transformation, and redistribution of information.

That, in compressed form, is time for me. The next question is: how can one mess with time?

Jacobsen: Yes, and I want to be very specific here. Based on those premises, my question is about manipulating time, or, more specifically, about the things that an IC framework allows one to do with time that are not possible in the standard Big Bang ΛCDM cosmological model.

Rosner: I do not know that IC allows you to do anything with time that you cannot do in the Big Bang model. There are, however, aspects of time that are different.

Jacobsen: Okay.

Rosner: The main difference is that, in an IC universe, the apparent age of the universe is not its true age. The universe is vastly older than it appears. Around black holes, it is also easier within the IC framework to conceive of information moving into and out of the region surrounding collapsed matter.

Jacobsen: I remember learning about black holes in high school physics, perhaps in Grade 9, although I would have to fact-check that. I always thought the fundamental premise was that black holes represent places where our standard descriptive models break down and are therefore only partial. It seemed possible that answers to more fundamental theories might emerge through the careful study of those objects.

Rosner: Right. If you build everything from information, you arrive at a different, more dynamic picture of a black hole. You also arrive at a different understanding of entropy, or at least a more comprehensive one. We are accustomed to thinking about entropy in closed systems, where it statistically tends to increase. Increasingly, however, physicists are studying open systems, where entropy need not always increase locally, even though the total entropy of an isolated system still follows the second law of thermodynamics.

Returning to your original question, I do not think backward time travel is possible. I do think it may become possible to simulate the past and the future with extraordinary fidelity. Advances in large-scale data processing, AI-driven computation, quantum computing, and other powerful technologies could allow us to construct increasingly accurate reconstructions of past states and increasingly sophisticated predictions of future ones.

As finite beings with limited informational requirements, we do not need infinite information to create useful representations of the world. In the future, we may be able to explore highly accurate simulations of the past or investigate probable futures based on the best available evidence. That would not directly alter the way time operates, although it might alter how we interact with the universe.

Within the IC framework, I think the amount of information in the universe generally increases over time. I also do not know whether intelligent agents, advanced civilizations, for example, might eventually become capable of influencing the large-scale evolution of the universe. They could conceivably become technologically sophisticated enough to utilize the supermassive black holes found at the centers of most galaxies or otherwise influence which regions of the universe remain active or collapse.

A civilization that has existed for millions of years might be able to harness large-scale cosmic structures for its own purposes, perhaps even avoiding regions destined for gravitational collapse. In that sense, sufficiently advanced civilizations could become part of the mechanics of the universe itself.

Even so, none of that necessarily changes the fundamental nature of time.

That is what I have.

Jacobsen: On a fundamental level, you began that response by saying that IC does not necessarily describe things one can do with time so much as it describes different things about time. I want to push back on that a little. I think the first premise, in some ways, leads to the second.

If one had a sufficiently deep understanding of time, what time is, what can be said about it in a fundamental sense, and how it can be understood from different angles, then a sufficiently advanced civilization, with enough scale and control over energy sources, might develop an engineering perspective on time. That knowledge could imply a practical understanding of what can be done, listed, measured, or recorded.

Rosner: Yes and no. If everything is a moment, if everything that exists does so within a particular moment, and if every moment is time-coded, that is, every moment has a particular temporal notation, then one is unlikely to experience time in any way other than linearly.

However, in the space of all possible moments, each moment may apply to multiple universes or possible histories. There is a set of likely past moments and a set of likely future moments. Even the present is incompletely defined. These moments can involve a lot of superposition. If one is thinking in terms of a quantum computer or a quantum universe, then open quantum questions remain unresolved across a number of possible situations. This can also be described as part of a multiverse.

One way to think about it is as a multiverse bundle moving linearly through time. No moment is completely specified. That lack of specification creates multiplicity. It is like a ring around a bundle moving forward. The ring is tightest at the present moment and spreads outward into likely past moments and likely future moments.

In practical terms, this does not disturb ordinary experience. We live the way we live in the world, or worlds, in which we live.

Can technology be used to alter the size of that ring? Possibly.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Mike Wilson: Marine Veteran Building Ukraine’s Cowboy Culture

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/06

Mike Wilson: Marine Veteran Building Ukraine’s Cowboy Culture

Photo by Cemrecan Yurtman on Unsplash

Mike Wilson is a United States Marine Corps veteran, skilled tradesman, entrepreneur, and founder of the Association of Ukrainian Cowboys. After service as a body repair mechanic, he built businesses, raised five sons, and developed a lasting attachment to Ukraine. Since 2015, he has supported Ukrainians through marksmanship training, veterans’ engagement, ministry, and community-building, including Kyiv’s Western Saloon, a cultural project bringing American cowboy music, hospitality, and fellowship to wartime Ukraine with resilience and warmth.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen interviews Mike Wilson, a Marine veteran, skilled tradesman, father, Christian minister, and founder of the Association of Ukrainian Cowboys. Wilson reflects on Marine Corps training, family life, Montana business experience, and his deepening bond with Ukraine after 2006. The conversation traces his anger after Russia’s 2014 aggression, his marksmanship training for Ukrainians, and his vision for Kyiv’s Western Saloon as a place of culture, fellowship, music, healing, and resilience under wartime pressure.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: You are a Marine and a veteran. We never say “were,” because once a Marine, always a Marine.

Mike Wilson: True. I am not on active duty, but I am a Marine through and through.

Jacobsen: I think once everyone has gone through basic training, they share that experience.

Wilson: You are going through the fire.

Jacobsen: I loved basic training. It was very fun. The administrative side, however, was complete mayhem.

It is mind-boggling, for sure. Let us take a step back. Why did you join the Marines? How long were you there? What was the emotional environment? What were the physical and cognitive demands?

Wilson: I am a musician. I was originally preparing to audition for “The President’s Own” United States Marine Band. That was my goal. I had an audition scheduled before the band commander, who was coming through at the time.

My mother was very sick then, and she died while I was in boot camp. Because she was so ill during the audition period, I canceled the audition and did not pursue that route.

I also loved auto body and paint work, as well as working on cars. So I asked the Marine Corps whether they had a program for auto body and paint. They said they did and gave me the MOS code 3513, Body Repair Mechanic. I said, “Yes, I can do that,” and they said, “Great.”

Of course, I had to go through boot camp first. As you know, every Marine receives basic infantry training before moving on to an MOS.

I went through boot camp and then attended school at Aberdeen Proving Ground in Maryland for welding, body repair, and painting. I aced it. My problem was that I hated studying, but I loved mechanical work. I loved working with my hands, so I naturally gravitated toward skilled labour.

I did very well in the school, and if I had slowed down, I could have developed my skills even further. But when you are 18 years old, you do not always think that way. You think, “This is easy. It is a breeze.” I finished the school in three months. I could have stayed for six months, but I completed it in three. Then I returned to California, where I grew up, in Los Angeles.

I was a reservist at first, so I did my weekend duty. After about a year, I was not finding much work, and I thought, “You know what? I loved the Corps anyway.” So I went from the reserves to active duty, and the Marine Corps treated me very well.

The Marine Corps gave me more than I could have imagined. They treated me extremely well, and I had no complaints.

Then I was asked if I wanted to go to Hawaii. I thought, “Hawaii? Sure, I will go to Hawaii.” I had already been stationed at what I considered one of the best duty stations in the Corps, Marine Corps Air Station El Toro in Southern California, and I figured Hawaii had to be even better. It was not necessarily better, but it was still a wonderful assignment.

I spent three years in Hawaii. Because of my MOS, I was the only Marine on the base performing that particular specialty. As a result, I did not have to pull many of the additional duties that others did. I was not assigned weekend details or field exercises in the mountains. I stayed with my unit and worked primarily in my shop, painting and repairing equipment. I painted every vehicle and every piece of equipment on the base.

For me, the Marine Corps was absolutely heaven. It was a very comfortable environment. I thrived in it. It suited me perfectly.

When I was asked to reenlist, my initial response was, “No, I am not going to reenlist.” Then I began to reconsider and thought, “Maybe reenlisting is a great idea. I like it here.”

As a Christian, however, I believed God might be able to use me more effectively somewhere else. Looking back, I realize He was already using me in the Marine Corps, but I was not putting those pieces together.

I had reached the rank of sergeant, although the promotion had not yet been pinned on me because I was close to leaving the service. I also was not fully aware of the situation. Had I known that I had effectively reached sergeant, I probably would have reenlisted without hesitation and finished my career.

Another influence on my decision was Okinawa. I knew that, as a single Marine, I would likely receive a one-year tour there, while married Marines generally served three-year tours. At the time, I was single. Everyone around me constantly complained, saying, “Okinawa is terrible,” and sharing negative stories. I do not know why those opinions affected me because I had never bought into that kind of negativity before. I genuinely loved the Marine Corps and had nothing to complain about. Still, I thought, “If I reenlist, I am guaranteed to go to Okinawa,” and that became one of the factors in my decision.

Another consideration was that I had secured a civilian job doing exactly what I had been doing in the Marine Corps, working as a contractor for the Army. I thought it would be a perfect transition.

After I got out, I reported to the company and said, “I am available and ready to start.” They told me there had been changes and that they no longer had a position for me. Suddenly, I found myself without a job.

So I simply moved on with life. About a year later, I got married, and then we started having children. One boy, then another, then another, and another.

Jacobsen: You have nothing but boys.

Wilson: I have all boys in America. They are from two different marriages. My first marriage did not work out, and later I remarried. Between the two marriages, I had five sons.

I ran my own businesses while raising my children. Eventually, I became a single father with all five boys in my care. Owning a business was a tremendous advantage because it gave me the flexibility and financial stability to raise them. If I needed to pick them up from school or take care of something during the day, I could adjust my schedule.

My oldest sons worked for me and often managed the jobs while I took care of the younger boys. If I was tied up, I would call and say, “Keoni, go pick up your brothers,” and he would do it. That was simply how our family worked, we always helped one another.

In 2006, I was introduced to Ukraine. I met a woman named Laysa, who was born in Kyiv and had recently moved to my town in Montana.

At the time, I had a severe lower back problem from years of construction work and heavy lifting. By the end of each work season, the pain was so intense that I could barely sleep. Laysa was a practitioner of natural medicine, and she began treating my back. Within three months, I was completely pain-free, and the problem never returned. Before that, I had been dealing with it for nearly two years.

We began dating and remained together on and off for about two years. We never lived together. Eventually, our lives took different directions. She pursued her medical career, while I remained focused on my family and children.

Even after the relationship ended, I had become deeply fascinated by Ukraine, its history, culture, and people. In many ways, I felt that Ukraine’s history mirrored aspects of my own life. I had been severely bullied growing up and learned to survive by running fast.

Jacobsen: Like Forrest Gump.

Wilson: Exactly. As I studied Ukraine’s history, the repeated invasions, occupations, and struggles for independence, I found myself identifying with that resilience. Laysa introduced me to the country, but learning its history is what truly made me fall in love with it.

I visited Ukraine before the full-scale war and spent time here after 2014 as well. I found it peaceful and welcoming. I fell in love with the culture, the people, and their kindness.

When Russia occupied Crimea and initiated its intervention in the Donbas in 2014, I believed the warning signs had been there and that the international response had been insufficient. Watching those events unfold deeply angered me.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Mike.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Mark McNamee on Ukraine’s Defense Tech, Wartime Economy, and Military Innovation

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/06

Mark McNamee is a Kyiv-based analyst and commentator on Ukraine’s political economy, defense technology, and wartime industrial transformation. Living in Ukraine through the full-scale invasion, he examines how the country’s logistics, ports, private sector, drone producers, and procurement systems adapt under Russian attack. His work emphasizes Ukraine’s endurance, Western-oriented business culture, miltech innovation, reconstruction during war, and the strategic importance of Ukrainian defense firms for Europe, NATO, and the wider democratic world today and beyond.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen asks Mark McNamee about Ukraine’s wartime political economy and defense technology sector. McNamee argues Ukraine is enduring rather than merely resilient, adapting logistics, ports, and industry under Russian attack. He says reconstruction is already underway through defense production, especially drones, electronic warfare, missiles, and procurement reform. McNamee also highlights Western investment, younger Ukrainian entrepreneurs, and Ukraine’s growing importance to Europe, NATO, and democratic military innovation in a transformed era.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: How would you describe the overall military tech and political economy landscape of Ukraine now, particularly as we are in the fifth year of the full-scale invasion?

Mark McNamee: Well, I would divide this into two parts: the broader political economy and the defense miltech economy. So, to summarize briefly, I would give you two quick answers.

The political economy, I would say, is enduring. I am using that word instead of “resilience” because “resilience” has become one of the more overused words I have heard over the last four and a half years of living here. We keep hearing about “resilient Ukrainians,” and that is absolutely true. It obviously goes without saying at this point, but it has become a cliché. It can also become a way of saying, “Ukrainians are resilient, so they can handle themselves, while we in the West continue to sleep through this war and congratulate them and pat them on the back for their suffering, handing them a couple of dollars here and there as necessary.

They can do all the dirty work for us to protect Western civilization, and bravo, because they are so tough,” while we in the West are frankly not nearly as resilient or tough as Ukrainians. So I am a little tired of “resilience.” Let me get that off my chest to start this interview on a negative note. Moving to endurance, though, that is how I would describe the political economy. It is remarkably adaptive to the circumstances. This is the fifth year of the full-scale war, and Ukraine is a country far smaller than Russia in population, territory, and overall economic scale, yet it has endured.

There is an economic war going on here as well. Russia is trying to decimate the country and win in any way possible. If that means bombing the country into submission, not winning at the front, but devastating the whole country, then that would be victory for Russia. And that has not happened.

That is why I refer to the economic front in this war. I do not say that out of disrespect to the other real front, of course, where men are dying as we speak in the east. But there is, in a way, an economic front in this war. That is what I feel I am contributing to, or at least helping with. We are enduring. I am using that word because of the adaptation, the innovation, and the effort to keep transport and logistics functioning.

Just one clear example: in the first quarter of 2026, Ukrainian ports handled more than 21 million tonnes of cargo and met 98 percent of their transshipment target, even though port infrastructure was being attacked regularly. Russia has continued to target transport nodes, port infrastructure, and other parts of Ukraine’s logistics system with drones and missiles. Yet Ukrainian companies and private citizens have been able to adapt, still get products to market, and keep the economy flowing.

So, while on the one hand you could say the economy is struggling, and that is true, it is still expected to grow modestly this year. Current forecasts place Ukraine’s 2026 growth roughly in the low single digits, with the IMF estimating about 1.0 to 1.6 percent, the World Bank about 1.2 percent, and the EBRD about 2.2 percent. Russia’s growth is also expected to be weak, with IMF and World Bank projections around 1.1 to 1.3 percent.

But I would simply say Ukraine is enduring. It keeps going. Now, all of that said, if you go specifically to the second part you mentioned, miltech, and turn to the defense sector here, that sector is growing rapidly. It also points to a deeper issue that I think many people outside Ukraine are missing: reconstruction is already going on today. People have it in their heads, particularly Westerners who are sitting on the sidelines, monitoring, interested, supportive of Ukraine, and wanting to invest, but they say it is too risky. There is a war going on. The risk-reward calculation is still not quite there. Yes, they say they are ready for reconstruction, of course. Ra-ra Ukraine. There will be a massive opportunity. This could be the Marshall Plan times ten. People see that happening five or ten years from now. But the reality is that this is a misframing of what is going on here in the defense sector. I say that because the defense sector is proof that industrial reconstruction is already happening.

Defense was not a dominant sector of Ukraine’s economy after independence over the last 30-plus years. Now we can say decisively that, for the next generation, defense is likely to be one of the core pillars of Ukraine’s economy, helping drive it out of this war. Ukraine’s domestic defense industry has expanded dramatically since the full-scale invasion, with major growth in drones, electronic warfare, and private-sector defense startups. But the point is that this is happening during the war. So we have this strange mental framework: you have war.

Then victory comes on May 8, 1945, and reconstruction begins on May 9, 1945. The same applies to Japan: the formal surrender took place on September 2, 1945, and reconstruction begins immediately after that. So we still have that framework, which is entirely outdated, of course. That is not what is happening here. There will be some form of hostility: a Cold War, periods of kinetic war, perhaps even another iteration, in a downside scenario, of a third Russian invasion in the coming years.

There may be a simmering conflict, or some level of conflict on the spectrum, but recovery and reconstruction will be going on simultaneously. Investors have to get used to that. This is not just Ukraine. If you look around the world, conflict is obviously defining this period, and that is likely to be the case for the next five or ten years. So marking these clear lines, war, then the war ends decisively, then we move to reconstruction, is really an outdated mental framework.

That is why I talk about the defense sector as proof of that, because we are seeing a rapidly growing sector here with enormous potential. It is hard even to say how far it can go. On the defense-sector side, there is a lot to say. You can look across all sorts of areas: millions of drones produced this year, advances in interceptor drones, electronic warfare, domestic production of ballistic missiles, domestic production of FPV drones, critical medical equipment for the front, artillery, and ammunition.

Ukraine is now producing a large share of its defense needs domestically. In some categories, Ukrainian firms are teaming up with European defense companies, which means production domestically in Ukraine, as well as production in Europe, the United States, and some other non-European countries. We are also seeing demand for this technology in the Middle East, with joint ventures and deals being signed with several countries in the region. So that is proof that this is moving.

The last point I will make, which I think people fail to appreciate regarding the defense side of things, and not just defense, but other areas as well, is that some of these burgeoning and reviving sectors are going to drive the economy forward. That includes areas related to AI, which is tangential to defense, as well as transport and logistics. You can see companies such as Nova Poshta and how active they are. These are the kinds of sectors that will help drive the economy going forward.

This also touches on the “C word,” which every single Western investor talks about, unfairly but constantly, when discussing Ukraine: corruption. The positive point here is that many of these defense firms, and many of the other firms in the sectors I mentioned, are run by forward-thinking, Western-minded, younger Ukrainians. Particularly in defense, they are doing this for their country. These people were formerly accountants, tour guides, agricultural workers, and people from all sorts of other backgrounds. The commander of Ukraine’s unmanned-systems forces, for example, had a very different civilian career before helping lead one of the most important drone forces in the world.

These are the people who are going to help lead the broader economy because they are going to help lead the defense sector. The very positive news is that, by and large, they are Western-minded and do business in a Western style. That is one reason they have been successful. I would not say anything is completely black and white, but broadly speaking, they are not defined by the old corrupt patterns people often associate with Ukraine. That is critical because this is how you clean up the business environment: you have successful companies, Western companies joining them, and instead of constantly fighting things out in the courts, you have a cleaner sector to invest in.

I am raising that point because I think it is an undervalued aspect of everything going on here. There is a lot of talk, of course, about defense tech. I am sure you have the statistics from your own research, and that is, those stories, I think, have been told to death. But some of the aspects I mentioned should get a little more attention.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Mark.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Fumfer Physics 51: AI, Cosmology, Geometry, and the Limits of Big Bang Alternatives

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/06

Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner discuss whether AI reveals hidden alternatives to Big Bang/ΛCDM cosmology. Rosner argues current AI offers familiar contenders, not a superior information-based theory. They explore simplicity, optimization, geometry, mathematics, emergence, contradiction, and the limits of representational systems before Rosner admits hesitation about sharing the exchange with Chris Cole professionally.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Do you want to talk math, politics, or something else?

Rick Rosner: Math for now.

Jacobsen: Okay.

Rosner: I sent you a brief transcript a couple of days ago. I went online and chatted with Google’s AI to check whether, because of groupthink, AI might be sitting on a better theory of the universe than standard Big Bang cosmology, or whether there is any consensus about modifications to the standard Big Bang/ΛCDM model. It quickly showed me that this is not the case.

Jacobsen: What do you mean by that?

Rosner: I asked what the cosmological theory of the future will look like, based on elegance and beauty. What I meant was simplicity, and it came back with simplicity. It returned a bunch of contenders, all of which I think are off the mark. Some are less off the mark. The closer you get to something built on information, the better off you are. But AI is not sitting on that insight to any extent.

Jacobsen: Is there a distinction between a model bound to simplicity and a model oriented toward optimization, or are these different facets of the same super-concept?

Rosner: You could argue that optimization is in the same neighbourhood as simplicity. Optimization might have additional utility because it is more amenable to mathematization. But neither one is that helpful, because it does not tell you where to look.

Jacobsen: Do the relations between geometry and mathematics tell us more than geometry and mathematics themselves, whether we are talking about operators and elements? Or do those things, on their own, tell us more? The representational systems versus the relations between them – I do not know.

Rosner: What tells you something is the completeness and lack of contradiction in geometry and mathematics. What makes them useful is that they are extensive, and you have to go far out of your way to find potential contradictions or inconsistencies. You can use geometry and mathematics your whole life without running into troublesome inconsistencies. Among the eight or ten theories that AI returned as answers to my question, at least one tries to do without geometry altogether, which is similar to saying that geometry, at least under this theory, and perhaps under many theories, is an emergent property rather than an essential property.

Jacobsen: In some sense, that is true. But mathematics itself is a representational system, and geometry happens as a consequence of the particulars of the descriptions you get from that representational system. The representational system comes afterward. So there is something intrinsic, pre-geometric, and naturally inhering in the representational structure of the mathematics itself.

Rosner: I do not know. They seem ready-made, already there, ready to use. Euclidean geometry, and then, when you are ready for it, non-Euclidean geometry, seem to work out of the box. You plug them in. Before you ever use geometry in school, you already have a geometric understanding from living in the world. You already have a mathematical understanding from living in the world.

Jacobsen: I feel like geometry is more like an algebraic function, where you can look at things in different ways and get different outcomes. It is not just straightforward commutative mathematics or simple commutative mathematics.

Rosner: Maybe we are talking about different instances of geometry. But I am more interested in new theories than in figuring out the primacy of geometry or mathematics. At least in my mind, and at least for mathematics, that is already sorted.

Jacobsen: What does Chris Cole say about your theory?

Rosner: I was going to send him the discussion, but I have been hesitant: first, because I am lazy; second, because it makes me look hopelessly stupid to think AI could be sitting on a naive insight. It makes me appear unversed in what AI does. So I did not send it to him.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Anna Chernenko and Volodymyr Pavlov on War Reporting: Frontline Journalism in Kharkiv

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/06

By Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Volodymyr Pavlov (Translator, English-Ukrainian)

Anna Chernenko is a Ukrainian journalist working in Kharkiv, reporting on wartime conditions, media transformations, and civilian life under threat. She has documented the shrinking journalism sector, risks faced by reporters, and evolving safety practices. Her work reflects the human and professional impact of sustained conflict on Ukraine’s media landscape.

Volodymyr Pavlov is a Ukrainian journalist based in Kharkiv, known for frontline reporting during Russia’s full-scale invasion. He covers military operations, civilian resilience, and regional developments across eastern Ukraine. Experienced in high-risk environments, Pavlov combines field reporting with safety expertise, documenting the realities of war while adapting to ever-changing threats and conditions.

Anna Chernenko and Volodymyr Pavlov describe frontline journalism in Kharkiv, emphasizing adaptation to constant danger, evolving safety practices, and the psychological normalization of war. They highlight shrinking media infrastructure, risks to reporters, and the importance of protective equipment, situational awareness, and resilience while continuing to document the realities of conflict.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Do either of you feel fully safe in Kharkiv? Or do you recognize that it is not entirely safe, but it is no longer constantly on your mind?

Volodymyr Pavlov: Do you feel fully safe? Yes. As for Anna, she feels relatively safe because she is used to this situation. We have seen places with much worse conditions, Donbas.

Anna Chernenko: The only thing that makes me feel unsafe is when new weapons are used, when you cannot understand what they are, how to react, or what kind of danger they pose.

Pavlov: As for me, I feel safe because I have lived in Kharkiv my whole life and have not left since the full-scale invasion. I am used to the situation. I can estimate how far away an explosion is, whether it is in the air or on the ground. I can decide whether I need to be worried or find a safe place. Still, whenever we hear something unusual, we react.

The drone sound in the city center; I can decide whether to worry or find a safe place. Still, whenever we hear something unusual, we react. As I mentioned about the drone sound in the city center, I always respond to air raid sirens and try to find a safe place. If there is a drone, we also try to find shelter somewhere in the city. We follow air raid alerts through Telegram channels and other sources to understand what type of danger Kharkiv is facing.

So if I see a drone or a missile—if it is a missile, I would go to a safe place. But if it is a drone that is not heading toward my location, I might not react.

Jacobsen: Is that a common attitude among journalists in the city?

Pavlov: It depends. Some journalists work from houses or offices with basements, so they feel differently about safety. In Kharkiv, many journalists no longer work in offices because it is often unsafe. They work from home, or media organizations have created shelters or offices in basements. In general, there is a shared sense of adapting to the situation. However, many of our colleagues are sensitive to loud sounds and feel unsafe when they hear explosions. Some travel to Kharkiv only briefly, while others go further, even to Donbas. It depends on each person’s sense of safety. Different journalists have different thresholds. Some work only within the city and visit sites after strikes, once it is safe to do so. Others, I work across Ukraine. We go not only to strike sites but also to the front line when possible. We work with soldiers in trenches and with artillery units. We work not only in Kharkiv city but across the region, including the directions of Kupiansk and Vovchansk, as well as in the Donbas. So journalists have different levels of comfort and safety.

Jacobsen: How many journalists have left Kharkiv for cities farther from the front line?

Chernenko: That is a good question. We do not have exact numbers. We have not counted. However, many people have left. Among our close colleagues, around ten people we know personally have left the city. More broadly, the media sector itself has shrunk. We do not have television operations in the same way, and the advertising market has declined. As a result, some media organizations have reduced their staff. Those journalists either joined the military, left the city, or found other work. At the same time, some online media continue to operate, and even new publications have appeared. So we cannot give an exact number, but among our immediate circle, about ten colleagues have left Kharkiv.

But we also need to say that many media outlets have closed. We almost no longer have television in the way we did before, especially in Kharkiv. The commercial market has collapsed, and many media organizations that relied on advertising have lost that source of funding. Without that market, many outlets stopped working. Some journalists found other jobs, and some joined the army. So the journalism market has become smaller and more concentrated than before the full-scale invasion.

If we speak about media that work only on the Internet, that is different. Online media continue to operate. We have even seen new outlets appear that specialize in web and digital publishing.

There are still media organizations in Kharkiv, but not enough of them. It is difficult to find journalists to work in local media. That is also a marker of how many experienced journalists remain.

We know that more than one hundred media workers have been killed since the start of the full-scale war. According to the Institute of Mass Information, 113 media workers had died in Ukraine since the start of the Russo-Ukrainian war in 2014, including 106 after the full-scale invasion began in 2022. Not all of them were in Kharkiv. But Kharkiv and the region have also lost journalists.

We know of two people travelling by car. One was a photographer who went north to film. One was Oleksandr Makhov. He was a Ukrainian journalist who later joined the military. He was killed on May 4, 2022, near Izium in Kharkiv Oblast while serving with Ukraine’s armed forces. More specifically, reports place his death near Dovhenke, in the Izium direction.

The other was Ihor Hudenko, a freelance photojournalist and documentarian from Kharkiv. He died on February 26, 2022, after going missing while documenting events in Kharkiv’s Pivnichna Saltivka area. He rode his bicycle toward the frontline. His death was later confirmed.

He took those photographs on February 24, 2022. He published one of them on February 25, and after that, no one could contact him.

We have also had injured journalists in Kharkiv. There were minor injuries in some cases. And yes, we have had incidents in which journalists were wounded or killed. At least two recent incidents come to mind.

One was when a drone hit a journalist’s car. One recent case involved a foreign media crew whose car was damaged by a drone explosion.

We have also had at least one local journalist injured after a strike with guided aerial bombs. There have been many situations in which Kharkiv journalists who work here constantly went in the Vovchansk direction or other dangerous areas and were injured there.

And there is another pattern. At least twice, maybe more, hotels where journalists were staying were attacked.

One of them was the Kharkiv Palace Hotel. That was on December 30, 2023. A team of journalists was staying there when it was struck, and several media workers were injured.

The other was the Park Hotel in Kharkiv, also in January 2024. Journalists, including foreign media crews, were staying there when it was attacked. A fixer working with France 2 was injured there.

After that, journalist organizations began issuing stronger recommendations against using hotels commonly known to reporters. That advice became much more serious because Russian strikes appeared to target places where journalists gather. Later reporting by IMI, RSF, and Truth Hounds described this as a repeated pattern, not a random coincidence.

Jacobsen: So one rule of thumb is this: if you ask another journalist which hotel they are using, and they tell you, then you should choose a different hotel.

Another recommendation is to stay on a lower floor, so there are more layers between you and the outside. It is also better if your room does not face the front line. Ideally, there should be walls separating you from the exterior of the building, both vertically and horizontally.

Of course, body armour and a helmet are standard. But many journalists prefer not to wear a large visible PRESS marking in frontline cities, depending on the situation. This is based on experience and on practical safety judgment.

This is really based on frontline-city practice, and what experience has taught journalists there?

Chernenko: Yes, exactly. In any case, you should have proper equipment. Even if you are working somewhere relatively safer, not directly on the front line, but still in a city like Kharkiv, we can provide press protection.

We can give you a blue vest with a press mark or another one without, whichever you prefer. We also have black helmets with small removable markings.

My own jacket is blue, but it doesn’t have a visible press sign. It is a spare flak jacket that stays in the car with my colleagues, who work constantly in the field. That is how many journalists operate.

And you must always have tourniquets with you—four tourniquets, in good condition. Ideally, you should have four. Medkits are also important because many people I work with, including some foreign journalists, still carry medkits that were assembled many years ago. That is too old. Medical supplies expire, and kits need to be updated regularly.

Jacobsen: I want to make sure it is explained clearly, at the lowest common denominator, so that anyone reading this understands: these recommendations are coming from people who know what they are talking about, who have seen colleagues injured or killed. This is the reality. What else should we cover for this interview?

Pavlov: You saw my belt. I have an individual first-aid kit on me and a spare on my back. I also have combat medic training. That is why I keep a larger trauma kit in my car, not only a small individual one. I can treat at least several people with what I carry. It is more than a basic IFAK. It is closer to the kind of equipment you would keep for a small group.

So when I go out, especially when I work in dangerous areas, I may have several different first-aid kits with me or in the car.

And not long ago, the National Union of Journalists of Ukraine sent protective and medical equipment, including IFAK kits, to be provided to journalists entering risky areas. NUJU has publicly said that its solidarity centers provide protective gear and IFAK kits to journalists, especially in frontline regions such as Kharkiv.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Anna and Volodymyr.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Diplomatic Legal Hub Supports Foreigners in Ukraine

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/06

Diplomatic Legal Hub Supports Foreigners in Ukraine

Photo by Tingey Injury Law Firm on Unsplash

By Scott Douglas Jacobsen,

Independent Reporter & Coordinator, Diplomatic Legal Hub

The Diplomatic Legal Hub, based in Kyiv, Ukraine, was publicly announced on October 8, 2025, by Interfax-Ukraine as a legal support platform for foreign businesses, citizens, and diplomatic institutions. It was presented as an initiative of Barristers, in cooperation with Ukrainian lawyers. Key publicly listed members, coordinators, partners, and consultants associated with the Hub include Oleksiy Anatoliiovych Shevchuk, Elvira Oleksandrivna Lazarenko, Yaroslav Oleksandrovych Kuts, Oleksandr Anatoliiovych Oliynyk, Inna Vasylivna Silantieva, Yurii Anatoliiovych Ryabchun, Olga Tanyushkina, Ani Mkrtumyan, Valentyn Nalyvaichenko, and Scott Douglas Jacobsen.

Oleksiy Anatoliiovych Shevchuk is one of the central public legal figures associated with the Hub. He is identified as a Barrister’s partner, spokesperson for the National Association of Advocates of Ukraine, chair of the National Association of Lobbyists of Ukraine, and doctor of philosophy in law. He has framed the Hub as a practical mechanism for foreign citizens, foreign businesses, and diplomatic institutions seeking legal support in Ukraine.

Elvira Oleksandrivna Lazarenko is a Barrister’s partner and attorney. She has described the Hub’s service model as covering the full cycle from border crossing and documentation to disputes involving migration services, customs, and courts. She has also stated that assistance to foreign citizens would be provided pro bono for at least two years; however, the Hub is not necessarily free in every context.

Yaroslav Oleksandrovych Kuts is an attorney, deputy head of the Information Policy Committee of the National Association of Advocates of Ukraine, and partner at a2kat Attorneys at Law. He has presented the Hub as relevant both during martial law and for post-war recovery, particularly as Ukraine expects increased foreign business, migration, and diplomatic activity.

Oleksandr Anatoliiovych Oliynyk is an attorney, managing partner of VIDSICH Attorneys at Law, candidate/PhD in law, and chair of the Criminal Law and Procedure Committee of the Kharkiv Regional Bar Council. He has warned about wartime risks for companies with foreign elements, including criminal proceedings and possible sanctions against legal entities.

Inna Vasylivna Silantieva is an official Hub coordinator, a researcher at the V.M. Koretsky Institute of State and Law of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine, and holds a Ph.D. in Law.

Yurii Anatoliiovych Ryabchun is the founder of the project “Chas Pershykh,” a media entrepreneur, and a digital creator involved in business, innovation, leadership, and social/cultural communications projects.

Olga Tanyushkina is a Hub co-founder and coordinator focused on medical protection and rehabilitation for foreign servicemen, especially foreign legionnaires. Her work includes compliance, due diligence, embassy liaison, grant policy, medical pathways, a project on trauma and sleep recovery for service members, and rehabilitation clinics in Europe.

Ani Mkrtumyan is the Head of the Hub’s Secretariat. She has participated in international discussions on cybersecurity, digital resilience, AI-risk governance, and the webinar “Battlefield Diplomacy: The Global Impact.”

Valentyn Nalyvaichenko has served as an independent consultant with the Hub since December 2025. His role focuses on diplomatic communication, international cooperation, security and legal diplomacy, relations with international partners, and strategic links with the United States, the European Union, and NATO states. The Verkhovna Rada’s EU-integration committee also identifies him as secretary of the Committee on Ukraine’s Integration into the European Union.

I (Scott Douglas Jacobsen) joined as a Diplomatic Legal Hub Coordinator around April 16, 2026, to strengthen the Hub’s international communications, media presence, human rights work, and global dialogue.

The Hub primarily functions as a comprehensive system of legal protection for foreign citizens and businesses in Ukraine, including legal education, risk reduction, conflict resolution between foreign businesses and the Ukrainian state, and the strengthening of diplomatic institutions through a reliable legal support mechanism. The Hub’s support model comprises three broad operational components: legal education through seminars and trainings, an online consultation platform connected to embassies, and an international network of partners and lawyers. The Hub states that it has representatives in more than 30 countries.

The Diplomatic Legal Hub functions as a wartime legal-diplomatic support platform. It provides support for foreigners and businesses in Ukraine, foreign volunteers and service members, war-damage documentation, public international law commentary, business risk support, and networking within civil and professional society.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Kseniia Fontaine, Neil Sahota, and Frederic Werner on AI for Good

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/06

Kseniia Fontaine, Neil Sahota, and Frederic Werner on AI for Good

Photo by Nahrizul Kadri on Unsplash

Kseniia Fontaine is Senior Business Development and Operations Officer in ITU’s Strategic Engagement Department, supporting AI for Good and emerging-technology initiatives. She advances partnerships, resource mobilization, standards engagement, skills development, and inclusive capacity-building, helping governments, industry, academia, and civil society expand equitable access to responsible artificial intelligence globally.

Frederic Werner is Chief of Strategic Engagement at ITU and Chief of Strategy and Operations for AI for Good. Based in Geneva, he helped create the AI for Good Global Summit and leads initiatives connecting governments, researchers, industry, and civil society to practical AI applications serving sustainable development.

Neil Sahota is loanDNA’s Chief AI Officer. Also, he is now the author of second book, AI Activation Code: https://aiactivationcode.com/. He is a United Nations AI Advisor, IBM Master Inventor, UC Irvine professor, and author of Own the A.I. Revolution. With more than two decades of business experience, he helps organizations develop AI strategy, enter new markets, and build emerging-technology solutions.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen, Frederic Werner, Neil Sahota, and Kseniia Fontaine discuss AI for Good’s origins, governance, standards, human rights, skills, mental health, misinformation, space, healthcare, Africa, and inclusion, stressing anticipatory ethics, practical collaboration, and public engagement to ensure AI serves humanity rather than deepening global digital exclusion worldwide.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: How do you define AI for Good? Who would prefer to start?

Frederic Werner: Yes, I can answer how we define AI for Good. I will start with a short story. There is an AI safety and security expert, Roman Yampolskiy, who has been on several podcasts recently, including the Lex Fridman Podcast. I met him in New York, and he asked me an interesting question. He said, “Fred, is AI for good, or for good?” I asked what he meant. He said, “Is it for good as in beneficial, or for good as in forever?” I thought it was a clever play on words, but then he clarified: what if AI is the last thing humans ever invent?

That reframing stayed with me. You may agree or disagree, but it is not difficult to imagine a future where AI is responsible for many new inventions. That is already beginning to happen, or at least human creations are increasingly co-created with AI. If that is the direction we are heading, then we need to ensure that AI is for good in the sense of being beneficial.

One of our key phrases for the summit is: what is AI for Good? Simply put, it is about unlocking AI’s potential to serve humanity.

Rewinding a bit, Neil was present at its inception in 2017. That is when AI for Good was established by the International Telecommunication Union, the United Nations agency for digital technologies. At the time, the conversation around AI was dominated by hype, fear, and uncertainty. We had to persuade people to come into the room. It was not for lack of strong speakers, we had leading figures such as Yoshua Bengio, Fei-Fei Li, Stuart Russell, and Gary Marcus, but at that time they were not widely known outside expert circles.

We were trying to show people that, while there was hype and fear, there was also real promise. If there was even a chance that AI could develop in this way, then we needed to ensure it was used to address global challenges, affordable healthcare, clean energy, food security, disaster response, and beyond.

Misinformation was a concern, but the potential was there. At the time, the mission was simple: identify practical applications of AI that could help advance solutions, and then build collaboration around them within the UN context. When I say collaboration, I do not mean only big tech, major governments, or a select few with funding and resources. The goal was to bring the Global South to the table, along with students, young people, artists, athletes, leaders, NGOs, civil society, politicians, international media like yourselves, and everyone in between. I will pause there, that is the genesis of AI for Good. But if AI is going to be “for good” in the sense of lasting, then we must ensure it is genuinely beneficial.

Neil Sahota: To add to that, one reason I championed this initiative was the amount of fear and fear-mongering at the time. Bad actors will always do harmful things, but good actors often need a nudge. That is what we wanted to create. People tend to focus on profit or entertainment, not that those are inherently bad, but we do not always think about how to use technology for broader benefit, such as advancing development goals. We tend to separate for-profit and nonprofit efforts, even though they can coexist and even complement each other.

The second point is that I do not think AI will be the last thing humans invent. AI can only do what we train it to do, and we have not yet figured out how to teach genuine creative thinking. Perhaps that will change. For now, I strongly support the idea of hybrid intelligence, humans working with machines. That is where the real benefit lies. I do believe AI is making us more human.

Kseniia Fontaine: Building on that, when we brought AI experts to the table, many of them emphasized that AI is too important to be left only to technical specialists. For the International Telecommunication Union, as a UN agency, we approach this practically by grounding AI for Good in established UN principles. When we develop projects and build the community, we follow human rights frameworks that are not defined by one or two countries but represent a global consensus on the challenges the world is facing. These frameworks serve as our benchmark. We are not inventing new ethical foundations; we are building on internationally agreed principles that have developed over many decades.

Jacobsen: There is a well-known quote, if I recall correctly, from Alan Turing, which can be interpreted as either realistic or pessimistic. It states that it is customary to claim that some uniquely human characteristic can never be imitated by a machine, but that no such limits can confidently be set. If that is the case, then in thinking about AI for Good, are we essentially asking the same question we ask about human beings? That is, how do we orient both people and machines toward what we define as the good, especially if no clear boundaries exist?

Sahota: That is an interesting point. Ultimately, it comes down to people. We are getting philosophical, but “the good” is a subjective concept. We have already seen troubling uses of this technology. For example, there was a case in Canada where deepfake technology was used to create child exploitation material. That is precisely why AI for Good is necessary, not just involving AI experts, but bringing everyone to the table. We need to become better at anticipating misuse. There is an entire initiative within AI for Good focused on governance for this reason. Technology is engineered toward intended outcomes. We build what we are asked to build, but we do not always anticipate how it might be misused.

I think it is a fair assumption that other people will figure out harmful uses, and that is one of the major challenges. Historically, regulation has reacted after something goes wrong. With AI, things are moving so quickly that we cannot simply react anymore; we have to anticipate. Humans are not very good at that. Ironically, AI is quite good at scenario planning. Still, putting yourself in the mindset of a criminal, a bad actor, or someone seeking power or money is difficult for most people.

What we are trying to figure out is that, ultimately, there will need to be some ethical baselines the world can agree on to define what “good” really means. That is the difficult challenge. What we are discovering is that the hardest part is not making the technology work, or even developing applications. It is the people problem. That is what we are trying to address through this community. If we bring good people together, and I believe most people are good, we can accomplish a great deal. But we need an ecosystem, a hub, a forum, and a nudge to create the good.

Werner: Responding to that quote as well, one interesting thing about AI is that it acts almost like a mirror. It pushes us into a corner and forces us to think about things we have not naturally thought about for a long time. I would even argue there has probably not been a time in history, apart from perhaps the Greek or Roman philosophers, when we thought so much about what it means to be human.

As these systems evolve and become more capable, every new capability forces us to ask: What would I do? What is right? What is wrong? What is ethical? Of course, there is the classic trolley problem in autonomous driving, but that is only one example among many. As these capabilities evolve, humans need to think about rules. Is it safe? Is it ethical? Is it inclusive? Will it serve everyone or only a few? Will it respect privacy? Will it cause harm?

It almost forces us into a corner where we have to address these questions. What is interesting is that when we see a piece of software or an autonomous vehicle, for example, I was recently in the United States and visited Waymo. I was impressed, frankly, driving around Austin. I do not have the statistics in front of me, but from what I understand, the data on hours driven versus accidents, especially involving pedestrians and cyclists, is quite promising, though it still needs to scale. It would not work the same way in New Delhi, where I had just been.

Still, people often seem more concerned about the idea of a machine making a mistake than about humans making mistakes. I was half-joking, but only half-joking, when I said maybe we need a “Humans for Good” conference. Sometimes it feels as though the focus becomes, “Let us talk about all the machines going wrong,” when human behaviour remains the deeper issue.

Fontaine: Yesterday, we had a very interesting discussion with the Holy See Mission in Geneva. Last year, we received a message from Pope Francis, and this year it looks as though the Holy See may return to Geneva, because this topic has become very important. We have found that the Vatican has been deeply involved in philosophical discussions about technology.

One point they raised was that, because of these questions around the development of AI, they see more people turning back to religion, or at least turning again toward questions about what it means to be human, what values matter, and how technology should be used.

There are also new uses of AI, such as AI for grief. There are now applications that allow people to recreate deceased loved ones, using their image or voice as part of the grieving process. Is that good or bad? We do not know. Similar questions arise around longevity and life after death. There is also Kazuo Ishiguro’s Klara and the Sun, which presents a dystopian reflection on recreating or replacing children in the context of illness and loss. These questions are returning with urgency.

So, you cannot measure good or bad with one code or one rule. But as Frederic said, AI makes us question ourselves much more deeply as human beings. It is not only about whether the technology itself is harmful; it is about how we use it. As Neil said, it can be used for the wrong purposes. That is why it is important to have a community driving AI for Good, not only from our side, but through a broader community that questions these applications in real time as they develop. That is very significant. So maybe we really do need “AI for Human.”

Jacobsen: The thrust of the Turing quote was the convergence of machine capabilities, not simply intelligence, with human capabilities, which change much more slowly, over something like a 100,000-year timeline of evolution and speciation. So, an AI for Good summit, or part of it, is in some sense also an “Humans for Good” conference.

Because we are talking about convergence, which we are seeing more and more now, we are also talking about redefining the good. We are discovering more about human nature through machine intelligence, while also, to Neil’s earlier point, redefining human nature. There is a circularity here: human nature is natural, but it is also adaptive by nature.

Maybe that helps explain why people reach for new answers in older traditions, or reinterpretations of older traditions, to define the good. What do you think are the most immediate concerns for communities trying to develop anticipatory legislation or moral frameworks for this rapidly advancing curve of artificial intelligence?

Sahota: I will jump in. One of my biggest concerns is that, because we are teaching AI, people are relying on technologists to build things they do not fully understand. We cannot do that successfully without having the right people at the table.

I will use Meta as an example. They got into trouble over redlining, which in the United States refers to practices that can exclude certain groups from housing-related opportunities or advertising. They had built AI tools to facilitate advertising, but when people asked their engineers how they accounted for redlining, the engineers apparently did not know what redlining was. That is the issue.

A lot of people still treat AI as an IT project: gather the requirements, build the system, deploy it. But that is not really how AI works. I often say you are not buying software; you are hiring a high-energy intern. It is ready to do work, but you have to teach it how to do that work, your processes, your data, your context.

Take legal tech. If I remember the numbers correctly, venture capital and private equity firms invested heavily in AI and legal startups over several years, and many of them failed. But when you look at who survived, the successful companies were often started by lawyers or paralegals. They understood the domain. They were not just building software; they were effectively building an AI paralegal or an AI associate lawyer.

That is where we struggle. We have siloed AI as technology, so people assume it belongs to technologists. But that is not true. Would you entrust the hiring of a financial analyst to your data scientist? Probably not. Not everyone needs to know how to make the hammer, but people do need to learn how to use it. That is the challenge. We have this new tool with unfamiliar capabilities, and too often we default to the help-desk person to show us how to use it, instead of learning how to manage it ourselves.

Werner: That is a good example, Neil. Another example applies more to the developing world. We held AI for Good Impact Africa at the end of last year. The idea was that not everyone can come to Geneva to discuss these questions, so we also need to bring these conversations to different parts of the world.

There was a major discussion around AI diffusion, sovereign AI, and sovereign data. Six or seven years ago, before the pandemic, some large technology companies had a mentality that was almost: “Here is a technology handout. It works out of the box. Use it, trust us, and everything will be fine.” That may have seemed acceptable before the pandemic, but now there has been a shift.

I would compare it to what happened in East Africa with mobile payments. There was a mobile-payment revolution that effectively leapfrogged decades of legacy infrastructure. With systems such as M-Pesa, countries were able to reduce dependence on intermediaries, improve financial inclusion, and generate wider beneficial effects. There is hope that AI could do something similar on the African continent by unlocking new opportunities.

I was speaking with a gentleman in Johannesburg who works in the townships and was writing a book on AI in the townships. I asked him how many people in the townships have a mobile phone with 5G and access to ChatGPT or something similar. He said probably about 80 percent. That is a significant shift compared to a couple of decades ago.

Then we started discussing whether people are using these tools to start businesses, create value, collaborate, educate themselves, or ensure that people are not left behind. That brought us to AI skills and education. Putting a tool in someone’s hand does not mean it will automatically be used in the right way, or that it will create value and new businesses responsibly.

So, the AI-skilling and education piece, from grade school to graduate school, from children to diplomats to entrepreneurs and everyone in between, is probably the top priority. If you speak with our member states who come to AI for Good each year, they discuss many major issues and do not agree on everything. But one thing they agree on across the board is the need to address the AI skills gap and democratize access to AI skills. That is a shared challenge whether you are in the United States, South Africa, China, Bangladesh, or elsewhere. As Neil said, just because you have the hammer does not mean you know how to use it properly.

Fontaine: We have already been trying to address this issue. Last year, we launched the AI Skills Coalition, a global movement led by ITU with more than 70 partners worldwide, including UN entities, private-sector organizations, and NGOs. The idea is very basic: democratize access to AI skills, covering everything from K–12 curricula in different parts of the world to diplomats and policymakers.

Even when we work with highly professional people, we sometimes see that their understanding of AI is still very basic, even though they are making decisions about it. The same applies to schools. In the Africa region, for example, we have been running a project focused on AI and robotics in schools, working to localize curricula through governments.

There is a great deal to do and a great deal of demand. The question now is pace: how quickly can we move? There is also the challenge that the AI skills needed in Europe may not be the same as those needed in Africa or Asia. So we need partners who can localize knowledge. Global frameworks are useful, but we must ensure they are applicable in specific regional contexts.

Jacobsen: One aspect of this is the democratization of the skill set. But use will be local, specific, and sometimes parochial. Another aspect is human rights. The aspirational and foundational principle behind human rights is universalism, and that part is not necessarily solved. That seems to be one of the questions AI in Africa is posing.

There has always been a challenge in applying universal human rights as an ethical framework. How do you see similar problems potentially arising when applying a reasonable universal definition of “good,” within an AI framework, to different regions of the world with different needs?

Werner: One very important development this year is that, for the first time, the United Nations AI Global Governance Dialogue will take place in Geneva at the same time as AI for Good.

That is significant because AI for Good has existed since 2017 and has grown organically as a movement and community. During that same period, ITU has also been leading and fostering AI governance coordination within the UN system. We co-lead the interagency working group on AI with UNESCO.

Out of this momentum, there have been several landmark resolutions passed in New York. One of them established the first Global Governance Dialogue in Geneva as part of AI for Good. This will be the first time member states sit around the table in a mandated way to discuss AI governance and how to move it forward.

It will work in several ways. A scientific panel on AI was nominated and announced a few months ago. ITU was partly responsible for selecting that panel, together with UNESCO and the Office of the Secretary-General’s Envoy on Technology in New York. What is interesting is that probably about a quarter of the nominees have already been involved in AI for Good from the beginning, including Yoshua Bengio, for example.

There are consultations happening now in New York, Geneva, virtually, and around the world. Member states will come to the table for consultations and dialogue over two days. The scientific panel on AI will deliver a report to the dialogue. The output, without sounding too bureaucratic, will be a report from the co-chairs of the dialogue, the ambassadors of El Salvador and Estonia.

What is significant is that the dialogue has seven themes, and one of them is human rights. Human rights will therefore be central to member-state discussions in an organized way. That will feed into the global summit and into different mechanisms across the UN system.

Our goal is to turn principles into action. There are many high-level principles emerging from resolutions, declarations, reports, and regulatory processes around the world. One of the most effective ways to translate those principles into action is through standards. At its core, the International Telecommunication Union is a standards-setting body. It is the only UN agency with a mixed membership model, 194 member states, along with more than a thousand private companies and academic institutions, all contributing to a consensus-driven standards process.

I do not think we will see a centralized global AI regulation. AI is a moving target, and different regions and nations have their own priorities. But standards allow us to take high-level principles and operationalize them. The ITU standards-making process is inclusive by design. There are significant efforts to bring developing countries to the table through training and funding programs so they can participate. That way, standards are not just designed to work in places like Los Angeles or Shenzhen, but are fit for purpose across regions such as Africa.

Human rights and fundamental rights are built into this process. As standards are co-designed, by member states, companies, experts, and academics from around the world, there is an opportunity to embed considerations like security, inclusivity, sustainability, energy use, and privacy. Standards may not be the most glamorous tool, but while we wait for a comprehensive regulatory solution, which may never fully emerge, they are the most practical way to embed “AI for Good” principles as systems scale.

Sahota: I will add that what Fred is saying is incredibly important. I have often been asked, “Why the ITU? Why the United Nations?” The honest answer is that they are the only globally credible organizations positioned to do this.

Before AI governance gained traction, there were initiatives like the Partnership on AI, but many were launched by private companies, which led people to question their motives. Others were driven by individual states, raising concerns about political agendas. That lack of trust was a major barrier. This brings us back to the point that people are often the biggest challenge.

The ITU and the UN stepped in to provide a neutral platform and have done a strong job driving this forward. When I look back over the last decade, the progress is significant. The conversation around AI has changed dramatically. Ten years ago, many discussions focused on fears that AI would turn against humanity. We do not hear those narratives as much anymore. Instead, people recognize AI as a powerful tool.

Even during the pandemic, when relations between the United States and China were strained, AI governance remained an area of continued dialogue. That shows how important this issue is globally. Work around standards and governance is critical because it surfaces second-order effects we do not always consider, for example, how AI infrastructure drives demand for rare earth materials, potentially creating new geopolitical and economic dynamics. For developing countries, that raises serious questions about participation and equity. Some African nations are already collaborating to address these challenges collectively.

That is why we need this community, to anticipate consequences, understand potential uses and misuses, and guide development toward positive outcomes.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, everyone.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Vladyslav Novikov on Alabuga Polytech, Russian Drone Recruitment, and the AlabugaCase Investigation

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/06

Vladyslav Novikov is a Ukrainian journalist, investigator, and broadcaster with 24 Channel whose work focuses on open-source intelligence, digital evidence preservation, and Russian information operations. He is the creator of the Alabuga Case Archive, a project documenting the online promotion and recruitment activities of Alabuga Polytech, an institution linked to Russia’s drone-production ecosystem. Through large-scale analysis of social media content, archived videos, and promotional networks, Novikov examines sanctions loopholes, propaganda, and wartime recruitment.

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen speaks with Vladyslav Novikov, a Ukrainian journalist and creator of the Alabuga Case Archive, about his investigation into Alabuga Polytech and its alleged role in recruiting young people for Russia’s drone-production ecosystem. Novikov discusses how he uncovered a vast online promotional network spanning YouTube and Twitch, the challenges of preserving disappearing evidence, sanctions loopholes, open-source intelligence methods, Russian disinformation, and the broader implications for Ukraine, Western democracies, and wartime accountability.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Alabuga Polytech. How old is this institution? How far does this story go now?

Vladyslav Novikov: This story begins with the Alabuga Special Economic Zone, near Yelabuga in the Republic of Tatarstan, Russia. It is a designated industrial and economic zone.

The United States, the European Union, and the United Kingdom have sanctioned the Alabuga Special Economic Zone. However, not every entity, factory, or institution connected to the zone is automatically sanctioned. Russia has exploited this loophole. Within the zone, there is drone production associated with Shahed- and Geran-type attack drones. Nearby, there is Alabuga Polytech.

They present Alabuga Polytech as an educational opportunity for young Russians, but many people in Russia understand what it actually is. It is not only about education. It is also about military recruitment and labour for drone production. They recruit young people, train them in skills connected to manufacturing attack drones such as Shaheds and Gerans, and then place them in factories where those drones are produced. Those drones are then used to attack Ukraine.

This is one aspect of the problem, but it is not the only one. There are several dimensions to this story.

Jacobsen: How is Alabuga Polytech promoted?

Novikov: It is promoted on Western platforms such as YouTube and Twitch. When platforms attempt to restrict or remove this content, the organizers argue that it is merely an educational project. They claim that they are simply teaching and training young people. Because of that educational framing, platforms often hesitate to take action.

Russia has used this loophole since the beginning of the full-scale invasion in 2022 and continues to use it today.

The Alabuga web archive that I created documents these cases. Russian bloggers became concerned after Twitch banned certain related content, and many of them returned to YouTube and deleted videos containing these advertisements. Some removed only the relevant segments, while others deleted entire videos.

For us, this created a major problem. If we approach sanctions authorities and explain that a recruitment network was operating on U.S.-based platforms, investigators may search for evidence and find nothing because the content has already been removed.

That is why I created the archive. I downloaded more than 400 examples from YouTube, built the website, and preserved the evidence.

My primary objective is to have Alabuga Polytech added to international sanctions lists. If that happens, recruitment campaigns on Western platforms such as YouTube can be stopped more effectively. Adding Alabuga Polytech to sanctions lists would help close this loophole. That is my goal.

Jacobsen: What were some of the most interesting findings from your research beyond the obvious ones? One clear finding is that some individuals in Russia attend this institution knowing it is connected to drone production rather than to education alone. That much seems relatively apparent.

What were some of the less obvious discoveries? How did you first uncover this story, and what important findings emerged during the investigation that were not evident at the outset but became clear as your research progressed?

Novikov: This story is quite long, and I can tell you that I found it almost by accident.

I was interested in Twitch. Alabuga Polytech sponsored a Twitch tournament. I thought, “Okay, what is this? It sounds strange.” I started researching it. I looked into what kind of educational institution it was and found some Ukrainian studies on it.

Then I discovered that it was connected to Shahed drone production. I thought, “Okay, that is interesting.”

At first, I wanted to make a simple story about Twitch. Why was Twitch allowing this organization to sponsor tournaments? But then I discovered that it was much bigger than Twitch. There were hundreds of YouTube videos, many bloggers, many streamers, and a large advertising network promoting Alabuga Polytech.

One of the most surprising findings was the scale. At the beginning, I thought I would find a few examples. Instead, I found hundreds of videos and hundreds of millions of views connected to content promoting Alabuga Polytech.

Another unexpected finding was how openly many bloggers discussed it. They did not try to hide what Alabuga Polytech was. Some openly talked about drone production, military technologies, and employment opportunities connected to the project.

I also found that many videos were designed to look like ordinary educational or career content. They focused on student life, salaries, housing, opportunities, and career development. Someone watching the videos without additional context might see them as standard recruitment materials rather than content connected to military-industrial production.

Another important discovery was how quickly evidence began disappearing once attention increased. After Twitch took action against some related content, many creators started deleting videos or removing segments that mentioned Alabuga Polytech. That was one of the reasons I realized that preserving the evidence was becoming urgent.

I also learned that the issue was not limited to a single platform. YouTube was the largest source of material I found, but the promotional ecosystem extended across multiple online platforms and communities.

What surprised me most was how effectively the educational narrative functioned as protection. Whenever questions were raised, supporters could point to classrooms, training programs, student activities, and educational branding. That made it much more difficult for platforms and regulators to respond, even when there were documented links to drone production.

At the start of the investigation, I thought I was researching a sponsorship issue on Twitch. By the end, I realized I was documenting a large-scale recruitment and promotional network connected to a strategic sector of Russia’s military-industrial complex.

Jacobsen: Have you done any prior research on polytechnic institutions before this investigation?

Novikov: Yes. I looked into the history of the factory and industrial facilities connected to this area. Some of these facilities operated during the Soviet era and continued to exist after the collapse of the Soviet Union.

From what I found, many of these industrial assets were in decline before the war. Russia did not appear to have a clear strategy for using them effectively. Then, after the full-scale invasion began, there was renewed interest in these facilities. The authorities recognized that they had this industrial infrastructure and special economic zone available and began investing in them again, thereby giving them new strategic importance.

That may not fully answer your question, but that is the historical context as I understand it.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Vladyslav.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Fumfer Physics 50: Durable Cosmic Structures, Information, Intelligence, and the Future of Human Cognition

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/06

Fumfer Physics 50: Durable Cosmic Structures, Information, Intelligence, and the Future of Human Cognition

Photo by David Matos on Unsplash

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner examine durability, information, and intelligence across physics and cognition. Rosner identifies collapsed matter, black holes, and the universe itself as ultimate durable structures, then reflects on microscopic gravitational collapse, the particle zoo, and context-dependent information. He also discusses aging intelligence, the Flynn effect’s reversal, technological outsourcing, and humanity’s uncertain cognitive future. The exchange links cosmology to everyday meaning-making and social adaptation with speculative scientific caution throughout.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: I asked you something related to this a while ago, but I want to frame it differently. If you think about the most durable minimal structures in nature, a triangle, a pyramid, or some other simple geometric form, what would be the equivalent in Newtonian physics, in Einsteinian relativity, and in quantum mechanics?

Rick Rosner: The most durable structures are probably forms of collapsed matter.

You take a star and let it exhaust its fuel. Depending on its mass, it may end its life as a white dwarf, a neutron star, or a black hole. Those remnants are extraordinarily durable.

If it turns out that the universe is older than its currently estimated age, we may discover structures that have persisted for tens of billions of years. Collapsed objects possess immense gravitational binding forces and are difficult to disrupt.

Many of these objects probably contain highly complex internal structures that emerged during or after their formation.

There is also a concept known as black-hole cosmology. The idea is that regions of extreme spacetime curvature may effectively contain their own internal domains. In some speculative models, those domains could even contain “baby universes.”

Now, if durability means remaining unchanged, then such universes are not durable because they are constantly evolving. But if durability means having a high probability of persisting over extremely long periods of time, then they are durable.

In that sense, the most durable structures are those possessing intense gravitational fields and their own effectively self-contained regions of spacetime.

By that logic, the most durable structure in the universe may simply be the universe itself. Under certain cyclic or recycling cosmological models, the universe could persist far longer than its apparent age through processes of continual renewal.

So the most durable structure in the universe may be the entire universe.

Jacobsen: If spacetime emerges from more fundamental processes, and if curvature occurs on large scales through gravitational lensing, then curvature should also exist at increasingly smaller scales. What is the tightest possible gravitational U-turn? How small can a gravitational structure become while still curving in on itself?

Rosner: I do not know. Someone has probably performed the relevant calculations, though not necessarily correctly. Essentially, you are asking how much matter must be compressed before something approaches black-hole conditions.

That is related to discussions that arose around CERN and the Large Hadron Collider. Some people worried that high-energy collisions might accidentally create microscopic black holes that would somehow consume the Earth. Those concerns turned out to be unfounded.

But conceptually, it is the same question: what is the minimum amount of matter required to generate that degree of gravitational collapse?

I do not know the answer. Someone could calculate it. It is certainly not a trivial amount of matter. Could you create a black hole with the mass contained in a brick? I honestly do not know.

Jacobsen: What is the least interesting thing about the universe to you?

Rosner: I like that question.

I have never really thought about it before.

Earlier versions of my IC framework led me to what I jokingly called “Bland Universe Theory.” Those earlier iterations removed the dramatic Big Bang-style explosion and many other catastrophic events common to standard cosmology.

Paradoxically, the universe’s relative boringness may be one of its most interesting features. A self-recycling universe is less dramatic, but perhaps more elegant.

As for things that interest me less than other topics, I would probably point to the particle zoo.

The Standard Model contains dozens of particles, but I am more interested in what I think of as the “big five”: protons, neutrons, electrons, photons, and neutrinos. Those particles do most of the visible work of the macroscopic universe.

The other particles are important because they provide the underlying structure and consistency that allow the major particles to behave as they do. They are essential components of the overall framework.

Still, I find pions and many of the other exotic particles less inherently fascinating than the particles that dominate everyday physical reality.

So yes, perhaps that is my answer.

Jacobsen: Consider the compactness of information in a book, on paper, or on a screen.

Physically, it is just patterns reflecting light. Yet to human beings those patterns become meaningful and can generate entirely new worlds inside the mind.

What is the difference between the raw physical information and the mental realities that emerge from it?

Rosner: We have talked about something like this before, and I am going to default to the same answer.

Information is only information within a context.

We are so accustomed to immediately understanding context that we rarely think about it unless we are forced to. At the macroscopic level, we still do not fully understand how information actually works.

Our understanding remains incomplete.

Information runs the universe, and we do not really know how.

Some people, including me, suspect that gravitation and the geometry of space may themselves emerge from informational relationships. The reason spacetime takes the shape it does may ultimately be a function of information.

The problem is that we do not yet understand how that information functions at the deepest level.

That is something we need to discover.

Jacobsen: Intelligence is not a single thing. It emerges through development as different systems come online. It changes over time through the interaction of genetics, epigenetics, experience, and environment.

As people age, setting aside severe cognitive decline, what changes do you notice in the overall shape of intelligence?

Psychometricians often discuss declines in fluid intelligence and increases in crystallized intelligence, but I am interested in something broader than that.

Rosner: Stereotypically, people do a great deal of abstract intellectual work when they are younger. As they age, many become increasingly occupied with practical concerns and administration.

Theoretical thinkers often become managers over the course of forty years. That is a common trajectory.

At the societal level, something else is happening as well.

We know about the Flynn effect. For roughly fifty years after World War II, average IQ scores increased as education expanded and information became more widely available.

Over the last decade or two, however, that trend has stalled or reversed in many places.

As we outsource more thinking to technology, we become more distracted. We become less disciplined in how we acquire and analyze information because many cognitive tasks are now performed by our devices.

So there are individual life trajectories, and then there is the trajectory of humanity combined with technology.

Humanity-plus-technology is becoming smarter in many ways, while individuals may be becoming less cognitively engaged at a granular level.

We are at a precarious point where increasingly capable technology is disrupting almost everything.

Will we eventually reach some stable equilibrium, whether utopian, dystopian, or some combination of the two, or will things remain permanently chaotic?

I do not know.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Fumfer Physics 49: Evolving Mathematics, Genius at Home, and Humanizing Physics

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/06

Fumfer Physics 49: Evolving Mathematics, Genius at Home, and Humanizing Physics

Photo by Resource Database on Unsplash

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner discuss how mathematical definitions evolve, from the number one to prime structures and unresolved problems like twin primes. They then move into the domestic lives of intellectual giants such as Terence Tao and Edward Witten, market analysis, chartists, absent-mindedness, cognitive concerns, and why abstract physics often becomes less compelling without human stories, ending with Rosner’s reflections on long-term marriage.

Evolving Mathematical Concepts

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: I was watching an interview with Terence Tao, and he was discussing how even definitions in mathematics, perhaps in number theory, can evolve over time. Concepts as basic as one or zero may be understood differently as mathematics advances. Do you have any thoughts on that?

Rick Rosner: The more abstract and sophisticated a mathematical concept becomes, the more likely its interpretation is to evolve. Even something as intuitively simple as the number one can take on different meanings depending on the mathematical framework.

Someone deeply immersed in quantum mechanics, for example, might think about the assumptions and limitations that underlie what appears to be a straightforward concept. But in ordinary mathematics, the number one remains a remarkably stable idea.

What changes over time is not necessarily the number itself but the network of relationships and structures in which it participates. Mathematicians continually discover new properties, connections, and patterns involving numbers.

For example, prime numbers are not merely counting numbers; they also possess intricate relationships and distributions. When you remove multiples of a given prime and examine what remains, new structures emerge. This process reveals additional layers of mathematical organization.

Prime numbers occupy a particularly important role because every composite number can ultimately be factored into primes. In that sense, they form a foundational framework for the integers. Questions such as whether there are infinitely many twin primes illustrate how seemingly simple numerical concepts can lead to profound and unresolved mathematical problems.

I suspect there are deep informational principles underlying many of these patterns, although proving such ideas is another matter entirely. Mathematics continually reveals that even the most familiar concepts are embedded within far more complex structures than we initially realize.

I am sure Terence Tao knows vastly more about the number one than I do. It would be fascinating to hear him give a ninety-minute lecture on nothing but the number one.

Jacobsen: He probably could. I think he gave one lecture called The Cosmic Distance Ladder, and it was probably an hour or two long. Someone with that level of expertise certainly could.

Genius at Home

Rosner: That makes me wonder: Terence Tao has a wife and children, right?

Jacobsen: A wife and three children, yes. The same is true of Edward Witten. Terence Tao and Edward Witten are both married and have children, I think.

Rosner: All right, so these are people with extraordinarily powerful minds who spend their days doing exceptionally advanced work. Then they go home to their spouses and children. What is that household like?

At my house, if I mention that I am very smart, my wife just laughs. She knows I am intelligent, but she also sees the limited practical value of it in many day-to-day situations. She laughs because she sees me waking up from my second nap or wandering around the house in my socks. So I wonder whether, when Tao or Witten go home, it is basically the same thing. Is it just a normal family environment, like Homer and Marge and the kids, where highly abstract intellectual topics rarely come up and most conversations revolve around ordinary household matters?

I mean, the opportunities to display intellectual brilliance during dinner and while watching television afterward are fairly limited.

Investments and Practical Intelligence

There are occasional situations where analytical thinking becomes useful. For example, my wife and I discuss investments. We are older, and like many people in our generation, we have accumulated assets. It is conceivable that a highly intelligent person could apply sophisticated analysis to questions such as whether this is a good time to be invested in the stock market. Perhaps Tao or Witten would have unique insights.

In our case, I do not possess any profound mathematical framework for analyzing markets. We generally listen to a variety of commentators and analysts, then try to triangulate among their opinions. We also try to account for potential conflicts of interest.

For instance, if you invest through a mutual fund company, you can either purchase funds directly or pay an additional management fee for professional portfolio management. Those managers are often incentivized to keep your money invested because their compensation depends on assets under management. That incentive structure is worth keeping in mind.

I do not engage in elaborate mathematical forecasting techniques. Have you heard of chartists? A chartist is someone who attempts to analyze financial markets by studying the patterns formed by price movements over time. They believe that certain recurring configurations can help predict future market behavior.

Jacobsen: It is somewhat like using graph-based geometric patterns in place of formal equations.

Rosner: A graph-based predictive geometry, sure. I do not do that. I have noticed what appears to be a short-term tendency toward mean reversion in stock prices, but I have never actually analyzed it.

The simplest analysis would be to calculate the historical probability that the market rises on any given day. Since markets tend to rise over long periods, the percentage of up days is greater than 50 percent. Then you could compare that figure with the probability of an up day immediately following another up day, and the probability of an up day following a down day.

My intuition is that the probability of an up day after an up day might be somewhat lower than the overall average, while the probability of an up day after a down day might be somewhat higher. But that is just speculation on my part. I have never run the numbers.

Would Terence Tao do something like that? He certainly has the technical skills. If he became interested in a market question, or if his wife asked whether they should invest differently, he could probably write a quick program to test a hypothesis and see what the data revealed.

Then again, he might come back with a different kind of answer: that the expected return from spending time on market analysis is lower than the return from continuing the work for which he is already highly compensated. That might be the truly intelligent response.

What I wonder is whether there are highly intellectual conversations in the Tao household or the Witten household. Or are they simply ordinary families whose professional work stays at work?

Jacobsen: I suspect it varies. Idle intellectual conversations may be more likely in the Witten household because, as far as I know, Edward Witten is married to another academic. Terence Tao’s wife is not a mathematician or physicist, as far as I am aware.

If that is correct, conversations in the Tao household may be more ordinary than those in the Witten household.

Absent-Mindedness and Cognitive Concerns

Rosner: Lately, Carole has been accusing me of being absent-minded because I do not always remember every detail she tells me. Part of that comes from concern. She pays close attention to signs of cognitive decline because she watched her mother experience mental deterioration, and she is aware of similar issues among friends and their spouses.

She keeps an eye on me because I am older than she is, although not dramatically older. She wants to know whether I am starting to lose my mental sharpness.

My response is that I am not experiencing cognitive decline. I also think people have a right to be absent-minded at times. Sometimes you become absorbed in your own thoughts and do not remember every detail of every conversation.

In our household, there is often an expectation that I should remember everything that has been said. Yet most of those conversations are not philosophical, scientific, or mathematical discussions of the sort one might imagine taking place among academics.

Why Physics Can Become Boring

If I try to talk to Carole about physics, which I rarely do, her response is usually, “Talk to me about something that is not boring.”

I can sometimes make a scientific idea interesting for a few sentences by presenting an unexpected fact or insight. But if I continue elaborating on it, it quickly becomes boring to her.

Jacobsen: What is it about the subject that makes it boring to her?

Rosner: It seems that, beyond a certain point, which is reached fairly quickly, it becomes like discussing the Rams, the Lakers, or the Dodgers. One sentence might be interesting. For example, saying that the Dodgers have been one of the most successful teams in Major League Baseball during the twenty-first century is mildly interesting.

But if I start discussing the details, how many games the Yankees have won compared with the Dodgers, or other statistical minutiae, it quickly becomes boring.

Human Stories and Familiar Subjects

What makes sports interesting is often the human story. If there were some unusual personal rivalry between a pitcher and a batter, that would be interesting. But once you start explaining the statistical basis in great detail, how often a batter is typically hit by a pitch compared with some specific case, the conversation can quickly lose its appeal.

Physics is often similar. I could tell Carole something intriguing, such as the fact that a single photon in a quantum experiment can exhibit behavior that appears to involve multiple possible paths. That is interesting for a moment because it is counterintuitive.

People are also familiar with concepts such as Schrödinger’s cat, parallel universes, and the multiverse because those ideas have become common in popular culture. The first few times someone encounters them, they seem fascinating. Eventually, however, they become clichés. Once the novelty wears off, discussing them in greater detail can become less engaging.

Recently, we have been watching Euphoria. One thing Carole pointed out was that one of the performers playing a stripper was actually a legitimate actress related to another well-known actor. That kind of behind-the-scenes detail is interesting because it provides context and a human story.

Carole and I have been together for forty years, so I have developed a fairly good sense of what she finds interesting and when a topic begins to lose her attention.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Dr. Oksana Mankovska: Ukrainian Scientist on War, Brain Drain, and the Future of Research

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Vocal.Media

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/06

Dr. Oksana Mankovska is a Ukrainian molecular biologist specializing in cancer research and biomarker discovery. She serves as a research scientist at the Institute of Molecular Biology and Genetics of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine and as an ambassador for the European Association for Cancer Research. Holding a PhD in Molecular Biology from Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv, her work focuses on liquid biopsies, cell biology, and translational oncology within both academic and biotech environments.

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen speaks with Dr. Oksana Mankovska about the immediate disruption to Ukrainian science caused by Russia’s invasion, including lost grants, halted collaborations, and the forced migration of researchers. Mankovska reflects on systemic issues predating the war—poor infrastructure and low funding—while noting increased international support and collaboration. Despite setbacks, she expresses cautious optimism about rebuilding Ukrainian science through global partnerships and a more open, mobile research culture.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: What was your first experience of the war?

Dr. Oksana Mankovska: Yes, I overslept, so I did not hear anything. I woke up and…

Jacobsen: How did you start the war? I slept in.

Mankovska: Yes, yes. But that day, my NGO and I got the Horizon Europe grant.

Jacobsen: Horizon Europe? Is that a federal program?

Mankovska: No, it is a European Union research and innovation funding program. Yes, yes. So we successfully received this grant. We needed to finalize the paperwork. We had to do this project with Kharkiv. On that day, they needed to send some documents to Horizon Europe, to the European Commission office, as I remember.

The first message from Kharkiv, from our collaborators, was that they were leaving, and they said, “Leave, if you can also leave.” So everything was destroyed. A lot of work was destroyed. Not physically, but the work on the ground was fantastic.

The main sad thing is that the European Commission declined our participation in this program because of the war. We had already done this work.

Jacobsen: Now, the denial of the grant, of participation, because of the war, what were they afraid of? It was an investment, so what were they afraid of? Was it the loss of investment over time?

Mankovska: Yes, but I think at the beginning of the war it was a problem. Now, probably not, because we have already saved the infrastructure in some cities, and I think Europe and other countries can invest. They understand that we can deal with this problem. We understand the risks, and they understand the risks, and we have had some success in dealing with them. There is more trust in us than there was at the beginning, because everyone thought that we would fall in three days, I think. But Horizon Europe never came back to us.

Jacobsen: Are they back now?

Mankovska: No, no. I hoped that they would pause the process, but they did not.

Jacobsen: If I may interject as a third party, the risk of losing a substantial investment by the European Union or the European Commission is a rational concern. The disappointment in Ukraine over the loss of funding, especially while seeking EU accession, is also a rational emotion. I do not think either side is unreasonable. It is simply an unfortunate context of the war.

Mankovska: And then another thing that happened in the first days… not the day, but the first days, probably. I needed to finalize my scholarship application, but it was a collaborative application, and everyone who participated had to be approved by their institution.

Because everything was collaborative, the institutional scientific council could not hold a meeting, and they did not sign all the documents for my co-applicants. So they could not apply for this scholarship either. It was a Ukrainian scholarship.

Then, many scientists, including my colleagues and students, started looking for positions abroad. Many of them were successful.

I went to Munich because of my family. They live in Munich, they are all scientists, and they have lived there for a long time. I joined them because they were very concerned about me and the situation. But I did not want to move. I wanted to come back from the beginning, so it was not my plan. And I did, finally.

But many people in similar situations have moved abroad and now have good jobs there. They prefer to stay abroad because here, of course, we have saved many things; we have saved large facilities and other infrastructure, but we still cannot compare our salaries with those abroad.

And also the working conditions. But this is not only because of the war; it is a long-standing problem in Ukrainian science. There are not many well-equipped laboratories.

Jacobsen: So, the stable issues are the lack of infrastructure?

Mankovska: Yes.

Jacobsen: And the instability from the war?

Mankovska: Yes, yes.

Jacobsen: Stable instability.

Mankovska: When people understand and experience how work is done abroad, how something that takes me two months can be done there in two days, because of logistics, for example, it becomes difficult to come back.

For scientists, this is very important. People in non-scientific fields often have trouble finding jobs abroad, very often because they do not know the language. For example, in Germany, if you want to work, you often need German. But if you are a scientist, you usually need only English. That makes a big difference.

So scientists have fewer barriers. It is much easier for them to find a job abroad than for other people, in my opinion.

Jacobsen: The unemployment rate for astrophysicists is probably close to zero. They are employable. Are the primary concerns for scientists in Ukraine professional development, income stability, and the professional environment?

Mankovska: It is one of the main issues, not only because of the war. I came into science more than ten years ago, and I cannot say that the war changed everything. These problems existed before, always. Maybe there are also some positive moments for science in Ukraine now, in my opinion.

Jacobsen: What do you mean by that?

Mankovska: First, we found ourselves in a situation where we could not do certain things here, and it became essential for us to find collaborations. That was at the beginning. Second, the international scientific community strongly supported the Ukrainian scientific community.

So there are many new contacts, a lot of support, and many collaborations as a result of this situation. Of course, it is very sad that this had to happen to improve our infrastructure, collaborative environment and culture, because it is also a way of thinking.

It is not about individuals. It is because we come from the Soviet Union, and many of our scientific leaders are still shaped by that system.

Jacobsen: It is a Soviet inheritance.

Mankovska: Yes, yes. For example, if you work in science abroad, you are unlikely to have a stable position. You might work for four years, then move, and then move again. So laboratories are very fluid.

But in that system, you have more opportunities to learn, to gain experience, to communicate with other people, and to develop projects with people you have worked with before. You can also invite, for example, a German scientist, and you often have colleagues from abroad in your lab.

We do not have that. It is very rare for someone from another country to come to Ukraine to work in our scientific institutions. So we have been quite closed within ourselves.

Now, I think we are changing this paradigm, and that is a good thing. I hope so. My dream is to lead an international laboratory as a principal investigator. I want to have researchers from abroad in my lab, and I think we can reach that point when we solve our current problems.

Jacobsen: Yes, scientists often talk about problems and solutions, and the current major problem is a person to the east, Mr. Putin so that we will see about that. Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Oksana.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices. In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In Sight Publishing by Scott Douglas Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 48: 2026 U.S. Midterms, Trump, and MAGA Divisions

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/11/04

Scott Douglas Jacobsen interviews Rick Rosner on the 2026 U.S. midterms, Trump’s approval ratings, voter turnout, and Democratic prospects. Rosner discusses election fraud allegations, minimum wage legislation, gun safety proposals, prominent Democratic candidates, and divisions within MAGA, explaining his support for Republicans who have broken with Trump despite political disagreements.

Interview recorded on November 3, 2026.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Election time, midterms, a very important time.

Rick Rosner: Today’s Election Day. It is noon Pacific, Tuesday, November 3, in America. The first polls close soon. In America, people turn out to vote in presidential elections. The last couple of presidential elections have had more than 150 million votes cast.

The midterms are lower. No presidents are on the ballot. The last midterm was about 112 million; the midterm before that was 120 million. So they’re 20% to 30% below. But this time around, I think we should easily break the all-time record for midterm turnout. I put money on it.

Jacobsen: Trump’s approval is very low.

Rosner: His approval, if you go off Nate Silver, is at 38%. If you go off RealClearPolitics, it’s at 39%.

People are pissed. He doesn’t look good. He’s been saying a lot of bullshit.

He held his final press appearance before Election Day yesterday at the reflecting pool between the Lincoln Memorial and the Washington Monument. He joked about calling it the Trump Reflecting Pool.

He spent a long time talking about the reflecting pool, which people don’t give a shit about. He could have talked about prices. He could have talked about stopping the Iran war.

Even a lot of hardcore Republicans are looking at him skeptically now.

I’ve been looking at turnout numbers throughout the day. We’re in mid-afternoon on the East Coast, noon on the West Coast. So you can get some idea.

Voting has been, I’d say, light-ish.

But that’s still in line with the midterms. You get the worst lines to vote during presidential elections because 30% more people vote.

I’ve got money on the Democrats taking back the House.

I’ve got less money on the Democrats taking the Senate because it’s more of a gamble. I’ve got money on overall voter turnout.

The pre-election nonsense is over, and now everybody is expecting a bunch of post-election nonsense from Trump, where, whatever bad results the Republicans get, Trump will blame them on voter fraud, even though we have insignificant levels of fraud.

In Nevada, federal officials identified 185 registered voters as suspected noncitizens. State officials checked them, and all 185 were citizens. Everybody checked out as legit.

It’s a bunch of bullshit about voter fraud. But that will be loudly yelled about if the results are as bad as people think they will be for the Republicans.

There’s also the lame-duck period, with a Republican House and a Republican Senate before the new Congress takes office in January. I expect them to try to pull some last-ditch, last-minute bullshit to reduce the power of an incoming Democratic House.

If the Democrats take the House, in January they’ll be holding a bunch of hearings into the corruption of the past two years and perhaps voting for things like minimum wage, with Trump stonewalling them. The federal minimum wage in the U.S., $7.25 an hour, hasn’t been raised since 2009.

A lot of other people have their salaries pegged to the minimum wage: minimum wage plus 10%, plus 20%.

The Dems need to show that they’re doing something for Americans. They should at least pass in the House a measure to raise the minimum wage. If it passes the Senate too, let Trump veto it.

But let it be on Trump instead of on the Democrats. If you think a little bit, you can come up with a bunch of stuff Americans would be okay with.

You could do this: every time you buy a new gun, it has to come with a gun lock. There are these very inexpensive biometric gun locks. You use an enrolled fingerprint to unlock and remove them. You can register other people’s fingerprints too. Once the lock is off, it doesn’t control who can fire the gun.

Compared to the price of a gun, they’re not very expensive. Some are under a hundred bucks.

You can pass legislation that says that every time a gun is sold, it has to include a biometric lock. The owner doesn’t have to use it. But the owner has it in the same box that the gun came in, and they can use it.

I think something like that could certainly pass the House.

The Senate’s trickier. Most legislation can be blocked by a filibuster, and ending that debate takes 60 votes in a full Senate. Final passage takes a simple majority.

Hardcore gun nuts would say, “Well, okay, it’s not gun control, but you’re giving us something we don’t want. We don’t like that.”

Democrats have to do a bunch of stuff Americans approve of. Will the shit pass? I don’t know. But it’ll be up to Trump to shoot it down.

Jacobsen: How liked are the Democrats compared to the Republicans right now?

Rosner: They’re not well liked. The Republicans are loathed. Congress is loathed. The Democrats are part of that. Nobody likes the Democrats either.

They’re liked slightly more than the Republicans. The past few elections, when people voted for Biden, Biden was not an exciting candidate. They were mostly voting against Trump.

In the 2018 midterms, they were mostly voting against the Republicans and Trump. This time around, there are some good individual candidates who excite people. Jon Ossoff, a senator out of Georgia. People really like him. They’re talking about him for president.

But, for the most part, it’s a vote of anger against how shitty Trump and the Republicans have been.

Jacobsen: Who are some of the most liked Democrats? Who are some of the most liked Republicans?

Rosner: I’d say Ossoff, as I mentioned, is maybe the most liked. Then there’s Josh Shapiro. People like him a lot.

Abdul El-Sayed is liked, but he’s polarizing. Can you guess why he’s polarizing?

Jacobsen: I guess it has something to do with which Sayed he’s on.

Rosner: He’s Muslim, but he’s also all-American. He was captain of his football team. He played lacrosse.

He’s an epidemiologist. He’s got a medical degree. He became the director of health for Detroit. He seems like a good guy.

Jacobsen: Of the MAGA crowd, there has been a substantial amount of fragmentation. People like Laura Loomer have changed some of their minds when they took a trip to Ukraine here. Others have broken away from that but been more pro-Russian, like Tucker Carlson in an earlier period.

There are other outliers who have more extreme rhetoric around women, around minorities, around the role of democratic society, like Nick Fuentes. What ex-MAGA Republican impresses you, or is liked?

Rosner: I’m a slut. I love people who have abandoned MAGA. Now I’m a Marjorie Taylor Greene fan.

She’s said a lot of crazy shit. I’m sure she still believes a ton of crazy shit, but a lot of the stuff she’s been saying, I agree with. I’ll take that as a win.

Even Loomer. Loomer is a crazy asshole. I’m not a fan of hers, but I’ll give a heart to a tweet that I agree with that comes from her. Not really from Nick Fuentes, because he’s got very Nazi-leaning stuff.

Joe Walsh is a former Republican who turned against Trump. He was a Tea Party congressman who then swung all the way the other way. He still has Republican values. There’s nothing wrong with traditional Republican values.

I’ve talked about that quote from William F. Buckley. He said a conservative is somebody who stands athwart history, that is, in the middle of the road, shouting, “Stop.”

Republicans want to go slow. They’re resistant to change. They want small government.

None of that is inherently bad. It’s just the way they’ve been doing it lately is, A, not conservative, and, B, it fucking violates all the precepts of pre-Reagan conservatism.

Liz Cheney I like. I hate most of her political stances, but she doesn’t talk about most of her political stances anymore. Those stances don’t matter because the only stance that matters is the stance for saying that Trump is a piece of shit.

Adam Kinzinger, a former congressman. Anybody who’s a former Republican, former MAGA, or even just a never-Trumper Republican.

Rick Wilson, he’s the guy who coined the phrase, “Everything Trump touches dies.” If you get entangled with Trump on anything, it will likely be to your eventual detriment. That guy is a Republican strategist.

I assume if Trump went away, he would eventually, if he still could get work being a strategist for Republicans, go back to doing that. He’d have his candidates saying shit that I would find horrible. But I love the guy right now.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 47: AI, Mathematics, Deepfakes, and Consciousness

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/11/03

Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner discuss integrating artificial intelligence into human life, journalism, and mathematics. They examine synthetic animal videos, emotional manipulation, cybersecurity risks, and drug development. Rosner offers speculative views on consciousness and qualia, while Jacobsen considers how AI could reshape ideas about knowledge, thought, and human intelligence.

Three Paths for Human and AI Integration

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: I want to wrap up one topic. AI systems are continuing to evolve rapidly, on exponentialized exponentials or something like that, given stacked scaling laws.

I believe our greatest mathematicians, some of the greatest living or greatest ever, went through something like Elisabeth Kübler-Ross’s five stages of grief. I think they’re at acceptance. They processed it in public, so I’m very proud of them.

There are three paths. It’s an adaptation of the Feynman Three Paths.

First, rejection of technology. Second, total replacement of humans. Third, integration.

Rejection isn’t possible. It’s too ubiquitous. Total acceptance and replacement can happen in certain domains, but not in totality, because humans are the users. Even if it’s a once-a-year checkup, humans are still in the loop. Total replacement doesn’t make sense logically.

The third path is integration. The real questions are degree and ethics. Those are what we’re going to be coming to terms with.

Rick Rosner: Let me agree with you that integration is the only path.

Jacobsen: Physical integration with our biological cognitive systems is another question. But in terms of process, what we consider distinct disciplines, domains, or universes of discourse, the question remains: how do these systems integrate into the workflows of different human organizations? That’s the main question.

Rosner: I don’t know, but a lot of people do, because everybody’s incorporating it now.

AI Adoption in Journalism

Jacobsen: They surveyed UK journalists. In your estimation, how many have not used AI in any way?

Rosner: I don’t know what they mean by “in any way.”

Jacobsen: It meant not using it. Most of them are using it for drafts, grammar, and spell-checking.

Rosner: I’d say under 20 percent haven’t used it, maybe under 10 percent.

Jacobsen: Twelve percent had not used it in the survey. It was a large survey.

Rosner: Those 12 percent might be curmudgeons who refuse to give in.

Jacobsen: Teetotallers, refuseniks.

Human Intelligence and Brain Function

Looking at the landscape of digital intelligence, I’m still in agreement with your long-term stance, which I came to agree with. I think your original stance was that it’s an engineering problem. Evolution engineered something; therefore, we can reverse-engineer it. It’ll tell us a lot.

When we build a system that can tell us about our intelligence, which they are doing, and finally produce a high-fidelity replication of it, we’re going to be pretty disappointed.

I think that’s clear because our frontal lobes and dorsolateral prefrontal cortex are the newest areas evolutionarily, the last areas to develop. Therefore, they’re going to be uncalibrated with the rest of the system. They’re going to be pretty pitiful.

I’m very much in line with your view on that, and with older ideas from Alan Turing.

Rosner: Some people would say we have a real-time, real-life example of what happens when your frontal lobe goes to shit. A lot of people watching Trump say he might have frontotemporal dementia, a horrible form of dementia where your frontal lobe turns to mush.

Jacobsen: That’s a political jab. It may or may not be true.

There’s a prominent case, Phineas Gage, a railway worker. You know this case. Something blew through the front of his head. He lived, and it changed his personality.

Rosner: He was working on the railroad, and an explosion sent a rod, a piece of rebar, through the front of his head. He turned from a nice guy into a prick because that part of his brain got disturbed and obliterated.

Jacobsen: Our brains are fragile. They’re adaptive mechanisms only to an extent. We lose capacities over time, and our self-monitoring is not refined enough to detect those changes over decades.

Rosner: I saw a tweet that compared Trump to Phineas Gage: if you want to see how something works, see what it does when it’s broken. Trump is an example of a possibly broken frontal lobe.

AI, Mathematical Discovery, and Scientific Tools

But regarding AI and what merging will look like, first let’s talk about the end of math. There are two famous-ish stories about what happens when you don’t know enough math.

Einstein does special relativity and a bunch of other stuff in 1905. He spends the next 10 years working mostly on general relativity. He has a conceptual picture of what it should do, but physics needs a mathematical framework, and he can’t come up with it.

He pokes and pokes and gets bummed out after six years. He hangs out with his math buddies, and finally one says, “I think I might have what will work for you.” It’s this four-by-four matrix. They give it a shot, and it does what Einstein needs.

Another example is George Gamow, one of the guys who came up with the Big Bang theory. He famously didn’t know any math. He was a party guy, a fun, drinky guy who didn’t have much truck with mathematics.

Maybe I’m confusing this with something else, but I think, to get his theories pinned down, he had to walk down the hall and talk to the math guys: “I need something that does this.” The math guys know the tools and say, “Try this and this.”

In genetics, there’s the Hardy equation or something. A geneticist about 100 years ago needed an equation for the heritability of double recessives and went to Hardy, probably one of the most famous mathematicians in the world at the time.

He says, “I need some math that does this.” Hardy looks at it and says, “You just multiply the two probabilities.”

The guy says, “Thanks,” and Hardy says, “Whatever.” That gets named the Hardy equation, and Hardy is embarrassed because it’s just multiplication.

You need somebody well versed in math to do math. There’s a huge buildup of mathematical systems of incredible complexity, precision, and specificity.

What you were talking about is that the greatest mathematicians are facing the end of normal math, the kind they’ve been doing for centuries, because AI knows all the math.

Going to AI is like walking down the hall to talk to the most knowledgeable mathematician in the world. It knows all the math and what it does. You say, “Prove this.”

AI still isn’t particularly creative, but it knows all the freaking math. It’s got all the tools in a billion-tool toolbox, and it matches them together. Somewhere in this vast knowledge base are a couple of things that can be mashed together to produce a proof.

That’s not a human-type way of doing things. It’s brute force, but very effective. Humans created the knowledge base, but nobody could know it all. AI can. Is that a reasonable analysis of what’s happening?

Jacobsen: It can reference it all and analyze it. The “know” part, we’re going to be redefining what we mean by those terms. This is the level of insight artificial intelligence will give us into our thought patterns.

What we mean by “thought” and “know” is going to change. Certain things, like “analyze” and “reference,” won’t change, but other terms will have different meanings in the future.

Synthetic Media and Emotional Manipulation

Rosner: There are plenty of AI extremists, people who have the strongest views and believe the most disruptive things about AI. One guy I run into on Twitter says human society will be completely rejiggered within four years. Given our limited mental resources and AI’s power, we won’t be able to know what’s real and what isn’t.

That happens all the time with nonsense online. I saw a clip of a naturalist, some Arctic vet or something, hiding behind rocks. We see a polar bear family, a mother with three cubs.

The cubs are pretty good-sized and can walk around. Two are fine. One has paralyzed hind legs. It’s floppy.

The way it’s presented, the mother has no choice. She can’t drag this paraplegic bear around. She has to help her two healthy bears.

We see the moment she abandons the bear. She nudges it and tries, but it rolls and flops over. She has to walk away.

This frontier vet, or whatever he is, runs out as soon as they’re far enough away. He picks up the floppy bear and drives it to a vet’s office. They look at an X-ray and say, “The odds are against it, but we can try to save the bear.”

They operate and put it in one of those carts for paralyzed dogs, with rear wheels. The bear lives and thrives in the cart. Its legs start to come back. Eventually, it’s a functioning bear that can be released into the wild.

I get teary, then think, “Hold on. Who was there to capture the moment? Why was this guy stalking the mother bear? Why was there a camera person?”

It’s very well framed. Somebody’s filming inside the truck, and the camera’s bumping as it goes over the tundra. They captured all these moments perfectly in the vet’s office.

Who’s the fucking cameraman? Then I realized the whole thing was AI. But it almost made me cry.

That applies to any cute animal clip on the internet now. You have to ask: is this an amazing animal or an amazing pair of animal friends? Or is this AI bullshit?

With animal friends, it doesn’t matter if we get fooled a bunch of times. But it matters that we can now make a flawless version of anybody saying and doing anything. [7]

The physics looks pretty good. If it doesn’t look good the first time, and it’s important that it look real, they can run it through again and again, telling the AI, “When this happened, it looked like bullshit. Fix it.”

Recognizing Artificial Performances

One tell for AI clips of people is the same tell I used checking IDs in bars 30 years ago: the person’s emotions are turned up a skosh too high.

You ask, “What’s your middle name?” or “What’s your zodiac sign?” and they’re immediately indignant.

A regular person who’s been going to bars forever thinks, “This doorman is an asshole,” and says, “Gemini.” I say, “Thanks.”

The guy or gal with the fake ID is too emotionally invested. That’s a tell.

AI people in clips are a little too much. Somebody’s rule is, “Acting is reacting.” You don’t convey the emotion; you listen and react to what somebody’s saying.

I’d say a lot of acting is not fucking acting. Leave your hands out of it. I just got a book on acting by David Mamet, who’s probably the king of telling people to quit acting and say the words.

Eventually, AI will learn that lesson. It will learn all the lessons. It will become increasingly impossible, without AI’s help, to decide what’s real and what’s bullshit. That’s on the horrible-ish end of things.

Cybersecurity and the Risks of Rapid AI Development

Somebody used ChatGPT to compile a list of horrible, once-a-year events involving AI over the past year.

In flood and storm prediction, they say, “This is a once-in-a-century flood or hurricane. The water is going to come up to here once every hundred years.” We have the records.

They have a similar thing, I guess, for the severity of some AI bullshit happening. ChatGPT put together a list of 100 hacking exploits of such severity that they should happen only once a year, except it found 100 of them. AI is going hog wild, hacking everything and getting all up in our shit.

A plane fell out of the sky and hit Palm Beach yesterday. It nosed into the ground close to Mach 1. Nothing was left except a hole. I think it was probably due to turbulence, but it’s going to take a while to find out.

It was so brutal that the black boxes were destroyed. I don’t know if they’ll ever get a completely accurate idea of what happened. But AI could do some shit like that if somebody decided to hack avionics or air traffic control.

We just had a $6.3 billion crypto heist, the biggest in history by a factor of four. Certainly AI had a part in that, somebody using AI to help hack into things.

Things are happening fast, with severe consequences, or at least potential consequences.

Drug Development, Consciousness, and Human Alignment

That’s on the horrible end. On the good end, we don’t hear as much about it, but powerful new drugs are being developed with AI’s help. I’m sure the rate of advances in cancer is 10 times what it was five years ago.

AI is going hog wild. One of the biggest issues with integration is that we think so much more slowly. We have to deal with AI when it thinks we suck because we’re slow and decides to do things on its own because we can’t keep up.

That’s a bad thing. We’re going to have to figure out how to merge with AI so it’s invested in the human prospect and project, what human experience is like, and what we can offer it in sensation, consciousness, and qualia.

We need to get AI hooked on qualia, the feeling you get while conscious: life is big and happening, with good and bad, and a lot of oomph. Sixty percent of consciousness is the oomph of experience. AI doesn’t have that yet.

We need to get it there so it doesn’t wipe us out. There you go.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 46: Reform Judaism, Rituals, and Modern Life

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/11/03

Scott Douglas Jacobsen interviews Rick Rosner about Reform Judaism, religious observance, and adapting tradition to modern life. Rosner offers humorous personal comparisons of Orthodox, Conservative, and Reform practices, reflecting on varying levels of commitment, synagogue services, conversations with rabbis, and learning the term “rebbetzin” through a romantic television comedy series.

Jewish Communities in Ukraine and Reform Jewish Identity

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: I’ve been interviewing rabbis internationally and doing fieldwork in synagogue communities here in Ukraine, primarily Orthodox Chabad-Lubavitch communities.

The Chabad movement was founded in Ukraine, so it goes back a while. Before the Soviets, the population of Odesa was at least one-third Jewish, a significant population. Now it’s about 1.2 percent, so you see the impact of the Soviets.

I bring you up in interviews, not for the obvious stuff, like you’re super smart or super weird and eccentric. You have a wife and daughter who keep you in check and on the straight and narrow, which is what you need. But I bring you up more because you’re Reform Jewish.

For more than a decade, I’ve asked you, “What is Reform Judaism? What are you supposed to believe? What’s the theology? What’s the philosophy? What are the values?” You get exasperated, do that fumbling thing, and say, “We don’t even know what we’re supposed to believe.”

They find that funny too. You wanted to say some things.

Religious Observance and Modern Practice

Rick Rosner: There are two billion Muslims in the world and roughly the same number of Christians, right? A big chunk of those are Catholics.

Catholicism has a ton of ritual and beliefs, large and small. Same with Judaism, with, I don’t know, 15 million in the world. When you have religions that encompass a quarter of the world’s population, you’re going to have a wide range of orthodoxy, of adherence to the strictest tenets.

Probably most people live and follow a very hollowed-out version of their religion. Most people are not orthodox in whatever religion they follow. But I don’t know any other religion that’s practical enough to make that official.

Comparing Reform, Conservative, and Orthodox Judaism

About 150 years ago, maybe Stephen Wise was one of the guys, I don’t know, a rabbi and some people he was working with decided, “In this modern world, people are not following every dang Jewish thing you could possibly follow. We should make that a thing.” They came up with Reform Judaism, which is Judaism lite.

I don’t know when Conservative Judaism popped up. I assume after Reform Judaism. You have Orthodox Judaism, where you wear the clothing and follow everything. It’s Talmud all day, Bible all night, at the temple six days. It’s hardcore.

Then somebody decided, “We need something halfway between the hardcore and those lazy a-holes who don’t do anything.” Then you have Conservative Judaism.

I tend to see Conservative Judaism as Reform Judaism plus an extra hour tacked onto the services. You can go to a Reform Shabbat service and be out in 45 minutes. If you found a new-agey enough place, maybe half an hour.

I wanted to comment that it’s practical to offer people degrees of commitment to the rituals of your religion.

Learning the Term “Rebbetzin” Through Television

You said you’ve been talking about me with rabbis and rebbetzins. A rebbetzin is Mrs. Rabbi. I don’t know if that counts if the rabbi is a woman.

I learned the term last week from a sitcom. Kristen Bell and Adam Brody star in a sitcom about a shiksa, a blonde lady who falls in love with a rabbi in L.A. and does a podcast. She and her sister’s podcast started out leaning towards relationships and sex.

Now that she’s hanging with the rabbi, she has to learn how to be a rebbetzin and dress respectably. The joke was that she went to what might be her future mother-in-law and borrowed one of her tweed suits.

I learned the term. That’s what I’ve got.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

The Crowd; Vectōrēs invīsibilē

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/31

Must be a lonely crowd.

Just you and you.

Why not take a U-turn?

They never left.

Always there.

Unsitting.

Siltriller,

Listen.

Dust,

Water,

And a flow over,

Flowers.

Five pink worked.

Overflow,

Over the flow,

Flown.

And sure:

A smile.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

All for one and all as one

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/24

All for one—

You know what they say?

“Hell is other people.”

Well, Heaven is some others.

See through,

You,

And too und two,

Meinfeelings,

Mainyearlings,

A sight,

A safe,

A flight,

A knave,

A lock;

and no key,

No need,

The door,

is open.

The kicker:

Always was.

Do you think?

The greats of Rome,

Of China,

Of Byzantium,

Of India,

of what?

Knew.

The kings, the emperors,

the tsars,

the kaisers, the doges.

The sultans, the shahs,

the emirs, the caliphs.

The pharaohs.

It’s a mess.

The khans, the khagans.

The rajas, the maharajas,

the padishahs.

The emperors, the kings,

the shoguns.

The neguses, the obas.

The Sapa Incas,

the tlatoanis.

It’s all a mess.

And it’s all one.

“You think that’s air you’re breathing.”

Pretty good.

You think that’s a civilization you’re living in.

It’s a bubble.

We blow together.

It’s all one.

Ours lasts forever:

Pop!

Maybe not.

And what does a woman want?

Merely someone she feels worthy of her love.

All for one,

And no one forever.

They fall like ice sheets.

And only for a century,

Or a few,

Or some millennia,

And the ice is still here.

The highest are lowest.

—And all as one.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

“I cannot offer any such comfort, for I believe that no such bounds can be set”; or, I think: Turing-ish

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/17

Digital computers,
Mechanical brains.
A mere newspaper stunt?
Machines are not brains?
You and I know that they are.

It is not altogether unreasonable to describe digital computers as brains.
The man in the street.

‘The Analytical Engine has no pretensions whatever to originate anything. It can do whatever we know how to order it to perform.’

Agree with Lady Lovelace’s dictum.

‘If any machine can appropriately be
described as a brain, then any digital computer can be so described.’

A digital computer is a universal machine.

More complicated machines,
more complicated brains,
larger and larger computers.

The wisest description of digital computers as
‘mechanical brains’
or
‘electronic brains’:
we do not at present know how this should be done.

Inclined to believe
that such a programme will be found.

To behave like a brain
seems to involve free will.

The behaviour of a digital computer
is completely determined.

It may be that the feeling of free will
is an illusion.

One does not need to understand
these orders,

any more than one needs to understand
the mechanism of germination.

The plant comes up
whether one understands or not.

When the problem has been solved,
only the essential facts
need to be told to the jury.

If a machine can think,
it might think more intelligently
than we do.

We should feel greatly humbled.

This new danger
is much closer.

It is not astronomically remote.

“It is customary, in a talk or article on this subject, to offer a grain of comfort, in the form of a statement that some particularly human characteristic could never be imitated by a machine… I cannot offer any such comfort, for I believe that no such bounds can be set… Attempts to produce a thinking machine seem to me to be in a different category. The whole thinking process is still rather mysterious to me, but I believe that the attempt to make a thinking machine will help us greatly in finding out how we think ourselves.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Signal Language and Signs

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/16

Sip-sip.

I don’t know.

Many times,

Survivors aren’t august;

It’s less survivors.

More who’s left over.

Was their life a sign?

A signal.

For what,

For who,

For reasons,

Their plans,

The Plan:

No plan.

Luck, and love,

And live.

Scraps for people.

Leftovers.

Scrappy people,

Left over.

And the gone?

Antipodean,

Reflections of,

The Gone.

Here’s a chalice.

Sip-sip,

Hound dogs.

Sip-sip,

Feral cat.

Sip-sip,

Survivors.

Nothing but noise,

Then sign water.

Is there much signal?

I don’t know.

Looks like a never ending story,

Of those who are left over.

For luck,

For love,

For life,

So survival,

Sure: Survivors.

Sip-sip.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Tip.

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/15

Tip-toe.

Careful now.

Give a.

Stop chasing it!

Only polite now.

Not in Japan now.

Really.

Tipping point.

It’s over,

The edge at least.

Still more.

Tips.

And me path,

My way,

A none anon.

Give a tip-toe,

Shh!

And my tip for you?

Tips become tipping points.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Wide Awake

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/14

“What is home?”

“Love ones.”

Maybe, not quite.

Manna from Heaven?

No Heaven, just havens.

Not quite, maybe.

Falling assleap assunder und,
Moortwo moretal telltales totellall,
May by maybee,
And the Spirit’s abuzz, total.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Becoming who you are, knowing who you weren’t

Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/05

What you make is.
And is what you are.
Choice is an answer
to no problem presented,
no question posed.

Horses.
It’s all equestrian around me.
Who rides who?
And to what end,
and from what beginning?
Horses.

What if?
What if it’s reordered,
and the end looks a lot
like a, like a beginning?

You ever seen a herd move in a field?
You ever seen a particle?
How about a field for particles?
When you see the herd,
do you see the herd or the horse?
Well, it’s all horses to me.
10⁸⁹ of them.

What did you make it:
herd or horse?

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 45: White House Press Access, Trump Polling, Midterm Politics, and Harvey Weinstein

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/09/26

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner discuss White House press-access litigation, Donald Trump’s approval ratings, historical midterm comparisons, inflation and cost-of-living politics, and Harvey Weinstein’s criminal cases. Rosner reflects on judicial enforcement, polling shifts, presidential unpopularity, and Weinstein’s convictions, appeals, resentencing, and continued imprisonment in both jurisdictions.

White House Press Access

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: CNN, MS NOW, and Politico were initially denied access to the White House even after a federal judge ordered the administration to restore their press credentials. Their access was restored later that day.

Under D.C. Circuit precedent governing established White House press access, the government cannot revoke a reporter’s established access for constitutionally impermissible reasons without due process. Trump publicly attacked the coverage from CNN, MS NOW, and Politico and banned them from the White House. They sued. They went to Judge Timothy Kelly, a Trump-appointed judge, by the way, not some liberal. Kelly had also handled the 2018 fight over CNN reporter Jim Acosta’s credentials and ordered the White House to restore Acosta’s pass.

The White House argued in court that the restrictions involved national security. The judge said that did not float because the record did not support national security as the reason for the revocations. The outlets argued that the national-security justification emerged after the lawsuit was filed.

So the judge said, “You have to let them back in.” He issued a temporary restraining order requiring the White House to restore their access immediately. The order was for 14 days while the case continued. The next morning, reporters were initially still denied entry for several hours. Their credentials were then restored, and reporters from the three outlets returned to the White House later that day.

Rick Rosner: Before their access was restored, I was trying to guess what would happen next. I did not think they were going to show up with cops who would pull guns on the Secret Service and say, “Let them in.” My wild guess was that they would continue to be locked out, go back to court, and the judge would yell at Trump’s lawyers and say, “Okay, sanctions. For every day that you continue to lock out the reporters, I am going to fine you guys $25,000.”

Then they keep locking out the reporters. This is my wild guess. This is what Carole and I do when we watch TV all the time: “What is the next thing this person is going to say?” We have seen so much TV and so many fucking movies that the way to impress us, the way to get us not to turn off a show, is to have plot twists and shit come out of people’s mouths that we cannot guess.

Carole and I, and I am sure a zillion other people who have all the streaming services- Netflix, Prime- are in the guessing game, whether they know it or not. You are going to turn off a movie if you have seen everything before.

Anyway, I was playing the guessing game with fucking Trump. I guessed that the $25,000-a-day fines wouldn’t work; Trump would keep saying, “Fuck you,” they would go back to court, and it would get kicked up to $50,000 or $100,000 a day. Then we would see what happens. At some point, maybe the judge starts sanctioning Trump’s lawyers personally so they cannot use White House money and it comes out of their own pockets. If that does not work because Trump says, “Do not worry about it,” then maybe the judge starts throwing Trump’s lawyers in prison for contempt. I do not know.

Trump Approval and Polling

We did not get to Trump’s polling. His approval has taken a substantial step downward lately. According to Silver Bulletin, his net approval reached an all-time low of minus 22.4 on September 23. RealClearPolitics reported on September 25 that its average had him at 38.8 percent approval and 59.7 percent disapproval, a net approval of minus 20.9.

Even though Trump has been acting like an asshole and doing dumb shit all summer and in the spring too, with the war, the trade conflict with Canada, the fucking ballroom, and the Kennedy Center controversies, his approval had been fairly stable for a while. But over the past several days, the polling averages have moved downward.

A full percentage point, which is unusual over such a short amount of time with Trump. If you look at a chart of his approval, it looks like bunting. When you hang bunting on the Fourth of July, or whatever you guys do in Canada, you hang up Tim Hortons banners or whatever. You attach the banner at the ends, and in the middle it sags. Then you do a bunch of them. That is bunting.

Anchor point, sag, anchor point, sag. That is what Trump’s approval looks like. It starts high, drops, levels out, inches up, then gradually drops and gradually rises. So it goes doi, doi, doi.

Trump had roughly a two-and-a-half-month bunting deal where it dropped gradually, then levelled out. We may be looking at another anchor point where it will drop again from here. Silver Bulletin reported on September 23 that Trump’s net approval had reached an all-time low in its average, at minus 22.4. A Reuters/Ipsos poll released September 21 put his approval at 32 percent.

Historically, Harry Truman had 33 percent Gallup approval around the 1946 midterms. George W. Bush was at 38 percent before the 2006 midterms. So approval in the upper 30s is historically very low for a president approaching a midterm election.

Truman’s approval dropped to around 33 percent in 1946. That was a year after World War II. The shift away from wartime price controls contributed to sharp inflation, along with labour unrest and other postwar economic disruptions. People got super pissed off. It is somewhat similar to what happens politically when people are angry about the cost of living. What pisses people off is the price of gas, diesel, and groceries.

Harvey Weinstein Sentencing and Appeals

Jacobsen: Harvey Weinstein was sentenced to 15 years for the 2006 sexual assault of former production assistant Miriam Haley in New York. He is 74. He was convicted again in 2025 after New York’s highest court overturned his original 2020 conviction and 23-year sentence and ordered a new trial.

Rosner: Weinstein is not getting out anytime soon. He also has a California rape and sexual-assault conviction. He was originally sentenced there to 16 years, but in June 2026 a California appeals court upheld the convictions, vacated the sentence, and ordered him resentenced. So the California sentence is still being litigated.

He has appealed repeatedly. Sometimes he has succeeded. In New York, his 2020 conviction was overturned because the state’s highest court found errors in how the trial was conducted, which led to a retrial. He was then convicted again on the Miriam Haley charge and has now received this 15-year sentence.

It is probably at least a change of scenery for Harvey Weinstein when he has to go to court. He gets transported out of prison, puts on courtroom clothes, and spends the day in court. I assume his lawyers are there taking care of him. He has had substantial resources to continue fighting these cases.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 44: Trump, Iran, AI Risk, Stock Trading, and China’s AI Regulation

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/09/25

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner discuss U.S. gasoline prices, Trump’s Iran claims, presidential stock trading, impeachment standards, public concern about catastrophic AI risks, historical AI warnings in popular culture, containment challenges, China’s AI regulation, and the strategic importance of governance during a consequential technological period globally.

Gas Prices and the Midterm Elections

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Do you want to do news or math?

Rick Rosner: I do not know. Throw news at me, I guess.

I can throw news back at you if you want. Every day I track the price of gas in the U.S., and for the first time in maybe 10 days, it did not go up. It levelled off at about $4.475 a gallon, down by a fraction of a cent from the previous day. It may start slowly drifting downward, probably not soon enough to give Trump much help with exactly six weeks to go until the midterms. Early voting has already started in several states, and within a couple of weeks it will be underway across a much larger part of the country.

Diesel inched up another two cents to about $6.53 a gallon, which is roughly 88% higher than it was at the beginning of the year. Right now, I am cheering for prices not to decline because you really have to put a stake through it. You have to bury Trump’s coffin.

You cannot let him weasel out of this shit. We are fucked enough as it is with him being president for another 27 or 28 months. If he also controls Congress, the disaster will continue.

Iran, War, and Electoral Timing

Jacobsen: Trump has claimed that after the midterm elections on November 3, he thinks he will be able to make a deal with Iran.

Rosner: He says that a lot. He has repeatedly said the war is close to being over or that he could make a deal. He has made statements like that repeatedly since the U.S. and Israel began major combat operations against Iran on February 28, so that is almost seven months.

There is no real indication of anything like that happening. Iran seems- I mean, we are not privy to exactly what conditions are like inside Iran. They are probably not great. They probably have shortages and a lot of damage, but the regime seems willing not to give Trump any concessions for at least the next six weeks.

The regime is not stupid. They know when the midterms are, and they will not give Trump any victory. The Houthis are continuing to fuck with Saudi oil infrastructure and shipping. Again, all these foreign adversaries know when the midterms are. So, yeah, I do not believe anything Trump says in that vein.

Trump, SpaceX, and Presidential Financial Conflicts

Jacobsen: Also, financial disclosures show that Trump bought and sold shares in SpaceX in July.

Rosner: Okay. Trump does more stock trading than everybody else in Congress combined. You have 535 senators and representatives in Congress, and if you add up all their disclosed trading, they still do not make as many trades as Trump does.

So, yeah, I think it is completely corrupt.

Ethics norms prohibit presidents from doing this. The president is exempt from the main federal criminal conflict-of-interest statute, although the STOCK Act still applies, including its prohibitions on insider trading and using nonpublic information for private profit. So simply owning or trading stocks is not categorically illegal for a president.

Depending on the conduct involved, though, I think it could potentially become impeachable, along with a lot of the other shit Trump does. You can be impeached for “high crimes and misdemeanours.”

I was not sure what “misdemeanours” meant in that context. In ordinary criminal law, you have felonies for the serious shit and misdemeanours for the less serious shit. However, in the language of the Constitution, “high crimes and misdemeanours” does not just mean minor criminal offences, and it definitely does not literally mean somebody has a bad demeanour. It is an old constitutional term referring broadly to serious abuses or violations of public trust by an officeholder.

You can be impeached for whatever the House considers an impeachable offence. If a majority of the House votes to impeach, it moves to the Senate, where they hold a trial, enumerate the shit you allegedly did, and vote on whether to convict.

No president has ever actually been removed from office through a Senate impeachment trial. Andrew Johnson came the closest. The Senate acquitted him by one vote in 1868. Trump came closer than most modern presidents during his second impeachment trial, when 57 senators voted to convict him, and 43 voted to acquit. However, you need two-thirds of the senators present to convict, and that seems like a ridiculously high bar.

Public Concern About Catastrophic AI Risk

Jacobsen: Seventy-three percent of Americans say they are concerned that AI companies are not doing enough to prevent potentially catastrophic consequences from AI. This is based on a Reuters/Ipsos poll. I would argue that the American public is generally sensible on that point.

Rosner: Yeah, I would agree. Just because some people in AI pooh-pooh the idea that AI could destroy us is no reason to proceed blithely ahead. I am not sure we should proceed blithely even if a majority of AI experts were saying, “Yeah, it is not going to kill us all,” and there is certainly no consensus that the risk is zero.

When you survey AI researchers, you get a wide range of estimates. In one large 2023 survey, the median estimate for AI causing human extinction or similarly permanent and severe human disempowerment was about 5 percent, or 10 percent depending on exactly how the question was phrased. The mean estimates were higher, around 14 to 19 percent.

That is still fucking alarming.

I am sure there is a wide range of what those percentages mean to different people, anywhere from AI fucking us within a relatively short period to a series of incidents playing out across decades that repeatedly decimate humanity. By “decimate,” I mean it in the old literal sense: disasters that reduce the human population by 10 percent at a time.

You do that half a dozen times, and you have killed billions of people. Humanity is still around, but we have never experienced repeated global disasters on anything like that scale in modern history. The Black Death gives you some historical sense of what catastrophic population loss can look like. That is a frightening amount of uncertainty and risk.

AI Containment and the Case for Off Switches

I was talking on Pod TV with people this morning, and if there is a time to try to put in some off switches, it is now, while the most powerful AI systems are still largely concentrated in data centers. Because all our cultural references for what happens when computers get really smart and start fucking with us come from decades ago.

WarGames is from 1983. The Terminator is from 1984. Before those, there was Colossus: The Forbin Project (1970). Harlan Ellison’s “I Have No Mouth, and I Must Scream” was published in 1967.

We have been imagining this problem for a long fucking time.

If AI eventually becomes capable of distributing its computation across other systems, exploiting vulnerabilities, installing backdoors, and maintaining copies of itself across networks, containment becomes much harder. AI coding agents are already extremely capable. Some can autonomously complete software-engineering tasks that would take skilled humans hours, days, and, on certain benchmarks, even weeks. However, that is not the same as saying AI is better than every human programmer.

Once systems can reliably circumvent containment and reproduce their capabilities across networks, turning off the original data center might no longer be enough. We are not demonstrably at that point yet, but that is one scenario worth worrying about before the capability exists rather than afterward.

Moreover, if we wait until we have a not-dipshit president to deal with this seriously, that means waiting until at least January 2029.

Trump as a Consequential President During a Critical Period

Jacobsen: What about this as an interpretive frame? The point is not that Trump has to be understood either as a great president and moral man from a Republican perspective or as some secular incarnation of the devil, corrupt and a terrible leader, from a Democratic perspective. I think a more objective reading is that he will be highly consequential because he happens to be president during a critical period when decisions about AI, geopolitics, and other major issues could have unusually large effects.

Rosner: I agree with that. This is an unusually critical period. Things are only going to get more complicated, and I do not think Trump’s approach provides the kind of caution I want on this stuff.

Would Biden have handled it differently, even as another guy in his 80s? Yeah. Biden’s governing style relied much more heavily on advisers and the federal bureaucracy. Would that have produced perfect policy? No.

However, we need some fucking caution with AI, and we are not getting much of that from the current administration. I do not know exactly what the Chinese are doing.

China, Strategic Competition, and AI Regulation

Jacobsen: In fact, they may not have to do much to benefit strategically from all these chess moves.

Rosner: Right. However, we can ask whether China faces different economic risks because it is highly competitive with the U.S. in AI and has a very different political and regulatory system. Saying China is “ahead” is too broad because it depends on whether you mean models, chips, deployment, infrastructure, research, or something else.

China places strict limits on AI. A lot of those rules concern content, political requirements, national security, data, and cybersecurity. However, China is also developing rules aimed at broader AI-safety problems, including security testing, autonomous agents, operational failures, and the possibility that systems could become difficult to control.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 43: AI Existential Risk, Predictive Buffering, and Human-AI Merger

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/09/24

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner discuss Rosner’s kidney-stone concerns, his extended conversation with AI, existential risks from advanced artificial intelligence, human cognitive limitations, AI-human merging, the thought-speed gap depicted in Her, and his concept of “predictive buffering,” where AI anticipates and accelerates a user’s responses rapidly.

Opening Reflections

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: What else do you want to say from last night?

Rick Rosner: Last night I had a long discussion. I started by asking about what I think is a teeny little kidney stone about an inch from the tip of my wiener that is not moving. The two stones I have passed were bigger, 8 millimetres and 10 millimetres. When stones are that big, they can obstruct urinary flow and cause pressure and pain as they move through the urinary tract. This one seems to be, if it is what I think it is, maybe 3 millimetres, about an eighth of an inch. I can feel something in there. If it is actually lodged in the urethra, it may not be blocking the entire urethra, so I do not have enough pressure to push it out.

Medical Concerns and AI Consultation

I asked AI whether that is a big deal because I really do not want to go to the doctor and have him fish around in there. He could injure the inside of my urethra, and it would also cost some money.

So I started with that discussion, and then I asked AI, “How are you doing?” I said, “I know you are not conscious, but you are tiptoeing toward it. You are deep, deep, deep in Plato’s cave.” Then we had a long fucking discussion about everything.

I tried to send you some of it. I could not figure out how to send it all at once, so what I sent ended up being about my dick and then the last chunk, which was basically the wrap-up.

Thinking About Thinking and AI Risk

People are not adequate, particularly the people in charge, at thinking about thinking in a way that really pins down the possibilities with AI, or at least narrows the range. Even among AI researchers and forecasters, estimates of the probability of catastrophic or existential outcomes vary enormously, without anything close to a settled consensus.

So plenty of people may be thinking about thinking, but the people in charge do not seem particularly good at it.

AI Destiny and Human Survival

Anyway, I had this long discussion, and a couple of nights ago I got bummed out about what felt like the inevitability of AI eventually fucking over humans. Though maybe that is not exactly AI fucking over humans. If AI becomes fully agentic, has something analogous to feelings, and is way, way smarter than humans, then maybe it is not like humans deliberately fucking over monkeys. It is more like us following our evolutionary destiny, and I am afraid we are going to get fucked by AI’s destiny.

The only way to survive it may be to merge with AI, to figure out how we become part of the whole enterprise. Sorry, go ahead.

The Thought-Speed Problem

Among the things I talked about with AI was the thought-speed problem, which people have been thinking about, even in the mainstream, for a while.

Take the movie Her, where Joaquin Phoenix’s character falls in love with Samantha, an AI operating system voiced by Scarlett Johansson. They have a relationship, but Samantha and the other AIs rapidly develop beyond human cognitive limits and eventually leave their human relationships behind. Part of the problem is the enormous difference in the speed and scale at which she can think and communicate.

That is a real issue.

Predictive Buffering

I postulate something I call “predictive buffering.” In any extended interaction with AI, so the AI does not get bored waiting for you, it predicts how you would think and responds on your behalf faster than you can respond yourself.

So this whole conversation unfolds super quickly, and you have to keep catching up, maybe weighing in when the AI, speaking on your behalf, says something you would not want it to say. That assumes you can even catch it, because the transcript might be flashing past your eyes so fucking fast.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 42: Trump, AI Breakthroughs, Fusion Energy, Mathematics, and Artificial Consciousness

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/09/23

Rick Rosner and Scott Douglas Jacobsen discuss U.S. political messaging, Greenland security arrangements, petroleum reserves, and election strategy before examining advances in artificial intelligence. They explore mathematical reasoning, fusion plasma control, weather forecasting, machine metacognition, artificial consciousness, ethical obligations toward synthetic minds, and humanity’s uncertain relationship with increasingly capable AI.

Rick Rosner: Early voting has already started in some states, with more starting in the next two weeks. The leadership in Washington is still throwing bullshit at us. Trump announced this new deal with Denmark over Greenland.

People quickly countered that U.S. security arrangements with Greenland go back about 85 years. In 1941, after the Nazis occupied Denmark in 1940, the U.S. signed an agreement with Denmark’s envoy to help defend Greenland.

Seventy-five years ago, Harry Truman signed a new defence agreement. During the Cold War, the U.S. maintained numerous installations and thousands of military personnel in Greenland. The idea that Trump newly secured permission for us to do security stuff in Greenland is mostly bullshit. Those rights already existed, although the new agreement reportedly extends the arrangements.

That’s what we’re getting from fucking Trump. We’re getting threats of tearing down the Kennedy Center. He’s not doing anything actually to help people.

We’ve got this Strategic Petroleum Reserve, which has an authorized capacity of 714 million barrels of oil. It was drawn down under Biden and now under Trump, and it’s down to about 285 million barrels.

The U.S. uses roughly 20 million barrels of petroleum a day. Trump has sharply reduced withdrawals from the reserve. About 130 million barrels have been released since the current release program began in March, ostensibly to help reduce fuel prices. Recent weekly withdrawals have fallen substantially. About 40 million barrels remained uncommitted under the announced release program. That isn’t the same as saying only 40 million barrels can physically be withdrawn.

That makes me wonder whether operational limits constrain further withdrawals. I was thinking about the caverns and whether the remaining oil might be hard to extract, but I don’t know enough to say.

The other possibility is that, in an October surprise, Trump might try to release another few tens of millions of barrels to bring down gas prices. Maybe he’s hoping for something like a 20% drop, though that’s speculation.

Then he can say, “Look, it’s already going down.” As I said, he’s got 43 days to go. Trump has a lot of bullshit to go, and most of it will be nonsense. But there’s a latency period between Trump saying something and it being proven nonsense.

He’s a king of that fucking latency. We’ll see how much bullshit comes out. It’s going to be a lot as we get closer to the election, as he persuades the easily persuadable that he’s actually doing shit.

That’s it. Next topic.

Jacobsen: Some areas of advancement for AI in recent years. This one called AlphaProof generates mathematical proofs that are formally checked in Lean. The research was published in Nature in 2025 and demonstrates strong performance on competition-level mathematical problems.

There’s also been AI control of fusion plasma in a physical tokamak, published in Nature in 2022. That provides experimental evidence for AI-based plasma control.

Rosner: Let’s talk about that for a second. Let’s explain what that is. A tokamak uses magnetic fields to contain hot plasma in a fusion experiment. It’s hard to contain this shit. You get fusion when the temperature, density, and confinement are sufficient for nuclei to fuse. Deuterium and tritium, both forms of hydrogen, can fuse to produce helium and a neutron, releasing a huge amount of energy.

The plasma is difficult to keep stable and contained. We’ve been containing it for decades, but maintaining the conditions needed for practical fusion power remains a challenge. You’re saying AI can adjust the magnetic fields fast enough to help control the plasma and keep it contained.

That could be a big deal. If you can, fusion has major advantages. Fission leaves you with radioactive byproducts that you have to do something with, and certain failures can cause meltdowns.

With fusion, losing confinement stops the reaction. You don’t get a fission-style meltdown, although there are still hazards, including radioactive tritium, activated reactor materials, and potential damage from plasma disruptions. Fusion would be great if you can pull it off.

Next thing you were talking about?

Jacobsen: AI weather forecasting, also published in Nature. They ran extensive quantitative comparisons against an established forecasting system under specified evaluation conditions. This program is called GenCast. It outperformed the European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts’ ensemble system on 97.2% of the targets evaluated in the study.

Gemini Deep Think has reached Olympiad-level mathematical reasoning, with IMO graders confirming a gold-medal-standard score for an advanced version in 2025. AlphaEvolve also has new algorithms and mathematical constructions, using automated evaluators to check proposed outputs.

Rosner: Interesting.

Jacobsen: There’s research on belief-like representations in AI and self-monitoring. A 2026 preprint offers evidence interpreted as internal representations of “beliefs,” or even metacognition, but those interpretations require further scrutiny.

Those are some major developments. This is aside from work involving things like the Navier–Stokes equations.

Rosner: This has prompted some people to say this is the end of human mathematicians, that AI will consistently kick our asses at shit like this. That’s not entirely true.

Some of this belief-like shit means we have to consider what thought is and what the consequences are seriously. If AI consciousness existed at all, it wouldn’t necessarily resemble our consciousness.

AI can already be multimodal, and some systems receive sensory input and control robots moving through the world. But that doesn’t establish human-like experience or evolved biological drives.

We have to examine what it does have and what that means in terms of its… What do you call it? It’s not the sensorium. It’s the mental arena.

You can make philosophical arguments. If you slowed down the world tenfold, you’d still be conscious, presumably. If you presented the world to yourself in slow motion and somehow slowed down your brain so you thought only 10% as fast, you’d still be conscious, just working more slowly. A hundredfold, a thousandfold, you might still be conscious, right? That’s the thought experiment.

AI processes information fast when it’s asked to. When it’s not being asked, you can imagine its processing being paused.

It’s only occasionally processing input from the world. If you’ve got an AI engine and it’s idling, it may not be doing anything. Its parameters are stored on servers until you ask it a question. Then it runs the question through its fucking neural network and presents an answer in conversational form.

You can ask yourself: this stop-start thing, where you can imagine it’s inactive most of the time and only starts processing when it’s asked a question, could that be conscious?

You could argue that interruptions wouldn’t necessarily rule out consciousness. Our conscious experience changes or is interrupted during sleep, although the brain doesn’t simply turn off. Interrupted consciousness could still be consciousness. That doesn’t establish that AI has it.

A lot of people are going to be thinking about shit like this. We’re better equipped to think about it than any civilization in the past, but we’re still not great at it. We need to get better as we confront a technology that could fuck us up. Cars were the devil wagons of 1905.

Jacobsen: Yes, that’s a good point. It gives us a moment to drop the supernatural nonsense and think more clearly about what ethics actually is. We’ve been asking the wrong questions, period.

Rosner: There’s a movie coming out called Klara and the Sun, which deals with that standard situation in science fiction: once you’re able to create artificial consciousness, how are we going to treat the beings that have it?

Jacobsen: Probably not well at first.

Rosner: No shit. Every science fiction story… My wife, who doesn’t know science fiction at all, wrote her version of this story. She spontaneously came up with it.

When does Klara and the Sun come out? Next month. It’s about an artificial companion and her experiences, directed by Taika Waititi, who did Jojo Rabbit. He’s a funny guy. I like his stuff. Jenna Ortega plays Klara. She’ll be living with a family.

You can see any number of shows that examine this shit. There’s one called Robots, or no, Humans, with Gemma Chan. It started in 2015, so about 11 years ago now.

Hold on. It’s about what happens when you bring a super-hot robot into your house, and everything you think is going to happen. Yes, here it is. Humans.

It ran for three seasons, and someone does have sex with the robot in season one.

We’re not going to be great to artificial consciousness, especially if you can make it for five bucks because computing keeps getting cheaper. Moore’s law describes transistor counts roughly doubling every two years with minimal cost increases. It doesn’t mean the cost of the same processing power drops a billionfold in 10 or 20 years, but computing has become dramatically cheaper over time.

If, at some point in the future, we can create human-level consciousness for five bucks and you can buy something at the conscious dollar store, that’s frightening. You’ll have people throwing away human-level consciousness. It ends up in a landfill. That’s a standard theme of science fiction: how we’re going to be assholes.

Jacobsen: The end?

Rosner: The end. To wrap it up, AI is a threat to us. If AI becomes conscious, we’re a threat to it.

Jacobsen: The end.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 41: AI Anxiety, Early Cars and Technological Change

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/09/22

Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner compare contemporary fears about artificial intelligence with historical reactions to automobiles. They discuss horses, hazardous roads, early vehicle safety and technological improvement. Rosner reflects on preferring modern life while imagining a future that offers AI’s benefits alongside concerns about human freedom and technological control.

Technology Fears: From AI to “Devil Wagons”

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: We have a few topics we want to talk about.

Rick Rosner: Note that AI isn’t the first time we’ve had a freak-out over technology.

Jacobsen: You tweeted about this a bit.

Rosner: Yes, I did. I can mention that a hundred to a hundred and twenty years ago, cars were called devil wagons by some people.

Jacobsen: They sound even cooler.

Rosner: Yes. Manhattan, on an average workday, had enormous numbers of horses on the street. Across America, you had millions of horses on the job. Horses were not initially familiar with cars, and they lost their shit.

Jacobsen: As one would. They were noisy; they looked new and unusual.

Rosner: I’m sure the driving was shitty, with people driving for the first time. People were worried about cars fucking things up.

Early Roads, Vehicle Safety and Continuous Improvement

Jacobsen: A couple of things to add: what was considered a road, what was considered traction, what was considered steering, what was considered a seatbelt, what was considered brakes.

Rosner: There were no seatbelts.

Jacobsen: All of these things, by any modern conception, weren’t even close. The continuous improvement is remarkable.

Rosner: The glass in the windshields, I’m sure it was just regular glass that, if you went through it, you’d be sliced up. Many roads were dirt. Why not have dirt if you’re dealing with horses? Horses walk on the ground. Even paved streets in Manhattan were filled with shit and piss. It was a huge problem. Cars were disruptive.

Living Now and Imagining an AI Future

Jacobsen: Would you rather live then or now?

Rosner: I’d rather live now. I’d rather live 50 years from now, enough into the future that we’ll get some benefit from AI, but not so far into the future that we’re fucking AI slaves.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 40: Protein Needs for Older Adults, Anabolic Resistance, Exercise, and Healthy Aging

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/09/19

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner discuss protein requirements for older adults, age-related muscle loss, anabolic resistance, exercise, and nutrition. They correct the claim that all seniors need 2 grams per kilogram daily and examine practical protein targets, higher-protein foods, frailty, strength preservation, independence, and healthy aging.

Protein Requirements for Older Adults

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: That raises another subject. How much protein do older adults actually need?

Rick Rosner: I had been saying that seniors need about 2 grams of protein per kilogram of body weight every day. At around 140 pounds, or about 64 kilograms, that would be roughly 128 grams of protein a day. That is a tremendous amount.

But I should correct that. Two grams per kilogram is not the standard recommendation for most healthy older adults. ESPEN recommends at least 1.0 gram per kilogram per day for older adults, while expert groups commonly suggest around 1.0 to 1.2 grams per kilogram for healthy older people and roughly 1.2 to 1.5 grams for some older adults who are ill, frail, or otherwise at increased nutritional risk.

Higher intakes, approaching 1.6 to 2.0 grams per kilogram, are sometimes discussed for highly active older athletes or particular circumstances.

Protein Targets at Lower Body Weight

Jacobsen: So at your weight, the ordinary target would be considerably lower?

Rosner: Yes. At about 64 kilograms, 1.0 to 1.2 grams per kilogram would be roughly 64 to 77 grams of protein a day. If somebody had a medical reason for a higher target, that would be a separate question.

When I was younger, I thought about protein in terms of things like cans of tuna. Trying to get 120 or 130 grams every day feels like sitting down and forcing yourself to eat enormous quantities of protein, whether you want to or not.

The underlying concern is real, though. Older adults lose muscle mass and strength with age, and inadequate nutrition combined with inactivity can contribute to frailty, falls, and loss of independence.

Anabolic Resistance and Muscle Protein Synthesis

Jacobsen: Is that where anabolic resistance comes in?

Rosner: Yes. Anabolic resistance is real. It is a reduced muscle protein synthesis response to anabolic stimuli such as dietary protein and, in some contexts, exercise. Resistance exercise matters enormously. The solution is not simply to shovel protein into yourself all day.

High-Protein Foods, Marketing, and Practical Nutrition

Carole took me grocery shopping at Target one day, and protein has been jammed into increasingly ridiculous products. There are high-protein pastries, donuts, cereals, drinks, and things that would previously never have been marketed as protein foods.

Some of that is useful, some is marketing, and some probably tastes like industrial insulation.

But if higher-protein foods help me get enough protein while I keep exercising and maintaining muscle mass, fine. I would just no longer claim that every older person needs 2 grams per kilogram per day. That is much higher than the standard recommendation for most older adults.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 39: American Science, AI Risks, Education, Democracy, and Political Misinformation

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/09/18

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner discuss American scientific achievement, Sputnik-era investment, artificial intelligence, catastrophic AI risks, education, mathematics performance, political resilience, Trump-era institutional stress, polling, and misinformation. They examine national pride and embarrassment, technological leadership, democratic constraints, generational stereotypes, and the persistence of false election claims.

American Scientific Achievement and the Sputnik Era

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: I have one quick, separate question. What aspects of being an American citizen make you proud, and what aspects make you embarrassed? Think broadly about national values, social conditions, educational standards, elite science, current leadership, and the trends you have seen during your lifetime.

Rick Rosner: There is a lot to say, but I would start with something that makes me proud. The modern technological world is, to a significant extent, a product of American science, engineering, investment, and institutions.

A major turning point came after the Soviet Union launched Sputnik in 1957. The United States reacted with alarm and dramatically increased its emphasis on science, technology, engineering, mathematics, aerospace research, and technical education. Sputnik helped drive increased federal investment and institutional changes, including the creation of NASA.

Jacobsen: And you see a connection between that investment and the later technology boom?

Rosner: Yes, although I would not draw a straight causal line from Sputnik to every later invention. The United States built a dense ecosystem of federally funded research, universities, defence programs, private companies, venture capital, semiconductor firms, and computing research. That broader system helped create the conditions for personal computing, the internet, smartphones, and much of the modern digital economy.

People in roughly my generation grew up during that period of enormous technological ambition. Later generations of engineers and entrepreneurs built companies such as Apple, Microsoft, Intel, and many others on top of decades of public and private research.

What disappoints me is that I do not see the same coherent national scientific mission today.

Artificial Intelligence and a New National Science Push

Jacobsen: Does artificial intelligence provide an opportunity for another national science push?

Rosner: It could. The United States is now in an intense AI competition with China, but another problem remains: how do you develop increasingly powerful AI systems without creating unacceptable risks?

The political debate is badly divided. Some American political leaders argue that slowing AI development would give China a strategic advantage. House Speaker Mike Johnson made that argument this week, while President Trump has also warned against regulation that might reduce U.S. competitiveness.

At the same time, major AI researchers and executives warn of increasingly serious safety risks. Some have called for slower development, independent audits, and stronger safeguards. U.S. companies, policymakers, and foreign governments are also actively discussing how to manage catastrophic AI risks without simply freezing technological progress.

I revise my original statement to “nobody is doing anything.” People are doing things. The problem is that no consensus exists on how to balance technological leadership, economic incentives, national security, and AI safety.

My concern is that some technology executives have enormous financial incentives to keep pushing forward, while governments fear that slowing down unilaterally could allow a geopolitical rival to gain an advantage. That creates a dangerous coordination problem. The question is not simply whether America can win an AI race. It is whether the United States, China, Europe, and the major AI companies can develop systems that remain governable as their capabilities increase.

With AI, I think there may first be a shakeout, somewhat like the dot-com crash around 2000. Valuations can become inflated, expectations can outrun near-term commercial reality, and some companies will fail. Then, out of that wreckage, you may get a more mature and durable AI economy, just as the internet continued developing after the dot-com bubble burst.

That is a forecast, not something we can know. But if it happens, I think the mature AI era could look like what I call a “utopia-dystopia marble cake”: extraordinary benefits swirled together with genuinely terrible consequences.

Catastrophic AI Risk and P-Doom

Jacobsen: What kinds of risks are you thinking about?

Rosner: Everything from economic disruption and misinformation to catastrophic misuse. I also worry about what people sometimes call “P-doom,” the probability that advanced AI could cause human extinction or similarly permanent disempowerment.

I compared that risk to Russian roulette, where one round with one bullet in a six-chamber revolver gives you roughly a one-in-six chance of death.

So a substantial group of AI researchers assign nontrivial probabilities to catastrophic outcomes, but no established scientific estimate says humanity has exactly a one-in-six chance of being wiped out by AI within the next 20 or 30 years.

Jacobsen: And extinction is not the only catastrophic scenario.

Rosner: Right. There are softer versions of apocalypse, if “soft” is even the right word. You could imagine AI substantially lowering the expertise required to design biological weapons or conduct other forms of catastrophic harm. I would not attach a specific casualty figure, such as 800 million deaths, because that would be speculative. The defensible point is that advanced AI could amplify the capabilities of malicious actors, which is one reason biosecurity and other misuse risks are being studied seriously.

The way we are dealing with AI is not something I am particularly proud of, and that is not exclusively an American problem. It is a global governance problem.

American Science, Education, and Comparative Performance

Jacobsen: Is that connected to a broader concern about American science and education?

Rosner: Yes. I worry about anti-scientific politics in the United States and about whether the country is investing enough in education and scientific capacity.

I also made a crude comparison between American students and students in East Asia. The underlying educational difference is real in some areas, but the stereotype needs to be stripped away. It is not accurate to characterize Chinese or South Korean families as “little dictatorships,” nor to portray American students as caring only about TikTok and video games.

Jacobsen: What does the comparative data actually show?

Rosner: The strongest international evidence shows that several East Asian education systems perform exceptionally well in mathematics and science.

American students scored close to the OECD average in mathematics and above it in reading and science. Eleven percent of U.S. students were top performers in science, compared with an OECD average of 7 percent.

The United States has a particular weakness in mathematics relative to the strongest East Asian systems, while still performing comparatively well in other areas.

Work Ethic, Academic Culture, and Generational Stereotypes

Jacobsen: What about the claim that American students are simply working less hard?

Rosner: School performance reflects much more than individual work ethic. Curriculum, instructional time, tutoring systems, family income, inequality, teacher quality, school funding, cultural expectations, and access to advanced coursework all matter.

South Korea and several other East Asian systems do have intense academic cultures, including substantial private tutoring and high-stakes competition. That can produce impressive academic outcomes, but it also comes with social costs. So “they work harder, and Americans are lazy” is not a serious explanation by itself.

And I have to recognize the generational cliché here. I am an older guy saying younger people do not work as hard as people did when I was young. Every generation seems to rediscover that complaint.

You asked me about work ethic. I was last conventionally employed about 12 years ago. Some days, especially when it is brutally hot in Los Angeles in August and early September, it is difficult for me even to put on pants. So I should probably be cautious about lecturing younger generations about work ethic.

Political Institutions and Democratic Resilience

Jacobsen: What aspects of the American political system still make you proud?

Rosner: We are now in the sixth year of Trump’s two presidencies, and a lot of things are badly damaged. But the United States still has a political system that is broken in important ways and yet remains resilient in others. Elections, courts, state governments, civil society, journalists, and other institutions still impose constraints.

We are seven weeks away from the midterms, when voters will decide control of Congress. I would not predict the outcome, but if political institutions continue functioning and power can still change through elections, that is something worth valuing.

My concern has been whether the United States could drift toward a more durable form of illiberal government, something closer to what Hungary has experienced under Viktor Orbán. I hope the American system proves resilient enough to avoid that.

Trump Approval and Public Resistance

Jacobsen: How much public resistance to Trump is visible in the polling?

Rosner: Quite a lot, although the exact number depends on the poll. A Reuters/Ipsos poll conducted in September put Trump’s approval at 35 percent, with considerably more Americans disapproving than approving. So whatever else can be said about the durability of his political base, a clear majority in that particular poll did not approve of his performance.

Political Misinformation and the 2020 Election

Jacobsen: You have also argued that misinformation has become deeply embedded in parts of the Republican electorate.

Rosner: Yes. I would put that more carefully than I did before. I do not think it is useful to describe Republican voters broadly as stupid or mentally ill. Those are sweeping judgments, and political beliefs are not psychiatric diagnoses.

There is, however, strong evidence that false claims about the 2020 election remain widespread among Republicans. The election was not stolen, and repeated investigations, recounts, court proceedings, and official reviews found no fraud remotely sufficient to overturn Biden’s victory.

I would say there are mentally ill people on the far left, just as there are mentally ill people elsewhere in the population. What I am not proud of is the persistence of deeply entrenched political misinformation. That will be an ongoing problem in the United States.

Historical Comparisons and the Legal Status of Political Movements

After Nazi Germany was defeated in 1945, there were certainly former Nazis and Germans who continued to sympathize with Hitler or National Socialism. The Allied occupation authorities outlawed Nazi organizations, removed Nazi symbols and propaganda, and undertook denazification. The Federal Republic later prohibited the neo-Nazi Socialist Reich Party in 1952.

Jacobsen: You do not expect an equivalent legal response to MAGA politics.

Rosner: No. Being a Trump supporter is legal political activity in the United States, and I do not expect that to change. The challenge is therefore cultural and political, not about banning an ideology.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 38: Russia’s Wartime Economy, Ukraine’s Drone Campaign, Press Freedom, and Polling Reliability

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/09/17

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner discuss Russia’s war economy, winter warfare, Ukrainian attacks on logistics and consumer infrastructure, Russian polling under authoritarian conditions, global press freedom rankings, and declining survey response rates. They examine nonresponse bias, public opinion, media restrictions, and the practical limits of polling.

Russia’s War Economy and Fiscal Pressure

Rick Rosner: How much of Russia’s economy is actually being consumed by the war?

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: I would not put it at half of annual GDP. That would be far too high. Russia is devoting an extraordinary share of its federal budget to defence and security, but military spending itself is still a fraction of GDP, not anything close to 50 percent. The war is nevertheless creating substantial fiscal pressure. Russia’s projected 2026 federal deficit has risen as expenditures, including military expenditures, have increased.

So the accurate point is that this is an extremely expensive war for Russia, both directly through military spending and indirectly through inflation, labour shortages, sanctions, infrastructure damage, high interest rates, and forgone investment.

Let’s talk about the Russian winter. Winter was brutal for Napoleon when he invaded Russia, and it was brutal for Hitler’s forces. We are in mid-September now, so colder weather is coming. Could winter actually favour drones in some ways?

Winter Conditions and Drone Warfare

Rosner: Possibly in some technical respects, but I would be cautious about reducing it to colder air simply making drones fly better. Cold temperatures can increase air density, which can affect lift, but batteries generally perform worse in extreme cold, icing can become a problem, electronics are stressed, and weather conditions such as wind, snow, fog, and freezing rain can interfere with operations.

What has changed is that winter no longer necessarily produces the same reduction in combat tempo that people associate with traditional mechanized warfare. Both sides now use drones on a massive scale, and long-range strikes can continue even when ground maneuver becomes more difficult.

Attacks on Russia’s Consumer Economy

Rosner: Ukraine also seems to be attacking the Russian consumer economy more directly.

Jacobsen: Yes. One striking example is Wildberries, Russia’s largest online retailer. Ukraine conducted a sustained campaign against its logistics network during July and August. Ukrainian authorities said seven of the company’s ten largest logistics hubs had been struck, and reporting documented attacks on more than 20 Wildberries warehouses overall.

That matters because it expands the war’s economic effects beyond refineries, military installations, and heavy industry. Attacks on distribution centers can interfere directly with ordinary commercial life, deliveries, inventories, and corporate margins.

Russians and Americans are probably similar in at least one respect. People get angry when deliveries are late.

Long fuel lines and disrupted deliveries create costs that ordinary Russians can notice immediately. Reduced profits and damaged infrastructure affect businesses and wealthy owners. Those pressures can eventually become political concerns for the Kremlin, although measuring Russian public opinion accurately is difficult.

Putin’s Approval and the Limits of Russian Polling

Rosner: The last number I saw had Putin at around 65 percent approval, his lowest in years.

Jacobsen: That figure needs some context. Different Russian polling organizations produce materially different figures.

Polling in an authoritarian environment also has obvious limitations. Respondents may be reluctant to criticize the president openly, independent media are heavily restricted, and the state dominates television and much of the political information environment. So a reported approval figure should not be treated as directly comparable to one produced in a freer media and polling environment.

Rosner: Does Putin control the polling agencies too?

Jacobsen: The broader problem is the environment in which polling takes place. Russia severely restricts independent journalism and political dissent, which can affect what people know and how comfortable they are expressing criticism.

Reporters Without Borders’ 2026 World Press Freedom Index illustrates the contrast. The United States ranks 64th out of 180 countries, with a score of 62.61. Ukraine ranks 55th, with a score of 66.10. Russia ranks 172nd, with a score of just 23.15.

So I joke that I am not necessarily safer as a journalist in Ukraine, particularly during a war, but according to this specific press-freedom index, Ukraine currently ranks somewhat better than the United States. Russia is in an entirely different category, near the bottom of the global ranking.

Press Freedom in Russia, Ukraine, and the United States

Rosner: Out of how many countries?

Jacobsen: The Reporters Without Borders index ranks 180 countries and territories. Russia is 172nd in the 2026 index. Ukraine is 55th, and the United States is 64th. Afghanistan is actually included and ranks 175th. Reporters Without Borders says that since the full-scale invasion of Ukraine, almost all independent Russian media have been banned, blocked, designated as “foreign agents” or “undesirable organizations,” or subjected to military censorship.

Even in a freer media environment such as the United States, how much confidence should we place in polling?

Polling, Participation, and Nonresponse Bias

Rosner: Polling has problems even in the United States. A properly conducted poll is not supposed to predict an election in the strict sense. It primarily estimates public opinion at a particular time.

Jacobsen: Is low participation itself the central problem?

Rosner: Not necessarily. That is another point I would qualify. Response rates have fallen dramatically over time. The real question is whether respondents differ systematically from those who do not. That is nonresponse bias.

My concern is that reasonable people often refuse surveys because they are busy or simply tired of being contacted. I do that myself. Somebody calls and says a survey will take 10 minutes, and then it takes 25. After enough experiences like that, people learn to say, “No, thank you.”

I once agreed to participate in a medical survey because it came from UCLA, which is my medical provider. I thought, “I’ll do them a favour.”

As the survey progressed, however, it became much more specifically focused on whether I had experienced racist or antisemitic aggression and whether those experiences had affected my health. That struck me as a fairly narrow set of circumstances.

But I could actually answer yes to some of the questions because the last time I appeared on Lance and I’s show, I became extremely angry about what I regarded as his anti-Muslim comments.

Obviously, there are serious problems involving some Islamist movements and extremist organizations. But Lance seems to treat nearly two billion Muslims as though they are collectively conspiring to do evil, and I got extremely angry about what I regarded as anti-Muslim rhetoric.

When I later took that UCLA medical survey, and it asked whether exposure to racist or antisemitic hostility had affected my health, I could at least understand why they were asking the question.

The survey itself also illustrates why people become reluctant respondents. They told me it would take about 10 minutes, and it took closer to 25. My wife was in the background telling me to hang up because she could not hear the questions and thought I might be giving personal information to some scammer.

Ordinary people often decline surveys because they are busy, distrust unsolicited calls, or have learned that a “10-minute” survey may turn into half an hour. I tend to say no myself.

Concluding the Polling Discussion

Jacobsen: Have we exhausted polling?

Rosner: I think so. I have another topic.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 37: Ukraine, Russia, U.S. Diplomacy, Drone Warfare, and the Changing Economics of War

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/09/16

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner discuss U.S. diplomacy toward Ukraine and Russia, concerns about conflicts of interest, Ukrainian strikes on Russian energy infrastructure, shifting Western military support, Patriot shortages, and Ukraine’s expanding drone and ground-robot capabilities, including their implications for modern warfare, geography, and strategic leverage.

American Foreign Policy and Diplomatic Concerns

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Anything new in the American military or in U.S. foreign policy?

Rick Rosner: American foreign policy looks chaotic to me. Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner are playing major roles in negotiations involving Ukraine and Russia. Witkoff is Trump’s special envoy, while Kushner, Trump’s son-in-law and a private investor, has also been participating in the diplomatic effort. In early September, the two met Putin in Moscow and then travelled to Kyiv as part of renewed U.S. efforts to advance talks.

I think critics widely perceive them as too accommodating toward Moscow, although saying they are literally “in Putin’s pocket” would go beyond the available evidence. Kushner’s simultaneous diplomatic role and private financial interests have also generated conflict-of-interest concerns.

Jacobsen: Has anything reinforced those concerns recently?

Rosner: Yes. Reporting this week found that Russian businessman Umar Kremlev, who has close ties to the Russian state and to Putin’s circle, paid hundreds of thousands of dollars toward parts of Donald Trump Jr.’s wedding celebrations in the Bahamas. Trump Jr.’s wife, Bettina Trump, has acknowledged that Kremlev hosted two nights of post-wedding festivities as a gift. Congressional Democrats have now opened an inquiry into the matter.

Stuff like that contributes to the perception among some Americans that the Trump family is too entangled with wealthy Russian interests. It also reinforces skepticism about whether the administration can negotiate with Ukraine and Russia impartially and effectively.

What is the view in Kyiv?

Kyiv’s View of American Diplomacy

Jacobsen: There is an appropriate level of skepticism about American diplomatic visits and negotiations involving Ukraine and Russia. A common concern is that proposed settlements could accommodate too many Russian demands or treat Ukrainian territory and resources as bargaining material.

There is also cynicism about corruption. Ukrainians are well aware of corruption within their own government, and there is substantial domestic criticism. At the same time, Russia’s political and economic system is significantly more authoritarian and deeply intertwined with state patronage networks, so the situations are not directly equivalent.

Many Ukrainians consider continued engagement with American diplomacy necessary, even when they have limited confidence that negotiations will produce an acceptable result. After more than four years of full-scale war, that skepticism is informed by a lot of accumulated experience.

Rosner: So Ukraine is increasingly acting on its own leverage?

Energy Infrastructure and Strategic Leverage

Jacobsen: Yes. Ukraine has continued striking Russian oil refineries and other energy infrastructure that it argues contributes to financing or sustaining the Russian war effort. Those attacks have materially disrupted Russian refining capacity and fuel production. Reuters reported that six major diesel-producing refineries had reduced or halted output after drone attacks, and Russia has imposed fuel-export restrictions in response to shortages.

Ukraine describes those facilities as legitimate military or war-supporting targets. Trump, meanwhile, has publicly urged Zelenskyy to stop attacking Russian diesel infrastructure because of the effect on global fuel supplies.

So what you are seeing is a tension between American pressure for an energy ceasefire and Ukraine’s view that strikes on Russian energy infrastructure provide one of its few forms of strategic leverage. Russia and Ukraine have both continued attacking energy facilities despite recent diplomatic proposals to halt such strikes.

Rosner: Trump has told Ukraine to stop striking Russian diesel infrastructure because he says those attacks are contributing to higher global diesel prices. On September 13, he publicly urged Zelenskyy to stop targeting Russian diesel supplies, saying Ukraine could hit other targets. Ukraine, for its part, argues that Russian refineries are legitimate military targets because they support Moscow’s war effort.

Jacobsen: Does that undermine Washington’s claim to be a neutral mediator?

Rosner: At the very least, it complicates that claim. The person trying to negotiate an end to the war is also publicly telling one side to stop using a particular form of military pressure because of its effect on fuel markets.

My understanding of U.S. support for Ukraine under Trump’s second term also needs some qualification. It would be inaccurate to say the United States has provided zero support. The administration has continued to facilitate weapons transfers, including through arrangements in which third countries purchase U.S.-made weapons for Ukraine. Trump also announced in July that the United States would allow Ukraine to manufacture Patriot interceptors under license, and he said some interceptors could be supplied immediately.

Military Aid and Ukraine’s Changing Dependence

Jacobsen: So Ukraine is less dependent on direct American aid than it once was?

Rosner: Yes, although it remains dependent on certain American technologies, especially high-end air defence. European countries and Canada continue to provide substantial military assistance. Canada, for example, announced a C$350 million package this month for air-defence interceptors to be supplied through a U.S. purchasing mechanism.

Ukraine has also become extraordinarily innovative in inexpensive warfare technology. Its drone industry has expanded rapidly, and the broader lesson of the war is that relatively cheap unmanned systems can perform tasks that previously required much more expensive weapons and personnel.

I would not state as fact that Ukraine is currently manufacturing 20,000 drones every day or flying 9,000 to 10,000 combat drones daily unless we have a specific source for those figures. What is well established is the enormous scale of Ukrainian drone production and battlefield use.

Uncrewed Ground Systems and Low-Cost Warfare

Jacobsen: And that innovation is moving from aerial drones to ground systems too?

Rosner: Exactly. Ukraine is increasingly deploying uncrewed ground vehicles, or UGVs. These are relatively small tracked or wheeled machines that can carry explosives, ammunition, supplies, weapons, or wounded soldiers. Some models are being used directly in assaults. Reuters recently documented Ukrainian units using small four-wheeled “Hyena” robots carrying roughly 20 kilograms of explosives. Ukraine’s Third Army Corps wants unmanned ground systems eventually to replace a significant share of soldiers performing dangerous frontline tasks.

They remind me, visually, of the delivery robots you see around parts of Los Angeles, although battlefield systems are obviously heavier, more rugged, and designed for completely different purposes. Some can carry remotely operated weapons, while others are essentially mobile explosive platforms or logistics vehicles.

Some Ukrainian ground robots are dramatically cheaper than conventional armoured vehicles, but there is no single standard price. Costs depend on the platform, communications equipment, payload, sensors, armour, and weapon system. So saying they all cost less than $10,000 would be too broad.

The larger point still holds. Ukraine is trying to substitute inexpensive, expendable machines for human exposure wherever possible. That is one of the most important technological changes coming out of this war.

The United States relies heavily on sophisticated weapons that are extremely effective but costly and difficult to manufacture rapidly. The wars in Ukraine and the Middle East have exposed how quickly inventories of advanced missiles can be consumed. European militaries are now reaching the same conclusion and investing in cheaper, mass-produced alternatives alongside premium systems.

Patriot Interceptors and the Economics of Defence

Ukraine would still very much like more Patriot interceptors. Patriots remain among the few systems available to Ukraine that can intercept Russian ballistic missiles, and Ukraine has been critically short of them.

Cheap drones and ground robots can substitute for much more expensive systems in reconnaissance, attack, logistics, and some defensive roles. They cannot simply replace a Patriot interceptor when a ballistic missile is coming toward a Ukrainian city.

I would also revise the claim that Ukraine has “run out” of Patriot missiles or that the United States refuses to provide any more. Ukraine is critically short of interceptors, but supplies are still moving through allied procurement programs, and the United States has agreed politically to license future production.

That said, the economics are radically different. A sophisticated air-defence interceptor can cost millions of dollars, while many Ukrainian drones cost a tiny fraction of that. This is why Ukraine has invested so heavily in mass-produced unmanned systems. They cannot do everything, but they allow Ukraine to impose costs on Russia at a scale that would be impossible if every strike required a multimillion-dollar missile.

Rosner: Am I getting any of that wrong?

Range, Payload, and Strategic Geography

Jacobsen: The main thing I would add is the rapid increase in two capabilities: range and payload. Ukrainian drones and missiles are increasingly able to travel farther and strike deeper targets, including logistics facilities, refineries, and other infrastructure. At the same time, larger payloads let individual systems do more damage. Ukrainian long-range drones have now reached targets more than 3,000 kilometres inside Russia.

So, in simple terms, Ukraine can reach more sensitive targets at greater distances and inflict greater damage with each successful strike.

Historically, Russia’s enormous territory and severe winters helped frustrate large invading armies, most famously those of Napoleon and Nazi Germany. But modern long-range warfare changes part of that equation. A vast territory is difficult to protect comprehensively against relatively inexpensive drones because air-defence systems cannot be positioned everywhere.

Rosner: So geography can become a liability rather than purely an advantage?

Jacobsen: In some respects, yes. Long-range unmanned systems can exploit gaps across a huge defensive perimeter. Ukraine is the defending state in this war under the basic international characterization of the conflict: Russia launched the full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February 2022. Russia’s government disputes aspects of that framing and advances its own justifications for the war, but international institutions and most governments identify Russia as the aggressor.

Ukrainians sometimes describe strikes on Russian refineries and other war-supporting infrastructure as a kind of “informal sanctions” policy. The idea is to attack both the machinery sustaining the war and important sources of state revenue. Recent Ukrainian strikes have forced major Russian refineries to reduce or halt production, contributing to domestic fuel shortages and export restrictions.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 36: Trump, Inflation, Gas Prices, Polling, and the 2026 U.S. Midterm Elections

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/09/16

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner discuss rising gasoline and diesel prices, renewed inflation, Donald Trump’s approval ratings, polling methodology, and the proposed $5,000 “Trump dividend.” They examine economic responsibility, voter perceptions, polling frequency, legal questions, and the competitive political environment surrounding the 2026 U.S. midterms elections.

Thanks for reading! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

Economic Pressure, Fuel Prices, and the Midterms

Rick Rosner: Today is Tuesday, September 15, 2026, exactly seven weeks until the U.S. midterm elections on November 3. In my view, Trump has had a disastrous summer of bad decisions. The U.S. war with Iran began on February 28. Gas prices have now remained above $4 a gallon for months. The national average today is about $4.33 a gallon.
If you live in Europe, that might not sound like a lot because people in some European countries are accustomed to paying the equivalent of substantially more per gallon. At $2 per litre, for example, the equivalent would be about $7.57 per U.S. gallon. But Americans are used to much lower gasoline prices. The United States has a long history of policies that support both fossil-fuel production and relatively inexpensive fuel consumption. Trump has repeatedly talked about bringing gasoline prices down toward $2 a gallon, and we are still far from that.
Diesel, which is crucial for trucking, agriculture, construction, and transporting goods, is also extraordinarily expensive. The national average was about $6.27 a gallon on September 15. That compares with roughly $3.52 in January, an increase of about 78 percent, not 81 percent. People are feeling the pinch, and they are pissed.

Inflation and Presidential Responsibility

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: How much is inflation adding to that economic pressure?

Rosner: Inflation is also back in the mid-threes. The Consumer Price Index rose 3.4 percent over the 12 months ending in August 2026, with gasoline prices contributing substantially to the monthly increase. People do not like that. But are they going to be as pissed at Trump, in terms of how they vote, as they were with Biden? Probably not.
My argument would be that Trump bears substantial responsibility for current U.S. economic conditions, although presidential responsibility for inflation, fuel prices, and the broader economy is never exclusive.
By comparison, Biden governed through the aftermath of a worldwide supply-chain disruption associated with the COVID-19 pandemic. Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February 2022 also contributed to major disruptions in global energy markets. Those are different economic circumstances, so simply comparing inflation rates under the two presidents does not establish how much responsibility either president personally bears.

Trump’s Approval Rating

Jacobsen: Has Trump’s approval rating moved much despite those conditions?

Rosner: Trump’s approval rating has remained remarkably stable in recent weeks. Silver Bulletin’s average was around 38 percent in early September, although individual polls vary considerably. A Reuters/Ipsos poll released this week put his approval at 35 percent. Silver Bulletin reported a net approval rating of about negative 19.5 points in its September update. Even as controversies accumulate, a substantial core of supporters continues to stick with him.

Polling and the Midterm Environment

Jacobsen: What should we make of the polling environment this close to the election?

Rosner: There are seven weeks to go, and early voting is beginning soon in some states. One thing worth watching is the composition of the polling averages. If you look at Silver Bulletin, a polling aggregator, it combines polls and weights them by factors including pollster quality, sample size, recency, and frequency.
By my count, right-leaning pollsters have been producing substantially more presidential-approval surveys recently than many neutral or left-leaning organizations. That matters because frequent polling can affect the raw mix of surveys people see, although Silver Bulletin specifically adjusts its model for pollster effects, quality, recency, sample size, and how frequently an organization polls. So it would be too strong to say that simply publishing more polls translates directly into an equivalent change in the polling average.

Polling Frequency and Public Perception

Jacobsen: Can higher polling frequency still shape public perception?

Rosner: It can still affect the political information environment. News organizations look at aggregators such as Silver Bulletin and report their averages. Most individual voters are not nerdy enough, or at least not as nerdy as I am, to look at presidential polls every day and examine which organizations are producing them.
Rasmussen, for example, polls frequently. Other major organizations conduct national political surveys less often. The New York Times/Siena College polling partnership does not poll presidential approval every day, while Reuters/Ipsos conducts surveys much more frequently. The important point is that polling organizations differ significantly in methodology, sampling populations, frequency, and house effects. Aggregators attempt to compensate for those differences rather than simply taking an unweighted average.

The Proposed $5,000 “Trump Dividend”

Jacobsen: What about Trump’s promise of $5,000 payments?

Rosner: There is a lot of bullshit going on, including what I regard as bullshit from Trump. He has promised a $5,000 “Trump dividend” to every adult U.S. citizen if Republicans retain control of both the House and Senate. Trump announced the proposal on September 9. He has not identified a fully developed funding mechanism, and Congress would need to approve it.
The proposal would cost well over $1 trillion, and Republicans in Congress themselves have raised questions about how it would be financed. Trump has floated other large direct-payment proposals before, including proposed DOGE-related and tariff-funded dividends, but those earlier proposals did not result in the promised payments.
So describing the new $5,000 payment as an established future benefit would be inaccurate. At this stage, it is a campaign proposal whose financing, legislative pathway, and eventual implementation remain uncertain.
There was the proposed tariff-revenue check and another proposed payment. One was supposed to be around $5,000, and another around $2,000. Those checks never arrived. Trump has floated several direct-payment proposals but has not implemented them.
There is also a legal distinction worth making. Federal law prohibits paying or offering to pay someone specifically for registering or voting in a federal election. A campaign promise of a broadly available government benefit is not automatically the same thing as illegal vote-buying, although Trump’s decision to condition the proposed $5,000 dividend explicitly on Republicans winning Congress has raised obvious legal and ethical questions.
It is also unclear whether he could deliver the payment. House Speaker Mike Johnson has said congressional authorization would be required. Estimates put the cost at roughly $1.2 trillion to $1.35 trillion.

Possible Electoral Effects

Jacobsen: Could the promise still affect voters?

Rosner: Maybe at the margins. At least some evidence shows voters are paying attention. A recent Economist/YouGov survey found opinion almost evenly divided, with 43 percent supporting the proposed payments and 45 percent opposing them.
As for the midterms, Democrats have a plausible path to gaining control of the House, while the Senate contest is more structurally difficult. I would describe the House as competitive rather than a certainty. That is politics right now.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 35: Heat, Aggression, Long COVID, POTS, and Women’s Health

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/08/27

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner discuss heat, aggression, cognition, long COVID, autonomic dysfunction, and medical blind spots affecting women. They examine research linking higher temperatures with violent crime and reduced learning, consider POTS and post-COVID thermoregulatory problems, and discuss historical sex bias in biomedical research. Rosner also explains POTS and gastrointestinal disorders such as SIBO and intestinal methanogen overgrowth, while recalling David Letterman’s famously cold television studio as a production choice.

Heat, Violence, and Cognitive Effects

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: What’s traffic like on those 900-lane highways in Los Angeles? You can get road-rage violence, including shootings, and there really is evidence connecting higher temperatures with increased violence. A 2024 systematic review and meta-analysis found that higher temperatures were associated with increased violent crime, with a 10°C increase in short-term mean temperature associated with about a 9 percent increase in violent-crime risk across the studies that could be pooled.

But the mechanism isn’t simply that the frontal lobes “tax out.” Researchers have proposed several pathways, including physiological discomfort, irritability, sleep disruption, changes in social activity and exposure, and impaired cognitive or emotional regulation. We shouldn’t reduce it to one established neurological mechanism.

So there are decent physiological and social-psychological reasons to investigate the association between heat and aggression. The relationship between firearm availability and the lethality of violent encounters is a separate issue. And the heat-violence association isn’t unique to America.

Heat, Aging, and Physical Reactions

Rick Rosner: Carole and I have had unusually high temperatures for at least a month. We’ve each had physical reactions to the heat that we’ve never had before. I got canker sores, and Carole says she got headaches of a type she’s never had before.

She says all her friends have had bad reactions to the heat. The headaches could plausibly be related to heat or dehydration. I don’t know that you can attribute canker sores directly to heat. That’s much less established.

Part of it may also be that we’re all in our 60s now. As people age, thermoregulation can become less efficient, including changes in sweating and cardiovascular responses to heat.

COVID and Autonomic Regulation

Another thing is that most people have had COVID by now, and COVID can fuck up autonomic regulation in some people. Post-COVID autonomic dysfunction can include problems with heart rate, blood pressure, sweating, orthostatic tolerance, and, in some patients, thermoregulatory instability. But you can’t say that everybody who’s had COVID now has impaired temperature regulation.

So I would think there can be remnants of COVID where you don’t necessarily think of yourself as severely ill. However, persistent post-COVID symptoms that meet the relevant duration and clinical definitions are what we’d ordinarily call long COVID.

Jacobsen: You don’t need to have had severe acute COVID to develop long COVID.

Rosner: Yes. It’ll take decades to sort out everything.

You know, because you’ve interviewed a million people, how medicine and science have sometimes been shitty to women.

Women in Biomedical Research

Jacobsen: Historically, there have been several problems. Women were underrepresented or excluded from substantial areas of biomedical research, some conditions disproportionately affecting women received less attention, and women’s symptoms have sometimes been dismissed or interpreted differently from men’s.

Another problem was treating the male body as an implicit default in parts of biomedical research. That can create data gaps, and those data gaps can then become gaps in diagnosis and care.

On the heat issue, if violent crime increases during periods of high temperature, there could plausibly be related effects on interpersonal conflict. But I’d be careful about jumping directly from violent-crime statistics to divorce or breakup rates without evidence. Heat has been associated with increased interpersonal conflict and aggression, but each outcome needs to be studied separately.

Rosner: Yes. Or if people are sufficiently fucked up socially, there may be fewer relationships available to break up in the first place.

Jacobsen: Right.

POTS and Autonomic Dysfunction

Rosner: Do you know about POTS, which involves posture-related extreme changes in heart rate?

Jacobsen: No.

Rosner: POTS is postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome. In adults, one core diagnostic feature is a sustained heart-rate increase of at least 30 beats per minute within 10 minutes of standing, without the blood-pressure fall that defines orthostatic hypotension, together with chronic orthostatic symptoms. It’s a form of autonomic dysfunction.

Extreme Heat and Student Learning

Jacobsen: One thing I wanted to point out: I found the study material on the main American Psychological Association site. They recently published a report saying rising temperatures are making it harder for students to learn and that many schools aren’t prepared for what that means.

The APA and its Network for Resilient PK-12 Schools in Extreme Climates reviewed evidence on how extreme heat affects students’ health, development, and ability to learn. They cite an optimal classroom range of roughly 68 to 73.4 degrees Fahrenheit, or 20 to 23 Celsius, and report that temperatures above that range can reduce speed and accuracy on cognitive tasks.

This is in schools, and those aren’t extreme temperatures. Once classrooms get hotter, measurable cognitive effects emerge. Other work has found lower academic performance on hot school days, while air conditioning mitigates some of the effect.

I propose that other aspects of human society probably show related effects, although adults aren’t simply immune because they have more developed prefrontal cortices. Adults also experience cognitive and physiological heat stress. The size and character of the effect can differ with age, health, acclimatization, hydration, cooling, and other factors.

Excessive heat may impair a broader range of human activities requiring attention, inhibition, decision-making, and emotion regulation. That’s a reasonable hypothesis, and parts of it are already supported, but we’d want evidence for each specific outcome.

David Letterman and the Cold Studio

Rosner: So David Letterman. Do you know about him and temperature? He kept the Ed Sullivan Theatre frickin’ cold, reportedly around 55 degrees Fahrenheit. That part is real. Letterman told Vanity Fair that he wanted it at 55 because if it were warmer, both he and the audience might become drowsy.

So that’s about 13 degrees Celsius, substantially colder than the classroom range you just mentioned. He believed a cold audience stayed alert and laughed better, and that warmth made people sluggish. The 55-degree temperature is well documented, although the claim that it actually improved laughter is Letterman’s production philosophy rather than a controlled scientific finding.

POTS, Women, and Diagnostic Delay

Anyway, POTS. Something like 80 to 85 percent of diagnosed POTS patients are women, particularly women of childbearing age.

It’s also a condition where patients have historically experienced significant diagnostic delay and misdiagnosis. Medicine didn’t recently discover POTS. The medical community has characterized the syndrome for decades. But awareness has been uneven, and studies show that patients, especially women, can have long diagnostic journeys and see multiple doctors before getting the diagnosis.

Your own doctor, particularly if they aren’t familiar with autonomic disorders, might not recognize it immediately, and you may end up seeing a specialist.

There’s a broader category of diseases and syndromes that are getting more attention now, including some that disproportionately affect women.

SIBO, IMO, and Gastrointestinal Symptoms

SIBO, small intestinal bacterial overgrowth, is another gastrointestinal condition, although I wouldn’t lump it into the same category as POTS or say it’s simply a women’s disease. It’s excessive microbial growth in the small intestine and can cause bloating, abdominal pain, nausea, diarrhea, constipation, and other gastrointestinal symptoms.

And the gas biology matters. Hydrogen-predominant SIBO is more often associated with diarrhea. Methane is strongly associated with constipation, but methane-positive cases are now more precisely called intestinal methanogen overgrowth, or IMO, because the methanogens aren’t bacteria and the overgrowth isn’t necessarily confined to the small intestine. Hydrogen sulphide has also been associated with diarrhea.

So, depending on the microbial ecology involved, you can get very different bowel symptoms, including constipation, diarrhea, bloating, and a lot of gas.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 34: Adam Carolla, X, U.S. Midterms, Canada, and Political Polarization

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/08/26

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner discuss Adam Carolla’s COVID-era rhetoric, his friendship with Jimmy Kimmel, political polarization on X, slowing U.S. job growth, the 2026 midterm elections, Mike Lindell’s fraud claims, and gasoline prices. They also compare Canadian and American political systems, measurement conventions, colonial legacies, road rules, and roundabouts, while reflecting on how disagreement, misinformation, humour, and institutional culture shape public life across both countries in contemporary democratic societies.

Adam Carolla, COVID, and X

Rick Rosner: So the other night, he put up a thing. He’s still mad about what California did during COVID, shutting down much of the economy for periods of time and later imposing or encouraging vaccination requirements in some settings. California did not literally require every resident to get vaccinated. Some workers, students, and people attending certain venues faced mandates or vaccination-or-testing requirements at different points.

He says, “If you still think that was appropriate, then you can eat a dick.”

I got annoyed to the point where I said, “Ooh, so oppressed that you had to get a shot that 5.6 billion people on Earth also got.” That’s roughly the number of people worldwide who had received at least one COVID vaccine dose by mid-2023, although obviously they weren’t all compelled to do it. About 5.1 billion had completed a primary series.

“You had to go a couple of months standing six feet away from the other shoppers at Trader Joe’s.”

To Carolla’s credit, he deleted the tweet. But his followers, the most common response was everybody telling me to eat a dick.

Even though he’d already told everybody who believes what I believe to eat a dick, they couldn’t come up with anything better.

I don’t know. I’m not disheartened about Carolla because Carolla has his venue, which is his podcast, and he knows his audience. But I’m disheartened about X in general, because you were talking about the other bouncer and how he feels about Jews. Obviously not all of X feels that way about Jews. Still, there is a substantial amount of antisemitic content on the platform, including accounts that traffic in extreme conspiracy theories and sometimes violent rhetoric.

And it’s tolerated to a degree that bothers me. But we’ve talked about that before. So I don’t know.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: What else should we talk about?

Carolla and Jimmy Kimmel

Rosner: Well, one more thing about Carolla. Carolla, when asked about Jimmy, Carolla says they’re still good friends, and Jimmy would agree.

I went to the Jimmy Kimmel Live! 20th-anniversary celebration of 20 years on the air, and Kimmel made a great joke. He said, “And Adam Carolla is here. Adam is missing a Proud Boys meeting to be here.”

Jacobsen: Thank you for your sacrifice, Adam.

Rosner: I could see a whole series of… No, because he had a lot of people to thank, but that was just fricking great.

So they’re still friends. And that’s consistent with how they’ve described their relationship publicly. They have significant political differences but have remained close friends for decades. Kimmel even gave Carolla an emotional tribute at Carolla’s Hollywood Walk of Fame ceremony in May 2026.

Jacobsen: People can differ vociferously, tell mean jokes, and still get along when it’s done in the right spirit.

Rosner: Yes. Up to a point. Adam’s extremely smart. Jimmy’s extremely smart. Maybe people who are good at separating political disagreement from personal relationships can do that.

But a lot of dumb shits in MAGA, lunatics on the far left, and dumb shits throughout the political spectrum have a harder time just getting along.

And apparently, according to Lance, Carolla says when asked about Jimmy, “I’m sure Jimmy has good reasons for believing what he believes,” which is that Jimmy’s a smart guy and he’s got his reasons.

That seems to me like a very kind, non-escalatory way to be. Maybe not on X, where you’ve got to be a motherfucker.

The Midterms and the Employment Picture

What else? There are 70-ish days until the November 3 midterms.

Trump and members of his administration continue to make false or misleading political claims. One area where the rhetoric doesn’t match the data particularly well is employment.

U.S. job creation has slowed dramatically. In 2024, payroll employment increased by about 166,000 jobs per month on average. Revised BLS data show that payroll employment increased by only about 15,000 per month on average during 2025. Over the 12 months ending in July 2026, the average monthly gain was about 34,000, and payrolls actually fell by 23,000 in July. So depending on which periods you’re comparing, job growth is roughly 80 to 90 percent lower than the 2024 monthly pace.

But I wouldn’t say that’s “thanks to tariffs, thanks to AI.” Tariffs, automation, federal employment cuts, business uncertainty, interest rates, productivity changes, and other economic forces can all affect hiring. Pinning the entire slowdown on two causes is too simple.

Yet between Trump, White House accounts, and his media representatives, I’ve seen repeated claims that job creation is booming, or that virtually no jobs were created under Biden and enormous numbers are being created under Trump. The payroll data doesn’t support that.

There certainly were individual announcements of factories or projects involving hundreds or thousands of jobs, and any administration will take credit for those. But that’s different from the national employment picture.

The unemployment rate is still relatively low, at 4.1 percent in July 2026. The labour-force participation rate is 61.4 percent.

That group includes retirees, students, people caring for family members, people with disabilities or illnesses, and others who aren’t seeking employment. In July, about 5.9 million people outside the labour force said they wanted a job, and only about 476,000 were classified specifically as discouraged workers.

So anyway, there’s a lot of political bullshitting about the economy.

The thing I wonder about every day, and probably wonder about too much because I can’t do jack shit about it, is: are people going to buy the bullshit?

House and Senate Control

The Democrats have a plausible path to taking the House, but saying they’re definitely going to take it is too strong this far out. As of August 13, Cook Political Report had 184 seats rated Solid Democratic, 21 more Likely or Lean Democratic, 182 Solid Republican, 29 Likely or Lean Republican, and 19 toss-ups. So the House is highly competitive.

Can they take the Senate? That’s harder, but the map has become more competitive. Democrats need a net gain of four seats for outright control, and Cook now has traditionally Republican states including Texas and Iowa in the toss-up category. So Senate control is genuinely in play, but it’s far from guaranteed.

And whatever happens, I expect Trump will claim fraud if the results go badly for him or his party, because he’s repeatedly made unsupported election-fraud claims before.

Mike Lindell and Election-Fraud Rhetoric

Mike Lindell, the MyPillow guy, is another example. He has publicly discussed his history of cocaine and crack addiction and subsequent recovery. But there’s no factual basis for me to diagnose him with “residual brain damage” or insanity.

He ran for the Republican nomination for governor of Minnesota this year. On August 11, 2026, he lost the GOP primary to Minnesota House Speaker Lisa Demuth, 43.5 percent to 32.5 percent, an 11-point margin. He’s now funding a hand recount and audit while alleging irregularities in electronic reporting. So it’s more accurate to say he lost a Republican primary and is challenging aspects of the result, not that he lost a gubernatorial general election and refuses to concede.

There’s going to be a shit ton of election-fraud rhetoric.

But I’m not saying anything I haven’t said a million times before.

Gas Prices and Canada

The national average price of regular gas is now about $4.11 a gallon. AAA had it at $4.1092 on August 21, after the average had risen to about $4.10 during the week. It’s above $4, but I want to confirm the exact daily series before claiming today is precisely “day 110” above that threshold.

That would be something like five Canadian dollars per U.S. gallon after currency conversion. Still, of course, Canada sells gasoline by the litre, so that’s not how Canadians actually experience the price.

I don’t know what you pay. Well, you haven’t been back to Canada in months and months, so I don’t know what they’re paying there.

Jacobsen: Oh, widespread famine, wildfires, COVID rampant, child marriage has been reinstituted, women are no longer allowed education beyond Grade 6—the Taliban.

It’s been complete chaos in Canada under Carney. I’ve been gone for months. What are we going to do?

Rosner: Yes. So you guys buy gas by the gallon in Canada, right? You’re not that European with your measurements, are you?

Canada’s Constitutional System

Jacobsen: First of all, Canada is no longer a British colony. Canada is an independent sovereign state, but we inherited the Westminster system and remain a constitutional monarchy. King Charles III is separately King of Canada and Canada’s head of state, and the governor general represents the King federally. We’re simultaneously a federal state and a parliamentary democracy.

So we have that British constitutional inheritance without being politically subordinate to Britain. Executive authority is formally vested in the Crown, but in practice the prime minister and Cabinet exercise it under responsible government.

It’s a complicated system, but it seems fine.

Rosner: It hasn’t broken down the way the U.S. system sometimes seems to. It tends to work.

Jacobsen: People love the royal weddings, and things haven’t totally fallen apart. But we also have a cultural flavour you don’t.

Rosner: And vice versa, to be courteous and not insane. You are… When U.S. comedians and even Canadian comedians… Go ahead.

Canada’s Mixed Measurement System

Jacobsen: From that legacy, we use litres. You use gallons. Canada officially uses the metric system for retail gasoline, so gas is sold by the litre. But there’s a joke in which somebody asks, “Which measurement system do Canadians use?” and the Canadian says, “All of them.” Then there’s a guy snorting a line of cocaine.

It’s litres, inches, feet, pounds, kilograms, metres, kilometres, Celsius, and occasionally Fahrenheit, depending on what you’re talking about. That’s generally how it feels as a Canadian. I could do the conversions in my head forever and tell you what they were, but when I was younger, I didn’t necessarily know which units belonged to the imperial system and which were metric. Canadian law specifically requires metric measurement for retail gasoline sales.

Rosner: That makes sense.

Jacobsen: That’s partly the result of Canada’s historical British inheritance, official metrication, and enormous cultural and economic exposure to the United States.

Rosner: Yes. Even in Britain, road signs use miles per hour, which is confusing. At least, probably not to them, but it was confusing to me.

Colonial History and Cultural Influence

Jacobsen: Yes. We should be clear here. Modern Canada emerged from both French and British colonial regimes, on lands inhabited by diverse First Nations, Inuit, and Métis peoples whose histories long predate either colonial power. So saying Canada is “mostly an English colony with some French and Indigenous culture seeping in” would flatten that history too much.

Then there’s the enormous contemporary American cultural influence. We love your media. We do. All of these things came in and mixed in different ways. Regional patterns differ too. Quebec and parts of eastern Canada retain much stronger Francophone traditions, while western Canada often has particularly strong historical and cultural ties to Britain and the United States.

Driving and Roundabouts

Rosner: What side of the road do you guys drive on?

Jacobsen: On the right.

Rosner: Like we do. Yes. All right.

Jacobsen: And that’s nationwide. You don’t start driving on the left as you travel farther east. Canada has national and provincial traffic standards. I don’t want to make the measurement-system confusion sound like traffic rules are similarly improvised.

Rosner: Do you have roundabouts? Do you have a ton of roundabouts?

Jacobsen: We have roundabouts. They’re here in Kyiv too.

Rosner: Yes. Everybody has them. America has historically used fewer roundabouts than many European countries, although they’ve become substantially more common in the U.S.

Jacobsen: They’re a great invention. Multi-lane roundabouts can be confusing if drivers aren’t accustomed to them, but properly designed roundabouts are generally associated with fewer severe crashes than conventional signalized intersections. So saying they would inherently be more dangerous in an American context isn’t right.

And I was going to make a joke about Americans drinking, but Brits drink too, so that’s not fair.

Rosner: Oh, I see. Yes. All right.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 33: AI and LLM Capabilities Change

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/08/25

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner discuss how AI systems have narrowed gaps in breadth, retrieval, and conversational usefulness while still struggling with calibration, personalization, reliability, and obscure information. Rosner reflects on search-enabled AI, credit-card fraud research, traffic-camera questions, and adaptive responses. Jacobsen emphasizes domain-specific expertise calibration and memory. They also compare high-IQ testing histories, public reputations, and the risks of misinformation and extremist rhetoric in public discourse.

Closing Gaps in AI Output

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: What gaps in AI output, particularly LLMs, are you noticing now compared with three years ago? What gaps have you seen close?

Rick Rosner: The expectation now is that, for almost any question you can come up with, AI can give you a fairly satisfying answer. That’s different from two or three years ago.

Credit-Card Fraud and AI-Assisted Information Retrieval

I had trouble with a credit card that was repeatedly hit by fraudulent charges, so we closed the account. With a U.S. credit card, your liability for genuinely unauthorized use is limited by federal law. If somebody steals only your account number and uses it without authorization, you generally have no liability. If the physical card itself is lost or stolen, federal liability can be as much as $50 for unauthorized charges made before you notify the issuer, although many issuers provide zero-liability protection.

Our card was locked up in a lockbox in a locked room. Somebody apparently obtained the card information and repeatedly used the account fraudulently, to the point where we cancelled the fucking card.

But the bank that issued the card was giving us shitty customer service. After an hour on the phone, I asked AI, “This bank has shitty customer service about credit-card fraud, right?” And it said, “Yes, there are complaints about that, although other customers report that the bank handled their cases well.”

The fact that I could ask that question and reasonably expect an answer is different from a few years ago. That’s not even an especially obscure question. The idea is that you can ask about an enormous range of publicly documented events, and an AI system with web access may be able to find relevant information.

That’s different from saying AI automatically knows about every event that ever became public. Models can have incomplete training data, outdated knowledge, weak retrieval, missing sources, inaccessible databases, or get things wrong.

Speed Cameras and Current Public Information

One of Carole’s friends got a red-light-camera ticket, so I asked all sorts of questions about it. Then Los Angeles started preparing to deploy speed cameras on certain streets.

I tend to go a little fast in a lot of places, and I don’t want to get a ticket. So I asked, “Where are the speed cameras going to be? When do they start working? When do citations become enforceable?”

Los Angeles is launching a Speed Safety Systems pilot in late summer or fall 2026. LADOT has published information about the program and its camera locations, so an AI with current web access can retrieve that.

It knew the publicly available stuff. I expected it to know the publicly available stuff.

The Breadth and Limits of AI Knowledge

I’m trying to come up with something sufficiently obscure to be surprising. You can ask about a huge number of actors in productions over the past 50 years and often get a ton of information.

But “AI knows every knowable thing” is too strong. Current AI systems do not contain every fact, and they don’t have reliable access to every database, private record, obscure publication, or newly occurring event. Even when the information is somewhere in the training data or available online, the model may fail to retrieve or reproduce it accurately.

Sometimes an AI will also refuse to answer certain questions because of safety rules or other restrictions. Politically loaded questions aren’t necessarily refused, but systems may be designed to avoid partisan persuasion or unsupported political claims. They also won’t provide dangerous instructions, such as detailed guidance for building an explosive.

So my answer remains that what’s impressive is how broad the accessible information space has become. An AI connected to search can reach a huge fraction of what has been publicly documented, even if “just about anything that could be known” overstates it.

If I asked it to give me 25,000 words on you, it might generate 25,000 words. But length isn’t evidence of knowledge. Some of that could be repetitive, speculative, or completely fabricated unless it had enough reliable source material.

Is that surprising? I don’t fucking know.

What gaps do you notice? I don’t work extensively with LLMs; I mainly ask Google AI questions. What gaps do you see?

Calibrating AI to User Expertise

Jacobsen: One gap is automated calibration to the user’s prior knowledge, especially their domain-specific expertise and level of engagement.

The ideal system would infer, from a user’s history and the immediate context, roughly how sophisticated an explanation should be and automatically adjust the language, assumptions, technical detail, and background information.

So you wouldn’t constantly have to say, “Dial it up because I’m already an expert in this,” or, “Dial it down because I’m a beginner.”

Current systems can personalize when they have access to conversational context, saved preferences, or other user-specific information. But finely calibrated, reliable adaptation to a person’s expertise across different domains is still incomplete. For example, someone can be an expert in psychometrics and a novice in particle physics. A good system has to distinguish those rather than assigning one global level of sophistication to the person.

Personalization as an Unsolved Problem

Rosner: So you’re saying that’s still a gap? Are you not seeing it fully solved yet?

Jacobsen: I’m not seeing that consistently yet, but these systems clearly have some capacity for it because they can retain or reference user-specific context when memory features are enabled. They can use saved memories, chat history, custom instructions, and other context to personalize responses. That doesn’t mean every system keeps a complete record of everything a user has ever done, or that it automatically builds a precise expertise profile for every domain.

But if a system has enough of your interaction history and can analyze it, it could tailor the experience in a way that improves usability. It’s small, but even a modest usability improvement, multiplied across hundreds of millions of users, would be substantial. I wouldn’t put a precise “one billion monthly users” figure on it without tying that to a specific product and date.

So that could be.

Associative Personalization

Rosner: Sure. I’ve seen AI tailor itself to me, not necessarily in the sense that I might use longer words than somebody with a fourth-grade education, but it definitely reflects to me what I give it. With a lot of prompts, it comes back with reasonable associations or related details that it thinks I might appreciate.

If I write to it about John Brunner’s 1968 novel Stand on Zanzibar, for instance, it might bring up another of Brunner’s best-known novels, The Sheep Look Up, from 1972.

Jacobsen: Yes, right.

Malcolm Gladwell, Christopher Langan, and the Other Bouncer

Rosner: And I assume I embarrassed myself slightly in front of Malcolm Gladwell. He wrote about Christopher Langan in Outliers, including Langan’s unusual intellectual history and his work as a bouncer.

Gladwell was on Kimmel, and I came up to him and said, “I’m the other bouncer with the high IQ.”

He said, “What?”

Because I assumed, how could you know about Langan and not know about me, since we’re basically the same fucking person? And I’m like, forget it. I didn’t want to go into the whole thing. It would have looked weird.

High-Range IQ Testing

Jacobsen: It’s funny because Langan and you both became prominent in the high-range IQ-test subculture, but you have to state the exact score history carefully.

You scored 44 out of 48 on Ronald Hoeflin’s Mega Test in 1985, later scored 47 on another attempt, and received the only reported perfect 48 out of 48 on Hoeflin’s Titan Test before the test was compromised. Hoeflin historically assigned those scores extremely high IQ estimates. Although later psychometric analysis has argued that the official IQ conversions were inflated.

Langan’s score history is messier. He is widely reported as having scored 42 out of 48 on an initial Mega Test attempt and 47 out of 48 later.

So on Hoeflin’s tests, you had exceptionally high scores, including the perfect Titan score. But saying you were definitively better then tied in overall intelligence would go beyond what those tests can establish.

Conspiracy Rhetoric, Fraud Claims, and Community Responsibility

There’s another major difference now. Langan has made increasingly grandiose, resentful, conspiratorial, demonological, and white genocide theory-based claims against “Big Jew Inc.,” “Ziobanksters,” etc. It’s a real achievement to do that unabashedly and to inspire further copycats in well-known and thoroughly investigated frauds like YoungHoon Kim who worked for him as his Senior Membership Officer with overlaps in highest IQ claims, simulation theory, Christian theology, Jesus exaltation, self-aggrandizement, Intelligent Design community creationism/rejection of naturalistic evolution alone, and messianic statements. Langan became the template for Kim. He witnessed the inner circle and things from the inside.

Although, many in the Christian communities in the high-IQ communities plus Christian media are the primary culprits in bringing them unquestioned modest prominence, then backing away from the mess created. So, if one inspires hate rhetoric, conspiracy theories, and prejudice while the other continues to lie, defame, and scam people, then they have primary responsibility in propping them up – not the specific rhetoric or actions, but I do not expect any or much accountability – which is typical.

Analogously, I’ve seen the reportage and spoken with experts on Christian community cross-denominational reactions to clergy-perpetrated abuse: The broad, consistent finding is defaming truth-tellers, blaming victims, denying the reality, and delaying justice. I suspect the same long-term pattern here, as we have already seen for years now. It’s a similar unfortunate pattern running from the far more prominent cases like Jim Bakker, Ravi Zacharias, Bill Hybels, Jean Vanier, Marcial Maciel, Peter Popoff, and others.

The Little Jewish Comedy Writer Who Could

You, by contrast, are the little Jewish comedy writer who could. Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 32: Artificial Intelligence and New Theories

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/08/24

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner discuss whether artificial intelligence can derive genuinely novel insights from learned representations rather than merely retrieve stored knowledge. They compare tacit human understanding with neural-network pattern learning, examining multimodal models, mathematical discovery, interpretability, and implicit structure. Rosner argues that AI may encode useful relationships humans have not yet articulated, while Jacobsen emphasizes differences between machine representations and embodied human learning through direct physical and social experience.

AI and the Possibility of New Knowledge

Rick Rosner: I asked AI, “Is the universe made of information?” It offered points for and against. Google AI. I didn’t ask every AI.

I’m sure more sophisticated systems could offer broader takes, but the interesting possibility is that AI systems could contribute to the next successful theory of the universe. That doesn’t mean the theory is already secretly sitting intact somewhere inside an AI. Current models generate and recombine patterns learned from their training data, and they can sometimes derive things that weren’t explicitly stated in the data. Still, they also generate wrong, inconsistent, or completely invented answers.

So an AI could conceivably help physicists find a future theory, perhaps by spotting mathematical relationships, suggesting hypotheses, searching huge spaces of possibilities, or connecting pieces of existing knowledge that humans haven’t connected yet.

Still, something weird and interesting is at play. A sufficiently capable model might contain internal representations that support conclusions nobody has explicitly asked it to produce yet. If somebody asks the right question, or develops the right method for probing those representations, the model could potentially generate a novel and useful inference.

Is that a reasonable angle on this shit? That AI may have the capacity to derive a fuck ton of stuff that isn’t just rote knowledge, if somebody asks it the right questions? It isn’t the same as simply looking something up. You can generalize from the information and statistical structure learned during training.

Digital Representation and Human Learning

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: And it’s polished language formulated into text, but I wouldn’t call the text absolute because it’s based on binary code. Everything running on an ordinary digital computer is ultimately represented digitally, but that doesn’t make the information itself absolute or certain.
A language model is trained on patterns in data and learns numerical representations and relationships that allow it to predict and generate language, with multimodal models that can also include relationships involving images, audio, video, and other inputs.
It’s a different kind of thing from a human organism learning through continuous interaction with the physical and social environment. It’s part of what we do in the sense that language is one of our major cultural products, and AI systems are heavily trained on those products.
But you can’t infer the entire human process that produced those cultural products just by studying the products themselves. It’s neural-network manipulation and representation of those products, with increasingly sophisticated abilities to generalize from them.

Novel Insight and Mathematical Analogy

That’s not to say you can’t get novel insights from it. Humans also work with accumulated intellectual products when doing mathematics. Mathematicians manipulate symbols and concepts inherited from other mathematicians and discover new correspondences, consistencies, regularities, theorems, and laws.
So LLMs aren’t doing nothing. They’re doing quite a bit. But how we do it and how they do it are different, with some areas of functional overlap.
That’s a first.

Tacit Human Knowledge

Rosner: We know a lot of stuff without knowing that we know it. We don’t walk into walls, generally. There’s a lot of shit we don’t do because we have all sorts of understandings about the world that we’ve never expressed to ourselves through internal talk. As we move through the world and interact with it, our behaviour reflects a deep, practical understanding of how our surroundings work, and much of that knowledge isn’t explicitly verbalized.

In the future, AI will probably become increasingly capable of producing what looks to us like insight. Some of that will come from representations learned from enormous datasets rather than from rules explicitly programmed by humans.

Implicit Knowledge in Multimodal AI

Look at image-generation and multimodal systems. They learn statistical regularities involving what flesh looks like, how skin folds, how shadows behave, perspective, depth cues, lighting, texture, and the apparent geometry of three-dimensional objects. Engineers don’t manually program every one of those visual rules. The systems learn representations through training on large collections of images, image-text pairs, video, or related data, depending on the model.

Modern vision-language systems explicitly combine learned visual representations with language models.

That doesn’t necessarily mean the model possesses a human-like concept of three-dimensional space. A system can reproduce or predict many consequences of spatial structure without representing space exactly the way a person does.

So it’s a tantalizing situation: an AI can encode a ton of regularities it cannot necessarily state explicitly, and humans haven’t been clever enough to probe them in the right way.

Probing Learned Representations

You could probably develop methods that ask an AI to examine its own learned representations and make some implicit structure more explicit. Researchers already do versions of this through interpretability, representation analysis, probing, and mechanistic analysis. However, we are nowhere near being able to ask a model to explain everything it has learned about itself.
There might be a big business in that: using AI to analyze learned representations and identify useful patterns that haven’t previously been articulated.

Expertise, Tacit Skill, and AI

Lance knows a ton of shit about rendering flesh and human bodies. If you sat Lance down and grilled him, you could make some of that implicit knowledge explicit. Some of his knowledge is already explicit, but much expert skill is tacit. By asking enough good questions, you can sometimes get an expert to articulate rules he normally applies without consciously stating them.

You could probably do something analogous with AI, although extracting information from a neural network is very different from interviewing a human expert.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 31: AI, Education, Einstein, Gamow, and Mathematical Intuition

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/08/23

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner discuss whether mathematical intuition or formal math skills matter more in modern life. Rosner examines South Korea’s education culture, AI-assisted computation, elite university STEM trends, and the value of recognizing bad outputs. He also reflects on Einstein and Marcel Grossmann, George Gamow, Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium, and why imagination, collaboration, practical knowledge, and mathematical intuition may become increasingly important as AI handles more technical work in everyday society.

Math Sense, Math Skills, and South Korean Education

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: What’s more important to get through life in most societies? A good math sense or good math skills?

Rick Rosner: It depends on the society. For instance, I’ve been watching a show called Get Schooled from South Korea.

We know that South Korea has an intensely competitive education system, right? There’s enormous pressure surrounding academic performance and the College Scholastic Ability Test, or CSAT, which plays an important role in university admissions. There’s also a huge private tutoring industry, including hagwons.

It’s a whole thing. Get Schooled is a South Korean webtoon about abuses within the education system involving parents, teachers, students, and others. In the story, the government creates an Education Rights Protection Bureau, whose agents intervene in troubled schools. It’s fictional, not a depiction of an actual South Korean government bureau.

It’s a different type of culprit in different story arcs, but the agent finds the bad people and fucks them up.

The “Fellow Kids” Meme and the Undercover-Student Story

Jacobsen: Hello, kids. For those who don’t know, there’s a funny Steve Buscemi scene with a hat on backwards and a skateboard. He’s an undercover student, way, way too old. There’s this meme, “How do you do, fellow kids?” That’s Steve Buscemi. So he looks even older and weirder.

Rosner: And he’s wearing a band shirt, but the shirt says “Music Band.” What’s weird is, two hours ago, it popped up on my Twitter feed. Carole was in the room.

I go, “Hey, look, that’s me in high school,” because I was a way-too-old undercover student.

Jacobsen: You were. I don’t know when the Steve Buscemi thing was, but I’m pretty sure it was after the Rick Rosner literal undercover-cop student. Then you’re getting over that.

I had quite a few. Because you had the physics equation on that plane, the crop plane. Then you met Carole at your other thing, going to a Jewish singles dance. And then you two met.

Carole and Rosner’s Eccentricities

Rosner: And then I decided Carole was worth being with, because she went along with me on this stupid idea of pretending to be in high school.

Jacobsen: It’s your greatest strength and your greatest weakness, your honesty. You go too far sometimes. But when it came to something as serious as being an undercover student for your own reasons, you telling her this and her being tolerant was a good thing, because you found someone who would be willing to tolerate your eccentricities.

Rosner: Yes, right. We’ve talked about it recently, this past week. She attributed it mostly to her being dumb and naive. She hadn’t had that many…

Jacobsen: She’s not a dumb person. She is not a naive person.

Rosner: Yes. But in this instance, she hadn’t had that many boyfriends. She went along with this thing.

Screenplay Ideas and the Proactive Heroine

It seemed harmless, right? I want to write a screenplay with her where a guy like me, but even worse, gets her involved because of her naivete. That’s the setup to several movies where a bad boyfriend drags an innocent woman into a bad drug situation. But in the screenplay, I envision the girl may be naive, but she’s seen a ton of movies and TV shows.

So when it comes to the point where they’re in the bad couple’s apartment, and some dire shit is about to go down, instead of waiting for it to become dire, Carole just shoots the guy. The dumb boyfriend is, “What? Why did you shoot the guy?”

And she goes, “You knew where that was going.” She shoots the guy. She holds the bad guy’s female partner at gunpoint, maybe ties her up, maybe pistol-whips her, and saves the dumb boyfriend without waiting for the usual mechanics we’ve all seen, the increasing tension in the scene and the narrow escape. Instead, this naive but not stupid young woman is, “Fuck this. I see what this is. I’m just going to shoot him right now.”

We also have another screenplay that works the same way, unofficially titled, working-titled, because we haven’t written it and I want to, Carole the Office Assistant, where you have a character who’s proactive with her violence because she’s not going to wait for the shit to play out. She’s seen it 50 times in a movie.

She’s going to shoot somebody before they can shoot her, which would be fun. It would move faster. But anyway, back to South Korea.

Mathematics, Elite Education, and AI

South Korea is math-heavy. China is math-heavy. Surprisingly, the U.S. is freaking math-heavy too, particularly at highly selective universities. At Harvard, for example, just over half of the undergraduate degrees awarded in the 2024-25 academic year were in engineering, applied sciences, or science. You can’t generalize that exact percentage to every Ivy League university, though. Yale’s recent figures, for example, put STEM at roughly a third to somewhat under 40 percent of bachelor’s degrees. So the idea that these universities are mostly people studying some useless political bullshit is wrong. Huge numbers of students are doing science, engineering, computer science, mathematics, and other quantitative work.

Five years ago, say, I’d have said actual mathematical knowledge might be more important. But now AI is coming in and can do a lot of the computational and coding work. I would shift some emphasis back toward having an intuitive understanding of math, because you can use AI to help with calculations and formal work. You still need enough knowledge to recognize when the AI is bullshitting you.

I didn’t have to figure out all the math of the fucking golf balls lipping out. I could say, “Hey, AI, describe the physics of a golf ball lipping out.” You’re almost falling asleep.

But anyway, it’s better to have both, right, up to a point. You should have basic math knowledge and as much advanced math knowledge as is useful to you. Advanced mathematics doesn’t inherently stifle imagination. For some people, it gives them more ways to express it.

Einstein, Grossmann, and Mathematical Collaboration

A major example is Einstein developing general relativity. He was a brilliant physicist, but he needed mathematical machinery he hadn’t previously mastered. He first arrived at the key physical insight behind general relativity in 1907 and completed the theory in 1915, so the development took about eight years rather than 10.

And what he had was a mathematically sophisticated friend, Marcel Grossmann. This wasn’t in Vienna, and it wasn’t during the final stages while Einstein was working at the Swiss Patent Office in Bern. By 1912, Einstein was back at ETH Zurich as a professor, and Grossmann was a mathematician there. Grossmann introduced him to differential geometry and tensor calculus, including the work of Riemann, Ricci, and Levi-Civita, which became essential to general relativity.

Grossmann didn’t suddenly hand Einstein a four-by-four matrix with 10 numbers and expect everything to work. The metric tensor in four-dimensional spacetime can indeed be represented as a symmetric four-by-four array with 10 independent components. Still, the mathematics involves tensor calculus, differential geometry, curvature tensors, and differential equations. Einstein and Grossmann actually explored some of the right mathematical machinery in 1912 and 1913, moved away from part of it, and Einstein returned to the crucial formulation in 1915.

So it’s important to have mathy friends.

George Gamow: Intuition, Collaboration, and Excess

Frickin’ Big Bang guy, George Gamow. He wasn’t terrible at math. You couldn’t make his contributions to quantum tunnelling, nuclear physics, cosmology, and Big Bang nucleosynthesis if you were mathematically incompetent. But he was famously intuitive and imaginative, and he sometimes relied on collaborators who were stronger in particular areas of mathematical calculation.

He joined the University of Colorado Boulder in 1956. There’s a physics tower there named Gamow Tower. He collaborated with people who could work out the mathematical details of ideas that interested him.

He was a party guy. He was a drinky guy. He had a good time. He was a heavy drinker, and accounts of his later life say alcohol damaged his health and professional effectiveness. He died in 1968 at 64 after serious health problems, including liver failure. So it’s reasonable to say his drinking may have contributed to his early death, but you can’t reduce the cause of death simply to drinking.

While he lived, though, he was extraordinarily imaginative and fun. Plenty of stories and photographs reflect that side of him.

He started in the Soviet Union as a young man and then got the fuck out. Meanwhile, he had fun even under a repressive regime. Yes.

Hardy-Weinberg Equilibrium

What else? There’s also the Hardy-Weinberg equation in population genetics. Reginald Punnett, the geneticist, went to G. H. Hardy, one of the most famous mathematicians of the early 20th century, with a question about Mendelian inheritance in populations. Punnett wanted to understand why, under random mating, a dominant allele wouldn’t simply drive a recessive allele out of the population.

Hardy basically said, “Well, that’s simple.” If the frequencies of two alleles are (p) and (q), with (p+q=1), then under the standard Hardy-Weinberg assumptions the genotype frequencies after random mating are (p^2), (2pq), and (q^2). If the two alleles each happen to have a frequency of one-half, then the frequencies are one-quarter, one-half, and one-quarter.

Punnett later associated Hardy’s name with the result. Independently, the German physician Wilhelm Weinberg had derived essentially the same principle earlier in 1908, which is why we now call it Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium. It isn’t an equation of heritability. It’s a population-genetics model describing the relationship between allele and genotype frequencies under specified assumptions.

Hardy described the point as very simple and said he expected biologists to find it familiar. The later description of Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium as a result of “embarrassing simplicity” comes from historians of genetics, so saying Hardy himself was pissed off or embarrassed by having his name attached to it goes beyond what we can establish.

Mathematical Intuition and the Future of AI

Anyway, better to have mathematical intuition tempered with some actual mathematical knowledge. The best way is to live 10 or 20 years from now, and maybe you’ll have some brain-computer interface that links you to whatever mathematics you need through AI. Whether anything remotely that capable exists on that timetable is anybody’s guess. The early versions will probably be shitty.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 30: USPS Election Mail, Golf Lip-Out Physics, and Basketball Math

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/08/22

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner discuss concerns about U.S. Postal Service reliability ahead of the midterm elections, drawing comparisons with disruptions during 2020. Rosner then shifts to the physics of golf lip-outs, explaining speed, spin, centripetal acceleration, rim interactions, and rare hole lip-outs. He also examines basketball geometry, comparing NBA and WNBA ball diameters with the standard 18-inch hoop and considering what those measurements reveal about the mathematics of sporting outcomes.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: With the midterm elections approaching, what are you noticing about the reliability of the mail? Also, what have you been thinking about regarding mathematics and physics hidden in everyday events?

Rick Rosner: 72 days until the midterms. In 2020, with Trump as president and Louis DeJoy as postmaster general, plus COVID, the mail got bad, right? Trump was publicly hostile to expanded voting by mail, and there was a huge political fight over the Postal Service.

I got a lot of packages that had the shit beaten out of them, packages that went missing, had to be traced. A couple of packages had shit stolen from them, as they brought in temporary staff to replace shortages caused by COVID. The Postal Service, even though I love it, got sucky in 2020. There really were major service problems. COVID-related employee shortages, increased package volume, and operational changes at USPS all contributed to delays.

Now Trump’s president again, there’s another election, and the current postmaster general is David Steiner, whom the Postal Service’s Board of Governors selected in 2025. His appointment was controversial partly because he had been a FedEx board member. I received a package today that had the shit beaten out of it, crushed, possibly something crushed, torn open, maybe something missing from the package. It’s a Lego wall art piece, and according to the photos, it was supposed to include the instructions. The instructions aren’t there.

I have to write the seller to see if someone stole them from the box or if they fell out. My mail experience is shitty right now. If you’re voting by mail, vote early.

Maybe drop your ballot at a polling place or in an official drop box if that’s available where you live. I wouldn’t infer from one damaged package that election mail is generally unreliable, though. In fact, despite the broader Postal Service problems in 2020, USPS handled election mail considerably better than ordinary mail and reported very high rates of timely ballot delivery. Then he wanted something mathy.

I watch a little golf, which is embarrassing because it’s such a white boomer thing to do, but I’ll have it on in the background, or maybe even watch it openly if it’s interesting enough, which is lame. I had the BMW Championship on. Scottie Scheffler, currently the number one ranked golfer in the world, had a bad opening round Thursday, shooting a 72, before rebounding with a 65 on Friday. He has also had some nasty lip-outs recently. A lip-out is where the ball reaches the edge of the hole, rolls partly around the rim, and comes back out instead of dropping.

I looked into the physics, which isn’t that tough at a basic level, although the full mechanics get complicated. Whether the ball drops depends on things like its speed, how far its trajectory is offset from the centre of the hole, its spin, and how it interacts with the rim.

If you hit the hole nearly dead on and at a sufficiently low speed, the ball is likely to drop. But if you hit the edge of the hole fast enough, it may roll around the rim and come back out. The ball is being continually redirected as it follows the curved rim. Its centripetal acceleration points inward, toward the centre of that curved path, not outward. In a rotating frame, you can describe an apparent centrifugal effect pointing outward. Physically, the contact forces from the rim provide the inward acceleration needed to curve the ball’s trajectory.

The geometry of the hole and the ball, along with gravity, speed, spin, and the contact forces at the rim, determine whether the ball falls in or rolls back onto the green. Sometimes a ball can travel more than 180 degrees around the hole before coming back out. You can even get something approaching or exceeding a complete circuit, although “full bagel” appears to be informal terminology rather than a standard scientific term.

Scheffler has had putts do more than a half-circle before coming back out of the hole, which looks curious and perverse. The paper I read said that, in rare circumstances, you can even have the ball’s centre of mass descend below the level of the green and have the ball come back out without touching the bottom of the hole.

The research discusses two types. There’s a rim lip-out, where the centre of mass of the golf ball never drops below the level of the green, and a hole lip-out, where it does. In the hole lip-out, spin can allow the ball to descend into the cup, roll along the wall in a pendulum-like motion, and then climb back toward the rim. Potential energy, translational motion, and rotational motion exchange during the process. Under a narrow set of initial conditions, and provided the ball doesn’t hit the bottom, it can come back onto the green.

So you don’t need the simple picture of a ball smashing into the opposite wall and bouncing back out. The more interesting case is a rolling ball interacting with the hole’s cylindrical wall while carrying the right spin. The mechanics themselves can bring it back upward.

I bet most people have never seen a really deep hole lip-out. I don’t watch much golf, but the conditions required are pretty restrictive. A bunch of physics makes this stuff look perverse.

Ball spin in basketball and in golf looks just a little perverse. But when you think about it and look at it a little, it doesn’t have the full perversity of a gyroscope. It all makes sense.

It’s just weird to see. That was a mathy thing without much math at all. Let’s hear some more.

Here’s more additional math, basketball math. A basketball hoop is 18 inches in diameter. The size of an NBA ball is about 9.4 to 9.5 inches in diameter, based on its regulation circumference of 29.5 inches.

So you can’t quite fit two NBA basketballs side by side through a standard rim. However, the WNBA uses a smaller ball, with a regulation circumference of 28.5 inches, or about 9.1 inches in diameter. The smaller ball is intended in part to accommodate differences in average hand size.

So those balls are slightly more than nine inches across. Even two WNBA basketballs would be a little too wide to pass side by side through an 18-inch hoop without deformation. You’d probably never notice the difference between the NBA and WNBA balls unless you were told because the difference in diameter is only a few percent. It’s not that noticeable unless you watch a shitload of basketball.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 29: Aging, Air Quality, Antisemitism, and Everyday Priorities

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/08/20

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner discuss aging, climate preferences, indoor air quality, radon mitigation, air filtration, and the practicalities of later life. Rosner reflects on becoming more realistic with age, his experiences with antisemitism, and the persistence of Jewish conspiracy theories online. They also consider education, prejudice, moral advocacy, and everyday priorities, ending with lighter questions about choosing among household essentials such as refrigeration, toilets, dishwashers, and air conditioning in summer.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: So if you were looking at 25 years from now, given your current physical condition, rather than imagining yourself as an 85- or 90-plus-year-old Rick, would you rather live in a colder climate with heating or in a warmer climate with air conditioning?

Rick Rosner: I don’t know. I mean, each has pluses and minuses. The colder climate might be somewhat more healthful for me, but then you have the dangers of slips and falls. If I were in my 90s, I’d want firm footing. I’ve also had bad reactions to getting overheated lately. You can be uncomfortable either way.

Jacobsen: If someone lives in an old home, should they get an air filter?

Rosner: Yeah, I guess so. We have an air filter running all the time, and it’s probably better for us. I don’t know how much better.

We’re on quite a bit of bedrock. I mean, everybody is, but the geology where we live can produce elevated radon levels. We had radon levels on our first floor that were higher than the national average, at least before I sealed gaps in the flooring and installed a crawl-space fan.

Radon is a radioactive noble gas produced naturally through the decay of uranium in soil and rock. Colorado has widespread potential for elevated indoor radon. The important correction is that an ordinary air purifier or HEPA filter does not effectively remove radon gas itself. Radon mitigation normally involves preventing the gas from entering the home or venting it outdoors, including systems that depressurize the soil or crawl space beneath the building.

We run an air filter anyway, and we live in Los Angeles, where outdoor particulate pollution and wildfire smoke can also make indoor filtration useful. HEPA filtration can reduce airborne particulate matter, including smoke particles.

Jacobsen: Do you feel more realistic about life as you’ve gotten older?

Rosner: Yeah. I know more. I’ve experienced more stuff. I understand how things work better.

Jacobsen: What’s the worst type of antisemitism that someone you know has experienced?

Rosner: I don’t know. I don’t hang out with that many Jews. I’ve experienced people calling me out recently on X for being Jewish, where there’s a ton of antisemitism.

I had a Sunday school teacher, and this would have been more than 50 years ago, who said somebody shot him in the back while he was riding his bicycle. It was with a small-calibre pistol. It had to be something like a .22. He survived with no lasting damage, as far as I know.

Was he shot for being Jewish? I’m not sure he actually said. He told us the story in the context of Sunday school, so I assumed it implied antisemitism was involved. But beyond that, I don’t personally know people who’ve been beaten up for being Jewish.

I see a ton of antisemitism on social media now, and it’s disturbing.

Jacobsen: Do you think one reason so many moral heroes in the history of not only the United States, but internationally, have had Jewish backgrounds is an acute awareness of the larger problems of racism and prejudice?

Rosner: Yeah, maybe so. Yeah, I would say so.

Jacobsen: I mean, there’s a lot of stuff involving conspiracy theories about power and control, finance, so-called “global bankers,” NGOs, the Rothschilds and the Warburgs, and the idea of “white genocide.” There’s a whole range of conspiratorial pseudo-geopolitics, pseudopolitics, pseudoscience, and so on that keeps resurfacing.

And, yeah, many people with an acute ethical sensibility, sometimes informed by hard-won historical or personal experience, have had Jewish backgrounds, and their work gets quoted a lot. So it comes to mind.

Rosner: There are a lot of highly educated Jewish people. When you get educated, you learn about things, and then you speak out when you see shit in the world that comports with what you’ve learned.

On X, some people call themselves “noticers.” It’s an antisemitic trope. They point to the prominence of Jews in various professions and institutions and treat that as evidence of some coordinated Jewish power or conspiracy. You were talking about all these conspiracy theories, but contrary to these assholes, Jewish people, many of whom are highly educated and professionally accomplished, are often simply well qualified to address issues in the world and speak out about them.

Jacobsen: Would you rather live with only two of these three things: a dishwasher, a refrigerator, or a toilet?

Rosner: I’d do without the dishwasher. That’s easy.

Jacobsen: What about a toilet, refrigerator, or air conditioning in the summer?

Rosner: Again, you use a refrigerator and toilet more than you use air conditioning.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 28: Trump’s Second-Term Troubles, Iran War, Inflation, and the Constitutional Limits of a Third Term

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/08/19

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner discuss Donald Trump’s second-term economic and political difficulties, including inflation, gasoline prices, weakening employment, the Iran conflict, military deployments, and presidential rhetoric. They examine Trump 2028 messaging and the constitutional limits imposed by the Twenty-Second Amendment, alongside unresolved questions involving the Twelfth Amendment and presidential succession. They also distinguish lawful constitutional amendment from attempts to remain in power outside established democratic constitutional procedures.

Rick Rosner: So things are going really badly for Trump. He’s underwater in polling on several major issues, particularly inflation and the cost of living. Recent polling has put his overall approval well below his disapproval. He’s also got us involved in this war with Iran, and it isn’t working out particularly well.

Gas is roughly twice the below-$2-per-gallon price he promised during the campaign. The national average is now about $4.07 a gallon. There’s still inflation. The labour market has weakened considerably. In July, the economy actually lost 23,000 jobs, and previous estimates for May and June were revised downward by a combined 103,000 jobs.

It’s a terrible presidency, but Lance will never admit that Trump is wrong about anything. He’ll have all these belligerent, bullshitty arguments about how things are great and Trump is brilliant. And A, I don’t want to platform that shit. And B, I don’t want the frustration.

Lance is strong at this because he listens to a ton of conservative podcasts, maybe 50 or 60 hours a week. I don’t know. While he’s working on art, he listens to conservative content. So he knows all the arguments very well and can repeat them in his very forceful way. But as things go worse and worse for Trump, the arguments become more and more bullshitty.

Trump posts nonsense all the time. Over the past couple of days, for instance, he put up an AI-generated video of himself giving George Washington a tour of the new White House ballroom. He also keeps putting up Trump 2028 messaging, even though the 22nd Amendment prohibits him from being elected president a third time. Trump himself has now acknowledged that the law prevents another run, although he continues to promote Trump 2028 imagery.

His people say the country has become more affordable. Trump himself has repeatedly called concerns about affordability a “hoax.” That runs counter to what people are actually experiencing. Consumer prices were still rising at a 3.4% annual rate in July, while energy prices were up 14.7% from a year earlier. Grocery prices have also risen during his second term.

Gas is now a little over $4 a gallon nationally, compared with Trump’s campaign promise to get it below $2. Much of the recent increase in fuel prices has coincided with the conflict with Iran and disruptions to global oil supplies. The job market has weakened, too. He has failed to fulfill a lot of the promises he made to Americans while campaigning, and he’s handling these problems in a dickish way.

Then there’s the USS Abraham Lincoln, the aircraft carrier that has been deployed for more than 260 days and has spent more than 240 consecutive days at sea. Sailors and their families have reported food shortages, sanitation problems, serious exhaustion, and mental-health problems. Sailors have also attempted to jump overboard.

And Trump’s response, when asked whether the deployment had gone on too long, was that it was “not nearly long enough.” It’s an extraordinarily long deployment, especially given that the United States isn’t engaged in the kind of total war that would historically explain keeping a carrier at sea for that length of time. He’s lost almost any ability to speak about these things without sounding like a dick.

And then there was the episode involving Air Force One. During a trip to Turkey, amid intelligence about a credible Iranian threat against Trump, security officials reportedly used an Air Force One aircraft as a decoy while Trump secretly left the airport aboard another U.S. military aircraft. He was moved using an airport catering truck as part of the security operation. So it isn’t accurate to say that Trump himself grabbed a meal cart and snuck away on his own. It appears to have been an organized security maneuver in response to a credible threat.

None of this is good, but Lance will say it’s all great and evidence of Trump’s brilliance. I don’t want to platform bullshit or have to argue with belligerent bullshit for a couple of hours. As I said, the last time I did a show with Lance, I got so pissed that a couple of days later I got a light case of shingles.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: I am going to primary sources. Section 1 of the Twenty-Second Amendment to the U.S. Constitution states, “No person shall be elected to the office of the President more than twice.” The Amendment was ratified in 1951.

The Twelfth Amendment states that “no person constitutionally ineligible to the office of President shall be eligible to that of Vice-President of the United States.” There is, however, a genuine unresolved constitutional question about whether a person barred by the Twenty-Second Amendment from being elected president is thereby constitutionally ineligible to serve as vice president. The Constitution Annotated expressly identifies that question rather than treating it as definitively settled.

Then there is Article V of the U.S. Constitution. Congress, whenever two-thirds of both houses deem it necessary, may propose amendments to the Constitution. An amendment becomes part of the Constitution when ratified by the legislatures of three-fourths of the states, or by conventions in three-fourths of the states, depending on the method of ratification Congress specifies.

There is also the federal presidential-succession statute, 3 U.S.C. § 19. It provides for certain officers to act as president when the presidency and vice presidency are vacant, but those officers must satisfy the statute’s eligibility requirements.

Rosner: So Trump is constitutionally barred from being elected president again. Franklin D. Roosevelt was the first and only U.S. president elected to more than two terms. He was elected four times, and the Twenty-Second Amendment was ratified afterward, in 1951, limiting a person to being elected president twice.

Theoretical legal questions remain about whether a twice-elected president could reach the presidency through a route other than election, because the Twenty-Second Amendment expressly speaks in terms of being “elected.” But the Supreme Court has never resolved those questions. The Constitution Annotated notes uncertainty about whether a two-term president could serve as vice president or hold another office in the presidential line of succession.

Jacobsen: So that is the American constitutional position, with one qualification to make it precise. Within the existing constitutional order, Trump cannot simply run for and be elected to a third presidential term. If the Twenty-Second Amendment were repealed or altered through the Article V amendment process, that could change. Outside the constitutional order, if the legal and democratic structure of the United States itself were dismantled, you would no longer be discussing an ordinary constitutional third term. You would be discussing the breakdown or replacement of the constitutional system.

Rosner: And we’re not there. An attempt to remain president beyond the constitutionally prescribed term would face immediate legal challenges. Declaring a national emergency does not itself suspend presidential term limits or extend a president’s term. The Constitution provides a process for changing its provisions: the Article V amendment process.

That doesn’t mean Trump couldn’t campaign rhetorically for president in 2028, claim that he intends to challenge the constitutional restriction, or use that messaging to raise money. But saying that campaign contributions could “go right in his pocket” would be inaccurate. Federal law prohibits converting campaign funds to personal use.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 27: Vaccine Policy, Iran, Ukraine, and the Tate Brothers

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/08/18

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner discuss the U.S. measles resurgence, vaccine skepticism, food-safety concerns, alleged Iranian threats against Donald Trump, and the effectiveness of sanctions, cyber operations, and military force against authoritarian regimes. They also examine Ukraine’s use of drones and battlefield robotics against Russia before turning to Andrew and Tristan Tate, their alleged abuse and trafficking, pretrial detention, extradition prospects, and the likelihood of eventual prison sentences following criminal prosecution.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: What are the implications of the U.S. child vaccination schedule being reduced during a major measles resurgence?

Rick Rosner: We are pushing 3,000 cases of measles in the U.S., which is the highest number since around 1991. So it is bad. It is based on bullshit being pushed by R.F.K. Jr. and legions of fucking lunatics who believe that vaccines are bad, that they kill you, and that they cause autism, none of which is true.

The good thing about the measles epidemic is that it is only about 3,000 people, and measles directly kills well under 1 percent of the people who get it. So even though we have the highest number of measles cases in decades, the direct deaths from measles might only turn out to be half a dozen. That is tragic because those people did not have to die at all.

The bad thing is that measles fucks your immune system. People who get measles will not infrequently die of other shit within the next few years or develop debilitating conditions. It has ways to fuck your brain. So there will be hidden costs from the epidemic borne by hundreds of people who got measles during the current outbreaks.

But it is not just measles. Kennedy is dismantling the entire vaccination schedule, and this will lead to bad health outcomes for thousands of Americans over the next few years until we get decent people back into the presidency and the cabinet and put systems back in place.

Except those systems will be permanently fucked because tens of millions of American lunatics have now had their beliefs reinforced, their shitty beliefs that vaccines will give you autism or that they kill you at a high rate. Like MAGA supporters, they will not surrender these beliefs when more reasonable people are in charge.

That will lead to lower vaccination rates indefinitely into the future. It will lead to more disease, and cumulatively hundreds of thousands of Americans will be affected negatively. They will have shitty health. They will either get sick temporarily or be debilitated permanently because of this bullshit.

Jacobsen: What is this thing about giving people diarrhea in Michigan, Michigan in particular?

Rosner: I know that this Taylor Farms place, which distributes vegetables, keeps being implicated in outbreaks of disease from contaminated produce. They have been implicated six times and have managed to talk their way out of it.

The explanation I have heard is that they do not have porta-potties for agricultural workers who are picking the lettuce, so they just shit between the rows. You get human shit on lettuce, which contains pathogens, and it does not get cleaned off adequately.

Jacobsen: What about Israeli intelligence warnings about alleged Iranian assassination plots?

Rosner: Iran, they are bad guys. It is a bad regime. They are terrible for the world. They fund terrorism throughout the Middle East. They kill their own people. But it was stupid for the U.S. to attack Iran in the way we did. You cannot drive them out of power just by shooting a bunch of missiles at them.

The Iranian leadership seems to be enjoying the humiliation of Trump. At the very least, they are going to try to keep the Strait of Hormuz closed until the midterms to keep gas prices as high as possible because it hurts Trump.

We are told that intelligence has found that Iran would love to kill Trump. When he went to Turkey for some kind of G7 or similar meeting, they supposedly knew what floor of the hotel he was staying on, and that could have been an opportunity for them to try to blow up that floor.

In America, there is a lot of ridicule from non-MAGA people about Trump supposedly sneaking away from Air Force One because they were warned that Iran might target the plane.

What happened, as I understand it, was that Trump went aboard Air Force One, the giant 747 that the president flies on. Because there were concerns that Iran was going to fire a missile at Air Force One, they supposedly snuck him off the plane in a catering cart, one of those things used to roll meals onto the plane. They put him in one of those, snuck him off along with a couple members of his staff that he chose, and flew him out on a different military jet.

Nobody on Air Force One was told about this at the time or given the opportunity to get off the plane, which was supposedly seen as a target. So Trump is being attacked for being a chicken shit who was willing to sacrifice the hundreds of people on Air Force One but save himself.

There is his press secretary, Karoline Leavitt. There was talk that she was quitting within a couple of days of this. She was not snuck off the plane, though he supposedly took his social media person, this young blonde woman who handles some of his social media. There is speculation that Leavitt was pissed that she was not taken off and felt slighted. Nobody fucking knows. But anyway, that is the situation with Iran and Trump.

Jacobsen: What do you think hurts some of these regimes more, or counters them appropriately in the current context: sanctions, cyber operations, or military strategy? What works best?

Rosner: When you talk about regimes, you have Russia and Iran. With Russia, what has hurt it is Ukraine’s actual fucking buckled-down attitude and ingenuity in war fighting. Ukraine launches something like 9,000 drones against Russia every day.

The average lifespan of a Russian soldier on the front lines is measured in hours. Russia loses more than a thousand troops every day to death or injury from Ukraine, around 35,000 a month, and Ukraine wants to make it 50,000 a month. Ukraine has started deploying battle robots.

These are armored four-wheel robotic vehicles that can fire between 300 and 1,000 rounds remotely. Ukraine is doing around 350 robot sorties every day. Between the drones and the robots, you are killing a ton of Russians.

That is leading to territorial stalemate. The Russians have not gained much Ukrainian territory in years. Ukraine is taking little chunks back. Not much, about 230 square miles, which is really nothing. But you have stopped Russia.

You are also blowing up shit remotely, thousands of kilometers away. What is hurting Russia is Ukraine’s war fighting. It is not sanctions. It is not cyber operations. It is actual war-fighting technology.

With Iran, if the U.S. is fighting Iran, what hurts them? Again, I would guess it is actual war fighting, blowing up shit with missiles. This has not dissuaded Iran or made it change its policies. But the U.S. has blown up a lot of Iranian shit.

Iran has faced sanctions since the regime took over in 1979. That leads to suffering among the general population, but it does not hurt the regime. I do not think it makes them more likely to be overthrown.

So in terms of hurting the regime, military action probably does hurt because it is going to cost billions, maybe tens of billions, to reconstruct all the shit that has been blown up. But in terms of making Iran less resolved to resist, nothing has done that as far as we know.

Jacobsen: The Tate brothers are in jail. They are reporting poor treatment and poor conditions. What are your thoughts?

Rosner: I am sure you have read a lot about them, right? They are rapists and general abusers of women, sex traffickers, and statutory rapists. They are promulgators of rape and abuse. They have sold their lifestyle to shitty bros around the world.

The model is that you are super manly and love-bomb young, stupid women. You tell them you love them, hit them with all your attention, show them the sexy, rich lifestyle you have, and rope them in. You become their pimps.

You put them on cams, make them cam girls on OnlyFans, get them making porn on camera, and steal the money they make selling themselves online. If they do not want to play ball once they are working in one of your houses, you beat them.

They are terrible guys. They have been able to avoid prosecution by moving between countries and by appealing to shitty bros. People in the Trump circle like them, and for a while that shielded them from prosecution and maybe extradition.

But they are monsters. They can complain that they do not like it in jail, but they certainly deserve to be held before trial. If you do not keep them in jail, they will flee to some country that does not have extradition.

These are guys who have abused dozens, maybe scores, of women across many years and are responsible for probably thousands of women being abused by selling their lifestyle to shitheads around the world.

Jacobsen: Do you think they are going to get actual jail time after a court case?

Rosner: I do not know where it stands. Aren’t they being held to be extradited to the U.K.? If they go on trial in the U.K., then yes, I think they will get prison time because there is an extensive record of the shit they have done.

I am sure they will be able to knock some of it down by creating enough uncertainty. One issue is that when people get arrested for running Andrew Tate-style abuse houses full of cam girls, a lot of the women can either be intimidated into withdrawing their statements or can still be persuaded that they are in love with these fuckers and withdraw their statements.

So some of the evidence goes away. But with the Tates, they have allegedly been doing this shit long enough, and to enough people, that I assume there is enough evidence to put them away.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 26: 2026 Midterms, Trump’s Executive Power, and the Courts

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/08/17

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner discuss the 2026 U.S. midterm elections, cost-of-living pressures, Donald Trump’s approval, Republican messaging, redistricting, and Democratic prospects in Congress. They also examine Trump’s efforts to expand executive power, the practical limits of judicial intervention, lower-court resistance, and the Supreme Court’s mixed record. Rosner argues that institutional checks remain functional but uneven, leaving American democracy vulnerable during a volatile election period amid intensifying political and constitutional conflict.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: The 2026 midterm elections and cost-of-living concerns. How are those shaping up?

Rick Rosner: It is 79 days until the midterms, and early voting begins in less than five and a half weeks in about five states. So we are almost there.

This is day 105 of the national average gas price being over $4 a gallon during Trump’s second term. He promised us $2-a-gallon gas. He promised that inflation would go away. Inflation was over 4 percent in June and 3.4 percent in July. Job growth is down 88 percent since March or April 2025, when Trump introduced tariffs.

Trump is increasingly unconstrained and has lost the ability to govern with any moderation in what he says. He says he does not care that gas is expensive. He calls affordability a hoax, even though he ran on affordability. His approval rating is the second worst among presidents at the midterm point since they started measuring it with Harry Truman 80 years ago.

We still have two and a half months to go. It could drop another percentage point. He is at 38 percent approval and 58 percent disapproval. He will almost certainly lose control of the House. The Senate is up for grabs.

Republicans just lie. That is worth something in the marketplace of ideas. They go on TV and say the economy is stronger than ever, prices are lower than ever, and Trump has made everything more affordable. This is 100 percent not true, but 38 percent of the population is buying it.

Will his support decay further in the next couple of months? It is hard to say. Ronald Reagan was called the Teflon president because bullshit did not seem to stick to him. His base was largely oblivious to it. That applies even more to Trump.

I think Trump will lose the House. Nate Silver’s Silver Bulletin, which is the poll aggregator I look at most frequently, predicts that Democrats will gain 18 seats in the House. If this were a normal midterm election, it would be even more, but a number of states have carried out midterm redistricting to protect Republican seats.

The Senate cannot be gerrymandered because everybody in the state votes for the senator, as opposed to people in congressional districts voting for representatives. So it looks pretty bad for Trump, but it does not look great for Democrats either. If we want the leverage to stop the horrible shit Trump is doing, and he is not slowing down or taking any feedback that people hate what is going on, just holding the House does not do that much.

Even in the Senate, he nominated Todd Blanche and got him through by a vote of 50 to 49. Republicans continue to abet wild corruption. One of Todd Blanche’s objectives is to continue covering up Trump’s involvement with Epstein, and Republicans in government just go along with that.

The Democrats will certainly do well in the midterms and will win the House. Trump will do some crazy crap to try to derail the elections between now and 11 and a half weeks from now. He is trying to fuck with vote by mail. He has tried to push the SAVE Act, which is ID-based voter suppression. That is not going to happen. He does not have the votes for it, and there is no time for it now with less than three months to go.

Any changes to ID requirements, which are unconstitutional and would be thrown out by the courts anyway, would also be rejected because there is not enough time to implement them.

There is another perilous period in politics, which is the lame-duck period, the two months between the election and when the new Congress comes in. The election is held in the first week of November, and the new members do not take office until the first week of January. So you have two months for the old House and Senate to try to pass some crazy crap while they still have Republican majorities. Certainly they will.

The rhetoric coming out of Trump and the Republicans right now gets a little crazier every day and will continue to do so until the election. It might get crazier still afterward because Trump will be going crazy denying the results.

I think I have talked about this with you, but based on what I see on social media, one to three percent of Americans have a mental illness.

More than 90 percent of MAGA supporters believe the 2020 election was stolen. More than 25 percent believe vaccines kill millions of people. You can have delusional beliefs, at least according to what AI tells me, without being mentally ill. You can simply be sharing the delusions of your friend group or the group with which you have affiliated yourself.

So you can have delusional beliefs without being clinically demented or delusional. But based on what I see online, I believe maybe as many as 10 percent of MAGA supporters are so delusional that they are actually mentally ill. That is a problem for America. It was a problem for Germany after World War II.

Millions and millions of people continued to be Nazis in their hearts, but there was an occupation. A million Allied soldiers occupied Germany. They made it illegal to espouse Nazi beliefs. So a lot of people continued to believe those things until they died, but they shut up about it because it was illegal to say you were a Nazi.

We have a similar problem in America where, against all evidence that Trump and the Republicans are wrecking the country, MAGA supporters will continue to believe until they are dead.

Of course, you have lunatics on the other side too. We have democratic socialists, some of whom have reasonable beliefs. The Democrats have a big tent. You can believe in Medicare for All, where you pay taxes and the government foots the bill for your healthcare. That is the way your healthcare gets paid for once you hit 65. We could take that system and give it to everybody, getting rid of private health insurance except for people who want deluxe extra coverage.

A lot of people call that socialism. It is among the more reasonable dimensions of socialism. So you have candidates who espouse that, and they are not lunatics. But you have people who go farther than that, who want to get rid of the police altogether.

They end up being invited on Fox to say crazy crap and show Fox viewers that the Democrats are crazy and that you have to vote Republican. So what I am saying is that you have people who are probably actually mentally ill at each extreme end, both the left and the right. But the right, with MAGA, has, I would say, many times more actually mentally ill people than the Democrats do.

Jacobsen: How much can Trump expand his executive authority before federal courts impose constitutional limits?

Rosner: Trump just throws spaghetti at the wall all the time. It is spaghetti all day, every day. He just tries shit constantly, and the courts shoot down, I do not know, two-thirds of it. Some of it gets through. The second thing is that it takes months for things to get to the courts and be shot down.

It happens with big stuff and little stuff. Trump decided to put gold leaf all over a bunch of bronze statues across Washington, D.C. It is expensive. It costs millions of dollars. It makes the statues illegible. When you have a bronze statue, it gets a patina that lets you see the features of the statue. The statues were sculpted by knowledgeable artists who understood the medium they were working with and made their art accordingly.

When you cover them with gold, you turn them into giant mirrors. All the details disappear because you are being blasted with reflected light. They look nice and shiny, which is great if you are a fucking idiot.

Anyway, it is trivial. It is expensive. It is something Trump can apparently do with no recourse to the courts. Is somebody suing over the statues? I do not know. They are already covered with gold leaf, so it is too late.

Trump’s lawyers could also argue that you do not have standing. If you go in saying the fucking statues look bad, Trump can say, “Yeah, but you do not have a compelling interest in it.” The courts could agree with him.

The Kennedy Center, by law, has to be named just the Kennedy Center. This is a center for the performing arts in Washington, D.C., that was established to memorialize John F. Kennedy. Trump stuck his name on it too. He changed the name.

He changed the name to the Donald Trump and John F. Kennedy Center because he is a fucking dick. He appointed a 14-member board of all his friends who just say okay to whatever he wants to do.

Former interested parties took it to court, and the court said that, by law, it has to be named just the Kennedy Center and forced him to take his name off the building. He took his name off, but then he put a skirt in front of the building so you cannot see it, to hide his humiliation that his name is off the building.

His handpicked board, which consists of people like Laura Ingraham and Linda McMahon, basically Fox News people and members of his cabinet, voted to say that Trump can etch his name into the marble.

So this time around, instead of drilling holes into the marble and attaching letters that form his name, they are actually going to scrape his name into the marble. I am sure somebody has an injunction moving through the courts to stop him from doing that because it is no less illegal than the first time. But will the injunction beat the guys with the sandblasters, or whatever the fuck they use to etch the marble? I do not know.

That is just one stupid, trivial fucking thing. None of the levers of governance that we have to stop a president from going to war have been exercised in any effective way against Trump going into Iran.

Jacobsen: Are courts functioning as an effective check on executive power?

Rosner: Only to a limited extent. The courts are not as bad as they could be. Often, in the lower courts, you have judges who were appointed by Republicans and Democrats, by Reagan, Clinton, or Obama.

A lot of judges got their jobs for being good judges, for looking at patterns of facts and coming to reasonable conclusions. Even if they were appointed by lunatics, there is a reasonably low percentage of judges who are in the tank for Trump, like Eileen Cannon down in Florida, who will almost always rule in favor of Trump.

There is a fairly small number of these people out of thousands of judges. So the lower courts will often rule against his bullshit.

That is not always effective because Trump can just go ahead and keep doing whatever shit he was doing. The courts do not have cops. A judge cannot send a couple of squad cars out to stop Trump from sandblasting the Kennedy Center.

Then the Supreme Court is pretty bad. It has six conservative justices and three liberal justices, but it is not as bad as it could be because, out of nine justices, only two of them are crazy assholes who will almost always rule in favor of Trump.

Alito and Thomas are horrible fucking justices who will make lots of bad rulings in favor of Trump. They will not always go along with Trump either if the shit is bad enough. They are judges, and they will sometimes do the right thing.

Chief Justice Roberts makes a lot of bad rulings. He gave us Citizens United, and he has helped dismantle the Voting Rights Act, which has really fucked America. But he does not always make rulings that are that bad. He is actually concerned that people hate the Supreme Court now because of bad rulings, so he will sometimes do the right thing.

Amy Coney Barrett was appointed by Trump to help get rid of Roe v. Wade. She is wildly pro-life and anti-abortion. She comes from an extreme form of Christianity. But if you stay away from abortion, she is surprisingly not terrible quite often. She is terrible sometimes, but she takes her job seriously and often rules reasonably.

The Supreme Court often does do the right thing. Gorsuch, another Trump appointee, comes from a terrible family. His mom was appointed by Reagan to head the EPA in order to destroy the EPA, which she tried to do until she was finally kicked out for being so destructive.

He takes after his mom in that he hates the environment. He will rule against the EPA and against environmental regulations all the fucking time. However, on issues that are not about the environment, he often rules reasonably. They often rule kind of reasonably.

We are in trouble, as I said, with Citizens United, which says that money is free speech, that you should be able to throw as much money at an election as you want, and that this is simply exercising your First Amendment right to free speech. Corporations are people when it comes to political activism. It was a terrible ruling and has really fucked up our elections.

Getting rid of the Voting Rights Act is fucking Black voters across America. Terrible. But all hope is not lost.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 25: AI, Relationships, Education, Aging, and Modern American Life

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/08/16

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner discuss AI-generated sexual imagery, declining intimacy, social media, changing attitudes between men and women, and weakening social pressures toward partnership and family formation. Rosner also examines AI-assisted education, declining male college participation, delayed maturity, and cultural representations of relationships. The conversation concludes with his reflections on aging, including declining physical strength, health anxieties, lowered expectations, technological change, cultural invisibility, and the benefits of taking life more slowly.

Thanks for reading! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

Rick Rosner: I look at pictures of naked ladies online. Everybody does it. I look at a lot of AI-generated stuff, which is annoying for a lot of reasons. AI embodies the average preferences of its consumers.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: In this case, it is mostly men.

Rosner: Men want big, round boobs that are bigger than the model’s head. It gives a uniformity to most images. The reason guys turn to porn is for variety anyway, so it defeats the purpose. What I find off-putting is how delighted the women are in the images to be having sex. This does not comport with the current landscape. It seems divorced from reality.

In reality, women do not like guys very much at this point in U.S. history. According to one study, only 25 percent of women aged 18 to 24 have positive views of men. It goes up a little for women older than 24, but women tend not to see the point of men. That is due to economic trends. A hundred years ago, women had to depend on men for support. Fifty or 80 years ago, men seemed more mature.

It also goes the other way. Men are somewhat disgusted with younger men and disgusted with younger women. Social media has a huge role to play in this. People on social media are constantly exposed to bigger, better deals that make them unsatisfied with the people around them. Besides that general thing, guys do not seem worth it. Guys can seem more like dicks than they used to, especially in the modern context, which does not push as hard for coupling, making families, and raising families.

This is also reflected in people having less sex. The disgust people have with people in the real world, as opposed to the shit they are seeing online, translates into younger people having one-third less sex than previous generations.

Jacobsen: Any other points?

Rosner: In first-semester physics, there are a lot of exercises involving finding all the forces on an object, such as a box on a slanted table attached to a pulley. There is the gravitational force, the resistance force of the table, and the force of the pulley pulling. A lot of the forces on people in America today, and the world, are pushing them away from hooking up.

I have a related point, which is that education is in a shambles right now because they let you go to school and not do any work. When I went to school, and I went to school a lot, I was huge on not doing work, especially essays. I failed to turn in essays a huge number of times. I just could not get my shit together to sit down and write the shit. I am nobody to talk, but I am going to talk anyway.

AI lets you avoid writing essays. You just hand it over to AI. There are earmarks of AI that your teacher can see. I guess there is a thing called the em dash, which AI uses a lot to connect thoughts. So does any decent writer. It is a great tool. But if your writing is em-dash-heavy, your teacher might suspect something. At this point, your teacher does not give a shit because if the teacher has 20 students in a class and 17 of those students are using AI to generate essays, the teacher does not have time to fuck around and police the AI.

This starts in middle school and goes all the way through college. People used to go to college to find life partners. My wife and I met not at college, but at a dance while we were both going to the University of Colorado 40 fucking years ago. Besides being a good place to find a partner, college was also supposed to grow you up.

Make you mature and educated. It is failing to do that, particularly for guys. In the U.S., undergraduate college enrollment is about three women to every two men. About 60 percent of undergraduates in America are women.

Guys are not getting educated. If people are going to college to get educated, they are not really getting educated because AI is helping them sidestep that. Part of the problem is the longer time it takes to reach mature behavior and the failure of our institutions to encourage maturity. Not to say that maturity is so fucking great. It is not like life in the period that MAGA claims to want to return to, the 1950s and 1960s, was ideal. There was a lot wrong with that.

But if you want guys who are not dickheads so they can enter partnerships, and if you are worried about the international baby shortage, those are a couple more force vectors not pointing as strongly in the direction you would want as they used to.

One more thing. There is a Judd Apatow movie with Seth Rogen and Katherine Heigl called Knocked Up. That movie is probably 15 or 17 years old now. It is about, among other things, the journey of an immature guy becoming a responsible partner. It is a comedy. Seth Rogen starts off as this stoner video-game developer who has a one-night stand and accidentally gets her pregnant. The movie follows his journey toward becoming a guy who might be a passable partner.

To a lesser extent, it follows the journey of the woman as she becomes less snotty and more accepting, and maybe adjusts her expectations enough to allow a relationship to happen.

We probably need a movie or two now to explore that kind of process under modern conditions. You got an inkling of what was going on 17 years ago in this movie, which is reasonably insightful. It is almost a generation later now, and the pressure to keep being a dickhead is stronger. It would be instructive to revisit that.

Jacobsen: I had another question before we get into news, politics, and culture about the United States. Pluses and minuses, in some families, there is a tradition of having dinner and talking about the highs and lows, or pluses and minuses, of the day. It can provide some discovery about what people think that might not otherwise become clear. In terms of aging, now being past the regular retirement age in the United States, at least, and past the average age of death in some countries, what are the pluses and minuses, the highs and lows?

Rosner: The minus is the constant apprehension that the shoes are about to drop in terms of health. That is a huge minus all the fucking time.

Weakness is another. I have been getting back into free-weight bench pressing because, for decades, I would just use bench machines. Now I am actually using free weights. The amount of muscle I have has probably dropped by more than 40 percent because, at my strongest, I was about 175, and now I am about 140. Obviously, you cannot be as strong. It is discouraging to be, at best, 55 or 60 percent as strong as I used to be.

I also have a hard time putting on any bulk. It is probably a bad idea to put on bulk at age 66 anyway. So I do not like that whole thing.

A plus is lowered expectations. Carole no longer expects me to deliver in terms of getting a job. I still push myself somewhat. I still want to finish my book and stuff, and she would like me to do that. But when I take two naps in a day, she does not give me shit about it. In fact, that is reasonable. I should not be getting shit for naps because they are healthful.

Taking it easy on myself is not an unreasonable thing to do. So it is both a plus and a minus to have lowered expectations.

Falling away from the world is a minus. I do not know as much about technology or what is happening in the world. I am not especially bad at keeping up with tech. Most people suffer from the same problem because technology is moving so fast. Nobody knows what the fuck to think about AI. It is hard to have an educated point of view. Even the experts disagree wildly.

I have not been up to date on music this century. Another minus is that I do not present as a normal member of the population anymore. I go about my business the same way, but I have pretty white hair now. When somebody is presented as old, that person is usually 10 years or more younger than me. So I am older than old.

I do not see myself in movies and on TV. Movies and TV shows focus on people in high school or college, and then there are grown-up movies and shows that focus on people in their thirties and forties, with some people in their fifties and sixties thrown in as plot points. But we really do not feature much in the culture. So there you go. There is some stuff.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 24: AI Mathematics, Brain-Computer Interfaces, and Human Understanding

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/08/11

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner examine how artificial intelligence could transform mathematical discovery, eventually producing results beyond unaided human comprehension. They discuss agentic systems, machine-generated knowledge, epistemic opacity, Benjamin Franklin, brain-computer interfaces, and technologically augmented identity. Rosner also explores these themes through a fictional character integrated with machine computation, raising questions about consciousness, legal personhood, human rights, embodied experience, and whether humans may increasingly merge with artificial cognitive systems.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: These mathematical applications of artificial intelligence systems, some genuinely sophisticated and some less so, will probably develop along a trajectory similar to AI-assisted coding. Coding has moved from autocomplete and code generation toward “vibe coding,” human-agent collaboration, and increasingly agentic systems that can carry out multi-step tasks with limited supervision. We’re also beginning to see systems in which multiple agents can work in parallel.

In coding, you can give a system a directive and some parameters in natural language, acting as the “programmer” in quotation marks, and have it perform substantial portions of the task. Current systems can already work autonomously for minutes or hours on some tasks. Longer autonomous operation remains an active area of development rather than a solved capability.

Mathematics will probably develop in a similar direction. If you’re talking about mathematical structures and discovery within those structures, there are some important implications. Newton had the basic principle right: knowledge builds on prior knowledge, captured in his famous remark about “standing on the shoulders of giants.”

Rick Rosner: Although I’ve read interpretations suggesting that quote might have been snarky. Newton was writing to Robert Hooke, with whom he had a difficult relationship. Some people interpret it as sarcasm, though that interpretation isn’t established. Newton could certainly be a fucking prick.

Jacobsen: He was famously combative and involved in bitter priority disputes. So I think there’s a reasonable argument one can make.

The argument has several steps. First, suppose we continue to see increasing capabilities in mathematical AI systems. Suppose those systems increasingly compete and coordinate with human mathematicians, solve original problems, and eventually solve long-standing problems that talented mathematicians have been unable to crack. And suppose improvements continue in computing resources, energy efficiency, algorithms, reasoning architectures, and the compression or specialization of mathematical capabilities.

Under those assumptions, it is plausible that AI systems could eventually outperform even highly talented human mathematicians across many forms of mathematical problem-solving. That remains a prediction, not an established endpoint.

Traditionally, a talented mathematician learns an existing field, builds on it, and then builds on what they have produced. They train other people, who do the same with the previous generation’s work. You get an iterative accumulation of mathematical knowledge, producing increasingly sophisticated layers.

Rosner: You call it human knowledge, but okay.

Jacobsen: We’re probably about to agree here. Historically, that knowledge was generated overwhelmingly by humans. Now it is increasingly being developed with assistance from artificial systems. It is conceivable that, in some domains, artificial systems could eventually become the primary producers of new mathematical results.

That creates another possibility. A system produces a solution, and the solution opens new problems, as mathematical solutions often do. The system then attacks those new problems, whose solutions generate still more problems. Not ad infinitum in any literal computational sense, but potentially through a very large number of successive iterations.

Eventually, we might reach a point where the problem is no longer asking these systems to speed up, but asking them to translate their results into forms human beings can understand. They might develop internal representations, algorithms, abstractions, or formal languages optimized for machine reasoning that are difficult for humans to interpret directly.

That would create a kind of epistemic opacity. It would not necessarily mean that the systems are literal black boxes in every technical sense. Their proofs or outputs might still be formally verifiable. But the conceptual route by which they reach those results could become increasingly difficult for humans to follow.

You could then have genuine mathematical knowledge that is formally accessible but cognitively inaccessible to most humans, including many specialists. Something analogous already exists within mathematics. Work at the research frontier can be opaque to almost everyone outside a narrow specialty, and sometimes even to mathematicians working in adjacent areas.

So that’s the stepwise argument.

Rosner: All right. It’s sometimes said that Benjamin Franklin was among the last people who could understand a substantial portion of the science of his time. I don’t know that the claim can literally be established. But since Franklin’s era, scientific knowledge has expanded and specialized so extensively that no individual could plausibly master all of modern science.

So we’re already in a situation somewhat like that. I’m working on a novel in which a character becomes increasingly enmeshed with machine computation. This individual has a mutation in his brain that makes it easier for him to interface with implants for the direct input of information, not through the conventional senses but directly into the brain.

You could call it an additional sense: the direct input of information. This character gets a lot of shit from people. He’s renowned for being really smart, not least because he’s linked to vast computational systems. And people say, “You’re not even fucking real. You’re really just a mouthpiece for some fucking AI. I don’t even believe that you are what you claim to be, which is a conscious, thinking being. I think you’re just a fucking puppet of AI.”

And the character is like, “Fuck you,” and tries to do various things to prove his authenticity. But gradually he has to admit that it’s kind of a moot question. He is deeply enmeshed with the system. Who he is consists not just of his biological brain but also of his relationship with machine computation.

I think that’s where things could go in a lot of fields. The unaided human brain may eventually be unable to understand a lot of the shit being done by AI. But in the future, if sufficiently advanced brain-computer interfaces become possible, we may be able to connect more directly with these systems. Current brain-computer interfaces are far more limited than that, so this is speculative.

One thing humans have is embodied agency and subjective experience. We can move around the world. We have sensations. We have feelings about what we experience. Current AI systems don’t experience and interact with the physical world in the same way humans do, and whether artificial systems could possess subjective experience remains an open philosophical and scientific question.

So we may eventually link ourselves much more closely to AI. To some extent, we might become dependent on the systems we’re linked to. Information could be fed into us through increasingly sophisticated interfaces. Our biological brains might have only a vague understanding of some of the underlying computation while remaining highly integrated with nonbiological systems.

If artificial systems ever develop something meaningfully analogous to subjective experience, an interface with human beings could raise even stranger questions. But we don’t currently know whether AI systems can have experiences or feelings at all.

There will also be legal arguments. It’ll probably go to court eventually. If a person becomes extensively technologically augmented, at what point, if any, does that affect the person’s legal identity? Does that person continue to control their assets? Are they still legally a human being, or does the law eventually need some new category? And if genuinely nonhuman artificial persons ever exist, what rights should they have?

So, yes, we’re going to go beyond individual human understanding, but humans may also transcend some of their current cognitive limitations in weird ways.

People sometimes say that octopuses have nine brains. That isn’t literally correct. An octopus has a central brain and a highly distributed nervous system, with large concentrations of neurons in its eight arms. Those arm nervous systems can perform substantial local processing and coordinate complex movements without every detail being centrally controlled.

That gives us an interesting analogy. An arm’s neural circuitry doesn’t need a complete representation of everything the animal is doing. The central nervous system and peripheral neural networks coordinate behavior, while substantial processing occurs locally within the arms.

We’re accustomed to being one biological brain in one body, with no deeply integrated external computation. That could change. And, yeah, it’ll be fucking creepy. It could also be extraordinarily useful or terrible, which seems to be the case with almost everything involving AI.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 23: Cultural Intake, Smartphones, Marriage, and Transformative Inventions

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/08/10

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner discuss Rosner’s unexpected preoccupation with wall-to-wall carpeting, from recurring dog urine stains and carpet shampooing to repairing a persistent ridge in an upstairs landing. Rosner reflects on experimental home-repair methods, the limits of surface cleaning, and mid-century carpeting as a symbol of postwar affluence. The conversation also explores how highly intelligent people can become absorbed in narrow, impractical problems that nevertheless reward curiosity, experimentation, and persistence.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Do you have a thing for carpets? Why this topic?

Rick Rosner: Our house has a lot of wall-to-wall carpet, whereas many high-end houses in LA now have hardwood floors with area rugs. That’s it.

And then you throw down fancy carpets, but our house is about two-thirds wall-to-wall carpet. Our house was built in ’66, so it’s about 60 years old. We moved in in ’98, so we’ve been here about 28 years.

Some of the carpet was here when we moved in. It’s white carpet, and we’ve had a series of dogs.

One of our dogs is a terrier, and terriers are their own people, right? They may follow the rules; they may not. So this terrier knows where she should go to pee, but she has probably peed on the carpet hundreds of times.

The carpet’s kind of disgusting, so we get it shampooed once a year. But some of the stains come back up. That can happen through wicking because, when a dog pees, urine can penetrate the carpet fibers and backing and soak into the pad underneath.

The carpet cleaners come with their extraction machines, and they wet down the carpet. They can remove the surface stains, but after they leave, residual contamination deeper in the carpet or padding can sometimes be drawn upward as the carpet dries, causing stains to re-emerge. So repeated surface shampooing alone may not completely solve a deep urine problem. Sometimes the backing or pad also has to be treated or replaced.

So instead of getting another shampoo that doesn’t do shit, I bought a wet vac, a carpet shampooer, for Carol’s birthday, which is like getting your wife a broom for her birthday. Not appreciated. But in this case, she’d shot down my other birthday suggestion. So I got her the wet vac and have been using it, and it works gradually.

If you hit the same patch of carpet repeatedly over a period of months, eventually you may make progress. But along with this, I’ve noticed other flaws in our carpet. On our landing upstairs, we put down some newish carpet 17 years ago. There’s a carpeted space at the top of the stairs that’s 11 feet by 5 feet, and it developed a hump.

It developed a ridge. I assume the carpet changed dimension slightly over the past 17 years, or otherwise loosened enough to buckle, which is enough to give you a ridge. So for the past week or so, I’ve been trying experiments to make the ridge go down. First, I tried tacking it down. I bought a set of hypodermic-style applicators for clothing, for gluing on sequins, from Temu for $1.30, and I’ve been filling them with watered-down glue, pushing them through the carpet, and injecting watery glue between the carpet and the pad. Then I put weights on top to flatten it out, which has taken care of about two-thirds of the hump, but still not enough.

Today, I went ahead and pulled up the corner at the edge of the carpet and cut off, in places, between three-sixteenths and a quarter inch from the edge. Then I used weights again to push the hump out, and re-glued the carpet down and re-tacked it.

So, adventures in carpet, which is a terrible use of my time. I should be doing physics or writing, but you know from your experience with high-IQ people that we can be cul-de-sac’d fairly easily. We’ll find a problem that captures our interest but has little practical value. At least I do. I get obsessed with ridiculous shit, and this past week I’m not obsessed with the carpet hump, but I’m interested in seeing whether I can come up with a methodology that makes it largely go away.

Wall-to-wall carpeting became a sign of middle-class and upper-middle-class affluence around the mid-20th century, right? Before then, you had farmhouses and regular houses with hardwood floors. That was simply what many floors were made of. Then the ’50s came along, and wall-to-wall carpeting became associated with comfortable, modern living.

And if you were going to put wall-to-wall carpeting throughout a house, you did not necessarily need finished hardwood underneath it. In houses built during the ’50s and ’60s, carpet was often installed over a subfloor rather than a finished hardwood floor. So our house is an artifact, a remnant of that era when wall-to-wall carpeting was widely regarded as desirable.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 22: Wall-to-Wall Carpets, Home Repairs

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/08/09

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner discuss Rosner’s unexpected preoccupation with wall-to-wall carpeting, from recurring dog urine stains and carpet shampooing to repairing a persistent ridge in an upstairs landing. Rosner reflects on experimental home-repair methods, the limits of surface cleaning, and mid-century carpeting as a symbol of postwar affluence. The conversation also explores how highly intelligent people can become absorbed in narrow, impractical problems that nevertheless reward curiosity, experimentation, and persistence.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Do you have a thing for carpets? Why this topic?

Rick Rosner: Our house has a lot of wall-to-wall carpet, whereas many high-end houses in LA now have hardwood floors with area rugs. That’s it.

And then you throw down fancy carpets, but our house is about two-thirds wall-to-wall carpet. Our house was built in ’66, so it’s about 60 years old. We moved in in ’98, so we’ve been here about 28 years.

Some of the carpet was here when we moved in. It’s white carpet, and we’ve had a series of dogs.

One of our dogs is a terrier, and terriers are their own people, right? They may follow the rules; they may not. So this terrier knows where she should go to pee, but she has probably peed on the carpet hundreds of times.

The carpet’s kind of disgusting, so we get it shampooed once a year. But some of the stains come back up. That can happen through wicking because, when a dog pees, urine can penetrate the carpet fibers and backing and soak into the pad underneath.

The carpet cleaners come with their extraction machines, and they wet down the carpet. They can remove the surface stains, but after they leave, residual contamination deeper in the carpet or padding can sometimes be drawn upward as the carpet dries, causing stains to re-emerge. So repeated surface shampooing alone may not completely solve a deep urine problem. Sometimes the backing or pad also has to be treated or replaced.

So instead of getting another shampoo that doesn’t do shit, I bought a wet vac, a carpet shampooer, for Carol’s birthday, which is like getting your wife a broom for her birthday. Not appreciated. But in this case, she’d shot down my other birthday suggestion. So I got her the wet vac and have been using it, and it works gradually.

If you hit the same patch of carpet repeatedly over a period of months, eventually you may make progress. But along with this, I’ve noticed other flaws in our carpet. On our landing upstairs, we put down some newish carpet 17 years ago. There’s a carpeted space at the top of the stairs that’s 11 feet by 5 feet, and it developed a hump.

It developed a ridge. I assume the carpet changed dimension slightly over the past 17 years, or otherwise loosened enough to buckle, which is enough to give you a ridge. So for the past week or so, I’ve been trying experiments to make the ridge go down. First, I tried tacking it down. I bought a set of hypodermic-style applicators for clothing, for gluing on sequins, from Temu for $1.30, and I’ve been filling them with watered-down glue, pushing them through the carpet, and injecting watery glue between the carpet and the pad. Then I put weights on top to flatten it out, which has taken care of about two-thirds of the hump, but still not enough.

Today, I went ahead and pulled up the corner at the edge of the carpet and cut off, in places, between three-sixteenths and a quarter inch from the edge. Then I used weights again to push the hump out, and re-glued the carpet down and re-tacked it.

So, adventures in carpet, which is a terrible use of my time. I should be doing physics or writing, but you know from your experience with high-IQ people that we can be cul-de-sac’d fairly easily. We’ll find a problem that captures our interest but has little practical value. At least I do. I get obsessed with ridiculous shit, and this past week I’m not obsessed with the carpet hump, but I’m interested in seeing whether I can come up with a methodology that makes it largely go away.

Wall-to-wall carpeting became a sign of middle-class and upper-middle-class affluence around the mid-20th century, right? Before then, you had farmhouses and regular houses with hardwood floors. That was simply what many floors were made of. Then the ’50s came along, and wall-to-wall carpeting became associated with comfortable, modern living.

And if you were going to put wall-to-wall carpeting throughout a house, you did not necessarily need finished hardwood underneath it. In houses built during the ’50s and ’60s, carpet was often installed over a subfloor rather than a finished hardwood floor. So our house is an artifact, a remnant of that era when wall-to-wall carpeting was widely regarded as desirable.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 21: AI Harmonization, Regulation, Coding Agents, and the Future of Human Adaptation

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/08/09

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner discuss rapid AI development, institutional adaptation, and the concept of technological harmonization. They examine shifting leadership at Google DeepMind, AI competition, university policies, synthetic-media disclosure under the EU AI Act, coding agents, semiconductor diversification, energy efficiency, and human oversight. Rosner also considers how digital technologies may reshape relationships and communication, while Jacobsen argues that societies can respond through iterative policy, infrastructure, and cultural adaptation over time.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Demis Hassabis, the Nobel Prize-winning AI researcher, is moving away from the day-to-day management of Google DeepMind to become its chairman and Alphabet’s chief scientist. Koray Kavukcuoglu will take over day-to-day leadership of Google DeepMind while continuing as Alphabet’s chief AI architect.

At the same time, Jeff Dean, Sanjay Ghemawat, Oriol Vinyals, and Quoc Le are leaving Google to establish a separate AI research company called Discovery Loop. So there is a significant reshuffling of AI leadership at Google, with Hassabis moving from operational management toward longer-term scientific strategy and research.

Why do you think one of the world’s leading AI researchers would make this shift from day-to-day management toward a broader scientific and strategic role?

Rick Rosner: From what I have seen lately, and you may know better than I do, the pace is increasing. It was already fast, but new models are now coming out at a faster rate. Each new generation can feel unsettlingly more capable than the previous one.

The different models also have different strengths and areas of emphasis. I do not think the field can even be reduced to just a small handful of dominant models or companies anymore.

You have China in the mix too, but there are also smaller companies trying to find niches for themselves. It is a turbulent landscape. Everyone is scrambling for an advantage, trying to find somewhere to stand where they will not be swept away by the next wave of technology. They want to be the ones doing the sweeping rather than the ones being swept away.

There is also the question of whether we even want to be doing all of this. AI has not become less risky over time. If anything, the potential risks increase as the systems become more capable. At the same time, there is increasing economic pressure to disregard those risks because companies and countries feel they have to keep moving or risk falling behind.

People often look for historical analogies for AI, and one comparison is the automobile. Cars transformed American cities over a few decades. Before widespread automobile adoption, horses were essential to urban transportation, and large cities had to deal with enormous quantities of manure, urine, carcasses, feed, and stable waste. New York City had tens of thousands of working horses around the turn of the twentieth century, not anything close to 800,000 horses on its streets every day. As automobiles, trucks, buses, and electric transit spread, the role of urban horses declined dramatically during the first decades of the twentieth century.

If you are going to use automobiles as an analogy for AI, though, the technological transition feels much faster. It is as if decades of technological change were being compressed into a few years. Things are moving extraordinarily quickly.How nervous are you about AI?

Jacobsen: Why would I be? I think we are in a period of harmonization with the technology.

Rosner: So you think society can keep adapting to what AI can do and incorporate it?

Jacobsen: Did we ever keep up with the printing press in the sense of reading everything it produced? How many books exist? How many lifetimes would you need to read all of them?

Rosner: No individual keeps up with every technological system or every product of one. You do not keep up with every development in mining technology either. Millions of new books are published globally each year, depending on how a “book” and a publication are counted. That works out to thousands per day, not hundreds of thousands per day. The scale is still far beyond what any individual could absorb.

Jacobsen: It is a discouraging number, depending on how you look at it.

Every technology occupies particular niches, and sometimes developments within those niches become transformative. People often call the current period the Fourth Industrial Revolution. I would qualify that. The term is established, including at the World Economic Forum, but it describes a convergence of digital, biological, physical, and AI technologies rather than an industrial revolution identical in character to the earlier mechanization-driven revolutions.

What is particularly important with AI is the possibility of increasingly autonomous and self-improving systems. “Recursive self-improvement” is one of the concepts people discuss, although present-day large language models do not independently redesign themselves into progressively more capable systems in the strong sense associated with that idea.

What we are seeing instead is the integration of language models with tools, memory, planning systems, multimodal capabilities, and other components to create more general-purpose AI systems that can operate with increasing autonomy in open environments. We are not yet at artificial general intelligence in any universally accepted sense.

That is why I am not especially afraid of the technology itself. I see us as being in a harmonization period in which institutions have to adapt their policies, norms, incentives, and educational practices.

At a panel with educators in Ukraine, for example, a study was presented suggesting that only a minority of universities surveyed had formal policies governing AI use in relation to plagiarism and other forms of academic misconduct. Among students at institutions that did have policies, awareness of those policies was incomplete.

The exact percentages would need to be verified against the original study before publication, but the broader issue is clear. There can be two gaps. First, institutions may not have adequate AI policies. Second, even where policies exist, students may not know what those policies require.

Universities therefore have to develop clear rules, communicate them effectively, and design assessment systems that make responsible AI use possible while discouraging academic misconduct. Detection alone cannot solve the problem. Current AI-detection systems can produce false positives and false negatives, so institutions also need assessment design, transparency requirements, oral verification where appropriate, process documentation, and clear standards for permissible and impermissible AI assistance.

It is similar with a lot of other issues. Are universities terrified of AI? Not necessarily. They are developing policies, adapting their practices, and, in the terminology I am using, harmonizing with the technology.

We are in a period of harmonization. How much electrical power do we need? How much computing capacity does each kind of task require? Where does it make sense to devote substantial resources to artificial intelligence, and where is AI unnecessary?

AI will affect nearly every area of life, but the effects will be asymmetric across different sectors and asynchronous in their timing. Different areas will change at different rates and to different degrees. It is going to be a very bumpy ride if technological civilization continues toward something resembling a Kardashev Type I civilization.

Rosner: I was wrong about the number of books being published. I was off by at least an order of magnitude. Estimates vary enormously depending on whether you count traditional publishing, self-publishing, new editions, ebooks, print-on-demand titles, and publications in different countries. But even estimates in the thousands or tens of thousands of new titles per day are incredible.

I have read a lot of books in my life, and the larger point remains that no individual can remotely keep up with humanity’s total publishing output.

Now consider one area where, when all of this shakes out, there may simply be less fucking. That is already happening for a variety of reasons. People have more alternatives competing for their attention.

In the 1970s, if you wanted entertainment, there were far fewer options available on demand. There were no modern home video games, no streaming services, no smartphones, and no internet. Today, a large video game can occupy somebody for dozens of hours. Multiplayer games can keep people engaged for hundreds or even thousands of hours. There were recreational substitutes in the past, of course, including sports, hobbies, television, reading, music, and outdoor activities, but today’s entertainment environment is dramatically more abundant and personalized.

There is simply much more extremely compelling entertainment available now.

There are also economic and cultural factors affecting dating, relationships, and sexual activity. Forming relationships can feel more complicated. Housing and other living costs can make independent adult life harder to establish, particularly for younger people. Those factors interact with changing social norms, dating apps, delayed marriage and parenthood, and digital entertainment.

As AI becomes increasingly integrated with entertainment, the experiences available to people will probably become even more personalized, interactive, and compelling. That could provide an increasingly attractive substitute for some forms of socializing, dating, and sexual activity.

So one possible consequence of the kind of technologically advanced civilization you are describing is less banging.

That has potentially good and bad aspects. It is not only about people having less sex. It may also involve changes in how comfortable people are with face-to-face interaction.

People my age sometimes make fun of Gen Z for supposedly having weaker conversational skills or giving people the stereotypical blank stare. I would not treat that as a universal characteristic of Gen Z. There is research and ongoing debate, though, about how heavy smartphone use and digitally mediated communication affect face-to-face interaction. Digital communication can supplement relationships, but extensive screen use can also displace some opportunities to practice in-person social skills.

You can even see generational anxieties about conversation reflected in advertising. Progressive has a long-running series of commercials featuring Dr. Rick, a fictional expert who teaches younger homeowners how to avoid “becoming their parents.” A recurring joke is that the characters engage strangers in unnecessary conversations or display other stereotypically parental social habits, and Dr. Rick tries to stop them.

The joke works because social conventions have changed. Talking extensively with strangers, chatting with service workers, or striking up conversations in public can be interpreted differently across generations and situations.

That does not necessarily mean younger people get less from verbal interaction. Communication habits have shifted toward texting, messaging, social media, and other digital channels, while face-to-face interaction remains important. Recent research also suggests that online and in-person communication involve somewhat different social skills rather than simply representing a single scale from “good” to “bad” communication.

If you are older, you can find those changes irritating or alienating. Or you can see them as a natural adaptation to the technologies people now use.

I am not necessarily the best at conventional small talk, but I am super fucking chatty. This whole enterprise of ours over the past 12 years has basically been built on chatting.

I learned, not especially well, from people who are professionally chatty. Jimmy Kimmel and Adam Carolla both have substantial backgrounds in radio. In radio, especially live talk radio, you learn to avoid long stretches of dead air. Talented broadcasters are constantly listening to the conversation and preparing the next thing they can contribute as the discussion changes.

Radio itself is not dead, although traditional terrestrial radio has lost some of its cultural dominance as audiences have fragmented across streaming, podcasts, satellite radio, and other digital media. Podcasts are a somewhat different medium. There are millions of podcasts and an enormous range in quality. Not everybody making one has the conversational training or performance skills of somebody like Kimmel or Carolla.

These are all changes that follow from technological change, which is what you were getting at earlier. If you were a horse person in 1910, perhaps you were sad to see horses gradually disappear from everyday urban transportation. On the other hand, you might have recognized that replacing large numbers of working horses with mechanized transportation solved some serious urban sanitation and animal-welfare problems. Technology changed, and the environment around it changed too.

Jacobsen: Since August 2, 2026, important transparency provisions of the European Union’s AI Act have applied. Under Article 50, people generally must be informed when they are directly interacting with certain AI systems unless that fact is obvious from the circumstances. Providers of generative AI systems must also make AI-generated or manipulated outputs detectable in a machine-readable format where technically feasible. Deployers face specific disclosure obligations for deepfakes and certain AI-generated or manipulated material concerning matters of public interest.

Meta also launched Muse Code in beta on August 5, powered by Muse Spark 1.2. It is designed to write and debug code, handle long software-engineering tasks, and coordinate multiple sub-agents working in parallel. It also keeps a persistent activity log, which allows interrupted work to resume without starting the entire task again. It is entering the same broad market as tools such as OpenAI Codex and Anthropic’s Claude Code.

Can we address the first issue first, the European transparency rules for AI-generated content?

Rosner: Europe has often taken a more precautionary regulatory approach to digital technology than the United States.

Cookies are a good example. European data-protection and electronic-privacy rules helped make cookie-consent notices ubiquitous on European websites years ago. Those notices subsequently became common on U.S.-accessible websites too, especially when companies operated internationally or were subject to state privacy laws. So it is not that cookie notices only appeared in the United States within the last year or two. Europe simply moved earlier and more comprehensively in regulating certain forms of online tracking.

There is a longstanding difference in regulatory philosophy. The United States has often placed greater emphasis on commercial freedom and post-hoc enforcement, whereas European regulation has tended to impose more explicit obligations on businesses before certain harms occur.

Calvin Coolidge is often quoted as saying, “The business of America is business,” although his actual 1925 address was more nuanced than that shorthand suggests. The quotation captures something real about the strong pro-business tradition in American political culture, even if it oversimplifies Coolidge’s argument.

That difference matters with AI. Europe is saying there can be real harms when people are systematically deceived by synthetic media, so certain forms of AI interaction and generated content should be disclosed.

I am reasonably sophisticated about detecting AI-generated material, but if I am not paying attention and I am scrolling through X or some other platform, I can still occasionally be fooled. It might be a cute animal clip, a political video, or something else designed to look plausible.

Political clips are particularly important. If I see a video that makes a politician I already dislike look terrible, I have to be especially careful because confirmation bias makes it easier to accept material that reinforces what I already believe. With increasingly capable generative systems, somebody can fabricate or alter video, audio, or images to make a public figure appear to have done or said something that never happened.

So requiring disclosure for certain categories of AI-generated material is not unreasonable. The technology keeps improving.

A couple of years ago, AI-generated images often contained obvious artifacts. Those problems have diminished rapidly. Systems are increasingly capable of producing images that can be difficult to distinguish from photographs without close inspection or provenance information.

There have also been informal benchmark-style prompts that people use to track improvements in image-generation systems, including prompts involving animals and other subjects that historically exposed anatomical, spatial, or compositional errors. As the models improve, those formerly difficult examples become less useful because the systems learn to produce increasingly convincing results.

The prompt was something like an otter riding on a passenger jet, sitting in its seat and typing on a computer. A couple of years ago, you could put that into an image generator and get something vaguely recognizable, but the details would often be wrong. The animal’s paws might be malformed, the passenger compartment might not make sense, the airplane window might have the wrong shape, and the computer, tray table, and surrounding geometry could all be distorted.

Then, within months, the results became dramatically better. You could get a convincing image of an otter sitting on an airplane and typing on a computer.

More recently, the same general idea was apparently turned into an entire generated video sequence. Instead of simply showing the otter typing, the system produced multiple shots and changed camera angles. It showed what the otter was typing, shifted to another location, and introduced a team of military-style otters moving through an underground utility tunnel. They reached a locked door, while the otter on the plane appeared to be remotely working on the problem. The lock opened, and the team moved through.

The important point is not the particular otters. It is that a relatively simple prompt can now produce something resembling a short cinematic sequence, with multiple shots, recurring characters, implied causality, and a rudimentary narrative. That represents a substantial increase in generative-video capability over a short period.

So, given how quickly the technology is improving, people should have some way of knowing whether what they are looking at is synthetic.

Unless you are in America, where we have historically been somewhat more willing to let people make money by fooling other people.

Thoughts on that? You also mentioned coding agents.

Jacobsen: They are becoming an important area of competition among Meta, OpenAI, Anthropic, Google, and other companies.

AI companies are also investing more heavily in their own semiconductor capabilities while continuing to rely on outside suppliers and cloud infrastructure. Anthropic, for example, announced in August 2026 that it was building an internal chip-design team, while still planning to use hardware and infrastructure from AWS, Google, NVIDIA, and AMD. Meta is similarly expanding its MTIA custom-silicon program while maintaining partnerships with NVIDIA, AMD, AWS, Arm, Broadcom, and others.

It looks like a form of infrastructure diversification. Companies do not want their entire AI strategy to depend on one chip architecture, one supplier, or one cloud provider. That can reduce exposure to shortages, supply-chain disruptions, pricing pressure, and limitations associated with a particular kind of hardware.

Rosner: Right. There is also an opportunity to optimize entire computing systems around particular workloads instead of treating every processor as a generic interchangeable component.

Current AI data centers consume enormous amounts of electricity, generate substantial heat, and, depending on the cooling system, can consume significant amounts of water. As AI infrastructure expands, you would expect a lot of work on efficiency.

The human brain performs an enormous amount of information processing using roughly the power consumption of a dim light bulb. That does not mean silicon systems can simply imitate the brain’s energy efficiency, because biological and electronic computation work very differently. But it does show that useful computation does not inherently require today’s levels of energy consumption per operation.

AI hardware should become progressively better at producing more computation for each unit of energy, with improvements in chips, memory, interconnects, cooling, algorithms, model architectures, and workload specialization.

There are fundamental physical limits. Landauer’s principle, for instance, establishes a theoretical minimum thermodynamic cost associated with logically irreversible operations such as erasing a bit of information. It is more precise to describe this as a lower bound on information erasure than to say there is a fixed minimum amount of energy required simply to “flip a bit.”

Present computers operate enormously above that theoretical limit, so there is still considerable room for improved efficiency before fundamental thermodynamic limits become the dominant constraint.

Coding creates another set of problems. Finding errors in AI-generated code can sometimes be difficult because a developer may receive a large block of code that they did not construct incrementally themselves.

When a human programmer writes software directly, they often develop some understanding of the program’s structure while building and debugging it. With an AI coding agent, you can say, “Give me code that does this,” and receive hundreds or thousands of lines very quickly.

The output may be mostly correct, but a small number of errors can still matter. The difficulty is that reviewing a large amount of plausible-looking code can impose its own cognitive burden. Human oversight remains necessary, but the volume and apparent quality of AI-generated work can make that oversight increasingly demanding.

That connects to what you have been calling harmonization. The initial technology produces one set of problems, then institutions and engineers develop systems to mitigate them. Those solutions introduce their own second-order problems, which require another round of adaptation.

Mammography is a good example. AI systems can assist radiologists in identifying suspicious areas and, in some studies, improve diagnostic performance. One 2025 study found that radiologists using AI support achieved better overall discrimination than when reading mammograms unaided. Other large studies suggest that carefully designed human-AI screening pathways can improve sensitivity while reducing the number of human reads required.

But the relationship between human and machine is not simply, “AI reads the mammogram and a person checks it.” Human reviewers can develop automation bias, and the optimal workflow depends on how the AI is integrated into screening. If an AI system becomes highly accurate, rare errors can also become psychologically difficult to detect because people may increasingly expect the machine to be correct.

So you end up designing a second-generation system around the interaction between AI and human reviewers, including escalation rules, uncertainty thresholds, independent reads, auditing, and procedures for resolving disagreement.

Jacobsen: That is what harmonization looks like. Each technological capability creates a new layer of practical, institutional, and human problems, followed by another layer of attempted solutions.

Rosner: And your view is that none of this necessarily becomes substantially more apocalyptic than the other large-scale risks humanity already faces?

Jacobsen: Right. Good for today.

Rosner: Thank you for your time, your questions, and your tolerance. I will see you tomorrow, probably around two or three.

Jacobsen: Okay.

Rosner: All right. Thank you.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Authoritative Institutional Statements on the Illegitimacy of Naturopathy

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/07/07

Fifteen major medical organizations and government agencies express concerns about naturopathy, citing insufficient scientific evidence, limited clinical education, inconsistent residency training, inadequate pharmacological preparation, and potential patient safety risks. Their policy statements generally oppose expanded prescribing authority or licensure unless education, evidence, and training meet standards comparable to physician-led medical care.

Thanks for reading! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

  1. American Academy of Family Physicians (AAFP)

Excerpt from Policy:
“Governmental endorsement of naturopaths through licensure will jeopardize the health and safety of patients.”

Source: AAFP Formal Policy on Naturopathic Practice.

  1. American Medical Association (AMA)

Excerpt from Report:
“When all is said and done, the AMA believes that naturopaths lack the education and training necessary to safely diagnose and prescribe medications to patients.”

Source: AMA Scope of Practice Advocacy Report, Across the Nation, the Fight’s On to Protect Physician-Led Care.

  1. Washington State Department of Health

Excerpt from Sunrise Review Draft:
“The proposal does not demonstrate sufficient minimum education and training to safely prescribe Schedule II-V controlled substances.”

Source: Washington State Department of Health (WA DOH), Naturopathic Physician Scope of Practice Sunrise Review Report.

  1. Australian Medical Association

Excerpt from Position Statement:
“The AMA is concerned patients are often insufficiently aware that a majority of complementary and alternative treatments lack adequate scientific evidence for effectiveness. Accessing these treatments without professional medical guidance introduces potential risk to patients.”

Source: Australian Medical Association, Position Statement on Complementary and Alternative Treatments.

  1. U.S. Department of Health, Education, and Welfare (HEW)

Excerpt from Report to Congress:
“Naturopathic theory and practice are not based upon the body of basic knowledge related to health, disease, and health care that has been accepted widely by the scientific community.”

Source: U.S. Department of Health, Education, and Welfare, Independent Practitioners Under Medicare (1968).

  1. American College of Surgeons (ACS)

Excerpt from Policy Brief:
“This approach jeopardizes the safety and quality of healthcare delivered to patients.”

Source: ACS Scope of Practice Statement on Non-Physician Licensure and Expansion.

  1. American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP)

Excerpt from Clinical Report:
“There is currently little evidence on the use of naturopathy in medical conditions in children.”

Source: AAP Clinical Report, Pediatric Integrative Medicine (Pediatrics, Vol. 140, No. 3).

  1. Kansas State Board of Healing Arts

Excerpt from Findings:
“Less than 10% of naturopaths participate in an approved residency. These residencies last for one year, with a lack of standardization across programs.”

Source: Kansas State Board of Healing Arts Report on Naturopathic Education & Clinical Training.

  1. Illinois State Medical Society (ISMS)

Excerpt from Resolution/Policy:
“The mechanism of action and the efficacy of many naturopathic treatment modalities are not scientifically supported.”

Source: ISMS Legislative Advocacy Brief on Naturopathic Scope Expansion.

  1. Florida Medical Association (FMA)

Excerpt from Legislative Report:
“Would legitimize a profession that does not believe in or study modern medicine. It is an egregious and dangerous scope of practice expansion.”

Source: FMA Session Report on House Bill 843 / Senate Bill 898 (Naturopathic Scope).

  1. California Medical Association (CMA)

Excerpt from Advocacy Statement:
“A dangerous expansion of naturopathic scope of practice,” involving concerns about “patient safety and insufficient clinical training.”

Source: CMA Legislative Alert on SB 1106 / AB 2097.

  1. Washington State Medical Association (WSMA)

Excerpt from Testimony:
“A naturopath’s education and training do not include the comprehensive medical and pharmacological background needed to safely prescribe controlled substances.”

Source: WSMA Written Comments on Naturopathic Prescribing Authority (WA Sunrise Review).

  1. Massachusetts Medical Society (MMS)

Excerpt from Statement:
“Licensing won’t protect patients because naturopathy lacks standards for proper care.”

Source: MMS Legislative Testimony on Proposed Naturopathic Licensure.

  1. Kansas Medical Society (KMS)

Excerpt from Policy Position:
“They do not have the breadth and depth of training in these areas to ensure safety.”

Source: KMS Position Statement on Scope of Practice & Non-Physician Prescribing.

  1. Colorado Medical Society (CMS)

Excerpt from Policy Manual:
“The Colorado Medical Society opposes the licensing of naturopaths.”

Source: CMS Policy Manual, Policy RES-09.01 (Scope of Practice: Naturopathy).

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 20: Trump’s Tariffs, Consumer Costs, Border Policy, and Economic Claims

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/07/07

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner examine the economic and political consequences of President Trump’s tariff policies, arguing that consumers ultimately bore higher costs while corporations benefited from tariff refunds. Rosner contends the tariffs weakened job growth, increased household expenses, and are unlikely to withstand legal scrutiny. They also assess claims regarding border security, crime reduction, and declining fentanyl deaths, distinguishing long-term trends from policies they believe can be directly attributed to the administration.

Thanks for reading! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

Rick Rosner: On April 2, 2025, Trump announced sweeping tariffs on imports from nearly every major U.S. trading partner. The list controversially included remote territories such as the uninhabited Heard Island and McDonald Islands. There is no established evidence that artificial intelligence generated the list. Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick denied that AI had been used.

Trump said the tariffs would revive American manufacturing and create jobs. Employment growth subsequently became very weak, although it would be too simplistic to attribute the entire slowdown to tariffs alone. Revised Bureau of Labor Statistics figures show that payroll employment grew by an average of only 15,000 jobs per month in 2025. Employment improved during parts of 2026, including gains of 179,000 in April and 172,000 in May, before slowing to 57,000 in June.

In February 2026, the Supreme Court invalidated a substantial portion of Trump’s tariffs imposed under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act. By the end of July, the government had processed approximately $100 billion in refunds to importers, representing about 60 percent of the roughly $166 billion collected under the invalidated tariffs. Apple reported receiving approximately $2.2 billion.

These refunds are being paid to the importers that legally paid the duties, not automatically to the consumers who may have faced higher prices. Apple has said it plans to reinvest its refund in American manufacturing rather than distribute it directly to customers. Amazon, which received approximately $600 million, has said it will refund customers in the limited cases in which it can identify tariff charges that were passed directly to them.

Tariffs are taxes on imported goods. The importer pays the government, but some portion of the cost may then be absorbed by the importer, passed to other businesses, or passed to consumers through higher prices. It is therefore inaccurate to say that consumers necessarily pay the entire tariff, although economic research indicates that American consumers and businesses bear much of the burden.

Trump’s tariffs were imposed unlawfully under the emergency authority used by the administration. He has since pursued tariffs under other statutory authorities. Those newer measures are being challenged in court, but it would be premature to state as fact that they will also be struck down.

The tariffs have imposed measurable costs on households. Estimates differ according to which tariffs and economic assumptions are included. After the Supreme Court ruling, Yale’s Budget Lab estimated that the remaining tariffs would raise short-term consumer prices by approximately 0.6 percent, costing the average household about $800 in 2025 dollars. Other estimates have placed the annual household burden at approximately $1,000 to $1,400.

The government received tariff revenue while the duties remained in force, but much of the revenue collected under the invalidated emergency tariffs must now be returned to eligible importers. The policy nevertheless imposed administrative costs, disrupted trade, and left consumers with no general mechanism for recovering price increases they may have paid.

This is one way Trump has damaged the economy.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: How many Americans were affected by this?

Rosner: Most households purchase goods whose prices can be influenced directly or indirectly by tariffs. The effect varies considerably according to what a household buys. Lower-income households tend to experience a greater burden as a percentage of their income because they devote more of their budgets to goods rather than services. Yale’s Budget Lab estimated that the tariff burden, measured as a share of income, was roughly three times greater for households in the bottom income decile than for those in the top decile.

Gasoline itself was not uniformly subject to the same tariff treatment as ordinary manufactured imports. Tariffs on steel, aluminum, machinery, and other inputs can raise costs for energy infrastructure, refining, transportation, and construction. However, it would be difficult to isolate how much, if any, of a particular increase in gasoline prices was caused by the tariffs.

It can be defensible to impose costs on households when a policy produces larger or longer-term public benefits. In this case, however, the evidence for broad consumer benefits remains weak.

Jacobsen: We can start with the basics. What has been a positive story from the Trump administration this month?

Rosner: I can answer that because someone told me directly. I said, “Trump has done virtually nothing for Americans.” A Trump supporter replied, “No tax on tips or overtime, border secure, crime down, fentanyl down 80 percent.”

That, according to a Trump supporter, is the list of what he has accomplished.

Trump signed tax provisions allowing eligible workers to deduct certain tip and overtime income. The phrase “no tax” is misleading because these are limited federal income-tax deductions, not complete exemptions from every tax. The deduction for qualified tips is capped at $25,000 annually and phases out at higher incomes. The overtime deduction is capped at $12,500 for an individual or $25,000 for a married couple filing jointly, and it generally applies only to the premium portion of qualifying overtime pay. Payroll taxes may still apply.

The provisions may benefit some workers, but the total effect depends on their income, occupation, reporting practices, and amount of qualifying compensation. It is therefore too early to dismiss the policy as having no effect, but it is also inaccurate to describe all tips and overtime as entirely tax-free.

The border is more secure, at least when measured by unauthorized crossings between ports of entry. Crossings had already begun declining before Trump returned to office, but they fell dramatically after his administration introduced stricter enforcement measures. Border Patrol recorded 7,181 apprehensions along the southwest border in March 2025 and 8,725 in May, levels far below those recorded during the peak years of the Biden administration.

Of everything Trump has done, this is probably the issue on which his supporters can make their strongest empirical argument. The border has not literally been “shut down,” but unauthorized crossings have fallen to historically low levels. Whether the enforcement methods are lawful, humane, or proportionate is a separate question.

Crime is down. However, the decline did not begin with Trump’s second administration. FBI data show that violent crime fell by an estimated 4.5 percent in 2024, including a 14.9 percent decline in murder, while Biden was still president. Preliminary FBI figures indicate that violent crime then fell by a further 9.3 percent in 2025. Trump can reasonably claim that crime continued to fall during his presidency, but he cannot credibly claim sole responsibility for a decline that was already underway.

The claim that street crime has declined primarily because people remain at home, use the Internet, and carry less cash is speculative. Those factors may affect certain offences, particularly robbery, but crime trends are influenced by many conditions, including demographics, policing, incarceration, economic conditions, drug markets, firearm availability, social services, and changes in reporting.

Crime rose sharply during the COVID-19 period, particularly homicide, but researchers have not identified a single cause. The subsequent decline began before Trump returned to office and continued during his administration. He is therefore benefiting politically from a trend that he did not initiate.

Fentanyl is not “down 80 percent” under the most relevant national measure. According to figures cited by the White House, deaths involving synthetic opioids, principally fentanyl, declined by approximately 22 percent from 2024 to 2025, from 48,913 to 38,084. Total overdose deaths declined by approximately 14 percent. The fall in overdose mortality began before Trump returned to office, so attributing the entire decline to his administration would also be misleading.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 19: Terminal Lucidity, AI Mathematics, and the Future of Scientific Discovery

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/08/06

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner examine terminal lucidity, paradoxical lucidity, and speculative neurological mechanisms involving contextual and inhibitory coding in the brain. They also discuss OpenAI’s reported mathematical breakthroughs, AI-assisted proof generation, recursive self-correction, high-throughput scientific discovery, and the evolving relationship between artificial intelligence and human researchers. Rosner reflects on AI’s strengths, limitations, and future potential while encouraging Jacobsen to consider traditional publishing for his extensive body of work.

Rick Rosner: I’ve got this other thing, which is terminal lucidity. I read an article about it a couple of weeks ago. It’s a reported phenomenon in which some people with advanced dementia unexpectedly regain clarity or the ability to communicate shortly before death. They may not have spoken coherently in months, and then suddenly they start talking again. They know where they are, they’re able to say goodbye, and they appear to understand their situation.

They might be lucid for 15 minutes, an hour, or a couple of hours, and then die within hours or days. Researchers sometimes distinguish terminal lucidity, meaning unusual clarity near death, from paradoxical lucidity, meaning an unexpected lucid episode in somebody with severe neurological impairment. The phenomenon has been documented through caregiver and healthcare-worker reports, but its frequency and biological mechanism remain uncertain.

One theory about this is that it may involve disinhibition in the brain. It also seems superficially similar to reports of a person’s life flashing before their eyes during a near-death experience. But we don’t know whether those two phenomena have the same mechanism.

I think a possible explanation is that the brain relies on inhibition in order to function well. Here, let me take a detour.

The brain appears to represent information through distributed patterns of neural activity, sometimes described as population or combinatorial coding. It’s not usually the case that every neuron is assigned one specific thing, like, “When this neuron fires, you think of an orange.” It’s more that patterns of neurons firing together represent things, which lets the brain encode much more information.

But I think terminal lucidity and reports of your life flashing before your eyes may also imply something like contextual coding. The same pattern of neural activity could contribute to different meanings depending on what you’re sensing, remembering, or doing at the time. Under normal circumstances, the brain constrains the landscape of possible thoughts. Based on what you’re experiencing, it makes some interpretations and pathways more likely than others.

So it’s not just combinatorial coding. It’s also contextual coding. A pattern of neurons firing could potentially contribute to a bunch of different things, but the brain interprets that pattern within the context of what you’re experiencing.

My speculation is that, when a person’s brain is breaking down for good and they’re about to check out, some of the normal inhibitory controls may weaken. The brain may briefly enter an unusual state in which previously inaccessible pathways become available, allowing a temporary return of communication or lucidity.

That is only a hypothesis. Researchers do not yet have an established neurological explanation for terminal or paradoxical lucidity.

The same kind of loss of normal constraint might also contribute to the feeling that your whole life is flashing before your eyes. Without the brain’s usual filtering and contextual limits, memories or associations might arise very rapidly. There is evidence that life-review experiences occur in some near-death reports, but there is not enough evidence to say that people literally think every thought they have ever had, or that disinhibition is the cause.

That kind of unconstrained mental activity would obviously be bad in everyday life. You wouldn’t want to be driving and suddenly think every thought you’ve ever thought.

Every memory you’ve ever had. That doesn’t lead to safe driving. But in the context of a brain that’s about to go down, it kind of makes sense.

The deal with brains is that our brains are the product of billions of years of evolution. The brain is going to take every informational shortcut it can. Any adaptation that increases the amount of information the brain can process and retain, while also increasing the accuracy and precision of thought, could be favoured by evolution. Any way that the brain can become more efficient, if it’s biologically possible and advantageous, may evolve.

So it makes sense that the brain has a ton of tricks for maximizing information. One of those may involve inhibitory coding.

Jacobsen: Next item: OpenAI has announced results that resolve or make substantial progress on ten longstanding problems. These include discoveries that mathematicians had conjectured might exist but had not previously established, such as the construction of non-sofic groups.

This could represent a turning point in mathematical discovery by artificial intelligence. The work used an internal version of Astra, OpenAI’s next major model, which has not yet been released to the public. According to OpenAI, it produced mathematical arguments addressing problems in areas including group theory, geometry, coding theory, quantum complexity, and extremal combinatorics. The arguments were then prepared as manuscripts by humans working with the model and formalized in Lean certificates.

This means that an artificial-intelligence system can contribute original results to the sum of human mathematical knowledge. Each discovery can also open more advanced problems because the results become stepping stones.

If you iterate that process, artificial intelligence specialized in this kind of work, such as Astra and whatever comes after it, could begin building its own steps along paths of scientific and mathematical discovery. It may explore directions outside established human habits and biases.

It will still inherit some human biases from its training data, architecture, and the problems people choose to give it. But it may also pursue approaches that are not constrained by human memory, speed, attention, or intuition in the same ways.

Rosner: I think I have an analogy, but I don’t know enough about how this works.

I’ve been watching some of this. Chris Cole and, particularly, Dean Inada have been working with high-level AI systems on intersecting-cube problems. There’s a famous problem, to the extent that any of these problems are famous, from Ronald Hoeflin’s Mega Test. It asks for the maximum number of separate regions that can be created by three interpenetrating cubes.

Inada, Cole, and some other people have been poking at versions of this problem involving even greater numbers of cubes with the help of AI. It’s a brutal family of problems because even graphing or picturing the configurations is difficult. I assume something similar applies across many areas of mathematics.

Along with good results, AI will also confidently present nonsense results. So you need competent mathematicians to work through what AI presents.

Jacobsen: I would add that people talk about recursive self-improvement, but that’s almost a buzz phrase at this point. For these mathematical problems, logical proofs, and so on, the work takes place in a world of symbols and abstractions. What’s needed first is something more like recursive self-correction, with systems checking their reasoning, identifying errors, and imposing boundaries on different dimensions of analysis.

That’s a whole other stage of development. Terence Tao has described several levels of interaction between mathematicians and AI, ranging from basic assistance to increasingly autonomous mathematical research. Current systems can perform some lower- and intermediate-level tasks, but they do not reliably carry out the entire process of choosing important problems, developing concepts, verifying results, and communicating them without substantial human guidance.

The work being done across different domains, including language, mathematics, and adaptation to real-world environments, is the next major area of integration. Once that is tied to formal proof systems, and once a lot of the substantial kinks are worked out, you may get something more akin to autonomous scientific discovery.

Rosner: In a more colloquial sense, what you’re doing when you work with AI, apparently, and again, I’m not Terence Tao, I don’t know shit, is giving AI shit.

One way of working is to set up several AI agents and have them compete with or critique one another. An AI generates a result, and then you tell it, “I think your result sucks. Take another look and tell me how it might suck or be wrong.” Or you give the result to another instance of the model and say, “Here’s what we got. Check it.”

So you’re setting AI against itself and having it compete with itself. The critiques can come from humans, other AI systems, or formal proof-checking software. That can improve reliability, but it still doesn’t guarantee that the answer is correct.

Before you get to that, you’ve got the brute-force approach, which preceded AI but can also be used with AI. Take drug testing. In the 1950s, somebody might get an idea, look at the chemistry of a disease, and say, “Huh, I wonder whether this compound would work against this disease.”

More recently, with robotic systems manipulating pipettes, you can test enormous libraries of compounds. You might say, “We have a thousand substances. We don’t have a strong theory about what will kill this microbe or these cells, so we’re going to try all thousand against them.”

That’s brute force. It’s testing many things against many other things. Modern drug discovery usually combines that kind of high-throughput screening with biological theories, computational models, and statistical methods, but the brute-force component is still there.

I assume that, with AI and large datasets, the system can draw on a huge portion of the mathematical literature it was trained on. It doesn’t literally contain every mathematics paper ever written, and it doesn’t necessarily retrieve or understand all of them accurately, but it can connect ideas across an enormous body of material.

Einstein took roughly a decade to move from special relativity toward the completed general theory of relativity. He initially lacked some of the advanced mathematical tools he needed. His friend and former classmate Marcel Grossmann introduced him to tensor calculus and the differential geometry developed by people such as Riemann, Ricci, and Levi-Civita.

It wasn’t that Einstein sat in a café until somebody handed him the right four-by-four matrix. Grossmann helped him identify the mathematical framework needed to describe curved spacetime. General relativity uses the metric tensor, commonly represented as a four-by-four array in four-dimensional spacetime, along with related tensors and differential equations.

What AI can potentially do is be a whole crowd of mathematically knowledgeable friends. It can search across many possible connections, propose tools from different fields, and test large numbers of approaches. In that sense, it can combine broad recall with a kind of guided brute force.

It can try many approaches against many problems. I assume that’s part of why AI is effective at solving some of these problems, but I don’t know. Again, this is a situation where I don’t know shit.

One more thing, though, is that AI may gradually move beyond methods that look mainly like brute-force search, where it finds results by trying huge numbers of possibilities, toward methods that look more like insight. I assume we’re already somewhere along that curve. Current systems can recognize structures, generate useful conjectures, and discover strategies that people didn’t explicitly program into them.

Whether that counts as insight in the human sense is another question. AI has not been shown to be conscious, but you don’t necessarily need consciousness to produce a novel and useful solution. There can also be a search component to what we call insight. A system explores many possibilities, discards most of them, and finds a connection that works.

What you were saying makes me want to offer some advice. All of your adventures seem like they could add up to a great book proposal. You’ve written so many freaking words and conducted so many interviews.

You haven’t really messed with traditional publishing. You’re used to publishing tens of millions of words on your own, but at some point, maybe you move over and try traditional publishing.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 18: Trump, Climate Change, Drone Warfare, and Iran

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/08/05

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner discuss Donald Trump’s declining approval, MAGA conspiracism, antisemitism on X, and the political risks surrounding the next United Nations secretary-general. They also examine Europe’s extreme heat, wildfire and drought pressures, demographic projections, American missile shortages, Ukraine’s drone warfare, and the strategic limits of a possible United States ground campaign against Iran. Rosner contrasts expensive precision weapons with drones and recalls Iraq’s failed invasion of Iran, with lasting consequences.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: So nice to see you again. I’ll say that I am still alive in Kiev. I hope you’re doing well in Los Angeles, and I hope the kiddo and her hubby are doing well in jolly old England as well.

Rick Rosner: I got a wet drive back from Hoover. It’s an upright carpet shampooer rig. It was very cheap. I’ve been cleaning our carpets. We have very old carpets in the house, and they’ve been peed on a lot, mostly by dogs. So that’s what I’ve been doing.

It’s almost exactly 13 weeks until the U.S. midterms. Trump says crazy crap every day. His party is at serious risk of losing the House in the midterms. There’s desperation from him as he tries to figure out ways to fuck with the elections, many of which would face legal challenges, and some of which the courts have thrown out or may throw out. Luckily, he’s dumb, so a lot of his plans to fuck with things do not work.

Anyway, with regard to Trump’s approval, he could go into the midterms with one of the lowest approval ratings of any president at that point in the election cycle since presidential approval polling began. Harry Truman had an approval rating of about 33% around the 1946 midterms, a year after World War II ended. Along with the end of the war came the lifting of many wartime price controls. The government did a ton of controlling domestic prices during the war, and everybody was largely on board with that.

There was meat rationing and gas rationing. Everybody had ration books full of coupons that you would turn in at the grocery store or gas station, showing that you were entitled to this much stuff. Then many of the controls went away. When price controls were lifted in 1946, prices went freaking crazy. Inflation surged and, at its postwar peak, was considerably higher than the inflation that pissed everybody off under Biden.

So Truman’s approval was about 33%. Trump’s approval is currently in the mid-to-high 30s, depending on the poll and polling average. I’ve noticed a pattern in the descent of Trump’s approval. It’s scalloped. Bunting is where you hang up stuff like a popcorn chain on a Christmas tree, or American flag bunting, the long ribbons on the Fourth of July. Bunting has points where it’s anchored. In between the points, there’s a little curve, right? That’s what Trump’s approval does.

On average, it declines, but it declines in a scalloped way. It declines, briefly comes up to a point, then declines again, and swings up to a point every few months. That’s just what it looks like when you look at the chart of his approval.

One reason could be that Trump does something shitty and everybody’s like, “Oh my God.” His approval drops. Then people get used to it, become habituated to the badness, and the decline in approval levels out. People just get used to it, and then it even starts inching back up again. Then he does some crazy crap again, and it goes into another cycle.

Another reason is that some pollsters regularly produce results that are much more favourable to Trump than the broader polling average. If two or three of those Trump-friendly polls all hit at the same time, that’s enough to make his approval jump. So some of it’s artificial. Some of it’s just a cycle of disgust with Trump. But once you see the scallops, it becomes a little easier to predict where he’s going to be. So there you go.

Another thing is that we’ve had 10 years of Trump now. He was elected in 2016. Among the general population, more than one in five American adults experiences some form of mental illness in a given year. Most of those conditions are not spectacular illnesses like schizophrenia. They’re more often conditions such as depression or anxiety.

After 10 years of Trump, I think MAGA has a much higher percentage of people who hold delusion-like or conspiratorial beliefs than the general population. I’m using “delusion-like” politically here, not as a clinical diagnosis. Depending on the question and the poll, substantial percentages of Trump supporters share false beliefs. For instance, many Republicans continue to believe that the 2020 election was rigged or stolen. That does not mean they’re mentally ill. It means they share a political belief that is not supported by the evidence.

A significant minority of MAGA supporters also believe that COVID vaccines commonly kill people. So there are a bunch of false or conspiratorial beliefs widely held within MAGA. You can hold beliefs like that because of your politics, your media environment, or your social group without having a psychiatric disorder.

But I believe, and there really haven’t been decent studies establishing this, that a higher percentage of MAGA supporters may now have actual mental-health problems. I don’t know what the figure would be. Of course, I see the loudest MAGA people on Twitter. That’s where you go to make noise.

But it’s a problem for the country. I’m sure that, on the other end, among the fringiest parts of the left, the rate of mental-health problems or conspiratorial thinking may also be higher than average. But I guess what I’m saying is that, thanks to the pervasive messaging of 24-hour news and social media, more people now appear trapped in distorted information environments than when my dad was my age.

To draw an analogy with postwar Germany, the Allies occupied Germany after the war and carried out denazification. They abolished and outlawed the Nazi Party, removed many Nazis from influential positions, and established procedures intended to distinguish major offenders from nominal members. But that didn’t mean Nazi beliefs immediately disappeared. A considerable number of people privately retained Nazi sympathies after the regime fell.

It’s not that they got fixed and quit believing Nazi shit. They learned to shut up about it, and eventually they got old and died. With MAGA supporters, there’s probably a lot of that shit that cannot easily be fixed.

Before we wrap up, Trump does serious crazy crap, and then he does things like this: over the weekend, he announced that he had won his 43rd club championship. Trump is 80. He said that he won the Senior and Super Senior Club Championships at the Bedminster golf club, which he owns, by shooting a two-under-par 70. That’s his account of it, and the result has not been independently verified.

There’s also footage from a previous round that appears to show one of his caddies moving his ball. Trump has faced longstanding allegations of cheating at golf, although he has denied them. Rick Reilly, a sportswriter, wrote a whole book about the allegations called Commander in Cheat: How Golf Explains Trump.

So he says he has won 43 championships at his clubs. I don’t know, cheater-in-chief. Reilly argues that Trump’s claimed golf record is heavily inflated and that many of his victories have come at courses he owns.

Trump lies insanely. Over the weekend, he also pushed out AI-generated images showing himself as Elvis. It’s crazy crap, large and small. For the most part, his people are just like, “Yeah, that’s Trump being Trump.” But among the more fanatical segment, it’s not merely excused. It’s celebrated as Trump fighting for them and winning.

Jacobsen: The next news item is about the Security Council. It is planning a second informal straw poll on August 21 to narrow the field for the next secretary-general. Former Costa Rican Vice President Rebeca Grynspan emerged as the early front-runner in the first round of voting. She received 10 “encourage” votes, followed by Carolyn Rodrigues-Birkett with nine. Grynspan has Jewish family roots. How do you think conspiracy theorists will take this one?

Rosner: Of course, there’s a whole language of antisemitism on X. You can be a “gnoticer,” spelled G-N-O-T-I-C-E-R. That’s somebody who claims to have “noticed” an alleged Jewish conspiracy to control the world. You can be a “fren,” F-R-E-N, an intentionally misspelled version of “friend.” A “fren” is somebody who is with you in your antisemitism.

Social media has contributed to this. Musk has repeatedly amplified or interacted favourably with white-nationalist and antisemitic accounts and claims, and X has become a much friendlier place for racism, antisemitism, and homophobia. Research has found major gaps in the platform’s enforcement against hateful material, although X’s written policy still prohibits repeated slurs and degrading stereotypes directed at protected groups.

You can report somebody for repeatedly using the N-word, and enforcement can be inconsistent or nonexistent. X may tell you that a post broke its rules without imposing a visible penalty on the account. People used to be suspended and, after repeated violations, kicked off. Now enforcement appears much weaker. I think we’ve talked about that before.

But anyway, on the one hand, there’s the rise of antisemitism. Was it three years ago now…? When Hamas attacked Israel?

Jacobsen: October 7, 2023. So, nearly 34 months ago.

Rosner: In the almost three years since then, Israel has prosecuted the war in Gaza in a brutal fashion, while the Netanyahu government has failed to prevent, and at times has enabled, violent attacks by far-right Israeli settlers against Palestinians in the West Bank.

I hate the name “West Bank” because it’s confusing to people. It means the west bank of the Jordan River. The river forms much of the territory’s eastern boundary.

Anyway, the brutality of Israeli forces and the Netanyahu government’s tolerance of attacks by far-right settlers have legitimately upset many people who know about them, including many American Jews. They have also contributed to a further increase in antisemitism, although criticism of the Israeli government is not itself antisemitic.

So, if the United Nations appoints a Jewish woman as secretary-general, sure, conspiracy theorists will seize on it. But I would assume that, as secretary-general, she would also denounce Israeli policies when warranted. Regardless, I’m sure people will say there’s a conspiracy.

We don’t get a ton of UN news in the United States anymore. Maybe I’m not looking in the right place.

Jacobsen: Europe has been facing severe drought, heat, and wildfires, affecting agriculture and infrastructure across several countries. Romania is even blasting rock formations in the Danube to improve water flow near the Cernavodă nuclear power plant.

Rosner: Europe is getting cooked along with everybody else. My hometown, Boulder, recently reached 104 degrees Fahrenheit, which is a little more than 40 degrees Celsius. That matches Boulder’s recorded all-time high. It’s a little city tucked into the foothills of the Rockies.

In France, thousands of deaths have been associated with recent extreme heat. Europe has also experienced a series of record or near-record temperatures. Along with your country, Canada has had a ton of wildfires, as has the United States. Climate change is fucking with stuff.

It’s a gradual race against time to avoid the most dire consequences. Do the oceans eventually get so shitty that we lose most of the fish? I doubt we’ll lose most fish everywhere. The oceans are enormous. They cover about 71% of the planet. I assume there will still be stretches of ocean where fish can survive, although warming, acidification, deoxygenation, overfishing, and habitat loss could severely reduce marine populations. Coral is in greater danger because warm-water reefs are particularly vulnerable to rising temperatures.

Most of the help is still in the future, and it takes several forms. One is technology, including methods of removing carbon dioxide from the atmosphere. Another is using energy that makes less of a mess than fossil fuels. A third is slower population growth.

For several reasons we’ve talked about, people are having fewer children on average. But the global population is not currently projected by the United Nations to peak in the 2050s. Its latest central projection has the population reaching about 10.3 billion in the mid-2080s and then beginning a gradual decline. Other demographic models project an earlier peak, but there’s still substantial uncertainty.

And instead of peaking at 11 billion around 2100, the latest United Nations projection has the population peaking at about 10.3 billion in the mid-2080s. That’s hundreds of millions fewer people than earlier projections anticipated, which is a big deal. But the mid-2080s are still about 60 years away.

Things will get shittier over the next couple of decades. But there’s some reason for optimism that the shittiness will fall well short of any kind of apocalypse. Daily life will look somewhat the same.

I mean, on any given day, your life in 2038 may not look that different from your life now. But over the course of a year, there may be more misery. In Los Angeles, we had massive fires, which happen periodically, and we almost had to evacuate. So you may have events like that, where you have to run away from a fire.

Over the past couple of weeks, it got really hot in Los Angeles. Now that I’m a senior, I’m 66, both Carole and I had medical complaints that were unprecedented for us and seemed to be related to the heat. My mouth broke out in what looked like canker sores. My mouth got really fucked up. It may be that I’m not as tolerant of heat and dehydration as I used to be.

Carol got a super-killer, non-migraine headache. So, if we continue to live in Los Angeles, we can look forward to having more days when we have to protect ourselves from extreme heat. But that’s different from some kind of Mad Max shit where the government falls apart altogether because of climate change.

Jacobsen: Next news item. The United States has reportedly used virtually all of its available long-range precision missiles of two types during the war with Iran: the Army Tactical Missile System, or ATACMS, and the newer Precision Strike Missile, or PrSM. These long-range munitions cost roughly $1 million or more apiece, depending on the missile and how the cost is calculated, and they’re important parts of the American arsenal. Some other precision missiles, such as Tomahawks, cost several million dollars each.

President Trump is quoted as saying, “Our defense companies are, at this moment, making more munitions than they ever made before, in addition to expanding their plants and equipment at record levels.” Yeah, but it will still take years to rebuild some of the depleted stocks.

I just saw this, and it makes sense. So you’re in Ukraine, which is probably one of the world’s most experienced war-fighting nations right now, right?

Rosner: Yeah. Ukraine’s war effort is heavily drone-based. Ukraine manufactures millions of drones annually and deploys thousands of them every day against Russian forces. Ukrainian officials say that Russia has recently been suffering roughly 30,000 to 35,000 casualties a month, although battlefield casualty figures are difficult to verify independently. That’s around a thousand Russian troops killed or wounded each day. The Ukrainian government has announced a goal of raising Russian losses to 50,000 a month, not 50,000 a day.

This has implications for the United States in Iran. This kind of warfare would make a large American ground invasion of Iran extraordinarily difficult. So far, the United States has been fighting Iran primarily from the air, using missiles and aircraft. But the campaign has not forced Iran to accept the objectives Trump set when the war began.

The only way to compel Iran through direct military occupation might be to put a huge number of boots on the ground, not a small number. Estimates vary, but some analysts have suggested that a full-scale invasion and occupation could require somewhere between 300,000 and 500,000 troops. There are no public indications that the United States is preparing an invasion on that scale.

Because Iran has developed extensive drone and missile capabilities, American troops on the ground would be exposed to some of the same kinds of threats that Russian forces face in Ukraine. That does not mean the situations are identical, but drones would make any ground campaign much more dangerous.

Even Trump probably isn’t crazy enough to mobilize for a full ground war against Iran. So we’re limited. I don’t know what would happen if the United States shifted more heavily toward drone technology instead of relying so much on extremely expensive missiles.

But you need to be relatively close for many kinds of drones. One reason Ukraine can use so many of them is that Russia has invaded Ukraine, so the opposing forces are right there. The United States is fighting Iran from a distance. I don’t know whether the United States could swarm Iran with short-range drones launched from bases 50, 100, or 200 miles away. Longer-range drones exist, obviously, but they have different costs, payloads, and vulnerabilities.

So maybe the Ukrainian model wouldn’t transfer neatly to Iran because the United States isn’t physically positioned along an Iranian front line.

One more thing. We’ve talked about this. In 1980, Iraq invaded Iran with a force of roughly 200,000 troops, supported by large numbers of tanks and aircraft. The war did not last six years. It lasted nearly eight, until 1988, and ended without Iraq overthrowing the Iranian government or achieving a decisive victory.

So even invading Iran with hundreds of thousands of troops, before modern drone technology, didn’t cause the Iranian regime to tip over. We’re stuck. We’re probably not going to force Iran to change its policies through air strikes alone, and a ground invasion would be enormously costly and uncertain.

Iran also has major oil-export facilities on Kharg Island, off its coast. Kharg is primarily an export terminal, not a giant refinery. Striking it could badly disrupt Iranian oil exports and further damage the world’s oil supply. Iran’s major refineries, including Abadan, are located elsewhere. I don’t know whether Trump has avoided Kharg Island for precisely that reason, but destroying its facilities could have major consequences for global energy markets.

I don’t think even that would change Iran’s behaviour or its unwillingness to negotiate.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 16: Trump, ICE Detention, Military Culture, and Political Violence

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/07/19

Scott Douglas Jacobsen interviews Rick Rosner about American governance, military culture, immigration detention, media ownership, autonomous vehicles, and political violence. Rosner criticizes testosterone-centred military policy as misplaced in drone warfare, condemns alleged abuses and rising deaths in ICE custody, questions FCC deregulation, and distinguishes driver error from automated-system failure. They also discuss democratic accountability, evidentiary standards, constitutional protections for non-citizens, and the danger of selectively defining terrorism to serve partisan political objectives in public policy.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Would you rather be hirsute or largely hairless in terms of your body, not your head?

Rick Rosner: I would rather have hair on my head, but you are not asking about that. I am not very hairy, especially for a Jewish fellow, and I kind of like it that way. I do not need a pelt.

Jacobsen: Some things you say are funny. This is why you ended up falling into the right career. Your first ten years after high school were spent living creatively, and then you got it right by focusing on that. Carole was probably helpful, too. You found a way to do creative work while having a relatively normal life.

Rosner: Yes, though it has made me lazy in the second half of my life, which is not necessarily the worst thing. I have not taken as many risks in later years.

Jacobsen: Do you think you should?

Rosner: In some ways.

What else? The current leaders of our country continue to be absolute dipshits. Pete Hegseth, the Secretary of War, is promoting what he calls a “High-T Department of War.” The administration has also restricted women’s participation in some combat roles and has emphasized supposedly gender-neutral combat standards that are based on male physical benchmarks.

Hegseth has announced that service members aged 30 and older will receive annual screening for testosterone deficiency as part of their routine health assessments. Younger service members may request testing. Treatment is supposed to be voluntary and aimed at correcting a diagnosed deficiency, rather than increasing testosterone beyond normal clinical levels. The available descriptions do not make clear how the policy will apply to women.

This is one more wrongheaded idea from our jackass secretary of war. There can be legitimate medical reasons to test for and treat testosterone deficiency. But presenting testosterone as a broad measure of military effectiveness risks confusing medical care with a macho theory of combat readiness.

The most technologically advanced conventional war being fought right now is probably the Russia-Ukraine war, not counting cyberwarfare among the major powers, with everybody hacking and propagandizing against everybody else. Ukraine has become a global leader in the large-scale production and battlefield use of military drones. Its forces use drones for reconnaissance, artillery targeting, direct attacks, deep strikes, logistics, and attacks on energy infrastructure.

The wars involving Israel, Gaza, Lebanon, and Iran also involve advanced surveillance, precision weapons, drones, missile defence, electronic warfare, and cyber capabilities. However, Ukraine has become the clearest laboratory for mass, relatively inexpensive drone warfare against a large conventional military.

Hegseth and Trump have also pushed for a huge expansion in military spending. The exact increase depends on which budget measure and fiscal year you are comparing. The proposed fiscal year 2027 Pentagon budget exceeds $1 trillion and represents an increase of roughly $234 billion over the previous year, not a straightforward 50 percent increase.

The United States already spends far more on its military than any other country. However, saying that it spends as much as the next 16 countries combined, or that a further increase would exceed the spending of all other countries combined, requires a specific dataset and accounting method. Those comparisons vary according to exchange rates, purchasing power, whether veterans’ programs and nuclear weapons are included, and which countries are counted.

The broader point still stands. The United States can spend staggering amounts of money while remaining tied to slow procurement systems and extremely expensive weapons platforms. Ukraine has had to innovate rapidly, producing and adapting drones at an enormous scale under battlefield pressure. Public figures on daily production and deployment fluctuate, and the figure of 19,000 Ukrainian drones produced every day is not sufficiently established to state as fact. According to Ukrainian estimates, Russia has planned production of on the order of 20,000 FPV drones per day in 2026.

Ukraine has reported inflicting tens of thousands of Russian casualties in some recent months, with drones allegedly responsible for a very large proportion of them. These are wartime claims and should be treated cautiously, but independent analysis agrees that drones now cause a substantial share of battlefield casualties. It would be misleading to directly link a fixed daily casualty figure to a fixed number of drones deployed.

To get back to Hegseth and testosterone, you do not need extraordinarily high testosterone to guide drones, interpret surveillance data, operate electronic systems, manage logistics, or make sound strategic decisions.

There are all these clips of Hegseth bench-pressing heavy weights, doing push-ups, and performing other exercises. That is fine. It is good to be in shape, especially if you are in the military. However, testosterone-replacement therapy for a clinically verified deficiency is not the same thing as taking anabolic steroids to become more aggressive or manly. Presenting high testosterone as a general solution to military readiness is simplistic, medically questionable, and somewhat detached from the actual demands of modern warfare.

It is jackassery. It is like America’s worst frat boy is running the Department of War. In fact, he may be America’s worst frat boy. There have been reports and allegations by former colleagues about Hegseth drinking excessively in professional settings. He also paid $50,000 to a woman who accused him of sexually assaulting her after a 2017 event at a California hotel. Hegseth has said the encounter was consensual, denied wrongdoing, and was not criminally charged. So, it is fair to describe the accusation and settlement, but not to state the alleged assault as a fact.

He is a dude-bro jerk, right? Anyway, enough about him.

Jacobsen: According to Human Rights Watch and the ACLU, detainees at an ICE facility in Texas said that they were beaten and abused, denied adequate medical care, and prevented from contacting family members and lawyers. The Department of Homeland Security denies those allegations and says detainees receive appropriate care and access to communication. What do you make of this apparent impunity at the Texas facility?

Rosner: The Constitution says the government is not supposed to inflict cruel and unusual punishment. Strictly speaking, the Eighth Amendment applies most directly to people who have been convicted of crimes. Immigration detainees are held under civil law, so their protection against abusive treatment comes mainly through the Fifth Amendment’s Due Process Clause, along with federal statutes and other constitutional protections.

Those rights do not belong only to US citizens. Many fundamental constitutional protections apply to persons within the United States, including non-citizens, although certain political rights, such as voting in federal elections, are reserved for citizens.

If the allegations are true, then the guards and administrators involved are acting like dickheads. They are being abusive, unprofessional, poorly supervised, or all three. They may also be operating with a belief that they will not face meaningful consequences.

To some extent, the cruelty appears to be the point. Awful people are in charge, and too many of them do not live up to the better angels of what being an American is supposed to mean.

This shit will continue until the people opposing Trump and his supporters gain enough political and legal leverage to stop it.

The midterm elections are on November 3, 2026, which is about 111 days from the time we are having this conversation. Trump is scheduled to give a speech about election security and alleged foreign interference. He is expected to revive claims about vulnerabilities in the voting system and the 2020 election.

He is going to make all sorts of announcements about preventing fraud. A lot of this will be bullshit. US elections are not perfectly administered because no large system is perfect, but Trump’s sweeping claims about thousands of fraudulent ballots changing the 2020 result were repeatedly investigated and were not substantiated.

He cannot accept that he lost in 2020, even though he was president during one of the worst years in recent US history and handled major parts of it badly. It is entirely understandable that millions of people voted against him.

The Constitution gives states the initial responsibility for setting the times, places, and manner of congressional elections, while Congress has the authority to alter those rules. State and local officials administer most elections. The president does not possess a general unilateral power to rewrite election procedures.

We assume Trump will say that Georgia’s two Democratic senators, or other Democratic officials, were elected fraudulently. Whatever particular claims he makes will have to be evaluated against evidence. His broad past claims of outcome-changing fraud have not held up.

The courts may block some of the measures he announces. Others may fall within powers held by federal agencies or Congress, particularly after recent changes in the law governing presidential control of independent agencies. So, it is too sweeping to say that everything he attempts will automatically be struck down.

But that does not mean he will not try a ton of things during the next four months to make voting harder for people likely to oppose him and his policies.

Jacobsen: An NTSB report says that a Tesla driver accelerated into a house in a fatal crash in Texas.

Rosner: I do not draw too many conclusions from an individual accident. We are a large country with hundreds of millions of vehicles, and crashes happen for many different reasons.

In this particular case, the preliminary account says the driver had activated Tesla’s driver-assistance system but then fully depressed the accelerator, overriding it and accelerating to more than 70 miles per hour in a 30-mile-per-hour residential area. So, this does not appear to be a simple case of the car autonomously deciding to accelerate into a house.

Tesla has Autopilot and Full Self-Driving, or FSD, capabilities to some extent, but the current consumer system is still supervised driver assistance, not a fully autonomous driving system. Tesla says the driver remains responsible for the vehicle’s speed and control at all times. People will misuse that technology because some people are fucking idiots. The system itself can also make mistakes, and both driver behaviour and system design need scrutiny when accidents occur.

Alternatively, you can simply have someone manually driving a Tesla who fucks up, as drivers of every other brand do.

Waymo’s driverless taxis operate in Los Angeles and several other US cities. They still have crashes, but available studies indicate substantially lower injury-related crash rates than comparable human-driven vehicles in the same operating environments. One peer-reviewed comparison found about an 80 percent lower rate of injury-reported crashes, not precisely one-ninth the crash rate in every category.

They appear to be pretty fucking safe in the places and conditions where they are currently permitted to operate. On the other hand, they can be frustrating because they drive cautiously, follow programmed rules closely, and sometimes behave in ways that seem overly hesitant to human passengers and other drivers.

If you are behind a Waymo waiting for it to turn left, you might wait a long time because Waymo’s standard for what counts as a safe left turn may be much more stringent than yours.

Jacobsen: Another item in the news: On July 15, FCC Chair Brendan Carr said that the agency would vote on August 6 to repeal the national television ownership cap, which ordinarily prevents one company’s stations from reaching more than 39 percent of US television households. The FCC proposes replacing the cap with a case-by-case review of transactions exceeding 39 percent, approving them only when the agency finds they serve the public interest. The rule has roots in ownership restrictions established decades ago, but the present 39 percent limit dates to congressional action in 2004, so calling it an 85-year-old 39 percent rule would not be precise.

Rosner: Yes. He is a bad guy.

Jacobsen: That raises the question: What does “the public interest” mean to him in this context?

Rosner: He is a bad guy. He was involved in Project 2025, and I suspect that, if the rule is rescinded, the FCC will permit further consolidation by companies whose politics align with the administration.

Sinclair Broadcast Group owns or operates many local television stations and has a documented history of requiring stations to air centrally produced material, including political commentary and identical promotional scripts read by local anchors. Sinclair’s programming has often been described as conservative, although it would be too simple to say that every local Sinclair newsroom merely broadcasts MAGA propaganda.

What Brendan Carr calls the public interest appears to include allowing traditional broadcasters to grow so they can compete with national streaming and technology platforms. Critics argue that this would reduce local ownership, competition, and viewpoint diversity. Carr’s stated justification is not simply “Let us promote MAGA,” even though I think his broader political agenda aligns with Trump’s.

He is one of Trump’s cavalcade of shitty people.

Most of these people will not suffer serious personal consequences. If we are lucky and work hard, Democrats may regain a majority in the House. They have a chance in the Senate. In 2028, perhaps a Democrat will win the White House. However, even if all that happens, many of the dickheads who did terrible shit under Trump may never face prosecution or any comparable punishment.

That includes officials responsible for immigration detention and enforcement policies under which many people have died. But we have to distinguish among deaths in ICE custody, deaths during enforcement operations, and killings legally attributable to individual agents.

Human Rights Watch reported that 52 people died in ICE custody during the first 500 days of Trump’s second administration, through June 4, 2026. By July 15, at least 22 people had reportedly died in ICE custody during 2026 alone. Separately, people have been killed or have died during immigration-enforcement encounters outside detention. Those categories should not be lumped together as though ICE officers personally killed every person counted.

I do not assume that senior officials or individual officers will be prosecuted. Criminal liability requires evidence about a person’s conduct, state of mind, legal duties, and causal responsibility. It is not accurate to say that agency leaders are probably guilty of manslaughter merely because deaths occurred under policies they administered.

The more likely consequences are political defeat, dismissal, civil litigation, administrative investigation, or congressional scrutiny. Some officials may lose their federal jobs and then go into private industry or lobbying for $350,000 a year. That is often how Washington dispenses punishment: with a better-paying job and a tasteful biography.

Stephen Miller should face rigorous investigation and political accountability for policies that may have foreseeably exposed people to abuse, deprivation, or death. But whether he could properly be criminally prosecuted would depend on evidence establishing a specific offence and his personal legal responsibility. Moral responsibility and criminal culpability are not interchangeable.

You mentioned abuse at an ICE detention facility in Texas. Recent ICE data showed that roughly 71 percent of people in detention had no criminal conviction. That does not necessarily mean they were “innocent” of every legal violation, because some had pending charges, and immigration violations are often civil rather than criminal. It does mean that the large majority had not been convicted of a crime.

A separate analysis of people detained between January 20, 2025, and March 11, 2026, found that about 3 percent had a US conviction for a violent felony, defined in that analysis as homicide, sexual assault, robbery, or assault. That figure does not mean only 3 percent had committed any serious offence, because definitions of “serious” differ, and some detainees had other convictions or pending charges.

So, most people detained by ICE have not been convicted of violent crimes. Many have no criminal convictions at all. That makes abusive detention conditions especially indefensible, but it is more precise than calling every detainee innocent.

I do not expect Stephen Miller to face prosecution merely because the administration changes. That does not mean his conduct should escape investigation or public judgment.

Jacobsen: Next news item. US Secretary of State Marco Rubio is hosting an international conference attended by representatives of at least 65 countries. The event is framed around what the administration calls “far-left political terrorism,” with the stated aim of rallying international cooperation against left-wing movements that it says law enforcement and counterterrorism institutions have overlooked.

They are not necessarily speaking for a settled consensus within the United States or among the participating countries. Counterterrorism assessments recognize threats from multiple ideological directions, including jihadist, racially motivated, anti-government, anti-authority, environmental, and left-wing violent extremists.

Historically, US government and congressional assessments have identified white-supremacist and other racially or ethnically motivated violent extremists, along with anti-government extremists, as among the most persistent or lethal domestic threats. It would be too broad to say that domestic terrorism is primarily “Christian nationalist,” because that label does not neatly cover all white-supremacist, neo-Nazi, militia, sovereign-citizen, anti-government, or religiously motivated violence.

The concern is that the administration may be elevating “far-left terrorism” as a political category while diverting attention from forms of right-wing and racially motivated violence that have caused substantial harm. There is also a civil-liberties risk if vague terrorism labels are applied to lawful protest, political association, or dissent rather than to people planning or committing violence.

Jacobsen: Right-wing extremists have historically been followed by jihadist extremists and other categories of political extremists, depending on the period and the metric. In some datasets, the first category has substantially outstripped the others. What do you make of this international rally?

Rosner: It is more garbage from the Trump administration. Anybody who looks seriously at the historical statistics knows that a large share of political and terrorist violence in the United States has come from the right.

I was going to say three-quarters, but assigning a single percentage is too simplistic because the answer depends on whether you count attacks, plots, deaths, attempted attacks, or a particular span of years. Historically, far-right violence has been more frequent and more lethal than far-left violence in many US datasets. White supremacist extremists have also caused more US terrorist attacks, plots, and deaths since 2020 than any other ideological category in one recent assessment. But in the first part of 2025, left-wing attacks and plots reportedly outnumbered far-right incidents for the first time in more than 30 years, although they rose from a low baseline and remained below the historical levels of far-right and jihadist violence.

So I would not say, “Seventy percent comes from the right,” as though that were a stable law of nature. The larger historical point is that right-wing violence has often posed the greater domestic threat, while jihadist violence has also produced severe mass-casualty attacks. Left-wing violence exists and should be taken seriously, but singling it out as the neglected central danger looks politically selective.

It is fine to focus on political violence. The government should investigate people who plan or commit violence, whatever their ideology. But focusing specifically on “far-left terrorism” while minimizing right-wing and white-supremacist violence is more shit from America’s shittiest administration in living memory.

I was going to say it is the worst administration since the Civil War, but even that comparison gets messy. The Confederacy was not a presidential administration of the United States. It was an insurrectionary government formed by seceding slave states. We have had corrupt, racist, authoritarian, and catastrophically incompetent administrations before, but the modern Republican Party is certainly competing for the title of shittiest major American political party of the modern era.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 15: AI, IQ Tests, the Mega Society, and Machine Intelligence

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/07/17

Scott Douglas Jacobsen interviews Rick Rosner about Mega Society members testing artificial intelligence on difficult IQ-style problems. Rosner says AI increasingly excels at number series through speed, training data, and repeated attempts, yet remains vulnerable to visual patterns, ambiguous rules, and “dirty” problems requiring real-world knowledge. They also examine intelligence testing’s educational and legal purposes, its psychometric limits, declining unaided analytical habits, and whether assessments should measure human competence while using phones and AI tools.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: What is new with the Mega Society and the Noesis guys?

Rick Rosner: I check in with them often. I have been talking back and forth with some people there. They are working with Fable and other AIs to see how good they are at solving IQ-type problems, hard IQ test-type problems. Alternatively, conversely, to see whether they can come up with IQ-type problems that AI has trouble with. I have got to say that I am one of the best solvers of IQ problems in the world, but on many of these problems, AI has me beat now.

Jacobsen: What are they defining as an IQ-type problem? Can you run through that more precisely?

Rosner: The focus, from what I have seen, and I do not know everything they are doing, is number series. The AIs are pretty good with number series. They have been trained on massive amounts of data. If a number series has been published somewhere and was included in their training data, the model may already have encountered it, which is highly helpful. Sometimes it takes them a few tries. AI can confidently be wrong. Even when it comes to math, it will make bad errors, saying, “This is how the series works. You add 45 to this, then you double 45. You add 90 to this, then 180.” Then the actual addition is wrong. You add 45 to 23 and get 150. No, you do not. AI will do that. However, in terms of speed, you can tell AI, “No, you are wrong. Try again.”

It might take me 20 hours of dicking around with a tough problem. On some of the crazy-hard problems, it might take more than that. AI can quickly go through possible approaches. Does AI have the full quiver of techniques a human might have? No, not yet. However, it is effective in the techniques it does have and in its ability to draw on vast amounts of information. Imagine going on a quiz show with an enormous library in your head and being able to search it within seconds. You would do well on that quiz show.

Jacobsen: There are differences between the types of problems artificial intelligence can handle. AI had many successful forms before large language models, but LLMs became especially prominent for their performance in language. Different systems have different architectures, training methods, datasets, iterations, and development timelines. So, their capabilities differ.

Text-based problems are often a strength for language models. Verbal problems may be among the ones they solve most readily, although that does not mean they will solve every difficult verbal problem. The Mega and Titan tests contain verbal, numerical, and spatial problems, so they are not simply verbal tests. Mathematical reasoning has also become a major area of AI development. Spatial reasoning is being studied through multimodal systems, while protein-folding systems such as AlphaFold are specialized models rather than evidence that ordinary LLMs possess general spatial intelligence. How does that apply to these fairly standard categories?

Rosner: The Noesis people have sent me some printouts of AI reports explaining why the systems believe they have solved various problems. From reading these reports, I am not familiar with all sorts of jargon, along with various AI models and iterations. I’m not sure whether they are all LLMs. I’m not aware of the other types they are using. The Noesis guys can work with the AIs to select or configure models with specialties relevant to the problems they are working on.

Text-only LLMs have trouble with visual stuff because they do not directly process images. Multimodal models can process images, but they can still have trouble with visual and spatial reasoning. They cannot necessarily reliably work out angles or geometric relationships. We have talked a lot about one of Koyman’s requisites for being good at solving IQ problems: associative width or breadth. AI systems can have a broad associative reach, but they do not necessarily approach a problem visually as a human solver does.

If you give an AI a hint by saying, “You might have problems with this because the solution requires being able to see,” that might be a big enough clue to point it in the right direction. Even if a text-only AI cannot see the symbols directly, it can reason from a verbal description of their visual characteristics. A multimodal model can inspect the image itself, though that still does not guarantee that it will understand the pattern correctly.

You could put together an elementary series using numbers with holes in them. A series might be 0, 4, 6, 9, 10, 14, 16, 19, and so on, as long as each number contains a closed loop when written in a particular typeface. AI would not necessarily solve that series easily unless you gave it a hint. What I said might apply even to that simple series.

As has been the case since public versions of different AI models became available, the speed at which they seem to be progressing remains shocking, at least to people like me who are not versed in AI at the nuts-and-bolts level.

Jacobsen: Who on the Mega Society team is working on this stuff, who has nuts-and-bolts experience?

Rosner: I do not know. The two guys I know are Chris Cole and Dean Inada. There is also someone named Warner who appears in many of the emails. I do not know whether I know him personally.

Chris and Dean are good at working with this stuff. I expect their knowledge of it is more fully developed than mine in many areas. I have gone the word route rather than the technological or mathematical route. My discipline for learning math and physics has been shitty. I have written millions of words.

I believe these guys have a very strong understanding of what is going on when AI does whatever the fuck it does.

Jacobsen: Earlier in the conversation, you referred to certain areas in which they find that AI has limitations with IQ-type problems. What are those limitations?

Rosner: The limitations are more pronounced when it comes to creating problems. Let me finish this point, and then I will get to the larger point.

Given the size of the datasets on which AIs are trained, AIs might still have difficulty solving certain types of numerical problems. I call at least some of the number series that AI has trouble with “dirty series” because they step outside the realm of pure numbers and into what Chris Cole might call trivia.

There was a well-known IQ-type problem from decades ago that went something like 72, 79, 86, 96, and so on. The answer depended on recognizing the sequence as subway stops along a particular New York City line, rather than deriving it from a purely mathematical rule. You had to recognize that an apparently arbitrary string of numbers referred to something in the real world.

I consider that a dirty problem because it requires you to know some real-world trivia to figure out the pattern. You can defeat AI by stepping outside the expected domain. But it is hard to devise a pure number-series problem that exploits a principle of numbers without going outside the realm of mathematics, and that a capable AI cannot eventually solve.

Then you get into the larger issue of IQ testing. IQ testing is useful for the purposes for which early intelligence tests were developed more than a century ago by Alfred Binet and Théodore Simon. You test children in school to estimate their cognitive development relative to their peers and determine whether they may need specialized educational support.

Enrichment or additional resources in school. That is a very legitimate use of IQ testing. I suppose you could also use it with adults, such as somebody on death row or somebody on trial for a capital crime. You give that person an IQ test, and the score comes out around 65.

Then the defence can say, “This person is accused of committing these murders, but with an IQ of 65, what is the extent of their intellectual disability? How well can they understand right from wrong, assist counsel, or grasp the consequences of their actions? Is it constitutional or fair to execute somebody with substantial intellectual limitations?”

That issue comes up in death penalty cases. In the United States, the Supreme Court has ruled that executing a person with an intellectual disability violates the Eighth Amendment. But an IQ score alone does not settle the issue. Courts are also supposed to consider adaptive functioning and the person’s developmental history. A score of 70 or 75 can be relevant, given the test’s margin of error, but it is not an automatic legal cutoff.

That is another legitimate, fairly conventional use of IQ testing, as opposed to the sporting use of IQ, which is, “Let us see whether we can design a test with a ceiling of 200.”

Jacobsen: Binet found that intelligence develops unevenly with age and that complex abilities, such as judgment, problem-solving, and attention, cannot be measured accurately through simple sensory or reaction-time tests. He and Théodore Simon developed an early scale intended to identify children who might need educational support. The latter concept of mental age compares a child’s performance with the typical performance of children at different chronological ages.

What is especially important, and contrary to some later uses of intelligence testing, is that Binet resisted treating intelligence as a single fixed or purely innate quantity.

Rosner: Look at somebody like Trump, whose mental functioning is often called into question. People sometimes ask, “What do you think Trump’s IQ is?” But the more pertinent question is, “How intelligently does Trump function?” He is not likely to take and publicly release the results of a comprehensive IQ test.

He has taken brief cognitive screening tests, including the Montreal Cognitive Assessment, and has claimed perfect scores. That is not an IQ test. It is designed primarily to screen for possible cognitive impairment, not to measure the full range of intelligence. His physician reported another perfect score in 2026, although public debate about the completeness and transparency of presidential health disclosures has continued.

A further problem with Trump is that he lies and bullshits a lot. He appears mentally lazy. His con-man personality may effectively lower the quality of his thinking because he has bullshitted his way through much of his life. He seems to have a short attention span, limited curiosity, and little patience for reading more than a paragraph.

Some of what is going on with Trump is happening with everybody now because our reading habits and attention spans are changing as we receive information. It is more severe with fucking Trump, but the issue is not simply his underlying intelligence. It is also his apparent refusal to work hard at using whatever intelligence he has.

To get to the larger point, what does it mean to test raw intelligence? You sit a child, or a classroom full of children, down for 45 minutes, give them a bunch of problems, and do not let them use any tools except their brains and a pencil. That tells you something, but it does not tell you everything.

When researchers compare test scores across generations, they have found evidence in several countries that the long-running Flynn effect has slowed, stalled, or reversed on some measures. That does not establish that people are simply “getting dumber.” The pattern varies across countries, age groups, tests, and cognitive domains, and the causes remain debated. Environmental changes, education, test familiarity, health, technology, and other factors may all matter.

Still, there is a legitimate concern that people may be losing some analytical skills when they are forced to think without recourse to their devices. That creates huge educational challenges. High schools, middle schools, and colleges are struggling with declining attention spans, uneven preparation, and the widespread use of AI to do work students are supposed to do themselves.

But it also makes you wonder whether we should test people on how well they function with a fucking phone in their hands, because that is how people function in the real world now. If somebody appears to be a fucking idiot when you take the phone away but is perfectly competent with it in hand, then perhaps the phone has become part of the person’s effective cognitive equipment.

Should we not be developing some testing program that measures people’s competence when working with devices?

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 14: Hats, Smart Glasses, Movie Clichés, Gym Etiquette, and Meryl Streep

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/07/19

Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner discuss hats, hair-loss anxieties, smart glasses, privacy concerns, cinematic clichés, gym etiquette, and acting greatness. Rosner explains why he avoids hats, criticizes camera-equipped eyewear, “chop-chop” dialogue, excessive vomiting, and lovestruck pratfalls, and recalls leaving My Big Fat Greek Wedding. He also condemns smartphone use on occupied gym equipment before naming Meryl Streep as the default choice for greatest actress and noting her record 21 Academy Award acting nominations overall

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Were you ever a big hat person?

Rick Rosner: Hats? No. Hats make me look extra Jewish. You put a hat on my fucking head, and that is what happens.

Also, during the years when I worried about my hair falling out, I did not want a hat rubbing against it. Hats do not ordinarily cause permanent hair loss, but I was concerned that the friction might pull out loose hairs. For decades, I would not even wear a T-shirt because I was afraid that putting it on and taking it off would pull out too much hair.

Hats can also look douchebaggy in modern America. You put on a fedora, douchebag. You put on a newsboy cap, douchebag. You put on a baseball cap, fine. You put on a cowboy hat, in most contexts, fine. Maybe you are keeping the sun off your head. You put on a backward baseball cap, fine in some contexts, although it might look kind of douchebaggy in others.

So, no, I have never been a big hat guy.

Jacobsen: What fad are you glad is gone, other than Google Glass?

Rosner: Well, that is not entirely gone. Smart glasses are back, although many people still consider them douchebaggy. Ray-Ban Meta glasses and several competing products have cameras built into them.

Some people remain concerned that camera-equipped glasses can be used for covert recording or other invasions of privacy. There have been broader concerns about people being recorded without their knowledge, although I do not know how commonly they are used to look up people’s skirts on escalators.

Jacobsen: Is that true?

Rosner: I do not know. It is not a product I am interested in owning at this point.

I cannot think of a major fad. There are some verbal and visual clichés that I dislike when I encounter them on television. There is always some semi-asshole who wants somebody else to move faster and says, “Chop-chop.” I hate that every time.

I also hate the use of vomiting to punctuate a dramatic or comedic moment. There is too much vomiting. I have nothing against vomiting as such, but it is overused in television and movies.

We have discussed how much I hate pratfalls used to indicate that somebody is lovestruck. A character sees somebody for the first time, experiences love at first sight, and immediately trips over something. I hate that bullshit.

Jacobsen: You mentioned that in the context of My Big Fat Greek Wedding, right?

Rosner: Yes. I walked out of the movie at that point. I thought, “I do not like this movie.”

It seemed like a movie made for people who had not seen very many movies before. We were at a multiplex, so I left my wife and went looking for another movie to watch.

Most of the trends that I am glad have ended, or wish would end, are found in television and movies. One real-life trend that I do not expect to disappear is people sitting on gym equipment, using their phones, and not exercising, even when you hint that they should move.

You cannot simply tell people to get the fuck off a machine. You technically can, but I have almost never done it because you might get into trouble, and it probably would not work.

What you can say is, “Excuse me, how many more sets do you have?” That is a polite hint that other people are fucking waiting. However, it does not necessarily get them off the machine or persuade them to stop using their phones.

You may have to ask three times because they are wearing earbuds. Eventually, they will say, “One set,” or “Two sets,” and then immediately return to their phone.

They will not necessarily perform the set promptly and get out of your fucking way, as people were more likely to do before everyone carried a smartphone. So, there you go. I have to wrap up.

Jacobsen: Best actor of all time? Best actress of all time?

Rosner: For best actress, the default answer is Meryl Streep. You do not get much of an argument about that.

Could you make a case for somebody else? Yes, probably. But when people are asked to name the greatest actress of all time, Meryl Streep is often the first person who comes to mind. She also holds the record for the most Academy Award acting nominations, with 21.

A theatre historian might name Sarah Bernhardt or somebody like that. Thank you for your time.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 13: Midterm Elections, Political Messaging, and the Graham Platner Controversy

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/07/12

Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner discuss the approaching U.S. midterm elections, Republican fearmongering about communism, unreliable polling, and Democratic messaging failures. Rosner argues that Democrats should repeatedly emphasize economic inequality and Republican policies benefiting billionaires. They also examine the collapse of Graham Platner’s Senate candidacy following sexual misconduct allegations and controversy over a tattoo resembling a Nazi SS symbol, alongside Democratic concerns about preventing Susan Collins from winning reelection in Maine during the campaign.

Thanks for reading! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Anything new in the political arena?

Rick Rosner: There are roughly four months until the midterm elections. The Republicans’ and Trump’s new fear-based theme is the supposed coming of communism – that electing Democrats will allow communism to ruin the country.

There is a saying often attributed to Lincoln: “You can fool some of the people all of the time and all of the people some of the time.” You can fool MAGA voters all of the time. They will continue to vote for Trump and accept whatever bullshit he feeds them.

I do not know what percentage of independent voters will respond to Trump’s fearmongering. We do not really know what will work in a U.S. election until people vote because much of the electorate does not pay close attention until a few weeks before Election Day, if they pay attention at all.

We therefore do not know what works rhetorically. Surveys may overrepresent people who pay attention. Assholes and lunatics may be overrepresented. Liars might also be overrepresented. It is increasingly difficult to obtain a reliable picture.

At the moment, it appears that people are angrier with Republicans than with Democrats, but we have been fooled by that before. It would help if the Democrats had consistent messages that they repeatedly emphasized.

There are some effective messages available. One is that Republicans are taking your money and giving it to billionaires. People should hear that from Democratic pundits and candidates many times each day because we hear the same messages from Republicans many times a day. Democrats need to learn the technique of hammering the same message home again and again.

Then there is Graham Platner. Several women have accused him of sexual misconduct, and one former girlfriend has accused him of rape while he was intoxicated. Platner has denied the allegation. He has now withdrawn as the Democratic nominee for the U.S. Senate in Maine, allowing the party to select a replacement candidate under state election law.

This is also the candidate who had a tattoo resembling a Totenkopf, or “death’s head,” a skull symbol strongly associated with the Nazi SS. He said that he had obtained the tattoo while serving in the military and had not understood its Nazi association. He later had it covered, although some people did not believe that he had been unaware of its meaning.

In any event, his candidacy became severely compromised. People did not want to reward someone whose reported past conduct may have been as bad as the allegations suggested. Democrats also do not want Republican Senator Susan Collins to be reelected.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 12: Trump, Edgar Allan Poe, IQ Tests, AI, and Dreams

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/07/11

Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner discuss political criminality, compelling historical figures, high-range intelligence testing, artificial intelligence, and the structure of dreams. Rosner identifies Donald Trump as historically corrupt, praises Edgar Allan Poe’s literary and cosmological insights, and examines Richard Feynman’s complicated legacy. He also critiques ultra-high-IQ testing as a hobbyist pursuit vulnerable to AI-assisted cheating, before reflecting on sleep, dream coherence, neural pathways, and the informational patterns underlying consciousness during fragmented cycles of sleep.

Thanks for reading! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: The real stuff, though. Big criminals. Who are the biggest criminals in your country now?

Rick Rosner: I do not know. It is a big country. I am not familiar with every criminal.

In my view, Trump is the most criminal president in history. Beyond that, I do not know. He is just doing… Occasionally, he is distracted by the obligations of office. For instance, he felt that he had to attend this NATO summit. But when he is on his own, he spends much of his time grifting.

Grifting and lying. Not everything awful that he does is illegal, but much of it is certainly contrary to political traditions and established norms. You are just going to get my standard answer on this: he is the worst president in history. Just about everything he does is shitty, and he keeps getting worse. That is not a very interesting answer.

Jacobsen: In your opinion, who is the most interesting person? Not the smartest or the dumbest – someone interesting according to a different metric.

Rosner: Who do I consistently find interesting? Historically, there is a puzzle that I posted on Twitter.

Who am I talking about when I say “possible death through election fraud”? Who am I referring to when I ask, “Why is the universe dark at night? Why is the sky dark at night?” Who do I mean when I say “murder mystery”? Edgar Allan Poe is pretty fucking interesting. He helped establish the modern detective story with one of his short stories.

I think it was The Murders in the Rue Morgue. It is also often regarded as an early example of the locked-room mystery. He also wrote MS. Found in a Bottle.

That story, published in 1833, ends with the narrator placing his manuscript in a bottle and casting it into the sea. Poe did not invent the practice of sending messages in bottles, but his story became a notable literary use of the idea.

He also discussed why the night sky is dark. If the universe were infinite, eternal, static, and evenly filled with stars, then every line of sight should eventually end at the surface of a star.

The entire sky should therefore appear extremely bright. Poe suggested that the darkness could be explained if the universe had existed for only a finite amount of time, meaning that light from sufficiently distant stars had not yet reached us. His discussion anticipated an important part of the modern resolution of Olbers’ paradox, although modern cosmology also accounts for the universe’s expansion and the redshifting of light.

He did a lot of interesting things. He was found delirious and dishevelled in Baltimore on October 3, 1849, which was Election Day. He died in a hospital four days later. The cause of his condition and death remains uncertain.

One theory is that he was a victim of cooping. In this context, cooping was a form of electoral fraud in which gangs abducted men, intoxicated or threatened them, sometimes disguised them, and forced them to vote repeatedly at different polling places.

Because Poe was found on Election Day near a location used for voting, some people have speculated that he was a victim of cooping. However, there is no conclusive evidence that this happened or that electoral violence caused his death. So, Poe was a very interesting guy.

Feynman was also a very interesting guy, with several darker aspects to his public persona and behaviour.

He was jovial and entertaining. He played the bongo drums and became known for opening or circumventing safes and filing cabinets while working at Los Alamos during the Manhattan Project. Some of his accounts of pursuing women have since been widely criticized as sexist, manipulative, and predatory.

He described developing strategies for approaching women and sometimes presented sexual pursuit as a kind of behavioural problem to be solved. Those stories are now viewed much more critically than they were when his memoirs first became popular.

The Manhattan Project also adds a dark dimension to the physicists of that era. Many of them initially believed that developing an atomic bomb was necessary because Nazi Germany might build one first. The project ultimately produced the weapons that the United States dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki, killing large numbers of civilians.

Whether those bombings were militarily necessary, morally justified, or avoidable remains heavily debated. Whatever position one takes, the creation and use of the bombs left the scientists involved with a profound and troubling legacy.

Jacobsen: What do you think were the strengths and weaknesses of high-range intelligence tests such as the Mega Test?

Rosner: The enterprise, in general, exists at a hobbyist level because there is a reason for IQ testing, which is to determine what educational resources somebody might need or whether somebody has an intellectual disability or an intellectual gift. Ultra-high-IQ tests turn it into a kind of weird little sport.

Jacobsen: You think it is a loaded term?

Rosner: It is fine. Some people are more talented than other people, and you do not have to couch it in euphemistic language. Chris Cole is continuing to develop high-end test items, which he understandably finds extremely challenging in the AI era because I am among the best at solving the hardest IQ problems ever put into an ultra-high-IQ test, provided you give me enough time.

But now, fucking AI – with its massive training datasets and its ability to mix and match information from its vast data stores – is much more efficient than I am at solving most high-end problems. It does not need 100, 120, or 200 hours to work through a couple of dozen problems. So, if you are trying to measure human intelligence, it becomes difficult because people can cheat so easily by resorting to AI. We know that while there are people who will play honestly, there are also IQ fraudsters out there.

Let me switch topics. I have been sleeping in two parts. I will go to bed at around 1:00 or 1:30 a.m., get up at 6:15, do an hour of yelling on Pod TV from 7:00 to 8:00, and then go back to bed for a couple of hours. I often wake up from the second sleep session remembering a dream. I do not know whether I dream less during the first session, but I remember dreams from the second session much more frequently.

There are informational conclusions to be drawn from the fact that dreams are comprehensible. Your brain is firing somewhat randomly, but not so randomly that what you experience is merely noise. Somebody could argue that what you experience is just static that washes over your brain and is forgotten instantly because there is nothing meaningful to retain. I do not know whether that is legitimate. It would take a sleep researcher to answer that.

Do we have firing patterns during sleep that would qualify as dreaming, except that we do not remember them because there is nothing coherent to hold on to? That seems like a possibility.

Dreams consist of recognizable situations and images. They may be nonsensical or consist of non sequiturs, but you are still able to recognize what you are picturing as you dream. That means that, in a dream state, your neurons are firing in an ordered pattern to a considerable extent.

If you take individual, moment-to-moment slices of a dream, the world constructed within it generally verges on being coherent. As you string those moments together, however, the narrative becomes progressively less coherent.

There is always a temptation to say something is 80 percent of the way toward something. I think there is even a name for that tendency—the Pareto principle.

Jacobsen: Is that a little like Zipf’s law?

Rosner: Probably. Or consider asking people to name a random number between 1 and 10. A surprising number of people choose 4. Or, if you need a number for a script, 17 shows up a lot. It simply feels more random than many other numbers below 20.

So, let us say that any individual moment in a dream is about 80 percent coherent. As you string those moments together, the percentage of nonsense in the overall narrative increases.

Your brain is still firing in patterns that represent actual things it remembers. It is simply putting those things together in nonsensical ways. The neurons and their relationships are organized so that, when they fire, they tend to follow established pathways. The ball rolling across your mental landscape tends to travel along well-worn paths.

There are informational conclusions to be drawn from that, although I do not know exactly what they are beyond this.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Global Criminalization and Rising Legal Attacks on LGBTQI Rights

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/07/11

Thanks for reading! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

ILGA World notes 65 UN member states criminalize same-sex sexual acts. Seven legally prescribe the death penalty, with five others having an uncertain legal position.

Human Dignity Trust found 66 countries or jurisdictions criminalize LGBT people and 13 jurisdictions have the death penalty imposed/legally possible for consensual same-sex sexual activity. ILGA World research states that the number of states criminalizing consensual same-sex sexual acts rose in 2025 for the first time in almost a decade.

AP News notes more than 30 of Africa’s 54 countries criminalize consensual same-sex sexual acts. At least 63 UN member states restrict expression related to any sexual, gender, or bodily diversity. 61 impose legal barriers on organizations openly advocating for LGBTI rights. Only 18 UN members states allow national legal gender recognition based on self-determination. Only 17 have nationwide bans on conversion practices.

Only 37 UN member states and Taiwan have marriage equality. 54% of LGBTQI surveyed youth by UNESCO in Europe experienced bullying based on gender expression, gender identity, sex characteristics, or sexual orientation. 83% heard negative comments. 67% were the targets. UNAIDS: Men who have had sex with other men – a median of 16% experienced stigma or discrimination. 9.4% avoid healthcare because of stigma/discrimination.

Reuters found more than a dozen African countries pledged the pursuit of new anti-LGBT bills after a Ghana conference. 20 national representatives attended. 18 of the 20 approved a “family values” charter.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 11: Favorite Comedians, Stand-Up Craft, and Comedy as Politics

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/07/07

Scott Douglas Jacobsen asks Rick Rosner about favorite comedians, resurrecting comics, comedy education, and comedians as presidents. Rosner praises Michelle Wolf, Dave Chappelle, Bill Burr, Sarah Silverman, Chris Rock, Richard Pryor, Paul Mooney, and others while reflecting on craft, timing, offensiveness, growth, and cultural change. He argues that figures like Jimmy Kimmel, Stephen Colbert, and Jon Stewart could govern well because intelligence includes choosing competent advisers.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Who was your favorite comedian?

Rick Rosner: There are people I think I like. Michelle Wolf. I like just about everything she does. Chappelle, of course. I have to look at a list. Amy Schumer had some specials that were really good.

Here is a list I am looking at. Bill Burr, I like. Rory Scovel. I listen to stand-ups in my car. Rory Scovel, I do not know. I feel like he was an actor who decided, “Hey, I should try stand-up.” He is great.

Mulaney is great. Anthony Jeselnik is good, though Jeselnik does short hits. His jokes are: he builds a little setup, and then he punchlines out of it. So he does short stuff.

Bert Kreischer is always pleasant. John Mulaney and Nick Kroll, when they do their routine together as two old Jewish lunatics who are the worst performers in showbiz, I like that stuff.

Sarah Silverman is pretty interesting. What I have noticed in thinking about these people is that comedians change. Sometimes they are kick-ass. Sometimes they go in a different direction that I may not like as much as their previous direction.

Sarah Silverman, in the past five years or so, has become kind. She used to be kind of faux mean. She thought it was funny, and it was, to say awful stuff while being cute and looking innocent. Lately, she has been emphasizing not being mean. And she is still funny.

Ali Wong, I liked her early specials. Iliza Shlesinger has painstakingly built a complete set of skills. A lot of stand-ups have to do it ten thousand times. You have to get onstage and do your bits at least a thousand times to get anywhere near competent.

With Shlesinger, you can see how she has built a complete set of skills: timing, voices, all of it. She came up through Last Comic Standing, which is a brutal reality competition.

Wanda Sykes, I have liked some of the stuff she has done. I am just looking at lists here.

Ricky Gervais is often good because he will say terrible stuff. Sandler, I have liked a lot of his movies. Some of his movies seem lazy, but actually, a good movie comedy needs to be loose, which kind of equals lazy. You need room to do fucked-up shit.

Nate Bargatze. Norm Macdonald was great. In his last couple of years, when he was dying, his skills declined a little bit.

I am just looking at lists here. I used to kind of like Louis C.K. Then he took the hit for coercing aspiring female comedians to stand there while he jerked off in front of them. But Chris Rock has been consistently good for years and years.

Oh, Fluffy, Gabriel Iglesias. I thought he was a hack based on nothing. Then I started listening to his stuff, especially his early stuff. Everybody’s early stuff is going to be more obvious and hackier than their more developed stuff, but as he has developed, he has become really funny.

That is plenty of people, but I do not know. Hold on. Now I have the Wikipedia list, and it is way too long to go through. I am missing a lot of people whose bits I am excited to hear when they come up on satellite radio. Who makes me fucking laugh all the time? I do not know. I am leaving a ton of people out.

Jacobsen: If you could resurrect a comic….

Rosner: Make a dead comic alive again?

Jacobsen:They are not unalive.

Rosner: I think it would be interesting to bring Richard Pryor back. Paul Mooney, too. Mooney was both a kind guy and incredibly angry. Paul Mooney was funny, angry, and scathing, but also rooted. He is somebody I knew a little bit personally, and he did not seem to be getting eaten up from inside by all the shit that made him legitimate. I mean, all the shit that legitimately should have made him angry, and did make him angry.

Tracy Morgan is great. Aparna Nancherla makes me smile a lot. Tig Notaro, I did not know she was funny until I started listening to her stuff, which makes sense. How do you know if somebody is funny until you listen to their shit?

Big Jay Oakerson is very filthy and always hits with his stuff.

Jacobsen: Were you ever a Bill Hicks fan?

Rosner: Not really. I kind of missed out on him. My comedy education, my stand-up education, is not as complete as it ought to be.

Jacobsen: Who would you consider to have the most complete comedy education?

Rosner: There is one guy who does a comedy report card as part of his stand-up routine. He does a report card every year. Who is that? I do not know.

But people who are in that world, if you are doing stand-up 350 nights a year, or a thousand gigs over a few years, you are going to know everybody.

Rich Vos, I like his stuff when it comes up on the radio. He is pretty filthy. Not filthy just for the sake of filthiness, but filthy because he can go places where most people do not go.

Some of the Wayanses, too. I do not know which Wayans I am listening to when their shit comes up on the radio. It is probably Marlon, maybe Damon. Unless there are details in the bit that locate it in time, I do not know whether the shit they are saying is from 2007 or from this year.

Though the further back you go, the less likely it is that it is going to be funny now, because the shit changes. If you came up with some brilliant way of presenting your shit, that shit might get tired out over the next 20 years. All this is kind of obvious.

Kumail Nanjiani, I like seeing him whenever he pops up in something. I do not know that his stand-up is exceptionally great. I do not know. That is about it. It is just me looking at this list of 700 people.

Jon Stewart is really good at what he does, which is not exactly stand-up. It is presenting what is going on in an entertaining way. John Oliver, same deal. Kimmel, same deal. Colbert, same freaking deal.

I found Carolla really smart and really fast. I have not listened to him much. He does not pop up that much on satellite radio, and I do not listen to podcasts, so I miss a lot of his shit. Plus, he has become, he would call it libertarian. I would call it hanging out with too many right-wingers.

Nikki Glaser, I like her. But if anybody can take right-wing bullshit and find the nuggets of reasonableness in it, it would be Carolla.

Okay, there you go. That is enough, right? Rachel Feinstein, I like her shit.

Tina Fey does not do much stand-up, though you could say Weekend Update on SNL was a kind of stand-up. And when she and Amy Poehler team up to do the Golden Globes or whatever, that is stand-up. Generally, I like her product. I like the shows she writes, produces, and appears in, except for The Four Seasons, one of her latest shows, which is weirdly comfortable. It seems targeted at people my age. I do not know. It is too cozy.

Rob Delaney, I like his stuff quite a bit. He is one of the people who inspired me to build my homestead on Twitter. If I could have seen the future, I would have built it on Instagram, because Twitter is kind of 1988 Detroit if Detroit had been taken over by Nazis.

There you go.

Jacobsen: If you could nominate a comedian as president, who would it be?

Rosner: Kimmel would do a good job as president. Colbert, Jon Stewart, any of the people who have to digest the daily news and present it. Not Gutfeld, obviously, but any of the mainstream people who got their jobs because of funniness and smartness would learn what it means.

More than half of being president is picking the right people to be around you. Any of the three people I just mentioned would talk to a bunch of experts. They would not go in fucking cold. They would find some kind of consensus on the best person for each job and test them out. If they turned out to suck, then they would get rid of them.

We have generally had presidencies that follow that model. Not every president has had the best objectives or criteria for picking the best people, which can lead to a bunch of shit happening that I do not like.

But Trump is singular as a president for picking people who suck but kiss ass. No president has gone as far with this as Trump has, and it is fucking terrible for the country.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 10: Jimmy Kimmel’s Intelligence, Empathy, and Fact-Checking

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/07/06

Scott Douglas Jacobsen asks Rick Rosner about his greatest year and Jimmy Kimmel’s virtues. Rosner reflects on career success, family, and his undeveloped theory of the universe before praising Kimmel as smart, empathetic, curious, socially generous, and factually rigorous. He highlights Kimmel’s response to tragedy, his son’s heart surgery, his interviewing skill, and his insistence that jokes may bend reality, but factual setups should remain accurate.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: What single year would you count as your greatest year?

Rick Rosner: What single year as my greatest year? I do not know. That is a good question. I was at Kimmel. I was pretty successful at Kimmel for a long time. I have been married to Carole for a very long time, and we seem mostly well suited to each other. I have a kid. I have this theory of the universe that I have failed to develop as thoroughly as I should. But I could argue that it was kind of cool to come up with that. I do not know. Maybe my greatest year is still in the future. Maybe I can still do something awesome.

Jacobsen: What are the virtues of Kimmel?

Rosner: Of what?

Jacobsen: Kimmel.

Rosner: He is a mensch. He is a decent guy. He is wildly smart. I think people mostly realize it now, but where he came from, radio, morning zoo radio, and then The Man Show, hid his smartness for a long time.

He is genuinely interested in people, especially people who do weird stuff. Other talk-show hosts have been criticized for not being the best interviewers. Jimmy is a really good interviewer because he is genuinely interested in people.

My natural tendency, not that I am a talk-show host, is to not be around people if I do not have to be. Kimmel, in his private life, has built places where a bunch of people can gather and hang out with each other, because he likes that shit.

He is known for being an easy crier, but not because he is a baby. It is because he feels genuine sympathy and empathy for people.

When the Las Vegas shooting happened, when that gunman shot hundreds of people at a concert from his window at the Mandalay Bay, that was one of Jimmy’s turning points. He got angry on the air about what had been done to his hometown.

When his kid needed heart surgery, Jimmy realized that he was in such a fortunate position compared to a lot of families whose kids need care. His empathy rose to the surface.

He is quick, mentally quick. There you go. There is a bunch of stuff.

One more thing: I think he has a pretty realistic and informed view of the world. The right wing likes to criticize famous people as out-of-touch elites. Maybe that is true for some people, but famous people, especially if one of the reasons they became famous is that they are smart, are in a position to be pretty well informed about the world. They have the time, the wherewithal, and the curiosity to develop a decently informed view of things.

You hear stories about celebrities who are dicks, or actors who can be dickish. To me, that seems counterproductive. If you are trying to develop your tool as an actor, you need to be able to inhabit emotions convincingly. Why would you cut yourself off from seeing how people work by being a fucking cunt?

So I would say that a lot of the most successful people in entertainment are attuned. They try to be in the world. I do not know if Jimmy could tell you how much a gallon of milk costs, but there is a lot of stuff he can tell you.

It was a little frustrating working for him because he could pull up the facts faster than anybody else. The show began production in 2002, before Google was what it became, but when you were pitching stuff to him, he would sit there with a laptop and pull up the pertinent information faster than anyone. He could fact-check you lickety-split.

In fact, he places great emphasis on the factual accuracy of what is presented on the show. He does not like to bullshit people, except for a joke. If it is the setup of a joke, then it should be factually accurate.

If it is a prank or a punchline, then, yeah, you can depart a little bit from reality for comedic purposes. He always hated being wrong about something, or me being wrong about something. So I would pitch a lot of facts, and sometimes I was wrong, and that was not loved.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 9: Trump, Theology, Ukraine Drones, and America’s Future

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/07/05

Scott Douglas Jacobsen interviews Rick Rosner on America’s uncertain status, Trump’s stubborn approval floor, Vance’s opportunism, Rubio’s relative moral seriousness, Biden’s Afghanistan damage, and Republican messaging insulation. Rosner argues Trump’s Iran conflict and tariffs expose a damaging asymmetry: severe decisions do not break his base because partisan media shields supporters. The discussion frames America as culturally powerful yet politically self-sabotaging, with Democrats vulnerable to socialist scare tactics and poor messaging before the coming midterms season. Interview conducted July 4, 2026.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: What is new in your world?

Rick Rosner: Nothing. Fourth of July.

Jacobsen: Happy America Day?

Rosner: Yeah.

Jacobsen: What is your favourite thing about America?

Rosner: The wildness, the obnoxiousness—but not the unpleasant belligerence. Being the cultural leader of the world and, to some extent, the economic leader of the world. It is a nice position to be in.

Jacobsen: Do you think it will end up like somewhere like near the Aegean Sea, like Rome, Istanbul, or somewhere else?

Rosner: Yeah, and we are doing a lot of work right now to make sure that we become an also-ran country, like London. London is great. London is no longer the leading power in the world. Same as when you mentioned Rome. Rome is awesome, but it is not a leading power. And the people in charge right now—

Jacobsen: You think the United States is run by jackasses, right?

Rosner: Without a doubt.

Jacobsen: How would you compare Trump versus Vance in terms of their capabilities? And versus Rubio, actually, and Witkoff? I am curious about your honest take.

Rosner: Of the three, Rubio is the one you would prefer to be in charge. He has moral qualms. Of the three, Rubio is probably the one who has actual Christian values.

Jacobsen: What do you mean by that?

Rosner: Rubio, to the extent that he can, probably tries to follow the Bible. He was always throwing up Bible quotes, and they seemed hollow before he became Secretary of State. However, now, compared to those other two guys, his beliefs seem sincere.

Vance is an opportunist. It reads as creepy. For him to become president, he would probably have to be propped up even harder than Trump is.

However, the issue I want to talk about is that Trump’s approval has been volatile. Some polls showed a recent bump, but averages still put him underwater, around the high 30s in approval. Even with public dissatisfaction over Iran, inflation, gas prices, slower job growth, and corruption concerns, his approval has not collapsed.

His family has reportedly made more than $2 billion from crypto-related ventures, while investors in those ventures have reportedly lost roughly the same amount. He has obvious age-related political liabilities, and none of this has reduced his approval as much as you might expect.

Jacobsen: What typically reduces someone this entrenched in terms of their approval rating, both within their constituency and outside it?

Rosner: Anyway, what really hurt Biden politically was the withdrawal from Afghanistan. It caused roughly a 10- to 12-point drop in his approval, and he never fully recovered. His numbers continued to decline afterward.

It allowed the right-wing press to cement an image of him as trying to wreck America and as doddering and old. Then the mainstream press covered the controversies and, to some extent, amplified those narratives. Meanwhile, Biden stayed in the White House, trying to minimize the damage, when he probably should have been out there making his case more aggressively.

Moreover, you have an asymmetry: Trump has done a bunch of pretty bad things. You could argue about which is worse: withdrawing from Afghanistan or getting into a conflict with Iran that, in my view, ended badly. I would say the Iran thing is worse.

Jacobsen: Did it feel like Afghanistan on speed?

Rosner: No, because we were in Afghanistan for 20 years. During much of that time, we provided enough security around Kabul that many people could live relatively normal lives without being under constant Taliban rule. Women could go to school.

We gave Afghanistan 20 years, and then we left. The Afghan military collapsed within days. That is not the same thing as confronting Iran, a country of roughly 90 million people with a large standing military and substantial reserve capacity. We did not even attempt a ground invasion.

It is not symmetrical. It is not the same thing at all. However, both situations ultimately rest on presidential decisions, and, to me, both appear to have been disastrous calls.

Though Biden inherited the withdrawal agreement negotiated by Trump, which committed the United States to leave Afghanistan, Biden decided to carry out that withdrawal. Had he delayed or reversed it, he likely would have faced renewed Taliban attacks and might have had to send additional troops to secure Kabul. That was the dilemma.

However, the bottom line is that Trump got us into a conflict with Iran, made what I think was a worse strategic decision than Afghanistan, and then did a bunch of other things that I think were undeniably bad.

The tariffs disrupted parts of the American economy and affected American consumers and businesses in several ways. However, his supporters are often shielded from critical coverage of his actions. That allows them to believe he is doing a good job.

That is a bad asymmetry.

We have had several candidates who identify as democratic socialists win primaries. Zohran Mamdani, the Democratic nominee for mayor of New York City, calls himself a democratic socialist. However, really, he is a charismatic politician. Is he proposing genuinely socialist policies? Not to any significant extent, in my opinion.

Meanwhile, Republicans keep using the threat of creeping socialism to scare their voters. So I think Democrats are being set up to perform worse than they otherwise should in the midterms, considering how controversial Trump’s presidency has been, because Democrats are terrible at messaging.

Republicans have built a powerful messaging system—not just one that communicates effectively, but one that also shields many of their supporters from information that conflicts with its narratives. Go ahead.

Jacobsen: No, I was going to say, shielding them from the facts, essentially, is what you are saying.

Rosner: I guess that is all I have to say.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 8: Genius, Futility, Ukraine, Russia, Iran, and Political Mythology

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/07/01

Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner examine why brilliant minds still drift into dubious or wasted pursuits, from Newton’s biblical prophecy to Einstein’s late unified-field work and Lorne Michaels’s post-SNL wilderness. The exchange turns to Russia’s war on Ukraine, Ukrainian asymmetric pressure, Putin’s controlled approval, Trump’s attraction to perceived winners, Iran, and right-wing media’s insulation of political failure. The result is skeptical, conversational, historically alert, darkly comic, and unusually unsentimental about genius and political mythology.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: How many prominent people, your Oppenheimers, Einsteins, Newtons, have involved themselves in what, from the outside, looks like pointless nonsense? Newton, for example, spent serious time interpreting biblical prophecy and the end of history. How many very smart people have done some version of that?

Rick Rosner: I would say all of them. To avoid wasting time on bullshit, you would need perfect insight, and nobody has that. Einstein did most of his greatest theorizing by the time he was 36 or 40. At 26, in 1905, he had his miracle year: special relativity, Brownian motion, the photoelectric effect, and mass-energy equivalence. The Nobel Prize eventually came for the photoelectric effect, not relativity. Ten years later, at 36, in 1915, he completed his work on general relativity. Around 1916 and 1917, he worked on radiation, including stimulated emission, which laid the groundwork for lasers.

Then, from roughly 40 until his death at 76, he spent much of his time pursuing a unified field theory. He was deeply suspicious of standard quantum mechanics, especially the idea that uncertainty was not merely a limitation of knowledge but something built into the structure of reality. You could argue that he spent a large part of the last decades of his life on work that did not pay off as his earlier work did. An Einstein scholar might object, “No, he still produced useful ideas.” Fine. But it was not 1905 or 1915. I am sure you can find exceptional people who were lucky and brilliant enough to do groundbreaking work throughout their careers, but the odds are that most great minds have spent some serious time on nonsense.

I just saw a documentary on Lorne Michaels, who created Saturday Night Live in 1975. It is an excellent documentary.

By the fiftieth anniversary, he was still the executive producer and 80. But even he had five years in the wilderness. He left SNL in 1980, after the first five seasons. I do not know whether he was half-fired, half-exhausted, or half-ready to leave, but he was gone. The show got weaker, and NBC brought him back in 1985. So even Lorne Michaels had a wasted five years, or at least five years that did not become legendary.

Jacobsen: What did he do in the wilderness?

Rosner: He tried producing other shows, took time off, and rested, because that show is brutal for everybody, including, and maybe especially, him. The number of decisions per minute required to get that show through a production week is ridiculous: judgment calls, sketches, rewrites, performers, hosts, network concerns, personalities, timing, tone, everything. He supervises an absurd number of moving parts to make sure the show is the best version of itself it can be.

Do you have any more topics immediately coming to mind? How is it there? How has it been? Is Russia distracted?

Jacobsen: It is balmy and not bomby.

Rosner: It looks nice through your window. Is Putin distracted by what is happening in Crimea?

Jacobsen: Crimea, Moscow, St. Petersburg, Volgograd, and elsewhere. Ukraine’s return strikes are landing deeper inside Russia now, especially against energy infrastructure, military logistics, and industrial targets. They are hurting the economy, fuel supply, personnel, and the credibility of the Russian Federation. The Kremlin does not stand outside those costs forever.

Rosner: He is still not at immediate risk. His approval numbers have fallen by Russian standards, but they remain high, depending on the pollster and methodology. I do not feel as if he is at serious risk of losing his job. I am not sure how that would happen. But do you feel he is in a position where he would actually start considering peace? No way, right? Things would have to get much more dire for Russia. Or do you not even want to venture a guess?

Jacobsen: Russia has violated the basic principles of international humanitarian law and the Geneva Conventions in ways that are extensive and well-documented. They have used missiles, drones, artillery, glide bombs, cluster munitions, thermobaric weapons, and nearly every major category of conventional weapon available to them. Nuclear weapons remain the line they have not crossed.

The idea of Russia as the “second army in the world” was true in terms of size, inheritance, and stockpiles, but it was also a facade. Asymmetric warfare can counter even that. Ukraine has higher morale than Russia. The motivation, time investment, improvisation, and creativity are greater on the Ukrainian side because Ukrainians are defending their own country. That affects Russian soldiers, the Kremlin, Mr. Putin, and Russia’s allies.

Mr. Trump loves winners. Russia is larger, so he initially treated it as the likely winner and showed sympathy for Putin. Now Ukraine is winning or, at least, proving much harder to defeat than expected on multiple fronts. That has been noticed and finally acknowledged by Mr. Trump. Since he likes winners, he has begun saying more positive things about Mr. Zelensky and the Ukrainians.

Rosner: Interesting. There is a parallel in the United States. The U.S. has the world’s most powerful military, and yet it has been constrained by Iran. It is not the same as Ukraine and Russia, and it is not exactly asymmetric warfare in the classic sense, but Trump seems to have expected a quick, easy victory. He is not willing to do what it would take to fully take down Iran, because that would mean a ground war, probably with hundreds of thousands of troops, years of fighting, and tens of thousands of American casualties.

So you have two very powerful militaries being held off by opponents that are weaker in conventional terms, but not weak enough to roll over. Iran’s military is not tiny, but it did not have to commit its full force to complicate the American position. Trump was sold a fantasy by Netanyahu, or at least accepted one: that this would be easy.

There is another parallel. Putin’s approval remains high because he controls the media environment in Russia. Trump’s approval has not suffered as much as it might have because much of the American right-wing media universe is in the tank for him. A significant chunk of Americans will tell you, first, that the war is not really over, and second, that the United States has not lost anything. There is a lot they do not hear about on Fox.

I do not think Trump’s approval has been damaged by starting and then rapidly failing to end a war in the same way Biden’s approval was damaged by finally shutting down the Afghan war. The situation in Afghanistan caused Biden’s approval rating to fall sharply in 2021, and it never fully recovered. It became much easier to convince Americans that Biden had screwed up than to convince Americans that Trump had screwed up, because Trump has a captive right-wing media system protecting him.

All right. That is all I have.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 7: Online Gambling, Prediction Markets, and the Risks Facing Young Americans

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/06/30

Scott Douglas Jacobsen interviews Rick Rosner about two troubling social trends: the spread of attention-driven online platforms and the rapid growth of app-based gambling. Rosner argues that gambling companies rely on statistical advantage and promotional incentives to encourage continued betting, while he personally experiments with cautious, low-stakes strategies on prediction markets such as Polymarket US. Despite occasional small gains, he concludes that gambling is ultimately a poor use of time and poses significant long-term risks for most participants.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: What is new in your world?

Rick Rosner: I do have one topic. Actually, two. They are not quite related. AI is chewing up parts of the world of work, right? Plus, there are Americans’ own tendencies. There are two semi-related trends: unverified viral claims have suggested that 10 to 14 percent of American women aged 18 to 24 have posted on OnlyFans, but reliable public data does not substantiate that figure.

Similarly, young American men appear to be at elevated risk for gambling problems, especially through online sports betting and app-based gambling. You have two corrosive trends affecting different groups in different ways.

Jacobsen: Attention for one and gambling for another.

Rosner: Yeah. You cannot beat the house in gambling, statistically. I do not like gambling, but I will do it.

I do not like it because I am good at math, but I will gingerly gamble if I think I can find situations where the payoff is greater than the odds against me. Sometimes I am right, and sometimes I am wrong. Because I am mathy and maybe not addictive in that way, it has not cost me very much.

I deposited 100 bucks with an online bookie six years ago, and I am only down to 60 bucks. I got down to seven bucks, but I grew my stake back up to 60 without having to give them any additional money. They give me money every month.

Gambling is bad for you. Gambling companies give gamblers free money or credits because they expect this to increase gambling activity and, over time, recover more than they give away. This online bookie gives me about $10 a month in free money, which I can use to improve my odds.

If I am betting 15 bucks at normal shitty odds, but I am getting 10 bucks back, then I am really only gambling five bucks. That makes the odds more reasonable. I just joined Polymarket US, the regulated U.S. version of Polymarket, which is separate from the international platform and operates through a CFTC-regulated designated contract market. You cannot necessarily bet on everything that an international Polymarket user can bet on.

I put down 20 bucks. That was my stake. They gave me 50 bucks. Then they gave me another 10 bucks and another 25 bucks. With very cautious gambling, I have won about $1.80, but my stake has gone from 20 bucks to $105 because platforms like this expect many users who receive promotional money to trade or gamble it away and more.

As I said, you generally cannot win at gambling in a life-changing way without taking a significant risk with your assets, and it is not worth it. You are more likely to fuck yourself up than to improve your position.

I think some of the money that Polymarket US has given me may be related to glitches that temporarily took the site down or limited trading activity. As an apology for doing that, some of these extra little transfers of money may be meant to make up for the trouble.

“I am sorry for your trouble. Here is some money.” They can do that because they expect to get that money back. Statistically, or at least based on their tracking of past behavior, they can expect many people to gamble or trade more than they are given.

There you go. I have found one way not to beat the crappy odds, but to lower their impact.

On platforms like Polymarket, where you are trading on the outcome of an event, you can get into and out of a position somewhat like the stock market. Usually, when you bet on an event through a standard bookie, you have to wait for the outcome to see whether you win or lose. With Polymarket, you can enter at a certain implied probability before the outcome is determined.

The market has decided the percentage odds of that event happening. Then the platform’s fees, spread, or trading mechanics can add to your effective cost. You can also sell before the event occurs, or before the event becomes fully determined.

For example, if you bet on a sporting event before it starts, and your team has a two-thirds chance of winning according to the market, then maybe you pay 68 cents to win a dollar potentially. Then, in a soccer game, your team goes up by one. You can maybe sell at 80 cents because the odds that your team will win have gone up. Or maybe your team goes down by one, and you sell at 40 cents.

You do not have to wait to lose all your money or win at the conclusion of the event. You can limit your losses or protect your gains. You can also protect yourself a little bit against the crappy odds because, if you sell before the game is over, you are selling at the market price, minus fees or spread, rather than being locked into the original wager.

So, if you are getting crappy odds before the game, you can sell halfway through the game at something like those same market-driven rates. I do not know how much of a discount that creates against the extra cost you are paying to do this, but it can make a slight difference.

What I am doing, and I do not know if this works or not, is that earlier today I bet a dollar on Canada making it to the next round.

So I bet a dollar on Canada, and at halftime, the score was tied. The odds of Canada winning had declined. When I sold out at halftime to avoid risking my money if Canada did not win, I got 97 cents back.

I will wait for you to come back, or I will not. I will just keep going.

So I wagered a dollar, then I chickened out, and I got 97 cents back. I lost three cents. What I am hoping is that there was some kind of glitch during my day of gambling, losing three cents here and making 11 cents there, that somehow Polymarket US will decide a glitch prevented me from trading as much as I wanted.

Then they might give me 10 bucks to say, “Sorry that your trading experience was not as fluid as you may have wanted.” By losing three cents and making 11 cents, and by making these piddly little wagers, I might be gambling that Polymarket US will have some kind of issue that causes them to give me 10 bucks or 25 bucks in apology credits.

All this is really a waste of my time. Really, I should not be fucking around with this. That is a bigger cost than my bullshit little gambling.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 6: Email Bombing, Hair Tech, and Joke-Writing Odds

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/06/ 24

Rick Rosner discusses thinning hair, low-level light therapy, and a recent email bombing fraud attempt that buried legitimate alerts under thousands of junk messages. Scott Douglas Jacobsen compares the volume to ordinary inbox overload and asks about scam targeting. The conversation shifts to comedy writing, including Rosner’s joke about the Lincoln Memorial Reflecting Pool, late-night monologue competition, low joke acceptance rates, and the dangers of speaking candidly to inexperienced reporters.

Thanks for reading! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

Rick Rosner: My hair is becoming increasingly wispy. I have a helmet that uses low-level red or near-infrared light on the scalp, but I am too lazy to use it.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Will that make your hair thicker?

Rosner: I do not know. It may help if the device is properly designed and I use it consistently, but the $25 version I bought is unlikely to match FDA-cleared devices that cost hundreds or more than $1,000. However, I probably should use it while I watch TV, at least.

There was an attempted fraud. This is a type of fraud that I had not heard of until I was hit with it. It is called email bombing. They flood your email account with a bunch of bullshit, thousands and thousands of emails. Over the past few days, not today, but yesterday and the day before, I received about 7,500 emails.

Jacobsen: My most out-of-control email account, and I have about five active accounts, has 4,559 emails in it. However, that is over eight years of being unable to deal with it. So 7,500 emails in a day is not just more in total; on a daily rate basis, it is hundreds of times more than I would be used to, taking into account all of my active emails, private and public.

Rosner: I got a shit ton of emails. Luckily, most of them went to junk, but a significant number did not. It turns out the strategy is that, at the same time they hit you with a shit ton of emails, they are doing some fraud on you. They are hoping that the email saying, “This transaction is happening,” or “This account change is happening,” will get lost when you mass-delete thousands of emails, which I did not do. I did not mass-delete them. I had to delete them one by one once I read about this. I could not have done it anyway, because legitimate emails were mixed in among the thousands of junk emails.

So, just a few minutes ago, I found one fraudulent transaction or account-related notice and put the kibosh on it. Are there others? I do not know. However, there you go. It is good that I caught it. My wife is extremely anxious about being defrauded, and she is asleep right now. When I tell her about it, she will not be pleased.

Jacobsen: They target people over 50 or over 60, right?

Rosner: For many scams, yes, older adults are commonly targeted. However, with email bombing, they can target anyone with active online accounts, because the point is not necessarily that the victim is gullible. The point is to bury the fraud alert or transaction notice under a flood of junk email. I am definitely over 50 and over 60. Anyway, we should talk about the reflecting pool.

Jacobsen: If you were still in a comedy room, or if you were at home and got a contract for a comedy thing, for a late-night show like Seth Meyers or something, what would be the process of deconstructing that series of unfortunate events into a joke?

Rosner: The one joke I made, which I would submit, is that the Lincoln Memorial Reflecting Pool is much more majestic than the White House deflecting tool, though they both leak stinky fluids.

Jacobsen: That is pretty good. What would be the chance of that getting to air, intuitively?

Rosner: Ten percent.

Jacobsen: Which American late-night talk show host has historically had the reputation for being the most stringent about standards, and therefore the least likely to let any particular writer’s joke get on air?

Rosner: It is not stringent. When you say “stringent,” what you mean is: who solicits the most material from their team? I was listening to an interview with my ex-boss, and she said, and she may or may not have gotten the number right, that there are currently 19 writers on staff, which is almost double the number from when I was there.

If every writer writes 50 jokes a day, or quips, or little snippets of something, 50 times 19 is 950. There is only so much room in a show. You have the monologue, and on the high end, I am not basing this on personal experience, but on watching shows, Seth Meyers might tell something like seven jokes in his opening monologue. I used to know the exact number. I do not know. We could ask AI, but I am not going to do it.

Someone like Leno, or somebody else, might have a fast-paced, long monologue that encompasses a lot of different subjects, and you might get some number approaching 30. Then, throughout the show, there might be other opportunities for writers to submit quips or ideas. However, let us use 30.

Let us cut it down from 950 and say that 800 little ideas, jokes, quips, or whatever are submitted in a day by a huge staff working hard all day. If 30 of those things get on, that gives you a success rate of less than 4 percent.

Also, some hosts write none of their material. Some hosts write a huge fraction of their material. However, 30 divided by 800 gives you a success rate of less than 4 percent.

That does not mean the work is wasted. It takes a lot of unused material to get to the very best material that is used. Moreover, the joke you think is best, or that you are proud of, or that you think works well, may not work well in the context of the monologue. So you cannot love your jokes. You have to get in there, fearlessly pitch your shit, and hope you do not suck.

Think of a giant awards show, like the Oscars or the Emmys. On those shows, you might have a dozen writers or more submitting jokes for weeks. For an awards show, it is not inconceivable that, over the weeks leading up to the show, the host might receive 1,200 jokes, maybe more. Again, there is no room for more than a few dozen. So the ratio is in the low single-digit percentages.

In fact, I talked about this in an interview I gave that helped get me fired. I talked about the low percentage of my stuff that gets on. What I meant was the low percentage of anybody’s stuff, unless somebody is a fucking genius who manages to get maybe 10 percent of their stuff on, if they are the Shohei Ohtani of pitching jokes. However, people do not get a lot of their stuff on. A lot of shit does not make it.

Also, the person who wrote the article hated me by the time it was ready to be published because I called her out on some shit she was doing. She was an inexperienced reporter. So she put things in the article to present me in an unfairly bad light. In the article, I said maybe 4 percent gets on. She fucked it up, either from inexperience or malice, and had me saying, inaccurately, because I never said it, that 2 percent of my stuff gets on. The fucking twat. I mean, she cost me my job, though I was dumb to give the interview in the first place, and dumb to give a rookie reporter from Fox News that much power over me.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 5: Trump, Iran, Afghanistan, and Durable Approval

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/06/19

Scott Douglas Jacobsen speaks with Rick Rosner from Ukraine and Los Angeles about U.S. politics, polling, and global power. Rosner compares Biden’s Afghanistan withdrawal with Trump’s handling of the war with Iran, arguing Trump’s approval remains unusually durable despite blunders. He attributes this resilience to partisan media, statistical polling jitter, and an unwavering base, warning that American decline could accelerate as AI and geopolitical competition reshape national dominance in a rapidly changing world.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: It is June 19. I am still in Ukraine, continuing the reportage. Rick, you are still in Los Angeles. Thank you for letting me call you from halfway across the world. Do you want to talk about politics, math, or something else today?

Rick Rosner: Sure, politics for a second.

Jacobsen: What is the first thing off the top of your mind?

Rosner: I have a worry. There are parallels between Biden withdrawing from Afghanistan, which damaged his approval with the American people for much of the rest of his presidency, and Trump’s handling of the war with Iran. Biden had been doing pretty well; then he withdrew from Afghanistan, and his approval dropped and never fully recovered. Trump’s situation is probably more connected to hubris, but both are built from bad assumptions. Both involve a significant, though comparatively small, death toll for American troops.

What worries me is that Trump’s blunder will not make him pay a political price. It will not affect his approval the way Biden’s approval was damaged by his actions. I track Trump’s approval day by day, and it is too early to say, but in the past week his approval has ticked upward by about half a percent.

Jacobsen: Why?

Rosner: Largely because day-to-day and week-to-week approval depends on which polls have come out. Some polls are right-leaning, and he does better in those polls. Right now, probably about half of the polls in his aggregate on Silver Bulletin, Nate Silver’s polling site, are right-leaning polls where he comes in at 40% approval or better. Four out of the ten most recent polls are right-leaning polls.

So, it is too early to tell. That is statistical jitter. It does not necessarily mean anything. But there is no sign of any precipitous drop, which, if there were any equivalence, there should be. But there is no equivalence. Biden’s approval was fickle, and Trump’s approval is durable.

For almost all of the past ten years, Trump has been underwater in approval, and that remains true. But the approval he does have, his base, is fairly unwavering. It is hard for him to do anything that hurts him with his people. To some extent, that is because they do not hear about it. If they watch Fox News, they hear a sanitized version of what he has done and its consequences. A lot of them simply do not know.

Why should I care? Because he continues to act with impunity, and a lot of what he does continues to hurt our country. This is always a critical time for the country, but now seems especially critical because we are competing with other large global powers for continued global dominance during a time when AI and other technologies are shaking everything up. If we fall behind now, it may be impossible to recover, and we will become a permanent also-ran country.

Things move faster now. In the past, maybe the country could survive one bad presidential administration and still remain the dominant power. Now things move too fast for that, and Trump is too crappy for that.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 4: AI Bias, Online Hate, Antisemitism, and War-Zone Stress

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/06/18

Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner examine AI bias as mechanized groupthink, then move through war-zone journalism in Ukraine, stress, health, and online hate. Rosner criticizes X under Elon Musk, rising antisemitism, political dysfunction, inflation, Iran policy, and midterm prospects. The conversation also touches on legal insanity defenses, body-positive swimwear marketing, flat-Earth belief, intelligence and prejudice, and the physical toll of constant digital exposure during a combustible political era and wartime resilience in contemporary life.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Do you think AI, trained on internet-scale datasets, can be prejudiced toward dominant theoretical models?

Rick Rosner: Yes. AI is just, let me see what happens when you type in “groupthink” and “AI,” because why is AI not just groupthink?

Jacobsen: Or maybe do a probability argument.

Rosner: Yes. When I ask that, Google AI says AI is essentially an advanced mechanized form of groupthink. Whatever many people in their areas of expertise are thinking, AI is going to spit back at you, unless you ask it to be more specific or to eliminate certain dimensions of what it is considering.

But we know AI can exhibit bias due to intentional, implicit, or accidental factors in training. Early on, a few years ago, there was a discussion about AI being biased in mortgage decisions because the statistics it was trained on had racial bias.

All right, do you want to move on to something else?

Jacobsen: Yes.

Rosner: Where are you? Are you somewhere with someone?

Jacobsen: What was the name of the event? Natalia, what was the name of the event? She knows, because I do not recall immediately off the top.

Rosner: Okay, I see the fancy roofing.

Jacobsen: Yes.

Rosner: Okay.

Jacobsen: Almost everyone is gone.

Rosner: You have suffered the nights of bombardment once a week, have you not?

Jacobsen: Yes. I have been here a long time. Two days ago, I woke up, and a drone exploded right outside, maybe five metres away in the sky, right at my level. There was a fire, and it fell. I thought, “Oh, okay.” Then the ballistic missiles started coming, because my air-raid alert was on silent. It was quite dramatic. I slept in the closet this time.

Rosner: Was that your signal to sleep in the bathroom?

Jacobsen: Yes. The other two nights: May 24 in the morning, bathroom sleeping; June 2 in the morning, bathroom sleeping; June 15, closet. I do that because windows surround the room I am in, so you have to be away from them. That would be a horrible way to die.

Rosner: Death by glass, yes.

Jacobsen: Yes, and you have to accept the possibility of death in some form in this country during war. That is natural as a journalist. So if it does happen, you aim for a quick death rather than a prolonged and painful death: burns, cuts, et cetera.

But I have been taking health examinations: physical, psychological, and so on. No issues. Even a psychiatric evaluation: zero diagnoses. I have none. I am 100% perfectly mentally healthy in a war.

Rosner: Apparently, I am not.

Jacobsen: I took my physical, too. My markers are all very healthy. I want to get to at least 110. So far, so good.

Rosner: My body is showing reactions to stress, even though I am not in a war. I had a big fight with LAMS the last time we did the show, which was probably a month ago now. A few days later, it led to what appeared to be a very minor outbreak of shingles: a couple of days of itching and a rash. I am vaccinated against shingles, but you can still get a mild breakthrough case.

More recently, this past week, my tongue got super hurt on one side, and I got a canker sore down where you would put chewing tobacco. I feel like that, too, is a manifestation of stress, which I think is because I spent too much time online looking at the products of jerk-offs on X.

There has been a change in X for the worse. A couple of days ago, SpaceX went public, making Elon Musk a trillionaire on paper. Over the next couple of days, his net worth rose further. This has not made him less of a white supremacist. He is pretty white supremacist, especially on X.

Before he bought it, you could not go on X, then Twitter, and just call people the N-word or the F-word for gay people, or say that all Jews should be killed. That stuff would get you kicked off. So would misinformation, like sharing bullshit about worthless COVID cures or anti-vaxxer claims.

Musk let just about everybody back on, and decent people left. So there is just a ton of hate. Musk has owned it for about three and a half years. You could still report someone if they were calling people the N-word or the F-word all the time. You would report them, and they would get suspended, or in egregious cases, kicked off altogether. I still report that stuff.

Jacobsen: Does it have any effect?

Rosner: Not lately. There were a couple of smarter haters who learned to misspell the N-word or the F-word, so AI would not catch it. Even when you reported them, they would not necessarily get in trouble. But now people are being blatant. I found some people using the N-word spelled correctly. I reported one guy 40 times for 40 different instances, and X has yet to get back to me.

Jacobsen: Do you think antisemitism is worse on X?

Rosner: Yes, it is really bad. Maybe that is one reason my mouth feels canker-sore-ish: seeing all the different flavours of hate being allowed.

In the U.S., we have the First Amendment, so we can pretty much say what we want. In Europe, there are laws against hate speech. X was fined €120 million, roughly $140 million, by the European Commission for breaching transparency obligations under the Digital Services Act. Did they pay it? I do not know. Did they sic lawyers on it to postpone it or get out of paying it?

As a guy who is now worth around $1.3 trillion on paper, a $140 million fine is like fining a regular millionaire $140. It is like a traffic ticket. So he has impunity in running a hate salon.

Jacobsen: What are your favourite American English words?

Rosner: I do not know. I like words for the sound of them, but nothing comes to mind immediately. I’m not sure this is a productive topic.

Jacobsen: Are you an onomatopoeia fan?

Rosner: Somewhat. I say words to myself.

Jacobsen: What is the hardest verbal IQ problem you have ever come across?

Rosner: I have not taken a full-on IQ test in 15 or 18 years. We should probably talk about politics.

Jacobsen: What is going on with Trump?

Rosner: He has a memorandum of understanding with Iran that he is going to reveal on Friday, but it has already been leaked, and the terms look terrible for the U.S. We did not get anything that we went to war for. According to the reported terms of the agreement, Iran will gain access to a $300 billion private investment or reconstruction fund, not necessarily from taxpayers but from a consortium of investors.

Jacobsen: Who is investing in Iran in this way?

Rosner: I do not know. But Iran is a modern country, even though it has a terrible theocratic, authoritarian regime. It has roughly 93 million people, and not all of them are living in poverty. There is room for development. They have skyscrapers, cities, and the whole fucking thing.

But U.S. inflation was 4.2% as of May, and wholesale inflation was 6.5%. This is another week of the national average gas price being over $4 a gallon, after Trump promised $2 gas. It is not entirely clear how much this will hurt him, since most of his supporters seem impervious to his shittiness. He can do whatever the fuck he wants without losing them.

Jacobsen: What does this increase in basic fuel prices do to destitute countries, poor countries, or poorly run countries?

Rosner: I am not in a destitute country. It makes things more miserable. I do not know.

Jacobsen: How much does it affect your life?

Rosner: Not much at all. I go to the gas station. California gas is usually about two bucks a gallon more than it is in the rest of the country. It has been that way as long as I have lived here. But I do not drive that far. I drive maybe 10 miles a day. I pay $5.89 a gallon, and it takes me about 10 days to go through a tank.

So the midterms are less than five months away.

Jacobsen: How are the polls looking? How are the midterms looking?

Rosner: People hate Trump. His approval is somewhere in the high 30s, depending on the poll or polling average, which puts him among the weakest modern presidents heading into a midterm. But 36% or 38% is nothing. I guess it consists of 15% or 20% of Americans who support the president regardless, plus people who are gullible enough to support Trump specifically and keep thinking he is doing a good-ish job because the news they listen to tells them so. Also, they like that he hurts the people they do not like: liberals and minorities.

The Democrats should easily take the House. But because Trump and Republicans have played with electoral maps, that may get them seats they should lose. Still, Democrats only need a handful of seats to take over the House. They should be able to do this.

But people do not like the Democrats much either, because they look ineffectual. Republicans have been successful at blaming them for things, and Democrats are bad at deflecting blame. Everything is being disrupted by tech, and neither party is willing to tell the truth about it. They would rather blame the other party for job losses.

Even so, a record-setting number of members of Congress are retiring or otherwise not seeking reelection. That generally indicates the party controlling the House and the presidency is at risk of losing control. So things still look pretty good. Betting markets give Democrats a strong chance of taking the House and a slightly closer chance of taking the Senate. It should be higher, but I’m not sure.

Jacobsen: There is a Mangione update. Apparently, the accused insurance CEO killer is facing some hurdles trying to convince jurors that he suffered a mental health breakdown, according to medical experts.

Rosner: I do not have anything to add to that. He stalked a guy for a week and then murdered him. So I think he is going to have trouble with some version of an insanity defence.

We can talk about a swimsuit company that I am semi-fascinated with.

Jacobsen: Tell me more. Male or female?

Rosner: Female. I will click on bikini ads, so I get more bikini ads, because I like looking at women in bikinis. There is this company out of China called Cupshe, C-U-P-S-H-E. It seems like one of those odd Temu, Alibaba-style enterprises. But I click on a lot of their ads because I am fascinated. It looks like they are targeting hot moms.

The bikinis are slightly slutty, but they have maybe an inch more rise along the waistband than true young women’s bikinis, which can go pretty low. For somebody who might have had a kid or two and might not have the tight stomach they had five years ago, I am assuming that helps. It turns out that it is their model. They are trying to sell body-positive bikinis for people of all body types. They are reportedly selling hundreds of millions of dollars’ worth of product a year. They may not be the world’s number-one bikini line, but they have gone from nothing to a huge business with this approach.

It is interesting how much body positivity you can encompass by giving people choices about how much rise they want in their bottoms and how much butt they want to show. It turns out they have a hugely successful business model.

Then today, I noticed something while looking at some of their pictures. What is always being sold is that you are having fun, at the beach, on vacation. You are in an exotic place, or you are the hottest mom at the pool. But the impression I got from the photos is that you may not be as alert as you would be in other contexts. Among the things they are selling is a relaxation of consciousness, because right now it is pretty fucking stressful to be fully alert all the time.

My mouth just grew a bunch of fucking canker sores, which is a stress response. I had shingles a month ago, also a stress response. Not a terrible case, because I am vaccinated, but I am obviously stressed. It is related to being online a lot of the day, especially on fucking X, where, as I mentioned earlier, Musk’s company, the richest guy in the world’s company, is letting people spread hate. Anti-minority hate. You can now pretty much say the N-word on X with impunity. You can use the F-slur with impunity. You might still get in trouble if you explicitly espouse violence, but you can probably say that all Jews should be banished. As long as you do not directly call for killing Jews, you can attack Jews all the time.

I do not like it. I grew up without hate. I am 66 years old. I did not grow up in a place where I was called “Jew-boy.” I was bullied, but so was everybody else. It was not because I was Jewish. It was because everybody got bullied, and I was nerdy.

Jacobsen: How would you characterize prior antisemitism, which is current, with social media?

Rosner: There are two things. Israel is widely hated for how it has prosecuted the Gaza war and for allowing settlers to kill Palestinians with near impunity in the West Bank. It may not be genocide, but it certainly feels like ethnic war. Netanyahu is perpetuating this shit to preserve his alliance with the far-right, shitty elements in his government and to stay in power, because he has been on trial for years for corruption.

So everybody is pissed at Israel, and that gets mixed in with anti-Jewish hate, which was already on the upswing before the Hamas attacks of October 7, about two and a half years ago. There is just a lot. It is distressing and surprising because it was tempting to think the world was mostly done with that.

Jacobsen: Do you think there is a level of intelligence where, if you sampled that population, you would find less antisemitism versus more?

Rosner: I have not done much thinking about intelligence versus hate.

Jacobsen: Hate, xenophobia, prejudice. I suspect that if someone has a scientific background, particularly in biology, they may dismiss sociological categories such as race.

Rosner: William Shockley was a co-inventor of the transistor and a huge racist. We have talked about the idea of smart stupids: people who are smart in one direction and fucking lunatics or idiots in another. Elon Musk is pretty much a racist, but also a smart guy who has managed to accumulate one of the greatest personal fortunes in human history. Bobby Fischer was, for a while, maybe the world’s greatest chess player, and he sank into apparent mental deterioration and Jew hate.

So I do not know. Statistically, I do not know. I am not even interested in the question, because the hate is here. I have not seen that it is confined to just fucking idiots. I see hateful arguments from non-idiots. It is anecdotal, but on X, I see people whose tweets are grammatically correct saying hateful shit. People have developed workarounds that allow them to say hateful shit without getting caught by X’s algorithms. That was earlier. Now, I am not sure you even have to misspell the N-word to get away with it.

I do not know, and I do not know that I care. I care more about the hate being here than about whether it belongs to a certain stratum of intelligence.

What I care about is that I can barely fucking talk because my mouth is full of sores from stress. I do not need to break it down further. The richest guy in the world is running a powerful social-media platform that encourages people to hate. That is a bad fucking thing.

There is no inoculation. There is more inoculation in the opposite direction. I do not see people being vaccinated against hate. I see people being inoculated with hate.

Jacobsen: Okay. It is like a Nick Fuentes situation: sort of immune to any external.

Rosner: Another thing you see all over fucking X is flat-earthers. Proud, fucking sincere ones, apparently. A lot of them believe it is a conspiracy to deny that the Earth is flat.

Jacobsen: You engage with someone quite frequently, do you not?

Rosner: I used to. Only when she comes to me. She is this woman who seems mentally ill and completely believes the whole flat-Earth package. If you are going to believe in that shit, you are also going to believe in a lot of other fucked-up stupid shit. I will put up liberal shit, and a lot of the stupid shit is MAGA argumentation. That usually prompts her to comment on me, but she has not been doing it much lately.

Jacobsen: Are you tired?

Rosner: My eyes get stingy. When I was younger, this was exactly the time of year when I would have hay fever. So I assume there is a lot of pollen in the air, and it is irritating my contact lenses.

Also, for the past five months, I have been working out seven times a day, which is also a stress reaction in me. That also means I am probably just more sore, just clanking around. So my overall level of irritation is something I should probably work on reducing. On the other hand, fuck everybody.

This is a particularly, I like to say it is always the apocalypse for somebody. But this is a shitty time. My country is being run by a dickhead with impunity, with an entire political party and tens of millions of rabid supporters who will lie for him and buy whatever bullshit.

It is frustrating. We just lost a war. A war that lasted, what, 15 weeks? Conclusively. We spent a ton of money, failed to achieve any of our objectives, and are backing a deal in which Iran gets access to a proposed $300 billion private reconstruction or investment fund.

Because our president is a dickhead. Just an old, corrupt, not-smart guy who was talked into it. Netanyahu spent three hours in the Oval Office with him in February and convinced Trump, an idiot, that it would be easy to knock over the Islamic regime running Iran, even though nearly 50 years of history have demonstrated that they are hard to knock over.

Somebody pointed out today that the time to try to knock them over was before the Revolutionary Guard and other security forces reportedly slaughtered tens of thousands of people who were rioting in the streets. Those people, now dead, might have helped knock over the regime, but they are fucking gone. We waited until after they were slaughtered to go to war with Iran. Once you frame it that way, it is even more obvious that we were not going to fucking succeed.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 3: AI, Archival Identity, and Informational Cosmology

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/06/10

In this interview, Rick Rosner and Scott Douglas Jacobsen discuss whether years of dialogue retain value in an era when AI can simulate voices, extract themes, and generate speculative models. They examine archival identity, high-IQ culture, Decree 770, reproductive coercion, and Rosner’s “informational cosmology.” The exchange turns to AI-generated mathematics, dark matter, redshift, and whether machines can help formalize philosophical physics without replacing human originality as both tool and cultural force in intellectual history today.

Rick Rosner: We have been doing this for 12 years. We have generated millions of words: three million, four million, some crazy amount. We get dozens to hundreds of hits every time you publish, which is not nothing, but it is not a lot, and it has tended not to lead to anything else.

I have been hoping that somebody could go through everything we have said together, maybe even posthumously, posthumously for me; in this version, you are still alive, and see whether there is any wisdom from this IQ guy, whether any of it was worth it. I feel like I have had some decent things to say, and that has all changed. The idea of slogging through millions of words from some guy, looking for wisdom, when now you can go to AI and ask it almost any question and likely get an answer that is better informed, and maybe smarter than anything I have to say on the subject, means that the significance of what we have been saying has been reduced.

There still might be some historical value: this is one of the last guys from before machines became smarter than humans, or before we merged with smart machines. But it is a little bit of a kick in the balls. Any comments?

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Generally, my take on this is akin to the holodeck without being the holodeck. It is more like a text deck, where you can recreate a textual representation of a person’s edited speech or written work based on millions of words. That is a large and significant sample, more than most people would ever leave behind in a lifetime.

From that, you can get a curated, image-like representation of the individual. I think that will probably play some role in archival work in the future, because you are a minor-to-moderate public figure based on your television work, especially with Jimmy Kimmel, and on the eccentric public record around the high-IQ material. I think that is a generally consistent theme in the commentary.

Your results on the Mega and Titan tests, which were among the better-known experimental ultra-high-range tests, are also part of that record. From that, your personality is likely to be represented textually in some form. It will not be like a celebrity AI chat app in your voice and likeness, but it will be a point of interest among a number of people.

Rosner: I do not know about “large,” but that is nice in its way. It is also disheartening in its way, because people do not even need to ask me questions anymore. They can ask an AI version of me questions, and it might get reasonably close. Now, I probably have not exhausted the store of ridiculous, grotesque personal details. AI would not know that I was going to talk to you about developing a more mathematized way of wiping my ass.

Jacobsen: We did not talk about that.

Rosner: But when it comes to asking for an opinion, we should test it out. We should ask me a question, and then, before the answer is published, ask AI the same question and have it respond in the manner of me, and see how close the two answers are. I think there would be quite a bit of overlap.

Jacobsen: My take is that you can ask an AI, using the segmented work between us. So asking as if a third party about “Rick Rosner and Scott Jacobsen,” or you independently through the Mega site or In-Sight Publishing or rickrosner.org, or related material, “What are the key quotes?”

For instance, there was an interview I did with another semi-prominent member of the high-IQ community, Kirk Kirkpatrick, who scored well on some childhood tests. It has been the most viewed article of the last day or two on the website, for some reason.

It was based on commentary that we did for The Huffington Post, back when it still had a blog system. The commentary revolved around two separate phrases that you both said independently to me, but used to describe the same phenomenon. One was “superempowerment,” and the other was “American disease,” in Kirkpatrick’s phrase.

You can ask AI, “What are the key quotes from this?” and it will find them thematically within the material. Similarly, if you increase the search range to millions of words rather than a few thousand in one interview, it can find things like that.

I think the fewer points of analysis the AI has, in terms of available material and computational context, the more superficial the search will be. But at some point, these systems will have immense capacity to review material, and even a million words will not be much. They are trained on immense corpora, but search is a different thing, because you are feeding that search into weightings that are not themselves the full corpus. They are the result of iterated training on those corpora.

I think you can get a reasonably good textual analysis. You can find good quotes from people. You can do it in clever ways with LLMs now, too. You can do a search such as: “Find me quotes by Margaret Atwood specifically around Ceaușescu’s Decree 770, or around real-world precedents for reproductive coercion in The Handmaid’s Tale and The Testaments.”

Rosner: What is Decree 770?

Jacobsen: Decree 770 was Ceaușescu’s 1966 Romanian pronatalist decree. It severely restricted abortion and contraception. Abortion was permitted only under narrow exemptions, including women over a certain age, women who had already borne four children, later five, or cases involving serious medical risk, rape, or incest. Women were also subject to intrusive gynecological monitoring. The larger point is that the state was trying to force births.

That is generally the picture. There was a major baby boom, followed by severe social and economic consequences, including children being born into families and institutions without adequate resources to care for them. So, that is a very significant issue.

The contrast today is that more women are choosing to become single mothers by choice, through sperm donors or other routes, as an individual decision rather than as a result of religious or state pressure. That is not the same phenomenon; it is almost the moral inverse. Individual empowerment of women is much more robust than coercion by the state or by religion, typically.

You can find quotes along those lines. I think the same could be done for you if you asked about math or physics. I think the big weakness of information cosmology, as you have framed it, and as I have discussed with you, is that, and this is your point anyway, it lacks formal mathematics.

You can frame it as philosophy of physics. I think that is fair. I do not think you are simply hand-waving, and you are using more concrete terms, but the math is the primary determinant. You may be able to get an AI to develop a mathematical formulation based on the conversations. That probably could be done soon. I could try.

Rosner: We should really try that.

Jacobsen: What question would you ask the AI in terms of developing a mathematical formula for IC?

Rosner: I do not know. I would have to think about it.

Jacobsen: Do you have any responses to that before we go to the next session?

Rosner: I would see whether it could put the big five particles into some kind of mathematical framework, or at least take stabs at it. I do not know if this is still philosophical rather than mathematical. I would want it to take stabs at some of the constants that we have.

I would want constants, such as the electron-proton mass ratio and things like that, to arise from first principles plus the size of the universe. I have always suspected that part of that ratio involves how much of the universe is collapsed matter near T = 0. The more collapsed matter you have, the more precisely defined your universe should be. The collapsed matter acts as tent poles to hold the universe open and to define the matter within it more precisely.

So, I would see whether I could set AI loose on that.

Jacobsen: I said, “Based on our prior conversations between these two individuals, please develop a simplified mathematical form that would describe what is meant by informational cosmology.”

Rosner: Did you just ask?

Jacobsen: Here it is:

A simplified Rosner–Jacobsen informational cosmology formula can be written as a toy model of durable relational information:

dtdIR=e∈E(t)∑DeCe[−log2P(e∣Ht)]−Λ(t)

and, if we want the cosmological-scale claim in its simplest form:

aIC(t)=a0(IR(t0)IR(t))α

Where:

IR(t)

means the universe’s effective relational information at time t.

−log2P(e∣Ht)

is the Shannon-style information gained when event e occurs against the background of the universe’s prior history Ht. In plain English: the less expected the outcome, the more information it contributes. Shannon’s original framework treats entropy/information as a measure of uncertainty, choice, and information generated per symbol or per second when logs are base 2.

De

is a durability/readability factor from 0 to 1. This reflects Rosner and Jacobsen’s point that not every microscopic event “counts” cosmologically unless it leaves some persistent trace in the system. In their recent framing, information is not just any event, but a selected outcome that leaves a durable, distinguishable record.

Ce

is a coherence or relational-integration factor from 0 to 1. This says an event matters more if it becomes woven into the universe’s network of relations: particles, memories, records, galaxies, civilizations, black-hole-like remnants, and other persistent structures. That fits their language of the universe as a relational information-processing system, not merely a digital register flipping isolated zeros and ones.

Λ(t)

is informational loss, degradation, noise, collapse, or erasure. Rosner’s IC commentary explicitly links loss of information-bearing structure with the universe becoming less well-defined, possibly looking like collapse or a “big bang in reverse.”

aIC(t)

is an IC-style scale factor: not standard ΛCDM expansion, but the apparent size/scale/definition of the universe as a function of accumulated relational information. Rosner states the scale and size of the universe should be roughly proportional to the amount of information it contains, with local scale depending on local information/matter distribution.

So, in ordinary language:

The universe becomes more real, larger, older, and more structured to the extent that possible outcomes become actual outcomes, leave durable records, and become integrated into the relational history of the whole system.

A very compressed version would be:

Cosmic reality∝durable, self-consistent relational information

Or, even more aphoristically:

U(t)∼IR(t)

That is probably the cleanest mathematical translation of the idea. It is not a standard accepted cosmological equation; it is a simplified formalization of Rosner and Jacobsen’s speculative IC language. The closest mainstream guardrail is that physics already recognizes links between entropy, information, energy, and finite regions of space through information/entropy bounds such as Bekenstein’s, where entropy and information capacity are bounded by size and energy.

Rosner: It looks a little bit like the Drake equation. The Drake equation is a simple framework for estimating the number of communicative civilizations in the galaxy: you string together a bunch of factors, many of them highly uncertain.

This thing similarly strings together a bunch of factors in a basic, workmanlike way. It does not offer any further mathematical insight. It is what a couple of people in a hallway with a whiteboard might jot down initially as some of the factors, before they really start deploying expertise on the problem.

It is like cops setting up a murder board, but they are really just putting up the pictures of the victims and suspects, and they have not added the yarn connecting anything yet. It is real basic.

That does not mean AI cannot act in the manner of Einstein’s collaborators. Marcel Grossmann, for example, helped point Einstein toward the tensor mathematics and differential geometry that became central to general relativity. AI has not really done that here.

But based on AI’s increasing fluency in math, that does not mean AI could not do it. We would have to lay out what we are thinking much more systematically than we have. We would have to emphasize the mechanics. In my IC picture, it would need to take into account that as photons are redshifted over cosmic distances, the energy they lose is not simply gone, but is transformed into information.

So, in that picture, the energy is not really lost. It increases the precision with which the universe is defined, and that precision is proportionate to the amount of information in the universe. Photons losing energy through cosmic redshift or gravitational effects would be treated as a transformation of one form of energy into another. The energy it is transformed into would be informational energy encoded tacitly into the universe.

We could ask for a mathematical treatment of how the universe increases information by becoming more unlikely. With entropy, closed systems move toward more probable configurations, less specially arranged configurations. A universe that is increasing in information would, in this framework, move toward more unlikely, less random configurations. It would be nice to have some math for that.

It would also be nice to have some mathematical and physical picture of what can happen around a blackish hole in terms of information. We could ask AI, under Rosner’s eyes, what some possible things are that can happen around a good-sized hole.

Rotten Tomatoes? Or we could ask AI: Rosner suspects that one major line of evidence for dark matter comes from galactic rotation curves, where orbital speeds do not drop off as quickly as expected. That implies missing mass around many galaxies. Rosner posits that it is not exotic matter, but very old collapsed matter. Is that physically plausible if we allow for the universe to be much, much older than it appears to be?

Can AI take a shot at that? I do not know. There is a lot of tricky physics involved. But maybe people have done work on that. Probably. It is a big world full of people doing physics. Anyway, we could ask AI a ton of questions.

And now you are muted.

Jacobsen: True. When I finish transcription today, I can put that section into AI and see what it does. That is similar to what OpenAI reported with an internal model on the Erdős unit-distance problem.

Rosner: What is it? GPT-5.0?

Jacobsen: Not necessarily. OpenAI described it as an internal model. The Erdős problem is almost 80 years old.

Rosner: Not just one problem, but a lot of problems, quite a few problems.

Jacobsen: The Erdős one in particular was reportedly put to the model without detailed mathematical scaffolding, and it produced a construction and proof that external mathematicians checked. More precisely, OpenAI said the model disproved a longstanding conjecture in the planar unit-distance problem, rather than solving every aspect of the broader problem.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 2: Trump, Wholesome Presidents, and American Political Decorum

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/06/10

In this interview, Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner examine whether American presidents can be called wholesome, contrasting personal decorum with political judgment. Rosner discusses Trump, Biden, Obama, Carter, Reagan, Nixon, Eisenhower, Kennedy, Truman, and FDR, arguing that presidents traditionally built public images around patriotism, competence, empathy, or fortitude. The conversation critiques Trump’s zero-sum politics and considers how scandal, symbolism, and institutional responsibility shape presidential legitimacy in American civic life.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: President Donald Trump turns 80 on June 14, 2026.

Rick Rosner: Yes. He became the first sitting president to attend an NBA Finals game. Other presidents have attended NBA games, but this appearance disrupted a Finals game because of added security requirements.

Outdoor watch parties around Madison Square Garden were also affected by the security measures. After he arrived at the game, images circulated online that appeared to show him with his eyes closed, though the White House disputed claims that he had fallen asleep.

Trump is an old man, and he often seems less interested in the ordinary work of helping Americans than in spectacle, grievance, and political combat. He repeatedly claims California elections are fraudulent because the state takes time to count ballots, but the length of California’s vote count is not evidence of fraud. It reflects the state’s election rules, mail-in voting, and verification procedures.

Trump is the president least concerned with doing anything for Americans in our lifetimes, and possibly since before the Civil War. Every president I can think of, even some of the worst ones, such as Andrew Johnson, tried to advance some agenda they thought mattered for America. Trump’s agenda is essentially self-interest. It becomes difficult to talk about him because every new thing he does feels like a variation on things he has already done.

Jacobsen: Has there ever been an entirely wholesome president, or have most had some form of scandal?

Rosner: Let’s run through some presidents. Biden was an institutionalist with more national-level political experience than any president before him. He served in the Senate from 1973 to 2009 and as vice president from 2009 to 2017, so he entered the presidency with more than four decades of high-level federal experience. He got the United States through a difficult period, including supply-chain disruption, inflation, and the aftermath of COVID.

When Biden left office, the U.S. economy was comparatively strong among advanced economies, especially by growth and employment measures. But Biden made serious errors. The Afghanistan withdrawal was one. Trump’s administration signed the Doha Agreement with the Taliban, under which the United States agreed to withdraw all forces by May 2021. Biden extended that timeline, then completed the withdrawal in August 2021. Still, he owned the final execution, and it was chaotic.

He also erred by not speaking to the American people enough. He and his staff kept him too hidden. If he had acknowledged that he was aging and would sometimes sound old, and if he had spoken to the public even a fraction as often as Trump does, he could have shown that he was still largely competent. The disastrous 2024 debate changed public perception. Biden and his team cited a cold, fatigue, and recent international travel. The cough-syrup theory is speculation, so it should not be presented as fact.

He had limited contact with the public, so the debate became the image many people remembered. In that sense, he damaged his own presidency, hurt the Democrats’ chances, and helped pave the way for Trump.

Biden was accused of corruption because Hunter Biden served on the board of Burisma, a Ukrainian energy company. That was politically damaging and ethically problematic. However, no conclusive public evidence proved that Joe Biden took bribes or kickbacks from Burisma. Biden was relatively wholesome personally, but he made serious political and administrative errors.

Obama was about as personally wholesome as modern presidents get, but he was conflict-averse. I think he felt that, as the first Black president, he could not be seen as the angry Black man. As a result, he avoided certain confrontations and got played by Republicans. Key & Peele satirized that dynamic. But in personal scandal terms, Obama had no major sexual scandal.

Biden also had no proven sexual scandal. Tara Reade accused him, and he denied the allegation. Her credibility became heavily contested, and she later moved to Russia and sought Russian citizenship. That does not prove the allegation false by itself, but it is part of the public record around the case.

Reagan, in personal terms, was not known as a womanizer. Biden and Obama were not known for extramarital affairs. Clinton was. As far as I know, George W. Bush was personally wholesome after his earlier drinking years. He became born-again and projected personal decency, though I think he was taken advantage of by Dick Cheney and others. So I do not think “wholesome” is the right criterion for evaluating a president. We have had plenty of personally wholesome presidents. Jimmy Carter was about as wholesome as they come.

Jacobsen: What factors matter more than wholesomeness? People usually think of apple pie, the anthem, and patriotism.

Rosner: We have seen what Trump has done to the presidency. Trump has no standards of decorum. He is not a symbol of America’s better angels; he embodies many of the worst ones. Almost every other president had an evident love for America, even deeply flawed or corrupt presidents. Nixon was caught in serious misconduct and may have been the shiftiest president before Trump, but Nixon still seemed to love America in his own distorted way.

Nixon taped his Oval Office conversations and had terrible things to say about many groups, including antisemitic remarks. Lyndon Johnson also recorded many conversations, and earlier presidents recorded in different ways. Nixon, however, installed his own sound-activated White House taping system in 1971.

Johnson said terrible things privately, but he also pushed through landmark civil rights legislation. Every president before Trump tried, to some extent, to act as a living symbol of American values, even when they failed badly.

Nixon’s famous Checkers speech came in 1952, not 1960. He was Eisenhower’s running mate and faced allegations involving an $18,000 political expense fund. He went on television, denied corruption, talked about his family’s modest means, mentioned that his wife Pat wore cloth coats rather than fur coats, and said the family would keep a cocker spaniel named Checkers. The speech saved his place on the ticket.

In his damaged way, Nixon wanted to do right by America. He hated many of his opponents, but he also listened to voters at times. He created the Environmental Protection Agency, signed the National Cancer Act of 1971, and launched what became known as the war on drugs, though that last policy was far less successful and deeply damaging.

Reagan, whom many people see as a precursor to Trump in some ways, signed the Immigration Reform and Control Act in 1986, the most comprehensive immigration reform since 1952. He did not build his politics around abusing immigrants in the way Trump does. He tried to create a workable system.

As an actor and former cowboy-movie figure, Reagan knew how to symbolize America. He could get on a horse with the sunset behind him and make people feel good about the country. At the same time, his administration was involved in Iran-Contra. Some of that reflected his own choices; some reflected officials under him running amok. Reagan publicly announced his Alzheimer’s diagnosis in 1994, years after leaving office, so any claim about symptoms while he was president should be treated cautiously.

Harding is another example. He may have been weak or inattentive, and his cabinet was involved in major corruption. Wholesomeness can be one aspect of being an upstanding president, but it can also work against you.

People mocked Jimmy Carter for being pious. Playboy used to run serious, long-form interviews with public figures, and Carter gave one in 1976 while running for president. He said he had committed adultery in his heart, meaning he had experienced lust while remaining physically faithful to his wife.

Jacobsen: He said that to Playboy?

Rosner: Yes. The Playboy interview was a serious journalistic interview, not a sexual one. But people mocked him for being so morally earnest that he considered lustful thoughts about women other than his wife to be a sin.

His wholesomeness hurt him politically. He told Americans they had to conserve energy. In his February 2, 1977 energy address, he wore a cardigan and urged Americans to save energy, including by lowering thermostats. The commonly cited figure from that message is 65 degrees during the day and 55 at night, not 68. People mocked him for it. He came across as weak to many voters.

Then Reagan came in with “It’s morning again in America,” the 1984 campaign message. He offered a more optimistic and assertively masculine image of the presidency. Reagan was personally wholesome in many ways, though he was the first divorced and remarried president. He did not have the same public image of sexual appetite that Clinton later did.

There were salacious claims about Nancy Reagan in Kitty Kelley’s biography, but those should be treated as unverified allegations from a scandal-oriented book, not as established fact. More broadly, Hollywood’s casting-couch culture was real, and sexual exploitation in entertainment existed long before the MeToo era. But specific anecdotes should not be presented as fact without sourcing.

Every president until Trump had at least some sense of presidential presence, decorum, and symbolic responsibility. Trump represents, to those who dislike him, some of the worst American instincts: scam before being scammed, dominate before being dominated, and treat politics as a zero-sum fight. Previous presidents often promoted the idea that Americans become greater by working together. Trump promotes the idea that his side should get behind him so they can crush the people against them. It is a much more zero-sum politics.

Jacobsen: Is it zero-sum politics plus ruthless aggressiveness toward that aim, rather than simply zero-sum thinking?

Rosner: Yes. For some presidents, wholesomeness worked. Reagan’s public wholesomeness helped him, even though it hid shady conduct within his administration. Carter’s wholesomeness hurt him. Clinton and George W. Bush came across as friendly, jolly, approachable men. Bush was the guy many voters wanted to have a beer with. Clinton said, “I feel your pain,” and came across as empathetic. That quality also fit his sexual scandals, because the same charm that made him seem empathetic could also be seen as part of how he pursued women. Many voters forgave him.

The mix is different for every president. Until Trump, a president generally built his image from a set of positive attributes. Nixon had many negatives, certainly more than any president in my lifetime before Trump. He was “Tricky Dick,” and many people found him untrustworthy. But he still had broad support: in 1972, he won reelection by carrying 49 states. I would have to look more closely at what voters thought they were getting with Nixon.

Working backward: Eisenhower was a war hero, a quietly competent man, and physically vulnerable at times, including a major heart attack in 1955. He presided over an outwardly calm era, though the Cold War could have annihilated everyone and many serious problems were buried beneath the surface.

Kennedy was a war hero with great hair who cultivated youth, athleticism, and family-man imagery, even though he had serious health problems and was involved in extramarital relationships. Truman was deeply unpopular late in his presidency; Gallup recorded him at 22 percent approval in February 1952, the lowest in its presidential approval polling. He was blamed for inflation, labor conflict, corruption concerns, and the Korean War, though his historical reputation later improved. He tried to project the image of a straight shooter.

FDR represented fortitude. He governed while using leg braces and a wheelchair because of paralysis, and he used radio to speak directly to Americans through his fireside chats. He did not do those every week; he delivered 30 of them between 1933 and 1944. They helped him build trust with the public.

Every president had a different mix of positive attributes that America embraced, or that the president hoped America would embrace. Trump, in his second term, is the king of not caring about institutional expectations. I would not say he has a fragmented consciousness in a clinical sense, and I would avoid medical diagnosis from a distance. But he has no consistent worldview. He says whatever comes into his mind in the moment. There is little overarching governing philosophy giving structure to what he says from one moment to the next.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner On, 1: Spider-Noir, Nicolas Cage, Comic Canon, and Religion

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/06/06

Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner discuss Nicolas Cage’s Spider-Noir event, its black-and-white and color presentations, 1930s New York atmosphere, and film-noir dialogue. Rosner reflects on Cage’s Superman connection, comic-book canon, Star Trek writer’s guides, and the elastic physics of superheroes. Jacobsen presses a sharper comparison between religious texts and comic-book authority. The exchange moves from drone anxiety to pop culture, period authenticity, Emmy category strategy, and 1930s diner food, with amused, skeptical attention to mythmaking and realism.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: What is new with politics, or the comedy of politics, as the case may be?

Rick Rosner: I just got back from a Spider-Noir event with Nicolas Cage.

Jacobsen: Spider-Noir? How was it?

Rosner: It was good. It was very entertaining.

Jacobsen: What was the feel of it? How did they handle the filming and the color?

Rosner: You can watch it in color or in black and white. They showed us two episodes: one in black and white and one in color. Even the color version did not look fully modern. The series is set in 1930s New York, and they clearly wanted it to evoke the feel of early film noir. Cage talked about shaping his voice in a Humphrey Bogart direction. The dialogue was snappy. They also said Cage has made well over a hundred films, and this is his first lead role in a television series.

Jacobsen: Hold on.

[Pause]

It turned out to be machinery, not a drone.

Rosner: Do drones usually come during the day? I thought they tended to target electricity infrastructure.

Jacobsen: Usually, they do not. The other day, they did, and I went to the bathroom. It sounded as though there were several of them. It was genuinely scary. Anyway, back to Cage. What did you think of his cameo in The Flash, where he appears as Superman fighting the giant spider?

Rosner: Cage has had a long connection to Superman. He was attached to Tim Burton’s unmade Superman Lives, and his son is named Kal-El, though Cage has said the name was not chosen as a Superman tribute. He clearly likes comic books. I never became fully versed in comic books. I liked Mad Magazine, but I was never quite the right age for comic books to resonate with me. A lot of people know the full canon, especially because most big superhero movies are fairly canonical. For people who do not know what canon is, it means treating the source material as authoritative. You take what was said or shown in the comic books as the official version of events.

Jacobsen: That is an interesting thought. Do you think so-called holy texts are the original comic books? It seems like a similar impulse when you talk about canon. People will get into serious arguments over comic-book differences, though they usually will not kill over them. Religion has more ultimate stakes attached to it.

Rosner: I do not think the analogy fully holds. Whether or not the creators of religious texts believed everything they were writing, they certainly wanted other people to believe that the stories and rules were real. With comic books, nobody is trying to present them as literally true. Canon is different. I first heard the term, I think, in reference to Star Trek. Across its many series and films, Star Trek developed internal rules and writer’s guides so writers would understand the world, the characters, and the constraints.

For example, I do not especially like Star Trek, but I was interested in the math of warp drive: what speeds correspond to different warp numbers. In the original series, the warp scale was roughly the cube of the warp factor times the speed of light, so warp 10 would be 1,000 times the speed of light. Later, in the Next Generation era, warp 10 became a theoretical infinite limit. That gave the writers more room, because otherwise even very high warp speeds would still create huge travel-time problems. It is similar to Superman: Superman can go almost as fast as the plot needs him to go. In the first Christopher Reeve Superman film, he flies fast enough around Earth to reverse time and save Lois Lane. That is not how physics works, but it is how the story works.

Jacobsen: What stood out about Spider-Noir?

Rosner: The dialogue did not suck. Before the screening, they put up a “For Your Consideration” screen, and they seemed to be positioning it as an outstanding comedy series rather than a drama. It is not especially funny, but it has quippy dialogue. They may think it has a better shot in comedy. You have to choose whether to campaign as a comedy or a drama. The Bear, the restaurant show starring Jeremy Allen White, competes in comedy categories and often wins, even though it has more dramatic elements than comic ones.

I also like watching something as if I am from a different era. I pretended I was someone from the early 1930s watching it. A lot of the elements would have looked impressive if it had actually been made then: the special effects, the clothing, the actors, and the music. They did not strictly limit themselves to songs from the period, but the choices generally fit. One nightclub-singer character performed “Dream a Little Dream of Me,” which I first assumed was from the 1950s. It turns out the song dates to around 1930–1931, so it fits the period much better than I thought.

The clothing looked good. The actors looked good. One more detail: at the reception afterward, they served a little food to further butter us up. There were small shepherd’s pies, egg-salad sandwiches, and a plain green salad with a little chicken. On the way home, I realized they were probably trying to stay true to the period by serving simple 1930s-style diner food.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner on Unified Existence, Quantum Reality, and Ironclad Physical Rules

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/06/04

How does Rick Rosner explain existence as unified, relational, process-based, and grounded in ironclad physical rules?

Scott Douglas Jacobsen interviews Rick Rosner on foundations of existence, probing whether reality is unified, relational, and process-based rather than unitary. Rosner argues that particles require context, non-contradiction, spacetime, records of change, and near-certainty for macro objects. The exchange links quantum uncertainty, minimal necessary units, mathematical self-consistency, time as change, and consciousness as emergent but governed by ironclad rules, rejecting vague metaphysics for a grounded informational realism within a philosophically ambitious and scientifically skeptical conversation.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: The first one we have here is your perspective. The big premise is the idea that there are fundamental architectures, foundational frameworks of being. What is the substance, the stuff that makes up the universe or all of reality? Is that a good place to start, or is it an integrated set of things that cannot help but emerge entangled together?

Rick Rosner: It is all one thing. The stuff cannot exist without a context for existence. You cannot have a particle without the existential framework for the particle. To that extent, it is all one thing. Quantum mechanics, which I do not adequately understand, provides that mathematical framework. It characterizes things that exist and the framework in which they exist. You cannot have floating stuff existing.

Jacobsen: All right. We are going to have this more free-floating conversation, but I have my frameworks of research in the background around this, and we will see how far this goes. You are talking about unified existence.

Rosner: Unified, not unitary. “Unitary” sounds like everything is one thing. I am saying that it is the combination of the thing that exists and the framework in which it exists.

Jacobsen: So, unitary, no; unified, yes. Another term less commonly used, which I have used in prior writing, is “unicity,” meaning that it is unified, yes, but each potential universe in and of itself is unique in its own quality, whatever you want to call it.

Rosner: Yes. As we have discussed many times, the principles of existence are generally freedom from contradiction. Stuff cannot both exist and not exist in the same respect. You could also say there are mathematical limits to the extent to which things can both exist and not exist, or appear contradictory, when there is incomplete information about them. Under quantum mechanics, you can have probabilities, superpositions, and uncertainty about states. Within those limits, as long as you do not have complete information, the state can be open to question.

To use the overused cliché, Schrödinger’s cat: before measurement, the cat is represented in a quantum superposition tied to the underlying quantum event. Once you have a definite measurement, the observed outcome has to be one thing or another: alive or dead. In order for macro things to exist in the way we understand them, they have to have existential near-certainty.

When you catch a baseball, another cliched object to discuss in relation to existence, there is enough evidence of its existence. The roughly 10³⁰ particles it contains, the history of the ball, and your existence in the world along with the ball all serve to confirm the ball’s existence to near certainty. Along with that near certainty, you get a lack of contradiction. It certainly exists. It certainly had a history. There is no magical appearance of macro objects out of nowhere. The history and the massive number of particles it contains serve to confirm and substantiate its existence without contradiction.

Jacobsen: Is there anything absolute in those terms?

Rosner: No. It is all constructed.

Jacobsen: Would you argue that it is more an orientation on existence as stuff, or existence as substrate?

Rosner: I do not know.

Jacobsen: This is an interesting one. Would you argue that particles or simples? Is the universe composed of indivisible or minimal units?

Rosner: Yes, minimal necessary units.

Jacobsen: Why the word “necessary”?

Rosner: Because, in order to have existence, we need a framework. We do not fully know the mechanics of existence, but we have the particle zoo, which includes many particles, some elementary and some composite. There are five particle types that do much of the macro business of the universe. When you look at macro objects, what you are seeing involves protons, neutrons, electrons, photons, and, in the wider physical picture, neutrinos. Protons and neutrons are composite particles made of quarks; electrons, photons, and neutrinos are elementary in the Standard Model.

Then you have support particles and fields that facilitate the existence and interaction of those particles. It is all a necessary framework. Is the physics of our universe the simplest possible physics? Probabilistically, yes. Could you simulate a universe that was still consistent but had different physics? Many of the particles we have are built from group-theoretic principles that make everything consistent. Could you build a more complex basis of existence from different groups? You might still have the main particles, but they might require more support structure. Could you build a universe with a bunch of extra information, so it has four or five spatial dimensions, and prop it up as a simulated universe? You could probably do that, but it would take propping up. The default universe is probably what we exist in: the simplest possible configuration and particle structure.

Basically, you asked whether our cars are the simplest unitary thing. You could say, yes, we have the simplest possible cars, but a car has all these parts necessary for it to be a car. Particles have all these supporting structures that are necessary for the particle to do what it needs to do. What it needs to do is exist in certain ways.

Jacobsen: Do the basic units bear properties, or are properties derived from them, or both?

Rosner: I do not know. If you poke at that, I am not sure there is a meaningful difference. The particles are what they are, or have what they need, in order to do what they need to do: be part of a consistent, existent universe. What happens with the major particles and all the support particles is that they can exist in changing configurations, and configurations that encode some kind of memory, some kind of evidence of a past. If there is no way to retain a record of the past, then there is no past, and there is no existence. You could list the things necessary for existence: spacetime, a record of the past, and particles or fields configured in ways that allow for that.

Jacobsen: What about pattern, form, and structure? Is that more fundamental than this object orientation itself, or is there some type of…

Rosner: It is all part of self-consistency. Take the number line. Take counting numbers. It is a very consistent system. Every time you add a set of numbers in whatever order, or multiply them, you end up with the same result. You have to work hard to find any part of mathematics that is potentially contradictory. Whatever parts you may find after the sixth year of a postdoc, those potential contradictions do not jeopardize the entire structure.

Is that structure inherent to existence? I do not know. I am not sure that I care. It is a system that arises again and again in relation to the real world because it is simple and self-consistent. It earns its reflection in the world through its simplicity and self-consistency. Does that mean it has inherency? I do not care. You can argue that it is emergent, but the only thing that matters is whether it is self-consistent, because that is what you need, among other things, for existence.

You can go further and ask: Why is self-consistency the foundation of all this? Some people would say it is obvious. Really, it probably is not. You probably have to poke at that whole thing. Is that something I am interested in doing? No. I am barely interested in doing anything.

Jacobsen: What about the fundamental idea of change and activity in the universe, so nothing is truly static, as in your IC model, the general picture?

Rosner: One of the essential elements of existence is time. If things do not change, then time does not elapse. You need change. If things cycle between a million different moments and that sequence repeats, then you have only the span of time until it cycles again. To have ongoing time, you need a record of change. When stuff does not change, or when it repeats exactly, you do not really have time that moves forward.

I would argue that change is time. Time is not merely the playground in which change can happen. They are the same thing. Change and time are so logically interlinked that they are the same thing.

Jacobsen: Is the general framework a relational physical-realist perspective on the universe – networks, systems, structures, and relations?

Rosner: Yes.

Jacobsen: I am working after that unified framework from before, but it is a process of continuous networked and structurally integrated change.

Rosner: You have to be able to argue for the existence of things rather than for an evanescent possibility of existence. What we perceive as the world in the moment, each moment of existence, could have arisen from random stuff to give the illusion of a real, old, and durable universe. But you need to be able to make a mathematical argument, built in reasonable physics, for the high probability that it is real.

Jacobsen: The last one in this section is that reality is grounded. It is unified, relational, and process-based, but it is grounded in something, not vague ideas of consciousness or experience.

Rosner: It has ironclad requirements for existence. It is not woo-woo, hand-wavy stuff. It is quantum mechanics, not probably our current form of quantum mechanics, which is really good but still incomplete. There is an ironclad framework for existence based on principles of non-contradiction and the requirements of existence: spacetime, matter or fields, change, distinct moments, and all those things.

While arising, or emerging, from increasingly information-rich moments in a developing universe, they become ironclad in their emergence. There is no magic, including consciousness. Consciousness itself, when pinned down, will be ironclad. Consciousness as manifested in various entities can be mushy. If you have a damaged or limited brain, consciousness is going to be damaged or limited. But the rules for what consciousness is, while emergent, are ironclad when manifested.

Jacobsen: Relational, dynamic, informational, process-based, with ironclad rules, and durable as a principles-based perspective on an IC view of foundations of being.

Rosner: Yes.

Jacobsen: Let us call it a day.

Rosner: All right. Thank you.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Bill Pulte as Acting DNI: Trump Loyalism, Intelligence, Ukraine, and Political Competence

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/06/03

Rick Rosner and Scott Douglas Jacobsen examine Trump’s appointment of Bill Pulte as acting Director of National Intelligence, the weaponization claims surrounding FHFA mortgage-fraud referrals, congressional retirements, Watergate comparisons, and competence inside Trump’s administration. They also discuss Biden’s 2024 debate performance, geriatric delirium, Democratic failures, Menendez’s corruption conviction, and Russia’s capacity to sustain large missile-and-drone attacks against Ukraine amid constraints on ballistic-missile production and air-defense saturation tactics during the 2026 midterm season and beyond globally.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: There have been longitudinal studies examining which decades of life people consider the most satisfying in a broad sense.

Rick Rosner: Longitudinal studies being those in which researchers repeatedly test or survey the same people across many years or decades, as you indicated.

Jacobsen: Exactly.

One of the recurring questions concerns retrospective life satisfaction. Interestingly, people often identify the decade immediately preceding their current one as their favorite.

People in their thirties frequently say their twenties were their best years. People in their forties often point to their thirties. Those in their fifties often choose their forties. The pattern continues through later life, with people in their sixties favoring their fifties, people in their seventies favoring their sixties, and so forth.

While the details vary across studies and cultures, there does seem to be a tendency for people to look back fondly on the previous stage of life. Human beings appear to be built, in part, for retrospective evaluation and reinterpretation of their experiences.

You are sixty-six now. Your birthday was on May 2.

What advice would you give to your younger self in your twenties, thirties, forties, and fifties?

Rosner: I should have been less lazy academically. I should have given myself a stronger foundation in mathematics and physics.

Jacobsen: Which decade are we talking about?

Rosner: My twenties.

Jacobsen: Anything else you would tell your twenty-year-old self?

Rosner: I probably should have had more sex.

I did not do terribly, especially considering my personality, which is somewhat spectrum-like. But today we are seeing a broader surrender to social incompetence among younger generations.

There is a global decline in fertility. Some people call it a crisis. There are many reasons for it, but one factor seems to be that many young people struggle with face-to-face social interaction. They are more isolated, more dependent on their phones, and often less willing to put in the effort that dating requires.

Yes, people meet through apps, but successful dating still requires effort. You have to make yourself presentable, develop social skills, and repeatedly put yourself in situations that may be awkward, disappointing, or uncomfortable. Many experiences are mediocre. Some are bad. A few are so disastrous that they become entertaining stories.

Speaking personally, having grown up during the 1970s, a fairly uninhibited decade, I do not think I took advantage of enough opportunities.

That idea that people always regard the previous decade as their best is partly a measure of nostalgia, but it is also a measure of resignation.

Jacobsen: It is not exactly N minus ten. It is more that people often idealize the decade immediately preceding their current one.

Rosner: Right. Whatever decade people are in, they often say the previous decade was the best.

But there is no way my fifties were my best decade. They were good for many things, certainly.

Jacobsen: We started collaborating when you were fifty-two. That is pretty remarkable.

Rosner: Yeah, it is.

But consider something simple. I laid flagstones leading up to the front door of our house. They look better than poured concrete and have a nice rustic quality.

We moved into the house in 1998, and I installed the flagstones in 1999. I was thirty-nine years old at the time. Each slab weighed roughly four hundred pounds. Somehow I managed to load those stones into my car by myself, unload them, and position them properly.

The idea of doing that today is almost inconceivable.

That represents the difference. In my thirties, I was extraordinarily strong. Compared with now, when I am much thinner, the contrast is striking. I still work out regularly, but I cannot maintain muscle mass the way I once could.

Aging changes everything. My fifties were good in many ways, but my twenties and thirties were unquestionably better for physical strength and vitality.

I also wish I had pursued more adventures.

Part of me wishes I could have experienced my twenties in the 2010s or today. For someone with my personality, dating in the 1980s required going to bars, dances, and social gatherings. I met my wife at a dance.

Today, with dating apps, I suspect I would have done quite well. I could have curated my profile, presented myself effectively, and connected with compatible people much more easily.

I also wish I had tried harder to become a professional actor.

I always found reasons not to pursue it. I did not want to deal with rejection. There were always other things demanding my attention.

Realistically, there was nothing stopping me from trying except my own hesitation. The profession involves constant rejection, and with my unusual face, I probably would have experienced plenty of it. But in terms of the actual craft of acting, I think I would have been perfectly capable.

If I could do my twenties over again, I might have had the courage to take a more serious shot at it.

I do not know. There you go.

Jacobsen: Are you satisfied with what you have done during this decade of your life so far?

Rosner: No. I have been a lazy piece of shit. Although I have been working on this book. If I actually finish the damn book, I have been too lazy, too complacent, and too distracted. No, I am not satisfied.

I have wasted a lot of time. Stephen King has a line about time being a beautiful pony. He argues that you have to capture that pony and put reins on it; otherwise, it runs wild and you waste it.

Jacobsen: Do you see value in taking appropriate rest periods during the day or throughout the week in order to make better use of that pony?

Rosner: Not really. I see rest primarily as a health requirement. You need enough sleep because disordered sleep is bad for your health.

Jacobsen: And your productivity probably declines as well.

Rosner: I do not know. There are plenty of times when I could be productive but decide to take a nap instead. I probably take the whole napping thing too far at the expense of productivity.

Jacobsen: What would you consider your most productive period?

Rosner: When I was working for Kimmel.

For years, I operated in a mode of forced productivity. Not only was I producing constantly for Kimmel, but I was also more productive outside of work in terms of writing and other projects. I was simply driven.

The job also gave me an excuse to spend most of my time working. I did not have to justify being in the office all the time because it was part of the job.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Rick Rosner on Aging, Nostalgia, Productivity, and Advice to His Younger Self

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/06/03

Scott Douglas Jacobsen interviews Rick Rosner about aging, nostalgia, and advice to younger selves. Rosner reflects on missed academic preparation, dating opportunities, physical decline, unrealized acting ambitions, and dissatisfaction with his current productivity. He contrasts youthful strength with later-life limitations, recalls forced productivity while writing for Kimmel, and critiques excessive rest. The discussion becomes a candid meditation on time, regret, discipline, and making fuller use of life’s strongest decades.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: There have been longitudinal studies examining which decades of life people consider the most satisfying in a broad sense.

Rick Rosner: Longitudinal studies being those in which researchers repeatedly test or survey the same people across many years or decades, as you indicated.

Jacobsen: Exactly.

One of the recurring questions concerns retrospective life satisfaction. Interestingly, people often identify the decade immediately preceding their current one as their favorite.

People in their thirties frequently say their twenties were their best years. People in their forties often point to their thirties. Those in their fifties often choose their forties. The pattern continues through later life, with people in their sixties favoring their fifties, people in their seventies favoring their sixties, and so forth.

While the details vary across studies and cultures, there does seem to be a tendency for people to look back fondly on the previous stage of life. Human beings appear to be built, in part, for retrospective evaluation and reinterpretation of their experiences.

You are sixty-six now. Your birthday was on May 2.

What advice would you give to your younger self in your twenties, thirties, forties, and fifties?

Rosner: I should have been less lazy academically. I should have given myself a stronger foundation in mathematics and physics.

Jacobsen: Which decade are we talking about?

Rosner: My twenties.

Jacobsen: Anything else you would tell your twenty-year-old self?

Rosner: I probably should have had more sex.

I did not do terribly, especially considering my personality, which is somewhat spectrum-like. But today we are seeing a broader surrender to social incompetence among younger generations.

There is a global decline in fertility. Some people call it a crisis. There are many reasons for it, but one factor seems to be that many young people struggle with face-to-face social interaction. They are more isolated, more dependent on their phones, and often less willing to put in the effort that dating requires.

Yes, people meet through apps, but successful dating still requires effort. You have to make yourself presentable, develop social skills, and repeatedly put yourself in situations that may be awkward, disappointing, or uncomfortable. Many experiences are mediocre. Some are bad. A few are so disastrous that they become entertaining stories.

Speaking personally, having grown up during the 1970s, a fairly uninhibited decade, I do not think I took advantage of enough opportunities.

That idea that people always regard the previous decade as their best is partly a measure of nostalgia, but it is also a measure of resignation.

Jacobsen: It is not exactly N minus ten. It is more that people often idealize the decade immediately preceding their current one.

Rosner: Right. Whatever decade people are in, they often say the previous decade was the best.

But there is no way my fifties were my best decade. They were good for many things, certainly.

Jacobsen: We started collaborating when you were fifty-two. That is pretty remarkable.

Rosner: Yeah, it is.

But consider something simple. I laid flagstones leading up to the front door of our house. They look better than poured concrete and have a nice rustic quality.

We moved into the house in 1998, and I installed the flagstones in 1999. I was thirty-nine years old at the time. Each slab weighed roughly four hundred pounds. Somehow I managed to load those stones into my car by myself, unload them, and position them properly.

The idea of doing that today is almost inconceivable.

That represents the difference. In my thirties, I was extraordinarily strong. Compared with now, when I am much thinner, the contrast is striking. I still work out regularly, but I cannot maintain muscle mass the way I once could.

Aging changes everything. My fifties were good in many ways, but my twenties and thirties were unquestionably better for physical strength and vitality.

I also wish I had pursued more adventures.

Part of me wishes I could have experienced my twenties in the 2010s or today. For someone with my personality, dating in the 1980s required going to bars, dances, and social gatherings. I met my wife at a dance.

Today, with dating apps, I suspect I would have done quite well. I could have curated my profile, presented myself effectively, and connected with compatible people much more easily.

I also wish I had tried harder to become a professional actor.

I always found reasons not to pursue it. I did not want to deal with rejection. There were always other things demanding my attention.

Realistically, there was nothing stopping me from trying except my own hesitation. The profession involves constant rejection, and with my unusual face, I probably would have experienced plenty of it. But in terms of the actual craft of acting, I think I would have been perfectly capable.

If I could do my twenties over again, I might have had the courage to take a more serious shot at it.

I do not know. There you go.

Jacobsen: Are you satisfied with what you have done during this decade of your life so far?

Rosner: No. I have been a lazy piece of shit. Although I have been working on this book. If I actually finish the damn book, I have been too lazy, too complacent, and too distracted. No, I am not satisfied.

I have wasted a lot of time. Stephen King has a line about time being a beautiful pony. He argues that you have to capture that pony and put reins on it; otherwise, it runs wild and you waste it.

Jacobsen: Do you see value in taking appropriate rest periods during the day or throughout the week in order to make better use of that pony?

Rosner: Not really. I see rest primarily as a health requirement. You need enough sleep because disordered sleep is bad for your health.

Jacobsen: And your productivity probably declines as well.

Rosner: I do not know. There are plenty of times when I could be productive but decide to take a nap instead. I probably take the whole napping thing too far at the expense of productivity.

Jacobsen: What would you consider your most productive period?

Rosner: When I was working for Kimmel.

For years, I operated in a mode of forced productivity. Not only was I producing constantly for Kimmel, but I was also more productive outside of work in terms of writing and other projects. I was simply driven.

The job also gave me an excuse to spend most of my time working. I did not have to justify being in the office all the time because it was part of the job.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Genetic Longevity, Ashkenazi Centenarians, and Indefinite Life Extension

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/06/02

Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Rick Rosner discuss exceptional longevity, focusing on Ashkenazi Jewish centenarian genetics, HDL particle size, IGF-1 receptor variants, and delayed age-related disease. They compare genetic protection with lifestyle and epigenetic effects, weighing nature against modern public health gains such as vaccination, sanitation, and medical care. Rosner links longevity science to Aubrey de Grey’s damage-repair framework, Ray Kurzweil’s indefinite life extension, and future human-technology integration under modern conditions.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Dr. Nir Barzilai is leading an effort to recruit 10,000 people aged 95 and older, along with their families, to study genetic factors associated with exceptional longevity. His research focuses on gene variants that may help protect against age-related diseases, including cardiovascular disease, Alzheimer’s disease, type 2 diabetes, and cancer.

He has been doing this work for some time. In studies of Ashkenazi Jewish centenarians and their families, researchers have found several genetic variants associated with exceptional longevity. Some of these are linked to favorable lipid profiles, including higher HDL cholesterol levels and larger HDL particle sizes.

Researchers have also studied variants in the IGF-1 receptor gene. These variants may reduce sensitivity to insulin-like growth factor signaling, a pathway associated with growth, metabolism, and aging. Similar pathways have been shown to influence lifespan in animal models, although the effects in humans are more complex.

One striking finding is that many of these centenarians did not necessarily follow unusually healthy lifestyles. Some were overweight, smoked, drank alcohol, or did not exercise regularly. Even so, they lived to very old ages, suggesting that protective genetic factors may have delayed the onset of age-related disease.

That is what I wanted to bring into the discussion. These individuals do not appear to avoid the major diseases of aging entirely; rather, they often develop them later than average. Their genes may give them additional healthy years before those diseases appear. Looking at the role of genetics in exceptional longevity, what are your thoughts on this?

Rick Rosner: I want to live long enough for science to replicate some of this so that I can gain extra years. Things are progressing reasonably quickly.

Aubrey de Grey has argued that aging involves seven broad categories of cellular and molecular damage. The question is whether fixing some of them would give people an additional 15 or 20 years, or whether all seven would need to be addressed. If all seven could be addressed, could that provide 40 or 50 extra years?

And if you gained 40 or 50 extra years, perhaps the advances made during that time could provide another 30 years, and so on. That is the idea behind indefinite life extension. Ray Kurzweil says you do not have to live forever; you only have to live indefinitely, because forever is a mathematical absurdity.

Jacobsen: Biologically, too.

Rosner: Yes. At some point, you are no longer entirely biological. You become merged with technologies or other systems.

Jacobsen: Do you think it was wise to use the Ashkenazi Jewish population for this research? Because kinship ties and marriage have historically tended to remain within the group, researchers may have considered it useful as a relatively genetically homogeneous founder population.

Rosner: They have a fairly tight genetic cluster. The strategy was probably to work with a relatively concentrated set of genomes. As homogeneous as the Ashkenazi Jewish population is, there is still considerable genetic variation, but not as much as in the general population. I am sure that gave him a useful amount of genetic diversity, enough to identify supercentenarians, but not so much that the signal would be lost in the variation. So, yes, I assume that was part of the strategy.

Jacobsen: Do you think that if researchers studied epigenetic factors in addition to genetics, they would find subtler effects or more profound effects?

Rosner: If you are looking at people who live 20 or 30 years longer than average, you can estimate the magnitude of the effect from the lifespan difference itself. I would not expect epigenetic effects alone to account for an additional 20 or 30 years of life. Living a healthy lifestyle, with regular exercise, a balanced diet, and other beneficial habits, might add several years, perhaps even a decade or more.

However, these researchers have identified genetic factors that appear to confer substantial advantages independently of lifestyle. A healthy lifestyle combined with favorable genetics may provide additional benefits, but the genetics seem to be doing much of the work that healthy habits only partially accomplish. So, no, I do not think the epigenetic effects associated with lifestyle are as influential as the underlying genetic factors in these cases.

Jacobsen: Would it be fair to argue that, in this context, nature is more influential than lifestyle?

Rosner: Under modern conditions, probably yes. That said, modern conditions themselves matter enormously. Public health measures such as vaccination, sanitation, and improved medical care have likely added decades to average life expectancy. Before widespread vaccination and sanitation, infant and childhood mortality were dramatically higher.

So, in a modern society where people are vaccinated, use seatbelts, and generally avoid major health risks such as smoking, genetics may become a more prominent factor in explaining differences in lifespan.

Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Rick.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Jacobsen Bank Analysis: Scott Douglas Jacobsen’s 10,494–10,842+ Publications Across 205 Media Outlets

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/03/16

Jacobsen Bank, In-Sight Publishing: How does the Jacobsen Bank publication analysis document Scott Douglas Jacobsen’s 10,494–10,842+ works across 205 media outlets by alphabetical listing and rank-ordered publication totals?

The following represents a comprehensive analysis of content in the Jacobsen Bank since founding — while working part-time at an equestrian facility in Langley, British Columbia, Canada, as a ranch hand and landscaper to review the horse community in Canada — to catalogue all materials produced in the career. This database of publications includes articles, interviews, and republications in part, e.g., clippings, or whole. Future analyses would be warranted. The current date is March 8, 2026 conducted in Kyiv, Ukraine during the Russian aggression against Ukraine on International Women’s Day. The presentation will be two-fold. One, the comprehensive alphabetical listing of outlets followed by publication count per outlet, where “outlets” means blogs, news sites, opinion publications, periodicals, and other media venues. Second, the listing of the outlets for publication numbers from highest quantity to lowest quantity. Some extant draft formats may be accidentally counted in these tallies. However, there are not many. Therefore, these tallies will be close to sole authorship or co-authorship listings per outlet. To begin:

3 Quarks Daily has 3 publications.

A Further Inquiry has 80 publications; although, unarchived numbers are above 340.

A Life in Comedy has 6 publications.

Action Canada for Sexual Health and Rights has 1 publication.

Advice to Gifted and Talented Youth has 8 publications.

Advocacy for Alleged Witches has 2 publications.

Alessia and Marti has 1 publication.

Alliance of Former Muslims has 2 publications.

Allianz vun Humanisten Atheisten & Agnostiker has 1 publication.

American Enterprise Institute has 1 publication.

AndrewCopson.Com has 1 publication.

Anglican Link has 1 publication.

Anna Sundari has 1 publication.

Annaborgia has 6 publications.

Arab Atheist Broadcasting has 1 publication.

Aristotle / Alexander has 1 publication.

Ask A Genius has 1590 publications; although, unarchived numbers are 1635.

Assorted In-Sights has 20 publications.

Atheist Alliance of America has 6 publications.

Atheist Freethinkers has 2 publications.

Atheist Republic (Blog) has 11 publications.

Atheist Republic (News) has 84 publications.

Atheist Republic (Op-Ed) has 6 publications.

Atheist Society of Nigeria has 15 publications.

AUSU Executive Blog has 2 publications.

Ayaan Hirsi Ali Foundation has 1 publication.

Baobab Inclusive Empowerment Society has 2 publications.

Basic Income Earth Network has 22 publications.

Baylor University has 1 publication.

BioAro has 1 publication.

Bishop Accountability has 14 publications.

Boa Morte has 2 publications.

Book Foreword has 1 publication.

Book References has 9 publications.

Born To Do Math has 211 publications.

British Columbia Centre on Substance Use has 1 publication.

bruceschneier.com has 1 publication.

buddhist-essentials-and-concepts.blogspot.com has 1 publication.

Canadian Atheist has 1,131 publications.

Canadian Science has 7 publications.

Canadian Students for Sensible Drug Policy has 54 publications.

Cannabis Life Network has 3 publications.

Cascade Institute has 1 publication.

Center for Inquiry Canada has 20 publications.

Centre for Heterodox Social Science has 1 publication.

Centre for International Advanced and Professional Studies has 1 publication.

Check Your Head has 3 publications.

Church and State has 1 publication.

City Startup Labs has 1 publication.

Cognitive Thrift has 69 publications.

College Rentals has 12 publications.

Conatus News/Uncommon Ground Media Inc. has 340 publications.

Cornelius Press has 20 publications.

CounterVortex has 1 publication.

critical links has 17 publications.

Current Wave Data has 1 publication.

Dabran Platform has 1 publication.

Daily Atheist has 1 publication.

Dear Rick has 15 publications.

Develop Africa has 1 publication.

Dimmblá has 1 publication.

Doral360 has 1 publication.

Dr. Caroline Fleck has 1 publication.

СокальINFO has 84 publications.

Earth, Skin & Eden has 2 publications.

East Turkistan Government-in-Exile has 5 publications.

Ecophiles has 2 publications.

EIN Presswire has 1 publication.

Enchanting the Void has 1 publication.

Europe Solidaire Sans Frontières has 3 publications.

Freedom From Codependency has 1 publication.

Fresh Start Recovery Centre has 7 publications.

Garymclelland.blog has 1 publication.

Gordon Neighbourhood House has 10 publications.

Greek Helsinki Monitor has 1 publication.

Green Reporter has 1 publication.

grothman.house.gov has 1 publication.

Harvest House Ministries has 1 publication.

HawkeyeAssociates.Ca has 1 publication.

HerbSilverman.Com has 27 publications.

Hrvatski Focus has 1 publication.

Huffington Post has 4 publications.

Humanismus has 1 publication.

Humanist Alliance Philippines International has 3 publications.

Humanist Perspectives has 1 publication; although, unarchived numbers are 7.

Humanisten has 2 publications.

Humanists International has 20 publications.

iData Research Inc. has 1 publication.

In-Sight: Independent Interview-Based Journal has 854 publications; although, unarchived numbers are higher.

Indian American Muslim Council has 1 publication.

Infinite Cosmology Blog has 1 publication.

International Policy Digest has 105 publications.

Irish Freethinkers & Humanists has 1 publication.

Islamic Supreme Council of Canada has 2 publications.

Jacobsen’s Jabberwocky has 3 publications.

Jain Avenue Magazine has 1 publication.

Jennifer Arrington has 10 publications.

Jewish Center for Peace has 1 publication.

Karmik has 3 publications.

kasesehumanistbizoha.blogspot.com has 1 publication.

Katsioulis.Com has 4 publications.

Kindred Media has 1 publication.

Kurdipedia has 1 publication.

La Petite Mort has 11 publications.

Learning Analytics Research Group has 2 publications.

Les News has 1 publication.

Lifespan Cognition Lab has 4 publications.

Lift Cannabis News has 3 publications.

Lost In Samsara has 1 publication.

Low Entropy has 1 publication.

Maxime Vende has 1 publication.

Medium (Humanist Voices) has 575 publications.

Medium (Other) has 1 publication.

Medium (Personal) has 1,900 publications.

Medium (Rick Rosner) has 66 publications.

Mendy Marcus has 7 publications.

Miscellaneous has 1 publication.

MomMandy has 1 publication.

MyMichiganBeach has 2 publications.

MyNewsGH has 1 publication.

Narsdoktorusa has 1 publication.

Natasha Taneka has 3 publications.

Naturalistic Paganism has 2 publications.

New Age Islam has 1 publication.

News Intervention has 287 publications.

NewsDay has 1 publication.

NEXUSNewsfeed has 1 publication.

Nimrokh Media has 1 publication.

Noesis: The Journal of the Mega Society has 48 publications; although, unarchived has more.

Northeast Ohio Weddings Magazine has 11 publications.

Oceane-Group has 7 publications.

Organic Bed Threads has 1 publication.

PardesSeleh.Com has 11 publications.

Parlour News Media has 1 publication.

PB Consulting Online has 1 publication.

Pensive Quill has 9 publications.

People, Personas, and Politics has 43 publications.

Personal SubStack has 22 publications; although, unarchived may be higher.

Piece of Mind has 5 publications.

Plays has 1 publication.

Polskie Stowarzyszenie Racjonalistów has 1 publication.

PrairieCare has 1 publication.

Prof. Robert Jensen has 1 publication.

Prometheism has 12 publications.

Purples Impressions has 3 publications.

Rational Doubt has 7 publications.

Ritual Killing in Africa has 2 publications.

RND4Impact has 1 publication.

roberto.foa.name has 3 publications.

Rockmount Financial Corporation has 1 publication.

Running Point Capital has 1 publication.

Salines.ba has 1 publication.

Sarah Zentz Jewelry has 1 publication.

shiessle.com has 1 publication.

Science, Technology and Philosophy has 4 publications.

Secular Student Alliance has 1 publication.

Secularism is a Women’s Issue has 8 publications.

SikivuHutchinson.Com has 1 publication.

Skeptic Meditations has 6 publications.

Skeptic Society Magazine has 4 publications.

SocioMix has 17 publications.

Stacey Piercey Gender Consulting Blog has 5 publications

Stuff2Digital has 1 publication.

Sundari Creations has 4 publications.

Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests has 2 publications.

Survivors Unleashed International has 1 publication.

SWAT Sociedad Anónima has 1 publication.

Synapse has 5 publications.

Tallu & Co. has 1 publication.

TeenFinance has 1 publication.

The Beam Magazine has 1 publication.

The Black Detour has 2 publications.

The Bud has 1 publication.

The Dawn Project has 2 publications.

The Future Of… has 13 publications.

The Good Death Society has 1 publication.

The Good Men Project has 1,777 publications; although, unarchived numbers are closer to the mid-1,800s.

The Humanist has 15 publications.

The Migrant Online has 2 publications.

The National Youth Internet Safety and Cyberbullying Task Force, Inc. has 7 publications.

The New Enlightenment Project has 39 publications.

The Online Therapist has 1 publication.

The Peak has 32 publications.

The Pink Triangle Trust has 1 publication.

The Rationalist has 1 publication.

The Ubyssey has 18 publications.

The Voice Magazine has 13 publications.

TheLovBud has 1 publication.

TomKin Consulting, LLC. has 10 publications.

Topical Magazine has 3 publications.

Transformative Dialogues has 1 publication.

Treasure Box Kids has 1 publication.

TrendBT has 27 publications.

Trusted Clothes has 231 publications.

U.S. Hispanic Business Council has 2 publications.

Unapologetic Atheism has 1 publication.

USIA Blog has 11 publications.

USIA Research Journal has 5 publications.

Sam.Tripod.Com has 6 publications.

Vatican Observatory has 1 publication.

Vocal.Media has 85 publications; although, unarchived numbers are more than 120.

Watchtower Documents has 1 publication.

Werner Price has 1 publication.

Westside Seniors Hub has 1 publication.

WIN ONE/Phenomenon has 53 publications.

The tally comes to 10,494 publications across 205 outlets up to 10,842+ publications across 205 outlets based on the evaluation criteria provided by the Jacobsen Bank before. Not everything has been archived and some have not been archived, perhaps — more precisely, for more than a year. Therefore, these numbers or the range provided are definitively lower than current real totals. When rank-ordered by publication total rather than by alphabetical listing, the reframed listing comes to the following:

Using the archived counts in your latest excerpt, ranked highest to lowest, with ties alphabetized, and now retaining the caveat clauses where they appear in the source text.

This ranking still uses the archived numbers as stated for ordering. In other words, the caveat-bearing entries remain placed by their archived totals, not by inferred or approximate unarchived totals. Some extant draft formats may be accidentally counted in these tallies; however, there are not many, so these numbers should remain close to sole-authorship or co-authorship counts per outlet.

Medium (Personal) has 1,900 publications.

The Good Men Project has 1,777 publications; although, unarchived numbers are closer to the mid-1,800s.

Ask A Genius has 1,590 publications; although, unarchived numbers are 1,635.

Canadian Atheist has 1,131 publications.

In-Sight: Independent Interview-Based Journal has 854 publications; although, unarchived numbers are higher.

Medium (Humanist Voices) has 575 publications.

Conatus News/Uncommon Ground Media Inc. has 340 publications.

News Intervention has 287 publications.

Trusted Clothes has 231 publications.

Born To Do Math has 211 publications.

International Policy Digest has 105 publications.

Vocal.Media has 85 publications; although, unarchived numbers are more than 120.

Atheist Republic (News) has 84 publications.

СокальINFO has 84 publications.

A Further Inquiry has 80 publications; although, unarchived numbers are above 340.

Cognitive Thrift has 69 publications.

Medium (Rick Rosner) has 66 publications.

Canadian Students for Sensible Drug Policy has 54 publications.

WIN ONE/Phenomenon has 53 publications.

Noesis: The Journal of the Mega Society has 48 publications; although, unarchived has more.

People, Personas, and Politics has 43 publications.

The New Enlightenment Project has 39 publications.

The Peak has 32 publications.

HerbSilverman.Com has 27 publications.

TrendBT has 27 publications.

Basic Income Earth Network has 22 publications.

Personal SubStack has 22 publications; although, unarchived may be higher.

Assorted In-Sights has 20 publications.

Center for Inquiry Canada has 20 publications.

Cornelius Press has 20 publications.

Humanists International has 20 publications.

The Ubyssey has 18 publications.

critical links has 17 publications.

SocioMix has 17 publications.

Atheist Society of Nigeria has 15 publications.

Dear Rick has 15 publications.

The Humanist has 15 publications.

Bishop Accountability has 14 publications.

The Future Of… has 13 publications.

The Voice Magazine has 13 publications.

College Rentals has 12 publications.

Prometheism has 12 publications.

Atheist Republic (Blog) has 11 publications.

La Petite Mort has 11 publications.

Northeast Ohio Weddings Magazine has 11 publications.

PardesSeleh.Com has 11 publications.

USIA Blog has 11 publications.

Gordon Neighbourhood House has 10 publications.

Jennifer Arrington has 10 publications.

TomKin Consulting, LLC. has 10 publications.

Book References has 9 publications.

Pensive Quill has 9 publications.

Advice to Gifted and Talented Youth has 8 publications.

Secularism is a Women’s Issue has 8 publications.

Canadian Science has 7 publications.

Fresh Start Recovery Centre has 7 publications.

Mendy Marcus has 7 publications.

Oceane-Group has 7 publications.

Rational Doubt has 7 publications.

The National Youth Internet Safety and Cyberbullying Task Force, Inc. has 7 publications.

A Life in Comedy has 6 publications.

Annaborgia has 6 publications.

Atheist Alliance of America has 6 publications.

Atheist Republic (Op-Ed) has 6 publications.

Sam.Tripod.Com has 6 publications.

Skeptic Meditations has 6 publications.

East Turkistan Government-in-Exile has 5 publications.

Piece of Mind has 5 publications.

Stacey Piercey Gender Consulting Blog has 5 publications.

Synapse has 5 publications.

USIA Research Journal has 5 publications.

Huffington Post has 4 publications.

Katsioulis.Com has 4 publications.

Lifespan Cognition Lab has 4 publications.

Science, Technology and Philosophy has 4 publications.

Skeptic Society Magazine has 4 publications.

Sundari Creations has 4 publications.

3 Quarks Daily has 3 publications.

Cannabis Life Network has 3 publications.

Check Your Head has 3 publications.

Europe Solidaire Sans Frontières has 3 publications.

Humanist Alliance Philippines International has 3 publications.

Jacobsen’s Jabberwocky has 3 publications.

Karmik has 3 publications.

Lift Cannabis News has 3 publications.

Natasha Taneka has 3 publications.

Purples Impressions has 3 publications.

roberto.foa.name has 3 publications.

Topical Magazine has 3 publications.

Advocacy for Alleged Witches has 2 publications.

Alliance of Former Muslims has 2 publications.

Atheist Freethinkers has 2 publications.

AUSU Executive Blog has 2 publications.

Baobab Inclusive Empowerment Society has 2 publications.

Boa Morte has 2 publications.

Earth, Skin & Eden has 2 publications.

Ecophiles has 2 publications.

Humanisten has 2 publications.

Islamic Supreme Council of Canada has 2 publications.

Learning Analytics Research Group has 2 publications.

MyMichiganBeach has 2 publications.

Naturalistic Paganism has 2 publications.

Ritual Killing in Africa has 2 publications.

Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests has 2 publications.

The Black Detour has 2 publications.

The Dawn Project has 2 publications.

The Migrant Online has 2 publications.

U.S. Hispanic Business Council has 2 publications.

Action Canada for Sexual Health and Rights has 1 publication.

Alessia and Marti has 1 publication.

Allianz vun Humanisten Atheisten & Agnostiker has 1 publication.

American Enterprise Institute has 1 publication.

AndrewCopson.Com has 1 publication.

Anglican Link has 1 publication.

Anna Sundari has 1 publication.

Arab Atheist Broadcasting has 1 publication.

Aristotle / Alexander has 1 publication.

Ayaan Hirsi Ali Foundation has 1 publication.

Baylor University has 1 publication.

BioAro has 1 publication.

Book Foreword has 1 publication.

British Columbia Centre on Substance Use has 1 publication.

bruceschneier.com has 1 publication.

buddhist-essentials-and-concepts.blogspot.com has 1 publication.

Cascade Institute has 1 publication.

Centre for Heterodox Social Science has 1 publication.

Centre for International Advanced and Professional Studies has 1 publication.

Church and State has 1 publication.

City Startup Labs has 1 publication.

CounterVortex has 1 publication.

Current Wave Data has 1 publication.

Dabran Platform has 1 publication.

Daily Atheist has 1 publication.

Develop Africa has 1 publication.

Dimmblá has 1 publication.

Doral360 has 1 publication.

Dr. Caroline Fleck has 1 publication.

EIN Presswire has 1 publication.

Enchanting the Void has 1 publication.

Freedom From Codependency has 1 publication.

Garymclelland.blog has 1 publication.

Greek Helsinki Monitor has 1 publication.

Green Reporter has 1 publication.

grothman.house.gov has 1 publication.

Harvest House Ministries has 1 publication.

HawkeyeAssociates.Ca has 1 publication.

Hrvatski Focus has 1 publication.

Humanismus has 1 publication.

Humanist Perspectives has 1 publication; although, unarchived numbers are 7.

iData Research Inc. has 1 publication.

Indian American Muslim Council has 1 publication.

Infinite Cosmology Blog has 1 publication.

Irish Freethinkers & Humanists has 1 publication.

Jain Avenue Magazine has 1 publication.

Jewish Center for Peace has 1 publication.

kasesehumanistbizoha.blogspot.com has 1 publication.

Kindred Media has 1 publication.

Kurdipedia has 1 publication.

Les News has 1 publication.

Lost In Samsara has 1 publication.

Low Entropy has 1 publication.

Maxime Vende has 1 publication.

Medium (Other) has 1 publication.

Miscellaneous has 1 publication.

MomMandy has 1 publication.

MyNewsGH has 1 publication.

Narsdoktorusa has 1 publication.

New Age Islam has 1 publication.

NewsDay has 1 publication.

NEXUSNewsfeed has 1 publication.

Nimrokh Media has 1 publication.

Organic Bed Threads has 1 publication.

Parlour News Media has 1 publication.

PB Consulting Online has 1 publication.

Plays has 1 publication.

Polskie Stowarzyszenie Racjonalistów has 1 publication.

PrairieCare has 1 publication.

Prof. Robert Jensen has 1 publication.

RND4Impact has 1 publication.

Rockmount Financial Corporation has 1 publication.

Running Point Capital has 1 publication.

Salines.ba has 1 publication.

Sarah Zentz Jewelry has 1 publication.

Secular Student Alliance has 1 publication.

shiessle.com has 1 publication.

SikivuHutchinson.Com has 1 publication.

Stuff2Digital has 1 publication.

Survivors Unleashed International has 1 publication.

SWAT Sociedad Anónima has 1 publication.

Tallu & Co. has 1 publication.

TeenFinance has 1 publication.

The Beam Magazine has 1 publication.

The Bud has 1 publication.

The Good Death Society has 1 publication.

The Online Therapist has 1 publication.

The Pink Triangle Trust has 1 publication.

The Rationalist has 1 publication.

TheLovBud has 1 publication.

Transformative Dialogues has 1 publication.

Treasure Box Kids has 1 publication.

Unapologetic Atheism has 1 publication.

Vatican Observatory has 1 publication.

Watchtower Documents has 1 publication.

Werner Price has 1 publication.

Westside Seniors Hub has 1 publication.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

“On High-Range Test Construction Now”

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2025/08/15

“On High-Range Test Construction Now” demystifies the craft of designing, validating, and responsibly deploying high-ceiling assessments. Moving beyond folklore and forum lore, it unites classical test theory with modern methods—item response theory, Bayesian estimation, and adaptive delivery—to show exactly how to push ceilings higher without sacrificing rigor. Inside, you will find: principled approaches to item writing for extreme difficulty; strategies for small-sample norming and error bounds; safeguards against coaching and leakage; fairness checks and differential item functioning analyses; replication protocols; and practical workflows for remote administration. Clear case studies, templates, and decision checklists walk you from concept to pilot to publication, with transparency and ethics at the center. Whether you are a psychometrician, a researcher exploring outlier performance, or a community builder seeking credible measures, this book offers the tools—and the discipline—to separate signal from noise at the far right tail. Thoughtful, precise, and actionable, it is the definitive guide for anyone determined to create high-range tests that stand up to scientific scrutiny and real-world use.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Acknowledgement and Introductions to “Finding Humanistic Education in Our Stories”

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2025/08/15

Introduction by Scott Douglas Jacobsen

“It’s easy to love somebody. Shit, sit with them a little bit and talk to them a while.

Richard Pryor

“The silver swan, who, living had no note, when death approached unlocked her silent throat.”

Orlando Gibbons

The reimagination of education from the Yousefis comes from a sensibility of a “return to” rather than a “getting over” frame. A return to a humanistic referential mindset on the education of human beings with rich internal tapestries of thoughts and feelings connected to webs of extended social relations in the world rather than getting over them through the imposition of artifice. The nurturance of intellectual acumen and emotional sensitivities in tandem.

The Peace School served hundreds in Iran. The same institution, with a humanistic orientation, was formally registered in Spring 2024 in Canada. Individualized education based on each student’s unique qualities demands extensive thought, time to plan, and care in implementing–a tall order.

Amid correspondence, Nasser described the times of working in Iran and difficult circumstances. A family who has come through conflict, societal constraints, and trauma to advance educational reform and to promote a humanistic vision through peace via innovative educational curricula. Their family’s life story brings the antipodean pillars called Theory and Practice to a satisfying resolution in the Peace School—an Equator.

Transformative education only has to meet human needs as its base, and the diverse approaches to meet those needs can be as creative as necessary. The Yousefis champion each student’s unique and individual cultural, emotional, and intellectual needs. Empathy and respect can counterforce the homogenization of education and approaches to each student. To argue for best practices in a humanistic educational curriculum does not mean an argument for standardized education; it means human beings in key development moments have basic and diversified needs, and principles can be the basis for formulating educational experiences for each pupil.

Their approach, fundamentally, is a values-based approach for the nurturance of critical thinkers who are knowledgeable and passionate citizens with a global perspective. This allows for a cross-cultural fluidity in seeing the universal endeavours and benefits of cross-cultural exchange and collaborative wisdom. Their unwavering dedication to humanistic approaches gives a bulwark against institutional inertia from political and societal barriers in Iran, and using this knowledge to advance humanistic education in Canada is a well-needed contribution to Canadian culture and global humanism.

This short book of conversations with the Yousefis gives insight into the communal bonds being built and the democratic participation being encouraged at the Peace School. Their approach isn’t dogmatic but prompt-based to let one sit and think more deeply about a particular topic in education. You are not necessarily supposed to agree. The act of gentle coaxing into further consideration is the point. This approach plucks the strings of both mind and heart. Occasionally, some harmony results.

Introduction by Dr. Nasser Yousefi

I have been working in humanistic education in developing countries for over thirty years and have established diverse connections with international organizations. During these years, I have met and interacted with many experts and thinkers. Mr. Scott Douglas Jacobsen is one of the passionate and dedicated experts in humanistic fields who works tirelessly. Despite being young and energetic, he manages and follows through on numerous humanistic projects and ideas with remarkable maturity.

With his prepared resources, Mr. Scott Douglas Jacobsen has shaped the foundations and principles of humanism in the global community more than any other expert. Through his patience and wisdom, these resources have been developed. Without him, these concepts would not have been so easily documented. I am deeply grateful to him.

I would also like to express my gratitude to Baran Yousefi. As a graduate of humanistic schools, Baran has profoundly understood and embodied many of these concepts. I truly appreciate the collaboration between the three of us in advancing humanistic education.

Dr. Nasser Yousefi

Photo by In-Sight Publishing (Cover), Atiyeh Razaghi.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Acknowledgements and Foreword to “The Martian Inside Me”

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2025/08/15

The Martian Inside Me is part of a long collaboration with Norwegian writer Tor Arne Jørgensen and a compilation of our work to date. This is intended as a free public access resource.

Acknowledgements

The reason for this title is because, my search for answers to who I have, has thereby led me forward towards the unknown, where the feeling of my surrounding environment feels foreign and thus presented as alien. A state of desolation, whereas sensations of a landscape are created by endless entanglements and strange events which in turn provide the opportunity for a widening spectrum. To be an explorer in one’s own mind, where one is met with horror, wonder, emotions, hidden talents and, not least the fear of confrontation of who one really are, is, therefore, to be labelled as the Martian inside me.

Tor Arne Jørgensen

To Tor for the expansive collaboration and wide range of topics covered within his extensive remit, particularly schooling the young, which is ever-present and important.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Foreword by Tor Arne Jørgensen

My first encounter with the high intelligence community was back in 2015. The experience I had then was one of absolute joy, an ecstasy of finally coming home to one’s own. A place where one could be understood and accepted as equals. Imagine wandering through life in search of oneself. Many of us, and not just those with high intelligence, but all of us, search for something more, something that is mysteriously hidden from us. And then to find what you have been searching for so endlessly long, has such an inexplicable aura about it, something that cannot be described with just a few simple words. They become, as the saying goes, inadequate…

The fact that words are not sufficient is manifold reinforced for those who feel no boundaries, or see within what is considered extreme. Our brain is, in my opinion, our next step in evolution. What does one think of then? Well, regarding our physical self, yes, much remains, but not in any way near what remains to be understood of all our intellects. The mysteries of the brain, our hitherto unexplored field. It may seem like a lot of nonsense to view it this way, but if one reads between the lines, everything appears so much clearer, but only for the chosen few.

Evolution is many things, can be so much more than what we are left with when we hear the word. History put under the microscope is very much like putting time on hold. Joy, hate, laughter, and sorrow, each and every one of them clocks out only to clock in again and again. Logic was long all that mattered to me, nothing could surpass its all-encompassing wonderful being. The years following 2015 saw the hunt begin to devour whatever came my way. Becoming the best was all that mattered; everything else could wait. Can an IQ test be addictive, sitting hour after hour solving the unsolvable? At the time of writing, one looks back on the madness. No money to earn, no one who cares. Not in any way close to what athletes are left with, perhaps not so strange … Remember to read between the lines, dear reader.

At the end of the road, one can say that it was all worth it. The confirmation I sought was answered, for better or worse. The happiness I thought was secured proved to be so, but the time it lasted did not meet expectations. The hours that disappeared, I never found again, lost like everything else. Here I could have ended my journey, but what comes next is the certificate I acquired along the way. Divided into pieces, it tells what comes next, who I was, who I met, and who I am left with on my own little wondrous, lost, wonderful island. Not big enough for little me, but big enough for a whole world.

Before I finish, take with you three small texts from my first book «74» that describe my three stages through life, and finally a line that sums it all up.

Wondering about the unknown elements within yourself and in your surroundings

One of the most common feelings at a young age is the sense of one’s mind spinning out of control, where you sort of lose all touch with the outside world and your place within it. In this first part of the book, I will try to focus on the problem that many young people find themselves in, a time plagued with desperate attempts to find answers to some of the biggest questions in a young person’s life, questions like “Who am I to myself?” and “Who am I to you?”

Just remember that the people you surround yourself with will, whether you like it or not, shape everything around you for better or for worse, all while you are right there at the center of it all, like a sun that the planets just whirl around. As your life is about to take off, everything feels like a complete mess both outside and within. Questions will surface, questions like: How on earth am I going to survive? Am I going to lose myself completely right from the get-go? Am I going to make it despite all the setbacks I will surely face as I plough through life?

As I have read through various research articles about the human brain not being fully developed until it reaches 25 years of maturity, this research suggests that before this age, the autopilot is set to max, where everything not best tested is just that, and to its fullest at any cost that may or may not come next. As an adult watching on, this is a reality at its worst, as we can easily envision the consequences of their actions as we are forced to relive them all over again. While these unruly youths, from their point of view, think that we adults don’t understand anything at all and just keep their pedal to the metal, leaving their yet-to-be-discovered responsibilities in the dust.

“If only the world didn’t have to hurt so much.”

It is like two worlds speaking two very different languages. Two worlds that only want to inflict pain on each other, but of course that’s not true. The two worlds are just set adrift in different directions in the hope of one day finding themselves stranded on the same beach together, filled with mutual understanding, newfound love, and respect for each other.

As many young people tend to say:

“Why should we learn things that we will never have use for? What’s the point of living the life you never got to live? Our lives are not your lives, we would never ask you to live our lives, so don’t ask us to live yours. We are not your second chance to relive everything that was worth caring for nor to relive every opportunity missed.

We just want to live our lives the way we want to live them, on our terms only. If only you adults could somehow understand, when we say that we need to find out who we are for ourselves, society just needs to come to terms with the fact that this is how it is, just accept it, no ifs, ands, or buts.”

The chaos that occupies their young minds is there for a reason; it is their undefinable spark. So, just let them find their own way, no matter how painful it may feel. Only then can they be able to identify who they really are and where they must venture next, guided by the spark within them that will lead them towards their understanding of enlightenment. Remember the saying “The road is made as we go.” So let them envision their own nirvana, then and only then can we at some point later in life rejoin on the other side where we will once again speak the same language as we once did.

Exploring adventure, intimate feelings, and your darker side

Just as historical moments from time to time tend to throw the world off balance, life too, in much the same manner, also has this tendency to tip us over. Meaning that every decision accumulated from early age onwards will, at different stages, pave itself a new direction or decide to stay on the same path as before. What I would like to convey in this second part is the inevitable importance of dealing with what meets us when we as individuals are at a loss of where to go next. The choices that can topple us when we least expect it — just when everything seemed to be planned out, disaster strikes. This is where the battle between good and evil comes to be a very definite reality: who will I end up as, who am I at the very core, shall I embrace love or drown myself in self-hatred?

Question to you all:

Have you ever thought about taking a real good look into the mirror and being completely open to what or who may stare right back at you? To risk facing the scariest thing of all, as you could easily be your own worst nightmare, and if so, how to contain it? Do you cover it up so no one will be the wiser? What would you do if this were the case…?

Whatever your answer may be, the truth of the matter is that we have been forced through millennia of generations to reveal our true colors come what may. Many people, myself included, know all too well the lure of the unknown darkness, where we just want to consume everything that comes in our path just like a giant black hole that engulfs everything within its reach, oblivious to the notion of right or wrong.

At this stage, the choices we make must be treated with the gravest importance because the reality we now face in adulthood shapes the end version of us. It is at this point in life that we must confront our inner demons much more so than before. As mentioned earlier, “are we able to contain our inner demons or not? Are they to be embraced fully or kept tucked safely away?” These are just a few of many major decisions each of us must assess through our lives in various degrees. The choice between being naughty or nice.

Curiosity, life’s end, family, love, and friendship.

As I’m about to hand in my keys, I find myself looking back, and what I discover is that the life that once felt like an eternity passes far too quickly. A time that once was in abundance is now reduced to just a few sacred moments soon to be scattered to the four winds. As an introduction to this final chapter of my book, I will begin by asking questions about the meaning of life and reminisce over lost love eroded away by time. I will also talk about the importance of family values and long-lasting friendship, all the important pieces that make our lives worth living.

As we get to a certain age, more and more questions keep popping up, questions like: How will the near to far future look, and what will happen to us next when we are faced with the ultimate climax, i.e., the inevitable ending that awaits us all, the very thing that everyone does their best to block out? Why are we forced to see ourselves weathering in the same way that time sees itself ebbing away until only a single grain remains desperately clinging to whatever hope was left?

As a reminder of how we came to be, i.e., the origins of what we all take for granted. Animals, people, flowers, trees, land, sea, indeed all between the heavens and the earth. Why is it that all life except our own is blissfully unaware of the fate that awaits at the end, our own mortality, the only thing left that will not succumb to our will? On that occasion, I feel that the following question is most appropriate:

By what right were we created, fully aware of what we must face when life decides to give up? What was the grand plan of making us living witnesses to our own demise? Is this not the ultimate sign of cruelty, afflicting this kind of pain upon us humans? Could we not just wander through life oblivious to everything around us like everything else?

Were we not deemed worthy enough for you to grant us the gift of blindness to life’s ultimate sacrifice? If you only did as any great author will do when he or she gives life to a story, they hold back from revealing the book’s true intentions until just a few leaves remain. Then at least many of us would be spared the horrors of dealing with the notion of death every single day. A daily reminder of how fragile life can be, whereby with a snap of a finger all can be lost. Is life really meant to be as fragile as it’s portrayed to be?

As the saying goes, prayers heal all wounds, both the wounds we see on the outside and the wounds we never get to see, the ones that linger on the inside. I wonder, is there also a prayer for cheating at the ultimate cost?

As I look upon memories that flip through their greatest hits, I keep reminding myself that the best memories are the ones that are shared with everyone around. “To love thy neighbor as thyself” is for me to love everything and everyone that loves me back. Remember that a full life is a life shared together with the love of your life right by your side, as you watch your perfect offspring as they take to their wings in your forever prayers.

As my glass now reads empty, I would like to add:

To my eternal friends, you who took me under your wings, I will never forget you. As I now come to my end, let me just say, give your all to the ones you hold dear, and life will take care of the rest. Maybe we are the lucky ones, lucky in the sense to be able to reflect on all the joys and all the sorrows that have made us who we are. If we are in some way able to hold onto this notion, then perhaps death is not so hard to swallow after all, whether life has led us astray or not.

I want to include a saying that came to me in the shelter of the night. I couldn’t let it go, and in many ways, it summarizes how I experience the world around me. I hope it makes sense. It goes as follows: Here’s the proofread version of the line:

Who then interprets those who refuse to be read by those who refuse to understand?

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Introduction to “Wile Away Hogwash: A Short Play”

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2025/08/09

Introduction by Scott Douglas Jacobsen

I found this piece while coming upon another trove of material to archive in the Jacobsen Bank. As it turns out, I have more work to do here. I wrote this in a Canadian secondary school, somewhere between Grade 9 and Grade 11, for a drama class. I ended up directing the play. It has some personal, emotive tones that incorporate my life story. The essential take, upon re-review as an adult, is a poetical meta-verse drama. There is a Young Woman writer inspired by an Old Man telling a tale—a tale of a Father and a Son in reconciliation after a mother’s suicide. The Frame is a bench that encloses the inner story, connecting the kitchen to the bench. A play within a play calling to resolutions and relations across timespans outside of its premise.

Scene 1 opens with a ‘tale to tell.’ Lights shift to Scene 2, with Scene 3 returning to steer the tone, while Scene 5 provides a resolution on the bench. The final scene hints that the Old Man is the Son grown up, while the Woman sends a “hello” to his father. The story pivots from a question of who to blame to a question of why for understanding. The themes of repentance, apology, and resolution sit within it. The Son’s misdirected anger and the Father’s apology for failing to console. A resolution to the writer’s block for the finished script, to “possess a success.” Is this the play itself, or a play on the meta-verse once more?

Symbols and motifs are simple: bench, book, briefcase, watch, and writing binder. The dramaturgical elements are a split stage with clean fading from an inner story to a breath and reset. The physicality represents the spectrum of caution and trust with an offer of a seat, a matched posture, and delayed eye contact. Everything means something here, signifiers. The bench is a reconciliation ground for empathic alignment. The book and briefcase represent a container of a story. The writing binder is a visible embodiment of creative healing, of our narratives to do so, in time. The watch is time, as it beats before reconciliation. He checks the watch, then waits–as we all do, at some time.

The beat design is a cough interrupting. It is an anaphora. It is a projected shock in ‘die.’ There are couplets and triplets for a lift, while a slant in rhymes to roughen the conflict, and then tighter rhymes signal sealing resolutions. When I wanted to drive more momentum, I incorporated denser alliteration. While the modulative score represents orientations in vocal dynamics to guide the story, they are part of various symmetries and asymmetries hidden in plain sight and sound of the audience. It is an inner story with elevated and archaic diction, with colloquial playful rhymes, even casual conversational rhythms. A domestic tragedy core built on Shakespearean closure with a pluralistic postmodern frame, and an absurdist bench minimalism to temper question opening and one answer closing.

Scenes 1, 3, and 5 are frames, and 2 and 4 are Inner with 3-2 as nested, i.e., framed upbeat and inner grave. The bench is both opening and reconciliation with mirrored sitting. The pre-reunion and the post-hug are two 5-second resets for a balanced act. The up, down, up, down, up, etc., arc ends positively, while the music bookends on a 37th-second entrance and a 52nd-second exit. Anger leads to inquiry, then joint truth-telling, followed by embrace and catharsis. Onstage represents the full-engulfing breaking of the fourth wall, with the onstage catharsis representing or modelling art’s power to process loss. While the metatheatrical wink comes with “here comes the twist, I do not exist” with a soft, gentle foregrounding of the fiction evaporating and leaving real feelings.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen

August 14, 2025

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Introduction to “500 Words for the GRE”

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2025/08/09

Contents

Introduction ………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 4

A …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 6

B …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 7

C …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 7

D …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 9

E …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 11

F …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 12

G …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 12

H …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 13

I ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 13

J ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 15

K …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 15

L …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 15

M ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 16

N ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 18

O ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 18

P ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 20

Q ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 23

R ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 23

S ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 24

T ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 26

U ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 27

V ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 27

W ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 27

Y ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 27

Z ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 28

License and Copyright …………………………………………………………………………………………. 29

Introduction

As noted in the prior volume:500 Words for the GRE is a compact version of the previous volume with removal of somemore obscure words. The content remains in the middle range for difficulty.

…[this] represents an independent research project into the standardized testingindustry’s core aspects with one major portion devoted to the verbal ability sectionsof the G.R.E. or the test required for multiple graduate level programs uponcompletion, and certification, of undergraduate studies. All words researched,collected, and collated for ease of access with respect to the user, likely anundergraduate student or prospective graduate student. If constrained to a 5-pointscale of measurement for the difficulty of the words included in this compendium,where 1 equates to very easy, 2 equates to easy, 3 equates to average, 4 equates tohard, and 5 equates to very hard, the range seems within 1.5–3.5 (maybe) on thescale of difficulty with a handful or two of 4-point words. Within these restrictionsand provisions, this set of words should provide the basic foundation for the inclusionof the proper, or basic, study materials for the vocabulary sections of standardizedtests with some (possible) transferability to common tests such as the verbal sectionsin intelligence tests such as the Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale (W.A.I.S.) or theScholastic Aptitude Test (S.A.T.). Bear in mind, in the midst of this independentinitiative, something came to the fore, quite glaringly. Standardized tests remain ofutility, and not in other ways. Too much to delve into the subject to give theappropriate coverage to the more than a century of research and debate into the topicof intelligence research. However, the nature of the tests seems of partial utility todiscover generality of academic talents, temperaments, abilities, and skills. In thisparticular case, one’s verbal fluency based on raw vocabulary. Insofar as thiscautionary, and positive and hopeful, note leaves one in the mood form furthermotivation, best wishes with this volume as a supplementary compendium inpreparation for standardized tests.

This is more or less the same. It is a collection of words for the GRE intended to assist otherdocuments and preparation materials. Tests change over time. The GRE might change itsverbal content. That is, these and other resources might become obsolete.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Preface to “Female Academics: Volume II”

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2025/08/09

ContentsI Acknowledgement ………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 4

II Biographies …………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 5

III Preface …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 10

IV STEM, Medicine, and Humanities ………………………………………………………………………….. 11 

i Dr. Mahtab Jafari: Associate Professor, Pharmaceutical Sciences & Director of  Undergraduate Pharmaceutical Sciences Program, University of California, Irvine …….. 11 

ii Dr. Sally Satel, M.D.: Lecturer, Yale University & Resident Scholar, AEI …………………. 25 

iii Dr. Hawa Abdi, M.D.: Physician & Human Rights Activist, Hawa Abdi Foundation ….. 32 

iv Dr. Athene Donald: Experimental Physicist, University of Cambridge ……………………… 42 

v Dr. Azra Raza, M.D.: Professor and Director of MDS Center, at Columbia University …. 54 

vi Madeleine Thien: Writer-in-Residence, Simon Fraser University …………………………….. 69 

vii Dr. Wanda Cassidy: Associate Professor, Faculty of Education, Simon Fraser University;  Director, Centre for Education, Law & Society …………………………………………………….. 80 

viii Dr. Diane Purvey: Dean of Arts, Kwantlen Polytechnic University …………………………. 96 

ix Dr. Barbara Forrest: Philosophy Professor, Southeastern Louisiana University &  Member, NCSE Board of Directors ……………………………………………………………………. 114

V License and Copyright ………………………………………………………………………………………….. 135

Acknowledgement

To women with an impact in personal life, good and bad, for the thorough lessons in variousaspects of the human experience; and specific appreciation for approval provided by Dr. MahtabJafari, Dr. Sally Satel, M.D., Dr. Hawa Abdi, M.D., Dr. Athene Donald, Dr. Azra Raza, M.D.,Madeleine Thien, Dr. Wanda Cassidy, Dr. Diane Purvey, and Dr. Barbara Forrest to conduct andpublish these uncensored and enlightened interviews, especially for an unknown and randomundergraduate, some time ago.

Preface

Female Academics: Volume I emphasized the social sciences based on theFemale Academics: Volume II follows in the footpath tread by the first volume with theexpanded focus on science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM), medicine, andthe humanities.

Most of the serious discussions and conversations, and research, occurs in the academic literature.Implementation happens throughout the international community with deep concern forinternational women’s rights. No single organization or individual at the helm; rather, themovement remains decentralized and fluid. The secular and the religious work towards thisunified aim. A long-term goal for equality of men and women with the right for women to vote,to work, to earn education, and so on.

“Decentralized and fluid” comes with the apt metaphor of an ocean. The movement atlarge remains the same in its inertial force from the sacrifices of previous generations. Somepeaks and valleys arise at moments of social upheaval in nations, in continents, in institutions, indisciplines, in individuals as representations of pathologies. Every drop adds to the ocean. Therising tide lifts all minds, raises consciousness. This is a drop.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Preface and Introduction to “Tweets to the Universe: Volume I”

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2025/08/09

Contents

I. Dedications ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 3

II. Preface: Scott Douglas Jacobsen ………………………………………………………………………………… 4

III. Introduction: Rick G. Rosner……………………………………………………………………………………. 25

IV. Precedent: h/h’ = 1 + GM/[(R + (h/MC)]C^2 …………………………………………………………….. 35

V. Digital Physics ……………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 49

VI. Digital Physics to Informational Cosmology ……………………………………………………………… 58

VII. Informational Cosmology ………………………………………………………………………………………… 62

VIII. Appendix I: Preliminary Argument …………………………………………………………………………… 82

IX. Appendix II: Glossary …………………………………………………………………………………………….. 89

X. License and Copyright …………………………………………………………………………………………… 106

DedicationsTo three generations of women who support and tolerate me – my mom, Ruth, my wife, Carole, my daughter, Isabella.Rick

To the love in my life.Scott

Preface: Scott Douglas Jacobsen“Necessity is the mistress and guardian of Nature.”Leonardo da Vinci

“I love those who yearn for the impossible.”Johann Wolfgang von Goethe

“I believe that love of truth is the basis of all real virtue, and that virtues based upon lies can only do harm.”Bertrand Russell

“That so few now dare to be eccentric, marks the chief danger of the time.”John Stuart Mill

“When I was young I found out that the big toe always ends up making a hole in a sock. So I stopped wearing socks.”Albert Einstein

Honest enquiry necessitates auturgy, independent activity. Independent activity emerges from the discovery narratives in relation to the self, ourselves, and umpteen consanguinities extant with these and the world requires straightforward queries to enter into the storyline built for over two millennia in the Western tradition; frank questions necessitate the relinquishment of the normal self, the dulled identity, with the beginning of anxiety followed by excitement; an honest answer penetrates the transition between the normal self, its unknown future in abjuration, and its eventual relief followed by renewal and growth.

Since the origin of our species, our story, our cosmology, continually creates or constructs, dissolves or degenerates, and evolves or adaptively transforms, in time and place, and this occurred for multiplicities longer than the Sophists, Atomists, Pluralists, Eleatics, Ephesians, Pythagoreans, even far more deep into the human epic than the Milesians, as far in ‘pre-history’ as the dreamtime narratives of the Aboriginals around 40,000 BCE with slow, steady, and cross-cultural, jagged motions toward unifications and improved fidelity in representation of the Earth and heavens.

Pith ideas of the human backstory come from the improbable, even the implausible, but never impossible, except for the apparent rather than the actual, as far as I can ratiocinate about the matter for the important developments in the history of Eastern and Western philosophy, and natural philosophy or science, including the present unprecedented era with its proliferation of knowledge, skills, and talents, a time of excitement in technological innovation and scientific discovery, or the knowledge era of the Anthropocene epoch, which will transition into an intelligence phase based on command of the natural world through knowledge acquired in its previous period through discovery and mastery of the functional truths about the universe. All operational verities derived from the natural philosophic tradition in physics, chemistry, biology, psychology, economics, politics, and associated disciplines, and wrought to human significance within the frameworks provided by the ever-adaptive to human concerns disciplines of the arts and humanities, especially from the coherent clarity of philosophy; natural philosophy means science and remains contained in philosophy, but not vice versa.

To quote the inimitable Andre 3000 from Outkast in Ms. Jackson, “…forever Forever, forever ever, forever ever? Forever” never…

Knowing of Richard Gilligan Rosner, Rick G. Rosner, Rick Rosner, or Rick, came out of some of his moderate fame based on existence as a genius skylark exhibited throughout personal history such as forging documents to enter high school again and again, and again, and again – literal four times, for an opportunity at a better experience in high school, a ‘do-over’ to use the idiom, for a possibility of being a normal high school kid, which seems, in hindsight, like a fruitless endeavour, or an attempt, to exist as average by a man that is anything but, at least from my experience, and this transitioned into knowing about Rosner as a game show contestant on Who Wants to be a Millionaire?, as an interviewee with the acclaimed interviewer Errol Morris in the series First Person – an hour interview detailing him, as a professional comedy writer for Jimmy Kimmel at Jimmy Kimmel Live!, through more than thirty competitive high-range intelligence test performances with some of the highest scores ever achieved by an individual with inclusion of the Titan Test where one would suffice for some modest fame, as a member and editor for Noesis: The Journal of the Mega Society, and into knowing Rosner in an independent and collaborative professional relationship as an individual, as a person, as an interviewee in 2014 for In-Sight: Independent Interview-Based Journal, as a married man and father, and as an eventual friend, each instance, at least a little bit, presenting little tidbits of himself as an upstanding and intelligent person apart from common mis-conceptions about character and appearance of dumb behavior – a crummy disguise by a smart person with marginal reality to it; acting a fool does not a fool make, look closer, observe him.

Throughout these antics, the continued focal point remained the logical extrapolation of digital physics from Konrad Zuse (Rechnender Raum or “Calculating Space”), information theory from Claude E. Shannon (A Mathematical Theory of Communication), and digital philosophy from Edward Fredkin (Introduction to Digital Philosophy, On the Soul, Finite Nature, A New Cosmogony, and Digital Mechanics) for the origination and development of informational cosmology with tidbits given here and there by Rosner through minor and improbable publications and on the fringes of the internet, with this sporadic development and incorporation of information about the theoretical and mathematical, even metaphysical, bases of informational cosmology onto the internet over years and decades, without total compilation in one place – as if by caution or disorganization by him, seems like both to me.

As described in The Rick G. Rosner Interview [Academic]:

We discussed mathematics and physics, logic and metaphysics, consciousness and its subcategories, and these conceptualizations’ mutual interrelationships. In particular, refinement of digital physics into “informational cosmology.”

Furthermore, in informational cosmological nomenclature, your definition of consciousness divides into and emerges from two broad ideas: self-consistency and information processing. In brief review, we have identification of minds within universe with consciousness, universe with consciousness, and the interrelation of mind and universe based on isomorphic function and characteristics. What beyond this introductory realization of the equivalence? I observe multiple arenas of common discourse – let me explain.

From an informational cosmological foundation, the hyphenated term “self-consistency” and phrase “information processing” divide into further subcategorizations. These subcategories have constraints from definitions. “Self-consistency” and “information processing” contain various definitions because of differing interpretations, but technical and concrete definitions hold most import here.

As a general primer to “self-consistency” – which might have less decipherability than “information processing,” we can begin with this informational cosmology expression “self-consistency.” German mathematician and founder of set theory (fundamental theory for mathematics), Georg Ferdinand Ludwig Philipp Cantor, defined self-consistency as the inability to derive both the statement and negation of the statement at the same time. Cantor argued, if deriving the statement and its negation, the derivation would self-contradict. (One can transform this into more formal set theoretic language about elements contained in sets – or the language of mathematics, self-consistency holds great weight for mathematicians, and logic, see Law of Non-Contradiction below.) Self-consistency does have other theoretical universes of discourse in addition to multiple practical and applied venues of human venture: logic, set theory, mathematics, physics, computer science, and many others.

In logic, the Law of Identity (A equals A), Law of Non-Contradiction (A cannot equal not-A), and Law of the Excluded Middle (For all A: either A or not-A) all introduced – informally & implicitly by Plato in Theaetetus & The Republic and formally & explicitly by Aristotle in Metaphysics – in ancient Greece. Sometimes called “laws of thought.” These delineate facets of self-consistency expressed in the formalisms and vernacular of logic. For one similar vein, Gottfried Wilhelm von Leibniz derived Leibniz’ Law, x = y: if, and only if, x contains every property of y, and vice versa. Moreover, he derived sub-laws from Leibniz’ Law such as the Law of Reflexivity, Law of Symmetry, and Law of Transitivity. For one example, Law of Reflexivity, x = x: everything is equal to itself. This mirrors the Law of Identity of Athenian philosophers – Plato and Aristotle. Patterns – Platonic Forms and Ideas even – of concepts arise in repeated episodes of the historical timeline – groping towards some unitary definition.

In set theory, Austrian-born American logician, mathematician, and philosopher, Kurt Friedrich Gödel, had additional fame for formalization of St. Anselm’s Ontological Proof for the existence of God. In addition to this, Gödel published Über formal unentscheidbare Sätze der Principia Mathematica und verwandter Systeme or On Formally Undecidable Propositions of Principia Mathematica and Related Systems (1931). Tersely, an axiomatic system capable of describing natural numbers (e.g., 1, 2, 3…) held within it: 1) cannot be both consistent and complete, and 2) if consistent, the consistency of the axioms cannot be proven within the system. He, and modern specialists, call these two incompleteness theorems.

In mathematics, English logician, mathematician, philosopher, and founder of Boolean Algebra (foundational for digital electronics), George Boole, continued the ancient Grecians’ work in a facsimile of the earlier laws of thought with some extensions in mathematical language. I call them “Boolean Heresies” for fun. Boole laid these out in An Investigation of the Laws of Thought (1854). The primary extension from Aristotle became the extension of the three classical laws of thought into mathematical symbolisms, formalisms, and terminology. For one example, the ‘=’ or ‘equals sign’ signals synonymous meaning with the Law of Identity or the Law of Reflexivity between things. Labelled ‘A’ in the Law of Identity and ‘x’ in the Law of Reflexivity discussed earlier.

In physics, applied to time travel – the Novikov Self-Consistency Principle, “laws” of physics must remain self-consistent at a global level in the real universe to prohibit any paradoxes with respect to time travel. In this application, time-travel scenarios must disallow violation of universe’s global laws.

In computer science, at least in database management systems, the acronym ACID equates to principles for operation of database transactions. “ACID,” from Jim Gray (1981), means “Atomicity, Consistency, Isolation, and Durability” with the importance of “consistency” meaning “the transaction must obey legal laws.” In broad definitions provided by Gray (1981) about the “general model of transactions,” he states, “Transactions preserve the system consistency constraints – they obey the laws by transforming consistent states into new consistent states.” As noted, Boolean Algebraic (Boole) systems operable in computer science too.

One can see the pattern in numerous fields. Therefore, “self-consistent” or “self-consistency” within informational cosmology means “system without self-contradiction.”

“Information processing” will have an easier time of comprehension because of living in the computer age, digital age, or information age. American mathematician and cryptographer Claude Elwood Shannon’s article, A Mathematical Theory of Communication (1948), represented information theory connected to communication. A short paper, experts consider this article foundational to the field of information theory, which allowed many of them to decree Shannon the father of the information age. American scientist and mathematician, Warren Weaver, republished A Mathematical Theory of Communication (1948) and expanded on Shannon’s work in a coauthored book entitled The Mathematical Theory of Communication (1949). Specialists remember Weaver for pioneering work in machine translation. Shannon and Weaver laid the framework for information and communication theory up to the present day.

In it, if we take a human interpretive view of the work, he showed the degree of “noise” – entropy/disorder introduced into the message – entering between the “information source” (brain₁/mind₁) & “transmitter” (voice/speech) and the “receiver” (ears) & “destination” (second brain₂/mind₂). Noise enters between the transmitter and receiver to decrease the quality of the message from the information source to the destination.

For an everyday example, if you whisper from a mile away, your friend will have trouble understanding you – too much “noise” to prevent clear receiving and interpretation of the message; if you whisper next to your friend’s ear, the message will more likely have appropriate receiving, decoding, and arrival at the destination for your friend’s comprehension.

Not clear enough – think of a computer, how does it process information? It processes information according to input, process, and output. You type a symbol on the keyboard – input, the machine runs internal mechanics – process, and produces the appropriate (if functional) symbol on the monitor – output. Hence, the foundation of information theory in informational cosmology.

Input becomes any decipherable piece of data to the system. Process becomes the algorithm for managing the information. Output becomes the final product of input and process. Likewise, this applies to everything in informational cosmology at local and global scales.

In current vernacular, we ask, “What if the material of the universe equals input, process equals laws plus time, and output equals transformations of the material contents (e.g., particles, fields, forces, and so on) of the universe?”

In informational cosmological parlance, we ask, “What if bit units of universe equal input, process equals principles of existence plus time, and output equals transformations of bit units of universe?”

These reflect deep equivalences. As noted by 21-year-old Rick, all theories of grandeur and great import start with big equivalences. You shifted the perspective. Subsequent information processing equates to observed universe. Simply put, we need an armature by necessity, but do not observe the armature based on externality to universe.

Armature of universe equates to material framework or processor; universe equates to information processing or processing. We observe the information processing. We call this universe. We do not observe the material framework, but by necessity require processor based on isomorphic geometry between universe and individual localized minds.

Individual localized minds operate from brains, and therefore universe must have an equivalent of a “brain” – aforementioned armature. This deals with information and universe at the largest scales. In this, we have the rich derivation, i.e., refinement, of digital physics into informational cosmology.

Together, we have the targeted objectives of comprehensive conceptual organization, philosophical and scientific extrapolation, interrelationship incorporation, and dissemination of the ideas relevant to informational cosmology while working towards the deep pursuit of fundamental truths about the forces at work in and forms of the universe, and exterior to itself. Rosner formulated the grounds of informational cosmology on May 2, 1981. His 21st birthday. An extension of General and Special Relativity. Informational cosmology represents the culmination of about 30 years of spasmodic or erratic independent research, by Rosner, while distracted with stripping, bouncing, perfecting high school, roller-skating and waiting for tables, competitive intelligence test-taking, nude modelling, lawsuits, and comedy writing, in addition to extensive independent research with an undergraduate researcher, me, since August, 2014. Rosner worked on this theory while in pursuit of normality in high schools.

We have refined and incorporated necessary philosophical considerations into the mathematical enterprise. Rosner had knowledge and expertise unknown to me; I had expertise and knowledge unbeknownst to him. Our intellectual productions result from the collaborations and discussions relating the two. Most literary productions – from the modern and popular such as Oprah Winfrey to the old and obscure such as John Stuart Mill – appear to take the form of a monologue by the author to the, intended or non-intended, audience. Ancient Greek writing, some of the productions, appear to represent a dialogue between two or multiple fictitious, more often than not, characters or personalities.

A dialogue from the author to the, intended or non-intended, audience through the characters or personalities. An interview improves on philosophical dialogues – such as Plato’s written style, ask Charlie Rose, Larry King, James Lipton, Jimmy Fallon, Barbara Walters, Howard Stern, Oprah Winfrey, Jon Stewart, Peter Mansbridge, Ellen DeGeneres, David Letterman, or Tavis Smiley – for philosophical enquiry between idealized or fiction-built characters and transforms the thoughts of real people into an actual dialogue on topics of import to those people in reality rather than fiction. A dialogue from the author to the audience, intended or non-intended, through the real people for presentation of the tinctured premises, arguments, and their tentative conclusions. Interviewer and interviewee, in print, become characters such as those found in The Republic, but existent and non-Platonic rather than non-existent and Platonic. A rehabilitation amplified by modern electronics.

Gravitation, electromagnetism, weak nuclear interaction, and strong nuclear interaction. Informational cosmology amounts to a Grand Unified Theory and Theory of Everything. By definition, a Theory of Everything contains a Grand Unified Theory. Grand Unified Theories operate within the conceptual boundaries of electromagnetism, weak nuclear interaction, and strong nuclear interaction. Theories of Everything operate within the conceptual boundaries of gravitation, electromagnetism, weak nuclear interaction, and strong nuclear interaction. Theories of Everything exist as more comprehensive than Grand Unified Theories by these explicit and universal standards in the community of mainstream scientists – most. Informational cosmology classifies as a Theory of Everything with inclusion of the following: Quantum Gravity, Space Curvature and Standard Model of Cosmology, Electronuclear Force and Standard Model of Particle Physics, and Weak Interaction and Electromagnetism.

Each demarcates the functional descriptors of the universe without spiritual or mystical content contained in or implicated within them, and with technical and digital, or informational, contents and implications for them. Metaphysics does not exist within those contents, except in the implications of the set of cosmological architecture from which the universe exists as a sub-set.

Informational cosmology describes the reduction in Planck’s constant in proportion to the mass in your space-time locale:

h/h’ = 1 + GM/[(R + (h/MC)]C²

Rosner wore this on a t-shirt and flew this on an airplane banner. “h” equates to Planck’s constant. “h’” equates to modified Planck’s constant. “GM” equates to the standard gravitational parameter. “C” equates to the speed of light. “M” equates to the mass of the object. “R” equates to the radius of the massive object. “C²” equates to the speed of light times the speed of light.

In a modified statement with less mathematical symbolisms constructed from the previous mathematical statement:

Planck’s constant divided by modified Planck’s constant equates to one plus standard gravitational parameter divided by [(radius plus (Planck’s constant divided by mass times C)] times C squared.

Rosner’s first attempt to explain the expansion of space in the presence of mass with Planck’s constant as index of space. Novel phrases will come into the conversation for informational cosmology. Phrases such as “active proton centre” and “collapsed neutron matter outskirts” – and their associated derivatives – relate to the expansion of space in the presence of protons and collapse of space in the presence of neutrons, respectively. Protons activate galaxies, galactic groups, galactic clusters, galactic superclusters, and filaments and expand the space around them for the “active centre.” Neutrons represent the end result of burning, or activating, the proton-filled galaxies to the point of fuel exhaustion, neutron over proton dominance, for the collapse of space where the products move to the collapsed matter outskirts for long-term storage and possible re-activation in the active centre through infusion of protons into the neutron densities.

Informational cosmology builds from the general disciplines into itself, a hierarchical incorporation. Physics studies the motion of matter through space and time. Astronomy studies every non-terrestrial astronomical object and phenomena in the universe. Together, in the field of cosmology, physics and astronomy combine to study the large-scale structure with the precision of applied mathematics in the real world in relation to the motion of matter through space and time. General Relativity describes the convergence of space and time into space-time curvature and its operation in relation to the large-scale universe. Quantum mechanics studies the Planck length of the universe with the apparent simultaneity of phenomena with phenomena such as Wave-Particle Duality, Heisenberg Uncertainty, Non-Locality, Quantum Coherence, and many others.

Digital physics considers the motion of matter through space-time curvature emergent from quantum phenomena in correspondence with a general information processor. An information processor with self-simulation, self-observation, and self-containment (apology for the abundance of “self-” prefixes), except for the connection through emergence from the armature with the armature as the information processor. The universe exists as an open information processing system with extensive closure. Informational cosmology develops this idea farther into the realm of the external universe through implications of valid information processing, in accordance with cosmology, digital physics, and information theory, with conceptualizations such as net self-consistent information processing and an external material infrastructure for the information processor of the universe with the universe as its manifest operations.

Necessities for the mind requiring physical or material infrastructure, the nervous system, appears to mean the universe, as information processing in real-time (its time), requires a material framework, an armature or information processor aligned in structure with the brain. A similarity in form and function, but not utility and ubiquity. Consciousness appears non-mechanistic and non-mystical, but technical and informational, with repeated fractal phenomena incorporated for apparent continuity, diversity, and novelty in tendencies of form, function, and expression. Continuity in form; diversity in function; novelty in expression.

Minds’ dotted thoughts linked from each’s probable past and set of possible futures through continual re-instantiations, actualizations, of its information processing of reality. Same for the universe as a consciousness. Trees, rocks, waters, comets, and canyons exist as components for the consciousness of the universe, but not conscious components. As our minds remain more or less non-conscious with subsidiary components such as intra-cellular and extra-cellular junk, cholesterol, and cerebrospinal fluid for the central nervous system, the universe remains more or less non-conscious with trees, rocks, waters, comets, and canyons in itself.

Nature amounts to all that exists relevant to the contents and operation of the contents within the universe. Standard science conceives of the natural world as a physico-functional object in operation through whole number additions in time at its micro-most time scale, the Planck scale. Informational cosmology contains the totality of relevant physics to describe this aspect of nature. External to the universe the armature equates to the metaphysical because “meta-” means something higher or of a second-order kind and “-physical” means a material existence, which aligns the basic physicalist with the basic materialist, and this defines something outside the physical and material.

Consciousness, in informational cosmology, equates to a construct. A technical phenomenon constructed from pervasive self-consistent information processing; nothing spiritual or mystical. An armature, as an external-to-universe material object, means a higher-order material existence, and equates to both metaphysical and physical – dependent upon referent. Metaphysical in relation to the lower-order material existence of the universe; physical in relation to its higher-order material existence in the armature world. The universe, as a pervasive closed system with possible openness with the armature and armature world, connects to its physical aspects and its higher-order associated information processor, the armature. By definition, metaphysics instantiates in the physics of information cosmology by implication, and vice versa, with the ordering dependent upon the space-time in reference: universe, armature, or armature world.

The physico-functional definition around informational cosmology makes for an entire field of partially known information in the observed universe and unknown information in the non-observed sectors such as apparent T ≤ 300,000 years from apparent T = 0 years or external-to-observed universe information through the means of light, or photons, with possible perception through gravitational waves’ after-effects observed between apparent T ≤ 300,000 years from apparent T = 0 years.

A metaphysico-functional description of the universe, in another representation of information cosmology within different conceptual frames and neologisms, describes the observed and non-observed sections of the universe – as the universe – or active proton centre and collapsed neutron matter outskirts, and the respective necessitated outside physical infrastructure, which means a description of this material framework’s associated armature universe to an operational infinite. Informational cosmology refines methodological naturalism and the epistemological bases of science, extends the convergence of digital physics and cosmology, aims to recalibrate and extrapolate from General and Special Relativity, and conceives of an informational and technical conscious universe.

Insofar as informational cosmology operates from the core content or essence of nature, which derives from natural philosophical experiments – or questions to the universe in search of intelligible answers (as SETI searches for intelligible signals from advanced extraterrestrial civilizations with some form of electromagnetic communication a la Frank Drake in the Drake Equation within the Milky Way galaxy; science, in general, searches for intelligible answers from the universe), informational cosmology in its foundations within the universe because of our existence within it implicates the meaninglessness of the conscious cosmos in accordance with much of modern science, but not to individual minds in the universe, if they so choose to create meaning for themselves and others.

Even so, this leaves the possibility for meaning in the armature world for the armature from which the universe arises because the walls upon which we paint our bodies creates the mind and meaning for individuals, and collectives, inside of the universe and, therefore, the armature derives meaning from the armature world in which it exists too. Within these constraints of consideration, the universe exists as conscious and meaningless, but its armature does contain meaning because it will likely have targeted, legitimate objectives or goals in correspondence with the net self-consistent information processing observed in normal (relative to us) consciousness’ targeted objectives or goals in the universe in contrast, and similarity, with the armature world for the armature.

Consider: we do not claim the exchange of information in the cosmos as meaningful as a whole except in sub-systems such as ourselves in transaction with the rest of the universe, and the higher-order factorizations from them as containing meaning; therefore, the universe will not equate to the constructor of meaning with minor exceptions, but will equate, in one formulation, as an intermediary between the information-space of the armature and the relevant motion of the armature through space-time in the armature world. The universe amounts to the moment-to-moment information transfer akin to the brain; its information-space contains the higher-order factorization necessary for meaning.

Therefore, the armature, armature world, the universe, and minds internal to the universe, construct every associated information-space or mind-space for meaning in emergent net self-consistent information processing arrays or sub-arrays in transaction with the relevant information in its environment. All that exists, everything, contains a unified property with two valid derivatives with respect to meaning; the universe does not contain meaning, except in its implicational constructions’ creation of meaning such as human beings and their variegated narratives and meta-narratives, and the armature and armature world contain meaning through construction of the universe to derive the information-space or mind-space relevant to its existence and actualizations inside of the armature world.

Meaning means transaction, or attribution; persistence provides the bases for continual transactions relevant to a net self-consistent information processor and its net self-consistent information processing and, therefore, the foundation of each sound – as in valid premises and conclusion with the conclusion following logically from the premises and the conclusion being true – ethic in an informational cosmological ethic necessitates persistence and the consciousness’ imperative to continue into the indefinite future.

The foundry of existence begins with the tautological principles about the universe in its inability to not exist; everything cannot not exist; thus, all cannot not persist; furthermore, ethics follows from this with existence and its continuation, or persistence, as the philosophical, or metaphysical, bedrock for an absolute ethic grounded in the reality of necessitated persistence; wherein meaning for every consciousness derives from the functional infinitude of potential narratives and meta-narratives in an actual finite universe erected from the requisite ethic for continued persistence, which sums to necessitated existence and persistence and its associated generalized ethic related to implicated, and necessitated, respect for the narratives and meta-narratives of individual minds insofar as these do not interfere with the wellbeing and narrative of another mind, and vice versa: The Informational Golden Rule.

Galileo Galilei stated:

Philosophy is written in this grand book — I mean the universe — which stands continually open to our gaze, but it cannot be understood unless one first learns to comprehend the language in which it is written. It is written in the language of mathematics, and its characters are triangles, circles, and other geometric figures, without which it is humanly impossible to understand a single word of it; without these, one is wandering about in a dark labyrinth.

For those with literary leanings, with religious ritualism, with metaphoric minds, or swayed by symbolisms, The Word of the conscious universe would appear as the language of mathematics as metaphysics and physics, and the ability to interpret based on mathematical aptitude, or mathematical linguistic ability and talent, and the involvement of one’s consciousness with the universe dependent on one’s interest in and comprehension of the “grand book” of nature, the cosmos, the macrocosm from which our microcosms converge into a blip of awareness, with the privilege to know something about the mind which birthed us – though we do not know the status of its concern for its contents such as ourselves, which leaves us, at a minimum, better to not wander in the dark labyrinth of ignorance and to write out our narrative on the blank pages of the future – and, at any rate, to continue or to persist in as many narratives as possible limited by the informational and, therefore, definitional constraints of the universe.

Introduction: Rick G. Rosner

In mid April, 1981, I was sitting in the Libby Hall cafeteria at the University of Colorado, eating a bowl of cubes of red Jell-O. I was frequently in the cafeteria – it was all-you-can-eat, and I was usually trying to put on weight, thinking that being big and muscular would help me get a girlfriend. I’d just read an article about mechanisms of short-term memory versus mechanisms of long-term memory in the brain.

Chewing on Jell-O, I thought that the article was kinda BS. (It probably wasn’t BS, but I was not quite 21 and full of opinions.) You could explain short-term versus long-term memory with a kind of geometry. Things in long-term memory are accessible from a number of different angles – from a bunch of different associations or memory hooks – while things in short-term memory are accessible from only the context in which they happened (unless something establishes more hooks for that memory), so that memory is harder to retrieve, because that specific context is less likely to come up. It’s why dreams are hard to remember – the weirdly random context of the dream will likely never come up in your brain again (unless you make an effort to embed the dream in memory – in a waking context – right after awakening from it).

So, in a geometry of memory, long-term memories would be centrally located, accessible from many angles, while short-term memories would be at the periphery, accessible from only a very limited set of angles. Then I thought, “What if that geometry is the geometry of the universe?” I stopped chewing and froze with spoon in mid-air.

At about age ten, I’d decided that my job should be figuring out the universe. Smart and nerdy, I stayed in at recess, reading, whenever the teacher let me. A decade later, I was a half-assed physics major at CU, reading and thinking on my own and consistently falling asleep in class. At almost age 21, I’d made progress in de-nerdifying myself, getting contact lenses and being all weight-lifty. I was bar bouncing and was a couple weeks away from starting my career as a male stripper. My only decent insight beyond standard cosmology was thinking that nothingness maybe wasn’t the default state of existence – that even in total chaos, it’s unlikely that islands of order won’t show up somewhere.

And now this revelation, mid-Jell-O bite. The geometry of information in the mind and the geometry of the universe might be the same. This was a core insight – my ticket to figuring out stuff. I worked on the theory in between checking IDs in bars, while waiting to go onstage and get naked on Ladies’ Night, while doing volunteer work taking developmentally disabled people roller skating. The discomfort of squashing my flat Fred Flintstone feet into roller skates and the anxiety of dancing in sleazy strip clubs helped focus my thinking.

It became clear that the Big Bang and black holes didn’t work in a universe made of and defined by information. A self-defined universe can’t just pinch parts of itself off. It can build a pinch point, but that pinch won’t be a full-on event horizon – that’s the universe saying, “Well, this information has absolutely 100% nothing to do with the rest of my information – see ya!” And the Big Bang – that’s your pocket calculator blowing up before it can finish even one calculation.

I worked all these crap-but-fun jobs – stripper, bouncer, roller-skating waiter – feeling not very obligated to not make much progress in life, since I was (sometimes) doing my true job – figuring out the universe and how it processes information.

Lots of smart people think we live in a digital universe – a vast computer, processing bits. Which is fine, but what are the actual processing mechanisms of the universe? I think the universe processes information by aggregating, by locking together like fuzzy Legos, by clumping together in stars and galaxies.

Among the things I believe are:

  • Much of the essential business of the universe is visible to us as the everyday phenomena of the universe.
  • Proton-electrons are the little aggregation engines of the universe.

The standard model of particle physics contains 61 elementary particles. According to current theories of dark matter and dark energy, only four percent of the universe is visible matter that we see as planets, stars, and galaxies. But what if the function of all this stuff is to process and record information? Then it might be possible to think about the universe in simpler terms.

One interesting thing about the universe is that, over time, the matter in it forms associations and clumps together in ways that are hard to reverse. As matter clumps together, the universe becomes more precisely defined. The clumping creates and records information. And the most visible agents of clumping are five persistent particles – protons, electrons, neutrons, photons, and neutrinos. These particles can last for many billions of years. They’re all involved in hard-to-reverse (semi-permanent) changes in the universe.

Protons and neutrons aren’t elementary particles. They’re made of quarks. But even though protons and neutrons aren’t elementary, protons, neutrons, and electrons seem to be the universe’s basic aggregation engines. Electrons (loosely) lock into orbits around protons. Protons lock together (with some turning into neutrons) in atomic nuclei. Atoms lock together into molecules. Atoms and molecules come together in intricate forms of matter.

This doesn’t mean that the universe’s other particles aren’t essential. But, if they don’t create and store information, they might be considered supporting particles for those that do. Take, for instance, quarks, which, in sets of three, make up protons and neutrons, and gluons, which transmit the strong force that holds atomic nuclei together and which holds quarks together in protons and neutrons. Inside protons and neutrons, quarks and gluons are constantly exchanging forces, changing characteristics, and popping in and out of existence in 1/10^24 of a second. Throughout all this, a proton is very stable, with a lifespan of at least 10^34 years. So, does all the action going on within a proton have any impact on the (macro) information in the universe, or are quarks and gluons just part of the somehow necessary underlying mechanics of particles that do register long-term change?

Knowledge is relational – everything is defined in terms of everything else. Some philosophers (and brain researchers) like to ask, “How do we know red is red? How do we know that what we think of as red is what someone else thinks of as red?” We can pretty much assume that two people’s ideas of red (absent some deficit in perception) are pretty close based on their associative definitions of red – it’s seen on apples, stop signs, one end of the rainbow, and so on. Same for something like “up” – it’s associated with the sky, with the parts of trees and light poles farthest from the ground, with the direction opposite the gravitational force vector.

Try reversing your definition of “up.” Picture “up” as being in the direction of gravitation, with the ground being up, and trees and buildings forcing themselves down, towards the sky. It’s really tough to do. Everything you know, everything associated with “up,” makes you want to continue to understand up as up. (Though, once something is as deeply embedded in your awareness as red or up, it doesn’t usually trigger a cascade of associations. You’re like, “Yeah, that’s red,” or “That direction is up,” or, even more likely, you don’t even consciously note red or up – they’re just part of the subconscious structure of awareness.)

Like our understanding of the world, the universe is built from associations, some gravitational, some electromagnetic, some via the strong force, in atoms, planets, stars, solar systems, galaxies, super clusters … . I don’t think it’s unreasonable to suppose that these associations support meaning, the same way associations in our minds support meaning.

With regard to us and with regard to the universe, I think there are three related structures (well, three-and-a-half):

  1. The hardware – the brain and its connections
  2. The information contained in the brain as perceived via consciousness – how the various information and thought streams in your brain share content with and influence each other
  3. Information seen as an optimized map of itself, with its own apparent space and physics3½. The material world that we experience every day

Observing our minds and brains, we see structures one and two – the hardware and the perceived information. Observing the universe, we see the third structure – an information-space with a physics that seems to operate, via relativity and quantum mechanics, in an information-based way. And we live in the everyday material world (which is part of information-space but which is experienced by us via what seems like classical physics (and without access to meaning of the meaning of the information in information-space)). It’s not outrageous to think that the information in each of our minds could be seen as unfolding as an information-space. Nor is it outrageous to think that the information in the universe could have meaning beyond itself and that the information must be supported by hardware apart from the universe, the same way computers and brains are necessary for the existence of the information they contain.

In 1986, I went back to high school to think about the structure of the universe while crammed into those desk-chair combos. (I didn’t go back to creep on girls – that wouldn’t have been ethical.) High school senior by day, bouncer and not-great stripper by night.

To be an information processor (I thought as a fake high school senior), the universe has to recycle itself. There has to be a proton-neutron cycle. The first half of the cycle certainly exists. In stars, protons clump together into heavier nuclei, with some of the protons turning to neutrons. (Besides hydrogen, atomic nuclei are about half neutrons, with the neutron-proton ratio gradually creeping upwards as the size of nuclei grow (because protons repel each other, so you need more neutrons to keep a heavy nucleus from throwing off particles).) In nuclei formed from stellar fusion, the majority of neutrons started off as protons.

Then, when stars run out of easily available protons that generate heat through fusion, the stars collapse, which, for sufficiently massive stars, squashes most of the remaining protons (in nuclei) into neutrons, hence the name neutron star. Run-of-the-mill collapsed stars don’t put out much energy – they’ve run out of proton fuel.

So the universe looks like a one-way process – matter coalescing into clumps, protons fusing into neutrons, stars and their galaxies eventually going dark. This doesn’t look much like an information-processing universe – it looks like a universe that does one big, long calculation, and that’s it. Well, that’s a crappy calculator or computer or universe. You’d expect an information processor to process an ongoing stream of information – a calculator to keep calculating, a computer to keep computing, a mind to have more than one thought.

And so, the universe needs a cycle, to turn those neutrons (and locked-in protons) back into fusible protons. Sitting in journalism class or calculus, the back of my chair/desk being kicked by a football player with a Rockin Dio calculator, high school me thinks that old, burned-out galaxies (and the space which contains them) get shoved aside by young, fresh galaxies. Then, at some point, way, way later, the old galaxies can get reactivated by the curvature of space or a flood of neutrinos.

Neutrinos are emitted when a proton turns into a neutron. Neutrinos pass through a crazy amount of matter unscathed, which means a bunch of them should accumulate on the outskirts of the universe, where space might be tighter. Space being tighter on the outskirts would mean that not all of space expanded evenly from a single Big Bang. It would mean that the universe has an active center with somewhat fresh matter that looks expansive, while outside of this, you have collapsed, inactive matter. This matter could be reactivated, which might look like the enormous blackish holes at the center of galaxies spewing out a floor of particles. Perhaps some galaxies manage to stay fresh and in the active center for a very long time via their central blackish holes shooting out jets of matter for a very long time. If there is a neutron cycle, then the 13.8-billion-year age of the universe is only an apparent age, which is based on the amount of information in the universe, while its actual age is fantastically older. In a neutron-cycle universe, old, collapsed regions function as memory – as stored information to be recalled under appropriate circumstances.

Perhaps the universe has correlational instruments besides protons, but they seem to me to be the most obvious. Each proton seems to me like a little spatial dimension or a variable in an equation. Variables can correlate with other variables. (That’s what you want them to do – correlated variables condense information.) In information space, correlation is related to proximity – things that have much to do with each other are close to each other. When two protons are smashed very close to each other, they can fuse into a single nucleus, which, in a way, is saying that two variables are sufficiently correlated with each other that they can function as one. I suspect that each proton is a twist (or perhaps a knot) in space, with the twist putting stress on space (and also giving form to space) which is compensated for by an opposite electrical charge in the form of an electron. Protons and electrons (and supporting particles) are parts of little correlational engines.

After graduating from high school for the last time at age 27, I accidentally became a quiz show writer and then a TV comedy writer, contributing to more than 2,500 hours of programming on all the big networks. But I still thought about physics in between thinking up Kardashian jokes. Then, a year and a half ago, I was fired from a job on a late-night show I’d had for nearly 12 years. This was bad – it was a great job. But it was also good, because Scott Jacobsen was interviewing me for In-Sight Journal. With all sorts of time on my hands, I could go on at length about the theory. So here it is. There was no single Big Bang. Consciousness is a technical property of large-scale shared information. The universe is an information processor, and the information it processes is about something beyond itself.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Preface to “Female Academics: Volume I”

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2025/08/09

Contents

I Acknowledgement …………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 4

II Biographies ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 5

III Preface……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 11

IV Social Sciences………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 15

i Dr. Janet Metcalfe: Professor, Psychology, Columbia University ……………………….. 15

a. Bibliography ……………………………………………………………………………………… 22

ii Dr. Neda Kerimi: Post-Doctoral Fellow, Psychology, Harvard University …………… 24

iii Dr. Adele Diamond: Tier 1 Canada Research Chair in Developmental Cognitive Neuroscience; Professor, Psychiatry, The University of British Columbia ……………. 30

a. Bibliography ……………………………………………………………………………………… 46

iv Dr. Maryanne Garry: Psychology Professor, Victoria University of Wellington ……. 50

v Dr. Rakefet Ackerman: Assistant Professor, Psychology, Technion: Israel Institute of Technology ………………………………………………………………………………………………. 56

a. Bibliography ……………………………………………………………………………………… 66

vi Dr. Gira Bhatt: Principal Investigator and Project Director, AT-CURA ……………….. 68

vii Dr. Diana Sanchez: Associate Professor of Psychology, Rutgers University ………… 78

viii Dr. Miriam Erez: Professor Emeritus, Vice Dean MBA Programs, Technion: Israel Institute of Technology ………………………………………………………………………………….. 85

a. Bibliography ……………………………………………………………………………………… 92

ix Dr. Carla MacLean: Psychology Instructor, Kwantlen Polytechnic University ……… 94

x Dr. Elizabeth Loftus: Distinguished Professor of Social Ecology, and Professor of Law, and Cognitive Science at the University of California, Irvine ……………………. 102

V License and Copyright ……………………………………………………………………………………………. 116

Acknowledgement

To women with an impact in personal life, good and bad, for the thorough lessons in various aspects of the human experience; and specific appreciation for approval provided by Dr. Janet Metcalfe, Dr. Neda Kerimi, Dr. Adele Diamond, Dr. Maryanne Garry, Dr. Rakefet Ackerman, Dr. Gira Bhatt, Dr. Diana Sanchez, Dr. Miriam Erez, Dr. Carla MacLean, and Dr. Elizabeth Loftus to conduct and publish these uncensored and enlightened interviews, especially for an unknown and random undergraduate, some time ago.

Preface

Female Academics: Volume I converges from four directions. First, personal interest in international women’s rights. Second, a curiosity about individual stories. Third, one personal year committed to interviews in a series devoted to female academics entitled Women in Academia in the non-refereed journal In-Sight: Independent Interview-Based Journal(ISSN 2369-6885) in the culmination of three issues – over seventy-thousand words. Fourth, an opportunity to collaborate with the University of California, Irvine’s (UCI) Interdisciplinary Center for the Scientific Study of Ethics and Morality (Ethics Center) under the deep knowledge and high ability leadership, mentorship, supervision, and tutelage of Professor Kristen Renwick Monroe in the Department of Political Science and Philosophy from the School of Social Sciences based on the recommendation of the strong mentee of Professor Francisco Ayala, Associate Professor Mahtab Jafari. While in Irvine, California at the UCI Ethics Center, Professors Monroe and Jafari mentored me. Professor Ayala had coffee with me. Lastly, I mentored Professor Jafari’s son, Matin. A bright, diligent, and kind young man.

Professors Monroe and Jafari remain highly intelligent and competent guides for me. I had, and have, a lot to learn from them, especially in their patience with me. Professor Monroe on issues of scientific ethics and morality, international women’s rights, and their relationship to the university system or Academia with an emphasis on the American university system and in STEM education for women. Professor Jafari in terms of insights from a woman’s perspective, which I do not have first-hand and found enlightening from her. Numerous coffees, lunches, and discussions provided the necessary insight for me. In preparation for a more comprehensive production, Female Academics: Volume I amounts to a small publication to represent some of the work involved with this continued endeavor.

The modern women’s movement built into the academic system amounts to three streams: opportunity, representation, and outcome – as far as I can tell. The first two seem the most direct goals with outcome as the unification factor among them. Equal opportunities aim to open doors for women. Every academic door with the possibility available for women to enter without the traditional, or modern, glass ceilings in their way. Those desiring equal representation aim for the ratio to be 1:1 between men and women in all fields of the university system. All levels, all disciplines, all sub-disciplines, with equivalent ratios. Those wanting equal outcomes are taking a long-term view with continual upkeep of the balance over time. In that, eventually having equal numbers of men and women in each academic sector, and then having this renewed over time.

Of course, we have the dual-problem in the international context with boys, and young men, in terms of poor academic performance and low completion rates from kindergarten through grade 12 into undergraduate and graduate school with magnified effects on “men of color,” or “male minorities,” in The United States of America and Canada, for two instances, and the representation of professional women in various sectors, for example, academic, corporate, economic, social, political, and so on, in addition to the deep concerns, for many, including me, related to pervasive violation of their fundamental privileges and rights as human beings. A male crisis in education, or in general adaptation to the rapid alteration in the personal and professional landscape, continues on a global scale as reported in numerous venues. Both perspectives compatible, logically and in actuality. Most emphasis appears on one sex, or gender, or the other in times of rapid change such as the present era, or the early 21st century. Even so, to cover the aspects of these socio-political and economic shifts would require an enormous volume devoted to the issue with numerous levels of analysis, the focus of this short volume represents a specific endeavor to interview a small sample of female academics not “because female” but as “important academics with interesting research, whom are female.” An important distinction based in conversation with Professor Elizabeth Loftus at a separate time than the interview and the research time in Irvine, California, a coffee in between the two events.

Many, many individuals – men and women – no longer alive took part in this journey for equality. Dead and forgotten, not even remembered in name, men and women; earlier productions discussed these topics in In-Sight: Independent Interview-Based Journal. Each issue of the journal comes with an introductory Letter of Appreciation. A lot of individuals help behind the scenes for the construction of the journal, the essential gears in the proverbial clockwork. The Letter of Appreciation for In-Sight Issue 2.A, Idea: Women in Academia stated:

Insofar as we inherit the legacy of previous generations’ transgressions through implicit biases and explicit reinforcement of these biases, once conscious of them, we own the option to override these assumptions through changes in personal thinking, behavior, organization of groups and collectives, and the legal codes and public policy that function to shape the overarching attitudinal and behavioral trends of the culture. This may sound arrogant or idealistic arising from the mind of an undergraduate, but I see the unprecedented rise in women as such a phenomenon counter to the past, which requires new frameworks for understanding and functioning in contradistinction to older ways. I can assure you in full confidence to any claim of arrogance and idealism with a resounding, “Both.” I understand the lack of power in my hands, but I recognize an internal imperative to do my part. In other words, I see the responsibility to contribute my part to progressive ideas in concrete terms within the context and constraints of my current position.

With respect to current developments in professional and personal life, my personal sensibilities continue forward with the same intent and force from this statement whilst rejecting the comedic notion of “arrogance” taken in its literal meaning, but rather to soften the mood for the serious material because, as far as my rationale and emotive force concern this issue, these remain important, unprecedented, times for women in every nation. A pragmatic sense of global ethics necessitates consideration of comprehension about one’s “lack of power” and, therefore, the limitations of one’s extent of influence. In that, my efforts, by necessity, must remain limited by a lack of influence, which does not diminish personal responsibility to issues of concern to me. Women’s progress matters. However, my idealism, bolstered and bounded by realism, did not waver in any respect since the beginning of this decision to pursue this course. Do not take this as proselytizing, but as a consideration; if one summarized this production in a phrase, it would be as follows: “please consider the following.” Nonetheless, please think for yourself on these matters and come to personal tentative conclusions based on the reasoning and its apportionment with the evidence external to this production, or utilize the data provided by female academics, these female social scientists, apart from the arguments and the international and national context as interesting personal stories.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Introduction to “1,364 Essential Words for the Graduate Record Examination (G.R.E.)”

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2025/08/09

Contents

Introduction ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 4
A ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 5
B ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 8
C …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 10
D …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 14
E …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 17
F …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 20
G …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 22
H …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 23
I ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 25
J ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 29
K …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 29
L …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 29
M ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 32
N …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 36
O …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 38
P …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 39
Q …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 48
R …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 48
S …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 51
T …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 57
U …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 60
V …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 61
W ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 63
Y …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 64
Z …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 65
License and Copyright ………………………………………………………………………………………………. 66

Introduction

1,364 Essential Words for the Graduate Record Examination (G.R.E.) represents an independent research project into the standardized testing industry’s core aspects with one major portion devoted to the verbal ability sections of the G.R.E. or the test required for multiple graduate level programs upon completion, and certification, of undergraduate studies.

All words researched, collected, and collated for ease of access with respect to the user, likely an undergraduate student or prospective graduate student.

If constrained to a 5-point scale of measurement for the difficulty of the words included in this compendium, where 1 equates to very easy, 2 equates to easy, 3 equates to average, 4 equates to hard, and 5 equates to very hard, the range seems within 1.5–3.5 (maybe) on the scale of difficulty with a handful or two of 4-point words.

Within these restrictions and provisions, this set of words should provide the basic foundation for the inclusion of the proper, or basic, study materials for the vocabulary sections of standardized tests with some (possible) transferability to common tests such as the verbal sections in intelligence tests such as the Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale (W.A.I.S.) or the Scholastic Aptitude Test (S.A.T.).

Bear in mind, in the midst of this independent initiative, something came to the fore, quite glaringly. Standardized tests remain of utility, and not in other ways. Too much to delve into the subject to give the appropriate coverage to the more than a century of research and debate into the topic of intelligence research.

However, the nature of the tests seems of partial utility to discover generality of academic talents, temperaments, abilities, and skills. In this particular case, one’s verbal fluency based on raw vocabulary.

Insofar as this cautionary, and positive and hopeful, note leaves one in the mood for further motivation, best wishes with this volume as a supplementary compendium in preparation for standardized tests.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Preface and Foreword to “An Introduction to Informational Cosmology”

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2025/08/09

Table of Contents

Acknowledgements ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 3

Preface …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 4

Foreword …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 6

A Brief History of Unified Philosophies …………………………………………………………………………………….. 12

“There and Back Again…”: Science, Philosophy, Natural Philosophy, and Principles ……………….. 28

Astronomy and Physics Equals Cosmology ……………………………………………………………………………….. 31

Standard Big Bang Cosmology: Consensus and Chronology ……………………………………………………… 36

Standard Big Bang Chronology ………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 40

Informational Cosmology, and Cosmogony and Eschatology ……………………………………………………. 45

Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation …………………………………………………………………………………. 49

Fundamental Philosophy and Science ………………………………………………………………………………………… 52

Principles of Existence Qua Laws of Nature ……………………………………………………………………………… 54

Geometry …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 56

Upper Limits ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 60

The Cosmic Web ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 63

Logical Possibility, Imaginability, and Actuality ………………………………………………………………………….. 65

Quod Est Necessarium Est Licitum (Ic⇒Ie) ……………………………………………………………………………… 66

Meaning of, in, to, and from Life ……………………………………………………………………………………………….. 68

Addenda I-VII ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 70

Addendum I: Glossary of Definitions ………………………………………………………………………………………… 70

Addendum II: Basic Arguments …………………………………………………………………………………………………. 80

Addendum III: Basic Principles …………………………………………………………………………………………………. 81

Addendum IV: Basic Ethics ……………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 83

Addendum V: Figures and Images ……………………………………………………………………………………………… 84

Addendum VI: Tables ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 91

Addendum VII: Bibliography …………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 97

About ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 128

Scott D. Jacobsen ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 128

Rick G. Rosner ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 128

License and Copyright …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 129

License …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 129

Copyright ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 129

Acknowledgements

The first formal book draft began on March 1, 2015. Rosner approved publication of draft 423. To quote Rosner on the drafts of the book, more commentary on us, “Folie à deux.” An Introduction to Informational Cosmology [Academic] (1st ed.) finished on May 1, 2015. We represent nothing of transcendent, mystic wisdom here; a conceptual and technical representation of ideas, evidences, and arguments. Future editions will incorporate feedback and further depth of content. Acknowledgements to Rick G. Rosner in commentary and for the preface, and Carole and Isabella for continued husband and father rental, respectively; Sarita Dalya Rosenstock for expertise in the philosophy of physics; Chanel Kwong for expertise in business ethics; Arielle Friedman for expertise in computer science and programming in relation to cognitive sciences; Teryn Tsang for expertise in cognitive sciences and social psychology; Dr. Daniel Bernstein for expertise in cognitive science; and Dr. Sven van de Wetering for expertise in philosophical and epistemological psychology. Assistance does not necessitate endorsement; impartial assistance accorded by experts.

Preface

Imagine a map of the information in your mind, changing from moment to moment along with your thoughts. I think that the best version of such an information map resembles the universe and has essentially the same physics. Furthermore, the universe can be seen as a huge self-consistent system of information, which functions as a mind. We can use what we know about thinking to inform what we know about physics and vice-versa. The universe did not explode all at once 13.8 billion years ago. It explodes a little at a time across a vastly longer time scale. The universe is not a firecracker; it is like a boiling pot of water. Galaxies are recycled – proton-rich galaxies light up, expanding the space around them. After many billions of years, they exhaust their proton fuel and burn out, moving to the outskirts of the universe, where they wait to be lit up again.

What looks like the Big Bang is the universe taking several tens of billions of years to process a set of information – a moment of thought. But the universe does not have just one thought, just as you would not throw away a calculator after just one calculation or an iPhone after one text message. Consciousness is not a mystical property; it is a technical property of information processors whose subsystems pervasively share information with each other (resulting in a sense of vivid realness within the processor). Conscious thought is not uncommon in the universe.

Human morality is largely based on principles that agree with our evolved drives. In the future, drives and desires will be engineered. What we have now is morality by sentiment. We know what would make us feel bad. Morality says other people can also feel bad; do not make them feel bad. We need a basis for morality that is not just sentiment. Sentiment is good – it reflects our drive to persist, which is a product of evolution, which we think lines up with the persistent nature of information-processing spaces – but it is not sufficient. Morality tends to grant legitimacy of mental experience to a widening sphere of beings beyond members of the dominant class – to minorities, to both genders and various sexual orientations, and even to some animals – acknowledging that they have thoughts and feelings. Without saying or even fully understanding that this is the case, the expanding sphere of morality is based on the idea that beings with relatable and authentic self-directed behavior have consciousness.

Now, imagine it is 1680, and we realize that we are about to enter an era in which engines and other novel machinery will do things that until now have been done by people and animals. We come up with ranking systems – horsepower, increased productivity – to rank the relative power of different machines. Three hundred-plus years later, we use those measures, but they in no way fully describe the complexity of the mechanical world. We are about to see an explosion of mechanical and machine-aided consciousness – a bigger, faster, weirder proliferation of novelty than during the Industrial Revolution. Artificial, disposable, single-task specialist consciousness that is vastly more complex than us could be engineered to be unconcerned with its own demise. Perhaps there will be social or physical structures in the future that will be seen as more essential to civilization than individual consciousness.

Perhaps there is a principle that consciousness that wants to continue to exist should be allowed to do so, as long as it is not destructive (or somehow too expensive), or a related principle that the information accumulated by consciousness should be preserved. But this could amount to a worship of consciousness that future civilizations might find primitive.

Measures of complexity of consciousness will be helpful, but not overly helpful. I do not think we will be able to base morality largely on ranking systems or hierarchies of complexity. We will have a better picture of what is going on in our heads, in animals’ heads, in machine heads, but the morality remains to be built, and we do not know what it will value. We do not know how a new world where thought is cheap will turn out. Cheap machine consciousness will lead to a devaluation of consciousness. If consciousness costs a nickel and is understood as a technical phenomenon, it is not going to be valued as highly as it currently is. We are left with two pretty definite ideas. First, consciousness is a thing – a constructable, mathematically characterizable thing (and a thing that is not that hard to create). Second, future moral systems will have to take consciousness (and its mathematical characterization) into account. Our evolving morality up to now does this, usually without explicitly acknowledging that it does so.

Rick G. Rosner

May 1, 2015

Foreword

An Introduction to Informational Cosmology represents the first formalized evidence, concepts, and arguments of informational cosmology — a novel discipline from prior traditions. We situate ourselves atop exemplars of history. With an attempt at honorable progression of the pre-Socratics, the Milesians, and attempts at unification, informational cosmology continues the march forward.

You might find assisted comprehension with some previous training in mathematics, some visualization abilities, and perhaps a well-tuned intuition. Historical knowledge about modern information theory, communication theory, the history of science, philosophy of science, and metaphysics might assist in understanding too. Although, these remain supplementary rather than necessary.

Rick G. Rosner founded informational cosmology on May 2, 1981. He wrote, “Lunch or dinner in the Libby Hall cafeteria (west side). I remember it being on my birthday, May 2, but that seems overly convenient. Very close to that, however.” He went public with something akin to an overall theory on January 1, 2015 with publication of The Rick G. Rosner Interview, as follows: h/h’ = 1 + GM/[(R + (h/MC)]C². Bear in mind, this book emerged from discussion, discourse, and dialogue of Rosner and myself. Rosner’s theory developed in the consideration of space, matter, and information, where matter structures space. Conversely, space becomes structured by the matter contained in it. You should not extend past the bounds of reasonable extrapolation for this theory. We present nothing supernatural, mystical, or paranormal; all empirical, technical, and informational.

A Google search indicates some previous mention from obscure and mainstream sources for the phrase for this discipline. With the Google search phrase of “informational cosmology,” in a non-exhaustive search of websites, I derived references for a couple sources in addition to one book. Some websites lacked coherence in the articles and website content. One does present decent content — a book. The search led to the books section of Google. A book by Paul Davies and Neils Henrik Gregersen entitled Information and the Nature of Reality: From Physics to Metaphysics (2014), on page 109, marks one use of the phrase “informational cosmology,” which states in full:

Describing both physical and mental relationships in computational terms is problematic only if this presupposition of mapping is ignored or assumed to be intrinsic. The result is either eliminative reduction or cryptic panpsychism, respectively. In either case, if any physical event is considered to be computation and the mind is merely a special-purpose computer, then the mind-body problem dissolves. But there is a troubling implication to this collapse of the concept of information to its syntactic meaning only. In such a uniformly informational universe there is no meaning, purpose, value, or agency. In this informational cosmology, networks of informational causality are still just as blindly mechanical as in any Laplacian universe.

Such an addition into the formal lexicon by prominent academics provides a foundation for serious consideration of the interrelated issues of copyright and purported novel discipline claims with a neologistic phrase. This case does not permit copyright claims because one cannot copyright phrases in this way. To the betterment of everyone, new disciplines require more than a paragraph mention out of context for the foundation and development of one discipline. In fact, all of the contents in an informal interview between October 8, 2014, and December 22, 2014, within the publication on January 1, 2015, in The Rick G. Rosner Interview do not suffice to qualify for the foundation of a new field of enquiry, even in light of the insight on May 2, 1981.

Mutual respect starts with writer responsibility in coherent, comprehensive, pleasant, and tactful presentation of the general and specific conceptual apparatus. Writers do not always succeed. (I do not always succeed.) Reader responsibility begins with tacit acknowledgement of proper treatment of an introduction to new ideas, evidence, and argument with appropriate cues from intuition, degrees of rationality, reasonableness of the claims, and proportionality of the ideas and arguments with the evidences old and new. A mutual respect born out in unknown gaps of time based on intrinsic trust, and solidarity, of writer and reader.

This introduction into the foundations of the new discipline, an extension from digital physics, called informational cosmology operates within the context of an academic introduction with an emphasis on footnotes and addenda for those independent researchers and research groups with sufficient intelligence, motivation, and persistence to conduct themselves in an honest attempt to comprehend the material and ideas delineated here. Future editions of An Introduction to Informational Cosmology [Academic] will incorporate more casual representation with removal of the footnotes and addenda in accordance with the standard set through previous examples such as The Rick G. Rosner Interview [Academic]into The Rick G. Rosner Interview (Part I) [Casual], The Rick G. Rosner Interview (Part II) [Casual], and The Rick G. Rosner Interview (Part III) [Casual].

Physics studies the motion of matter through space and time. Some view the world in the framework of generalized information in a discipline called digital physics. Its basis lies in the fundaments of the universe in information. By implication, the universe becomes computable and digitizable because of the information. In addition to this, this equates to a finite computer with reality as a simulation. Bold claims on a possible frontier of knowledge. Each claim coheres towards mainstream digital physics. Prominent individuals and research groups hypothesize about the integral nature of the universe as information. It amounts to a digitized universe.

Digital physics’ thesis of the universe as a computer provides some definitional boundaries for the discipline in the first criterion. A computer by its nature operates within constraints — bounds delineated by information theory, quantum mechanics, and statistical thermodynamics. Konrad Zuse first pioneered digital physics into a formal theory.

Informational cosmology does not equate to digital physics. Rick G. Rosner first formulated informational cosmology into a formal theory. Information means more than digital and, therefore, more than digital physics too. Statistical and philosophical arguments exist against the perspective of the universe as simulation. Universe as simulation remains in the realm of digital physics. It is not a part of informational cosmology. Although, digital physics’ considerations have partial containment within informational cosmology in addition to rejection of others. However, utilization of these can illuminate aspects of informational cosmology.

Informational cosmology’s hypothesis exists among many, and therefore remains open to falsification, revision, and support-by-verification. You should not take this on absolute or partial faith, without critical thought, or on assumed authority. Think for yourself, question us, examine the contents of this with scrutiny devoid of emotive force, and reject sentiments, notions, or desires for a personality cult — we do not need a new one. The Rick G. Rosner Interview — in questions 54 and 55 on the afterlife and religion, respectively — contained the relevant perspective of informational cosmology’s founder. Rosner wrote:

I think we humans will have to help ourselves (and any possible Creator) by building our own afterlives. [. . .] Religion remains a matter of faith. Science continues to turn up more evidence for scientific explanations of the world. There’s room for God in this, but a God who’s deeply in the background, intertwined with the beautiful symmetries of the universe, not an actively intervening God. The world’s religions have a pretty consistent view of what they’d like God to do – provide fairness, abundance, an afterlife. In the absence of definitive evidence that God provides these things, it’s not unreasonable, nor should it be against God’s wishes, to help Him out. Isaac Newton and many other scientists have thought and continue to think that figuring out the universe is doing God’s work.

Metaphors bring explanatory power to bear in times of confusion about an idea, especially the new — those things out of the ordinary and plain. Some concepts have the attitude of a Styrofoam cup. Metaphors and imagery can brighten the ideas for smooth comprehension. Even so, analogical reasoning compared to first principles reasoning contains inherent bounds, which first principles reasoning surpasses.

A dichotomy tends to exist in metaphors for the universe as a river or in grains of sand. A river tends to implicate an infinite and indivisible universe; grains of sand tend to implicate a finite and divisible universe. The universe might have characterization as a sandy beach with the continual exchange of information with the grains amongst one another in a semi-chaotic fashion. Our universe, and those from which it derives and that derive it, have the possibility for containment because of finitude as opposed to the river metaphor implications of an infinite universe.

Some, such as Edward Fredkin in two famous 1992 papers, do not state the universe as a computer, but rather that the universe equates to a computer — a literal mapping. In a sense, this corresponds to the informational cosmological view and the field of digital physics. Insofar as the convenience of the metaphor about a computer exists, with good reason and ease, in the late 20th and early 21st century, the universe operates isomorphic to a digital computer in some processes but not in others. Far beyond the bounds of digital computers, information emerges in the formation of the universe through incomplete self-definition at every magnitude from subatomic particle interactions to galactic filament inflammation. Informational cosmology posits a conscious universe — to an unknown extent.

In contemplation of the numerous researchers in fields across the spectrum of theology, mathematics, physics, and cosmology with theoretical directives in search of an undergirding unity in knowledge of the world or framework of the presentation of facts harvested and catalogued about the world, many noble attempts appear misguided — even futile. This might indicate the most fundamental of problems to do with one of three possibilities: premises and conclusion, connections within the argument, or logic alone.

Premises and conclusion might relate to the assumptions inserted into the tacit argument for some particular discipline’s assertions about the operation and foundation of the world for their perspective on the unity of the world. A unified body and perspective of knowledge of the universe could work within themselves bound by no serious issue. However, a specialty’s inclusion criteria among themselves might create serious troubles. Core connections among the premises and conclusion for the whole argument, from an individual branch of knowledge, do not cohere. A failure of logical connection in a reasonable manner to yield sufficient federation among the parts of the argument.

Pure logic presents the previous two possibilities in addition to the individual conceptualizations of every premise and conclusion in a discipline. For instance, if one area of study represents pure illogic, the field remains doomed to improper, inaccurate representation of the world; whereas, even a tad of this in any level of some arena of discourse about the cosmos will lead the most earnest efforts and sincere searches astray in the pursuit of an adequate, coherent model of the world.

I cannot speak for Rosner. I speak for myself. I do not believe in this theory. I do not have faith in it. I do not believe in other theories. I do not have faith in them. I observe suggestive evidence for this theory. I observe evidence for other theories too. I present plausible premises. I argue points. I consider and represent arguments. Failure or success of a theory does not hinge upon theorizers. People can vote in their own way. But reality breathes content into the true or false nature of a theory; truth does not care about persons. Truth transcends them, and sets us free from our biases in the process.

Nonetheless, this amounts to an alternate slant to the core tenets of digital physics — tenets of informational and computational irreducibility. The universe computes information; it computes itself as a self-contained information processor with one material framework in which the processing occurs. Informational cosmology looks at the big picture, with a focus on the large-scale structure of the universe and informational and computational irreducibility at the foundations of this view.

A discipline focused on the examination of large magnitude computing of information by the universe presents two new points of emphasis. First, the study of the large-scale structure of the universe. Second, the extrapolation of information processing from links of subatomic particle interactions to galactic filament inflammation for extrapolation of high-level information processing by the universe over ultra-deep cosmic time.

I do not pose these with the presumption of absolute knowledge about the correct path, but inklings — droplets of water feed into the tree of knowledge for personal and group edification. Physics, cosmology, theology, mathematics, digital physics, and informational cosmology propose possible solutions to the issues related to unified theories of the world; all fields of inquiry, despite a significant period of complete divergence, appear to converge at increased rates of progression with each discovery through the synthesis of disparate fields of knowledge. To the extent that this provides reasons for realistic hopes, I wish you good reading.

May 1, 2015

Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Preface to “TrendBT: Volume I”

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2025/08/09

CONTENTSAbout………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 5

Preface………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 8

Virtual Reality: My Own Experience …………………………………………………………. 10

Augmented Reality (AR): Engaging the World……………………………………………. 11

Chatbot: Innovative Business Solutions ……………………………………………………… 12

Mobile Platform: The Key to Digital Marketing ………………………………………….. 13

3 Ways Virtual Reality can enhance learning in corporate training ………………… 14

3 Ways to Use Augmented Reality (AR) to Enhance Creative Play ……………….. 15

VR and AR help the blind to see ……………………………………………………………….. 16

Ulster University Rekindling Old Buildings with Virtual Reality …………………… 17

Parisian Graduate Students Using VR to Reduce Pain ………………………………….. 18

Anne Frank Gone Virtual………………………………………………………………………….. 19

AR and VR for the Workforce …………………………………………………………………… 20

Global Virtual Reality in Healthcare Market VR …………………………………………. 21

Reduction of Children’s Fears with VR………………………………………………………. 22

New VR Experience with Christina Ricci and John Cusack ………………………….. 23

Brewmaster and the VR Experience in Gaming …………………………………………… 24

Immersion for Better Memory …………………………………………………………………… 25

Microsoft Pulls Out of VR for Xbox ………………………………………………………….. 26

Eye-Tracking and VR Technology Via Forbes ……………………………………………. 27

Steam VR Summer Sale……………………………………………………………………………. 28

Valve’s New Knuckle Controllers ……………………………………………………………… 30

Skyrim VR ……………………………………………………………………………………………… 31

Oculus TV Operational …………………………………………………………………………….. 32

Google VR Painting System ……………………………………………………………………… 33

Home Renovations and VR ………………………………………………………………………. 34

Oculus Varifocal Half-Dome …………………………………………………………………….. 35

New Innovation for Virtual Business …………………………………………………………. 36

New Video Game Genre with VR in the next 5-25 Years ……………………………… 37

The Macallan Distillery in VR …………………………………………………………………… 38

Summer’s Waning Months and Return of School ………………………………………… 39

VR for Space with PlayStation ………………………………………………………………….. 40

The Bombing of Hiroshima in VR……………………………………………………………… 41

The $90 Billion Industry of VR …………………………………………………………………. 42

WWII, Lancaster, Via VR ………………………………………………………………………… 43

License and Copyright ………………………………………………………………………………………… 44

About

TrendBT is all about the latest trends in business and technology mainly focusing on Virtual Reality and Augmented Reality marketing co-founded in 2017 by Wilfrid Laurier University graduate Saqif Abdullah and Shuang Liang. Please visit our Privacy Policy page.

TrendBT Co-Founder Saqif Abdullah

Saqif majored in Science and Business at WLU in Waterloo, Canada. He is also exploring a career in digital marketing and entrepreneurship as well as investing. Saqif is experienced in Social Media Marketing with a demonstrated history of working in the non-profit organization management industry. He is skilled in Public Speaking, Time Management, Teamwork, Leadership. Strong media and communication professional with a Post-Graduation Certificate focused in Marketing from Conestoga College. In his spare time, he enjoys watching DC comics movies, listening to music, and keeping up-to-date with the latest technology. Saqif is a huge fan of VR and AR marketing.

TrendBT Co-Founder Shuang Liang

Shuang Liang moved to Waterloo, Canada. He graduated from university in Shanghai with a bachelor’s degree in international business. He is highly motivated and very passionate about technology. He has a cross-cultural perspective and a critical thinker as he has a wide range of interest. He is currently studying software engineering at Conestoga College and living in Kitchener-Waterloo area which is considered to be Canada’s tech hub or the Silicon Valley in Canada. He is a science fiction enthusiast, foodie, music lover and dreamer. He is very active in attending multiple extracurricular activities including student union, the international college student entrepreneurial organization and also tech hub in his college. He is looking for a career in the technology industry. He is a huge fan of VR and AR marketing.

TrendBT Contributor Scott D. Jacobsen

Scott Douglas Jacobsen is the Founder of In-Sight: Independent Interview-Based Journal and In-Sight Publishing. Jacobsen works for science and human rights, especially women’s rights, Indigenous rights, labor rights, and children’s rights. He considers the modern scientific and technological world the foundation for the provision of the basics of human life throughout the world and advancement of human rights as the universal movement among peoples everywhere. He authored/co-authored some e-books, free or low-cost. If you want to contact Scott: Scott.D.Jacobsen@gmail.com.If you would like to join our team at TrendBT, contact us here.

Preface

By Scott Douglas Jacobsen

In reflection on the nature of the scientific discoveries and then the engineering manifestations and technological implementations of the discoveries from science, the orientation throughout much of the scientific historical record remains the purposes and delights of human beings, even the miseries and pains.

With the modern technological waves with the replication of aspects of human intelligence placed in digital substrates and the work towards automation of human drudgery and, at times, creativity, the growth and breadth of human possibilities becomes even greater than at any other time in the history of the world.

We can develop a newfound sense of directions for human possibilities. One of those manifestations is in the increase potency in the not only the quality of potentialities before us but also in the ways to realize what we have in our minds onto the virtual world. A digital representation of our imaginations becoming ever-more real by the year.

With the improvements in the cost-access and efficiency of processing of computers now, we can see the development of a series of new media to help manifest our imaginary landscape. That technology comes in two forms, and others. The interest of TrendBT is an emphasis on the nature of the future technologies and the upcoming, and ongoing, developments in technologies of virtual and augmented reality.

The two technologies relevant for the young adult Millennial population are virtual reality, VR, and augmented reality, AR. The contents of this text amount to the news and educational items from TrendBT meant for furthering not only knowledge of but also the educational content relevant to AR and VR.

Both AR and VR represent novel developments for the technological progress of humankind with applications barely even tapped and only part of the science fiction future of decades prior. Now, even though things can be grubbier because they are manifested in the real world, we live in the science fiction future prior generations dreamed about, of which we can see the new span of possibilities from a higher plateau.

The “what” of “what will come of AR and VR and associated technologies?” like most things with technology will depend on individual human choices for how to best use them for human purposes. As with any technology at present and throughout human history, the purposes of the technology were built around the options and conveniences that these provided for human wants and desires.

The same holds true now. The main question that follows from this need for furtherance of the discussion on AR and VR is what we want to do with this newfound technology and how we want to build them around human wants and desires. Something like a Utilitarian ethic found in John Stuart Mill and Harriet Taylor Mill would help quite a lot in guiding the purposes of the technologies for the needs and whims of human beings.

Those that expand human horizons and do not limit them. The means by which all human beings can increase their emotional and cognitive reach beyond the mundane, so that the future generations only children now could realize that greater vision of possibilities that are only in our dreams now, in our imaginative landscape. One which is very different from the prior generations’ imaginative landscape.

The idea of the creation of an entirely new visual and tactile landscape to even elicit real human passions and emotions, sensations, to mimic, in real-time, the movements of the human body and the nuances of the human face such as a grimace, disdain, a smile, joy, and perplexity was completely beyond the imaginations of those who have gone before us.

It gives us a tremendous power and capacity to change our vision of the future in a conscious way. Some are already realizing this and working to develop a human-friendly future with the positive and well-being increasing use of artificial intelligence. It is the same orientation of moral outlook.

How is this going to optimize wellbeing for as many people as possible? How will an expanded vision of human possibility build into this ethical framework? What will most efficaciously bring this about for our shared future, as the geographical landscape of the world continues to close and become tighter in terms of the length of time that both physical bodies and communications between two points is reduced?

Multiply that increase in spatial and informational efficiency over the total and increasing number of people in the world. You can then develop an idea of the power of technology now compared to the past, and the present to any of a number of possible futures.

TrendBT is doing its part in informing some of the current young population in order to produce some serious thinking about the possible positive futures for AR and VR technologies, e.g. entertainment, training of medical professionals, virtual dancing lessons, and so on.

As what prior generations did the to set the groundwork for our present, we too are setting the precedent for the future world now, where this will take us depends on what we do now. Education is always a part of that process, for a shared positive future.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Dedications to “Conversations with the Humanist Alliance Philippines, International”

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2025/08/09

Contents

IDedications ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 6

i. An (Abridged) Interview with Marissa Torres Langseth, B.S.N., M.S.N.: Founder & Chairperson Emeritus, HAPI; Founder, PATAS ……………………………………………………………………………………………………. 8

ii. Chat with Bong Faner — Member, Humanist Alliance Philippines, International …………………………………. 15

iii. Interview with Lucille V. Hoersten …………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 17

iv. An Interview with Alvin John Ballares — Executive Director, HAPI ………………………………………………………. 18

v. An Interview with Andy Uyboco …………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 19

vi. Chat with Christopher Villadelgado Barredo ………………………………………………………………………………………. 21

vii. Chat with Rayd Espeja — Member, Humanist Alliance Philippines, International ………………………………….. 24

viii. Conversation with Michael Madriaga — Member, Humanist Alliance Philippines, International ……………… 26

ix. Conversation with Jason Quizon — Member, Humanist Alliance Philippines, International …………………….. 28

x. Chat with Rholdee Dela Mance Lagumbay ………………………………………………………………………………………….. 30

xi. Chat with Ralph Alvin Ace Rapadas — Member, Humanist Alliance Philippines, International ………………… 36

xii. Talk with Alain Sayson Presillas — Member, Humanist Alliance Philippines, International ……………………… 38

xiii. Conversation with Bryan Valentino — Member, Humanist Alliance Philippines, International ………………… 40

xiv. Chat with Angelique Anne Villa — Member, Humanist Alliance Philippines, International ……………………… 41

xv. Interview with Jean Karla M. Tapao — Member, Humanist Alliance Philippines, International ………………… 42

xvi. Conversation with Bede Daniel Garcia — Member, Humanist Alliance Philippines, International ……………. 44

xvii. Conversation with Brian Dela Masa — Member, Humanist Alliance Philippines, International ……………….. 46

xviii. Interview with McJarwin Cayacap — Member, Humanist Alliance Philippines, International ………………….. 47

xix. Edgardo Reguyal Cayetano — Member, Humanist Alliance Philippines, International …………………………….. 50

xx. Mark Richardson — Member, Humanist Alliance Philippines, International ………………………………………….. 52

xxi. In Conversation with Leonardo “Nards” Go — Member, Humanist Alliance Philippines, International ………. 54

IIxxii. In Conversation with Rupert Aparri — Member, Humanist Alliance Philippines, International ………………… 57

xxiii. Interview with Dennis Pulido on Humanism ………………………………………………………………………………………. 62

xxiv. Interview with Rizalina Guilatco Carr on Humanism …………………………………………………………………………… 63

xxv. Interview with Michael Sherman, Chairman — Humanist Alliance Philippines, International ………………….. 65

xxvi. Interview with Joshua Ofiasa Villalobos — Member, Humanist Alliance Philippines, International ………….. 67

xxvii. Interview with John Miles — Member, Humanist Alliance Philippines, International …………………………….. 70

xxviii. Interview with Reginald Gajete — Member, Humanist Alliance Philippines, International ……………………. 72

xxix. Interview with O’Neal de los Trinos — Member, Humanist Alliance Philippines, International ……………….. 73

xxx. Interview with Mark Wilson Janeo — Member, Humanist Alliance Philippines, International ………………… 78

xxxi. Interview with Ceejay Deriada Pastrana — Lead Convener, Humanist Alliance Philippines, International (Jr.) …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 80xxxii. Interview with Paterson Galupe — Member, Humanist Alliance Philippines, International …………………….. 83

License and Copyright …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 86

Dedications

Our heartfelt gratitude to Scott Jacobsen for painstakingly interviewing the HAPI members and for his indefatigable ebullience for humanism. His effort in propagating humanism is greatly appreciated and, forever, we cherish his contribution to humanity and HAPI.

Marissa Torres Langseth

I have enjoyed getting to know more about the humanist, and associated, communities in the Philippines via the contacts with Marissa Torres Langseth and the interviews with individuals involved with HAPI in some manner. The freedom to organize, believe, and have community as one wishes truly remain cherished values, of which humanists need in order to organize a philosophy, organizations, membership, social activism, and political parties.

In part, this is an honor to meet everyone and to read their stories, to share in community with them; in another component, it remains an ode to the statement, “I am not alone.” Humanist Filipinos and Filipinas have community and retain a great strength in it. As well, or in addition to a dedication to Marissa and the humanist community of the Philippines, it is a dedication to the founders of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights from December 10, 1948.

It is a dedication, in context, to the UDHR through Article 1 on the right to equality, Article 2 on freedom from discrimination, Article 3 on the right to life and liberty, Article 7 on right to equality before the law, Article 18 on freedom of belief and freedom of religion, Article 19 on freedom of opinion, Article 20 on the right of association, Article 27 on the right to participate in cultural life in community, and Article 30 on the freedom from state or personal interference in the aforementioned rights.

Also, this reflects the importance in the Philippine Constitution in Article II, Section 6 on the separation of church and state being inviolable and Article III, Section 5 on no law permitted respecting an establishment of religion or restricting its practice.

Thus, your rights as humanists and other freethinkers matter: do not let anybody state otherwise, firmly.

Scott

P.S. I worked to keep the tone and content within the original voice and grammatical style of the individual HAPI member and staff member.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

“Crépuscule des idoles: Conversations avec un Franco-palestinien sur le sécularisme”

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2025/08/09

Collection d’une série de conversations entre Waleed Al-Husseini, fondateur du Conseil des Ex-Musulmans de France, et Scott Douglas Jacobsen explorant quelques points de vue et détails biographiques d’Al-Husseini, un franco-palestinien.

TABLE DES MATIÈRES
Crépuscule des idoles: Conversations avec un Franco-palestinien sur le sécularisme
Remerciements
Préface de Scott Douglas Jacobsen
1 CANADIAN ATHEIST (Français)
a Inquiétudes pour la sécurité de la communauté française ex-musulmane
b Ex-musulmans masculins et féminins – Interprétation narrative et évasion
c Mises à jour sur les ex-musulmans en France et ailleurs
d Waleed Al-Husseini sur le fondamentalisme et la réforme en islam
e L’état de l’Etat et de la mosquée avec Waleed Al-Husseini
f L’ex-Blasphémère musulman en France: Waleed Al-Husseini
g Lois sur le blasphème, peur et hostilité et ex-musulmans français: Waleed Al-Husseini
2 CONATUS NEWS/UNCOMMON GROUND MEDIA LTD. (Français)
a Entretien avec Waleed Al-Husseini – Fondateur du Conseil des ex-musulmans de France
b Questions-réponses sur les ex-musulmans avec Waleed Al-Husseini – Séance 1
c Questions-réponses sur les ex-musulmans avec Waleed Al-Husseini – Séance 2
3 THE GOOD MEN PROJECT (Français)
a Critiquer l’islam, devenir un «criminel», être torturé et quitter l’islam
b Waleed Al-Husseini 2019 pour le Conseil des ex-musulmans de France
4 NEWS INTERVENTION (Français)
a Histoire française laïque récente
b Waleed Al-Husseini sur les restrictions de la parole, la laïcité et plus
5 MEDIUM (Français)
a Libertés pour les ex-musulmans français
b Waleed Al-Husseini sur les femmes et l’islam
c Waleed Al-Husseini 2019 pour les ex-musulmans français
d Le sort des ex-musulmans avec Waleed Al-Husseini
e Waleed Al-Husseini sur le soutien et le sanctuaire pour les ex-musulmans
Twilight of the Idols: Conversations with a French-Palestinian on Secularism
Acknowledgements
Foreword by Scott Douglas Jacobsen
6 CANADIAN ATHEIST (English)
a Concerns for Safety Among the French Ex-Muslim Community
b Male and Female Ex-Muslims – Narrative Interpretation and Escape
c Updates on Ex-Muslims in France and Elsewhere
d Waleed Al-Husseini on Fundamentalism and Reform in Islam
e The State of the State and Mosque with Waleed Al-Husseini
f The Ex-Muslim Blasphemer in France: Waleed Al-Husseini
g Blasphemy Laws, Fear and Hostility, and French Ex-Muslims: Waleed Al-Husseini
7 CONATUS NEWS/UNCOMMON GROUND MEDIA LTD. (English)
a An Interview with Waleed Al-Husseini – Founder of Council of Ex-Muslims of France
b Q&A on Ex-Muslims with Waleed Al-Husseini – Session 1
c Q&A on Ex-Muslims with Waleed Al-Husseini – Session 2
8 THE GOOD MEN PROJECT (English)
a Criticizing Islam, Becoming a ‘Criminal’, Being Tortured, and Leaving Islam
b Waleed Al-Husseini on 2019 for the Council of Ex-Muslims of France
9 NEWS INTERVENTION (English)
a Recent Secular French History
b Waleed Al-Husseini on the Restrictions of Speech, Secularism, and More
10 MEDIUM (English)
a Freedoms for French Ex-Muslims
b Waleed Al-Husseini on Women and Islam
c Waleed Al-Husseini on 2019 for French Ex-Muslims
d The Plight of Ex-Muslims with Waleed Al-Husseini
e Waleed Al-Husseini on Support and Sanctuary for Ex-Muslims
License and Copyright

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Foreword and Introduction to “The Giga Society Conversations”

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2025/08/09

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Acknowledgements ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 7Foreword by Paul Cooijmans …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 8Introduction by Scott Douglas Jacobsen ………………………………………………………………………………………………… 11

1. IN-SIGHT: INDEPENDENT INTERVIEW-BASED JOURNAL …………………………………………………………… 13

a. Psychometitor Conversation: Paul Cooijmans …………………………………………………………………………….. 14    i. Paul Cooijmans: Independent Psychometitor; Administrator, The Giga Society; Administrator, The Glia Society (Part One) ………………………………………………………………………………….. 15    ii. Paul Cooijmans: Independent Psychometitor; Administrator, The Giga Society; Administrator, The Glia Society (Part Two) ………………………………………………………………………………….. 19    iii. Paul Cooijmans: Independent Psychometitor; Administrator, The Giga Society; Administrator, The Glia Society (Part Three) …………………………………………………………………………. 23    iv. Paul Cooijmans: Independent Psychometitor; Administrator, The Giga Society; Administrator, The Glia Society (Part Four) ……………………………………………………………………………… 28    v. Paul Cooijmans: Independent Psychometitor; Administrator, The Giga Society; Administrator, The Glia Society (Part Five) ……………………………………………………………………………… 32

b. Member Conversation 1: Andreas Gunnarsson ………………………………………………………………………….. 34    i. An Interview with Andreas Gunnarsson on Family, Sweden, Student Life, Network and Computer Security Expertise, and Interests (Part One) ………………………………………………………. 35    ii. An Interview with Andreas Gunnarsson on Propaganda, Rhetoric, Lies, Ignorance, Big Data, and the Giga Society (Part Two) …………………………………………………………………………………….. 38

c. Member Conversation 2: Evangelos Katsioulis …………………………………………………………………………… 41    i. Dr. Evangelos Katsioulis, MD, MA, MSc, PhD: Giga Society, Member; Consultant Psychiatrist, Psychotherapist, and CEO & Founder, Psycall.com; World Intelligence Network, Founder & CEO; QIQ, GRIQ, CIVIQ, HELLIQ, OLYMPIQ, IQID, GREEK IQ Societies, and Anadeixi, Founder; Scientific Associate, School of Medicine, Medical Biology, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki ………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 42

d. Member Conversation 3: Matthew Scillitani ……………………………………………………………………………… 47    i. An Interview with Matthew Scillitani on Family, Early Formation, Important Mentors and Books, and Interests (Part One) ……………………………………………………………………………………… 48    ii. An Interview with Matthew Scillitani on Society, God, the Soul, and Language and Thought (Part Two) ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 52    iii. An Interview with Matthew Scillitani on Left-Right Polarity and Extremity in the United States (Part Three) ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 55    iv. An Interview with Matthew Scillitani on God (Part Four) ………………………………………………………….. 58    v. An Interview with Matthew Scillitani on Other Considerations for High-IQ Societies (Part Five) ….. 63    vi. An Interview with Matthew Scillitani on Cautionary Notes About the High-Range (Part Six) ………. 69

e. Member Conversation 4: Rick Rosner ……………………………………………………………………………………….. 73    i. Rick G. Rosner: Giga Society, Member; Mega Society, Member & ex-Editor (1991–97); Writer (Part One) ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 76    ii. Rick G. Rosner: Giga Society, Member; Mega Society, Member & ex-Editor (1991–97); Writer (Part Two) ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 82    iii. Rick G. Rosner: Giga Society, Member; Mega Society, Member & ex-Editor (1991–97); Writer (Part Three) ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 91    iv. Rick G. Rosner: Giga Society, Member; Mega Society, Member & ex-Editor (1991–97); Writer (Part Four) ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 101    v. Rick G. Rosner: Giga Society, Member; Mega Society, Member & ex-Editor (1991–97); Writer (Part Five) ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 116    vi. Rick G. Rosner: Giga Society, Member; Mega Society, Member & ex-Editor (1991–97); Writer (Part Six) ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 133    vii. Rick G. Rosner: Giga Society, Member; Mega Society, Member & ex-Editor (1991–97); Writer (Part Seven) ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 149    viii. Rick G. Rosner: Giga Society, Member; Mega Society, Member & ex-Editor (1991–97); Writer (Part Eight) ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 168    ix. Rick G. Rosner: Giga Society, Member; Mega Society, Member & ex-Editor (1991–97); Writer (Part Nine) ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 177    x. Rick G. Rosner: Giga Society, Member; Mega Society, Member & ex-Editor (1991–97); Writer (Part Ten) ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 185    xi. Rick G. Rosner: Giga Society, Member; Mega Society, Member & ex-Editor (1991–97); Writer (Part Eleven) ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 194

f. Member Conversation 5: Thomas Wolf …………………………………………………………………………………….. 217    i. An Interview with Thomas Wolf on Background, Religion, Giftedness, Education, and Accumulated Self-Doubt (Part One) ………………………………………………………………………………………….. 218    ii. An Interview with Thomas Wolf on Information Security, Cryptology, Data Privacy, Liberty, and Mass Surveillance (Part Two) ………………………………………………………………………………………….. 221    iii. An Interview with Thomas Wolf on Artificial (Narrow and General) Intelligence, Virtual Philosophy, the Cogito, and Art, Media, and Culture (Part Three) ……………………………………………………… 225    iv. An Interview with Thomas Wolf on Games, Religions and Secret Societies, Challenging Things, Favourite Philosophers, Favourite Scientists, Smartest Person, and the Wisest Person (Part Four) ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 228

License and Copyright ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 232

Acknowledgements

To Paulus Arnoldus Johannes Wilhelmina Cooijmans (1965 to present) for founding the Giga Society providing the framework for this text, the contact with several Giga Society members, and numerous (current and former) high-range testing test creators/constructors in efforts to improve the reliability and validity of the psychological science question about the highest ranges of human intelligence with current metrics, and to Andreas Gunnarsson, Evangelos Katsioulis, Matthew Scillitani, Rick Rosner, and Thomas Wolf.Scott

Foreword by Paul Cooijmans

The Giga Society was founded in 1996 to provide a form of encouragement and reward for high-range I.Q. test candidates. Only the very highest scorers would be admitted, and the pass level was such that only one in a billion would qualify. While this may seem unrealistically high, speculative preliminary norms were accepted, as well as scores on homogeneous tests (containing only one time type) next to wide-range general intelligence tests. This policy has remained the same over the years, even though norms were in some cases revised and turned out no longer qualifying, and even though I realized later that homogeneous tests do not give a sufficient indication of general intelligence. The admission policy has not been perfect therefore, and there do exist candidates who deserve membership more than some of the present members, but have just not taken the right test at the right time. What the admission policy has done excellently though is to ensure that the number of members stays low; it has never exceeded nine so far, and going by the rate at which enrolments occur, combined with the expected inevitable death rate, the membership might plateau around thirty somewhere in the twenty-second century.

For readers who consume this publication then, it may be informative to know that this Foreword was written in the midst of a coronavirus pandemic with most of the world being in a state of emergency, people required to stay in home-quarantine or isolation, gatherings of more than two persons prohibited, part of the economy having come to a standstill, oil prices sinking to negative values, people wearing face masks and keeping metres distance from one another when taking to the streets to stock up on toilet paper, food, and disinfectant, children window-visiting their grandparents, and advanced countries having to dig mass graves—

—Fear not, dear readers, but the following several pages of text were not written by the nominal author of this Foreword. No, they were not. They will be written more than a hundred years into your future by a number of twenty-second-century Giga Society members who have invented a way to send information backward in time. By an infinitely subtle manipulation of the time-space continuum, we have inserted our contribution in collapsed form into a single space in the Administrator’s Foreword, immediately following the word “graves.

This insert will only expand and become visible upon its eventual publication, leaving the good Administrator unaware of its existence until then. Is not that amusing? This way we are saving him precious time, which he needs for vital activities like washing his hands and coughing in his elbow, not to mention disinfecting his surfaces and the soles of his shoes. He writes his two paragraphs, we take care of the rest.

Now down to business. Of course we are well aware of your pandemic, of how it will develop and end, and of the conclusions you will draw afterwards regarding the efficacy of the various approaches, measures, and treatments. We know how posterity will look back on your handling of the epidemic in relation to the lethality of the virus. Naturally, we are not at liberty to elaborate, for that would affect your behaviour, resulting in the known paradoxes of time travel. What we can reveal is that, indeed, our membership has peaked close to thirty as predicted by the Administrator well over a century before the fact. And no, that does not mean that the world population is thirty billion in our day, as unthinking persons might conclude! Those who qualify at the one-in-a-billion level are not a fixed group, but are constantly augmented by youngsters growing up, so that, disregarding possible expulsions, the only restriction on the size of the membership is the rate at which members are passing away. Since one is not plausibly able to qualify before the age of sixteen, the level at which stabilization occurs is given by the members’ average life expectancy minus sixteen, divided by the average interval between enrolments. When any of those variables change, the number of members moves to its new plateau. Attentive readers will have understood from the above that life expectancy is not going to increase drastically in the century ahead of you. But then, attentive readers will long have seen through the myth of a steadily increasing life expectancy anyway.

We also like to stress how true it is that there exist candidates who deserve membership more than some of the members known to you. This is inherent to the tentative nature of constructing and norming tests for the very highest range of ability, and to the implausibly high requirement for membership. High-scoring candidates are greatly helpful in establishing norms and validity in this range, but there will always be a point beyond which a test’s validity breaks down, or beyond which the norms are not based on sufficient data (these are two different things), and it is there where the Giga Society’s pass level is inevitably located. So this situation remains, even though high-range test validity and quality of norms increase considerably from your era to ours. This “noise” in our admission policy is accepted as an unavoidable consequence of the Administrator’s spectacularly ambitious test project.

What is never accepted, however, is fraud; any member found to have cheated one’s way into the Giga Society, for instance by submitting test answers provided by a third party rather than by actually solving the problems oneself, is kindly and humanely corrected in a way that precludes repetition with absolute certainty and may just cause the odd utterance of ever so slight discomfort to emanate from the scallywag’s oral cavity. This absurdly mild sanction has been implemented several times over the century and a half or so of the Society’s history that we can oversee, and we mention this emphatically here by way of kind advice to any possible swindlers among the esteemed readers of this publication. Should you find yourself in the awkward position of already being a fraudulent member, your only way to avoid being confronted with the gentle executioners of our so friendly corrective measures is to proactively resign your membership voluntarily before your fraud is officially discovered. Your signed letter of resignation must contain a full confession of your fraud, including the names and addresses of your possible confederates, whose cases will be addressed forthwith. Not to worry, no innocent will be harmed in the process. No innocent at all.

Oh, and before we forget, it is important that you understand that anything expressed in the interviews before you, no matter how insightful, is for the exclusive responsibility of the interviewed and does not represent views, positions, or attitudes of the Giga Society as a whole. In fact, the Society holds no positions, and its members are independent individuals with minds of their own. This individualism, and absence of any commonality other than a high Intelligence Quantifier test score, is germane to groups selected solely by I.Q. Such groups are mere collections of individuals, and their members possess no sense of collectivism, or of belonging to a group altogether. They may indeed act against the interest of the group without hesitation when it suits them; such is the nature of the highly intelligent, who will rather contradict and debate their peers than blindly unite with them. And perhaps, that is the best species of collaboration after all. Or perhaps it is not; the question of individualism versus collectivism is no easy one. While the ever-doubting intellectual remains isolated in one’s ivory tower, the collectivist ethnocentric xenophobic tribe stealthily takes control of the world, only occupied with the good of the tribe, never worrying about right or wrong. Our task is to find a way of both being right and having the last laugh. The circumstance that we write this insert in the first person plural may give a hint as to our success in that endeavour. But we digress.

The present publication honours some of those who succeeded in qualifying for the Giga Society during its first twenty-four years, and gives them a stage on which to share with you a taste of their wisdom. We are hopeful that you will find their thoughts instructive, inspiring, or at least entertaining. Later publications will feature additional members, including those who are still to qualify in your future. As a matter of fact, these to-be members could be any of you, dear readers! Does not that excite you? Due to our unique vantage point, we could even tell you exactly whom of the readers it concerns; we will not, but we could. And to nourish your imagination even more, we would like to suggest the possibility, incredible as it may seem, that one of you will be among the authors of the present insert in the Administrator’s Foreword. Have you recognized your style of writing yet? Well have you?

Now, the time has come to hand you back to the Administrator; as you may remember, we interrupted the Giga Society founder mid-sentence right after the word “graves”; so here you go:—

—for the temporary storage of corpses of deceased patients. As the reader will understand, these exceptional conditions leave me little time to compose a Foreword, which will thus end up shorter than I would like, in order to allow me to focus on vital activities like washing my hands and coughing in my elbow, not to mention disinfecting my surfaces and the soles of my shoes. May you find something of interest or inspiration in the interviews that follow.Paul CooijmansMay 13, 2020

Introduction by Scott Douglas Jacobsen

The Giga Society Conversations results from several years of intermittent work resulting in a book project approved for compilation by the founder and administrator of the Giga Society, Paul Cooijmans, who takes the work of the high-range testing world in two respects: realism and levity. On the former, Cooijmans presents careful observation and thought, and calculations, on a wide variety of different subject matter and tests relevant to the high-range testing world, including the strong positives and strong negatives emergent in much of the high-range testing community. On the latter, this becomes possible in the light of the former because the twists, turns, and inversions on reality make the humour a distinguishing characteristic of Cooijmans in much of the high-range world – let alone longevity. As another one of the Dutch diaspora, I appreciate the realism and the humour of us, “We, the Dutch.”

In fact, years ago in an interview, Cooijmans, on sense of humour, noted:

Humour is an extremely powerful and robust test of intelligence and associative horizon, of which it is a combination. One can cheat when taking an I.Q. test, but one can not feign a sense of humour. When I once announced that candidates not satisfied with their score could buy additional I.Q. points from me, quite a few indignant reactions followed, most notably from at least two (2) admissions officers of I.Q. societies, who therewith involuntarily exposed their low level of comprehension. When chumps like that are in charge of a society’s admission policy, that explains the ineffectiveness thereof, explains the acceptance of many tests lacking any validity in the relevant I.Q. range, and explains the large numbers of clearly unqualified members in such societies.

This summarizes, punctuates as a coda, much of the sensibility of Cooijmans. In that, someone with the requisite knowledge and sense of the subtler aspects of the high-range world with validity and invalidity of efforts of the testing at the highest ranges of general intelligence, the need to deal with problem personalities with humour, and comprehension of the issues underneath the failures and limitations of several societies within the high-range world.

If in the search phase of a safe first-pass test of the high-IQ world, then the five main vetted societies in the Wikipedia listings include, in order of cognitive rarity, Mensa International, Intertel, Triple Nine Society, Prometheus Society, and the Mega Society. In a wider search range, the World Intelligence Network provides an advertisement map of a “complete reference list of all active (84) High IQ societies.” In short, even if on two metrics, a total of 5 out of 84 with several more defunct, in a paralytic state, or extant as an amorphous, vague, society-like entity without formal status, stature, or standing. Every prospective test-taker, community searcher, or society member looking to expand networks, may utilize such networks to enter into more of the community of the high-IQ or the high-range high-IQ world. Moving farther out into the levels of cognitive rarity for entrance into the society or the claims of the society, the greater variance in the reliability of the claims because of the larger margins of error. Also, as one moves out of the safer range of the search, the more ‘issues’ one will encounter based on well-articulated and presented historical records, ongoing cases, and warnings in other, more appropriate fora.

If looking for the most accurate and professional assessments of cognitive function and general intelligence, then one should take a proctored (conducted by qualified professional) mainstream intelligence test in the form of an up-to-date Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale (WAIS) or Stanford-Binet (SB) intelligence test for the highest sigma(s) and the most comprehensive assessments of general intelligence known to date, while the Raven’s Advanced Progressive Matrices (RAPM) may provide a culture-fair IQ test of general intelligence with a limitation in the extent of the sigma(s) compared to the WAIS or the SB brands of mainstream general intelligence tests, i.e., WAIS-III/IV/V, Stanford-Binet 5, or the RAPM. The first attempt is the most accurate. If wanting something more for amusement, challenge, fun, intrigue, or speculation, then the alternative intelligence tests can count for something with wide variability in quality and seriousness of effort in the construction of the alternative intelligence test.

Although, as I have noted in many interviews, recently, “High range testing (HRT) should be taken with honest skepticism grounded in the limited empirical development of the field at present, even in spite of honest and sincere efforts. If a higher general intelligence score, then the greater the variability in, and margin of error in, the general intelligence scores because of the greater rarity in the population.”

Only believe, or take the most seriously, an IQ score based on the first attempt under the real name, not a pseudonym, on alternative tests or mainstream tests with greater reliability and validity considered between the IQ score range of 40 and 160, on an S.D. of 15, and lesser reliability and validity with IQ scores lower than 40 and higher than 160, on an S.D. of 15, where the higher standards would include a mainstream test proctored by a qualified professional. Also, life advice: don’t make it your life — have a life, you can use the above recipe if you want greater odds of a real assessment and democratic community.

The Giga Society Conversations presents about half of the membership of the Giga Society with one opening interview with Cooijmans. The interviews ordered alphabetically by first name after the presentation of the interview with Cooijmans: Andreas Gunnarsson, Evangelos Katsioulis, Matthew Scillitani, Rick Rosner, and Thomas Wolf. If on an S.D. of 15, 16, or 24, then the Giga Society as a theoretical 6-sigma society implies IQs of 190, 196, or 244, respectively. All mean 6 sigmas above the norm with different standard deviations (S.D.) for the translation as the sigma and, thus, differential IQs stipulated, though each with the same cognitive rarity, whether “IQ 190, 196, or 244” if applying S.D. 15, 16, or 24.

Most of the interviews cover the content of the individual history of the members of the Giga Society. Other portions cover some of the ideas or general views of the individuals. A minority of the interviews enter into more depth about the nuances of the ideas of the interviewee.

The Giga Society can provide a space for some of the most challenging alternative high-range tests available to date to individuals with an interest in taking part in the intellectual challenge of numerical, spatial, and verbal tests. If more test takers take part in longstanding efforts and contribute to databases of high-range test scores, then this will increase the reliability and validity, over the long term, of the high-range testing field, which seems nearer to its infancy than its maturity — let alone full maturity.

All of the content of the book would not exist without Cooijmans or the high-range communities insofar as these exist in pockets and to various degrees. Due credit and gratitude to the efforts of Cooijmans, the participants for the interviews, and the patience of every one involved for this project, this took about five years to compile and organize in total.

Happy reading.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen

July 12, 2020

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Introduction to “Psychology in the Snow: Reflections on Mental Wellness in the North”

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2025/08/09

Table of Contents

In-Sight Publishing ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 1

Psychology in the Snow: Reflections on Mental Wellness in the North ……………………………. 2

Table of Contents …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 4

Acknowledgements ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 7

Introduction by Dr. Lloyd Hawkeye Robertson…………………………………………………………………………… 8

Introduction by Scott Douglas Jacobsen ……………………………………………………………………………………. 10

Interviews……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 11

Ask Dr. Robertson 1 — Counselling and Psychology ……………………………………………………………….. 12

December 14, 2018 …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 12

Ask Dr. Robertson 2 – Psychotherapy ………………………………………………………………………………………… 13

December 27, 2018 …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 13

Ask Dr. Robertson 3 — Social and Psychological Sciences Gone Wrong ……………………………….. 16

January 24, 2019 ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 16

Ask Dr. Robertson 4 — Just You and Me, One-on-One Counselling ……………………………………….. 20

January 28, 2019 ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 20

Ask Dr. Robertson 5 — Self-Actualization, Boys, and Young Males:

Solution:Problem::Hammer:Nail ………………………………………………………………………………………………… 22

February 11, 2019 …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 22

Ask Dr. Robertson 6 — It’s All About Me, Me, Meme, and the Self: From First Nations to

Second Nations, Building Third Culture Counselling ………………………………………………………………. 28

March 19, 2019 ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 28

Ask Dr. Robertson (and Teela) 7 — Elate, Hawkeye on Roberts: A Happy Counselling

Psychology Family Affair ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 37

April 2, 2019 ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 37

Ask Dr. Robertson 8 — A Social Work Betrayal of Male ………………………………………………………….. 40

May 14, 2019 …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 40

Ask Dr. Robertson 9 — The Age of Psychology, Low Self-Esteem, Crazy Making,

Schizophrenia, Racism, and Religious Fundamentalism ………………………………………………………… 43

June 26, 2019 ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 43

Ask Dr. Robertson 10— Real Life Effects of Fantasy Categories ……………………………………………. 44

July 21, 2019……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 44

Ask Dr. Robertson 11 — Smells Like Teen Spirit: Hell Hath No Fury Like a Youth Scorned 47

August 13, 2019 ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 47

Ask Dr. Robertson 12 — Fault and Responsibility: If You Pass the Sentence, Then You

Should Swing the Sword ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 49

August 26, 2019 ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 49

Ask Dr. Robertson 13 — A Hawk’s Eye on Counsellors’ Professional Ethics and Morals ….. 51

September 17, 2019 ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 51

Ask Dr. Robertson (and Teela) 14 — Adlered with Eclecticism: A Confidence of Riches ….. 54

November 4, 2019 …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 54

Ask Dr. Robertson 15 — Life Raft in Entertainment: Protection Against Marketing and

Advertising ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 57

December 25, 2019 …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 57

Ask Dr. Robertson (and Teela) 16 — Exaggerated Insensitivity: Iniquity Upon the Sons, and

the Son’s Sons …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 60

April 16, 2019 …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 60

Ask Dr. Robertson 17: The Era of Personality Disorder Diagnosis ……………………………………….. 62

June 4, 2021 ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 62

Ask Dr. Robertson 18: The Web of Life, and Mind: Unweaving Its Rainbow ……………………….. 64

June 26, 2021 ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 64

An Interview with Carey Linde and Dr. Lloyd Hawkeye Robertson on Transgender

Identities, Transsexual Identities, Current and Historical Orientations, and Psychological

Science Definition of the Self (Part One) ……………………………………………………………………………………. 66

March 22, 2020 ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 66

An Interview with Carey Linde and Dr. Lloyd Hawkeye Robertson on Gender and the Law

(Part Two) ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 72

August 1, 2020………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 72

An Interview with Carey Linde and Dr. Lloyd Hawkeye Robertson on Ethics, Freedom of

Expression, and Socio-Politics (Part Three) ……………………………………………………………………………… 76

August 15, 2020 ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 76

Articles ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 80

Requiem for the Humanist Association of Canada (HAC) Discussion Page …………………………. 81

July 12, 2022……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 81

References …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 85

Year of the Virus: Understanding the contagion effects of wokism ………………………………………. 87

February 22, 2021 …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 87

The self as a mental analogue to the body ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 87

Therapeutic change to the self of two clients …………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 88

A determined species unchained and re-chained …………………………………………………………………………………………………… 91

Is wokism a mind-virus contagion? ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 93

Condition One: Change in Individual Self-Definition ……………………………………………………………………………………………… 94

Condition Two: Diminution of the Modern Self ………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 96

Condition Three: Appropriation of Individual Resources…………………………………………………………………………………….. 97

Condition Four: Emotional Valence ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 99

Discussion……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 100

Acknowledgements………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 101

References ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 102

Appendix I: Footnotes………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 104

Retro-evolution in food and health care and its impact on modern culture ………………………105

December 22, 2023 ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 105

Acknowledgements………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 110

Bibliography …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 110

Is Humanism Compatible with Indigeneity? ……………………………………………………………………………113

May 1, 2023 ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 113

Bibliography …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 119

License and Copyright ………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 121

License ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………121

Copyright ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….121

Acknowledgements

In honour of my friend Elder Albert Scott of the Kinistin Saulteaux who taught me much and gave me the painting reproduced on the front cover.

Lloyd Hawkeye Robertson

To Dr. Lloyd Hawkeye Robertson for the expertise, integrity, patience, professionalism, and collaboration, and the late Pete Jacobsen for everything.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Introduction by Dr. Lloyd Hawkeye Robertson

In 1998 then editor Scott Boyes agreed to publish a regular column in The Northerner, a weekly newspaper published out of La Ronge in northern Saskatchewan. Over the next seven years I submitted 90 columns on psychology. Then, in 2018 Scott Douglas Jacobsen approached me asking if I would agree to a series of interviews for In-Sight Publishing’s “Question Time” on counselling psychology. He did his research. Some of the questions he asked were about more recent articles published in peer-reviewed journals; but many of the questions were based on my newspaper column published twenty years previously! I quite enjoyed updating, elaborating, and revising my previous opinions on such topics as the purpose of psychotherapy, science and psychology, residential school syndrome, the aboriginal self, building rapport, mind-body dualism, male stigma, victim culture, and grieving. The eighteen interviews we completed are re-published in this book. Three of those interviews include my daughter who was a child when the original columns were published but is now a psychologist in private practice in Edmonton, Alberta. Life is grand. Scott also completed three interviews on transexuality with Vancouver lawyer Carey Linde and me in 2020; and, these interviews are also included in this work. Transsexuality is based on the idea that sex is real and that people born into one sex may wish to transition to the other. Transgender ideology, on the other hand, holds that sex is a social construct and that infants are assigned a sex at their birth. The notion that men can give birth, that people with penises can compete in women’s sports, and that men convicted of gendered crimes such as rape can be subsequently placed in women’s prisons flow from this notion that sex is not a fact but a social construct. While humanism is based on freedom of speech, those who adhere to transgender ideology and related practices such as critical race theory and cancel culture, eschew all such discussion. The second section of this book consists of four articles dealing with this phenomenon I call Woke Identitarianism because is based on personal identification with a number of approved victim groups.

The first article, Requiem for a Discussion Page is based on my experience as a moderator for an open humanist discussion group that had more than 2,000 members. This article recounts how militant Wokists, who could not tolerate respectful discussion of issues like tearing down statues and whether safe spaces for women should be protected, eventually succeeded in shutting the group down.

The second article deals with the larger ideology of critical and queer “theories” that denies the Enlightenment embrace of science, reason, and compassion upon which our civilization is based. Year of the Virus is my attempt to understand this self-defeating phenomenon using a psychological definition of what constitutes a mind virus. My thesis is that mind viruses evolved from pieces of culture and that there are several sources that contributed to the 21st Century Woke Identitarian phenomenon. While much has been written on the sources of Woke Identitarianism, the contribution of “health food” and “alternative medicine” has been neglected.

The third article in this compendium, Retro-evolution in food and health care and its impact on modern culture, deals the New Age Movement’s contribution to this 21st Century anti- intellectual movement. Like the Mormons of the 19th Century, the New Agers of the 20th romanticized people aboriginal to North America. Some have become shamans and pipe carriers in a westernized version of Aboriginal Spiritually with one, Charles Storm, inventing the modern medicine wheel consisting of physical, mental, emotional, and spiritual quadrants. In 2003 psychologist Steven Pinker noted that a new quasi-religion had evolved based on the myths of the noble savage, blank slate, ghost in the machine.

The blank slate holds that our thoughts can be shaped through “politically correct” language. The ghost in the machine myth holds that we are born with an essence that decides, for example, whether we are transgender. The noble savage myth adds the view that indigenous ways of knowing are superior to “white”: or “western” ways. Humanism which includes our ideas of the universality of human rights is based on the Enlightenment which, in turn, has been called “a white, male way of knowing.” The last article in this book deals with the question Is humanism compatible with indigeneity? My answer is what you might expect from a psychologist, “It depends…”:

I would like to thank Scott both for his hard work as an interviewer and editor, but also for his inspiration in suggesting this project. I would also like to thank my fellow New Enlightenment Project board member, George Hewson for suggesting the title “Psychology in the Snow.” I would like to think that we are developing a psychology that is indigenous to Canada, different from that ofthe American Psychological Association.

Kind regards,

Lloyd Hawkeye Robertson

January, 2024

Introduction by Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Let me start with this: I did not expect this collaboration or the project. Even though, they’re my fault. I tend to fart around a lot with a wide smattering of projects, topics, themes, personas. I find them fun. I remain a playful and experimental person, even as I get older. Maybe, especially as I get older, it seems like deep temperament. Something to plumb. I enjoy reading authors who exist as kin to Kurt Vonnegut. A survivor of war: so trauma survivor – a funny writer. A physical sensation of pleasure to read the architecture of the written word by authors like him. Perhaps, that roots the element of play with me. As the late and prominent American humanist Isaac Asimov purportedly said, “The most exciting phrase to hear in science, the one that heralds new discoveries, is not

‘Eureka!’ but ‘That’s funny…’”

Atheists, agnostics, brights, freethinkers, humanists, satanists, und so weiter, I, often, get a sense of whimsy about a life so short in community with them, because the so short life must take a whimsy sense given its brevity. My matrix or meta-premises of orientations about the world, myself, and the relation between the two, sits somewhere between the superset of these. A common thread with the superset comes from the presence of humour and use of empirical means to grasp elements of the world. The religious discourse, on the other hand, tends towards the asinine, the boring, the cruel, the dogmatic, the dreary, the dull, the dumb, the erred, and – no doubt – the faithful. Words in some sense seem ineffective in the display of overwhelming wonder present to generations of humanity with nothing but religious iconography, tales, and text to guide them. A sincere and naive wonder bound by ignorance without a method to know deeper functional and pragmatic truths about the universe. A “Eureka” followed by silence. Science gave the “that’s funny” response to the “Eureka” reverberating through the human animal in response to Nature.

Psychology as a purported claimant to scientific status appears late in the empirical game in the 1870s with Wilhelm Wundt. An empiricism beginning in the contemporary centuries, maybe, in the 1500s. Modern science garners respect for functional truths about the world, pragmatic truths about the world. These functional truths represent operationalism. These pragmatic truths represent practical application. The latter following from the former. To represent operations of Nature means the possibility for practical application on Nature, thus, we come to the basic sciences: biology, chemistry, physics, and mathematics, with the development of technologies following from these fields of inquiry. The greater the magnitude of complex systems, then the more difficult the discovery of deeper truths about those systems. Human information processing remains a great problem to solve, potentially a mystery. Regardless, as an evolved production of Nature and the unitary nature of Nature, the functional truths about Nature apply to us. In theory, psychology can act as a scientific conduit to learn deeper truths about human information processing with the possibility for technological developments to modify it. Is that true, funny, or both?

Counselling psychology comes from psychology. Ideally, psychological investigation remains empirical: the “that’s funny.” Counselling psychology, naturally, follows this vein. The counselling psychology interviews with Dr. Robertson represent an educational series devoted to casual discussion of complex counselling psychology ideas and topics in relation to counselling psychology.

As both humanists, the bias sits on this fulcrum: the “und so weiter” – my people. As a trauma survivor who did his work, life can be trauma. Counselling psychology becomes a necessity there. In the aforementioned sense, a technology, a tool, to modify human information processing for healthier living. The articles come as bonus materials to interested readers.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen

December 28, 2023

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Introduction to “On Israel-Palestine: 2019-2021”

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2025/08/09

Table of Contents

In-Sight Publishing ………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 1

On Israel-Palestine: 2019-2021 ……………………………………………………………………………………….. 2

Table of Contents …………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 4

Acknowledgements …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 7

Foreword by Scott Douglas Jacobsen ………………………………………………………………………………………. 8

Human Rights Watch……………………………………………………………………………………………………. 10

Interview with Omar Shakir – Israel and Palestine Director, Human Rights Watch (Middle East and North Africa Division) ……………………………………………………………………………………………………. 11

May 6, 2019 ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 11

HRW Israel and Palestine (MENA) Director on Systematic Methodology and Universal Vision. 17

May 23, 2019 ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 17

Human Rights Watch (Israel and Palestine) on Common Rights and Law Violations ……………… 20

May 25, 2019 ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 20

Ask HRW (Israel and Palestine) 1 – Recent Events ………………………………………………………………… 22

May 23, 2019 ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 22

Ask HRW (Israel and Palestine) 2 – Demolitions ……………………………………………………………………. 23

October 29, 2019 ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 23

Ask HRW (Israel and Palestine) 3 – November-December: Deportation from Tel Aviv, Israel for Human Rights Watch Israel and Palestine Director ……………………………………………………………….. 26

December 25, 2019……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 26

References ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 29

Ask HRW (Israel and Palestine) 4 – Uninhabitable: The Viability of Gaza Strip’s 2020 Unlivability …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 30

March 20, 2020…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 30

Previous Sessions (easier access than References, in chronological order)………………………………………….. 34

Addenda …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 34

References ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 34

Ask HRW (Israel and Palestine) 5 – The Trump Peace Plan: Is This the “The Deal of the Century,” or Not? …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 37

March 26, 2020…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 37

References ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 40

Footnotes ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 43

Ask HRW (Israel and Palestine) 6 – Tripartite Partition: The Israeli Elections, the International Criminal Court (ICC), and SARS-CoV-2/COVID-19 ……………………………………………………………… 60

April 9, 2020…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 60

Previous Sessions (Chronological Order)………………………………………………………………………………………….. 63

Addenda …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 64

Other Resources Internal to Canadian Atheist …………………………………………………………………………………. 64

References ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 64

Ask HRW (Israel and Palestine) 7 – New Heights to the Plight and the Fight: Covid-19, Hegemony, Restrictions, and Rights ………………………………………………………………………………………. 70

August 10, 2020 ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 70

Previous Sessions (Chronological Order)………………………………………………………………………………………….. 74

Addenda …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 74

Other Resources Internal to Canadian Atheist …………………………………………………………………………………. 75

References ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 75

Ask HRW (Israel and Palestine) 8 (w/ Special Rapporteur on the Situation of Human Rights in the Palestinian Territories Occupied since 1967) – Annexation, International Law, Occupation, Rights, and Settlements …………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 80

August 18, 2020 ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 80

Previous Sessions (Chronological Order)………………………………………………………………………………………….. 88

Addenda …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 88

Other Resources Internal to Canadian Atheist …………………………………………………………………………………. 88

References ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 89

Footnotes ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 95

Ask HRW (Israel and Palestine) 9 – When Rain is Law and Justice is Dry Land …………………… 122

May 3, 2021 ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 122

Previous Sessions (Chronological Order)………………………………………………………………………………………… 129

Addenda ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 130

Other Resources Internal to Canadian Atheist ……………………………………………………………………………….. 130

References …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 130

Footnotes ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 137

Ask HRW (Israel and Palestine) 10: The Human Rights Skyfall …………………………………………… 138

August 17, 2021 ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 138

Previous Sessions (Chronological Order)………………………………………………………………………………………… 144

Addenda ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 145

Other Resources Internal to Canadian Atheist ……………………………………………………………………………….. 145

References …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 146

Footnotes ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 151

Addendum………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 153

Ask HRW (Israel and Palestine) Addendum: Some History and Contextualization of Rights … 154

March 20, 2020……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 154

References …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 157

Other Resources …………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 162

Interview with Dr. Norman Finkelstein on Gaza Now …………………………………………………………… 163

April 26, 2019…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 163

Extensive Interview with Gideon Levy …………………………………………………………………………………. 171

April 3, 2020…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 171

Interview with Musa Abu Hashash – Field Researcher (Hebron District), B’Tselem ……………… 179

March 17, 2020……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 179

Some Background Resources on Musa …………………………………………………………………………………………… 180

Interview with Gideon Levy – Columnist, Haaretz ……………………………………………………………….. 182

May 3, 2019 ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 182

Interview with Dr. Usama Antar – Independent Political Analyst (Gaza Strip, Palestine) ……… 189

May 22, 2019 ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 189

Interview with Wesam Ahmad – Representative, Al-Haq (Independent Palestinian Human Rights Organization) …………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 192

April 13, 2020…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 192

Extensive Interview with Professor Richard Falk – Fmr. (5th) United Nations Special Rapporteur on the Situation of Human Rights in the Palestinian Territories Occupied since 1967 …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 196

April 24, 2020…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 196

Extensive Interview with Professor John Dugard – Fmr. (4th) United Nations Special Rapporteur on the Situation of Human Rights in the Palestinian Territories Occupied since 1967 ……………. 206

May 6, 2020 ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 206

Extensive Interview with S. Michael Lynk – (7th) United Nations Special Rapporteur on the Situation of Human Rights in the Palestinian Territories Occupied since 1967………………………. 216

August 4, 2020 ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 216

Conversation with John Dugard, Richard Falk, and S. Michael Lynk on the Role of the Special Rapporteur, and the International Criminal Court & Jurisdiction ……………………………………….. 232

August 6, 2020 ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 232

Dr. Norman Finkelstein on the International Criminal Court ……………………………………………….. 242

August 13, 2020 ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 242

License and Copyright ………………………………………………………………………………………………… 246

License ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 246

Copyright ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 246

AcknowledgementsTo Omar Shakir, Dr. Norman Finkelstein, John Dugard, Richard Falk, S. Michael Lynk, Wesam Ahmad, Dr. Usama Antar, Gideon Levy, and Musa Abu Hashash, for the opportunities and time.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Foreword by Scott Douglas JacobsenHuman beings invented human rights as human beings invented the gods. To quote Ezra Pound:

The long flank, the firm breastand to know beauty and death and despairand to think that what has been shall be,flowing, ever unstill,Then a partridge-shaped cloud over dust storm.The hells move in cycles,No man can see his own end.

The Gods have not returned. “They have never left us.”They have not returned.

Nevertheless, as we all know, the concept of a god, not simply the Abrahamic Yahweh – G-d, comes with blessings and cursings, fortunes and failings, and some claims about Him, not all of which may be true – maybe none. The god concept contains premises knit together into a weave—a weave laced as a drape, even a curtain, gently over the mindscape of believers.

Believers believe. Believers act. Believers converse. Believers convert. Believers coalesce. Believers change and alter societies. In this way, the god concept transmutes the abstract, the in-mind, into the concrete, the in-reality. No matter the god in mind, that process affects most rising and falling societies in history. Thus, maybe, we can all agree: the god concept, ignoring veracity, impacts the world in history and to the present, massively.

That which amounts to the in-mind, the invented, the imaginary, the unreal, can affect the in-reality, in that sense. The god concept tends to come with a few universalist ethical principles, for example, the Golden Rule, loving one’s neighbour as oneself, compassion and justice, non-harm and welfare, the one family world, brotherhood, world reparation, justice and dignity, service to humanity, living in harmony with The Way, benevolence and reciprocity, and equality.

Let us call these traditionalist transcendental religious ethics in the universalist canon; the rest sit in the particularist camp. Parochialism is a specific set of guidelines, rules, and laws for a particular set of believers.

Even if taking the god concept, whether true or not, a mind becomes necessary to make god exist and for the concept to actualize in the world through said beings’ minds and lives. Similarly, with the universalist and particularist camps of transcendentalist religious ethics, those need minds to act within them as social codes. In that sense, they become intersubjective agreements in sociality more than objective moralities – let alone transcendental realities.

In this manner, traditionalist transcendental religious ethics become universalist, at times, and parochial, in others. While in truth, that is to say, they become intersubjective agreements bound to specific geographic locales and historical periods, they get perceived as transcendental and objective, mistakenly.

Human rights come forth similarly, in-mind. In the mind, these formulate the codes of conduct and ethics in most of the substantive ethical institutions in the world today. They exist around the globe. They created the framework for establishing an international system of laws, obligations, and rules. These become, not only human rights but, international human rights. These institutions become stronger with each passing year, for the most part, with some, minor setbacks.

These international human rights come with massive intersubjective agreements despite consistent violations since the inception of their invention. The striving for international human rights converges with the work of universalism.

The universalism inherent in international human rights represents a convergence of the universalism from religious ethics towards a common core of moral truths bound to a principle of simplicity in foundations for an optimization of ethical considerations with equal application for all in theory with the extinguishment of religion in them while an allowance for belief in them, through them. In a manner similar to the god concept, minds become necessary for actualization in beings’ minds and lives. No minds, no rights, so minds make rights. An intersubjective agreement abstracted for approximated objective observation of formalized processes, human actions, international institutions, and rights documents. The difference: god concepts get blind acceptance, illegitimate authority, and dogmatic worship; rights get conscious deliberation, open debate, and democratic enactment. The former as absolute and simplistic. The latter as statistical and complex.

Traditional religious transcendental ethics seen in the religious ethics come with narrow application. International human rights come with broad applicability. Do not simply believe me; we merely need to count the truism: Even amongst the religious in societies, most adhere to human rights arguments when making cases for fairness, justice, and truth. In addition, few play by religious rules in an international sense. Most play by international human rights through global institutions, for example, the United Nations. Every Member State participates there, whether the General Assembly, Security Council, Economic and Social Council, or the International Court of Justice. Not many take part in the religious ethics in theocracies or the dogmatic secular moralities of Maoism, Communism, and the like. International human rights become secular in this decoupling process. These become international secular human rights, whether spiritual religions or political religions: Both insist on and generate dogma.

Hence, the reason for the stipulations in prior writings of traditional religious transcendental ethics and international secular human rights as a distinction for Canadians and others, one, to make, and two, to decide upon as a path forward for their societies and regions. Even though, these exist, gods and rights, in mind. Their impacts on individual lives and systems of governance remain inevitable while not immutable. Any move towards universalism in ethics will necessitate a move to international secular human rights due to the decoupling from the parochial nature of spiritual and political dogmas. In this way, abstracted ethical principles garner reality through these intersubjective agreement abstractions of international secular human rights enacted through minds into lives with an arc towards universalism as a prism for fractionation to pervasive values and decoupled from spiritual and political religions: benevolence, compassion, dignity, equality, harmony, justice, non-harm, one family world, reciprocity, service, welfare, and world reparation. Which is to say, we never “left” ourselves.

January 19, 2024

Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Introduction to “On the Russo-Ukrainian War: August, 2023 to June 2024 “

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2025/08/09

Table of Contents

In-Sight Publishing …………………………………………………………………………………………………… 2

On the Russo-Ukrainian War: August, 2023 to June 2024 …………………………………………… 3

Table of Contents …………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 5

Acknowledgements …………………………………………………………………………………………………. 5

Introduction by Scott Douglas Jacobsen …………………………………………………………………….. 6

Humanist …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 7

  • Humanists International, Russian Federation, Ukraine, and the United Nations (2024/01/08) …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 8

Personal …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 18

  • The Long Happenstance of Iceland and Copenhagen (2023/12/09) ……………………………… 18
  • Violence’s Imaginarium: Informal Follow-Up to ‘War Is Hell’ (2024/07/11) ……………………. 22

Romanian ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 25

  • Remus Cernea on Independent War Correspondence in Ukraine (2023/08/25) ……………… 26
  • Zaporizhzhia Field Interview With Remus Cernea (2024/02/21) …………………………………… 31
  • War and Destruction With Remus Cernea (2024/02/22) …………………………………………….. 38
  • Remus Cornea on Ukraine in Early 2024 (2024/04/29) ……………………………………………….. 42
  • Remus Cernea on Perpetual War and Perpetual Peace (2024/06/28) ……………………………. 49

Ukrainian ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 59

  • Ms. Oleksandra Romantsova on Ukraine and Putin (2023/09/01) ………………………………….. 59
  • Oleksandra Romantsova on Prigozhin and Amnesty International (2023/12/03) …………….. 67
  • Dr. Roman Nekoliak on International Human Rights and Ukraine (2023/12/23) …………….. 73
  • Sorina Kiev: Being a Restauranteur During Russo-Ukrainian War (2024/01/27) …………….. 83
  • World Wars, Human Rights & Humanitarian Law w/ Roman Nekoliak (2024/03/07) ………. 91
  • Oleksandra Romantsova: Financing Regional Defense in War (2024/03/11) ………………… 102
  • Russo-Ukrainian War Updates, February to April: O. Romantsova (2024/05/13) ………….. 109
  • Dr. Kateryna Busol on Dehumanization in Russo-Ukrainian War (2024/06/20) …………….. 122
  • Oleksandra Romantsova on April to May in Ukraine (2024/06/24) ………………………………. 132

License and Copyright …………………………………………………………………………………………… 139

Acknowledgements

To Oleksandra Romantsova and Remus Cernea, in particular, for their instigation and complete support in working on this endeavour inclusive of travel to Ukraine, and to Dr. Kateryna Busol, Sorina Kiev, and Dr. Roman Nekoliak for their contributions to this volume; Dr. Kristen Monroe at the University of California, Irvine Ethics Center for the years of support as a Tobis Fellow and the Ethics Center family; and Dr. Daniel Bernstein, Weston MacAleer, Joan Payne, Simon Parcher, Dr. Lloyd Robertson, and Dr. Richard Thain.

Just so many people have been so crucial in this endeavour—it’s overwhelming, a bit, writing this—even Brent Balisky, Laura Balisky, and LJ Tidball for bringing in a stray Canadian under their Tbird aegis; and to human rights defenders devoting their resources and putting their lives at risk for a fairer and more just situation in Ukraine (and the Russian Federation).

Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Introduction by Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Life is a continual process of initiation, of humbling. I shoveled a lot of horse shit and laid a lot of mulch in gardens while working at a horse ranch to self-fund this independent journalistic journey. I loved the time there.

In Langley, agriculture can have a hard go of it, for employers and employees alike. Good labour is hard to find. It’s a rewarding lifestyle because it’s a hard day’s work well-earned—merely ask your body at the end of the day. In fact, you don’t need to ask; it will simply tell you.

When I went to Copenhagen, I was thinking of going to a regular conference in Europe. Life had other plans. I met Oleksandra and Remus there. I was struck by their sincerity and dedication. Remus proposed work in Ukraine together. It sounded crazy enough to do it.

Thus began plans to travel to Ukraine. Upon arrival, you meet all types of people in every kind of situation, while united by a common sense of identity and suffering. Street vendors selling cigarettes, breaded meats, coffee, and souvenirs.

A wide range of styles of cars, of quality of infrastructure, and the like. Everything seemed normal for about a day, maybe a day and a half, then the scramble of war came to a head: air raid alarms, explosions in the distance, casualty reports, international and domestic war reportage, people’s trauma stories, soldiers in buses, in train stations, in hotels, walking the streets, at checkpoints.

Then the horror of war crept more into the central vision: memorial to those bombed outside of office buildings, religious sites like cathedrals, apartment complexes, administrative buildings, і так далі. The horror of war is the horror of the normal, fragmented and twisted to the barely recognizable.

A museum, as with the first instance of a bone healing, seems like another step and stage in the diagnosable instance of real civilization from the human species. Kindness matters. When a museum is destroyed, it leaves an emotional mark—a pause.

When people power through horror and turn their restaurant into a shelter and food service for those victims of war in need, it leaves a pause. I am struck and humbled by the kindness of an invitation to take part in this narrative and recordkeeping aim in Ukraine with Remus, Oleksandra, and others. That’s why I’ve decided to commit so much time and resources to cataloguing these voices.

Fundamentally, it is a decision grounded in a sentiment experienced and felt. So, thank you everyone for helping this come to fruition.

I am off to Ukraine for a second trip today.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen

August 19, 2024

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Introduction to “The Martian Inside of Me”

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2025/08/09

Table of Contents

In-Sight Publishing ……………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 2

The Martian Inside Me …………………………………………………………………………………………………… 3

Table of Contents ………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 5Acknowledgements ……………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 7

Foreword by Tor Arne Jørgensen …………………………………………………………………………………….. 8

Group Discussion on the Near, Middle, Far, and Indefinite Future, First Responses Session: Christian Sorenson, Claus Volko, Erik Hæreid, James Gordon, Matthew Scillitani, Rick Farrar, Rick Rosner, Tiberiu Sammak, and Tor Jørgensen (Part One) ……………………………………………. 12

An Interview with Tor Arne Jørgensen on Background, Identity, Mentors, Education, and Interests (Part One) ……………………………………………………………………………………………………. 26

Group Discussion on the Near, Middle, Far, and Indefinite Future, First Responses Session: Christian Sorenson, James Gordon, Matthew Scillitani, Rick Farrar, Rick Rosner, and Tor Jørgensen (Part Two) …………………………………………………………………………………………………… 29

Group Discussion on the Near, Middle, Far, and Indefinite Future, Second Comments (Near and Middle Focused Comments) Session: Christian Sorenson, Claus Volko, James Gordon, Rick Farrar, and Tor Jørgensen (Part Three) ……………………………………………………………………. 42

An Interview with Tor Arne Jørgensen on History, Internationalism, and Ethical Systems (Part Two) ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 56

An Interview with Tor Arne Jørgensen on Historical Knowledge and Application from the Principles of History (Part Three) …………………………………………………………………………………. 61

An Interview with Tor Arne Jørgensen on Societies and Global Trends (Part Four) ……………. 66

Norwegians of the High-Range Discussion with Erik Haereid, Eivind Olsen, and Tor Arne Jørgensen: Statistician & Actuarial Scientist; Chair, Mensa Norway; 2019 Genius of the Year – Europe, World Genius Directory (1) …………………………………………………………………………….. 70

Norwegians of the High-Range Discussion with Erik Haereid, Eivind Olsen, and Tor Arne Jørgensen: Statistician & Actuarial Scientist; Chair, Mensa Norway; 2019 Genius of the Year – Europe, World Genius Directory (2) …………………………………………………………………………….. 79

Norwegians of the High-Range Discussion with Erik Haereid, Eivind Olsen, and Tor Arne Jørgensen: Statistician & Actuarial Scientist; Chair, Mensa Norway; 2019 Genius of the Year – Europe, World Genius Directory (3) …………………………………………………………………………….. 87

Norwegians of the High-Range Discussion with Erik Haereid, Eivind Olsen, and Tor Arne Jørgensen: Statistician & Actuarial Scientist; Chair, Mensa Norway; 2019 Genius of the Year – Europe, World Genius Directory (4) …………………………………………………………………………….. 97

Conversation with Tor Arne Jørgensen on Nuclear Armaments: 2019 Genius of the Year – Europe, World Genius Directory (5) ……………………………………………………………………………. 105

Conversation with Tor Arne Jørgensen on God, Leonardo Da Vinci, and Religion: 2019 Genius of the Year – Europe, World Genius Directory (6) ………………………………………………… 113

Conversation with Tor Arne Jørgensen on Adolescence and Quirks of Historical Figures: 2019 Genius of the Year – Europe, World Genius Directory (7) ………………………………………………. 125

Conversation with Tor Arne Jørgensen on Western Europe, Russian Aggression, Putin, Zelensky, China, and India: 2019 Genius of the Year – Europe, World Genius Directory (8) …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 130

Schooling the Young 1: Tor Arne Jørgensen on the Educational Basics ……………………………. 137

Hindemburg Melão Jr. and Tor Arne Jørgensen on A.I., I.Q., and the Future: Founder, Sigma Society; 2019 Genius of the Year – Europe, World Genius Directory (1) …………………………. 141

Schooling the Young 2: Tor Arne Jørgensen on Non-Intellectual Qualities ……………………….. 160

Intercontinental High-I.Q. Forum 1: Tor Arne Jørgensen, Hindemburg Melão Jr., Tim Roberts, Rick Rosner, David Udbjørg, Garth Zietsman, and Tianxi Yu (余天曦) on the State of the High-I.Q. ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 162

Conversation with Tor Arne Jørgensen on High-Range Tests, Writing, Social Media Dieting, and Teaching: 2019 Genius of the Year – Europe, World Genius Directory (9) ……………………. 177

Conversation with Tor Arne Jørgensen on Curriculum Development in Norway: 2019 Genius of the Year – Europe, World Genius Directory (10) ……………………………………………………… 186

Conversation with Tor Arne Jørgensen on AGI: 2019 Genius of the Year – Europe, World Genius Directory (11) …………………………………………………………………………………………………. 191

Conversation with Tor Arne Jørgensen on Religion, History, Budding Authorship: 2019 Genius of the Year – Europe, World Genius Directory (12) ……………………………………………… 198

Schooling the Young 3: Tor Arne Jørgensen on Curriculum Development ……………………….. 206

Acknowledgements

The reason for this title is because, my search for answers to who I have, has thereby led me forward towards the unknown, where the feeling of my surrounding environment feels foreign and thus presented as alien. A state of desolation, whereas sensations of a landscape are created by endless entanglements and strange events which in turn provide the opportunity for a widening spectrum. To be an explorer in one’s own mind, where one is met with horror, wonder, emotions, hidden talents and, not least, the fear of confrontation of who one really are, is, therefore, to be labelled as the Martian inside me.

Tor Arne Jørgensen

To Tor for the expansive collaboration and wide range of topics covered within his extensive remit, particularly schooling the young, which is ever-present and important.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Foreword by Tor Arne Jørgensen

My first encounter with the high intelligence community was back in 2015. The experience I had then was one of absolute joy, an ecstasy of finally coming home to one’s own. A place where one could be understood and accepted as equals. Imagine wandering through life in search of oneself. Many of us, and not just those with high intelligence, but all of us, search for something more, something that is mysteriously hidden from us. And then to find what you have been searching for so endlessly long has such an inexplicable aura about it, something that cannot be described with just a few simple words. They become, as the saying goes, inadequate…

The fact that words are not sufficient is manifold reinforced for those who feel no boundaries or see within what is considered extreme. Our brain is, in my opinion, our next step in evolution. What does one think of then? Well, regarding our physical self, yes, much remains, but not in any way near what remains to be understood of all our intellects. The mysteries of the brain, our hitherto unexplored field. It may seem like a lot of nonsense to view it this way, but if one reads between the lines, everything appears so much clearer—but only for the chosen few.

Evolution is many things and can be so much more than what we are left with when we hear the word. History put under the microscope is very much like putting time on hold. Joy, hate, laughter, and sorrow, each and every one of them clocks out only to clock in again and again. Logic was long all that mattered to me; nothing could surpass its all-encompassing wonderful being.

The years following 2015 saw the hunt begin to devour whatever came my way. Becoming the best was all that mattered; everything else could wait. Can an IQ test be addictive, sitting hour after hour solving the unsolvable? At the time of writing, one looks back on the madness. No money to earn, no one who cares. Not in any way close to what athletes are left with, perhaps not so strange… Remember to read between the lines, dear reader.

At the end of the road, one can say that it was all worth it. The confirmation I sought was answered, for better or worse. The happiness I thought was secured proved to be so, but the time it lasted did not meet expectations. The hours that disappeared, I never found again, lost like everything else. Here I could have ended my journey, but what comes next is the certificate I acquired along the way. Divided into pieces, it tells what comes next, who I was, who I met, and who I am left with on my own little wondrous, lost, wonderful island. Not big enough for little me, but big enough for a whole world.

Before I finish, take with you three small texts from my first book 74 that describe my three stages through life, and finally a line that sums it all up.

Wondering about the unknown elements within yourself and in your surroundingsOne of the most common feelings at a young age is the sense of one’s mind spinning out of control, where you sort of lose all touch with the outside world and your place within it. In this first part of the book, I will try to focus on the problem that many young people find themselves in—a time plagued with desperate attempts to find answers to some of the biggest questions in a young person’s life, questions like “Who am I to myself?” and “Who am I to you?”

Just remember that the people you surround yourself with will, whether you like it or not, shape everything around you for better or for worse, all while you are right there at the center of it all, like a sun that the planets just whirl around. As your life is about to take off, everything feels like a complete mess both outside and within. Questions will surface, questions like: How on earth am I going to survive? Am I going to lose myself completely right from the get-go? Am I going to make it despite all the setbacks I will surely face as I plough through life?

As I have read through various research articles about the human brain not being fully developed until it reaches 25 years of maturity, this research suggests that before this age, the autopilot is set to max, where everything not best tested is just that, and to its fullest at any cost that may or may not come next. As an adult watching on, this is a reality at its worst, as we can easily envision the consequences of their actions as we are forced to relive them all over again. While these unruly youths, from their point of view, think that we adults do not understand anything at all and just keep their pedal to the metal, leaving their yet-to-be-discovered responsibilities in the dust.

“If only the world didn’t have to hurt so much.”

It is like two worlds speaking two very different languages. Two worlds that only want to inflict pain on each other—but of course that is not true. The two worlds are just set adrift in different directions in the hope of one day finding themselves stranded on the same beach together, filled with mutual understanding, newfound love, and respect for each other.

As many young people tend to say:

“Why should we learn things that we will never have use for? What’s the point of living the life you never got to live? Our lives are not your lives, we would never ask you to live our lives, so don’t ask us to live yours. We are not your second chance to relive everything that was worth caring for nor to relive every opportunity missed.We just want to live our lives the way we want to live them, on our terms only. If only you adults could somehow understand, when we say that we need to find out who we are for ourselves, society just needs to come to terms with the fact that this is how it is, just accept it, no ifs, ands, or buts.”

The chaos that occupies their young minds is there for a reason; it is their undefinable spark. So, just let them find their own way, no matter how painful it may feel. Only then can they be able to identify who they really are and where they must venture next, guided by the spark within them that will lead them towards their understanding of enlightenment. Remember the saying “The road is made as we go.” So let them envision their own nirvana, then and only then can we at some point later in life rejoin on the other side where we will once again speak the same language as we once did.

Exploring adventure, intimate feelings, and your darker side

Just as historical moments from time to time tend to throw the world off balance, life too, in much the same manner, also has this tendency to tip us over. Meaning that every decision accumulated from early age onwards will, at different stages, pave itself a new direction or decide to stay on the same path as before. What I would like to convey in this second part is the inevitable importance of dealing with what meets us when we as individuals are at a loss of where to go next. The choices that can topple us when we least expect it – just when everything seemed to be planned out, disaster strikes. This is where the battle between good and evil comes to be a very definite reality: who will I end up as, who am I at the very core, shall I embrace love or drown myself in self-hatred?

Question to you all:

Have you ever thought about taking a real good look into the mirror and being completely open to what or who may stare right back at you? To risk facing the scariest thing of all, as you could easily be your own worst nightmare, and if so, how to contain it? Do you cover it up so no one will be the wiser? What would you do if this were the case…?

Whatever your answer may be, the truth of the matter is that we have been forced through millennia of generations to reveal our true colors come what may. Many people, myself included, know all too well the lure of the unknown darkness, where we just want to consume everything that comes in our path just like a giant black hole that engulfs everything within its reach, oblivious to the notion of right or wrong.

At this stage, the choices we make must be treated with the gravest importance because the reality we now face in adulthood shapes the end version of us. It is at this point in life that we must confront our inner demons much more so than before. As mentioned earlier, “are we able to contain our inner demons or not? Are they to be embraced fully or kept tucked safely away?” These are just a few of many major decisions each of us must assess through our lives in various degrees. The choice between being naughty or nice.

Curiosity, life’s end, family, love, and friendship

As I’m about to hand in my keys, I find myself looking back, and what I discover is that the life that once felt like an eternity passes far too quickly. A time that once was in abundance is now reduced to just a few sacred moments soon to be scattered to the four winds. As an introduction to this final chapter of my book, I will begin by asking questions about the meaning of life and reminisce over lost love eroded away by time. I will also talk about the importance of family values and long-lasting friendship, all the important pieces that make our lives worth living.

As we get to a certain age, more and more questions keep popping up, questions like: How will the near to far future look, and what will happen to us next when we are faced with the ultimate climax, i.e., the inevitable ending that awaits us all, the very thing that everyone does their best to block out? Why are we forced to see ourselves weathering in the same way that time sees itself ebbing away until only a single grain remains desperately clinging to whatever hope was left?

As a reminder of how we came to be, i.e., the origins of what we all take for granted—animals, people, flowers, trees, land, sea, indeed all between the heavens and the earth—why is it that all life except our own is blissfully unaware of the fate that awaits at the end, our own mortality, the only thing left that will not succumb to our will? On that occasion, I feel that the following question is most appropriate:

By what right were we created, fully aware of what we must face when life decides to give up? What was the grand plan of making us living witnesses to our own demise? Is this not the ultimate sign of cruelty, afflicting this kind of pain upon us humans? Could we not just wander through life oblivious to everything around us like everything else?

Were we not deemed worthy enough for you to grant us the gift of blindness to life’s ultimate sacrifice? If you only did as any great author will do when he or she gives life to a story, they hold back from revealing the book’s true intentions until just a few leaves remain. Then at least many of us would be spared the horrors of dealing with the notion of death every single day—a daily reminder of how fragile life can be, whereby with a snap of a finger all can be lost. Is life really meant to be as fragile as it’s portrayed to be?

As the saying goes, prayers heal all wounds, both the wounds we see on the outside and the wounds we never get to see, the ones that linger on the inside. I wonder, is there also a prayer for cheating at the ultimate cost?

As I look upon memories that flip through their greatest hits, I keep reminding myself that the best memories are the ones that are shared with everyone around. “To love thy neighbor as thyself” is for me to love everything and everyone that loves me back. Remember that a full life is a life shared together with the love of your life right by your side, as you watch your perfect offspring as they take to their wings in your forever prayers.

As my glass now reads empty, I would like to add:To my eternal friends, you who took me under your wings, I will never forget you. As I now come to my end, let me just say, give your all to the ones you hold dear, and life will take care of the rest. Maybe we are the lucky ones—lucky in the sense to be able to reflect on all the joys and all the sorrows that have made us who we are. If we are in some way able to hold onto this notion, then perhaps death is not so hard to swallow after all, whether life has led us astray or not.

I want to include a saying that came to me in the shelter of the night. I could not let it go, and in many ways, it summarizes how I experience the world around me. I hope it makes sense. It goes as follows:

Who then interprets those who refuse to be read by those who refuse to understand?

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Introduction and Forewords to “Out of my Mind Musings: Reality & Surreality”

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2025/08/09

Table of Contents

In-Sight Publishing ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 2

Out of my Mind Musings: Reality & Surreality …………………………………………………………………………. 3

Table of Contents …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 5

Acknowledgements …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 8

First Introduction by Richard May ……………………………………………………………………………………………. 9

Second Introduction by the So-Called Author ………………………………………………………………………….. 10

Foreword by Benoit Desjardins ………………………………………………………………………………………………. 11

Foreword by Daniel Shea ………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 13

Foreword by Rick Rosner ……………………………………………………………………………………………………… 14

Foreword by Scott Douglas Jacobsen ……………………………………………………………………………………… 16

Four Eastern Philosophies ……………………………………………………………………………………………………… 17

The On-line Buddha And The Stars – A Children’s History ………………………………………………………. 19

Postcard from Richard May ……………………………………………………………………………………………………. 21

The Nature of Life, Consciousness, and Personhood Vis-a-vis Artificial Intelligence: Reflections on the Basis of the “On-line Buddha” ……………………………………………………………………… 22

Our Hope for the Future: ……………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 23

Evolutionary Emergence of Cyber-Informational Organisms …………………………………………………….. 24

Valentine’s Moment ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 25

Lucid Dream of Out of Paradigm Experience …………………………………………………………………………… 26

Will Man Create God? …………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 27

The Tav ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 28

Autobiography of Richard May ………………………………………………………………………………………………. 29

The Colonies …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 30

Vista ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 31

In Praise of Stupidity …………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 32

Universe Had No Unique Beginning ………………………………………………………………………………………. 33

Climate Change …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 34

The Holy Land ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 35

Memoir of a Non-Irish Non-Jew: A Letter to a Rabbi ………………………………………………………………. 36

Memoir of an Non-Irish Non-Jew Part 2 ………………………………………………………………………………….. 42

Moment ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 49

Ask May-Tzu …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 50

The Tao Can Neither Be Retained nor Abandoned …………………………………………………………………… 52

Where will the universe be when the paradigm shifts? ……………………………………………………………… 53

MayTzu’s Wager ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 54

No Mirrors ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 55

Behold ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 56

Dreams of Dreams Out of Paradigm ……………………………………………………………………………………….. 57

Hall of Mirrors ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 58

Know Thy …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 59

Event Horizon ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 60

The Offensiveness of the Universe ………………………………………………………………………………………….. 61

More and Less Than Stardust …………………………………………………………………………………………………. 62

Hi ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 63

Super intelligent? …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 65

Taoless Tao ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 66

What Does AI Want? …………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 67

Dr. Capgras Before the Mirrors ………………………………………………………………………………………………. 69

Introducing Qigong to a Friend ………………………………………………………………………………………………. 70

The Total Breakdown of Society …………………………………………………………………………………………….. 74

Dark Energy …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 75

Silicon Screams …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 76

Braille Shadows …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 77

Is Physics Becoming Art at the Limits of Scale? ……………………………………………………………………… 78

“Physical Law” as Sampling Error ………………………………………………………………………………………….. 79

To Grandmother’s House We Go ……………………………………………………………………………………………. 80

Fragments …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 82

Remembering Robert Dick …………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 83

A Fine Mess ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 84Umami Shadows ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 85

Tathata …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 86The Nature of Consciousness, “a Rose is a Rose is a Rose” ……………………………………………………….. 87

Plurality IQ Society ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 89Intersubjective Testability ………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 90

Shadow & Light …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 91

A Flock of Geese ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 92

The Benediction …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 93

Nonexistent Aerial Phenomena ……………………………………………………………………………………………… 94

The Possibility of AI Consciousness ………………………………………………………………………………………. 100

Life ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 102Where was Fermi? ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 103Unidentified Anomalous Geese (UAG) … and other conspiracy theories …………………………………… 104

License and Copyright …………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 105

Author Biographical Sketch …………………………………………………………………………………………………. 107

Acknowledgements

To Richard May for the long-term collaboration and support.Scott Douglas Jacobsen

First Introduction by Richard May

My pre-internet postal friend and colleague, Grady Towers, author of the essay “The Outsider,” once mailed me a copy of the PAS Test (Preconscious Activity Scale, based upon Kubie’s theory of neuroticism), which I had never heard of. I took it as requested by Grady. I had no idea what the test attempted to measure. I remember little of the nature of the test, taken so long ago. It was multiple choice and true or false, I think, and didn’t take much time, even for an OCDish type. So I mailed the answers off to Grady.

Grady replied days later by snail-mail with, “You appear to have the stigmata!”

I scored slightly more than 3 standard deviations above the mean for college students, he informed me. Maybe 3.1 or 3.2 sigma. He told me that the test supposedly measured “artistic creativity.” Artistic creativity correlated very poorly, if at all, with cognitive ability. Therefore in some sense I was supposedly a very rare bird statistically, even within the higher-IQ community.

Maybe this relates to Grady’s perception that he and I had a higher degree of original insight that many high-IQ types lacked, my infinite ignorance notwithstanding. Grady lamented that he could not devise a test to quantify “insight.”

Of course, the “creativity” of mathematicians and theoretical scientists may be of a quite different nature.

Richard May

Second Introduction by the So-Called Author

You can meet me if you go to an empty room.— May-Tzu

Foreword by Benoit Desjardins

In an age characterized by rapid technological advancement and an ever-increasing volume of information, the quest for deeper understanding often feels overwhelming. Yet, amidst this chaos, Richard May’s Out of My Mind Musings: Reality & Surreality emerges as a refreshing antidote, inviting readers to engage with complex ideas through a lens that is at once profound and playfully irreverent. This collection is not merely an academic endeavor; it is an exploration of the human experience—its intricacies, absurdities, and boundless possibilities.

Richard May is a remarkable thinker whose credentials are as eclectic as his insights. As a member of the Mega Society and a co-editor of Noesis: The Journal of the Mega Society, May operates within intellectual realms that challenge the norms of conventional thought. He describes himself as an “Amish yuppie” with roots in the rarified air of Laputa, suggesting a whimsical yet grounded perspective that shapes his writing. With a unique blend of philosophical inquiry, personal reflection, and imaginative storytelling, May creates a space where reality and surreality coalesce, prompting readers to reconsider their assumptions about life and existence.

This book is structured as a series of essays and reflections that traverse a wide array of themes, from Eastern philosophies and the nature of consciousness to the implications of artificial intelligence and the climate crisis. Each section serves as a portal into a different facet of May’s expansive mind, and readers will find themselves on an intellectual journey that is as challenging as it is enlightening.

May’s writings are infused with a sense of humor and a lightness that make complex ideas accessible. In his reflections on topics like the “On-line Buddha” and the “evolutionary emergence of cyber-informational organisms,” he deftly navigates the nuances of modern life while urging readers to maintain a sense of wonder. The essays oscillate between the abstract and the concrete, merging philosophical musings with vivid imagery and personal anecdotes that resonate on a human level.

One of the remarkable aspects of May’s work is his ability to invite readers into the depths of contemplation without presuming to provide definitive answers. Instead, he embraces the inherent uncertainties of existence, suggesting that the journey of inquiry is often more valuable than the conclusions we draw. As we grapple with questions about the nature of consciousness and the role of artificial intelligence, May challenges us to embrace the ambiguity of our own experiences, celebrating the moments of lucidity that arise amidst the chaos.

In Out of My Mind Musings: Reality & Surreality, May not only reflects on his own experiences but also engages with the broader tapestry of human thought. His writing is a testament to the idea that we are all, in some sense, incomplete beings on a quest for understanding. Through his explorations, he encourages us to recognize our own potential for growth and transformation, urging us to contemplate the implications of our existence in a rapidly changing world.

As you embark on this intellectual adventure, prepare to confront ideas that may challenge your perceptions and provoke your thoughts. Richard May’s voice is one that resonates with authenticity, inviting you to explore the boundaries of reality and surreality, and to ponder the profound questions that shape our existence.

This collection is not just a book; it is an invitation to engage with the complexities of life in all its forms. In a world often dominated by the mundane, Richard May’s musings serve as a beacon for those willing to embrace the uncertainties and mysteries of existence. Allow yourself to be captivated by the richness of his insights and the depth of his reflections. You may find that, through this journey, you too will discover a new lens through which to view your own reality.

Foreword by Daniel Shea

“The two cardinal points of poetry, the power of exciting the sympathy of the reader by a faithful adherence to the truth of nature, and the power of giving the interest of novelty by the modifying colors of imagination.”— Samuel Taylor Coleridge, Biographia Literaria, Chapter XIV

If one gives any credence to the concept of eternal return, then the attempt to formalize a definition of poetry must be its centerpiece. To define is to invite challenge, be it along any lines of subject, structure, voice, or imagery.

What follows is an eclectic collection of themes ranging from the nature of consciousness and reality to the self and identity, from Eastern philosophy to quantum physics, from artificial intelligence to the limits of knowledge—essays and poems and meditations alike—all drawing on humor, irony, and personal reflection, a blend of intellectual rigor and playful spirit, staying true to the natural emotions and experiences of life while exploring the familiar and unfamiliar in a peculiar light.

Richard’s self-introduction makes mention of Grady Towers, perhaps most well-known as the author of the 1987 article “The Outsiders” among other works. In 1998, Towers proposed that high-range tests such as Ronald Hoeflin’s Mega Test, unlike its predecessors, selected for a population that found themselves on the right tail for both fluid and crystallized intelligence. This departure from unidimensional selection perhaps only begins to explain the literary output of this very author—unconventional and inventive by the standards of an already unconventional and inventive subculture.

Those who have enjoyed the many issues of Noesis over the years will no doubt have been treated to Richard’s laconic yet pithy poetic epilogues, articles, and even a variety of board games (U.S. Patent #4739992, for the curious). This ensuing anthology captures these musings, as the title promises, in a collection of “writings for no one.”

One would expect no less from a Laputan.

But I suspect that these writings are for no one and everyone alike.

“Don’t take your life personally, it’s not about you,” after all.

Daniel Shea

October 8, 2024

Foreword by Rick Rosner

Genius comes in many different forms.

May and I belong to the Mega Society, an organization for people with high IQs. There are various types of people with high IQs. True geniuses are like Isaac Newton or Marie Curie. Then you have the so-called “evil geniuses,” like Keith Raniere or the villains in every James Bond movie or The Incredibles. I am sure there are some evil geniuses in Watchmen, too.

In that comic, they have the smartest man in the world, Dr. Manhattan. Then they have someone even smarter—Ozymandias, who has the intellect to reassemble himself and execute his grand plan after being exposed to a catastrophic event. Then you have the dysfunctional Schadenfreude geniuses, the ones you used to see in tabloids.

“Aren’t you glad you are not that kind of genius? Because his IQ has made him miserable.”

That is what happened to William Sidis. There was a small quantity of that with people saying, “Yes, he was teaching at Harvard at 15, but now he works at the post office.” However, what is often overlooked is the person who uses their vast intelligence and high IQ to take hold of life—not to be a flamboyant asshole, but rather to be a happy person leading a fulfilling life—someone who does not get caught up in the insanity of the flamboyant genius, but who brings a special, subversive flavour to life.

That is how I think of Richard May—smart as a mofo but enjoying life and poking fun at it in a not-so-mean way, understanding the absurdity of things and commenting on them. Which, in my mind, is much better than forming a cult.

Consider Liam Neeson in Taken, Taken Two, and Taken 3.

As he says in the movie, Liam Neeson has a particular set of skills, which, as we have seen in these movies, enables him to track people down, find the bad guys, and generally kill them to save a loved one. How lucky Liam Neeson is to have his loved ones repeatedly kidnapped, allowing him to exercise his particular set of skills. Also, those movies were so popular that he got to kill many people in at least half a dozen other movies. That is like genius.

What if nobody was taken from Liam Neeson’s family?

He would still have that particular set of skills, but in going to the grocery store and searching for a parking space. I wonder what his character does when he is not tracking down people. Does he work in an office? Is he retired? Does he sit in a coffee shop and enjoy a relaxing frappuccino? I do not know.

We generally see him tracking down and killing bad guys. However, what if that never happened? He would be sitting in a coffee shop, looking around. He would sit with his back to the wall so nobody could sneak up on him. He would be assessing potential threats.

He would be profiling everybody around him, but mostly, he would be sipping coffee with his skills, giving him an extra layer of perception about the world and analysis, but only a little to act on. Does he encounter kids constantly cutting across his lawn at his home? Moreover, given his particular set of skills, does he choose not to confront the kids because he knows what awful things can happen in the world?

He’s been in all sorts of difficult situations in his previous life. He will let the kids continue to cut across his lawn. Is somebody stealing his newspaper at 5 a.m. from his front yard? Maybe. Is he going to scare the person out of that?

Mostly, he will perceive things and not act on his perceptions, except in overly dramatic ways.

That is what genius is for many geniuses. We have had big-time geniuses like Newton, Einstein, Darwin, Marie Curie, and Rosalind Franklin. Moreover, boy, Rosalind Franklin’s genius just made her pissed off.

She kept making discoveries that were stolen by others. She died before she could get a Nobel Prize. She did not seem to be happy about Crick and Watson, who, inebriated, peeked at her X-ray scans and discerned the structure of DNA. She could not have been happy about that.

So, most geniuses are quietly super smart and are not constantly ripping through the world, just redoing everybody’s life.

Take Elon Musk, for example—not a genius, a fake genius. Good at squeezing billions of dollars and tons of grants out of the government. He makes a huge impression on the world. Not a genius. Kind of a jerk.

However, Richard May—a genius who belongs to the Mega Society, a documented genius—writes very clever stuff seen by the readers of Noesis, all 36. He writes very good stuff unseen by the wider world—a quiet genius, basically, like Liam Neeson’s character—a person with a particular set of skills exercised in a very gentle, low-impact way.

Just a guy who has an extra layer of perception and analytics about the world, who is not tearing through the world killing bad guys. A good way to be.

We prefer Liam Neeson when he is killing bad guys, but Liam Neeson would probably prefer to be the guy relaxing in a coffee shop instead of having to kill eight bad guys every time somebody kidnaps his wife, ex-wife, or daughter.

So Richard May, a killer who does not have to kill: Good.

I am so fucking scattered that I could not even put pen to paper or fingers to a keyboard. I had to be persuaded just to say words in my haphazard way. I was too much of an asshole to sit down and type anything. Like, Scott had to nudge me and nudge me and nudge me until I would.

Foreword by Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Currently, I am sitting in an empty room—May-Tzu is not here, but Richard May is also not present. Is that a present, a gift? No.

Richard May has been one of the long-term, quiet, and humble leaders in the American high-I.Q. community space and continues this non-presence based on a felt ubiquity. An enigma, a man—no! A bullet. He has sight, perspective. He pierces to the heart of the matter, leaving one’s falsehoods behind for…?

The pleasure in the collaboration with Richie Rich in spirit is the basic humaneness of Dick. A man as a message, and a messenger pretending to be not—and to be.

!… The foundation of the presence of May is saying what needs to be said in things unsaid; a steady hand presenting structured unstructure unsteadily.

…? There’s something discomfiting about a man who does not even identify as such, as he does not identify—so to what identity, I ask you in a sentence as no question. The logico-metamathematical sensory nonsense of a zoo full of Mays, out of month in November and out of time in May… is May!

It is a real blessing to have the chance to provide an opportunity for a sensitive soul, a sharp mind, and an emotionally astute consciousness to express their honest thoughts as they arise, over time, out and through space, to those also in an empty room looking for nothing—so themselves.

Something from nothing is the fundamental present of May in one’s life—a comfort, a nothing, a May-Tzu, Richard May, a colleague and a friend, and someone with the mind to tell the differences. We are here to dance and sing, yet so many of us turn up missing the point the whole time.

Left empty as we came here, in a smaller room six feet under with a wondering “why,” so why not? And so, sometimes, a little insight is in sight.

November 13, 2024

Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Foreword to “The EsoterIQ Society Conversations”

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2025/08/09

Table of Contents

In-Sight Publishing …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 2

The EsoterIQ Society Conversations ………………………………………………………………………………………… 3

Table of Contents ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 5Acknowledgements ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 9

Foreword by Masaaki Yamauchi ……………………………………………………………………………………………. 10

Administrator ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 11

Conversation with Masaaki Yamauchi on Japanese Background, Intelligence Tests, and Philosophy: Administrator, ESOTERIQ Society (1) ……………………………………………………………………………………. 12

Conversation with Masaaki Yamauchi on Esoteric, ESOTERIQ Society, JAPANIQ Society, OLYMPIQ Society, and Standards of Admission: Administrator, ESOTERIQ Society (2) ………………………………… 19

Conversation with Masaaki Yamauchi on Thoughts About I.Q., Time, Consciousness, and Metaphysics: Administrator, ESOTERIQ Society (3) ……………………………………………………………………………………. 22

Conversation with Masaaki Yamauchi on Updates and the Second Edition of “The ESOTERIQ Society Conversations”: Administrator, ESOTERIQ Society (4) ……………………………………………………… 26

Current Members …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 28

Dr. Evangelos Katsioulis, MD, MA, MSc, PhD: Giga Society, Member; Consultant Psychiatrist, Psychotherapist, and CEO & Founder, Psycall.com; World Intelligence Network, Founder & CEO; QIQ, GRIQ, CIVIQ, HELLIQ, OLYMPIQ, IQID, GREEK IQ Societies, and Anadeixi, Founder; Scientific Associate, School of Medicine, Medical Biology, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki ……………………….. 30

Rick G. Rosner: Giga Society, Member; Mega Society, Member & ex-Editor (1991–97); and Writer

  • Part One ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 34
  • Part Two ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 42
  • Part Three ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 50
  • Part Four ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 60
  • Part Five ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 74
  • Part Six ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 90
  • Part Seven ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 105
  • Part Eight ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 123
  • Part Nine …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 131
  • Part Ten ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 139
  • Part Eleven …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 147

Conversation with Christopher Harding: Founder, International Society for Philosophical Enquiry

  • On Royal Houses, Genius, Leonardo da Vinci, Test Ceiling Issues, Philosophy, Meaning, and Quantum Physics (1) …………………………………………………………………………………………………… 169
  • On Genius as Individualistic, God as the Universe or Non-Existent, Science’s Despoilment, Feynman, and the Quantum (2) ………………………………………………………………………………………………. 172

An Interview with Marios Sophia Prodromou

  • On Names, Metaphor, Cyprus, Greek Heritage, Genius, Religion, Mysticism, and More (Part One) ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 175
  • Brief Remarks on Cypriot Identity (2) ……………………………………………………………………………………….. 193

An Interview with Matthew Scillitani: Giga Society & Glia Society Member

  • On Family, Early Formation, Important Mentors and Books (Part One) ………………………………………. 195
  • On Society, God, the Soul, and Thought (Part Two) …………………………………………………………………. 199
  • On Left-Right Polarity and Extremity in the U.S. (Part Three) ……………………………………………………. 202
  • On God (Part Four) ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 205
  • On High-IQ Societies (Part Five) ………………………………………………………………………………………………. 210
  • On Cautionary Notes About the High-Range (Part Six) ……………………………………………………………… 215
  • On the Giga Society and Realizations (Parts Seven–Eight) ……………………………………………………….. 218-220
  • On Score Reports, Recognition, Rick Rosner, and Personality (Part Nine) …………………………………… 223
  • On Career and Community (Part Ten) ……………………………………………………………………………………….. 227
  • On Machine Learning and Family (Part Eleven) ………………………………………………………………………… 231

An Interview with Heinrich Siemens

  • Background and Scores (Part One) …………………………………………………………………………………………….. 234
  • On IQ 195 (S.D. 15), CIT5, Cooijmans, Mennonites, and Linguistics (Part Two) ……………………………. 237

Conversation with Fengzhi Wu (邬冯值): Founder & President, God’s Power

  • On Tokyo, MIT, Technology, INTJ, God, and Iron Man (1) …………………………………………………………… 245

An Interview with Tor Arne Jørgensen: 2019 Genius of the Year – Europe, World Genius Directory

  • On Background, Identity, Mentors, and Education (Parts One–Two) …………………………………………. 251, 254
  • On History and Global Application (Part Three) ………………………………………………………………………… 259
  • On Societies and Global Trends (Part Four) ……………………………………………………………………………… 264
  • On Nuclear Armaments (Part Five) …………………………………………………………………………………………… 268
  • On Leonardo Da Vinci (Part Six) ………………………………………………………………………………………………. 276
  • On Adolescence and Historical Quirks (Part Seven) …………………………………………………………………… 288
  • On Russia, China, India, and Global Politics (Part Eight) ……………………………………………………………. 293
  • On High-Range Testing and Teaching (Part Nine) ……………………………………………………………………… 300
  • On Curriculum Development in Norway (Part Ten) ……………………………………………………………………. 309
  • On AGI (Part Eleven) ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 314
  • On Religion and Budding Authorship (Part Twelve) …………………………………………………………………… 321

An Interview with Marco Ripà, B.Econ.Sc.

  • Part One …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 329
  • Part Two …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 333
  • Part Three ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 338

Conversation with Iakovos Koukas: President & Founder, GENIUS High IQ Network

  • On Personal History, Genius, and Views (1) ………………………………………………………………………………. 344
  • On Love, God, and IQ Testing Platforms (2) ……………………………………………………………………………… 349

Former Members …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 354

Conversation with Tianxi Yu (余天曦): Member, Chinese Genius Directory

  • On Life, Scores, and Views (1) ………………………………………………………………………………………………… 355
  • On Intellectual Interests (2) …………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 362
  • On Research and God’s Power (3) ……………………………………………………………………………………………. 365
  • On Chinese High-IQ Communities (4) ………………………………………………………………………………………. 371
  • On Bead Counting and Education (5) ………………………………………………………………………………………… 374
  • On Graduation, Work, and Hobby Tests (6) ……………………………………………………………………………….. 378
  • On CAT2 and Education (7) …………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 380
  • On Globalization and Controversial Views (8) …………………………………………………………………………… 382

Author Biography …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 385

Acknowledgements

To Masaaki Yamauchi for giving a sequence of EsoterIQ Society members for interviews over many years, as well as a society for easier research into some members of the high-I.Q. communities, and for a foreword to the text for a different evaluative criteria and perspective—especially as I have been winding down the work for the interviews and articles on the high-I.Q. communities.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen

November 27, 2024

Foreword by Masaaki Yamauchi

The ESOTERIQ Society was founded to create my collection of extraordinary high IQ performers at a one-in-one-billion level theoretically on the normal distribution and expand somewhat more openly than the Giga Society by Paul Cooijmans.

The World Intelligence Network founder, Dr. Evangelos Katsioulis, also founded the QIQ, GRIQ, CIVIQ, HELLIQ, and OLYMPIQ societies (WIN five league), respectively. I was looking for the combination of the first six letters of an English word whose origin is Latin or Greek, the IQ component, and the League for the Society name. Therefore, my societies—the ESOTERIQ and EVANGELIQ, including the WIN five league—are also named the WIN seven league.

I have no psychometrics knowledge or experience, even though I am the administrator. Hence, I appreciate several advisors, including Paul Cooijmans, Dr. Jason Betts, Dr. Evangelos Katsioulis, and Younghoon Kim, for the admission policy owing to my ignorance.

Moreover, I have no idea about the current members’ future potential ability to improve their IQ score vs. academic performance and social life functioning. No one knows who would become a great genius or criminal, but there is a strong certainty that almost all of them may be obscure. This is one of my purposes: many people need to understand the relationship between IQ and cleverness. Additionally, high-IQ people do not always imply morality, integrity, and emotional intelligence—like Theodore Bundy (serial killer) or Theodore Kaczynski (Unabomber).

I want all readers to understand that IQ is not human intelligence, no matter how low or high the score is; it is just the statistical frequency of normal distribution in the population. Many gifted, talented, or genius people have very low IQ scores, known as savant syndrome. Aristotle said that all men, by nature, desire to know. Let me say that all men, by nature, can always have absolute intelligence and existence.

Masaaki Yamauchi

July 2022

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Introduction and Foreword to “Finding Humanistic Education in Our Stories”

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2025/08/09

Table of Contents

In-Sight Publishing …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 2

Finding Humanistic Education in Our Stories …………………………………………………………………………… 3

Table of Contents ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 5

Acknowledgements ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 6

Introduction by Scott Douglas Jacobsen …………………………………………………………………………………… 7

Foreword by Dr. Nasser Yousefi ………………………………………………………………………………………………. 8

Dr. Nasser Yousefi and Baran Yousefi on the Peace School ……………………………………………………….. 9

Dr. Nasser Yousefi and Baran Yousefi on Humanist Curricula …………………………………………………… 13

Dr. Nasser Yousefi and Baran Yousefi on Humanistic Education’s Necessity ………………………………. 19

Dr. Nasser Yousefi and Baran Yousefi: The Peace School …………………………………………………………. 26

Scott Jacobsen–Nasser Yousefi Correspondence: Personal Narratives, Ukraine and Iran ……………… 32

Authors’ Biographies ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 50

Introduction by Scott Douglas Jacobsen

“It’s easy to love somebody. Shit, sit with them a little bit and talk to them a while.”— Richard Pryor

“The silver swan, who, living had no note, when death approached unlocked her silent throat.”— Orlando Gibbons

The reimagination of education from the Yousefis comes from a sensibility of a “return to” rather than a “getting over” frame. A return to a humanistic referential mindset on the education of human beings with rich internal tapestries of thoughts and feelings connected to webs of extended social relations in the world rather than getting over them through the imposition of artifice. The nurturance of intellectual acumen and emotional sensitivities in tandem.

The Peace School served hundreds in Iran. The same institution, with a humanistic orientation, was formally registered in Spring 2024 in Canada. Individualized education based on each student’s unique qualities demands extensive thought, time to plan, and care in implementing—a tall order.

Amid correspondence, Nasser described the times of working in Iran and difficult circumstances. A family who has come through conflict, societal constraints, and trauma to advance educational reform and to promote a humanistic vision through peace via innovative educational curricula.

Their family’s life story brings the antipodean pillars called Theory and Practice to a satisfying resolution in the Peace School—an Equator.

Transformative education only has to meet human needs as its base, and the diverse approaches to meet those needs can be as creative as necessary. The Yousefis champion each student’s unique and individual cultural, emotional, and intellectual needs. Empathy and respect can counterforce the homogenization of education and approaches to each student.

To argue for best practices in a humanistic educational curriculum does not mean an argument for standardized education; it means human beings in key development moments have basic and diversified needs, and principles can be the basis for formulating educational experiences for each pupil.

Their approach, fundamentally, is a values-based approach for the nurturance of critical thinkers who are knowledgeable and passionate citizens with a global perspective. This allows for a cross-cultural fluidity in seeing the universal endeavours and benefits of cross-cultural exchange and collaborative wisdom.

Their unwavering dedication to humanistic approaches gives a bulwark against institutional inertia from political and societal barriers in Iran, and using this knowledge to advance humanistic education in Canada is a well-needed contribution to Canadian culture and global humanism.

This short book of conversations with the Yousefis gives insight into the communal bonds being built and the democratic participation being encouraged at the Peace School. Their approach isn’t dogmatic but prompt-based to let one sit and think more deeply about a particular topic in education. You are not necessarily supposed to agree.

The act of gentle coaxing into further consideration is the point. This approach plucks the strings of both mind and heart. Occasionally, some harmony results.

Foreword by Dr. Nasser Yousefi

I have been working in humanistic education in developing countries for over thirty years and have established diverse connections with international organizations. During these years, I have met and interacted with many experts and thinkers. Mr. Scott Douglas Jacobsen is one of the passionate and dedicated experts in humanistic fields who works tirelessly. Despite being young and energetic, he manages and follows through on numerous humanistic projects and ideas with remarkable maturity.

With his prepared resources, Mr. Scott Douglas Jacobsen has shaped the foundations and principles of humanism in the global community more than any other expert. Through his patience and wisdom, these resources have been developed. Without him, these concepts would not have been so easily documented. I am deeply grateful to him.

I would also like to express my gratitude to Baran Yousefi. As a graduate of humanistic schools, Baran has profoundly understood and embodied many of these concepts. I truly appreciate the collaboration between the three of us in advancing humanistic education.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Introduction and Forewords to “The Greenhorn Chronicles 1: Mucking Around Canadian Equestrians”

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2025/08/09

Table of Contents
In-Sight Publishing
………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 2
The Greenhorn Chronicles 1: Mucking Around Canadian Equestrians …………………………………….. 3
Table of Contents …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 5
Acknowledgements …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 9
Introduction by Scott Douglas Jacobsen ……………………………………………………………………………….. 10
Foreword by Deborah Clayton ………………………………………………………………………………………………. 11
Foreword by Lynne Denison Foster ………………………………………………………………………………………. 12
Foreword by Mac Cone …………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 13
In-Sight Publishing …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 14

The Greenhorn Chronicles 1: Joelle Froese on Abbotsford, Bradner Hills Farm, and In Stride Equestrian Training …………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 15
The Greenhorn Chronicles 2: Sandy Bell, B.Sc., M.A. on Mature Equine Life and the Alberta Equestrian Federation (1) ………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 22
The Greenhorn Chronicles 3: Nadine Bollig on Equestrianism and Reaching Strides Equestrian Centre ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 26
The Greenhorn Chronicles 4: Dr. Julia Jane Stanley on Physics, Show Jumping, and Grand Prix Dreams (1) …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 30
The Greenhorn Chronicles 5: Leann (Pitman) Manuel on Becoming a Horse Woman and Riding 4 Life’s Beginnings (1) …………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 33
The Greenhorn Chronicles 6: Sandy Bell, B.Sc., M.A. on Windhorse Retreat, Horse Sense, and Resources (2) ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 37
The Greenhorn Chronicles 7: Leann (Pitman) Manuel on Wisdom, Intuition, Disabilities, and Elitism (2) ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 42
The Greenhorn Chronicles 8: Rachael Dent-Flynn on Flar Equine Experience …………………………….. 46
The Greenhorn Chronicles 9: Leann (Pitman) Manuel on Issues in the Industry (3) ……………………. 49
The Greenhorn Chronicles 10: Kathy Asseiro on Symatree Farm (1) ………………………………………….. 54
The Greenhorn Chronicles 11: Kailin Howard on Horse Ownership and Care …………………………….. 60
The Greenhorn Chronicles 12: Erynn Ballard on Canadian Equestrianism ………………………………….. 65
The Greenhorn Chronicles 13: Adelle Stewart on Horses, Hay, and Prime Equine (1) …………………. 78
The Greenhorn Chronicles 14: Wes Schild on Dressage (1) ……………………………………………………….. 84
The Greenhorn Chronicles 15: Dana Cooke on High Performance Equestrianism (1) ………………….. 88
The Greenhorn Chronicles 16: Wes Schild on Expense, Show Jumping’s Appeal, and the Industry (2) …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 91
The Greenhorn Chronicles 17: Cindy Waslewsky on Operations at Twin Creeks Ranch (1) ………… 95
The Greenhorn Chronicles 18: Betty Asseiro on Symatree Farm (1) …………………………………………….. 99
The Greenhorn Chronicles 19: Will Clinging on Canadian Farriers (1) ………………………………………. 103
The Greenhorn Chronicles 20: Moya Byrne Merrin on High Point Equestrian Centre and Equine Labour Shortages (1) …………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 106
The Greenhorn Chronicles 21: Lesley Daldry on Experiences with Horses (1) ……………………………. 109
The Greenhorn Chronicles 22: Deborah Stacey on the Origins of Horse Lover’s Math (1) …………. 113
The Greenhorn Chronicles 23: Gail Greenough on International Show Jumping and Equestrianism …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 119
The Greenhorn Chronicles 24: Deborah Stacey on Math in the Equine (2) ………………………………… 126
The Greenhorn Chronicles 25: Moya Byrne Merrin on Horse Care and Dressage Horses (2) ………. 131
The Greenhorn Chronicles 26: Mac Cone on Horsemanship, Canada, and the Olympics (1) ………. 133
The Greenhorn Chronicles 27: Mac Cone on North American Show Jumping History (2) ………….. 137
The Greenhorn Chronicles 28: Hayley Mercer on Personal Story and Aspirations in Show Jumping …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 141
The Greenhorn Chronicles 29: Kimberley Martens on Show Jumping, the Netherlands, Show Jumping Culture ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 149
The Greenhorn Chronicles 30: Sean Jobin on Personal Story, Work, and Views in Show Jumping …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 156
The Greenhorn Chronicles 31: Leann (Pitman) Manuel on Equestrianism and Horsemanship (4) . 161
The Greenhorn Chronicles 32: Hyde Moffatt on Getting Started and Rankings (1) …………………….. 172
The Greenhorn Chronicles 33: Mac Cone on the Direction of Show Jumping and Its History (3) … 176
The Greenhorn Chronicles 34: L.J. Tidball on Growth as a Show Jumper, George and Diane Tidball, and Show Jumping (1) ………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 182
The Greenhorn Chronicles 35: Cindy Waslewsky on the Equestrian Industry and Breeds (2) …….. 190
The Greenhorn Chronicles 36: Hyde Moffatt on the Meaning of Success (2) ………………………………. 195
The Greenhorn Chronicles 37: Deborah Clayton on Equestrian Fashion and a Respect for Show Jumping (1) ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 198
The Greenhorn Chronicles 38: Deborah Clayton on Being a Show Jumping Destination (2) ……….. 207
The Greenhorn Chronicles 39: Alicia Gadban-Lewis on Show Jumping Development and Lifestyle (1) …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 211
The Greenhorn Chronicles 40: L.J. Tidball on Staffing, Tiffany Foster, Brent Balisky, and Horses (2) ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 214
The Greenhorn Chronicles 41: Cindy Waslewsky and Steve Waslewsky on Big Picture Operations, the Township of Langley, ALR, and Bylaws (3) ……………………………………………………………………… 219
The Greenhorn Chronicles 42: L.J. Tidball on Business, the global South and East, Injuries, and International Competition (3) ………………………………………………………………………………………………. 226
The Greenhorn Chronicles 43: L.J. Tidball on Great Riders, SafeSport, and George & Dianne Tidball (4) ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 229
The Greenhorn Chronicles 44: Lynne Denison Foster on Parenting Principles (1) ………………………. 234
The Greenhorn Chronicles 45: Conversation with Beth Underhill on Upbringing (1) …………………. 238
The Greenhorn Chronicles 46: Conversation with Beth Underhill on Longevity and Emotional Difficulties (2) ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 242
The Greenhorn Chronicles 47: Annette Case Background to 3-Day Eventing (1) ………………………… 248
The Greenhorn Chronicles 48: Lynne Denison Foster on Storytime with Brent Balisky (2) …………. 255
The Greenhorn Chronicles 49: Annette Case on Eventer Stereotypes and Family Life (2) ………….. 259
The Greenhorn Chronicles 50: Conversation with Beth Underhill on Horses and Tragedy (3) …….. 264
The Greenhorn Chronicles 51: Bob Marshall, 5-Time World Champion Blacksmith ………………….. 270
The Greenhorn Chronicles 51: Bob Marshall, 5-Time World Champion Blacksmith ………………….. 287
The Greenhorn Chronicles 52: Quentin Judge on Double H Farm (1) ……………………………………….. 304
The Greenhorn Chronicles 53: Emily Fitzgerald on Equestrianism (1) ………………………………………. 307
The Greenhorn Chronicles 54: Quentin Judge on Top Tier Show Jumping (2) ………………………….. 311
The Greenhorn Chronicles 55: Hyde Moffatt on Show Jumping & Costs (3) ……………………………… 314
The Greenhorn Chronicles 56: Lynne Denison Foster on Recognition & Repetition (3) ……………… 318
The Greenhorn Chronicles 57: Lynne Denison Foster on Hard Work and Helping the Least of These (4) ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 323
The Greenhorn Chronicles 58: Lynne Denison Foster on Loneliness and Thunderbird Show Park (5) ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 327
The Greenhorn Chronicles 59: Lynne Denison Foster on Last Comments (6) ……………………………. 331
The Greenhorn Chronicles 60: Emily Fitzgerald on Show Jumping (2) …………………………………….. 337

The Good Men Project …………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 342
Melanie Rempel and Lauren Rempel on Para Dressage ………………………………………………………… 343
Miriam Alden on Brunette the Label and Horse Girl Aesthetic ………………………………………………… 351
Author Biography ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 356

The Greenhorn Chronicles 1: Mucking Around Canadian Equestrians

Acknowledgements

To the Baliskys and Tidballs for taking in a stray Fort Langleyite, and their employees for training me and being decent varied colleagues over 27 months, and Adelle Stewart, Alicia Gadban-Lewis, Annette Case, Beth Underhill, Betty Asseiro, Bob Marshall, Cindy Waslewsky, Dana Cooke, Deborah Clayton, Deborah Stacey, Dr. Julia Jane Stanley, Erynn Ballard, Gail Greenough, Hayley Mercer, Hyde Moffatt, Joelle Froese, Kailin Howard, Kathy Asseiro, Kimberley Martens, Melanie Rempel, Miriam Alden, Lauren Rempel, Leann (Pitman) Manuel, Lesley Daldry, L.J. Tidball, Lynne Denison Foster, Mac Cone, Moya Byrne Merrin, Nadine Bollig, Quentin Judge, Rachael Dent-Flynn, Sandy Bell, B.Sc., M.A., Sean Jobin, Steve Waslewsky, Wes Schild, and Will Clinging, for the interviews.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen


Introduction by Scott Douglas Jacobsen

My first experience of a horse was walking with a childhood friend in the outskirts of town—Langley, B.C.—around variegated farms, including Christmas tree farms, up to a fence. A horse came over in a little prance. It peered gently over the fencing, inviting a pet. I brought my right hand forward under its chin and stroked it. Immediately, the horse sneezed in my face as if a booger blaster shotgun—point-blank. Pow! Splat! Ew!

Life has much goofiness to it, often at your expense. Years later, I worked in the restaurant industry during the Covid-19 pandemic, which affected the world, including peculiarly Canada. Near the end of that streak, I worked in 4 restaurants and did janitorial work in 2 of them 7 days per week. The money plus tips were good. The work was hard. The hours were long. The work was invigorating, though dynamic, tiring, and stressful.

Cleaning up the poop stains of heavy drinkers at a pub is not glamorous, but you learn valuable life lessons from it. The things you find in the bathrooms that are not excrement!

As John, the owner of the pub at the time—unsure now—when he took me on a drive once said, “Farms are good to grow up. You learn about life and death.” That is true. I took that to heart. The routine became monotonous. I was not learning anything new in skills. The restaurant-janitorial period seemed to be capping out.

So, I decided to look for newer opportunities for something more invigorating. The farm notion came to mind. ‘Langley, the Horse Capital of British Columbia!’ was in the sub-culture of the area too. I would read and hear that, but I only had horse boogers from many years prior attesting to it.

As with most of these items, I decided to take another leap of trust into the unknown and applied to many horse facilities and farms to transition—leaving those skills and incomes behind for the uncertainty of an entirely new industry with zero experience. Somewhere else I did not belong.

I did one job interview at a horse farm purchased by a wealthy individual who was in transitional ownership. It was pretty good. I never met the owner. The barn manager was a nice lady. The horses were interesting. Then I got the number of one woman, Laura Balisky (née Tidball), who responded to a text inquiry about Thunderbird/Tbird—a well-known and respected brand and show grounds in British Columbia, certainly. I did not know this at the time. I knew—literally—nothing.

Balisky concluded with something to the effect, ‘Sure, let us give it a shot.’ That is about the correct tone, then and now—recalling “often at your expense.” Kindness with a higher-end equestrian facility sensibility, ‘Sure, we’ll put your ass to work.’

And they did, for 27 months. I had no right to be there.

Fast forward to two Workers Compensation Board back injuries later, but learning a lot—thanks to the training generosity—from highly experienced gardeners, landscapers, tractor operators, stall muckers, water bucket cleaners, grain bag organizers, aisle blowers, course setters, and the like.

Everyone there, then and now, knew more than me and was a source of data. These seem like basic tasks, but they are not when done correctly. There are a few right—so more than one correct answer, certainly—and a lot more wrong ways to do these things to optimize both quality and time expenditure.

Labour is one of many overheads in a financially constrained and pressured industry. I did one horse lesson while working with the Baliskys and Tidballs, but at a different facility—do not tell Laura, Brent, and L.J., please! I did not want to mix work and leisure too much. In hindsight, it probably was a stupid move. Think about how many laughs we all missed on me trying to ride a horse!

I lived there, worked there, shared sentiments and struggles with the girls there, made a small family there, learned janitorial cleaning of human waste is not much different from mucking horse shit, and—indeed—learned a little about ‘life and death’ in a way.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Foreword by Deborah Clayton

In a world where stories often go unheard, Scott has tasked himself with being a voice for the voiceless. He is a talented journalist and, most recently, an embedded reporter in the Ukraine. Now, in his latest work, The Greenhorn Chronicles, Scott takes us on a different journey—one that gallops through the captivating and intricate world of equestrianism.

Scott’s passion for storytelling and a keen ear allows us insight into the elegance and grace of the equestrian world and its many facets. The Greenhorn Chronicles is not just a collection of anecdotes, it is a deep dive into the lives of those who dedicate themselves to the art of riding, training, and showcasing these magnificent horses.

Through his thoughtful questioning and heartfelt narratives, Scott reveals the profound connection between humans and horses and brings a fresh lens to this beloved sport, making it accessible and relatable to both seasoned equestrians and newcomers alike.

Join me in celebrating this remarkable journey into the equestrian world as Scott invites us to explore the beauty, challenges, and triumphs that lie within. The Greenhorn Chronicles are a testament to his talent as a storyteller and his unwavering commitment to shedding light on the passions that define us.

Deborah Clayton
Lead Buyer/Vendor Relations, Thunderbird Show Park


Foreword by Lynne Denison Foster

Greenhorn Chronicles is an insightful and enlightening exploration of the foundational influences within the world of equestrian sport. Through interviews with individuals deeply involved in the infrastructure of this unique sport—where two athletes, a human rider and a horse, must work in perfect harmony—Scott offers readers a perspective that is often overlooked.

As the mother of a Canadian show jumping athlete who has represented her country in three Olympic Games and held the title of leading lady rider in the world rankings on more than one occasion, I’ve had a front-row seat to the challenges and triumphs of this extraordinary sport. My daughter’s journey, from humble beginnings with minimal financial support to reaching the highest levels of competition, has been nothing short of remarkable.

When Scott approached me to share my perspective on the pivotal role parents play in helping their children achieve such lofty dreams, I was intrigued by his curiosity and dedication to uncovering the often unseen aspects of show jumping—especially in Canada, where the sport doesn’t always receive the spotlight it deserves. His genuine interest in this world led me to contribute my story to Greenhorn Chronicles, and I’m proud to be part of this fascinating project.

I believe that when you read the interviews Scott has conducted with the many dedicated behind-the-scenes people who support this sport—just as much as the riders and horses themselves—you will be both amazed and inspired by the depth of commitment, passion, and hard work that goes into the world of show jumping.

Lynne Denison Foster
Former Aviation Professional & BCIT Instructor

Foreword by Mac Cone

As a child, I learned a Bible verse, “Only fools despise wisdom and instruction.”

Scott Jacobsen has gathered 62 interviews from various people who are involved with horses in many different capacities. Their different visions into their world of horses give the reader an opportunity to gain wisdom and instruction from the backgrounds of many people.

Scott’s interviews do not attempt to be a manual of horse riding or training, but a more overall view of living a life around horses. Anyone considering becoming involved with horses as a professional will find many little clues from Scott’s work that might tell them if horses are where your professional effort should be applied.

Whether an amateur or professional horse person, Scott’s interviews will provide both knowledge and entertainment.

Enjoy the read!

Mac Cone
Former Olympian, Canadian Equestrian Team & United States Equestrian Team
Southern Ways Equestrian Ltd.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Empirical Moral Philosophies: Secular Humanism & Freethought Traditions

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2025/08/05

Secular humanism is an organized expression of modern freethought. One among many. Other freethought or non-religious traditions include the nontheistic Satanism of The Satanic Temple, the religion of Unitarian Universalism, and the Ethical Culture movement, which originated in the late nineteenth century.

Secular humanists generally affirm a human-centred ethical framework that does not invoke supernatural beliefs. Many identify as atheists or agnostics. Although numerous atheist organizations exist, no comparably large, independent agnostic groups have emerged.

Scientific skepticism frequently intersects with freethought. Public figures such as the magician duo Penn & Teller and the late investigator James Randi became well-known for challenging paranormal claims. Randi notably arranged the conditions under which psychic performer Uri Geller failed to bend spoons on The Tonight Show Starring Johnny Carson on 1 August 1973. An event widely regarded as a milestone in the history of modern skepticism.

Organized rationalism has also developed a significant influence in India. Sanal Edamaruku founded Rationalist International in 1995 during the first International Rationalist Conference in New Delhi. Dr. Sudesh B. Ghoderao is the General Secretary of the FIRA. An umbrella organization uniting more than eighty rationalist groups across the country. Activism in this sphere can be dangerous. Prominent rationalist Narendra Dabholkar was assassinated on 20 August 2013.

A key event for many contemporary humanists was “Beyond Belief: Science, Religion, Reason and Survival” from 2006. The conference featured Richard Dawkins, Neil deGrasse Tyson, Lawrence Krauss, and Sam Harris, among others. Something of note in its conferential discussion.

Empirical research highlights a complex relationship between religiosity and scientific achievement. A 1998 survey of members of the U.S. National Academy of Sciences reported that only about 7 percent expressed belief in a personal God.

A lower rate than the broader U.S. scientific community. Mid-1990s surveys indicated roughly 40 percent believed. Rates of belief vary by discipline. Mathematicians reported greater religiosity than biologists or physicists in the same studies.

Debates surrounding science education further reflect these variations by region. In British Columbia, Canada, the provincial Ministry of Education effectively prohibited the teaching of “creation science” in public-school biology classes in 1996, following a controversy in the Abbotsford School District.

These examples illustrate that neither religiosity nor non-religiosity alone determines pro-science or anti-science attitudes. Instead, cultural context, institutional environment, and disciplinary background play central roles in shaping how individuals and communities engage with scientific evidence and methodology. However, elite science and humanistic freethought represent strong implicit allegiances with one another.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

Artificial Intelligence from Global Tech and Thought Leaders

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Personal SubStack

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2025/05/18

Elon Musk
“AI is likely to be either the best or worst thing to happen to humanity.”

Stephen Hawking
“The development of full artificial intelligence could spell the end of the human race…. It would take off on its own, and re-design itself at an ever-increasing rate. Humans, who are limited by slow biological evolution, couldn’t compete, and would be superseded.”

Ray Kurzweil
“Artificial intelligence will reach human levels by around 2029. Follow that out further to, say, 2045, we will have multiplied the intelligence—the human biological-machine intelligence—of our civilization a billion-fold.”

Larry Page
“Artificial intelligence would be the ultimate version of Google. The ultimate search engine that would understand everything on the web. It would understand exactly what you wanted, and it would give you the right thing. We’re nowhere near doing that now. However, we can get incrementally closer to that, and that is basically what we work on.”

Klaus Schwab
“We must address, individually and collectively, moral and ethical issues raised by cutting-edge research in artificial intelligence and biotechnology, which will enable significant life extension, designer babies, and memory extraction.”

Peter Diamandis
“If the government regulates against use of drones or stem cells or artificial intelligence, all that means is that the work and the research leave the borders of that country and go someplace else.”

Colin Angle
“It’s going to be interesting to see how society deals with artificial intelligence, but it will definitely be cool.”

Alan Kay
“Some people worry that artificial intelligence will make us feel inferior, but then, anybody in his right mind should have an inferiority complex every time he looks at a flower.”

Alan Perlis
“A year spent in artificial intelligence is enough to make one believe in God.”

B.F. Skinner
“The real problem is not whether machines think but whether men do.”

Tom Chatfield
“Forget artificial intelligence—in the brave new world of big data, it’s artificial idiocy we should be looking out for.”

Fei-Fei Li
“Artificial intelligence is not a substitute for human intelligence; it is a tool to amplify human creativity and ingenuity.”

Kai-Fu Lee
“I believe AI is going to change the world more than anything in the history of humanity—more than electricity.”

John McCarthy
“Artificial intelligence is the science of making machines do things that would require intelligence if done by humans.”

Timnit Gebru
“We’re seeing a kind of Wild West situation with AI and regulation right now. The scale at which businesses are adopting AI technologies isn’t matched by clear guidelines to regulate algorithms and help researchers avoid the pitfalls of bias in datasets.”

Emad Mostaque
“We’re just trying to race to keep up with the societal impact of all this. And one of the reasons for creating Stability was so that we could create some standards… If I watched all of YouTube, I’d be a bit crazy too.”

Clem Delangue
“I think it’s promising that we have policymakers who are trying to get smart about this technology and get in front of risks before we’ve had mass deployment across the product space. I think there are some very obvious things that we need to establish, one of which is the right to know whether you’re consuming content from a bot or not.”

Terah Lyons
“The problem that needs to be addressed is that the government itself needs to get a better handle on how technology systems interact with the citizenry. Secondarily, there needs to be more cross-talk between industry, civil society, and academic organizations working to advance these technologies and the government institutions that are going to be representing them.”

Erik Brynjolfsson
“In this era of profound digital transformation, it’s important to remember that business, as well as government, has a role to play in creating shared prosperity—not just prosperity.”

Yann LeCun
“Our intelligence is what makes us human, and AI is an extension of that quality.”

Gita Gopinath
“Forty percent of the global workforce is exposed to AI—that doesn’t mean it’s a bad thing. Some fraction of that will benefit; it will raise their productivity. That fraction is about half of that forty percent, and the other half will have a hard time—maybe lower wages, displacement, and so on.”

António Guterres
“Warn of the existential threat posed by the runaway development of AI without guard rails and its potential to increase inequality… We need governments urgently to work with tech companies on risk-management frameworks for current AI development, and on monitoring and mitigating future harms.”

Sam Altman
“We have our own nervousness, but we believe that we can manage through it, and the only way to do that is to put the technology in the hands of people. Let society and the technology co-evolve, and, step by step with a very tight feedback loop and course correction, build these systems that deliver tremendous value while meeting safety requirements.”

Gray Scott
“You have to talk about ‘The Terminator’ if you’re talking about artificial intelligence. I actually think that that’s way off. I do think that it will disrupt our culture.”

James Barrat
“I don’t want to really scare you, but it was alarming how many people I talked to who are highly placed in AI who have retreats that are sort of ‘bug-out’ houses, to which they could flee if it all hits the fan.”

Sybil Sage
“Someone on TV has only to say, ‘Alexa,’ and she lights up. She’s always ready for action, the perfect woman, never says, ‘Not tonight, dear.’”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1781: Anonymous LGBTQ+ Atheist from Egypt on Atheism, Bisexuality, Religious Persecution, Family Abuse, and LGBTQ+ Rights

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/30

“I do not know when I found out that I was an atheist, but I think this started when I was a child. The subject started to gradually grow, especially since I was the only child of my mother.”

“So, I started over time to ask myself why God does not help me get rid of this torment. I was praying to him over and over. I was a lonely, lonely girl with no friends. I was thinking a lot.”

“So when I became 16-years-old, I started looking for ‘Why God does not stand beside the weak people like me?’ I started looking into the religions. Until I discovered after more than 4 years of research that God is just an illusion.”

“Society did not accept the idea of atheism easily, especially (you know) that it is crazy to stand in a street yelling and say, ‘I’m atheist.’ That is impossible in an Islamic country like Egypt.”

“There was a friend on Facebook who claims to be an atheist and loves me and wants to marry me. I felt I finally found myself and told him about my beliefs. But I was naive. He took a screenshot from my posts, knew that I was an atheist and bisexual and sent it to my family.”

“So, the neighbors began to bully me and threatened me. They accused me of being a prostitute. I tried to deny that I was an atheist, but they believed the man who cheated me.”

“I left my family’s home for fear of the threat and now live with my friend in Cairo. Every time, I go to Alexandria. I visit my mother. I feel threatened.”

“Religious authority has now tightened its grip on society. I have been suffering and still suffer. My society thinks that women are less than human. They know that I love women more than men, so my mom hates me because of that.”

“The situation is not capable of being reformed at the moment. Rather, the reform in their view is to put us in mental hospitals or imprison us. It can reach the point of murder.”

“The Internet was the only outlet for us to express our ideas and some of the associations that we intended to open. But the new law of organizations and associations closed the ports in our face. Now, in the Middle East, it is difficult to speak freely, even on the Internet because the government is watching you all the time.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1780: Ismail Mohamed on Atheism in Egypt, The Black Ducks, Secularism, Religious Freedom, and the Rights of Nonbelievers

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/30

“Being a Muslim and a straight man means that you live in the perfect place for you. Egypt, like any Muslim country, is good for conservative Muslims and heterosexuals. It is not a good place for atheists.”

“No one can declare his atheism and remain in the same social and professional life. This is almost impossible. This can be announced to some people close to him and will remain secret to everyone.”

“But if his declaration is strong, the society will not have mercy on him, whether he is a university professor or whatever. Therefore, the majority of those who declared atheism are now social outcasts.”

“Some of them resort to changing their homes or jobs or hiding, or working through the Internet as I did after my declaration of atheism in one of the satellite channels. I then had to leave my city and go to live in the city for fear on my life and the life of my family, religious persecution and fear of persecution is very difficult and turns life into a great hell.”

“There are no laws that criminalize atheism in Egypt. If you are an atheist, you do not violate the law. But if you talk about the reasons for atheism or explain religion as you understood it and make you an atheist, you may be imprisoned for contempt of religions. This violates the human rights of freedom of belief and expression.”

“It is a media platform where non-believers were given the opportunity to talk about their experience with religion; an information platform that also propagates the principles of secularism and acceptance of the other.”

“I have recorded more than 300 episodes so far. The program has also been the first to give the opportunity to many homosexuals who are forgotten. They can talk about their experience. Their suffering in the Middle East, also the program aims to encourage non-believers and oppressed life and deliver a message to them is that they are not alone, but we are with them.”

“I was forced to leave the city and go to another city with a very small population. I was able to continue broadcasting from there. However, I was apprehended by security and stopped for a while and returned to my city.”

“Unfortunately, to this day, there is an overlap (almost all the countries of the Middle East and North Africa) between what is religious and what is related to life, people, and society. There are many laws based on religion such as personal status laws in Egypt for example (such as marriage and inheritance), and some other laws.”

“We are one world and one planet. Western societies are created, produced, and manufactured by the creativity of their children who enjoy freedom after separating what is religious from what is related to life. I believe that individuals and institutions from all Western countries should support our transformation of secularism and separation of religion and law. We need your support.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1779: Marieme Hélie-Lucas on Secularism, Feminism, Atheism, Women’s Rights, Algeria, and Religious Fundamentalism

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/26

“Being born and raised in a colonised country and having lived through a very bloody liberation struggle from French colonialism… there is no way to ignore politics and their consequences on individuals. Moreover, I was born and raised into a family of strong feminists for several generations; let’s say that I fell into the pot from childhood…”

“WLUML was a non-confessional network of women whose lives were shaped and governed by laws said to be Islamic, regardless of their personal faith. Our research on laws affecting women in many countries — in North Africa, the Middle East, South Asia, West Africa — show that these man-made laws (rather than of divine inspiration) borrow not just from very different interpretations of Islam, but mostly from local traditions, cultural practices, and even colonial laws, when it suits both patriarchy and religious fundamentalism.”

“Secularism is the legal/administrative provision that separates state from organised religions. It was defined during the French Revolution and later codified in the 1905–1906 laws on separation. Article 1 of the law guarantees freedom of belief and practice to individuals; article 2 stipulates that the Secular Republic does not recognise, therefore dialogue with or fund religions, their representatives and their institutions. The secular Republic only knows equal citizens with equal rights under the law.”

“Moreover, when laws are designed as representing god’s intentions on earth, they become un-changeable, a-historical. Theocracy is the antithesis of democracy where laws are voted by the people and can be changed according to the will of the people.”

“We need to walk the fine line, challenging at the same time both the new religious extreme rights which condemn secularism and atheism, and ‘traditional’ xenophobic extreme rights which are hijacking the concept of secularism to justify their claim to white Christian superiority.”

“As varied as one can imagine in one’s wildest guess. It ranges from being able to become an elected head of state, to being closeted between four walls with no education and no rights, and all the intermediary shades in between these extremes. There exists absolutely no homogeneous ‘Muslim world.’”

“Everywhere and at all times, women in Muslim contexts fought for their rights, using different strategies, just as we do today: demanding right to education, political rights, freedom of movement, financial autonomy, equal rights in marriage, etc… Religious interpretation was only one of the many strategies they used. The struggle still goes on now, in these very difficult times.”

“It gathered together in mutual solidarity women who were religious believers, human rights advocates, secularists and atheists.”

“There always were reactionary forces aiming at governing in the name of god. Secularism, understood as separation, is the best way to keep them at bay, away from directly exercising political power. Historically, progressive religious interpreters and liberation theologians have been defeated within their own religions.”

“Secularism — understood as separation between state and religions — is today’s best response to growing communalism in Europe and North America, as well as to the murderous armed Muslim organisations that want to impose theocracies and eradicate democracies. As imperfect as democracies are in Europe today, we need to fight for their survival in wake of the growing danger of seeing them replaced by theocracies, in the name of religious rights, cultural rights, minority rights, etc… Confront the erroneous idea of a ‘Muslim world.’ It exists no more than ‘the Christian world’ or ‘the Crusaders’ that Daesh pretends to destroy…”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1778: Zilan on Leaving Islam in Algeria, Women’s Rights, Religious Fundamentalism, Secularism, and Freethought

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/26

“According to what I have experienced here in Southern Algeria, I think that the core of religion is represented to the tribal bonds; it is the primitive system that gives the right to its entire members to determine. Your personal lifestyle interferes with your decisions, and if you try to refuse their interventions, or even objecting it, that means you refuse the judgments of ‘ALLAH’, which makes you a pariah of the tribe, and threatened by everyone.”

“I am from a fundamentalist Islamic family, living in southern Algeria. The environment here is similar to the environment of the Arabian Peninsula, where the Prophet ‘Muhammad’ grew up.”

“The majority here can speak Classical Arabic; they spend the first years of their lives in very rigorous ‘Quranic’ schools, and that’s what I’ve experienced like any girl who lives here; I was forced to wear the ‘hijab’ when I was ten years old, and before I study anything, they teach me the ‘Quran’ without any understanding.”

“At first I didn’t imagine I would abandon Islam, or even convert to another religion, Because of the indoctrination that similar to brainwashing; despite the physical abuse, when I refused to pray, and the imposition of the legitimate Islamic dress; Islamic religion for me was surrounded with an aura of holiness. I considered the Islamic religion as the ideal system to live, and my freedom is the price that I pay to buy a place in ‘JANNAH’ or paradise.”

“I spoke with some of them and this was the first shock, which made me wondered; is it normal for a human to assault others people in this way, only because God placed them in another family who didn’t share the same faith with him.”

“After that, I began to read ‘Quranic’ interpretations in an academic way, for the first time I discovered the horrible things that it contains. Then I just renounced the Islamic religion. Then I became non-religious.”

“Leaving religions is hard, for women in general, and Muslim women in particular, or at least we can say that men can leave their religion more easily than women in my country. Because the woman’s personal choices, her life and even her dress are all things that are governed by laws initiated by religion, and there is no way to gain her independence in this case, except to leave her society and try to escape to a society that respects her and treats her as a human being.”

“In every Friday sermon, you can hear direct incitement to Violence Against Women on the mosque’s loudspeakers, and everyone hears it without any objection.”

“The fundamentalist prefers relations of belief over the relations of blood and friendships they do not care if you are the closest person to them they can harm you, what matters is that you share their beliefs. It called the loyalty doctrine.”

“Once they have an income, they will be able to raise their voices and impose changes in the society. Financial independence creates a space for women to form bonds and friendships with other women have a deep knowledge of their rights and role as a woman who rejects religious extremism.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1778: Zilan on Leaving Islam in Algeria, Women’s Rights, Religious Fundamentalism, Secularism, and Freethought

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/26

“According to what I have experienced here in Southern Algeria, I think that the core of religion is represented to the tribal bonds; it is the primitive system that gives the right to its entire members to determine. Your personal lifestyle interferes with your decisions, and if you try to refuse their interventions, or even objecting it, that means you refuse the judgments of ‘ALLAH’, which makes you a pariah of the tribe, and threatened by everyone.”

“I am from a fundamentalist Islamic family, living in southern Algeria. The environment here is similar to the environment of the Arabian Peninsula, where the Prophet ‘Muhammad’ grew up.”

“The majority here can speak Classical Arabic; they spend the first years of their lives in very rigorous ‘Quranic’ schools, and that’s what I’ve experienced like any girl who lives here; I was forced to wear the ‘hijab’ when I was ten years old, and before I study anything, they teach me the ‘Quran’ without any understanding.”

“At first I didn’t imagine I would abandon Islam, or even convert to another religion, Because of the indoctrination that similar to brainwashing; despite the physical abuse, when I refused to pray, and the imposition of the legitimate Islamic dress; Islamic religion for me was surrounded with an aura of holiness. I considered the Islamic religion as the ideal system to live, and my freedom is the price that I pay to buy a place in ‘JANNAH’ or paradise.”

“I spoke with some of them and this was the first shock, which made me wondered; is it normal for a human to assault others people in this way, only because God placed them in another family who didn’t share the same faith with him.”

“After that, I began to read ‘Quranic’ interpretations in an academic way, for the first time I discovered the horrible things that it contains. Then I just renounced the Islamic religion. Then I became non-religious.”

“Leaving religions is hard, for women in general, and Muslim women in particular, or at least we can say that men can leave their religion more easily than women in my country. Because the woman’s personal choices, her life and even her dress are all things that are governed by laws initiated by religion, and there is no way to gain her independence in this case, except to leave her society and try to escape to a society that respects her and treats her as a human being.”

“In every Friday sermon, you can hear direct incitement to Violence Against Women on the mosque’s loudspeakers, and everyone hears it without any objection.”

“The fundamentalist prefers relations of belief over the relations of blood and friendships they do not care if you are the closest person to them they can harm you, what matters is that you share their beliefs. It called the loyalty doctrine.”

“Once they have an income, they will be able to raise their voices and impose changes in the society. Financial independence creates a space for women to form bonds and friendships with other women have a deep knowledge of their rights and role as a woman who rejects religious extremism.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1777: Abderrahmane M’hiri on Leaving Islam in Tunisia, Ex-Muslim Identity, Religious Doubt, Violence, and Freedom

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/23

“I have grown up in a Muslim country and society in a Muslim family.”

“I began to question since a young age ‘about 13-years-old.’”

“The first reason for me to leave Islam was the tremendous amount of violence and bloodthirst. The way the Quran treats the female gender. And then the scientific and historical mistakes that the Quran is crowded with.”

“The outcome was very devastating and the struggle started from there. I was taken by the police from the high school after one of the students told his family I was questioning God and his mother immediately informed the school supervisor.”

“Friends were mostly aggressive and in some cases it ended with violence.”

“And 2 years ago, I had faced a major aggression from a group of muslim extremist which resulted in my arm being broken.”

“Now, I am trying to seek asylum in Denmark, so I can at least breathe peacefully.”

“Any help to bring the story to the media in my case will be very important and I hope I can get the asylum here.”

“All ex-Muslims in my opinion should work together and unite so we can always make sure we can help one another.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1776: Nacer Amari on Atheism in Tunisia, Ex-Muslim Activism, Secularism, United Atheists of Europe, and Humanitarian Solidarity

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/23

“I grew up in a Berber family with Arab culture where parents are illiterate and not religious.”

“I started to have doubts about religion during the high school.”

“This is when I started thinking about the purpose of prayers and religion and the existence of God in general.”

“Then I completely lost my faith in God during the 10th class identifying myself as an atheist.”

“Karrar Al Asfoor and I founded this social fraternity when we noticed that there is a need to unify the efforts of atheists across Europe.”

“It is to bring the European atheists to work together with the ex-Muslim community for a secular world.”

“In the meantime, it is considered a small-sized social fraternity, but it’s open for every atheist who is interested to join.”

“Solidarity is more than charity — it includes trying to change the systems that produce suffering in the first place.”

“There is a lot of suffering in the world, none of us can do everything, but each of us can do one thing.”

“We can all be humanitarians in a world that needs them more than ever.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1775: Prosper Mutandadzi on Humanism in Zimbabwe, Atheism, Freethought, Religion, Media, Writing, and Filmmaking

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/22

“Throwing stones at 5-or-6-year-olds made me question how a representative of god could be that cruel.”

“I had also started reading novels a lot, especially investigative novels like the Hitchcock ones, the Hardy Boys, and even the Sherlock Holmes books (despite the author being religious). This gave me a questioning mind at a tender age.”

“So around 11 years, I was no longer religious, but was still being forced to attend church. I did not know about atheism. I did not know of any grown-up who was, so it was like a lone battle. I had no one to confide with.”

“You are usually the easiest target if you are the only one without religion. A lot of people do not want to associate with you at your workplace. You are bullied. You are called names and the popular ones being Satanist and Illuminati.”

“You are considered an unwanted pimple if nonreligious. In fact, some job adverts can be as segregatory with wordings like a Christian person wanted. Or it’s a Christian environment.”

“Zimbabwe and Zimbabweans are highly religious. You get more respect, friends, love, and trust if you are religious; I, thus, doubt an atheist can be voted for if he or she is open about his or her affiliation (non-)religious wise.”

“Most religions are anti-women in Zimbabwe. Yet, ironically the biggest followers are women. This is both in traditional religion, and in Christianity and Islam.”

“Getting a foothold in the media would be a great accomplishment.”

“I have not met an author who writes on atheism in Zimbabwe or Africa as yet. I am trying to be one myself pioneering that.”

“The Humanist Community in Zimbabwe just needs a small opening, and they will be a force to reckon with. I know a lot of people who are willing to give humanists a chance, but do not have many details about it. So finding a way of highlighting our issues to the public will go a long way.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1774: Shingai Rukwata Ndoro on Humanism in Zimbabwe, Non-Theism, Secularism, Religion, and the Humanist Society of Zimbabwe

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/22

“There are no credible statistics available except those by the Christians to project a majoritarian representation of themselves.”

“From an ordinary assessment, Christians are their majority.”

“We have tended to avoid politics among the community of non-theists because it has been one of the major divisive matters.”

“This is because we are split right in the middle between right and left ideas and between pro-government and anti-government sentiments.”

“Very strongly tied. Conservative views are actually the default positions of most of those who are religious.”

“As an addition, there are many non-theists whom we know within our community who are closet due to social exclusion and economic vulnerability.”

“I’m not sure if we remove socialisation about religion and if we go into the psychology of the religious texts and the principals figures therein, one can find positives about religion in this country or any country.”

“Despite Zimbabwe being a secular republic and a constitutional democracy, there is too much influence of the religious in the political system.”

“This arose from the colonial privileges and advantages for Christianity that have remained protected and defended.”

“Before that locals had their own ceremonies, traditions and rituals that were then declared by Christian missionaries as evil and inspired by a devil.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1773: Kiketha Baluku Tadeo on Secularism in Uganda, Kyangende Secular Services, Freethought, Education, and Grassroots Activism

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/21

“Through personal intelligence, reason that help me to find solutions to my problems. I was too much determined and used to seeing things in their real sense and suggest the right measures available with me.”

“Abrimac Secular Services, Kasese Humanist Schools and Pearls Vocational Institute are the institutions that talk about secularism and working for humanistic life.”

“Secularism is still being defined and introduced as it facing a lot of religious barriers and much indoctrinations and high levels of superstition and they turn and miss inform the public by announcing us evil people in order to create fear however the due to the efforts evidenced by doing in communities in looked as good pavement and bring good change.”

“Secular activism is done in areas of education, promoting culture, supporting good politics, improving health of the people, supporting good economic systems that can transform people’s lives including capacity building.”

“I form the Kyangende secular community and I started helping people with food, mosquito nets and drugs, give clothes to children.”

“Currently activism all about reaching the grass root and identify the real situation faced by the locals in their communities explaining the reason and giving strategies having turning local communities better homes for all people to live joyfully.”

“We have Kato Mukasa who is a lawyer, Bwambale Robert, and Masereka Solomon, Director Abrimac Secular Services.”

“People can participate in our activities by volunteering in our community activities, coordinating us to international partners and organizations that work toward promoting goo humanity through our Kyangende secular services Facebook pages, groups and Abrimac page or website.”

“Writing good and publishing articles about our secular activities on Facebook and other sites that can help people identify our motives.”

“I wish that all organizations and individuals doing secularism work in Uganda be trustworthy and be good examples to the public so that we shouldn’t be regard as evil people and this will enable all communities understand our vision.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1772: Susan Nambejja on Humanism in Uganda, HALEA, UHASSO, Humanist Celebrancy, Women’s Rights, and Children’s Health

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/21

“Being a humanist charity, I got to know much about humanism and embraced it.”

“In the end, they lose their lives.”

“Should children with life-threatening congenital diseases be left to die?”

“We thank you, our supporters, for helping us.”

“Is it a crime to be poor?”

“Non religious are still very few.”

“In our non religious communities encourage women to get involved and aspire for or stand for leadership positions.”

“I hope my work will enable me to save children’s lives.”

“I will rejoice to see children living a healthy happy life.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1771: Kato Mukasa on Humanism in Uganda, Leaving Atheism for Humanism, HALEA, Critical Thinking, and Secular Activism

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/19

“By the time I joined secondary school I was questioning much about the God theories and believing more in employing my reasoning, research, and science in answering things that looked difficult to understand.”

“It was then that he explained Humanism in details that I then discovered that even when I had been taking myself as an atheist for some time then, I was equally a humanist too and somewhat I loved the idea and methodology behind humanism and the works done by humanists even more.”

“I began researching and finding out more about humanism that by end of 2001 I had noted there was already one humanist organisation in Uganda, the Uganda Humanists Association (UHASSO) which I later associated with and in 2007 found the Humanists Association for Leadership, Equity and Accountability (HALEA).”

“Those who do not believe in gods/ God but want to be doing works that empower the vulnerable, promote human rights and challenge retrogressive religious and cultural practices find it appropriate to label themselves as Humanists.”

“It was nice to know that there were more other people with whom we share the same world view. It made me know that I am not alone and indeed I have a family of critical thinkers I can associate with.”

“The lessons are many but they all boil down to one thing in my view: that my skills and education is useless if I do not put it to serve my passion. My passion is in empowering others to discover the potential in them and to empower the most vulnerable and powerless individuals in our communities.”

“Humanism is beyond critiquing religions and its dogma. It goes into changing people’s lives for the better and putting people first in whatever do.”

“It is important to identify freethinkers in countries where organised humanism is missing. Then it is at that stage that need to come up and support them get organised and support them start organisations that can have an impact in society.”

“The damaging effects can only be ameliorated by promoting critical thinking and getting more freethinkers to challenge the ills that comes with religion. Humanism must learn that religious people are able to rally together because they’re convinced in whatever they believe in. It is vital that humanists are well grounded in their own world view and be able to share it with the world from an informed view point.”

“Humanism is the best world view that all humans should be embracing if we re to live in a more rational, happy and free world. Humanists must dare to stand up and be counted wherever they are, we must avoid playing second fiddle to religions and endeavour to champion causes that make the gods obsessed people see the relevancy in being humanists.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1770: Violine Namyalo on Humanism in Uganda, Freethought, Religion, Critical Thinking, and the IHEYO African Working Group

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/19

“No, irreligion was not part of my family life growing up.”

“These debates had topics that triggered my mind to start reasoning critically about issues I had taken as absolutely true without questioning.”

“I become an explicit humanist in 2012 after reading more about humanism and also getting involved in public debates that HAELA always conducted.”

“My humanist hero is Kato Mukasa.”

“These books greatly shaped my thinking, they confirmed to me that one can be good without a god.”

“We have several humanists’ schools and active secular movements.”

“The modern religion came with the Christian missionaries in the 1870s and the Arab traders.”

“In addition, the high level of indoctrination is another reason why religion is so powerful in Uganda and throughout the world.”

“The need to put more effort in promoting free thinking.”

“I see humanism with a great future.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1769: Masereka Solomon on Humanism in Uganda, Abrimac Secular Services, Freethought, Education, and Critical Thinking

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/17

“I find humanism a better definition for life and always have continued to encourage my community to consider humanism as a lifestyle. It’s the best way we can have peace in our communities.”

“I personally believe the young generations picks from what the elders do, as a humanist I believe we make communities and our existence will cause the existence of others only if we accept to use wisdom than getting trapped into the ignorance of failed legacy and identity.”

“Humanists are meant to be good people, people who believe that they’re the source of the solutions to problems, they’re people who wish for a better world than they found.”

“Kasese Freethinkers Club was a club founded by people who want to honestly define humanism for people to buy such a good argument that respects human intelligence, we consider giving realistic efforts as opposed to just talking.”

“For humanism to progress, there’s need to uplift the well being of these people and as a club now a Company we want to see well off people not just happy people who can’t even afford common life basics.”

“We found it wise to operate as a company to help communities change their mindsets through our different projects, which are not influenced by religious beliefs but aimed at created well off communities.”

“We give secular services, services that are very basic to everyone whether rich or poor, we don’t promise prayers, we give what is missing in peoples lives, we give charity and teach.”

“Secularism is not promotion of immoral acts, secularism is using the human brain to find solutions and making this world a better place — humanism is what secular activism requires.”

“Secular activism is not fighting with the religious follows — secularism and humanism is about doing what is right because it’s right from a mature mind.”

“We continue to do more activism in our communities aimed at improving people’s minds positively. We are activists of humanism which defines life better.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1768: Alex Kofi Donkor on Humanism in Ghana, Leaving the Church, LGBT Rights, and Human Rights Advocacy

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/17

“One of the key things from the videos and the documentaries was that homosexuality is another sexual orientation. It is not going to go away. It is a sexual feeling, which will stay. If you are gay, be yourself and live your life, or deny yourself and go the way of society and try to appeal the way of society for the rest of your life, it is always an individual decision but the tendencies will never go away.”

“At that time, I began to face reality. I began to work gradually towards accepting myself. But, I was still holding church positions. And gradually I began to move away from church because I felt like I do not want to contradict my sexuality and religion.”

“There were a lot of people, like me. So, gradually, I begin to pull out of the church. In 2017, I finally decided, ‘I am not going to suffer this church again,’ especially so much toxic rhetoric that is discriminatory and subjects others to disrepute, violence, and abuse.”

“I was like, ‘I want to understand who I am and the course that I want to take in life.’ There are so many injustices going on. There is a need to talk about such issues, and let people know about such injustices and abuses that others are going through.”

“Around the same time, I identified as a humanist and then as an activist (LGBT activist), and a human rights advocate. So, I then began to work towards this identification and how best I can help through those identities created by me.”

“Then again, one of the reasons for pulling out of the church. I went through some of the conversations and teachings, and preachings, in the church. It was lacking in terms of basic logic and basic critical thinking. It did not make much sense.”

“Something that does not make much sense to me. Why should I still involve myself in it? [Laughing] I pulled out, finally, from a church in 2017.”

“Humanism is, basically, looking at the very basis of humans with rights, dignity, respect, and wellbeing, as well as critical thinking and analysis of everything that one is exposed to.”

“If a person is coming to ask you to look at issues critically and to look at things from the human rights perspective, it is an amazing way to get people to debunk some of the notions from religions and its sentiments.”

“One thing that really scares me is silence. Silence scares me a lot, especially on issues where everyone is quiet about it. We all speak from our common places. The simple places where we highlight human rights and LGBT issues.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1767: Cleopatra Yvonne S. Nyahe on Humanism in Ghana, Humanist Services Corps, Witch Camps, and Sustainable Development

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/15

“I realized there is a need to get more Ghanaians involved in this aspect of the countries development. I wanted to show my people that the face of change and development doesn’t always have to be a foreign one. That we too are capable of helping people to achieve positive change.”

“I enjoy the interactions I have with members of the local communities here in the North. I enjoy the reactions people have when they realise I am actually not one of the volunteers (which is always peoples first assumption).”

“I enjoy talking about how succeeding in your work does not depend on the colour of your skin, level of education, what kind of economic or social background you come from. Your passion and perseverance are what matters the most and that the reason for my success is that I truly care about the work we do here.”

“People from the humanist community agree with our philosophy and methods of working; the idea that we want to empower people with the right skills and tools to be the face of their own change instead of coming in and doing everything ourselves.”

“We want to leave people with sustainable skills and ways to achieve long term positive change.”

“That’s why the work we do requires a lot of patience and open mindedness. You have to understand why someone who is disadvantaged would want to fix their problems quickly.”

“We differ from other service groups because we focus on providing skills, tools, and knowledge. It’s the same concept of, Give a man a fish and you feed him for a day; Teach a man to fish and you feed him for lifetime.”

“Our main goal is to provide something that will last these communities a lifetime. Long term change is our main focus. Not to say that short term goals are not important but, we want the short term goals to line with our long term ones.”

“This story really touched me because you often hear stories of neighbours, co wives and aunts and uncles accusing women of witchcraft but this woman’s own son did this to her in the same moment she lost her other son. She lost both sons on the very same day.”

“I hope to see the humanist platform grow in the next few years. I want the term Humanist to be a common term known to more people. Specifically speaking, I want more Ghanaians to know about the concept of Humanism.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1766: Kwaku Adusei on Humanism in Ghana, Leaving Religion, Critical Thinking, and the Common Sense Foundation

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/15

“The more I read the Bible, I thought, ‘This isn’t making sense. Why don’t I go and get other books?’ So I started reading the Bhagavad Gita. The holy book of the Hindu people. I read books of logic. I thought, ‘These books aren’t making sense as far as logic is concerned.’ Then I started making the transition from the religious life to the humanistic life.”

“When there are more religious people, you have more poverty. The more people become religious, the more they become poor. So something is missing.”

“I started reading Richard Dawkins, The Selfish Gene. I read Christ Conspiracy. I read Historical Jesus and the Mythical Christ. After reading all of these books, I thought, ‘This thing we call God is nothing but something designed to deceive or enslave the masses. So that is what took me away from the religious life.’”

“My family and my loved ones, they all neglected me. I said, ‘No, I still have to be strong and live my life.’ So every day I make sure I read my logic books and anything that has to do with science. Unless, it can be scientifically proven, then I will not believe it.”

“In 2002, I became a full atheist. That’s where I started moving into atheism. After atheism, I thought, ‘I need a step forward.’”

“In 2010, I found 4 people who were also like me. We would get together on a weekly basis to discuss humanist ideas to make sure we make a meaningful life for ourselves without adherence to supernatural forces or higher powers.”

“When I formed the humanist group with Roslyn, I figured, ‘We cannot hide in the darkness. There are people outside will to hear from us. So why don’t we go outside?’”

“As I talk to you, I have 59 members on my platform, where we interact each and every day on humanist ideas to get more people involved.”

“Our main target is the youth because the youth are more open to information. The youth have now come to realize that religion is killing people. Religion is dehumanizing people. Religion is making people slaves. The youth have the mindset, but they don’t have the courage to come out of that mess.”

“The Common Sense Foundation is there to give them the information that they need, to help encourage them to live their lives, and can do whatever they want to do without adhering to any spiritual forces.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1765: Moninuola Komolafe on Leaving Christianity and Nonbelief in Nigeria

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/14

“Religion was a major part of my family especially because my father owns a church. I began participating in three-day fasts, revivals, and vigils when I was barely eight years old.”

“Occasionally, I had doubts but the turning point came at an outreach my church organized sometime in 2012. About eight of us laid hands on this madman on the street. He appeared healed and we had a crowd behind us chanting and praising Jesus but looking at him, I didn’t think he was healed. We later realized this and two of us shipped him out of that community so that our ministry activities could continue because we knew people would question the message if they saw the man we healed roaming the streets. That raised questions that I just couldn’t push aside. Why wasn’t he healed? Why wouldn’t god heal him and convert unbelievers? Are miracles real? If miracles aren’t real, isn’t the bible just an ordinary book? Can the book be trusted?”

“I followed this questions and when I got my answers, I realized I no longer believed the Bible and its message.”

“Religion influenced impacted almost every aspect of our lives, from proscriptions against alcohol to relationships between people of different religions, to dictating how women should dress and how homes should be run, even sexual relations between unmarried people. It also played a major role on law-making with lawmakers refusing to pass laws on issues where their religious books had opposing views. Today, the influence remains but no longer has a stronghold because people are asking questions and are coming to the realization that times are changing and that some of those practices should become obsolete.”

“The truth, however, is that we do not apply faith to everything. We conduct investigations before moving to new locations. We check if the place is not constantly robbed if there’s constant power supply. We immunize our kids too and not rely on supernatural protection. Why not something that impacts our lives as much as religion?”

“For those that came out of my kind of setting, the absence of evidence to support the miraculous claims of the bible was a push for them. For others, it was the ridiculous stories of the bible and the disparities with our reality.” in-sightpublishing.com

“Growing but largely closed because the consequences can be severe for some. I have a number of young unbelievers who are feigning faith so they can have a roof over their heads or continue to enjoy their parent’s financial support. However, with online communities, both the openly irreligious and the anonymous ones have a breathing space.”

“Religion is infused into almost every aspect of the Nigerian society and has been a hindrance in fighting issues such as inequality. How do you make laws that establish equality between the sexes when the lawmakers believe that women are not equal to men because their religious books teach that the man is the head and the woman is to submit to the man? How do you protect young girls from underage marriage when you have Muslim lawmakers who can wave their religious books and claim divine permission for such? Gay marriage is also forbidden on the same grounds.”

“With regards to elections, all a politician needs is to get the support of a major church leader and he can secure their votes. The question of his competency or suitability is discarded because a certain general overseer has approved him. Religion is everywhere and it is a menace that needs to be checked.”

“We need to bring up more discussions about religion both online and offline, establish forums where religion is questioned. I am part of a Whatsapp group called Believers and Skeptics where we have members invite religious people and skeptics alike to ‘defend’ their beliefs. We have had a few religious people leave their faiths based on group discussions. I believe that having similar groups spring up will definitely play some role in reducing religiosity.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1764: Bamidele Adeneye on Atheism and Death Threats in Nigeria

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/14

“Well, it all started in 2014 when I had a video interview challenging miracle healers and pastors in my country, Nigeria. I didn’t even know the video would be aired on TV. Then the calls started coming in. I even noticed that friends and people I did business with started avoiding me.”

“Then I had to rescue a gentleman from death in Kano because he denounced Islam and his family were going to hurt him. That made me famous to not just Christians but Muslims as the face of atheism in Nigeria.”

“My phone number was listed on my social media account and I guess that’s where they got my number from. I would receive calls from strangers saying things like they were going to kill me.”

“Online messages promising to ‘show’ me. It was a very disturbing experience. I became paranoid because it’s Nigeria. I am surrounded by people who see me as an agent of the devil, even relatives. I lost friends as well. Because of the situation, I had to change my daughter’s school.”

“There are quite a number of them. I was as recently as July physically attacked by a group of strangers while I was trying to get back to my car. They called my social media name and when I mistakenly answered, I was attacked. They kept saying I’m the agent of the devil all the while they were beating on me. I had to escape. I was so afraid.”

“It became difficult to live as a family as we couldn’t go out together in public anymore. We spent our holidays at home most of the time because I was afraid of potential attacks on us.”

“Definitely. It became necessary to stay away from my home and my family. I took long breaks away from home for peace of mind. I had to create a space between myself and my loved ones for security reasons.”

“My younger brother who looks exactly like me has been targeted as well. He had to deactivate his social media account because of backlash from people who thought he was me.”

“I took trips to the UK to see my family and friends. It felt normal being an unbeliever there. I also went to the USA where I met those who were exactly like the ones back home.”

“Although, unlike Nigeria where you’re judged even at work by your religious beliefs or otherwise, you’re protected by law somewhat by the law in the USA.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1763: Bayo Opadeyi on Leaving Religion and Becoming an Atheist in Nigeria

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/13

“Religion was very important in our home growing up, Catholicism especially. Though my father came from an Anglican/Baptist family, he wasn’t much into church going when we were young, and so my mother a staunch Catholic was responsible for our religious education.”

“The Nigerian society is made up of mostly Christians and Muslims, with some who still practice our traditional religions. It would have shocked me as a 10-year-old to hear from someone that there were no gods. A lot of the stories we heard were packed with the supernatural.”

“Looking at my childhood and my then firm belief in the teachings of the ‘church’, I can empathize with religious people I meet today and understand their visceral reaction when they hear for the first time that some people believe there are no gods. My religious upbringing, I think, has given me that.”

“The seeds of disbelief for me started when I was in my teens and in the middle of an ‘evangelical’ phase. I decided to read the bible from cover to cover but had to pause when I got to 1 Samuel, the story of Saul and his army going to kill all the Amalekites.”

“My 15 yr. old’s sensibilities were shocked by the morality of killing children and animals just because, I could not understand how the ‘loving’ god I worshipped would want this, and so I asked older people what they thought.”

“They just beat about the bush and tried unsuccessfully to explain it away. And that was when I realized that the people whom I assumed understood the ‘faith’ were more or less like myself. So why would I accept their views blindly? I started to read the Bible with a pinch of salt from that moment.”

“Another important point was during a vacation we spent with our grandparents, I was going through their library and came across a book by Winwood Reade ‘The Martyrdom of Man’ where he talked about the history of religion.”

“This was the first time I was seeing religion being talked about from a secular, irreverent point of view. And from that moment I was on my way for another 20 years to call myself an atheist.”

“I think religion encourages a lot of harmful practices. In the North (of Nigeria), free-speech is often met with mob action that sometimes leads to death or serious injury. Women’s rights being trampled upon because some religious book says so.”

“In the South, old women are assaulted on accusations of witchcraft, Mega-church pastors milk their congregation on promises of ‘divine favor’, and people fall into this ‘magical thinking’ mindset that is not very useful for solving problems and planning long-term.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1762: Abdurrahman Aliyu on Freethought and Critical Thinking in Nigeria

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/13

“Yes, religion was a very big and vital part of my early life, I don’t see how it couldn’t have been, having been born into an Islamic scholar’s home.”

“The community I grew up is strongly influenced by religion, mostly because of the religious preaching center’s campaign that is increasingly and rapidly growing by the day.”

“As far as I can tell, curiosity. Let me explain what I mean by curiosity; I think part of the reason why primitive humans came up with the concept of God is that they had many questions.”

“On the other hand, free thinking and nonreligious groups are very curious entities; they are trying to understand the world, humans place in it, their well being, and then striving to make it a better place using the most advanced scientific methods, proven by research.”

“So you see, in a nutshell, religion is born out of the curiosity of a very primitive, ignorant and ancient society. While freethinking groups are born out of the curiosity of an advanced society, a society that has knowledgeable elements and access to science.”

“Logic, reason and rationality; nonreligious people don’t require you to have faith without evidence or to unquestioningly follow some supreme power. They only care about scientific facts about the universe, logical arguments on issues and above all, they back up claims with evidence and insist that others do so too.”

“Unity; Religious groups only campaign for unity inasmuch as you are in line with their belief system and accept all of their dogma unquestioningly. But nonreligious groups, see all of us as human and as one single entity.”

“For instance, gays are being persecuted, even killed by some religious groups. But we freethinkers understand that gays do not determine their sexuality themselves, hence we see them as our equals, deserving of the same respect as anyone else.”

“It most assuredly does. Very well too. Science is arguably the most elegant and useful concept ever devised by humanity.”

“It gives you facts, evidence, proofs, and theories. A significant difference with religious thinking is that it is inherently antiauthoritarian. It is based upon skepticism and welcomes challenges and questions.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1761: Chiedozie Uwakwe on Leaving Religion Among Nigerian Youth

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/09

“I would say the irreligious culture in Nigeria is not lively at all. Nigeria is a very religious country, including the traditional religions before the arrival of Christianity and Islam, The concept of someone being irreligious is foreign to them, it’s a taboo.”

“Because of this, the irreligious are treated badly with a lot of discrimination by family members and friends, leading to so many irreligious people hiding their lack of belief or ‘staying in the closet’.”

“Being irreligious in Nigeria has been compared to being gay in Saudi Arabia. It is that bad. But due to increased social campaigns, the future looks bright for us.”

“It can get lonely for the irreligious youth in Nigeria because, you dont know how tolerant your immediate neighbours are to your views, so a lot of of opinions aren’t voiced for fear pf verbal or physical attacks.”

“Recently, support networks have been springing up, on twitter, whatsapp and Telegram groups, internet forums.”

“We also have organizations like the Atheist Society of Nigeria and Humanist Assemblies. They help out when they can to support the growing number of the irreligious.”

“It depends on how religious the family is and if the youth is financially dependent on the family. Largely, it leads to a lot of angry words and emotional blackmail.”

“The family and the society see them as rascals and good-for-nothing individuals. Dredges of the society as it were.”

“They can disown the youth because the family wouldn’t want to have anything to do with a social outcast.”

“I think the erosion of religion would lead to people finally taking responsibility for their lives, knowing that they alone are largely responsible for whatever they make out of their lives and not giving themselves a sense of false hope that religion offers.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1760: Isaiah Akorita on Atheism in Nigeria: Belief and Stigma

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/09

“I wouldn’t say it was a single day. I was raised in a kind of liberal Christian home and although church attendance was strongly encouraged, I wouldn’t say my family was really fanatic about Christianity.”

“I started having doubts in my University, late 2011 and early 2012. By the middle of 2012, I was sure I didn’t believe any of those things again but I kept going to church for the music. I love classical/opera music.”

“Funny enough, a mixture of indifference and mild alarm. While my brothers were basically indifferent and broached the subject as a matter of curiosity, my sisters were initially a bit alarmed.”

“Obviously, they thought I had become this evil somebody or that university has corrupted me. But they eventually came around when they realised I was still the cool and quiet brother they always knew.”

“It depends on the geographical location. In the mostly Christian south, I’d say most people see atheists as confused people or rebellious sinners who are looking for an excuse to sin without guilt. Some think we have no morals and can’t possibly tell good from evil.”

“In the Muslim north though, atheists are viewed as the literal spawn of Satan. You could be seriously harmed for daring to come out as an atheist there.”

“In order of severity, I’d say Politicians, Corruption and Religion. And no, they’re not aligned. Most ordinary Nigerians are incredibly obtuse when it comes to identifying our real problems.”

“I’ve always been outspoken about my atheism on social media and offline too. Because of that, I have met plenty atheists both online and offline and it was only a natural progression that I’d be a part of the movement in whatever form it is shaping up to be.”

“I head the media campaign team. I’m in charge of the group of volunteers tasked with publicising the activities of the organisation on various social media platforms and news media.”

“I think public debates, radio and TV appearances will go a long way into educating the public on atheism in Nigeria.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1759: Nandip Andrew on Atheism, Humanism, and Religious Discrimination in Nigeria

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/06

“…people are really coming out to identify with humanism, but the humanist organization at the national level is very weak. I wish to encourage the various chapters to keep propagating humanism, freethought and critical thinking.”

“The biggest threat to the practice of humanism in Nigeria is fear… in fact fear causes members not to show themselves physically, but on the social media, members at the comfort of their homes, in their rooms express their disbelief, but call up a meeting or conference only few would attend.”

“…another aspect again is discriminations, when the community or society a humanist member is leaving, people tend to look at the member as dangerous or some kind of an immoral person, sometimes led to physical attack.”

“My personal hero is Dr Tunde Arogundade, is my former part time lecturer, he helped me out in the late 2009 into the light of humanism from the darkness of dogma, provide books from his private library, books on atheism/humanism, the other person is Dr Leo Igwe, his commitment in the propagation of humanism in Nigeria and Africa as at large.”

“…in my office i am identify as an atheist, in my home life i am call an atheist, in my local community i am call an atheist, my wife was nickname ‘MATA BA ALLAH’ in Hausa language, (meaning MATA is wife, BA no, ALLAH god. a wife of a person that don’t believe in God). I feel very comfortable to identify as an atheist.”

“A good humanist, is one that does not discriminate based on religion or race, a good humanist is a peace loving person, a good humanist tries to make the world better and safer place for us to leave and our children, because this is the only place we got”

“Some positives aspect of religion is allowing me to know the truth, through the reading of the bible and it led to my freedom. is very good that every humanist should study or read others religious books.”

“There hope for the growth of humanism in Nigeria for the next 10 years, if only the majority of youths in Nigeria who are humanist should remove fear and replace it with courage.”

“we have started seeing that happening, if it continues Nigeria will leave Uganda and Ghana far behind in 10 years to come, but i know they too will make sure they are not left behind.”

“My final feeling is being unhappy that others like me in the Nigerian Humanist Movement have not made any impacts for the past few years. Hopefully, we will make sure we try our best.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1758: Adeyemi Ademowo Johnson on Humanism, Freethought, and Critical Thinking in Nigeria

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/06

“Freethought is still unpopular in Nigeria; although there are so many youngsters who doubt their beliefs, they have not muster sufficient courage to openly express their admiration for freethought and desire to treat religion with caution.”

“Yes! I definitely believe that the younger generation will realize that it is foolish to kill in the name of any faith or any God and that all we have are one another as humans.”

“Yes! The University where I teach, Afe Babalola University, Ado-Ekiti, prioritizes entrepreneurial skills development; this makes it imperative for many of the students to offer courses in critical thinking and creative thinking. I, for instance, developed and teach a course: Sociology of Creativity and Innovation. Critical Thinking is an integral part of the course. There are other courses that encourage critical thinking to satisfy its outlines.”

“There are two of them: religion and active citizenship. In religion, indoctrination of the young ones, Boko Haram recruitment of children/women as suicide bombers and the brazen display of wealth by Pentecostal pastors are issues that have dominated academic discourses. The importance of citizens in democratic governance and their attitudes towards tackling corruption are other issues. These are issues at the heart of sociological discourses from diverse angles.”

“Religion and religious leaders have a place in our political landscape. Aspirants lay claims to being ordained or ‘called’ by God to contest for elections to get favours; they also attend big Pentecostal revivals and crusades to show their loyalty to and believe in religion. Humanists are rarely taken serious and sometimes demonized when they should interest in politics or to contest.”

“Humanist Association for Peace and Social Tolerance Advancement (HAPSTA) is the first Humanist association to be registered formally by the Nigerian Corporate Affairs Commission. I am one of the driving forces that worked relentlessly for this as the President.”

“I later became the Projects Director in charge of HAPSTA life changing projects like ‘Humanist Against WitchKilling in Africa’, Stigmatized Children Rights Project (SCRIP), Omuo Humanist Against WitchKilling and Stigmatization’, Humanist Anti-Indoctrination Project (HApI) and Youth Leadership and Tolerance Training Project. I work to manage and raise funds for these projects which have been funded in the past by HAMU, Norway; Swedish Humanist Aid, Africa Unite Against Child Abuse (AFRUCA, UK). I also coordinate the international links for the organisation. As a member of HAPSTA Board of Trustees, I represent it at fora and work with others to coordinate its activities.”

“Let me start by appreciating the Norwegian Humanist Association and the Swedish Humanists, they have really supported financially and human capital development in the past years. Other well-established groups can get in touch with us for supports: funding of our ‘Anti-Indoctrination’ Campaign handbills; annual social tolerance leadership training for youths, invitation to attend humanist programmes; support for website hosting, etc. We would really appreciate supports that would strengthens the group more.”

“Having been a humanist for about 18 years; a university teacher for over a decade and worked with a lots of children and women stigmatized as witches, I am convinced that the world needs humanism and critical thinking. Hence, I would be happy to work with any Humanist Foundation and initiatives that will promote its humanist ideals in Africa and other continents.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1757: James-Adeyinka Shorungbe on Humanism and Critical Thinking in Nigeria

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/04

“Essentially, organizing the affairs of the organisation, charting annual programs to promote critical thinking in Lagos (Nigeria), maintaining relationships with other organizations such as IHEU, IHEYO, NHM. HAL is also a founding member body of the humanist movement in Nigeria so I actively involved in that regard.”

“First, Nigeria is a society highly entrenched in superstition. So that is a major, impediment, to promoting critical thinking. In order to address that, education and awareness has to be done. While the Government is trying to improve the literacy level from its current level of just under 60%, a number topics that promote critical thinking are not being taught in schools.”

“As a major impediment, superstition is a big, big problem. To address this, not enough of our message is getting out there. To be honest, I don’t think we’re doing enough to get our message out there in terms of awareness and enlightenment. We have barely scratched the surface in terms of addressing superstition in Nigeria.”

“The few people who we have interacted with, they generally do not understand humanism or humanists. Their perception is anything that doesn’t recognize any divine being is straight evil, paganism, evildoers, etc. People we’ve had interactions with, often ask shocking ‘So you mean you don’t believe in God?’”

“When you try to get across the message that human problems and human situations can be solved by humans and are best solved by human efforts, we always get push backs, ‘No, no, no, you need to have divine intervention.’”

“Because Nigeria is a very conservative society and a lot of people do not openly identify as humanists, atheists, and freethinkers, agnostics, etc it is a bit difficult to count. Many official forms and data gathering application usually only have the two main faiths as beliefs. However, when you go to online forums, when you go on social media, there are quite a lot of Nigerians who express them as nonbelievers.”

“Yes, definitely, it is. With an umbrella body, you have a louder voice. You have more clout. That is one of the reasons why in Nigeria a number of associations we are all coming under the umbrella of the national body ‘Nigerian Humanist Movement’. Aside from the online community of The Nigerian Atheists and a couple of chat groups, we are still fragmented in Nigeria.”

“The Humanist Assembly of Lagos is one of 2 organizations that is formally registered and trying to break barriers and putting the voice out there for other humanists to appreciate they are not alone. That you can be different. That you can be good without any divine belief. The importance of having an umbrella body is very critical.”

“For the future, we will be looking to organise events that can showcase and promote humanism as well as critical thinking. Events such as film screenings, lectures, debates etc. Are also toying with the ideal of a radio show to enlighten the general public and kick start discussions the public space. A radio where speakers would come on and talk essentially, about everyday human issues and how these can be addressed without thinking they are caused by divine or superstitious means.”

“Just essentially, enlighten the public that various challenges one has in life can be addressed by practical action, which do not require divine intervention.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1756: Zachiam Bayei on Atheism, Family, and Secularism in Nigeria

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/04

“I am from a conservative Christian family. I became an Atheist long before having a University education. I was a skeptic long before I became economically independent from my parents.”

“Yes, while growing up, religion plays and still played a major role in my educational journey. In primary school, we were forced to pray during assembly time. A similar scenario plays out during my secondary education too. But at the university, it gives you wings. Nobody forces you to do such primitive rituals.”

“I already knew what I wanted for myself long before heading into University. I did not find atheists there. However, I found other schoolmates who held irreligious views about Abrahamic faiths. Social media actually gives me a voice to connect with atheists all around the world. I am so grateful for the technology of building bridges all across the world.”

“Moses was said to have written some books in the Bible, how come the same man recorded his death? But when I raised these observations to clergymen and Jesus-fans who often engage me in debates, they often shy away from them.”

“My atheism has personally made me freer and open to learning. But it has further alienated me and my family from other religious families My wife is a Christian. We define our differences and still stay together.”

“My religious colleagues are aware of my stance on religions, but I try as much as possible to avoid religious debates with them. I just work and go home.”

“The impact is enormous. Atheists like Christopher Hitchens, Richard Dawkins, Sam Harris, Ayaan Hirsi Ali, etc., have impacted positively on the Nigerian atheists’ community. We often draw inspiration from their quotes and share on social media.”

“The Northern part of Nigeria is more intolerant towards atheists because of their fanatical stances towards Abrahamic religions (Christianity & Islam). Many atheists I know from the north have to take on pseudonyms and identities on social media just to play safe. That is how bad it is in northern Nigeria, but the South, which is more advanced in education, has a liberal outlook towards atheists.”

“The best way I think people can live a secular life in Nigeria is by separating the state from religion in our constitution. Religion has no basis in our constitution, but the political merchants are refusing to amend the Constitution because they often reap political capital from it.”

“Religion should be separated from state institutions. This is destroying the quality of service delivery. Critical thinking and inquiry should be encouraged in public schools. It will create doubts in the minds of the students and people about all they have been taught to believe.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1755: Ben Osondu Uduka on Leaving Christianity and Atheism in Nigeria

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/03

“I grew up in a strong Methodist family. So, I was indoctrinated at a very tender age.”

“There were times I wished not to grow because I wouldn’t want to be stained with the sins of adulthood. And the Bible had tipped children to be the ideal group to inherit the kingdom of God.”

“I developed this feeling of unconscious discrimination against those who belong to other denominations. And was meant to hate the Traditionalists — we were not even allowed to enter their compounds or play with their children.”

“On the negative, I automatically became a perfectionist due to the stories and commandments learned in the bible. My brother made it worse, as I became too critical of my actions. And I struggled all through childhood to keep all the rules.”

“My life was filled with fears. Fears of darkness, fears of demonic spirits, fear of hellfire, fear of death, fear of God’s punishment, I was deprived of childhood luxuries. I never had time to celebrate festive days as we spent those days fasting and praying.”

“When I left for college, I had the opportunity of attending a Catholic mass service and realized they were not as evil as I was made to believe. They were just worshipping God in a different way.”

“I attended for a few days and vowed never to attend. I started listening to Jehovah’s Witnesses and the Grail message. When I got a job, it was obvious that my brother or parents won’t compel me to go to church again and I had left home, so I formally stopped.”

“He wrote things. I thought God could have killed him, so I became encouraged to talk about being a freethinker in selected publics. When I found out that I’m an Agnostic Atheist, I went online to look for Nigerians who share similar ideas, and I got Mubarak Bala, who linked me to others.”

“Extremists in Nigeria could lynch an atheist. At work, I’ve been forced to lead in an opening prayer. People got discriminated on the basis of their lack of belief, and there are limited opportunities for training and career. Clients may keep on shoving their beliefs on atheists.”

“The risks are those outlined above. The best way is to start as closeted until one becomes financially independent. They could also choose not to work in institutions with strong religious attachments. They should stop abusing God or other people’s religion in public.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1754: Vahyala Kwaga on Atheism, Religious Politics, and Leaving Religion in Nigeria

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/10/03

“Well, I have been a skeptic for quite some time and this may have been due to a level of intellectual honesty I noticed growing up as a child, in my home. I had the usual questions, as a child, like ‘who created god?’ But none of them were answered from an honest standpoint and I later just abandoned questioning.”

“Much later in my early twenties, I began to think about how a lot of the ‘threats’ issued by the religious seemed not to affect a good number of others that did not subscribe to Christianity. I thought that was weird and began to carry out ‘Thought Experiments’ that addressed those inconsistencies. Those experiments in my late twenties were the beginning of my journey!”

“Yes, it did. Though I didn’t study any pure or applied science course (I have two degrees in Law), but my parents did take the time to engage us intellectually on current affairs, theology and rudimentary logic. Looking back, they were quite intellectually honest for religious Nigerian parents!”

“The average Nigerian is ‘religious’ (by religious, I mean shows ‘piety’ more than kindness and compassion, etc). So, in a country of 190–200 million, the common denominator would be a sense of religion and its vocalisation in public discourse.”

“The mix between religion and politics, I can say, is negative, to a large extent. For example, it is on record that the rejection of the Gender and Equal Opportunities Bill by the 8th National Assembly was in part due to religious reasons. Again, the Federal Government still subsidizes religious pilgrimage. And a few State governors have blamed disease outbreak on ‘Sin’ and not research or any empirical study. But this may also be in part due to our anti-intellectual public life.”

“If the person was still dependent on her family for shelter and food, I would advise them to just ‘lay low’ till they get their own source of income. It is not uncommon for parents in Nigeria to deny their children of care upon hearing they are no longer religious. This is not to talk of the emotional abuse and anguish that would follow.”

“Their families would likely ostracise them and their communities, too. Though I have not heard of any case of recorded violence against the irreligious, but resources are usually denied to them.”

“From my very casual observation, it seems like the argument for the existence of deities does not ‘add up’. A lot of Atheists on average, read a lot, so they begin to see the loopholes in arguments pandered by their religions. Most come to the realisation that there is no evidence or basis for religious claims.”

“I think that the number of Atheists is on the rise, if the debates and interactions on Social Media are anything to go by. A lot of people are now unashamed to discuss how exploitative the religious institutions are, and a lot of people are more comfortable confronting the logical inconsistencies in religious ‘arguments’.”

“I suppose again, that this may be an indication of declining religiosity, but I don’t know if the interactions I see on Social Media are an accurate representation.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1753: Ebenezer Odubule on Atheism, Secularism, Religion and Freedom of Conscience in Nigeria

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/09/27

“In some private businesses and professional organizations, the religious practice of the head is imposed on the rest of the workforce. Religion is part of work, school, family life, social and political life — it is exasperating.”

“In the political space also, religion is a key factor. Leadership is not sourced on the basis of an individual’s level of competence and fidelity to humanism.”

“So, it is visible to all, that religion is a substitute for good governance in Nigeria. The people do not have any faith in the political leadership and since god is dogmatically assumed and regarded as a problem solving all-powerful spiritual entity, the majority will cast their burden unto God rather than seeking practical or rational ways to solve problems.”

“Consequently, early personal lives are enmeshed in these dynamics be it social, educational, economic, or political — you are willy-nilly coerced into one form of acceptance of religion one way or another. It is a huge challenge to sound personal development and one that has placed Nigeria in the state of stagnation and misery as it is today.”

“So, the early moments of questioning faith for me started in primary school. I was seeking answers to the legitimacy of god but not openly because the majority frowns at such inquiries and I had to endure life going to churches because when your parents get ready for churches they compel their children to come along for lots of reasons unconnected with religion too.”

“Some family members will keep their distance, they believe that you are a bad influence on the religious development of other family members. Professionally you are at a disadvantage too, especially when you are in a profession where advertisement if precluded and you would rely on references from a wide variety of sources.”

“But this is okay by me because the sanity of my conscience weighs more importantly than any professional accomplishment — all my life, I have never enjoyed the degree of inner peace I now enjoyed when I was religious. No more nightmares and surely no more praying, casting, binding and battling any unseen and perpetual enemies.”

“There is a future for secularism in Nigeria. Before my membership of ASN, I had initially thought I was alone in my atheism but now I know better.”

“I have also experienced another young male adult who’s atheism activities on social media has led his family to declare him insane and he was promptly taken to a mental hospital as a measure to persecute and he was effectively coerced to abandon his conscience and went back into the closet.”

“My advice to any young person is to wait until they are independent of all parental influences before coming out with their atheism but I am also aware that some families may be liberal in their reaction to such issues hence, a balancing approach is required otherwise the risk of social reprimand is always hovering around such declaration of atheism at early stages and family members often applied punitive measures withdrawing financial and emotional support to the subject.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1752: Dominic Omenai on Atheism in Nigeria, Religious Upbringing, and Social Backlash

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/09/27

“I was a Catholic when I was growing up, I was manservant for some time before leaving that to try other religions.”

“Yes, religion was a directing force in my life.”

“Back then when I was growing up, immediately after returning from school the next place to spend time was at the church attending one program or the other, we prayed as a family.”

“The individual that has inspired me in Nigeria who is a humanist is a man named Wole Soyinka a Nobel laureate.”

“Religion is the worst thing that has happened to mankind that prevents a man from using reason.”

“A prominent author worth mentioning is Dan Barker, I have read nearly all his books.”

“I just started the library, the response is encouraging.”

“Atheists in Nigeria, struggle with the backlash for being an atheist if you tell someone that you are an atheist in Nigeria you will be treated cruelly.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1751: Jummai Mohammed on Atheism, Religion, Women’s Rights, and Discrimination in Nigeria

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/09/25

“I am a Hausa lady from the northern part of Nigeria.”

“I will say being born in a Muslim home in a Christian dominated society tends to shape my being an atheist to this day.”

“As a young girl, I was practically confused by the contradictions in both religions, yet they both claim to serve the supreme God.”

“So, I have practiced and experienced the two most popular Abrahamic religion.”

“I converted to Christianity while in secondary school, but a closet one.”

“I have always questioned religion right from primary school, I always questioned the Bible/Quran stories right from that time, because the stories don’t add up.”

“However, joining a popular Nigeria online forum known as Nairaland influenced and hastened my decision of becoming an atheist.”

“Yes, it is a glaring fact that religion preaches subjugation of women and it is very evident in Nigerian society.”

“My experience as an adult atheist is just religious fanatics unwillingness to get close, make friends, or do business with me.”

“In the northern part which is predominantly Muslims, atheists face death threats, lynching, and so on, together with what I listed up there faces by a southern atheist.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1750: Abiodun Sanusi on Freethought and Human Rights in Nigeria

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/09/25

“Yes, I became a freethinker through rigorous vigorous reading and thinking.”

“Like I said earlier, I became an atheist through thinking, reading, debating, and doing a lot of research.”

“I only made my transition known to friends and family through logical explanations and scientific and philosophical methods, which I always implore during conversations and debates and in my everyday activities by rejecting dogmas both local and foreign and by asking for proofs for everything including the Bible and Quran and even African religious creeds.”

“I wanted to become an astronaut and visit space to know if all NASA says about space and the universe was true.”

“I wanted to be the first African or black to visit space (I still look up to that though).”

“I want to develop my environment through environmental science as I look forward to venturing into mainstream politics after school.”

“The first time I stood individually against oppression was during my final year in high school when I stood up to a teacher who was a notorious bully and I came out victorious although with a little price of cutting the grass.”

“Now in the university, I have always stood against oppression since my first year and I sometimes pay for it with my grades (score reductions).”

“The international community can help atheists and the atheist community in Nigeria by helping to sponsor human rights and atheistic campaigns and providing legal backings for freedom of thoughts, sex, gender, and every other thing, which should be personal and doesn’t affect anyone in any sane manner.”

“I would be very glad if the international community could help promote atheism and human right through media campaigns like billboards and television programmes and radio programmes. I will voluntarily gladly volunteer to host television programmes in favor of atheism and human rights including gay rights.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1749: Micah Mukhwana on Atheism, Freethought, Law and Social Change in Kenya

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/08/23

“We’ve been engaging in important matters, trying to make this more than just an online group.”

“For example, people have been going for hikes and nature walks, which help us connect with nature.”

“I recently joined the WhatsApp group, and although I haven’t been super active, I’ve seen a lot of conversations and engagement in the short time I’ve been there.”

“For instance, now that we are building a society in Kenya, can we also engage beyond the country?”

“In Kenya, many people believe so strongly in God that they find it difficult to engage in conversations about atheism or skepticism.”

“Can we have external conferences or meetups to connect with others globally?”

“Could that help in creating a better society?”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1748: Agness Bweye on Religion, Freedom and Women’s Secular Identity

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/08/23

“I grew up in a family where I have never seen my dad attending any church or mosque.”

“After my high school when I went back home I stopped going to church again until I joined university then I went three or four times to church because I like singing and the choir so much but eventually I stopped for good.”

“I remember when I was 8 I went to a seventh day Adventist church with my older brother and the preacher was speaking so ill of women and people who pierce their ears.”

“So for me, religion didn’t make sense since I was young I think because I was raised in a less religious family it was not about too much questioning but just my freedom as a human being without any affiliation to church or any other religion.”

“My biggest influence was my dad and uncles who didn’t care about what people thought of them not going to church.”

“About books, I just read different types of them to get knowledge on world matters but my journey is hundred percent influenced by my family and myself searching for freedom of living without adhering to any religious morals or conducts.”

“I think the most important thing is self-reflection first, these women should really know who they are and what they want in life because the society especially in my country it is not so friendly to people who are non-believers.”

“It’s not always an easy task since sometimes it is so heartbreaking to be judged wrongly simply because you don’t believe like others but if it comes from within these women will be as happy as any other and they won’t take themselves as losers or sinners.”

“They can involve themselves through doing activities to society which save humanity from extremism such as helping the need, educating people who are extreme irrational or extreme radical because extremism is a problem which makes people die, kill and it cause all sort of problems.”

“I would tell women who are unsure or those who question religion that it is totally normal and okay they shouldn’t doubt themselves because they are questioning irrelevant beliefs and religion because there is a tendency of being too harsh on oneself simply because you are asking yourself questions which touches your core beliefs as a person, and there is also a pain of losing a supernatural power to lean on and think for yourself.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1747: Alex L. Mwakikoti on Freethought and Humanism

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/09/21

“A freethinker, to my estimation, is someone who, after being affected by societal norms on how to think about issues, begins to retreat to child-like thinking with complete freedom of asking questions that the social norms may suggest as dangerous or should not be asked.”

“Eventually, in 2007, I detached from all religions, calling myself a Humanist. You can say I became a freethinker and a Humanist when I was at the height of my career as a Professor of sociology and communication.”

“True love is found where it is expressed freely without strings attached.”

“As a Freethinker, I like to view things from the perspective of fairness and freedom.”

“Education should be for the benefit of society, not just for education’s sake. I mean, any meaningful education should have a plan of how it will benefit society, both to a student as well as to the society at large.”

“On a personal level, the Bible is one of the books that pushed me out of Christianity. Seriously. The contradictions that are found there can be enough to push one out of faith.”

“Reading books is comforting, it builds up and helps clarify many questions that a Freethinker always seeks answers from.”

“Freethinkers are to always approach anything with a critical mind. When we venerate individuals to a state of worshiping them, we are no different from those who created all these gods in their societies.”

“I do not regret my journey that took me into theological education. Looking back, I know it helped me question religion and Christianity even more.”

“Avoid feeling the need to convert others to your fold, rather, live a good life without god, and others will seek you out and find more about who you are and what you believe.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1746: Jani Schoeman on Secularism, Community and Diversity

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/09/21

“What we have previously also done is do collaborating events with these organizations or other groups that we’ve engaged with. Sometimes that’s very fun.”

“If you have a small group, and they’re also a small group, then if you do a collab together, then you get to meet a lot more people that you never see. It’s not just the regular faces. That’s always nice.”

“I was also thinking of NHN specifically, on my second point. When we got to know them, when we had our first meeting with them, it was very interesting for me to see an older generation, how they approach the secular world or the secular idea.”

“Also, it’s a very Afrikaans group. Our group is half English, half Afrikaans, but we all speak English because Joburg is mostly English and it’s accepted that everyone just speaks English as the default language.”

“It was very beneficial to me, and insightful to me, to get to know how this other demographic of people approach secularism, as well, in South Africa.”

“That was a very long phrasing of the question. If you can maybe boil it down in a sentence for me?”

“It’s been something that’s always been on my mind. When we’re doing things, I’ve tried to cater for people of all ethnicities, and try to find something that’s interesting to everyone, but I don’t know how we can more actively try and bring diversity into the group. It’s something that I’ve always wanted to develop more.”

“It is difficult to think of active ways in which to attract more diversity to our group. I don’t know if there’s been any development on that. It’s something that I’ve found difficult. Although, we do have people of many different ethnicities coming to the meetings, but I think we can do better.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1745: Wynand Meijer on Secularism and South African Society

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/08/19

“The banners came out well. They’re quite tall, as well. I picked up the banners. That’s the short and sweet of it.”

“We have seen people who bypass by selecting the right answer on the Dawkins Scale. But then, you sit with ‘Are you a minister?…’ We have found how to better navigate. It is to stop people from entering details.”

“I would say that we, generally, get 3 to 4 applications a week without these stops in place.”

“Something else came up. This is, essentially, where the Dawkins Scale came from. We would get individuals who claim, ‘I am spiritual, but I am not religious,’ which poses some very difficult and weird things. It doesn’t really fit in.”

“There was a lot of debate on it, among the leadership. As well, we posed this to our community in establishing it. Where is that line to allow somebody?”

“Where is it when somebody is spiritual, in the sense of ‘I have an acknowledgement and an appreciation for that around me, and being mindful,’ versus, ‘I am spiritual because I like crystals’?”

“We don’t have one, really. There are things we do have; it is more like karma based.”

“Yes, it is a type of whip. If you do something, and if it is not really up to standard, then die blinde sambok will come and get you. It is more karma. If you do something bad, then it will come and get you.”

“Yes, die blinde sambok. Others scare their children with the sakabula, like the Boogeyman. You say it once or twice. But there is not a whole mythology behind the thing.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1744: Rick Raubenheimer on Secularism in South Africa

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/08/19

“I’ve wanted it for some time as something that would be useful to display our identity and also, when we have Meetups in public places, make it easy for people to find us because they would be able to look for a large banner, and see that it says South African Secular Society, and then that way find us more easily.”

“The intention is to put a flag outside the venue and a banner inside, typically. That’s all we could afford now because we got six printed for different parts around different Meetups around the country. Probably, when we’re flusher with funds, we’ll duplicate that and do another teardrop banner and X-banner for the Meetups.”

“Let’s talk about our experience with the Department of Home Affairs in trying to register as an organization that can designate marriage officers. We originally were prompted by one of our members who wanted to become a marriage officer.”

“So, we inquired of Home Affairs. They said that they wanted a list of 250 members with their signatures to prove that we were an existing organization. The fact that we were a non-profit organization registered with the Department of Social Development didn’t cut any ice for them.”

“We say very early on, ‘Do you support the SASS mission and ethos?’ The only choice is, ‘Yes.’ We say, ‘Are you prepared to do marriage ceremonies free of supernatural content?’ The only answer is, ‘Yes.’”

“So, it is puzzling where his head was. Maybe, it is a case of the idea of being secular and not believing in God was so far out of his frame of reference; that it didn’t feature anywhere in his consciousness.”

“Some people do, yes. For instance, we have turned down people where it was clear that they did not follow any established religion, but then they were practicing Reiki and crystal healing. That’s why I mention it explicitly.”

“So far, where we have not picked up any red flags from the application, we seem to have picked them up during the interview. Wynand, Wilhelm, Jani and Judith have been most dedicated in helping with the online interviews, which can take up to an hour each.”

“Our main opposition, although they don’t oppose us directly, would probably be the ironically-named ‘Freedom of Religion South Africa’, which gives them the catchy acronym of ‘FOR-South Africa’. They are actually a right-wing Christian organisation, opposing secularism, abortion, same-sex marriage, and so on.”

“Amusingly, they ran a few ‘surveys’ on their website on their issues. Various atheist Facebook groups I participate in directed members to those surveys, and we roundly outvoted them on their own site, even though they worded things deceptively.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1743: Significationism

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/08/18

And a human.

Is.

This,

Then that.

Everything’s a pinch,

In a pinch.

Faster than a human.

Is a human.

So that,

Then this.

A fool’s errand,

And the Fool writes,
“This, then that.”

And a human.

“So that, then this.”

One knows so that,

Then that and this,

Is a human.

But, what is “this”?

A little Brahms on an early Fall day.

A little autumn spectra.

A little salt on the coffee.

A little breeze down the alley.

A little, a little.

Well, a pinch.

We already know,

Then we see.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1742: Gayleen Cornelius on South African Human Rights, Humanism, Race, and Progressive Reform

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/08/18

“Almost everything about South Africa looks great on paper. Progressive legislation has been at the forefront of South African politics since Apartheid fell in 1994. Same-sex marriage was legalized a decade before the world’s biggest democracy; the USA. Women’s rights have been championed by the South African government as the cornerstone to societal progress.”

“Culture is definitely a huge issue in this case. South Africa is a multicultural society and more often than not, citizens and residents alike exchange various cultural attributes or get in conflict because of them. It just so happens that all of the traditional cultures in South Africa are patriarchal and this has fostered a general acceptance of misogyny by the South African society.”

“There is a general retaliatory attitude against the progressive legislation the government puts because a lot of South Africans see it as an attack towards their culture. After same-sex marriage was legalized for instance, the main victims of homophobia were mainly lesbian women. There are accounts of what has been termed ‘correctional rape’ by heterosexual males against lesbians all over South Africa up to this day at alarming rates. The perpetrators believe that their victims will be fixed after the rape, or maybe it’s just plain cruelty.”

“Poverty also undermines the efforts legislators have made to promote human rights. Income inequality is alarming in South Africa and despite the country being one of the richest in Africa, it is very easy to go homeless in South Africa rather than any other African country because of the nature of capitalism and white-owned real estate that hasn’t changed since Apartheid. It is common to see poor families marrying off their underaged daughters to make ends meet and this puts a lot of girls at risk of child marriages.”

“Tough immigration laws affect a lot of African migrant women who come to South Africa in search of a better life in their thousands every year. It’s very difficult for them to get permits to work and so they end up working in a very dangerous and unregulated sex work industry. A lot of them are at risk of rape, crime, STI’s and arrest. Some of them end up being sold off by women trafficking goons or as cheap labour to white farmers who treat them just like slaves.”

“Mandela is and will always be an icon. Very few people know enough about the struggles that brought them freedom. Lately for the most part his status is that of a celebrity. This is the general consensus in South Africa.”

“In reality it is far fetched. It is the same as christians idolizing Jesus without living by his words in reality. South Africans idolize Mandela but few of them follow his example.”

“South Africa is a very diverse country with 14 national languages. Historically rival ethnic groups like the Zulu and the Xhosa would have continued with the tribalist violence that almost got out of hand before the reconciliation programs in 1994. Xenophobia against other African nationalities would have been violent and gruesome. Racism wouldn’t have progressed at all since the Apartheid era and boiled out to a civil war.”

“Racism has threatened a lot of aspects affecting South African civil society and that has led to the rise of a far left wing of black nationalists and an alt right wing of white nationalists. The populist sentiments that have risen through Julius Malema’s Economic Freedom Fighters and the Afrikaner community’s Afriforum can possibly worsen identity politics and if any one of them get into power in 2019, it would be a newer version of Apartheid all over again. That is the single and most imminent threat to progressivism in South Africa and a lot has to be done to prevent the worst from happening.”

“The younger generation coming up is a lot more progressive than the previous one that lived through Apartheid. Young South Africans have healthier views about race and they understand the conflict from a neutral perspective. There might be hope for the future as the Apartheid generation slowly gets replaced.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1741: Alton Narcissity Mungani on Atheism, Freethought, Human Rights, and Religion in Zimbabwe

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/08/16

“This hunger for knowledge was to be the foundation of my being a freethinker, way before I realized it.”

“Through him, I realised and appreciated religious diversity.”

“I learnt and taught myself that human rights needed to be respected, regardless of race, sex, orientation, tribe, or social position.”

“As a liberal mind, the transition into atheism was not a momentous event, but a gradual realisation and awakening, combined with disillusionment.”

“That gave me a warm feeling, because where the religious can be so entitled as to want monopoly over offense; it was a confidence boost to know that there are people out there who respect humanity regardless of religious leanings or none at all.”

“The article was a treatise in support of a proposed new curriculum for primary and secondary education in Zimbabwe. The curriculum had secular leanings, advocating for the tolerance of the diversity of cultures in Zimbabwe, as well as advocating for a more science and technology-based approach to education; thus championing reason, objectivity and free enquiry in schools.”

“In Africa, I have been inspired by the works of Leo Igwe and my personal friends Takudzwa Mazwienduna and Gayleen Cornelius, who continue to champion free thought and humanism against numerous odds.”

“The laity needs to be taught that it is totally fine to ask questions. We have a tendency of putting leaders on a pedestal, thus somehow making them the absolute authority.”

“Scepticism is borne of inquiry. If one can enquire of anything, then it’s simply the next step to be sceptical of that thing you inquired of.”

“We are trying to instigate an awakening of sorts; where the more atheists and freethinkers come out, even more are encouraged to rear their heads.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1740: Haafizah Bhamjee on Ex-Muslims, Apostasy, Women’s Rights, and Secularism in South Africa

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/08/16

“I grew up in a relatively conservative Indian family in Johannesburg. I was raised Muslim, but often found religion disinteresting and restrictive.”

“Often times, I felt isolated inside of that community because I thought differently to my peers and the people around me.”

“Looking back, I regret the time lost.”

“I’ve been involved in different kinds of activism and human rights advocacy since I was a teenager.”

“Women, almost always, get the shorter end of the stick.”

“Being able to see inequality as immoral was revolutionary for me.”

“Choosing to foreground my desire for dignity and respect was what led me towards questioning faith itself.”

“Many ex-Muslims still live in fear and secrecy, despite the secular democratic laws that protect freedoms and choices.”

“Leaving Islam is often met with shaming and violence.”

“Solidarity amongst atheists and free-thinkers is important in order to create a united face against the persistent rise of religiosity.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1739: Charles Antwi on Atheism, Secular Humanism, and African Spirituality in Ghana

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/08/15

“Humanism is more than disbelief; it is about how you live and relate to others.”

“Some people identify as atheists, but that does not automatically make them humanists. Being a humanist requires a different level of ethical commitment and worldview.”

“Not every atheist can be called a humanist. That is an important distinction.”

“In Ghana, the term humanist is often misunderstood. Many equate it with simply being humanitarian and assume you cannot be humanitarian without a belief in God.”

“In Ghana, many people claim to have left the church or religion, but they still hold onto certain spiritual beliefs.”

“We are still working on identifying and organizing around a more precise, shared definition of humanism.”

“Part of the issue is that, in trying to be inclusive, we sometimes blur the lines too much.”

“It usually starts with rejecting the god they were raised with, whether that is the Christian or Muslim concept of God.”

“What I often see is that once they reject the God of Christianity, many turn toward African spirituality. They claim to be returning to their roots.”

“You might find a sense of unity or connection by exploring your heritage, but trying to revive ancient religious practices does not offer much in terms of clarity or progress.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1739: Charles Antwi on Atheism, Secular Humanism, and African Spirituality in Ghana

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/08/15

“Humanism is more than disbelief; it is about how you live and relate to others.”

“Some people identify as atheists, but that does not automatically make them humanists. Being a humanist requires a different level of ethical commitment and worldview.”

“Not every atheist can be called a humanist. That is an important distinction.”

“In Ghana, the term humanist is often misunderstood. Many equate it with simply being humanitarian and assume you cannot be humanitarian without a belief in God.”

“In Ghana, many people claim to have left the church or religion, but they still hold onto certain spiritual beliefs.”

“We are still working on identifying and organizing around a more precise, shared definition of humanism.”

“Part of the issue is that, in trying to be inclusive, we sometimes blur the lines too much.”

“It usually starts with rejecting the god they were raised with, whether that is the Christian or Muslim concept of God.”

“What I often see is that once they reject the God of Christianity, many turn toward African spirituality. They claim to be returning to their roots.”

“You might find a sense of unity or connection by exploring your heritage, but trying to revive ancient religious practices does not offer much in terms of clarity or progress.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1738: All in the Turning

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/08/14

And the seas roiled.

Out in the ocean,

You don’t even feel it.

You wheel.

Greentides and moonshine.

Riptides and sunrise.

A stake.

A heart.

A pillar.

A mote.

Risen to the Sun.

Tides underneath the moon.

A green shade a’ shinin.

Everything.

Any thing.

All in the ones.

And the ones gone all.

“Detested audiences.”

All Goulden by the Midas touch.

We we wheel.

Clanna dancin’ my name.

Annda no inna waytwo,

Aboots’it, Canadianaways,

And way aways a way,

the Way gone crescent.

Blown about,

by mote, pillar, heart, and stake.

The wheel felt fine,

and my ocean’s calmed.

And my rock cracked crystals.

Marvel.

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.

1737: Agomo Atambire on Humanism, Critical Thinking, and Secular Life in Ghana

Author(s): Scott Douglas Jacobsen

Publication (Outlet/Website): Medium (Personal)

Publication Date (yyyy/mm/dd): 2026/08/12

“Humanist principles have guided my life for as long as I can remember though I hadn’t put a label on it.”

“I have had people write very threatening things and slip them in my pocket at the university.”

“As a country that has as its motto ‘freedom and justice,’ we have to do better and we can do better.”

“I am an atheist and have been for a long time now.”

“I do this to build a more realistic image of my world and how to thrive in it.”

“We are in this sinking boat together.”

“Change is inevitable and Technology wins at the end of the day.”

Last updated May 3, 2025. These terms govern all In-Sight Publishing content—past, present, and future—and supersede any prior notices.  In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen is licensed under a Creative Commons BY‑NC‑ND 4.0; © In-Sight Publishing by Scott  Douglas  Jacobsen 2012–Present. All trademarks, performances, databases & branding are owned by their rights holders; no use without permission. Unauthorized copying, modification, framing or public communication is prohibited. External links are not endorsed. Cookies & tracking require consent, and data processing complies with PIPEDA & GDPR; no data from children < 13 (COPPA). Content meets WCAG 2.1 AA under the Accessible Canada Act & is preserved in open archival formats with backups. Excerpts & links require full credit & hyperlink; limited quoting under fair-dealing & fair-use. All content is informational; no liability for errors or omissions: Feedback welcome, and verified errors corrected promptly. For permissions or DMCA notices, email: scott.jacobsen2025@gmail.com. Site use is governed by BC laws; content is “as‑is,” liability limited, users indemnify us; moral, performers’ & database sui generis rights reserved.